Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless
you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you
may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use.
Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at
http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=illinois.
Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed
page of such transmission.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit organization founded in 1995 to build trusted digital archives for scholarship. We work with the
scholarly community to preserve their work and the materials they rely upon, and to build a common research platform that
promotes the discovery and use of these resources. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Congress on Research in Dance and University of Illinois Press are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize,
preserve and extend access to Dance Research Journal.
http://www.jstor.org
Brownface: Representations of Latin-ness in Dancesport
Juliet McMains
Juliet McMains is a Ph.D. candidate in dance history and theory at the University of
California, Riverside. She has been competing in dancesport for ten years, currentlyin the
professional Latin division.An earlier version of this paper, "Brownface:A New Performance
of Minstrelsyin LatinAmericanDance," was presentedat the 2000 Dancing in the Millennium
Conference,where it received the Congress on Researchin Dance GraduateResearchAward.
She is the co-author,with Danielle Robinson,of "SwingingOut: SouthernCalifornia'sLindy
Revival," in I See America Dancing: Selected Readings, 1685-2000 (forthcoming). Most
recentlyshe presentedher paper, "'Latin'AmericanDance: Salseros and BallroomDancers"
at the 2001 CORD Conferencein New YorkCity.
Brownface's MinstrelLegacy
Whilethecurrentvisibilityof dancesportin theUnitedStatesdoes not approachthe popular-
ity attained
by Americanblackface minstrelsy (1830s-1930s),theparallelsbetweenthesetwo
entertainmentformsarestriking.Inbothpractices,lighter-skinnedperforms painttheirbody
darkerin orderto takeon behavioralstereotypesascribedto an ethnicgroupwithdarkerskin
and less social, political, and economic power.In the case of minstrelsy performerswere pri-
* .ai
'::::
:=??=~s~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~:??
#~~~.
::'::
=?:??
..:...'.:....:
}:}:
'?/!i??::???
'???
....j~i::i!?!i: .=
..=..-
.
: :.:.::... :::'.'' ?Xq.S..:. :.4.: :}:.
*: :..: ?::: :... ;u:'. o91
:
.=
African Roots
If Latin dance is racializedin orderto hide the functionof class difference,there are also ways
in which class is used to disguise its racial history. The ballroom Latin dances, while
Westernized,are derivativeof African-basedmovement forms. Rumba, mambo, and cha-cha
are descendantsof Afro-Cubandance and music; samba is an Afro-Braziliandance; andjive
is the English version of African-Americanswing dancing. All these dance forms were syn-
cretizationsof African and Europeandance traditionsin their Cuban,Brazilian,andAmerican
settings. No doubtthese dances were successful in EuropeanandAmericanballroomsin part
because practitionerscould imagine that they were engaging in "primitive"Latin behavior.
For example, in his 1942 dance manual,ArthurMurraystates that La Conga as practicedin
ballrooms was adaptedfrom dances practicedby "colorednatives" in Cuba. "Remember-it
originatedwith, and for generationshas been danced by, simple natives. And if they learn it,
you certainlycan!" (Murray1942, 175) Not only does such a statementinsult the intelligence
and culturalcomplexity of Cubans,it also ignores the culturalcontext and physical complex-
Bodily Presence
More poignantthanthe absence of the black butt in the discourse and techniqueis the absence
of the black body in the contemporarypractice. There are very few black dancesportcom-
petitors.Asians and a growing numberof Latinos are beginning to participatein dancesport
competitions,but black bodies are almost entirely absent.Those representingthis sportto the
public are acutely aware of this absence, at times distorting the demographics so that the
American public will not call it racism. For example, creators of the 1998 dancesportfilm
Dance WithMe, starringAfrican American Vanessa Williams, invented a "South African"
competitionpartnershipby teamingup Rick Robinsonand MariaTorres,two of the only black
competitors in the professional American dancesportscene. Dancers in the film's climactic
"international"competition scene were drawn from the ranks of American and Canadian
dancesportprofessionals,appearingundertheir own names with their own partnersrepresent-
ing the country of origin of at least one member of the partnership,with the exception of
Robinson and Torres(plate 3).
During a personal interview,Torresexpressed her own mixed feelings about this casting
decision. On the one hand, she recognizes that positively representingan ethnic minorityin a
Hollywood film is in itself a victory to be celebrated.However, she laments that neither she
nor Robinson was representingtheir own competitioncareeror ethnic background.The film's
producersmay have felt compelled to reinventthe racial demographicsof dancesportcompe-
tition in order to justify their casting of Vanessa Williams in the starringrole as dancesport
champion,but the irony of choosing SouthAfrica as a symbolic representationof racial toler-
ance and diversity could not have failed to register with many viewers. Throughoutthe pub-
licity surroundingthe film, no dancesportexpert broachedthe sensitive topic of black disin-
terest in the sport. In an essay for Dance Beat (an American dancesportnewspaper),two of
the dancersappearingin this scene stressedhow authenticthe directorhad tried to make this
scene by seeking out the most highly rankedcompetitors."They were looking for the top six
and if somebody couldn't do it they went down the list" ("Dance WithMe" 1988, 22). There
was no mention in the interview of why this pursuitto representdancesportaccuratelyled to
the fabricationof a SouthAfrican couple. While dancesportLatin is all about imagined racial
difference of the Latin Other, explicit discussion of bodies of particularrace is apparently
Acknowledgements
I wouldlike to thankthemembersof the 1999RaceandRepresentation in Danceseminargroupat the
all
Universityof California,Riverside, of whomhelpedto developmentof thiswork.I would
stimulate
like to extend particulargratitudeto my friend and colleague Danielle Robinson. Withouther similar
engagementwith issues of race and representationin Americansocial dance forms, I might never have
passionsfor
been ableto workmyselfbeyonda perceivedstateof paralysiscausedby simultaneous
dancesportandcriticalracetheory.
Notes
1. Beforethe IndustrialRevolution,palewhiteskinwas a sign of upper-classleisure,represent-
ing anindividual'sexemptionfromthe toils of outdoorlabor.
2. Originally,this divisionof competitionwas called"LatinandAmerican"to accountfor the
inclusionof the Americanjive. Eventuallythis namewas shortenedto "LatinAmerican"or
evenmorecommonly"Latin." Thanksto dancehistorianTerryMonaghanforpointingoutthis
historicaldevelopmentto me.
Latin,see McMains(2001).
3. Fora moredetailedcomparisonof salsaanddancesport
DancesportFederationWorld
4. Countriesthat enteredcontestantsin the 2000 International
LatinAmericanDancesportChampionships heldin Miami,Florida,on September10, 2000,
includedEngland,Italy,SouthAfrica,Japan,China,Germany,Australia,Slovenia,Russia,
Ireland,Denmark,Canada,United States, Yugoslavia,Latvia, Norway,Bosnia, France,
Taiwan,Luxembourg, Ukraine,Poland,CzechRepublic,Switzerland,Romania,Finland,New
Zealand,Hungary,Slovakia,Israel,Belarus,The Netherlands,Scotland,Sweden,Armenia,
Belgium,Austria,Norway,Spain,Estonia,andBulgaria.
see Butler(1990).
5. Forthe cardinalworkon performativity,
are the tango,a danceof Argentineandescentthatis
6. The exceptionsto this generalization
dancedin the standardsection, and the jive, a derivationof the Americanswing, whichis
dancedin the Latin division.These categorizations emergedfromthe historicalmomentat
whichtheserespectivedancesgainedpopularity Europe.The tangowas alreadya popular
in
dancein Englandwhenthe standarddivisionwas definedin the 1920s.TheLatindivisionof
dancesportwas addedseveraldecadeslater.
Bhabha. Homi K. 1990. 'The Other Question: Difference, Discrimination and the Discourse of
Colonialism." In Out There: Marginalization and ContemporaryCultures. Edited by Russell
Ferguson,MarthaGever,TrinhT. Minh-ha,and CornelWest, 71-87. New York:The New Museum