Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
From the Editor B via the shortest route; you just got serve as categories in classification
Sandy Siegel it in the first paragraph, and you can systems. And for the most part,
get on with life. For those of you those categories are arbitrary. For
My column in this issue of the who are endowed with great pa- instance, there are some societies
newsletter is going to conclude with tience and have twenty minutes to and cultures in which the language
the following statement: The Trans- devote to reading … this article is only has three different color cate-
verse Myelitis Association advo- really about the manifest purposes gories. Does this mean that the peo-
cates for people who have trans- for medical concepts or definitions ple who were raised in that society
verse myelitis; recurrent transverse and the latent or less explicit pur- with that particular culture and lan-
myelitis; recurrent transverse mye- poses of those definitions. The guage only see or perceive three dif-
litis and recurrent optic neuritis or roadmap I will use on this explana- ferent and distinct colors? No, they
Devics Disease; recurrent optic neu- tory journey has been heavily influ- see the same things that we see.
ritis; and acute disseminating en- enced by my experiences teaching The categories do not reflect what is
cephalomyelitis or ADEM. We physical anthropology and also by possible to see; the categories repre-
have always had people with these my education and experience in cul- sent what these people define as
conditions in our membership. The tural anthropology, and particularly meaningful from their perceptions.
TMA was not focused on their is- linguistics and sociolinguistics. They group the entire range of all
sues, nor were we very clear about Linguistics is the study of language. perceivable color into only three dif-
our role with regard to their con- Sociolinguistics concerns the way ferent color categories. For in-
cerns. Our murkiness was a reflec- people use language and the mean- stance, what we see and define as
tion of our ignorance, and perhaps ings of communication in particular yellow, orange, brown and red they
also reflected a lack of clear direc- social contexts. group into one category because the
tion from the medical community. distinctions between these grada-
Two brilliant linguists came up with tions of color are not meaningful to
All of these conditions are neuroim- this really interesting theory that the their way of life.
munologic disorders of the central words we use in a particular lan-
nervous system. Each of these dis- guage determine the way we per- Another great example and one
orders occurs when a person experi- ceive the world around us. What which demonstrates the arbitrariness
ences a demyelinating attack at they meant was that the categories of categories is the system for defin-
some location in their central nerv- we use from our language determine ing relatives. In American society,
ous system. Multiple sclerosis is how we see our world, and in fact, all of our first cousins are related to
also a neuroimmunologic disorder limit how we perceive our experi- us in the same way regardless of
of the central nervous system. Why ences. For those of you who find whether they are related through
did I not identify MS in my list of this to be a totally fascinating idea your mother’s or father’s side of the
conditions represented by the TMA? and would like to read everything family. In some societies, there are
Well, the answer to that question they ever wrote, their names were two very different classes of first
will eventually be addressed in this Edward Sapir and Benjamin Whorf. cousins. The one type of cousin is
article. How this all works is probably a called by a term which means
great deal more complicated than brother or sister; they are considered
This article starts with the conclu- has been explained by the Sapir- brothers or sisters and are treated as
sion because I am going to take you Whorf hypothesis, but there is no such. The other type of cousin
on a circuitous journey; much like dispute that language strongly influ- represents the group from whom
the experience the TMA has had ences how we perceive our experi- you are supposed to select your wife
since 1994. For those of you who ence. Each culture has a different or husband. In our culture, it is
need the classic comic book version language. A feature of those lan- frowned upon to marry a first
that proceeds from point A to point guages is that there are words which cousin, and we do not think of cous-
ins as being the same as our brothers
Page 2 The Transverse Myelitis Association
and sisters. Every society has its own dish. At this time, Jews were not per- about the world around us.
kinship classification system, and mitted to attend the Russian schools
there are tremendous differences be- and they were isolated from the rest One of the all-time great accomplish-
tween these systems. Of course, the of Russian society. His world was ments of humankind, after the inven-
American system is the correct system one of horse drawn carts, shacks with tion of Chinese food, was Karl von
and everyone else in the world is no electricity or plumbing and dirt Linne’s classification of the plant
dazed and confused. And of course, floors. My Zadie came to America and animal kingdoms. Linne’ was a
they all think the exact same thing during the Pogroms; when they Swedish botanist who developed a
about us! Isn’t diversity lovely. started killing the Jews and burning taxonomy that organized all of the
down their villages, for a change. He known plant and animal types based
How we classify the universe around came to America as an adult. His na- on a comparison of the similarities
us with our language does reflect our tive language was not filled with and differences of their characteris-
way of life. Our language and our many categories for technology, be- tics. He grouped the categories based
way of life and the way we think of cause his technological world was on the types of characteristics they
the world around us are all inextrica- very simple. He learned English, he shared and based on the characteris-
bly bound. To the Inuits who live in learned enough of our culture to be a tics that distinguished them from
the Artic and Subartic snow is central participant, but he never fully assimi- other groups. Ultimately, he defines
to their world and way of life. There lated. He went from dirt shacks in a a specific plant or animal based on an
are twenty-two words in their lan- peasant village to watching a man entirely unique set of characteristics.
guage to describe different kinds of land on the moon on his television No other plant or animal possesses
snow. In American English we can set; yet, he never learned how to drive the same set of characteristics. Hu-
describe a type of snow as “the kind a car. mans share characteristics with all
that has just the right amount of wet- other animals, a fewer number of
ness to make a great snowball.” The In American culture technology is characteristics with all other verte-
Inuit language has a single word to de- central to our way of life. We have brates, a fewer number still with all
scribe this kind of snow. Do our an enormously complicated language other mammals, and so forth. But
words and the way we develop cate- to define our technology with literally humans have a complete set of char-
gories influence how we perceive the thousands of concepts to describe it. acteristics that are unique to only hu-
world? Can you even think of twenty- My Zadie called everything that had mans, and which distinguish us from
two different kinds of snow? Snow is an engine a machine. From his world all other animals.
not as meaningful to us in our physical view and his perceptions of the uni-
and social environment, so we don’t verse, what mattered was that it had Karl was a very cleaver and a very
need all of those categories. Colors an engine and was classified as a ma- organized person. I would bet that
are very meaningful to us, so some chine or it didn’t have an engine and the things in his house were all lined
paint companies actually sell 140 dif- was something else. He asked me to up with the true meridian, as they are
ferent shades of white. cut his lawn with a machine. He in my house.
asked me to pick him up in the ma-
A very personal example and one chine to take him to the store. I knew Okay, I’m getting there; don’t hurt
which provides some insight as to the machine he was talking about the dog.
how classification or the development from the context of his request. What
of categories works in our language was meaningful to my Zadie in his I was provided with a perspective and
and culture comes from my grandfa- classification of technology was the a new sense of clarity about TM at
ther. My Zadie was raised in a small presence or absence of an engine. the end of March of this year. I had
village in the Ukraine just outside of And, yes, we went to the moon in a an experience which changed the way
Kiev. The people who lived in these machine, a very sophisticated ma- I think about TM, because it changed
villages were peasants. These people chine. the way I think about the classifica-
were very poor. If you’ve seen Fid- tion of TM. And it, therefore,
dler on the Roof, it was like that, but Where the heck is he going? Hang changed the way I think about the
without the orchestra and great music. on, it’s going to get worse. Okay, our TMA.
My grandfather knew some Russian language and culture provide us with
because he had been forced to serve in a way to categorize our experience, Dr. Kerr and I were working on a
the Czar’s army. But his first lan- and these categories influence our grant and we were doing lots of writ-
guage, his native language, was Yid- perceptions and the way we think ing, talking and emailing. During
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 3
Pauline’s spring vacation we treated. The specific category deter- optic nerve and does involve demyeli-
headed for Baltimore. Dr. Kerr and mines the specific treatment. The nation in the brain. The lesions or de-
I had three days to think and talk definition also allows the medical myelination that occur in the brain are
about TM and the TMA. Dr. Kerr community to determine prognosis; ordinarily identified in a specific pat-
and I communicate often. Ordinar- and we all want to know what’s go- tern; the lesions tend to be aligned per-
ily, we have a long list of items to ing to happen. These are the explicit pendicular to the ventricle (although
cover and it is a stream of con- purposes of these definitions. lesions may be present anywhere in
scious communication. We sum- the white matter). MS involves more
marize our to-do lists before we This classification system operates in than one episode and the multiple epi-
hang up the phones, but I always the same manner as my Zadie’s tech- sodes occur in different locations in
feel as though I have spent an hour nology classification and Linne’s the central nervous system.
spinning inside a tornado afterward. classification of plants and animals.
Having three uninterrupted days to Medicine classifies conditions, disor- Devics is another category of these
talk was really wonderful, and the ders, diseases based on a set of char- neuroimmunologic conditions. Devics
benefits for both of us were signifi- acteristics that are unique to that de- is recurrent spinal cord and optic nerve
cant. There are likely no two peo- fined category. Each condition is de- demyelination. Put another way, De-
ple who do more thinking about fined as a unique category based on vics is recurrent TM and recurrent Op-
Transverse Myelitis, who do not the presence and absence of various tic Neuritis. It is not TM because
have Transverse Myelitis, than Dr. characteristics. While there are simi- there is optic nerve involvement and it
Kerr and I. We also had some time larities between certain classes of dis- is not MS because there is no brain in-
to talk and visit with Chitra and eases or disorders, in order to be volvement.
with Dr. Adam Kaplin. It was a re- placed or defined in a specific cate-
markable weekend. I believe that gory, the condition must possess a ADEM or acute disseminating enceph-
we both came away from the dis- unique set of characteristics. alomyelitis involves demyelination in
cussion with a better understanding the spinal cord and in the brain. The
of our mission and the nature of re- At the present state of medical demyelination in the brain is different
lationships between the neuroim- knowledge, there is what I would re- than a demyelinating attack from MS;
munologic disorders. fer to as a class of neuroimmunologic the lesions are scattered and do not ap-
disorders of the central nervous sys- pear in the same pattern as those from
The practice of medicine has a clas- tem. The different diseases or disor- an MS attack. It is, like most TM
sification system. The classifica- ders which make up this class of con- cases, monophasic. It can be charac-
tion systems in medicine operate in ditions each results from a demyeli- terized by headache or seizures and
much the same ways as the other nating attack at various locations in may involve vision loss. The spinal
classifications that exist in our lan- the central nervous system. cord involvement is the same as
guage and culture and, for that mat- Transverse Myelitis, as are the associ-
ter, all languages and cultures. The One of the conditions or disorders is ated symptoms.
categories serve as a way to clas- Transverse Myelitis. TM is demyeli-
sify what is meaningful from the nation in the spinal cord only; there is Finally, Recurrent Optic Neuritis is a
full range of possible experience. no brain or optic nerve involvement. category of these neuroimmunologic
And there are direct and explicit It is a monophasic condition; the de- conditions, which involves multiple
purposes and meanings associated myelinating attack only occurs once. episodes of demyelinating attacks of
with this classification system and Most cases of TM are monophasic. the optic nerve. There is no brain or
there are meanings which are less spinal cord involvement.
explicit or obvious. A second condition is Recurrent TM.
Recurrent TM is not MS. Recurrent I have just described different catego-
Now, what is the purpose of the TM involves different and distinct ries of neuroimmunologic conditions
medical classification system? If episodes of inflammatory attack in each of which is defined by a unique
you asked the medical community the spinal cord. There is no brain or set of characteristics. While they are
why it is that they classify diseases optic nerve involvement in any of the all categories of demyelinating attacks
or disorders, they are going to tell demyelinating episodes. of the central nervous system, each
you that they have to define the dis- can be distinguished and defined based
ease because this definition deter- MS is a demyelinating attack that can upon the location of the attack and
mines how the person is going to be occur in the spinal cord and/or in the whether the attacks are a monophasic
Page 4 The Transverse Myelitis Association
or recurring event. TM diagnosis. A second attack oc- multiple episodes of demyelinating at-
curs only in the spinal cord again, tacks? If there are differences, could
In some sense, TM may be conceived and the person will receive a Recur- they be genetically based. Could those
of as a subset of the other demyelinat- rent TM diagnosis. A third demyli- who experience multiple episodes of
ing conditions, with the exception of nating attack can occur in the spinal these neuroimmunologic disorders
recurrent optic neuritis. All of the cord and this time also involve optic have compromised immune systems
symptoms of TM can be found in neuritis. This person will now be di- which are prone to be triggered to at-
these other conditions. Spinal cord agnosed as having Devics and will be tack their own myelin in the spinal
demyelination does or can take place treated as a Devics patient. The first cord, optic nerve or brain? Is there
in TM, Recurrent TM, Devics, ADEM diagnosis of TM was correct. The some genetic predisposition which
and MS. Spasticity, parasthesias, second diagnosis of Recurrent TM might explain weaknesses in the blood
bowel, bladder and sexual dysfunc- was correct. brain barrier in different places in the
tion, fatigue, muscle weakness or pa- central nervous system which could
ralysis, or depression from an inflam- I have come to appreciate and believe explain the differences between TM,
matory attack in the spinal cord from that the answers about one of these ADEM, Devics, and Optic Neuritis?
any of these conditions is going to be conditions is going to provide an- These are all questions I would try to
pretty much the same, and the treat- swers to all of these conditions; even answer if I had taken less kinship and
ments for each of these symptoms, re- if they are different conditions. I also linguistics courses and more organic
gardless of the condition, are going to believe that so long as there are dis- chemistry and microbiology.
be the same. From the perspective of tinct characteristics that define each
symptoms, these conditions share of these categories, they have to be When Karl Linne’ defined the differ-
many similar and important character- treated as unique and distinct condi- ent categories of animals, he did not
istics. tions and should be treated that way know anything about genetics. If he
and studied in that manner. If a per- had, he would have had a completely
As I noted above, it is the disease son has TM and has not had a second different and really wonderful set of
process which distinguishes the cate- episode in years or if they have characteristics that he could have used
gories; where in the central nervous ADEM, they are going to be treated to define groups of animals and to dis-
system the inflammatory attack occurs differently than a person who has Re- tinguish them from other groups of
and whether the attacks are monopha- current TM, MS or Devics. Identify- animals. But he was limited by the
sic or multiple. It is suspected that ing the differences between these then current understandings of biol-
there are some very complicated rela- conditions is critical from a medical ogy. He could only use characteristics
tionships between these conditions. treatment perspective. that he could observe and that he
Besides the fact that they are all de- knew. It is not different today. Medi-
myelinating attacks in the central As there is no clear set of causes in cal scientists can only use characteris-
nervous system, the following are all cases for all of these conditions, tics that they can identify and that they
some interesting clues or insights there is no understanding as to why know. If there is no diagnostic test for
about these relationships. one person is effected in one place in it, it is not available for this definition.
the central nervous system and not a Today, physicians are using MRIs,
A person can have a demyelinating at- different place; or why one person CAT scans, lumbar punctures and
tack that occurs only in their spinal has one episode and another person various blood tests to observe the pres-
cord. There is no brain or optic nerve has multiple episodes of demyelina- ence or absence of various characteris-
involvement, so they get a diagnosis tion. Why is it that I could have the tics. If they observe one set of unique
of TM. Some time later, they have same flu virus as Pauline and her’s characteristics, you are told you have
another episode of demyelination could trigger an auto-immune attack one condition; if they see something
which involves the spinal cord and the of the myelin in her spinal cord, and else, you are going to get the diagnosis
brain and may involve optic neuritis. mine just makes me miserable? How of a different condition.
This person will be diagnosed with is it possible that I could complain
MS. Their first diagnosis was correct; more about my flu symptoms than One day, they are going to find new
they had TM. Now they have MS and Pauline complains about her paraly- characteristics, and then they will bet-
will be treated as an MS patient. sis, bowel and bladder dysfunction ter understand how to define these
and nerve pain? Is there a difference categories, and diagnose these condi-
A person can have an inflammatory in the immune systems between peo- tions. I have no doubt in my mind but
attack in the spinal cord and receive a ple who have monophasic versus that the paradigm we are thinking
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 5
about today will change. And I be- couldn’t be; Deanne and I aren’t that tural world at work all the time. Sci-
lieve this even more strongly about cleaver or devious. And besides, if I entific discoveries would progress at a
the neuroimmunologic conditions, be- was going to get really creative, I faster pace if scientists would regu-
cause we are thinking about them wouldn’t invent a disease, I would larly share the results of their work
with such large gaps in our under- create a religion. I started thinking; and would collaborate on a more inti-
standing about these conditions. there are physicians all over the mate basis. If all scientists had access
world who are looking at a collection to unlimited information, there would
It is now time for me to shift gears of characteristics and they are inde- be more and more rapid discoveries
from the explicit medical to the latent pendently concluding that the person made across medical disciplines.
purposes of these definitions. When they are evaluating has something There are, however, substantial finan-
Pauline was first given the diagnosis that they are going to define as TM. cial rewards and prestige rewards as-
of Transverse Myelitis, we were told If this isn’t something, then all of sociated with these discoveries, and as
by one of the physicians that TM was these different physicians need to a result, most research is done without
really not a disease; it was a descrip- stop giving people this diagnosis. open and frequent communications be-
tion of symptoms. I have thought So, I concluded, I needn’t be para- tween scientists, and the opportunity
about that comment a great deal over noid about a conspiracy to concoct to build on information during the
the years, because as I have described, TM; Deanne and I didn’t do it. course of research is sometimes lost.
I think of language and categories in Results are published when the re-
these anthropological terms. I know, Finally, I was speaking with a physi- search is completed, and the research
I should probably give my brain a cian who had applied for an educa- results are often proprietary and are
rest. Early in my evolution, my reac- tion grant involving TM. One of the patented if there is a financial gain as-
tion to his comment was, “Wow, reviewers suggested that funding a sociated with it. An argument could
given all of the stuff this woman has TM grant might not be an effective be made that without the underlying
been through, couldn’t you at least approach because it might result in a competition which is driven by finan-
dignify her experience by giving her a balkanization of the neuroimmu- cial rewards and prestige rewards, that
disease? What’s with the disorder nologic and spinal cord injury areas. research would not progress at all. I
and condition business?” Early in this It was at this point that I concluded, am merely pointing out that science
process, I felt a reluctance by the that while I am hypersensitive and and medicine exist in a culture which
medical community to firm up the should probably work on that flaw in strongly influences how it is practiced.
definition of Pauline’s condition. my next life, there was something I am not evaluating the merits of the
Hey, me and Karl like order. really funky going on with this defi- system or proposing we all move onto
nition of TM. the medical research kibbutz.
Okay, maybe I’m being sensitive; I
can be overly sensitive. On another If you think only in terms of physiol- How we classify and define disease,
occasion, I was listening to physicians ogy and biology when trying to make disorders, conditions has the explicit
talk about the definition of TM. The sense of the medical classification medical purpose of determining treat-
gist of a remark I heard was, “well, system, you are not getting the com- ment and prognosis. Another aspect
I’m not sure about the specific con- plete understanding of the system. of these definitions and classifications
cept; I know that there is a Transverse Language and culture are quite com- has to do with the more latent pur-
Myelitis Association.” My translation plicated. We have a tendency in our poses of these medical classifications.
of this statement was that they were culture to see science as having a set How we classify and define these con-
not at all certain that there was a cate- of laws or rules which operate in a ditions is also influenced by the
gory of unique characteristics that very systematic way, and we tend to broader social and cultural rules in
could be defined as TM, but there was minimize the impact of social rules American society. And these less ob-
an association which was somehow on the natural world. But, of course, vious purposes of medical definitions
formalizing the definition from out- science does not exist in a vacuum; it concern funding for research, re-
side of the customary practices and exists within a complex culture that sources for medical centers, universi-
rules of medicine. strongly influences how science is ties and private companies, career op-
practiced and also how the laws and portunities and prestige assignments
I thought, “that is really amazing; rules of science operate. for scientists, physicians and faculties,
maybe Deanne Gilmur and Sandy and the individual financial rewards
Siegel are responsible for the exis- We can see the interplay of the medi- which motivate so much of our behav-
tence of Transverse Myelitis.” That cal and scientific world and sociocul- ior. A part of the definitional process
Page 6 The Transverse Myelitis Association
concerns a very objective application traumatic spinal cord injury popula- not invent TM; the medical commu-
of rules; another part of this process tion or the MS population, we might nity discovered TM and this article at-
concerns a very subjective and human appear as some pesky group trying to tempts to make explicit on what basis
application of a totally different set of siphon off resources from the com- the discovery was made. The TMA
rules. The medical definitions have a mon good. And we are. Because the merely gave those with TM a voice
very real set of perhaps unintended common good provides for better and shined a spotlight on their experi-
social, emotional, psychological, and treatments and the possibility of re- ences. We helped those with TM find
financial consequences. I do not be- storative therapies for all people in each other and to start to organize an
lieve that there is anything unethical this large community. The common effort to compete for the resources that
or devious or unprofessional about the good will not, however, provide our are available. And we have begun to
“other” set of rules operating in this community with the answers to: what arm people with information to make
environment. After all it is the same is TM, what causes it; what is recur- them more effective advocates for
society and culture that establishes rent TM, what causes it; what is De- themselves and their loved ones.
both sets of rules and society very cer- vics, what causes it; what is ADEM,
tainly defines the goals that are held and what causes it. And I don’t think But if the TMA has helped to solidify
up as rewards from the application of we get to be a disease until we get TM, in my mind, that is a good thing –
both sets of rules. the answers to those questions. cause my wife has it; and a bunch of
doctors have told her she has it. But
I do believe that over the years, the There was a large and well organized what the TMA has accomplished in
comments I have heard do reflect a re- traumatic spinal cord injury commu- this regard does not compare with
luctance to define TM as a specific nity with a very large infrastructure what the Johns Hopkins Transverse
category of disease or disorder. I be- long before there was a TMA, and Myelitis Center has done. The TMA
lieve that the reluctance was, in part, there was no one who decided to spe- may have solidified TM into jello;
accounted for by the lack of under- cialize in the treatment of TM or fo- having a premier medical center in the
standing about what TM is and how it cus on TM research. The same can United States establish a center of ex-
relates to the other neuroimmunologic be said about the MS community. I cellence in TM has transformed it into
conditions. I also believe that this re- do not have great faith that the an- concrete.
luctance is partially motivated by the swers about TM are going to emanate
competition for the scarce resources from these existing disease commu- The TMA does not advocate for peo-
that are available for research and all nities. ple with MS. The reasons for this
of the other costs associated with the have nothing to do with the medical
existence of a particular disorder or There is no group or individual that definitions of the neuroimmunologic
disease. is not deserving of a share of these disorders. In fact, when it comes to
resources. Unfortunately, before research, we should be advocating for
The entire medical community is there was a TMA or a JHTMC or collaborative work. What is learned
competing for a finite amount of re- physicians interested in these condi- about TM will benefit the MS commu-
sources. These resources make re- tions, the likelihood that significant nity, and the reverse is also true. Un-
search, treatment, education, and resources would be made available to fortunately, for all of the other-than-
quality of life programs possible. our neighborhood of the neuroimmu- science reasons, at the present time,
These resources are also required for nologic community just because we there are few benefits to the TM, De-
the hiring of faculty, scientists or phy- were a population in need was not vics and ADEM communities as com-
sicians, the building of facilities, the good. So not good, in fact, that even pared to the disadvantages of a union
hiring of staff and the development of with our organizations, we still aren’t of efforts and organizations.
the enormous and complex infrastruc- getting any of it. But the potential
tures that support these people and or- for our ability to compete for re- Before I pull my pants down totally in
ganizations. The expenses are tre- sources is growing. public, I would like to make myself
mendous. perfectly clear about what I am con-
The physician who made the state- tending here. Our medical advisory
Who needs another disease with a ment about the relationship between board is well represented by physi-
separate infrastructure and all of the the TMA and a definition of TM did, cians who specialize in the treatment
costs associated with it? In this con- in fact, make a rather insightful com- of people with MS and research on
text, I fully appreciate the “balkanized ment about the social order and the MS. They have been incredibly gener-
concept.” From the perspective of the medical community. The TMA did ous in donating their time, expertise
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 7
and resources in providing so many have enough of their own issues to cry and sit shiva). Do we get the pic-
services and assistance to the TMA focus on without adding more. And, ture?
and the TM community. I have been as I noted, our members have been
on many an MS walk-a-thon and have embraced in far more instances than I left Baltimore thinking, wow, my
all of the t-shirts to prove it. We have we have been denied. head hurts and I could sure use an eas-
members in our Association who have ier hobby. I also felt really blessed to
MS; I love them the same as I love A person is one hundred times more be involved with such amazing peo-
our members with TM, ADEM and likely to get MS than they are to get ple. The physicians on our medical
Devics. I regularly suggest that our TM. I am concerned that if we advisory board are such a brilliant and
members, regardless of their diagno- joined forces with the MS commu- a wonderful group of people.
sis, be treated by a neurologist who nity, the answers about TM, ADEM,
specializes in the treatment of MS. I Devics, and the variants of these con- We have always had members with
have the utmost respect and apprecia- ditions would be further buried than recurrent TM, Devics, recurrent optic
tion for all of the good that has been they are now. As I have said many neuritis and ADEM. I am sorry that
done by the MS community! Some of times before, we benefit from MS re- you have been buried in our igno-
my best friends and favorite relatives search and from spinal injury re- rance. The TMA is committed to do-
have MS. search. The central issues for our ing more for you. I will work on hav-
community, however are not going to ing more information about these con-
I have been in contact with various be addressed in primarily MS re- ditions published in our newsletters.
people who work for the MS organi- search; we need a focus on our issues We will address more of your unique
zations. Most of them are not aware by our researchers. And we need to issues at our symposia. We will work
of TM. I have no idea what their do a better job of competing for our hard to encourage research across the
level of awareness or knowledge is of share of these scarce and valuable re- spectrum of neuroimmunologic condi-
Devics or ADEM, since I can’t say I sources. tions so that each condition is better
was all that aware of these disorders understood and so that the relation-
myself until our members began forc- I am developing a better awareness ships between them are better under-
ing me to learn about their conditions. of the other-than-scientific implica- stood. And we will work hard to be
I would assume their understanding of tions of these definitions. How we sure that there are physicians inter-
all of these conditions are about the are organized and defined is about ested and focused on your treatment,
same. They are focused on MS, as more than a disease classification and care, and quality of life.
they should be. it has implications for how we are
perceived by the medical community, And to conclude with total mayhem in
The MS community is not very highly by the government and private insti- this column, if you have Devics or Re-
sensitized to the existence of these tutions that fund research, education current TM or Recurrent Optic Neuri-
other conditions or their relationship and quality of life programs, and the tis, I would strongly encourage you to
to the class of neuroimmunologic dis- general public. Maybe all of this has join the MS organizations, to get on
orders to which MS also belongs. I been totally obvious to all of you; it their mailing list, to read their publica-
have heard from more than a few peo- wasn’t for me. But then let’s review tions, to pay close attention to MS re-
ple with TM that an MS doctor did the qualifications I bring to this job. search results and to participate in
not want to see them or feel comfort- I love Pauline very much. When she their education opportunities. Due to
able seeing them because their prac- got TM, it totally broke my heart and the element of recurrence in your con-
tice was limited to MS patients and I felt helpless to do anything to help ditions, you need to be fully educated
their expertise was MS. If physicians her. I ache to see people who are about the full range of treatment op-
are confused about the relationships frightened and hurting and I want to tions and any new treatments or medi-
between these conditions, I don’t ex- do something to make them less cations that are available or are in
pect the lay people who run these or- frightened and to make their hurts go clinical trials for multiple sclerosis.
ganizations to be any more highly away. I am willing to work hours You should probably be discussing
evolved. In fairness to the organiza- and hours for free. And I don’t have these issues with your physicians
tions and the physicians who compose enough good sense to keep my mouth regularly, and being aware of options
this community, if I were in their po- shut. Let’s see, never ran a company, is part of what makes you a good ad-
sition, I would likely be doing the never held a bake sale, and I insisted vocate for your care. These issues
same thing. They don’t have to pay that my lab partner pith the frog will be thoroughly addressed by the
any attention to us; and they certainly (while I excused myself to go vomit, MS organizations. And always re-
Page 8 The Transverse Myelitis Association
main a member of the TMA, because The Pathology of Transverse cord and how it relates to its function.
we are committed to making a differ- Myelitis But what is most important for us to
ence for you and we care about you! Carlos A. Pardo, MD understand is what went wrong and
why? In other words, pathology, the
We are going to remain the TMA; it Assistant Professor of Neurology science of Quincy (my favorite TV
may become a vestigial name reflect- and Pathology, Johns Hopkins show in the 80’s!), is closely related
ing the state of medical understanding University School of Medicine to the science of criminology, as we
in the early 21st century. For now, Co-Director, Johns Hopkins learned from Sherlock Holmes. Pa-
I’m not paid enough to be motivated Transverse Myelopathy Center thology is then the science that inves-
to think of a new name and then tigates the scene of the crime, the evi-
change it on every publication we cur- dence, the actors and the killers. By
What happened in my spinal cord?
rently produce, not to mention the studying the pathology of TM, we
What does myelitis mean?
work Jim would have to do on the want to find out what happened and
What is transverse myelitis?
web site. So, read TM, think neuro- why. Understanding these questions
Why did I lose bladder control?
immunologic. will help us to apprehend the crimi-
Why do I have pain several months
nals.
after my attack of TM?
The Transverse Myelitis Association
advocates for people who have trans- Understanding the spinal cord …
These are just some of the many
verse myelitis, recurrent transverse the scene of the crime!
questions that all patients suffering
myelitis, recurrent transverse myelitis
from transverse myelitis ask after
and recurrent optic neuritis or Devics The spinal cord is an extension of the
confronting the reality of this prob-
Disease; recurrent optic neuritis; and central nervous system that estab-
lem and its effect on activities of
acute disseminating encephalomye- lishes a structural connection be-
daily living. Often neurologists tak-
litis or ADEM – and their loved ones tween the brain and the other struc-
ing care of TM patients understand
and caregivers. tures of the body (e.g., arms and legs,
the problem, potential causes and
bowel, bladder) through nerve fibers.
consequences. However, for patients
Please take good care of yourselves Located inside of the spinal column,
and families, much of our explanation
and each other. the spinal cord is an elongated and
is just jargon with no real meaning.
cylindrical structure of the central
Sooner or later, after long hours of
nervous system that is divided into
reading and web searches, some
regions that correspond to the bony
questions may be answered, but many
The TMA does not endorse any of the column in which it is located. So, we
remain unanswered. What I would
medications, treatments or products have the cervical, thoracic and lum-
like to do in this short introduction to
reported in this newsletter. This in- bar-sacral regions of the spinal cord
the pathology of transverse myelitis
formation is intended only to keep that serve different parts of the pe-
is to explain what we have learned
you informed. We strongly advise riphery. We can say, for example,
about this condition and how the un-
that you check any drugs or treat- that the cervical spinal cord serves
derstanding of the problems that oc-
ments mentioned with your physician. arm function, the thoracic is mostly
cur during those first few minutes,
for chest and abdominal organs and
hours, days or weeks of spinal cord
the lumbar-sacral cord serves the legs
damage may help us establish better
and genitalia (Figure 1). Since the
treatment approaches and improve
spinal cord is really the bridge be-
quality of life.
tween the brain and periphery, the in-
© The Transverse Myelitis Associa- formation traveling along the cord
tion Newsletter is published by The Let me start by explaining the mean-
goes in two directions.
Transverse Myelitis Association, Se- ing of the word pathology. My Web-
attle, Washington. Copyright 2003 by ster’s says that pathology is “the
In one direction, the spinal cord car-
The Transverse Myelitis Association. study of the essential nature of dis-
ries information from the brain to pe-
All rights reserved. We ask that other eases and specifically of the struc-
ripheral areas, particularly motor
publications contact us for permission tural and functional changes pro-
function that facilitates movement
to reprint any article from The Trans- duced by them.” So, to understand
(descending information). Nerve fi-
verse Myelitis Association Newslet- the pathology of TM, we need to un-
bers called motor nerves originate in
ters. derstand the structure of the spinal
the spinal cord as part of the periph-
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 9
These pathways are located in the ex-
ternal portion of the spinal cord, in
what we call white matter (Figure 2).
There are then different pathways spe-
cifically located within the white mat-
ter of the spinal cord. Each pathway
carries specific motor information
down to the motor nerves (descending
pathways) and the periphery or carries
specific sensory information from the
periphery to the brain (ascending in-
formation).
observe complete transection of the TM. One of them is the itis or, as I TM, it is much better to set things
cord, we then have patients with a ful- explained, the inflammation of the straight.
minate disruption of cord function. cord. The other one is a well known
This is the reason some patients and criminal … and the name is …. Lets learn about the criminals!
also physicians talk about a “partial” Well, there is no well established
transverse myelitis or “incomplete” name, but we know that this criminal There are two major gangs of crimi-
transverse myelitis to define the ex- resembles the famous stroke of the nals in TM. One big gang is the itis
tent of the structural damage of the brain or stroke of the heart that at- gang. The other I will call the bloody
cord. tacks many other patients. Yes, in gang. We now know that the -itis
many patients with TM, the criminal gang produces inflammation of the
Now, the other problem in the defini- is a stroke of the cord. Since the cord and subsequently damages and
tion is what myelitis means in TM. As term transverse myelitis has been destroys focal areas. These are the
a pathology term, everything that with us for many years, it is now dif- real myelitis cases. The bloody gang
ends with -itis means inflammation. ficult to modify the term. In many in- targets blood supply to the cord either
For example, encephalitis means in- stances, we would prefer to call the by a stroke of the cord occluding
flammation of the brain. Opthalmitis problem Myelopathy instead of blood vessels or via malformed blood
means inflammation of the eye. Hepa- Myelitis to mean that there has been vessels or by attacking blood vessels
titis means inflammation of the liver. a “…-pathy” of the spinal cord or, supplying different areas of the spinal
So, myelitis would mean inflamma- in more accurate terms, a damage or cord. To understand how these gangs
tion of the spinal cord. But again, the injury to the cord. As I said before, operate take a look at Figure 3.
reality is that not all cases of TM are many of these words are just medical
myelitis; not all problems are caused terms with no real meaning for pa- One branch (itis) is associated with
by inflammation of the cord. To ex- tients, where the consequences of direct infection of the spinal cord pro-
plain this situation, I need to name the “TM” are the same regardless of the duced by viruses, bacteria, fungi or
two major “criminals” involved in the cause of the problem. But since we parasites. This can affect any region
“crime” against the spinal cord in are talking about the pathology of of the spinal cord: cervical, thoracic
Page 12 The Transverse Myelitis Association
or lumbo-sacral. The extent of the at- fending. Some known disorders in- volved, itis (inflammation) or non-it is
tack and damage to the cord is vari- clude Systemic Lupus Erythemato- (non-inflammation or pathy), is the
able and depends on the type of or- sus, a disorder in which auto- first approach for an adequate treat-
ganism involved. Some parasites, antibodies are excessively produced. ment in TM patients. That is the rea-
such as those that cause schistosomi- Others, such as multiple sclerosis, a son we jump to do more investigation,
asis and cisticercosis, and viruses, neurological disease associated with such as the use of imaging by mag-
such as herpes, belong to this gang. autoimmunity, is frequently of con- netic resonance or studies of the cere-
The main crime occurs when these or- cern when patients are diagnosed brospinal fluid. These “searches” help
ganisms invade the spinal cord pro- with transverse myelitis. In many of clarify whether the suspect is part of
ducing focal damage to the cord by the autoimmune disorders, damage to the gang itis or bloody and help iden-
triggering inflammation and destruc- the blood vessels and subsequent in- tify treatment modalities. One exam-
tion of the white matter, gray matter jury to the white or gray matter struc- ple of this concern is when patients
or both. The inflammation may tures of the cord are the main cause are identified as having transverse
spread like wild fire along the cord or of the problem. myelitis, it is believed that use of cor-
may remain localized. The acute ticosteroids may improve the inflam-
clinical presentation depends on the No blood … no function! mation. Of course, when the problem
extent and magnitude of the inflam- is transverse myelopathy, things may
matory reaction mediated by white The no-itis “bloody” gang is, of turn out to be more difficult and com-
blood cells and proteins from the course, associated with blood. The plicated. The reason for the complica-
bloodstream. blood supply to the spinal cord is tion, no it is, no inflammation, no re-
fundamental to its function. Any dis- sponse to corticosteroids (or at least,
The postinfectious branch is formed turbance produced to the blood sup- that it is what we believe)!
by “friendly fire” from our immune ply of the cord may have deleterious
system. The body’s defense mecha- consequences and is a major concern How to clarify the pathology of
nism, our immune system, is com- when evaluating patients with trans- TM?
prised of two lines, proteins called im- verse myelopathy (oops, this is pathy
munoglobulins that try to neutralize rather than itis!). The “bloody” gang The gang names are important to un-
the infective agent and white blood may have different faces. One face is derstanding TM and its consequences.
cells that also attack the infective malformation. Abnormal and mal- Different approaches of investigation,
agent or produce substances to neu- formed blood vessels form dysfunc- imaging by MRI, spinal fluid studies
tralize the infection. In the majority tional blood vessels called arterio- or blood testing, facilitate some an-
of cases, our immune system tri- venous malformations, which are as- swers to questions. Occasionally, the
umphs, defending our body from di- sociated with decreased blood supply use of “biopsies” or tissue sampling
verse types of infections. But in few to the cord and injury to the white or for microscopic examination is re-
cases, they mistakenly attack parts of gray matter structures. Another face quired. All of these studies are not su-
the nervous system. Our immune sys- is clogged pipes, in which blood ves- perfluous, they are necessary to our
tem self attacks and damages parts of sels supplying the cord get occluded understanding this condition and how
the spinal cord or brain. Immu- by arteriosclerosis, clots or injury to treat its consequences. After assess-
noglobulins or white cells, generated produced by herniated discs or ment and identification of the sources
against the spinal cord weeks or masses external to the cord. In many of the problem, the next step is to
months after infections, such as gas- patients, the attack is quite fast, leav- evaluate the magnitude of the problem
troenteritis or upper respiratory infec- ing behind a lot of spinal cord dam- or, in other words, how much damage
tions, trigger additional inflammatory age. Occasionally, the face of this was done and what we need to do for
chain reactions that damage the struc- gang may turn “bloody” due to hem- improvement.
ture of the cord. As in the case of di- orrhages inside the cord.
rect infection of the cord, the inflam- Next: How the pathology determines
mation can spread along the cord or Why the identification of the crimi- the presence or absence of symp-
may remain localized. nal’s last name is important! toms? Why do I have pain months
after my TM?
The third well known branch is com- The criminal investigation or the
prised of a group of systemic autoim- pathological investigation is just the
mune disorders in which the immune search for the reason why? and how?
system turns against the body it is de- Understanding the criminal gang in-
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 13
Depression in TM the Johns Hopkins TM Center in col- with whom to compare experiences,
Adam Kaplin, MD, PhD laboration between the Departments and so feelings of isolation are all too
of Neurology and Psychiatry has be- often the norm.
Dr. Kaplin is an Assistant gun to shed light on the prevalence of
Professor of the Department of depression as a reflection of autoim- Sometimes an individual’s capacity to
Psychiatry at the Johns Hopkins mune disease activity in TM. Before adapt is overwhelmed by the stresses
University School of Medicine and reviewing the findings of this pre- with which he is confronted, and he
serves as the Chief Psychiatric liminary research, we must first dif- becomes discouraged, bewildered and
consultant to the Johns Hopkins ferentiate demoralization, which is a overwhelmed. This is a state called de-
Transverse Myelitis and Multiple psychological state of overwhelming moralization. Demoralization has been
Sclerosis Centers. Dr. Kaplin also sadness appearing as a consequence defined (Frank JD 1991) as a state of
serves on The Transverse Myelitis of adverse circumstances, from clini- helplessness, hopelessness, confusion,
Association Medical Advisory cal depression, which we view as a subjective incompetence, isolation and
Board. disease of the brain. diminished self-esteem. The subjective
experience of demoralization involves
Demoralization feeling incapable of meeting both in-
Traditionally, Transverse Myelitis ternal and external expectations, feel-
(TM) has been thought of as a spinal There is no despair so absolute as ings of being trapped and powerless to
cord disease, affecting motor, sensory, that which comes with the first mo- change or escape, and feelings of be-
bowel, bladder and sexual function as ments of our first great sorrow, when ing unique and, therefore, not under-
a result of a spinal lesion visible by we have not yet known what it is to stood. The combined effect usually
neuroimaging studies. However, TM have suffered and be healed, to have leads to frustration, bewilderment and
is an autoimmune neurologic disease despaired and have recovered hope. isolation.
of the Central Nervous System George Eliot (1819-1880)
(CNS), with activated immune cells To combat the feelings of failure, be-
seen (by spinal tap) floating in the Sadness is an understandable and ing overwhelmed and a sense of isola-
Cerebro-Spinal Fluid (CSF) that predictable response to suddenly tion that collectively represent demor-
bathes the spinal cord and brain to- finding oneself thrust against one’s alization, people must be taught how
gether. TM is probably best thought will into a life under altered circum- to achieve remoralization. Assistance
of as lying on a continuum with recur- stances, in which there is a need to with developing problem-focused cop-
rent Optic Neuritis (that affects the accept losses of desired abilities and ing skills can instill a new sense of
optic nerves that carries visual signals confrontation with unwanted strug- progressive mastery. For example,
from the eye to the brain), Neuromye- gles. Thus is the case with all chronic building rest periods into an afternoon
litis Optica (involving the optic nerves diseases. In addition to the poten- schedule can combat fatigue. Shop-
and spinal cord), and Multiple Sclero- tially dramatic disability that can af- ping at off-peak times can avoid feel-
sis (which can affect anywhere in the flict patients with TM, this disease ings of being rushed and embarrassed
CNS). The traditional view of TM as has certain aspects that make it par- publicly because of a disability. Indi-
solely a spinal cord disease, which ticularly difficult for many patients to vidual and group support and educa-
persists today, has eclipsed considera- endure. It is more difficult to adapt to tion can help combat hopelessness and
tion of the effects of this autoimmune acute rather than gradual changes, isolation. Cognitive reframing can be
disease on the brain. Multiple Sclero- and TM begins without warning and employed to help examine unfair as-
sis (MS), in contrast, has had a fair evolves over hours to days. More- sumptions. For example, reexamining
amount of research into the effect of over, the fact that TM is an uncom- the beliefs that all of the gains
this autoimmune disease on the brain. mon ailment has two troubling con- achieved through rehabilitation are in-
A growing body of work has begun to sequences for those affected. First, significant, because they did not result
shed light on the impact of this brain physicians are not often familiar with in complete recovery helps dispel un-
involvement in producing depression. the diagnosis, prognosis and manage- realistic short-term expectations.
In fact, MS has the highest rate of de- ment of TM, and, as a result, patients Sometimes gaining an appreciation for
pression thus far described in any ma- commonly go undiagnosed, inade- one’s own accomplishments by view-
jor chronic disease, with 20% of pa- quately educated and under-treated. ing them through someone else’s per-
tients suffering from depression at any Second, many patients affected with spective can be very comforting and
given time and a lifetime prevalence TM have no contact with anyone else inspiring.
of depression over 50%. Work done at in their area with this disease, and
Page 14 The Transverse Myelitis Association
Psychosocial Impact and Long lation of several symptoms that clus- Depression during the course of their
Term Adaptation ter together in affected individuals. lifetime. Depression is a very debili-
Sadness is to Depression what cough tating disease. Compared to the lead-
MS, being more common, has been is to pneumonia; cough can be an in- ing medical causes of chronic disabil-
investigated more extensively than dicator of pneumonia, but not every ity, Depression is second only to heart
TM. A study of MS patients whose cough is the result of pneumonia and disease in terms of its impact on daily
average time since diagnosis was nine sometimes pneumonia can present functioning. Depression is also a le-
years, examined their subjective ex- without a cough. If the cough is pro- thal disease, resulting in suicide in up
periences and the psychosocial conse- ductive of green mucous and accom- to 15% of those severely affected. In
quences of their disease (Mohr, Dick panied by fever, rapid breathing and the United States, suicide is the third
et al. 1999). The results of this study evidence of infection in a lung by ex- leading cause of death in those 1-24
are very instructive, in that they dem- amination or x-ray, we call this the years of age, and the fourth leading
onstrate that even though autoimmune syndrome pneumonia. What then is cause for young adults aged 24-44. In
neurologic diseases can be difficult to the syndrome of Major Depressive MS, suicide is the third leading cause
adapt to acutely, most patients appre- Disorder (as Depression is referred to of death overall, after pneumonia and
ciate, over time, the beneficial as well in the medical literature)? The cardi- cancer, and occurs at a rate 7.5 times
as detrimental effects of their illness nal features are a fixed and unre- that of the general population. Com-
on their lives. In this study, the mi- sponsive low mood, poor self- pared to other common causes of
nority of patients (20%) reported that attitude or self-esteem and decreased death in MS, suicide tends to occur in
MS had led to a deterioration in their vitality. How can these features be relatively younger individuals who
relationships, most often character- translated into straightforward diag- have milder disability, making the
ized as concerns that they were not as nostic criteria? years of life lost particularly tragic.
good a mate or that their partners
were angry or irritated more often. The Diagnostic and Statistical Man- We are no more accustomed to think-
There were 30% who reported feeling ual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV) is ing about how our brains regulate our
demoralized, with feelings of sadness, the main diagnostic reference of moods, much as thermostats regulate
loss of independence, or uncertainty Mental Health professionals in the the temperature within our homes,
about the future. The majority of pa- United States. The DSM-IV criteria than we are to considering how our
tients (60%) endorsed finding benefit for Major Depression require the brains facilitate our use of language to
as a result of contracting their disease: presence of at least five of the nine communicate. Although it can result
their relationships seemed closer, they following symptoms: 1) decreased from a combination of genetic predis-
felt they were more compassionate interest (or pleasure) and/or; 2) low positions and environmental stressors,
and communicative, and they gained mood; 3) increased or decreased a number of medical diseases are
a better appreciation of, and perspec- sleep; 4) increased or decreased ap- known to predispose to Depression.
tive on, life. Thus, over time, as the petite; 5) feelings of guilt or worth- Neuropsychiatric diseases that cause
body and mind adapt to life under al- lessness; 6) subjective sense of fa- insults to the brain are known to be as-
tered circumstances, unrelenting sad- tigue or low energy; 7) poor concen- sociated with extremely high rates of
ness is usually tempered by adapta- tration; 8) feeling/appearing as Depression. Diseases such as strokes,
tion, appreciation and growth. De- though one’s thoughts and actions brain tumors, Alzheimers and Parkin-
pression is among the reasons that in- are either slowed down (e.g., drag- sons disease are associated with rates
dividuals find themselves incapable ging) or sped up (e.g., agitated); and of Depression between 30-50%. Im-
of coping with their disease and mov- 9) thoughts of death or suicide. portantly, studies have shown that De-
ing on with their lives, even after pression in such diseases is not simply
many months or years. Because the minority of individuals an inevitable reaction to severe adver-
suffering from depression seek treat- sity. For example, Amyotrophic Lat-
What is Depression? ment, and those that do often conceal eral Sclerosis (also known as ALS or
their diagnosis from friends because Lou Gehrig’s Disease) is a selective
The sadness that accompanies demor- of the stigma that surrounds mental motor neuron disease resulting in the
alization is not equivalent to clinical illness, the prevalence of Depression paralysis of all skeletal muscles,
depression (which will subsequently is often unappreciated. In the general which follows a relentless course and
be referred to as Depression). Sad- population, Depression affects 5% of usually results in death from respira-
ness is a symptom whereas Depres- individuals at any given time, and tory failure or aspiration in three to
sion is a clinical syndrome; a constel- 17% of individuals will suffer from five years. There is no general insult
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 15
to the brain and there is no increase in natively, an effect of sensory symp- have noted that a minority of TM pa-
the rate of Depression seen in patients toms on patient’s mood cannot be tients, even those without depression
afflicted with this devastating illness. determined from these findings. It and on no medications, report that fol-
Thus, Depression should not be as- may be fair to suggest that of the lowing the onset of their neurologic
sumed to be an inevitable or even known ongoing chronic symptoms of disease, they could no longer remem-
common outcome of misfortune TM, sensory symptoms (including ber as many details without writing
alone. chronic pain) may be among the them down, and required additional
most distressing and difficult to ac- time to complete complex mental
Of all the medical conditions reported commodate. An additional associa- tasks.
to date, MS is believed to have the tion was found between rates of De-
highest rate of associated Depression, pression and history of IV steroid Special Considerations in TM
with a lifetime prevalence following treatment. Patients who received IV Depression
diagnosis of 50-60% (Patten and Metz steroids did not appear to differ with
1997). Evidence for a role of the im- respect to the severity of symptoms The importance of making the diagno-
mune system’s effects on the brain as at presentation or level of ongoing sis of Depression in TM cannot be
a contributor to Depression in MS in- disability following recovery. The overestimated. Often what is most de-
cludes the following three findings: 1) possibility cannot yet be excluded bilitating is not the requirement for
patients with MS who become de- that those patients who appeared assistance with walking or the chronic
pressed do not have a greater likeli- most distressed because of Depres- pain that must be endured, but the De-
hood of having depressed relatives sion at the time of presentation were pression that leads to difficulty getting
than non-depressed MS patients, sug- more likely to be treated with IV out of bed, social isolation and low-
gesting an insult, and not a genetic steroids. Because steroids are known ered pain tolerance. Routinely for pa-
predisposition, plays the key role, 2) to cause Depression in numerous tients with TM and Depression, the
Depression increases during periods other patient populations, the finding majority of their disability is due to
of immune-system activation resulting of higher rates of Depression in TM the Depression and treatment leads to
in disease exacerbation, and 3) there patients who received steroid treat- a dramatic increase in their function.
is no correlation between the degree ment suggests that it would be pru- Depression, despite its often devastat-
of disability and occurrence of De- dent to closely monitor the patient’s ing impact on patients, is a treatable
pression in MS patients. mood, if they receive such treat- disease with the majority of patients
ments. who receive adequate treatment able
TM and Depression to make a complete symptomatic re-
We found high rates of Depression in covery. What is required to achieve
Work done in the Johns Hopkins TM TM reminiscent of what had been this result is often the same level of
Center in collaboration between the described previously in MS. We aggressive management that TM pa-
Departments of Neurology and Psy- wondered whether this Depression tients routinely invest in managing
chiatry has begun to examine the rates was a marker for brain involvement other aspects of the effects of their
of Depression in patients with TM. due to immune-activation in the disease, such as physical therapy and
Only a summary of the initial findings CNS. In addition to high rates of De- rehabilitation to enhance ambulation,
will be presented here. Evidence was pression, patients with MS also suf- or urologic consultation for bladder
obtained for rates of Depression in fer from elevated rates of cognitive management. Before Depression can
TM patients exceeding those seen in impairment manifesting as difficul- be managed, however, it must be
comparably disabled MS patients. As ties with certain tasks of concentra- properly diagnosed.
in previous studies of MS patients, tion, short-term recall of details and
there was no correlation between se- processing speed. When we exam- As in the case of many medical or
verity of Depression in TM patients ined mental processing in TM pa- neurologic diseases, recognizing De-
and motor, bladder or sexual dysfunc- tients, we found preliminary evi- pression in TM patients can be chal-
tion. There was a modest correlation dence that they excelled at many lenging because of the overlap of
between Depression and sensory dis- cognitive tasks. There were subtle symptoms between these psychiatric
ability (predominantly symptoms as- paper-and-pencil tests, however, on and neurologic diseases. Fatigue and
sociated with prickling, tingling or which some TM patients performed poor concentration, for example, oc-
numbness). Whether this represents a worse than expected, and these were cur in many patients with TM making
lowered tolerance for these symptoms the same tests that often were diffi- reliance on these symptoms difficult
in patients with Depression or, alter- cult for MS patients. Clinically, we in making a diagnosis of Depression.
Page 16 The Transverse Myelitis Association
Certain clues that can help differenti- trained professional can confirm and sants based on a perception that they
ate symptoms of TM from those of assist with the treatment of Depres- do not want to “end up like a zombie”
Depression can be recommended. sion. If there is any question about based on knowing or having heard of
Feelings of self-blame, guilt and self- whether a person is afflicted with De- someone who was not the same once
recrimination are not common reac- pression, an evaluation should cer- they started taking medication. The
tions to a medical illness, but are al- tainly be requested. fallacy in this argument is that De-
most always found to some degree in pression is far more likely to make
Depression. The pervasiveness of Barriers to Seeking and Accepting someone appear impaired then is the
symptoms can also suggest Depres- Treatment for TM Depression medication that is started to treat his
sion. Low mood most of the time or mood disorder. While it is true that
loss of pleasure in activities that re- Rehabilitation and recovery from TM medications that are used to treat
quire skills that are made more diffi- is often a painstaking and laborious other mental disorders, such as
cult because of neurologic deficits journey. Adjusting to life under al- schizophrenia, can produce noticeable
can occur commonly in TM, particu- tered circumstances when neurologic side effects such as over-sedation and
larly during the first few weeks of ad- deficits become long-term can be stiffness, the judicious use of antide-
justment to this disease. But low dramatically taxing. Unfortunately, pressants by trained psychiatrists re-
mood all of the time, and lack of symptoms of Depression, such as sults in a return to previous function-
pleasure in all activities should raise hopelessness and loss of interest, are ing in patients in whom Depression
suspicion for Depression. Similarly, a often first interpreted as “giving up” has made their behavior different. The
failure to progress beyond the acute and equated with being “weak” or goal with antidepressant therapy is to
shock of being afflicted with TM after “lazy.” Moreover, many people return an effected individual to the
many months or years should raise equate Depression with being helm of their own ship, and allow
questions about a supervening De- “crazy” and so avoid seeking treat- them better to chart the course of their
pression. The statement “He/She is ment for this reason. Recognizing thoughts, emotions and behaviors as
not the same person since the disease that Depression is a chemical imbal- they regain control of the direction
hit,” many months after the disease ance in the brain that is treated with a their life is taking. Rather than de-
onset, should also raise suspicion for class of chemicals called antidepres- velop noticeable side effects that sug-
a Depression. If an individual was sants, rather than a character flaw or gest a person is being treated for de-
progressing well, initially, in terms of personal failure, can sometimes pression with medication, the only
their recovery from their neurologic prove helpful in combating this thing that other people notice is that
deficits, but suddenly stopped pro- stigma. the person being treated seems “more
gressing and, in fact, began to lose like their old self.”
ground, the possibility of Depression Preconceptions and myths about anti-
should be entertained as a possible depressants also represent common The biggest barrier to seeking and ac-
cause. Finally, suicidal thoughts are barriers to accepting treatment for cepting treatment for depression, bar
the result of Depression until proven Depression. Antidepressants specifi- none, is the effects of depression it-
otherwise, and should prompt an ur- cally target and treat changes in the self, which makes people hopeless,
gent assessment by a trained physi- brains of patients who are suffering unmotivated and unable to imagine
cian or Mental Health professional. from Depression, but they have no that things could get better. Ironically,
This is because the rate of suicide in mood elevating effects on individuals it is these same symptoms of Depres-
TM Depression appears at least as who are not depressed. As a result, sion that are among the important rea-
great, if not greater, as that found in antidepressants are not addicting, like sons an individual requires treatment,
other medical conditions. drugs that induce euphoria, and they yet they interfere with his ability to
have no street value. And antidepres- get the help he needs. The following
Ultimately, the diagnosis of Depres- sants do not give people “fake” feel- three points can help overcome the in-
sion can best be made by an individ- ings or make them feel things they ertia of such situations. First, success-
ual, usually a physician, with exten- would not normally feel. Instead, an- ful treatment of Depression requires
sive training and expertise in mood tidepressants restore the normal cycle an individual be compliant with his
disorders, such as a psychiatrist. Just of ups and downs, in response to treatment, not that he believe he will
as individuals afflicted with TM life’s rewards and stresses, that is lost return to being well. Second, in light
could not rely on their own knowl- in individuals suffering from Depres- of the fact that what has been tried has
edge or that of their loved ones to sion. Finally, individuals occasion- clearly not succeeded in changing the
make the neurologic diagnosis, only a ally refrain from using antidepres- situation, accepting treatment for De-
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 17
pression is often the only reasonable mood disorder. sion, on the other hand, is a disease
course of action. Even if treatment that appears to be at least, in part, a
were to fail, the person will certainly Four issues can be recommended for direct result of the effects of the acti-
be no worse off for having tried caregivers to keep in mind in caring vated immune system in TM patients
something new. And third, sometimes for their loved ones without neglect- on their brain. Depression is not a
we must all accept the advice of our ing themselves. First, caregivers character flaw or sign of personal
loved ones, knowing that it is offered should enhance their problem- weakness, anymore than is diabetes or
in good faith and with an objectivity focused coping skills. This usually hypertension. Like other medical ill-
that may elude us for the moment, es- involves recognizing what can and nesses, Depression is a disease that is
pecially in situations where our own cannot be changed, and trying differ- associated with considerable morbid-
judgment may be compromised by an ent solutions to the problems that ity and mortality, and, therefore, must
illness. To this end, caregivers often arise until the right one is found. be aggressively identified and treated.
play a critical role in persuading pa- Both caregivers and care recipients Fortunately, Depression is also one of
tients to seek and accept treatment for must avoid entrenchment in failed the most treatable consequences of
their Depression. solutions that only serve to increase TM, with the expectation that indi-
distress. Second, information is cru- viduals will make a complete recov-
Who Cares for the Caregivers? cial because what caregivers don’t ery with proper management. Finally,
know about TM and Depression will it is imperative to consider the impact
There are both positive and negative increase their anxiety and prevent that TM and Depression have on both
aspects of being a caregiver; in real- them from being able to efficiently patients and their loved ones, because
ity, being able to care for the people problem solve. Peer education op- success will ultimately be measured in
whom we love, in their time of need, portunities are often invaluable for how well individuals are functioning
is both a privilege and a burden. A both information and support. Third, in the context of their families.
full consideration of the impact of caregivers must remember to peri-
TM on caregivers goes beyond the odically ask themselves “how am I It has been argued in this article that
scope of this article. It is necessary to doing?” Taking care of their own Depression in TM, as has been sug-
point out, however, that caregivers needs should not be viewed as being gested in MS, can be the result of the
are dramatically impacted by both in conflict with the care recipient’s immune system’s influence on the
TM and Depression in the people needs. Caregivers are no good to brain. We are actively pursuing the
whom they love. Despite this fact, their care recipients if they are burnt mechanisms underlying this influ-
caregivers, care recipients and health out, and knowing how to get addi- ence. Recent studies have reported on
care providers usually focus virtually tional help is often critical to the the effect that treating Depression has
all of their attention on the well being wellbeing of both parties. And on immune system functioning. Pre-
of the patient with TM and Depres- fourth, caregivers and care recipients liminary studies have suggested that
sion, often to the neglect of concerns must not lose sight of the obvious Depressed MS patients have even
for the caregiver. In general, the care- fact that they are in this together. more aggressive immune systems, ca-
giver’s health status is often compro- Coping strategies must therefore be pable of wreaking greater neurologic
mised because of neglect of their own complimentary. There are often mul- damage, than their non-depressed
health. This occurs despite the fact tiple solutions to the same problems, counterparts (Mohr, Goodkin et al.
that the wellbeing of the care recipi- so a premium should often be placed 2001). Treatment of Depression in
ent is often vitally dependent on the on maintaining enough flexibility to these MS patients led to an ameliora-
continued efforts and support from maximize the benefits for both care tion of their immune system, suggest-
the caregiver, which can best be fur- recipients and caregivers. ing that treating Depression could be
nished by a healthy individual. Stud- of important benefit to patient’s neu-
ies have shown that the care recipient Conclusion rologic as well as psychiatric wellbe-
variables associated with increased ing.
caregiver burden include an unstable Sadness and demoralization are
course, increased physical disability, commonly the result of the acute Many patients with TM suffer greatly,
pain and depression. Since Depres- hardships that people afflicted with often without timely diagnosis or
sion exacerbates all of these variables, TM are made to undergo. Time to treatment of their neurologic disease.
caregivers often have a very real per- adjust and strategies to achieve re- Importantly, the Depression that can
sonal stake in whether a care recipient moralization are the keys to recovery accompany this disease should not
receives adequate treatment for their from these acute situations. Depres- similarly be overlooked or inade-
Page 18 The Transverse Myelitis Association
quately treated, because of the tremen- The Spiritual Life of all of the TM patients I see report
dous benefits patients and their loved Transverse Myelitis struggles with questions such as ‘why
ones can obtain from proper manage- Rabbi Gary A. Huber did this happen to me?’ A history of
ment. past or current religious conviction
Congregation Beth Tikvah
can be one of my greatest allies as a
psychiatrist in attempting to assist my
The one law that does not change is patients with turning away from sui-
Several months ago I asked my
that everything changes, and the hard- cide as an option and finding structure
friend Sandy Siegel if I could write
ship I was bearing today was only a and support for themselves especially
an article for the Newsletter regard-
breath away from the pleasures I during grim times.” Actually, at first
ing spiritual approaches in coping
would have tomorrow, and those pleas- I fully expected to hear many tales of
with all of the difficult physical, so-
ures would be all the richer because of how the disease had utterly destroyed
cial and emotional issues surround-
the memories of this I was enduring. any sense of faith in God or even faith
ing TM. My inspiration for this goes
Louis L’Amour (1908-1988) in the goodness of life. I was wrong.
back to the wonderfully happy event
of Sandy and Pauline’s wedding, at If anything, my conversations with
which I had the great joy and honor several individuals point in the oppo-
of officiating. I officiate at many site direction: a growth in faith and a
Bibliography weddings but I cannot recall in my deepening of faith. But the faith of
25 years as a rabbi a more joyous people with TM is not the same as be-
Frank JD, F. J. (1991). Persuasion and event. The sanctuary seemed to fore their diagnosis. It is a more
healing: A comparative study of psy- glow from the happiness of the gath- thoughtful, more profound and a more
chotherapy. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins ered guests who came to share their mature faith. By that I mean a faith
University Press. love with two very special people. that comes after many a “dark night of
But this event was unique in another the soul” and after periods of anger at
Mohr, D. C., L. P. Dick, et al. (1999). regard: many of the guests present God.
"The psychosocial impact of multiple had lived many years with TM or
sclerosis: exploring the patient's per- were related to someone with TM. This bears some comment. As a cler-
spective." Health Psychol 18(4): 376- gyman, I am never worried about
82. Reflecting back on this, I wondered someone being angry at God. Anger
if there were special issues relating at God following a diagnosis of TM is
Mohr, D. C., D. E. Goodkin, et al. to the spiritual life affecting folks a natural and expected reaction to a
(2001). "Treatment of depression is as- with TM and their families. At life-transforming event. And, in a
sociated with suppression of nonspe- Sandy’s encouragement, I inter- very real sense, it is a statement of in-
cific and antigen-specific T(H)1 re- viewed about 15 individuals and timacy with God. After all, you can
sponses in multiple sclerosis." Arch families, as well as several medical only be angry at someone you believe
Neurol 58(7): 1081-6. specialists, as to the role of spiritual- exists and has an important role in
ity and religious faith in their life. your life. I recall the words of the
Patten, S. B. and L. M. Metz (1997). And what I discovered is that they Nobel laureate Elie Weisel, who alone
"Depression in multiple sclerosis." Psy- have a very special insight into the of his entire family survived the hell
chother Psychosom 66(6): 286-92. life of the spirit that is both deeply of Auschwitz: “I can sometimes be
inspirational as well as profoundly very angry at God and sometimes I
insightful. People with TM and their can be very much in love with God,
families have much to teach the but I can never be without God.” I
world about the role of faith and the know that many people with TM have
meaning of human suffering. felt the same. Anger at God is an ex-
pected emotion for folks who suffer
No doubt, the central emotional chal- from such a difficult illness. The
lenge relating to TM is clinical de- question is: does one get stuck at an-
pression. And the sense of despair ger or does one move on in the life of
often takes on a religious dimension. faith? The testament of the people I
Dr. Adam Kaplin, professor of psy- interviewed is one of very impressive
chiatry at Johns Hopkins School of spiritual growth.
Medicine, told me that “many if not
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 19
In what ways? Though the respon- “my hope and strength to deal with was very interesting is that not one of
dents (and their families) were from a TM on a daily basis comes mostly my respondents said that they felt they
large variety of religious traditions through knowing God's character and were being punished with TM for be-
and practices, all of them to a person His promises” and that “my disease ing a bad, sinful person. They are not
expressed three fundamental gifts that makes me look upon others with only wise in this response, but they
their religious faith bestowed on their great compassion, because I know all said the very opposite. Each of them
lives: a feeling of gratitude, a sense about suffering. This, too, is part of expressed how deeply loved they felt
of perspective and a renewed experi- God’s plan for me.” by God and how worthy of that love
ence of self-esteem. From a psycho- they felt. Said one person: “I feel
logical standpoint, these three com- Perspective. Another theme that comfortable and confident with the re-
prise the fundamental armor, a kind emerged in my conversations is that lationship I have with God and I know
of immune system, in the daily battle one’s religious faith literally gives that I am very blessed. I believe God
against depression. From a theologi- one the largest perspective one could loves me and accepts me just the way
cal standpoint, they point to the life hope for: the perspective of God. It I am. I am in control of my life and
God wants, I believe, for each of His is to see one’s pain from the larger take responsibility for my ac-
children: one of spiritual fulfillment, and grand perspective of eternity or tions. Bad things do happen to peo-
empathetic compassion for others and God’s purpose and thus to achieve a ple, and life is very difficult at
a fundamental regard for one’s self. degree of separation between one’s times. Still, I think God does have a
self and one’s body. As one person plan for my life, and occasionally he
Gratitude. One definition of grati- put it: “My body is the temporary needs to guide me in a different direc-
tude is the ability to be mindful and tent of my soul.” This is a crucial tion from what I had planned for my-
appreciative of the blessings that are way to think. It is to remember that self. When this happens, I rely on my
in one’s life, regardless of your diffi- we are not bodies inhabited by a faith in God, and trust he knows what
culties and struggles. Put differently, soul, but rather souls who for a time is best for me at that time. My faith
it is very difficult to be depressed and occupy a body. This shift in focus gives me confidence and assur-
profoundly filled with gratitude, at the reminds us that we are created in the ance. The stories I've heard growing
same time. The opposite of being Divine image, and even though the up about the wonder of God are very
grateful is taking these blessings in body is corruptible and suffers pain, real for me. I know what that kind of
your life for granted, which we of my true and essential self is imper- love and acceptance feels like. I be-
course do all the time. Many people ishable and indestructible. This lieve God loves me in this wonderful
focused on this as the greatest benefit thought gives one great strength and way. How blessed am I to have such
of their prayer life. While some peo- courage in the battle against despair love in my life.”
ple feel very comfortable in struc- and depression.
tured ritual traditions and others em- While each of my respondents shared
phasize more spontaneous private Self-Esteem. One of the tasks of their faith and its role in coping with
prayer, what is fascinating is that no any theology is to attempt to answer TM, there was one additional insight
one said that their primary or first the age old question as to the suffer- many of them shared. Each one in
prayer is to be healed. That is always ing of the innocent. The classic cry some way made helping other people
prayer #2. Prayer #1 is to simply of the Biblical Job is to ask why the a key element in their lives. One is a
thank God for the blessings that are in righteous suffer and there are as spokesperson for TM research, an-
one’s life: your spouse, your chil- many answers to this as there are re- other a teacher, another volunteers in
dren, life, nature, freedom, your mind, ligions. But one of the standard her church to feed the hungry. All of
etc. As one person put it: “At first, “answers” one sometimes hears, and these serve to take themselves out of
all I wanted was for this miracle that is proposed in the Book of Job, themselves for a few moments by fo-
working Jesus to heal my body. That's is that suffering is always due to cusing on the needs of others. They
all I thought I needed. But I needed some bad thing, some sin that the feel they have something essential to
lots more. Having been hit with TM person committed. In fact, the au- contribute to society, and they are
at 15 forced me to seek God for an- thor of Job puts this view into the right. It is often said that volunteering
swers and comfort and the ability to mouth of Job’s so-called friends, to help others is good for them. What
handle it all. Even more than healing, who are not very friendly and whom needs to be stressed as well is that it is
I pray daily for strength to cope. And the book treats with disdain. (God good for you, too! In all these ways,
that starts with counting my bless- appears at the end of the Book and pursuing the life of the spirit is a key
ings.” Many people commented that dismisses this view). Still, it is a element in coping with TM.
simple and often heard view. What
Page 20 The Transverse Myelitis Association
Translational Pain Research
caused by overuse and subsequent age to the nerve roots, as well as to
at the Brigham and Women’s damage to normal tissues; such as the spinal cord itself. Doctors and
Hospital: Help for People bones, joints, and muscles. It often other health care professionals may
with TM who Suffer from becomes worse with movement, and refer to this as “girdle zone pain.”
Pain eases with rest. This pain usually re- This pain follows a band-like pattern,
sponds well to existing pain treat- such as circumferentially from the
ments, such as narcotics and stomach around to the back. Central
Christine Sang, MD, MPH is an As- NSAIDS (i.e., ibuprofen), and will spinal cord pain may also occur eve-
sistant Professor at the Harvard often go away when the body heals rywhere below the level of injury,
Medical School and the Director of or when the problem is removed. even if the entire cross-section of the
Translational Pain Research at the There are numerous medical and sur- cord is not damaged. This pain is of-
Brigham and Women’s Hospital in gical conditions that may cause neu- ten made worse with light touch or
Boston, Massachusetts. She serves ropathic pain. Damage to peripheral cold.
on the Board of Directors to the nerves can also lead to neuropathic
American Pain Society, and is a pain, but is often easier to treat. The Central pain, like chronic pain in gen-
Founder and serves on the Steering conditions that may cause neuro- eral, may begin at the time of injury
Committee of the Neuropathic Pain pathic pain include: or develop slowly over months or
Institute. She also serves on the advi- years. It can persist for long periods
sory board committees of several • Spinal cord (central) pain of time, and interfere with one’s qual-
companies that develop new drugs • Painful peripheral neuropathy ity of life. According to some reports,
for pain, and is a consultant for the (due to diabetes, AIDS, chemo- as many as 90% of people with SCI
FDA on the treatment of pain syn- therapy, etc.) have had chronic pain.
dromes. • Radiculopathy (damage to nerve
roots) Unfortunately, central pain does not
Dr. Sang and our research team work • Trigeminal neuralgia usually respond well to narcotics
together to bring laboratory research • Complex regional pain syn- (e.g., morphine). On the other hand,
into a safe and effective clinical re- dromes (formerly reflex sympa- the pain can respond to neuropathic
search setting. The primary aim of thetic dystrophy) pain medications (e.g., certain anti-
our ongoing research is to systemati- • Phantom limb pain convulsants or antidepressants). Some
cally evaluate new drugs for pain and • Pain following mastectomy, tho- physicians recommend nerve root
to determine the cause of different racotomy, or other surgeries blocks that will numb the painful ar-
types of pain to improve therapy. Our • Pain following shingles eas. This numb effect only lasts a
overall goal is to relieve each person's (postherpetic neuralgia) short time and returns to baseline.
pain experience, which we hope will • Cancer infiltrating the nerve, Sometimes, a surgical procedure such
ultimately improve quality of life. plexus, or root. as DREZ (dorsal root entry zone),
The focus of our research group is rhizotomy, or cordotomy is recom-
spinal cord pain following injury, in- Central pain can be caused by dam- mended, although these procedures
fection, or inflammation, including age to the spinal cord. In essence, the may result in yet another (secondary)
transverse myelitis. We realize that spinal cord and the brain interpret spinal cord pain syndrome.
people suffer from severe pain which otherwise normal sensations as pain.
can prohibit them from everyday ac- Central pain can be described in As neuropathic pain can be intermit-
tivities. With each person, pain var- many ways -- burning, electric, tin- tent or constant, localized in one spe-
ies in its intensity, frequency, and du- gling, shooting, stabbing, numbness, cific region or affecting the entire
ration of episodes, as well as in over- aching, throbbing, or squeezing. It body below the level of injury, our re-
all sensations. This pain can be at its can be very difficult to relieve. The search aims to treat the specific
best annoying, and at its worst, nearly responses to currently available pain mechanisms believed to cause central
unbearable. treatments are often limited by side pain, rather than merely masking the
effects – such as drowsiness, dry pain. Our study evaluates new drugs,
Although there are many types of mouth, and dizziness. The side ef- as well as new methods of delivering
pain, there are two broad categories fects and lack of adequate analgesia conventional drugs, that can hopefully
that distinguish the mechanisms of are frustrating for both the patient reduce chronic central spinal cord
pain: mechanical pain and neuro- and physician. Central pain may oc- pain with fewer side effects than cur-
pathic pain. Mechanical pain is cur at the level of injury due to dam- rently available medications. We usu-
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 21
ally have multiple studies going on si- Considerations in Achieving Terminology
multaneously and we are always Bowel Continence
looking at new therapies and different Katharine Finney Kinsman, There are many strategies to ap-
ways to relieve neuropathic pain. CRNP proaching continence, but unfortu-
nately there is no one way that will
The Translational Pain Research Pro- absolutely work for every person.
Kathy is a nurse practitioner at the
gram at the Brigham and Women’s That is part of the challenge facing
Center for Spina Bifida and Related
Hospital in Boston is committed to both the provider and the patient. Be-
Conditions, Kennedy Krieger Insti-
working with people with TM and the fore it is possible to discuss specific
tute, Baltimore MD. Kathy conducts
other neuroimmunologic disorders to strategies, one must understand some
a Continence Clinic and has devel-
find an effective approach to treating commonly used terms.
oped an expertise in managing in-
pain. Our funding sources have in-
continence due to a wide variety of
cluded the Paralyzed Veterans of Neurogenic bowel is a very broad
conditions. The Clinic conducts
America, The Christopher Reeve Pa- term that can apply to anyone who has
evaluations and focuses on the man-
ralysis Foundation, and the National nerve injury (temporary or perma-
agement of urinary and bowel incon-
Institute of Neurological Disorders nent) to the part of the spinal cord that
tinence through an interdisciplinary
and Stroke (National Institutes of controls bowel function. The bowel
approach that includes Nursing, Be-
Health). Our program will work with and bladder are controlled both cen-
havioral Psychology, and Occupa-
patients and will also consult with and trally, with messages traveling from
tional Therapy.
work with your physicians. the brain to the bladder or bowel, as
Introduction well as peripherally, by nerves that
We will continue working with you branch off from the spinal cord. The
until the goal of relieving your pain is lowest portion of the spinal cord, lo-
Transverse myelitis (TM) is a rare
achieved. cated in the sacral area, houses the
disorder that results in spinal cord
inflammation which causes secon- nerves that impact bowel and bladder
For more information, please contact continence. Damage or inflammation
us: dary conditions such as immobility,
risk of skin breakdown, and bowel to either the spinal cord or the path-
Kate Jenkins, B.A., Program Coordi- and bladder dysfunction. Research- way through which messages travel
nator ers have found that generally, about from brain to lower spinal cord may
Leah McInerney-Killion, R.N., two-thirds of those affected by this result in an inability to sense or feel
B.S.N., Lead Study Nurse disorder are left with a moderate to the need to have a bowel movement.
severe degree of permanent impair- Additionally, there is often lack of
Kristie Chin, B.S. Study Coordinator voluntary control over the rectal mus-
ments. Even in those that recover,
Aparna Sarin, M.D., M.P.H. Research there is nearly always a temporary cles. An individual with intact neural
Fellow time during which organ systems pathways can consciously initiate
such as the bowel and bladder are af- defecation by relaxing the anal
Karen Wang, B.A, B.S, Research As-
fected. sphincter to allow the passage of stool
sistant
or conversely, squeeze the anal
Christine Sang, MD, MPH, Principal sphincter to hold back stool which has
Investigator This article will focus on how an in-
dividual with a neurogenic bowel already passed into the rectal vault.
can achieve continence. This author Without the ability to control the anal
Translational Pain Research
shares the belief of a growing num- sphincter, when stool enters the rec-
Department of Anesthesiology,
ber of health care practitioners that tum, there is the risk of an unplanned
Perioperative and Pain Medicine
every individual deserves to and has spontaneous bowel movement.
Brigham and Women's Hospital
75 Francis Street the right to expect to be continent. If
help is not available at your particu- A person is considered continent if
Boston, MA 02115
lar location, keep looking, because they are able to be free from unex-
Office (617) 525-7246, there are many different types of pected accidents. For example, an in-
Page (617) 726-2066 health care providers who may have dividual without neurological prob-
Fax (425) 675-5556 expertise in this area. lems, who is toilet trained, anticipates
the need to go and can make it to the
http://www.mgh.harvard.edu/paintrials toilet in time to have a bowel move-
ment. Conversely, an individual with
Page 22 The Transverse Myelitis Association
TM affecting the lower spinal cord Behavioral Considerations dividuals with other neurological dis-
would require a bowel regime abilities.
whereby bowel movements occur on Often, incontinent individuals have
the toilet, but as a result of timed toi- encountered teasing or ridicule from Becoming continent is a journey that
leting with or without an enema, sup- peers, family members, or other in- is unique to each individual. There are
pository, or other measures. Both in- sensitive people who do not under- no “cook book” answers, but at the
dividuals would then be free of acci- stand the situation. The whole sub- same time, there are almost an endless
dents (continent) and able to wear ject may be fraught with negative number of strategies or combination
regular underwear. There are several emotion for the incontinent individ- of strategies to try. Developing trust
other factors that must be contem- ual. Social punishment is not an ef- and confidence in one’s medical team
plated to really understand how to fective treatment for incontinence, is essential to be able to tackle conti-
achieve bowel continence. and is frequently observed to exact a nence both emotionally and physi-
heavy toll on one’s self esteem and cally. After considering the above fac-
Developmental Considerations self efficacy. tors, the basic question is still “but
how does one go about this?”
An individual’s developmental age Becoming continent takes a lot of
must be considered to know when it work for both the patient and their Getting Started
is appropriate to start a toileting pro- family or significant others. Compre-
gram. In fact, it is really more impor- hensive bathroom habit diaries need Treatment regimes usually involve a
tant to understand one’s developmen- to be kept, food and fluid intake combination of dietary manipulation,
tal age than the actual chronological must be considered, and ultimately, behavior modification, medication,
age. A child is considered develop- behavioral changes incorporated and positive reinforcement initiated in
mentally ready for toileting when he with specific regular routines must a stepwise approach. Laxatives by
or she is able to participate in his or be followed. This takes sustained mouth should be used with caution,
her program. Success can only be motivation, dedication and above all, because of the difficulty in predicting
achieved if the child (or any individ- patience. Children often require tan- when they may work.
ual) is an active participant and be- gible rewards and varied approaches
lieves there are benefits to obtaining to keep them interested. At times, Taking advantage of the body’s natu-
continence. This usually occurs formal behavioral therapy is required ral reflexes and biomechanics should
around the age of three. If, however, a to establish lifestyle changes. Often, always be used if possible. One exam-
procedure such as regular enemas the difference between continence ple is that of the gastrocolic reflex.
must be performed, the child may and incontinence lies in minute de- This is the body’s natural response to
need to be older. I always encourage tails that ultimately, when put to- a full stomach. After a meal, the stom-
my families not to send an otherwise gether like pieces of a puzzle, yield a ach becomes stretched and messages
developmentally normal child to solution. are sent telling this to the brain. Invol-
school in diapers, if at all possible. untary squeezing of the smooth mus-
Emotional Impact cles of the gut occurs in waves,
Children like to copy one another, so known as peristalsis. The food is di-
if a sibling or a parent models a be- Our society expects all individuals to gested as it moves through the small
havior such as going to the bathroom, be continent after about the age of bowel and then into the large bowel.
a child is likely to want to do it too. three. The inability to control one’s It becomes more formed as it moves
There are books and videos available bowel and bladder carries an enor- closer to the rectum. As the waves of
that expose the child to going to the mous social and emotional stigma. peristalsis occur, the bowel contents
bathroom on the toilet. In addition, The impact that having accidents or are moved along. What we perceive is
medical supply companies have col- wearing diapers has on a child or an sometimes cramping or gas or “the
oring books and video’s available for adult cannot be over emphasized. feeling that it is time to go.” This re-
children who are learning to catheter- Recent research with children who flex occurs even if one can not feel it
ize as a part of their continence pro- have spina bifida revealed that or perceive it. Some people have a
gram. chronic incontinence caused greater very strong reaction after meals and
distress than any other associated some do not. Those that say, “I am
problem, including paralysis of the like clockwork; I go to the bathroom
legs and the inability to walk. These every morning after breakfast no mat-
results are very likely similar for in- ter what” are usually ones with a
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 23
strong gastrocolic reflex. One way to come hard and “back-up” in the sys- used, the doses may need to be very
tell if you have a strong gastrocolic tem. How often one has a bowel small; remember that the ability to
reflex and to identify other toileting movement is usually not as important predict when a laxative is going to
patterns is to keep a diary of toileting as the consistency and quantity of the work is very difficult. Laxatives are
habits for one to two weeks. Vari- stool. often better used just to move the
ables to track include bowel move- stool along at a better pace rather than
ment timing and if there is an associa- Developing a Plan to actually cause a bowel movement.
tion with incontinence or not. Every Interventions such as digital stimula-
two hour undergarment checks may Bowel programs start with the practi- tion, suppositories or enemas are gen-
be necessary for those that have no tioner completing a problem history erally far more predictable. Add or
awareness of when they go. Bathroom and physical examination. Questions change one measure at a time so that
habit trackers should also provide in- to be answered by the examination it is clear what has helped and what
formation such as size and consis- include: Is the abdomen soft or firm, has not.
tency of the stools. which could indicate large amounts
of retained stool. Is there stool in the When conservative medical manage-
An example of the use of body bio- rectal vault? Can the individual vol- ment is inadequate, there are multiple
mechanics is one’s position on the untarily squeeze the anal sphincter surgical or procedural options includ-
toilet. Sit comfortably on the toilet. muscle? Is there a perianal wink re- ing surgical continent stomas, ce-
Make sure there is no danger of fal- flex? Finally, what is the current neu- costomy buttons, and incontinent
ling in or off on the floor. A well- rological sensory and motor level of ostomies. An option that works for
fitting seat and something to hold on the individual? one may not be right for another. Im-
to for balance goes a long way in as- portant factors that may influence
sisting with relaxation. Remember, In this author’s experience, bowel one’s choice include patient age, com-
stool is passed when lower pelvic programs are more successful if rou- plication rates of the procedure,
muscles are relaxed. The body is in tine interventions are begun after the knowledge of long-term outcomes,
the best anatomic position for defeca- colon is cleaned out. Accidents can and ability to be independent with the
tion when the pelvic muscles are al- not occur if there is no stool in the overall bowel program. There is an in-
lowed to relax and descend. Legs lower colon and rectum. Though an creased prevalence of pediatric sur-
should be spread apart and knees initial cleanout is the first step, the geons and interventional radiologists
should be higher than the pelvis such real success lies in making sure the who are committed to working on in-
as when one’s feet are up on a stool colon stays clean till the next time terdisciplinary teams with the goal of
or telephone books placed on either the person is in a controlled setting achieving social continence.
side of the toilet. When trying to (such as in the bathroom) and on the
evacuate the stool, push by tightening toilet! Bowel continence in an individual
the stomach muscles. Coughing or with neurologic injuries such as trans-
laughing help facilitate pushing. Colonic cleanouts can be accom- verse myelitis is achievable with a
When teaching a child to push, I pre- plished in a myriad of ways such as multilayered approach, patience and
tend I am holding a birthday cake and with oral laxatives, enemas, supposi- perseverance. It is important to real-
tell the child to blow out the candles, tories, or a combination thereof. ize that advances are occurring on a
or tell the child to imagine he is the Colonic cleanouts are not fun, but if regular basis and that there are a vari-
wolf in The Three Little Pigs and try orchestrated correctly, take a single ety of professionals that can direct pa-
to “huff and puff and blow the house day to complete. To most, this is a tients and families through the myriad
down.” small price to pay for continence. of options available.
Finally, one must consider that The maintenance part of the bowel
achieving continence is bit like riding program should begin immediately
a bike on a tight rope. Stool must pass after the cleanout to keep stool from
through the bowel at a rate sufficient backing up in the system again. Be-
to produce soft but formed stool. If ginning with non-invasive measures
the passage is too swift, too much wa- such as behavioral and dietary
ter will remain in the stool and it will changes may be all that is needed,
be too loose. Conversely, if the pas- particularly if there is even partial
sage is too slow, the stool may be- bowel control. If oral laxatives are
Page 24 The Transverse Myelitis Association
Update on Research at the sometimes difficult to reach Dr. • Treatment Strategies
Johns Hopkins Transverse Kerr, Edie (and I) can handle many
Myelopathy Center of the patient’s questions. Edie’s ad- Pediatric TM
Chitra Krishnan dition to our staff will allow us to • Studying a possible correlation
provide even better service to our pa- with immunization
tients. • Clinical features
There is always a great deal of activ- • Outcomes
ity going on at the JHTMC. The most Finally, Deepa Desphande (Masters • Scientific manuscript to be sub-
significant changes have been the ad- degree in biology and biotechnol- mitted this year
dition of four new people to our staff. ogy) has joined the JHTMC research
Peter Calabresi, MD is a close col- team. She has joined us from Texas Risk Factors in the Development of
league of Dr. Kerr, is a neurologist, A and M University and will run the TM
and recently joined the Hopkins fac- immunology projects in the lab. • Federally funded grant to study
ulty. He is the director of the Johns These studies have already begun to the frequency of particular events
Hopkins MS Center (JHMSC). Dr. reveal fascinating insights into the that occur prior to the develop-
Calabresi is a well-known immunolo- acute inflammatory process in TM ment of TM
gist and is applying this training to patients, giving us potential new • We will compare the frequency of
the development of new treatments therapeutic strategies to pursue. these events in TM and in other
for MS. Dr. Calabresi is also an ex-
neurologic disorders to see if they
pert in running clinical trials. He and We will provide a brief overview of are more common in TM patients
Dr. Kerr are already working on de- our ongoing projects, using this as an • If so, it provides us a lead in de-
veloping new treatments for acute update to the previous newsletter.
fining how these events may trig-
TM and are working towards a clini-
Continued Development of the ger TM
cal trial within the next 12-18 months.
Clinical Database of TM
• Includes over 400 patients with Spasticity Treatment Trial
Sanjay Keswani (MBBS) is also a
new neurologist recruit onto the Hop- transverse myelitis • We want to develop better treat-
kins faculty. Dr. Keswani’s research • Cross-sectional and longitudinal ment strategies for spasticity in
and clinical interests have previously • CSF, serological, radiological, patients with TM since the regular
been HIV-related neurology and clinical components treatment options (tizanidine, ba-
mechanisms of peripheral nerve de- clofen, diazepam) have problems,
generation. But we have convinced Clinical Classification Project of e.g., fatigue and sleepiness
him that the study of TM is really Monophasic TM • Tiagabine (Gabitril) vs. placebo
where it’s at! He is now beginning to • Clinical Features • Crossover design
investigate how axons get damaged in • Risk Factors • Potentially less sedating than ba-
the spinal cord and will run the first • Prognostic Factors clofen, tizanidine, diazepam
human study in protecting those ax- • Outcomes
ons during the acute phase of TM. • Scientific manuscript to be sub- Depression and Cognitive Impair-
mitted this year ment with TM
Edie Goldberg (RN) is a nurse who • We want to investigate the fre-
has just joined the JHTMC. Edie was Recurrent TM quency and mechanisms of de-
first a nurse and most recently came • 20% of all TM patients seen at pression and subtle cognitive
from Pfizer where she was one of the the JHTMC are recurrent cases changes that occur in some people
best hospital representatives in the en- • A particular antibody in the after TM
tire country (this is important because blood of some patients predicts a • Funded clinical trial (run by Dr.
it is always good to have an “in” with possible recurrent course Adam Kaplin) that is now enroll-
a big pharmaceutical company). Edie • Scientific manuscript accepted ing patients in the acute phase of
will run the clinical trials at the and will be published this year TM
JHTMC and the JHMSC. She will (Hummers, Krishnan et al., • Novel neuroimaging-magnetic
also serve to assist with clinical mat- 2003) resonance spectroscopy-and cyto-
ters of patients that Dr. Kerr has seen, • Clinical course and immunologic kine profiles to assess pathophysi-
i.e., medication refills, change in abnormalities in patients with re- ology
status, new symptoms, etc. Since it is current TM
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 25
Novel Imaging of The Spinal Cord Announcing the 2004 Symposium in Baltimore
• We want to investigate a better Sandy Siegel
strategy to image the spinal cord
• We are developing a new MRI The Transverse Myelitis Association symposium.
protocol (magnetization transfer) and the Johns Hopkins Transverse
that may help to define the extent Myelitis Center are co-sponsoring The Hyatt has thirteen accessible
of inflammation in the spinal cord the 2004 Symposium on the Neuro- rooms and only three of the 13 rooms
and how much damage is occur- immunologic Diseases of the Cen- have roll-in showers. Please do not
ring tral Nervous System. The sympo- ask for an accessible room unless it is
• If this technique does give us a sium will focus on TM, Devics and absolutely necessary that you have
better understanding of the spinal ADEM, and will include both pedi- one. If you need an accessible room,
cord process, it may allow us to atric and adult cases of these neuro- please indicate that need when you
identify patients who need more immunologic conditions. make your reservation. At the time
aggressive treatment you make your reservation, you are
The symposium will be held at the going to be given a room that is not
Animal Model of TM Hyatt Regency at the Inner Harbor accessible, to be certain that you ob-
• We are trying to develop an ani- in Baltimore from Wednesday, Au- tain a reservation, and then you will
mal model of TM gust 18 through Sunday, August 22. be placed on a list that will ultimately
• Some early studies suggest that if Members of the TMA are going to be given to the JHTMC and the rooms
we give a rat the same inflamma- get a rate of $115 plus tax per night are going to be assigned on the basis
tory proteins that are present in for a single or double occupancy of the greatest need. If you can travel
the spinal fluid of TM patients, room at the Hyatt. For planning with a companion who is able to assist
they get weak purposes and also to accommodate you with transfers, please consider do-
• This now gives us a way to test the Hyatt, we are asking our mem- ing so. We are sorry for the inconven-
how the spinal cord gets weak bers to make their reservations as ience this may cause any of you. We
quickly as possible. The Associa- are trying to find an equitable solution
Stem Cells In TM tion, the JHTMC and the Hyatt are to a difficult problem. If you are go-
• Not near clinical trials going to require some sense of the ing to request an accessible room,
• But… size of our attendance to plan for you need to make your reservation
• In animals, we can protect from meeting space. While we are hoping before April 1, 2004; the list of re-
ongoing neural injury using stem that they will have sufficient space quests will be given to the JHTMC
cells for us, it is possible that we would on April 1st. The accessible rooms at
• We can now generate new motor have to limit the numbers of people the Hyatt will not be available after
neurons and coax axons to grow who can attend the symposium. The April 1st. Please be certain to commu-
out of the spinal cord one certain way for us to avoid any nicate any other needs you may have,
• We are getting closer, but these limitations is to have people make such as for a shower bench, at the time
studies are so expensive and we reservations at the hotel by January you make your reservation.
have not yet convinced the fed- 2004.
eral government to fund such It is important to bear in mind that
studies. To make a reservation at the Hyatt, making your reservation at the Hyatt
• We will succeed, but not yet please call (800) 233-1234. To get is a different process and fee from the
the TMA membership rate, please symposium registration. The registra-
identify yourself as a member and tion process will begin in the winter or
let the customer service person early spring; you will receive the reg-
know that you are attending the istration materials by mail in the next
TMA/JHTMC Symposium. By newsletter or in a separate mailing
making your reservation, your credit from the Johns Hopkins Continuing
card will not be charged in advance Medical Education (CME) Office.
of your stay. The Hyatt does, how- The registration fee will be set based
ever, have a cancellation policy and on the costs of conducting the sympo-
you would have at least a week to sium.
cancel this reservation before the
Page 26 The Transverse Myelitis Association
We wanted to provide you with some community. The symposium program has also
idea of a possible registration fee so been designed to encourage and maxi-
that you were able to decide whether The symptom management section mize the interactions between the
you should make the hotel reserva- of the symposium will be the focus medical community and the patient
tions. Based on a guess of 200 TMA of approximately half of the pro- and caregiver communities. This in-
members attending the symposium, gram. The other half of the program teraction will be promoted both in a
the registration fee would be approxi- will be devoted to the science and re- formal setting with discussions and
mately $300 per person. If our fund- search on the neuroimmunologic dis- question and answer sessions, as well
raising efforts do not succeed in rais- orders and restorative therapies. as in more informal settings during so-
ing anything, the registration fee While the science and research por- cial activities and meals. Physicians
could be more or less than this tion of the program is of primary in- learn a great deal about the personal
amount depending on the numbers of terest to the physician/scientist par- experiences of the people who have
people who register to attend. If we ticipants, it is equally beneficial for these conditions through these infor-
are able to raise a lot of money, the the TMA membership. It has been mal connections.
registration fee could be a great deal our experience that knowledge of the
less. research is an important component The TMA/JHTMC Symposium will
of how we all think about the poten- be offering CME credits through the
The symposium is an educational and tial for improved quality of life for Johns Hopkins Continuing Education
networking opportunity for people ourselves and our loved ones. A ma- Program. From the patient and advo-
who have the neuroimmunologic con- jor portion of the program is devoted cacy perspective, this represents a tre-
ditions and their caregivers, for the to rehabilitative and management mendous opportunity to attract inter-
medical professionals who provide strategies, as the TMA is committed ested medical professionals and scien-
treatment to this rare disease popula- to the highest quality of life for peo- tists into an important area of treat-
tion, as well as scientists and physi- ple who suffer from these neuroim- ment and research. This educational
cians who are performing research in munologic conditions today. The opportunity will result in the sharing
rehabilitative and restorative thera- current state of research, however, of best practices in treatment, as well
pies. Presentations will be made by a represents the future potential for a as provide the synergies that result
group of physician specialists focused better and significantly improved from the scientists sharing new infor-
on the full range of symptom manage- quality of life. mation, techniques and research re-
ment issues of concern to the TM, sults.
Devics and ADEM community. The As these are rare conditions and
goal of this section of the program is there is no concentration of people in The TMA and JHTMC are also
to assist the person to become an in- any community around the country strongly committed to better educating
formed and effective advocate for or around the world, most of those the first line of defense in the diagno-
their treatment and medical care. In with these neuroimmunologic condi- sis and treatment of these neuroimmu-
addition to the many physical symp- tions have never met another person nologic disorders. Emergency physi-
toms people need to address, they are who shares their disorder. We are cians, general practitioners, and pedia-
also faced with significant social and sensitive to the needs of bringing to- tricians are the physicians who first
emotional issues, which surround gether people with the rare neuroim- see a patient who is presenting with
having a devastating illness. The munologic conditions and their care- the symptoms of TM, ADEM, and
symposium will also attend to these givers to offer them the opportunity Devics. A rapid diagnosis and treat-
important issues through presenta- to share in their experiences, to help ment is critical for the patient. The
tions by experts from a variety of people feel less isolated, to foster so- TMA and JHTMC will promote the
medical and other disciplines. cial support and networks, and to educational program to these medical
provide critical information to help specializations in an attempt to in-
In addition to the formal presenta- people better understand their condi- crease awareness and to better educate
tions, there will be extensive opportu- tions. We know from the previous these disciplines about diagnostic
nity for TMA members to ask ques- meetings that most people create techniques.
tions of the specialists. An entire ses- lifelong friendships at these gather-
sion will involve a discussion and ings. There will be numerous oppor- If you have not attended a previous
question and answer program which tunities for people to meet and so- TMA/JHTMC Symposium, we
will include the patient and caregiver cialize. strongly urge you to participate in this
community and the medical specialist important event. If you have attended
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 27
other workshops and symposia, the the checks that are sent to the TMA. raising with Pauline’s and my family
2004 meeting will offer you the op- Paula will be sure to designate these and friends.
portunity to learn about the most up- funds for the 2004 symposium. All
to-date symptom management strate- funds that are raised above the costs Please get involved in fundraising ef-
gies and research and to renew your of the symposium will be designated forts. Help us provide this important
friendships from the TMA member- to the TMA research fund. The opportunity to the many deserving
ship. This is also an important oppor- TMA and the JHTMC are fully com- people in our community who need
tunity to meet the physicians and sci- mitted to encouraging research on this education and support. By reduc-
entists who are focused on the neuro- the neuroimmunologic conditions ing or eliminating a registration fee
immunologic conditions. and to attracting the best physicians for the symposium, we will widen the
and scientists into this area of re- numbers of people who are able to at-
The TMA and the JHTMC have al- search. tend.
ready begun the fundraising efforts
for the 2004 symposium. We need The TMA and JHTMC will deter- The final level of fundraising I would
for you to get involved! There are mine the registration fee in January like for you to consider is fundraising
three levels of fundraising in which I 2004 and the fee will be set to cover with your family and friends to help
am going to encourage you to partici- the total cost of the symposium. Our you cover your personal costs for
pate. The first level is the formal fundraising goal is to raise enough travel and the hotel. We have mem-
fundraising program that is being di- money so that there is no registration bers from across the United States and
rected by the TMA and the JHTMC. fee and so that there is a substantial from around the world. Whether you
This effort is being coordinated by amount of money designated for the live in India or Brazil or Australia or
Chitra Krishnan from the JHTMC and research fund. We would love to Alaska or San Francisco or Chicago,
by Stephen Miller and myself from have the only cost for our member- you should be able to attend this sym-
the TMA. If you would like to assist ship be their travel and hotel and a posium. You need to begin today to
in these efforts, please contact few dinners during the symposium fundraise with your family and
Stephen. You can reach Stephen by weekend. Whether we can realize friends. If they know how important
email at: smiller@myelitis.org or call that goal is going to depend on you. it is for you to come to this sympo-
(937)453-9832. We are going to commit hundreds of sium, they will want to help you. If
hours to raising money and to apply- you are not comfortable asking for fi-
The second level of fundraising in- ing for foundation grants. There are nancial help, hold a personal fund-
volves the activities that our member- no guarantees that these efforts will raiser to cover your travel and hotel
ship regularly engages in to raise result in raising anything. Our most costs. You can hold a bake sale in
money for the TMA operating ex- effective fundraising efforts are those your church or find some other crea-
penses and for TM research. There that are conducted by our members tive ways to raise the money to make
are hop-a-thons, hoop-a-thons, roll-a- who do their fundraising in their lo- this happen for you. We have such a
thons, read-a-thons, dinner parties, cal communities and with their fam- difficult time asking for help in Amer-
auctions, raffles, golf outings and ily and friends. These are the people ica. Please don’t let your pride inter-
many other programs going on all the who care most about TM; these are fere with the opportunity to have this
time around the country and around the only people who know anything life changing experience for yourself.
the world. Amazing, kind, and gener- about these neuroimmunologic con- If you have never met another person
ous people take the personal responsi- ditions and how they have impacted who has your condition, you owe it to
bility to perform these wonderful our lives. yourself to find the support, compas-
deeds. Often, we don’t even hear sion and understanding that you will
about these events until after they There was no registration fee for the only find from others who have been
have been completed. To say that we TMA Childrens and Family Work- through this same experience.
are grateful for these efforts is the shop that was held in Columbus,
greatest of understatements. We need Ohio in the summer of 2002. All of If you are looking for information
for more people to get involved in the costs of the workshop were cov- about how to get involved in fundrais-
more of these efforts and please direct ered from fundraising. The vast ma- ing or what sorts of things you can be
the funds to the 2004 symposium. jority of money was raised by the doing, please go to the donations page
This can be easily accomplished by parents in their fundraising efforts on the TMA web site. There is a great
writing “2004 symposium” on the with their family and friends. I ac- deal of information about the TMA
checks or in a letter accompanying complished the same goals by fund- and about fundraising on this site.
Page 28 The Transverse Myelitis Association
Also, you can get some great ideas for will they be able to attend the pres- names and postal addresses. And
fundraising activities from the news- entations about the neuroimmu- please remember to include their
letters, all of which are posted on the nologic conditions and learn about medical specializations.
web site. the most up-to-date treatment prac-
tices for symptoms, they will also be This is a wonderful opportunity for us
Please get yourself motivated to make able to talk to other physicians who to increase the quality of care our
this enormous difference for yourself are caring for TM patients and they members are receiving from the medi-
and for others who share in your ex- will be able to meet many other peo- cal community. Please help us to take
periences. Please help me make this ple with TM and their caregivers. advantage of this great opportunity!
opportunity available to as many peo- Now, how great would that be?
ple as possible by keeping the regis-
tration fee as low as possible. Please, Here is how you can help to make TMA Members: Portions of
let’s make this an opportunity to get this happen. Please send us the Your 2004 Baltimore
seriously energized to raise money for names and postal addresses of all of Symposium Trip May be Tax
TM research. your physicians and therapists. Be Deductible
sure to identify their specialization
Paula Lazzeri
Inviting Your Physicians and (i.e., neurologist, physiatrist, urolo-
gist, PT or OT) along with their full
Therapists to the 2004 TMA/
name and complete postal address.
JHTMC Symposium You can include in medical expenses
We would prefer to receive this in- amounts paid for admission and trans-
formation electronically in an email portation to a medical conference if
We all want the best care and treat- message. If you do not have a com- the medical conference concerns the
ment for TM, recurrent TM, ADEM, puter or internet access, you may chronic illness of yourself, your
and Devics; we want this for our- send this information in a letter. spouse, or your dependent. You are
selves and our loved ones. Most of You should send this information as only going to be able to take this de-
the people in the TM community have quickly as possible, as we will need duction if you itemize on 1040 Sched-
a number of medical professionals in- time to compile the mailing lists. ule A. The costs of the medical con-
volved in the treatment of their symp- You have until the end of November ference must be primarily for and nec-
toms, i.e., neurologists, physiatrists, to send us your physicians’ and essary to the medical care of you, your
urologists, physical therapists and oc- therapists’ names and contact infor- spouse, or your dependent. You must
cupational therapists. How important mation. The JHTMC and Dr. Kerr spend the majority of your time at the
is it to you that these physicians and will send them a personal letter of conference attending sessions on
therapists have the most comprehen- invitation to the symposium, along medical information. The cost of
sive understanding of your condition with the registration packet and pro- meals and lodging while attending the
and also know the most recent devel- gram agenda. conference is not deductible as a
opments in the techniques and thera- medical expense.
pies for managing your symptoms? Please send your information via
We are excited to offer you and your email to: You should, of course, know the tax
medical professionals this educational law or consult with your tax advisor
opportunity. dcapen@myelitis.org before taking any deductions. For
more information on this deduction
We would like to invite your physi- If you send the information via the see IRS Publication 502, Medical and
cians and therapists to attend the 2004 postal service, please mail it to: Dental Expenses.
TMA/JHTMC Symposium in Balti-
more. And we would encourage you Debbie Capen Additional information may also be
to advocate for them to accept this in- Secretary found at:
vitation; be nice, be gentle, be diplo- The Transverse Myelitis Association
matic, but do strongly encourage them PO Box 2084 http://www.irs.gov/individuals/
to attend. It is in your greatest interest Hemet CA 92546 index.html.
that they come to this educational
symposium. They will receive CME Please remember to include your
credits from Johns Hopkins. Not only physician’s and therapist’s complete
The Transverse Myelitis Association Page 29
The Board of Directors elected Stephen J. Miller and on all weekend. Monday morn-
ing brought the first session of physi-
to serve as the next Vice President of The cal therapy. There would be four
Transverse Myelitis Association. years more of them to follow.