Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
CE
HOURS
Continuing Education
Fear
The
Is Still in Me:
Caring for Survivors of Torture
How to identify, assess, and treat those
who have endured this extreme trauma.
Editors note: The three cases that begin this article are composite characters based
on real survivors of torture. The fourth case, that of the Cambodian woman, is
real, but details have been changed to protect her anonymity.
hile visiting the home of a 34-year-old immigrant from Cameroon who recently
delivered her second child, a public health nurse notices that the womans husband
seems overly vigilant. During the visit, the couples three-year-old son makes a
loud noise by hitting a plastic toy against a wooden table. The husband jumps up
at the sound, then yells at his son for making noise. After her husband leaves
the room, the woman explains that he doesnt sleep well and that he hasnt been the
same since his imprisonment in Cameroon for organizing a public demonstration
critical of the governments human rights abuses. Weeping, she explains that her
husband used to be a happy person who enjoyed life. She says she doesnt know
what was done to him during his imprisonment because he wont discuss it with
her, and now she doesnt know how to help him.
A 26-year-old Iraqi man comes to the ED of a county hospital complaining of
chest pain. The man speaks limited English. While waiting for the Arabic interpreter, the nurse checks his blood pressure and pulse, which are 150/98 mmHg
and 110 beats per minute, respectively. Using gestures, she indicates that the man
should remove his shirt and lie down; he seems nervous but complies. As she
places cardiac monitor electrodes on his chest and begins connecting the monitor
Kathleen McCullough-Zander is the former clinic manager, St. Paul Healing Center, and Sharyn Larson is the
clinic manager, Minneapolis Healing Center, both facilities of the Center for Victims of Torture in Minneapolis.
Some of the research mentioned here was funded by local grants from the Otto Bremer Foundation, the Archibald
Bush Foundation, and the Blue Cross and Blue Shield Minnesota Foundation. Contact author, Sharyn Larson:
(612) 436-4814, slarson@cvt.org. The authors of this article have no other significant ties, financial or otherwise,
to any company that might have an interest in the publication of this educational activity.
54
http://www.nursingcenter.com
Image courtesy of the Rehabilitation and Research Centre for Torture Victims, Copenhagen, Denmark
55
annual report cites instances of torture and ill treatment by state authorities in 132 out of 155 nations
(85%)including the United States.2 A literature
review conducted by Eisenman and colleagues found
that between 5% and 35% of refugees (men,
women, and children) worldwide have been tortured.3 And in particular cultural groups, the percentage of torture survivors may be even higher. For
example, a recent study conducted in Minnesota
among Ethiopian Oromo and Somali refugees found
the prevalence of torture to be as high as 69%.4
Countries that have ratified the United Nations
1984 Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel,
Inhuman, or Degrading Treatment or Punishment
(including the United States, in 1990) are legally
bound to ensure that health care personnel learn
about torture.5 But such education has not yet been
included in the curricula of U.S. schools of nursing.
The Center for Victims of Torture (CVT; www.
cvt.org) in Minneapolis, where each of us has
worked or works, focuses on treating survivors of
torture by foreign governments. The CVTs
resources are limited and so therefore is its focus;
although torture is sometimes perpetrated by U.S.
citizens against U.S. citizens, it was thought that
these survivors would have greater access to the
mainstream health care system. This article focuses
on immigrants or refugees living in the United States
who have been tortured.
AN OVERVIEW
Torture defined. The Geneva Conventions that were
written in 1949 and ratified by the United States in
1955 constitute the main source of international
humanitarian laws today, according to Human
Rights Watch.6 The conventions explicitly forbade
physical or mental coercion and made the use of
torture a war crime; they were a basis for the 1984
United Nations convention mentioned above. In
1975 the World Medical Association defined torture as the deliberate, systematic, or wanton infliction of physical or mental suffering by one or more
persons acting alone or on the orders of any authority, to force another person to yield information, to
make a confession, or for any other reason.7 In its
1998 position statement on nurses and torture, the
International Council of Nurses stated that nurses
have the duty to provide the highest possible level of
care to victims of cruel, degrading, and inhumane
treatment. The nurse shall not voluntarily participate in any deliberate infliction of physical or mental suffering.8 (See Working Against Torture: The
Importance of Education, page 60.)
Why people torture. While the media usually
portray torture being used to extract information
from someone, this is just one aspect; in fact, information so obtained is notoriously unreliable
because most people subjected to torture will admit
56
ajn@lww.com
Image courtesy of the Rehabilitation and Research Centre for Torture Victims, Copenhagen, Denmark
dents, and heart disease, as compared with nontortured, culturally matched controls, according to
Goldman and Goldston (as cited by Basoglu and
colleagues in The Mental Health Consequences of
Torture).12 The reasons for the differences in risk are
unknown. Survivors may also have illnesses such as
tuberculosis or parasitic infection acquired in
prison, in a refugee camp, or by fleeing.
Psychological effects. At the CVT, survivors say
that psychological torture is harder to endure than
physical torture and that its effects are more difficult
to live with. Forms of psychological torture include
prolonged interrogation, sensory deprivation, mock
execution, and being forced to watch loved ones
being tortured.
Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and
depression are the most common psychological disorders in people whove survived torture. Symptoms of PTSD commonly seen in this population
include reexperiencing phenomena (such as flashbacks, intrusive thoughts, and nightmares), the
avoidance of stimuli associated with being tortured
(such as other people from ones cultural group,
people in uniforms, windowless rooms), and physiologic symptoms of increased arousal and reactivity
of the sympathetic nervous system (such as hypertension, sleep disturbances, and a heightened startle
response).12, 13 Survivors may find themselves caught
in a cycle of trying to move on with their lives as
vivid reminders of the past encroach. Though it may
seem paradoxical, severely depressed survivors can
have physiologic symptoms of increased arousal
and reactivity; clinicians should look for symptoms
of both depression and PTSD. Other possible symptoms include social isolation, impaired memory and
concentration (which may or may not be a result of
head injury), fatigue, sexual dysfunction (especially
if sexual trauma has occurred), and personality
changes.12 (See PTSD in the World War II Combat
Veteran, November 2003.)
Although PTSD appears to be a common response
to severe stress, the interpretation and expression of
symptoms differs among cultural groups.14 For example, a 49-year-old Cambodian woman who survived
the killing fields of the Khmer Rouge and emigrated to the United States several years ago reported
that for more than 25 years she has experienced
chronic headaches, abdominal pain, nightmares, and
difficulty sleeping. Her U.S. providers attributed these
symptoms to the extreme trauma she had endured,
which included being starved, beaten, raped, and
forced to witness the torture and execution of family
members and friends. But the woman believed that
her symptoms were caused by the spirit of her dead
mother, who shook her feet at night because her
daughter hadnt buried her properly. Some survivors
view their suffering as punishment for bad behavior
in this or a previous life.
57
therapies) focus on a patients current or past experiences, thoughts, and feelings. The underlying
assumption is that gaining insight into ones feelings
and actions can bring about desired change.
Psychotropic medications, especially selective
serotonin reuptake inhibitors that have been
approved by the Food and Drug Administration for
the treatment of PTSD, such as paroxetine (Paxil)
and sertraline (Zoloft), are also used frequently in
the treatment of torture survivors. Although no
research on their use in treating torture survivors
has yet been done, the efficacy of these drugs in
treating anxiety and depression associated with
PTSD is well established.
Many survivors now living in the United States
have difficulty obtaining access to health care that is
affordable and culturally appropriate. In our experience, cultural differences in beliefs about health,
illness, and care create the most formidable barriers
to their getting that care. Western-based psychological treatment isnt acceptable to all survivors, and
as Ortiz has noted, Talk therapy is not the only
form of treatment that has proved useful.17 She
points out that treatment by traditional or folk
healers and interventions considered alternative or
complementary in Western health care, such as
herbal remedies, massage therapy, aromatherapy,
and breathing and relaxation exercises, may also be
valuable. For example, a British nurse and Reiki
practitioner reported that Reiki treatments helped
reduce the frequency and severity of nightmares,
abdominal pain, headaches, and stress in two
Bosnian torture survivors.23
NURSING CARE FOR TORTURE SURVIVORS
Torture assessment. If a nurse suspects that a patient
may have been tortured, an assessment for this
should be done. A good opening question is Can
you tell me a little about what happened in your
country that made you come to the United States?
Based on the patients response and apparent comfort level, the nurse might follow with more specific
questions, such as I know that in your country
many people have been beaten or arrested by soldiers or rebels. Have you ever been attacked like
that? We find that its best to avoid the word torture as the word encompasses different things in
different cultures. For example, not all cultures consider rape to be a form of torture.
We have found that it can be very therapeutic for
survivors to tell their stories. As nurses, we are often
so busy with more concrete tasks that we sometimes
forget the tremendous healing power of presence
and empathy. Indeed, in the July 1 issue of the New
England Journal of Medicine, Mollica noted that
despite routine exposure to the suffering of victims
of human brutality, health care professionals tend to
shy away from confronting this reality . . . they
ajn@lww.com
59
http://www.nursingcenter.com
61
Giving Light
A book of short stories offers hope of redemption.
62
63
CE
HOURS
Continuing Education
64
http://www.nursingcenter.com