Nwokocha, Paschal 0., Esq.

Paschallaw Ofices,LLC
105 Fifh Avenue South, Suite 550
Minneapolis, MN 55401
U.S. Department of Justice
Executive Ofce fr Imigration Review
Board of Immigation Appeals
Ofce of the Clerk
5107 Leeburg Pike, Suite 2000
Fall Curch, Vrginia 20530
OHS/ICE Ofice of Chief Counsel BLM
2901 Metro Drive, Suite 100
Bloomington, MN 55425
Name: PACAS, ELOCASTICO GUILLER .. A 094-189-099
Date of this notice: 5/30/2014
Enclosed is a copy of the Boad's decision and order in the above-refrenced case.
Enclosue
Panel Members:
Guendelsberger, John
Sincerely,
Do CW
Dona Car
Chief Clerk
williame
Usertea m: Docket
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
Cite as: Elocastico Guillermo Pacas, A094 189 099 (BIA May 30, 2014)
. b

U.S. Department of Justice
Executive Ofce fr Immigration Review
Decision of the Board of Immigration Appeals
Fans Church, :irginia 20530
File: A094 189 099 - Bloomington, M Date: MAY 3 0 2014
In re: ELOCASTICO GUILLERMO PACAS a.k.a. Elocastico Guillermo Pacas Mainez
IN REMOVAL PROCEEDINGS
APPEAL
ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT: Paschal 0. Nwokocha, Esquire
ON BEHALF OF OHS: Ryan R. Wood
Assistant Chief Counsel
APPLICATION: Temporary protected status; voluntay depaure
This mater was last befre the Board on June 18, 2008, when the Board sustained the
respondent's appeal of the January 23, 2007, decision of the Immigation Judge denying his
application fr temporary protected status (TPS) under section 244 of the Immigration and
Nationality Act, 8 U.S.C. 1254a. The record was remanded fr frter proceedings and the
entry of a new decision on the respondent's application fr TPS. The curent appeal fled by the
respondent is fom the June 11, 2012, decision of the Immigration Judge denying his renewed
application fr TPS. The record will be remanded.
The Board reviews fndings of fct, including credibility determinations, under a "clearly
erroneous" standard. See Matter of R-S-H-, 23 l&N Dec. 629 (BIA 2003); 8 C.F.R.
1003.l(d)(3)(i). If the Board deterines that an Immigration Judge's fndings of fct are not
clealy eroneous, it may review de novo whether the fcts are suffcient to meet an applicable
legal standard. See Matter of A-S-B-, 24 I&N Dec. 493, 497 (BIA 2008).
On appeal, the respondent argues that the Immigration Judge made her decision without
consideration of all of the evidence of record. Review of the transcript confrms that, afer the
recitation of the oral decision on the record, respondent's counsel cited to specifc evidence that
the Immigration Judge did not consider in making her decision (Tr. at 54-55). In paicular,
respondent's counsel cited to a 2002 afdavit fom Jodelinda Heradez contained in Exhibit A
at page 257 tat addressed the issue of the respondent's continuous physical presence fr
purposes of his eligibilit fr TPS. The Immigration Judge ackowledges that she "missed it"
but indicated that she had ,incorporated the evidence in her decision (Tr. at 54). While the
Immigration Judge indicated that the missed evidence would not change her decision, we fnd
that a remand is warranted to ensure that all evidence has been flly considered in determining
the respondent's eligibility fr TPS. On remand, the Immigration Judge should conduct any
additional fct-fnding necessary to provide a detailed analysis of the respondent's eligibility fr
TPS. See Matter ofS-H-, 23 I&N Dec. 462 (BIA 2002).
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
Cite as: Elocastico Guillermo Pacas, A094 189 099 (BIA May 30, 2014)
,l . .
-.
A094 189 099
ORER: The record is remaded fr frther proceedings.
2
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
Cite as: Elocastico Guillermo Pacas, A094 189 099 (BIA May 30, 2014)
.,
/
\
UNI1ED S1A1ES DEAR1NEN1 OF US1ICE
EXECU1IVE OFFICE FOR INNIOH1ION REVIEw
UNI1ED S1A1ES INNIORA1ION COUR1
BIOONINO1ON, NINNESO1A
F11C. AU54lb5U55
In LhC NaLLC C
UnC ll, ZUlZ
EIOCAS1ICO OUIIIERNO ACAS IN RENOVAI ROCEEDINOS
RESONDEN1
CHAROES:
AIICA1IONS:
SCCL1Cn ZlZ (a) (b} A} (1) CSCnL W1LhCUL
aCIlSS1Cn CI aC1C
RCnCWa1 C an a11CaL1Cn CI LCICIay
ICLCCLCC SLaLUS anC VC1UnLay CCaILUC
ON BEHAIF OF RESONDEN1: ASCHAI NwOKOCHA, ESQUIRE
ON BEHAIF OF DHS: RYAN wOOD, ESQUIRE
ORAI DECISION OF 1HE INNIOHA1ION UDOE
1h1S CaSC 1S OaCK OCCIC LhC I0I1QaL1Cn CCUIL aLCI
an CCC CaLCC Un lb, ZUUb, CI LhC BCaIC C IIIlQIaL1Cn
ACa1S ICIanC1nQ LhC CaSC LC LhC ITI1QaLlCn UCQC C ULhCI
CCCCC1nQS. AL LhC CaI11CI ICCCCC1nQS, Wh1Ch LhC CCUL haS
ICV1CWCC anC 1S aI111a LhCCWlLh, LhC RCSCnCCnL aCI1LLCC anC
CCnCCCCC LhC aCLUa1 a11CQaL1CnS CCnLa1nCC 1n LhC NCL1CC LC
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
ACaI; ExhlOlL 1. ThC FCSCnCCnL haC OCCn ChaIQCC WlLh OClnQ
SUOjCCL LC ICTCVa1 UnCCI SCCLlCn ZlZ\a} \b) \A} \l) C LhC
lTTlQIaLlCn anC NaLlCna1lLy ACL (ACL} CI CnLCIlnQ LhC UnlLCC
SLaLCS WlLhCUL OClnQ aCTlLLCC CI aIC1CC aLCI lnSCCLlCn Oy an
ITlQIaLlCn ClCCI.
ThC ChaIQC lS nCL ln ClSULC ln LhlS CaSC. ThC
FCSCnCCnL CIlQlna11y l1CC CI LCTCIaIy ICLCCLCC SLaLUS ln
FCOIUaIy C ZUUZ. ThaL a1lCaLlCn lS lnC1UCCC ln VaIlCUS
1aCCS ln LhC ICCCIC lnC1UClnQ ExhlOlLS 3; 4; anC b; aS WC11 aS
CSL~ICTanC EXhlOlL A. ThC ICCCIC IC1CCLS a1SC ln VaIlCUS
1aCCS LhaL LhC RCSCnCCnL'S CIlQlna1 a1lCaLlCn CI LCTCIaIy
ICLCCLCC SLaLUS \TS) WaS CCnlCC CI al1UIC LC SUOTlL
SUlClCnL CVlCCnCC LC CSLaO1lSh LhaL hC CnLCICC LhC UnlLCC
SLaLCS anC haC OCCn ln anC ICSlClnQ ln LhC UnlLCC SLaLCS SlnCC
FCOIUaIy lo; ZUUl; anC LhaL hC haC CCnLlnUCUS hySlCa1 ICSCnCC
SlnCC NaICh 5; ZUUl.
ThC ICCCIC IC1CCLS LhaL LhC FCSCnCCnL aL SCTC ClnL
aCa1CC LhaL CCClSlCn LC LhC aCTlnlSLIaLlVC aCa1S UnlL; WhlCh
UhC1C LhC CCnla1 C TS SLaLUS. ThC ICCCIC a1SC IC1CCLS LhaL
LhC FCSCnCCnL CCnLlnUCC LC SUOTlL SUOSCqUCnL a1lCaLlCnS CI
LCTCIaIy ICLCCLCC SLaLUS; WhlCh a1lCaLlCnS WCIC a1SC CCnlCC;
SCC ExhlOlL A. Tn a11 CaSCS LhC CCnla1 C LhC SUOSCqUCnL1y
l1CC a1lCaLlCnS WCIC OaSCC Cn al1UIC LC CSLaO1lSh IlTa
aClC C1lQlOl1lLy IC1aLlnQ LC ICSlCCnCC anC hySlCa1 ICSCnCC.
RCSCnCCnL SCCKS LC ICnCW hlS a1lCaLlCn CI
AU54~lb5~U55 Z JUnC ll; ZUlZ
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t

(
LCTCIaIy ICLCCLCC SLaLUS OCCIC LhC CCUIL. 1hC CCUIL nCLCS
LhaL LhC IlIaIy lSSUC ln LhlS CaSC lS LhC RCSCnCCnL'S
ICSlCCnCC anC hySlCa1 ICSCnCC. 1hC lnlLla1 CCSlQnaLlCn C E1
Sa1VaCCI UnCCI LhC LCTCIaIy ICLCCLCC SLaLUS ICQIaT CCCUIICC
Cn NaICh 5; ZUUl; aL WhlCh LlTC E1 Sa1VaCCI WaS CCSlQnaLCC WlLh
1IS SLaLUS WlLh a ICQlSLIaLlCn CIlCC OCQlnnlnQCn NaICh 5;
ZUUl; anC CnClnQ Cn SCLCTOCI 5; ZUUZ. SCC FCC RCQ VC1UTC bb;
F4; l4Zl4 (NaICh 5; ZUUl). 1hC nCLlCC CCSlQnaLlnQ E1 Sa1VaCCI
UnCCI LhC 1S ICQIaT lnClCaLlnQ LhC ICqUlICICnL CI C1lQlOl1lLy
LhaL an a1lCanL TUSL haVC OCCn CCnLlnUCUS hySlCal1y ICSCnL
SlnCC NaICh 5; ZUUl; anC haVC CCnLlnUCUS1y ICSlCCC ln LhC UnlLCC
SLaLCS SlnCC ECOIUaIy lo; ZUUl. IC aL l4Zlb.
SlnCC LhC RCSCnCCnL'S lnlLla1 a1lCaLlCn CI
LCTCIaIy ICLCCLCC SLaLUS UnLl1 ShCIL1y OCCIC LhC CaLC C LhC
lna1 hCaIlnQ Cn UnC ll; ZUlZ; LhC Cn1y CVlCCnCC LhaL LhC
RCSCnCCnL CVCI SUOTlLLCC LC SUCIL a ShCWlnQ C hySlCa1
ICSCnCC anC ICSlCCnCC ln LhC UnlLCC SLaLCS WCIC LhICC
CCCUICnLS; ExhlOlL A; aQCS 5b; 5b anC 5. 1hC lISL CCCUTCnL
lS a 1CLLCI aCCICSSCC LC whCI IL Nay CCnCCIn CaLCC anUaIy Z5;
ZUUZ; ICT an lnClVlCUa1 naTCC NaIla AIlaS. 1haL ShCIL 1CLLCI
SLaLCS LhaL "NI. aCaS aIIlVCC ln KCClaK Cn UnC; ZUUl; anC haC
1lVCC CCnLlnUCUSJy ln LhC U.S. SlnCC LhaL CaLC. ThlS CCCUTCnL;
C CCUISC; al1S LC CSLaO1lSh LhaL LhC ICSCnCCnL haS ICSlCCC ln
LhC UnlLCC SLaLCS anC TalnLalnCC hySlCa1 ICSCnCC SlnCC LhC
IC1CVanL CaLCS. 1hC nCxL CCCUTCnL lS a nCLaIlZCC 1CLLCI CaLCC
AU54~lb5~U55 o JUnC ll; ZUlZ
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t

(
(
Nay Zl, ZUUZ, ICT an lnClVlCUa1 naTCC NaIla A1aIC WhC
CCILllCS LhaL ShC lS a 1CQa1 CITanCnL ICSlCCnL anC LhaL ShC
KnCWS NI. OUl11CITC PaCaS SlnCC JanUaIy Zb, ZUUJ, LC LhC
ICSCnL. NC aCClLlCna1 lnCITaLlCn lS lnC1UCCC ln LhaL lCLLCI.
1hCIC lS a1SC an alCaVlL, WhlCh aCaIS LC OC a SCCCnC
alCaVlL Oy JCCC1lnCa HCInanCCZ CaLCC JanUaIy l5, ZUUZ, WhlCh
SLaLCS LhaL LhC FCSCnCCnL 1lVCC WlLh hCI CI aOCUL lVC TCnLhS
anC hC'S TaIIlCC LC CnC C hCI nlCCCS. O CCUISC LhaL SLaLCTCnL
lS lnCCIICCL SlnCC LhC FCSCnCCnL LCSLllCC LhaL LhlS WaS LhC
aUnL C hlS QlI1IlCnC anC LhC FCSCnCCnL LCSLllCC hC 1lVCC
WlLh LhlS lnClVlCUa1 CI aICxlTaLC1y Slx TCnLhS anC LhC CCUIL
CCCS nCL lnC LhlS CUTU1aLlVC CVlCCnCC LC OC SUlClCnL. 1hC
lna1 lCCC C CVlCCnCC lS a nCLaIlZCC 1CLLCI ICT a CISCn
naTCC DCTlLl1a HCInanCCZ; WhlCh SLaLCS LhaL ShC haS OCCCTC
aCqUalnLCC WlLh GUl11CITC PaCaS SlnCC JanUaIy, ZUUl. 1hlS aQaln
1aCKS any aILlCU1aIS IC1aLlnQ LC LhaL SLaLCTCnL.
NC aCClLlCna1 CVlCCnCC CCnCCInlnQ LhC FCSCnCCnL'S
ICSlCCnCC CI hySlCa1 ICSCnCC ln LhC UnlLCC SLaLCS WaS
SUOTlLLCC LC LhC CCUIL UnLl1 a l1lnQ Cn JUnC 4, ZUlZ, a WCCK
OCCIC LhC lna1 hCaIlnQ. 1haL l1lnQ CCnSlSLS C LWC nCLaIlZCC
SLaLCTCnLS, ExhlOlL B. 1hC LWC SLaLCTCnLS aIC aaICnL1y ICT
SlSLCIS; CnC C WhCT SUOmlLLCC LhC CaI1lCI 1CLLCIS CCnLalnCC ln
ExhlOlL A aL aQC 5. 1hC nCW SLaLCTCnL ICT DCTlLl1a
HCInanCCZ, ExhlOlL B, aQC LhICC; ICVlCCS SlQnllCanL1y TCIC
CCLal1 CCnCCInlnQ LhC RCSCnCCnL'S ICSlCCnCC anC ICSCnCC ln LhC
AU54~lb5U55 4 UnC ll; ZUlZ
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
(
UnlLCC SLaLCS. JhC CLhCI alCaVlL ICI JCCC1lnCa HCInanCCZ
ICVlCCS aCClLlCna1 CVlCCnCC C SlQnllCanL CCLal1 CCnCCInlnQ
LhC RCSCnCCnL'S ICSCnCC anC ICSlCCnCC ln LhC UnlLCC SLaLCS.
JhC RCSCnCCnL a1SC LCSLllCC CCnCCInlnQ CCIlnQ LC LhC
UnlLCC SLaLCS anC WhCIC hC 1lVCC anC WCIKCC; CL CCLCIa. JhC
CCUIL nCLCS LhaL LhC RCSCnCCnL'S LCSLlICny lS ICSL1y
lnCCI1CLC. Tn ICSCnSC LC nUICICUS qUCSLlCnS LhC RCSCnCCnL
WCU1C I LhlnK; I OC1lCVC; I'I nCL SUIC CI I CCn'L
KnCW WhCn aSKCC aOCUL CCLal1S SUCh aS LhC naICS C CC1C
lnVC1VCC ln hlS LIaVC1; WhCIC hC WCU1C haVC WCIKCC; WhCn; anC
nUICICUS CLhCI qUCSLlCnS. JhC Cn1y qUCSLlCn aOCUL WhlCh LhC
RCSCnCCnL aCaIanL1y LCSLllCC aS DClnQ aCLUa11y aCCUIaLC WaS
LhC CaLC hC CnLCICC LhC UnlLCC SLaLCS; anUaIy Zb, ZUUU.
JhC ICQU1aLlCnS ICVlCC LhaL an a1lCn Iay "ln LhC
ClSCICLlCn C LhC DlICCLCI DC QIanLCC LCICIaIy ICLCCLCC
SLaLUS l LhC a1lCn CSLaO1lShCS CCILaln ICqUlICTCnLS. b C. F. R.
iZ44. Z. JhC RCSCnCCnL haS LhC OUICCn C ICC CCnCCInlnQ
C1lQlOl1lLy CI LCICIaIy ICLCCLCC SLaLUS. JhC ICQU1aLlCnS QC
Cn LC CCSCIlOC CVlCCnCC WhlCh Iay OC CCnSlCCICC IC1aLlnQ LC;
aICnQ CLhCI LhlnQS; ICC C ICSlCCnCC. b C.F. R.
iZ44.5 [} [Z} [l} LhICUQh [Vl} CCSCIlOC LhC LyCS C CVlCCnCC
WhlCh Iay OC CCnSlCCICC LC CSLaO1lSh ICC C ICSlCCnCC CUIlnQ
LhC ICqUlSlLC CIlCC C LlIC. JhC 1aSL lLCI 1lSLCC ln aIaQIah
(Vl} lnC1UCC aCClLlCna1 CCCUICnLS; WhlCh LhCn aQaln 1lSL
CCCUICnLS [A} LhICUQh (I), LhC 1aSL C WhlCh lS CUnC aL (I)
AU54~1b5~U55 b JUnC l, ZU1Z
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t

(
"any CLhCI IC1CVanL CCCUTCnL.

(
1hC CCUIL nCLCS lISL C a11 LhaL LhC RCSCnCCnL l1CC
an UnLlTC1y WlLnCSS 1lSL anC NCLlCn CI 1C1ChCnlC 1CSLlTCny.
1haL WaS l1CC Cn UnC 4; ZUJZ; anC WaS nCL IU1CC UCn Oy LhC
CCUIL QlVCn LhaL LhC OCV CInTCnL ClC nCL haVC lLS JU CayS LC
ICSCnC. 1hC CCUIL WCU1C nCL CCnSlCCI LC1ChCnlC LCSLlTCny aL
LhC lna1 hCaIlnQ QlVCn LhC ShCIL UnLlTC1y ICqUCSL anC WlLhCUL
IlCI aIIanQCTCnLS haVlnQ OCCn TaCC LC VCIly LhC LC1ChCnlC
WlLnCSSCS' lCCnLlLlCS IlCI LC LCSLlTCny. 1hCSC WlLnCSSCS;
hCWCVCI; aIC LhC SaTC LWC CC1C WhC l1CC LhC alCaVlLS
CCnLalnCC ln ExhlOlL B.
1hC CCUIL Wl11 CCnC1UCC; aS ClC a11 C LhC ICVlCUS
lnClVlCUa1S anC CnLlLlCS WhC haVC ICVlCWCC LhC RCSCnCCnL'S
a1lCaLlCnS CI LCTCIaIy ICLCCLCC SLaLUS; LhaL hC haS al1CC
LC CSLaO1lSh IlTa aClC C1lQlOl1lLy CI 1S. SCCllCa11y; LhC
CCUIL lnCS LhaL LhC RCSCnCCnL haS al1CC LC CSLaO1lSh hl
CCnLlnUCUS ICSlCCnCC SlnCC Cn CI OCCIC FCOIUaIy Jo; ZUUJ anC
1lKCWlSC hlS CCnLlnUCUS hySlCa1 ICS

nCC SlnCC Cn CI OCCIC

NaICh 5 C ZUUJ.
FlISL C a11; LhC CCUIL nCLCS LhaL LhC CVlCCnCC
SUOTlLLCC Oy LhC RCSCnCCnL WlLhln a yCaI C hlS lnlLla1
a1lCaLlCn WaS WCCU11y CClClCnL ln ICVlClnQ CVlCCnCC C hlS
ICSlCCnCC anC hySlCa1 ICSCnCC ln LhC UnlLCC SLaLCS. 1hCSC
OClnQ LhC 1CLLCIS CCnLalnCC

ln ExhlOlL A aL aQCS 5b LhICUQh 5J.

A1LhCUQh LhC RCSCnCCnL CCnLlnUCC LC a1y CI LCTCIaIy
AU54~Jb5~U55 b UnC JJ; ZUJZ
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
(
(
ICLCCLCC SLaLUS ln ZUUo; ZUUb; ZUUb; ZUUb; aS WC11 aS aCa1
LhC CCnla1 C LhCSC a1lCaLlCnS; LhC RCSCnCCnL nCVCI lnC1UCCC
any aCClLlCna1 SUCILlnQ CCCUmCnLS LC OC1SLCI hlS C1alm C
mCCLlnQ LhC ICqUlICICnLS C CCnLlnUCUS ICSlCCnCC anO CCnLlnUCUS
hySlCa1 ICSCnCC. 1hC CCUIL ClSCCUnLS LhC alCaVlLS l1CC CnC
WCCK IlCI LC LhC hCaIlnQ QlVCn LhaL LhCy CCU1C haVC OCCn
COLalnCC WC11 OCCIC LhC RCSCnCCnL WaS 1aCCC ln ICmCVa1
ICCCCClnQS anC ICSCnLCC aL any ClnL ln LlIC CUIlnQ LhC
lnLCIVCnnQ lU yCaIS OCLWCCn LhC RCSCnCCnL'S lnlLla1
a1lCaLlCn anC hlS lna1 hCaIlnQ.
In aCClLlCn LhC CCUIL nCLCS LhaL LhC RCSCnCCnL'S
LCSLlmCny lS lnSUlClCnL ln anC C lLSC1 UISUanL LC b C.F.R .

lZ44.5 (D); WhlCh SLaLCS LhaL LhC SUlClCnCy C a11 CVlCCnCC
Wl11 OC jUCQCC aCCCIClnQ LC lLS IC1CVanCy; CCnSlSLCnCy,
CICClOl1lLy anC ICOaLlVC Va1UC. 1C ICCL hlS CI hCI OUICCn C
ICC LhC a1lCanL mUSL ICVlCC SUCILlnQ CCCUmCnLaIy CVlCCnCC
J
C C1lQlOl1lLy aaIL ICI hlS CI hCI CWn SLaLCmCnLS. 1hC CCUIL
CCnSlCCICC LhC alCaVlLS l1CC CnC WCCK aQC OUL ClSCCUnLS LhClI

-
ICOaLlVC Va1UC QlVCn LhClI lnCCnSlSLCnCySUOmlLLCC ln ZUUZ LC
SUCIL LhC RCSCnCCnL'S a1lCaLlCn. Tn aCClLlCn LhC CCUIL
lnCS LhC RCSCnCCnL'S LCSLlICny CCU1CC WlLh LhCSC alCaVlLS
1lKCWSC nSUlClCnL LC mCCL hlS OUICCn C ICC CCnCCInlnQ
LhCSC C1lQlOl1lLy ICqUlICmCnLS.
1hC CCUIL nCLCS LhaL LhC RCSCnCCnL LCSLllCC
CCnCCInlnQ LhC 1aCK C any CCCUmCnLaLlCn LhaL CCU1C CCIICOCIaLC
AU54~lb5~U55 7 JUnC ll; ZUlZ
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
(
h1S hySlCa1 ICSCnCC 1n LhC UnlLCC SLaLCS aL LhC IC1CVanL LlTCS
CLhCI Lhan LhCSC alCaVlLS; OUL CUIlnQ LhC LCSLlTCny LhCIC WCIC
VaI1CUS aVCnUCS C CCCUICnLaL1Cn LhaL CCU1C haVC OCCn UISUCC
LhaL WCIC nCL. 1hC CCUIL nCLCS LhaL LhlS RCSCnCCnL lS an
lnLC111QCnL lnClVlCUa1 WhC haS CSL~SCCCnCaIy CCUCaLlCn anC WaS
CI1CyCC aS an aCCCUnLlnQ ICCSSlCna1 ln E1 Sa1VaCCI IlCI LC
CCTlnQ LC LhC Un1LCC SLaLCS. 1hC CCUIL LaKCS LhlS 1nLC
CCnS1CCIaLlCn ln CVa1UaLlnQ LhC RCSCnCCnL'S LCSLlTCny anC
CCILS LC COLaln CCCUTCnLaL1Cn.
ALCI CaICU11y CCnSlCCI1nQ LhC CVlCCnCC; lnC1UClnQ
LhC RCSCnCCnL'S LCSLlICny anC LhC LWC SCLS C 1CLLCIS anC
alCaV1LS ICSCnLCC ln ExhlDlLS A anC B, LhC CCUIL lnCS LhC
RCSCnCCnL haS al1CC LC ICV1CC SUlClCnL CVlCCnCC LC
CSLaD1lSh LhC ICqU1S1LC CIlCC C CCnL1nUCUS hySlCa1 ICSCnCC
aS WC11 aS CCnL1nUCUS ICSlCCnCC ln CICCI LC qUa11y CI
LCTCIaIy ICLCCLCC SLaLUS. OlVCn LhC CCUIL'S CCClSlCn Cn Lh1S
a1lCaLlCn lL 1S UnnCCCSSaIy CI LhC CCUIL LC Wa1L CI
CCI1CLlCn C LhC O1CICLI1CS ICCCIC ChCCKS; WhlCh haVC QCnC
SLa1C 1n LhC 1nLCIlT ln LhlS CaSC.
1hC RCSCnCCnL LCSLllCC hC CCCS nCL haVC a CUIICnL
Va1lC aSSCIL. CCnSCqUCnL1y; hC 1S lnC1lQlO1C CI VC1UnLaIy
CCaILUIC UnCCI SCCLlCn Z4UB\O) C LhC ACL. ACCCIClng1y LhC
C11CWlnQ CICCI Sha11 OC CnLCICC:
AU54~lb5~U55 b UnC JJ; ZUJZ
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
ORDERS
IT IS HEREB ORDERED LhC ChaIQC UnCCI ZZ\a) |b) (A} |1)
C LhC ACL lS SUSLalnCC.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED LhaL LhC RCSCnCCnL'S
a1lCaLlCn CI LCICIaIy ICLCCLCC SLaLUS lS CCnlCC.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED LhaL LhC RCSCnCCnL'S ICqUCSL
CI VC1UnLaIy CCaILUIC lS CCnlCC.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED LhaL LhC RCSCnCCnL 1S ICTCVCC
ICI LhC Un1LCC SLaLCS LC E1 SalVaCCI.
s
ITI1QIaLlCn UCQC
AU54~b5~U55 5 UnC l; ZUZ
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
CER1IFICA1E IAOE
l hCICOy CCILly LhL LhC LLChCC ICCCCClnQ OCCIC JUDOE
SUSAN E. CAS1FO; ln LhC TLLCI C:
EIOCAS1ICO OUIIIERNO IACAS
AU54~lb5~U55
BIOONINO1ON; NINNESO1A
lS n CCUILC; VCIOLlT LInSCIlL C LhC ICCCIClnQ S ICVlCCC
Oy LhC ExCCULlVC OlCC CI I0lQILlCn RCVlCW nC LhL LhlS lS
LhC CIlQln1 LInSCIlL LhCICC CI LhC l1C C LhC ExCCULlVC
OlCC CI I0lQILlCn FCVlCW.
SHI/jT
SIENCE H. IROC1OR (1InSCIlOCI)
YORK S1ENOORAIHIC SERVICES; InC.
AUQUSL 5, ZUlZ
(CCT1CLlCn DLC)
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t