Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
The fact that some folks may attend films as resisting spectators
does not really change the reality that most of us, no matter how
sophisticated our strategies of critique and intervention, are usually
seduced, at least for a time, by the images we see on the screen. They
have power over us and we have no power over them.1
IN T R O D U C T IO N
The first shot of the Finnish film Riisuttu mies (Easy Livin, also known as:
Man Exposed, 2006) shows a young man lying on a mattress. He makes the
following statement:
A pig says oink oink.
A sheep says baa baa.
A donkey says hee-haw hee-haw.
My name is Antti Pitknen. I weigh 120 kilos and 206 grams. I have
a lot of problems. A whole lot.
The scenes that follow depict the same man having fun and being a bit
rowdy. He plays in a rock band, drinks with his friends, rides a bicycle
through the city. The film then cuts to him in bed with his wife. They are
startled as they hear the church bells and realise they are late for a service;
he is supposed to preside.2
This can be contrasted with the beginning of Ingmar Bergmans
Nattvardsgsterna (Winter Light, 1962). That film begins with a shot of
Tomas, the protagonist, in a religious service. The shot fades from black
The question of the image of the clergy in film was important from early
on. The production guidelines of Will Hays, which were approved in 1927,
included a ban on swearing, any suggestive nudity, ridicule of the clergy,
anti-patriotism, and so on. (Johnston 2000, 35). Until the mid-1960s,
portrayals of Catholic priests, nuns, rituals, and objects on the screen
[in films from the US] were checked over to make sure that they were
accurate and gave no offence. (McDannell 2008, 19). The situation was
different on the other side of the Atlantic, for example in the films of the
Swedish director Ingmar Bergman. There one could find quite nuanced
portrayals that some might even find offensive, like the doubting Tomas
in Nattvardsgsterna.
In recent years, some scholars have expressed worries over the image
of clergy in the media, including film. In Hollywood vs. America Michael
Medved raises concerns about the lack of positive images of priests and
clergy in recent Hollywood films.3 He argues that clergy and priests
are usually portrayed as conmen or clowns which serves to encourage
skepticism towards religious institutions.4
Duncan Forrester writes in Truthful Action: In the media, ministers
commonly appear as figures of fun if they appear at all. It is seldom
that we see a minister as a person with a recognised role and function
164 ST U D IE S
IN
WO R L D CH R IST IA N IT Y
166 ST U D IE S
IN
WO R L D CH R IST IA N IT Y
168 ST U D IE S
IN
WO R L D CH R IST IA N IT Y
Why a pastor?
The friends are sitting around a dinner table and Hanna-Rikka comes
to the table with a bottle of wine and a basket of bread. Bread and
wine, she announces, making a reference to Holy Communion. However,
she declines an invitation to lead the group in a prayer.5 An interesting
exchange then develops between Ari and Hanna-Riika:
Ari: Why did you want to be a priest?
Hanna-Riika: Why did you want to be a doctor [dismissively]?
A: Nice job. Good money. [. . . ]
Riku: People spend 90% of their time continuing with something they
once started. Someone said that.
A: For me its 100%.
H-R: Why? Do you think theres anything good and true in life?
R: The right answer is Jesus.
H-R: Christianity is the whole damn answer for me. What is it to Ari?
Ilona: Not all people believe in something.
H-R: Yes they do, or theyre not human.
A: I must be a monkey then.
Everbody but Hanna-Riika laughs and she leaves the table upset. The scene
serves to illustrate that she sees Christianity as a firm foundation to build
upon. At the same time she seems to be a bit defensive when it comes to
her faith, at least in the present company.
Summary
The portrait of the pastor in this film is most interesting. Her religiosity
is strongly emphasised as is her position as a pastor. This is done through
dialogue and visual cues. Of the pastors discussed in this article she is
probably the most frail, the most human and the most sympathetic. She is
shown drunk, she lives with a man but doesnt love him. She has an affair
with her best friends boyfriend. And it is hinted that there are difficult
experiences in her past.
It is obvious that she finds strength in her faith and sees Christianity
as something important. At one point in the film, before deciding if she
should have an affair with Ari, she is shown praying. In the scene a cross
that she wears around her neck is almost constantly visible in the frame.
This serves to affirm her religiosity and is a moral critique. The pastor isnt
perfect.
Italiensk for begyndere (Italian for Beginners) is a Danish dogma film from
the year 2000. It was directed by Lone Scherfig. The film was well received
by critics and audiences and won the Silver Bear in Berlin. This is a
romantic comendy about a group of people in their thirties who meet in
Italian classes. One of these is Andreas, a young widower. He is a pastor in
his first post, a temporary position. He has replaced an older pastor called
Wredmann, who was sent on leave.
Pastoral care and a Christmas service
One of the most memorable scenes in the film takes place in a swimming
pool at the hotel where Andreas stays. An employee of the hotel, Jrgen
Pedersen, aproaches him to discuss a problem. The scene shows how the
pastor is trusted and shows an example of pastoral care in a place not
usually associated with that activity. Andreas responds to him in a very
personal and warm manner. They speak of prayer, what one can pray
about. The scene ends with the following exchange:
Jrgen: One can tell you are a pastor.
Andreas: Can one?
A: Its not going very well, though.
J: No. [Pause] But it will.
As if to emphasise this, the film cuts to a service at Christmas. Andreas
stands facing the altar and behind him every seat is filled. The congregation
sings a Christmas hymn, but the pastor doesnt sing. The service finishes,
the people in the congregation wish each other merry Christmas. Many
come to Andreas and encourage him to apply for a permanent post. This
scene serves to illustrate two points, first that things are changing for the
better and the importance of the church during feasts such as Christmas.
Again there is a change of scene as the film cuts to a Christmas meal
in the hotel restaurant. Andreas eats alone and is lonely. The audience
witnesses a transition from Andreas the pastor to Andreas the widower.
He walks to the back and asks if he can join the staff. He needs company.
170 ST U D IE S
IN
WO R L D CH R IST IA N IT Y
Now the situation has been reversed. Jrgen, who has earlier sought and
received pastoral care from Andreas, is in a consoling role and gives the
pastor advice about how to cope with grief. And the viewer gets the feeling
that the pastor is human too. He needs companionship and someone to
help him cope.
Summary
Andreas is one of the two priests in these films who has recently
finished his training. His understanding of the church and its mission is
exemplified by the scene where he has a discussion with the former priest
in his congregation. There he expresses hope for the church.
The film shows him growing in his work. Church attendance goes
up and his position changes from being temporary to permanent. It is
also evident that people seem to trust him; they approach him with
encouragement to apply for the post. He is sought out for pastoral care,
in the church and outside it. His background gives the character added
depth. The same is hinted at with Hanna-Riika in Levottomat. It is obvious
that he has had a difficult past, but he seems to have dealt with it in a
constructive manner. Thus there emerges an image of a pastor who is not
perfect, but who is aware of his limitations and is trying to do well.
M IFF O
These are but a few depcitions of pastors from an extensive corpus. There
are many other intriguing pastors in recent Nordic films. We cannot see
the whole picture by looking at four films, but we glimpse a part of it. And
this shows that the image is more diverse than we might think at first. In
some cases it is negative, in other cases positive.
172 ST U D IE S
IN
WO R L D CH R IST IA N IT Y
The pastors
Six of the pastors are men, one is a woman. This need not reflect the
situation in Nordic films in general, but rather the choice of films. However
there are more Nordic films in which male pastors are the protagonists.
In these four films we have both young and old priests. There are four
young pastors and three middle-aged or old. It seems that the general
picture of the young priests is that they are inexperienced but energetic,
well educated and willing to do a lot at their job. On the other hand the
picture of the older priests is rather negative, especially in Sndagsengler
and Italiensk for begyndere. And while Johannes in Sndagsengler appears
to be quite good at his job, his family life suffers and he is quite moralistic.
Thus the image of the younger pastors seems to be more positive than that
of their older colleagues.
Generally speaking the image of the pastor is more human than holy.
Most of them make mistakes and deal with problems, small and large.
Most admit their faults and take responsibility. Some deal with grief and
difficulty, with loss. Some are confused. All ends well (except perhaps in
Sndagsengler). In this respect it might be of interest to compare films
about pastors with Jesus films. In Jesus films we can discern a development
from a far-away-divine-Jesus in the 1950s to an ever more human Jesus
in recent years. Perhaps a similar development can be discerned in films
about pastors.
What about the pastors as believers? In Sndagsengler we see that
faith seems to be a large part of the life of Johannes and his family,
exemplified in the prayers at the table. In Italiensk for begyndere the pastor
is asked whether he prays and answers promptly that he does (otherwise
he couldnt be a pastor) but he is not shown praying. In Levottomat we hear
Hanna-Riike state that for her the Christian faith is basic for existence, she
is shown praying and religious symbols are shown as being important for
her. It is interesting that the pastor who is shown as being most frail is
also the one who seems to be the most sincere believer. In Miffo we dont
have that many indicators of this, and there is no scene where Tobias prays
outside of the church.
The church
What about the church in general? What is its situation and where is it
headed? Sndagsengler shows a full church that seems to be very important
for the society, the pastors are respected in the community. At the same
time the pastors are criticised as described above.
174 ST U D IE S
IN
WO R L D CH R IST IA N IT Y
film, ethical themes such as pre-natal testing and abortion are explored
and this is put in the context of guilt and repentance. Riisuttu mies is
a Finnish film that explores the tension between image and identity in
the context of vocation. Finally there is the Norwegian film DeUsynlige
(Troubled Water, 2008), directed by Erik Poppe, which connects grief,
repentance and guilt creatively. In each of these films a pastor is in a
central role and in many cases we can relate the function and presence
of the pastor to the exploration of these themes.
C O N C L U SIO N
The image of the pastor in these films is both complex and nuanced. For
that reason it might be desirable to refrain from using terminology such as
positive and negative when discussing the image of the pastors in films for
that might be to simplify matters too much.
We can see a movement in these films towards an ever more human
portrayal of the pastor. Rather than being an image of perfect morals and
living, the pastor is a typical human being, imperfect and frail like the rest
of us. Sndagsengler can on one level be seen as an attempt to address and
defy such a demand of perfection. In the other three films we have pastors
who deal with a variety of problems, ranging from infidelity in Levottomat,
to grief in Italiensk for begyndere and cowardice in Miffo. At the same time
the pastors in these three films are all quite likable.
It seems that some of these films play with our expectations about the
pastor and circumvent them. There is a reversal of expectations. Miffo is a
good example of this. It portrays the inexperienced pastor in a comic way
but can also be seen as a critique of the pastor who is self-absorbed and
not really concerned about others. Sndagsengler can be seen as a similar
critique of the demand for perfection. It is clear that more examples of
female pastors in films are needed and it will be interesting to compare the
portrayal of male and female pastors in films. Last but not least, in many of
the films the pastor is used as a vehicle to explore questions about ethics
and life in depth and perhaps from a different angle than might otherwise
be possible.
rni Svanur Danelsson (cand. theol.) is a member of the Deus ex cinema
group and is one of the two editors of the Deus ex cinema website and
journal (www.dec.is). He is also a doctoral student in Systematic Theology
at the University of Iceland, and is currently working on a dissertation on
theology and film. arnida@hi
1. Quoted in Lynch 2005: 83. Cf. Gordon Lynch who writes: Concern about media can
often reflect an underlying belief that the ideas and images we receive through the media
can in some way shape our own thoughts, attitudes and actions (Lynch 2005: 823).
2. Later in the film we learn the context of the statement Antti makes at the beginning.
Most of the film is a flashback. Thus it serves as a background that explains his actions at
the end of the film.
3. Quoted in Lynch 2005: 85.
4. Ibid.
5. Here we see a contrast between Johannes and Hanna-Riika. Table prayers were an
integral part of the family life in the household in Sndagsengler. Later in the film there is a
very strong scene where we see Hanna-Riika praying, so it is evident that she is a religious
person. But for some reason the pastor does not want to pray at this point.
6. In an informative article about the in the Swedish anthology Film och religion Maria
Kchen discusses her own reception of Miffo and calls Tobias a teddy bear tyrant (Kchen
2005).
REFERENCES
Films
Adams bler (Anders Thomas Jensen: 2005)
DeUsynlige (Erik Poppe: 2008)
Forbrydelser (Annette K. Olesen: 2004)
Italiensk for begyndere (Lone Scherfig: 2000)
Levottomat (Aku Louhimies: 2000)
Miffo (Daniel Lind Lagerlf: 2003)
Nattvardsgsterna (Ingmar Bergman: 1962)
Princess (Anders Morgenthaler: 2006)
Riisuttu mies (Aku Louhimies: 2006)
Sndagsengler (Berit Nesheim: 1996)
DOI: 10.3366/E1354990109000471