Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities 1
Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities
Jennifer Byrd Northwestern University Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities 2
With one of the fastest growing economies in the world, Africas most-populous country, Nigeria, has great potential. Goldman Sachs identified Nigeria as one of its Next Eleven economies in 2005 and Citigroup in 2011 declared it a Global Growth Generator country based on growth potential and profitable investment opportunities. The Nigerian government has rallied around a Vision 20:2020 plan that aims at placing Nigeria among the 20 largest world economies by 2020. Demographics are certainly on the countrys side. A recent task force chaired by Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala of the World Bank and David Bloom of Harvards School of Public Health pointed out that by 2030 Nigeria will be one of the few countries in the world that has a numerous supply of young workers. Youth, not oil, will be Nigerias most valuable resource in the twenty-first century, the report says. But in order for the country to live up to its promise, these workers must be well educated and be able to find gainful employment. If not, they could be a force for instability and social unrest (Nigeria The Next Generation 2010). In order to prevent this, Nigeria with the help of international partners must improve its education system. Currently, nearly 32 percent of the country is illiterate; with gender differences significant (the literacy rate for men is 75.7 percent, but just 60.6 percent for women.) Despite being a member of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries and making billions from oil exports over the past thirty years, 70 percent of Nigerians live below the poverty line (CIA World Factbook.)While the country clearly faces numerous difficulties in its primary and secondary education sectors, this paper will focus specifically on the countrys tertiary education system. Once proud Nigerian universities are struggling with funding and staffing issues and are barely able to serve the small percentage of Nigerian students who are able to secure a spot (only about 20 percent of all high school graduates who qualify make it into these institutions.) Demand for quality higher education far Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities 3
exceeds supply in Nigeria, and government and university officials must come up with new strategies to serve these students. History of Nigerian Higher Education The roots of higher education in Nigera go back to the colonial period when leaders demanded a university as a means to their own emancipation (Ajayi, 1975). The British colonial rulers established the Yaba Higher College in 1932 in order to provide well qualified assistants in medical, engineering, and other vocations as well as teachers for secondary schools (Okojie, 2008). The limited scope of the college generated greater pressures on the colonial government to expand opportunities for higher education. In 1948 the University College of Ibadan was established as an external branch of the University of London. The new university absorbed the Yaba Higher College. The University of Ibadan became an independent university in 1962, following the country gaining independence from Britain in 1960. The early 1960s saw the establishment of the University of Nigeria, Nsukka, and the Universities of Lagos and Ife. Propelled by the increased income from oil and the increased demand for higher education in the country, universities continued to be established and already existing regional universities were taken over by the federal government. By 1980, Nigeria had established a well-regarded higher education system offering instruction at an international standard in a number of disciplinary areas. The universities of Ibadan and Ahmadu Bello, for example, earned global recognition for their research in tropical health and agriculture, respectively (Saint, 2003). Only a small number of top students could attend the colleges and standards were high. Funding for research was readily available during the oil boom years of the 1970s (Bollag, 2002). But political pressures soon led to a rapid expansion in the number of universities in the country without regard to adequate funding and adequate data on manpower requirements Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities 4
(Pereira, 2007). After the crash of oil prices in the second half of the 1980s, the universities were hit hard financially and many of the strongest academics at these universities left the country for better opportunities in the U.S. or Europe (Pereira, 2007). Quality of programs, staff and facilities greatly declined. A string of military governments in the 1980s and 1990s reduced university autonomy, and incentives and rewards for research productivity, teaching excellence and associated innovation disappeared (Saint, 2003). Cronies of military dictators were often named vice chancellors of the universities without regard to academic protocols. Many believed the neglect by the military leaders during this time was intentional since the universities were at the forefront of the opposition to military rule (Bollag, 2002). Violence often gripped the campuses where so-called cults (student gangs) terrorized other students into giving up limited dormitory bed space, intimidated faculty members for better grades, and invaded women's dormitories to rape students (Bollag, 2002). The cults, which usually had sons of military and police officers in their ranks, strong-armed the administration to relax admission requirements and inflate grades for their members (Guidice, 1999). Current state of Nigerian universities Following the return of a democratically elected government in 1999, several positive policy changes were made, but the universities had been damaged greatly. Universities started seeing an increase in funding (but it did not keep up with demand), vice-chancellors could no longer personally select 10 percent of each years incoming student body, university governing councils were reconstituted and had broader representation, more private universities were licensed and university staff was exempted from public service salary scales and regulations (Saint, 2003). In 2000, the government granted federal and state universities autonomy over their budgets and governance. The autonomy policy gave university councils responsibility for the Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities 5
appointment of senior officers and gave university senates authority to decide on curriculum (Saint, 2003). The Joint Admissions and Matriculation Board (JAMB) administers a national university entrance examination and informs universities of applicant scores. A National Education Bank is charged with providing merit scholarships and student loans (Saint, 2003). While Nigeria now has several of the policies and institutions in place to have a successful higher education system, the country is still rattled with many challenges. Some of the biggest concerns are similar to those that other countries in this era of higher education massification face; issues surrounding capacity, access and quality. As mentioned earlier, only a fraction of students who pass the JAMB exam can gain a spot at a university in Nigeria. Due to the high demand, several illegal universities (diploma mills) have popped up around the country (Lindow, 2009a). With more than two-thirds of the Nigerians under the age of 30 and 40 percent below the age of 15, this will only grow if capacity issues are not addressed. Funding remains a major issue, as many universities struggle to pay adequate wages to lecturers and frequent labor strikes close down universities for months at a time. Basic infrastructure (buildings, classrooms, dormitories) and information and communications technology infrastructure (computers, internet access, electrical wiring) are both problem areas for many Nigerian universities, as well as electricity and bandwidth constraints (Ekundayo & Ekundayo, 2009). Ways Forward Connections with the Diaspora Nigerian university administrators are now in the slightly unique situation of building back once-great universities. Because of that, the universities have some options other countries seeking to build world-class universities may not have, namely reaching out to alumni and members of the Diaspora for support. It has been estimated that more than 21,000 Nigerian Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities 6
academics and medical doctors are working in the United States (Ekundayo & Ekundayo, 2009). There are more in Europe. Many Nigerian universities are just starting to hire alumni-relations officers and starting annual-giving campaigns to raise funds for scholarships, new dormitories, libraries, and computers (Lindow, 2010). It has not been easy, because many people in and from Nigeria are used to the idea that the government should completely fund higher education. In addition, the labor strikes leading to long university shut-downs cast a negative light on many institutions. Roger Makanjuola at Obafemi Awolowo University in Ife-Ife described the lack of trust when he tried to talk to alumni about donating to the university. People felt that standards had dropped. The attitudes toward the university were negative. As far as the alumni were concerned, if they gave us money, we would steal it (Lindow, 2010). Over time, Mr. Makanjuola was eventually able to convince some donors he was passionate about improving Obafemi Awolowo University, and was able to raise enough money to paint several of the universitys run-down buildings and build new dormitories (Lindow, 2010). The potential for this type of fundraising at African universities is great, and two U.S. foundations, the Carnegie Corporation of New York and the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, have joined together to hire the Council for Advancement and Support of Education to help train people at African universities in fund-raising skills. But much depends on how these alumni and potential donors feel about university, the country and the stability of both. In general, the political situation in Nigeria has begun to stabilize since 1999 (although still not completely stable) and Diaspora members want to do their part to help bring back Nigerian universities. The Nigeria Higher Education Foundation was established in 2004 by prominent Nigerian academics in the United States to support Nigerian universities, with seed money from the MacArthur Foundation. Among its many activities, the Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities 7
foundation works closely with five partner universities (Ahmadu Bello University, Bayero University, University of Ibadan, University of Nigeria, Nsukka and University of Port Harcourt) to identify funding and grant opportunities. It also maintains a database of subject matter experts in the Diaspora and connects those experts with Nigerian universities in the hope that partnerships are established. Sola Olopade, a pulmonologist at the University of Chicago and his wife, Funmi, a geneticist at the University of Chicago who won a genius grant from the MacArthur Foundation in 2005, have helped to establish the Healthy Life for All Foundation, an organization to promote academic health research in Nigeria. The foundation sponsors research that builds on Funmi Olopade's work in Chicago that examines the molecular genetics of breast cancer in African and African-American women (Lindow, 2010). In addition, the Nigerian government set up a program called Linkages with Experts and Academics in the Diaspora in 2007 to attract experts in the Diaspora to come to Nigerian universities on a short-term basis, which the Nigerian government hopes might keep them in the country permanently. To lure the academics back, the program offers a month stipend, air travel and accommodations. On its website, the program says it has been able to create appropriate engagement-positions and job satisfaction for Nigerian academics and experts so that they will not be attracted away. That is, conversion from brain-drain to brain-gain (Brief Update on Linkages with Experts and Academics in the Diaspora Scheme). Other Diaspora connections have been far less formal, with professors at Western universities sending colleagues in Africa PDFs of research papers that they may not have access to or helping them pay a membership fees to academic associations (Lindow, 2009b). A young lecturer at the University of Ibadan described the Diaspora as his generations lifeline and essential to keeping intellectual output at the universities alive. Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities 8
Ways Forward Partnering with Foreign Universities/Open and Distance Learning The British Council, a U.K.-based body that specializes in international educational and cultural opportunities, has focused quite a lot of attention on Nigeria lately. The council estimates that around 14,000 Nigerian students attend British universities (that number is around 6,200 in the U.S., according to the Chronicle of Higher Education), but the council wants to recruit U.K. universities to partner with Nigerian universities in order to expand access to higher education in the country. According to a posting on its website, the British Council and the National Universities Commission have been working to develop a cross-border higher education framework, where U.K. schools can set up branch campuses in Nigeria or provide open and distance learning. A focus of current pilot programs is entrepreneurship education because there is a growing interest in the country that graduates have skills to create their own businesses, rather than look for white-collar jobs (Fatunde, 2011). In another public-private partnership, Patrick Ezepue a lecturer of applied statistics at Sheffield Hallam University is coordinating the Nigerian Mathematics, Statistics and Economics Research Consortium, which is researching problems confronting Nigerias banking and telecommunications sectors. In order to conduct the research, he is partnering with a multi-disciplinary group of academics and graduate students in the social sciences, applied science and management sciences in Nigerian universities (Fatunde, 2011). Other areas if interest for partnership the British Council has been thinking about includes programs that bring oil industry experts to Nigeria to teach students so graduates can work in that industry once they finish, or programs in the hotel management and tourism area, because it has lately been a growth sector in the country (Fatunde, 2011). The Lagos Business School has been regularly partnering with other business schools around the globe since essentially its founding in 1991. In a speech at the British Councils Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities 9
Going Global 3 conference, Albert Alos, who helped establish and grow the school, said collaborative initiatives were one of the most effective ways to build capacity for quality education in Nigerian universities (Alos, 2008). Lagos Business School, which started as an independent institution but is now part of the Pan-African University in Lagos, is a member of the Global Business School Network, an organization that works to improve faculty development and business school curriculum, as well as build partnerships between its members - which include some of the top business schools in the world (Alos, 2008). The network allows faculty at Lagos Business School to work with faculty all over the world in order to develop quality case studies that can be used in classes. The school has also partnered with the Goldman Sachs 10,000 women program, where 50 women per year participate in the schools Certificate in Entrepreneurial Management program (Alos, 2008). Partnerships in business-related areas seem to be growing in Nigeria, but given ongoing violence in the country and political instability, it is unlikely foreign universities will want to set down any firm roots in the country in the near future. Open and Distance Learning programs have the potential to serve a large number of students in Nigeria, but only if internet access improves. The Partnership for Higher Education in Africa, a joint initiative of the Carnegie Corporation, The Ford Foundation, the MacArthur Foundation, the Rockefeller Foundation, the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and the Kresge Foundation, has established a Bandwidth Consortium that negotiated an agreement with a satellite service provider to bring vastly expanded Internet bandwidth, at approximately one-third the cost, to academic institutions on the continent. The partnership also helped train new network engineers that would manage the universities IT networks and brought educational technology to improve teaching and learning at African universities. This work has been crucial in building Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities 10
the information and communications technology infrastructure that was so badly needed on the continent. The National Open University of Nigeria (NOUN) provides open and distance learning to some 40,000 students in Nigeria and offers more than 50 programs and 750 courses (Ekundayo & Ekundayo, 2009). The universitys administrative headquarters in Lagos and has 28 study centers spread across the country. It delivers course materials in print and electronic format, with most centers containing several computers. NOUN says its goals are to ensure more access to education, provide life-long learning and reduce the costs of education. Given the growth of information and communication technologies taking place on the continent, NOUN is planning to introduce more e-learning initiatives with the support of the African Virtual University, African Council for Distance Education and the International Council for Distance Education (Ekundayo & Ekundayo, 2009). These initiatives could make a huge difference in a country where so many are desperate for education. Conclusion In many ways, the globalization of higher education offers Nigerian universities many positive opportunities through connections with the Diaspora and online and distance learning. Of course, the ease of movement among highly-qualified academics, which is a characteristic of globalization, hurt the country in the 1980s and 1990s when it lost many of its best and brightest to American and European universities. But with enhanced information and communication technologies, these experts can now reconnect with the universities that produced them and offer guidance and help to students who hope to follow in their footsteps. Nigeria is often talked about as a potential economic powerhouse, but violence, political instability, poverty and lack of opportunity keeps it a troubled state. Perhaps new education partnerships and strategies can improve this. Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities 11
Alos, A. (2008). Going Global 3 - Developing partnerships with Nigerian Universities [Video file]. Retrieved from: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CbeJpXgxRMY
Bollag, B. (2002, Feb 1). Nigerian Universities Start to Recover From Years of Violence, Corruption, and Neglect. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retried from http://chronicle.com/article/Nigerian-Universities-Start-to/33828/.
Brief Update on Linkages with Experts and Academics in the Diaspora Scheme. National Universities Commission. Retrieved from: http://www.nuc.edu.ng/pages/pages.asp?id=54
Central Intelligence Agency. (2011). The World Factbook: Nigeria. Updated July 5, 2011. Retrieved from https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ni.html.
Ekundayo, M.S. & Ekundayo, J.M. Capacity constraints in developing countries: A need for more e-learning space? The case of Nigeria. Ascilite Auckland 2009, New Zealand. Retrieved from: www.ascilite.org.au/conferences/auckland09/procs/ekundayo.pdf
Fatunde, T. (2011, April 10). NIGERIA: British universities on partnership mission. University World News. Retrieved from: http://www.universityworldnews.com/article.php?story=20110408184438297
Giudice, G. (1999, May 21). New Government in Nigeria Offers Little Hope to Academics. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved from: https://chronicle.com/article/New- Government-in-Nigeria/5771/
Lindow, M. (2009a, Nov 1). As Degree Mills Proliferate, Nigeria Struggles to Fix a Tattered University System. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved from: https://chronicle.com/article/Degree-Mills-Proliferate-as/48969/
Lindow, M. (2009b, Dec 13). Academics in African Diaspora Reach Back to Help Universities Rebuild. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved from: http://chronicle.com/article/Academics-of-African-Diaspora/49441/
Lindow, M. (2010, May 9). Africas Universities Learn to Tap a Precious Resource: Their Alumni. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved from: http://chronicle.com/article/In-Africa-Universities-Learn/65438/
Nigeria: The Next Generation The Report. 17 August 2010. Retrieved from: http://www.nextgenerationnigeria.org/publications.
Okojie, J. A.(2008). Licensing, Accreditation and Quality Assurance in Nigerian Universities: Achievements and Challenges. A paper presented at the 2008 CHEA Summer Workshop. Higher Education in Nigeria: Challenges and Opportunities 12
Pereira, Charmaine. 2007. Gender in the Making of the Nigerian University System. Oxford: James Currey. Retrieved from: http://www.foundation-partnership.org/index.php?id=18
Saint, W., Hartnett, T., & Strassner, E. (2003). Higher Education in Nigeria: A Status Report. Higher Education Policy, 16, 259-281.