Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
General Principles
I.
Public Office
Purpose
Nature
1) A public office is a public trust. (Art. XI, Sec. 1,
1987 Consti)
Philippine Constitution, Art. XI Sec. 1. Public
office is a public trust. Public officers and employees
must, at all times, be accountable to the people, serve
them with utmost responsibility, integrity, loyalty, and
efficiency; act with patriotism and justice, and lead
modest lives.
of law
Public
Contract
Creation
Incident of
sovereignty
Originates
from will of
contracting
parties
Object
Carrying out
of sovereign
as well as
governmental
functions
Obligations
imposed only
upon the
persons who
entered into
Elements
i.
affecting even
persons not
bound by the
contract
the contract
Subject
Matter
Tenure,
duration,
continuity
Limited
duration
Scope
Duties that
are generally
continuing
and
permanent
Duties are
very specific
to the contract
The law
Contract
Where duties
are defined
Exceptions:
where the offices are created by the
Constitution;
where the Legislature delegates such power.
Cornejo v. Gabriel
Abeja v. Tanada
Board System
Compositio
n
One head
assisted by
subordinates.
Collegial body
in formulating
polices and
implementing
programs.
Efficiency
Swifter
decision and
actions but
may
sometimes be
hastily made.
Mature
studies and
deliberations
but may be
slow in
responding to
issues and
problems.
GENERAL RULE:
The power to create an office
includes the power to modify or abolish it. (i.e., this is
generally a legislative function)
EXCEPTIONS:
(1) Where the Constitution prohibits such modification /
abolition;
(2) Where the Constitution gives the people the power to
modify or abolish the office;
EXCEPTIONS:
1) When citizens are required, under conditions
provided by law,
2) to render personal military or civil service (Sec.
4, Art. II, 1987 Const.);
3) When a person who, having been elected by
popular election to a public office, refuses
without legal motive to be sworn in or to
discharge the duties of said office (Art. 234,
RPC; Note: the penalty shall be either arresto
mayor, or a fine not exceeding P 1,000.00, or
both)
II.
Public Officer
Definition:
Constitutional
Statutory
National
Local
Legislative
Executive
Judicial
Civil
Military
Quasi-judicial
Ministerial
De Jure
De Facto
Lucrative
Honorary
Election
a. Selection or designation by popular vote.
2. Appointment
Designation
Definition
Imposition of
Appointmen
t
Appointing
additional
duties upon
existing office
Extent of
Powers
Limited
Comprehensiv
e
Security of
tenure?
No
Yes
Is prior/1st
office
abandoned
when
a 2nd
designated
position is
assumed? NO
a 2nd
appointive
position is
assumed?
Usually YES
3. Others:
a. Succession by operation of law;
b. Direct provision of law, e.g. ex-officio officers
authority
selects an
individual who
will occupy a
certain public
office
Classification of Appointments
a. Permanent
i. The permanent appointee:
must be qualified
must be eligible
is constitutionally guaranteed
security of tenure
permanent.
b. Temporary
i. an acting appointment;
ii. the temporary appointee NEED NOT be
qualified or eligible;
iii. (No Security of Tenure) revocable at will: just
cause or valid investigation UNNECESSARY;
1. an acting appointment is a temporary
appointment and revocable in character.
[Marohombsar v. Alonto (1991)]
iv. A temporary appointee is like a designated
officer V they:
occupy a position in an acting capacity and
do not enjoy security of tenure. [Sevilla v. CA
(1992)]
II.
Designation v. Appointment
Definition
Extent of
Powers
Security of
tenure?
When
deemed
abandonment
of prior office
Designation
Imposition of
additional
duties upon
an existing
office
Limited
No.
Assumption
of a
designated
position is not
deemed
abandonment
of the 1st
position
Appointment
Selection of an
individual to
occupy a
certain public
office by one
authorized by
law to make
such selection
Comprehensiv
e
Yes.
Assumption of
a 2nd
appointive
position is
usually
deemed
abandonment
of the first
office.
Presidential Appointees
IV.
Presumed.
Administrators of public officers, primarily the
department heads should be entrusted with
plenary, or at least sufficient, discretion. Their
position most favorably determines who can best
fulfill the functions of a vacated office. There
should always be full recognition of the wide
scope of a discretionary authority, UNLESS the
law speaks in the most mandatory and
peremptory tone, considering all the
circumstances. [Reyes v. Abeleda (1968)]
Discretionary Act.
V.
Effectivity of Appointment
Q: When does an appointment take effect?
o A: Immediately upon its issuance by the
appointing authority. (Rule V, Sec. 10,
Omnibus Rules).
VI.
Natural-born citizen
Natural-born citizen
registered voter
Natural-born citizen
Natural-born citizen
Natural-born citizen
Natural-born citizen
Public Officer
The President, Vice
President, the
Members of the
Cabinet and their
deputies or assistants
Senator or Member of
the House of
Representatives
Disqualifications
shall not hold any
other office or
employment during
their tenure, UNLESS
otherwise provided in
the Constitution, (Art.
VII, Sec. 13)
may not hold during
his term any other
office or employment
Members of the
Supreme Court and
other courts
established by law
Members of the
Constitutional
Commission
Ombudsman and his
Deputies
Members of
Constitutional
Commissions, the
Ombudsman and his
Deputies
Members of
Constitutional
Commissions, the
Ombudsman and his
Deputies
The Presidents spouse
and relatives by
consanguinity or
affinity within the
fourth civil degree
in the Government, or
any subdivision,
agency or
instrumentality
thereof, including
government -owned or
-controlled
corporations or their
subsidiaries Effect: or
else he forfeits his seat
Shall also not be
appointed to any office
when such was created
or its emoluments
were increased during
his term. (Art. VI, Sec
13)
shall not be designated
to any agency
performing quasijudicial or
administrative
functions. (Art. VIII,
Sec. 12)
shall not hold any
other office or
employment [during
their tenure]. (Art. IXA, Sec. 2) (Art. XI, Sec.
8)
must not have been
candidates for any
elective position in the
elections immediately
preceding their
appointment (Art IXB, Sec. 1; Art. IX-C,
Sec. 1; Art. IX-D, Sec.
1; Art XI, Sec. 8)
are appointed to 7year term, without
reappointment (Sec.
1(2) of Arts. IX-B, C,
D; Art. XI, Sec. 11)
shall not be appointed
during Presidents
tenure as Members of
the Constitutional
Commissions, or the
Office of the
Ombudsman, or as
Secretaries,
Undersecretaries,
chairmen or heads of
bureaus or offices,
including governmentowned-or -controlled
corporations. (Art.
VIII, Sec. 13)
Other Disqualifications
1. Mental or physical incapacity
Definition
Can be
delegated?
Discretionar
y
Acts which
require the
exercise of
reason in
determining
when, where,
and how to
exercise the
power
Generally, NO.
Exception:
When the
power to
substitute /
delegate has
been given
When is
mandamus
proper?
Is public
officer liable?
Only if the
duty to do
something has
been delayed
for an
unreasonable
period of time.
Generally not
liable
Exceptions: if
there is fraud
or malice
Ministerial
Acts which
are
performed in
a given state
of facts, in a
prescribed
manner, in
obedience to
the mandate
of legal
authority,
without
regard to or
the exercise
of his own
judgment
upon the
propriety or
impropriety
of the act
done (Lamb
v. Phipps)
Generally,
YES.
Exception:
When the law
expressly
requires the
act to be
performed by
the officer in
person and /
or prohibits
such
delegation
In all cases.
Liable if duty
exercised
contrary to
the manner
prescribed by
law.
Power of Control
o It implies the power of an officer to manage,
direct or govern, including the power to alter or
modify or set aside what a subordinate had done
in the performance of his duties and to
substitute his judgment for that of the latter.
b. Power of Supervision
o Supervisory power is the power of mere
oversight over an inferior body which does not
include any restraining authority over such
body.
o A supervising officer merely sees to it that the
rules are followed, but he himself does not lay
down such rules, nor does he have the discretion
to modify or replace them.
Right to Compensation
b. The power to fix the compensation of public officers
is not inherently and exclusively legislative in
character.
c. Unless the Constitution expressly or impliedly
prohibits Congress from doing so, it may delegate
the power to other government bodies or officers.
d. The salary of a public officer may not, by
garnishment, attachment or order of execution, be
seized before being paid to him and, appropriated
for the payment of his debts.
e. The rationale behind this doctrine is obvious
consideration of public policy. The functions and
public services rendered by the State cannot be
allowed to be paralyzed or disrupted by the diversion
of public funds from their legitimate and specific
objects, as appropriated by law. [De la Victoria v.
Burgos, (1995)]
Basis of Right to Compensation
f. The relation between an officer and the public is not
the creation of contract, nor is the office itself a
contract. Hence, his right to compensation is not the
creation of contract. It exists as the creation of law
and belongs to him not by force of any contract but
because the law attaches it to the office.
Other Rights
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
I. De Facto Officers
Officer De Jure v. Officer De Facto
Requisites
(2) must
possess the
legal
qualifications
for the office
in question;
(3) must be
lawfully
chosen to
such office;
De Jure
(1) Existence
of a de jure
office;
Basis of
Authority
How ousted
Validity of
official acts
Rule on
Compensation
(4) must
have qualified
himself to
perform the
duties of such
office
according to
the mode
prescribed by
law.
Right: he has
the lawful
right / title to
the office
Cannot be
ousted.
Valid, subject
to exceptions
(e.g., they
were done
beyond the
scope of his
authority,
etc.)
Entitled to
compensation
as a matter of
right;
De Facto
(1) De jure
office;
(2) Color of
right or
general
acquiescence
by the public;
(3) Actual
physical
possession of
the office in
good faith
Reputation:
Has the
possession
and performs
the duties
under color of
right, without
being
technically
qualified in all
points of law
to act.
Only by a
direct
proceeding
(quo
warranto);
not
collaterally
Valid as to the
public until
such time as
his title to the
office is
adjudged
insufficient.
Entitled to
receive
compensation
only during
the time when
The principle
of "no work,
no pay" is not
applicable to
him.
no de jure
officer is
declared;
He is paid
only for actual
services
rendered by
him.
De Facto
Officer under
any of the 4
circumstances
discussed
under Part II
(above).
De Facto Doctrine
Q: What is the de facto doctrine?
A: It is the principle which holds that a person, who, by
the proper authority, is admitted and sworn into office is
deemed to be rightfully in such office until:
(a) by judicial declaration in a proper
proceeding he is ousted therefrom; or
(b) his admission thereto is declared void.
Q: What is the purpose for the doctrine?
Basis of
authority
Color of right
or title to
office
Validity of
"official" acts
Valid as to the
public until
such time as
his title to the
office is
adjudged
insufficient
Rule on
compensation
Entitled
to
receive
compensation
only
during
the time when
no de jure
officer
is
declared;
Intruder
One who
takes
possession of
an office and
undertakes to
act officially
without any
authority,
either actual
or apparent
None. He has
neither lawful
title nor color
of right or title
to office.
Absolutely
void; they can
be impeached
at any time in
any
proceeding
(unless and
until he
continues to
act for so
long a time as
to afford a
presumption
of his right to
act)
Not entitled to
compensation
at all.
He is paid
only for actual
services
rendered by
him.
EXCEPTIONS
Where there is no de jure public officer, the
officer de facto who in good faith has had
possession of the office and has discharged the
duties pertaining thereto is legally entitled to
the emoluments of the office. [Monroy v. CA
[1967])
4. Resignation
6. Abandonment of office
8. Removal
12. Recall
9. Impeachment
Ombudsman
Disciplinary Power Over Public Officers
The Office of the Ombudsman has disciplinary
authority over all elective and appointive
officials of the government and its subdivisions,
Sandiganbayan
Exclusive Original Jurisdiction over
a. violations of R.A. No. 3019 and No. 1379
b. crimes committed by public officers and
employees embraced in Title VIII of the Revised
Penal Code
c. other offenses or felonies (whether simple or
complexed with other crimes) committed by
public officers and employees in relation to their
office, where the penalty prescribed by law is
higher than prision correccional or
imprisonment for six (6) years, or a fine of
P6,000; and
d. Civil and criminal cases filed pursuant to and in
connection with Executive Orders No. 1,2, 14,
and 14-a issued in 1986.
L. Term Limits