Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
B Y PAUL F . KERR *
INTRODUCTION
Temperature
Temperature of Sunthesis. Kaolinite has been_ produced synthetically at different temperatures and under
a variety of conditions. It was formed by Noll (1934) at
320C in the presence of 0.5N IICl. Noll expressed the
opinion that kaolinite would form below 200C in the
proper acid concentration, if given sufScient time. Earlj'
experiments by Collins (1887) were said to have produced kaolinite by alteration of orthoclase in dilute H F
in 96 hours at "l6C. Schwarz and Waleker (1925)
20
[Bull. 169
Part I]
21
Clay Minerals in Active Thermal Regions. Knowledge of clay minerals in active thermal localities is fragmentary. The solfataric action reported by MacDonald
(1944) has resulted in the formation of kaolinite at the
expense of olivine basalt lava and ash. As early as 1851,
Bunsen (1851) observed that the transformation of a
basalt to clay was no simple soaking process, but that
certain constituents might be added, others subtracted.
The alteration usually starts in the glassy or microcrystalline groundmass, leaving the phenoerysts intact. The
rock eventually becomes soft. Barth (1950, p. 49) found
the rocks in Iceland to be "profoundly altered by hotspring action; most intense and rapid is the alteration
caused by acid springs. The end product consists of opal
with small amounts of clay minerals. The mechanical
action of boiling and gas exhalation breaks up the rock
into a finely divided elaylike substance. In areas of intense acid-spring activity such slippery warm clay deposits cover large areas. . . . The basaltic lava is attacked
bj- acid steam and vapors emanating from cracks and
fissures in the lava. Around such cracks incrustations
usually occur, and the pores and vesicles of the rock are
filled with secondary minerals. Simultaneously the primary minerals are altered by metasomatic action, inducing changes in the bulk chemistry of the rock."
The dome around Geysir, Iceland, he described (Barth
1950, p. 97) as having "been built up by precipitation of
silica from the hot-spring water as it flowed out of the
basin. It is stratified (consisting chiefly of alternating
layers of clay and silica sinter.) . . . The clay (layers)
are identical (in composition) with the decomposition
product formed by the action of acid hot-spring water
on basaltic rocks at other places in Iceland, and it appears that only acid waters can produce this kind of
clay. On the other hand, only alkaline waters deposit
silica sinter. . . . The hot spring activity in this place
has changed many times from alkaline to acid and vice
versa.''
Rock alterations in the Kilauea region of Hawaii have
been described by MacDonald (1944) and by Payne and
22
[Bull. 169
Part I]
23
Clay-mineral development under normal surface conditions may require periods that are long even in terms
of geologic time unless some accelerating conditions
prevail. Under even slightly favorable conditions, however, leaching and deposition, together with weathering
and soil formation, do take place. The chemistry of
supergene processes is complex. It is generally thought,
however, that even weak concentrations of acid or alkali
solijtions together with small amounts of alkali or alkaline-earth elements, alumina, silica, and other chemical
constituents, given sufficient time, may produce clay
deposits, some of which are very large. Special conditions, such as a more concentrated chemical action or
moderate increase in temperature, may greatly decrease
the time factor.
In saline or brackish bodies of water, clay minerals
are thought to be often subject to diagenesis. In regions
of heavy rainfall and high temperature, organic acids
are apt to accumulate in unusual concentration, accelerating the formation of clay. Even organic concentrations in bogs where the temperature is not extreme may
form clay minerals.
The formation of clay minerals originally, by either
hypogene or supergene action, followed by removal,
transportation, and redeposition at a new site, is simple
in general concept but involves many features that
should receive further scrutinyparticularly the extent to which the alteration or direct precipitation of
clay minerals may take place in the cycle.
N o r m a l Surface Action
24
Allen (1944) emphasizes the importance of sedimentary processes in elay-mineral foriftation in certain Pacific Coast areas where volcanic materials predominate.
Sedimentary processes are more important than volcanic processes at Tone, California; Castle Rock, Washinjiton ; Whiteware, Montana; Ilobart Butte and Molalla,
Orei>on. Clays derived directl.v from volcanic materials
are composed dominantly of niontmorillonite; but these
clays, with the exception of the beidellite-nontronite
varieties, have relatively low percentages of available
alumina. In contrast, clays derived through leaching of
various aluminous rocks in thoroughly drained areas are
composed dominantly of kaolinite; furthermoi'e, the depositional structure of these sedimentary clays favors the
formation of gibbsite by weathering or the formation of
dickite or kaolinite by hydrothermal action.
Large accumulations of fuller's earth that contain
attapulgite as the eifective clay mineral have been
worked for many years in the Georgia-Florida region
(Kerr, 1937). The sediments which contain the clays
have been derived from the erosion of the crystalline
rocks of the highlands. On the other hand, no such accumulation of attapulgite as is found in the sedimentary
layers has been reported in the source area. It seems
likely that the accumulation of attapulgite may represent more than simple transport and deposition; perhaps waters unusually high in magnesium, or long-continued action of waters low in magnesium, contributed
to the formation of this unusually high-magnesia clay.
The unique clay mineral lieetorite described by Foshag
and Woodford (1936) is found in the Mojave Desert,
California, in folded sediments of Tertiary age. Relic
textures are abundant in the clay matrix; they include
minute collapsed cavities lined with layers of the clay
mineral, and curved structures which may be altered
pumice shards. The rock is probably a greatly altered
daeite t\iff. The clay mineral of which the rock is now
chiefly composed, is chemicall.v and optically almost
identical with the magnesian clay mineral, but differs
from it by swelling greatly in water. In origin, therefore, this bentonitic magnesian clay is not essentially
difiPerent from most normal bentonites. Chemical analyses of this clay show that it is essentially a magnesium
silicate with only an insignificant amount of alumina.
Noteworthy are the high soda content (3 percent) and
the lithia content (1.12 percent).
According to Tarr and Keller (1937), kaolinite found
in several localities in Missouri gives evidence of having
been deposited from solution. Kaolinite occurs in the
Orongp Circle mine as thin veins in nearly vertical joints
of the Pennsylvanian shales, as well as in cavities and
as a replacement mineral. The kaolinite at the National
Pigment barite mine was deposited in joints in dolomite
that had been enlarged by solution. At the Reavis mine,
kaolinite occurs dominantly in solution cavities and along
joints in the Jefferson City dolomite. This mine and the
National Pigment mine are in sink holes. Kaolinite in the
Keokuk, Iowa, area occurs in quartz geodes and in small
solution cavities in siltstone.
Allen (1937) has described kaolinite derived from
limestone by supergene processes. The Cheltenham clay
of Missouri had its source in an earthy limestone subject
to the action of carbonic-acid waters. Erosion into a
[Bull. 169
choked sink hole or closed basin has resulted in the accumulation of a sedimentary clay deposit.
MacKenzie (1949) has described a clay mineral of
possible supergene origin, which differs somewhat from
illite but belongs to the same groi;p. The material occurs
at Ballater, Aberdeenshire, in a crush-band in the altered rock along a vein in a granite outcrop exposed in
road-widening. The alteration is apparently a result of
the action of water, but since the band was still highly
altered at the base of the exposure (about 25 feet from
the surface), it is not certain from the field relationships
whether the water was of hydrothermal origin or
whether it percolated from the surface.
As pointed out by Ross and Kerr (1934) halloysite
forms many times bj' supergene processes. Callaghan
(1948) has described halloysite 4H2O from Bedford,
Indiana, which represents a supergene reorganization of
deposited material. Other halloysite deposits were apparently at one time a residual soil. Halloysite from
Wagon Wheel Gap, Colorado (Cross, 1896), formed as
an alteration product of rhyolite, and may have been
deposited from solution or suspension by downwardmoving waters.
Lovering (1949) has described kaolinite, halloysite,
and allophane in the East Tintie district, Eureka, tltah,
which formed when weathering of sulphide ores produced acid solutions. Away from the sulphide bodies,
montmorillonite and beidellite are the common products
of weathering.
Bates et al. (1950) have made a number of interesting
observations on the morphology of halloysite. Halloysite
4II2O (endellite) is believed to consist of well-developed
tubes which split upon dehydration to halloysite 2H2O.
Study with an electron microscope has revealed that
halloysite 2H2O crystals consist of hollow tubes which
have collapsed, or have split and partially or completely
unrolled. It is suggested that this change in morphology
explains the irreversibility of the dehydration process.
There is no apparent morphological transition from
these crystals to the pseudo-hexagonal plates characteristic of kaolinite, dickite, and nacrite.
Stringham and Taylor (1950) ascribe the formation
of nontronite occurring in a contact metamorphic zone
to the action of slightly acid solutions. This clay is probably a weathering product of diopside, tremolite, and
pyrophyllite. Nontronite (Main, 1950) occurs within fissures and fills cracks and spaces between polygonal joints
in basalt in the vicinity of Garfield and Manito, Washington. The mineral occurs chiefly as a filling, although
in some cases the basalt is altered to nontronite. The
nontronite contains a small amount of sericite, pyrite,
and quartz. Presumably neutral or alkaline solutions at
normal temperature and supergene in origin, acted on
the basalt and deposited nontronite in openings.
Weathering and Soil Formation. Clay minerals are
produced in various areas on the earth's surface where
the normal temperature is low; at such a temperature,
however, special physical or chemical conditions are
essential, and small differences may be significant. The
clay minerals form slowly by rock decomposition. Varve
clays deposited during Pleistocene glaciation along the
Hudson Valley are essentially rock flour with a minor
clay-mineral content; working near Newburgh, New
Part I]
25
26
[Bull. 169
Part I]
27
28
[Bull. 169
Part I]
29
CONCLUSION
R. E. G r i m :
The American Petroleum Institute is investigating recent sediments in the Gulf of Mexico and a number of samples have been
collected off the south part of the Texas coast in deep water. These
samples are being studied in my laboratory. The water-soluble
salts have been washed out of the samples and the amounts of
calcium, sodium, potassium, and magnesium determined. The determinations did not yield absolute values but ratios of sodium to
each of the elements. It was found that material deposited on the
Gulf floor is largely montmorillonite, with a little illite and kaolinite. A plot of the ratio of sodium to potassium in the soluble
salts against distance from shore shows a relative decrease in
potassium close to shore. There is a correlative increase in the
proportion of illite-like material close to shore. The sodium-magnesium ratios remain constant until some distance from shore,
where the magnesium seems to disappear.
P. F. K e r r :
As to whether isomorphous substitution plays a role in diagenesisI would say that it probably does not. I t is unnecessary
to postulate isomorphous changes to explain the results.
W . F, Bradley:
One difference between kaolin minerals and montmorillonite minerals is that those of the montmorillonite group are stable in
extremely minute flakes, while those of the kaolin group have a
large inherent particle size. Alteration resulting in kaolinite usually
ends at that point. When alteration products pass through a
degraded mica or montmorillonite stage they are highly mobile.
They lose alkalis and magnesium and the particles are then rela-
30
[Bull. 169
or stronger fixation of potash. Alumina wreckage and high polymerized silica may get together and illite may be formed. The clay
particles carried by the Missouri and Mississippi Rivers are not as
flaky as those found in shales. I t seems that the crystals are developed during or after deposition. I t wotdd seem to be that diagenesis
is a .slow reversal of the weathering, or stripping, process.
W.J.Weiss:
Is the potassium bond in illite or hydrous mica strong enough
to resist breakage by mechanical shearing, and could the bond be
disrupted without disintegrating the resulting fragments?
Isaac Barshad:
The answer to the first part of your question is "yes". The
evidence which supports this answer is based on the finding that
only small variations in the cation exchange-capacity exist in illite
fractions of varying particle size. Thus, in an illite from Fithian,
Vermilion ("bounty, Illinois, the exchange capacity of the fraction
consisting of particles less than 0.3 micron was found to be about
28 me. per 100 g. whereas that of the fraction consisting of particles
ranging in size from 1.0 micron to 0..") micron was about 22 me.
per 100 g. Such a small difference in exchange capacity, in spite of
the large difference in particle size, would indicate that the breakage of the coarse illite particles into the finer ones must have
occurred across the plates rather than parallel to the plates. This
kind of breakage indicates therefore that the potassium bond is
strong enough to resist the glacial grinding action which these
illite particles underwent.
The answer to the second tiart of your question is also "yes".
Evidence for this is found in grinding experiments in which the
mica particles were broken in a direction parallel to the jjlates
and also in cation exchange experiments in which the K+ was
replaced with a cation such as Mg+*. In both cases the cation
exchange capacity of the finer particles goes up markedly but the
particles when resaturated with K+ are as true a mica as before
the grinding or removal of the K+ by exchange.
SELECTED REFERENCES
Allen, E. T., 1935, Geyser basins and igneous emanations : Econ.
Geology, v. 30, pp. 1-35.
Allen, E. T. and Day, A. E., 1935, Hot springs in the Yellowstone National Park : Carnegie Inst. Wash., Pub. 466.
Allen, V. T., 1937, The Cheltenham clay-of Missouri: Missouri
Geol. Survey and Water Resources, Appendix V, 59th Biennial
Rept., pp. 1-29.
Allen, V. T., 1944, Sedimentary and volcanic processes in the
formation of high-alumina clays (abstract) : Econ. Geology, v.
39, p. 85.
Allen, V. T., 1048, Bauxitization and resilication (abstract) :
Geol. Soc. America Bull., v. 59, p. 1307.
Allen, V. T., 1952, Petrographic relations in some typical bauxite
and diaspore deposits : Geol. Soc. America Bull., v. 63, pp. 649-688.
Allen, Walter C , 1947, Mineralogy of the brick clays at Kingston, New York, M.A. thesis, Columbia University.
Anderson, C. A., 1935, Alteration of the lavas surrounding the
hot springs in Lassen Volcanic National Park : Am. Mineralogist,
V. 20, pp. 240-252.
Barth, Tom F . W., 19.50, Volcanic geology, hot springs, and
geysers of Iceland : Carnegie Inst. W^ash., Pub. 587.
Bates, T. F., 1942, Nature and origin of the Edwin clay, lone,
California (abstract) : Am. Mineralogist, v. 27, p. 214.
Bates, T. E., 1945, Origin of the Edwin clay, lone, California :
Geol. Soc. America Bull., v. 56, pp. 1-38.
Bates, T. F., 1947, Investigation of the micaceous minerals in
slate : Am. Mineralogist, v. 32, pp. 625-636.
Bates, T. F., Hildebrand, F . A., and Swincford, A., 1950, Morphology and structure of endellite and halloysite : i\.m. Mineralogist,
V. 35, pp. 463-484.
Brannock, W. W., Fix, P . F., Gianella, V. P., and White, D. E.,
1948, Preliminary geochemical results at Steamboat Springs, Nevada : Am. Geophys. Union, Trans., v. 20, no. 2, pp. 211-226.
Brown, G., and MacEwan, D.M.C., 1951, X-ray diffraction by
structure with random interstratification, in Brindley, G.W., ed..
X-ray identification and crystal structures of clay minerals:
Chap. 11, pp. 2()6-284. Mineralog. Soc. London.
Brush, (5. .!., and Dana, E. S., 1880, On the mineral locality at
Branchville. Connecticut, spodumene and its alteration products:
Am. Jour. Sci., v. 20, 3d ser., pp. 283-284.
Buchanan, H., 1807, .Tourney from Madras through M.vsore.
Canada, and Malabar.
Part I]
HuiiKen, K. 1S.)1, ijber die Prozesse <ler vulkanischen GesteinsliildimK'oii Islands: I'oggendorffs Ann. Phys. u. ('hem., v. S3, pp.
]! 17-272.
P>yors, F. i l . , Jr., and P>raniK)ek, W. W., 1049, Volcanic activity
on Umnak and Great Sitkin I.slands, 1940-11)48: Am. Geophys.
Union, Trans., v. 30, pp. 719-71)4.
Callaghan, E., 1948, Endollite deposits in Gardner Mine Ridge,
Pa^vrente County, Indiana: Indiana Dept. Conservation, Div.
(Jcology, Bull. 1.
Campbell, J. M., 1917, Laterite, its origin, structure, and minerals: Mining Mag., v. 17, pp. 07-77, 120-128, 171-179, 220-229.
Collins, J. H., 1887, On the nature and origin of clays : Mineralog. Mag., V. 7, pp. 205-214.
Correns, C. A\'., and Engelliardt, W. von, 1938, Neuc Untersuchungen liber die Verwitterung des Kalifeldspates (abstract) :
Chom. Krde, v. 12, pp. 1-22; Min. Abstracts, v. 7, p. 405.
Cross, Whitman, 1890, Geology of Silver Cliff and Rosita Hills,
C(]lorado: V. S. Geol. Survey, 17th Ann. Reijt., pt. I I . pp. 209-403.
Davidson, C. F., and Bowie, S. H. U., 1951, On thucholite and
related hydrocarbon-uraninite complexes, with a note on the origin
of the Witwatersrand gold ores : O o l . Survey Great Britain, Bull.
no. 3, pp. 409-415.
Day, A. E., and Allen, K. T., 1925, The volcanic activity and hot
springs of Eassen Peak : C'arnegie Inst. Wash., Pub. 300.
Dietz, R. S., 1941, VAay minerals in recent marine sediments:
T^niv. Illinois Library, Ph.D. thesis.
Ewell, R. H., and Insley, H., 1935, Hydrothermal synthesis of
kaolinite, dickite, beidellite, and nontronite : Jour. Research, U. S.
Bur. Statistics, v. 15, pp. 173-186.
Fenner, C. N., 1934, Hydrothermal metamorphism in geyserbasins of Yellowstone Park, as shown by deep drilling: Carnegie
Inst. Wash., Geophys. Eab., Pub. 8.50.
Fenner, C. N., 1936, Bore hole investigations in Yellowstone
Park : Jour. Geology, v. 44, pp. 225-315.
Folk, R. L., 1947, The alteration of feldspar and its products
as studied in the laboratory : Am. ,Tour. Sci., v. 245, pp. 388-394.
Foshag, W. F., and Woodford, A. O., 1936, Bentonitie magnesian clav-mineral from California: Am. Mineralogist, v. 21,
pp. 238-244.
Frankel, J . J., 1949, Dickite from the Witwatersrand gold
mines : Mineralog. Mag., v. 28, pp. 582-586.
Frederickson, A. P., 1951. Mechanism of weathering : Geal. Soc.
America Bull., v. 62, pp. 221-232.
Galpin, S. L., 1912, Studies of fiint clays and their associates:
Am. Ceramic Soc. Trans., v. 14, pp. 301-340.
Gieseking, J. E., and Mortland, M. M., 1951, Influences of the
silicate ion on potassium fixation : Soil Sci., v. 71, pp. 381-385.
Glass, Herbert D., 1951, Clay mineralogy of the coastal plain
formations of New Jersey: Ph.D. thesis, Columbia University.
Goldich, Samuel S., 1948, Origin and development of aluminous
laterite and bauxite (abstract) : Geol. Soc. America Bull., v. 59,
p. 1326.
Goldman, Marcus I., 1949, Petrology of bauxite surrounding a
boulder-like core of kaolinized nepheline syenite in Arkansas (abstract) : Geol. Soc. America Bull., y. 60, pp. 1890-1891.
Gordon, M., Jr., Tracey, J. I., Jr., and Ellis, M. W., 1949, Field
relations of Arkansas bauxite deposits (abstract) : Econ. Geology,
V. 44, pp. 640-641.
Graham, B. R., 1941, An acid clayan agent in chemical
weathering : .Tour. Geology, v. 49, pp. 392-401.
Grim, R. E., 1033, Petrography of the fuller's earth deposits,
Olmstead, Illinois, with a brief study of some non-Illinois earths :
Econ. Geology, v. 28, pp. 344-363.
Grim, R. E., and Allen, V. T.. 1938. Petrology of the Pennsylvanian underclavs of Illinois : (Jeol. Soc. America Bull., v. 49,
pp. 1485-1514.
Grim. R. E., and Bradley, AV. F., 1939, A unicpie clay from the
Goose Lake, Illinois, a r e a : Am. Ceramic Soc, Jour., v. 22, pp.
157-164.
Grim, R. E., Dietz, R. S., and Bradley, W. F., 1949, Clay
niineral comx)osition of some sediments from the Pacific Ocean off
the California coast and the Gulf of California : Geol. Soc. America
Bull., V. 60, pp. 1786-1808.
Grim, R. E., Lamar, J. E., and Bradley, W. F., 19,39, The clay
minerals in Illinois limestones and dolomites: Jour. Geology, v.
45, pp. 829-834.
Gruner, J. W., 1936, Hydrothermal alteration of montmorillonite
to feldspar (abstract) : Am. Mineralogist, v. 21, p. 201.
Gruner, ,J. W., 1944, The hydrothermal alteration of feldspars
in acid solutions between 300 and 400C.: Econ. Geology, v. 34,
pp. 578-589.
31
32
[Bull. 169