Check of Beam with Circular Penetrations:

PEN-001

Assumptions:

1.0 No concentrated load is applied within influence zone 'a z' (section A.2). If concentrated load exists, then skip section
and go to section 'B' (with intermediate stiffener).

2.0 Reduction in shear resistance due to an individual web opening may be neglected at cross-sections located further f
length 'ap' of influence zone. Or beyond the distance 'a s' to the next transverse stiffener, if this is less (section A.2 & s

3.0 Reduction in moment resistance due to an individual web opening may be neglected at cross-sections located furthe
additional length 'ap' of influence zone (section A.2 & section A.4).

4.0 Conservatively, all openings are checked considering no reinforcement. Whereas, Structural detail shows reinforcem

II

Sectional Properties and Forces

Material properties
Material yield stress;

Fy

335.0

Young's modulus;

210000.0

Material factor;

E
m0

1.15

Poisson's ratio;

0.30

tw

tf

1200

450

18

30

Length of beam (overall);

Lb

8.400

Cross-section area;

Ax

47520.0

Iy

1.15E+10
Wey

1.911E+07
Wpl,y

2.171E+07
Mpy

Sectional properties of beam (without penetration);

Moment of inertia of section;

Elastic section modulus;
Plastic section modulus;
Plastic moment capacity;

6325.1
Torsional rigidity of beam;

Jt

c/t

=
<

10316160.0

Assumed Section Class:

Web:

62.0
69.5

Flange:

c/t

=
<

6.8
7.5

Sectional Forces at location of penetration (from SACS);

SACS Member No.:

My,Ed

1007.83

Axial force;

NEd

312.70

Horizontal shear force;

Vy,Ed

15.20

Vertical shear force;

Maximum Relative Deflection;

Vsd

=
=

336.61
4.87

Major bending moment;

Member stress at location of penetration (from SACS);

Euler buckling;
Axial;
Bending about Y;
Bending about Z;
Shear in Y;
Shear in Z;

Stress (N/mm2)
Actual
0.00
6.58
52.75
0.87
0.84
15.20

Euler
Fa/Ft
Fby
Fbz
Fvy
Fvz

=
=
=
=
=
=

do
dr
br
hp
EL1
EL2
EL3
d2
Sd
w

=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=

273.0
7.8
200.0
569.0
32400.0
31200.0
31769.0
219.1
4236.0
3990.0

c/c dist. of penetration from nearest support/ web

stiffener;

aw

1277.0

c/c dist. of penetration from nearest transverse

force/ support reaction;

at

2894.0

Penetration Details;
Diameter of Pipe Sleeve;
Thickness of Pipe Sleeve;
Length of Pipe Sleeve;
Height of C/l of penetration;
Top of Steel Elevation;
Bottom of Steel Elevation;
Elevation of C/l of penetration;
Dia. of nearest opening;
c/c spacing between nearest opening;
clear spacing between two opening;

III

Resistance of Beams without intermediate Web stiffeners (N.2.1 - ENV 1993-1-1:1192/A2:1998):

This section covers sectional check in two steps:
A. Check without web reinforcement
B. Check with web reinforcement

Annex N (Euro Code)

ed load exists, then skip section 'A' (without intermediate stiffener)

cross-sections located further from the opening than the additional

er, if this is less (section A.2 & section A.3).
at cross-sections located further from the opening than the

ructural detail shows reinforcement.

N/mm
N/mm
(Cl. 5.1.1)

r
12

mm

m
mm2
Iz
4.56E+08 mm4
Wez
2.03E+06 mm3
Wpl,z
3.13E+06 mm3
Mpz
911.7
10316160.0

(= 83)

kN-m
mm

Flanges only
Wpl,y
Wpl,z
1.580E+07
Mpy
4601.2

---------->

Web is Class 2

3.04E+06 mm3
Mpz
884.8

kN-m

(= 9)

---------->

Flange is Class 1

SACS Member No.: 1144-1145

SACS Notation
kNm

My

kN

Fx

kN

Fy

kN
mm

Fz

Stress (N/mm2)
Allowable
450.00
291.30
329.96
449.69
168.18
163.21

mm
mm
mm
mm
mm
mm
mm
mm
mm
mm

(If applicable, else enter 3000mm)

mm

(If applicable, else enter 3000mm)

mm

(If applicable, else enter 3000mm)

:1192/A2:1998):

7 OF 93

A. Check without Web Reinforcement

A.1 Criteria for Geometry of Web Penetration (N.2.1.1)

b
tf

tw

d0
dw Y
a0

ap

Check 1:

(Clause N.1.6(8))

The compression tee, formed by the compression flange and the adjacent portion of the web above or below an openin
member for buckling in the plane of the web if the buckling length '0.5 d o' of the tee exceeds three times its minimum ov

Check 1a:

Check 1b:

Criteria
Check

h1 = d1 + tf

494.5

h2 = d2 + tf

432.5

Buckling length, l (= 0.5 do)

136.5

<

3 * min(h1, h2)

1297.5
Buckling check of compr

Check for requirement of transverse stiffener to prevent the possibility of the compression flange b

Transverse stiffener not required if:

Criteria
Check

Where,

d w / tw
63.3

<

0.4(E / fyf) [1 - 0.45do / dw][Aw /

275.8

Afc = the area of compression flange

Aw = the area of unperforated web

Check 2:

(Clause N.1.7.2(3))

Unstiffened webs of tees above and below web openings shall be at least Class 3.

=
=

(235/Fy)
0.84

8 OF 93

For Class 2
Criteria
Check

0.7 do
191.1

<

32 tw
482.4

OR
bwc

Criteria

10t w

bwc

=
=

36t w
1
0.7do

min(d1, d2) - r
390.5

For Class 3
Criteria
Check

0.7 do
191.1

<

36 tw
542.7

OR
bwc

Criteria

14t w
36t w
1
0.7do

Check 3:

dw/tw

>

69

dw

1140.0

dw/tw

63.3

Criteria

do

0.8 dw

Check for dia. of opening;

do

273.0

Criteria

d1

0.1 dw

Criteria

d2

0.1 dw

d1
d2

=
=

464.5
402.5

0.125 dw

Criteria
Depth of web;
Check

Check 4: Dimensions of an individual web opening

Check 4.1:

Check 4.2:

Depth of top web (above penetration);

Depth of bottom web (below penetration);

Check 5: Eccentricity of an opening (in compression zone) 'e0'

Eccentricity criteria;
Check

e0
e0

31.0

NOTE 1: Eccentricity of more than 142.5mm is allowed in tension zone if above check 4.2 is satisfied.

9 OF 93
Check 6: Minimum clear width 'w' of web (between two adjacent opening)

NOTE 2: This sheet is only applicable for beam with single penetration. Check here is presented only for ge
Criteria
Where;

d0 Vsd / (Vc,Rd - Vsd)

Vc,Rd

Shear resistance of unperfora

Minimum of Vpl,Rd (Plastic shea

or Vba,Rd (Shear buckling resist

=
VSd

Minimum allowable 'w' is greater of the following:

d0 Vsd / (Vc,Rd - Vsd)

Check

3289.50

Shear force at mid length of w

336.6

31.12

1.5 d0

409.5

3990.0

ar

0.5 dw

0.5 dw

570.0

ar

1140.5

dw/tw

63.3

90

75.4

ap

=
=
=
=

Check 7: Minimum distance from nearest support/ end stiffener 'a r'
Criteria

Check

A.2 Resistance to transverse forces (N.2.1.2):

Additional length of influence zone;

ap

Total length of influence zone of opening;

az

0.9 d0
245.7
[(dw/tw)/100] d0
206.4

a0 + 2 ap

764.4

Check 1: Minimum distance from nearest transverse force 'a t' (for unstiffened web)
Criteria

at
0.5 az

Check

at

0.5 az

382.2

2894.0

NOTE 3: Transverse web stiffeners should be provided where support reactions or other significant concent
influence zone length az of web opening.

NOTE 4: If Transverse forces are applied within influence zone, tee should be analyzed as a fixed ended be
stiffeners if this is less.

10 OF 93

11 OF 93
A.3 Shear Resistance (N.2.1.3):

Reduction in shear resistance due to an individual web opening may be neglected at cross-sections located further from
influence zone. Or beyond the distance 'a t' to the next transverse stiffener, if this less.

Shear resistance of perforated cross-section 'V o, Rd'

Vo, Rd

Vo, pl, Rd

Vpl, Rd

0.9d 0 t w f y

M0

2674.19

Where;

kN

Plastic Shear resistance of the unperforated cross-section (5.4.6)

Vpl, Rd

=
=
=

Plastic Shear resistance of the unperforated cross-section (5.4.6)

Av (fy/ 3 ) / M0
3451.15

kN

For welded I, H sections with load parallel to web; Av

dw*tw

20520.0

Shear buckling resistance of perforated cross-section 'V o, ba, Rd':

Vo, ba, Rd

=
=

Vba, Rd * (1 - d0/dw)
2501.75

kN

Shear buckling resistance of unperforated cross-section (5.6.3)

Vba, Rd

=
=

Shear buckling resistance of unperforated cross-section (5.6.3)

dw tw ba / M1

Where; M1

Resistance of member to buckling

Vba, Rd

1.15

3289.50

kN

ba (Post - critical shear strength):

w

Web slenderness

[(fyw/3)/cr] 0.5

=
=
Where; kT

=
=

Where; ba

=
=

Where; cr

dw/tw
37.4 kT
0.875
Buckling factor for shear
5.34

For webs with transverse stiffeners at supports but no inetrmedi

Post - critical shear strength

fyw/ 3

When w 0.8

Hence; ba
Vo, Rd

[1-0.625(w-0.8)](fyw/ 3)

When 0.8 < w < 1.2

[0.9/w] (fyw/ 3)

When w 1.2

=
=
=

184.35

12 OF 93

N/mm2

Minimum of (i) and (ii)

2501.75
kN
Vsd / Vo, Rd

UR

A.4 Moment Resistance (N.2.1.4):

Reduction in moment resistance due to an individual web opening may be neglected at cross-sections located further fr
additional length 'ap' of influence zone.

13 OF 93
A.4.1 In-plane moment
Moment resistance of perforated cross-section 'Mo, Rd' (accounting effect of Shear Force)
Vo,Rd

=
=

Shear resistance of perforated cross-section

2674.19
kN

=
=

Mpl, Rd (1 - 0.225 tw d0 (0.9d0 + 4e0)/W pl - 1 Vsd/V

Mpl, Rd (1 - 0.25 tw d0 (d0 + 4e0)/W pl)

minimum of (iii) and (iv)

Criteria For Class 1 & 2 cross-sections:

Mo, Rd

but

Mo, Rd

Hence,

Mo, Rd

5957.97 kN-m

6197.20 kN-m

5957.97 kN-m

Criteria For Class 3 cross-sections:

Mo, Rd

but

Mo, Rd

=
=

Mel, Rd (1 - tw(0.9d0 + 2e0)3/12Iy - 1 Vsd/Vo, Rd) 2

Mel, Rd (1 - tw(d0 + 2e0)3/12Iy)

5326.58 kN-m

5538.68 kN-m
5326.58 kN-m

Hence,

Mo, Rd

with

0.25 tw dw2 [1 + 1.35(0.7 - 0.9d0/dw) a0/dw] / Wpl

0.312
1.125 - 0.001 a0/tw

=
=

Iy

Where;

=
=

Mel,Rd

=
=

Mpl,Rd

=
=

W pl

=
=

Check :

(for a0/tw > 125

(for a0/tw 125)

1.0

Second moment of area of unperforated cross-section

1.15E+10

mm4

Elastic resistance moment of unperforated cross-section (5.4.5.

5566.06

kN-m

Plastic resistance moment of unperforated cross-section (5.4.5.

6325.1

kN-m

Plastic Modulus of unperforated cross-section

21712916.4

mm3

Moment resistance of perforated cross-section 'Mo, Rd' > Moment at section

My,Ed / Mo, Rd

A.4.2 Out-of-plane moment

Properties of section (about minor axis)

UR

Plastic section modulus of un-perforated section;

Plastic section modulus of perforated section;
Out of plane bending stress from SACS
Bending stress due to perforation

W pl,z
W o,pl,z

=
=

Fbz

Fo,bz

=
UR

14 OF 93

15 OF 93

A.4 Axial Resistance:

Area of un-perforated section
Area of perforated section
Axial stress from SACS
Increased axial stress due to perforation

Ax
Ao,x

=
=

Fa

Fo,a

=
UR

Euperm

A.5 Euler buckling Resistance:

Permissible Euler's buckling stress

Second moment of area of un-perforated section;

Second moment of area of top Tee;
Second moment of area of bottom Tee;

Iz
Izt
Izb

=
=
=

Area of un-perforated section;

Ax

Area of top Tee;

Axt

Area of bottom Tee;

Axb

=
=

Increased axial stress due to perforation

Euler
Eulero

Permissible Euler's buckling stress in top Tee

Euperm,t

Euler's stress from SACS

=
UR

A.6 Combined UR:

Bn + Ax

Second moment of area of un-perforated section;

Iy

Second moment of area of perforated section;

Iyo

Deflection of un-perforated section from SACS;

Deflection of perforated section from SACS;

=
=

A.7 Deflection :

=
Permissible deflection;

Lb / 200

UR

16 OF 93

17 OF 93

EL1

d1

h1
EL
3

e0

ap

d2

h2

hp
EL2

bove or below an opening, should be checked as a compression

ee times its minimum overall depth h 1 or h2.

mm
mm

mm
ckling check of compression flange in plane of web NOT required.

e compression flange buckling in the plane of the web.

/ fyf) [1 - 0.45do / dw][Aw / Afc]0.5

Hence, Transverse stiffeners NOT required.
=

13500 mm2

20520 mm2

18 OF 93
mm

10t w
2

36t w

0.7do

mm
Web of tee is Class 2, Hence OK.

mm

14t w

36t w

0.7do

(Clause N.2.1.1.(2))
mm
>

57.8
(= 69)
Hence, Web stiffeners required at support.

(Clause N.2.1.1.(3))

912.0

mm
Opening dia. is OK.

(Clause N.2.1.1.(3))

mm
mm

>
>

(Clause N.2.1.1.(4))
mm

ck 4.2 is satisfied.

114.0
mm
114.0
mm
Centerline height is OK.

142.5

mm
Eccentricity is OK.

19 OF 93

is presented only for geometry.

/ (Vc,Rd - Vsd)

but, w

1.5 d0

resistance of unperforated web

um of Vpl,Rd (Plastic shear resistance)

(Shear buckling resistance) see section A.3
Rd
kN
force at mid length of web opening
kN

mm
mm
mm

>
409.5
mm
Hence spacing between adjacent opening is OK.

mm
mm

570.0

mm

Hence the distance to end stiffener is OK.

if dw/tw < 90;

mm

/100] d0

if dw/tw > 90;

mm

mm

(a0 = d0)

mm
mm

382.2 mm
Hence 'at' is OK.

ther significant concentrated transverse forces are applied within total

zed as a fixed ended beam spanning length a z, or between transverse

20 OF 93

21 OF 93

ions located further from the opening than the additional length 'a p' of

=
=

d w 0.9d 0 2 4e 02
3.7

d 0 d w 0.9d 0

40.09

.(i)

mm2

.(ii)

Elastic critical shear strength

upports but no inetrmediate transverse stiffeners.

22 OF 93

0.135

Hence OK

ections located further from the opening than the

23 OF 93

1 Vsd/Vo, Rd)
.(iii)

.(iv)

tw > 125)

a0/tw =

15.17

tw 125)

125 =

104.69

cross-section

ed cross-section (5.4.5.1 (2))

ed cross-section (5.4.5.1 (1))

0.17

Hence OK

24 OF 93

3.13E+06 mm3
3.11E+06 mm3
0.9 N/mm2
Fbz * W pl,z
W o,pl,z
0.88 N/mm2
0.002

Hence OK

25 OF 93
47520.0 mm2
42606.0 mm2
6.58 N/mm2
Fa * A x
Ao,x
7.34 N/mm2
0.025

Hence OK

[2 E I / (kL)2] / A =

450 N/mm2

I/A
4.56E+08 mm4
2.28E+08 mm4
2.28E+08 mm4
47520.0 mm2

21861 mm2
20745 mm2
0.00 N/mm2
7.34 N/mm2
Euperm *

(Izt / Axt)
(Iz / Ax)

488.98 N/mm2
0.015

Hence OK

0.21

Hence OK

1.15E+10 mm4
1.14E+10 mm4
4.87

mm
* Iy
Iyo

4.89

mm

42.0

mm

0.116

26 OF 93

Hence OK

Resistance of beams with intermediate transverse web stiffeners

Note: Valid only for Class 1 & 2 sections.

b
tf

tw
dr

Transverse
stiffeners for
penetrations

d1

br
h

e0

dw Y
a0

ap

Pipe sleeve

ap
as

as

Z
B.1

Input
Spacing (shorter) between edge of penetration and inetrmediate
transverse stiffener;

B.2

as

General requirements
Check 1:

(Clause N.1.7.2(3))

Unstiffened webs of tees above and below web openings shall be at least Class 3.

300.0

mm

d2

hp

=
=

(235 / Fy)

<

32 tw

0.84

For Class 2
Criteria
Check

0.7 do
191.1

482.4

mm

OR
Criteria

bwc

bwc

=
=

10t w
36t w
1
0.7d o

min(d1, d2)
402.5 mm

Web of tee is Class 2, He

For Class 3
Criteria
Check

0.7 do
191.1

<

36 tw
542.7

mm

OR
Criteria

bwc

14t w
36t w
0.7d o

Check 2: Web slenderness

dw/tw

390
Depth of web

dw
dw/tw

<
=
=
=

390
326.6
1140
63.3

mm
<

326.6

Hence, Web slenderne

Check 3: Clearance from flange and stiffener

Check 3.1:

Depth of top web (above penetration);

Depth of bottom web (below penetration);

d1
d2

0.1 dw
0.1 dw

(Clause N.2.1.1.(3))

d1
d2

=
=

464.5
402.5

mm
mm

as

300.0

mm

>
>

114.0
114.0
Clearance from flang

Check 3.2:

Check 4: Stiffener spacing 'a'

Clear spacing between intermediate transverse stiffeners;

Hence,

1.0 dw
1.0 dw

a
a

3.0 dw
1.25 dw

1140.0

a/dw

> 0.1 dw, He

for central opening

for eccentric opening
mm

1.0
Stiffener spacing
for central opening
for eccentric opening

Check 5: Size of opening 'do'

do

dw Cos - a Sin
0.3 dw

The inclination of the tension field

=
=

0.67 (1 - do / dw)
0.40
radians

Where as

=
=

arc tan(dw / a)
0.79
radians

Check
1.0 dw a 3.0 dw
1.0 dw a 1.25 dw
for central opening.
for eccentric opening.

dw Cos - a Sin
0.3 dw

=
=

605.8
342.0

mm
mm

>
>

273.0
273.0

Check

Opening size
for central opening
for eccentric opening

d0 < dw Cos - a Sin

d0 < 0.3 dw

Sc

St

NOTE 1: Transverse web stiffeners should be provided where support reactions or other significant concentrated transverse forces are applied.

B.3

Shear resistance of web panel with opening [N.2.1.3(4)]

Shear resistance of web panel

But,

Vo,Rd

Vbb,Rd

Vo,pl,Rd

=
=

3451.1 kN
2674.2 kN

Hence,

Vo,Rd

Vsd / Vo, Rd

2674.2 kN

UR

e0

31.0

0.126

Hence OK

Shear resistance of perforated cross-section 'Vo,pl,Rd'

Eccentricity;

Vo, pl, Rd

Vpl, Rd

0.9d 0 t w f y
M0

2674.19

mm

Where;

kN

d w 0.9d 0 2 4e 02
3.7

d 0 d w 0.9d 0

40.09

Plastic Shear resistance of the unperforated cross-section (5.4.6)

Plastic Shear resistance of the unperforated cross-section (5.4.6)
Vpl, Rd

For welded I, H sections with load parallel to web; Av

Shear buckling resistance (5.6.4.1)

Vbb,Rd

=
=

Av (fy/ 3 ) / M0

dw tw

20520.0

=
=

Strength of the tension field

in which

bb

3451.15

kN

mm2

[(dw tw bb) + 0.9 (g tw bb Sin)] / M1

3451.1 kN
(fyw2 - 3 bb2 + 2)0.5 -

0.00

1.5 bb Sin2

208.20

N/mm2

N/mm2

Initial shear buckling strength

bb

fyw / 3

When w 0.8

[1 - 0.8(w - 0.8)] (fyw / 3)

When 0.8 < w < 1.25

[1 / w ] (fyw / 3)

When w 1.25

Hence;

bb

193.41

Web slenderness
[(fyw/3)/cr] 0.5
dw/tw
37.4 kT

=
=
=

cr

Where;
Where;

kT

Buckling factor for shear

5.34

4 + 5.34/(a/dw)2

=
=
=
Hence; for

[5.6.3(2) of EN 1993-

0.662

Elastic critical shear strength

Case1 :

For webs with transverse stiffeners at supports but no inetrmediate transverse stif

Case2 :

For webs with transverse stiffeners at supports and inetrmediate transverse stiffen
with a/d < 1.

Case3 :

For webs with transverse stiffeners at supports and inetrmediate transverse stiffen
with a/d 1

9.34
5.34 + 4/(a/dw)2

N/mm2

9.34

Case3 :
kT

Width of tension field;

[5.6.4.1(3) of EN 1993-1-1:1992]

9.34

=
=

dw Cos - (a - sc - st) Sin - do

1221.1 mm

[N.2.2.1.(5) of Annex N to EN 1993-1-1:1992]

Where sc and st are the anchorage lengths of the tension field along the compression and tension flanges respectively.
sc or st
But,

2
Sin

MNf,Rk
tw bb

0.5

MNf,Rk
=
Reduced plastic resistance moment of the flange;
Where, Nf.Sd is the longitudinal force in the flange due to the moment M Sd and axial force NSd in the member)

0.25 b tf2 fyf [1 - {Nf.Sd / (b tf fyf / M0)}2]

Axial stress in beam

Fa

Bending stress in extreme fibre of flange

Fby

Area of flange

Af

Combined compressive stress in top flange;

Hence, axial force in top flange

Fa + Fby
Nf.Sd,T

Combined tensile stress in bottom flange;

Hence, axial force in bottom flange

Fa - Fby
Nf.Sd,B

=
=

-46.2 N/mm2
-623.3 kN

Reduced plastic resistance moment of top flange;

Reduced plastic resistance moment of bottom flange;

MNf,Rk,T
MNf,Rk,B

=
=

32.51 kN-m
33.07 kN-m

Anchorage length of the tension field along the compression flange; s c

st

Anchorage length of the tension field along the tension flange;

B.4

6.6 N/mm2
52.8 N/mm2
13500.0 mm2
59.3 N/mm2
801.0 kN

1140.00 mm

1140.00 mm

Moment resistance at mid-length of an opening

(Allowing for the effects of shear force VSd)
Mo,Rd

Check :

=
=

5996.30 kN-m

Moment resistance of perforated cross-section 'Mo, Rd' > Moment at section

My,Ed / Mo, Rd

Where,

Mf,Rd + (Mo,pl,Rd - Mf,Rd)(1 - VSd / Vo,Rd)

UR

0.168

Mf,Rd

=
=

Plastic moment resistance of a cross-section consisting of the flanges only;

4601.15 kN-m

Mo,pl,Rd

Plastic moment resistance of the perforated cross-section;

Hence OK

=
Vo,Rd

=
=

6197.20 kN-m
Shear resistance of the perforated cross-section;
2674.19 kN

VSd

=
=

B.4.1

Design shear force;

336.6 kN

In-plane moment
Moment resistance of perforated cross-section 'Mo,pl, Rd' (without accounting the effect of Shear Force)
Mo,pl, Rd

but

Mo,pl, Rd

Mpl, Rd (1 - 0.225 tw d0 (0.9d0 + 4e0)/Wpl)

Mpl, Rd (1 - 0.25 tw d0 (d0 + 4e0)/Wpl)

6205.99 kN-m

.(i)

6197.20 kN-m

.(ii)

Hence,

Mo,pl, Rd

=
=

minimum of (i) and (ii)

6197.20 kN-m

Where;

Mpl,Rd

=
=

Plastic resistance moment of unperforated cross-section

6325.07 kN-m

[5.4.5.1(1) of EN 1993-1-1:1992]

B.4.2

=
=

Out-of-plane moment
Properties of section (about minor axis)
Plastic section modulus of un-perforated section;

Wpl,z

3129840.0 mm3

Plastic section modulus of perforated section;

Wo,pl,z

3107727.0 mm3

Out of plane bending stress from SACS

Fbz

Bending stress due to perforation

Fo,bz

0.9 N/mm2
Fbz * Wpl,z
Wo,pl,z

=
UR

0.88 N/mm2
0.002

Hence OK

B.5

Axial Resistance:
Area of un-perforated section

Ax

47520.0 mm2

Area of perforated section

Ao,x

42606.0 mm2

Axial stress from SACS

Fa

Axial stress due to perforation

Fo,a

6.6 N/mm2
Fa * Ax
Ao,x

=
UR
B.6

B.7

7.3 N/mm2

0.025

Hence OK

Combined UR:

0.195

Bn + Ax

Hence OK

Second moment of area of un-perforated section;

Iy

1.15E+10 mm4

Second moment of area of un-perforated section;

Iyo

1.14E+10 mm4

Deflection of un-perforated section from SACS;

Deflection of perforated section from SACS;

=
=

4.87

mm
* Iy
Iyo

4.89

mm

Lb / 200

42.0

mm

UR

Deflection :

Permissible deflection;

0.116

Hence OK

B.8

B.8.1

Moment Resistance of circular stiffener [N.2.2.3.4(3)]:

Plastic moment resistance of the circular reinforcement

Mpl,r,Rk

=
=

0.25 br dr2 fyr

1.02 kNm

>

Mr,Sk

Internal moment in the reinforcement

do2 tw bb / 16
0.00 kNm

B.8.2

To compensate for the effect of the opening on the critical buckling resistance the dimesions of the reinforcement should satisfy the following criteria:

1.5d 0
a 2 d w2

1 6d r

dw

br

tw

do

a 2 d w2
2.30

do
a 2 d w2

1.0

>

1.0

0.17

EL1

EL3
Y

hp

EL2

of tee is Class 2, Hence OK

ce, Web slenderness is OK

mm
mm
earance from flange is OK

> 0.1 dw, Hence OK

Remarks
OK
OK

mm
mm

Remarks
OK
OK

 4e 02

d0

< w < 1.25

1.25

5.6.3(2) of EN 1993-1-1:1992]

diate transverse stiffeners.

ate transverse stiffeners

ate transverse stiffeners

a
a

Mr,Sk
0.00 kNm
Hence OK

Hence OK

STIFFENER DESIGN AS PER "EN 1993-1-1:2005"

It is assumed that all the compressive load is taken by stiffener only. No contribution of web plate is considered.
450

15
420
1140

1200

201
Input for stiffener:
Thickness of Stiffener
Yield stress of stiffener
Material Factor

Section A-A

ts

fy
M1

=
=

h
b
tw

=
=
=

Section properties:
Beam
Overall Depth of Member
Width of flange
Thickness of web
Thickness of flange
Height of web (= dw)

tf

hw

Stiffener
Thickness of Stiffener

ts

Height of Stiffener

hs

Width of Stiffener

ws

Cross Sectional Area

As

Second moment of area about x-x axis

Radius of gyration

Ix

=
=
=

Loading:
Transverse load on beam
Design load on stiffener
[9.2.1.(6) & 9.3.3.(3) of EN 1993-1-5]

Vsd
P

=
=
=

Minimum second moment of area:

[9.3.3.(3) of EN 1993-1-5]
i.

If stiffener is loaded
Stiffener spacing

a / hw
if

a / hw < 2 :

Second moment of area;

if

=
<
Ist

Ist

Ist

=
=
>

a / hw > 2 :

Second moment of area;

Hence, since the stiffener is not loaded:

Check for Compression:
Design resistance of stiffener, Nrd = As x fy / M1

Check for Buckling:

=
UR

Lcr

=
=

= (235 / fy)
1 = 93.9 x
= Lcr / (i x 1)
= 0.5 x (1 + x ( - 0.2) + 2)

=
=
=
=

= 1 / ( + (2 - 2))

[6.3.1 of EN 1993-1-1]

Buckling Length
[9.4.(2) of EN 1993-1-5]
Imperfaction factor (using buckling curve 'c')
[9.4.(2)
of EN
1993-1-5]
(Table 6.1
& 6.2,
page no. 57, EN 1993-1-1)

Reduction factor due to buckling,

Area of stiffener to be considered for buckling check

Asb

=
=

[9.1.(2) of EN 1993-1-5]
Design buckling resistance of stiffener

Nb,rd = x Asb x fy / M1

UR

Weld check:
Permissible Stress In Weld
Material Grade
Minimum Yield Strength Fy
Minimum Tensile Strength Fu
Strength of weld shall be min. of

=
=

=
(Refer EN 1993-1-1

1)

2)

Allowable stress =

w
Mw
Hence, weld area required

=
=
=

Effective weld length

Hence, weld size = weld area / (0.707 x weld length)
Provide Weld

ii.

Lw = 2 x Lcr
w
UR

=
=
=
=
=

If stiffener is not loaded

Beam web

Transverse stiffeners

Ist

Second moment of area;

118125
Where,
b
=
=
wo

=
=
=

a1 and a2 =

Initial sinsoidal imperfection

min(a1, a2, b) / 300
3.8 mm
The lengths of the panels adjacent to the transverse stiffener under consideration.
1140.0 mm

a2

1130.0 mm

cr,c NEd
cr,p b

m =
=

cr,p

Hence,

(Refer section C-C in above figure)

1
1

a1 a 2

0.235 N/mm2

cr,c
As per

>
Hence, Second m

The height between the centroids of the flanges or span of the transverse stiffeners.
1170.0 mm

a1 = a =
=

[4.5.4.(1) of EN 1993-1-5]

cr,c
cr,p

Note: In the absence of longitudinal stiffeners

0.1

0. 5
0.50

cr,c
cr,p

1.0

Where,

cr,c

=
=

The elastic critical column buckling stress

2Et 2
12 1 2 ws2

cr,p

1057.0 N/mm2

The elastic critical plate buckling stress

k,p E

20481.8 N/mm2

190000 (ts / b)2

Where,

k,p

Note: In the absence of longitudinal stiffeners

k,p

31.2 N/mm2

2
2 1 2 1

2 11

2 2

Where,

655.8

=
=
=

Assumption: The transverse stiffener is subjected to uniform compression, hence

=
=

Note: In the absence of longitudinal stiffeners

max(0.187,0.5)
0.50

2 / 1
1.0
Isl / Ip
163.4

Isl

=
=

Ip

=
=

3.58

Asl / Ap

0.00

Asl

Ap

Note: In the absence of longitudinal stiffeners

=
=

ws,eff / b

=
Isl

Second moment of area of the whole stiffened plate;

Ip

Second moment of area for out-of-plane bending of the plate;

Asl

Sum of the gross areas of the individual longitudinal stiffeners;

Ap
1

=
=

Gross area of the plate;

Larger edge stress;

Smaller edge stress;

As per
[4.4.(2) & table 4.2 of EN 1993-1-5]
Effective width of outstand compression elements;
ws,eff

ws

=
=
=

0.187 x 201
218.8 mm

1.0

=
=

(p - 0.188) / p2 1.0

0.187
=

b t
28.4 k

=
[Table 4.2 of EN 1993-1-5]
NEd =

The maximum compresive force of the adjacent panels but not les than the maximum copmp
effective compression area of the panel including stiffeners;
=

Hence,

5.15

312.7 kN

2 Ee max

f y 300b
=
=

emax =

M1

1.0

max(0.143,1.0)
1.00
The maximum distance from the extreme fibre of the stiffener to the centroid of the stiffener;

=
=

ts / 2

(Assumed)
7.5 mm

ed.

15
x

y
Section A-A

15.0 mm
355.0 N/mm2
1.15

1200.0 mm
450.0 mm
18.0 mm
30.0 mm
1140.0 mm

15.0 mm
1140.0 mm
201.0 mm
3015.0 mm2
118125 mm4
(Ix / As)
6.3 mm

Vsd - Vo,Rd

336.6 kN
+ m b2 / 2
0.0 kN

1140.0 mm

1.0
2
1.5 hw3 t3 / a2
9972720 mm4

0.75 hw t3
4986360 mm4
Iy
92610000 mm4
9972720 mm4
Check 'ii' is to be verified.

930.72 kN
0.00
Check 'ii' is to be verified.

0.75 hw
855.0 mm
0.49
0.81
76.40
1.79
2.49
0.24
2As + 15tw2 + as tw
15384.18 mm2
1126.24 kN
0.00
Check 'ii' is to be verified.

SMAW
390.0

N/mm2

480.0
N/mm2
fer EN 1993-1-1, Sec. 3.2.1, Pg. 25)
426.67 N/mm2

384.00 N/mm2
384.00 N/mm2

0.90
1.25
3 x P / allowable stress

0.00 mm2
1710 mm
0.00 mm
8.0
mm
0.00

a1

ffeners

a2

Section C-C

m b

1 w 0

300
u
b

42405 mm4
nce, Second moment of area of stiff. is OK

ffeners.

[Eqn. A.2 of EN 1993-1-5]

0.5
4

<

0.5

ts ws3 / 12
10150751.25 mm4
ws ts3 / (12 (1 - 2))
62122.3 mm4

0.0
b ts
17550

mm2

for

p 0.748

for

p > 0.748

b t
4 k

0.43

maximum copmpressive stress times half the

of the stiffener;

MEMBER
NUMBER
1036-1062

MEMBER
END
1036

GROUP
ID
P05

LOAD
COND
1101
1102
1103
1104
1105
1106
1107
1108
1109
1110
1111
1112
1113
1114
1115
1116
1201
1202
1203
1204
1205
1206
1207
1208
1209
1210
1211
1212
1213
1214
1215
1216
1301
1302
1303
1304
1305
1306

***************
***** kN *******
**************
FORCE
FORCE
FORCE
(X)
(Y)
(Z)
8.76
80.65
10.80
82.69
-0.99
70.90
1.05
72.94
4.86
81.83
-4.89
72.08
6.90
83.87
-2.85
74.12
13.54
69.77
15.58
71.81
5.50
61.74
7.54
63.78
10.62
70.65
2.58
62.62
12.66
72.69
4.62
64.66
-28.11
105.40
-25.61
107.89
-46.22
87.29

-11.30
-5.26
-11.32
-5.28
-10.48
-4.44
-10.50
-4.46
-11.33
-5.08
-10.52
-4.27
-11.36
-5.11
-10.54
-4.29
-9.30
-4.92
-9.33
-4.94
-8.54
-4.16
-8.56
-4.18
-9.33
-4.79
-8.57
-4.03
-9.35
-4.82
-8.59
-4.05
-17.05
-5.84
-17.08
-5.87
-15.53
-4.32

127.33
141.17
124.70
138.53
89.27
103.10
86.63
100.46
137.82
152.02
99.75
113.95
135.18
149.38
97.12
111.31
114.34
122.64
111.70
120.00
85.44
93.74
82.80
91.10
122.16
130.73
93.26
101.83
119.52
128.10
90.62
99.20
62.27
87.96
59.04
84.73
-8.43
17.27

1062

1307
1308
1309
1310
1311
1312
1313
1314
1315
1316
1401
1402
1403
1404
1405
1406
1407
1408
1409
1410
1411
1412
1413
1414
1415
1416
1101
1102
1103
1104
1105
1106
1107
1108
1109
1110
1111
1112
1113
1114
1115
1116
1201
1202
1203
1204
1205
1206

-43.72
89.78
-35.36
107.59
-53.47
89.48
-32.87
110.09
-50.97
91.98
-16.20
88.22
-13.70
90.72
-31.12
73.30
-28.63
75.80
-21.62
89.86
-36.55
74.93
-19.13
92.35
-34.05
77.43
-13.51
102.93
-11.48
104.97
-23.26
93.18
-21.23
95.22
-17.42
104.11
-27.17
94.36
-15.38
106.15
-25.13
96.40
1.77
81.55
3.81
83.59
-6.27
73.52

-15.56
-4.35
-17.12
-5.52
-15.60
-4.00
-17.15
-5.55
-15.63
-4.03
-13.24
-5.10
-13.27
-5.13
-11.82
-3.68
-11.85
-3.71
-13.29
-4.86
-11.87
-3.44
-13.32
-4.89
-11.90
-3.47
-4.22
1.82
-4.24
1.80
-3.40
2.64
-3.43
2.61
-4.26
1.99
-3.44
2.81
-4.28
1.97
-3.46
2.78
-4.86
-0.47
-4.88
-0.50
-4.09
0.29

-11.66
14.04
81.74
108.11
11.05
37.41
78.52
104.88
7.82
34.18
63.46
78.88
60.23
75.65
9.78
25.20
6.56
21.97
77.99
93.91
24.31
40.23
74.76
90.68
21.08
37.00
28.20
42.03
25.56
39.40
11.00
24.84
8.36
22.20
38.69
52.88
21.49
35.68
36.05
50.24
18.85
33.05
42.48
50.78
39.84
48.14
26.95
35.25

1207
1208
1209
1210
1211
1212
1213
1214
1215
1216
1301
1302
1303
1304
1305
1306
1307
1308
1309
1310
1311
1312
1313
1314
1315
1316
1401
1402
1403
1404
1405
1406
1407
1408
1409
1410
1411
1412
1413
1414
1415
1416

-4.23
75.55
-1.15
82.43
-9.19
74.40
0.88
84.47
-7.15
76.43
-69.48
146.78
-66.99
149.27
-87.59
128.67
-85.09
131.16
-76.73
148.97
-94.84
130.86
-74.24
151.47
-92.35
133.36
-38.06
110.09
-35.56
112.59
-52.98
95.17
-50.49
97.66
-43.49
111.72
-58.41
96.80
-40.99
114.22
-55.91
99.29

-4.11
0.27
-4.88
-0.34
-4.12
0.42
-4.91
-0.37
-4.14
0.40
-3.92
7.30
-3.95
7.27
-2.40
8.82
-2.43
8.79
-3.99
7.62
-2.47
9.13
-4.02
7.59
-2.50
9.11
-4.98
3.15
-5.01
3.12
-3.56
4.57
-3.59
4.55
-5.04
3.39
-3.62
4.81
-5.07
3.36
-3.64
4.78

24.31
32.61
50.30
58.87
34.77
43.34
47.66
56.23
32.13
40.71
-25.34
0.35
-28.57
-2.88
-57.28
-31.58
-60.51
-34.81
-5.87
20.50
-37.80
-11.44
-9.10
17.27
-41.03
-14.67
-0.23
15.18
-3.46
11.95
-29.07
-13.66
-32.30
-16.89
14.29
30.21
-14.55
1.37
11.06
26.98
-17.78
-1.86

*******************
kN-m ****** **************
MOMENT
MOMENT
MOMENT
(X)
(Y)
(Z)
0.37
0.49
0.37
0.49
0.28
0.41
0.29
0.41
0.34
0.47
0.26
0.39
0.35
0.48
0.27
0.40
0.32
0.40
0.32
0.41
0.26
0.34
0.26
0.35
0.30
0.39
0.24
0.33
0.31
0.40
0.25
0.34
0.31
0.53
0.32
0.54
0.16
0.39

850.15
867.45
837.01
854.31
625.66
642.96
612.52
629.82
897.41
915.33
672.93
690.85
884.28
902.20
659.79
677.71
829.44
836.34
816.31
823.20
642.03
648.93
628.89
635.79
864.70
872.07
677.29
684.66
851.57
858.94
664.15
671.52
546.89
579.01
530.80
562.93
129.98
162.11

9.59
3.59
9.57
3.58
8.65
2.66
8.64
2.65
9.65
3.40
8.72
2.46
9.64
3.38
8.70
2.45
8.58
4.39
8.57
4.38
7.69
3.50
7.68
3.49
8.63
4.25
7.74
3.36
8.62
4.24
7.73
3.35
13.27
2.14
13.26
2.12
11.54
0.41

Maximum
Minimum

My
Fx
Fy
Fz

FORCE
(X)
151.47
-94.84

FORCE
(Y)
9.13
-17.15

1099.74 kNm
151.47 kN
17.15 kN
152.02 kN

0.17
0.39
0.27
0.51
0.12
0.36
0.28
0.51
0.13
0.36
0.28
0.43
0.28
0.44
0.16
0.32
0.17
0.32
0.25
0.41
0.13
0.30
0.25
0.42
0.14
0.30
0.37
0.49
0.37
0.49
0.28
0.41
0.29
0.41
0.34
0.47
0.26
0.39
0.35
0.48
0.27
0.40
0.32
0.40
0.32
0.41
0.26
0.34

113.90
146.02
634.67
667.95
217.76
251.04
618.58
651.86
201.68
234.96
593.14
605.94
577.05
589.86
245.03
257.83
228.94
241.75
658.62
672.31
310.51
324.19
642.53
656.22
294.42
308.11
990.13
1032.33
972.24
1014.44
715.90
758.10
698.02
740.22
1056.27
1099.74
782.04
825.51
1038.38
1081.85
764.16
807.63
970.58
992.42
952.69
974.53
743.18
765.02

11.52
0.39
13.39
1.78
11.66
0.04
13.37
1.76
11.64
0.03
11.20
3.42
11.18
3.40
9.54
1.76
9.53
1.75
11.28
3.15
9.63
1.49
11.27
3.13
9.61
1.48
-4.38
0.50
-4.43
0.44
-3.84
1.04
-3.89
0.98
-4.38
0.61
-3.84
1.15
-4.44
0.56
-3.90
1.10
-4.16
-0.46
-4.21
-0.51
-3.67
0.03

0.26
0.35
0.30
0.39
0.24
0.33
0.31
0.40
0.25
0.34
0.31
0.53
0.32
0.54
0.16
0.39
0.17
0.39
0.27
0.51
0.12
0.36
0.28
0.51
0.13
0.36
0.28
0.43
0.28
0.44
0.16
0.32
0.17
0.32
0.25
0.41
0.13
0.30
0.25
0.42
0.14
0.30

725.30
747.14
1019.91
1042.72
792.52
815.32
1002.03
1024.83
774.63
797.44
580.12
658.50
558.22
636.60
70.85
149.22
48.95
127.33
702.96
783.69
193.68
274.41
681.06
761.79
171.79
252.52
650.04
690.60
628.15
668.70
227.66
268.22
205.77
246.32
741.67
784.01
319.29
361.63
719.77
762.11
297.39
339.73

-3.73
-0.03
-4.16
-0.37
-3.68
0.11
-4.22
-0.43
-3.73
0.06
-5.60
3.45
-5.67
3.39
-4.60
4.45
-4.67
4.39
-5.61
3.66
-4.61
4.67
-5.68
3.60
-4.68
4.60
-5.20
1.67
-5.27
1.60
-4.30
2.57
-4.37
2.50
-5.21
1.82
-4.31
2.73
-5.28
1.76
-4.38
2.66

FORCE
(Z)
152.02
-60.51

MOMENT
(X)
0.54
0.12

MOMENT
(Y)
1099.74
48.95

MOMENT
(Z)
13.39
-5.68

_x000C_
DATE
M-71

0 INPL

ACE ANA

LYSIS

Err:509
MEMBER

MEMBER
NUMBER
1036-1062

MEMBER
END

GROUP
ID

1036 P05

LOAD
COND
1101
1102
1103
1104
1105
1106
1107
1108
1109
1110
1111
1112
1113
1114
1115
1116
1201
1202
1203
1204
1205
1206
1207
1208
1209
1210
1211
1212
1213
1214
1215
1216
1301
1302
1303
1304
1305
1306

FORCES AND
MENTS
MO

***************
***** kN *******
**************
*******************
FORCE(X) FORCE(Y) FORCE(Z) MOMENT(X)

8.762
80.6493
10.7998
82.6871
-0.9879
70.8994
1.05
72.9373
4.8572
81.8311
-4.8926
72.0813
6.895
83.8689
-2.8548
74.1191
13.539
69.7744
15.5768
71.8122
5.5046
61.7399
7.5424
63.7777
10.6176
70.653
2.5832
62.6186
12.6554
72.6908
4.621
64.6564
-28.1095
105.3955
-25.6143
107.8907
-46.2163
87.2887

-11.2951
-5.2565
-11.3184
-5.2798
-10.4777
-4.4391
-10.5011
-4.4624
-11.333
-5.0846
-10.5157
-4.2672
-11.3564
-5.1079
-10.539
-4.2905
-9.3031
-4.9205
-9.3265
-4.9439
-8.5378
-4.1552
-8.5611
-4.1786
-9.3312
-4.7921
-8.5659
-4.0268
-9.3545
-4.8154
-8.5892
-4.0501
-17.0514
-5.8368
-17.08
-5.8654
-15.5334
-4.3188

127.3333
141.1689
124.6963
138.5319
89.2655
103.1012
86.6285
100.4642
137.82
152.015
99.7522
113.9472
135.183
149.378
97.1152
111.3102
114.3393
122.6405
111.7024
120.0035
85.4405
93.7416
82.8035
91.1047
122.1602
130.7333
93.2614
101.8345
119.5232
128.0964
90.6244
99.1975
62.2689
87.9637
59.04
84.7348
-8.4283
17.2664

0.3652
0.486
0.3702
0.4911
0.2848
0.4057
0.2899
0.4108
0.3442
0.4711
0.2639
0.3907
0.3493
0.4762
0.269
0.3958
0.3193
0.4043
0.3243
0.4094
0.2575
0.3426
0.2626
0.3476
0.3036
0.3931
0.2419
0.3314
0.3087
0.3982
0.2469
0.3365
0.3102
0.5347
0.3164
0.5409
0.161
0.3855

1062

1307
1308
1309
1310
1311
1312
1313
1314
1315
1316
1401
1402
1403
1404
1405
1406
1407
1408
1409
1410
1411
1412
1413
1414
1415
1416
1101
1102
1103
1104
1105
1106
1107
1108
1109
1110
1111
1112
1113
1114
1115
1116
1201
1202
1203
1204
1205
1206

-43.721
89.784
-35.3612
107.5903
-53.468
89.4835
-32.866
110.0856
-50.9728
91.9788
-16.1993
88.2248
-13.7041
90.7201
-31.123
73.3011
-28.6278
75.7964
-21.6248
89.8566
-36.5484
74.9329
-19.1295
92.3518
-34.0532
77.4281
-13.5144
102.9325
-11.4766
104.9703
-23.2642
93.1826
-21.2264
95.2204
-17.4192
104.1143
-27.169
94.3645
-15.3814
106.1521
-25.1312
96.4023
1.7676
81.5509
3.8054
83.5887
-6.2668
73.5164

-15.562 -11.6573
-4.3474 14.0375
-17.1219 81.7442
-5.5176 108.1064
-15.6039
11.047
-3.9996 37.4092
-17.1504 78.5153
-5.5461 104.8775
-15.6324
7.8181
-4.0281 34.1802
-13.2392 63.4633
-5.1011 78.8777
-13.2677 60.2343
-5.1297 75.6487
-11.8176
9.7846
-3.6796
25.199
-11.8462
6.5557
-3.7081 21.9701
-13.2912 77.9878
-4.8625 93.9073
-11.8697 24.3091
-3.441 40.2286
-13.3198 74.7588
-4.8911 90.6784
-11.8983 21.0802
-3.4695 36.9997
-4.2199 28.1983
1.8187
42.034
-4.2432 25.5613
1.7954
39.397
-3.4025 11.0014
2.6361 24.8371
-3.4258
8.3644
2.6128 22.2001
-4.2578
38.685
1.9906
52.88
-3.4404 21.4881
2.808 35.6832
-4.2811
36.048
1.9673
50.243
-3.4638 18.8512
2.7847 33.0462
-4.8558 42.4753
-0.4732 50.7764
-4.8791 39.8383
-0.4965 48.1394
-4.0905 26.9489
0.2921 35.2501

0.1672
0.3917
0.2713
0.5069
0.1221
0.3577
0.2775
0.5132
0.1283
0.364
0.275
0.4329
0.2812
0.4392
0.1603
0.3182
0.1665
0.3245
0.246
0.4122
0.1313
0.2975
0.2522
0.4184
0.1375
0.3037
0.3652
0.486
0.3702
0.4911
0.2848
0.4057
0.2899
0.4108
0.3442
0.4711
0.2639
0.3907
0.3493
0.4762
0.269
0.3958
0.3193
0.4043
0.3243
0.4094
0.2575
0.3426

1207
1208
1209
1210
1211
1212
1213
1214
1215
1216
1301
1302
1303
1304
1305
1306
1307
1308
1309
1310
1311
1312
1313
1314
1315
1316
1401
1402
1403
1404
1405
1406
1407
1408
1409
1410
1411
1412
1413
1414
1415
1416

-4.229
75.5542
-1.1538
82.4295
-9.1882
74.3951
0.884
84.4673
-7.1504
76.4329
-69.4828
146.7757
-66.9876
149.2709
-87.5896
128.6689
-85.0944
131.1641
-76.7345
148.9705
-94.8413
130.8637
-74.2393
151.4657
-92.3461
133.3589
-38.0598
110.0904
-35.5646
112.5856
-52.9835
95.1667
-50.4883
97.6619
-43.4852
111.7222
-58.4089
96.7985
-40.99
114.2174
-55.9137
99.2937

-4.1138
0.2688
-4.8839
-0.3448
-4.1185
0.4206
-4.9072
-0.3681
-4.1419
0.3972
-3.9176
7.297
-3.9461
7.2685
-2.3996
8.815
-2.4281
8.7865
-3.988
7.6163
-2.47
9.1343
-4.0166
7.5877
-2.4986
9.1057
-4.9849
3.1531
-5.0135
3.1246
-3.5634
4.5746
-3.592
4.5461
-5.037
3.3917
-3.6155
4.8132
-5.0656
3.3632
-3.644
4.7847

24.3119
32.6131
50.2962
58.8693
34.7698
43.3429
47.6592
56.2323
32.1328
40.7059
-25.3424
0.3524
-28.5713
-2.8765
-57.2794
-31.5846
-60.5084
-34.8136
-5.8671
20.4951
-37.8041
-11.4419
-9.096
17.2662
-41.033
-14.6709
-0.2348
15.1796
-3.4638
11.9506
-29.0746
-13.6602
-32.3035
-16.8891
14.2897
30.2092
-14.5501
1.3694
11.0607
26.9803
-17.779
-1.8595

0.2626
0.3476
0.3036
0.3931
0.2419
0.3314
0.3087
0.3982
0.2469
0.3365
0.3102
0.5347
0.3164
0.5409
0.161
0.3855
0.1672
0.3917
0.2713
0.5069
0.1221
0.3577
0.2775
0.5132
0.1283
0.364
0.275
0.4329
0.2812
0.4392
0.1603
0.3182
0.1665
0.3245
0.246
0.4122
0.1313
0.2975
0.2522
0.4184
0.1375
0.3037

18-Sep-12 TIME 11:52: 9

kN-m ******
**************
MOMENT(Y)MOMENT(Z)

850.1473
867.4457
837.0104
854.3089
625.6605
642.9589
612.5236
629.8221
897.4135
915.3325
672.9267
690.8457
884.2767
902.1957
659.7899
677.7089
829.4437
836.34
816.3069
823.2032
642.0316
648.9279
628.8948
635.7911
864.7024
872.0731
677.2902
684.6609
851.5656
858.9362
664.1534
671.5241
546.8885
579.0142
530.8027
562.9285
129.9844
162.1101

9.5858
3.5908
9.5735
3.5785
8.6537
2.6587
8.6415
2.6465
9.6486
3.3961
8.7165
2.464
9.6363
3.3839
8.7042
2.4518
8.5844
4.3949
8.5722
4.3826
7.6925
3.5029
7.6802
3.4907
8.6309
4.2493
7.739
3.3574
8.6187
4.2371
7.7268
3.3452
13.2709
2.1373
13.2558
2.1223
11.5399
0.4063

113.8986
146.0244
634.6686
667.9467
217.7645
251.0426
618.5829
651.861
201.6788
234.9569
593.1379
605.9438
577.0522
589.8581
245.0258
257.8317
228.9401
241.746
658.6183
672.3051
310.5061
324.193
642.5325
656.2194
294.4204
308.1072
990.1254
1032.328
972.2419
1014.445
715.9005
758.1031
698.017
740.2196
1056.268
1099.738
782.0428
825.5128
1038.384
1081.854
764.1594
807.6293
970.5767
992.415
952.6932
974.5316
743.1819
765.0203

11.5248
0.3913
13.3874
1.7757
11.6564
0.0447
13.3724
1.7607
11.6414
0.0297
11.1983
3.4187
11.1833
3.4037
9.5416
1.762
9.5266
1.747
11.2847
3.1484
9.628
1.4917
11.2697
3.1334
9.613
1.4767
-4.3777
0.4968
-4.4319
0.4426
-3.8385
1.036
-3.8927
0.9818
-4.3832
0.6116
-3.844
1.1508
-4.4374
0.5573
-3.8982
1.0965
-4.1586
-0.4595
-4.2128
-0.5138
-3.673
0.0261

725.2985
747.1369
1019.913
1042.715
792.5181
815.3205
1002.029
1024.832
774.6346
797.437
580.1223
658.4985
558.2245
636.6007
70.8475
149.2237
48.9497
127.3259
702.9579
783.6878
193.6831
274.413
681.0601
761.79
171.7853
252.5152
650.0433
690.595
628.1456
668.6972
227.6649
268.2166
205.7671
246.3188
741.6677
784.0096
319.2892
361.6311
719.7698
762.1118
297.3914
339.7333

-3.7272
-0.0281
-4.1626
-0.3738
-3.6769
0.1118
-4.2168
-0.428
-3.7311
0.0576
-5.6012
3.4515
-5.6676
3.3851
-4.5998
4.4529
-4.6662
4.3864
-5.6114
3.6645
-4.61
4.6659
-5.6778
3.5981
-4.6764
4.5995
-5.2034
1.6655
-5.2698
1.599
-4.3013
2.5675
-4.3677
2.5011
-5.2107
1.8247
-4.3086
2.7267
-5.2771
1.7583
-4.375
2.6603

v1.1

changes from last revision

1.0 in this revision the design is for envelop forces.
2.0 assumptions modified.
3.0 "B. Stiff. design for penetr." sheet is for the design of transverse stiffeners on either side of the penetratio

either side of the penetrations.