Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Council Report
March 3, 2015
To:
From:
Subject:
Consideration of a Resolution rescinding City Council Policies C8935: Firewood; C99-03: Fire Department Mutual Aid Response
Reimbursement; C99-05:
Named Gift Opportunities for the
Campaign for Sunset; and Administration Policy A95-2: Smoking
Breaks-City Hall.
RECOMMENDATION(S): Adopt the Resolution rescinding City Council Policies C8935: Firewood; C99-03: Fire Department Mutual Aid Response Reimbursement; C99-05:
Named Gift Opportunities for the Campaign for Sunset; and Administration Policy A95-2:
Smoking Breaks-City Hall.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: In June of 1988, the City Council identified as one of its goals
the preparation and adoption of a formal Policy and Procedure Manual and on March 21,
198, the City Council identified and approved 37 original policies/procedures. As new
policies/procedures are developed they are added to the manual. The City Council has
set a goal of commencing an update of the Manual in 2015.
ATTACHMENTS:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Policy/Procedure C89-35
Policy/Procedure A95-2
Policy/Procedure C99-03
Policy/Procedure C99-05
Memo dated February 9, 2015
Resolution
APPROVED:
____________________________________
Douglas J. Schmitz, City Administrator
Date: __________________
ATTACHMENTS:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Policy/Procedure C89-35
Policy/Procedure A95-2
Policy/Procedure C99-03
Policy/Procedure C99-05
Memo dated February 9, 2015
Resolution
APPROVED:
____________________________________
Douglas J. Schmitz, City Administrator
Date: __________________
!====================================================================!
II
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
II
[====================================================================l
I!Policy/Procedure
No.:
~Effective
24 Feb 1984
Date:
~?~~
Department
of Origin:
Authority:
Administrative memo
II
/Revision Date(s):
I
I
====================================================================
SUBJECT:
RESPONSIBLE PARTY:
City Forester
I
I
-------------------------------------------------------------1
PURPOSE:
I
I
II
I
I
I
I
I
---------------------------------------------------------1
POLICY/PROCEDURE:
As set forth fully in the policy
document, attached.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
------------------------~-------------------------------1
I
RESCINDED: (Date)
CITY ADMINISTRATOR APPROVAL OF
I
DEPARTMENTAL POLICIES:
Date:
--------
Initial:
II
======================================================================
Council Agenda Packet for 3/3/15
Page 85
82
PAGE 106
MEMORANDUH
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Firewood Policy
DATE:
24 February 1984
2.
.3.
4.
PAGE 107
======================================================================
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
POLICY AND PROCEDURE DATA SHEET
====================================================================
Po 1 icy /Procedure No . : A 9 5-2
Department
of Origin : _--=.A;:;.;drn=l=-:.::n=i-=s--=t:..::r:.. :a=-:t:::..:l::.o=n_ _ __
Authority:
City Administrator
Revision Date(s) :
====================================================================
SUBJECT:
RESPONSIBLE PARTY:
City Administrator
PURPOSE:
POLICY/PROCEDURE:
1. Employees may take two smoking breaks each during
morning and afternoon hours.
2. The smoking breaks are limited to no more than five
minutes each.
3. No more than one employee from any of the departments
in City Hall shall take a smoking break at the same
time.
4. Employees shall ensure that coverage of functions
is maintained while a smoking break is being taken.
RESCINDED:
( Date)
Date: :./;ck t)
Initial:._ J ~
==========================================================~===
\\
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
POLICY AND PROCEDURE DATA SHEET
Policy/Procedure No:
C99-03
Department of Origin:
City Council
Effective Date:
14 September 1999
Authority:
1. The Fire Chief will accept funds received by the Fire Department from
agencies with which the City has mutual aid agreements on behalf of
the City.
2. The Fire Chief shall deposit all such funds into the Fire Mutual Aid
Response Reimbursement Account, a sub-account of the Equipment
Acquisition Fund.
3. Funds from the account shall be transferred as necessary to Sl!-ch line
item accounts as appropriate to offset expenses incurred by the City
related to the mutual aid response effort.
4. Remaining funds, if any, shall be allocated for the purchase of Fire
Department apparatus and equipment subject to approval via
Resolution of the City Council
RESCINDED: (Date)
CITY ADMINISTRATOR APPROVAL OF DEPARTMENTAL POLICIES:
Date:
Initial:
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
POLICY AND PROCEDURE DATA SHEET
Policy/Procedure No:
C99-05
Department of Origin:
City Council
Effective Date:
14 September 1999
Authority:
SUBJECT:
Named gift opportunities for the campaign for Sunset
RESPONSIBLE PARTY:
PURPOSE:
To establish a policy for named gift opportunities related to the Sunset
Theater Project.
POLICY PROCEDURE:
See attached
RESCINDED: (Date)
CITY ADMINISTRATOR APPROVAL OF DEPARTMENTAL POLICIES:
Date:
Initial:
j
- 294Council Agenda Packet for 3/3/15
Page 89
86
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
CITY COUNCIL
RESOLUTION NO. 2001-22
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THESEA AMENDING POLICY C99-05 -NAMED GIFT OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE
CAMPAIGN FOR SUNSET.
WHEREAS, Nancy Doolittle, President of Sunset Center for the Arts has made
a presentation to the Community & Cultural Commission proposing new "Naming
Opportunities; and
WHEREAS, the Community & Cultural Commission has identified and
approved the Conductors Room, the Large Warm-Up Room, the two Warm-Up Rooms
on the lower level, the Sound Control Room, the Lighting Booth, the Recording Room,
and the Lighting Cat Walk as further naming opportunities for the Sunset Theater
Renovation;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL OF
THE CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA DOES:
1.
2.
Authorize the Sunset Center of the Arts to solicit donations for these
Named Gift Opportunities.
NOES:
COUNCIL MEMBERS:
None
ABSENT:
COUNCIL MEMBERS:
None
SIGNED:
~k~
SUE McCLOUD, MAYOR
City of Carmel-by-the-Sea
ATTEST:
i{fkbJ~
Karen Crouch
City Clerk
MEMORANDUM
(
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
September 7, 1999
The Commission recognizes that an integral part of any successful fund-raising campaign
is a donor recognition program. One of the many traditional ways to do this is to name a
segment of the capital project in honor of a significant donor. Bearing in mind the longstanding tradition of naming after donors at Sunset Community and Cultural Center, we
endorse the continuation of this practice within certain parameters.
The Community and Cultural Commission has approved the following and recommends
that the City Council adopt these policies as set forth below:
1. The Sunset Community and Cultural Center is a historically significant name,
tracing its origin to the original school. Because of its historical significance, the
name of the center should remain unchanged.
Also, such a name change could cause much confusion, for the term Sunset Community
and Cultural Center is used by the Commission to describe not only the theater, but also
complex ofbuildings. These include:
-296-
2. Portions of the Sunset Center buildings and cottages, spaces outside the scope of
the theater renovation, have previously been named after significant donors.
These areas should maintain their existing names. They include:
3. The most appropriate areas for naming opportunities are within the scope of the
theater renovation project. They include indoor elements and spaces, rooms,
equipment, and the outdoor plaza.
The dollar value assigned to each "naming opportunity" should remain the responsibility
ofthe Arts group.
-2 97 -
appears to be no registry or list of those donors. Donors of $25,000 and above will
receive two prime seat plaques.
7. Any purchase, commission or donation for art or sculpture for the new facility
must go through the Committee for Art in Publics Places and comply with the
guidelines of Policy No. C97-01. Recommendations are made to the Community
and Cultural Commission for approval and forwarded to the City Council for
acceptance.
8. The Babcock Room will most likely be displaced in the renovation project. As far as
can be ascertained, no members ofthe Babcock family remain in Carmel. Because
this family has given $10-25,000 to the center, we recommend that some kind of
acknowledgement of this remain somewhere within the structure. This is not
intended to be included on the main donor wall plaque.
On August 11, 1999 the Building Committee reviewed our Commission's work to date.
The Committee asked that the following work be completed before presenting to the City
Council the subject of naming opportunities:
1.
2.
3.
The Arts should assign dollar values to the various naming opportunities.
The Commission should address what is appropriate for Carmel with respect to
naming opportunities which could include donations from businesses, groups,
foundations and corporations in addition to those from individuals.
The Commission should return the revised recommendations to the Building
Committee before forwarding them to the Ci ty Council.
After further discussions with the Arts, Commissioners Anderson and Hardy
recommended and the Cultural Commission adopted the following items at their
September 3, 1999 meeting:
9. The Commission approved the Campaign for Sunset- Named Gift
Opportunities with recommended donation amounts as submitted to them by the
Campaign Committee for the Arts. They now forward them (via the Building
Committee) to the City Council for approval. Naming opportunities can include
"memorials" and "honorariums." At the present time, 26 naming opportunities
have been identified.
Please refer to the "Campaign for Sunset- Named Gifts" attachment to this document.
The list has been pared down from 55 naming opportunities originally identified and
approved by the Commission. It has been revised to 26 and includes the value of each
named gift. The 26 items and the amounts assigned to these equals $15.95 million of the
$16.65 million needed for the project.
-298-
3. Lobby
4_
5_
6_
7_
8_
Promenade
Proscenium Arch
House Curtain
Restrooms
Heating-Ventilation-Air Conditioning (HVAC)- plaque positioned at front of
house_
9_ Gift Shop
Those less visib le areas are:
10_Balcony
11 . Mezzanine
12. Box
13_ Box
The remaining locations within the project would be displayed "back of house", behind
the public areas and not as visible to the general public_
Based on the 55 naming opportunities originally identified, which included a number of
outdoor elements, the Cultural Commission adopted a policy that donations for outside
areas should not involve outdoor plaques. The list of naming opportunities now includes
only one outside element. In acknowledgement of the difficult task of raising funds, we
further recommend that if the Arts group receives a donation of $3 million for the
Public Plaza, the display and placement of the naming element be open for
negotiation and handled on an individual basis.
-299-
11. The Commission recommends to the Sunset Center for the Arts and the Building
Committee that in exchange for the City's $5 million commitment to the project
the City of Carmel retain the name "Sunset Theater".
We recommend that this name remain unchanged. We believe by retaining the name
"Sunset Theater", we honor the historical aspects of the center and former school.
12. The Commission recommends that donations not be limited in any way to
exclude businesses or corporations from participation and recognition in the
donor program. We recognize in any fundraising campaign that in addition to
giving by individuals, foundations, families and groups there is the possibility of
receiving donations from businesses and corporations.
Corporate names would appear alone, without addition of any corporate logos.
Many corporations contribute to the betterment of their communities and many
community projects could not happen without the help of those entities. In today's world,
it would be unrealistic to think otherwise. We do not find it objectionable nor offensive
to have such names appear on a centralized "donor board" and would recognize that all
those names are a part of a community "family", committed to the same goal of an
improved community theater.
We believe that any group willing to contribute such amounts of money who want their
name di splayed, can be so recognized by name. At the same time we do not feel it
appropriate for corporate logos to be displayed anywhere in conjunction with this project.
Not all donors will want their names prominently displayed. By lim iting the number of
nam es displayed and by requiring naming elements to be discreet and tastefu l this should
be acceptable to the average, resident or visitor.
The Commission's recommendations adopted on August 9 and September 3, 1999
reflected in this Memorandum dated September 7, 1999 will be referred to the City
Council (via the Building Committee) for placement on their September l4 1h agenda for
approval of naming opportunities relating to the Sunset Theater Project.
The Community and Cultural Commission recognizes that this is a work in progress.
Further design changes or other circumstances may cause us to re-examine this policy.
-300-
Attachments:
1.
2.
-3 01-
Named gifts will be available at a variety of pledge levels to both attract giving
interest and raise the sights of donors.
The value assigned to named area will be based on desirability rather than actual
costs. It will relate to perceived visibility and overall appeal.
Named gift opportunities will be included in the campaign brochure and in
presentation folders.
Named gifts will assist campaign volunteers by providing an opportunity to "sell" a
gift, especially one that is of interest to the donor but at a higher level of giving than
the donor had originally planned. The volunteer will be assisted in motivating and
raising the sights of the donor she/he is soliciting.
Family gifts can be combined for naming purposes.
Memorials and honorariums can be designed for naming purposes.
If a change in the project affects the desirability of a reserved named gift, the donor
will be notified, and arrangements will be made for an alternative selection.
The Sunset Center for the Arts will maintain a named gifts registry for the accurate
and timely reservation of named gifts.
Tills list of naming opportunities is prepared as a guideline to reassure the City Council
that our approach to a successful campaign is to raise the sights of potential donors and
show appropriate appreciation. The suggested dollar amounts are not meant to restrict
the fundraisers who need maximum flexibility in assigning fmal dollar amounts.
DONOR WALL PLAQUE IN LOBBY
All gifts of $25,000 and above. (Could result in 60+ names.) It is recommended that
donors be listed by giving categories, without listing dollar amounts.
$5,000,000 (1 potential naming opportunity)
Performance Hall
$3,000,000 (1 potential naming opportunity)
Public Plaza
$2,000,000 (1 potential naming opportunity)
Lobby
$1.,000,000 (2 potential naming opportunity)
Promenade
Stage - naming element to be positioned backstage
$500,000 (3 potential naming opportunity)
Proscenium Arch
House Curtain
Green Room - backstage
$250,000 (5 potential naming opportunity)
Balcony
Mezzanine
Box
Box
Electronic Enhancement System
$100,000 (13 potential naming opportunity) Most naming elements positioned backstage
Star Dressing Rooms (2)
Orchestra Pit
Orchestra Shell
Fly loft
Sprung Dance Floor
Chorus Dressing Rooms (2)
Stage Right Wing
Stage Left Wing
Gift Shop - front of house
Restrooms - front of house
Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning (HVAC) - front of house
- 303Council Agenda Packet for 3/3/15
Page 98
95
TOTAL
There would be 26 potential naming opportunities (i.e. individual naming elements where
appropriate and desirable). Naming opportunities also mean memorial and honorarium
naming opportunities.
If the Campaign achieves fewer gifts than required at the highest level, we will need to
seek more gifts at the lower levels. This would increase the number of names on the
lobby plaque.
Special Consideration
Concession Stand: Reserved for Friends of Sunset Foundation
Naming Opportunities for Seats
Donors of $100,000 or more will receive 2 prime seat plaques.
Donors of $25,000 to $99,999 will also receive 2 prime seat plaques.
Remaining seats will be designated for $5,000 each.
Recognition for all donations
All donors at all levels will receive program credit for one year and/or listing in other
commemorative/historical materials.
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
SUBJECT:
The following City of Carmel-by-the-Sea policies should be rescinded for the following reasons:
1.
RESOLUTION 2015-__
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
RESCINDING CITY COUNCIL POLICIES/PROCEDURES C89-35: FIREWOOD; C9903: FIRE DEPARTMENT MUTUAL AID RESPONSE REIMBURSEMENT; C99-05:
NAMED GIFT OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE CAMPAIN FOR SUNSET AND
ADMINISTRATIVE POLICY A95-2: SMOKING BREAKS-CITY HALL.
WHEREAS, City Council developed a formal Policy and Procedure Manual in
March 1989; and
WHEREAS, the current City Council has identified one of its 2015 goals to
commence updating the Policy and Procedure Manual; and
WHEREAS, staff has identified four Policy/Procedures that are outdated and
should be rescinded;
WHEREAS, these four policies are the first step towards the continuing updating
of the Policy and Procedure Manual.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA DOES:
1.
PASSED AND ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CARMELBY-THE-SEA this __ day of _________ 2015, by the following roll call vote:
AYES:
COUNCIL MEMBERS:
NOES:
COUNCIL MEMBERS:
ABSENT:
COUNCIL MEMBERS:
SIGNED:
ATTEST:
_______________________________
Jason Burnett, Mayor
____________________________
Lee Price, MMC, Interim City Clerk