Sunteți pe pagina 1din 2

Before Fatima ® died she was pleased with Abo Bakr ® !

(faitima(as) ) was angry about what abu bakr did untill she died

Before Fatima ® died she was pleased with Abo Bakr ® !

Regarding the accusations that Sayydina Fatima died angry with Sayyidina Abu Bakr. We
say: It is false and untrue, and only a man devoid of sense would believe such a thing. When
looking at a narration, one must look at all of them as a whole. Even if we suppose that
Sayyidina Fatima was angry at Sayyidina Abu bakr we must note that Fatima was not
omniscient, and her understanding was as limited as that of any other human: just as Musa
lost patience with Khidr, because he did not understand the latters actions, so Fatima lost
patience with Abu Bakr, since she misunderstood the latters actions. Allah be pleased with
them both.

And note that Musa - peace be upon him- is Infallible.

"When Fatima became ill, Abu Bakr came to her and asked for the permission to enter. So Ali
said: "O Fatima, this is Abu Bakr asking for permission to enter." She answered: "Do you
want me to give him permission?" He said: "Yes." So she allowed him (to enter), and he came
in seeking her pleasure, so he told her: "By Allah, I only left my home and property and my
family seeking the pleasure of Allah and His messenger and you, O Ahl ul Bait. So he talked
to her until she was pleased with him." (Sunan Al-Bayhaqi, with an authentic chain)

^^^this is islam this is brotherhood this is forgiveness and they call such a man a "munafiq!
may allah curse u products of majoos and jews o Rafidha Shia !

The truth of the matter is that people--even loved ones--get in arguments. We have yet to see
a husband who does not get in arguments with his wife. Siblings fight all the time, and parents
get angry at their children. We even have the example of Prophet Musa (‫ )عليه السلم‬who lost
patience with Khidr (‫)عليه السلم‬, and yet we find that these are amongst the best of people as
mentioned in the Quran. Abu Bakr (‫ضى ال عنه‬ ّ ‫ )ر‬and Umar (‫ضى ال عنه‬ ّ ‫ )ر‬got in arguments, and
yet we know that they were best of friends. Likewise, we believe that Ali (‫ضى ال عنه‬ ّ ‫ )ر‬got in
arguments with Abu Bakr (‫ضى ال عنه‬ ّ ‫ )ر‬and Umar (‫ضى ال عنه‬ ّ ‫)ر‬. The Shia use the Hadith about
whoever makes Fatima (‫ضى ال عنها‬ ّ ‫ )ر‬angry makes the Prophet (‫ )صّلى ال عليه وآله وسّلم‬angry.
The Shia believe that the same is true of Ali (‫ضى ال عنه‬ّ ‫)ر‬, that whoever makes him angry also
makes the Prophet (‫ )صّلى ال عليه وآله وسّلم‬angry. Likewise, the Ahlus Sunnah believes that
whoever upsets the Sahabah makes the Prophet (‫ )صّلى ال عليه وآله وسّلم‬angry. Thus, the Hadith
about angering Fatima (‫ضى ال عنها‬
ّ ‫ )ر‬must be taken into the appropriate context.

S-ar putea să vă placă și