Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
i
t he i nf or mat i on r equest ed f or LA Super i or Cour t J udge Davi d P. Yaf f e. We do . .
r ecor ds pr i or t o 1989. Pl ease e- mai l at gi ver son@audi t or . l acount y. gov i f I
quest i ons. !
I
I
~
~
MegaFl ex
Cont r i but i on
401( k) / 457
Cont r i but i ons Al l owance
Pr of essi onal Devel opment
11989 $ 6, 111. 54 $
11990 $ 7, 206. 83 $
11991 $ 15, 192. 52 $
' 11992 $ 18, 866. 40 $
1993 $ 18, 866. 40 $
1994 $ 19, 731. 22 $
11995 $ 20, 354. 56 $
11996 $ 20, 404. 08 $
f 1997 $ 20, 404. 08 $
I 1998 $ 20, 659. 16 $
I
I1999 $ 21, 594. 24 $
2000 $ 22, 627. 29 $
2001 $ 25, 114. 87 $
i 2002 $ 26, 290. 67 $
12003 $ 26, 845. 62 $
!2004 $ 27, 329. 28 $
!2005 $ 28, 256. 14 s
!2006 $ 29, 177. 76 $
'. .2007 $ 32, 965. 52 $
i 200B $ 33, 969. 96 $
~2009 $ 33, 969. 96 $
12010 $ 31, 139. 13 $
I- - - - - Or i gi nal Message- - - - -
iFr om: dr hassoc@ear t hl i nk. net [ mai l t o; dr hassoc@ear t hl i nk. net ]
I
I,sent: Thur sday, May 12, 2011 4; 29 PM
i To: I ver son, Gr egg M.
ISubj ect : Publ i c Recor ds Request - Ur gent - 2nd r equest
IThi s i s a f ol l ow up t o my pr evi ous r equest . Can you pr ovi de me wi t h t he i nf or mat i on
I or a st at us on t he r equest ?
i
IThank you,
IDavi d Her nandez
Year
3, 450. 24
3, 699. 51
4, 432. 01
5, 995. 22
4, 475. 74
2, 875. 30
7, 442. 24
7, 667. 64
7, 420. 97
5, 175. 66
5, 409. 92
8, 357. 13
11, 307. 39
9, 90B. 39
12, 377. 21
12, 600. 24
13, 027. 59
13, 452. 48
15, 19B. B3
15, 661. 92
15, 661. 92
14, 356. 76
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
s
$
$
$
s
$
$
$
$
$
$
1, 960. 00
4, 704. 00
5, 162. 50
5, 004. 00
5, 161. 50
5, l B4. 00
5, 331. 00
5, 352. 00
5, 499. 00
5, 520. 00
5, 814. 00
5, 856. 00
6, 150. 00
6, 192. 00
6, 528. 00
6, 838. 50
7, 075. 50
7, 366. 50
7, 404. 00
6, 478. 50
EXHIBIT "A"
,- 1
; I
\-----Forwarded Message----- l t
!! ,~
\ 1 Fr om: dr hassoc@ear t hl i nk. net j'
If Sent : May 2/ 2011 6:08 PM 1:,1
I t To: GI VERSON@audi t or . l acount y. gov .1
I Cc; Davi d Her nandez <dr hassoc@ear t hl i nk. net > "I
1 Subj ect : Publ i c Recor ds Request - Ur gent II
IIDear Audi t or : I
I I Pur suant t o t he pr ovi si ons of t he Cal i f or ni a Publ i c Recor ds Act , r equest i s her eby f:
i'.made f or document s showi ng al l payment s f r om , LACount y commonl y known as " l ocal !~
I,' j udi ci al benef i t s" t o LA Super i or Cour t J udge Davi d P. Yaf f e f r om t he commencement II
IIof such payment s bel i eved t o be f r om 1986 t hr ough t he pr esent . A year l y summar y of ~I
I I I " Me9af l ex caf et er i a pl an benef i t s" , 401( K) , 457 or ot her r et i r ement cont r i but i ons, I I
I " pr of essi onal devel opment al l owances" and any ot her LA Count y compensat i on f or each II
I f year t hat t he " l ocal j udi ci al benef i t s" wer e pai d wi l l be suf f i ci ent . (
p 1111
!I Ti ne i s of t he essence. An e- mai l r esponse t o dr hassoc@ear t hl i nk. net cont ai ni ng al l .1
I f avai l abl e r ecor ds or a summar y t her eof wi l l be suf f i ci ent . I i
IIThank you f or your at t ent i on t o t he most ur gent mat t er . II
,i ,_ ,,'!_ ',! II
!I Si ncer el y, .
II iI
!IDavi d R. Her nandez II
! !
l I
EXHIBIT "A"
Me~ 27 10 04~21p
AAW CPA FDN
310- 919- 2890 p. 1
Case 2 :09- cv- Oi 914-J Ft\i:-PW Document 1- 4
1
2
3
4
5
fi
7
8
~
10
II
12
13
14
1:1
) . 6
17
18
1.'9
20
21
22
23
:
.
I 2'1
;
j
2S
!
t
2 6
1. 7
I
2 8
I
~
Filed 03f29/~p09 Page i06 of 169
sOPE~rOR C'oU'R'.r OF THE STATE OF CJ \l.l~ORNIA
~OR 4HE COUNT~OF LOS ANGELES
ompAR~~NT NO. 86
flON. DA.VIO P. YAFl!'E/ 'J UDGE
)
)
)
)
}
)
)
}
RSSPONDEN'1' )
-~---------"~--~-~ .... --- '- - )
MAR.:.tNl\ STRAND COLON' I I
PETJ : TI ONER,
VS.
NO. as 109420
REPORTER'S
CERTl: rICA't1!:
coUN'rY OF LOS ANGELES.
SThTE OF CALXFORNI A
SB
couNTY OF LOS ~~GELES
r r CYNTHJ :A S. CRUZ, OFFICIAL REPORTER O~ THE SUPl!:RrOR
COURT OF 'tHE STATE Of' CA,LlfORNI t FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS
ANGELES, DO tlERgBY' CERTIFY TH.1\T 'rHI:i F'O~E~OXNG PAGS. 1
THROUGH a, COMPRISE A PAflT!AL, TROl'; AND CORRl!;CT 'l"J UNSCRIPT OF
THE PROCE~D.INCS HELD IN THe: l\f}OVS- 'SNTI'I'LED MATTER ON OECEMl3B'R
22, 2008.
DATED l'HIS 23It" DAY OF OSCEM6gR, 2006.
EXHIBIT "B"
Mo~ 27 10 04: 21p AAW CPA F' DN 310- 818- 2890
. t 3
4
5
"-t
"
6
: "
7
8
9
10
11
12
1: }
14
p. 2
Case 2 :09- cv"'()1914- J P.W~CW Document ~-4
J
. ,
F\\ea 03~Ol?QQ9 P2Qi se 9f.__
1
LOS ~GELES. CALI F. ; MON. , DEC~aER 22, 2008; A. ~. SESSI ON
DtPAR.TMENT N'O. a6
HON~ DAVI D P. YAFFE, J ODGE
{THE REAL PARTXES r . NI NT~EST WXTHTHEI ~
COUNSEL, J OSHUA L. ROS~N AND R. J . COM2~,
ATTORNEYS AT LAW; lUCHARDX. FINE, XN PROPRIA
PERSONA. )
( CYNTHI A S. CRUZ, C. S. R. 9095, OFFI Ci AL
REPOltTER. )
(THE FOI,LOWJ :NG PARTI AL fROCEEDl:NGS WERE HELD IN
OPEN COURT:)
TfIE COURT l ALl:, RIGHT. rI M SOMEWHAT TROUBLED BY
E"l'lXOENCE CODE SECTION 703 (D) WltJ :CH SAYS IN TUE ABSENCE OF
15 on~ECTI ON BY A , PARTY, THE J UDGE PRESI DI NG AT THE ~RI AL OF
16 AN 1\CTION MAY TESTIFY IN THAT T.RIAL AS A WJ :'l'NESS. I DON'T
17 SEE HOW I CAN TaSTr FY I N A Tnl AL ~S A WI ~SS XN WHI CH!
18 AM THE SOLE DECIDER OF FACT I F THERE ~s. I N FACT. ANY
20 MYS~LF WOOLD BE A FACTOR. HOWEVER, TH~ FI RST PART OF THI S
19 I SSUE I N DI SPUTE WI TH RESPECT - - WH~CH MY CR~Cl aXLr TY TO
,
t
t
I
i
~
,
27
21 STATUTE SAYS THAT BEFORE I MAY BE CALLBD TO TESTI FY AS A
Z2 WI t NESS, I AM TO, I N PROCEEDI NGS HELD OUT OF THE PRESENCE
23 OF THE J URy, I NFORM TH~ PART~Ea OF THAT POSI Tr ON THAT I
24 l1:AVEON ANr MATTER .ANY FACT OR botATTER OF FACT UPON' WHICH
25 I WI LL BE CALLED UPON TO TESTI FY.
l S
l
NOW, MR. F:nn~ HAS LISTED THE MATTF;~S ON WHICH
I ' M TO BE CALLeD TO TSTI F~. X DON' T ~Hr NK THERE I S ~
DI SPUTE AS TO ANY OF THOSE MATTERS. '[-
EXHIBIT "B"
Ma~ 27 10 04: 22p AAW CPA FDN
310- 919- 2890
p. 3
Case 2 :Q9- G'V- Q1914- J ~CW Docume nt 1-4
Filed 03/20J2009 Page 99 of 169
.. ~
1
2
J
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
l'l
15
16
17
16
19
20
21
2~
23
24
25
2 6
21
29
:t HAVE RECIVEtl PAYMEN'l'S FROM THE COUNTY. 1 DID
RECEIVE THEM WHILE I WA.S tiANOLING CASES '"1'0 WHJ :CH THIS
COUNTY WAS Po. ?ARTY. I DID NOT REPORT THEM ON THI!! FORM 700
~RAT rs FI LED WI TH THE FEOERAL WZTH THS FAIR POLITICAL
i Pt..YMI!NTS l'IHICH ~ou RECEIVE "Hleu AR& MEGA FLEX PAW " " , " S. J
L_ - - - - - ~- - - ~- - ~- - - .- - - ~- .- - ~- - - - "-
i
r)t
PRACTICES COMl"XSSIOl't OF' THE STATP.: OF CALJ :FORNl:A. 1.'RI!!Y
WSRE REl?QR"rEO ON TWO STATEMENTS THAT r WAS Issueo AT TH~
EN'D OF EACH YEAR MUCH R~POItTr;:D ALL THE PAYMENTS TlIAT I
OOT FOR - - FROM SITTING AS A J UDGE FROM BOTH T1fS STArt: AND
THl!: COUNTY.
13Y THE WAY, ALl; P1l.'fMtJ :N'l"S 'l'IihT 1RECEJ ;VEO AS A
J UOQE ARE O~ A WA~nANT I SSUED BY TH CO~~Y OF LOs
ANGELES. THE STATE REIMBURSES THE COUNTY AND THE COl.TN1'Y
I SSUES A WARRANT WHI CH PAYS ME ~ ~~ OF TH~ OTHER
. 10" 0GEB.
MR. F:tNE: l!;XCUSE ME, YOUR HONOR. WITH ALI,. "QUI::
RESPECT. YOUR HONOR. THAT Is 1:NCORRECT. THE STATE DOES
NOT RE:rMI3URSE 1.'HE COUNTY OF LOS AN'G~LF.S FOR THE PAYMENTS
THAT THE COUN'l'Y OF LOS ANGEL]!;S KAK.E.:;l, TJ lE cotnrrx or r..os
ANGELl'!;S MAKES THose PA~MEN'I'S OUT OF THE COUNTY' 5 GeNERA!..
F'UND, AND THERE IS NO R1l:IMBtrnSEMI:!NTS.
THE COURT; 'l"AAT'S CORRECT. TtrAT'S RIGHT. THE
COUNTY REIMBURSES ~- THE S1'ATE REIMBURSES THE COUNTY fOR
THE PORTI ON OF TH~ COUNTY Wh~~wr TRAT PAYS MY SA~ARY
OTHER THAN THS MECA F~EX BENEPI TS.
MR. F:INI!:: FURTHER CORRECTION. THAT I S UN'l'RUB. THE:
PAYMENTS THAT YOU Al't PAID OUT OF A SPECJ :A[, FUN'O, THAT IS
)-lOT r.. COUN1'Y FUND. IT r s 1\ SPF.<;:'IAL TRUST FUND.
AJ I10 THE
EXHIBIT "B"
Ma~ 27 10 04.22p AAW CPA FDN 310~919- 2890
Case 2 :09- cv- 01914- J F~W OOC\J ment 1-4
'. ,
Flied03/2Pl ~009 Page 100 of 169
p.4
1 - pnOFBss:tONJ \.L OEVELOPMENT Pl\YMEN"rS AND CON"I'RIB'lJ TIONS TO
2 YOUR - tOl- K, ARE PAID OUT 01:" THE COUNTY'S GENERAL FtJ N!>. FOR
3 WHI CH THE~E' S NO REI MnURSEM~NT F~OM THm ST~TE.
THE COUR~; ~R. F~NE, ~ SAI D T~E PORTI ON THAT
5 CONST;t:TUTt:S MY SALAR~ Wl-!tCH r GET IN A WARRJ \N't fROM THE
6 COUNT':.:' IS RE:tMtH)'RSED TO 'rHE COt]N'T'X" flY THE STATB, -
1
MR, FINE I NO, l'M CORReCTING yoO. YOUR HONOR, THERE,
8 TlJ J \T rS A S PEC:t1\L FVND. NO't' 1\ COUNTY f''OND. IT'S A SPECIAL
9 TRUST FUl- m.
10
TFfE CO"O""RT! ALL RIOHT. WHATKVl!:R.
11 NOW, IS THERE ANYT1-ING ELSE yoU HAVEN'T COVERED
12 THAT YOU W}UIT TO ASK MlJ : Aaotrr?
13
MR. Vll'tE; 'llSS. YOU HAVE NOT COVERED THE F'ACT THAT
14 yocr O"ID NOT HAVE p.N'{ Ell1PLOYMENT CONTRACT WITH 'l'J -IE COUNTY.
1:5 IS THAT CORREC'r?
16
:1.7
16
19
21
27.
23
25
26
17
THE COURT: CQRRBT,
MR. FlNE: AND 00 '[01.] NOT HAVE [J .NY ARAANG8M1::N1' T
PROV10E ~ERV~CZS ~OR THF. COUNTY?
THE COURT: OTHlSR THAN TH"S SERVICn:S THAT I P~RFORM AS
A J UDGE PRSSI DI NG I N TH! Z COURT, NO.
MR. FINE ~ OKJ \Y. /\NO SERvrc~S - rAA'r YOU PROVIDE AS 1\
J UDGE SI TT~NC I N THI S COUf l T ARE Tas ~ERVI CES AS A
CONS-r:TUT:tO:-r
AL
-eLECTED OfFlC!At. OF' t'HE STAT6 OF CALIFORNIA
PURSU.1't.NT TO THE CALIFORN!A CONS-rI-rr.rT'LON. I'\RTIClIE 16. HI
TW-T CORRECT?
1'111 COtIRT; 'tS.
AND ON Tl{E PAYMn:NTS TAAT YOU ARB
OK,A.Y.
nECE::rvrNG _ FROM TH COlrN"fY J\~E I'IOT .. LI\CI::O I.I>fTO A.N"\" - l'.IH:
3
EXl IIBIT " B"
n
Me~ 27
10 04!22p
AAW CPA FDN
310- 919- 2890
Case 2 :09- cv- 01914- J F'!fV::CW
"\ 1
3
Document 1- 4
Filed 03/2p/2P09
Page 101 of 169
TUE coua-r J CORRECT.
M~. Vl:NE 1 OKAY, A.NP '.nu:: PAYMENTS 't'H.1\'1' YOU ARB
5 RECE;rV~NG f'ROM THE COUNTt ARE NOT A SALA'S. IS TH.AT
o CORR~CT?
'J THE COURT: 4 CONst OE~ TEM ~ SA~ARY, YES.
MR. FINE I WELL, SINCE YOU DIO NOT HAVE ANY CONTRACT
9 WITH THE comny FOn. SERVICES lV'I'D YOU ARll: NO'!' AN EMPLOYEE
10 OF THE' COUN'l7, "tHESE P1\1'Mlffi"'l'S .ARE NOT A SALARY FROM TlfE
11 COUNTY, ARE THEY?
12
l 3
THE COURT; I CONS IOER THeM TO BE PART 01' 'MY ~ALAP:Y.
MR. FI NEI DUT LEGALLY SPEAKI NG, YOU ARE - .
THE COtm.T: !.'M A WITNESS HERE NOW, MR. FINE, :IO l'M
15 NO'.!' GOING TO C:HVE: ANY OPINIONS 0 THE LEGAL:ITIES OV THIS
10 STU' I 4' F.
11
J >fR. FINE I YOUR HONOR, DO yOU HAVJ ;; AN EMPLOYlf~NT
18 CONTRACT WITH THE COUNTY?
19
zo NO.
21
22
25
26
THE COUR'l': r ANSrl,fiREO THAT Qt1Ii!STrON. THE ANSWER :(3
FI
"Oc"", OK1\Y. N'fO 00 YOU HAVE ANY SJ !!RV:!Cli!
MR. .'.!,:
CONTRACT wrrtt THE coUNTY?
THE COURT: NO
l'tR. Fl~E ~ OKAY'. THE - DO YOU l<NOW - DO YOO" KNOW
co
r.. 1"'T'V 15 GIVING '[OU THESE PAV'MsmS
Of' ANY REASON THAT 1'HE v'" ~
OTHER TltAN THE REASON 1' 0 rNFL{j1:!NCE YOUR DECIS10N ON COUNT1'
CASES?
ROSEN: OBJ ECT:tOl'l; CALLS FOR qfleCrJ LAT!ON.
I MR.
L- ~- . ~- - - .- - - - - ', ... - - - ~- - - -
I
------~ ......
--------------- .._ ....-~-- ..- - - '.....
EXHIBIT "B"
p.5
I
I
I
I
I
i
. ,-
Ma~ 27 10 04~23p
AAW CPA FDN
310- 313- 2890
Case 2:09-CV-01914-J Frr-pW Document 1-4
1
:l
3
4
So
G
7
B
9
10
II
12
13
14
15
15
17
;1.8
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
~6
27
26
Filed Q3J 2 pJ 2 1009 Page 102 of 169
TH~COURTI SUSTAJ NEO.
MR. F:tNE 1 OKAY. YOU ARE THE ~- YOU AREN'T THS J UDGE
HER. YO'O'R HONOR. YOU. Cl il i' T BUSTAIN YOUR OWN TE:STZHON1'.
THE COURT 1 WHO'S TO ~ULE ON Tnl'.: 05J ECTION'. MR. FINE,
i"0t17
MR. FI~E; IT SHOULD UIi: 6".C ANOTHZR .TOOGE, YOUR HON'O~.
THE COORT: ALL R~GHT. WHAT mLS~?
MR. F'INE; NOW. YO\.1f(. HONOR. IN THIS LAST YSAR. OTKER
THAN THE CASS OF MAJ UNA STRAND COLONY I I. IS THERE ANY -
CASE WHErtE YOU'VE RULED AGAINST THE CQUNTY OF LOS ANGELES?
THB COURT: IN THE LA$'I' YEAR?
MR. FINE i YES.
AGA.INST THE: COUNT~ OF LOS l\NGEI..1!:S Wl:'1'HIN THE I..AST YEAR,
BUT I CAN' T REM~MDt R ANY PARTXCV~AR ~AS.
MR. FINE: OKAY. IN 'r'HE LAST TWO Yi;;;ARS, CAlf YO'O' Tnt.
ME ANY CASE WHERE YOU' 'IE RULSP AGAINS'l' 'l'HE COUNTY OF LOS
1\.NOBLli:S?
' t HE
COUR' I ' :
AGAl:NS'l' THE; COUN'TY?
MR. F:tNE:
AGAI NST THE
COmn' Y OF LOS I\NO!::t.ES.
7'ttE
COURT:
WELL. I 010
IN -rur s C' " SE.
MR.
FI NE:
r{o,
OTHER ' t HAN THI S
CASE.
THE:
COURT:
OH,
I ' M SORRY.
NO, I CAN' T
RE:MP.MDER TJ {E
NJ \ME OF ANY CASE IN - IN THE NAMI!: OF TI-IS PLAINTIFF OR THE
_ _ wELL. THE NAME OF THE OTHER PARTY rN ANY CASE WHICH r
RULED AGA! NST. BUT I ' M SURE 1 ~~v~_
I N TH~ LAST THReE YRARS.
CJ \.N YOU TELL ME
NJ \.M~ OF I\N'.( -C1\$t; iN wlHCH lC~r VE RU1.D AGAINST THE: I
TME ._ _ .J
L
... - ------ ,-----.- -~...- .,
-
EXHIBIT "B" .
Ma~ ?7 10 0~: 23p
flfl(J CPR FDN
310- 919- 2890
p.?
Case2:09-cv-01914-J F~W Oocum~nti-4
" 1
rUed03{Z9t4009 Page i03 of 169
2
' f HE COt J R' ! ' :
THI S 1$
!-I'D'l' ,-
WHAT 001;;$ THIS HAv!!: TO 00
1 COtJ 'N"I'Y OF LO~ l\.NaEL~S'?
'THE COUR"l'. IF I CAN'T REMEMnER WITHIN THE LAST ysAR
J Al'fO THi!! LAST n'10 YEARS, I C~R'T1\:rNL~ CAN' T REMEMB~R AlITY :tN
'1 THE LAST THREE YEARS.
I) CASZ!::. O:tD 'tOO' :r.NV:e:STIGATE -ro DETERMJ :N~ IN THE ~gCORD -
s
MR. FINE: OKA)". NOW, 'ic){j~ HONOR. IN nus PARTlCULAR
7 1\NP I'M NOT I\$~ING YOU ABOUT YOUR DECISION. I'M ASXING YOU
8 IN THIS PJ \.RTICt.1LAR CASE. DID YOU DETERMINE - - oro YOU
9 INVESTIGATE Tl-n?; RECORD TO OF,TERM:I.Nl':: IF THE MAY lS'tH VOT~ BY
10 THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS INVOLVING THE J l;, 1+R, W1\SA VALIt>
11 VOT~ J :N THAT THE SUPERVISORS HA.D THE AUTHORITY TO VOTE TO
13
l~ APPROVE THE ll!. I . R. 7
MR. ROSEN: OaJ ECTl o~.
14
15 MY RULING IN THE VNDEIU':CIl'lG CA1;iE liE::RE.
'J "liE COUItT! NOW, ~OU' HE GETTING INTO TliE NATURE FOR
16
17
18
19
20
22
23
25
26
MR. FINE! N'O, THE BAsts OF YOUR RULING IN TiCE
mroERLY:ING CASE WAS T!U\T soo SAID THAT THE E .I. R. HAD
NOT "BEEN CIRCULATED DU~ TO THE AMOUNT OF DIRT TIJ .AT wAS
S'O'PPOSED TO ~E 2-tOVED.
OS
""N OBJ ECTION. '{O'IJ R HON'OR " Ll\CKS FOUN!>ATION.
MR. R "":
TMT ISSUE IS NOT PRESENT!.::D HI THE CASk: IHi:FORE TOt] AT THE
' t I ME.
.".. 'I.1E _ _ MY QUESTION IS THAT IN J .,OQKING AT
MR, f'"IN.c. : ..'
THE ~ECORP XN THI S CAS~ . .
TJ - I ECOURT:
I DON'T UNDERSTAND THe: OI3J ECTION, so IT'S
6
I
I
f
I - - ~- - - - ~- - - ....- .- - - - ... _ ..' .....~- ~- - - .~
L_---------------
' 1' 7
I
~
EXIllBIT "B"-j
28
OVE~Rt1LED, SU"l'
MR. f ' : t : NE!
LET ME G~VE YOU ~ OF?ER O~ PROOF.
If }J
~
; 2<5
EXHIBIT "B'" '-
Md~ 2 7 10 04:23p
RAW CPR FDN
310- 919- 2890
Ca~e2:09-cv-01914-J FFpW Document 1-4
Filed03/Z0/~009 Page 104 of1S9
.----~-~---------~. -----~---~--------.--...
1 WITH Tl-l:IS CONTBMPT PROCEEnrNG?
2 MR ~:tNE $ - IT HAS TO DO W~J ;'HTaE l!'OLl.owl:NO TRJ :NCl.
J YOUR HONOR: 1 WILL G:rVE YOU AN OW'F~R. OF 'E'ROOF OF WHAT
4 WltL COf.!E INTO !!:VIDENCE WHICH IS ALREADY BEFORE YOU FROM
6 90TH SUPZRv:rSOn. AN'TONOVICH AND SUPltRV;rSOR !<NABS HAV~
7 RECEIVEO CON"rRlBO'l"IONS WI"nUN 12 MONTHS PRIOR ':to THl!: T:rM~
fl THAT 'l'HEY VOTED ON MAY 15
7H
~007, WHICH l'IJ \KES_ "l'HE!R vOTE
9 I LLEGAL UNPER THE POLI TI CAL REFORM ACT UNDER THE
10 BREAKSTONE CAse. MY QUES'l'ION - - ANn "I'J tAT CAN 8E SHOWN
1l FROM 'l'RE DOCOMENTS - -
12
'r}l:E; COtrRT I THEY HAVS RECEIVED CON'TRrlH)TIONS FROM
14
MR. FINE! FROt{ J SRRY EPSTEIN. PJ >.T EPSTEXN AND DAVID
rs A. LEVIN}'::, ANY
16
THE COURT 1 WlV\1' OOES ALL THIS HAVE TO DO WlTH ME?
MR. FINg I IT HAS 'TO DO WITH 'lOU I YOIJ R f-lONOR, TH -r rr
GOES 1'0 THE "POINT TI- fAT IN THg RECORD OF THIS PJ \RTIcut.AR
CASE rS THE l'VI.Y 15
TH
VOTE WHICH SHOWS 'I'HAT VOTE HAl) FOUR
SUPJ ::l\VISORS VOTING rN FAVOR OF THe E.I.R, J \.ND THE E.I.R.
WAS THE aAS~S OF TRI ~CA~6, ANP
THE COURT; VOTED rN ~~VO~ OF THE E. I . R. ?
17
l 6
20
21
22
THAT'S CORRECT, IN FAVOR OF THE p1I.SSAGB OF
23
MR. FI NE:
21
AND THAT THOSE FOUR VOTES J_
'I'HF.: E. I ,R
25
OURT YOU
U"'AN THY A.OOPTEO THE E. r. R. 7
THE C ! ,-,.,.
26
MH. TI NE:
'rHEt )lJ )QPTEll 'tHE E. 1. R " CORREC'I'. 8Y 10'fJ R
~7
VOTES.
TWO OF THS I~OUH VOlE!)
THl 3l COURT!
THE E. I . R- r SUBS~QUE~LY HELD WAS
7
Ma~ ~7 10 04! 24p
RRW CPR FDN
310- 919- 2890
Case 2:09-CV-01914-J F~,""'_ :CW
?Vj_ Document 10.4
Filed 03J~Ol~009 Page 105 of 16~
INOORRECT.
MR P:rN~ I ONLY FOR THJ i;~EASON THAT THE A.MOUNT o-q
Ol:RT 'rHAT WAS 6Enm 'l'RANSPORTEO ftAO NOT BEEN SHOWN' TO THE
PSOPLE.
YOU DI D NOT HOLD XT TO BE r NSUFF~CI ENT WITH
RESPECT TO WHETHER T1tE I\CT'tJ A.l" ADOPTXON OF THE VOTE WAS
lt~OI\L OR ~OT. MY QUESTXON TO 'to!J IS j Dro YOU "OOK AT THe
RECORD TO DETERMINE WHETHER Tl{l!: VOTE OF MAY' 15'1'H WA3 Hll1LD ~
THE COURT l ~'lHAT RECORD?
MR. FINE; 'l'RE RECORD IN THE CASE OF MARINA STRANO
COLONY I I V:ElR?-oS THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES.
~. ROSEN: YOUR HONOR
THE COURT; I CE'RTAINL'i INSPECTJ ;;D THE ADMl:Nl:tlTUTIVl!:
RECORD.
MR. FI NE: O~Y. TN THE I NSPECT1NO THE
ADMINISTAAT:IVE RECORD. D:!D yOU INSPECT THE lLPMIN:ISTRATIVE
RECORO TO DBTERMl:NE THE LEGALITY OF THE MAY l s'tlf VOTE?
THE COURT; I. DONt '1' THINK ~- 1: DOUBT IT :6ECA."(J Sao; t
DON'T THlNK ANYBOOY RArGEP N'f'i I SSU'E AS TO TH'1Z LEGAr,IT~ OF
'l'H!!: MAY l. S'1'" VOTE.
S
~N ~F X MAY OBJ F. CT, YOUR ~ONOn?
MR. RO ~
MR. FIN~:
r
.... TLr"1' ANSWERS MY QUESTION; YOTJ R
!" _ "",. n.l'
} t ONOR.
I 1U\VE NO l"'UR'l'HER QUEST!ONS.
( TH~ FOREGOI NG PARTI AL PROCE~Dr NGS WERE
CONCM1P~b . )
p.9
EXHIBIT "B"
4
SUPERIOR COURT FOR THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES, CENTRAL DISTRICT
1 DAVID R. HERNANDEZ
5 312 Bellingham Avenue #3
2 Valley Village, CA 91607
(818) 448-3403
3 In Pro Pe r
5
6
7
8
9
10
DAVID HERNANDEZ, e t a l ,
11
Plaintiffs,
12
vs.
13
COUNTY of LOS ANGELES,
14
CITY OF LOS ANGELES e t a l ,
15 Respondents
16
17 LOS ANGELES CITY COUNCIL,
18
e t a l ,
Real Parties inInterest.
19
Case No. BS 10645 6
DECLARATION OF
DAVID R. HERNANDEZ IN
SUPPORT OF:
NOTICE OF MOTION AND
MOTION TO VOID, ANNUL,
VACATE AND SET ASIDE ALL
I ORDERS AND J UDGMENTS IN
I THIS CASE, PURSUANT TO
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ J\ CALIFORNIA C.C.P. 473
)
}
)
20
<
21
22
DECLARATION
23
If called upon in this case, I can and will testify competently to the
24
following facts:
25
1. My name is David R. Hernandez.
1
EXHIBIT "C"
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
2. I amaplaintiff inthe above entitled case.
3. The above entitled case was filed on December 11, 2006, and was
dismissed on August 20,2007.
4. J udge David P. Yaffe was thejudge for the entire course of the case.
5 . I contacted the L.A. County Auditor-Controller and requested and
received information on all payments made by the County to J udge
Yaffe. (See Exhibit "A" to the Motion to Void, to which this
Declaration is attached.)
6. While the above entitled case was pending in J udge Yaffe's court, for
the years 1987 through September 2010, J udge Yaffe received
$821,613.5 4 fromLos Angeles County, aparty to this case.
7. During the pendency of this case during 2007, J udge Yaffe received
$5 5 ,239.85 fromLos Angeles County, aparty to this case.
8. J udge Yaffe never disclosed to me, nor to my attorneys, the fact that
he was receiving these payments, either before or during the course of
the case.
I certify and declare, under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State
of California, that the foregoing istrue and correct. -
Executed this ~ day of J une, 2011, at Los Angeles,
r<
/ ~/ ~
-1kt /6~ -~~--' ~
David R. Hemand~
r=:
California.
2
EXHIBIT "C"