23.11.

2014

Globes English - IEC to file NIS 4b suit against Siemens, partners

IEC to file NIS 4b suit against Siemens,

partners
02/10/2013, 19:52

Amiram Barkat

Siemens, Alstom, and ABB were part of the gas insulated switchgear cartel, which allegedly
fixed wins in 50 IEC projects.
Sources inform ''Globes'' that Israel Electric Corporation (IEC) (TASE: ELEC.B22) is preparing
to sue Siemens AG (NYSE: SI; DAX: SIE) and its partners in the gas insulated switchgear (GIS)
cartel for NIS 4 billion. The amount is more than double preliminary estimates by IEC, after
its meticulous checks found that the damage caused by the cartel was much greater than
initially thought.
IEC will file the suit against Germany's Siemens, France's Alstom SA (Euronext: ALO), and
Swiss-Swedish ABB Group AG (NYSE; OMX: ABB; SXZ: ABBN) in a few weeks, after the
amount of damage is finalized. Siemens, one of IEC's major suppliers, will be at the center
of the lawsuit, which will also name Alstom and ABB. IEC has not yet decided whether to
name the Japanese members of the GIS cartel, since the Antitrust Authority report on the
case does not mention them.
Legal experts told "Globes" that the respondents will argue that the statute of limitation
applies to the case. They note that only a few suits have been filed against the cartel's
members in Europe to date, possibly due to worries about countersuits or the success of
out-of-court settlements. The damage the cartel caused utilities in Europe and around the
world is estimated in the billions of euros.
The path to sue Siemens and its cartel partners opened in September, when Antitrust
Authority director general David Gilo declared that there was a cartel in electricity
infrastructures between 1988 and 2004. He ruled that this cartel, which was part of a global
Nasdaq Nov

S&P 500 Nov

TA Bluet Nov

TA25 Nov

USD/EUR Nov

NIS/EUR

21 23:06switchgear
20 17:31 affected
20 17:24
22 00:36
cartel22in03:02
gas insulated
the Israeli
market,22especially prices paid by IEC,

+0.24% 4712.97

+0.52% 2063.5

-0.45% 302.05

+0.1% 1453.26

+0.02% 1.239

-0.45% 4.7869

which were passed on to consumers. Gas insulated switchgear is a critical component in

protecting high and very high-voltage transmission lines from radical changes in voltage.
Gilo found that, between November 1988 and June 1999, the GIS cartel fixed wins in at least
50 projects in Israel, all of them for IEC. Gilo's ruling means that the parties affected by the
http://www.globes.co.il/en/article-1000882631

1/2

23.11.2014

Globes English - IEC to file NIS 4b suit against Siemens, partners

cartel can sue for damages in court on the basis of the ruling.
IEC today announced that an electricity consumer group has filed a NIS 2.7 billion lawsuit
against the utility and the GIS cartel with the Central District Court with a request to
recognize the suit as a class-action suit. Of the claim, IEC is being sued for NIS 412.5 million,
for rolling the overpricing by the cartel on to consumers.
Israel Business Conference 2014 Registration and details >>
Published by Globes [online], Israel business news - www.globes-online.com - on October 2, 2013
Copyright of Globes Publisher Itonut (1983) Ltd. 2013

http://www.globes.co.il/en/article-1000882631

2/2