4/9/2015

www.sefindia.org::ViewtopicINTERACTIONCURVES&DESIGNOFRCCCOLUMN

www.sefindia.org
STRUCTURALENGINEERINGFORUMOFINDIA[SEFI]

Search
Like

Subscriptions

Share

66k

DigestPreferences

Profile

FAQ

Search

Follow@sefindia

Memberlist

Logintocheckyourprivatemessages

2,670followers

Usergroups

Logintowebsite

Register

SecurityTips

Donate

Logintoforum

Warning:Makesureyouscanthedownloadedattachmentwithupdatedantivirustoolsbeforeopeningthem.Theymaycontainviruses.
Useonlinescannershereandheretouploaddownloadedattachmenttocheckforsafety.

INTERACTION CURVES & DESIGN OF RCC COLUMN

Gotopage1,2,3,4,5Next

www.sefindia.orgForumIndex>SEFIGeneralDiscussion
Viewprevioustopic::Viewnexttopic

Author
bijaysarkar
...

Message
Posted:ThuMar04,20106:39amPostsubject:INTERACTIONCURVES&DESIGNOFRCCCOLUMN

DearSir,
Joined:14Dec2009
Posts:314

Ihavedevelopedoneexcelsheetprogramforcolumninteractioncurves&designofRCCcolumns
undercompressionwithbending(biaxial/uniaxial/pureaxial/purebending)foranypercentageofsteel,
anyfck,anyfy,anyd'/Dfromtheverybasicconceptofstressstraindesigndiagramswhichissimilar
withthatofSP16.
Ihavealsostartedsomeworkoncolumnsundertensionwithbending.
Iwanttouploadtheseinsefindiasite.Buthow,idontknow.Anybodymaypleaseguideme.
Withregards
BijaySarkar
M09748510409

Backtotop

ThankfulPeople

1user(s)is/arethankfulforthispost.

shiven2004
...

Posted:ThuMar04,20108:42amPostsubject:

dearsefians
justchooseanytopicrelatedtocolumndesignandinreplyaddattachment
asyourexcelsheet.......
thanks
regards
shivendrakumar
Joined:08Oct2009
Posts:115
Location:NEWDELHI

Backtotop

shiven2004
...

Posted:ThuMar04,20108:44amPostsubject:

itmaybeusefulthatyoumakenewtopicandaddattachmentinthat................

Joined:08Oct2009
Posts:115
Location:NEWDELHI

Backtotop
Dr.N.Subramanian

Posted:ThuMar04,20104:15pmPostsubject:Re:INTERACTIONCURVES&DESIGNOFRCC

http://www.sefindia.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7123&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=0&sid=47c4bb04743de6c54d231724dc3678c5

1/5

4/9/2015

www.sefindia.org::ViewtopicINTERACTIONCURVES&DESIGNOFRCCCOLUMN
GeneralSponsor

COLUMN

DearErBijaySarkar,
SendanemailtoSefi.orgwithattachment.Whatistheproblem?
Bestwishes,
NS
bijaysarkarwrote:
DearSir,
Joined:21Feb2008
Posts:4865
Location:Gaithersburg,MD,
U.S.A.

Ihavedevelopedoneexcelsheetprogramforcolumninteractioncurves&designofRCC
columnsundercompressionwithbending(biaxial/uniaxial/pureaxial/purebending)forany
percentageofsteel,anyfck,anyfy,anyd'/Dfromtheverybasicconceptofstressstrain
designdiagramswhichissimilarwiththatofSP16.
Ihavealsostartedsomeworkoncolumnsundertensionwithbending.
Iwanttouploadtheseinsefindiasite.Buthow,idontknow.Anybodymaypleaseguideme.
Withregards
BijaySarkar
M09748510409

bijaysarkar
...

Backtotop

Posted:FriMar05,20105:43amPostsubject:

DearSir,
Joined:14Dec2009
Posts:314

Thefileisattachedherewithandcompletewithinputdataof370rows/LoadCombination.Youjust
clickonthe"Clickonme..."buttonandseetheoutputresult.Input&Outpurareonthesamesheet
:Sheet1.Pleasecontactmeforanyproposaltoenhancetheprogram.Pleasealsointimateforany
kindoferrorobservedbyanybody.Ihavetestcheckedtheprogrambygeneratingseveralinteraction
curveswhicharesimilartothatofSP16.Theprogramwillalsoworkforanyvalueofp,Fck,Fy,d'/D
beyondtheboundaryofSP16orIS:456.
withregards,
BijaySarkar
Kolkata
M09748510409

Warning:Makesureyouscanthedownloadedattachmentwithupdatedantivirustoolsbeforeopeningthem.
Theymaycontainviruses.
Useonlinescannershereandheretouploaddownloadedattachmenttocheckforsafety.

COLUMNDESIGNCHECK.zip
Description:

Interactioncurves&RCCcolumnDesign

Filename:

COLUMNDESIGNCHECK.zip

Filesize:

62.93KB

Download

Downloaded: 3221Time(s)
Backtotop
bijaysarkar
...

Posted:SatMar06,20105:04pmPostsubject:

DearSirs,
Joined:14Dec2009
Posts:314

Somecomments/observationsareexpected.Afteruploading,nosuchcomment/observationismade.
Somebodytoldmeviasmsonmymobilethattheinteractioncurvesarenotbeinggeneratedin
Sheet3.Iamreplyingtothatquery:Theinteractioncurveportionhasbeendisconnectedasthe
sameisnotrequiredforgeneraldesignpurpose.Imaydiscusstheissueoruploadanotherconnected
fileifsefiansreallywanttoknowhowtogeneratetheinteractioncurves.Butuntillnow,ievendont
knowwhethertheexcelfileisworkingintheseians'scomputer.
Iwanttohighlightanotherpointinthisregard,normallywearerestrictedtodesignthecolumns
basedonSP16curveswiththenexthighervalueofd'/Dmakingmorecosttoourdesignaswehave
nocurveinSP16forexactvalueofd'/D(manyatimehappens).Thisprogramhasalsobeen
preparedwiththatconceptiontokeepatparwithSP16.Alittlemodificationintheprogramwill
designthecolumnswithexactvalueofd'/Dthuseconomisingthestructure.Ithink,thentherewill
benoproblemsofartheIScodesareconcerned.Sirshere,maypleaseindicatewhethersuchdesign
isacceptablebyIScodes.
Lastly,iwillrequesteverybody,toatleastsaywhethertheprogramisrunningintheircomputeras
expected.
Expectingreply!!!

http://www.sefindia.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7123&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=0&sid=47c4bb04743de6c54d231724dc3678c5

2/5

4/9/2015

www.sefindia.org::ViewtopicINTERACTIONCURVES&DESIGNOFRCCCOLUMN
withregards,
BijaySarkar
M09748510409
Kolkata

Backtotop
santoshbiraj
SEFIRegulars

Posted:SunMar07,20107:26pmPostsubject:

Hello,
Joined:05Jun2008
Posts:36

Ijustsawyoursheetbutnotindepth.Iappreciateyoureffort.Butithinkyoushouldexplainthe
calculationsalittleistheprogramabletofindtherequiredpt?basedonthesectionandotherinput
orweshouldgivetrials?inshorthowisthecalculationmadeinthesheetsothatitwillbeeasierto
understand.

Backtotop
sukanta.adhikari
GeneralSponsor

Posted:MonMar08,20104:20amPostsubject:

DearShriBijay,
Itooappreciateurgoodwork...buttoreviewurexcelsheetweneedsomeexplanation..howuhave
generatedtheinteractiondiagram...thestrainconsideredforcompressionandbending...andthen
averagingit...otherwisewehavetocheckprecedentanddependentinexcelandthenunderstandur
excelsheet...whichiscumbersome..
Regards,
S.Adhikari
Joined:26Jan2003
Posts:679

bijaysarkarwrote:
DearSirs,
Somecomments/observationsareexpected.Afteruploading,nosuchcomment/observation
ismade.Somebodytoldmeviasmsonmymobilethattheinteractioncurvesarenotbeing
generatedinSheet3.Iamreplyingtothatquery:Theinteractioncurveportionhasbeen
disconnectedasthesameisnotrequiredforgeneraldesignpurpose.Imaydiscusstheissue
oruploadanotherconnectedfileifsefiansreallywanttoknowhowtogeneratethe
interactioncurves.Butuntillnow,ievendontknowwhethertheexcelfileisworkinginthe
seians'scomputer.
Iwanttohighlightanotherpointinthisregard,normallywearerestrictedtodesignthe
columnsbasedonSP16curveswiththenexthighervalueofd'/Dmakingmorecosttoour
designaswehavenocurveinSP16forexactvalueofd'/D(manyatimehappens).This
programhasalsobeenpreparedwiththatconceptiontokeepatparwithSP16.Alittle
modificationintheprogramwilldesignthecolumnswithexactvalueofd'/Dthuseconomising
thestructure.Ithink,thentherewillbenoproblemsofartheIScodesareconcerned.Sirs
here,maypleaseindicatewhethersuchdesignisacceptablebyIScodes.
Lastly,iwillrequesteverybody,toatleastsaywhethertheprogramisrunningintheir
computerasexpected.
Expectingreply!!!
withregards,
BijaySarkar
M09748510409
Kolkata

Backtotop
bijaysarkar
...

Posted:MonMar08,20108:34amPostsubject:

DearSirs,
Joined:14Dec2009
Posts:314

Attachedherewithafilecontainingdescriptionoftheinput,output&workingmethodsothatucan
understandthefileforuse.Iwillgivemoredetailsinthenextround.

WithRegards,
BijaySarkar
M09748510409
Kolkata

Warning:Makesureyouscanthedownloadedattachmentwithupdatedantivirustoolsbeforeopeningthem.
Theymaycontainviruses.
Useonlinescannershereandheretouploaddownloadedattachmenttocheckforsafety.

DISCUSSIONONEXCELFILE.zip

http://www.sefindia.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7123&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=0&sid=47c4bb04743de6c54d231724dc3678c5

3/5

4/9/2015

www.sefindia.org::ViewtopicINTERACTIONCURVES&DESIGNOFRCCCOLUMN
Description:

DISCUSSIONONINPUT,OUTPUTANDWORKINGMETHODOLOGY

Filename:

DISCUSSIONONEXCELFILE.zip

Filesize:

4.98KB

Download

Downloaded: 1913Time(s)

bijaysarkar
...

Backtotop

Posted:WedMar10,20108:34amPostsubject:

DearSirs,
Joined:14Dec2009
Posts:314

1stofall,ithanktoallaboveandallothersefians.ThankstoErSantoshbiraj&Ersukantaadhikary
fortheirresponseandenquiry.Somequeriesfromthemareyettherependingformetoreply.Im
replyingasfollows:
1.CalculationsarebeingmadethroughaprogrampreparedinVisualBasicMacro.
2.AllstraindataconsideredareasperIS456/SP16.However,imfurnishingthedataherealso.
3.Forpurelyaxialcompression,strainconsideredis0.002.
4.Forbendingcompression,twocasesarises:(i)WhenNeutralAxisformedremainswithinthe
crosssection,(ii)WhenNeutralAxisformedisoutsidethecrosssection.
5.Forcase(i)i.e.whenNAremainswithinthesection,compressionstrainconsideredatthehighly
compressededgeis0.0035.
6.Forcase(ii)i.e.whenNAisformedoutsidethesection,compressionstrainconsideredatthehighly
compressededgevariesdependingonthedistanceoftheneutralaxisfromthehighlycompressed
edgewhichislessthan0.0035buthigherthan0.002andarebeingcalculatedforeachofthecase.
7.Nocompressionstrainisaveragedout,allarecalculatedateachofthelocationsseparatelyfor
concreteaswellasreinforcementsteelforcalculatingstress/forcecapacities.
8.Interactiondiagramscanbegeneratedbyyourselffromthegivensheet:sheet1
9.PutPAU=0,1,2,3,4.......400.FeelthatatsomeincreasedvalueofPAU,momentcapacityofthe
sectionwillbezero.ChooseB,D,d,p(percentsteel),Fck,Fyinsuchawaythatgraphparameter
d/D,Fy,p/Fckareasperyourdesiredvalues.
10.FillallothercellswithsamevaluesofB,D,d,p(percentsteel),Fck,Fy.
11.GiveanyvalueofMAY&MAZ.Thesehavenothingtodowiththegraph.Iwillsayutokeepit1
or2inallthecells.
12.Nowwithallyourinputcellsready,putanENDatnextrowofyourdatarangeinthecolumnof
PAU.
13.Clicknowtoruntheprogramandallyouroutputdataarenowhavecomeup.Seethatatsome
increasedvalueofPAU,correspondingvalueofMUYis0.CopyPAU&MUYuptothatMUY=0value
andpasteinseparatesheet.Alternatively,youcanalsointerconnectthetwosheetsbyexcelsheet
inbuiltfunction.IfMUYisnotyetzerowithupto400MTPAUvalue,increasethePAUvaluessothat
outputMUYiszero.
14.Morethedatatoprocess,moretimemaybetakentocalculate.Dontbenervous.Letthecursor
changefrombusytonormal.
15.NowcalculatePAU/FckBD&MUY/FckBD2whichareyourintendedYaxis&Xaxisvaluesinline
withSP16withdesiredparametersofFy,p/Fck,d/D.
16.Drawachart/graphwiththesevaluestoseetheinteractioncurvefortheparameters.
17.Ithink,allthequeriesmadeabovehavebeennowcoveredexceptgenerationof
Pleasefeedbackmewhetheritisworking.
BijaySarkar
M9748510409
Kolkata

Backtotop

Displaypostsfromprevious: AllPosts

OldestFirst

Go

www.sefindia.orgForumIndex>SEFIGeneral
Discussion

AlltimesareGMT

Gotopage1,2,3,4,5Next

Page1of5
Jumpto: SEFIGeneralDiscussion
Translation: Translatetopic

Go

Go

Youcannotpostnewtopicsinthisforum
Youcannotreplytotopicsinthisforum
Youcannotedityourpostsinthisforum
Youcannotdeleteyourpostsinthisforum
Youcannotvoteinpollsinthisforum
Youcannotattachfilesinthisforum
Youcandownloadfilesinthisforum

http://www.sefindia.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7123&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=0&sid=47c4bb04743de6c54d231724dc3678c5

4/5

4/9/2015

www.sefindia.org::ViewtopicINTERACTIONCURVES&DESIGNOFRCCCOLUMN
2003,2008SEFINDIA,IndianDomainRegistration

StructuralEngineeringForumofIndia
Like Youlikethis.

StructuralEngineeringForumofIndia
Yesterdayat12:10am

Partsofstaircase

Youand66,002otherslikeStructuralEngineeringForumofIndia.

Facebooksocialplugin

tsunami
earthquake

TorontoStarFutureearthquake,tsunamilikelytostartoffBritishColumbia'sHaidaGwaii
MTV.comWatchTheRockShaveAMan'sBeardInAnEarthquakeSimulator

http://www.sefindia.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7123&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=0&sid=47c4bb04743de6c54d231724dc3678c5

poweredby
poweredby

5/5