Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Abstract—A linear-in-dB variable-gain amplifier (VGA) using the IF frequency is higher, that is, the order of the band-pass
a pre-distortion circuit to generate the gain-control signal is fabri- filter can be lower.
cated in a BiCMOS process with = 20 GHz. The VGA com- The transmission/reception frequency of future CDMA sys-
prises two cascaded stages of signal-summing VGA and has a vari-
able-gain range of over 70 dB. It can operate at up to 500 MHz and tems is expected to be above 2 GHz, which is twice that of
dissipates 36 mW from a 3-V supply. A noise figure of below 5 dB narrow-band CDMA systems, i.e, 900 MHz. This requires an IF
and IIP3 of over 38 dBm at 43-dB gain were obtained. The VGA frequency of over 150 MHz to reject image frequency compo-
achieved a gain error of less than 2 dB over 70-dB gain range, and nents down to the allowable level by using a low-cost small-size
it occupies approximately 1 mm2 . The VGA is applicable to future image rejection filter, because the ratio of the image frequency
code division multiple access (CDMA) receivers.
to the desired frequency will be almost the same as that of
Index Terms—Code division multiple access (CDMA), the typical narrow-band CDMA case for obtaining a necessary
gain-compensated circuit, linear-in-dB gain characteristic, tem- image signal rejection.
perature-compensation circuit, variable-gain amplifier (VGA).
Considering the signal bandwidth and the transmission/re-
ception frequency in future CDMA systems, a high-frequency
I. INTRODUCTION VGA is desired; however, circuits dissipate higher power when
the operating frequency becomes higher. Therefore, power re-
C ODE division multiple access (CDMA) systems capable
of obtaining large channel capacity have been emerging.
A desired signal must be amplified linearly through downcon-
duction techniques are required for high-frequency IF VGA.
This paper describes low-power high-frequency VGA circuit
version in the analog blocks of the CDMA receiver because techniques for future CDMA receivers with high reception fre-
many unwanted signals occupy the same frequency range as quency and wide signal bandwidth. In Section II, our design
the desired signal and the unwanted signals have almost the objectives are described. We discuss VGA implementations re-
same power as the desired signal. Thus, CDMA systems require specting high-frequency operation, low-power operation, and
variable-gain amplifiers (VGAs) with high linearity and wide obtainable gain range, and, for that purpose, compare the four
gain range in the receiver. There are two options in realizing reported types of VGAs in Section III. A circuit design of the
the highly linear wide-gain-range VGA. One is a digitally con- VGA for the receiver is illustrated in Section IV, where a pre-dis-
trolled VGA which comprises a series of switchable gain stages tortion circuit to generate the gain-control signal and tempera-
[1], [2]. The other is an analog linear-in-dB VGA which uses a ture-compensation circuits are proposed. Section V shows mea-
variable transconductance or a variable resistance controlled by sured results when the VGA chip is mounted on a circuit board.
an analog gain-control signal [3]–[7]. The analog linear-in-dB Section VI summarizes the techniques employed for the VGA.
VGA is preferred because it needs only one gain-control signal
line. II. DESIGN OBJECTIVES
Future CDMA systems will require wider signal bandwidth We aim to design a low-power high-frequency VGA for
than that of narrow-band CDMA systems because they must future CDMA systems. For a low-insertion-loss IF band-pass
handle high-rate data transmission. A wide signal bandwidth filter, the operable frequency range for our design objective
causes high insertion loss for an IF band-pass filter which is is assigned from 150–400 MHz. An insertion loss of less
equipped in front of an IF VGA. This degrades the noise per- than 10 dB is expected for a signal bandwidth of 4 MHz in
formance of the receiver. In order to reduce the insertion loss that IF frequency range. This insertion-loss value of the IF
of the IF band-pass filter with wide signal bandwidth, the IF band-pass filter is acceptable for realizing low-noise receivers.
frequency is required to be higher. This is because the required A sufficient image rejection can also be achieved for an RF
quality factor ( ) of the IF band-pass filter becomes lower when signal of over 2 GHz when the IF frequency is over 150 MHz.
CDMA systems require a gain range exceeding 80 dB in total.
A gain range of less than 70 dB is preferable for the IF VGA
from the viewpoint of the realization of a low-noise and low-
Manuscript received April 24, 2000; revised July 10, 2000. distortion receiver. The variable-gain range of 70 dB includes a
S. Otaka is with the Corporate Research and Development Center, Toshiba
Corporation, Kawasaki 212-8582, Japan (e-mail: otaka@csl.rdc.toshiba.co.jp). 10-dB margin, assuming that a 20-dB gain range is assigned to
G. Takemura is with the System LSI Group, Semiconductor Company, the RF stage.
Toshiba Corporation, Kawasaki 212-8582, Japan. A noise figure (NF) of 7 dB and an input-referred intercept
H. Tanimoto is with the Kitami Institute of Technology, Hokkaido 090-8507,
Japan. point (IIP3) of 50 dBm are required at maximum gain to
Publisher Item Identifier S 0018-9200(00)09474-9. achieve a wide dynamic range receiver. The intercept point at a
0018–9200/00$10.00 © 2000 IEEE
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY WARANGAL. Downloaded on November 2, 2008 at 07:28 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
OTAKA et al.: LOW-POWER LOW-NOISE ACCURATE LINEAR-IN-dB VARIABLE-GAIN AMPLIFIER 1943
Fig. 1. Comparison of the VGAs. (a) Signal-summing VGA. (b) A VGA using differential pairs with MOS emitter-degeneration variable resistors. (c) “Triplus”
variable-g m cell VGA. (d) A variable current amplifier in which a gain is controlled in linear-in-dB fashion for current ratio, I =I .
minimum gain is determined to be 8 dBm with the help of a . This condition requires the VGA to operate
VGA or a variable attenuator at the RF stage. with a 20-dB headroom from the maximum gain. This damages
The power dissipation target is 36 mW, which is almost the the noise performance and reduces the operable gain range.
same power dissipation as that of the VGA for narrow-band A VGA using a differential pair with an MOS emitter-degen-
CDMA system [5]. The gain-control signal range is from eration variable resistor [Fig. 1(b)] has high-frequency opera-
0.3–2 V, where the maximum gain is set at 2 V. tion capability, low noise, and low distortion [5]. The resistance
of the MOS resistor must be set to about a few hundred ohms at
high gain setting in order to reduce the error in the linear-in-dB
III. COMPARISON OF VGA CIRCUITS gain characteristic. This is because the resistance of the MOS
VGAs with a wide gain range have been studied for many resistor must be set much larger than , where
years [1], [4]–[7]. Fig. 1(a) shows a signal-summing VGA is the equivalent resistance in series with the MOS resistor and
which is advantageous in terms of low-noise and low-distortion is set to a few tens of ohms for low-power operation. In this case,
characteristics [3], [4]. The signal-summing VGA can also the resistance of the MOS resistor becomes a few ten-thousands
operate at high frequency, because the gain-control stages of ohms at low gain setting. Considering that the cut-off fre-
operate as common-base transistors. However, there remains quency due to the MOS resistor and MOS parasitic capacitances
an unusable gain-control range of about 20 dB around the which exist between the source and/or drain electrode and sub-
maximum gain in linear-in-dB VGAs of this type. This is strate electrode is decreased at low gain setting, the linear-in-dB
because the current gain ( ) dependence on the gain-control gain range is reduced at high-frequency operation.
signal is given by the following expression [8]: Fig. 1(c) shows a “triplus” variable-gm cell which has an
excellent linear-in-dB variable-gain characteristic [6]. Since its
gain is controlled by changing the bias current of transistors, this
type of VGA degrades frequency response at low gain settings
(1)
in the case that a multiplication factor of transistors must be
large, for example , to obtain low-noise performance.
Therefore, this VGA is not suitable for high-frequency opera-
where and are the transconductances of and tion up to 400 MHz.
, respectively, and is the thermal voltage. The current Fig. 1(d) shows a variable current amplifier in which the gain
gain is an approximately exponential function of only for is controlled in a linear-in-dB fashion through the current ratio
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY WARANGAL. Downloaded on November 2, 2008 at 07:28 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1944 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 35, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2000
[5]. This configuration can operate at high frequency be- of the VGA stages must be increased so as to obtain the desired
cause the gain is determined by the current ratio, , and the gain range.
range over which tail currents and change can be reduced By subtracting one from the denominator in (1), the signal-
compared to that for the VGA shown in Fig. 1(c). However, this summing VGA can have a complete linear-in-dB characteristic
configuration dissipates a large amount of power because two and 20-dB wider gain range. This realizes a gain range of 40 dB
stages of the amplifier are required in the signal path. using one gain stage. Thus, only two cascaded stages of the
The signal-summing VGA [Fig. 1(a)] and the differential signal-summing VGA are needed to obtain an 80-dB gain range,
pair VGA with an MOS resistor [Fig. 1(b)] are superior among which reduces the power dissipation of the VGA by approxi-
the four types of VGAs from the viewpoint of high-frequency mately one-half.
and low-power operation. We adopted the signal-summing
VGA because, as outlined below, a linear-in-dB function can B. VGA with Accurate Linear-in-dB Gain Control
be achieved over the complete gain-range by modifying the
The biggest issue in using the signal-summing VGA is the
gain-control signal, which does not affect signal path. Hence,
large gain deviation from the linear-in-dB gain-control charac-
there is no need to consider the frequency response of the gain
teristic at high gain. We propose a gain compensation scheme
compensation circuit. On the other hand, the differential pair
in which the gain-control signal is applied to a pre-distortion
VGA with an MOS resistor deviates from the linear-in-dB gain
circuit. Fig. 2 shows the signal-summing VGA with the pro-
characteristic at high frequency even if the gain-control signal
posed pre-distortion circuit, which is referred to as a control
is modified for linear-in-dB characteristic at some frequency.
signal converter (CSC). Signal currents ( ) are input
to the VGA (emitters of , , and , ) and attenuated
IV. CIRCUIT DESIGN according to the gain-control signal . The CSC converts the
gain-control signal into to obtain a linear-in-dB vari-
A design consideration for low-power operation and the
able-gain characteristic up to the maximum gain of the VGA.
VGA circuit implementation are described in this section.
To realize a linear-in-dB characteristic based on (1), the transfer
In particular, we focus on a proposed gain-compensation
function of the CSC must satisfy
scheme and temperature-compensation techniques for realizing
an accurate linear-in-dB function up to the maximum gain.
These techniques enable a low-power operation of the VGA. (2)
Two temperature-compensation techniques are applied to the
gain-compensation scheme and a differential amplifier of the
where is a constant. The gain-control signal
first stage of the VGA, which are explained in Sections IV-C
generates a voltage drop of between the
and IV-D, respectively.
bases of and . Due to the exponential nature
of bipolar transistors and , the collector cur-
A. Design Consideration for Lower-Power Operation rents of and are and
The signal-summing VGA has an unusable gain-control , respectively. The resulting
range of about 20 dB below its maximum gain. Supposing that base voltage difference satisfies (2) for
the minimum current gain is limited to 40 dB due to signal . Thus, the current gain is expressed as follows:
feedthrough, the VGA will have a usable gain range of only
20 dB. This reduced gain range due to incomplete linear-in-dB
(3)
function causes high power consumption because the number
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY WARANGAL. Downloaded on November 2, 2008 at 07:28 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
OTAKA et al.: LOW-POWER LOW-NOISE ACCURATE LINEAR-IN-dB VARIABLE-GAIN AMPLIFIER 1945
(4)
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY WARANGAL. Downloaded on November 2, 2008 at 07:28 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1946 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 35, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2000
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY WARANGAL. Downloaded on November 2, 2008 at 07:28 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
OTAKA et al.: LOW-POWER LOW-NOISE ACCURATE LINEAR-IN-dB VARIABLE-GAIN AMPLIFIER 1947
Fig. 10. Linear-in-dB gain and noise characteristics at 190 MHz. Fig. 12. Linear-in-dB gain and noise characteristics at 500 MHz.
Over a gain range of 70 dB, the gain deviation from the gain at
room temperature was within 3 dB throughout the temperature
range. This figure indicates that the proposed VGA is success-
fully compensated for temperature variations of the gain. An
NF of less than 5 dB was obtained at the maximum gain. The
temperature dependence of the gain characteristics is mainly
caused by inaccurate device parameters used for circuit design.
The temperature dependence can be easily corrected by using a
proper parameter set.
Fig. 11 shows the gain linearity of linear-in-dB gain charac-
teristics at 190 MHz. The gain error is only 2 dB over 70-dB
gain range for each temperature. The results confirm the validity
of our ideas for obtaining accurate linear-in-dB variable-gain
characteristics.
Figs. 12 and 13 show the temperature dependence of the gain
characteristics and the gain linearity of linear-in-dB gain char- Fig. 14. Dependence of the linear-in-dB gain characteristics on the
power-supply voltage.
acteristics at 500 MHz. The results are almost the same as those
at 190 MHz.
Fig. 14 shows the dependence of the linear-in-dB gain char- The VGA had an IIP3 dBm at the maximum gain and
acteristics on the power supply voltage. The proposed VGA can an IIP3 dBm at the minimum gain. The IIP3 at the min-
operate down at 2.5 V. This indicates that the power dissipation imum gain is lower than that of the VGA for the narrow-band
of the VGA is reduced to 30 mW. The power dissipation at 2.5 V CDMA [5]. The VGA such as that shown in Fig. 1(b) or (c) is
was less than 85% that of a VGA for narrow-band CDMA [5]. preferable when high IIP3 is required at low gain.
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY WARANGAL. Downloaded on November 2, 2008 at 07:28 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1948 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS, VOL. 35, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2000
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors wish to thank H. Fujiki and M. Araki for tech- Hiroshi Tanimoto (M’92) received the B.E., M.E.,
nical support regarding chip layout and fabrication. They are and Ph.D. degrees in electronic engineering from
also grateful to Dr. H. Tsurumi for valuable discussion on the Hokkaido University, Sapporo, Japan, in 1975, 1977,
and 1980, respectively.
system specifications. In 1980, he joined the Research and Development
Center, Toshiba Corporation, Kawasaki, Japan,
REFERENCES where he was engaged in research and development
of telecommunication LSIs. Since 2000, he has
[1] F. Piazza, P. Orsatti, Q. Huang, and H. Miyakawa, “A 2-mA 3-V 71-MHz been a Professor in the Department of Electrical
IF amplifier in 0.4-m CMOS programmable over 80-dB range,” in and Electronics Engineering, Kitami Institute of
ISSCC Dig. Tech. Papers, Feb. 1997, pp. 78–79. Technology, Kitami, Japan. His main research
[2] S. Otaka, H. Tanimoto, S. Watanabe, and T. Maeda, “A 1.9-GHz interests include analog integrated circuit design, analog signal processing, and
Si-bipolar variable attenuator for PHS transmitter,” IEEE J. Solid-State circuit simulation algorithms.
Circuits, vol. 32, pp. 1424–1429, Sept. 1997. Dr. Tanimoto is a member of the IEEJ.
Authorized licensed use limited to: NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY WARANGAL. Downloaded on November 2, 2008 at 07:28 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.