Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
-A MYTH OR REALITY?
Abstract: Derivatives are powerful risk management tools. The advent of modern day derivative
contracts is attributed to the need for farmers to protect themselves from any decline in the price
of their crops due to delayed monsoon or overproduction. This paper analyses the history of
world derivative and evolution of Indian derivative market and its impact and contribution to the
The current study is also trying to find out the similarities and dissimilarities between the Indian
derivative market and the derivative market of the developed countries. It also shows how
different is Indian derivative market and its need .In last ten years the rate of growth of Indian
derivative market is higher than many other countries. The possible trends of derivative market
in near future and possible changes that could be incorporated is also being studied.
It is a topic of research why during recession of 2008 Indian market was somewhat stable
compared to the market of major developed countries. The study involves the in-depth analysis
on the relation- ship between risk and return involved with the use of derivatives (Malik,2008).
Is it because the Indian derivative market is at nascent stage or the SEBI laws help in less
1
1. ESSENCE AND HISTORY OF DERIVATIVE MARKET
prices. The origin of derivatives can be traced back to the need of farmers to protect themselves
against fluctuations in the price of crop. From the time it was sown to the time it was ready for
Forward delivery contracts that states what is to be delivered for a fixed price at a specified place
on a specified date, existed in ancient Greece and Rome. Roman emperors entered forward
contracts to provide the masses with their supply of Egyptian grain. These contracts were also
undertaken between farmers and merchants to eliminate risk arising out of uncertain future prices
of grains. Thus, forward contracts have existed for centuries for hedging price risk. The first
organized commodity exchange came into existence in the early 1700’s in Japan. The first
formal commodities exchange, the Chicago Board of Trade (CBOT), was formed in 1848 in the
US to deal with the problem of ‘credit risk’ and to provide centralized location to negotiate
forward contracts. From ‘forward’ trading in commodities emerged the commodity ‘futures’.
The first type of futures contract was called ‘to arrive at’. Trading in futures began on the CBOT
in the 1860’s. In 1865, CBOT listed the first ‘exchange traded’ derivatives contract, known as
the futures contracts. Futures trading grew out of the need for hedging the price risk involved in
many commercial operations. The first financial futures to emerge were the currency in 1972 in
the US. The first foreign currency futures were traded on May 16, 1972, on International
Monetary Market (IMM). Currency futures were followed soon by interest rate futures. Interest
rate futures contracts were traded for the first time on the CBOT on October 20, 1975. Stock
2
index futures and options emerged in 1982. The first stock index futures contracts were traded on
The first call and put options were invented by an American financier, Russell Sage, in 1872.
These options were traded over the counter. Agricultural commodities options were traded in the
nineteenth century in England and the US. Options on shares were available in the US on the
over the counter (OTC) market only until 1973 without much knowledge of valuation. A group
of firms known as Put and Call brokers and Dealer’s Association was set up in early 1900’s to
provide a mechanism for bringing buyers and sellers together. On April 26, 1973, the Chicago
Board options Exchange (CBOE) was set up at CBOT for the purpose of trading stock options. It
was in 1973 again that black, Merton, and Scholes invented the famous Black-Scholes Option
Formula. This model helped in assessing the fair price of an option which led to an increased
interest in trading of options. With the options markets becoming increasingly popular, the
American Stock Exchange (AMEX) and the Philadelphia Stock Exchange (PHLX) began trading
in options in 1975. The market for futures and options grew at a rapid pace in the eighties and
nineties. The collapse of the Bretton Woods regime of fixed parties and the introduction of
floating rates for currencies in the international financial markets paved the way for development
of a number of financial derivatives which served as effective risk management tools to cope
with market uncertainties. The CBOE is the largest exchange for trading stock options. The
CBOE trades options on the S&P 100 and the S&P 500 stock indices. The most traded stock
indices include S&P 500, the Dow Jones Industrial Average, the Nasdaq 100, and the Nikkei
225. The US indices and the Nikkei 225 trade almost round the clock.
Today, derivatives have become part and parcel of the day-to-day life for ordinary people in
major parts of the world. In the past two decades, there is spectacular growth of the derivatives
3
products in worldwide financial market. In 1996, the notional value of all derivatives traded in
domestic and international markets were approximately US$ 20 trillion (Jalilvand and Switzer,
2000).While this is true for many countries; there are still apprehensions about the introduction
of derivatives. In recent years, the market for financial derivatives has grown tremendously both
With over 25 million shareholders, India has the third largest investor base in the world after
USA and Japan. The Indian capital market is significant in terms of the degree of development,
Over 7500 companies are listed on the Indian stock exchanges more than the number of
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
Recent surveys provide useful information on risk management practices and policies of U.S>,
Canadian and European corporations. Bondar, Hayt, Marston, and Smithson(1995), Downie,
McMillan, and Nosal (1995) and Bodnar, Hayt and Marston (1996) examined the use of
Derivatives by U.S. and Canadian non-financial firms. A clear finding of these surveys is that
larger companies make greater use of derivatives than smaller ones. Dolde (1993) conducted a
survey of Fortune 500 companies. He also documents that respondents take speculative positions
This paper provides detailed information on derivatives market in India and its stable structure. It
also focus on the investment strategy on Indian investors in the time of recession.
4
3. GROWTH AND STRUCTURE OF DERIVATIVE MARKET IN INDIA
The first step towards introduction of derivatives trading in India was with Securities Laws
(Amendment) Ordinance, 1995, which withdrew the prohibition on options in securities. The
market for derivatives, however, did not take off, as there was no regulatory framework to
govern trading of derivatives. SEBI set up a 24–member committee under the Chairmanship of
derivatives trading in India. The committee submitted its report on March 17, 1998 prescribing
applicable to trading of ‘securities’ could also govern trading of securities. SEBI also set up a
group in June 1998 under the Chairmanship of Prof.J.R.Varma, to recommend measures for risk
containment in derivatives market in India. The report, which was submitted in October 1998,
worked out the operational details of margining system, methodology for charging initial
margins, broker net worth, deposit requirement and real–time monitoring requirements.
The Securities Contract Regulation Act (SCRA) was amended in December 1999 to include
derivatives within the scope of ‘securities’ and the regulatory framework were developed for
The Forwards Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1952, regulates the forward/futures contracts in
commodities all over India. As per this the Forward Markets Commission (FMC) continues to
have jurisdiction over commodity futures contracts. However when derivatives trading in
securities was introduced in 2001, the term “security” in the Securities Contracts (Regulation)
5
Act, 1956 (SCRA), was amended to include derivative contracts in securities. Consequently,
regulation of derivatives came under the purview of Securities Exchange Board of India (SEBI).
We thus have separate regulatory authorities for securities and commodity derivative markets.
Derivatives are securities under the SCRA and hence the trading of derivatives is governed by
the regulatory framework under the SCRA. The act also made it clear that derivatives shall be
legal and valid only if such contracts are traded on a recognized stock exchange, thus there is no
OTC derivatives. The government also rescinded the three decade old notification, which
prohibited forward trading in securities in March 2000. Derivatives trading commenced in India
in June 2000 after SEBI granted the final approval to this effect in May 2001. SEBI permitted the
derivative segments of two stock exchanges NSE and BSE, and their clearing house/corporation
to commence trading and settlement in approved derivatives contracts. To begin with, SEBI
approved trading in index futures contracts based on S&P CNX Nifty and BSE–30 (Sensex)
index. This was followed by approval for trading in options based on these two indexes and
The Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956 defines “derivative” to include- A security
derived from a debt instrument, share, loan whether secured or unsecured, risk instrument or
14 December 1995 NSE asked SEBI for permission to trade index futures.
6
18 November 1996 SEBI setup L.C.Gupta Committee to draft a policy
7 July 1999 RBI gave permission for OTC forward rate agreements
24 May 2000 SIMEX chose Nifty for trading futures and options on an
Indian index.
futures trading
25 September
The Total Turnover of Indian Financial Markets crossed US$ 2256 billion in 2006 with an
increase of 82% from US $ 1237 billion in 2004 in a short span of 2 years only. Turnover in the
Spot and Derivatives segment both in NSE & BSE was higher by 45% into 2006 as compared to
2005. With daily average volume of US $ 9.4 billion, the Sensex has posted excellent returns in
the recent years. Foreign Institutional Investors (FII) held stock assets valued close to Rs 2
trillion as of November ‘08. There were 1,113 registered FIIs as of October '07. Currently the
market cap of the Sensex as on July 4th, 2009 was Rs 48.4 lakh Crore with a P/E of more than
20.
7
Following figure shows the structure of derivative market in India
Derivatives Market
Derivative Exchange
The first trade in derivative was the culmination of legislative and legal effort which had begun
as early as 1995. Thus the entire system of existing securities regulations including anti-fraud
and various disclosure obligations have become part of regulations of derivative in India. This is
The following figures shows the Indian trading system with Exchange at the top ,governed by
three governing bodies i.e. Governing council, Governing board, Clearing council. It is further
assisted by Clearing House, Clearing Bank, Clearing Member, Trading Member, and the client.
There is also Trade Guarantee Fund and Investor Protection Fund as a part of risk reduction
scheme.
8
The Stock Exchange
Clearing Member
Trade Guarantee Fund
Trading Member
4. DATA
The data that is analyzed is taken from the official website of NSE India and SEBI. It is year
wise data of the number of contracts as well as the turnover of Future and Option trading in
terms of Index and individual stocks.It also analyse the growth of total transaction and total
turnover in the derivative market since its inception in India. During July-September 2008-09,
the turnover at BSE was Rs.1,510 crore, which was insignifi- cant as compared to that of NSE at
Rs. 3,315,491 crore. Moreover NSE constitutes the major part of turnover than BSE . Therefore
we will analyse the NSE derivative market trend assuming that the BSE have followed more or
9
less the same trend. In the data analysed it is to be noted that during 2000-01 there was only
Index Future trading available and the data of 2009-10 is not yet completed .
(a) Future
Year No. of contracts Turnover (Rs. Cr.) No. of contracts Turnover (Rs. Cr.)
Source www.nse-india.com
From the data it is clear that there is high business growth in the derivative segment in India. In
the year 2000-01, the number of contracts in Index Future was 90580 where as a significant
increase to 210428103 is observed in the year 2008-09 which is nearly 35% more than 2007-08.
10
Moreover in the year 2001-02 the turnover of index future was 21483 where as a huge increase
Moreover there were no stock futures available in the year 2000-01. There was a steady increase
in the turnover of stock future with 51515cr. in the year 2001-02. Again in the year there was a
huge increase to 7548563.23cr.of turnover in the year 2007-08 with a considerable decline of
3479642.12 in the year 2008-09.So the Stock future was the major upset during the time of
recession proving that stock future are more volatile and investor takes less risk during recession.
(b) Option
Year No. of contracts Turnover (Rs. Cr.) No. of contracts Turnover (Rs. Cr.)
Source www.nse-india.com
There was only 1,75,900 transactions in the year 2001-2002. In the year 2007-2008 there was a
huge increase in the index option contracts to 5,53,66,038 and in the recession time of 2008-09 it
increased nearly four time to 21,20,88,444. In terms of turnover it slowly started increasing in
11
the year 2000-2001 to 3765cr and in the year 2007-2008 there was a huge increase of
1362110.088 and shot up in 2008-09 to 3731501.84cr showing increase of about three times.
So the major target for investment during the recession was Index Option because of less risk
or a fixed risk of premium amount only. Therefore Index Option helped a lot of investment
inflow.
Moreover the stock option turnover in the year 2000-2001 was nil. There was a slow increase of
25163 in the year 2001-2002. But a phenomenal increase of 359136.55 in the year 2007-2008,
and a decline of 229226.81 in the year 2008-2009.Again showing that during downturn of
market investor prefer Index rather than the individual stock as the investment in index
distribute the risk in the different sectors of market making it more stable.
(c) Total
Source www.nse-india.com
12
From the data ,the overall trading contracts in the year 2000-2001 was 90580 and huge increase
of 657390497 in the year 2008-2009. and the overall trading turnover in the year 2000-2001 was
as low as 2365 but a predominant increase of 11010482.20 observed in the year 2008-2009.
Derivative market is growing very fast in the Indian Economy. The turnover of this Market is
increasing year by year in the India’s largest stock exchange NSE. In the case of index future
there is a phenomenal increase in the number of contracts. But the turnover has declined
considerably. In the case of stock future there was a slow increase observed in the number of
contracts whereas a decline was also observed in its turnover. In the case of index option there
was a huge increase observed both in the number of contracts and turnover. Earlier only
Institutional investors were attracted towards Index based derivatives but in the recession time
the common investors also realized the power and stability of index over the stocks.
Table : List of the most actively traded futures and options contracts worldwide ranked by
13
7 S&P CNX Nifty Futures, NSE India 202,390,223 138,794,235 45.80
Source www.nse-india.com
6. RECESSION- 2008
The Global recession of 2008 was marked by Lehman Brothers filing bankrupt on 15th
September ’08 .followed by AIG seeking bailout and distress sale of Merrill Lynch.
The possible reason for fallout are that small banks lent money to borrowers with dubious record
(mostly housing loan) banks repackaged these loans as tradable securities (derivative) and sold to
speculative financial offerings. When borrowers defaulted, market for such securities collapsed
Lehman also directly invested in realties that also collapsed. Worried about angry voters in an
election year Govt. refused to use public fund to absorb part of Lehman’s losses. Lehman filed
for bankruptcy - the biggest bankruptcy filing with a debt of $630 billion.
Warren Buffet called Derivative as Financial Weapons of Mass Destruction, but in India strong
rules and regulations made for investment in derivative helped it to stand strong even in this
storm of Global Recession. The extent of impact has been restricted due to several reasons such
as- Indian financial sector particularly our banks have no direct exposure to tainted assets and its
14
off-balance sheet activities have been limited. The credit derivatives market is in an embryonic
stage and there are restrictions on investments by residents in such products issued abroad.
India’s growth process has been largely domestic demand driven and its reliance on foreign
savings has remained around 1.5 per cent in recent period. India’s comfortable foreign exchange
reserves provide confidence in our ability to manage our balance of payments not withstanding
lower export demand and dampened capital flows. Rural demand continues to be robust due to
mandated agricultural lending and social safety-net programs. India’s merchandise exports are
During this recession as well Indian derivative market was showing potential. This is clear with
the following data and analysis made by SEBI during JULY-SEPTEMBER 2008-09 quarter.
Table 1: Status report of the developments in the derivative market at the time of ‘08recession
(Source: SEBI)
15
From the above table major observations are that the number of contracts increased by 42.06%
to 1,698.7 lakh while turnover increased by 24.77% to Rs. 3,317 thousand crore in July-
September 2008-09 over April-June 2008-09. Futures (Index Future + Stock Future) constituted
67.20% of the total number of contracts traded in the F&O Segment. Stock Future and Index
Future accounted for 35.26% and 31.94% respectively. Options constituted 32.80% of the total
(Source : SEBI)
During the month of October 2008, at NSE 2,275,261 contracts, at BSE 161,502 contracts and at
MCX-SX 1,119,968 contracts were traded in the currency futures segment .Total turnover during
October 2008, at NSE was Rs. 11,142 crore at BSE Rs.765 crore and at MCX-SX was Rs.5,521
crore, in the currency futures segment. Open interest at the end of October 2008, in terms of
number of contracts was 170,202 for NSE, 10,546 for BSE and 60,055 for MCX-SX.
The number of contracts and open interest in the derivatives market has increased even when the
underlying market is witnessing a downward trend. This indicates that there are sufficient long
16
position holders who anticipate value proposition in a falling market. Falling or rising markets on
the back of low volumes may be a cause of concern from the point of market integrity. However,
as observed from the data, under the present scenario the fall in the market has been
In Index Option, there is a sharp increase in turnover (97.95%) and volume (117.08%) during
July-September 2008-09 over April-June 2008-09. Possible reasons for increase in options
trading activity can be attributed to increase in volatility. Market observers believe that
conditions across markets and asset classes have become more volatile and uncertain in the
recent past. Generally in such conditions, many people believe that options act as "insurance"
against adverse price movements while offering the flexibility to benefit from possible favorable
price movements at the same time. Another reason which can be attributed to the increase in
activity is the new directive as per the Budget 2008- 09 which states that STT (Securities
Transaction Tax) would now be levied on the Option premium instead of the strike price.
In Index Future, both turnover (15.17%) and volume (30.53%) have increased during July-
in Single Stock Futures during July- September 2008-09 as compared to April-June 2008-09.
(Source: www.sebi.gov.in)
After study it is clear that Derivative influence our Indian Economy to much extent. So, SEBI
should take necessary steps for improvement in Derivative Market so that more investors can
17
invest in Derivative market. It encourages entrepreneurship in India. There is a need of more
innovation in Derivative Market because in today scenario even educated people also fear for
derivatives have a crucial role to play in the price risk management process for the commodities
India, as the commodity market mainly involves agricultural product. The commodity
derivatives have been utilized in a very limited scale. Only forwards and futures trading are
permitted in certain commodity items. Other Factors that need improvement are mainly that RBI
should play a greater role in supporting derivatives and Derivatives market should be developed
in order to keep it at par with other derivative markets in the world. There must be more
derivative instruments aimed at individual investors. As in India most people do not believe in
high risk but they go for calculated risk so more diverse investment technique should be evolved
8. CONCLUSION
From the data analysis made above, it is clear that the Financial Derivative is really a potential
investment as in India since its inception the investment in derivative market has been
increasing. Financial derivative increases the no. of options for investment. In fact it should have
been introduced much before and NSE had approved it but was not active because of
politicization in SEBI. India is certainly more integrated into the world economy than ten years
ago. Even at the time of Global recession the market was more or less stable but there was
decrease in the investment made by Foreign Institutional Investor. The introduction in new
18
products has seen more of changes in micro regulations like provide margin money to start
investment. So it can be concluded that financial derivative market in India is not only stable
compared to other markets across globe but also it is at the stage of growth and because of the
regulations made by Indian laws on this market based on the recommendations made by different
committees there is a constant watch over the investment. India managed to progress as far as not
just technology but also regulations. But as we all know from economical demand that things
what goes up, that will come down with time , this may be the beginning so the market is going
up but to maintain at that level regular measures should be taken or else it may be also seen a
downfall after reaching the peak as what happened to Global market . In May 2008, German
leaders have planned to propose a worldwide ban on oil trading by speculators, blaming the 2008
oil price rises on manipulation by hedge fund. Therefore Indian law should also regularly check
19
9. REFERENCES
Gupta,S. L.(2006). Financial Derivative. New Delhi: Prentice- Hall of India Pvt. Ltd.
Kaur, P. (2000), “Financial Derivatives: Potential of Derivative market in India and emerging
Jalilvand, A., Switzer, J. and Tang, C. (2000), “A Global Perspective on the Use of Derivatives
Reddy, Y. V., & Sebastin A. (2008), “Interaction Between Equity and Derivatives Markets in
India: An Entropy Approach”, The Icfai Journal of Derivatives Markets, 5(1): 18-32
Bodla, B.S. and Jindal, K. (2008). “Equity Derivatives in India: Growth Pattern and Trading
Hull, J.C. (2008). Options,Futures and Other Derivatives. New Delhi: PHI Learning Pvt. Ltd.
http://www.sebi.gov.in/boardmeetings/derivatives.pdf
http://www.nse-india.com/content/fo/fo_businessgrowth.htm
20
21