Sowing Seeds of Thought

Satyameva Jayate - Truth Alone Triumphs

Friday, November 5, 2010
No Horse at Harappa! Sarasvati River and the Vedic Civilisation by NS Rajaram
Part 5

No Horse at Harappa!

American archaeologist Jim Shaffer noted:

Current archaeological data do not support the existence of an Indo-Aryan or European
invasion into South Asia any time in the pre- or proto historic periods. Instead, it is possible to
document archaeologically a series of cultural changes reflecting indigenous cultural
development from prehistoric to historic period.
In addition to such negative evidence, positive evidence has shown that the Harappan
civilisation was a part of the Vedic Aryan fold and this evidence includes the presence of
horses. The proponents of the AIT theory have in a child like manner harped about the
absence of horse by coining a slogan No Horse at Harappa. The juvenile fashion in which
they have gone about dancing and celebrating this worthy of note because the scientific
evidence shows otherwise. Horse both domestic and wild varieties have been found at
places like Koldihwa and Mahagarh in interior India dating back to 6500 BC! These are
Neolithic sites. The issue of horse has been blown out of proportion by scholars with the
vested interest in preserving the invasion theory and the non indigenous basis of the Vedas
and the Vedic civilisation.
One of the most vociferous deniers is Michael Witzel who has gone to claim that any
Harappan horse remains is a later introduction. This means that horse remains found and
described by John Marshall in the 1920s was introduced later. Witzel and his band of
happily ignorant deniers stand discredited after this episode. How they lost their tongue
can be illustrated by evidence found which is scientific and accepted by scholars
worldwide. Sample the findings below.


Ref: Sarasvati and the Vedic Civilisation by NS Rajaram

Remains of horses have been found among other places in Mahagara near Allahabad (dated
to c. 2265 BC to 1480 BC, described as Equus ferus caballus Linn), Hallur in Karnataka
(c.1500 - 1300 BC, described as Equus ferus caballus), Mohenjo-Daro, Harappa ("small
horse"), Lothal (e.g., a terracotta figurine and a molar horse tooth, dated to 2200 BC),
Kalibangan, and Kuntasi (dated to 2300 1900 BC). Horse remains from the Harappan site
Surkotada (dated to c. 2400-1700 BC) have been identified by A.K. Sharma as Equus ferus
caballus. The horse specialist Sandor Bknyi (1997) later confirmed these conclusions and
stated that the excavated tooth specimens could "in all probability be considered remnants of
true horses [i.e. Equus ferus caballus]". Bknyi stated that "The occurrence of true horse
(Equus caballus L.) was evidenced by the enamel pattern of the upper and lower cheek and
teeth and by the size and form of incisors and phalanges (toe bones)." An alleged clay model of
a horse has been found in Mohenjo-Daro and an alleged horse figurine in Periano Ghundai in
the Indus Valley.
Trautmann (1982) thus remarked that the supply and import of horses has "always" been a
preoccupation of the Indians and that "it is a structure of its history, then, that India has
always been dependent upon western and central Asia for horses." The paucity of horse
remains could also be explained by India's climatic factors which lead to a faster decay of
horse bones. Horse bones may also be rare because horses were probably not eaten or used in
burials by the Harappans.
It should however also be noted that other sites like the BMAC (Bactrian Margiania
Archaeological complex i.e. areas surrounding the Caspian Sea) which some consider
nevertheless as Indo-Aryan are at least as poor in horse remains as the Harappan sites. Note
also that the horse only appears in Mesopotamia from ca. 1800 BC when it acquires military
significance with the invention of the chariot. Domestication of the horse before the 2nd
millennium appears confined to its native habitat (the Great Steppe).
Colin Renfrew (1999) also remarked that "the significance of the horse ... has been much
exaggerated" and Bryant holds that "using such negative evidence, by the same logic used to
eliminate India as a candidate, ultimately any potential homeland can be disqualified due to
lacking some fundamental Proto-Indo-European item or another.
Source: Wikipedia

Comment: Moreover the horse Equus Namadicus (named after remains found in Narmada
basin) had been an indigenous animal in India since the Pleistocene, which means 2.5
million years from the Common Era. Equus Namadius remains have been found as far as in
present day Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh also. Another strain the Equus Sivalensis was
found in the Shivalik Mountains and all across northern India. Thus horses have been
known in India from untold antiquity a fact that is borne out by hard scientific evidence
thus demolishing the No horse at Harappa dogma. Ever since this evidence was presented
Witzel and his cronies with no room to escape have been quiet on this subject.

Please read more from the same series
http://sowingseedsofthought.blogspot.com/2010/11/synopses-from-book-sarasvati-and-
vedic.html
http://sowingseedsofthought.blogspot.com/2010/11/synopses-from-book-sarasvati-and-
vedic_02.html
http://sowingseedsofthought.blogspot.com/2010/11/excerpts-from-book-sarasvati-river-
and.html
http://sowingseedsofthought.blogspot.com/2010/11/excerpts-from-book-sarasvati-river-
and_03.html
http://sowingseedsofthought.blogspot.com/2010/11/global-drought-ended-harappa-not-
any.html
http://sowingseedsofthought.blogspot.com/2010/11/reference-to-sarasvati-in-
rigveda.html
http://sowingseedsofthought.blogspot.com/2010/11/sarasvati-great-mother-of-us-
all.html
http://sowingseedsofthought.blogspot.com/2010/12/ancient-chronology-harappa-
sutra.html
http://sowingseedsofthought.blogspot.com/2010/12/ancient-indian-history-retrofitted-
into.html
http://sowingseedsofthought.blogspot.com/2010/10/4-recommended-books-for-all-
ancient.html
Posted by Shankara at 9:12 AM
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to TwitterShare to Facebook
Labels: Aryan Invasion theory, Colin Renfrew, History, Horse at Harappa, Jim Schaffer,
Kalibangan, Mesopotamia, NS Rajaram, Politics, Pseudo Secularism, Religion, Trautmann,
Vedic Saraswati Civilisation
Reactions: