Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
021616
REC'D
UNSOLICITED
AUG 2 0 1990
1
SPE
PUBLICATIONS
v. 2.0
by
august 1990
1)
SPE 2161 6
Global
estimates of oil reserves are very much in line with the estimates provide by
the company. Moreover, global precision estimates obtained by kriging for in-
situ reserves show that the qualifier "proven" used to describe the cannopolis
reserves
IN1'.RODUCTION
SP.E 2161 6
3
oil reserve estimation and a definition of the top-of-reservoir height are two
i.J:rportant elements in the assessment of a reservoir. Examples of other i.J:rportant
parameters are block penneability, internal pressure and oil viscosity (Jones,
1984).
Among the available methods for oil reserve estimation (Davis, 1988),
SP.E 2161 5
for decades in the mining irrlustty and now in many other areas of human activity,
can therefore be used in this context to advantage.
In this paper, geostatistical techniques are used. to obtain an estimate
in production
zone CPS 2 of the CCum:>polis oil field, Sergipe-Alagoas basin, Brazil. Also,
local estimation of the height of top of reservoir is perfonned. Prior geological
infornation such as known reservoir limits and faults is explicitly taken into
account in the estimation process. A corrparison with the oil reserve estimates
obtained by the company (Petrobras) geologists and engineers is provided.
Possible advantages of using geostatistics are discussed.
in 1963, more than one thousand production or injection wells have been drilled
over a total surface area in the order of 75 km2
in the
precambrian basement and the other defined by Jurassic sandstones and IDwer
cretaceous sandstones and conglomerates (candido, 1984).
Up to 1969, the oil recuperation process relied on the natural internal
pressure of the reservoir. since then, fluid injection projects have been set
up in order to maintain pressure
physical characteristics of the oil (oil gravities between 18 and 28 API degrees
and viscosities between 30 and 80 centipoise) and extremely high penneability
SPE 216 t
6'
5
PRODUCTION ZONES
various subdivisions of the canoopolis field have been proposed over the
years. '!he subdivision used by the company was proposed by Baungarten in 1980
(carrlido, 1984). According to Baungarten, the IDwer Cretaceous reservoirs should
:be subdivided into six production zones (CPS lA,lB,2,3A,3B and 4), each separated
by more or less laterally continuous shales. The CPS 2 zone is studied in this
paper. '!his 34.6 knt zone includes 747 wells fully or partially saturated with
oil. Of these 747 wells, 529 were the object of well-logging interpretation to
obtain measures for porosity, net pay and water saturation (Figure 2). 'Ihe
spacing :between wells varies from 100m, where assisted recuperation projects
have been installed, to 200m elsewhere (Figure 2).
seE
2161 6
(1)
with
A
htt y (x)
= hex) <$lex)
(1~
(x
(2)
where
h
<$l
Sw
planimeter.
am practical
am
Huijbreghts, 1978).
sketched.
Geostatistics adopt a stochastic view of a deposit. '!he particular
RE 21616
(am
observations.
Once the variogram is knovm (in practice, an experilnental variogram is
calculated
am
any
'!he basic
the estimation
am most
iIrportant step in
am modelization of the
any geostatistical
study is therefore
(the variogram under the secom order stationarity assunption, the generaliZed
"RE 21616
8
less erratic
am
easier to IOOde1led.
sh~
sh~
obtained with pairs crossing known faults removed. '!he variograms are sinri.lari
both are well adjusted by an isotropic spherical IOOdeI with a small nugget effect
(Journel
am
am
across
"1
(h) = 0.01
nf+
)]
(3)
where
a is 700 m
am
0=0.4
a is 750 m
am
0=0.49
nf
nf
(Figure 4)
(Figure 5)
am 5.
cross-validation kriging
(Table 1) by removal of sample points one at a time gave starrlardized errors with
mean
am
values of 0 and 1 (although their variance obtained when faults are taken into
account is slightly too low). It can be observed that limitation of the kriging
neighbo:rhood by faults decreases the quality of the estimation as irrlicated by
bigger mean absolute
am
into account reduces the number of points in the neighbortlood used for kriging
which results in less precise estimation. '!hus, for oil thickness, taking faults
(Jot1n1el arrl
SPE 2161 5
10
the necessity of taking into account correlation between kriging errors with
the local approach. An approximate solution is, hOW'ever, easily obtainable by
the method
of composition
of
(Journel
arrl
Here, we dealt with 529 wells spread ItDre or less unifonnly over a 34.6
millions m2 area. Making the assumption that these samples can be considered as
the product of a ramam stratified sampling plan, an area of 65.4 thousarrl
(a square with sides 256 m)
ref
We find
rf (.IV)
= 0.12 m
'Ihus
if t hie k n e s s ~ 0.12/529
arrl
O'volume
= 0.0002 m
m3
Although not necessa1Y here where reseJ:Ves are very precisely k:r1OW'n, the
use of kriging (estimation) error standard deviation as a basis for defining
proven, probable arrl possible reseJ:Ves has been advocated in same instances
(Sabourin, 1984) for the mining i.n:lustry arrl could also be envisaged for the
petroleum i.n:lustry.
RE 21616
11
advance and was considered known. If this were not the case, an additionnal
error term associated with the surface estilnation should be included. Here this
term would be negligible due to the dense grid of wells.
TOP-OF-RESERVOIR FSl'IMM'IClN
A similar procedure
reservoir.
All the available data (747 wells) were used. Figures 7 and 8 show
the directional variograms with all pairs (Figure 7) and with pairs not crossing
faults (Figure 8). variograms obtained when faults are taken into ac:::x::ount (Figure
8)
present better continuity with a sill less than half the one obtained
i.
where
a,. is
960 m if r=N80W
650 m if r=NIOE
SEE 2161 6
12
ii.
where
430 m if 1"=NI0E
system.
geologists '
SP.E 2161 6
13
am
am
11.
The adopted lOlNer variogram when faults are taken into account gave
theoretical kriging standard deviations reduced by a factor of 1.5.
'!Wo ilrportant variables used in reservoir evaluation are the in-situ oil
reserves
am
in the personnel)
one
am
subjectivity.
should not forget that these estilnates serve essentially as input for
am
to match historical
am his model
am
RE 21616
14
observed
on
our variograms
correspond
to
the
direction
of
paleochannels described by the geologists. Also, the fact that only top-ofreservoir height variograms and. estinlation were affected by faults indicates that
the relative movement of the faulted blocks has been essentially vertical,
othe:rwise thickness variograms and. estinlation would have also been affected.
At canropolis, good agreement was found to exist between the resmves as
documented by the company and. those obtained by geostatistics. '!he global
relative precision is very good at 1% (2% for an approx:i.nate 95% confidence
interval), a confinnation of the tenn "proven" attached by the company to its
resmve estinlate. A top-of-resmvoir map has been produced which closely matches
the one produced by experienced geologists. Estinlates and. estinlated precision
are available at each grid node which, in a resmvoir simulation study, obviates
the need to digitize map values to provide input on a regular grid. Updating
these maps with new'ly acquired infonnation or new' geological interpretation is
a routine task.
In
this
study,
only
"classical"
geostatistics
was
used.
other
RE 2161 6
15
~rtant
1lCRNJWIEDGMENT
'!he data from canropolis and the financial support for this research has
been provided by Petroleo Brasileiro S/A - PErnOBRAS. Software Geo-Eas from
u. S.
Enviromnental Protection Agency and software from Geostat Systems Inti (Montreal)
and Radian CO:rp. (Austin) has been used in this study.
translations to samples from the same block, and then calculate the variogra:ms
as usual.
RE 21616
16
am
am
am
Time
am
am
am
case
SPE 2161 6
17
MA'I'HERON, G., BEUCHER, H., de FOUQUEI', 01., GAIU, A. am RAVENNE, 01., 1988,
simulation corrlitionnelle
GOOstatistiques
a trois facies
se.minaire
C.F.S.G.
sur
la
GOOstatistique,
seE
2161 6
18
FIGURE CAPl'IONS
Fig. 1:
map.
Fig. 2:
Fig. 3:
Fig. 4:
ref,
Fig. 5:
0=0.40
ref
and a=700 m.
ref,
Fig. 6:
0=0.49
ref
and a=750 m.
seE
2161 6
19
Fig. 7:
am
adopted theoretical model when faults are not taken into account.
Ntnnber of pairs for each variogram point is indicated. Distances in
2
rrr,
Fig. 8:
0=1725
rrr
am
..
am adopted theoretical model when faults are not taken into account.
Ntnnber of pairs for each variogram point is indicated. Distances in
rrr,
Fig. 9:
0=740 m
am
in m.
Fig. 10:
m.
Fig. 11:
-seE
2161 6
20
TABLE 1
statistic
Table 1:
without faults
with faults
-0.01
0.87
0.28 m
0.14 nt
0.87
-0.01
0.74
0.31 m
0.17 mZ
0.84
is the
coefficient, mean and fi- are respectiVely the mean and the variance
of the starrlardized kriging error.
TABLE 2
statistic
without faults
mean
SZ
r
Table 2:
Top-of-reservoir
-0.09
3.38
7.74 m
133.5 mZ
0.98
height
-0.02
0.89
5.77 m
74.6 nt
0.99
cross-validation
With faults
I I
results.
is
the
coefficient. mean and fi- are respectiVely the mean and the variance
of the starrlardized kriging error.
I!E 2161 6
\\
SERGIPE - ALAGOAS
+ BASIN
+.
~-.,
+ 7 ~
+ /.
+ /:
+ /
+//
+/
+ I
jv'U
.v
+/
.,
+:V~S.ARMOPOllS
+1
ARlcAJU
'-j
+
+ + !.
DIVINA
PASTORA
LOW
CAMORIM
1- i G
)
1..
01
lSI
lSI
lSI
Ln
CD
CD
lSI
lSI
lSI
CT1
01
CD
CD
o.
i.
~.
lSI
lSI
lSI
.......
(J\
lSI
lSI
lSI
01
.......
CD
CD
z
o
I-f
CD
CD
o
.....
I:::J
en
I:
o
:::J
I-
I-f
I-f
t-:l
Z
I-f
0::
W
I:
>o
0..
.J
z
o
I-f
.J
I<I
....
I:
:::J
I-
CD
CD
........
(J\
CD
lSI .......
lSI l '
lSI
CD
lSI
lSI
lSI .
lSI
lSI
lSI
01
01
l'
lSI
lSI
lSI
ill
01
l'
lSI
lSI
lSI
(!)
CI
I-f
o
o
I:
<I
W
I-
D~
.J
I.L.
0::
W
I<I
3
IU
W
lSI
lSI
lSI
CD
-..
__
..
. ~~
..... \\~. .. .
.-.LJ
0a--,
--"-y-I' :...:.-.--
..~
O~~
lSI
lSI
lSI
CD
CD
.......
01
..~~~~~~~~
.
.
~. .~''(
~.
. .... -. ~
. .. -.. -:
. ..: ...
. .-::.
..
. . .
..
..
...
- I
.... " .
s::..-:
. o. ::=.:.
..... _o~.oSO-
'0,
CT1
CD
CD
01
lSI
lSI
lSI
~~~O
,~~~~?--
~':":~.,
~~~
01
l'
~~:-~
~"'~~
01
l'
.......
lSI
lSI
lSI
CD
l'
lSI
lSI
lSI
Ln
01
CD
CD
SPE 2161 6
SPE 2161 6
1-----Ic::r=J--------i
S tat i
tic s
98.
N ,.
r-r--
68.
r--
Yo
r--
38.
Minimm
25th Yo
Median
1h
8.
8.
1.
2.
Hean
Uariance:
Std. Dev:
Coer. Uar :
Skewness:
Ilurtosis:
1.747
.582
.763
43.663
.287
2.728
r--
r---
'--
529
3.
75th
Yo
Haxil'lU.l'I
.188
1.288
1.788
2.388
4.288
4.
5.
fib. '3
....
....'0
aI
Jj
......
.
to
0
t")
0
N
00
0
0
N
o
o
go
...q-
lO
.
0
WD.J6opDA
..-
~I
l'l
..-
00
lO
.
...q-
Q)
U
C
....o
4'1
Q
F1 0.
~I
seE
21616
0.7
-,
0.6
0.5
"en
0.4
l-
1209
1318
n
1378
'454
._
908
'i:
"
0.3
>
6~
0.2 --I
/
11~
"7
0.1 -1
II
I i i
0.2
0.4
0.6
(\
<5'
VI
0.8
1.2
J!E 2161 6
t----c=E
S tat i s tic s
168.
N
128.
r-r--
.,l:
~
.,'d
I---
88.
r--
I---
SIlt
I---
48.
I---
---..-.
8.
0.
1.
2.
3.
4.
865
Mean
Uariance:
Std. De\!:
:I. Coer .Uar:
Skewness:
Kurtosis:
1.538
.448
.669
43.504
.138
2.186
MinitlUl'l
25th :I.
Median
75th :I.
ttaxitul.tl
.241
1.823
1.519
2.054
3.335
SPE 2161 6
<>
~---------
/~/
780
/~~ 0854
/
<>//
;<lOS
/
!::
rt)
I::"'C
I:
::s
<>
93"
t"""'\.
;V
"'"
0
art)
'i: 0
OJ:
>~
~Io
......"
896
('01086
~O
qa{/
/45
m065
0)H12
<>
O~
/~./
617
4.3.~
10/
12
/'
~5
,)
~
-J
1.2
N 80 W
Dlstonce ( km )
0
N 10 E
1.4
SEE 2161 6
1.8
1.7
1.6
1.5
1.4
1.3
1.2
"'"
E~
64
1.1
<)
"to.. 0
:
OIl/)
:::s
'i: 0
".c
>1-
'...,;
0.9
139
211
~------------_
..
0.8
u/
337
o
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
D259
--
~~57
34
~>
0.2
~530
0'~1~
o
0.2
II
o
60
0.8
0.4
N 80 W
Dlstance ( km )
.()
1.2
N 10 E
1.4
21616
"""
'"
"u">
'"
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
. 3000
3500:---
'1000
.....
.
RE 21616
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
.,.
.'
tOOO
f /6 lo - .
I
RE 21616
o
o
'"'"
'"
'"'"
o
o
o
'"
o
o
'"
o
o
;!
o
o
:::
o
o
o
'"
L-..,------.------,---.-.-----T-----.,---------,------.,---------.-J
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
1000
r if, II
.,
I ~