Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Archaeological Institute of America is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
American Journal of Archaeology.
http://www.jstor.org
The
Early
Period
and
the
Golden
Age
of
Ionia1
EKREM AKURGAL
PLATES
(1050-650)
CITIES (PAN-
IONION)
96-103
370
[AIA 66
of ancient Smyrna, and especially the dwellings of
great and famous cities like Ephesus and Miletus,
were better and had more elaborate domestic installations than these houses beside the city wall facing the rocky southern slopes of Mount Sipylus.
However, it does not seem likely that the difference
could be a very great one.
The rectangular houses of the second level of
Bayrakli are covered with a burnt layer which
shows us that they have been destroyed by violence.
Perhaps this destruction of the buildings and the
city wall is connected with the conquest of the Aeolian Smyrna by the lonians of Colophon, an event
recorded by Mimnermus and Herodotus.'5 The
originally non-Ionian cities of Clazomenae and
Phocaea must have been conquered by the Ionians also as early as the capture of Old Smyrna. Thus
it seems that the expansion of the Ionians, which
was directed two centuries later towards the northern parts of western Anatolia, had begun at the end
of the 9th century.'"This means that the Panionion,
actually a political league of the Ionian cities, was
founded at least by the end of the 9th century.'
The rise of the Ionian cities is due to their early
political union which enabled them to enlarge their
territories to the disadvantage of the Aeolian cities.
EKREM AKURGAL
Vermeule, Archaeology
13(1960)
74ff.
14 E. Akurgal, "Smyrne a lI'poque Archaique Grecque,"
Belleten 9(i946)77ff, pls.18,19.
15 DKA I2. See also G.L. Huxley, "Mimnermos and Pylos,"
Greek, Roman and Byzantine
Studies
2(1959)1o3-1o7.
cenaean survivals or "revivals" after the fall of the Mycenaean CAH 2, chapter 38(I96I)3I;
DKA 12,20.
1962]
371
fig.3.
29 Prehellenic Smyrna: Akurgal, Bayrakli, Erster Vorldufiger
Bericht iiber die Ausgrabungen in Altsmyrna (Ankara 1950)5458.
30 Concerning the problem of population in Ionia see John
M. Cook, BSA 53-54(i958-I959)i9ff; Carl Roebuck, Ionian
Trade and Colonization 21-23.
31 John M. Cook, CAH vol.2,25.
EKREM AKURGAL
372
[AJA 66
36 The problem of kingship in Ionia has been studied recently by C. Roebuck, Ionian Trade and Colonization 30-31,
and John M. Cook, CAH 2,31 (chapter 38).
37E. Akurgal, Phrygische Kunst Io8-iio.
38Martin
Robertson,
JHS 60(1940)20-21.
John Boardman,
(1957)320-331;
42 DKA
62(1958)139-154;
66(1962)153-168.
70-121.
1962]
373
PHASE
(650-600).
1.14-15.
47 Strabo 14.1.37(646).
40.
49 ibid.
50 DKA 229 and
fig.23 on page 308. The connection between
the inscription and the colonization of the Black Sea was first
54DKA 176.
EKREM AKURGAL
374
[AJA 66
graffitomentionedabove bearing the name of Istrokles.It dates, accordingto the style of a fragment of the dinos on which it is engraved,to the
middle of the 7th century.65This is the period in
which the Aeolian and Ionian lyric arose as one
of the finestpoeticcreationsof westerncivilization.
In the debrisof the templeof Smyrnawerefound
a greatnumberof terracottastatuettesand piecesof
a life-size terracottastatue,66all in Cypriotestyle.
Some of the vases show inscriptionsin the Carian
language;and a great deal of potterywith linear
decorationmust have belongedto the Lydiansliving in Smyrna.Lydian potteryand Lydian weapons were found in a tumulus of the necropolisof
the city, in which apparentlya Smyrniotecitizen
of Lydianorigin was buried.Thus the finds show
clearlyenough how cosmopolitewas.Old Smyrna
in this period of internationaltrade which the
Ioniansdevelopedafterthe middle of the 7th century. We have evidenceof this from other sources
as well. The fatherof Thales, Hexamyes,and the
dedicantof the statueof Hera from Samos in the
Louvre, Cheramyes,had Cariannames.67Chiton,
the characteristic
tunicof the Ionians,is alsoa Carian word.68Tyrannosis a Lydianword; and it was
from the Lydiansthat the Ionianslearnedto strike
coins.In SmyrnaandPitanewerefound representations,one in eachcity,of a lyrewith sevenstrings."6
We know that Terpanderof Lesboshad invented
the heptachordlyre underthe inspirationof Lydian
models.7"In the following pages we shall see that
in Ephesussome of the priestsand priestessesare
definitely a non-Greekethnic type, and we can
imagine how considerablythe Anatolian mother
goddess must have influencedthe Greek Cybele
and the goddessArtemisof Ephesus.Religion,music and dance are the fields in which the Ionians
were greatlystimulatedby the indigenouspeoples.
The luxuriousway of living that the Ioniansliked
was also influencedby their wealthyneighbours.71
mistakenly as the "2nd quarter." However, in the text (p.229)
correctly as "the middle" of the 7th century. For another early
Greek inscription from Smyrna, dating back to the second half
of the 7th century, see DKA 308, fig.24; the same inscription
61 DKA 184.
E. Akurgal, Bayrakli, Erster vorldufiger Bericht iiber die
67 Cf. George M.A. Hanfmann, "Ionia, Leader or Follower?"
Ausgrabungen in Alt-Smyrna (Festschrift der Philosophischen 3.
Fakultdt der Universitdt Ankara vol. 8, 1950) pls. 2,3. DKA
68Rodney S. Young, AJA 64(I960)385.
62
184, fig-134.
64DKA
63John M. Cook, JHS 70(1950)IO-II.
I84ff.
65 DKA 308, fig.3. There the date is given in the caption
1962]
375
period(pl.97,figs.8,9).The divinecoupleappears
SECOND
PHASE(600-545).THECLIMAXOF IONIANCIVILIZATION
295ff.
2(1934)23ff.
the 6th centuryalreadyoccurin this statuette.Specifically Ionian are the soft and fleshy modeling of
the body, the sloping shoulders,the roughly indicated and obliquelyset mouth. Its hairdressis exactly the same as that which we observed on the
above mentioned east Greek statuettes from Samos
and Delphi.
We find the same Ionian characteristics,but in
a more elaborate rendering, on a bronze statuette
78 E. Akurgal,Spdthethitische
BildkunstII I-I8.
Die Kunst der Hethiterpl.I39.
79Akurgal-Hirmer,
so P. Amandry,
Syria
24(I944-45)I9ff.
81Karl Schefold,Orient,
Hellas und Rom 107.
82 DKA 218.
83 ibid. 276ff.
I86ff, figs.137-I39.
EKREM AKURGAL
376
DKA 202-203,
figs.162-I64.
[AJA 66
I02;
2I(1943)57-58,
and
Carl
Lehmann-Haupt, Armenien einst und jetzt 484ff; Lehmann-Haupt, "Zur Herkunft der ionischen Sdiule," Klio 13
108
WJh 31(1938)42-52.
figs.200,22o.
101 ibid. 247,
figs.212,213.
103 ibid. ix.
102 ibid. 247, figs.218,219.
104Anatolia I (I956)7ff. DKA 284ff.
105 DKA 284, fig.251.
logica 238ff.
377
1962]
A. Gerkan,
(1913)468-484;
Akurgal,
Anatolia
5(1960)7;
DKA
293.
378
EKREM AKURGAL
[AJA 66
consists of two vertical volutes bound together; the power and fine artistic feeling of the Ionian spirit.
empty space between the volutes is filled with a When, in the Periclean Age in Athens, the Doric
palmette. Optically considered, the weight of the order, which had become canonic, needed enrichsuperstructure is supported only by this palmette. ment, Attic architects embellished the Doric temFurthermore, the wedge-shaped palmette produces ples with the elements and the slender proportions
an impression of dividing the capital into two parts. of the Ionic order.
The Greeks, who attached great importance to the
Painting was the only branch of the fine arts in
optical effect, could not long use such an untectonic which Ionia never held a leading position.'? The
element to carry the superstructuresof their marble Ionian potters produced, however, vases of fascinattemples. We possess Greek capitals showing sev- ing beauty. As the most important east Greek proderal types of attempts to avoid this optical illusion.111 ucts of this period in ceramics, we might mention
But it was an Ionian architect who linked the two the handsome Chian vases which were found in the
vertical volutes horizontally and solved the prob- excavations at Pitane, the ancient Aeolian city lolem in an ingenious way: the palmette disappeared; cated some 20 km. southeast of Pergamon. The
its upper part in the form of a fillet became the drawing of a stemmed skyphos crater, consisting
abacus; the girdle of the hanging leaves moved up of crouching sphinxes and lions, is careless, but the
between the volutes below the channel and the composition of the whole picture displays conIonic capital was created (pl.1o2, fig.29).
siderable charm, and the attractiveshape of the vase
The capital from Neandria mentioned in this has great elegance (pl.1o3,
fig-.3).
article (pl.1o2, fig.28) is a restored one."2 However,
The high artistic ability of the Ionian potters is
since we possess a representation of an "Aeolic" even to be seen in some vases of provincial quality.
capital on a bronze plaque." from Samos showing On an amphora from Pitane (pl.io3, fig.3o) we
the three essential elements of the capital of Nean- see an interesting figure of a man in a fantastic
dria, volutes, palmette and the girdle with the hang- world of ornaments, bending over, as if gathering
ing leaves (pl.io2, fig.27), we may assume that this flowers. This figure, which is full of expression and
type of capital really existed and served as a model looks like a caricature, is a creation of an Aeolian
for the creation of the Ionic capital. We may re- Greek from Pitane or Myrina. A similar face is
gard it as a step in the evolution of the Ionic capi- represented on an amphora in the Louvren7 which
tal, composed as it is of the two different types was found in Myrina (pl.Io3, fig.32). Both vases
which preceded it, that with the vertical volutes might be products of the same workshop, whether
and that with the girdle of hanging leaves.
in Pitane or Myrina is a question that only further
The canonic form of the Ionic capital must have excavations on both sites could resolve. But the
been perfected on the Anatolian coast at the begin- painters of this workshop were, in the provincial
ning of the second quarter of the 6th century. The landscape of Aeolis, great artists, who illustrated,
Naxian column in Delphi with an Ionic capital114 in an admirably expressive style, the humorous
supporting a sphinx, from about 570 or 56o B.c., character of the east Greek art of painting.
is the earliest example known up to the present
The capture of Sardis by Cyrus in 546 B.c.marked
that we can date almost certainly according to the the end of the splendor of
Ionia. The small cityof
the
The
marble
temwith
a
style
sphinx."5
magnificent
states,
only very restricted military effectiveple of Ephesus, erected before the middle of the ness, were not able to resist the well organized and
6th century, was one of the finest architecturalcrea- mighty Achaemenid kingdom. The final
political
tions of western civilization.
decline of the Ionian cities began a half century
The elegance, charm and originality of Greek later, with the destruction of Miletus in
494 B.c.,
architecture are in great part due to the creative but even in this period of desperation the scientific
111 W.B. Dinsmoor, The Architecture of Ancient Greece
I43,
fig.53; see also P. Amandry, "La colonne des Naxiens," FdD
2(1953) pl.I5, fig-3, pl.I6, fig.I.
112For the bibliography concerning the problem of the
restoration see supra n.Io6.
"I AM 58(1933)38 with picture.
114P. Amandry, "La colonne des Naxiens," FdD 2(1953)I32, pls.12ff.
Hanfmann,
fig.I6.
HSCP 6I(1953)22,
1962]
work of Ionian scholars and artistic activity continued in many cities. In Phocaea, of which it is
recorded that a part of the population emigrated'1l
to the western Mediterranean, the workshops were
still active. As the architectural finds in stone and
terracotta (pl.ioi, figs.24-25) dating from the second part of the 6th century clearly reveal, the temple of Athena was restored to a great extentl9
after its destruction. Samos even enjoyed, under the
tyranny of Polycrates, a period of grandeur.'20
However, the sudden appearancein Etruria of vase
118
Her. i.I64ff.
119 Akurgal, Anatolia
I(1956)7.
1200. Reuther, Der Hera Tempel von Samos, der Bau seit
der Zeit des Polykrates (Berlin 1957).
379
BSA 47(1952)I49.
124DKA 269ff.
AKURGAL
FIG.
PLATE
96
PLATE
97
AKURGAL
FIG. 4
FIG. 6
FIG. 5
FIG.
ette, Delphi
FIG.
.. .
.....
FIG.
7. Ivory statu-
.. . ..... .... .. . .
FIG. Io.
Hittite gravestone from
AKURGAL
FIc. II
FIG. 12
98
PLATE
FIG. 13
FIG.
14
FIG.
IS
FIG.
16
PLATE
FIG. 17
99
AKURGAL
FIG.
18
AKURGAL
FIG.
PLATE
I00
PLATE
101
FIG.
AKURGAL
w
FIG. 24
FIG.
FIG. 25
AKURGAL
PLATE
102
FIG.
FIG.
PLATE
103
AKURGAL
FIG.