Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
JeI
APPLETONS'
School and Colle&e Text-Books
TjCbtiTL, Gr-peel^,
Syrtac, Hebrew.
Arnoli
By
Beza.
Butle:
ith
N(
Caesar
Cicen
Corne
Crosb
the
G
Friez
;es.
0.
0.
:ies.
G
t
Gate!
Harl
the
iS
edition.
1881.
12mo:
For Schools and Colleges.
etc.
Books of
Cicero,
ary.
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA
AT LOS ANGELES
most
ay of the
Iready in
iise i
instil
classical
Herl
Hors
John
Lati
Line
Lind
Qd Exer-
Livy
Lord
Ovid
Qnin
Qmn
Salk
Sews
forMem-
Spen
Taci
Thac
and Con-
^1
Tyle
Verg
Adar
Anal
Anti
Arno
tUlO.
i'.
A
e^-^^'
THE
GREEK PREPOSITIONS,
STUDIED FROM THEIR ORIGINAL MEANINGS
AS DESIGNATIONS OF SPACE.
BY
F. A.
It is
ADAMS,
Ph. D.
know what
'>
-.
>
NEW YORK:
D.
AND 5
BOND 8TKEET,
1885.
COPTKIGHT,
By
CI',
It
D.
1885,
mTRODUCTION.
"Whatevek theory we adopt of the origin of language, it is agreed by all scholars that its words are
derived largely from notions of things in space. This
book presents the results of a study of the Greek
Prepositions from the stand-point of that admission.
No class of words in the Greek is more important
and none are more imperthan the Prepositions
these
are the words that, beunderstood
yet
fectly
all others, bear on their face the suggestions of
yond
But the clew is soon lost that conducts from
space.
;
But
learners of the
Greek
find
no harder thing,
meanings of
The
mind
the
verbs
difiicnlty is
memory
to aid
him
160839
He
has
iv
Introduction.
give only
citements to his power of discrimination and logical
deduction. The definitions in the Lexicons burden
his
memory
way. Even
Greek Prepositions do
not evince any systematic endeavor to interpret the
prepositions through a logical deduction from their
Treatises on the
The
primary meanings as designations of space.
learner under these conditions naturally becomes indifferent
for what he cannot do intelligently, he
;
those
who complain
To show
much time
little profit.
is
not too
it
hta,
Kara, jrapa, vtto, let him form English
sentences that, if written in Greek, would require the
use of these prepositions respectively compounded
6/c,
iv, eTrl,
finds himself
S>}Xo9,
in a
e/cSv^Xo?,
hke
evSrjXo'i,
difficulty.
KaTdBr]Xo<;,
The
all
adjectives
contain the
Introduction.
And
through what
lines of
to
The Greek
guage.
object of the
that
whole
field of
purpose,
is
it
human
Thus the
experience.
of thought, passion, and
laid open, and the Prepositions enter it in
analogues of these in
human
own right.
The store-house
life,
their
is
vi
Introduction.
is
have
that
it
in our
is in
we know
hands
now
to
be a complete
Introduction.
treatise
on
tlie
Greek Preposition.
vii
The author
has
SUGGESTIONS TO TEACHERS.
This book, it is believed, may, with advantage, be put in
the hands of learners as soon as they have left the reading of
detached sentences, and have entered on continuous prose. It
tlien,
recitations.
The
a plan hke the following: Select from the book a single preposition, and make the whole, or a part of the matter relating to
it, and no more, the subject of one, or at most two recitations,
the teacher eagerly lending his maturer thought to the pupils to
them in the new line of study. Then let him direct that for
the next two weeks (or more, at his discretion) that preposition
aid
be marked for special attention whenever it occurs in the readAt the end of this time let all these instances
ing of the class.
be reviewed, in the combined light of the statements in the book
on that preposition, and of the quickened attention which the
Let
pupils will not fail to give to the word thus singled out.
the prepositions be taken up, one' at a time, in a way like this,
and the result will be not to load the memory with words of
definition,
underlies them.
its
own
reward.
EREATA.
Page
21,
27,
29,
31,
31,
39,
43,
44,
45,
59,
60,
KOTeVxe.
line 6 from bottom, /or i.vi(Txov read avicrxov.
top, for Seiv, KoraSfii' read Selv, KaraSelv.
top, foi' ^rjTiiy, ava^-qreiv read ^7)tuv, avaQr]Teti>.
line 9, /or Karti^ov read KaTit^ov.
line 10 from bottom, /or (rrjixdwciev read a-riixaivotev,
top, for iKpTjyeiro read ucpriyelro.
line 2, for opvfjLaySov read 6puj.iay5ov.
Od.
19:13.
68, line 9, for Uposaireip reeid TlposaiTe^v.
69, liue 11 from bottom, /or irposSeiv read irposSeli/.
60, liue 12 from bottom, /or iinSeip read iiriSelv.
74, line 1 from bottom, for Occ.
87, line 7, for yap read yap.
87,
88,
92, line 8,
96,
read Oec.
for
iis
read
read
Els.
Els.
Two instances.
98, near bottom, for eis read els.
99, top, for 'Eis read Els, and near bottom, for its read
instances.
101,
101,
102,
102,
line
1,/or
'Els
read
Els.
iroieiv
read
Ttoielv.
'lovir]v.
els.
Two
COI^TEI^nTS.
CHAPTER
I.
Words
SECTION
1
2
3
its
defects
CHAPTER
avh AND Kara.
its
II.
UP AND DOWN.
attendant notions,
Second,
First,
Third,
1
Fourth
its
...........
CHAPTER
ava AND KOTO.
Preposition and Adverb
III.
PRIMARILY ADVERBIAL.
9
their difference
'Ai/a, tip,
illustrated
.10
.
11
12
Contejits.
CHAPTER
AND
hih.
IV.
KOTO.
SECTION
Analogue of
/caro in
in speech;
in
13-17
judgment
tox iT6\ets, Kara tus v6\eis
'Aya and Kara with numerals
'Aj/o
18
19
20, 21
22,23
CHAPTER
dj/A
'AvdyeffOai, Kardyeadai
AND Kara
V.
IN COMPOSITION.
.........
......
.........
.......
....
avUvai, KadUvai
'AvoKaleiv, KaroKaleiv
25
27
marks of upward
32
(Sec. 7)
Avaviveiv, Karaveveiv
'AvaSely, third
30, 31
KarayiyvdxTKUv
motion in each
25
27, 28, 29
'Avafj.eveiv, Karafiiveiv
'Aj/aSexetrSaj, /caTaSexetrOai,
'
24
avaa-irav, to
pull down
.33
...
.........
(7)
34
35, 36
......
......
........
37
38
39
'Aua^riTeiv,
avaXvuv
40, 41
42
Kadopav
43,44
45
'AvafMiyyvyai, Kwrafxiyyvyai
Kre/j'ejj/,
KaraKTelyetv, airoKTflyeiy
&yr}(TKity, KaTadyfiCKetv
'Aya.
46
result
by
different paths
47
48
Contents.
CHAPTER
eVJ,
XI
VI.
ON, UPON.
SECTION
Primary suggestion
gravition
Two forms
of power suggested in
(ir\
impact
pressure
Object of
eTri
....
58
xu
Contents.
SECTION
aperV, compared
The object of irphs becomes to the imagination active
'Eirl
II.
'H
tV
ISiSlI
6dhs eV
Uphs rh
euBaifioyiav
aWo
irphs evSaifioviav
rh
4irl
awixa,
aWo
CnAPTER
AND
irphs IN
90
91
IX.
COMPOSITION
104
and tested
105
106, 107
108
iJds
109
110, 111
114
115
116
117
2K7rT6(r0ot, eiriffKiiTTeaOai
IleldeaQai, iiriireldfaOat
120
Bivilv, (Tnlivelv
....
tpecr
AfiKvwai, iinBeiKvwai
'E<pUvai, irpoffUvai
121
5iB6i'ai, iiriBiSdyai
2Tpe<peiv, iiri(rrpe<peiv
118 119
Xiyeiv, iiriXeyeiv
iirdyeiv, irpoadyeiv
'Eirirdcrffeiv, irpo(rrd(T(Teiv
112
113
'Ev(p7]fji.iiy,
92
93
94-103
89
'EttI
7rl
ffiifia
81
82-88
irepeffBai
122
123
124
125
126
12'7
xiii
Contents.
CHAPTER
X.
Trapa.
With
SECTION
128
Implied superiority in
its
129
object
CHAPTER
itapa.
Used
XI.
IN COMPOSITION.
......
131, 132
Literal application
'ZKevT],
.130
napareiveiv
..........
........
134
135, 136
TlapayiyvdiffKeiv
'Aiz/eij/, iiraivetv,
CHAPTER
The notions
.137
AND
off from
6/C.
XII.
from
illustrated
139, 140
the Greek
e/c
CHAPTER
7r5
'Airo7r(7rTiV, iKiriirTeii'
'AiroSiSdvat, fKSiBSvai
'
....
141-143
Continued illustrations
and
138
irapaiveiv
OTTO
'AwJ)
133
in morals
AND
XIII.
iK IN COMPOSITION.
.........
......
.....
.
'Eicireipaadai, airoTpeireadai,
iKTpinearBai
'AiroSeiKftiyai, eKSeiKUvvai
QvflffKeiu, aTToOvriaKeiv,
iKOvriaKdv
147
148
.149
.150
......
.
145
.146
A.<piKveia6aty i^iKvelffOat
Ueipaffdai, aTT0ireipa(r6ai
144
151
XIV
Contetiis.
........
..,..,.
........
.......
SECTION
'AiroKTilveiv, KaraKTeifeii'
'E^Tiy(7(rdai, a(pr}yei(Tdai
'A-KO(palveiv, iKcpaiveiv
iiraiTilv
'AiraiTiTv,
and
.........
.
is
.162
AKD
eV.
....
e/c
by law of contrast
'Eiffl3o\'fi, ejUjSoAeus,
eV
t^
'EfxfidKKeiv, iicrPdWeiv;
eiri
rou evwvvfiov
1*70, 1*71
172
iix^oKri, irpocrfioKr)
ififidweiv, continued
173
174
........
....
......
ifj^(pavris
'EKSeiKvvvai, iyBfiKvvi'ai
'Eyxfipf?*'
and
iirixfipe'i'',
66
169
evuvifxep,
'EvSjjAos, eKSrjKos
'EK<paj^s,
167, 168
'EisandeV; discrimination
'Efj.Pifid(fiv,
164
XIV.
'Eio-jSaAAeji/,
163
165
its
inr))
CHAPTER
'Ets, eV
.158
155
156, 15Y
'Airo55Jmj, iiriSiSdvai
'AiroreXiiy, kTrireXuv
152
153, 154
compared deductively
182
183
184
185
CHAPTER XV.
vep]
AND
VTfep.
186
,
187
xv
Contents.
SECTION
the reason .
nepl followed by the Dative; uirep never;
Discrimination resulting from original suggestion in space
Applied
to a
passage in
188, 189
190, 191
192
Homer
CHAPTER
Trepl
AND
XVI.
vTrep IN COMPOSITION.
193
Intensive force
Uipifxiviiv,
.......
194, 195
Apparent contradictions
IS*?
the change
CHAPTER
XVII.
198-201
CHAPTER
ON BOTH SIDES
0;U^f,
Its original
196
the reason of
meaning
XVIII.
OF,
compared with
AROUND, ABOUT.
irepi
CHAPTER
202
XIX.
203, 204
ripb
and
ujrip
205
CHAPTER XX.
<T\}V
The discrimination
AND
jUTa.
illustrated
WITH, AMONG.
206-210
XVI
Contents.
CHAPTER
5ta,
Its
primary suggestion
XXI.
THROUGH, ACROSS.
wide
field for
the Genitive
Why
......
....
by the Dative
11.
247
....
.....
....
.....
Aex^c^at with
|o77-, Trapayy-
Aiaxeipeiv, iirix^ipuv,
compared
ITS
SILENT TEACHINGS.
The
1.
When
"
Laban was a
crooked fellow, but, then, Jacob was not square in his
dealings with him," he chose his words, not for their
beauty, but for their special fitness to his thought.
ble.
3.
By
space,
and
to objects in space,
of
space through any definition by a physicist, or a metaphysician, or in any labored way at all ; but as felt
and
structed
guage.
word meanings
trary
to its
that
original
seem
alien,
import
as
it
light
passes,
is
and
Language does
press thought,
it
except
in the
Of
space,
and
its
Silent
Teachings.
As we have
birthright.
shall
down,
of prepositions they are not allowed to dictate by virtue of their suggestions in space.
They point the
the forecasting question,
the
raise
and
question
way,
The answer in all cases comes from exthat is all.
is
necessary to elucidate
CHAPTEE
ava AND Kara,
7.
The
to itself in
II.
up and down.
fore
it
In like manner, simple motion downward sugFirst, such mogests notions that go along with it.
tion has no fixed, or definite, point of beginning.
Secondly, it is natural, requiring no force to effect it.
Thirdly, it has a fixed place of ending. Fourthly,
the downward moving body remains where it stops.
the
less,
there,
and, beyond
Avh and
Kara.
Primarily Adverbial.
CHAPTER
ava AND
9.
KaT6..
III.
primarily adverbial.
to notions of space,
is
best explained
This
last
applied
by comparing it
word from lyroe,
placed before
pono carries the suggestion that
another wordthat other word being a substantive or
it is
pronoun. This phrase, preposition and noun, are attached to the verb, the leading word in the sentence,
to complete its
meaning
On
But there
is
it
in that place.
that
its
What
then
is
the
but
it
may
6
hefore you.
we
call
device one
uj>
on a golden
staff,
ava aKyyKTpw
(II.
15),
the
and Kara
down
down
He
prep-
Am
and
Kara.
Primarily Adverbial.
minates.
send
it
who
shoots,
Kara
o-kottov, will
make allowance
fall
here
is causative, showing
the shooter, inciting to his
phrase perfectly clear. It
" to
To^euety Kara gkotzov,
for the
by gravitation
The Genitive
Lexicon says :
shoot at, because the arrow
is
not, as the
We have been led unawares into positive statements about cases, and tbese statements may seem
dogmatic. They are not dogmatic at all. "We have
simply accepted the hint of l^ature, and following that
hint we find we have in hand just the phrase that
meets the case. The shaft sent Kara arrjdo'i, straight
to the hreast, goes no whit straighter than a stone
goes
when
The
arr/Oo^ is in
is
whole descent.
We
the point of departure, or cause or source of that incitement, and therefore must be in the genitive.
commonly thrown
straight up,
and therefore
He
the genitive
thing calling
the ship.
vtjo^ e^rj,
tions in the
translation
CHAPTEE
13.
first.
lY.
charging
the
enemy
in battle, the
as the
falling of a stone
as natural
10
words, Kara
called
is
motion.
Do
on to do
Do
not
fail
memory with
the
its part.
in
This
formula that Kcvra sometimes means before.
would hinder more than it would help. Take into
your thought the whole phrase, in this and in all like
seize the picture it presents to the imagination ;
express this in the best English you can command,
cases
is
done.
over against them / this has a show of careful literalness, but the life and motion are all gone, good for
the posts of a gate-way, over against each other, but
poor for a
battle.
us
live
derived
from Analogy. 11
from
may
be
aim
what-
to hit, in
a thing, so
in doors weave,
is
carried
the
the people
whom we
now
life.
16.
We
"We
read
will
(II.
53),
own
flight,
Each
its
upward motion
hence dva.
to
make
a lustration
ot,
and
(II. 1
312-
12
to
It has
an analogy
Hounds
'Xoipov
jDursued
av vX-qevra
in either case.
the
game
they do not
know
find or
straight downward.
To stand up to a fight, laraaOai ava ixayT]v, ava
is here
doing its proper work nothing is more uncertain in its end than a fight, or more sure to call
forth at each moment of its progress the whole power
is
of the actor.
When
(Hdt. 6
Darius
The same
father
own
The
TToXet?.
explorer, to
lirst
whom
a traveler or
known
before-
hand, and who does not find the end of his journey
till he comes to it.
Such action is like upward moknown
beforehand. The second,
tion
the end is not
Kara racr TTokeiq, implies a knowledge of the cities
this is
analogous to
downward
end predetermined.
stranger
traveling tlirough all the rest of Greece^ ava waaav
Here are three things,
Tr)v 'EWdSa (Hdt. 6 86, 1).
in this stranger's journey, like upward motion
he
did not know his road, but found it as he went he
did not know how far he should go, nor where he
should stop. Again (Hdt. 5 102), the fugitives were
scattered, ava rag TroXea, each one going where he
motion, having
its
like
pleased
to seek
When wild
And gentle
for himself.
is
But
blown,
peace returning,"
to
is
their homes,
going
to stop.
Kar
6lkov<;,
14
we
can
gatherers went through the cities, with all the resources catalogued, they went Kara ra<i 7r6\ei<i.
let
us suppose a case
life.
messenger,
with printed notices in his hands of a popular entertainment, is instructed to leave one at each house in
the town.
There are many houses in the town not
so many notices
what does he do ? He distributes
them as far as they will go, that is, dva ra? olKLa<;.
But on a subsequent day, with more notices than
there are houses, he can be ordered to distribute them,
Kara ra? oiKiwi. In the first case the end of the dis-
together.
Kva
Meajtings derived
arid Kara.
from Analogy. 15
ev,
they
may be
up and
down
This is
carry our thought over the same line.
mere groping it neglects to note what is peculiar
to these motions respectively, and leads to grave errors
;
in translation.
speed
till
16
is
The
upward
This
is
is
it.
To run Kara
them
dva KpdTo<;.
21. Let us now bring this distinction into the
this last
is
We
cannot
Kpdro^;, thpovvn rw 'iinrai.
miss the meaning of dva Kpdro<; here the rider did
not spare his horse. Let us go on a little further in
ikauvmv dva
'Ai/a
to ru7i
fast,
/ir;
Oelv Bpofio),
but
to
own
experience
In another place, the barbarians, assaulted in their
in
strong hold, make their escape, fleeing dvd KpdTO<;,
!
at his quickest, as
disorder, each one for himself, and
is the way of barbarians when retreating.
Let us look
wise nation
power, Kara Kpdro^.
It
plans, and comgoing to war does not hurry.
view
just as the
bines, and keeps the end ever in
He
emphatic point of downward motion is its end.
with
all their
who
acts
the crowd.
We
have in
Homer
a story of a
18
on the same
and
o/xiXov
;
we
captive, when
him unseen to
and Menelaus, supposing him to be among
his home
the Trojans, went here and there among the crowd
to find
see
36, 449).
23.
free,
goes back
secondly, he
went spontaneously,
as
'Am and
Kara
19
in Composition.
and would
it falls.
where
have stayed if he could, as a stone
"We have then, in Paris's action, three marks of downward motion and the Greek mind by instinct took
the preposition whose primary meaning was down.
a stone
falls
thirdly, lie
went
to stay,
lies
ward motion
(see 7, 8).
CHAPTER
avh AND Kara
A ship
ent
V.
composition.
from
sailing
employment
is
of the
denoted
20
but there
an analogy
is
Olympic games
the end
It was the
like the end of free downward motion.
the
races
were to
on
the
appointed day,
city where,
take place; the place of the games, and the roads
leading to it all well known. The races were subsequent, separated from the sending by intervening
time, and are not embraced in the verb KadrjKa.
'Avievai,, to release, from the bonds of sleep (II. 2
when honeyed sleep
34), VT av ere jxekl^pwv virva avyr},
from
man
released
let up
The
shall release thee.
KudT^Ka
Also, to send
sleep goes forth of his own free will.
forth to the uncertain chances of battle (II. 20 118),
:
'Am and
Kara in Composition.
forth.
21
seiit
him
cases.
26. Katetv, to
hum,
dvaKuUiv, to begin to
hum,
to
kindle.
gone up in flame.
hold up, as
hands, to
up
against
tain ; (II. 15
my will,
is, if
Kurex'^iv, to hold down, hold fast, de186), if he shall keep me back against
iifiaKeovra Kadi]^eL
(II.
11
check
',
at
all
When
22
a thing, or a creature,
is
quite at rest,
its
natural state
that interrupted
it
be removed
shall
a falling
power that
as
works
will
stopping
is final
the verb
29. M-eveiv, to
time, that
is
some
is, till
taken away
to
is
remain,
If the
Karairaveiv.
dvaju,iveiv, to
transient
remain for a
for
the
nat-
{Kare/xeve)
cated there.
30. Ae'x^eaOat, to receive; dvaZexGcrdat, to catch,
as arrows upon a shield,
arrest something on its flight
blows upon the body KaraBe'^eadai, to receive per-
homes
these
banished citizens
23
stones
are
received on
stay.
We
avehe^aru.
may say, then, that when a company
of ball-players adojjt rules for their playing, the verb
these rules are to be permanent;
is Karahex^adaL
remain up.
31. To know, jLyvcoa-Keiv, KaTor/fyvooa-Keiv, to know
what one has a special interest in knowing. The act
alKaTory always implies some standard of judgment
the
act is always
the
result
of
mind
and
in
the
ready
;
know
mean,
certainly
as the
(2)
it
Lexicon
says, to
know
of the knower.
The
student
who
faithfully studies
As motion
to the natural
force to effect
it,
uj),
ava,
is
it,
has
sons, contrary to their natural state, or bent, are deThe spear's point
scribed by aid of this preposition.
24
was
al')Qir] (II. 3
348).
the
ro
look, ava-KTv^a^
rolling
/31/3\lop (Hdt. 1
^
AvaTTTvacreLv rb Kepa<i, to wheel back the
TJn-
125).
wing (Anab.
10, 9).
straight
the
The
wing of an army,
to be in line.
to
is
;
be
that of
Avaireideiv, to
bodily
or mental.
Men
go forward.
as truly as
it
I
1
2,
lift it
hence avd.
has said.
33. ^eveiv,
way and
nod ; Hector's
nodded
crest
(II. 1
this
that, as
Karaveveiv, to
debate
to
311).
We
'Am and
Kara
25
in Composition.
will observe, amounts to the same tiling, for relaxing the will lets the head fall forward arousing
it in opposition throws the head back (see Sec. 7,
3).
you
In
this
Convin., ch.
3,
[loKa
avaairdaa'^ to irpoa-wKov,
ava suggests the constraint
crefjivoi^
bundle
upward motion
ance
The
ava carries
Crowning the
something
fiM ivl
ship.
V7]l,
fixed.
they
Od. 14 345,
:
KareSijcrav ivaeX-
e/ie
hound me fast in
thing dvahovjxevov
may
the
welUenched
be moved
not so a
thing KaTaSov/xevov.
35.
It
The compound
Kardp'^eiv
invites
dpx^iv,
which means
to
attention.
How
can
begi?i,
in
thought before
The Greek
26
it is
begun
in act
as to
planned beforehand
celebration, that
The beginning
out before
1
is
is
Cyrus, when
4, 4,
Prepositio7is.
a youth,
would
knew
Cyri. Inst.
select out^
e^vPX^^i
himself to be
defi-
Tlie course of
ginning
0)87)9,
hence
there
Kara.
Socrates began a song, VPX^^
was no forethought called for, only
therefore the simple verb is used. Afterwards he began his argument anew, Karrip-xe his
argument was directed at every step to reach the
memory
forethought conclusion.
36. Whenever the end
is
mentally seen from the
then
the
beginning,
beginning is naturally expressed
by KUTapxetv, whether
it
be beginning of a campaign
'Am and
27
kotcl in Composition.
Kara
mid
Cheops the
of
greatest
compared.
'
38.
may
see
raising
a concerted
signal,
all as
a possession (Hdt. 4
42).
KaTahd^a<i,
first
Libya, Africa,
."
So Columbus
was surrounded by water, except
was the first who showed, KaTaS6i^a<i, that there was
In ancient times,
a new world west of the Atlantic.
" the Carians were the first to show
how, KaTahei^avTe<i,
In
to bind crests upon their helmets" (Hdt. 1 171).
was
the
first
who
modern times, Professor Morse
showed how, KaTaSei^a<;, to send word across the con.
tinent in a
moment
39. MavOdveiv,
of time.
to
learn hy inquiry
avaiJ,,
to
The Lex.,
search into to see what a thing contains.
The
to learn again, to iiiquire closely, is in error.
word means neither the one nor the other of
When
one examines an
these.
without prepossession,
and finds successively the minerals it contains, his
finding is expressed by avafJuavOdvuv but if, starting
ore,
28
Tlie
Greek Prepositions.
him how
were, aei
rov<i
irapovra'i
his questionsthings
had no settled aim therefore
avrjpfora
avd
(Inst.
1:4).
250),
I recognized
him and
She questioned
till
to find
the things
she found
them.
fiadovre^
it
an end.
Hecognizing him,
they
"When one
he
leams many things this is fiavddveiv. Another traveler, going with prepared questions, finds the answers
to these questions
this
is
KaTajxavOdveiv.
'Ai/a
40.
To
and Kara
search,
^v'^eiv
29
in Composition.
ava^T^reiv,
to
examine a
Socrates (Apol.
search-
him with
when a stone is
known beforehand how
thrown upward,
far
of
it
it
cannot be
an idea
find.
him look
at the early
hand
;
or, rising to the dignity of
If
the matter were searched
1
:
137),
history (see Hdt.
one
of these things would
to the hottoyn, dva^'nTeofxeva,
of rubbish, hook
in
'Am
be discovered.
honds ;
200)
i/j,
8'
e'/c
prompts
the will
is
as free as air.
But
to
let loose
the dogs upon the game is not dvaXveiv, for dogs have
To undo the web, dvaXvetv, the act
not free will.
To dissolve a
leaves the threads free and floating.
30
body
into its
unknown
elements,
to take a
it
example
to
made
is
of.
house, a government.
42.
is
the same as the simple verb opav^ and it is said sometimes to mean to see clearly ', these statements are
misleading.
for what
It
KaQopav.^
is
or-
tower,
Kvpo<i KaOopa
TOP /3aai\ea,
Kal
lero
iir
dvTov,
Even where the seeing is clear, the indispensable condition justifying the use of Kara is that the seeing answers an important question.
In Romans 1 20, KaOoparai, the invisible things of Him are
'
questions.
all
possible
and Kara
^hvh,
31
Composition.
Cyrus
1
in
9).
and rushed
saw him,
or seeing
gave place to another. Here the looking
was not down, but Kara is called for none the less
the seeing ended a question already in the seer's
mind.
When
those in front
saw
(Anab.
21).
when
Observe that a
little
them
before,
to a place
where they would see the sea, he uses the simple verb,
he had no longing for the
oy^ovrat Tr}v dakarrav
not
need
he
did
and
so
Kadopav to express his
sight
thought.
They
the
hills, that, if
see
anything,
any
down, that
what
is
they should
32
ravTTjv oSov.
43.
mean
The Adjective
clearly in
sometimes said to
Kara<^avrj<i is
This
sigJtt.
is
misleading.
If a
it
is
in the
mind
before.
Anab.
is
The
tracks of
(1
the battle
8, 8), as
drew
They were not in fact clearly seen, but they were just
what the Greeks were looking for they were seen
clearly enough to settle the question that was in all
minds. The glimpse of the spears showed that the
battle was upon them.
44. A meteor appears, ^alverat
a comet foretold
and expected appears, Karac^alvera.
The day dawns begins to appear ava^aiverai.
45. Od. 4 41, They threw before the horses spelt,
and therewith mixed white barley, ave^t^av a chance
'Am and
Kara in Composition.
Anab. 7
2, 3,
83
little
more
therefore
After a time they mixed with
and made their home there
cities,
KaTeyuv^vvvTO.
coming
hence
avd.
II.
24
529,
To whomsoever
Zeits giveth
a min-
voi
hence
The mingled blossoms in the field are avafii'^vvfiethey come by chance, and each grows as it can
down,
by
accident, the
3
end reached
is
34
In Anab. 4
85,
25,
iratSa
ukcov
KaraKravoctv,
the
by sentence
but
death
verb
is
treated
not the
the
but this
sometimes airoKrelveiv
a special suggestion, which will be
in its place.
U. 6 409, Soon the
Kreivecv,
carries
last
is
and
of
blind instinct.
Od. 16 lOG,
KaTaKTd/j,evo<;, slain in
his
Tcine.
The
l3od<;
killing
it
my own
cKrafiev
rj/xei^,
halls
in the
we had slain
it
was
Anab.
9, 6,
^he
'
purpose
before
it is
in
85
Composition.
begun in act/
at first view
single passage (Herod. 2 75) seems
to conflict with this position ; but it is, in fact, confirmatory of it. Tbe story is that the Ibises do not
let
into
made
of
forming
capable
an
in-
act, KaTo-
telligent
KTelveiv here
is
attributed to
it.
fulfilling a purpose
him.
106, Achilles to Lykaon, a suppliant, die
KarOave koX JldTpoK\o<;,
tlunu also, Odve koX av
II.
21
'
Such, at least, seems to have been the Greek opinion, so far as I
have been able to gather it in reading. Perhaps the reading has been
defective but I have preferred not to wait for an impossible leisure,
;
Greek thought.
In any case, the opinion here ventured invites no reference to
modern Biology nor docs it impair the honors of those rare creatures
of ancient story companions of man inspired or trained
" Who bear a
memory and a mind,
;
36
Greek Prepositions.
TJie
PatroMos
also died.
the phrase
if
mean only that Patroklos died, as all men die, perhaps in his bed. Note also how the imperative, Odve,
asks no help from Kara ; the lifted arm told the purpose (II. 21 106, 107).
:
II.
89,
There
the
is
old,
died, KaTaTe6v7]Mro'i
tomb of
whom
champion who
glorious Hector sleiu ;
a
slew, KareicTave
icara points
the
prjvrai,
CHAPTEE
irrl,
49.
EvEETTHiNG
is
first
YI.
ON, UPON.
by force
of gravitation.
When the object uj)on which a thing
or
on
which
it rests, is named, we have a noun
comes,
in hand, which requires a preposition to introduce
it,
'EttI, on,
and show
its
37
upon.
relation to the
word^ before
This
it.
The
IttL
The
from
is
dicular
that of gravitation
its
direction
is its
is
in
perpen-
unvarying con-
comitant.
50.
is
spent in a
Men
perpendicular direction.
strength in movements
and not in motions up and down.
We
must
there-
make
it
horizontal,
lines
Before doing
this,
however,
we
power upon
it
in other words,byby
1608{.iV^
38
Greek Prepositions.
TJie
Our
language of this constant, inevitable power.
note
the
facts
to
draw
to
and, then,
study is, first,
;
all fair
now we
52. If
power, as
we
take
wider, and
more varied
The power,
service.
ever at
is
in
man
it
is
as-
But
pirations, the hopes and fears that rule his life.
in both spheres, brute and rational, iirl carries the
suggestion of power of some sort, physical or mental ;
and the object of the preposition is in the Accusative.
They came
they came
enter
to the river,
to the
city,
eVl rov
eirl
ti-jv
irora/jiov, to
cross
ttoXlv, to take
it
it,
or
it.
54. If the
movement be
a journey
from a
distant
that
distant object
Greece,
iir
is
'EXXaSo?
in
the Genitive
for home,
iir
to sail
oIkov
for
he hegan
'Etti, on,
to
39
upon.
eVt
into.
the
genitive here is causative, suggesting to
to the endeavor.
incites
which
the
thing
imagination
The
expressed by
axi'Kfl'^
standing on
fixed, or definite, is
if
the
on
flesh
tw
spits,
iirl
if
the
Bl^pfo
is
position
on.,
the Dative
indefinite,
transiently
table, eirl
56.
pens
is
6pxw^'^''
XevovTO'i,
57.
Tpa'Tret,'t]<i
fijne
in the
Bearing in mind
7'eign
of Leo.
comes against
down on it
comes
what
that whatever
we are prepared
gravitation, exerts power upon it,
to see how first, and last, and all through, eVl is the
from the subject to the object ;
index of
by
power passing
known thing
unknown as
it
is
to locate
this
known
locality
so of the
40
to
it
it
enemy,
to assault them.
58.
less,
The
may
activity
it
object of eVt, commonly pictured as lifebe in fact not lifeless, or passive ; but any
may have
will
The treatment of eVt is here suspended, to be resumed in a comparison of it with prepositions which
follow.
CHAPTER
viro,
59.
The
along with
it
VII.
or virep.
Nothing
can.
under with
on,
'Tiro,
41
it.
Thirdly, that whicli is under is in a defrom the light. As light comes from
withdrawn
gree
is under something must of necesthat
which
above,
receive
a
less
degree of light than that which is
sity
over or ujpon it. It follows from this that viro readily
or over
cealment, deceit.
61.
That which
under
is
is
naturally thought of
which
is
uj^on
it
resistance
and
this
may become
to the imagination
We
many
as the
xrrro
ways in which
governs
the position under can be presented to our thought
;
three.
64. Firsts the position under, vtto, may be suggested without regard to the coming into that position, or the leaving of
it.
II.
under
the wall,
i.
e.,
2 307,
:
tree,
We were offering
vivo
TrXaravidrw
Telxe'i (H.
42
21
277).
like
them, nat-
urally take the dative case after t'Tro, as the case exSometimes the verb implies
pressive of position.
motion, but the act looks forward to the position and
rest that shall follow
II.
14 24,
:
He
under
literally,
shall place a
the feet, viro
iroaiv.
The
him.
15
II.
637, i^S^rjOev
v<f)
II. 11
121, Themselves also
jput in fear hy Hector.
were filled with fear before the Argives^ vir ^ApyeLoiat.
65. Secondly, the position under, vtto, may be the
:
as, vtto
he drove his
KvW')]V7)<i
Cyllene.
by
mind
e. g,,
air,
This form
II.
248, to
'Ttto,
of
tlie
Achaians
war-din
the
from
43
vtto,
from
under.
is followed
by the genitive
tov
inro
cnrohov rfkaaa
/xo^ov
phrase e'^cb
stake
into
the
I
the
thrust
TToXKrj<i^
hurning embers j
in the
the
So (Od. 11
52),
fited
<yoveaiv
vtto
68.
vite to
correlative, in-
side
by
side, that
Wine
man
to sing, icpirjKe
44:
(Od. 14
VTT
To each dam
404).
he put
(Od. 9
to such,
Tie hath sent
its
young
309).
eirdp'xco iroXKrj'i,
T ride over
over
;
%(pa?
in an act thought of as
the cause or incentive to other acts Kke a founda-
4:6,
2)
virapxetv, to he
Socrates
tion.
fi/rst
(Mem. 2:3)
is
;
it is
and
life
that
rests.
It is
who
TTOioiv virdp^T},
we
will not be
'Ttto,
But
1
5, I shall
45
more common
is
in history.
Hdt.
bring
war on
to bring
on
the chariot
the
leading
important
is
i.
e.,
harnessed to
a necessary condition to
This is analogous to vtto aireo'i I'jkacre /xifka,
that end.
where the end to be gained is to have the flock in the
dinate
cave
the driving
In Xen. Yenat. 4
the dogs out
when
for
the same
only as
is
:
Tm
46
For, to a living
away from under me
is before him
what
motion
forward
creature,
against
is as natm-al as striking on what is under it is to a fall-
me
literally,
ing stone.
and
'ETTt
horizontal direction, as
pendicular
me
me
it is viro.
II.
885,
is
eVt,
He
and
assailed
under.
Anab. 3
TrapeKoXevero,
071,
i.
virdyeiv,
He
e.,
efiirpoaOev vTrwyeiv
behind them.
71. The English preposition under does not bear
"We can
transference to this horizontal direction.
" stand from under " this
;
suggests perpendicular
say
motion ; but, if we change the line of motion in the
no longer serve.
Matt. 13 44, He goetli and eelleth all that he
he goeth, virwyei ; the
hath, and buyeth that field
the
buying the going is merely
emphatic point is
will
are co-ordinate, but in thought there is a clear subMore commonly the subordinate action
ordination.
Under ; Accessory
'Ttto,
47
Notioits.
To
riding up^ vTrekdaa^i.
translate this riding up gently^ or slovdy, does not
commend itself it does not suit the business of the
would give any orders
hour.
To
it
to
is
Cyrus
is
need-
inept moreover,
tion
is
answer expected.
72. Me//eti/, to remain, abide, wait; v7ro/j,eviv, to remain under ^ to hear^ s^istain, endtire / the actor is sta-
dure chastening,
viro^evere.
remain on.
Cyr. Inst. 1 4, The
horse stumbled U]3on his knees, and nearly threw
Cyrus over his head, yet he held on, iirefMecvev.
''Eirifieveiv,
to
When
4:8
It is therefore in the
to be gained by waiting.
and
would
have no right to be,
a
connective,
thought
but for the phrase that follows. The preposition and
English phrase
amples.
because
But
is
let
we cannot always
English.
73. If the conqueror j>mfe the yoke ujpon the conbea/r it,
inro^epetv ;
quered, iTTiTtdevai,, the conquered
if
eirep'xea-Oai,
eTnirlirTeiv,
upon the
other, eTnevai,
we
say
'Ttto,
vTToSixovTac
if
49
flee
from under
it,
v7rocf)euyov-
(TLV.
The study
of eVt
is
Prep,
ck) suggests
the leader
subject of the verb; vc^-qyelaOai presents
as subordinate to some other person, or power, or to
some
battle
as the pioneers,
as the
marking
they did so
is
them
virojyeiv,
paratory to a hunt.
Compare with
common
this
Hdt. 1
151,
They
resolved in
whatever
50
way
from
act
terously shunning
vivo,
t5. It
is
who
leads, vcf^rjyecrai,
is
his death.
It simply prothat
Orestes
lead
in
the
poses
way
retiring from the
scene
an
act
present
preparatory, and hence subordinate to the act which was soon to follow his
death.
swift
coming
So the gods lead men, vcpTjyovvraL, by suggestions
drawn from objects and creatures around them (Xen.
man's reason and will are here pictured
Cyri., Bk. 3)
the
actors
as
no one is convinced against his
great
;
reason, or
made good
76. Crito
Crito,
way God is
The
16, Let
leading us,
this
iTretSr)
Il/jo?,
Toiuards,
To,
Near
51
must at last,
life and death.
sovereign, decide the question of
reason,
wliicli
will,
as
It
is
remembrance and
tried and tempted
CHAPTEK
TOWAEDS, NEAIt
7rp09, TO,
VIII.
TO,
FACE TO FACE.
sense
tells
78.
regard
lations.
him he
We
tt/jo?
shall
The
prepositions
ava.,
Kara,
and errl, in
wide range
viro,
It is the
man
whence
the
is
The Greek
52
Prepositions.
meaning
tliis fii'st
this
to,
comes
naturally to
of
being the relation in space
meet face
79.
7rpo9
From
mean near
persons who
tlie state.^
to face.
When man
man
it
is
prima-
never and
were
;
tt/do?,
living object as if it
often it makes alive to the imagination what is, in itnever does. To say Trpo? Tpwa?
self, lifeless ; this eVl
lifeless
fidxea-dai implies
it
was
built to
o-T/'}^o9
As
relations of things,
different
from the start as subserving these higher relations.
fact in the study and
supposition would not affect any important
For the derived meanings, betherefore invites no discussion here.
irphs
sides,
in addition
to,
Near
to,
Face
to Face.
53
them.
some quality residing in the object of the preposition or, to put it briefly, eVl ctt^^o? ^dWetv would
;
be quite proper,
at him.
To
81.
if
you
the
kill
eV
attain to virtue,
man
aperrjv, if
you
are think-
it costs
but if
ing especially of the manly endeavor
you are thinking chiefly of the happiness it brings, tt/jo?
;
soldiers
dper^v (Xen. Conviv., ch. 4). The discouraged
(Anab. 3 1) had no spirit to go to their arms, eVt to,
:
oifXa',
no
and
call
till
i.
e.,
the enemy,
hence
'>
suggested by
tt/jo?,
but in
many
subject
tion.
Trpo"?
It is
K6vrpa 'KaKrl^etv.
to
Here
54:
may be
83.
very different,
to
what the
did to them
Ik
S'
84.
Hector
(II,
would weave,
woman ;
that
mand
7, 1,
me
cusing
the
Keptune
rocks,
IX we
7r/)09
ireTpycn ^a\cov.
The
read that
against the
ship met the rocks
it
to
its
To,
11/309,
own
to Face.
They leaned
ivwina leaned
their
them
55
and
irrl
irpo'i aXktjXovi ;
forbids the reciprocation which dW7]\ov'i al-
ways
carries
with
There
it.
eV
What
shall
we
say?
and the English translation each describes a common fact by a short phi-ase,
at the botimpossible to be taken literally (for those
tom were not heaped upon others), but so suggestive
:
its
inaccuracy
is
pardoned for
brevity's sake.
we read
that
him on
board.
Had he
the
word
7rpo9, suiting
66
89. But,
may be
it
all this ?
Probably they thought nothing about it,
but spoke from habit just as a well educated person
uses, in English, the words shall and will^ correctly
of
from
reflect.
him
here
is
return to his
The
preposition
home
at
his door.
90. Achilles bewailed his friend, the slain Patroklus, placing his hands upon his breast, eVl crr^Oea-aiv ;
if he had laid his hands upon the breast to find if the
heart was
been
still
Trpo? (II.
91.
18
The way
would have
317).
to
happiness,
rj
6So<i etr
evSaifioviav,
also TT/jo? evhaLjjLovlav ; but the former, where happiness is found at the end of a course of labor, or search ;
the
latter,
where
it
comes of
itself,
to one
who
refuses
examine
and
then to
buy
the
rest
the
to
dWo
He had
to
acofxa.
hody, irpo'i
of
go
do
rather
to
to
the
but
horse,
something to
nothing
receive namely, an impression good, or bad, as he
first
To,
11/309,
to Face.
57
in-
structing the
when he had
for
latter,
when
enemy
as to stimulate
When
(II.
them
come
so near to the
to face about
and
fight
4).
at
the Scean gate, the nurse held the child on her hreast^
etrX KoXtrm ; a burden, a charge
resting on the nurse ;
fvm
koKttov,
the nurse.
cipal act
68
Great stones
wliicli
were
fell
the object
3)
come
eVt
07i thee,
ere
(Kev. 3
But
eVt.
in the
How
96.
shall I
You may
eVt ro Trvp, or
to stir the
fire, it
be eVl to
will
When
elfit
3, 20).
fire
"
say
cording to what your object is in going
to warm yourself, it will be tt/oo? to Trvp
e2//.fc
the
if
if
you go
you go
irvp.
a fire breaks out in a city, great numbers come together in two classes firemen and spectators ; the one class come eVt to Trvp, the other tt/jo?
97.
TO TTvp
though
themselves or to
act
upon the
from
neither class
stir
fire,
the
fire
come
warm
either to
but one
class
come
to
it.
To^
11/309,
to Face.
59
the
all
usage.
Anab. 1
8,
acnriai
spears.^ rdt^
irpo^;
the shields
ra Bopara
upon
iSovTrrjcrav
the
tliey
call
If one strikes
it,
or to break
strikes
ujyon
upon
is
99.
built
it
Trpo?.
In
New
upon
house
"the
not eVt.
Xen. Oecon. 7
God, methinks, has prepared the nature of woman /b^' works and cares within doors, iirl epya koL eVi/ieXT^/zara for he made her
100.
23,
be done
7r/jo9,
sj)irit less
eVt
is
101.
They encamped on
the sea-shore,
the object
near the
60
Greek Prepositions,
TJie
iirl
harbor^
rov acyiaXov
Trpo'i
tm
somewhere
indefinitely ujpon
on,
with
7rpo<i
how
IS'ote
own
the other.
tion
Xtfjuevi
it
downward motion
pictures
Sec-
arrested.
downward motion.
the sea
stone
is
is
merely near
In the expression
to.
is
made
by the added
explicit
102. In the implied converse of two persons, sugby 7rpo9, we observe that there is no impact,
gested
nor contact
are only
near to each other ; hence this preposition comes to
express the idea of nearness ; Trpo? r^ y^ vavfia'xelv,
;
tt/jo?
t/ie
sea
why
When,
8, 1),
at
cities
near the
irpo^;
6a\sea,
Be-
and
'EttI
61
Trpb^ in Composition.
cause the cities did not act on the sea, but received
the reciprocal action is
sea their supplies
from the
We
on equal terms.
They
prepares them
to be counted, or added ;
not fractions
in
must
all
the
world
be
but
only,
things
brought to
common denominator
or added.
its
own
The
right the
meaning
hesides,
in addition
to /
CHAPTER
eVt
104.
AND
''^irk')(ei
7r/309
tc tlm, to
IX.
IN COMPOSITION.
if,
The Greek
62
tive, iire'^eiv
rov
cease
Bpofjuov, to
erally, to
Prepositions.
is,
from
running^
lit-
are.
The
work
in this
way
He
laid a
irpoae.'xeiv,
not
shield to
him
eire'xeiv.
We
it,
we
e')(eiv.
his
pidse,
106. Hdt. 1
and ieing
(Mem.
tion, rjv
[i7i
if],
3, 9).
Jf
shall need
any more
instruc-
'EttI
and
irpo^ in Composition.
more
63
instruc-
tion.
takes on
iirl
this
shows what
it
was
in
fact
own thought.
108. 'EttI sometimes looks forward to a phrase
immediately followiug that justifies and requires its
up
his
any towards
y^difieOa, ei
this
hy discoursing as follows,
Trpovfil/Sa^e
Xiycov
ic<i
iyna-Ke-
tuvttjv TocuSe',
64
iirl
sider.
which of these
into
self
'Etti points
classes
sentence
mind
just
what
this
less
equation
Head
thing.
TovTo
again
(Mem.
2, 10),
Then,
o-ycei/rw/ie^a, irorepoL.
if
BouXa
you
ovv koI
will, let
us
consider this, whether, etc. Here we have the equation before us, drawn from the same page aKe'y^aaOat
:
TOVTO
= i'TnaKe'^acrOat eh iroTepav.
TTOTcpoc
Heb. 12
.
Tt9 va-Tepwv
,
exact
form
of
the
the
15, iirlaKOTrovvTe'i
/jlij
It
is
in
"
"
does not follow that looking to it is the best possible transphrase to it has lost cast a little has become too
and dignity of
this place.
Not every
and
'EttI
65
Trpo^ in Composition.
went for
and then
first,
aXkot orl av
You had
ap'x^cov.
is
stated afterwards
to that.
cusers
here,
but, for
my
eTreXadofirjv, iirl
was there
to
translation that
literal
my
life.
is
That
fact
was in
it
all
The most
for the ser-
and so
like a
English allows.
mon
may be thought
mean
com-
66
To
the characteristic
but when he saw the deer he rushed forward, lirCkaOo^evo^ Trdvra, forgetting everything about it / eirl
refers to tlie cautions he had received about rough
ground
it
is
done
thereto, e^eXtcerai.
112.
fell,
When
struck
by
a stone
brought to an end
hence
satisfied to say
But
in
limitation which the English phrase leaves the reader to supply with-
out saying
it.
'Etti
and
7rpo<i
in
67
Composition.
''
Lucian's Dial.,
Aphrodite and Eros," Helios is comas
i-TnXeXrja-fjievov rf}? l7nraaia<;, forgetting
plained of
as charioteer ; it was a forgetting of somehis
duty
113. 'EttI
may
word
that
word
is
Kuraveueiv.
Why then
and
when
it
had been
said
given, should be of
doubts (Mem. 2
1, 22), as
also to see if
68
serving her
eVt
looks
ask on the basis of some ground or reason that justithe asking, eTrairelu.
Oed. Tyr. 14 16, a)v eVat-
fies
the
Tet9, eVl refers to the ground of the demand
23
extreme
need.
et
Kev
dWo
II.
593,
fiel^ov
king's
:
If
i7raiT7]aeia<;.
ahout something,
swallows
it
'
compounds
is
in
hearing
longs to the other as if they had crossed traclis, and each was doing
duty in the other's field. The passages referred to in illustration dis;
prove the definition offered. II. 23 593, Xen. Vict. 4 39, In no case
does nphs denote "for a purpose"; in no case does ^ir2 denote simply
:
"
more, besides."
If ever so rendered,
tion, as a resource in
tion
we must
think
it
without saying
it.
'EttI
I'jraKovaa'i
and
why eVt
'7rpo<;
69
in Composition.
squeal.
and hearing
TovTo,
1,
irpoaaKovaa'i he koX
in addition to
Why
not laxov
Be-
based upon
it.
ample,
to
hind
\6(pov<i iiriBecv
if
crests
(Hdt. 1
on the helmets,
:
eirl
to,
Kpdvea
171).
all
The
thong (Hdt.).
priest
a seconding of the prayer ; it knits the phrases, otherwise disjointed, into an organic unity of thought.
119.
To
say, Xiyetv
iTriXeyeiv, to say
on the
basis
70
of
3),
eVt, in explanation.
120. Socrates
"
says
to
5)
You
fjuaiiirl refers to
that," etc.
121. ''n?
(}>aTO
HdrpoKko^
Se
(ptka
eireireiOeO''
had been
of you,
said.
whom,
^N'ew Testament,
if his
his asking.
122. II. 1
What man
is
there
ivill
give him,
him
iirl,
for
Compare
" would
Anab. Y 4, 9, And Seuthes asked, '^pero
"
Then,
you even be willing to die for this one ?
after an answer had been given, we read iTVTjpero 6
asked thereupon. This would usually
"tevd-qq, Seuthes
:
and
'EttI
7r/)09
ond question
the
made
is
the
is
is
that
thought
'E-TTt
first.
71
ni Composition.
strict
of a smoother phrase.
123. Menelaus in
him
springing iipon
it is
fight
is
the office of
It
with Paris
(eVal'fa?),
(II.
369),
horse-hair crest,
tt/jo?.
{iTrio-Tpiylra^;),
be-
him
in
literally it
means tmming
so as to face those to
e.,
turning toward,
victim.
met
i.
ujjon,
whom
when
the hel-
hand, Menelaus,
a throw, slung
eirLhivrjaa^;,
it
sivingmg
away among
it
around for
the Achaians.
Let us
in another
drop the eVl, and find the simple Zuvelv
Od. 9 384, when Odysseus and his party had
place.
:
to
it
here the verb denotes the main acBut look forward in the same
simple.
about, eUveov
tion,
and
is
swinging
when
up a huge stone,
for the throw.
T2
We
124.
ging a well
iirervxpu
something happened
me, Trpoaervx^v.
125. AeiKvvvat, to show, 2^oint out an object ; eVti.
e., having the object already in
hetKvvvai, to exhibit,
an
as to
qualities
Such a showing is
its
is
in or belonging
to a thing.
basis of
and
Xoz/
mef
rj/cev,
Who of
Therefore
you as messenger to
compounded with levai, has
else to
to
'EttI
and
allow
to
IIpoo-Levac,
73
irpb^ in Composition.
to co?ne, to
admit (Anab. 4
55),
i(f)C6vai,,
of a stone.
1:3," Having
implying force
Yesp.
is
eira/ye
reciprocal
each jaw as
moves
the %i]pper
it.
acts
on the other
Ildt. 2
68,
The
is
at
croco-
yvdOov
/caret).
irpoadryet Trj
Anab. 3
jaw
it
4,
127.
The
'E7rtTacrG'6iz^, TTpoaTdacrecv.
definitions of these words in the
Lexicon seem
very near alike indeed, they are both used to exThe proper
press the idea of injunction, command.
74
TJie
Greek Prepositions.
made
two prepositions
'Etti
command
responds by a free choice whether to obey or disobey. If a command is disobeyed, the word to express the giving of it is naturally Trpoardaaeiv, in
order to harmonize by anticipation the word with the
completed thought.
in Hdt. 1
mand
the
be readily accepted
if one is recusant
but
Trpoo-Tdao-eiv;
takes towards him a sharper tone it is
and obeyed
is
command
iTTiTaaaeLv.
7,
When God
has
women
as if the
a willing acceptance.
75
Ilapd.
CHAPTER
X.
Trapd.
128.
Uapd,
ly, heside, is
used with
tlie
Gen., the
We
use of this preposition ; Gorgias 473, C, Let us compare our views together, Trap dWrjXovi, and see whether.
The
side
picture
by
is
that of
common
conclusion.
He
him,
irapd
It
Trapd XaxppovLaKro, with Sophrotiiscus.
that
does not admit the idea of hostility like eVt nor
he
lives,
The
of mutual converse between equals, like tt/jo?.
the preposition
parties are unequal, and the object of
is naturally the superior of the two, as it should be.
7Q
TJie
for
is fitting
it
and the
place,
Greek Prepositions.
The
from the
Lexicon implies, that the judge is acting offibut only as every man is a judge of his fellow
cially
man when he forms and holds an opinion about him.
as the
This essential relation of the parties or things underlies all the uses
and shows with what modifications
;
guarded
(Tirovha'^
where the
is
Trapa
Ta<;
o-7r6vBa<i,
contrary
to the
truce,
Uapa
CHAPTER
irapa
77
in Composition.
est
XI.
composition.
'EkXdSa
Traptjcrovai e? rrjv
0Ka)<; /xr]
roi)^ ^ap/3dpov<i.
and
let it jpass,
irapUaOai.
the
command
resign
2
let
Anab.
me
to
indulge me,
7, 10, irapi'qixi, 1
Hdt.
to another.
:
go hy
dragged along tip the stream
ravra ra 7r\oia ava tov iroraixov
iy those on shore,
the shore.
irapeKKerai iic yfj<i irapa, along beside
133. l>Kv^ denotes the equipments needed in cara
rying on a business, whether in a shop, a kitchen,
such
make
or
furnish
or a camp aKevd^eiv is to
ship,
The Greek
78
is
Prepositions.
more
is
necessary
stores of pro-
is
OP shop, and
is
The Kara-
'wapaaKevaaTo^.
permanent
the irapaaKevr)
when
]^ow,
all
irapea-Kevaa/xivo'?,
only for
its
present march
prepared, irapeaKevaap.evo'i, to resist the loving dishe groups all the vices
ciple then wishes to say more
his
and
that
master
was KaTeaKeuaafietogether,
says
;
vo<i
them
against
all.
The
TrapaaKevrj
had become a
nature
impress
it
aKevaaev)
the nature of
7,
Hapa
doors
for
lie
79
in Composition.
is
ience
cold,
is
less
changed.
wall eoitends along either hank of the river,
Trapa '^(eTX.o'i eKarepov rov irorap.ov ai/jLacnr) irapaTeivei
(Hdt.
runs /
TO,
7rpo9
rr]v
t^? Odkdaarj'i
eaTreprjv (pipovra
In
203).
this
ing
The
to
Anab.
7,
15,
had
men who
like
138.
lost their
The verb
way.
alveiv
means
to
praise j irraiveiv,
]^ow, the same feeling
that prompts to the praise of an action after it is done
would lead to the encouragement of it while it is doto praise for
ing
something done.
Trapaiveov, therefore,
means
to
encourage, to ap-
80
the actor.
in the
meaning
CHAPTEE
AND
airo
XII.
e'/c.
''
139.
are
they
the
Geni-
Where
tive.
loses
and
as
from
good
{aTTo)
the table,
is
not so
with ix ; water poured from a bowl, e/c ^LoXrjf;, cannot be gathered up coins dropped from a bowl, airb
be gathered up again.
<}iid\7]^, may
;
connection implied by
e/c
'Atto
implied by anro
and
81
'E/c.
as we might well
hints of space, since that which is in is more intimately connected than that which is merely near
or hy.
The relation suggested by e/c with Hviug
is
things
hand, eK
often dynamic, or
x^^P^'^
tlie
To
lead hy the
proceding con-
guiding power
II. 16
365, As
tinually
vital.
when
a cloud
ttTTo
'E/c,
its
root
while airb
among
15,
the Athenians
irdvv dpxp-Lov.
The
great change.
From
this
in
commemoration
by the
makes us
e'l
113.
Mem.
7, 2,
e/c
We
ri}? 7759,
82
is
them;
e/c,
arm, e'/c tov ^pa-)^lovo<i eVeXKovaa the connection was not broken.
IM. Descent yVom fathers and near progenitors is
expressed bj eV, as if the descendants so near had
their life in their progenitors
but if the time be
long, the tie grows weaker to the imagination, in
tracing it upward, till at last it seems to break, and
we iind utto as if the far distant descendants had
become quite sundered, and no longer were originated
the
Leading from
;
in their ancestors
rom
immediately from,
e'^.
CHAPTER
aTTO
i^ avroiv
far descent, dirb, others
some by
AND
CK
XIII.
COMPOSITION.
'
'EK, which
is
a mistake in Art.
Page 428,
line 16:
"With
Xen. An.
to the material of
army formed
which the
its line
8,
14."
line
out of those
'E/c
was formed.
still marching up
i.
e., the front
marched up, formed in line with them.
'Atto
them kings
rights
for
and
'E/c in
citizens banished,
its life
no more for
in the tree
it
nature
is
83
Composition.
completed
airoirLirrei,
testifies to this in
the weaken-
shaken
'
146.
to
pay
ATroBtSovaL, to restore
the
act settles
the parties free iKScBovac, to give out without a previous consideration, as a housewife might put out
;
cloth
To
2).
reach, 'iKvelaOaL
power
of thought
culture, or training.
also to reach
by natural growth,
The emphasis throughout is on
ment.
The examples
are
frequent enough,
from
84
TJie
Homer down
Greek Prepositions.
but they
A single one
here drawn.
is
of thought
as it
;
introduced here
is homely, and is
against
a fashion.
tells
us (De Equest., ch. 5),
Xenophon
" The colt's tail should
be let grow, that it may Teach
as
far
brush
as possible,
oira><i
eVt irXela-rov
off
i^LKvovfjbevo<;,
The word
also
to
means
and distance
measured
the
intervene,
by
halting-places
the emphasis
on the starting-point fades to the imthe end of the
agination the
passes over
action
comdropped, and cmo lends
to
interest
itself to
is
e'/c
Of
hard-worked verb,
the
student
will not fail
of
the
Anabasis
dcpiKvetaOaL,
to find examples more than enough.
7:1,/
Cyri. Inst.
this
and do you
so
(Hdt. 1
be placed in a
as to
:
46)
made
TOiv fjbavTrjtojv,
a sea fight
by
itself.
Croesus
hoping
Xerxes (Hdt. 8
rrreLpoofxevo'i),
class
trial
he did
this
'Atto
favor
and
Pausanias
it.
'E/ic
85
in Composition,
made
trial
of
21).
my
With
is tried.
the
trial are
prescribed
settled beforehand
it
is
may
that
If
number
tion, tries to
avoid something in his path (Hdt. 1 10-1), dirorpeireadat, to turn aside as one would do to observe
:
something not
in his path.
150. LaKvvvai, to sJiow, point out, as one
would
86
as
airoheiKvvvaL.
(Hdt. 1
171).
Pointing out the sepulchres, aTroSas
LKvvvre<i,
proofs of their rights in the land (Thuc.
1 26).
This compound also means to appoint, thus
:
setting a
man
acqnired name.
151. vrj(7KeLv, to die j airoOvrjaKeiv, to die
away
the word.
and 'E
'Atto
^
152.
in
87
Composition.
KiroKTelveLvoi which
often
airodvi'ia-KeLv is
tlie
loss of friends,
Andromache
mother,"
(II.
rjrot <yap
414),
irarep
"I have no
father,
aireKrave
d/juov
no dear
Slo<i A;j^tA,\ei;9,
my father
Jhr
the
ing not of
moment
the picture.
153. ^AvoTeXetv, eKreXecv.
would
spoil
which a thing
pressed
by
is
brought to
it out in action
and every
thus
carried
out
invites the use of the verb
purpose
TeKhv but not till he has completed a work that
;
stands
him
off,
aloof
88
or
its
hand
bad
to tilings
as well as
were
set
its
very nature;
it.
Kind handling tnakes colts gentle, airorekeiv ;
puts them in a class (Xen. Equest.). Wise administration makes a city prosperous, diroreXeiv (Plato).^
'
(hZaifxova is translated
"
to
make
tV
"fi^^i"
airoreXeiy
Tliis is
happyP
mere
by an adjective,
is,
only
the class
is
a narrower one.
To regard
'Atto
154.
and
Kow, what
'E: in
is
89
Composition.
It is to achieve a
iKrekelvl
of the actor's
thing out of the spontaneous promptings
own spirit or life ; not by command, nor by promise*
or outward obligation. II. 9 493, The Gods were
:
e'/c
suggests that
granting {i^ereXetov) to me no son,
their will was sovereign., Od. 3 275, Aegisthus, see:
Why
fulfillment of
end.
had
It
its
of the doer.
II.
286,
The Achaians
ai^e 7iot
fulfilling, ovic
made.
The
eKreXiovatv, the promise which they
not
for
them
words are a taunt^'^against
making good
their boastful promise.
They were under no obliga-
make
to
tion, except to themselves,
it
good.
Had
expressed
The people
airorekeovaLV.
The vow,
evxv,
ment put
known
and
The
et-^a?
claim
fulfill-
class of actions
set
them
it
free (aTro)
fugitive
safety.
Hdt. 1
25, Croesus
made
The Greek
90
Prepositions.
d7ro(f)vyr)
from
disease.
The guard
iK^uyrj
what wider,
156.
To
cw? aTro^vyr].
lead rjyeladai.
rjyetTai.
mind
is
it
is
The
expressed by i^rjyelaOac
has no law or limit but in the
arbitrary,
of the leader ; hence this
to express military
command
word
(II.
is
806
naturally used
Hdt. 1 151).
;
:
But suppose we change a little the picture of the procession, and say, as if reading from a newspaper report It was determined to close the celebration by
and
services at the monument, one mile distant
Company C led the procession. Here the simple
it would express
verb riyeiadat will not be used
A new feature
truth, but not the truth wanted here.
has been added to the picture, and this demands
:
recognition.
Nor
will e^rjyelaOai
expresses too
case
and, further,
it
'Atto
the
and
movement has
'Eac in
91
Composition.
is
[Note the
compounds
in
Hdt.
2 121, 1, in the story of the cunningly-built treasurefather calling up his two sons set
The
house.
:
dying
he had always
forth to them., tovtokji dirrj'yrjaaTO, how
in
live
should
taken good care that they
plenty, then
all
about the
revealing to them, rovroiai i^'r]yTj(Td/j,evot,
men
knew therefore
his
dcprjy-
all
the contrivance of a
secret
See also
took pride in the thought that he could explain,
the heavens as things
i^Tjiyeladai, the mechanism of
therefore i^vy--
known
to himself alone.
40),
92
117)
5
also
^/voiix'qv,
if it
36).
The judge
declares the
airot^ai-
they reveal
it.
The judge
is
responsible to a higher
159. 'ETTt, on, and airo, off, seem far enough apart
alone ; but in composition the compound
when used
as to in-
'
vite comparison.
A7roBi,S6vat, iTrthihovai ; airoreKelv,
and
others.
AiroBLSovai, to jpay, it diseTTLTeXeiv,
^
" To
iinhihovai the Lex. says
give beis wrong ; it is aside from the natural
On
This
aw.
If thou
reqidre&t
me
to give to
Eumeliis some
sides ',
'Atto
He
and
'E/c
in
93
Composition.
was
missed
Myers, has followed the Lexicon, and therein
if
eVt
does
iirchovvai,
a point. What then does
mean,
not suggest the idea hesides, in addition to
It
means
to give
claims.
to those claims,
alive.
The same
161.
force of eVt
again seen in
is
eirat-
marked upon
It is respectfully
strictly hesides, in
so is always a concession to English phraseology (see Sec. 91).
162. 'ATToreXetf, to complete a thing, so that it is
addition
to ;
that to translate
it
thought of by
by
he
is
aTTOTeXelv.
free
it.
When
from
the
it {airo),
man
fulfills his
his act
'EircTeXeiu, to fulfill
is
vow,
expressed
an order or com-
The Greek
94
mand
Prepositiojis.
from a
to
Thuc. 1 YO,
ray orders^ ra eirtraffao^ieva iTrereXeov.
The Athenians are quick to put in execution, eVtre:
Xiarat epyo),
demanded
answer to this demand
soldiers
^^iraLTelv (Lex.),
seen.
It
means
is
to
by
wrong,
expressed
The
airohLhovau.
as
we have
To make
'Atto
haps
we
and
'E/c in
miglit reply
It
95
Composition.
is
we do study
all
a recorded language in
own
our
165.
friends^
to
in
any
rich
from
jiocks,
hij
vtto (^tkwv,
if
is acts
owner
(aTTo),
'
rich,
do not act
not by them
As a
he
is
made
rich
from them
(utto).
by
shall
and
will,
entered.
The Greek
96
Prepositions.
CHAPTER
et9
166. 'Et9,
AND
XIV.
Iv.
These two prepositions (originally one eV?) carryto a wide extent the same suggestion as in in the
Latin, in its two meanings of motion info, and posi'Et9 always governs the Accusative, iv al-
tion in.
We
the other.
The Preposition
the names of all things
167.
is
et9,
a denial of
into,
by
opposite.
before
bounded in space.
boundary from with-
that are
out, can-ying,
its
may be used
motion before
*Et9
and
97
'Ez/,
phrase.
life is
everything, in short,
may be
the
toil
old coin,
of
memory supply
by heating,
when
it is
to give back
its
use,
An
may be made,
cold.
Greek phrase,
it was first struck in the mind's mint.
when
We
man
end
thought.
is
98
of
entrance
made
is
room
that of
is
669 (into),
(this is
to
true,
move
in after the
is it
always
but with
eV,
on the
is
as
and absolute
iv is closer
is
more
that they
Kol av ev
170.
may
ifiol,
he
made
avTdi<;,
inroad into a country by an army is exthe noun ka^oXr) ev with the same verbal
The
pressed by
a plug or stopper.
These examples show with what tenacity the primary
root gives
the noun
ifj,/3o\v<;,
and
'Et9
99
'Ey.
immovable.
With this
discrimination in mind,
we
find a reason
We
translation.
find, in deexpress in an English
tw
eV
for
evcovvfiw,
battle,
scribing an army arrayed
on the left, and tTrl rov evcovufiov, on the left; and
We must
Observe,
body
they might
of the battle should require ; but Ariaeus and his barbarian force were an integral part of the line of battle
fixed there, for his removal would have changed
We
have seen,
in
On
comparing
et<?
and
iv,
that
or obstacle
iv,
100
TJie
Greek Prepositions.
confines
it.
which they
did.
The
(Hdt. 8
81).
arrest of motion,
conflict,
The
173.
situation.
is
^peara,
and
object of elaj3a>Ckeiv
is
something that
and eh helps fit the word to the
To throw poison into the wells, eV ra
it is in,
acts after
ifi^dWeiv are
itself
throw
is i/j,/3aX\etv
The
objects of
'Et9
and
101
'Ev.
on board;
is
inert, or
to be carried
passive placed on board simply
of the verb
to
is
etV/3-j
man
command
of
these, tovtcov
175.
mekevov
eiriixeketaOat.
iv
and
e/c
are appar-
are
ently so nearly alike in meaning while yet they
is
them
of
a
that
different
comparison
distinctly
means
"E^St^Xo? and
The
known
6/^817X09.
from what
known
means
is around
through
evBrjko^
clearly
is more than clearly perceived, it is
perception; it
known by name. A dark speck is clearly seen in the
it is eKBrjXo^.
is
sky it is not known at once what it
After a little study the observer becomes sure what
then it is ev^7]\o<i. It
it is, and can give it a name
its home iii a class,
has, to the observer's mind, found
this it was only
before
its name
taken
has
and
iv,
by name
II.
of, iK,
The Greek
102
Prepositions.
little
know who he
is
he
is
but after a
eKSr]\,o<;;
little,
from
is evSrjXo^.
my window
I look out of
brilliant
it
when
it
I shall learn
its
its
name through
specific
its specific
name;
marks,
will be evSrjXo';.
it
speak
only hear
and plain /
clear
my
Do
you not
other sounds
evBrjXa, so that
among
but you
I
what
mean.
know
voice distinct
'E49
and
103
'Ey,
would
cial light
it
is
eKcpavi]';,
and no more,
as
long as that
doubt remains.
httle,
take it out of
thing shining in a colorless heap, we
the heap, and finding it to be a jewel, put it in a
box.
179.
Ta
in alto-rilkvo (Plato
eK^avr), figures
Con-
not before ;
as soon as they are interpreted
to
the
forward
the iv looking
meaning ; e/c looking
erly,
from which
the figures
sprung.
they are
ifx(f>avr].
The Greek
104
4
II.
4:G8,
buckler as
lie
Prepositions.
down
bowed
<f>(ovf}<i
uncovered^ i^e-
'O X6709
d.,
hcdvotav
ti]v
means of vocal
sounds with words and phrases. Sounds of an unknown language can be no more than eK^aveh to him
discourse snakes j>lain our thought iy
who
hears.
For a comparison of
Sec. 150).
182. ^^KheLKvvvat^ to
is
show
the
object
the act communicates no knowledge,
the senses. Show his children to me,
it
only serves
e'/cS-
(Oed. Col,
The
II.
19
/ will
The
first
verb
is
e'/cS-,
the second
evZ-] iv
is
them good,
or do
them harm
the preposition
and
'Et9
105
'Ey.
The meanings
183.
of these two
able
to
compounds seem
To take
suggested by the prepositions.
iiyxeLpelv, implies that the thing so
taken can be grasped and handled is under control.'
difference
is
a thing in hand,
The hand
is
here
it is
the
mined, that
calls for
power of
is
resist-
iyx^ip^lv., to
This mistakes the figure. The thing is taken in hand into the hand
in order to manage and control it, and not the hand put into the thing.
whether
it
is
This
hand
last,
itself.
be
fire,
not the
way
106
make a worthy
must he undertaken^
The proposed work was in the writer's
e'y')(eip'qTeov.
no one was more competent, therefore he could
line
do it the work was in his hand. Plato Apol. Soc,
Xen. Ages. 1
1, It is
not easy to
it
little
time I have,
to
something that it might be beyond his strength to remove. Mem. 2 3, To win over my friend to care
for my affairs when I should be away from home, I
would endeavor to take an interest in his affairs when
he should be absent would endeavor to take an inthis he could certainly
terest., e'7%et/3ow/y iircfjieXelaOaL
:
do, hence iv
word
is
wider and more important interests. This is in conformity with the primary suggestions of iv and evrl
respectively and the instances found in reading con;
would come not from the nature of the case, but from
some accidental cause hence iyX'Hdt. 2 158, Necos was the first who tried, eVefor a canal leading into the Red sea which
'Xelprjae,
;
'Et9
and
107
'Ei^.
as
by chance
to fall ujpon,
hnTv^^Aveiv,
making
is
meet with
The
crocodile
swallows
it
coming upon,
down. Hdt. 2
:
this.
Anab. 1 9, 25, The crocodile must needs swallow the bated hook
with Cyrus drinking up the
or
ev^en
wine,
taking possession of it, was a matter for
:
his discretion
When
therefore eVruy^ai/ety
digging
/ came
kimv'^')(av.iv.
108
CHAPTEE XY.
AND
Trept
VTT^p.
They
(II.
187. These
in the
two prepositions
Accusative
citij, irepl
dcTTv
(II.
22
173).
To go round
the city
We
He/Ji
and
109
'Tirep.
We
from the
original difference in
which
to
is
around another
the Dative
a bracelet
may
and
The thing
be so attached to
it
as
around
vTTep,
is different.
The
no
mentary
there
result of passing
discharged, yielding
therefore, that virep
case
is
is
its
place to iiri
The
reason,
110
drawn up around a
irepX
vTrep rov
work
last
an endeavor
it is
jxr)
in
was
fitting for
To speak
VTrep.
ahout our
the
Trepl,
ro3v
To
offer sacrifice
(Mem. 2
to those
form
yor
Tr}<i
Tr6\ea)<;
2, 13),
who
it.
This
is
7rpd'y/j,aTo<;
true of the
that
many
They are
191.
may
be
said.
Trepl
hearth
Instit.
3,
They
in place.
Cyri.
will not cease talking about us,
Uepl and
BLaXeyofjbevoL irepl
Ill
"Tirep.
r)fia)u.
speak far you and for ourselves^ virep crov koI virep
to protect or
vfiwv; in behalf of, as standing over
defend.
Anab. 7
4, 10,
one
one
first
in the second,
the object of
;
I will not
BiafxdxecrOai, for
fiot,
necessarily
is
of neces-
more than
Sow
is it that
proaches
from
the
Trojans,
69'
virep
aeOev aia^i
it
presents,
112
CHAPTER
7re/>l
193. In
AND
XYI.
vTrlp in composition.
and in many
Ttepi^
with
'very beautiful
noun
may
fjii<ya<;,
g?'eat
vTrepfieya^;, irainensely
great.
object of
because the
yond
(Trept)
others
great
vTrepixe'ya<;,
above
{virep)
others.
In most compounds of
ing
is
irepl
and
vTrep,
the mean-
examples.
An
194.
apparent contradiction
is
found
words
in the
usually
siderations
"
the head of the family responsible for all its members ; it spares the
self-love of Paris, since it does not present Hector as telling him the
bad things the Trojans were saying about him (Hector takes all this
it is more winning, making the appeal not to Paris's
love of country, but to his love of family it presents a picture all
pulsating with life the chieftain weighted with public cares, yet warm
upon himself)
people.
irphs
Ilepl
and
classed
The word
avoid
113
'TTrep in Composition.
if
it
in a like case.
permit,
he
17
7rpuSr]<i, this
plundering.
II.
10
247, Since
yap
permit, fir)
t'xyeac
wepiyhr].
heyond
195.
others, irepioiZe
aWcov.
look
and
see
with the
We
business of an overseer
item in
it.
it
has to serve.
58),
or-
the time of
114
Hdt. 4
fxevetv.
89,
trepifjueveiv,
to
fMevca.
197. It
may be
ing
how to complete
go by
their return
sea, if possible.
home.
They wish
Chirisophus speaks
to
" Anaxi-
If you
a friend of mine, and is now admiral.
and
transI
shall
obtain
I
think
will send me,
ships
bius
is
Now
do you, if
ports sufficient to carry you home.
you wish to return by sea, remain hei^e (TrepLfMeveTe)
Heartill I shall return, and that will not be long."
ing this the soldiers rejoiced, and voted that he
as quick as possible.
addresses
Xenophon
After so
them
"
:
is
sail
settled
sent to
ought to
situation
we wait."
when
Xenophon
changed
be'
is
doing while
Observe, the
speaks.
They
The
when
Are
115
Prepositions Interchangeable ?
CHAPTER
X7II.
'
The
prepositions given
X6709 ttoXXo?.
Through,
Ionia,
the speaker was an Ionian
ac-
know
all
knew
his
own
little
We
other prepositions
each to his place.
iv, irepl
even changed.
199. Again, from Demos.
ohov Kol
T)}? etV
Jelf., vol.
ii,
p.
317, Oxf.
He
has
116
to
Attica,
We
and of
that into
Peloponnesus.
etV rr)v
for
cious bottle.
as for
states
its use.
on
Greek
fall
may seem
200. It
we have
seen that
when he
This
stumbles
last situation
On Both
'A/i^t,
Sides
Arotmd, About.
of,
117
The
position.
petitioner
on
is
his knees to
do some-
for eVt.
To
say that Prepositions cannot ever be interchanged would be a very rash statement ; but before
adducing examples in proof of a possible interchange
201.
the
criticise
it.
CHAPTER
a/A<^t,
ON BOTH SIDES
XYIII.
AEOUND, AEOUT.
OF,
Trepi,
specific difference.
Originally
it
means on hoth
sides
many
cases
it
HeiaavSpop (Thuc. 8
65)
ol dfx<pl
it
a^p^ea
118
(Hdt. 8 25)
:
of numbers, oi
(Cyri. Inst. 1
afji,<f>l
ra<i
StoBeKa fivpi,dSa<;
2, 15)
irepl e^Bofi^Kovra (Thuc. 1 54),
In other instances the distinction between d/j,<f)l and
:
Trepl is plain
in
in ol
Trepl
d/x(f>l
is
Td<;
number,
as
But
with
or on a string.
suits the
However
mental picture, as
irepl
this
would
may
be, d/xcfn
not, in noting
Time
enemy.
thought of
is
119
of.
as a line.
ye
me
There
many
But the
dficfn and TrepL
the
less
distinct
are
not
in
;
space
original designations
is the servitor of the dimensions, length, and
Trepl
breadth,
dfi(}>l
CHAPTER
XIX.
TT/JO,
he goes
for him.
and the
II.
10
relation
286,
is,
otg. Trpo
'Axacwv ajyeXo'i
yei,
120
forth
by
205.
fear.^
The
prepositions
They
man
can
and freely
toil
for
to
him
Trpo
man
and
vTrep
has in
have one
own
loss,
Cyri. Inst. 8
his fellow-
can
suffer,
8, 4, Siukiv-
CHAPTER XX.
(Tvv
206.
mon
Sw,
AND
fierd.
with.
"
'Zijv
and Mera.
121
TOicrSe,
escaped
destruction.
The
here
association
is transient and purely incidental to the act of making their escape. Od. 10 320, Now go to the stj,
:
lie
9, 2, For first when yet a boy, and receiving his training vnth his hrother and luith the other
hoys, avv tw aSe\cf>o) koX cruv roi<i aX\,oi<i irauai, he was
Anab. 1
reckoned far superior to them all. Here the association expressed by avv is incidental, subservient to the
comparison, which
Od. 16
ants, fxTa
is
He
140,
SfjLoocov,
the
main
point.
in the house.
Here the
association
is
not incidental
it is
who sit together at table must participate in the common fare those who travel together must participate
The use of /j,ra or of
in the hardships of the way.
;
The Greek
122
Prepositio7is.
There
good or bad.
is
nothing
^eco,
With
We
thing.
IL 24
400,
TraWofievo'i,
man
we
to live
We
we have come
steps
209. After
aiiv
roL<;
and by what
6eoi<i,
to the discrimination.
verbs of motion
yttera
means
to
go
among, to go for, or after, so as to secure one's presgo after without any added implicaII. 3 370, "E\k fi6T 'A%a/ou9, he was dragging
tion.
him in among the Achaians. Anab. 1 1, ILvpov /jueraence
finally, to
:
Tre/xerat,
Ciia,
123
Through, Across.
With
the idea
in the
The men
as its necessary condition.
all
as
it
is
a chess-board travel much ; but,
among
relative
on
among
change
themselves,
it
is
relative position.
invite special
consideration.
CHAPTER XXL
Sia,
THROUGH, ACROSS.
beyond
it.
The
spear inflicted a
wound
hia OoopaKO'^,
through the hr east-plate, hia Kvver]<i, through the helmet it did not begin to fulfill the warrior's aim till
;
it
124
The Greek
proper work.
Here opens
Prepositions.
tive case.
had Cyrus on
Greek is more
all
their
picturesque
much
amount
to
through
{8ia) the
till
it
is
spoken
door of the
lips.
it
This
last
phrase
is,
after a
all
meaning
of Blu, through
^'
tirne, Bt
Ata,
that
all
is
125
Through^ Across.
would be conquered,
St'
avrov,
is
p-(pea<;,
come
to
means through
till
mind.
Of
214.
Any
through
it
one
may
may begin
126
ipations,
settled
it
before gramma-
rians
the
The
215.
is
for that
is
are
" Ato of
Place, only in Poets, the same sense as hta w.
Gen." Before accepting so discouraging a statement,
let
II.
127
247, e^ Se Sia
'irrv-)(a<i
way
the un-
It
stopped ;
yielding spear.
hut in the seventh fold of hide it stuck, iv rfj S' efiSoall
fidrr} pivot ax^To ; it did not get clean through at
it
plate,
The
through the thick co2)pice and woods.
within
the
limits
us
what
took
shows
place
picture
vXrjp,
word
to the thought
on what is going on
Od. 9 400, The Cyclops dwelt
aicpia<i r}veixoeaaa<i,
along
128
the
no
windy
The
heights.
picture.
218. Cyri. Inst. 1
6,
By
Ta<;
eVtycieXeta?,
you
pious conduct
him
as
"
covering
surrounding, or accomj)anying presence,
his head in the day of battle." Cyi-i. Inst. 1 5, Those
:
as
may be looked
for in
Ata,
Through, Across,
129
wMcli announces something of known and felt imfrom irapayyeWeiv, to announce by auportance
thority, while i^ayjiXkeiv is to annoimce a secret;
TrpoaayyeXkeLv, to announce in expectation of a re;
sponse.
Hermes ?
Heemes. Quite impossible
PosEiDoisr. J^ut at least announce me to him, ofxco^
Trpoadyyetkov avTO); in modern phrase, take up my
name, or card, to him. This act of announcement
looks for a response, and tt/oo? attaches itself to the
verb to mark that fact.
Zeus,
command BiaKeXeveaOat, to
incite, man by man.
^ex^cr;
ScaSexecrdai, to receive
fire
suit of
as hunters
an animal
;
dvaSix'^adac, Karahe^eaOaL (see
Sec. 30).
221. AiaKplveiv, to discriminate between two. Luc.
Bca/cpivaLfiL avrou<;,
same
AiajivooaKeiv,
Dial.,
aj^art f
to
i.
e.,
tell
IIft)9 StaYti'cocr/cet?,
T could not
Aia^evyeiv, to escape
by fleeing through
130
TJbe
Greek Prepositions.
dangers ; the thonglit often is of a succession of dangers on the right and left, through which the fugitive
makes
his escape.
222. Aiaxeipeiv, to do, or take in hand, one's part
where two are acting, as to take an oar to match one
Cyrus, Inst.
to try to
side,
is hLa'xeipetv.
near
to,
may be formed by
bringing them
by
to,
zontal motion.
If, however, the collection is thought of as if made by
heaping the things on each other, the preposition in Gr. would be ewl
each thing resting on what was there before as its basis. If now
we translate this spatial relation into English by any of the terms to,
near
to, beside,
mental picture
in addition
;
we use a
to,
locution
Ata,
severalty by it.
the accumulated
With
mass
e'lri
131
Through, Across.
the case
is
different.
The
particulars of
THE END.
APPLETON &
D.
CO.'S
EDUCATIONAL WORKS,
GREEK.
Hadley's Greek Grammar.
366 pages.
12mo.
This Orammar not only presents the latest and best results of Greek Btudies,
bat also treats the language in the light received from comparative philology.
The work
is clear in its
language, accurate in
its definitions,
judicious in its
246 pages.
12mo.
276 pages.
As an introductory book
in Greek, one fitted to lead the learner from the alphabet up to a fair knowledge of Attic narrative Greek, the American teacher can
no text-book superior to this. It is grammar, composition, and readingbook, all in one and, if it be carefully mastered, the student may pass with
perfect ease to the "Anabasis" of Xenophon. The book is complete in itself;
out, for the convenience of such as prefer to use it in connection with some standard grammar, references are made in the syntactical parts to the Grammarg of
Eadley, Crosby, and Sophocles.
find
On
297 pages.
12mo.
237 pages.
12mo.
248 pages.
Containing the Substance of the
12mo.
618
pages.
The
and References
to
By James
ED UCA TIONAL
TFOiZZS. (Continued.)
Xenophon's Anabasis
The demand for a convenient edition of this great claeBic, really adapted to
the wautB of schools, has been met by Professor Boise in a manner that leaves
nothing to be desired. Decidedly the best German editions, whether text or
commentary be considered, have appeared within the last few years and of these
Mr. Boise has made free use while, at the same time, he has not lost sight of the
fact that the classical schools of this country are behind those of Germany, and
that simpler and more elementary explanations are therefore often necessary in
a work prepared for American schools. Nothing has been put in the notes for
the sake of a mere display of learning, and nothing has been introduced by way
of comment except what can be turned to practical use by the reader.
;
Greek
for Beginners.
By
12mo.
of
in
185 pages.
The
First Three
of Dindorf
Clark Johnson, A.
M., LL. B.
12mo.
Grammars.
By Henry
180 pages.
" In
preparing this edition, it has been ray aim to render the Notes sufflciently
elementary to enable the beginner in the Epic Dialect to study with pleasure and
and, with this end in view, I have endeavored to point out and explain
profit
difBculties arising from the dialect, the meter, and the sj-ntax, and to call attention to the exact shades of meaning denoted by the various words employed by
;
EDUCATIONAL
Selections from Herodotus
TFOiZZ^S.(Continued.)
comprising mainly such Portions ae
give a Connected History of the East, to the Fall of Babylon and the
Death of Cyrus the Great.
By Herman M. Johnson, D. D., Professor of Philosophy
185 pages.
12mo.
The
By Herman M. Johnson,
D. D.
15 pages.
Paper.
for the
Use
12mo.
138 pages.
The
to
12mo.
Greek
Grammar.
or,
12mo.
208 pages.
Large 12mo.
620 pages.
Ollendorff.
in the University of
Rochester.
Arranged by John Augustus TittMANN, according to the best authorized Version. Completely revised,
Edited by Edward
American edition.
corrected, and annotated.
Robinson,
S. T.
D.
1 vol.,
12mo.
ED UCA TIONAL
irO^iT-S^. (Continued.)
I'imo.
Map.
Owen's Homer's
12mo.
Iliad.
Adapted
With a
beauti-
'759 pages.
Revised edition.
4-iO pages.
to Sophocles's, Kiihner's,
Owen's Thucydides.
276 pages.
12rao.
516 pages.
12mo.
12mo.
338 pages.
12mo.
683 pages.
5*73 pages.
Socrates.
12mo.
421
pages.
Smead's Antigone
of Sophocles.
242 pages.
12mo.
and
Critical
Tyler's Plato's
12mo.
Historical Introduc-
12mo.
12mo.
180 pages.
Ill pages.
HEBREW.
Gesenius's Hebrew Grammar.
rections
New
SYRIAC.
TJhlemann's Syriac Grammar.
German by
Enoch Hutchinson.
lator.
8vo.
D.
With a Course
367 pages.
APPLETON &
NEW
CO., Publishers,
YORK, BOSTON, CHICAGO, SAN FRANCISCO.
D.
APPLETON &
CO.'S
EDUCATIONAL WORKS
LATIN.
Professor Harkness's Series of Latin Text-Books.
An
as an Elementary Drill
the Language.
12mo
162 pages.
This work gives a distinct outline of the whole grammar, with exercises in
translation from each language into the other, suggestions to the learner, notes,
and vocabularies, and prepares the way to both the reading and the writing of
easy classic Latin.
Latin Grammar.
12mo.
Latin Grammar.
1881.
Edition of ISt*.
357 pages.
12mo.
Standard edition of
430 pages.
This is a complete, philosophical, and attractive work. It presents a systematic arrangement of the great facts and laws of the language, exhibiting not
only the grammatical forms and constructions, but also those vital principles
which underlie, control, and explain them.
The present edition is the result of a thorough and complete revision of that
of 1874. To a large extent It is a new and independent work yet the paradigms,
rules of construction, and in general all parts intended for recitation, have been
only slightly changed. The aim of the work in its present form is threefold 1.
To be a clear, simple, and convenient Elementary Latin Grammar, giving the
essentials for that use in distinctive type and in the form best adapted to the end.
2. To be an adequate and trustworthy Grammar for the advanced student a
complete Grammar of the Latin language, for the use of critical students of every
grade of scholarship. 3. To be a practical introduction to the broader fields of
philology and modern linguistic research, with references to the latest and best
authorities upon the numerous questions which arise in such study.
;
The Elements
of Latin
Grammar.
For Schools.
12mo.
156
pages.
A New
[bee
next page.]
ED UCA TIONAL
TTOiJZ'/S. (Continued.)
Large 12mo.
639 pages.
This work presents, in a single volame, a course of reading in the prose
authors sufficiently extended to meet the requirements "for admission to any
Commentaries," the
American college. It contains four books of Csesar's
"Catiline" of Salhist, and eight of Cicero's orations the four "In Catilinam,"
"Pro
Marcello," and "Pro
the "Pro Archia Poeta." "De Imperio Pompeii,"
Ligario." The editorial aids consist of notes, illustrations, special dictionary,
as
It
convenient
Gaul.
is
part of the shorter
especially
analyses, and a map of
course marked out above, inasmuch as it, the "Grammar," and the "New
in
the
course.
all
that
is
required
Header," only three books, provide
comprising an
in
Reading and
12mo.
Siglit.
will
title
with
Both editions contain numerous notes and suggestions, and an adequate LatinEnglish and English-Latin Dictionary.
versity of Michigan.
The Aeneid
Frieze.
of Vergil.
By Henry
of Vergil.
12mo.
S.
Dictionary.
By Henry
S.
Cloth.
[see
next PAGE.l
of Vergil,
598 pages.
With
Notes.
By Henry
S.
Friezk.
12mo.
Large type.
Books
First Six
Dictionary.
By Henry
S.
at
Frieze.
12mo.
A Vergilian
Dictionary.
By Henry
S.
Frieze.
12mo.
229 pages.
The
With Explanatory
Notes.
By Henry
S.
Frieze.
12rao.
175 pages.
M.
By John K. Lord,
12mo.
The
Ill pages.
In preparing the notes, the aim has been to furnish explanations on points of
grammar, history, biography, and ancient customs, and, particularly by translation and special remark, to indicate the diflferent and the corresponding idioms
of the Latin and the English, and thus, through idiomatic English, to assist to a
better understanding of the structure of the Latin.
Poems
of Ovid.
With
Brown
Notes.
By
University.
J.
L.
12mo.
238 pages.
This edition of Ovid was prepared at the request of many teachers of Latin
who regard the poetry of Ovid more suitable for the use of beginners than that
of Vergil, an opinion that governs the course pursued in the European schools
generally. The text is very carefully annotated, and references made to Harkness's Standard Grammar.
Some selections from the " Amores," the " Fasti," and the " Tristia," have
been added to those made from the "Metamorphoses," not only on account of
the interesting themes of which they treat, but also for the sake of giving the
student an opportunity of becoming acquainted with Latin elegiac verse, of
which, in Latin poetry, Ovid is the acknowledged master.
NEXT PAGE.]
ED U CA TIONAL
TF0i2A';S'. (Continued.)
With
12mo,
Lincoln's Horace.
12mo.
Colleges.
Lincoln's Livy.
and Literature
in
Brown
University.
12mo.
329 pages.
Sallust's
By
Colleges.
of
New
Cicero de
York.
12mo.
for the
459 pages.
Bonnell.
194 pages.
Beza's Latin
Caesar's
12mo.
Ofi&ciis.
Zumpt and
With Notes,
New
Testament.
Commentaries on
12mo.
the Gallic
War.
291 pages.
With English
Notes,
408 pages.
12mo.
385 pages.
D.
APPLET ON &
CO., Publishers,
SAN FRANCISCO.
0'-l^iyu-^i:t-^
^ ^~
With Notes,
etc.
12mo.
Herodotus.
Homer.
Iliad.
See Johnson, H. M.
Johnson, Henry C. Homer's Iliad. First Three Books. Note and References.
Revised edition.
Johnson, Herman M. Herodoti Orientalia Antiquiora.
1-^ino
Memorabilia
Odyssey.
cf
8vo.
Xenophon.
See Owkn.
(Edipus Tyrannus.
See Robbins.
See Crosbt, H.
With Lexicon.
12nio.
Standard
Owen, John
L,
l,^-_
With Notes,
Cyropsedia of Xenophon.
etc.
Eighth edition.
12010.
12mo.
oer,
With N
Demosthenes.
W.
.oduc-
D.
Plato's Apolo^
Plutan
Witli Notes.
WithNr
ito.
Hackett
Wicked.
liton,
See Owen.
S.
ler and
l/r'"
.t'
12mo.
iition.
See Cbosbt, H.
ucydides.
ler,
ai.'u >.i;>i
..ocles.
tions,
)liOCles.
Hadley,
Beginners,
Delay of
tl.
Three Months
.i..o.
Xendpnon.
lit'
James M.
jreek
First 1
Grammar. 12mo.
nchell, S. R. Lessons
the Beginner's
Companion
to
Had-
ley
See Boise,
nophon.
ii
Ow
)BBINS.
lAC.
lemann.
iNsoN.
Syrinc
Gramm
With a Course
elated
-es in Svriac
le
HEBREW.
Hebrew Grammar. Edited by Rod ..:... Translated from the
sijventeenth) German edition by Conant. With an Index, gvo.
Gesenius.
(the
APPLETON
V
"*'c,
.-
&
CO., Publish^--s,
UNIVERSITY
last
of
San Francisco.
CALIFORNIA
LOS ANGELES
LIBRARY
^1