Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ab st r a c t
Khirbat al-Majar is a well-known Umayyad palace
complex located near Jericho. he monument is one of
the most important cultural symbols of early Islamic
archaeology in Palestine. his article discusses the sites
initial association with the caliphate of Walid ibn Yazid
in light of new excavations. Recent discoveries suggest
the existence of an early Islamic agricultural estate and
the potential for a new understanding of early Islamic
qusur or proto-urban settlements.
donald Whitcomb
hamdan taha
Formation of a Narrative
his archaeological analysis of Khirbat al-Majar stands
in contrast to the writings of Robert W. Hamilton, then
the young director of the British Mandates Department
of Archaeology in Jerusalem. As early as 1945 he took an
fig. 1
56 | T h e A r c h A e o l o g i c A l h e r i TA g e o f PA l e s T i n e
fig. 2
fig. 4
colorized reconstruction of
the faade of the bath. (After
hamilton 1959: ig. 52.)
58 | T h e A r c h A e o l o g i c A l h e r i TA g e o f PA l e s T i n e
fig. 6
fig. 7
6 0 | T h e A r c h A e o l o g i c A l h e r i TA g e o f PA l e s T i n e
His excavations continued through the 1960s; regrettably, the only published reports are two short notes
(Dajani 1958, n. d.).10 Dajani seems to have concentrated
his eforts on the untouched Northern Area, about 70
meters north of the bath. his was the third or northernmost mound described by Bliss in 1894, whose plan
includes walls exposed at that time from serious looting
for building stones (1894: 178). he only plan available
of these excavations was that made by the Palestinian
Authority after they took control of the site in 1993
(Fig. 8), showing an amalgam of walls of at least three
diferent architectural phases obscured by some thirty
years of neglect.
Renewed Excavations
Current excavations began in 2006 under the direction of
Hamdan Taha of the Palestinian Department of Antiquities
and Cultural Heritage. he Jericho Majar Project, a
collaboration between the Palestinian Department of
Antiquities and Cultural Heritage and the University
of Chicago, was created with the expressed goal of an
integrated archaeological re-assessment of the original
excavations and architectural studies by Baramki and
Hamilton with new archaeological research. he initial
assessment is based on excavations by Taha (2011) and
studies by Whitcomb (1988, 1995).
here are two directions this archaeological re-assessment of Majar may take. he irst is a careful stratiication
of the long history of the building complexes, an approach
systematically pursued by Baramki (1944a, 1953). Based
on Baramkis evidence from the palace (1944a) as modiied
by Whitcomb (1988), an archaeological sequence of four
periods may be proposed:
1. 700750 CE: Construction and destruction debris
mixed with painted wares.
2. 750800 CE: Further occupation, suggesting less
extensive damage from the earthquake in the
mid-eighth century. Ceramics seem to be
transitional types, similar to the Mahesh phase
at Ayla (Aqaba) (Whitcomb 2001: 509).
3. 800950 CE: Major reoccupation of the site in the
Abbasid period; continuities and introduction of
fig. 8
6 2 | T h e A r c h A e o l o g i c A l h e r i TA g e o f PA l e s T i n e
fig. 9
the north gate discovered in 2011. (Drawing by D. Whitcomb and the Department of Antiquities and cultural
heritage, Palestinian Authority.)
f i g . 10
6 4 | T h e A r c h A e o l o g i c A l h e r i TA g e o f PA l e s T i n e
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
notes
1. he excavation reports are found in the Quarterly of the
Department of Archaeology of Palestine for 1936 to 1944.
Twoadditional reports, V and VI, languish unpublished
inthe archives of the Rockefeller Museum.
2. he irst article states that the bath building had not yet
been excavated; this began in 1944 and was accomplished
during the last ive seasons. In this article Hamilton states
that . . . the discovery of . . . the name of Hisham Abd
al-Malik . . . leaves no doubt that they are contemporary with
the construction . . . within the limits of that Caliphs reign
(A.D.72443) (1945: 47, n. 1).
3. It is curious to examine the progression of this argument
every ten years1950, 1959, 1969, 1978, and 1988with
increasing intensity and assuredness.
4. he repetitions and their uncritical acceptance recall
the dictum of Silberman that archaeology was not the
12.
13.
14.
donald whitcomb is an archaeologist at he Oriental Institute, University of Chicago, specializing in Islamic archaeology
and urban planning of the Early Islamic city. His research began in Iran at Istakhr and Qasr-i Abu Nasr. He has directed
excavations at Quseir al-Qadim, Aqaba, Luxor, and Hadir Qinnasrin.
hamdan taha is the director general of the Palestinian Department of Antiquities. Since 1994 he has directed a series of
excavations and restoration projects in Palestine, including Khirbet Balama, Tell es-Sultan, Khirbat al-Majar, and Tell Balata.
Dr. Taha is the co-author of A Hoard of Silver Coins at Qabatiya, Palestine (2006), he Water Tunnel System at Khirbet Balama
(2007), and Jericho, A Living History: Ten housand Years of Civilization (2010). He is also the author of many ield reports and
scholarly articles.
references
Baramki, D. C. 1936. Excavations at Khirbet el Mejer. Quarterly of
the Department of Antiquities in Palestine 5: 13238.
Baramki, D. C. 1937. Excavations at Khirbet el Mejer II. Quarterly
of the Department of Antiquities in Palestine 6: 15768.
Baramki, D. C. 1939. Excavations at Khirbet el Mejer III. Quarterly
of the Department of Antiquities in Palestine 8: 5153.
Baramki, D. C. 1944a. he Pottery from Kh. el Mejer. Quarterly of
the Department of Antiquities in Palestine 10: 65103.
Baramki, D. C. 1944b. Excavations at Khirbet el Mejer IV. Quarterly
of the Department of Antiquities in Palestine 10:15359.
Baramki, D. C. [1947] 1956. Guide to the Umayyad Palace at Khirbat
al Majar. Jerusalem: Government of Palestine. Repr.
Amman: Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan.
Baramki, D. C. 1953. Arab Culture and Architecture of the Umayyad
Period: A Comparative Study with Special Reference to the
Results of the Excavations of Hishams Palace. PhD diss.,
University of London.
Bisheh, G. 2000. An Iconographic Detail from Khirbet al-Majar:
he Fruit-and-Knife Motif. In he Archaeology of Jordan and
Beyond: Essays in Honor of James A. Sauer, ed. L. E. Stager,
J.A. Greene, and M. D. Coogan, 5965. Harvard Semitic
Museum Publications; Studies in the Archaeology and
History of the Levant 1. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns.
Bliss, F. J. 1894. Notes on the Plain of Jericho. Palestine
ExplorationFund Quarterly Statement 1894: 17583.
Cirelli, E., and F. Zagari. 2000. Loasi di Gerico in et bizantina ed
islamica: Problemi e proposte di ricerca. Archeologia Medievale
27: 36576.
Conrad, L. I. 1981. he Qus.r of Medieval Islam: Some Implications
for the Social History of the Near East. al-Abh.th 29: 723.
Creswell, K. A. C. 1969. Khirbat al-Majar. In Umayyads, A.D.
622750. Vol. 1, pt. 2 of Early Muslim Architecture, ed.
K. A. C. Creswell, 54577. 2nd ed. Oxford: Clarendon.
Dajani, A. K. 1958. Excavations in the Town of Jericho, Jordan
(Ar.). In al-Mutamar al-hani lil-Athar i al-Bilad al-Arabiya,
Baghdad, 1828 Nuimbir (Tishrin al-hani) 1957, 19799.
al-Qahirah: Jami`at al-Duwal al-`Arabiyah.
Dajani, A. K. n.d. Qasr Hisham ibn Abd al-Malik. Excavations in
Jericho (Ar.), 13. Amman: privately published.
Ettinghausen, R. 1972. he hrone and Banquet Hall of Khirbat
al-Majar. In From Byzantium to Sasanian Iran and the Islamic
World: hree Modes of Artistic Inluence, ed. R. Ettinghausen,
1765. L. A. Mayor Memorial Studies in Islamic Art and
Archaeology 3. Leiden: Brill.
Genequand, D. 2010. Les lites omeyyades en Palmyrne:
Contribution ltude des aspects fonctionnels et conomiques