Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
E. PERSSON,
M. GRUFMAN
and U. THEMNER
mentally
retarded
children
are scanty. Rutter et a!
(1970) performed
a comprehensive
study on the Isle
of Wight in the l960s and found the prevalence
of
Epidemiological
studies of psychiatric
disorders
of
3.3 to
2.0 standard deviation (SD) from the mean
of 100 (SD= 15), i.e. as an IQ of 5070.The Wechsler
Intelligence Scale for Children or the TermanMerrill test
20 years
It is now
out in a typically
(a) psychoticbehaviour(Gillberg,1983),including
cases with: (i) infantile autism (DSM-III, 1980), (ii)
from
urban
areas
where
psychiatric
dis
(Wing, 1981)
disorder
and adolescents;
psychiatric
prevalence
in mentally
in individual
children;
children
the association
between
psychiatric
impairments
to analyse
disorders
of epilepsy
and
Method
with
(g)
the
World
Health
as defined
by Spitzer
et al
stealing,
firesetting,
or
Definition of terms
In accordance
syndrome,
kind of
depressive
(1975)
(c) conduct disorder in cases showing socially unaccept
figures for
retarded
disorder
(b)
Organisation
different settings)
other psychiatric disorder in cases which could not
be included under any of the foregoing headings.
PSYCHIATRIC
69
TABLEI
Description of the mentally retarded series in the psychiatric
follow-up study
SMRMMRNumber
original7391epidemiologicalstudyPrevalence
in
(%)0.300.37Dead
follow-up40Moved
at
to14another
epilepsy'
or who had had at least one seizure in the 12
study were diagnosed
as
Population Investigated
regionRefused
to24participateTotal
rate38at
attrition
psychiatricfollow-up(dead
respectively.
excluded)(%)Number
The prevalence
in6683psychiatricfollow-up
studyBoy:girl
to
services
for
handicapped
children,
since
20%
ratio38:28
(1.9:1)Age
range13171317Epilepsy:
(1.4:1)54:29
brackets)18(27)8(10)Down's
n (% in
syndrome: n (% in brackets)18(27)2(2)
TABLE
II
Psychiatric
disorders
have been
Disordern(%)%
ratiosyndromeSo
with
epilepsy%
retardedthat
severely
ofpsychiatric
rating
statewasnotpossible71157291.3:1No
disorder17260530.9:1Depressive
psychiatric
syndromeI1.510000:1Emotional
disorder34.50670.5:1Conduct
disorder34.5002:1Psychosomatic
disorder230502:0Psychotic
behaviour335039122:1Schizophrenia11.5001:0Infantile
autism5860204:1Triad
languageand
of
impairment182733Il2.6:1Severe
social
socialimpairment91444111.3:1Total
psychiatricdisorders426433171.6:1
with
retardation
with
Down'sBoy:girl
70
GILLBERG ETAL
Psychiatric
TABLE III
in cases with mild mental
disorders
Disorder
n(%)
retardation
% with
% with
epilepsy
Down's
Boy:girl
ratio
syndrome
No psychiatric
disorder
10 12
Psychosomatic disorder
Hyperactive disorder
Psychotic behaviour
9 11
12 14
Schizophrenia
Infantile autism
Triad of language
and social impairment
Severe social
impairment
Asperger's syndrome
Other disorders
Total with psychiatric
disorder
Psychiatric
36 43
Depressive syndrome
Emotional disorder
Conduct disorder
diagnostic
34
8 10
1.1:1
0
0
0
3:0
1.7:1
1.5:4
13
0
0
0.5:1
0
0
0
34
22
17
0
0
3.5:1
5:1
1:0
2:1
56
40
4:1
22
22
0
0
0
2:0
11
4757
11
2.9:1
34
11
assessment
1:0
2:0
handicapped,
and hencetheir
behavioural
repertoire
so
limited, that it was impossible to make a psychiatric
classification. Only about one quarter of the SMR children
were considered clearly psychiatrically normal. Altogether,
factors, developmental
milestones, siblings' and parents'
health, hereditary factors, important somatic disorders,
and treatment given by other doctors. The child was
plus psychotic
behaviour'
were used.
was
Results
Children with severe mental retardation
The results for this group are summarised in Table II. About
one in ten of the SMR children were so severely mentally
PSYCHIATRIC
71
disturbances of sexual behaviour) were referred to the otherboth severely and mildly mentally retarded children.
disorder' category.Slightlylessthan half the childrenwere The results, therefore, must be considered to be of
particular interest. In the Isle ofWigbt study (Rutter
Psychotic behaviour, conduct disorder, hyperactive et a!, 1970) 50% of the severelymentally retarded
judged psychiatricallynormal'.
of psychotic
behaviour'
plus MMR
in
of the children,
while a further
13%
disorders
in severely mentally
Epilepsy
according
psychotic behaviour.
to
who attended
In the MMR group 10% sufferedfrom epilepsy.There out-patient clinic for the mentally retarded. She
were no clear-cut differences between psychiatrically concluded that it was quite feasible to diagnose
normal and abnormal children in respect of epilepsy in
this group. However, hyperactive
disorders
and psychotic
psychiatric
disorder
in mentally
retarded
children
psychiatric handi
Down's syndrome
implications.
with psychiatric
abnormality' (P<0.02). however, it is
worth noting that one of the Down's
syndrome
children
There was a marked preponderanceof boys in the MMR et al. (1981a, 1981b), who carried out the earlier
group (1.9:1),but in the SMR group the differencewasless study of mental retardation, argued that the sample
marked (1.4:1). Boy:girl ratios were close to population
is indeed representative. Certainly the reported pre
ratios in the groups of psychiatricallynormal mentally valence of 0.3% SMR in our study is similar to rates
retarded children
marked contrast,
Discussion
This is possibly the first-ever systematic study of
psychiatric disorders in a population-basedseries
of
72
GILLBERG ETAL
and
the frequent association with epilepsy indicate
that brain dysfunction (malfunction rather than loss
of function (Corbett,
problems
indicating
the combination
to cause
child psychiatric
team.
PSYCHIATRIC
73
dis
be considerable
psychiatric
disturbance
in the nature
of these
differences
se, as measured
by registration
at child
per
and youth
Acknowledgement
References
AMERICAN
PSYCHIATRIC
ASSOCIATION
(1980)
DSM-JJI.
Diagnostic
and
Statistical
Manual
of Mental
Disorders,
3rd
Ed.
Washington
DC:
APA.
CORBETr,
Epilepsy.
In Mental
Retardation
and Developmental
Disabilities:
(ed. J. Wortis),
VII,
74
GILLBERG ET AL
epidemiological
(1983)
considerations.
Perceptual,
motor
and
deficits
in
Swedish
psychoses
primary
Some
in a Swedish urban
child
psychiatric
aspects.
region. Epidemiological
G(X)DMAN, N. & TIZARD, J. (1962) Prevalence of imbecility and idiocy among children. British Medicaliournal,
GUSTAVSON, Kfl, HAGBERG, B., HAGBERG, G. & SARS, K. (1977) Severe mental
retardation
in a Swedish
gestational
age, birth weight and associated CNS handicaps in children born 19591970.Acta Paediatrica
urban
children.
Some
4, 207218.
school-children.
Tidskr@ft, 7, 401408
Mild
mental
retardation
Journal
of
aspects. Journal
Child
of Child
216219.
county.
I. Epidemiology,
in Swedish children.
I. Prevalence.
Acta
in Swedish school children. II. Etiologic and pathologic aspects. Acta Paediatrica
W. (1970)
A neuropsychiatric
study
in childhood.
Clinics
in Developmental
Medicine.
London:
SIMP
SHAFFER,
TIZARD,
D.
J.
&
&
SHEPHERD,
M.(1975)A
WHITMORE,
K.
(eds.)
Multiaxial
Evaluating,
Class@ficationof
Health
and
ChildPsychiatric
Behaviour.
criteria. In Predictability
in Psychopharmacology:
London:
Disorders.
Oxford:
Blackwell
Scientific
Publications.
Longmans.
in children:
epidemiology
and classifi
Christopher
Gillberg, MD, Professor of Child and Youth Psychiatry and Handicap Research
MD,
UllaThemnr,
Nurse,
Department of Child and Youth Psychiatry.
Correspondence.
(Accepted 7 May 1985)
References
Reprints/
permissions
You can respond
to this article at
Downloaded
from
This article cites 0 articles, 0 of which you can access for free at:
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/content/149/1/68#BIBL
To obtain reprints or permission to reproduce material from this paper, please write
to permissions@rcpsych.ac.uk
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/letters/submit/bjprcpsych;149/1/68
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/ on December 23, 2014
Published by The Royal College of Psychiatrists