Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
I.
NATURE; CREATION
A.
Kinds of Organizations:
(1)
Sole proprietorship has a business name;
only one individual
(2)
Partnership partnership name; separate
personality; 2 or more individuals
(3)
Corporation Corporate name; separate
personality; multiple owners (not limited to
individuals)
(4)
Trusts
(5)
Associations
Requisites of a Partnership:
(1)
Two or more persons bind themselves to
contribute money, property or industry to a
common fund (even if there is no actual
contribution as long as there is an agreement to
contribute).
(2)
Intention to divide the profits among
themselves (profits and losses)
Industry work, i.e., any activity of the human body; it
actually pertains to future industry
(a) time rendered
(b) idea
(c) service rendered
Features of a partnership: (Quiz)
(1)
Partnership name
(2)
Joint interest (Common fund)
(3)
Joint management and control
(4)
Mutual agency
(5)
Business for profit
Purpose: to engage in a commercial or business
transaction (there is the element of habituality)
Cause: The undertaking to contribute
Object: Must be lawful
- Unlawful objects: (1) Prohibited by law (RPC);
(2) Those not penal in nature but prohibited by law
B.
Creation
CODE OF COMMERCE
Title II: Joint Accounts
Art. 239. Merchants may interest themselves in the
transaction of other merchants, contributing thereto
the part of the capital they may agree upon, and
participating in the favorable or unfavorable results
thereof in the proportion they may determine.
Art. 240. In their formation, joint accounts shall not be
subject to any formality, and may be privately
contracted orally or in writing, and their existence may
be proved by any of the means recognized by law
(according to the provisions of Article 51).
Art. 241. In the transactions referred to by the two
preceding articles, no commercial name common to all
the participants can be adopted, nor can any further
direct credit be used than that of the merchant who
makes and directs them in his name and under his
individual responsibility.
Art. 242. Those who contract with the merchant who
carries on the business shall have a right of action
against him only and not against the others interested
D.
B.
E.
At Will
F.
G.
Commercial
H.
I.
By Estoppel/Apparent
Partner by Estoppel:
Person who:
As a partner in
existing partnership or
As a partner in
apparent partnership
To anyone
(b)
to
an
an
Partnership/Joint Obligor
Requires consent
Ortega vs. CA
The birth and life of a partnership at will is
predicated on the mutual desire and consent of the
partners.
Through the doctrine of delectus personae, all
the partners have the power, though not
necessarily the right, to dissolve the partnership.
Thus, any of the partners may dissolve the
partnership at will at his sole pleasure; but he
must do so in good faith or he will be liable for
damages.
Industrial
B.
C.
partner.
D.
By Estoppel
See previous discussion on kinds of
partnerships.
To Contribute; Warrant
risk
of
loss
is
B.
C.
D.
o
o
Liwanag vs. CA
Even when a contract of partnership has been entered
into, when money or property have been received by a
partner for a specific purpose and he later
misappropriated it, such partner is guilty of estafa.
US vs. Clarin
Pioneer Insurance v. CA
Quick Facts: Lim, owner-operator of Southern Air
Lines, purchased 2 aircrafts and set of spare parts
form Japan Domestic Airlines to be paid in
VI.
PARTNERS OBLIGATIONS TO
PERSONAL AND PARTNERSHIP
CREDITORS; THIRD PARTIES
A. To have his partnership interest charged for
personal debts (primary)
CHARGING ORDER
- attaches interest of the partner
1) Directs the partnership to pay any profits that
may be due to the judgment debtor, in favour of the
judgment creditor in satisfaction of his credit
(including interests)
2) May ask the court to appoint a receiver
- to collect money
3) may be sold at auction/foreclosure
remedy: right of redemption
a) with separate property
b) with partnership property
(requires the consent of all partners)
Best Choice?
No. 1 first since the payment will be ongoing
No. 2 comes second
No. 3 is a poor remedy, single payment; net effect: only
sell back to judgment debtor
partnership obligation
1) entered in the firm name, under its signature
2) by a person authorized (ex: employee)
2nd paragraph
discharged
1) agreement
- (3 parties: partner, creditor, and partnership)
2) no agreement
- knowledge of the creditor and continues to
transact with the partnership continuing the
business
pro rata
= proportional
- basis? in proportion to his SHARE in the PROFITS
NOT capital contribution
3rd paragraph
estate
pay personal debts before partnership debts
condition:
a) dead partner
b) no more partnership assets
MISAPPROPRIATION
SOLIDARY LIABILITY
PARTNERSHIP BY ESTOPPEL
liability
- liable as a partner: pro rata and subsidiary
ONLY WHEN it results in a partnership liability
There is partnership liability when all the partners
consent to the representation
allows to be represented as a partner to a nonpartner
liability joint, as if one of those liable
Corporation Code
Sec. 21. Corporation by estoppel. - All persons who
assume to act as a corporation knowing it to be
without authority to do so shall be liable as general
partners for all debts, liabilities and damages incurred
or arising as a result thereof: Provided, however, That
when any such ostensible corporation is sued on any
transaction entered by it as a corporation or on any
tort committed by it as such, it shall not be allowed to
use as a defense its lack of corporate personality.
One who assumes an obligation to an ostensible
corporation as such, cannot resist performance thereof
on the ground that there was in fact no corporation.
The fact that the other partner had left the country
CANNOT increase the liability of remaining partners.
extends to insolvent and dead partners
Pacific Commercial v. Aboitiz
*applied Compania doctrine
- distinguished loss from liability
- while A141 of the Code of Commerce provides that
industrial partners will not be liable for loss, A127
(which applies in this case) provides that ALL partners
are liable for for transactions in the name of the
partnership, albeit subsidiarily
Magdusa v. Albaran (in the quiz)
- demanded shares upon withdrawal from the
partnership, suit against capitalist, managing partner
only
- SC: partners share cannot be returned without first
dissolving and liquidating because of the preference for
partnership creditors AND the fact that the others
partners are indispensible parties to the suit
- since the liquidation document prepared by the
managing partner was not signed by the others, it does
not bind them
- moreover, the managing partner could not be held
personally liable since as such MP, he merely acts as a
trustee of the partnership
Island Sales v. United
- the case was dismissed, upon motion of the plaintiff,
in favour of one of the 5 general partners
- SC: clarified pro rata liability remained at 1/5;
condonation of one did not unmake him as a general
partner to effect an increase in the shares of the other
partners
Munasque v. CA
- misunderstanding between the partners
- SC: third party had the right to presume the
authority of the partner when the contract was entered
into in the name of the partnership authority
- since the payments were misappropriated, Art. 1823
would apply on solidarity of liability
Lim Tong Lim v. Philippine Fishing Gear, Inc.
- fact of partnership: common funds, purpose of
business, sold boat for partners debt, sharing of
profits
- SC: corporation by estoppels applies against third
persons who benefitted (partner); therefore, liable as a
general partner despite not being named in the
contract
Bachrach v. La Protectora
- partnership common carrier
- Barba: president and partner
TC: Partnership and all partners liable solidarily
VII.
RIGHTS OF A PARTNER
D. Property rights
Art. 1810. The property rights of a partner are:
(1) His rights in specific partnership property;
(2) His interest in the partnership; and
(3) His right to participate in the management. (n)
1.
2.
assignors share of
partnership assets.
the
residue,
if
any,
of