Sunteți pe pagina 1din 324

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



1&341&$5*7"4%&-"#*05*$"&/*#&30".3*$"

1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDBEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE
0SHBOJ[BDJO.VOEJBMEFMB4BMVE 0140.4
1SJNFSBFEJDJOFOFTQBPM BHPTUPEF
"WFOJEB1SPWJEFODJB 1JTP 1SPWJEFODJB$BTJMMB5 4BOUJBHP $IJMF
5FMGPOP 
'BY 

IUUQXXXQBIPPSHTQBOJTICJPIPNFIUN
CJPFUJDB!DIJPQTPNTPSH
3FHJTUSPEF1SPQJFEBE*OUFMFDUVBM/P
*4#/
%JTFPZEJBHSBNBDJO'BCJPMB)VSUBEP$TQFEFT
*NQSFTPFO"OESPT*NQSFTPSFT
*NQSFTPFO$IJMF
/JOHVOBQBSUFEFFTUBQVCMJDBDJO JODMVZFOEPFMEJTFPEFMBDVCJFSUB QVFEFTFSSFQSPEVDJEB 
BMNBDFOBEBPUSBOTNJUJEBQPSNFEJPBMHVOP ZBTFBFMDUSJDP RVNJDP NFDOJDP QUJDP
EFHSBCBDJOPGPUPDPQJB TJOBVUPSJ[BDJOQSFWJBEFMFEJUPS

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



1&341&$5*7"4%&-"#*05*$"
&/*#&30".3*$"
-FP1FTTJOJt$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOFt'FSOBOEP-PMBT
$PPSEJOBEPSFT

5SBEVDDJO
"EBJM4PCSBM.BSB4UFMB(POBMWFT.BSUB(MVLNBO
&EJDJOFOFTQBPM
MWBSP2VF[BEB



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



OEJDF

&MEFTBGPEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWBJCFSPBNFSJDBOBFOCJPUJDB
"EWFSUFODJBQBSBMPTMFDUPSFTEFFTUFMJCSP



*OUSPEVDDJO



1*
3FnFYJPOFTEFTEFFMDPOUFYUPJCFSPBNFSJDBOP



&MDPOUFYUPIJTUSJDPEFMBCJPUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB
%JFHP(SBDJB
*OUSPEVDDJO
&MQFSPEPQSJNJUJWPZMBQPDBEFMEFTDVCSJNJFOUPMBUJDBEFMEPO
&MQSPCMFNBUJDPEFMBDPORVJTUBMBTSB[POFTNPSBMFTEFMEFTQPUJTNP
-BQPDBDPMPOJBMMBUJDBEFMQBUFSOBMJTNP
-BQPDBEFMBJOEFQFOEFODJBMBTWJDJTJUVEFTEFMBUJDBEFMB
BVUPOPNBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB
3FGFSFODJBT
-PTEJTDVSTPTEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB
+PT"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDB1SF[
*OUSPEVDDJO
3FDFQDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFOMBEDBEBEF
-BBTJNJMBDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFOMBEDBEBEF
-BSFDSFBDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFOMBEDBEBEF
$PODMVTJO
3FGFSFODJBT
-B0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE 014
ZMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
'FSOBOEP-PMBT
*NQMJDBDJOEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE 014

&EVDBDJOZFOUSFOBNJFOUP
*OWFTUJHBDJOZBCPHBDB
%FTBGPTQBSBFMGVUVSP
3FGFSFODJBT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
























-BCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBZFO$PMPNCJB
"MGPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS 4+
6CJDBDJOEFMUFNB
*NQBDUPEFMBCJPUJDBFOMBDVMUVSBVOJWFSTBMDPOUFNQPSOFB
1SJNFSBFUBQBEFMBCJPUJDBFO-BUJOPBNSJDBiFMUSBTQMBOUFw
5SBTQMBOUFZEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDBFO-BUJOPBNSJDB
4FHVOEBFUBQBDPOTPMJEBDJPOEFMBCJPUJDBFO-BUJOPBNSJDB
3QJEBEJGVTJOEFMBCJPUJDBFO-BUJOPBNSJDB
1SPTZDPOUSBT
3FGFSFODJBT
6OBIJTUPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB&MEFTBGPBDUVBMBMB
QSPGFTJONEJDBZMBJOnVFODJBEFMBTFNQSFTBTGBSNBDPRVNJDBT
+BNFT%SBOF
-PTQSJODJQJPTEFMBCJPUJDB
&MQBQFMEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEF4BMVE 014

6OQSPZFDUPCJPUJDPFODVSTP
-BJOnVFODJBEFMBJOEVTUSJBGBSNBDVUJDB
$PODMVTJO

1**
3FnFYJPOFTEFTEFWPDFTQJPOFSBTFOMPTEJWFSTPTQBTFT
3FGFSFODJBTEFCJPUJDBFO"SHFOUJOB
+PT"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDB1SF[
*OUSPEVDDJO
$FOUSPTEFFTUVEJP
$PNJUT DPNJTJPOFTZDPOTFKPTEFUJDB
1PMUJDBTQCMJDBT
1VCMJDBDJPOFT
-BCJPUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT
+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP
1SFDVSTPSFTZBOUFDFEFOUFTJOJDJBMFT
$POUFYUPJOTUJUVDJPOBMEFMBCJPUJDBFO#PMJWJB
$PNJU/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB
3FMBDJPOFTJOUFSJOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
1VCMJDBDJPOFT
.PUJWBDJPOFTZPSJFOUBDJPOFTGVUVSBTEFM$/#
&M*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDB#PMJWJBOB 6$#

FO$PDIBCBNCB
"TPDJBDJO#PMJWJBOBEF#JPUJDBZ%FSFDIP(FOUJDP
$PODMVTJPOFT
#JCMJPHSBGB
6OBSBEJPHSBGBEFMBCJPUJDBFO#SBTJMWPDFTQJPOFSBT QSPHSBNBT
JOTUJUVDJPOBMFTZFEVDBUJWPT ZQFSTQFDUJWBT
-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
*OUSPEVDDJO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD








































-PTQSJNFSPTDPOHSFTPTEFCJPUJDBZTBMVEFO#SBTJM
-B4PDJFEBE#SBTJMFBEF#JPUJDB 4##

*OJDJBUJWBTFEVDBUJWBTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTCSBTJMFBT
UJDBEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJOFOTFSFTIVNBOPT 

6OBFWBMVBDJOQSPTQFDUJWB
3FGFSFODJBT
#JPUJDBFO$IJMF
.JHVFM,PUUPX
*OUSPEVDDJO
'POEPIJTUSJDP
-PTDPNJFO[PTEFMBCJPUJDB
*OTUJUVDJPOFT
%FMJCFSBDJPOFTCJPUJDBTFJOnVFODJBTDVMUVSBMFT
3FGFSFODJBT
#JPUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE
+PT3BNO"DPTUB4BSJFHP
6OBQFSTQFDUJWBEFTEF$VCBEFMOVFWPQBSBEJHNBEFSFMBDJPOFTTBOJUBSJBT
"QPSUFTEFTEF$VCBBMBCJPUJDBHMPCBMTVTUFOUBCMF
-BCJPUJDBDPNPOVFWPTBCFS{UJDBBQMJDBEBPNFUBUJDB 
$PODMVTJO
3FGFSFODJBT
%JOBNJTNPEFMEJMPHPCJPUJDPFO&TQBB
'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT
*OUSPEVDDJO
*OTUJUVUP#PSKBEF#JPUJDB *##

4FHVOEPQFSPEPEFMBCJPUJDBFO&TQBB
1FSPEPEFSFWJTJO QSPZFDDJOFJOUFHSBDJO
3FGFSFODJBT
1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB-BNFEJDJOBHFONJDB
FO.YJDPDPNPVOPEFMPTNBZPSFTSFUPTCJPUJDPT
(FSBSEP+JNOF[4ODIF[ $TBS'SBODJTDP-BSBMWBSF[Z"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP.OEF[
1MBOUFBNJFOUPEFMQSPCMFNB
-BDPOTUSVDDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFO.YJDP
-BCJPUJDBZMBQMBUBGPSNBEFMBNFEJDJOBHFONJDBFO.YJDP
3FnFYJPOFTmOBMFT
3FGFSFODJBT
3FGFSFODJBTMFHBMFT
)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ
.BSUB"TDVSSB
4JUVBDJOHFPHSmDB*OEJDBEPSFTEFNPHSmDPTZEFTBMVE FOUSFPUSPT
-FZFT EFDSFUPTEFM1PEFS&KFDVUJWPZSFTPMVDJPOFTNJOJTUFSJBMFT
"TPDJBDJPOFTDJWJMFT
$PNJUTEFUJDBZEFCJPUJDB
&OTFBO[B
1VCMJDBDJPOFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD











































$VSTPT KPSOBEBTZDPOHSFTPT
%FDMBSBDJO6OJWFSTBMTPCSF#JPUJDBZ%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT
$PODMVTJO
3FGFSFODJBT






#JPUJDBFO1FS
3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHB
*OUSPEVDDJO
)POPSJP%FMHBEP QSFDVSTPS
*OJDJPTEFMNPWJNJFOUPCJPUJDPQFSVBOP
-B"TPDJBDJO1FSVBOBEF#JPUJDB "41&#*0

"TQFDUPTMFHBMFT
-PTDPNJUTEFUJDBEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJOFOTBMVEFO1FS
&M*OTUJUVUPEF4BMVE$SJTUGPSJT%FOFLF *4%&/
QPSMBTFOEB
EFMBCJPUJDB 

$PODMVTJPOFT
3FGFSFODJBT



#JPUJDBFO1PSUVHBM
+PSHF#JTDBJBZ8BMUFS0TTXBME
*OTUJUVDJPOFT
"DUJWJEBEFTQSJODJQBMFT
1VCMJDBDJPOFT
-BFOTFBO[BEFMBCJPUJDB
*OWFTUJHBDJOCJPNEJDB
-FZFTEFJNQPSUBODJBCJPNEJDB
7ODVMPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
3FGFSFODJBT
%JSFDDJPOFT
#JCMJPHSBGB






















-BIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPUJDBFO3FQCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
.JHVFM4VB[P
"OUFDFEFOUFTFMOBDJNJFOUP
&UBQBEFGPSNBMJ[BDJO 
EFTBSSPMMP
*OUFSOBDJPOBMJ[BDJO
$SFDJNJFOUP FYUFOTJOZEFTBSSPMMP
"TQFDUPTMFHBMFT
-BTJUVBDJOBDUVBMEFMBCJPUJDBFO3FQCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
3FGFSFODJBT









1***
$VFTUJPOFTFTQFDmDBTSFMJHJOZNVKFSFT



#JPUJDBZSFMJHJOFO"NSJDB-BUJOB
.SDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT
i1VFOUFTBMGVUVSPwQVFOUFTDPNVOFT
{&YJTUFVODPOnJDUPFOUSFMBSB[OZMBSFMJHJOFOMBCJPUJDB 






PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





3FMJHJOZCJPUJDBFOVODPOUFYUPEFJOKVTUJDJBTQFSTJTUFOUFT
.TBMMEFMEPHNBUJTNP
#JPUJDBZUFPMPHBFOMBDVFTUJOEFMBUSBTDFOEFODJB
{)BCSVOBSFMJHJOJNQMDJUBFOMBCJPUJDB 
#JPUJDBMBJDBZCJPUJDBSFMJHJPTBFMEFTBGPEFMEJTDVSTP
#JPUJDBZSFMJHJOFMEFTBGPEFTVTMVHBSFTFOMBTPDJFEBE
3FGFSFODJBT









-BCJPUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NSJDB-BUJOBVOFOTBZPCJPHSmDP
ZHFOFBMHJDP
%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN
6OQBOPSBNBHFOFBMHJDP
&OUSFNEJDPTZUFMPHPT MBTNVKFSFTGFNJOJTUBT
&OUSFQSPUBHPOJTUBTBDBENJDBTFJOUFSMPDVUPSBTQCMJDBT
.VKFSFTZOVFWPTEFTBGPT
3FGFSFODJBT







1*7
1BTBEP QSFTFOUFZEFTBGPTGVUVSPT



6OBMFDUVSBDSUJDBEFMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
(FSNO$BMEFSO-FHBSEB
*EFOUJmDBOEPVOBQFSTQFDUJWBEFBDFSDBNJFOUP
&MUSBCBKPEFMPTQJPOFSPTEFMIVNBOJTNPNEJDP
6OBSFTQFUVPTBNJSBEBSFUSPTQFDUJWB
-BFNFSHFODJBEFMBSFnFYJOCJPUJDBBDFSDBEFDVFTUJPOFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT
-BBmSNBDJOEFJEFBMFTNPSBMFTZFMSJFTHPEFMiQBOnFUJTNPwCJPUJDP
-BBQFSUVSBEFMBCJPUJDBIBDJBMPTHSBOEFTUFNBTEFMBWJEB
-BCTRVFEBEFMFTUBUVUPFQJTUFNPMHJDPEFMBCJPUJDB
6OBPCTFSWBDJOmOBM
3FGFSFODJBT
6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWBQBSBJEFOUJmDBSEFTBGPTBQBSUJSEFMDPOUFYUP
IJTUSJDPIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOP
)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS
*OUSPEVDDJOTJUVBOEPFMDPOUFYUPIJTUSJDP
-BQFSTQFDUJWBVOJWFSTBMJTUBEFMBCJPUJDBSFTVSHFSFMBUJWJ[BEB
QFSPDPOGVFS[B
-BDPNQMFNFOUBDJOZFMQBSBMFMJTNPEFMPTODMFPTCJPUJDPT
JEFOUJmDBEPT
$PTUPTFDPONJDPTZTPDJBMFT
&WBMVBDJOHFOFSBM
'SFOUFBMBTBNFOB[BTQMBOFUBSJBTNFEJBOUFMBCJPUJDBZBEFNTEFFMMB
3FGFSFODJBT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD
























"MHVOPTSFUPTQBSBFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB
-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF
"MHVOPTQVOUPTEJHOPTEFSFnFYJO
6OBPCTFSWBDJOmOBM
3FGFSFODJBT





"QOEJDFT



4FMFDDJOEFQSPHSBNBTGPSNBUJWPTFOCJPUJDB



4FMFDDJOEFJOTUJUVDJPOFTEFCJPUJDB



4FMFDDJOEFQVCMJDBDJPOFTQFSJEJDBTEFCJPUJDB



1VCMJDBDJPOFTEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDB0140.4



4PCSFMPTBVUPSFTZUSBEVDUPSFT
"VUPSFT
5SBEVDUPSFT





PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD







&MEFTBGPEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWB
JCFSPBNFSJDBOBFOCJPUJDB
"EWFSUFODJBQBSBMPTMFDUPSFTEFFTUFMJCSP

PNPTFTFBMBFOMB*OUSPEVDDJO FTUFMJCSPFTGSVUPEFVOQSPMPOHBEPQSPDFTP
EFEJMPHPFJOUFSDBNCJPEFDPSSFTQPOEFODJBFOUSFEJGFSFOUFTJOUFSMPDVUPSFT&M
QSFTFOUFWPMVNFODPOUJFOFMBUSBEVDDJOSFWJTBEBEFDBQUVMPTJODMVJEPTFOFMWP
MVNFOi#JPUJDBOB*CFSPBNSJDB)JTUSJBF1FSTQFDUJWBTw -1FTTJOJZ$EF1EF
#SBDIJGPOUBJOF PSHBOJ[BEPSFT &EJDPFT-PZPMBZ$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUBSJP4P$BNJMP 
4BP1BVMP 
FEJUBEBZFOSJRVFDJEBDPOBQOEJDFT
-B DPOUSJCVDJO EFM 1SPHSBNB EF #JPUJDB EF MB 0SHBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF
MB4BMVE 014
EFSJWEFVOBJOWJUBDJOEF-FPDJS1FTTJOJBQBSUJDJQBSFOFMMJCSP
CSJOEBOEPMBQFSTQFDUJWBRVFPGSFDFFTUBBUBMBZBJOUFSOBDJPOBM&OVOBSFBMJEBEUBO
EJONJDBDPNPMBRVFFTUFWPMVNFOJOUFOUBmKBS QBSUFEFMPRVFTFQFOTZFTDSJ
CJEVSBOUFTVFMBCPSBDJOUJFOFBIPSBNFOPTVSHFODJB WJHFODJBPJNQPSUBODJB"M
FEJUBS MPTDPMBCPSBEPSFTEFM1SPHSBNBBQPSUBSPOTVFYQFSJFODJBFEJUPSJBMSFmOBOEP
ZNFKPSBOEPTJOUBYJT FTUJMPZQSPQJFEBEEFMMFOHVBKF TJONPEJmDBSBQSFDJBDJPOFTP
KVJDJPT EF WBMPS  FYDFQUP DVBOEP IBCB JOGPSNBDJPOFT JOFYBDUBT P FSSPSFT GDUJDPT
-BTBQPSUBDJPOFTEFMWBSP2VF[BEBZ"OESFBHVJMBZMBTNBTBBEFOTJOBMUFSBSZ
DPSSJHFOTJODPSSPNQFS&TOFDFTBSJPBEWFSUJSRVFFTUFWPMVNFOOPSFQMJDBMBTWFSTJPOFT
RVFDPOTFNFKBOUFUUVMPZQBSFDJEBJOUFODJODJSDVMBSOFOJOHMTZQPSUVHVT&TUB
MUJNB RVFUFOFNPTBMBWJTUBBMQSFQBSBSFTUBBEWFSUFODJB QSFTFOUBSFQFUJDJPOFTZ
EFUBMMFT RVF TMP QBSDJBMNFOUF IFNPT DPOTFSWBEP )FNPT BBEJEP JOGPSNBDJPOFT
RVFKV[HBNPTUJMFTZSFMFWBOUFTDPNPBQOEJDFTZSFGFSFODJBTBTJUJPT*OUFSOFURVF
FOSJRVFDFOFTUBWFSTJO
%FCFEFTUBDBSTFFOFTUFMJCSPMBIFUFSPHFOFJEBEEFMBTNJSBEBT/PFYJTUFVOJGPSNJ
EBEFOMPTQMBOUFBNJFOUPT5BNQPDPIBZIPNPHFOFJEBEFOMBEFOTJEBEJOUFMFDUVBM
EFMBTDPOUSJCVDJPOFT&MUFNBCJPUJDP FOSJHPSEFWFSEBE OPOBDJFTQPOUOFB
NFOUFFOUJFSSBTTVEBNFSJDBOBTZGVFSFDJCJEPEFNBOFSBEFTJHVBMFOMPTEJTUJOUPT
QBTFT 1BSUF EF MB CJPUJDB JCFSPBNFSJDBOB FT JNQPSUBDJO Z BEBQUBDJO "MHVOBT
 -PMBT ' FEJUPS
 
%JMPHPZDPPQFSBDJOFOTBMVE%JF[BPTEFCJPUJDBFOMB0144BO
UJBHPEF$IJMF 6OJEBEEF#JPUJDB0140.4

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

WPDFTRVFDMBNBOQPSNBZPSPSJHJOBMJEBEOPTJFNQSFTPOJOUFMFDUVBMNFOUFBUSBDUJWBT
PTPMWFOUFT-BWFSEBEFSBPSJHJOBMJEBEFTMBBMVEJEBQPSFMJOUFMFDUVBMNFYJDBOP-FP
QPMEP;FBDVBOEPEFDBRVF-BUJOPBNSJDBEFCBUFOFSmMPTPGBiTJONTw&MBGO
EFPSJHJOBMJEBE TVHFSB TFDPOGVOEFFOOVFTUSPFOUPSOPDPOMBCTRVFEBBGBOPTB
EFJEFOUJEBEQSPQJBBCBOEPOBOEPMPTEFSSPUFSPTEFMBDVMUVSBFVSPQFBZEFM*NQFSJP
EFM/PSUF"SHVNFOUBCBRVFIBDJFOEPCVFOBmMPTPGBiTJONTwTFIBDBimMPTPGB
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBwQVFTMPTHSJFHPT DVBOEPmMPTPGBCBOZDSFBCBO OPTFQSFHVOUBCBO
TJMPRVFIBDBOFSBHSJFHP CBCJMOJDPPFHJQDJP$POTUSVZFSPOVOJNQPOFOUFMFHBEP
QBSBMBIVNBOJEBEIBDJFOEPmMPTPGBiTJONTw$SFPRVFFMOGBTJTEFCFQPOFSTF
FOMBFYQSFTJOiCVFOBmMPTPGBw QPSRVFSFTVNFMBFYJHFODJBEFDBMJEBEZVOJWFSTBMJ
EBERVFUPEBUBSFBJOUFMFDUVBMTVQPOF
$POMBCJPUJDBPDVSSFBMHPQBSFDJEP%FFMMPEBOUFTUJNPOJPMBTQHJOBTRVFTJHVFO
-BNFOUBCMFNFOUF BWFDFTMBCTRVFEBEFPSJHJOBMJEBEZBVUFOUJDJEBETFSFEVDFB
QJOUPSFTDPTiBOUJTNPTwBOUJJNQFSJBMJTNP BOUJFVSPQFTNP BOUJJOUFMFDUVBMJTNP
'VFSB EFM QJOUPSFTRVJTNP DSJPMMJ[BOUF  UBM BDUJUVE OP TVFMF BDPNQBBSTF EF BQPS
UBDJPOFTRVFNFSF[DBOFOUSBSBMBDFSWPEFMBJOUFMFDUVBMJEBENVOEJBMDPOFOUJEBE
QSPQJB4JOBVUPDSUJDBUBMFTBGBOFTEFTFNCPDBOFOWFSCBMJTNPQBOnFUBSJPZEFNB
HHJDP)BZDBVTBTWBMJPTBTZEJHOBTEFFODPNJPEFHSBEBEBTQPSMBTVQFSmDJBMJEBE
ZMBEFNBHPHJBFOMBBDUJWJEBEQPMUJDBZMBQSPEVDDJOJOUFMFDUVBM&MMPIBDFEVEBS
EFMQSPZFDUPEFVOBCJPUJDBHFTUBEBFOZQBSB*CFSPBNSJDBZOPBQPSUBBSHVNFOUPT
QBSBVOEJMPHPTJOPDPOTJHOBTQBSBVOBMVDIB"MHVOBQFSTQFDUJWBDSUJDB NFTVSBEB 
TFFODVFOUSBFOFTUFWPMVNFO$POTJEFSBDJPOFTBEJDJPOBMFTQVFEFODPOTVMUBSTFFO
BMHVOBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTZTJUJPTXFC QPSFKFNQMP XXXQBIPPSHCJPFUJDBZXXX
VDIJMFDMCJPFUJDB RVFSFNJUFOBBCVOEBOUFNBUFSJBM

$PNPIPOFTUPUSBCBKPJOUFMFDUVBM TUFFTQFSBEFMEJMPHPDPOTVTMFDUPSFTZMFDUPSBT
BDFSDBSTFBVOBJNQPTJCMFQFSGFDDJO%FTPCSBTBCFORVJFOFTFTDSJCFOPFEJUBOMJCSPT
RVFMBMFUSBOVODBDBQUVSBUPUBMNFOUFFMQFOTBNJFOUP&OTVBQBSFOUFQFSNBOFODJB 
FTUTVKFUBBJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFTZNBMFOUFOEJEPT/POPTSFTUBNPTBOJOHVOBQPMNJDB
QFSPOPRVFSFNPTDSFBSEFCBUFQPSFMMEJDPBGOEFDSFFSOPTQSPUBHPOJTUBTEFVO
EFTBSSPMMPRVF QBSBCJFOPQBSBNBM OPEFQFOEFEFOBEJFFOQBSUJDVMBSQFSPTEF
VOBFWPMVDJODPNPMBRVFWBUJDJOBO1FTTJOJZEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOFFOTVDBQUVMPmOBM
&TBFWPMVDJOFTQPSBIPSBNTFTQFSBO[BRVFQSPOTUJDPZNTQSPGFDBRVFIFDIP
DPODSFUP

 -PMBT  ' 


 4PCSF BNFSJDBOJ[BE &O /PUBT BM .BSHFO &OTBZPT 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF  $PMFDDJO
5SBWFTB &EJUPSJBM$VBUSP7JFOUPT
 1PSFKFNQMP -PMBT ' FEJUPS
 
#JPUJDBZDVJEBEPEFMBTBMVE&RVJEBE $BMJEBE %FSFDIPT4BOUJB
HPEF$IJMF 1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPUJDB 0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





&MEFTBGPEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWBJCFSPBNFSJDBOBFOCJPUJDB"EWFSUFODJBQBSBMPTMFDUPSFTEFFTUFMJCSP

0CTSWFTFRVFFMUSBUBNJFOUPEFNVDIPTQBTFTGBMUBFOFTUBSFDPQJMBDJOEFQFSTQFD
UJWBT&MMPEFNVFTUSBMBOFDFTJEBEEFDPNQMFUBSMPRVFGBMUBFOVOBGVUVSBFEJDJO
BNQMJBEB1PSDJFSUP MBTPNJTJPOFTOPPCFEFDFOBOJOHOEFTJHOJPEFMPTFEJUPSFT
TJOPTPMBNFOUFBMBQSFNVSBDPORVFTFSFDPQJMFMNBUFSJBM1PSFTPFTUBFEJDJOOP
UJFOFMBQBMBCSBiIJTUPSJBwFOFMUUVMP QPSRVFEFSFDVFOUPIJTUSJDPUJFOFQPDPZT
NVDIPEFVOQFSTQFDUJWJTNPRVFFTOFDFTBSJPBTJNJMBS QPOEFSBSZDSJUJDBS
"QPSUBDJPOFTUJMFTTFFODVFOUSBOFOMBSFWJTUB"DUB#JPFUIJDB *44/
Z
VOBDSOJDBEFTVDFTPTSFMFWBOUFTEFTEFIBDFNTEFEPTMVTUSPTFOFMCPMFUO#JPUJDB
*OGPSNB *44/

+VOUPDPOMPTBHSBEFDJNJFOUPTBUPEPTRVJFOFTQBSUJDJQBSPOFOFTUBJOJDJBUJWBoFTQF
DJBMNFOUFMBTJFNQSFJHOPSBEBMBCPSFEJUPSJBMo EFCFBEWFSUJSTFRVFFTUFMJCSP BVO
DVBOEPQSPEVDJEPDPOFMBQPZPEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDBEFMB014 EFM$FOUSP
6OJWFSTJUBSJP 4P $BNJMP Z EFM$FOUSP*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO#JPUJDB
$*&#
EFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF OPDPNQSPNFUFBFTUBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTZUPEBTMBT
BmSNBDJPOFTTPOEFFYDMVTJWBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFRVJFOFTMBTFNJUFO

'FSOBOEP-PMBT

 "NCBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTEJTQPOJCMFTFOXXXQBIPPSHCJPFUJDB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





*OUSPEVDDJO

BEBOVFWPMJCSPUJFOFTVQSPQJBIJT
UPSJB NBSDBEBBWFDFTQPSVOQMB
OFBNJFOUP SBDJPOBM SJHVSPTP  DPNP MBT
EJTFSUBDJPOFT Z UFTJT  Z PUSBT EFTEF VOB
JOTQJSBDJO JOEJWJEVBM PSJHJOBM &TUF MJ
CSP 1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDB*CFSPBNF
SJDBOB TVSHJEFVOBOJNBEPDPMPRVJP
BDDJEFOUBM FOVOWJBKFFOUSF4P1BVMP
Z'P[EF*HVB[ DPOOVFTUSPBNJHPEF
DBNJOPTCJPUJDPT5SJTUSBN&OHFMIBSEU 
DVBOEPWJOPB#SBTJMQBSBQBSUJDJQBSFO
FM7$POHSFTP#SBTJMFPEF#JPUJDBFO
'P[ EF *HVB[ 1BSBO
 FO  %F
BMMQSPWJOPMBJOTQJSBDJOQBSBQSFQBSBS
VOWPMVNFOEFFOTBZPTRVFBHSVQBTFB
MPTQJPOFSPTSFTQPOTBCMFTEFMBEJGVTJO
EFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB FM$B
SJCFZMB1FOOTVMB*CSJDB
&OFMNFNPSBOEPFOFMDVBMFYQSFTCB
NPTFMPCKFUJWPEFFTUFQSPZFDUPEJKJNPT
BMPTDPMBCPSBEPSFTRVFMBCJPUJDBFNFS
HJ QSDUJDBNFOUF IBDFDVBUSPEDBEBT

DPNPVOBOVFWBSFBEF
MB FEVDBDJO Z EF MB TFOTJCJMJEBE UJDB
EFEJDBEB B MB QSFTFSWBDJO Z FM DVJEB
EP EF MB WJEB IVNBOB  F JODMVTP EF MB
WJEBDTNJDPFDPMHJDB BOUFMPTBWBODFT
UFDOPDJFOUmDPT FYUSBPSEJOBSJPT FO MBT
DJFODJBT EF MB WJEB Z EF MB TBMVE $BEB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

QBSUFEFMNVOEPUJFOFTVIJTUPSJBQFDV
MJBSFOUSNJOPTEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJP
UJDB EJTFBEBQPSEJWFSTBTQFSTPOBMJEB
EFT QJPOFSBT Z DPOUFYUPT DVMUVSBMFT  BT
DPNP QPS MBT DJSDVOTUBODJBT FTQFDmDBT
EFDBEBQBT/VFTUSPQSPZFDUPBQVOUB
BQSFTFOUBSFOTBZPTEFMPTJOWFTUJHBEPSFT
SFTQPOTBCMFTEFMBBQBSJDJOEFMBCJPUJ
DBFOTVTSFTQFDUJWBTSFHJPOFT EJDJFOEP
FO QSJNFSB QFSTPOB TVT JOUVJDJPOFT BT
DPNPTVTFYQFSJFODJBTZDPOUSJCVDJPOFT
QBSBTVEFTBSSPMMP
-B FTQFSBO[B FT QSFTFOUBS VOB IJTUPSJB
DSUJDB EF MBT EJTDVTJPOFT  DPOUSPWFSTJBT
Z QSFPDVQBDJPOFT EF VOB CJPUJDB RVF
GPSNTVQSPQJBJEFOUJEBEFOUJFSSBTMB
UJOPBNFSJDBOBT1BSBBMDBO[BSVOBEJGV
TJONTHSBOEF FMQSPZFDUP1FSTQFDUJWBT
EFMB#JPUJDB*CFSPBNFSJDBOBGVFQMBOFB
EP QBSB TFS QVCMJDBEP FO USFT JEJPNBT 
JOHMT FTQBPMZQPSUVHVT
&TUF MJCSP FT SFTVMUBEP EF EPT BPT EF
USBCBKP JOUFOTP  DPOUBDUPT Z EJMPHPT
oUFMFGOJDPTZQPS*OUFSOFUo DPSSFTQPO
EFODJBFTDSJUBPSFVOJPOFTDPOMPTBNJ
HPT EF MB DBVTB EJTQFSTPT QPS "NSJDB
-BUJOB FM$BSJCFZMB1FOOTVMB*CSJDB
0QUBNPT QPS BEPQUBS MB DBUFHPSB EF
i*CFSPBNSJDBiDPNPFYQSFTJOHFPHS





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

mDBJODMVTJWBHFOFSBM BKVTUBEBBMSFTVM
UBEP mOBM EF MBT DPOUSJCVDJPOFT EF MPT
QSFDVSTPSFTEFMBCJPUJDBFOFTUBTQBSUFT
EFM HMPCP /VFTUSB QFSTQFDUJWB EF CT
RVFEBEFCBTFSBCJFSUBFJODMVTJWBQBSB
QFSNJUJSMBQBSUJDJQBDJOEFVOONFSP
NBZPSEFQBTFT"VORVFOPUFOFNPTMB
QBSUJDJQBDJOEFUPEPTMPTEFMBSFHJO 
DPOUSBSJBNFOUFBOVFTUSPEFTFP FOVOB
FEJDJOTJHVJFOUFQPESFNPTJODMVJSNT
QBTFTRVFUFOHBOVOBIJTUPSJBCJPUJDB
RVFDPNVOJDBS$SFFNPTRVFMBQBSUJDJ
QBDJOEFEPDFOBDJPOFTFTZBVOMPHSP
ZTFBMBRVFOVFTUSPPCKFUJWPTFBMDBO[
DBTJ DPNQMFUBNFOUF -PT SFMBUPT BRV
QSFTFOUBEPT FOTVEJWFSTJEBEEFQVOUPT
EFWJTUB PGSFDFOVOBiGPUPHSBGBwEFMBT
NTFYQSFTJWBTSFBMJ[BDJPOFTZQFSTQFDUJ
WBTGVUVSBTEFMBCJPUJDBFOMBSFHJO
/VFTUSBDPODFQDJOEFFTUFUSBCBKPOPT
MMFW B EJWJEJS FM MJCSP FO USFT HSVQPT
EF DVFTUJPOFT &O VO QSJNFS CMPRVF
EF SFnFYJPOFT QSFTFOUBNPT FM DPOUFYUP
IJTUSJDP EF MB CJPUJDB IJTQBOPBNFSJ
DBOB %JFHP (SBDJB
 MPT EJTDVSTPT EF
MBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBZMBTSFGF
SFODJBTEFMBCJPUJDBFO"SHFOUJOB +PT
"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB1SF[
MB0S
HBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVEZ
MBCJPUJDB 'FSOBOEP-PMBT
MBCJPUJDB
FO"NSJDB-BUJOBZ$PMPNCJB "MGPOTP
-MBOP&TDPCBS
Z mOBMNFOUF VOBIJT
UPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB
-BUJOBEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFVOCJPFUJ
DJTUBOPSUFBNFSJDBOP +BNFT%SBOF

&O FM TFHVOEP HSVQP IBZ SFnFYJPOFT
EFTEF WPDFT QJPOFSBT EF EJWFSTPT QB
TFT #SBTJM -FP 1FTTJOJ Z $ISJTUJBO EF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

1 EF #BSDIJGPOUBJOF


 #PMJWJB +BWJFS
-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP
$IJMF .JHVFM
,PUUPX
$VCB +PT3BNO"DPTUB4B
SJFHP
 &TQBB 'SBODFTD "CFM Z /VSJB
5FSSJCBT
.YJDP $TBS-BSB "MCFSUP
"SFMMBOPZ(FSBSEP+JNOF[
3FQCMJDB
%PNJOJDBOB .JHVFM4VB[P
1BSBHVBZ
.BSUB"TDVSSB
1FS 3PCFSUP-MBOPT
;VMPBHB
 Z 1PSUVHBM +PSHF #JTDBJB Z
8BMUFS0TTXBME

&OFMUFSDFSCMPRVF QBSBQSPCBSMBBN
QMJUVEEFMBCJPUJDBFOMBSFHJO JODMVJ
NPTEPTDVFTUJPOFTFTQFDmDBTCJPUJDB
Z SFMJHJO FO "NSJDB -BUJOB .SDJP
'BCSJEPT"OKPT
ZCJPUJDBZNVKFSFTFO
"NSJDB-BUJOB %FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF
(VJMIFN
 &O MB DPODMVTJO QSFTFOUB
NPTUSFTUFYUPTRVFIBDFOVOBEJTDVTJO
QSPTQFDUJWBEFMNPWJNJFOUPCJPUJDPMB
JOUFSFTBOUF MFDUVSB DSUJDB EF (FSNO
$BMEFSO BDFSDB EF MB CJPUJDB MBUJOPB
NFSJDBOB  FM BOMJTJT EFM USBUBEP QPS
)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVSZMBSFnFYJOEFMPT
DPPSEJOBEPSFT TPCSF BMHVOPT EFTBGPT
QBSBFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPUJDBJCFSPBNF
SJDBOB
&TQFSBNPTRVFFTUFUSBCBKPTFBOPTMP
VOB JOEJDBDJO CJCMJPHSmDB EFM BMDBO
DF TJFNQSF DSFDJFOUF EF MB MJUFSBUVSB
CJPUJDB EF OVFTUSPT QBTFT  TJOP RVF
TF DPOWJFSUB BEFNT FO VOB SFGFSFODJB
IJTUSJDBGVOEBNFOUBMQBSBMPTRVFoFO
FM QSFTFOUF Z FM GVUVSPo JOWFTUJHVFO Z
FTUVEJFO MPT UFNBT SFMBDJPOBEPT DPO
MBIJTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB
FO*CFSPBNSJDB&OMPTBPTDPOP
DJNPT BMHVOPT FTGVFS[PT JOJDJBMFT QBSB
VO QBOPSBNB IJTUSJDP EF MB CJPUJDB





*OUSPEVDDJO

FOFMDPOUFYUPMBUJOPBNFSJDBOP3FDPS
EBNPT  FOUSF PUSBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT  VOB
FEJDJOFTQFDJBMEF#PMFUOEFMB0mDJOB
4BOJUBSJB 1BOBNFSJDBOB 0SHBOJ[B
DJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE  014

FO EPTUFYUPTEFMPTDPPSEJOBEPSFT
QVCMJDBEPT FO MPT QFSJEJDPT 4BEF FN
%FCBUFZ0.VOEPEB4BEFFO
ZVOONFSPNPOPHSmDPEFM+PVSOBMPG
.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZQVCMJDBEPFO
 /BUVSBMNFOUF  IB TJEP KVTUP B
QBSUJSEFFTUBMUJNBEDBEB MBQSJNFSB
EFMTJHMPWFJOUJVOP FOMBDVBMDPOUBNPT
DPOTJHOJmDBUJWPTBWBODFTFOFEVDBDJO
oDPOMBFTQFDJBMJ[BDJOZMBTNBFTUSBTo 

QVCMJDBDJPOFTZMBQSFTFODJBEFDPNJTJP
OFTZDPNJUTFONBUFSJBEFJOWFTUJHB
DJOFOTFSFTIVNBOPTPFOGVODJPOFT
DPOTVMUJWBT TPMJDJUBEBT QPS MPT HPCJFS
OPT 1BSDJBM DPNP FT  FM NFSP BDUP EF
EFNPTUSBSMPTOVFWPTBWBODFTCJPUJDPT
KVTUJmDBSBMBFYJTUFODJBEFVOBQVCMJDB
DJODPNPTUB
/VFTUSPT BHSBEFDJNJFOUPT NT TJODF
SPTBMPTDPMBCPSBEPSFT MPTiBNJHPTEF
MB DBVTB CJPUJDBw  RVJFOFT QFSNJUJFSPO
RVF mOBMNFOUF DPOWJSUJSBNPTFOSFB
MJEBEFMTVFPEFFTUFQSPZFDUPDVMUJWBEP
QPSNVDIPT




-PTDPPSEJOBEPSFT

 1")08)0IBQVCMJDBEPVOONFSPFTQF
DJBMTPCSFCJPUJDBFOTVCPMFUOPmDJBMFO 
BPTBOUFTEFFTUBCMFDFSFM1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBM
EF#JPUJDB&MONFSPQSFTFOUBWBSJPTBSUDV
MPTUSBEVDJEPTEFBVUPSFTEF&&66 $BOBE
Z&VSPQB&O"NSJDB-BUJOBIBZEBUPTBDFSDB
EFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDBFO"SHFOUJOB #SB
TJM $PMPNCJB $IJMF .YJDPZ1FS EFTEFMB
QFSTQFDUJWBEFMBUJDBNEJDB
 1FTTJOJ - 
i0EFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBCJP
UJDBOB"NSJDB-BUJOBw4BEFFN%FCBUF  
QQ  1FTTJOJ  - 
 i0 EFTFOWPMWJ
NFOUPEBCJPUJDBOB"NSJDB-BUJOBoBMHVNBT
DPOTJEFSBFTo QBSUF *w 0 .VOEP EB 4BEF 
  QQ  1FTTJOJ  - 
 i0 EFTFO
WPMWJNFOUPEBCJPUJDBOB"NSJDB-BUJOBoBM
HVNBTDPOTJEFSBFToQBSUF**w 0.VOEPEB
4BEF QQ
 %SBOF +' FE
 
F+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOF
BOE1IJMPTPQIZ"'PSVNGPS#JPFUIJDTBOE1IJ
MPTPQIZPG.FEJDJOF  


PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



1*
3FnFYJPOFTEFTEFFMDPOUFYUPJCFSPBNFSJDBOP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





&MDPOUFYUPIJTUSJDPEFMBCJPUJDB
IJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB
%JFHP(SBDJB

*OUSPEVDDJO

PTQFSPEPTIJTUSJDPTQPSMPTRVFIB
QBTBEPMBTPDJFEBEIJTQBOPBNFSJDB
OBTPO DVBOEPNFOPT DVBUSPFMQSJNJ
UJWP FOFMRVFJNQFSVOUJQPQBSUJDVMBS
EFUJDBRVFIFEFOPNJOBEPiUJDBEFM
EPOw FM EF MB $PORVJTUB  RVF JNQVTP
VOBUJDBEFHVFSSBZEFTPNFUJNJFOUP
GPS[BEPRVFMMBNBSiUJDBEFMEFTQPUJT
NPwFMQFSPEPEFMB$PMPOJB DPOVO
NPEFMP UJDP EF OVFWP DPSUF  MB iUJDB
QBUFSOBMJTUBw Z mOBMNFOUF MBiUJDBEF
MB BVUPOPNBw  RVF DPNFO[ DPO MPT
NPWJNJFOUPT JOEFQFOEFOUJTUBT EF MPT
TJHMPT97***Z9*9 ZRVFBOEJTUBEF
FTUBSDPNQMFUP
-BJOEFQFOEFODJBMBMMFWBSPOBDBCPMPT
DSJPMMPTFODPOUSBEFMBEPNJOBDJOFV
SPQFB  DPO NVZ QPDB QBSUJDJQBDJO EF
MBQPCMBDJOJOEHFOBTUBRVFEGVFSB
EFMQSPDFTPEFNPDSUJDPZFOVOBTJUVB
DJOQFPSRVFMBRVFUVWPFOMPTTJHMPT
EFMB$PMPOJB QPSRVFOPTFIBMMBCBZB
QSPUFHJEB QPS FM QBUFSOBMJTNP EF MBT
-FZFT EF *OEJBT EF  &MMP QFSNJUF
FOUFOEFSQPSRVMBTPDJFEBEMBUJOPBNF
SJDBOBEFMMUJNPTJHMPFTUEJWJEJEBFO
EPTFTUSBUPTTPDJBMFTNVZEJGFSFODJBEPT
VOPCVSHVToRVFIBBTJNJMBEPQFSGFD

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UBNFOUFMBSFWPMVDJOMJCFSBM RVFUJFOF
VOUJQPEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJBTJNJMBSBM
EFDVBMRVJFSPUSPQBTPDDJEFOUBMZRVF 
QPSUBOUP UJFOFMPTNJTNPTQSPCMFNBT
CJPUJDPT RVF DVBMRVJFS PUSB TPDJFEBE
PDDJEFOUBM EFTBSSPMMBEBo Z PUSP NVZ
QPCSFoRVFDBSFDFEFQPEFSFDPONJDP
ZTPDJBMZRVF QPSFMMP UBNQPDPQVFEF
IBDFSVTPEFTVTEFSFDIPTDJWJMFT DPNP
FMEFSFDIPBMBWJEBZBMBJOUFHSJEBEG
TJDB NVZDFSDFOBEPTQPSMBTEVSBTDPO
EJDJPOFTFOMBTRVFWJWF&OFTUFTFDUPS
EF MB QPCMBDJO  OVNSJDBNFOUF NT
JNQPSUBOUF  MPT QSPCMFNBT CJPUJDPT
GVOEBNFOUBMFTTPOMPTSFMBDJPOBEPTDPO
MB KVTUJDJB Z MB EJTUSJCVDJO EF SFDVSTPT
FTDBTPT&MFTUVEJPEFNPEFMPTDPNPFM
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP QVFEF TFSWJS QBSB RVF
FTUPT UFNBT  IBTUB BIPSB QPDP USBUBEPT
QPSMBCJPUJDBEFMPTQBTFTEFM1SJNFS
.VOEP BERVJFSBOMBSFMFWBODJBRVFMFT
DPSSFTQPOEF
-BCJPUJDBIBTJEPZFTVONPWJNJFO
UP CTJDBNFOUF OPSUFBNFSJDBOP 4VT
QMBOUFBNJFOUPT TPO EJGDJMNFOUF USBT
QMBOUBCMFT TJO NPEJmDBDJPOFT B PUSPT
QBTFT  BVO FO FM DBTP EF DPOEJDJPOFT
FDPONJDBT  TPDJBMFT Z DVMUVSBMFT NVZ
TFNFKBOUFT B MBT OPSUFBNFSJDBOBT 





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DPNPTVDFEFFOFMDBTPEF&VSPQB FO
HFOFSBM ZEFMB&VSPQBMBUJOBPNFEJ
UFSSOFB  FO QBSUJDVMBS %SBOF  
(SBDJB 
-BTEJGFSFODJBT
TPONVDIPNBZPSFTDVBOEPTFUSBUBEF
DVMUVSBT EJTUJOUBT EF MBT PDDJEFOUBMFT 
ZBTFBOEFTBSSPMMBEBT DPNPMBKBQPOF
TB #BJ  4IJSBJ  *TIJJ   

P FTUO FO WBT EF EFTBSSPMMP  DPNP
MB DIJOB 3FO;POH 2JV   

PMBOJHFSJBOB (CBEFHFTJO 

%FBIMBJNQPSUBODJBEFMPT
FTUVEJPT USBOTDVMUVSBMFT Z EF MB IJTUP
SJBEFMPTQSPQJPTQVFCMPT'VFSBEFFTF
DPOUFYUPOPFTDPNQSFOTJCMFMBUJDBEF
VOQVFCMPPEFVOBQPDBOJUBNQPDP
TVCJPUJDB
&O FTUF USBCBKP NF QSPQPOHP FTUVEJBS
FMDPOUFYUPIJTUSJDPEFMBCJPUJDBMBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOB&MMPFTOFDFTBSJPQPSRVF 
DVBOEPNFOPT MBDVMUVSBEFFTUPTQVF
CMPTOPQSPDFEFEFMBUSBEJDJOBOHMP
TBKPOBTJOPEFMBMBUJOBZNFEJUFSSOFB 
MP RVF MF DPOmFSF QFDVMJBSJEBEFT NVZ
FTQFDmDBT&OMPRVFTJHVFWBNPTBJO
UFOUBSSFDPOTUSVJSCSFWFNFOUFMBIJTUP
SJBEFFTUPTQVFCMPT QBSBMVFHPEFmOJS
MBTDBSBDUFSTUJDBTUJDBTEFDBEBVOPEF
TVTQFSPEPTQSJODJQBMFT

&MQFSPEPQSJNJUJWPZMBQPDB
EFMEFTDVCSJNJFOUPMBUJDBEFM
EPO
-BNBZPSBEFMBTDVMUVSBTQSJNJUJWBT FT
EFDJS EJTUJOUBTEFMBPDDJEFOUBM
QBSFDF
IBCFSDPJODJEJEPFOUFOFSVOBDPODFQ
DJO SFMJHJPTB EFM NVOEP Z EF MB WJEB
-BO &OUSBMHP  
 -BT DVMUVSBT
QSFDPMPNCJOBTEFMDPOUJOFOUFBNFSJDB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

OP OP TPO VOB FYDFQDJO B FTUB SFHMB


"QFTBSEFTVSJRVTJNBWBSJFEBE UPEBT
FMMBTDPJODJEFOFOFOUFOEFSMBSFBMJEBE
ZMPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTEFMBWJEBDPNP
VODPNQMFKPTJTUFNBEFQPEFSFT VOPT
CVFOPTZNBMPTPUSPT FYQSFTJOZTN
CPMP EF MBT CVFOBT P NBMBT SFMBDJPOFT
EF MPT NPSUBMFT DPO MB EJWJOJEBE Z EF
TUB DPO MPT NPSUBMFT %F BI RVF MPT
GFONFOPT OBUVSBMFT Z MPT BDPOUFDJ
NJFOUPT EF MB WJEB BQBSF[DBO TJFNQSF
DPNPiEPOFTwEFMBEJWJOJEBEPDPNP
iEFVEBTwDPOUSBEBTDPOFMMB-BEJBM
DUJDBEFMEPOEFVEBFTQBSUJDVMBSNFOUF
DMBSBFOMPTDBTPTEFFOGFSNFEBEMBTB
MVEFTVOEPOEFMBEJWJOJEBE TJHOPEF
BHSBEPEJWJOP FOUBOUPMBFOGFSNFEBE
FTVODBTUJHPQPSMPTQFDBEPTDPNFUJEPT
PFMSFTVMUBEPEFMBBDUVBDJOEFFTQSJ
UVT NBMJHOPT &TUF UJQP EF JOUFSQSFUB
DJPOFT QBSFDF DPNO B QSDUJDBNFOUF
MB UPUBMJEBE EF MBT DVMUVSBT QSFDPMPN
CJOBT (VFSSB 
ZEF
M DPOTFSWBNPT UFTUJNPOJPT MJUFSBSJPT
EFBMUPWBMPS FTQFDJBMNFOUFNBZBT 3J
WFSB  4FO[EF4BOUB
.BSB 

&TUFUJQPEFJOUFSQSFUBDJONUJDPN
HJDB Z SFMJHJPTB EF MB SFBMJEBE OP EFT
BQBSFDJDPOMBMMFHBEBEFMPTFTQBPMFT
B"NSJDB FO&OQSJNFSMVHBS 
QPSRVFMPTJOEHFOBTTJHVJFSPODPOTFS
WBOEP TVT DSFFODJBT TFHVOEP  QPSRVF
MPTFTQBPMFTMMFHBSPOQSPWJTUPTEFVOB
NFOUBMJEBEOPNFOPTQSPWJEFODJBMJTUB
RVF MB EF MPT JOEHFOBT BNFSJDBOPT  TJ
CJFOMBSFMJHJORVFQSPGFTBCBOoMBDSJT
UJBOBoFSBDJFSUBNFOUFEJTUJOUBEFUPEBT
MBTFYJTUFOUFTFOFM/VFWP.VOEP





&MDPOUFYUPIJTUSJDPEFMBCJPUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB

#BTUBMFFSMBTDBSUBTEF$SJTUCBM$PMO
BM 3FZ EF &TQBB $PMO  
 P MBT
EFWJBKFEF"NSJDP7FTQVDJP "NFSJHP
7FTQVDDJ  
 QBSB DPOWFODFSTF EF
RVF JOUFSQSFUBSPO FM EFTDVCSJNJFOUP
DPNPVOiEPOwRVFMBEJWJOJEBEMFIB
CBPUPSHBEPBMZBMPTSFZFTEF&TQBB
-PTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTQPTJUJWPTTJHVJFSPO
WJOEPTF DPNP EPOFT Z MPT OFHBUJWPT
DPNPSFWFTFTEFCJEPTBMBEVSF[BEFMPT
DPSB[POFTEFMPTDPORVJTUBEPSFTZ TPCSF
UPEP  EF MPT JOEHFOBT BNFSJDBOPT &M
EFTDVCSJNJFOUP EFM OVFWP DPOUJOFOUF
GVF FODVBMRVJFSDBTP VOEPONBSBWJ
MMPTP&MIFDIPEFRVF$SJTUCBM$PMO
MMFHBSBB"NSJDBJOFTQFSBEBNFOUF iQPS
DBTVBMJEBEw MFIJ[PTVQPOFSRVFBRVFMMP
FSB VO SFHBMP EFM DJFMP Z RVF BT EFCB
JOUFSQSFUBSTF$PNFO[VOBJOUFSQSFUB
DJOSFMJHJPTBZQSPWJEFODJBMJTUBEFMIF
DIPBNFSJDBOPRVFJCBBUFOFSJODBMDV
MBCMFTDPOTFDVFODJBT 9JSBV 
6OB
QSJNFSB GVF MB NJUJmDBDJO EFM JOEJP Z
EFMBTPDJFEBEBNFSJDBOBT&OMBTDBSUBT
EF$PMOFTDPOUJOVBMBSFGFSFODJBBMP
RVF QPEFNPT MMBNBS MB iMFZFOEB CMBO
DBwBNFSJDBOB DPOJOEJPTRVFWJWFOFO
iFTUBEPEFOBUVSBMF[Bw TJOMFZFTOJ&TUB
EP ZDPOVOBJEFBEJTUJOUBBMBNFEJFWBM
FVSPQFBTPCSFMPRVFFT QPSFKFNQMP MB
NPSBMJEBETFYVBM
)BTUB UBM QVOUP MMFHB FTUF QSPDFTP EF
NJUJmDBDJO EFM IFDIP BNFSJDBOP RVF
UBOUP$PMODPNPMPTQSJNFSPTEFTDV
CSJEPSFT FMBCPSBO UPEB VOB iVUPQBw 
RVFMFTMMFWBBTJUVBSFM1BSBTP5FSSFOBM
FOMB[POBTVSEFMDPOUJOFOUFBNFSJDBOP
%JDF$PMO FOFMSFMBUPEFTVUFSDFSWJB
KF RVFFTUFOFMIFNJTGFSJPTVS EFCBKP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EF MB MOFB FRVJOPDDJBM $PMO  



&TUFUFNBUVWPHSBOSFQFSDVTJO
FOMBMJUFSBUVSBNEJDB ZBRVFFMMVHBS
EFM1BSBTP5FSSFOBMEFCBTFS QPSEFm
OJDJO FMNTCFMMPZTBMVEBCMFEFUPEPT
MPTFYJTUFOUFT $JTOFSPT TT
&M
NJUPEFM1BSBTPZEFMBCPOEBEOBUVSBM
EFMPTRVFBMMIBCJUBCBOEJPMVHBSBUPEB
MBMJUFSBUVSBFVSPQFBTPCSFFMiNJUPEFM
CVFO TBMWBKFw  IBCJUBOUF EF MP RVF EJP
FOUPODFTFOMMBNBSTFiFTUBEPEFOBUVSB
MF[Bw/PTFSBDPNQSFOTJCMFMBEPDUSJOB
QPMUJDB NPEFSOB  EF )PCCFT Z -PDLF
B 3PVTTFBV Z ,BOU  TJO FTUF QSFDFEFO
UF4MPEFTEFMGVFQPTJCMFFMBCPSBSMB
EJTUJODJOFOUSFiFTUBEPEFOBUVSBMF[Bw
ZiFTUBEPDJWJMwZ QPSUBOUP EFmOJSMBT
DBSBDUFSTUJDBTEFMMMBNBEPiDPOUSBUPTP
DJBMw %PVDIFU  
 -BT DPOTFDVFO
DJBTEFFTUPMBTWFSFNPTNTBEFMBOUF

&MQSPCMFNBUJDPEFMB
DPORVJTUBMBTSB[POFTNPSBMFT
EFMEFTQPUJTNP
1PSNTRVFMBTSFMBDJPOFTEFMPTFTQBP
MFTDPOMPTJOEHFOBTDPNFO[BSBOTJFOEP
FYDFMFOUFT OP UBSEBSPO FO EFUFSJPSBSTF
-B DPBDDJO Z MB GVFS[B TVTUJUVZFSPO
QBVMBUJOBNFOUFBMBMJCFSBMJEBEZMBDP
FYJTUFODJB QBDmDB &M GBNPTP TFSNO
EFGSBZ"OUPOJPEF.POUFTJOPT EFMBP
 FO MB JTMB EF -B &TQBPMB  GVF MB
QSJNFSBEFOVODJBQCMJDBEFRVFMBTDP
TBTIBCBODBNCJBEP )BOLF 
1FSFB TT
1PDPBQPDP MB
UFTJTEFMCVFOTBMWBKFGVFTVTUJUVJEBQPS
MBEFMNBMTBMWBKF RVFEFCBTFSUSBUBEP
DBTJDPNPVOTFSJSSBDJPOBM4FJNQVTP
FMVTPTJTUFNUJDPEFMBGVFS[BDPOFMmO





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

EFBUSBFSMPTBMBWFSEBEFSBSFMJHJOZBM
TFSWJDJP EFM 3FZ EF &TQBB &TUB BDUJ
UVETFBDSFDFOUBQBSUJSEF DPO
PDBTJOEFMBDPORVJTUBEF.YJDPQPS
)FSOO $PSUT &O MB BSFOHB RVF FTUF
MUJNPIBDFBTVTUSPQBTBOUFTEFFNCBS
DBSQBSBFTFMVHBSOPRVFEBZBOBEBEFMB
BOUFSJPSVUPQBEFMJOEJP OBUVSBMNFOUF
CVFOPZNBOTP.VZQPSFMDPOUSBSJP 
$PSUTWFBMPTJOEJPTDPNPTFSFTQFSWFS
TPT RVFFTQSFDJTPHBOBS BVORVFTFBQPS
MBGVFS[B QBSBMBDJWJMJ[BDJOZMBNPSBM
DSJTUJBOBT 1FSFB 
"MBGBTF
EF DPFYJTUFODJB QBDmDB TVDFEF  QVFT 
MBEFMBDPORVJTUBCMJDB ZBMBiMFZFO
EBCMBODBwMBiMFZFOEBOFHSBw .PMJOB 

&MJOEJPOPFTZBFMiCVFOTBMWB
KFwTJOPVOiQFSSPTVDJPw BMRVFIBZRVF
TPKV[HBSZFTDMBWJ[BS7JWFFOiFTUBEPEF
OBUVSBMF[Bw QFSPFTFFTUBEPFTEFCFTUJB
MJEBEFTFMCFMMVNPNOJVNDPOUSBPNOFT
EFPNBT)PCCFT
-PT DPORVJTUBEPSFT DPOTJEFSBSO RVF
B MPT JOEJPT IBZ RVF TPNFUFSMPT QPS MB
GVFS[B CVTDBOEPFOMBSFMBDJODPOFMMPT
OP FM CJFO EF MPT JOEJPT TJOP FM EF MPT
DPORVJTUBEPSFTZEF&TQBB"MBUJDB
EFMEPOTVDFEFMBUJDBEFMiEFTQPUJTNPw
Z MB iUJSBOBw 5PEB MB mMPTPGB DMTJDB
BDFQUTJOEJTDVTJO BMNFOPTEFTEFFM
UJFNQP EF "SJTUUFMFT  RVF FM HPCJFSOP
EFMFTDMBWPEFCFIBDFSTFEFBDVFSEPDPO
MBTDPOWFOJFODJBTEFMBNPOPDPOMBTEFM
FTDMBWP "SJTUUFMFT    C 

"FTUP"SJTUUFMFTMPMMBNBiEFTQP
UJTNPw DVBOEPMPSFBMJ[BFMBNPEFVOB
DBTB ZiUJSBOBw DVBOEPMPIBDFVONP
OBSDB "SJTUUFMFT    B
 "N
CPTTFEJGFSFODJBO EJDF"SJTUUFMFT EFM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

HPCJFSOPEFMPTIJKPT ZBRVFFMQBESFOP
CVTDBTVQSPQJPCFOFmDJP DPNPFOMBT
SFMBDJPOFTEFTQUJDBTZUJSOJDBT TJOPFM
CFOFmDJPEFMPTHPCFSOBEPT "SJTUUFMFT 
 C
&OFTUPDPOTJTUF
FMQBUFSOBMJTNP
/PIBZEVEBEFRVFBQBSUJSEFMB
UJDBEFMBDPORVJTUBBNFSJDBOBTFIJ[P
DMBSBNFOUF EFTQUJDB /P TFSB DPSSFD
UP EFOPNJOBSMB iUJSOJDBw  ZB RVF MB
DPSPOB FTQBPMB JOUFOU FWJUBS  EFTEF
 MBEFHSBEBDJOEFMJOEJP 1FSFB 

QFSP EFTEFMVFHP UBNQPDP
UVWPDBSDUFSQBUFSOBMJTUB-BUJDBRVF
TFJNQVTPFOFTUPTBPTGVFDMBSBNFOUF
EFTQUJDB'SBODJTDPEF7JUPSJBDPOTJEF
SBCBRVFBTTFIBCBIFDIPMBDPORVJT
UBEF1FS 
ZQPSFTPMMBNBCB
EFTQFDUJWBNFOUF B MPT ETQPUBT EF MPT
JOEJPT JODBT iQFSVMFSPTw $POUSB FMMPT
MFWBOUTVTJOWFDUJWBTFOi/PNF
FTQBOUBOOJNFFNCBSB[BOMBTDPTBTRVF
WJFOFOBNJTNBOPT FYDFQUPUSBNQBTEF
CFOFmDJPTZDPTBTEF*OEJBT RVFTFNF
IJFMBMBTBOHSFFOFMDVFSQPFONFOUO
EPNFMBTw 7JUPSJB 

-BDBSUBFTUGFDIBEBFMEFOPWJFNCSF
EFZFTUPEBVOBJOWFDUJWBDPOUSB
MPTDPORVJTUBEPSFTEFM1FSi%FTUPTEFM
1FS UJNFPRVFTFBOEFBRVFMMPTRVJWP
MVOUEJWJUFTmFSJ:QPSBMHVOPTTFEJKP
*NQPTTJCJMFFTUEJWJUFNJOUSBSFJOSFHOVN
DBFMPSVNw 7JUPSJB 

7JUPSJBEJDFRVFiOPFOUJFOEFMBKVTUJDJB
EFBRVFMMBHVFSSBw 7JUPSJB 

QVFT iB MP RVF ZP IF FOUFOEJEP EF MPT
NJTNPT RVF FTUVWJFSPO FO MB QSYJNB
CBUBMMBEF5BCBMJQB OVODB5BCBMJQBOJ





&MDPOUFYUPIJTUSJDPEFMBCJPUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB

MPT TVZPT IBCBO IFDIP OJOHO BHSB


WJP B MPT DSJTUJBOPT  OJ DPTB QPS EPOEF
MFT EFCJFSBO IBDFS MB HVFSSBw 7JUPSJB 
 
 &O TV PQJOJO  iOP IBCB
OJOHVOBDBVTBNTEFHVFSSB NTRVF
QBSBSPCBSMPTw 7JUPSJB 
i:
DSFP RVF NT SVJOFT IBO TJEP MBT PUSBT
DPORVJTUBTEFTQVTBDw 7JUPSJB 

&O TVPQJOJO  MPTJOEJPTiQJFO
TBORVFMPTFTQBPMFTMPTUJSBOJ[BOZMFT
IBDFO HVFSSB JOKVTUBNFOUFw 7JUPSJB 
 
 -B UFTJT EF 7JUPSJB FT RVF
iMBHVFSSB NYJNFDPOMPTWBTBMMPT IBTF
EFUPNBSZQSPTFHVJSQPSCJFOEFMPTWB
TBMMPTZOPEFMQSODJQFw 7JUPSJB 

 -P QSJNFSP TFSB iQBUFSOBMJTNPw
ZMPTFHVOEPiUJSBOBw7JUPSJBDSFFRVF
MPT QFSVMFSPT FTUO BDUVBOEP UJSOJDB
NFOUF  FO CFOFmDJP QSPQJP  Z QPS FTP
MFTSPCBOUPEBTTVTSJRVF[BTi/JTQPS
EPOEF QVFEBO SPCBS Z EFTQPKBS B MPT
USJTUFTEFMPTWFODJEPTEFDVBOUPUJFOFO
ZOPUJFOFOw 7JUPSJB 

i4MPIBZVOBNBOFSBEFKVTUJmDBSMBUJ
SBOBEFMPTDPORVJTUBEPSFTZFTQFOTBS
RVFMPTJOEJPTOPTPOQFSTPOBTTJOPBOJ
NBMFT  NPOBT &O WFSEBE  TJ MPT JOEJPT
OP TPO IPNCSFT  TJOP NPOBT  OPO TVOU
DBQBDFT JOKVSJBF 1FSP TJ TPO IPNCSFT
Z QSKJNPT  FU RVPE JQTF QSBF TF GFSVOU 
WBTBMMPT EFM FNQFSBEPS  OPO WJEFP RVP
NPEPFYDVTBSBUPEPTDPORVJTUBEPSFTEF
MUJNBJNQJFEBEZUJSBOB OJTRVFUBO
HSBOEFTFSWJDJPIBHBOBTVNBHFTUBEEF
FDIBSMF B QFSEFS TVT WBTBMMPTw 7JUPSJB 


-B BDDJO EF MPT DPORVJTUBEPSFT FT UBO
JOKVTUJmDBCMF RVF7JUPSJBFTDSJCFi4JZP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EFTFBTFNVDIPFMBS[PCJTQBEPEF5PMF
EP  RVF FTU WBDP Z NF MP IPWJFTFO EF
EBSQPSRVFZPmSNBTFPBmSNBTFMBJOP
DFODJBEFFTUPTQFSVMFSPT TJOEVEBOPMP
PTBSBIBDFS"OUFTTFTFRVFMBMFOHVBZ
MBNBOP RVFZPEJHBOJFTDSJCBDPTBUBO
JOIVNBOB Z GVFSB EF UPEB DSJTUJBOEBE
"MMMPIBZBO ZEKFOOPTFOQB[w 7JUP
SJB 

&MKVJDJPEF7JUPSJBDPJODJEFDPOFMRVF
FOTVTPCSBTQPMNJDBTWFOBEFGFOEJFO
EP #BSUPMPN EF -BT $BTBT  FTQFDJBM
NFOUFFOMBUJUVMBEBi#SFWTJNBSFMBDJO
EFMBEFTUSVDDJOEFMBT*OEJBTw 

'SFOUFBM VOHSBOBSJTUPUMJDPZDSPOJT
UBPmDJBMEFM&NQFSBEPS$BSMPT7 +VBO
(JOTEF4FQMWFEB EFGFOEJFOTVMJ
CSP i%FNPDSBUFT TFDVOEVTw 
 RVF
FMEFTQPUJTNPBNFSJDBOPFSBUJDBNFOUF
DPSSFDUP %F MB EJTQVUB EF 7BMMBEPMJE

 EPOEF BNCPT TF FOGSFO
UBSPO 1BHEFO 
TVSHJBMNFOPT
VOBJEFBDMBSBFMHPCJFSOPEFTQUJDPEF
MPT JOEJPT EFCB DFEFS QBTP B PUSP NT
IVNBOP  FO RVF GVFSBO USBUBEPT OP
DPNP BOJNBMFT P DPNP FTDMBWPT TJOP
DPNPIJKPT"MEFTQPUJTNPEFMBQPDB
EFMBDPORVJTUBJCBBTVDFEFSFMQBUFSOB
MJTNPEFMQFSPEPDPMPOJBM
{5VWPDPOTFDVFODJBTFTUBUJDBEFMEFT
QPUJTNPQBSBMBWJEBEFMPTJOEJPTBNFSJ
DBOPT 1PSTVQVFTUPRVFT-BTEFOVO
DJBTEF#BSUPMPNEF-BT$BTBTTPOVO
CVFOUFTUJNPOJPEFMBTEFTUSVDDJPOFTZ
NVFSUFTRVFFTUBQPMUJDBEFHVFSSBQSP
EVKPi&OFTUFUJFNQPZBMPTSFMJHJPTPT
EF4BODUP%PNJOHPIBCBODPOTJEFSB
EPMBUSJTUFWJEBZBTQSSJNPDBQUJWFSJP





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

RVFMBHFOUFOBUVSBMEFTUBJTMBQBEFDB Z
DNPTFDPOTVNBO TJOIBDFSDBTPEFMMP
MPTFTQBPMFTRVFMPTQPTFBO NTRVFTJ
GVFSBOVOPTBOJNBMFTTJOQSPWFDIP EFT
QVT EF NVFSUPT TPMBNFOUF QFTOEPMFT
EFRVFTFMFTNVSJFTFO QPSMBGBMUBRVF
FOMBTNJOBTEFPSPZFOMBTPUSBTHSBO
KFSBTMFTIBDBOOPQPSFTPFOMPTRVF
MFTRVFEBCBOVTBCBOEFNTDPNQBTJO
OJ CMBOEVSB  DFSDB EFM SJHPS Z BTQFSF[B
DPO RVF PQSJNJS Z GBUJHBS Z DPOTVNJS
MPTTPMBO:FOUPEPFTUPIBCBFOUSFMPT
FTQBPMFT NT Z NFOPT  QPSRVF VOPT
FSBODSVEFMTJNPT TJOQJFEBEOJNJTFSJ
DPSEJB TMPUFOJFOEPSFTQFDUPBIBDFSTF
SJDPTDPOMBTBOHSFEFBRVFMMPTNTFSPT
PUSPT NFOPTDSVFMFT ZPUSPT FTEFDSFFS
RVFMFTEFCBEPMFSMBNJTFSJBZBOHVTUJB
EFMMPTQFSPUPEPT VOPTZPUSPT MBTBMVE
ZTVTWJEBTZTBMWBDJOEFMPTUSJTUFT UDJ
UBPFYQSFTBNFOUF BTVTJOUFSFTFTTPMPT 
QBSUJDVMBSFT Z UFNQPSBMFT  QPTQPOBOw
-BT$BTBT 


-BQPDBDPMPOJBMMBUJDBEFM
QBUFSOBMJTNP
-B QPDB EF MB DPMPOJB TF BQBSUB UBOUP
EF MB GBTF PQUJNJTUB EFM iCVFO TBMWBKFw
DPNPEFMBQFTJTNJTUBEFMiQFSSPTVDJPw
-BJEFPMPHBEFFTUBUFSDFSBGBTFTFSJO
UFSNFEJBFMJOEJPFTMJCSF QFSPEFCFTFS
DPOTJEFSBEP DPNP VO NFOPS EF FEBE 
DPNPVOOJPQFRVFPRVFOFDFTJUBEF
UVUFMB &TUP TF BEWJFSUF ZB FO MBT -FZFT
EF#VSHPTEF .PMJOB 

QFSPBERVJFSFDBSUBEFOBUVSBMF[BFOMBT
-FZFT/VFWBTEF*OEJBTEF$PNP
IB FTDSJUP -VDJBOP 1FSFB  FTUBT MFZFT
TPO MB DPOTFDVFODJB EF MB MBCPS UFSJDB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

MMFWBEB B DBCP QPS MB &TDVFMB EF 4BMB


NBODB DPO7JUPSJB $PWBSSVCJBT 4PUP
Z$BOP 1FSFB 

&MQBUFSOBMJTNPFTMBTPMVDJORVFQSP
QPOF -BT $BTBT FO TVT MJCSPT Z 7JUPSJB
FOMBi3FMFDUJPEF*OEJTwEF7JUPSJB
OPBDFQUBMBUFTJTEFRVFMPTJOEJPTTFBO
QPS OBUVSBMF[B TFSFT JSSBDJPOBMFT 5BN
QPDPBDFQUBMBUFTJTEF"SJTUUFMFTEFRVF
iIBZ RVJFOFT QPS OBUVSBMF[B TPO FTDMB
WPTw 7JUPSJB 
"QFTBSEF
RVF FOTVPQJOJO MPTJOEJPTTFQBSFDFO
NVDIPBMPTBOJNBMFT OPDSFFRVFTFBO
iBNFOUFTPJEJPUBTw
i&O SFBMJEBE OP TPO JEJPUBT  TJOP RVF
UJFOFO  B TV NPEP  VTP EF SB[O &T
FWJEFOUFRVFUJFOFODJFSUPPSEFOFOTVT
DPTBTRVFUJFOFODJVEBEFTEFCJEBNFO
UFSFHJEBT NBUSJNPOJPTCJFOEFmOJEPT 
NBHJTUSBEPT  TFPSFT  MFZFT  QSPGFTPSFT 
JOEVTUSJBT  DPNFSDJP UPEP MP DVBM SF
RVJFSF VTP EF SB[O "EFNT  UJFOFO
UBNCJO VOB GPSNB EF SFMJHJO  Z OP
ZFSSBO UBNQPDP FO MBT DPTBT RVF TPO
FWJEFOUFT B PUSPT  MP RVF FT JOEJDJP EF
VTP EF SB[O %JPT Z MB OBUVSBMF[B OP
MFTBCBOEPOBOFOMPRVFFTJOEJTQFOTB
CMFQBSBMBFTQFDJFZMPQSJODJQBMFOFM
IPNCSFFTMBSB[O ZFTJOUJMMBQPUFO
DJBRVFOPTFSFEVDFBMBDUP"TJNJTNP 
IVCJFSBO FTUBEP UBOUPT NJMFT EF BPT 
TJODVMQBTVZB GVFSBEFMFTUBEPEFTBMWB
DJO QVFTUPRVFIBOOBDJEPFOQFDBEP
Z DBSFDFO EFM CBVUJTNP  Z OP UFOESBO
VTPEFSB[OQBSBJOWFTUJHBSMPOFDFTB
SJP QBSB MB TBMWBDJO 1PS MP RVF DSFP
RVF FM IFDIP EF RVF OPT QBSF[DBO UBO
JEJPUBT Z SPNPT QSPWJFOF FO TV NBZPS





&MDPOUFYUPIJTUSJDPEFMBCJPUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB

QBSUF EF TV NBMB Z CSCBSB FEVDBDJO 


QVFTUBNCJOFOUSFOPTPUSPTWFNPTRVF
NVDIPTIPNCSFTEFMDBNQPCJFOQPDP
TF EJGFSFODJBO EF MPT CSVUPT BOJNBMFTw
7JUPSJB 

5SBTFTUP 7JUPSJBDPOUFTUBBMBSHVNFOUP
FODPOUSBSJPRVFOFHBCBMBSBDJPOBMJEBE
BMPTJOEJPTBQBSUJSEFMBBVUPSJEBEEF
"SJTUUFMFT  EJDJFOEP RVF MP WFSEBEFSB
NFOUF BDPSEF DPO MB NFOUF EF "SJTU
UFMFTFTiRVFIBZFOFMMPTVOBOFDFTJEBE
OBUVSBMEFTFSSFHJEPTZHPCFSOBEPTQPS
PUSPT TJOEPMFTNVZQSPWFDIPTPFMFTUBS
TPNFUJEPTBPUSPT DPNPMPTIJKPTOFDF
TJUBO FTUBS TPNFUJEPT B MPT QBESFT Z MB
NVKFSBMNBSJEPw 7JUPSJB DG
"SJTUUFMFT  BC
"RVTFWF
DMBSPDNPMBTPMVDJOEF7JUPSJBFTMB
QBUFSOBMJTUB
7JUPSJBOPEFKBEFUFOFSEVEBTTPCSFFTUF
QVOUP TUBT MF MMFWBO B DPOTJEFSBS FTF
BSHVNFOUPDPNPNFSBNFOUFQSPCBCMF 
QFSPQPSFMMPNJTNPWMJEPQBSBEJSJHJS
MB DPOEVDUB QSDUJDB OP IBZ RVF PMWJ
EBSRVFMBFTDVFMBTBMNBOUJOBRVFQBSUF
EF7JUPSJBGVFMBDSFBEPSBEFMBEPDUSJOB
NPSBM EFM QSPCBCJMJTNP
 )F BRV VO
UFYUPCBTUBOUFTJHOJmDBUJWP
i)BZPUSPUUVMPRVFOPQPESBBmSNBS
TFDPOTFHVSJEBE QFSPTEJTDVUJSTFZRVF
QBSFDFMFHUJNPQBSBBMHVOPT:POPNF
BUSFWPBEBSMPQPSCVFOPOJBDPOEFOBS
MPFOBCTPMVUP&TUFUUVMPFTTUFFTPT
CSCBSPT BVORVF DPNPTFIBEJDIP OP
TFBOEFMUPEPJODBQBDFT EJTUBO TJOFN
CBSHP UBOQPDPEFMPTSFUSBTBEPTNFO
UBMFT RVF QBSFDF OP TPO JEOFPT QBSB
DPOTUJUVJS Z BENJOJTUSBS VOB SFQCMJDB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

MFHUJNB EFOUSP EF MNJUFT IVNBOPT Z


QPMUJDPT 1PS MP DVBM OP UJFOFO MFZFT
BEFDVBEBT OJNBHJTUSBEPT ZOJTJRVJFSB
TPOTVmDJFOUFNFOUFDBQBDFTQBSBHPCFS
OBSMBGBNJMJB)BTUBDBSFDFOEFDJFODJBT
Z BSUFT  OP TMP MJCFSBMFT TJOP UBNCJO
NFDOJDBT  Z EF VOB BHSJDVMUVSB EJMJ
HFOUF  EF BSUFTBOPT Z EF PUSBT NVDIBT
DPNPEJEBEFT RVF TPO IBTUB OFDFTBSJBT
QBSBMBWJEBIVNBOB
1PESBFOUPODFTEFDJSTFRVFQBSBVUJMJ
EBEEFUPEPTFMMPTQVFEFOMPTSFZFTEF
&TQBBFODBSHBSTFEFMBBENJOJTUSBDJO
ZHPCJFSOPEFBRVFMMPTCSCBSPT OPN
CSBSMFT NJOJTUSPT Z HPCFSOBEPSFT QBSB
TVTQVFCMPT ZBVOEBSMFTOVFWPTQSO
DJQFTNJFOUSBTDPOTUBTFRVFFSBDPOWF
OJFOUFQBSBTVCJFOFTUBS
4FSB EJGDJM DPOWFODFSTF EF UPEP FTUP 
QPSRVF TJ UPEPT GVFSPO JODBQBDFT OP
IBZ EVEB EF RVF OP TMP TFSB MDJUP Z
NVZ DPOWFOJFOUF  TJOP RVF IBTUB MPT
QSODJQFT FTUBSBO PCMJHBEPT B IBDFSMP 
MPNJTNPRVFTJGVFSBOEFMUPEPOJPT
:QBSFDFRVFIBZMBNJTNBSB[OQBSB
FTPTCSCBSPTRVFQBSBMPTBNFOUFT QPS
RVFOBEBPQPDPNTQVFEFOIBDFSQBSB
HPCFSOBSTF RVF MPT EFmDJFOUFT NFOUB
MFT : TPO DBTJ DPNP MBT NJTNBT mFSBT
Z CFTUJBT  QVFT OP VTBO BMJNFOUPT NT
FMBCPSBEPTOJBQFOBTNFKPSFTRVFFMMBT
-VFHP EFMBNJTNBNBOFSBQPESBOTFS
DPOmBEPT B MB UVUFMB EF IPNCSFT NT
JOUFMJHFOUFT
: TF DPOmSNB FTUB UFTJT DPO DJFSUB WF
SPTJNJMJUVE 1PSRVF TJ  QPS VO BDBTP 
QFSFDJFSBOUPEPTMPTBEVMUPTEFBRVFMMBT
SFHJPOFTZRVFEBSBOOJDBNFOUFMPTOJ





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

PTZMPTBEPMFTDFOUFTRVFUJFOFOBMHO
VTPEFSB[O QFSPEFOUSPUPEBWBEFMPT
BPT EF MB JOGBODJB Z QVCFSUBE  QBSFDF
DMBSPRVFQPEBOMPTQSODJQFTUPNBSMPT
CBKP TV UVUFMB Z HPCFSOBSMPT NJFOUSBT
FTUVWJFSBOFOTFNFKBOUFFTUBEP4JFTUP
TF BENJUF  QBSFDF DJFSUP RVF OP TF IB
EF OFHBS RVF QVFEB IBDFSTF MP NJTNP
DPOMPTQBESFTEFMPTCSCBSPT TVQVFTUB
MBJODBQBDJEBENFOUBMRVFMFTBUSJCVZFO
MPTRVFIBOFTUBEPBMM MBDVBMEJDFORVF
FTNVDIPNBZPSRVFMBRVFUJFOFOMPT
OJPTBEPMFTDFOUFTFOPUSBTOBDJPOFT
:BMBWFSEBERVFIBTUBQPESBGVOEBS
TF FTUB DPOEVDUB FO FM QSFDFQUP EF MB
DBSJEBE  QVFTUP RVF FMMPT TPO OVFTUSPT
QSKJNPTZFTUBNPTPCMJHBEPTBQSPDV
SBSTVCJFO-PBDFQUP DPNPEJKF
TJO
BmSNBSMP BCTPMVUBNFOUF Z BVO DPO MB
DPOEJDJOEFRVFTFIBHBQPSFMCJFOZ
VUJMJEBEEFMPTNJTNPTZOPDPNPQSF
UFYUPEFMMVDSPEFMPTFTQBPMFT2VFFO
FTUPFTUUPEPFMQFMJHSPQBSBMBTBMNBT
Z TV TBMWBDJO FUFSOB 5BNCJO QBSB
FTUBBSHVNFOUBDJOQVFEFWBMFSMPRVF
TFEJKPBOUFTEFRVFBMHVOPTTPOTJFSWPT
QPS OBUVSBMF[B : UBMFT QBSFDFO TFS FT
UPTCSCBSPT RVFFOQBSUFQPESBOQPS
FTUBSB[OTFSHPCFSOBEPTDPNPTJFSWPTw
7JUPSJB 

"QBSUJSEFFTUPTUFYUPTQVFEFFOUFOEFS
TF NVZ CJFO MB NFOUBMJEBE EF 7JUPSJB
Z MB EF MBT -FZFT EF *OEJBT -PT JOEJPT
TPO IPNCSFT  OP BOJNBMFT Z  QPS UBO
UP  NFSFDFO OVFTUSP SFTQFUP QFSP TPO
IPNCSFT CSCBSPT B MPT RVF IBZ RVF
QSPUFHFS DPNP B IJKPT NVZ QFRVFPT
7JUPSJB QSPQPOF BDUVBS DPO FMMPT EF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

NBOFSB QBUFSOBMJTUB Z FWJUBS MB UJSBOB


1PS FTP DMBNB DPOUSB MPT EFTNBOFT EF
MPTDPORVJTUBEPSFTZFOVOBDBSUBBM1
"SDPTEJDFiOPOWJEFPRVPNPEPFYDVTBS
BFTUPTDPORVJTUBEPSFTEFMUJNBJNQJF
EBEZUJSBOBw 7JUPSJB 

+PT EF "DPTUB FT PUSP EF MPT HSBOEFT
UFSJDPT EFM QSPUFDUPSBEP QBUFSOBMJTUB
EF MPT JOEJPT &O TV PCSB i%F 1SPDV
SBOEB *OEPSVN 4BMVUFw 
 EFmOF
B MPT JOEJPT DPNP iCSCBSPTw Z BmSNB
RVFiTFHOMBEFmOJDJOEFQSFTUJHJPTPT
BVUPSFT  CSCBSPT TPO BRVFMMPT RVF TF
BQBSUBOEFMBSFDUBSB[OZEFMBQSDUJ
DBIBCJUVBMEFMPTIPNCSFT RVJBSFDUB
SBUJPOFFUIPNJOVNDPNNVOJDPOTVFUV
EJOFBCIPSSFOU
1PSFTPTVFMFOEFTUBDBS
MPTFTDSJUPSFTNTJMVTUSFTMBJODBQBDJEBE
EF MPT CSCBSPT  TV mFSF[B  JODMVTP TVT
UDOJDBTZUSBCBKPT TJHOJmDBOEPMPMFKPT
RVFFTUOEFMBQSDUJDBVTVBMEFMPTEF
NT IPNCSFT Z MP QPDP RVF UJFOFO EF
TBCJEVSBZBDUJWJEBESBDJPOBMw "DPTUB 


&TUB FT MB UFTJT RVF QSFTJEF UPEB MB DP


MPOJ[BDJOFTQBPMBRVFMPTJOEJPTTPO
CSCBSPTFOFTUFTFOUJEPQPSFTP UJFOFO
GVFS[B DPSQPSBM QFSP OP WJHPS SBDJPOBM
ZFTQJSJUVBM ZOFDFTJUBO QPSOBUVSBMF[B 
UVUFMB 4PO DPNP MPT BSUFTBOPT EF i-B
3FQCMJDBwEF1MBUO FOUBOUPRVFMPT
FTQBPMFT TPO MPT HVBSEJBOFT Z MPT HP
CFSOBOUFT
+PTEF"DPTUBEJTUJOHVFUSFTOJWFMFTEF
CBSCBSJF EFNFOPSBNBZPS-BNFOPS
FTMBQSPQJBEFMBT*OEJBT0SJFOUBMFT-PT
QVFCMPTEFMBT*OEJBT0DDJEFOUBMFTFTUO





&MDPOUFYUPIJTUSJDPEFMBCJPUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB

FOMPTOJWFMFTTFHVOEPZUFSDFSP&OFM
TFHVOEPFTUOMPTNFKJDBOPTZMPTQFSVB
OPTFOFMUFSDFSP DBTJUPEPTMPTEFNT
QVFCMPT BNFSJDBOPT : BBEF +PT EF
"DPTUB
i" UPEPT FTUPT IPNCSFT P NFEJPIPN
CSFTFTQSFDJTPEBSMFTJOTUSVDDJOIVNB
OB  QBSB RVF BQSFOEBO B TFS IPNCSFT 
FEVDBSMPTDPNPBOJPT:TJDPOIBMB
HPT TF EFKBO FTQPOUOFBNFOUF QSPNP
DJPOBS UBOUPNFKPSEFOPTFSBT OPTF
MFTIBEFEFKBSBTVTVFSUFTJTFSFTJTUFO
DPOUFSRVFEBEBTVQSPQJBSFHFOFSBDJO
Z EFTWBSBO DPOUSB TVT QSPQJPT NBFT
USPT Z NEJDPT  IBZ RVF PCMJHBSMFT QPS
MBGVFS[BZIBDFSMFTBMHVOBDPOWFOJFOUF
QSFTJOQBSBRVFOPQPOHBOPCTUDVMPT
BM&WBOHFMJP ZIBZRVFIBDFSMFTDVNQMJS
TVT PCMJHBDJPOFT Z DPOWFOES IBDFSMFT
GVFS[BQBSBRVFTFUSBTMBEFOEFMBTFMWB
B MB DPOWJWFODJB IVNBOB EF MB DJVEBE
ZFOUSFO BVORVFTFBVOQPDPBSFHBB
EJFOUFT FOFMSFJOPEFMPTDJFMPTw "DPT
UB 

+PTEF"DPTUBOPEVEBFOBQMJDBSBMPT
JOEJPT BNFSJDBOPT MBT EVSBT QBMBCSBT
EFM -JCSP EF MB 4BCJEVSB B QSPQTJUP
EF MPT $BOBOFPT i" TBCJFOEBT EF RVF
FSBOEFNBMBDFQB EFNBMJDJBDPOHOJ
UBZRVFTVNBOFSBEFTFSOPDBNCJBSB
OVODB&SBOSB[BNBMEJUBEFTEFTVPSJ
HFOw 4BQ 
:"DPTUBBBEF
i)BZ QPSDPOTJHVJFOUF TVKFUPTRVFFT
UOBGFDUBEPTEFVOBNBMJDJBDPOHOJUB
Z IFSFEJUBSJB  QPS BT EFDJS TV NPEP
EFQFOTBSFTUUBOQFSUJOB[ZQFSWFSTB
NFOUF BSSBJHBEP RVF DBTJ FT JNQPTJCMF
FYUJSQBSMP 
&TUBFT QVFT MBQSJNFSB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

ZQSJODJQBMDBVTBQPSMBRVFFOFTUBTSF
HJPOFTTFIBEFFTQFSBSUBOQPDPGSVUP
EFUBOUPFTGVFS[PTPOSB[BNBMEJUB DBTJ
QSJWBEB EF MPT BVYJMJPT EJWJOPT Z EFT
UJOBEB B MB QFSEJDJOw "DPTUB  

 -PT UFYUPT TF QPESBO NVMUJQMJDBS
TJOOJOHOFTGVFS[P "DPTUB 


$POFTUBTZPUSBTNVDITJNBTGSBTFTTJ
NJMBSFT  +PT EF "DPTUB OP FTU KVTUJm
DBOEP MB UJSBOB EF MPT DPORVJTUBEPSFT
.VZBMDPOUSBSJP MPRVF"DPTUBQSPQP
OF FT FM QBUFSOBMJTNP  QPS FTP FTDSJCF
BDUPTFHVJEP
i5SBJHPBDPMBDJOUPEPFTUPOPQPSRVF
E NJ BQSPCBDJO FO NPEP BMHVOP BM
QPEFSUJSOJDPZBMBDSVFMEBE UBOBKF
OBTBMBTFOTFBO[BTEF$SJTUP
RVFTFIB
VTBEP DPO MPT QVFCMPT EF MPT JOEJPT  P
QPSRVFQJFOTFRVFTFMPTIBEFNBOEBS
DPNPBTJFSWPT PQPSRVFOPBCPSSF[DBZ
DPOEFOFDPOUPEBFOFSHBMPTDSNFOFT
EFMPTNBMWBEPTZMBBWBSJDJBEFMPTRVF
DPOWJFSUFOMPTCJFOFT USBCBKPTZTVEPSFT
EF FTUPT NJTFSBCMFT FYDMVTJWBNFOUF FO
TVQSPQJPQSPWFDIP BCVTBOEPEFMBNB
OFSBNTJOJDVBEFTVUPSQF[Bw "DPTUB 


&TUBFTMBNFOUBMJEBEDPOMBRVFMPTFT
QBPMFT JOUFOUBO HPCFSOBS MBT DPMPOJBT
BNFSJDBOBT EFTEF   BQSPYJNBEB
NFOUF IBTUBMBQPDBEFMBJOEFQFOEFO
DJB-PTJOEJPTGVFSPOQSPUFHJEPTDPNP
OJPT OPDPNPFTDMBWPT MPRVFFTUBCB
QSPIJCJEPQPSMBT-FZFTEF*OEJBT
&TUP
OPRVJFSFEFDJSRVFOPIVCJFSBFTDMBWPT
FMUSmDPEFOFHSPTBGSJDBOPTB"NSJDB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

TF SFBMJ[ QSFDJTBNFOUF QBSB RVF FMMPT


MMFWBSBO B DBCP MBT UBSFBT NT QFTBEBT
TUPT OP FTUBCBO DPOUFNQMBEPT FO MB
-FZFT EF *OEJBT Z  QPS UBOUP  B FMMPT T
QPEB USBUSTFMFT DPNP B FTDMBWPT DPO
GPSNFBMBMFHJTMBDJONFEJFWBMRVF"M
GPOTP 9 SFDPQJM FO MBT i1BSUJEBTw %F
FTUF NPEP  MB TPDJFEBE DPMPOJBM RVFE
FTUSBUJmDBEBFOVOBVUOUJDPTJTUFNBEF
DBTUBT FOFMDVBMMPTFTQBPMFTPDVQBCBO
FMOJWFMTVQFSJPS MVFHPWFOBOMPTFTQB
PMFTBNFSJDBOPTPDSJPMMPT EFTQVTMPT
NFTUJ[PT NF[DMBEFFVSPQFPTFJOEJPT

NT BCBKP FTUBCBO NVMBUPT NF[DMB EF
FVSPQFPT Z BGSJDBOPT
 FO VO OJWFM JO
GFSJPS MPT [BNCPT NF[DMB EF JOEJPT Z
BGSJDBOPT
NTBCBKPMPTJOEJPTZ FOM
UJNPMVHBS MPTOFHSPTFTDMBWPT$PNPFT
FWJEFOUF FMQBUFSOBMJTNPOPMMFHBFTUF
MUJNPOJWFM
&OFMPSEFOEFMBNFEJDJOB FTUBEJWJTJO
FODBTUBTUVWPDPOTFDVFODJBTQPTJUJWBTZ
OFHBUJWBT6OFGFDUPQPTJUJWPGVFMBQSP
IJCJDJOUBKBOUF QPSQBSUFEFMBT-FZFT
/VFWBTEF EFUSBCBKPTJOIVNBOPT
ZEFHSBEBOUFT4FQSPIJCJRVFMPTJOEJPT
MMFWBTFOQFSTPOBMNFOUFDBSHBT DPOTMP
MBTFYDFQDJPOFTJNQVFTUBTQPSMBGBMUBEF
BOJNBMFT P DBNJOPT  Z TJFNQSF DPNP
GBFOBTWPMVOUBSJBTZNPEFSBEBT ZOVO
DBGPS[BEBT ZTJONFOPTDBCPEFMBTBMVE 
EFMBWJEBZEFMBDPOTFSWBDJOEFMPTJO
EJPT ZQBHOEPMFTFOUPEPDBTPQPSTV
USBCBKP RVFEFCFTFSBDFQUBEPQPSFMMPT
WPMVOUBSJBZMJCSFNFOUF 1FSFB 

4FQSPIJCJFSPOUBNCJOMPTNBMPT
USBUPTZBCVTPT DBTUJHBOEPTFWFSBNFOUF
BMPTRVFNBUBSBOPIJSJFSBOBDVBMRVJFS
JOEJP -B DPOTFDVFODJB OFHBUJWB GVF FM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

QBUFSOBMJTNP NT BDFOESBEP &M CJFO


EFMJOEJPWFOBEFmOJEPQPSFMFTQBPM
PQPSFMDSJPMMP OPQPSFMJOEJPNJTNP
"M mOBM TF BDBCBCB IBDJFOEP MP RVF FM
FTQBPM Z FM DSJPMMP DPOTJEFSBCBO CJFO
EFMJOEJP RVFFOMBNBZPSBEFMPTDBTPT
OPFSBPUSBDPTBRVFFMQSPQJPCJFOEFM
FTQBPMZEFMDSJPMMP
-FKPTEFSFTPMWFSMPTQSPCMFNBTFYJTUFO
UFT MBUFTJTEFMBJOGFSJPSJEBEOBUVSBMEFM
JOEJPZEFMBOFDFTJEBEEFTVUVUFMBOP
IJ[PTJOPJODSFNFOUBSMPT&TUPFTFWJEFO
UFFOFMDBNQPEFMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJB
7JOEPTF NFOPTQSFDJBEP Z SFDIB[BEP
QPSMBTPDJFEBEEFMPTCMBODPTZDSJPMMPT 
FMJOEJPTFSFGVHJFOTVTUSBEJDJPOFTZ
SFUPSO B MB NFEJDJOB DSFFODJBM EF TVT
BOUFQBTBEPT-BNFEJDJOBPDDJEFOUBMOP
MFTMMFHBUSBWTEFMPTNEJDPTPEFMPT
DJSVKBOPT TJOPBUSBWTEFMPTNJTJPOFSPT
RVF DPNPNFEJPEFFWBOHFMJ[BDJO SFB
MJ[BSPOVOBJNQPSUBOUFMBCPSGVOEBOEP
IPTQJUBMFTZFEVDBOEPTBOJUBSJBNFOUFB
MBQPCMBDJO
&ODPODMVTJO QPEFNPTEFDJSRVFEV
SBOUFMPTTJHMPTEFMBDPMPOJBBMJOEJPTF
MF DPODFEJFSPO VOPT DJFSUPT EFSFDIPT
DJWJMFT oFM EFSFDIP B MB WJEB Z B MB JO
UFHSJEBE GTJDBo  QFSP TUPT OVODB TF
DPOWJSUJFSPO FO EFSFDIPT QPMUJDPT  SB
[OQPSMBDVBMWJWJFSPOFOVOQSPGVO
EP FTUBEP EF NBSHJOBDJO TPDJBM &TUP
MFTMMFWBSFQMFHBSTFZFODFSSBSTFFOTVT
BOUJHVBTUSBEJDJPOFT NPUJWPQPSFMRVF
MB BTJTUFODJB TBOJUBSJB RVFE SFEVDJEB 
FOHSBONFEJEB BTVTBOUJHVBTQSDUJ
DBTDSFFODJBMFTZBMBBTJTUFODJBPDDJEFO
UBMSFDJCJEBOPEFNEJDPTZDJSVKBOPT 





&MDPOUFYUPIJTUSJDPEFMBCJPUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB

TJOPEFNJTJPOFSPT&MQBUFSOBMJTNPEF
MBQPDBEFMBDPMPOJBQSPUFHJTVWJEB
QFSP BMBWF[ MPTTFHSFHTPDJBMNFOUF 
FWJUBOEPTVQSPNPDJOZIBDJFOEPRVF
OPQVEJFSBOSFDJCJSMPTCFOFmDJPTEFMB
NFEJDJOBPDDJEFOUBM
-PT FVSPQFPT SFTJEFOUFT FO "NSJDB
Z MPT DSJPMMPT  QPS PUSB QBSUF  TF CFOF
mDJBSPO EF MBT QSDUJDBT NEJDBT PDDJ
EFOUBMFT RVF MPT FTQBPMFT MMFWBSPO B
"NSJDB &M TJHMP 97* GVF EF VO HSBO
FTQMFOEPSFOMBNFEJDJOBFTQBPMB RVF
SFQFSDVUJ DMBSBNFOUF FO MB BNFSJDBOB
(VFSSB   
 4F GVOEBSPO GB
DVMUBEFTEFNFEJDJOBFOMBTQSJODJQBMFT
VOJWFSTJEBEFT .YJDP   -JNB 
(VBUFNBMB 2VJUP 
#PHPU -B)BCBOB $BSB
DBT 
EFMBTRVFTBMJFSPONEJDPT
GPSNBEPTDPOMPTFTUOEBSFTFVSPQFPT
"EFNT FO DPOMBQSPNVMHBDJO
EFMBT-FZFT/VFWBTEF*OEJBT FMFKFS
DJDJP NEJDP QBT B FTUBS DPOUSPMBEP
QPSFM5SJCVOBMEFM1SPUPNFEJDBUP RVF
DPNFO[TVBDUJWJEBEFO4FJOJ
DJBTVOQSPDFTPEFnPSFDJNJFOUPEF
MBNFEJDJOBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB RVFGVF
JODSFNFOUOEPTFJOJOUFSSVNQJEBNFOUF
IBTUBmOBMFTEFMTJHMP97***
%FFTUFNPEP FOMBTPDJFEBEJOEJBOB
TF FTUBCMFDJFSPO WBSJPT UJQPT EJTUJOUPT
EF BTJTUFODJB TBOJUBSJB  SFMBDJPOBEPT
DPOFMTJTUFNBEFDBTUBTEFMBTPDJFEBE
-PT NEJDPT HSBEVBEPT FO VOJWFSTJ
EBEFTBUFOEBOMBTBMVEEFMFTUSBUPTV
QFSJPS EF MB TPDJFEBE  DPNQVFTUP QPS
OPCMFTZHPCFSOBOUFTWFOJEPTEF&TQB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

BZQPSDSJPMMPTQPTFFEPSFTEFMQPEFS
FDPONJDP -PT DJSVKBOPT Z CBSCFSPT
DVJEBCBO EF NFTUJ[PT Z NVMBUPT RVF 
BEFNT  VUJMJ[BCBO MPT SFDVSTPT EF MB
NFEJDJOB QPQVMBS 6O TFDUPS EF JOE
HFOBTTFCFOFmDJEFMBNFEJDJOBPDDJ
EFOUBMJNQBSUJEBQPSMPTNJTJPOFSPTFM
SFTUP MBNBZPSB FSBOBUFOEJEPQPSMPT
QSPQJPTNEJDPTJOEHFOBT'JOBMNFO
UF  MPT FTDMBWPT OFHSPT FSBO BUFOEJEPT
DPOQSPDFEJNJFOUPTQSPQJPTEFMBNF
EJDJOB QPQVMBS BGSJDBOB 5PEPT FTUPT
UJQPT EF NFEJDJOB  FYDFQUP FM MUJNP 
GVFSPO QBUFSOBMJTUBT QFSP EF EJGFSFOUF
NPEP-BNFEJDJOBFVSPQFBDPOTJEFSB
CBBMFOGFSNPDPNPNFOPSEFFEBEP
DPNPJOWMJEPNPSBMZ QPSUBOUP JO
DBQBDJUBEP QBSB EFDJEJS MBT DVFTUJPOFT
SFMBDJPOBEBTDPOTVQSPQJPDVFSQP&M
DBTPEFMJOEJPFSBBMHPEJTUJOUP QVFTB
MTFMFDPOTJEFSBCBNFOPSEFFEBEBVO
FO FTUBEP EF TBMVE  SB[O QPS MB DVBM
FMQBUFSOBMJTNPTFFYUFOEBBUPEBTMBT
EJNFOTJPOFTEFTVWJEB5BNCJODBCF
EFDJSRVFFMJOEJPFSBWJTUPZUSBUBEP FO
UPEPTMPTDBTPTZTJOFYDFQDJO DPNP
VOFOGFSNP&OFMCMBODPZFMDSJPMMPFM
QBUFSOBMJTNPFSBVOBFYDFQDJORVFTF
FKFSDBTMPFODBTPEFFOGFSNFEBEFO
FM NFTUJ[P Z TPCSF UPEP FO FM JOEJP FM
QBUFSOBMJTNPFSBMBSFHMB RVFBGFDUBCB
BUPEPTMPTBTQFDUPTEFTVWJEB-BSB[B
FSBWJTUBZUSBUBEBDPNPVOBFOGFSNF
EBE&TUPGVFQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFDMBSPFO
FMDBTPEFMOFHSP FOFMRVFMBSB[BZFM
DPMPS EF MB QJFM MF DPOEFOBSPO B BMHP
QFPS RVF FM QBUFSOBMJTNP BM EFTQPUJT
NPZMBUJSBOB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

-BQPDBEFMBJOEFQFOEFODJB
MBTWJDJTJUVEFTEFMBUJDBEFMB
BVUPOPNBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB
%VSBOUF MPT TJHMPT EF MB DPMPOJB MB TP
DJFEBEBNFSJDBOBFTUVWPDPNQVFTUBQPS
WBSJPT FTUSBUPT VOP TVQFSJPS  DPNQVFT
UP QPS MPT HPCFSOBOUFT FVSPQFPT  PUSP
NFEJP  NBZPSJUBSJBNFOUF GPSNBEP QPS
DSJPMMPT  Z PUSP JOGFSJPS  GPSNBEP QPS
JOEHFOBT$POFMUJFNQPTFWJPRVFMPT
EPTQSJNFSPTUFOBOJOUFSFTFTDMBSBNFOUF
DPOUSBQVFTUPT ZBRVFFMCJFOEFMBDPSP
OB oRVF SFQSFTFOUBCBO MPT HPCFSOBOUFT
FVSPQFPToZFMEFMPTDPMPOPTOPUFOBO
QPSRVDPJODJEJS&TPFYQMJDBRVFFOFM
TJHMP97***DPNFO[BSBOMBTMVDIBTJOUFT
UJOBTQPSFMQPEFSQPMUJDPEFMBTDPMPOJBT
-BPDBTJOMBCSJOEMBJOWBTJOGSBODFTB
EF&TQBBZMBQSJTJOEFMNPOBSDBFTQB
PM'FSOBOEP7** FO&O"NSJDB
TFPSHBOJ[BSPOKVOUBTMPDBMFTZWJSSFJOB
MFTRVFUPNBSPOFMNBOEPQPMUJDPEFMBT
DJVEBEFT Z UFSSJUPSJPT DPMPOJBMFT &TUBT
KVOUBTFTUBCBOEJSJHJEBTQPSDSJPMMPTRVF 
EFFTUBNBOFSB TFIJDJFSPODPOFMQPEFS
FGFDUJWPEFMBTDPMPOJBT FODPOUSBEFMBT
BVUPSJEBEFTFTQBPMBT&TUFQSPDFTP RVF
UVWP MVHBS FOUSF   TF DPOTP
MJE BPT EFTQVT  FOUSF  Z  
FOGPSNBEFBVUPSJEBEQPMUJDBBVUOP
NB  JOEFQFOEJFOUF EF MB DPSPOB FTQB
PMB &O FTUP JOnVZFSPO MB EFDMBSBDJO
EF JOEFQFOEFODJB OPSUFBNFSJDBOB EF
 MB3FWPMVDJO'SBODFTB EF
Z  FO HFOFSBM  FM DMJNB JOUFMFDUVBM EF MB
*MVTUSBDJO GSBODFTB -PT HSBOEFT SFWP
MVDJPOBSJPT IJTQBOPBNFSJDBOPT "OUP
OJP/BSJP 'SBODJTDP.JSBOEB 4JNO
#PMWBS FOUSFPUSPT
FSBOQSPEVDUPEFMB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

CVSHVFTBDSJPMMB SJDBZDVMUB RVFIBCB


FTUVEJBEPFO&VSPQBZDPOPDBMBJEFPMP
HBMJCFSBMZMBJNQPSUBODJBRVFQBSBVOB
QPMUJDBEFNPDSUJDBUFOBMBOVFWBEPD
USJOBEFMPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT/BSJP
USBEVKPFJNQSJNJFO#PHPU 
MB
%FDMBSBDJOEFMPT%FSFDIPTEFM)PN
CSF RVF IBCB QSPNVMHBEP QPDP BOUFT
MB "TBNCMFB $POTUJUVZFOUF GSBODFTB FO
&TJOUFSFTBOUFSFTBMUBSRVF DPNP
UBNCJOTVDFEJFO&TQBBoEPOEFMBT
$PSUFT RVF QSPDMBNBSPO FO  MB
QSJNFSB$POTUJUVDJOMJCFSBMFTUVWJFSPO
DPNQVFTUBT FO VO BMUP QPSDFOUBKF QPS
NEJDPTo  MPT QSPDFTPT EF JOEFQFOEFO
DJB EF MBT OVFWBT OBDJPOFT BNFSJDBOBT
FTUVWJFSPO MJEFSBEPT  FO NFEJEB NVZ
FMFWBEB  UBNCJO QPS NEJDPT (VFSSB 

/PFOWBOPMBNFEJDJOB
FSBVOBEFMBTQSPGFTJPOFTNTFTUJNBEBT
QPSMBOVFWBCVSHVFTBDSJPMMB
-BTDPOTUJUVDJPOFTEFMPTOVFWPTQBTFT
BNFSJDBOPTTFFMBCPSBSPOTJHVJFOEPMPT
NPEFMPT OPSUFBNFSJDBOP 
 GSBO
DT 
ZFTQBPM 
&TUPRVJF
SFEFDJSRVFQBSUJFSPOEFMBBmSNBDJO
EFMBTPCFSBOBQPQVMBSZEFMSFDPOPDJ
NJFOUPEFVOPTEFSFDIPTJOOBUPTFJO
BMJFOBCMFT FO UPEPT MPT TFSFT IVNBOPT
MPTMMBNBEPTEFSFDIPTDJWJMFTZQPMUJDPT
'SFOUF BM WJFKP NPEFMP EFM &TUBEP QB
UFSOBMJTUB FMOVFWPBmSNBCBRVFUPEPT
MPT TFSFT IVNBOPT TPO BEVMUPT Z BVU
OPNPT  FT EFDJS  TVKFUPT EF EFSFDIPT
RVFOBEJFQVFEFWJPMBS 4ODIF["HFTUB 

%FFTUFNPEP FMMVHBSRVFFOFM
WJFKP NPEFMP PDVQ FM QBUFSOBMJTNP MP
PDVQBBIPSBMBJEFBEFBVUPOPNB5P
EPTMPTDJVEBEBOPT JODMVJEPTMPTJOEJPT 





&MDPOUFYUPIJTUSJDPEFMBCJPUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB

FSBODPOTJEFSBEPTBVUOPNPTZEFCBO
TFS USBUBEPT DPNP JHVBMFT FO FM OVFWP
&TUBEPEFNPDSUJDP
4JCJFO EFTEFVOQVOUPEFWJTUBGPSNBM 
FTUP DPOTUJUVZ VO JOEJTDVUJCMF BWBODF 
FOPUSPTBTQFDUPTQSPWPDVODMBSPSFUSP
DFTP&OMPTIFDIPT FMJOEJPOPHBOFO
QSFTUJHJPPFOOJWFMTPDJBMFOFTUBOVFWB
GBTF TJOPRVFTJHVJFTUBOEPDPNQMFUB
NFOUFNBSHJOBEPEFOUSPEFMBEJONJ
DB TPDJBM EF FTUPT QVFCMPT .T BO  BM
OPFTUBSZBQSPUFHJEPQPSMBTFTUSVDUVSBT
EFM WJFKP &TUBEP QBUFSOBMJTUB TF FODPO
US DPNQMFUBNFOUF JOEFGFOTP GSFOUF B
MPTJOUFSFTFTFDPONJDPTZTPDJBMFTEFMB
CVSHVFTBDSJPMMB"TTFFYQMJDBOMBTHVF
SSBTEFQFSTFDVDJOEFJOEJPTRVFTFFN
QSFOEJFSPO FO EJWFSTPT QBTFT IJTQBOP
BNFSJDBOPTFOMBTFHVOEBNJUBEEFMTJHMP
9*9ZRVF FOBMHVOPTDBTPT DPOEVKFSPO
QSDUJDBNFOUFBTVFYUFSNJOJP
-B SFWPMVDJO QFSNJUJ B MB CVSHVFTB
DSJPMMBPSHBOJ[BSTFTFHOOVFWPTQBUSP
OFT EF DPOEVDUB  NVZ TJNJMBSFT B MPT
FVSPQFPT Z OPSUFBNFSJDBOPT " QBSUJS
EFMBJOEFQFOEFODJBEFMBTDPMPOJBTFT
QBPMBT FOFGFDUP DBEBWF[TFIJ[PNT
FWJEFOUFVOBFTUSVDUVSBTPDJBMEFDBSD
UFS DMBSBNFOUF CJQPMBS FO MPT OVFWPT
QBTFT BNFSJDBOPT  DPO VOB CVSHVFTB
EF VTPT Z DPTUVNCSFT FVSPQFPT Z QSJ
NFSNVOEJTUBT ZVOBBNQMJBDMBTFNF
OFTUFSPTBNVZBUFOJEBBMBTUSBEJDJPOFT
JOEJBTZOFHSBT ZEFDBSBDUFSTUJDBTDMB
SBNFOUFUFSDFSNVOEJTUBT
&TUF UJQP EF FTUSVDUVSB TPDJBM UVWP JN
QPSUBOUFTDPOTFDVFODJBTTBOJUBSJBT%FT
EFMBQPDBEFMBJOEFQFOEFODJB MBTDMB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

TFTCVSHVFTBTEJTGSVUBSPOEFVOBTBOJEBE
NVZTJNJMBSBMBPDDJEFOUBM FOUBOUPRVF
MBBUFODJOTBOJUBSJBEFMBTDMBTFTNFOFT
UFSPTBTGVFNVZEFmDJFOUF&OMPTQBTFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT TF DVNQMJ FM QSJODJ
QJPEFRVFFMFKFSDJDJPEFEFSFDIPTDJWJ
MFTZQPMUJDPTFTJNQPTJCMFDVBOEPOPWB
BDPNQBBEPQPSFMEFEFSFDIPTFDPO
NJDPT TPDJBMFTZDVMUVSBMFT6OEFSFDIP
DJWJMZQPMUJDPFTFMEFSFDIPBMBWJEBZB
MBJOUFHSJEBEGTJDB/PIBZEVEBEFRVF
MBTQFSTPOBTCJFOTJUVBEBTFDPONJDBZ
TPDJBMNFOUFQVFEFOHFTUJPOBSFTFEFSF
DIPTJOBZVEBEFM&TUBEP1FSPRVJFOFT
TF FODVFOUSBO FO TJUVBDJPOFT FDPONJ
DBTZTPDJBMFTNVZEFmDJFOUFTOPQVFEFO
IBDFSVTPEFTVTEFSFDIPTFDPONJDPT 
TPDJBMFTZDVMUVSBMFT FOUSFMPTRVFFTUFM
EFSFDIPBMBBTJTUFODJBTBOJUBSJB%JDIP
EFPUSBNBOFSB FOFTUPTDBTPTMPTEFSF
DIPTDJWJMFTZQPMUJDPT ZFODPODSFUPFM
EFSFDIP B MB BVUPOPNB  TF RVFEBO FO
EFSFDIPTNFSBNFOUFGPSNBMFT QFSPOP
SFBMFT4VFKFSDJDJPSFBMFYJHFVOBTDPO
EJDJPOFTCTJDBTRVF EFTEJDIBEBNFOUF 
BOOPTFEBOFOBNQMJPTTFDUPSFTEFMB
TPDJFEBEMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
-B DBSBDUFSTUJDB UQJDB EF MPT TJTUFNBT
TBOJUBSJPT QSPQJPT EF MPT QBTFT FO WBT
EFEFTBSSPMMPFTRVFFOMBTHSBOEFTDJV
EBEFT IBZ DFOUSPT TBOJUBSJPT NVZ CJFO
FRVJQBEPT  FO MPT DVBMFT TF BUJFOEF BM
TFDUPS EF QPCMBDJO RVF QVFEF QBHBS
FTPT TFSWJDJPT  QFSP FM SFTUP UJFOF VOB
BTJTUFODJB NEJDB NVZ QSFDBSJB 1PS
UBOUP  MPT QSPCMFNBT CJPUJDPT NT
JNQPSUBOUFT BMM TPO MPT SFMBDJPOBEPT
DPO MB KVTUJDJB Z MB EJTUSJCVDJO EF SF
DVSTPT FTDBTPT " NVDIPT TFDUPSFT EF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

MB QPCMBDJO OP MFT IB MMFHBEP BO MB


BMUBUFDOPMPHBTBOJUBSJB OJUBNQPDPFM
NPWJNJFOUP EF BVUPOPNJ[BDJO EF MPT
FOGFSNPT1PSUBOUP FTUBTDVFTUJPOFTOP
TPOBMMQSJPSJUBSJBT BVORVFTTFEBOFO
MPTTFDUPSFTBEJOFSBEPTRVFBDVEFOBMPT
DFOUSPTEFBMUBUFDOPMPHBEFMBTHSBOEFT
DJVEBEFT&OMPTQBTFTFOWBTEFEFTB
SSPMMP MB TPDJFEBE FTU EJWJEJEB FO EPT
HSVQPTNVZBMFKBEPTFMVOPEFMPUSPMB
CVSHVFTBBDBVEBMBEBZMBHSBONBTBEF
MBQPCMBDJOFTUPIBDFRVFFYJTUBOEPT
TBOJEBEFTDPNQMFUBNFOUFEJTUJOUBT VOB
EFMBTDVBMFTUJFOFMPTQSPCMFNBTQSPQJPT
EFMBTBOJEBEPDDJEFOUBM FOUBOUPMBPUSB
OP (SBDJB 

&TVOIFDIPDBSBDUFSTUJDPEFMPTQBTFT
FOWBTEFEFTBSSPMMPoDPODSFUBNFOUFEF
NVDIPT QBTFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT  DPNP
$IJMF  $PTUB 3JDB  1BOBN  7FOF[VF
MB P .YJDPo RVF TJ CJFO MB TFHVSJEBE
TPDJBM DVCSF MB BTJTUFODJB TBOJUBSJB EF
HSBOQBSUFEFMBQPCMBDJO FTBBTJTUFO
DJBUJFOFVODBSDUFSGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUF
UFSDJBSJPZDPFYJTUFDPOVOBNVZQPCSF
BTJTUFODJB QSJNBSJB  DBSBDUFSJ[BEB QPS
MB EFTOVUSJDJO  MB GBMUB EF TFSWJDJPT EF
BHVBQPUBCMFZBMDBOUBSJMMBEP MBGBMUBEF
FEVDBDJO Z DVMUVSB  EFmDJFOUF IJHJFOF
QFSTPOBM EFTFNQMFPZNBSHJOBMJTNP
&TUPQFSNJUFFOUFOEFSQPSRVMPTQSP
CMFNBTCJPUJDPTZMBTFOTJCJMJEBECJPUJ
DBEFMBTPDJFEBEMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBBDUVBM
TPONVZEJTUJOUPTTFHOFMOJWFMRVFTF
BOBMJDF-BTDMBTFTCVSHVFTBTSFDJCFOVOB
BTJTUFODJBNEJDBEFUJQPPDDJEFOUBM TJ
NJMBSBMBEFMPTPUSPTQBTFTEFM1SJNFS
.VOEP ZTFQMBOUFBOMPTNJTNPTQSP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

CMFNBTNPSBMFTRVFIPZQSFPDVQBOBMM
BVUPOPNB EF MPT QBDJFOUFT  DPOTFOUJ
NJFOUPJOGPSNBEP SFDIB[PEFMQBUFSOB
MJTNP QSPCMFNBTEFSFQSPEVDDJOBTJT
UJEB EJBHOTUJDPQSFOBUBM USBTQMBOUFTEF
SHBOPT FOUSFPUSPT"OBMJ[BEBMBCJPUJ
DBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBFOFTUFOJWFM QPESB
EFDJSTFRVFFTTJNJMBSBMBRVFTFSFBMJ[B
FODVBMRVJFSPUSPMVHBSEFMNVOEP
1FSP TJ TF FOGPDBO MPT QSPCMFNBT EF MB
CJPUJDB EFTEF MB QFSTQFDUJWB EF MBT QFS
TPOBT NFOFTUFSPTBT  RVF FO FTUPT QBTFT
TPOMBNBZPSBEFMBQPCMBDJO FOUPODFT
TFBEWJFSUFRVFFOTVNBZPSBDBSFDFOEF
TFOUJEP&MQSPCMFNBEFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUP
JOGPSNBEP EFKB EF TFS SFMFWBOUF DVBOEP
TFWJWFFOTJUVBDJOEFHSBOQFOVSJBZTF
UJFOFDPNPQSPCMFNBQSJNBSJPZDPUJEJB
OPFMEFMBBMJNFOUBDJOZIBTUBFMEFMB
TVCTJTUFODJB"FTUFNFEJPTPDJBMOPMMFHB
MBNFEJDJOBEFUFSDFSOJWFM RVFFTMBRVF
IBQSPWPDBEPFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB
FO MPT QBTFT EFM 1SJNFS .VOEP  Z BE
RVJFSF UPEB TV JNQPSUBODJB MB NFEJDJOB
EFQSJNFSOJWFM"RVMPTQSPCMFNBTQSJP
SJUBSJPTOPUJFOFORVFWFSDPOFMQSJODJQJP
UJDPEFBVUPOPNB TJOPDPOMPTQSJODJ
QJPTEFKVTUJDJBZOPNBMFmDFODJB
)BTUB BIPSB  FTUPT QSPCMFNBT OP IBO
TJEPPCKFUPEFVOHSBOEFTBSSPMMPFOMB
CJPUJDBEFMBTMUJNBTEDBEBT.JPQJ
OJOFTRVFFMDPOUBDUPDPOMBSFBMJEBE
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB QVFEF TFS VOB NBHO
mDB PDBTJO QBSB GPNFOUBS TV FTUVEJP
/P QPEFNPT PMWJEBS RVF FTUPT TPO MPT
QSPCMFNBTRVFBGFDUBOBM5FSDFS.VOEP
RVF IPZQPSIPZ FTMBNBZPSQBSUFEF
MBIVNBOJEBE



&MDPOUFYUPIJTUSJDPEFMBCJPUJDBIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOB%JFHP(SBDJB



3FGFSFODJBT
"DPTUB  + 
 %F 1SPDVSBOEB *OEPSVN 4BMVUF .BESJE  $POTFKP 4VQFSJPS EF
*OWFTUJHBDJPOFT$JFOUGJDBT
"SJTUUFMFT 
1PMUJDB.BESJE *OTUJUVUPEF&TUVEJPT1PMUJDPT
#BJ , 4IJSBJ :BOE*TIJJ . 
*O+BQBO $POTFOTVT)BT-JNJUT)BTUJOHT$FOUFS
3FQPSU  
+VOF QQ
$JTOFSPT % 
4JUJP /BUVSBMF[BZ1SPQJFEBEFTEFMB$JVEBEEF.YJDP.YJDP 
+PBO#MBODPEF"MD[BS
$PMO $ 
5FYUPTZEPDVNFOUPTDPNQMFUPT3FMBDJPOFTEFWJBKFT DBSUBTZNFNPSJBMFT
.BESJE "MJBO[B&EJUPSJBM
%PVDIFU . 
"OUISPQPMPHJFFUIJTUPJSFBVTJDMFEFTMVNJSFT1BSJT .BTQFSP
%SBOF +' 
#FDPNJOHB(PPE%PDUPS5IF1MBDFPG7JSUVFBOE$IBSBDUFSJO.FEJDBM
&UIJDT,BOTBT$JUZ 4IFFUBOE8BSE
(CBEFHFTJO 4 
#JPFUIJDT"O"GSJDBO1FSTQFDUJWF #JPFUIJDT  
+VMF QQ

(SBDJB  % 
 * QSPCMFNJ FUJDJ EFMMB .FEJDJOB OFMMBSFB MJOHVJTUJDB TQBHOPMB *O
7JBGPSB  $  FE 7FOUBOOJ EJ #JPFUJDB 1BEPWB  'POEB[JPOF -BO[B(SFHPSJBOB
-JCSFSJB&EJUSJDF
(SBDJB % 
5IF*OUFMMFDUVBM#BTJTPG#JPFUIJDTJO4PVUIFSO&VSPQFBO$PVOUSJFT 
#JPFUIJDT  
"QSJM QQ
(VFSSB ' 
5IF1SFDPMVNCJBN.JOE-POEPO 4FNJOBS1SFTT
(VFSSB ' 
.FEJDJOBDPMPOJBMFO)JTQBOPBNSJDB&O-BO&OUSBMHP 1 EJS
)JTUPSJB6OJWFSTBMEFMB.FEJDJOB7PM*7 #BSDFMPOB 4BMWBU
(VFSSB ' 
&MNEJDPQPMUJDP.BESJE "GSPEJTJP"HVBEP
(VFSSB ' 
-BNFEJDJOBQSFDPMPNCJOB.BESJE &EJDJPOFTEF$VMUVSB)JTQOJDB
)BOLF - 
-BMVDIBQPSMBKVTUJDJBFOMBDPORVJTUBEF"NSJDB.BESJE *TUNP
-BO&OUSBMHP 1 
&OGFSNFEBEZQFDBEP#BSDFMPOB 5PSBZ
-BT$BTBT # 
)JTUPSJBEFMBT*OEJBT .BESJE 3JWBEFOFZSB
.PMJOB. 
-BMFZFOEBOFHSB.BESJE /FSFB
1BHEFO " 
5IF'BMMPG/BUVSBM.BO5IF"NFSJDBO*OEJBOBOEUIF0SJHJOTPG
$PNQBSBUJWF&UIOPMPHZ$BNCSJEHF $BNCSJEHF6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
1FSFB - 
-BJEFBEFKVTUJDJBFOMBDPORVJTUBEF"NSJDB.BESJE .BQGSF
2JV 3; 
8IBUIBT#JPFUIJDTUPPGGFSUIF%FWFMPQJOH$PVOUSJFT#JPFUIJDT  

"QSJM QQ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

3JWFSB . FE 


$IJMBN#BMBNEF$IVNBZFM.BESJE )JTUPSJB
4FO[EF4BOUB.BSB $ FE 
1PQPM7VI.BESJE )JTUPSJB
4ODIF["HFTUB - 
-BEFNPDSBDJBFO)JTQBOPBNSJDB.BESJE 3JBMQ
7FTQVDDJ " 
$BSUBTEF7JBKF.BESJE "MJBO[B
7JUPSJB  ' 
 3FMFDUJP EF JOEJBT .BESJE  $POTFKP 4VQFSJPS EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT
$JFOUGJDBT
9JSBV 3FE 
*EFBZRVFSFMMBEFMB/VFWB&TQBB.BESJE "MJBO[B

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





-PTEJTDVSTPTEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB
+PT"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDB1SF[

*OUSPEVDDJO

BCJPUJDBOBDJFO&TUBEPT6OJEPT
Z  DPO FM UJFNQP  GVF BEPQUBEB Z
BEBQUBEB
 QPS PUSPT QBTFT  FOUSF FMMMPT
MPT EF "NSJDB -BUJOB &TUB MUJNB TF
IBEFTBSSPMMBEPEVSBOUFUSFJOUBBPT FO
USFTFUBQBT DVCSJFOEPEDBEBT DPNFO
[BOEPFOMPTBPT
SFDFQDJO BTJNJ
MBDJOZSFDSFBDJO$PNPQJPOFSPEFM
QSPDFTP QPS FM DVBM MB CJPUJDB GVF JOT
UJUVDJPOBMJ[BEB FO "SHFOUJOB OP QVFEP
FWJUBSVOBDJFSUBSFGFSFODJBBNJQSPQJB
FYQFSJFODJBDPNPEFQPOFOUF .BJOFUUJ
 .BJOFUUJ  .BJOFUUJ 
.BJOFUUJ 
 KVTUJmDBEB QPS FM DP
NFOUBSJP EF VO CJPFUJDJTUB BNFSJDBOP 
CJFODPOPDJEPiJEFOUJmDBSFMPSJHFOEF
MB CJPUJDB FO &&66 FT VOB DVFTUJO
EFDJFSUBDPOUSPWFSTJBDPOTJEFSBCMF1FSP
MBIJTUPSJBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBEFMBCJPUJDB
FT B VO HSBOEFHSBEP MB IJTUPSJBEFVO
IPNCSFw %SBOF


3FDFQDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFOMB
EDBEBEF
&MUSNJOPiSFDFQDJOwOPTFEFCFFO
UFOEFS DPNP JOUSPEVDDJO GPSNBM EF
MB EJTDJQMJOB oQVFTUP RVF FO MPT BPT
 MB QBMBCSB OP FSB DPNO  JODMVTP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

FO &&66o  TJOP FO UBOUP SFGFSFODJB


BDNPMBTJUVBDJODVMUVSBMFIJTUSJDB
FOMBSFHJOQPTJCJMJUPJNQJEJTVJOJ
DJP-PTBPTTFDBSBDUFSJ[BSPOQPSMB
SFBDDJOEFSFTJTUFODJBPSFDIB[PBFTUF
OVFWPNPWJNJFOUPQPSQBSUFEFRVJFOFT
BEIFSBOBVOFUIPTDWJDPZQSPGFTJPOBM
USBEJDJPOBM $PNP NPSBMJEBE MJCFSBM Z
TFDVMBS MBCJPUJDBQSPNPWBMBBVUPOP
NBEFMQBDJFOUF JOUSPEVDJFOEPMBJEFB
EFTUFDPNPTVKFUPNPSBMFONFEJDJOB
ZBDFOUVBOEPTVQBQFMDPNPBHFOUFSB
DJPOBM Z MJCSF  FODBSHBEP EF EFDJTJPOFT
DFOUSBMFTFOMBSFMBDJOUFSBQVUJDB&T
UBTJEFBTFSBOFYUSBBTBMBBOUJHVBUJDB
NEJDBUPEBWBSFJOBOUFFO"NSJDB-B
UJOB RVFTFHVBTJFOEPDPOGFTJPOBMoEF
BDVFSEPDPOMBEPDUSJOBZMBBVUPSJEBE
NPSBMFTEFMDBUPMJDJTNPSPNBOPoZQB
UFSOBMJTUB -PT NEJDPT QSBDUJDBCBO TF
HOFMiQBQFMEFEPNJOBDJOw EFMRVF
IBCMB.BY8FCFS FOFMDVBMMBBVUPSJ
EBEEFMNEJDPFTTVQSFNBZFTPCMJHB
DJOEFMQBDJFOUFTPNFUFSTFBFMMB .BD
LMJOZ-VOB 

*OJDJBMNFOUF  MB CJPUJDB GVF QFSDJCJEB
DPNP iQSPEVDJEB FO MPT &&66w  FT
EFDJS VOBDFSDBNJFOUPBMBNFEJDJOBZ
BMPTDVJEBEPTNEJDPTEFFTUJMPOPSUF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

BNFSJDBOP &TUBT JEFBT  QPS PUSB QBSUF 


EFCBOFODPOUSBSSFTJTUFODJB QPSRVFMBT
BDUJUVEFT NBSYJTUBT BOUJBNFSJDBOBT TF
IBCBO BUSJODIFSBEP FO -BUJOPBNSJDB
-B CJPUJDB OP TF QPESB USBTQMBOUBS B
FTUFDPOUFYUPTJODPOTJEFSBSEJGFSFODJBT
DVMUVSBMFTZQPMUJDBT Z QPSMPUBOUP TV
TJHOJmDBEPEFCBDBNCJBSFOFTBTTPDJF
EBEFTQBSUJDVMBSFT
"SHFOUJOB GVF QJPOFSB FO FTUF QSPDFTP
EFSFDFQDJO&MQSJNFS1SPHSBNB*CF
SPBNFSJDBOPEF#JPUJDBGVFFTUBCMFDJEP
FOFM*OTUJUVUPEF)VNBOJEBEFT.EJ
DBTEFMB'VOEBDJO+PT.BSB.BJOFUUJ

 &O   FM %S +PT "MCFSUP
.BJOFUUJGVOEFMJOTUJUVUPZEFTFNQF
VOQBQFMJNQPSUBOUFFOMBTBDUJWJEBEFT
UFNQSBOBT FO MB SFHJO .T BEFMBOUF 
TF EFTBSSPMMBSPO QSPHSBNBT FEVDBUJWPT
FO MB &TDVFMB -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF #JP
UJDB  CBKP MB EJSFDDJO EF +VBO $BSMPT
5FBMEJ%VSBOUFNVDIPTBPT FSVEJUPT
EF&&66IBOQBSUJDJQBEPFOFTUFQSP
ZFDUP&MDFOUSPIBQVCMJDBEPMBSFWJTUB
2VJSOEFTEF ZQSPEVDJEPWBSJBT
NPOPHSBGBTTPCSFUJDBNEJDB 'JHVF
SPBZ'VFO[BMJEB 

&TUF JOTUJUVUP GPNFOU FTUVEJPT CJPUJ
DPT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTCBKP MB JOnVFODJB
EFMBFTDVFMBFTQBPMBEFIJTUPSJBEFMB
NFEJDJOB  DPOEVDJEB QPS 1FESP -BO
&OUSBMHP &TUF FOGPRVF QSPQPOF VOB
UFPSBEFMBNFEJDJOBCBTBEBFOMBBOUSP
QPMPHBNEJDBmMPTmDB JOTQJSBEBQPS
MB mMPTPGB FYJTUFODJBM Z IFSNFOVUJDB
FVSPQFB%JDIPNPWJNJFOUPJOUFMFDUVBM
DSF DPOEJDJPOFT GBWPSBCMFT QBSB MB SF
DFQDJO EFM NPWJNJFOUP NEJDP OPS

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UFBNFSJDBOP EF MBT IVNBOJEBEFT FO MB


CJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
-BQSJNFSBEDBEBEFM*OTUJUVUPEF)V
NBOJEBEFT.EJDBTSFHJTUSBMBSFDFQDJO
EFFTUBTEJTDJQMJOBT FTUJNVMBEBFOQBSUF
QPS FM WODVMP QFSTPOBM F JOTUJUVDJPOBM
JOJDJBEP QPS FM NEJDP Z mMTPGP )
5SJTUSBN&OHFMIBSEU +S FOUPODFTFOFM
*OTUJUVUP EF )VNBOJEBEFT .EJDBT EF
MB6OJWFSTJEBEEFM5FYBT FO(BMWFTUPO
*OTUJUVUFGPS.FEJDBM)VNBOJUJFTPGUIF
6OJWFSTJUZ PG 5FYBT .FEJDBM #SBODI
 Z
FMCJPFUJDJTUBNEJDP&ENVOE1FMMFHSJ
OP EJSFDUPSEFMJOnVZFOUF*OTUJUVUPEF
7BMPSFT )VNBOPT FO .FEJDJOB *OTUJ
UVUF PG )VNBO 7BMVFT JO .FEJDJOF
 EF
8BTIJOHUPO %$&TBDPOFYJODPOMBT
IVNBOJEBEFT NEJDBT FYQMJDB QPS RV
"SHFOUJOBZ&TQBBGVFSPOMPTQSJNFSPT
QBTFTRVFJOJDJBSPOMBCJPUJDBFO"N
SJDB-BUJOBZ&VSPQB SFTQFDUJWBNFOUF
&M NPWJNJFOUP EF MBT IVNBOJEBEFT
NEJDBT FTUBCB FO DPOTPOBODJB DPO MB
BOUSPQPMPHBNEJDBEF-BO&OUSBMHP 
BDVZBFTDVFMBEFQFOTBNJFOUPTFBTPDJB
SPOBMHVOPTFTUVEJPTPTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT
&TDPCBS 
-BSFDFQDJO
EFMBCJPUJDBDPNPQBSUFEFMBQFSTQFD
UJWBUFSJDBEFMBTIVNBOJEBEFTNEJDBT
TJHOJmD QPSMPUBOUP VOBBDUJUVEDS
UJDB QPSRVFEFTBmTVQPTJDJPOFTZKVJ
DJPTEFWBMPSPDVMUPT%VSBOUFMPTBPT
MBiNFEJDJOBQPTNPEFSOBwFNFSHJ
DPNP DSUJDB EFM SB[POBNJFOUP NEJDP
QPTJUJWJTUB  UFOB MBSHP BMDBODF MFKBOP Z
BGFDUBCBBMPCKFUP NUPEPZNFUBEFMB
QSPQJBNFEJDJOB&TEFDJS MBNFEJDJOB
ZB OP FSB VOB iDJFODJB OPSNBMw  FO FM





-PTEJTDVSTPTEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB+PT"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDB1SF[

TFOUJEP EF ,VIO  TJOP RVF QBTBCB QPS


VOBSFWPMVDJONPSBM4VSHJFOUPODFT
DJFSUB MJUFSBUVSB DSUJDB TPCSF NFEJDJOB 
JODMVZFOEP FM DMFCSF .FEJDBM /NFTJT
EF *WBO *MMJDI *MMJDI 
 MBT JDPOP
DMBTUBT DPOGFSFODJBT 3FJUI EF *BO ,FO
OFEZ iF 6ONBTLJOH PG .FEJDJOFw

,FOOFEZ  
 Z FM BOMJTJT TPDJBM
DSUJDPEFMQPEFSNEJDPDBQJUBMJTUBQPS
QBSUFEFFTDSJUPSFTBNFSJDBOPTDPNP7J
DFOUF /BWBSSP /BWBSSP   
WBTFUBNCJOFMDBQUVMP

-BiNFEJDJOBQPTNPEFSOBwEFCFTVSF
MBUJWJTNP B TV OBUVSBMF[B DBEB WF[ NT
DPNQSFOTJWB JOUFSQSFUBUJWBZFWBMVBUJWB
FO TVNB  B TV SFnFYJWJEBE -B mMPTPGB
EF MB NFEJDJOB BCBSDB MB BOUSPQPMPHB 
MBFQJTUFNPMPHBZMBBYJPMPHBNEJDBT
&MMUJNPFTUBEJPJODMVJSBMBCJPUJDBFO
TVTBTQFDUPTEFTBMVEDMOJDBZQCMJDB
%F FTUB NBOFSB  FO "NSJDB -BUJOB MB
CJPUJDB FT FM OVFWP QBSBEJHNB NEJ
DP IVNBOJTUB Z  TPCSF UPEP  VOB UJDB
iJNQMJDBEBwNTCJFORVFiBQMJDBEBwB
MBNFEJDJOB RVFEFSJWEFMBBYJPMPHB
JOUSOTFDB B MB QSPGFTJO NEJDB &O
DPOUSBTUFDPOFMEFTBSSPMMPBNFSJDBOPEF
MBCJPUJDBoRVFJNQMJDBNEJDPT UF
MPHPT mMTPGPTZBCPHBEPToMPTQSPUBHP
OJTUBTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTEFMBEJTDJQMJOB
GVFSPOQSJODJQBMNFOUFNEJDPTZPUSPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMPTDVJEBEPTNEJDPT

-BBTJNJMBDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFO
MBEDBEBEF
&M EJTDVSTP BDBENJDP Z QCMJDP EF MB
EJTDJQMJOB TF JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[ FO MB SF
HJO TJHVJFOEP FM NPEFMP BNFSJDBOP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

$POMBSFTUBVSBDJOEFMBEFNPDSBDJBZ
MB JOUSPEVDDJO EF OVFWBT UFDOPMPHBT
NEJDBT oUBMFT DPNP MPT DVJEBEPT JO
UFOTJWPT FMUSBTQMBOUFZMBSFQSPEVDDJO
BTJTUJEBo FMJOUFSTQCMJDPZBDBENJ
DPQPSMBCJPUJDBTFBNQMJFOMPTBPT
-BBTJNJMBDJOTFIBSFnFKBEPFOMB
CJPUJDB BNFSJDBOB EF EPT NBOFSBT FM
BVNFOUP EF MJUJHJPT QPS OFHMJHFODJB FO
MB BTJTUFODJB NEJDB Z FM NPWJNJFOUP
QPS MPT EFSFDIPT EFM QBDJFOUF JNJUBSPO
GBDUPSFTRVFIBCBODPOEVDJEPBTVOB
DJNJFOUP FO &&66 DPO MB SFTUBVSB
DJO EF MB EFNPDSBDJB WJOP VO JOUFST
SFOPWBEPFOMBmMPTPGBNPSBMZQPMUJDB
ZFOMBGPSNBDJOEFMQMVSBMJTNPJEFPM
HJDPZEFMDPOTFOTP RVFEFTQVTGVFSPO
BQMJDBEPTBMBNFEJDJOBZTFDPOWJSUJFSPO
FODPNQPOFOUFTEPNJOBOUFTEFMBOVF
WBCJPUJDB UBMDPNPFO&&66 -PMBT 


&O   MB GVOEBDJO .BJOFUUJ MBO[
VOB TFHVOEB FUBQB EF JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[B
DJO FO EPT BNCJFOUFT BDBENJDPT MB
&TDVFMB .EJDB Z FM %FQBSUBNFOUP EF
'JMPTPGBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF
-B 1MBUB -B DUFESB EF )VNBOJEBEFT
.EJDBT QSPQPSDJPO MB PQPSUVOJEBE
QBSBVOBmMPTPGBEFMBNFEJDJOBDPNP
NFEJUBDJO QPTnFYOFSJBOB EFM BSUF DV
SBUJWP DPOUSBVONPEFMPSFEVDDJPOJTUB
&MNPEFMP'MFYOFSJNQMJDBCBFMBOUJHVP
QBSBEJHNBNEJDPQPTJUJWJTUBEFMBNF
EJDJOB SFTUSJOHJEPBMBTDJFODJBTOBUVSB
MFTBQMJDBEBT-BCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDB
OBBEPQUVOOVFWPQBSBEJHNBNEJDP
RVFFNQMFBCBMBTDJFODJBTZMBTIVNBOJ
EBEFTQBSBEFTBSSPMMBSVOBUFPSBZVOB
QSDUJDBEFMBNFEJDJOB&OMPTBPT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

FMJOTUJUVUPDPOUJOVBTJNJMBOEPMBCJP
UJDBBMBBDUVBMmMPTPGBEFMBNFEJDJOB
-B DUFESB EF "OUSPQPMPHB 'JMPTmDB
JOUSPEVKP MB CJPUJDB DPNP GFONFOP
DVMUVSBM FTEFDJS MBDPODFQDJOEFVOB
SFWPMVDJOCJPMHJDBRVFUSBOTGPSNMB
OBUVSBMF[BIVNBOBZVOBOVFWBNPSBMJ
EBEDWJDBTPCSFMPTDVJEBEPTNEJDPT
&M mOBM EF MB EDBEB BUFTUJHV MB nP
SBDJO EF DFOUSPT  JOTUJUVUPT Z HSVQPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFT FO MB SFHJO &M *OTUJUVUP
$PMPNCJBOPEF&TUVEJPT#JPUJDPT #P
HPU $PMPNCJB
GVFGVOEBEPFO 
BOJNBEPQPSMBFOTFBO[BOPUBCMFEF"M
GPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS 4+ EFMB6OJWFS
TJEBE+BWFSJBOB&O7FOF[VFMB FMEPDUPS
"VHVTUP -FO $  BVUPS EF VO UFYUP
DMTJDPEFUJDBNEJDBFO GVFSFT
QPOTBCMF EFM BSUDVMP TPCSF CJPUJDB FO
"NSJDB -BUJOB FO MB QSJNFSB FEJDJO
EF MB &ODZDMPQFEJB PG #JPFUIJDT -FO
$  
 -B 6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUMJDB EF $IJMF DSF VOB VOJEBE EF
CJPUJDBFOMB&TDVFMBEF.FEJDJOB FO
  Z QBSUJDJQBSPO FO FTUF QSPHSBNB
MPTEPDUPSFT"MFKBOESP4FSBOJZ.BOVFM
-BWBEPT-B1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$B
UMJDBEF3P(SBOEFEP4VM FO1PSUP
"MFHSF  #SBTJM  FTUBCMFDJ VO QSPHSBNB
HSBEVBEPFOCJPUJDBFO EJSJHJEP
QPS+PBRVJN$MPUFU mMTPGPEF#BSDF
MPOB &TQBB
"MBFUBQBEFBTJNJMBDJOEFMBCJPUJDB
TJHVJ MB FUBQB DSUJDB EF SFDFQDJO FO
"NSJDB -BUJOB -B OBUVSBMF[B SBEJDBM
EF MB CJPUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB WB NT
BMM EF MB mMPTPGB EF MB NFEJDJOB Z TF
DPOWJFSUFFOVOBmMPTPGBEFMBDVMUVSB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

Z MB UFDOPMPHB  NPWJOEPTF EFTEF MB


NFUBNFEJDJOBBMBNFUBUJDB BMCVTDBS
VODVFTUJPOBNJFOUPGVOEBNFOUBMEFMB
UFDOPDJFODJB
-BOPWFEBEZMBTFSJFEBEEFMPTQSPCMF
NBT SFGFSFOUFT B MB WJEB NPEFMBO VOB
DSJTJTCJPUJDBEFMBFSBUFDOPMHJDB&O
FTUB OVFWB DSJTJT WJUBM Z OPSNBUJWB IBZ
USFT UFNBT FOUSFMB[BEPT MB DBUTUSPGF
FDPMHJDB  MB SFWPMVDJO CJPMHJDB Z MB
NFEJDBMJ[BDJO EF MB WJEB -B CJPUJ
DB TVSHJ DPNP SFTVMUBEP EF DBNCJPT
EF HSBO FOWFSHBEVSB FO OVFTUSB DPN
QSFOTJOEFMBDPOEJDJOIVNBOBZFO
OVFTUSBDBQBDJEBEBVNFOUBEBEFUSBOT
GPSNBSFMDVFSQP%FTEFTVTDPNJFO[PT 
FMDBNJOPMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPBMBCJPUJDB
IBTJEPVOBCTRVFEBEFMTFSIVNBOP 
FOFMTFOUJEPEFVOBCTRVFEBEFCBTF
FO MB BOUSPQPMPHB mMPTmDB  DFOUSBEB
FOMBOVFWBDBQBDJEBEEFBMUFSBSFMDVFS
QPZEFDSFBSVOBNPSBMJEBEBMUFSOBUJWB
%SBOF 


-BSFDSFBDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFOMB
EDBEBEF
&OMPTBPTMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBTFSFDPOTUSVZVTBOEPGPSNBTRVF
JODPSQPSBO USBEJDJPOFT JOUFMFDUVBMFT Z
NPSBMFTUQJDBTEFMBSFHJO&OMBNB
ZPSBEFMPTQBTFTFMNPWJNJFOUPTFPS
HBOJ[FOUSFTSFBTBDBENJDB JOWFTUJ
HBDJODJFOUmDBZFEVDBDJOTVQFSJPS

DVJEBEPT NEJDPT DPOTVMUBT EF TBMVE
DMOJDB Z QCMJDB  DPNJUT IPTQJUBMBSJPT
EF UJDB
 Z QPMUJDB QCMJDB TFSWJDJPT
EFDPOTVMUPSBZSFDPNFOEBDJPOFTBMBT
BVUPSJEBEFT FO DVFTUJPOFT OPSNBUJWBT





-PTEJTDVSTPTEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB+PT"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDB1SF[

Z SFHVMBUJWBT
 $PODVSSFOUFNFOUF  MBT
BTPDJBDJPOFTSFHJPOBMFTTFEFTBSSPMMBSPO
F JNQVMTBSPO FM NPWJNJFOUP CJPUJDP
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP FO DPOTFDVFODJB  VOB
JEFOUJEBEUJDBSFHJPOBMEJTUJOUJWBTFIB
DPOWFSUJEP FO NPEFMP EF FTUF NPWJ
NJFOUP
'VOEBEBFO MB&TDVFMB-BUJOPBNF
SJDBOBEF#JPUJDB &-"#&
EFMB'VO
EBDJO.BJOFUUJ GVFMBQSJNFSBJOJDJBUJWB
EFUSBCBKPBDBENJDPFOFTUBSFBEFJO
nVFODJBDVMUVSBM&TVOQSPHSBNBEFFO
USFOBNJFOUPRVFGPSNBSFDVSTPTIVNB
OPTQBSBFMMJEFSB[HPEFMBEJTDJQMJOBFO
MPTQBTFTEFPSJHFOEFMPTQBSUJDJQBOUFT
ZQSPQPSDJPOBVOGPSPQBSBFMJOUFSDBN
CJPDVMUVSBMZDJFOUmDP&MDVSTPJOUFS
OBDJPOBMEFCJPUJDBEF&-"#&EVSBOUF
MPTBPTGVFQSFTJEJEPQPSQSPGFTPSFT
QSPNJOFOUFT EF DFOUSPT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
JNQPSUBOUFT &M $FOUSP 0ODPMHJDP EF
&YDFMFODJB 'VOEBDJO.BJOFUUJ
DSFMB
'FEFSBDJO-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF#JPUJDB
FOEJDJFNCSFEF
&O +BNFT%SBOF EF&&66 GVF
DPNJTJPOBEPQPSMB0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOB
NFSJDBOBEF4BMVE 014
QBSBWJTJUBSWB
SJPTQBTFTZQSPEVDJSVOJOGPSNFTPCSF
FM EFTBSSPMMP EF MB CJPUJDB FO "NSJDB
-BUJOB&TUFJOnVZFOUFJOGPSNFQSPQVTP
EJWFSTPTQBTPTQBSBFMEFTBSSPMMPSFHJPOBM
QPTUFSJPSEFMBEJTDJQMJOB %SBOFZ'VFO
[BMJEB 
&OFMNJTNPBP 
MB014QVCMJDVOBFEJDJOFTQFDJBMEF
CJPUJDB  DPPSEJOBEB QPS 4VTBO 4DIPMMF
$POOPS Z )FSOO 'VFO[BMJEB1VFMNB 
JOUSPEVDJFOEP GPSNBMNFOUF MB CJPUJDB
FO "NSJDB -BUJOB 4DIPMMF $POOPS Z

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

'VFO[BMJEB 
'VFMBQSJNFSBDPN
QJMBDJORVFBCPSEBTVOUPTEJWFSTPTZTF
QSPQVTJFSPOEJTUJOUBTQFSTQFDUJWBTTPCSF
MB EJTDJQMJOB "EFNT  MB 014  QJPOFSB
FOUSF MBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
EFTBMVE DSFFM1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF
#JPUJDB 
DPOTFEFFO4BOUJBHPEF
$IJMFQFSPDPOBDUJWJEBEFTEFTDFOUSBMJ[B
EBTQBSBTFSWJSBUPEPTMPTQBTFTNJFN
CSPT&TUFQSPHSBNB EJTFBEPQBSBEF
TBSSPMMBSVOBQPMUJDBBNQMJBFOCJPUJDB
ZTVTEJTDJQMJOBTBTPDJBEBT TFFODVFOUSB
FOVOBOVFWBFUBQBCBKPMBEJSFDDJOEFM
EPDUPS'FSOBOEP-PMBT4UFQLF 1SPHSB
NB3FHJPOBMEF#JPUJDB 

-BFUBQBEFSFDSFBDJOSFWFMBVOBUFSDFSB
DBSBDUFSTUJDBEFMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBTVQSFPDVQBDJOHMPCBM-BCJP
UJDB FT FODJDMPQEJDB QPS EFmOJDJO  FT
FUJNPMHJDBNFOUF iUJDB EF MB WJEBw Z
iWJEBEFMBUJDBw
QFSPTFNOUJDBNFOUF
OPDJSDVOTDSJUBBMCJPTUFDOPMHJDPOJBM
FUIPT MJCFSBM  DBSBDUFSTUJDPT EFM NPEFMP
OPSUFBNFSJDBOP&ODPOUSBTUFDPOTUF 
FM NPEFMP MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP BDFOUB VO
CJPT IVNBOP Z VO FUIPT DPNVOJUBSJP
1PS FTP MB CJPUJDB FT BIPSB VO NPWJ
NJFOUPQPMUJDPPEFSFGPSNBTPDJBMNT
RVFVOBEJTDJQMJOBBDBENJDBSFTUSJOHJ
EBBMEPNJOJPEFMPTDVJEBEPTNEJDPT
&OMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBMPTQSJO
DJQJPTEFTPMJEBSJEBEZKVTUJDJBEFTFNQF
BOFMQBQFMDFOUSBMRVFUJFOFMBBVUPOP
NBFOMBCJPUJDBOPSUFBNFSJDBOB"T 
MBT QPMUJDBT TBOJUBSJBT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT
JODMVZFOFMBDDFTPVOJWFSTBMBMPTDVJEB
EPTNEJDPTZBDFOUBOMBKVTUJDJBZMB
FRVJEBE EJTUSJCVUJWBT FO MB BTJHOBDJO
EFSFDVSTPTEFTBMVE





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

&TUFOPFTMVHBSQBSBVOFYBNFOEFQSP
HSFTPT CJPUJDPT FO EJWFSTPT QBTFT MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOPTPQBSBVOBSFWJTJOEFMPT
QSPCMFNBTCJPUJDPTQFDVMJBSFTBMBSFHJO
.BJOFUUJ 1JT%JF[Z5FBMEJ 
&TRVJTBCFM 1JT%JF[Z5FBMEJ 

 -B CJPUJDB TF IB DPOWFSUJEP
FODBNQPEFOVFWPTEFTBGPTFO"NSJDB
-BUJOB 6OB VOJGPSNJEBE EF TVQFSmDJF
QBSFDFPDVMUBSVODPOKVOUPSJDPZIFUF
SPHOFPEFBDUJWJEBEFT/PTMPJOnVFO
DJBTFVSPQFBTZDSJTUJBOBT TJOPUBNCJO
MBT USBEJDJPOFT JOUFMFDUVBMFT JOEHFOBT
TPO NVZ JNQPSUBOUFT FO FM EFTBSSPMMP
EF MB CJPUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB /P UJF
OFTVQSPQJBmMPTPGB FODPOUSBTUFDPO
MBQFSDFQDJORVFTFUJFOFEFMBCJPUJDB
BOHMPBNFSJDBOB QFSPTTVQSPQJPFTUJMP
EFMJUFSBUVSBZEFOBSSBUJWB&MDPOUFYUP
IJTUSJDP QBSUJDVMBS  FM FUIPT DVMUVSBM Z
MBSFBMJEBETPDJBMEF-BUJOPBNSJDBIBO
QPEJEPJOGVOEJSOVFWBWJEBFOMBDPNV
OJEBEHMPCBMEFMBCJPUJDB6OTOUPNB
EFMPTOVFWPTUJFNQPTFTRVFFMTFHVOEP
DPOHSFTPEFMB"TPDJBDJO*OUFSOBDJPOBM
EF#JPUJDBPDVSSJFO#VFOPT"JSFT "S
HFOUJOB FO ZFMTFYUPFO#SBTJMJB 
#SBTJM  FO  6OB iOVFWB CJPUJDB
CSBTJMFBwPiCJPUJDBEVSBwDPNFO[B
QSPTQFSBS FO BPT SFDJFOUFT *OTQJSBEB

QPSMBSFBMJEBETPDJBMDPOUSBEJDUPSJBEFM
QBT  FYQMPSB QFSTQFDUJWBT BMUFSOBUJWBT
B MBT DPSSJFOUFT CJPUJDBT USBEJDJPOBMFT
(BSSBGB 


$PODMVTJO
&TUF DBQUVMP SFMBUB FM EFTBSSPMMP EF MB
CJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBEVSBOUFMBT
MUJNBTUSFTEDBEBTFOUSNJOPTEFUSFT
FUBQBTSFDFQDJO BTJNJMBDJOZSFDSFB
DJO -B CJPUJDB MMFH QSJNFSP DPNP
VOB FYUSBB Z MVFHP FYQFSJNFOU VOB
USBOTGPSNBDJO DVMUVSBM 5SBTQMBOUBEB
BVOBUJFSSBRVFOPFSBTVICJUBUiOB
UVSBMw IBBERVJSJEPTVQSPQJPDBSDUFS
ZWP[EJTUJOUJWPTZTFIBDPOWFSUJEPFO
VO FNQSFOEJNJFOUP JOUFMFDUVBM Z QPM
UJDP GVFSUF -PMBT    -PMBT 


&ODPNQBSBDJODPOFMFTUJMPOPSUFBNF
SJDBOP  QSFTFOUB VO BDFSDBNJFOUP NT
UFSJDPZNTmMPTmDP$PNPCTRVF
EBEFVOBCJPUJDBDSUJDBZSBEJDBM NB
OJmFTUBVOBQPDBHMPCBM iQPTCJPUJDBw
%SBOF 
"VORVFFTUMF
KPTEFTFSVOTJTUFNBUFSJDPVOJmDBEP
PVOBTPMBQFSTQFDUJWBDPIFSFOUF SFQSF
TFOUB TJOFNCBSHP MBFUIJDBTQFT FTQF
SBO[BUJDB
EFMOVFWPNJMFOJP

3FGFSFODJBT
%SBOF +' 
6OJWFSTBM.FEJDBM&UIJDT2VJSO  
KVOJP QQ
%SBOF +' 
#JPFUIJDBM1FSTQFDUJWFTGSPN*CFSP"NFSJDB5IF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOF
F1IJMPTPQIZ  
QQ
%SBOF +' 'VFO[BMJEB ) 
.FEJDBM&UIJDTJO-BUJO"NFSJDBBOFXJOUFSFTUF
DPNNJUNFOU,FOOFEZ*OTUJUVUFPG&UIJDT+PVSOBM  
QQ
&TDPCBS5SJBOB + 
)VNBOJTUJDF4PDJBM&EVDBUJPOGPS1IZTJDJBOT5IF&YQFSJFODF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



-PTEJTDVSTPTEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB+PT"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDB1SF[



PG UIF $PMPNCJBO 4DIPPM PG .FEJDJOF 5IF +PVSOBM PG .FEJDJOF BOE 1IJMPTPQIZ 
 
QQ
'JHVFSPB 13 'VFO[BMJEB ) 
#JPFUIJDTJO*CFSP"NFSJDBFUIF$BSJCCFBO5IF
+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZ  
QQ
(BSSBGB 7 
"CJPFUIJDBMSBEJPHSBQIZPG#SB[JM"DUB#JPFUIJDB  
QQ
*MMJDI  * 
 -JNJUT UP .FEJDJOF .FEJDBM /FNFTJT 5IF &YQSPQJBUJPO PG )FBMUI
-POEPO .BSJPO#PZBST1VCMJTIFST-UE
,FOOFEZ * 
5IF6ONBTLJOHPG.FEJDJOF-POEPO "MMFOBOE6OXJO
-FO$FDDIJOJ " 
-BUJO"NFSJDBJOUIF5XFOUJFUI$FOUVSZ*O8BSSFO53
PSH &ODZDMPQFEJBPG#JPFUIJDT/FX:PSL.BD.JMMBO
-PMBT 4UFQLF  ' 
 &M EJTDVSTP CJPUJDP 6OB BODEPUB QFSTPOBM 2VJSO   

EJDJFNCSF QQ
-PMBT4UFQLF ' 
#JPUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJUPSJBM6OJWFSTJUBSJB
-PMBT 4UFQLF  ' 
 #JPUJDB Z "OUSPQPMPHB .EJDB 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF 
.FEJUFSSOFP
-PMBT4UFQLF ' 
#JPFUIJDTBOEUIFDVMUVSFPGMJGFBDPOUSJCVUJPOUPQFBDF#JPUJDB
*OGPSNB  QQ
.BDLMJO 3 'MPSFODJB- 
#JPFUIJDTJO"SHFOUJOB"$PVOUSZ3FQPSU#JPFUIJDT 
 
QQ
.BJOFUUJ +" 
#JPFUIJDBM1SPCMFNTJOUIF%FWFMPQJOH8PSME"7JFXGSPN-BUJO
"NFSJDB6OJUBT"2VBSUFSMZGPSUIF"SUTBOE4DJFODFT 
+VOF QQ
.BJOFUUJ +"$PNQMFKP#JPUJDP1JHNBMJO /BSDJTPZ,OPDL"DUBQTJRVJUSQTJDPM
"N-BU  
QQ
.BJOFUUJ  + " 
 0VU PG "NFSJDB 5IF 4DIPMBTUJD BOE .VOEBOF #JPFUIJDBM
4DFOF JO "SHFOUJOB *O 4JNQTJP 5SBOTDVMUVSBM %JNFOTJPOT PG .FEJDBM &UIJDT 
DPQBUSPDJOBEPQPS'JEJB3FTFBSDI'PVOEBUJPOF(FPSHFUPXO6OJWFSTJUZ$FOUFS
GPS UIF "EWBODFE 4UVEZ PG &UIJDT /BUJPOBM "DBEFNZ PG 4DJFODFT 8BTIJOHUPO
%$ EFBCSJM
.BJOFUUJ +PT" 1JT%JF[ (Z5FBMEJ +$ 
#JPFUIJDTJO-BUJO"NFSJDB*O
-VTUJH "0SH#JPFUIJDT:FBSCPPL7PM3FHJPOBM%FWFMPQNFOUJO#JPFUIJDT
%PSESFDIU 5IF/FUIFSMBOET ,MVXFS"DBEFNJD1VCMJTIFST QQ
.BJOFUUJ +PT" 
.FEJDBM&UIJDT )JTUPSZPG5IF"NFSJDBT-BUJO"NFSJDB*O
8BSSFO 53 PSH&ODZDMPQFEJBPG#JPFUIJDT/FX:PSL .BDNJMMBO
.BJOFUUJ +PT" 
*OTFBSDIPG#JPFUIJDT"QFSTPOBMQPTUTDSJQU5IF+PVSOBMPG
.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZ  
QQ
/BWBSSP 7 
5IF1PMJUJDBM&DPOPNZPG)FBMUI$BSF5IF*OUFSOBUJPOBM+PVSOBMPG
)FBMUI4FSWJDFT QQ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

4DIPMMF$POOPS 4Z'VFO[BMJEB ) 


#JPFUIJDT*TTVFTBOE1FSTQFDUJWFT8BTIJOH
UPO1BO"NFSJDBO)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO 1")04DJFOUJGJD1VCMJDBUJPO

5FBMEJ +$ 1JT%JF[ (Z&TRVJTBCFM 0 
#JPFUIJDTJO-BUJO"NFSJDB
 *O -VTUJH  " PSH #JPFUIJDT :FBSCPPL 7PM  3FHJPOBM %FWFMPQNFOU JO
#JPFUIJDT%PSESFDIU 5IF/FUIFSMBOET ,MVXFS"DBEFNJD1VCMJTIFST 
QQ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





-B0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE 014
Z
MBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
'FSOBOEP-PMBT

&

O VO BSUDVMP QVCMJDBEP FO 


-PMBT  
 EFMJOF DVM FSB  FO
BRVFMMB QPDB  MB TJUVBDJO EF MB UJDB
CJPNEJDBDIJMFOB TVTQSJODJQBMFTDVFT
UJPOFTZTVTQSPHSFTPTQPUFODJBMFT$IJMF
FTUBCBFOFTFFOUPODFTCBKPFMSHJNFO
NJMJUBS Z MBT BTPDJBDJPOFT QSPGFTJPOBMFT
IBCBO QFSEJEP FM DPOUSPM UJDP EF TVT
BTPDJBEPT MBT FTDVFMBT NEJDBT EFEJDB
CBO OP NT EF  EFM UJFNQP BDBE
NJDP B FOTFBS BTQFDUPT IVNBOJTUBT Z
UJDPT EF MB NFEJDJOB Z MB CJPUJDB OP
BQBSFDB FO QMBOFT EF FTUVEJPT  UUVMPT
EFQVCMJDBDJPOFTPBTPDJBDJPOFT
%VSBOUFMPTBPTDPNFO[VONPWJ
NJFOUPGVFSUFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
FTUBCMFDJVOB$PNJTJOEF#JPUJDBBO
UFTEF MBGPSNBMJ[FOZPS
HBOJ[FMNJTNPBPVOBSFVOJOCBKP
FMUUVMPiJOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJOEFMBCJP
UJDBi&OTFFTUBCMFDJFM$FOUSP
*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO#JPUJ
DBZDPNFO[GPSNBMNFOUFFMUSBCBKPEF
DPNQJMBDJOEFMBJOGPSNBDJOFYJTUFOUF
Z MB GPSNBDJO EF BMJBO[BT FTUSBUHJDBT
DPO PUSBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT -PMBT  

&OUSF MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT TFMFDDJPOBEBT 
MB 0SHBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB
4BMVEEFNPTUSTFSMBNTJNQPSUBOUF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

TVQSFTUJHJPFOUSFUSBCBKBEPSFTEFTBMVE 
FMBNQMJPBMDBODFEFTVTBDUJWJEBEFTZFM
DPNQSPNJTPEFTVTBVUPSJEBEFTQSJODJ
QBMFTFOBRVFMMBQPDBIBOTJEPJNQPS
UBOUFT QBSB FTUBCMFDFS VOB BTPDJBDJO
GSVDUGFSB

*NQMJDBDJOEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE 014

&O   MB 0SHBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJ


DBOB EF MB 4BMVE  014 1BO "NFSJDBO
)FBMUI 0SHBOJ[BUJPO  1")0
 0mDJOB
3FHJPOBM EF MB 0SHBOJ[BDJO .VOEJBM
EFMB4BMVE 0.4
FOBTPDJBDJODPOMB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMFZFMHPCJFSOPDIJ
MFOP DSFBSPOVO1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF
#JPUJDBQBSB-BUJOPBNSJDBZFM$BSJCF
4V QSPQTJUP FSB SFTQPOEFS B MBT OFDF
TJEBEFT EF FTPT QBTFT Z UFSSJUPSJPT RVF
IBCBOJOJDJBEPQSPDFTPTEFSFGPSNBEF
TVTTJTUFNBTEFTBMVE EFNFKPSBEFTV
JOGSBFTUSVDUVSBDJFOUmDBZRVFQSPQPS
DJPOBCBOTFSWJDJPTNEJDPTZTBOJUBSJPT
BMBTQPCMBDJPOFT -PMBT 
1BSBFM
FTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFFTUFQSPHSBNBFOMB
014GVFJNQPSUBOUFMBDPOUSJCVDJOEF
+BNFT %SBOF Z EF )FSOO 'VFO[BMJEB
%SBOFZ'VFO[BMJEB 

-BJOJDJBUJWBEFMB014GVFTJNVMUOFB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DPO FM FTUBCMFDJNJFOUP EF MB $PNJTJO


*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPUJDBEFMB6/&4
$0  DSFBEB QBSB BGSPOUBS MPT EFTBGPT
QMBOUFBEPTQPSMBJOWFTUJHBDJOHFONJ
DBZFMBWBODFEFMDPOPDJNJFOUPFOMBT
DJFODJBTCJPMHJDBT&OTFDSF FO
MBTFEFEFMB0.4FO(JOFCSB VOBVOJ
EBEFODBSHBEBEFMBUJDB FMDPNFSDJPZ
MPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPTDPNPDPOUSBQBS
UFBMQSPHSBNBEFMB014

&EVDBDJOZFOUSFOBNJFOUP
%VSBOUF MPT QSJNFSPT BPT TF PCUVWJF
SPO SFDVSTPT QBSB QSPHSBNBT EJSJHJEPT
BMFOUSFOBNJFOUPEFVODVBESPEFQSP
GFTJPOBMFTGBNJMJBSJ[BEPTDPOMBCJPUJDB
FOMBT"NSJDBTZFM$BSJCF4FFTUBCMF
DJFSPO QSPHSBNBT BWBO[BEPT FO MPT OJ
WFMFTEFNBFTUSBZEJQMPNBEPFOWBSJBT
VOJWFSTJEBEFTZTFDSFBSPODVSTPTDPSUPT
P QBUSPDJOBEPT FO NT EF WFJOUJDJODP
QBTFT FYQPOJFOEPBNTEFUSFTDJFOUPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFTBTVTDPODFQUPTZQSPDFEJ
NJFOUPT"MHVOPTEFFTUPTQSPHSBNBTEF
NBFTUSBGVFSPODSFBEPTFOMB6OJWFSTJ
EBEEF$IJMF FOFM*OTUJUVUP5FDOPM
HJDP EF 4BOUP %PNJOHP */5&$
 FO
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE /BDJPOBM EF 4BO .BS
DPT FO-JNB 1FS ZFOMB6OJWFSTJEBE
/BDJPOBM EF $VZP  FO "SHFOUJOB  DPO
MBBZVEBEFMQSPGFTPS%JFHP(SBDJB EF
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE $PNQMVUFOTF EF .B
ESJE  &TQBB "EFNT  MPT QSPGFTPSFT
EFMQSPHSBNBQBSUJDJQBCBOFOBDUJWJEB
EFT FEVDBUJWBT FO PUSBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT Z
EFTBSSPMMBCBO VOB TFSJF EF TFNJOBSJPT
EFEJDBEPT B MB EJEDUJDB EF MB CJPUJDB
QBSBQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFUPEPFMDPOUJOFO
UF6OBTOUFTJTEFFTUBTBDUJWJEBEFT ZEF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

MBTQVCMJDBDJPOFT
FTUEJTQPOJCMFFOFM
TJUJPXXXQBIPPSHCJPUJDB
4FQSFQBSBSPOZEJTUSJCVZFSPO BEFNT 
EJWFSTPT NBUFSJBMFT FEVDBUJWPT  JODMV
ZFOEP WBSJPT MJCSPT VTBEPT BIPSB FY
UFOTBNFOUF DPO QSPQTJUPT FEVDBUJWPT
6OB CJCMJPUFDB WJSUVBM EF CJPUJDB GVF
BHSFHBEBBMBCJCMJPUFDBWJSUVBMEFTBMVE 
VOQSPZFDUPEFTBSSPMMBEPFODPNODPO
MB#JCMJPUFDB3FHJPOBMEF.FEJDJOB #*
3&.& EF4BP1BVMP #SBTJM
&M QFSPEP JOJDJBM UBNCJO JNQMJD MB
MFHJUJNBDJO EF MB CJPUJDB FO FM DPO
UFYUP EF VOB PSHBOJ[BDJO JOUFSOBDJP
OBMEFTFSWJDJP"MHVOPTDSUJDPTEJKFSPO
RVFFSBVOMVKPZ FODJFSUPHSBEP VOB
QSFPDVQBDJO JSSFMFWBOUF  FO DPOUSBTUF
DPOOFDFTJEBEFTEFTBMVENTBQSFNJBO
UFTZVSHFOUFT&SBOFDFTBSJPEFNPTUSBS
DNPQPESBTFSBQMJDBEBFOMBQSDUJDB
Z TFS SFMFWBOUF B MBT OFDFTJEBEFT SFBMFT
-BCJPUJDBTFPDVQBEFMBDBMJEBEEFMPT
TFSWJDJPT Z EF MB FYDFMFODJB EF MB JOWFT
UJHBDJO  DPNQPOFOUFT FTFODJBMFT EF MB
TBUJTGBDDJOEFMQBDJFOUFZEFMBDPSSFDUB
KFSBSRVBEFQPMUJDBT-BPSJFOUBDJOIB
DJBMBHFOUFGVFFWJEFODJBEBUBNCJOFO
MBTBDDJPOFTEJSJHJEBTBNFKPSBSFMFOUSF
OBNJFOUPEFMPTFTUVEJBOUFTFJODPSQPSBS
MBCJPUJDBFOMPTQMBOFTEFFTUVEJPQBSB
EJWFSTBTQSPGFTJPOFT JODMVZFOEPMBNF
EJDJOB MBFOGFSNFSBZMBTDJFODJBTCJPM
HJDPBNCJFOUBMFTFOEJWFSTPTDPOUFYUPT

*OWFTUJHBDJOZBCPHBDB
"EFNT EFM FOUSFOBNJFOUP EF QSPGF
TJPOBMFT Z EF GPSNBEPSFT EF PQJOJO 
FM QSPHSBNB UBNCJO SFTQPOEB B MBT





-B0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE 014
ZMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB'FSOBOEP-PMBT

EFNBOEBT EF JOGPSNBDJO Z EF EFGFO


TB EF HSVQPT Z EF PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT 4VT
NJFNCSPTDPOUFTUBCBOQSFHVOUBTZEB
CBO QBSFDFSFT TPCSF NBUFSJBT EF QPMUJ
DBT QCMJDBT Z MB QVFTUB FO QSDUJDB EF
QBVUBT UJDBT $PNFO[ B QVCMJDBS VO
CPMFUO EF OPUJDJBT USJNFTUSBM #JPUJDB
*OGPSNB  *44/ 
 Z VOB SF
WJTUB BDBENJDB "DUB #JPFUIJDB  *44/
  DPOUJOVBDJO EFTEF 
EF MPT $VBEFSOPT EFM 1SPHSBNB 3FHJP
OBM EF #JPUJDB
 RVF  FO BMHVOPT BPT 
TFDPOWJSUJFSPOFOMFDUVSBFTUOEBSQBSB
MPT FTUVEJPTPT Z NEJDPT MBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOPT Z EFM $BSJCF $PNP QBSUF EF TV
QPMUJDB EF EJGVTJO  UBNCJO IBO TJEP
QSFTFOUBEPTDBTPTCJPUJDPTFOGPSNBEF
IJTUPSJFUBT JMVTUSBEBT DNJDT
 QBSB MBT
BVEJFODJBT KWFOFT  UJMFT FO MB TBMB EF
DMBTFT Z VTBEBT FO EJWFSTPT BNCJFOUFT
6O QSPHSBNB FTQFDJBM TPCSF TBMVE PSBM
ZCJPUJDBGVFJOJDJBEPFOFMDPOUFYUPEF
VODPOWFOJPDPOFM/*)'PHBSUZ*OUFS
OBUJPOBM$FOUFS DPOVOCPMFUOEFOPUJ
DJBT 4BMVE0SBMZ#JPUJDB *44/

 Z PUSBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT  SFVOJPOFT
FTQFDJBMFTZFTUVEJPTEFMBTJUVBDJOEFMB
FOTFBO[BEFCJPUJDBFOFTDVFMBTEFOUB
MFT&MQSPHSBNBUBNCJOIBBZVEBEPFO
MBUSBEVDDJOEFQBVUBTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
ZFOMBPSHBOJ[BDJOEFTFNJOBSJPTTPCSF
TV DPOUFOJEP QBSB EJWFSTPT QCMJDPT  Z
IBTJEPGVOEBNFOUBMQBSBSFVOJSBHFOUF
EFEJWFSTBTSFBTEFFTUVEJPZPSJFOUBDJP
OFTQBSBEJTFNJOBSFMNBUFSJBM
1PDPEFTQVTEFTVFTUBCMFDJNJFOUP FM
1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDBEFMB014DPNFO
[BSFDPHFSEBUPTTPCSFQFSTPOBTFJOT
UJUVDJPOFT  PSHBOJ[BOEP CBTFT EF EBUPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

TPCSFPQPSUVOJEBEFTEFFOUSFOBNJFOUP 
QSPZFDUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJOZQVCMJDBDJP
OFT ZEBOEPBDPOPDFSSFTFBTEFFEJ
DJPOFTCJPNEJDBT BHFODJBTEFmOBODJB
NJFOUP DEJHPTEFUJDBZMFHJTMBDJPOFT
SFMFWBOUFT 6O $PNJU $POTVMUJWP *O
UFSOBDJPOBM JOUFHSBEPQPSSFOPNCSBEPT
CJPFUJDJTUBT ZMBDPOUSJCVDJOEFMPTSF
QSFTFOUBOUFTEFMB014FOMPTQBTFTIBO
BZVEBEP B FTUBCMFDFS MPT QSJODJQJPT EF
BDDJOEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDB
$POVOQSFTVQVFTUPMJNJUBEPQFSPVOB
FmDJFOUFBDDJOEFPCUFODJOEFSFDVS
TPTZMBDPPQFSBDJOEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EF$IJMFZEFMHPCJFSOPDIJMFOP FM1SP
HSBNB EF #JPUJDB EF MB 014 TF VCJD
DPNP SFGFSFOUF OP TMP FO MB SFHJO 
TJOP UBNCJO FO PUSBT QBSUFT EFM NVO
EP &O FM DPOUFYUP EF MB DPPQFSBDJO
UDOJDB MBDSFBDJOEFDPNJUTEFUJDB
EFJOWFTUJHBDJOZEFDVJEBEPTDMOJDPT 
FMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFDPNJTJPOFTOBDJP
OBMFTEFCJPUJDBZFMFOUSFOBNJFOUPEF
QSPGFTJPOBMFT IBO TJEP MBT QSJPSJEBEFT
$POUSJCVZFOBVOBBENJOJTUSBDJONF
KPSEFSFDVSTPT BVODPODFQUPNTBN
QMJP EF DBMJEBE oJODMVZFOEP QSJODJQJPT
UJDPTo BMBTBUJTGBDDJODSFDJFOUFFOUSF
JOWFTUJHBEPSFTEFMSFBEFMBTBMVEZN
EJDPT ZBVOBNFKPSDPODJFODJBQCMJDB
TPCSFDVFTUJPOFTEFJOUFSTHFOFSBM
-BCJPUJDBVUJMJ[BFMEJMPHPQBSBMMFHBS
B EFDJTJPOFT UJDBT TPTUFOJCMFT Z EFTBGB
UPEPT Z DBEB EPHNB  DSFFODJB  V PQJ
OJOQBSBEBSSFTQVFTUBTBMBTDVFTUJPOFT
BDVDJBOUFTQMBOUFBEBTQPSMBDJFODJBZMB
UFDOPMPHBBQMJDBEBTBMPTBTVOUPTIVNB
OPT&MDBSDUFSEJBMHJDPZEFQBSUJDJQB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DJOEFUPEPTMPTJOUFSFTBEPTFOEFDJTJP
OFTSFMBUJWBTBMBTBMVETFIBBDFOUVBEPB
USBWTEFMUSBCBKPEFMQSPHSBNB"MHVOBT
BDUJWJEBEFTZQSPEVDUPTEFMBCJPUJDBEF
MB014TFQSFTFOUBOFOMBUBCMB

KPSFT FO MB JOWFTUJHBDJO Z MB DPPQFSB


DJOTPOUBNCJOQSPEVDUPEFMBTFOTJ
CJMJEBEEFMBCJPUJDB BVORVFFTEJGDJM
FWBMVBSMBT

5BCMB3FTVNFOEFBDUJWJEBEFTZQSPEVDUPTEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDBEF014
$VSTPT

1VCMJDBDJPOFT

*OUFSWFODJPOFT

"MJBO[BT

0USBTBDUJWJEBEFT

&OUSFOBNJFOUP
&TQFDJBMJ[BDJO
&MBCPSBDJO
EFQMBOFTEF
FOTFBO[B

1FSJEJDP
BDBENJDP
#PMFUO
-JCSPT

3FTQVFTUBTB
DVFTUJPOFT
&TUBCMFDJNJFOUP
EFDPNJUTEF
UJDB

*OTUJUVDJPOFT
BDBENJDBT
0USPTSHBOPT
*OEVTUSJB

"CPHBDB
3FTFBT
#BTFTEFEBUPT
%JTFNJOBDJO
QCMJDBEF
JOGPSNBDJPOFT

&O MBT "NSJDBT Z FM $BSJCF FM QFOTB


NJFOUP CJPUJDP Z MB QSDUJDB EF MB EF
MJCFSBDJOTPOQBSUJDVMBSNFOUFSFMFWBO
UFT"MHVOPTQBTFTFYIJCFOJOFRVJEBEFT
FOFMBDDFTPBMBTBMVE MBQPCSF[BBGFDUB
DBTJ MB NJUBE EF MB QPCMBDJO Z MB DP
SSVQDJO FT VOB QFSNBOFOUF BNFOB[B
-BJOFTUBCJMJEBEQPMUJDBZMBJOnVFODJB
QFOFUSBOUF EFM DBQJUBM USBOTOBDJPOBM
BGFDUBOMBDPOUJOVJEBEEFEFDJTJPOFTHV
CFSOBNFOUBMFT-PTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMPT
DVJEBEPTNEJDPTZEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJO
EFMBTBMVE FOHFOFSBM TJFOUFOGSVTUSB
DJOZDMFSBQPSOPDPOUBSDPOSFDVSTPT
TVmDJFOUFT QBSB EFTFNQFBS BEFDVBEB
NFOUFTVQBQFM

&M 1SPHSBNB EF #JPUJDB TVQFSWJTB MB


DBMJEBE EF MBT BDUJWJEBEFT BDBENJDBT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT Z EFM $BSJCF  FTUBCMF
DF OVFWPT QSPHSBNBT FEVDBUJWPT Z EF
JOWFTUJHBDJO  QSPNVFWF MB DSFBDJO EF
JOTUJUVDJPOFTZBZVEBBMPTJOUFSFTBEPTB
QSFQBSBSQSPZFDUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJOQBSB
MBTBHFODJBTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTEFmOBODJB
NJFOUP &O MBT SFVOJPOFT EFM $POTFKP
$POTVMUJWP *OUFSOBDJPOBM  FTUBCMFDJEP
QPS FM BOUJHVP EJSFDUPS EF MB 014  4JS
(FPSHF"MMFZOF TFIBOBCPSEBEPWBSJPT
BTVOUPT EF JNQPSUBODJB -PMBT  
-PMBT Z "HBS   -PMBT Z 2VF[BEB 



)BIBCJEPQSPHSFTPTFOBMHVOPTQBTFT 
BVORVFDPONFOPTJOUFOTJEBEPJNQBD
UPFOPUSPT/PPCTUBOUF iCJPUJDBiTF
IBDPOWFSUJEPFOVOBQBMBCSBFTUOEBS
Z MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT TPMJDJUBO DPOTFKP Z
EJSFDDJO&MFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFDPNJ
TJPOFTZEFDPNJUTOBDJPOBMFTEFUJDB
FTVOBCVFOBNFEJEBEFMUSBCBKPEFMB
014ZPUSPTPSHBOJTNPT1SDUJDBTNF

%FTBGPTQBSBFMGVUVSP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

$PO FM FTUBCMFDJNJFOUP QJPOFSP EF MB


CJPUJDB MB0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOB
EFMB4BMVE 014
EFNPTUSRVFIBCB
JEFOUJmDBEP VOB OFDFTJEBE HFOVJOB Z
SFTQPOEJEPBQSPQJBEBNFOUFBFMMB
1BSBDPOUJOVBSEFTFNQFBOEPTVQBQFM 
MB014EFCFDPOTPMJEBSTVDBSDUFSDPNP





-B0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE 014
ZMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB'FSOBOEP-PMBT

PSHBOJ[BDJOCBTBEBFOFMDPOPDJNJFO
UP RVFGPNFOUBOPTMPMBBERVJTJDJOZ
FMVTPEFJOGPSNBDJPOFTSFMFWBOUFTTJOP 
UBNCJO  DPOTJEFSBS MBT JNQMJDBDJPOFT
NPSBMFTEFMDPOPDJNJFOUPZEFMBBDDJO
FmDJFOUF&TUPFTQPTJCMFFOVOQSPHSB
NBRVFJODPSQPSBBFYQFSUPTSFTQFUBEPT 
JOEFQFOEJFOUFNFOUF EF TV QBT EF PSJ
HFO  BmMJBDJO BDBENJDB P QSPGFTJO
-BT SFMBDJPOFT FOUSF MPT SFQSFTFOUBOUFT
EF MB 014 Z FM 1SPHSBNB EF #JPUJDB
TPO CVFO FKFNQMP EFM FTGVFS[P DPODFS
UBEPQBSBEFTBSSPMMBSMBBDDJOFOGPDBEB
FOQBTFT)BZBZVEBFTQFDJBMJ[BEBEJT
QPOJCMFFOMBNBZPSBEFFMMPTHSBDJBTB
FTUBBMJBO[B
-B 014 IB SFTQPOEJEP BEFDVBEBNFO
UFBMBTOFDFTJEBEFTFOMBSFHJOEFMBT
"NSJDBTZEFM$BSJCFFONVDIBTSFBT
-PMBT  
 1BSB FWBMVBS TV NJTJO
EF TFSWJDJP QCMJDP FO CJPUJDB Z TV
JOnVFODJBFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJOZMPTDVJ
EBEPTNEJDPTFTQSFDJTPIBDFSBMHVOBT
DPOTJEFSBDJPOFT
$VBOEP TF FTUBCMFDF MB CJPUJDB DPNP
DBNQP MFHUJNP EF BDUJWJEBE JOUFMFD
UVBMZGVFOUFEFEJSFDDJOQBSBMBBDDJO
BQSPQJBEB  FT NVZ HSBOEF FM SJFTHP EF
GPSNBSBVOHSVQPEFHFOUFDPOWFODJEB
EFTVTVQFSJPSJEBEFONBUFSJBTEFKVJDJP
NPSBM Z OFDFTJUBEP EF SFDPOPDJNJFO
UP-BQSPGFTJPOBMJ[BDJOEFMBCJPUJDB
OP FT SFDPNFOEBCMF FO FTUF QVOUP EFM
EFTBSSPMMP EFM DBNQP &OUSFOBS QSPGF
TJPOBMFTFOMBEFMJCFSBDJOZMBEJGVTJO
EFMPTQSJODJQJPTCJPUJDPTFOUSFQPCMB
DJPOFT NTCJFORVFQSPNPWFSFMDPOP
DJNJFOUPBDBENJDPBWBO[BEPEFCFTFS

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

MB QSJPSJEBE  BVORVF FTF DPOPDJNJFOUP


FT JNQSFTDJOEJCMF QBSB MPT QSPHSFTPT
GVUVSPT Z MBT DPOUSJCVDJPOFT PSJHJOBMFT
-PTWFSEBEFSPTFYQFSUPTOPDPOGVOEFO
MB EFMJCFSBDJO UJDB DPO FM BEPDUSJOB
NJFOUPQPMUJDPZDPNQSFOEFOMBOFDF
TJEBEWJUBMEFMBUPMFSBODJBZEFMEJMPHP 
UBO FTFODJBMFT QBSB MB CJPUJDB /P MFT
TFEVDFO MBT EFNBOEBT EFNBHHJDBT EF
PSJHJOBMJEBEFJNQFSJBMJTNPZTFFTGVFS
[BOFOEFTDVCSJSSFTQVFTUBTBQSPCMFNBT
QFSFOOFT
-B FEVDBDJO EF MB QPCMBDJO FT QBSUF
EFMFTGVFS[PCJPUJDP1VFTUPRVFTVGVO
EBNFOUP FT FM EJMPHP  MPT JOEJWJEVPT
EFCFOBERVJSJSMBDBQBDJEBEEFEFCBUJS
&TUPJNQMJDBVOFTGVFS[PDPODFSUBEPEF
QBSUF EF FYQFSUPT  JOTUJUVDJPOFT BDBE
NJDBT HSVQPTEFBVUPBZVEBZTFSWJDJPT
QCMJDPT-BHFOUFEFCFQFSDJCJSRVFMB
TBMVE FT VOB DPOTUSVDDJO TPDJFUBSJB Z
QFSTPOBM BZVEBEB QPS FM USBCBKP QSPGF
TJPOBM 6OB DPNVOJEBE CJFO JOTUSVJEB
OPJNQPOFEFNBOEBTJSSFBMFTTPCSFMPT
QSPWFFEPSFT EF TFSWJDJPT FT NT JOGPS
NBEB DPOmBEBFOTVTQSPQJPTSFDVSTPT
Z EFTBSSPMMB VO TFOUJEP EF TPMJEBSJEBE
DPNPDPOEJDJOQSFWJBQBSBVOBCVFOB
DBMJEBEEFWJEB
-BCJPUJDBFOMB014WBBSFDJCJSBQPZP
TFHOMBFWPMVDJOEFMDBNQP4VQSF
TFODJBFOFMEFCBUFNPSBMTFKVTUJmDBQPS
EJWFSTBTSB[POFT(SVQPTSBEJDBMFTQVF
EFO VUJMJ[BSMB QBSB TPTUFOFS TVT DPOWJD
DJPOFT P QBSB EJTFNJOBS DSFFODJBT QBS
UJDVMBSFT -B JOEVTUSJB QVFEF FODPOUSBS
BSHVNFOUPTQBSBJOUFSWFODJPOFTBHSFTJ
WBTRVFQSPEV[DBOMVDSPT-PTHPCJFSOPT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

QVFEFO FNQMFBS FM EJTDVSTP CJPUJDP


QBSB MFHJUJNBS QSDUJDBT JOBEFDVBEBT P
BVUPSJUBSJBT $PNP SHBOP UDOJDP EF
DPPQFSBDJO  014 HBSBOUJ[B MB OFVUSB
MJEBE EF FTQFDJBMJTUBT FO DVFTUJPOFT EF
JOUFSTDPNOBMBTNJOPSBTZBMBTNB
ZPSBT1VFEFBZVEBSBSFEVDJSFMQFMJHSP
EFMVTPFSSOFPEFBSHVNFOUPTNPSBMFT
DPONFUBTFDPONJDBTPQPMUJDBT

&MEFTBGPFTUSBCBKBSQPSFMCJFODPNO
EFMBHFOUFEFMBT"NSJDBTZEFM$BSJCF 
MJCSF EF BQSFNJPT FDPONJDPT P JEFP
MHJDPT  HP[BOEP EF MB DPOmBO[B Z EFM
SFTQFUPEFTVTJOUFSMPDVUPSFTZFWJUBOEP
MBEJTDSJNJOBDJOZMBFYDMVTJO1PSRVF
FODVFTUJPOFTEFMBTBMVEUPEPTDVFOUBO
ZMBNFUBTJHVFTJFOEPiTBMVEQBSBUPEPT 
QPSUPEPT DPOUPEPTw

3FGFSFODJBT
%SBOF +''VFO[BMJEB ) 
.FEJDBM&UIJDTJO-BUJO"NFSJDBBOFXJOUFSFTU
BOEDPNNJUNFOU,FOOFEZ*OTUJUVUFPG&UIJDT+PVSOBM  
QQ
-PMBT  ' 
 #JPFUIJDT JO $IJMF 1SFTFOU BOE GVUVSF TUBUVT *O $POOPS  44 
'VFO[BMJEB1VFMNB  )  FET #JPFUIJDT *TTVFT BOE 1FSTQFDUJWFT 8BTIJOHUPO  %$ 
1BO"NFSJDBO)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO QQ
-PMBT ' 
#JPUJDBFOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF"OBMFTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
4FYUB4FSJF / QQ
-PMBT ' 
-BCJPUJDBFOFMDPOUFYUPEFMPTQSPHSBNBTHMPCBMFTEFTBMVE3FWJTUB
1BOBNFSJDBOBEF4BMVE1CMJDB  
QQ
-PMBT  ' FEJU
 
 #JPUJDB Z DVJEBEP EF MB TBMVE &RVJEBE  $BMJEBE  %FSFDIPT
4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF  1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPUJDB  0SHBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB
EFMB4BMVE
-PMBT ' FEJU
 
%JMPHPZDPPQFSBDJOFOTBMVE%JF[BPTEFCJPUJDBFOMB014
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF 6OJEBEEF#JPUJDB0140.4
-PMBT  '  "HBS  - FET
 
 *OUFSGBDFT CFUXFFO CJPFUIJDT BOE UIF FNQJSJDBM
TPDJBM TDJFODFT 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF  1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPUJDB  0SHBOJ[BDJO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE
-PMBT '2VF[BEB " FET
 
1BVUBTUJDBTEFJOWFTUJHBDJOFOTVKFUPTIVNBOPT
OVFWBTQFSTQFDUJWBT4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF 1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPUJDB 0SHBOJ[BDJO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





-BCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBZFO$PMPNCJB
"MGPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS 4+

6CJDBDJOEFMUFNB

BCJPUJDBOBDJFO&TUBEPT6OJEPT
FO MB TFHVOEB NJUBE EFM TJHMP 99
DPNP VO iQSPEVDUPw UQJDBNFOUF OPS
UFBNFSJDBOPDPODSFUBNFOUF DPNPVOB
iOVFWBUJDBwDPODBSBDUFSTUJDBTOPSUF
BNFSJDBOBTZQBSBTPMVDJPOBSQSPCMFNBT
OPSUFBNFSJDBOPT *ODMVTJWF  OP OBDJ
DPNPVOBTPMBCJPUJDB:BFOTVPSJHFO
FODPOUSBNPT EPT UFOEFODJBT CJFO EJT
UJOUBTRVFMVFHPTFNVMUJQMJDBO BTBCFS
MBEF7BO3FOTTFMBFS1PUUFS QSFTFOUBEB

 i-B SFBMJEBE FT RVF FYJTUFO DVBUSP "NSJDBT 


DBEB VOB EF MBT DVBMFT SFQSFTFOUB IJTUSJDB
NFOUFVOUFSSJUPSJP VOBFYQFSJFODJB VOFTUJMP 
VONPEPEFTFSQSPQJPTDVBUSP"NSJDBTRVF
CVTDBO QPSEJWFSTPTDBNJOPT TVGPSNBQSPQJB
EF FYQSFTJO  TV DVMUVSB MB "NSJDB JOEPIJT
QBOB  DPO VOB TVQFSmDJF EF  LN
DVBESBEPTMB"NSJDBQPSUVHVFTB #SBTJM
DPO
 LN DVBESBEPT  MB "NSJDB JOHMFTB
PBOHMPTBKPOB 64"
DPOLNDVB
ESBEPT  Z MB "NSJDB BOHMPGSBODFTB $BOBE

DPO  LN DVBESBEPT 4MP MB QSJNF
SB UJFOF RVF WFS DPO $PMO MB IJTUPSJB EF MBT
EFNT DPNFO[ BPT  BVO TJHMPT NT UBSEFw
&MOPNCSFEF"NSJDBiTFBQMJDBQPSQSJNFSB
WF[BM/VFWP.VOEPFOMB$PTNPHSBQIJBF*O
USPEVDUJP FO 4BJOU%JFV -PT 7PTHPT  -PSFOB

FMEFBCSJMEF QPSFYBHFSBEBHSBUJUVE
BMDBSUHSBGPJUBMJBOP"NSJDP7FTQVDDJUFYUP
EFMQPFUB.BUUIJBT3JOHNBOONBQBBEKVOUP 
EFMDBSUHSBGPMPSFOT.BSUJO8BMETFFNMMFSw
(BMJOEP 
&OFTUFFTUVEJPOPTSFGFSJSF
NPTBMBTBNSJDBTJOEPIJTQBOBZQPSUVHVFTB 
RVF TPMFNPT EFOPNJOBS "NSJDB -BUJOB  B MB
DVBMTFBBEFOMPTQBTFTEFM$BSJCF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

FOTVMJCSP#JPFUIJDT #SJEHFUPUIF'VUVSF
1PUUFS 
RVJFOBDVBFMWPDBCMP 
MBO[BMBJEFBEFVOBOVFWBEJTDJQMJOBZ
VO NPWJNJFOUP NVOEJBM B GBWPS EF MB
WJEB Z FM NFEJPBNCJFOUF FO QFMJHSP
$PODJCF MB CJPUJDB iFO FNFSHFODJBw
DPNP VO EJMPHP FOUSF EPT DVMUVSBT P
TBCFSFT oFM DJFOUmDP Z FM UJDPo  DPO
NJSBT B MB TVQFSWJWFODJB EFM IPNCSF Z
EFMQMBOFUB5JFSSB
-B EF F ,FOOFEZ *OTUJUVUF PG &UIJDT 
EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF (FPSHFUPXO  FO
8BTIJOHUPO&MNJTNPBPFORVF1P
UUFSMBO[BTVMJCSPZTVQSPQVFTUBEFVOB
OVFWB EJTDJQMJOB  (FPSHFUPXO GPSNBMJ[B
MB CJPUJDB  MB JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[B BM EBSMF
TPQPSUF BDBENJDP Z MB FOGPDB DPNP
VOB NBDSPUJDB NEJDB  UFOEFODJB RVF
WBBQSFWBMFDFSFOMBTTJHVJFOUFTEDBEBT

FO&TUBEPT6OJEPT
-B CJPUJDB OBDF FO VO DPOUFYUP DJFO
UmDP Z FO VO NBSDP TFDVMBS oFT EF
 &OFM.D"SEMF-BCPSBUPSZ%FQBSUNFOUPG0ODP
MPHZ EFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF8JTDPOTJO
 &MBNCJFOUFTFDVMBS WBMFEFDJS OPDPOGFTJPOBM 
RVJFSF QPOFS EF SFMJFWF FM IFDIP EF RVF FTUB
OVFWBUJDBOPFTUFMBCPSBEBQPSSFQSFTFOUBO
UFT EF BMHVOB SFMJHJO .T BO  OP TF QVFEF
EFDJS TJRVJFSB RVF FTU FMBCPSBEB  ZB RVF VOB
EFMBTDBSBDUFSTUJDBTEFMBOVFWBUJDBPCJPUJDB
DPOTJTUFFORVFOPFTUUFSNJOBEB OJQPTJCMF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DJS  OP SFMJHJPTPo DPNP VO JOUFOUP EF


IVNBOJ[BS MB OVFWB CJPUFDOPMPHB  FO
SQJEP DSFDJNJFOUP  Z EF EBSMF DBCJEB
BM QBDJFOUF  DPNP QFSTPOB  QBSB FGFD
UPT QSDUJDPT FO MB UPNB EF EFDJTJPOFT
RVFUJFOFORVFWFSDPOTVUSBUBNJFOUP
3BNTFZ 


*NQBDUPEFMBCJPUJDBFOMB
DVMUVSBVOJWFSTBMDPOUFNQPSOFB
1PTJCMFNFOUF  DPO OJOHVOB PUSB SFB
EF FTUVEJP Z EFM TBCFS IVNBOP  FO MB
IJTUPSJB SFDJFOUF EF MB DVMUVSB VOJWFS
TBM  IB TVDFEJEP DPNP DPO MB CJPUJDB
TF IB EFTBSSPMMBEP SQJEBNFOUF NPEJ
mDB FORVJFOMBFTUVEJB MBGPSNBEFWFS
Z NBOFKBS MB SFBMJEBE QSFTFOUF BCBSDB
BNQMJBT [POBT EF JOUFST  OP TMP EFM
QSPGFTJPOBMTJOPEFMIPNCSFNFEJPDVM
UPFTUMMBNBEBBFKFSDFSVOJOnVKPEF
NBZPS JNQPSUBODJB FO MB WJEB QCMJDB 
Z DBSBDUFSJ[B Z SFnFKB NT mFMNFOUF MB
QPDBDPOUFNQPSOFB
-PT EPT DPNQPOFOUFT FTFODJBMFT EF MB
CJPUJDB CJPTZFUIPT TPORVJ[MPTEPT
UQJDPTQPSMPTDVBMFTFMIPNCSFBDUVBM
EFNVFTUSB NBZPS JOUFST Z BUSBDDJO
iUJDBwTFIBDPOWFSUJEP FOMPTMUJNPT
BPT FOVOUSNJOPVOJWFSTBM VTVBM JO

NFOUF MP FTUBS 4F TJHVF USBCBKBOEP FO FMMB 


EF NBOFSB FTQFDJBM FO MBT VOJWFSTJEBEFT 4JO
QSFUFOEFSFODFSSBSMBFOVOBEFmOJDJO QPESB
TFSWJS EF PSJFOUBDJO MB BQSPYJNBDJO  MJHFSB
NFOUFNBRVJMMBEB RVFPGSFDFFM1SPHSBNBEF
#JPUJDB EF 014 i#JPUJDB FT FM VTP DSFBUJWP
EFM EJMPHP JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP QBSB GPSNVMBS 
BSUJDVMBS Z  FO MP QPTJCMF  SFTPMWFS BMHVOPT EF
MPTQSPCMFNBTRVFQMBOUFBBMBTPDJFEBEBDUVBM
MBJOWFTUJHBDJOZMBJOUFSWFODJOTPCSFMBWJEB 
MBTBMVEZFMNFEJPBNCJFOUFw

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UFSFTBOUF EJHOPEFFTUVEJBSTFFODVBOUP
DPOEVDUBIVNBOBCVFOBPNBMBNPSBM
NFOUF &T VO USNJOP NT QSPQJP EF
VOBTPDJFEBETFDVMBS BVUOPNBZQMV
SBMJTUB
RVFFMEFiNPSBMw RVFFSBNT
DPNOFOUJFNQPTQBTBEPT

1SJNFSBFUBQBEFMBCJPUJDBFO
-BUJOPBNSJDBiFMUSBTQMBOUFw
"OUFDFEFOUFT
%BEPFMJOVTJUBEPEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJP
UJDB  QSJNFSP "SHFOUJOB  MVFHP $P
MPNCJB  $IJMF  .YJDP  #SBTJM Z EFNT
QBTFTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT TFQSPEVKPVO
iUSBTQMBOUFwEFMBCJPUJDBB"NSJDB-B
UJOB TJOBUFOEFSBMBEJGFSFODJBEFiUJF
SSBTwZTJOQSFHVOUBSTFTJEJDIBiQMBOUBw
iHFSNJOBSBw FO QBTFT EF UJFSSBT UBO
EJTUJOUBT  P TJO BWFSJHVBS TJ FTUF OVFWP
iNFEJDBNFOUPwFSBBQUPQBSBDVSBSMPT
NBMFTUBOEJGFSFOUFTEFFTUPTQVFCMPT
"RV OPT PDVQBSFNPT EFM OBDJNJFOUP
Z EFTBSSPMMP EF MB CJPUJDB FO "NSJDB
-BUJOB  BEFNT EF #SBTJM Z MBT JTMBT EFM
$BSJCF
"EWJSUJFOEP RVF TPO NBZPSFT MBT EJGF
SFODJBT DVMUVSBMFT  QPMUJDBT Z SFMJHJPTBT
RVF MPT EFOPNJOBEPSFT DPNVOFT EF
FTUPTPQBTFT QPCSF[B TVCEFTB
SSPMMP  WJPMFODJB  JOFTUBCJMJEBE QPMUJDB 
SFMJHJO
 WBNPT B USBUBS EF JOEJDBS BM
HVOPTEBUPTIJTUSJDPTEFMOBDJNJFOUPZ
EFTBSSPMMPEFFTUBEJTDJQMJOBFOMBSFHJO 
QSPDVSBOEPMVFHPEFTUBDBSTVTGPSUBMF[BT
ZGBMFODJBT/VFTUSPFTUVEJP PCKFUJWPZ
KVTUPFOMPQPTJCMF GVFSBEFPGSFDFSVOB
BDUVBMJ[BEB JOGPSNBDJO B FSVEJUPT Z





-BCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBZFO$PMPNCJB"MGPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS 4+

OPFSVEJUPTCJPFUJDJTUBTOPMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOPT  QSFUFOEF BQPSUBS UBNCJO  B MPT
NJTNPT JCFSPBNFSJDBOPT  QPS VOB QBS
UF EBUPTZSFnFYJPOFTEFMBTGPSUBMF[BTEF
MBCJPUJDBDPOUJOFOUBM QBSBBQSPQJBSMBT
ZNFKPSBSMBT Z QPSPUSB VOBCSFWFWJ
TJOEFTVTGBMFODJBTZMJNJUBDJPOFT QBSB
DPSSFHJSMBTZTVQFSBSMBTFOMBNFEJEBEF
MPQPTJCMF
6OBOUFDFEFOUFEJHOPEFDPOTJEFSBSFTMB
FOTFBO[BEFMBUJDBZEFMBEFPOUPMPHB
NEJDBT QSPNPWJEB QPS MB 'FEFSBDJO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEF'BDVMUBEFTZ&TDVFMBT
EF.FEJDJOB '&1"'&.
FOMBTOVNF
SPTBT FTDVFMBT EF MPT EJGFSFOUFT QBTFT
5BMFOTFBO[B TJSWJ QBSB RVFMVFHPTF
DPOWJSUJFSBFOCJPUJDB NEJDB
IFDIP
QPTJUJWP BQFTBSEFFTUBSFEVDDJORVF
QSFWBMFDJFOMPTQSJNFSPTMVTUSPT
-B CJPUJDB  DPNP UBM  GVF EFTDPOPDJEB
FO OVFTUSPT QBTFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT FO
MBEDBEBEFTVBQBSJDJOFOMPT&TUBEPT
6OJEPT 
GVFSBEFMEFTBSSP
MMPEFMBTIVNBOJEBEFTZEFMBUJDB ZEF
BMHVOBTBMVTJPOFTFOMBTBVMBTEFNFEJDJ
OBFO"SHFOUJOB $PMPNCJB 7FOF[VFMB
Z QPTJCMFNFOUF FOPUSPTQBTFTMBUJOPB
NFSJDBOPT

$POUSBTUFFOUSFEPTDVMUVSBT
/VFTUSPTQSPCMFNBTUQJDPT EVSBOUFMPT
TJHMPT9*9Z99 EJGFSBOEFMPTEF&T
UBEPT6OJEPT4FUSBUBCBEFQBTFTRVF
BDBCBCBOEFFTUSFOBSTVJOEFQFOEFODJB
EF &TQBB P 1PSUVHBM  DPO FM MBTUSF EF
QPCSF[B  TVCEFTBSSPMMP Z EPNJOBDJO
EFNJOPSBTQPMUJDBTZFDPONJDBTRVF
FYQMPUBCBO B MPT JOEJWJEVPT  JNQJEJFO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EPFMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFWFSEBEFSBTEF
NPDSBDJBT1PSPUSBQBSUF FMEFTBSSPMMP
DJFOUmDP Z UFDOPMHJDP FSB FTDBTP QPS
GBMUBEFSFDVSTPTIVNBOPTZmOBODJFSPT
.BJOFUUJ 

-BNPSBMDBUMJDB VOBEFMBTGVFOUFTEF
MBUJDBNEJDB
EJSJHBMBWJEBQSJWBEB
ZQCMJDBEFDBTJUPEPTMPT&TUBEPTMB
UJOPBNFSJDBOPT-BTFDVMBSJ[BDJO MFO
UB Z EJGDJM FO BMHVOPT QBTFT .YJDP 
6SVHVBZ $IJMF FOUSFPUSPT
BDFMFSBEB
Z UBSEB FO PUSPT $PMPNCJB
 BDBSSF
MBEJTNJOVDJOEFMBBVUPSJEBEQCMJDB
ZQSJWBEBEFMB*HMFTJB$BUMJDBZEFMB
NPSBM RVF FMMB QSFEJDBCB  TJO RVF GVF
SB TVTUJUVJEB QPS VOB UJDB DJWJM %F
3PVY  
 DBQB[ EF GSFOBS MPT BCV
TPTEFMPTQPMUJDPTEFUVSOPZMPTSJDPT
UFSSBUFOJFOUFT  Z MB EJMBQJEBDJO EF MBT
SJRVF[BTOBUVSBMFTZSFDVSTPTEFMNFEJP
BNCJFOUF

-BSFWPMVDJOCJPUJDB
0CTFSWB.BJOFUUJRVFFTUFCJPT UFDOJm
DBDJOEFMBWJEB
ZFTUFFUIPT TFDVMBSJ
[BDJOEFMBNPSBM
BEWJFOFOEFMDBN
CJP IJTUSJDP RVF SFTVMUB EFM QSPHSFTP
CJPUFDOPMHJDP FO &TUBEPT 6OJEPT Z
EFMDBSDUFSMJCFSBMZTFDVMBSEFMBUJDB
QSPUFTUBOUF &TUPT EPT IFDIPT DPOUSBT
UBCBO DPO MB DVMUVSB iQSFUDOJDBi MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOBZDPOVOBNPSBMSFMJHJPTB
EJGFSFOUF
"MIBDFSFMiUSBTQMBOUFwEFFTUBCJPUJDB
oNEJDB  QSJODJQJBMJTUB  VUJMJUBSJTUBo OP
TFUVWPFODVFOUBFTUFDPOUSBTUF EFTDP
OPDJNJFOUPRVFQVFEFFYQMJDBSMBTNV
DIBTEJmDVMUBEFTRVFTFFYQFSJNFOUBSPO





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

FO FTUB QSJNFSB FUBQB QBSB TV BDFQUB


DJO FTUVEJPZEJGVTJO

5SBTQMBOUFZEFTBSSPMMPEFMB
CJPUJDBFO-BUJOPBNSJDB

.T DPODSFUBNFOUF  USBTQMBOUBS VOB


CJPUJDBPDVQBEBFOIVNBOJ[BSCJPUFD
OPMPHB BWBO[BEB F JOTQJSBEB FO VOB
UJDBBOHMPTBKPOBBQBTFTQPDPEFTBSSP
MMBEPT oUFDOPMHJDB Z DVMUVSBMNFOUFo 
JOnVFODJBEPTGVFSUFNFOUFQPSMBNPSBM
DBUMJDB  DPO VOB USBEJDJO NEJDB IJ
QPDSUJDB Z QBUFSOBMJTUB  OP QPEB NF
OPT RVF FODPOUSBS TFSJBT EJmDVMUBEFT
1PSDJUBSBMHVOBT

"SHFOUJOB*OTUJUVUPEF
)VNBOJEBEFT.EJDBTZ&-"#&

t
t
t
t

t

RVF OP EFTQFSUBSB JOUFST  FO VO


DPNJFO[P
RVF OP TF FOUFOEJFSB QPS RV Z
DVOEPTFFNQF[BFTUVEJBSMB
RVFOPTFTVQJFSBVUJMJ[BSDVBOEPTF
USBUEFBQMJDBSMB
RVFFNQF[BSBBTFSDPOPDJEBZFT
UVEJBEBTMPDPNPVOBOVFWBUJDB
NEJDB DPNPGVFFMDBTPEF"SHFO
UJOB Z 7FOF[VFMB Z  FO QBSUF  $P
MPNCJB
RVFMBEFTDPOPDJFSBOMPT&TUBEPTZ
VOJWFSTJEBEFT

%JDF.BJOFUUJ SFmSJOEPTFBFTUBQSJNF
SB FUBQB i-B JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJO EF MB
CJPUJDB MBDSFBDJOEFDFOUSPTEFJOWFT
UJHBDJO  DUFESBT VOJWFSTJUBSJBT  DPNJ
UTEFUJDBFOMPTIPTQJUBMFT DPNJTJPOFT
OBDJPOBMFTEFCJPUJDB FUD FT IBTUBFM
NPNFOUP 
 QPDP TJHOJmDBUJWB Z 
EFTEFMVFHP UBNQPDPTFDVNQMFOQSP
HSBNUJDBNFOUFMBTUSFTGVODJPOFTQSJO
DJQBMFT EF MPT FTUVEJPT CJPUJDPT FEV
DBUJWB BTJTUFODJBMZQPMUJDBw .BJOFUUJ 



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&MNEJDPBSHFOUJOP+PT"MCFSUP.BJ
OFUUJ  NJFNCSP EF MB 'VOEBDJO +PT
.BSB .BJOFUUJ  SBEJDBEB FO MB MPDBMJ
EBE EF (POOFU  DFSDB EF MB DJVEBE EF
-B1MBUB "SHFOUJOB UJFOFFMNSJUPEF
IBCFSJOJDJBEPFMNPWJNJFOUPEFIVNB
OJ[BDJOEFMBNFEJDJOB RVFQSFDFEJBM
iUSBTQMBOUFwEFMBCJPUJDBEF&&66B
"NSJDB-BUJOBFOUSFZ
.BJOFUUJ JOTQJSBEPFO1FESP-BO&O
USBMHP GVOEBMM FO FM*OTUJUVUP
EF)VNBOJEBEFT.EJDBT RVFQSPOUP
EJGVOEJTVTJEFBMFTIVNBOTUJDPTFOFM
$POP 4VS EF -BUJOPBNSJDB  B USBWT
EF DPOGFSFODJBT  DVSTPT Z EF MB SFWJTUB
2VJSO
"QSJODJQJPTEFMBEDBEBEFM .BJOFU
UJ WJTJU FM ,FOOFEZ *OTUJUVUF PG &UIJDT EF
MB6OJWFSTJEBEEF(FPSHFUPXO FO8BT
IJOHUPO FJOWJUBCJPFUJDJTUBTEFFTFDFO
USPQBSBEJDUBSDPOGFSFODJBTFOFM*OTUJUVUP
EF(POOFU&ENVOE1FMMFHSJOP 5SJTUSBN
&OHFMIBSEU +BNFT%SBOFZPUSPT
.T BEFMBOUF  B mOFT EF MPT PDIFOUB 
+VBO$BSMPT5FBMEJ DPOFMSFTQBMEPEF
.BJOFUUJ GVOEMB&TDVFMB-BUJOPBNF
SJDBOBEF#JPUJDB &-"#&
MBDVBMPS
HBOJ[ Z EJDU EVSBOUF WBSJPT BPT VO
QSPHSBNB EF FOTFBO[B EF MB CJPUJDB 
EFEPTNFTFTEFEVSBDJO DPOMBDPMB
CPSBDJOEFCJPFUJDJTUBTEFM,FOOFEZ*OT
UJUVUFPG&UIJDT





-BCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBZFO$PMPNCJB"MGPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS 4+

$PMPNCJBFOUSBFOBDDJO
&OUSFZ TJORVFTFDPOPDJFSB
QCMJDBNFOUF MB CJPUJDB  DPNFO[ FO
$PMPNCJBVONPWJNJFOUPEFIVNBOJ
[BDJO EF MB NFEJDJOB  QSPQJDJBEP QPS
HSBOEFTIVNBOJTUBTEF#PHPUZ.FEF
MMO RVFEJFSPODPNJFO[PBOVFWBTFT
DVFMBTQBSBTVQFSBSMPTEFTNBOFTEFMPT
FTUVEJBOUFTEFMBTFTDVFMBTQCMJDBT FDP
EF MBT DMFCSFT SFWVFMUBT VOJWFSTJUBSJBT
EF &VSPQB 
 "M GVOEBSMBT  FTUPT
IVNBOJTUBTTFFTGPS[BSPOFODPOUSJCVJS
BMBGPSNBDJOJOUFHSBMEFMGVUVSPHBMF
OP7BMFMBQFOBNFODJPOBSB'FSOBOEP
4ODIF[5PSSFT +BJNF&TDPCBS5SJBOB 
+VBO.FOEP[B7FHB FOUSFPUSPT
-B "TPDJBDJO $PMPNCJBOB EF 'BDVM
UBEFT EF .FEJDJOB "4$0'".&
 m
MJBM EF MB 'FEFSBDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF
"TPDJBDJPOFT EF 'BDVMUBEFT &TDVFMBT

EF .FEJDJOB '&1"'&.  EJSJHJEB QPS
"CFM %VFBT 1BUSO  DPOUSJCVZ OP
TMPDPOFMEJTFPFJNQMBOUBDJOEFVO
QSPHSBNBEFFOTFBO[BEFMBUJDBN
EJDBTJOPDPOFMOGBTJTFOMBGPSNBDJO
JOUFHSBMRVFEFCBEBSTFBMPTFTUVEJBO
UFTEFNFEJDJOB
:B FO MB EDBEB EF MPT   Z TJO FTQF
DJBMDPOFYJODPO"SHFOUJOB 'FSOBOEP
4ODIF[5PSSFT RVJFOIBCBTJEPEFDB
OP EF NFEJDJOB Z SFDUPS EF MB 6OJWFS
TJEBE/BDJPOBMEF$PMPNCJB GVOEFO
EJDJFNCSF EF   DPO VO HSVQP EF
QSPGFTJPOBMFTEFEJWFSTBTSBNBT FM*OTUJ
UVUP$PMPNCJBOPEF&TUVEJPT#JPUJDPT
*$&#
FMDVBMIBNBOUFOJEPEFTEFFO
UPODFTVOTFNJOBSJP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

4FHVOEBFUBQBDPOTPMJEBDJPOEF
MBCJPUJDBFO-BUJOPBNSJDB
-B TFHVOEB FUBQB 
 TF DB
SBDUFSJ[BQPSVOJOUFOTPEFTBSSPMMPEFMB
CJPUJDBFOUPEPTMPTQBTFTMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOPTZEFM$BSJCF EFCJEP BNJKVJDJP 
BUSFTIFDIPT

#PMFUOEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE
014

&O 4VTBO4DIPMMF$POOPSZ)FS
OO 'VFO[BMJEB1VFMNB  EF MB 014 FO
8BTIJOHUPO QVCMJDBSPOVOONFSPEFM
CPMFUOEFMBPSHBOJ[BDJODPOVOBTFSJF
EF BSUDVMPT  RVF BQBSFDJFSPO MVFHP FO
GPSNBEFMJCSP TPCSFEJWFSTPTUQJDPTEF
CJPUJDB FTDSJUPTQPSOPUBCMFTBVUPSJEB
EFTFOMBNBUFSJB DVZBBNQMJBEJGVTJO
QSDUJDBNFOUF JOUSPEVKP GPSNBMNFOUF
MBCJPUJDBFO-BUJOPBNSJDB
&KFNQMBSFT EF FTUF CPMFUO Z MVFHP EFM
MJCSP MMFHBSPO B NBOPT EF NEJDPT Z
QSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBTBMVE JOUFSFTBEPTFO
IBDFS VOB QSJNFSB BQSPYJNBDJO B UBO
OPWFEPTBEJTDJQMJOB

'&-"*#&
&O NJFOUSBTUSBCBKBCBFOMB"TP
DJBDJO $PMPNCJBOB EF 'BDVMUBEFT EF
.FEJDJOB "4$0'".&
GVOEFM$FO
USP/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB $&/"-#&

RVFTFIBQSFPDVQBEPEFMFTUVEJPZEJ
GVTJOEFMBCJPUJDBEFOUSPZGVFSBEF
$PMPNCJB3FDJFOUFNFOUF$&/"-#& 
IPZ WJODVMBEP BM *OTUJUVUP EF #JPUJDB
EF MB 1POUJmDJB 6OJWFSTJEBE +BWFSJBOB 





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DPOUSJCVZ DPO FmDBDJB B MB GVOEBDJO


EFMB"TPDJBDJO/BDJPOBM$PMPNCJBOB
EF #JPUJDB "/"-#&
 Z BM FTUBCMFDJ
NJFOUPEFMB$PNJTJO*OUFSTFDUPSJBMEF
#JPUJDB  DSFBEB QPS %FDSFUP 1SFTJEFO
DJBM FOKVOJPEF
&O   $&/"-#& EFDJEJ GVOEBS
VOB 'FEFSBDJO -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF
*OTUJUVDJPOFT EF #JPUJDB '&-"*#&

NT QBSB QSPNPWFS MB GVOEBDJO EF
JOTUJUVUPT Z DFOUSPT FO UPEPT MPT QBTFT
RVFQBSBGFEFSBSMPTRVFUPEBWBOPFYJT
UBO$&/"-#& QBSBEBSBDPOPDFSB
'&-"*#& PSHBOJ[ BQBSUJSEFTVGVO
EBDJO  GPSPT Z BTBNCMFBT FO EJWFSTPT
QBTFT EFM DPOUJOFOUF BNFSJDBOP Z EFM
$BSJCF
:B FO   '&-"*#& FNQF[ B PS
HBOJ[BS DPOHSFTPT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT EF
CJPUJDB FOPSEFOBQSPNPWFSTVDPOP
DJNJFOUPZEJGVTJO&MQSJNFSPGVFFO
4BP 1BVMP  #SBTJM  FO  FM TFHVOEP
FO #PHPU  $PMPNCJB  FO   DPO MB
BTJTUFODJBEFNJMRVJOJFOUBTQFSTPOBTFM
UFSDFSPFOMB$JVEBEEF1BOBNFO 
ZFMDVBSUPFO1VFSUP3JDPFO
'&-"*#&QVCMJDBDVBUSPWFDFTBMBPVO
CPMFUODPOFMOPNCSFEF#*07/$6
-0 RVFEBBDPOPDFSMBTEJWFSTBTBDUJWJ
EBEFT EF MB CJPUJDB FO -BUJOPBNSJDB
$&/"-#&UJFOFUBNCJOFMNSJUPEF
IBCFS JOJDJBEP FO  MPT QSPHSBNBT
EF FTQFDJBMJEBE FO CJPUJDB  FM QSJNFSP
EFMPTDVBMFTGVFFMBCPSBEPZEJDUBEPFO
MB6OJWFSTJEBEEF&M#PTRVF FO#PHPU
&OMBBDUVBMJEBETFEJDUBOEJQMPNBEPTZ
QPTHSBEPTEFFTQFDJBMJ[BDJOZNBFTUSB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

FOMBTDJVEBEFTEF#PHPU $BMJZ.FEF
MMO-B6OJWFSTJEBEEF&M#PTRVFDVFO
UB DPO VO 1SPHSBNB EF %PDUPSBEP FO
#JPUJDB FMQSJNFSPEFFTUFHOFSPFOFM
QBT TJFOEP$PMPNCJBVOPEFMPTTJUJPT
EPOEFTFEJDUBONTDVSTPTEFQPTHSBEP
FO-BUJOPBNSJDB

1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPUJDB
EFMB014
0USP IFDIP EFDJTJWP IB TJEP MB GVOEB
DJO  B DPNJFO[PT EF   FO MB DJV
EBEEF4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF EFM1SPHSBNB
3FHJPOBMEF#JPUJDBEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE 0140.4 
FOFTUSFDIBDPMBCPSBDJODPOMB6OJWFS
TJEBEEF$IJMF
'VFSBEFMBQPZPDPODFQUVBMZFDPONJ
DPBNMUJQMFTBDUJWJEBEFT FMQSPHSBNB
IBPGSFDJEP BQBSUJSEFZBQSPGF
TJPOBMFTEJWFSTPT VOB.BFTUSBFO#JP
UJDBCBKPMBEJSFDDJOEF%JFHP(SBDJB
(VJMMO  RVF NBSDB VO WFSEBEFSP IJUP
FOFMTMJEPFTUVEJPZQSPGVOEJ[BDJOEF
MBCJPUJDBFO-BUJOPBNSJDB
&O MPT MUJNPT BPT 
 FM
1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDBTFFODVFOUSBCBKP
MBEJSFDDJOEFMQSPGFTPSEPDUPS'FSOBO
EP-PMBT4UFQLF

3QJEBEJGVTJOEFMBCJPUJDBFO
-BUJOPBNSJDB
" QBSUJS EF   FM QSFTJEFOUF EF
'&-"*#&SFDPSSJMPTQSJODJQBMFTQBTFT
EF -BUJOPBNSJDB JOWJUBOEP B GVOEBS
DFOUSPTFJOTUJUVUPT&ODBEBVOPJEFO
UJmDBVOMEFSRVFTFIJDJFSBDBSHPEFM





-BCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBZFO$PMPNCJB"MGPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS 4+

FTUVEJPZEJGVTJOEFMBCJPUJDBZRVF
BTJTUJFSBBMPTGPSPTZBTBNCMFBTBOVBMFT
EF '&-"*#& &M QSJNFSP TF SFBMJ[ FO
(POOFU  "SHFOUJOB  FO EJDJFNCSF EF
  BP Z TJUJP EF TV GVOEBDJO FM
TFHVOEP FO 7JMMB EF -FZWB  $PMPNCJB
FM UFSDFSP FO -JNB  1FS FM DVBSUP FO
(VBOBKVBUP  .YJDP FM RVJOUP FO 4BP
1BVMP #SBTJM 
FOFMDVBMFMTFO
DJMMPGPSPEFBPTBOUFSJPSFTTFDPOWJSUJ
FOFM1SJNFS$POHSFTP-BUJOPBNFSJDBOP
EF#JPUJDB

1SPTZDPOUSBT
&OMBBDUVBMJEBEMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBQSFTFOUBBWBODFTZNSJUPT BDPN
QBBEPT EF GBMMBT Z EFmDJFODJBT &OUSF
MBT QSJNFSBT  EFCFNPT SFDPOPDFS BMHP
EFEFTPSEFOZGBMUBEFVOJmDBDJOEFSF
DVSTPTIVNBOPTZFDPONJDPTJNQSP
WJTBDJO TFSFQJUF PNJUFPTFTVTQFOEF
VOBPCSB DFOUSP SFWJTUB FUD
BVTFODJB
EF VOB JEFOUJEBE QSPQJB UFOEFNPT B
SFQFUJS MP RVF TF IBDF FO PUSPT QBTFT 
FOFTQFDJBMFO&TUBEPTVOJEPTZ&TQBB 
TJOQSPQPOFSOPTVOBCJPUJDBDPOGVO
EBNFOUBDJO UFOEFODJBT UFNBTZQSP
CMFNBTQSPQJPT
ZGBMUBEFJOUFSTFOMB
CJPUJDB QPS QBSUF EF BMHVOPT &TUBEPT
QSFEPNJOBMPRVFMMBNBSBNPTCJPUJDB
QSJWBEBPQBSUJDVMBS DVMUJWBEBFOGPSNB
EF DPNJUT  DPNJTJPOFT  DFOUSPT  JOTUJ
UVUPT  QVCMJDBDJPOFT  QSPHSBNBT EF QSF
ZQPTHSBEP FOUSFPUSPT UPEPMPDVBMFT
PSHBOJ[BEP FOCVFOBQBSUF QPSMBTVOJ
WFSTJEBEFTZIPTQJUBMFT1FSPMPT&TUBEPT 
PDVQBEPTFOQSPCMFNBTVSHFOUFTEFPS
EFO QCMJDP  QPMUJDP Z FDPONJDP  OP
BMDBO[BO B QSFTUBS BUFODJO Z mOBODJB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DJOBMBMFHJTMBDJOZBMFTUBCMFDJNJFO
UP EF MB SFTQFDUJWB DPNJTJO P DPOTFKP
OBDJPOBMEFCJPUJDB&YJTUFNTCJPUJDB
QPMUJDBPQCMJDBFO&TUBEPT6OJEPTZ
FO &VSPQB RVF FO OVFTUSPT QBTFT MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOPTZEFM$BSJCF
&OUSF MPT NSJUPT FT KVTUP SFDPOPDFS
RVF BQFTBSEFMPTFTDBTPTSFDVSTPTFDP
ONJDPT Z DJFOUmDPT  MB CJPUJDB TF IB
EFTBSSPMMBEPBNQMJBNFOUFFODBTJUPEPT
MPTQBTFTEF-BUJOPBNSJDBZRVFTFIBO
PSHBOJ[BEPDVSTPTEFQPTHSBEPEFFTQF
DJBMJ[BDJO NBFTUSBZEPDUPSBEP
2VJTJFSB EFTUBDBS MB QSFTFODJB FO DBEB
QBTEFBMHVOPTMEFSFTRVFWJFOFOQSP
NPWJFOEPMBCJPUJDBFOGPSNBEFGPSPT 
DVSTPT  QVCMJDBDJPOFT &OUSF PUSPT  TJO
TFSFYIBVTUJWP
.YJDP

.BOVFM7FMBTDP4VSF[
GBMMFDJEP
Z'FSOBOEP$BOP
$PTUB3JDB )FSOO$PMMBEP
(VBUFNBMB $BSMPT-BSB3PDIF
1BOBN
&EVBSEP4PVTB-FOOPYZ
-VJT1JDBSE
$VCB
+PT"DPTUBZ%BOJFM1JFESB
1VFSUP3JDP +PSHF'FSSFSZ)FMFOB-VHP
7FOF[VFMB "VHVTUP-FOZ"MGSFEP
$BTUJMMP7BMMFSZ
&DVBEPS
&NJMJP$FSF[PZ.BSZEF
.BSUOF[
1FS
3PCFSUP-MBOPT
$IJMF
'FSOBOEP-PMBTZ"MFKBOESP
4FSBOJ
1BSBHVBZ "MCFSUP-FO
6SVHVBZ 0NBS'SBODB
#PMJWJB
.JHVFM.BO[BOFSB
#SBTJM
7PMOFJ(BSSBGB +PT&EVBSEP
EF4JRVFJSB -FP1FTTJOJ
$PMPNCJB +BJNF&TDPCBS5SJBOB 
'FSOBOEP4ODIF[5PSSFT 
"MGPOTP-MBOP&TDPCBS
3FQCMJDB
%PNJOJDBOB"OEST1FSBMUB

1BSBmOFTEFMBEDBEBEFMPTQSDUJ
DBNFOUFUPEPTMPTQBTFTMBUJOPBNFSJDB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

OPTPSHBOJ[BCBOBDUJWJEBEFTEFCJPUJDB
DPOHSFTPT GPSPT QBOFMFT KPSOBEBT DP
NJUTIPTQJUBMBSJPT JOTUJUVUPTZDFOUSPT 
SFWJTUBT MJCSPT DVSTPTEFQSFZQPTHSBEP

Z EFNBOFSBFTQFDJBM GPSNBCBOBTPDJB
DJPOFTOBDJPOBMFT)BTUB QSDUJDB
NFOUFUPEPTMPTQBTFTSFBMJ[BOUPEBTP
DBTJUPEBTFTUBTBDUJWJEBEFT

3FGFSFODJBT
(BMJOEP ' 
&M'FONFOPEFMBT4FDUBT'VOEBNFOUBMJTUBT-BDPORVJTUBFWBOHMJDB
EF"NSJDB-BUJOB/BWBSSB &EJUPSJBM7FSCP%JWJOP
.BJOFUUJ +PT" 1JT%JF[ (Z5FBMEJ +$ 
#JPFUIJDTJO-BUJO"NFSJDB*O
-VTUJH " 0SH
#JPFUIJDT:FBSCPPL7PM3FHJPOBM%FWFMPQNFOUJO#JPFUIJDT
%PSESFDIU 5IF/FUIFSMBOET ,MVXFS"DBEFNJD1VCMJTIFST QQ
1PUUFS 7BO3FOTTFMBFS 
#JPFUIJDT #SJEHFUPUIF'VUVSF/FX:PSL 1SFOUJDF)BMM
3BNTFZ 1 
5IF1BUJFOUBT1FSTPO&YQMPSBUJPOTJO.FEJDBM&UIJDT/FX)BWFO 
:BMF6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
3PVY  ' 
 'VOEBNFOUPT EF VOB UJDB DJVEBEBOB *O $PMPNCJB VOB DBTB QBSB
UPEPTEFCBUFUJDP4BOUB'FEF#PHPU 1SPHSBNBQPSMB1B[ $PNQBBEF+FTT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





6OBIJTUPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB
-BUJOB&MEFTBGPBDUVBMBMBQSPGFTJONEJDBZMB
JOnVFODJBEFMBTFNQSFTBTGBSNBDPRVNJDBT
+BNFT%SBOF

-PTQSJODJQJPTEFMBCJPUJDB

&

O MPT BPT   %BO $BMMBIBO Z ZP


WJBKBNPTKVOUPTBMSFEFEPSEFMNVO
EP&OBRVFMMBQPDB %BOFSBFMDPPS
EJOBEPSEF$PNNPOXFBM.BHB[JOF VOB
SFWJTUBDBUMJDBEFSFMJHJOZQPMUJDBEF
/VFWB:PSL:PFTUBCBFOMB6OJWFSTJ
EBEEF:BMF FOVOBCFDB MVFHPEFNJ
TVTQFOTJO EFM TBDFSEPDJP EFCJEP B VO
BSUDVMPNPRVFBCPHBCBQPSFMDBNCJP
FO MBT FOTFBO[BT EF MB *HMFTJB TPCSF FM
DPOUSPM EF MB OBUBMJEBE .JFOUSBT %BO
IBDBVOBJOWFTUJHBDJOEFQPMUJDBTQ
CMJDBTEFMBCPSUPFOEJWFSTBTDVMUVSBT ZP
FTUVEJBCBEJWFSTBTQPMUJDBTQCMJDBTEFM
DPOUSPMEFMBOBUBMJEBE-PRVFSFDVFSEP
NT EF FTF UJFNQP FSB RVF M BPSBCB
BTVFTQPTBZOJPT ZTFQSFHVOUBCBTJ
OP QPESB EFKBS TV USBCBKP FO MB $PN
NPOXFBM QBSB FTUBCMFDFS VO JOTUJUVUP
QBSBFMFTUVEJPEFQSPCMFNBTUJDPTFOMB
NFEJDJOBDPOUFNQPSOFB
-BTDVFTUJPOFTUJDBTFONFEJDJOBFTUB
CBO QSFTFOUFT FO MB DPODJFODJB QCMJDB
EFTQVTEFMB4FHVOEB(VFSSB.VOEJBM
1SJNFSP  MPT DIPDBOUFT DSNFOFT UJDPT
EF MPT NEJDPT OB[JT SFWFMBEPT FO MPT
KVJDJPT EF /VSFNCFSH %FTQVT EF MB
HVFSSB FMHPCJFSOPEF&&66JOWJSUJ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DBOUJEBEFTFOPSNFTEFEJOFSPFOJOWFT
UJHBDJO NEJDB -BT DVFTUJPOFT UJDBT
QSFTFOUFT FO MPT QSPZFDUPT EF JOWFTUJ
HBDJOFSBTVQVFTUBNFOUFTPMVDJPOBEBT
QPS VO FUJDJTUB FQJTDPQBM  VO TBDFSEPUF
+PIO'MFUDIFS
FNQMFBEPFOMPT*OTUJUV
UPT/BDJPOBMFTEF4BMVE /*)
1FSPM
UFOBNVZQPDBBVUPSJEBEZMPTQSPZFD
UPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJO EFNBTJBEP OVNF
SPTPT DPNP QBSB RVF VOB TPMB QFSTPOB
QVEJFSBTVQFSWJTBSMPTDPOFmDBDJB
-PT GSVUPT EF MB FOPSNF JOWFSTJO EFM
HPCJFSOP OVFWPTUSBUBNJFOUPTZUFDOP
MPHBT  MMFHBCBO B MB QSDUJDB DMOJDB FO
VOB DPSSJFOUF DPOTUBOUF $BEB OVFWP
EFTBSSPMMP TVTDJUBCB QSPCMFNBT UJDPT
FTQFDmDPT -BT DVFTUJPOFT BTPDJBEBT BM
QSJODJQJPZFMmOBMEFMBWJEB RVFWFOBO
EFBOUFTEFMB4FHVOEB(VFSSB.VOEJBM 
TF UPSOBCBO NT Z NT QSPNJOFOUFT
$VFTUJPOFT BTPDJBEBT B MB QSPDSFBDJO 
DPNPFMBCPSUPZFMDPOUSPMEFMBOBUB
MJEBE  FSBO EJTDVUJEBT FYUFOTBNFOUF FO
MPTNFEJPTEFDPNVOJDBDJO FOMFHJTMB
UVSBTGFEFSBMFTZFTUBUBMFTZFOMBTDPSUFT
-BUFOEFODJBHFOFSBMFSBRVJUBSSFTUSJD
DJPOFTMFHBMFT-BEJTDVTJOFSBJOUFOTB
Z MB HFOUF CVTDBCB EJTDFSOJNJFOUP UJ
DP-PTDMOJDPTOFDFTJUBCBOBZVEBDPO





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DVFTUJPOFTUJDBTDVBOEPMBTUFDOPMPHBT
EFMBQPTHVFSSBMMFHBSBOBMPTMFDIPTEFM
IPTQJUBM.VDIBTEFTUBTQFSNJUBOFY
UFOEFSMBWJEBEFQBDJFOUFTNPSJCVOEPT
ZDSFBSPOEVEBTTPCSFFMQBQFMEFMBNF
EJDJOBVOBWF[RVFVOQBDJFOUFFOUSBCB
FOFMQSPDFTPEFMNPSJS
/P GBMUBCBO MBT DVFTUJPOFT NT mMPT
mDBTTPCSFMBOBUVSBMF[BEFMBQSPGFTJO
NEJDBZMBTNFUBTEFMBNFEJDJOB&O
MPTBPTIBCBQSPCMFNBTUJDPTFO
UPEPT MPT BTQFDUPT EF TUB RVF SFRVF
SBO FTUVEJP TFSJP  PSJFOUBDJPOFT QBSB
MPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT Z QPMUJDBT QCMJDBT
FmDBDFT
%BOZZPIBCMCBNPTEFFTPTUFNBTEV
SBOUFOVFTUSPTSFDPSSJEPT4PCSFMBQSPMJ
GFSBDJOEFMPTQSPCMFNBTUJDPTDSFBEPT
QPSMBNFEJDJOBDJFOUmDBDPOUFNQPS
OFB OP IBCB EVEB -B JODFSUJEVNCSF
FSB TBCFS TJ TF QPESB FODPOUSBS BZVEB
mOBODJFSB QBSB FTUBCMFDFS VO JOTUJUVUP
QBSBFMFTUVEJPEFMPTQSPCMFNBTUJDPT
FO NFEJDJOB {1PESB M FODPOUSBS CBT
UBOUFTSFDVSTPTQBSBDPNFO[BSVOJOTUJ
UVUPDPNPTUF 
$VBOEP SFUPSOBNPT EF FTF WJBKF  %BO
QVCMJD TV MJCSP TPCSF FM BCPSUP  RVF
UFOESB VO JNQBDUP JNQPSUBOUF FO MPT
KVFDFT EF MB $PSUF 4VQSFNB OPSUFBNF
SJDBOB DVBOEP TF TFOUFODJ FM DBTP 3PF
WT 8BEF %FTQVT  M SFDJCJ MB BZVEB
mOBODJFSB RVF OFDFTJUBCB  EFK TV QP
TJDJO FO $PNNPOXFBM Z DPNFO[ FM
)BTUJOHT $FOUFS FO  &TF QSJNFS
JOTUJUVUPEFUJDBNEJDBNBSDVOQBTP
JNQPSUBOUF IBDJB FM FTUBCMFDJNJFOUP EF
VOB OVFWB EJTDJQMJOB BDBENJDB RVF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

WJOPBMMBNBSTFiCJPUJDBw&MUSNJOPTF
BUSJCVZFB7BO3FOTTFMBFS1PUUFS DVZP
MJCSP #JPFUIJDT #SJEHF UP UIF GVUVSF GVF
QVCMJDBEPFO
"DUVBMNFOUF  FT JOJNBHJOBCMF MB JEFB
EFMBNFEJDJOBBQBSUBEBEFMBCJPUJDB 
FOFMTFOUJEPEFVOBOMJTJTGPSNBMZTJT
UFNUJDP-BOVFWBCJPUJDBFSBNVDIP
NTBNQMJBZNTDPNQMFKBRVFMBUJDB
NEJDBUSBEJDJPOBM6OBWF[FTUBCMFDJEB 
TFEJTFNJOSQJEBNFOUFBMSFEFEPSEFM
NVOEP Z FT IPZ VOB EF MBT EJTDJQMJOBT
RVF EFmOFO OVFTUSB QPDB /BEJF QP
ESB QSFTVNJS FOUFOEFS MB DVMUVSB NF
EJFWBMTJOFTUVEJBSTFSJBNFOUFMBUFPMPHB
Z  FO FM GVUVSP  OBEJF QPES FOUFOEFS
MB DVMUVSB NEJDB EF IPZ TJO FTUVEJBS
MB CJPUJDB -B EJTDJQMJOB EF MB CJPUJDB
OPTEFmOFQPSRVFMBNFEJDJOBZMBTBMVE
TPOIPZQBSBOPTPUSPTMPRVFGVFSPOMB
SFMJHJOZMBTBMWBDJOQBSBMBHFOUFEF
MB&EBE.FEJB&OGFSNFEBEFT DJSVHBT 
FYQFSJNFOUPT FOWFKFDJNJFOUP NFKPSBT 
HFOUJDB  FOUSF PUSPT QSPCMFNBT  OPT
QSFPDVQBO Z OPT JEFOUJmDBO -BT QSF
HVOUBTUJDBTTFMJHBODPODBEBBTQFDUP
EFMBNFEJDJOBDPOUFNQPSOFB-BTBTP
DJBDJPOFT QSPGFTJPOBMFT  DPNP MB 0SHB
OJ[BDJO.VOEJBMEFMB4BMVE 0.4
MB
0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE
014
MB"NFSJDBO.FEJDBM"TTPDJBUJPOT
"."
ZBTPDJBDJPOFTNEJDBTTJNJMBSFT
FODBEBQBTUJFOFORVFQSFPDVQBSTFQPS
MPT FTUOEBSFT UJDPT QBSB MB JOWFTUJHB
DJOZMBQSDUJDBNEJDBT

 1PUUFS 7BO3FOTTFMBFS 


#JPFUIJDT#SJE
HFUPUIF'VUVSF&OHMFXPPE$MJT /+ 1SFO
UJDF)BMM





6OBIJTUPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB+BNFT%SBOF

)BDJBmOBMFTEFMTJHMP9*9ZDPNJFO[PT
EFM 99  MBT BTPDJBDJPOFT NEJDBT Z MBT
BVUPSJEBEFTBMFNBOBTIBCBOEFTBSSPMMB
EPSFHMBTUJDBTQBSBMBJOWFTUJHBDJOZMB
QSDUJDBNEJDBT4BCFNPT TJOFNCBS
HP  RVF SQJEBNFOUF FTBT OPSNBT GVF
SPO SFDIB[BEBT QPS MPT NEJDPT OB[JT 
RVJFOFTTVCTUJUVZFSPOMBCBTFDMTJDBEFM
BNPS B MB IVNBOJEBE  FYQSFTBEB FO FM
$EJHP )JQPDSUJDP  QPS VOB DSFFODJB
FOMBFVHFOFTJB
&O/VSFNCFSH EFTQVTEFMB4FHVOEB
(VFSSB .VOEJBM  TF SFBMJ[BSPO KVJDJPT
QBSBUSBUBSMPTDSNFOFTDPOUSBMBIVNB
OJEBEDPNFUJEPTQPSNEJDPT-PTKVF
DFT FO /VSFNCFSH GPSNVMBSPO TV QSP
QJP DEJHP UJDP QBSB MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
NEJDB1FSPFTFDEJHPOPFSBEJGFSFOUF
EFMBTSFHVMBDJPOFTBMFNBOBTSFDIB[BEBT
UBOFWJEFOUFNFOUFQPSMPTNEJDPTOB
[JT-PRVFGBDJMJUMBTWJPMBDJPOFTUJDBT
OB[JTOPGVFMBBVTFODJBEFSFHVMBDJPOFT
UJDBTTJOPMBDBSFODJBEFVOBWJHJMBODJB
DPOUJOVBEBQPSMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTQSP
GFTJPOBMFT  VOB TVQFSWJTJO QSPGFTJPOBM
EFMBTBDUJWJEBEFTNEJDBTZVOOGBTJT
FO MPT DPNQPOFOUFT UJDPT EF MB NFEJ
DJOBQSPGFTJPOBM&TBFTVOBMFDDJORVF
OPTFQVFEFPMWJEBSTJOFMQFMJHSPEFRVF
BMHPTJNJMBSTVDFEBEFOVFWP

 )BCMP EF MB %JSFDUJWF PO )VNBO &YQFSJNFO


UBUJPO  QSPNVMHBEB QPS FM .JOJTUSP 1SVTJBOP
EF "TVOUPT 3FMJHJPTPT  &EVDBUJWPT Z .EJDPT
FO&O FM.JOJTUSPEFM*OUFSJPSEFM
3FJDIQVCMJDOPSNBTUJDBTDMBSBTZDPODSFUBT
QBSBMBJOWFTUJHBDJODPOTFSFTIVNBOPT4FUSB
UBCBEFOPSNBTBONTFTQFDmDBTZEFNT
MBSHP BMDBODF RVF MBT QSJNFSBT EJSFDUSJDFT EF
/VSFNCFSHZ)FMTJOLJ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&M $EJHP EF /VSFNCFSH GVF TFHVJEP


QPSMBTEJSFDUSJDFTUJDBTRVFQSPNVMHB
SPOFMHPCJFSOPEF&&66 MB"TPDJB
DJO.EJDB.VOEJBM 8."
MB"TP
DJBDJO.EJDB"NFSJDBOB "."
ZMB
%FDMBSBDJOEF)FMTJOLJ&OMPTBPT
TF QVCMJDBSPO NVDIPT BSUDVMPT TPCSF
JOWFTUJHBDJO NEJDB FO &&66  QFSP
TJOEBSNVDIBBUFODJOBMBTDVFTUJPOFT
UJDBT QPSRVFTFQFOTBCBRVFFM$EJHP
Z MBT SFHVMBDJPOFT TVCTFDVFOUFT IBCBO
QSPQPSDJPOBEP VOB EJSFDDJO NT RVF
BEFDVBEB QBSB FWJUBS QSPCMFNBT UJDPT
"EFNT MBTWJPMBDJPOFTUJDBTDPNFUJEBT
QPSMPTNEJDPTOB[JT QFOTBCBMBHFOUF 
OPQPESBOTVDFEFSFO"NSJDB
&OUPODFT FO )FOSZ,#FFDIFS 
QSPGFTPS EF BOFTUFTJB FO MB VOJWFSTJEBE
EF )BSWBSE  QVCMJD FO F /FX &O
HMBOE +PVSOBM PG .FEJDJOF VO BSUDVMP
RVFEFUBMMBCBBMSFEFEPSEFQSPZFDUPT
EF JOWFTUJHBDJO RVF WJPMBCBO FTUOEB
SFT UJDPT &SB JOEFDFOUF MB TFNFKBO[B
FOUSFUBMFTGBMUBTZMBTRVFIBCBODPNF
UJEPMPTOB[JT-BTWJPMBDJPOFTUJDBTRVF
FMEPDUPS#FFDIFSSFWFMUVWJFSPODPNP
WDUJNBTBQBDJFOUFTWVMOFSBCMFT VTBSPO
FMEJOFSPEFMHPCJFSOPZ QSPCBCMFNFO
UF UVWJFSPODPNPBHFOUFTBCVFOPTN
EJDPTBNFSJDBOPT
3FHMBTZOPSNBTFYJTUBOEFTEFNVDIP
BOUFT -P RVF OP FYJTUB FSB MB FmDB[
TVQFSWJTJO JO TJUV EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
.VDIBTWDUJNBTFSBOQBDJFOUFTRVFIB
CBOJEPBQFEJSBZVEBBTVTEPDUPSFTZTF
 #FFDIFS )FOSZ, 
&UIJDBMBOE$MJOJ
DBM3FTFBSDI/FX&OHMBOE+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOF 
 
QQ





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DPOWJSUJFSPOFOTVKFUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJO
TJOTFSJOGPSNBEPTPTJOEBSTVDPOTFO
UJNJFOUP-PTDPOUSPMFTUJDPTFTUBCMFDJ
EPTOPGVODJPOBCBOQPSRVFMPTNEJDPT
Z MPT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT UFOBO JODFOUJWPT
QFSTPOBMFTQBSBQFSTFHVJSMPTRVFDSFBO
PCKFUJWPTDJFOUmDPTJNQPSUBOUFT
-BT SFWFMBDJPOFT EFM EPDUPS )FOSZ
#FFDIFS TFBMBSPO MB OFDFTJEBE EF VOB
FYUFOTB SFGPSNB FO MB FEVDBDJO Z MB
QSDUJDBNEJDBT6SHBNTTVQFSWJTJO
QPS FM HPCJFSOP Z QPS PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT
QSPGFTJPOBMFT NEJDBT -B JEFB EF %BO
$BMMBIBOEFVOJOTUJUVUPQBSBFMFTUVEJP
EFDVFTUJPOFTUJDBTFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJO
NEJDB Z MB QSDUJDB DMOJDB QBSFDB VO
QBTPNVZBQSPQJBEP

&MQBQFMEFMB0SHBOJ[BDJO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEF4BMVE 014

-B0SHBOJ[BDJO.VOEJBMEF4BMVEFY
QSFT TV DPNQSPNJTP DPO MB UJDB FO
NFEJDJOBFOFMQSFNCVMPEFTVDPOTUJ
UVDJO-B0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOB
EF4BMVEIBCBIFDIPMPNJTNPNVDIP
BOUFT Z FTUBCMFDJ VO $PNJU EF UJDB
FO8BTIJOHUPOQBSBFYBNJOBSUPEPTMPT
QSPZFDUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJOEFOUSPEFTV
SFHJO &M EPDUPS (FPSHF "MMFZOF  MVF
HPEJSFDUPSEFMB014 EJSJHJFMDPNJU
JOTUJUVDJPOBMEFUJDBEFMB014QPSNV
DIPT BPT %VSBOUF TVT BPT DPNP EJ
SFDUPS 
 NBOUVWP FM OGBTJT
FOMBUJDBEFOUSPEFMBPSHBOJ[BDJO
&M EPDUPS $BSMJMF (VFSSB EF .BDFEP 
EVSBOUF TV QFSPEP DPNP EJSFDUPS EF
MB014 
SFDPOPDJRVFMB
SFWJTJO EF MPT QSPZFDUPT EF JOWFTUJHB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DJO OP FSB TVmDJFOUF QBSB HBSBOUJ[BS


FM SFTQFUP IBDJB MPT TVKFUPT IVNBOPT
#BKPTVBENJOJTUSBDJOTFPSHBOJ[VOB
DPOGFSFODJB TPCSF CJPUJDB FO "NSJDB
-BUJOB -BT QVCMJDBDJPOFT EF CJPUJ
DB PSJHJOBEBT EF MB PmDJOB EF MB 014
FO 8BTIJOHUPO GVFSPO EJTUSJCVJEBT FO
MPT QBTFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT 1FSP FTP
OPFSBTVmDJFOUF4FSFRVFSB BEFNT 
QSFQBSBSBMPTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTFOCJP
UJDBZ EFTQVT PSHBOJ[BSDPNJUTJOT
UJUVDJPOBMFTEFSFWJTJOQBSBTVQFSWJTBS
BDUJWJEBEFTEFJOWFTUJHBDJOJOTJUV&TB
OFDFTJEBESFRVFSBEFMB014VOOVFWP
DPNQSPNJTP FO MVHBS EF TFS VO QSP
ZFDUP MJHBEP B 8BTIJOHUPO  TF EFDJEJ
FOUSFOBSFOCJPUJDBBQSPGFTJPOBMFTFO
DBEBQBTEF"NSJDB-BUJOBZEFM$B
SJCFDPOFMmOEFDFSDJPSBSTFEFRVFMB
JOWFTUJHBDJO MBQSDUJDBZMBFEVDBDJO
NEJDBTFTUVWJFTFODPNQSPNFUJEBTDPO
MBOVFWBEJTDJQMJOB
6OBGBMUBUJDBDPNQMFKBNPUJWMBEF
DJTJO EF BNQMJBS MPT QSPZFDUPT CJPUJ
DPT EF MB 014 $JFSUBT DPNQBBT GBS
NBDVUJDBT BNFSJDBOBT EFTFBCBO IBDFS
GVFSBEF&&66MPTFOTBZPTSFRVFSJEPT
QBSBMBBQSPCBDJOEFESPHBT&OQBTFT
NTQPCSFTEF"NSJDB-BUJOBFSBNT
GDJMSFDMVUBSTVKFUPTQBSBFTUPTFOTBZPT
UBNCJO MP FSB FWJUBS MBT SFTUSJDDJPOFT
JNQVFTUBTQPSFMHPCJFSOPZMBTBTPDJB
DJPOFTNEJDBTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEF&&66
$VBOEPBMHOFOTBZPDPOESPHBTDBVT
DPOTFDVFODJBTQFSKVEJDJBMFTQBSBMPTTV
KFUPT TPCSFUPEPNVKFSFT
MB014GVF
DVMQBEBQPSMBTGBMUBT&TPDSFVOBDSJ
TJT6OBDPOTFDVFODJBGVFMBEFDJTJOEF
DSFBS DPNJUT EF TVQFSWJTJO UJDB FO





6OBIJTUPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB+BNFT%SBOF

DBEB QBT QBSB QSPWFFS EJSFDUBNFOUF MB


TVQFSWJTJO EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJO NEJDB
FO TVKFUPT IVNBOPT $PMBCPS DPO MB
014QBSBFTUBCMFDFSFTFQSPZFDUP
'VFSPOBMHVOBTUSBOTHSFTJPOFTUJDBTEF
MBTDPNQBBTGBSNBDVUJDBT QFSTJHVJFO
EPTVTJOUFSFTFTFDPONJDPT MPRVFDSF
MBOFDFTJEBEEFUSBFSMBCJPUJDBEFVOB
NBOFSBNTBHSFTJWBB"NSJDB-BUJOB
4FIBIFDIPNVDIPQFSPRVFEBCBTUBO
UF QPS IBDFS 4FHVJSFNPT WJODVMBEPT B
USBWT EF MPT WBMPSFT RVF DPNQBSUJNPT
ZUBNCJOQPSMBOFDFTJEBEEFBGSPOUBS
BNFOB[BTBMBNFEJDJOBQSPGFTJPOBMRVF
UPEBWBOPTBGFDUBO
1BSUJDJQFOFMQSPZFDUPEFCJPUJDBFO
MB014EVSBOUFMPTBPT&OMPTDP
NJFO[PTEFMPTWJBKQPSUPEBMBSF
HJOQBSBJEFOUJmDBSQFSTPOBTRVFRVF
SBOUSBCBKBSFOFTFDBNQP5SBCBKDPO
MBTPmDJOBTEFMB014FODBEBQBT WJTJU
SHBOPTPmDJBMFTEFHPCJFSOPZIPTQJUB
MFTEFVOJWFSTJEBEFTZFTDVFMBTNEJDBT
QBSBJOGPSNBSBMBTQFSTPOBTJOUFSFTBEBT
TPCSFFMQMBOEFMB014-PRVFDPNV
OJRVFONJTDPOUBDUPTGVFMBOFDFTJEBE
VSHFOUFEFVOBCJPUJDBRVFGVODJPOBTF
MPDBMNFOUFFOUPEBMBSFHJOQBSBUSBUBS
MPTQSPCMFNBTUJDPTFOMBQSDUJDBDMOJDB
ZFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJONEJDB5BNCJO
DPNVOJRV NJ DPOWJDDJO QFSTPOBM EF
RVF VOB CJPUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB UFO
ESB RVF TFS EFTBSSPMMBEB QBSB BNQMJBS 
FOSJRVFDFS Z FOBMHVOPTDBTPT DPSSFHJS
MBTQFSTQFDUJWBTOPSUFBNFSJDBOBTZFVSP
QFBT&TFQSPZFDUPNBSDFMQSJODJQJPEF
FTUBEJTDJQMJOBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB QSP
NPWJEB Z QBUSPDJOBEB QPS VOB PSHBOJ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

[BDJONEJDBEFMBSHPBMDBODF 014

SFTQPOTBCMFQPSFMDBSDUFSZMBDBMJEBE
EFMBNFEJDJOBFOMBSFHJO
6OB DPTB FT TFHVSB FO MPT BPT WFOJ
EFSPT MB CJPUJDB OP WB B EFDMJOBS FO
JNQPSUBODJBPSFUSPDFEFSFOMBTQSFPDV
QBDJPOFT QSJPSJUBSJBT EF PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT
QSPGFTJPOBMFT DPNP MB 014 &TP OP
QVFEF PDVSSJS QPSRVF IBZ JODMVTP NB
ZPSFT QFMJHSPT IPZ RVF MPT QSFTFOUBEPT
QPS MBT WJPMBDJPOFT UJDBT BOUFSJPSFT 4F
IBO SFBMJ[BEP EJWFSTPT DPOHSFTPT Z TF
NJOBSJPTTPCSFUJDBFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJO
NEJDBZTFIBEFNPTUSBEPMBOFDFTJEBE
EFDPOUJOVBSMBBZVEBBMB014ZPUSPT
QSPHSBNBTJOEFQFOEJFOUFT-BTDVFTUJP
OFTCJPUJDBTTPCSFQBTBOFMSFBEFMBJO
WFTUJHBDJONEJDB)PZMBQSPQJBBMNB
EFMBQSPGFTJONEJDBFTUFOQFMJHSP
)FOSZ #FFDIFS FT VOP EF MPT HJHBOUFT
EFMBUJDBNEJDB*NQVMTBHPCJFSOPT 
PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT EF TBMVE Z BTPDJBDJPOFT
EF JOWFTUJHBDJO B EFTBSSPMMBS SFHMBT Z
QPMUJDBTUJDBT FTQFDJBMNFOUFFOFMSFB
EFM DPOTFOUJNJFOUP JOGPSNBEP 1FSP
IJ[PNTRVFFTP&OTVMJCSPEFmOFT
EF MPT  TFBM RVF  QPS HSBOEF RVF
TFB TV JNQPSUBODJB  MBT SFHMBT UJDBT FO
NFEJDJOB OVODB TFSO TVmDJFOUFT QBSB
IBDFS MB NFEJDJOB WFSEBEFSBNFOUF UJ
DB&OTVUSBCBKPmOBMFYQSFTRVFTMP
QSPGFTJPOBMFTNEJDPTDBQBDFT JOGPSNB
EPT DPNQBTJWPTZSFTQPOTBCMFTQVFEFO
 0USBWFSTJOEFMBIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPUJDBJCFSP
BNFSJDBOBFT%SBOF +BNFT' 
#JPFUIJ
DBM1FSTQFDUJWFT'SPN*CFSP"NFSJDB F+PVS
OBMPG.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZ  
 #FFDIFS )FOSZ,.% 
3FTFBSDIBOE
UIF*OEJWJEVBM .BTT -JUUMF#SPXOBOE$P





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

BTFHVSBS RVF MB NFEJDJOB DVNQMB TVT


PCKFUJWPTUJDPT&MQSPZFDUPMBUJOPBNF
SJDBOP EF MB CJPUJDB RVF TF PSJHJOB FO
MB 014 BTQJSBCB B DSFBS MB TVQFSWJTJO
FmDB[EFMBJOWFTUJHBDJOZGPSNBSQSP
GFTJPOBMFTNEJDPTDPNQSPNFUJEPTDPO
MPT BMUPT JEFBMFT UJDPT EF MB NFEJDJOB
QSPGFTJPOBM

6OQSPZFDUPCJPUJDPFODVSTP
%VSBOUF NJT SFDPSSJEPT B USBWT EF
"NSJDB-BUJOBFODPOUSNVDIPTNEJ
DPTJOUFSFTBEPTFOMBOVFWBEJTDJQMJOBZ
QFSTPOBTRVFIBDBOZBMPRVFZPJOUFO
UBCB QSPNPWFS &O "SHFOUJOB TBCB EF
VOQSPHSBNBFOIVNBOJEBEFTNEJDBT
CBKP MB EJSFDDJO EF +PT "MCFSUP .BJ
OFUUJMZZPGVJNPTGPSNBEPTFOUJDB
NEJDBQPSMPTNJTNPTJOUFMFDUVBMFTFT
QBPMFT+PT"MCFSUPQSPQPSDJPOVOB
BZVEBJNQPSUBOUFQBSBFMEJTFPEFVO
QSPZFDUPEFCJPUJDBEFMB014BUSBWT
EF"NSJDB-BUJOB%FTEFTVTJEFBT ZMBT
EFNJFNCSPTEFMBTPmDJOBTMFHBMFTEFMB
014ZEFQSPGFTJPOBMFTNEJDPTFOMPT
EJGFSFOUFT QBTFT  FNFSHJ VO QSPZFDUP
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPEFCJPUJDB FTUBCMFDJEP
FO4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF RVFSFQSFTFOUVO
FTGVFS[PEFDPMBCPSBDJOFOUSFMB014 
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF $IJMF Z FM HPCJFSOP
DIJMFOP
 "PTEFTQVT VOMJCSPEFNJBVUPSBIBTJEP
QVCMJDBEPFOMPT&&665SBUBCBEFMBWJSUVE
ZEFMDBSDUFSFOMBUJDBNEJDB$G%SBOF +B
NFT'#FDPNJOH"(PPE%PDUPS,BOTBT
$JUZ  4IFFE BOE 8BSE )B TJEP USBEVDJEP BM
FTQBPM Z FTU EJTQPOJCMF FO "NSJDB -BUJOB
%SBOF +' 
{$NPTFSVOCVFONEJDP 
4BOUBGEF#PHPU 4BO1BCMP
 .FSFmFSPB+PT-VJT"SBOHVSFOZ1FESP-BO
&OUSBMHP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

.JGPSNBDJOBDBENJDBQFSTPOBMJODMV
ZMBUFPMPHBDBUMJDBFOMB6OJWFSTJEBE
(SFHPSJBOBFO3PNBZmMPTPGBUJDBFO
MB6OJWFSTJEBEEF.BESJE.TBEFMBOUF
FTUVEJ NFEJDJOB F IJDF VOB SFTJEFODJB
FO QTJRVJBUSB DPO ,BSM .FOOJOHFS FO
5PQFLB  ,BOTBT %FCJEP B NJ GPSNB
DJOFOUFPMPHBDPOPDBBMPTUFMPHPT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT %VSBOUF NJT SFDP
SSJEPT WJTJUBBMHVOPTRVFHP[BCBOEF
SFDPOPDJNJFOUP JOUFSOBDJPOBM Z UFOBO
JOUFST QBSUJDVMBS FO MB KVTUJDJB TPDJBM 
JODMVZFOEP MB BQMJDBDJO EF MB KVTUJDJB
BMDVJEBEPNEJDP5BNCJOIJDFDPO
UBDUP DPO WBSJPT KFSBSDBT DBUMJDPT QPS
FKFNQMP  FM $BSEFOBM &WBSJTUP "SOT

:P KV[HBCB JNQPSUBOUF EFTBSSPMMBS VOB
QFSTQFDUJWB TPDJBM EF MB KVTUJDJB FO CJP
UJDB RVFFO&&66Z&VSPQBFSB FO
FMNFKPSEFMPTDBTPT VOBQSFPDVQBDJO
NBSHJOBM -BT VOJWFSTJEBEFT DBUMJDBT Z
MBTFTDVFMBTNEJDBTRVFWJTJUUFOBOZB
VO DPNQPOFOUF EF UJDB RVF EFTFBCBO
BNQMJBS&OQPDPTBPT DPOMBBZVEBEF
VOB CBTF EF UJDB NEJDB ZB FYJTUFOUF 
TF FTUBCMFDJ VOB OVFWB EJTDJQMJOB MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOBEFCJPUJDBZDPNFO[TV
QSPQJPEFTBSSPMMP
&OIBCMFOMBDFSFNPOJBEFMBJO
BVHVSBDJOEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDBFO
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF%JF[BPTNTUBSEF 
FO   FYQVTF FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF
$IJMF  JOUFOUBOEP EFTDSJCJS DNP IB
CBNPTQSPDFEJEPFOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMB
CJPUJDB Z DNP UFOBNPT UPEBWB RVF
BWBO[BSTUBOPEFCFSBEFDMJOBSFOJN
QPSUBODJB  QFSP QPESB GBMMBS B NFOPT
RVF DJFSUPT QFMJHSPT GVFSBO SFDPOPDJ
EPT&OFTBDIBSMBNFSFGFSBBTQFDUPT





6OBIJTUPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB+BNFT%SBOF

JNQPSUBOUFTEFMBQSPGFTJONEJDBRVF 
QJFOTP  FTUO IPZ CBKP BNFOB[B Z RVF
MB CJPUJDB EFCF BCPSEBS &O SFBMJEBE 
FTUO NT BNFOB[BEPT UBM WF[ IPZ RVF
FO
-BTWJPMBDJPOFTEFFTUOEBSFTEFMBJOWFT
UJHBDJONEJDBQPSMBTDPNQBBTGBS
NBDVUJDBTIBCBOHFOFSBEPMBDBNQBB
PSJHJOBMEFCJPUJDBFO014ZNJJNQMJ
DBDJOQFSTPOBMDPOMBCJPUJDBFO"N
SJDB-BUJOB&MMBTOPIBOEFTBQBSFDJEP
-PTBPTNPTUSBSPORVFIBCBNEJDPT
RVF USBCBKBCBO FO MB NFEJDJOB DMOJDB
DPOWFSUJEPT FO WFOEFEPSFT EF BMHVOBT
DPNQBBTGBSNBDVUJDBTZQSPNPUPSFT
EFDJFSUBTESPHBT&OMPTBPTIBCB
VOBBNFOB[BBMBQSPGFTJONEJDBRVF
QSPWFOB EF MBT DPNQBBT GBSNBDVUJ
DBT Z FTP TJHVF TVDFEJFOEP EFTQVT EF
UPEP MP RVF TF IB IFDIP EVSBOUF FTUF
QSJNFS QFSPEP 6O FOMBDF FOUSF CJPF
UJDJTUBTEFMBQSJNFSBHFOFSBDJOoDPNP
ZPoZMPTRVFBIPSBFTUOMMFWBOEPFTB
CBOEFSBFTMBQSFPDVQBDJODPNOQPS
MBJOnVFODJBEFVOBJOEVTUSJBBHSFTJWB
NFOUFDBQJUBMJTUBTPCSFMBQSPGFTJON
EJDB MBQSDUJDBEFMBNFEJDJOBZMBUJDB
QFSTPOBMEFMPTNEJDPT
4JO VO GVFSUF DPNQSPNJTP DPO FTUO
EBSFT UJDPT USBEJDJPOBMFT Z QSJODJQJPT
CJPUJDPTMBNFEJDJOBQJFSEFTVDBSDUFS
QSPGFTJPOBMZMPTNEJDPTTFQSFDJQJUBO
IBDJB MB DPOEJDJO EF FNQMFBEPT -B
NBOFSBNTSQJEBEFEFTUSVJSMBNFEJ
DJOBDPNPQSPGFTJOFTOPIBDFSDBTPP
SFEVDJS MB JNQPSUBODJB EF MB CJPUJDB Z
EFMBTPCMJHBDJPOFTUJDBTQSPGFTJPOBMFT
$BEBGBMUBUJDBFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJON

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EJDBPMBQSDUJDBDMOJDBJOWJUBBMDPOUSPM
FYUFSJPS ZDPOFYDFTJWPDPOUSPMFYUFSOP
MBQSPGFTJONEJDBEFTBQBSFDF

-BJOnVFODJBEFMBJOEVTUSJB
GBSNBDVUJDB
-BJOEVTUSJBGBSNBDVUJDBUJFOFDBEBEB
NTDPOUSPMEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJONEJDB
4VJOnVFODJBFTFOPSNFQBSBEFUFSNJOBS
RVESPHBTTPOBQSPCBEBT$VBOEPVOB
ESPHBFTUFOFMNFSDBEP MBJOEVTUSJBTF
NPWJMJ[BQBSBJOTUSVJSBMPTNEJDPT-B
JOTUSVDDJO IJTUSJDBNFOUFZQPSEFmOJ
DJOPGSFDJEBQPSMBVOJWFSTJEBEoZCBKP
FMDPOUSPMEFMBQSPGFTJOo FTUTJFOEP
HSBEVBMNFOUF SFBMJ[BEB QPS HJHBOUFTDBT
DPNQBBTGBSNBDVUJDBT-BFEVDBDJO
DPOUJOVBFTOFDFTBSJBQBSBDPOTFSWBSMB
DPNQFUFODJB QSPGFTJPOBM NEJDB -BT
SFVOJPOFT RVF QSPQPSDJPOBO DSEJUPT
EFGPSNBDJOQFSNBOFOUFQBSBNEJDPT
TPOPSHBOJ[BEBTDBEBWF[NTGSFDVFOUF
NFOUFQPSMBTDPNQBBTGBSNBDVUJDBT
&MMBTQVCMJDJUBO QBHBOMPTDPOGFSFODJT
UBTZFMJHFOMPTBTVOUPTRVFTFUSBUBSO
.VDIPT EF MPT DPOGFSFODJTUBT TPO FN
QMFBEPTEFMBTDPNQBBT-BFEVDBDJO
DPUJEJBOB PDVSSF FO MBT PmDJOBT EF MPT
NEJDPT  QSPQPSDJPOBEB QPS WFOEFEP
SFT EF DPNQBBT GBSNBDVUJDBT " MPT
FODBSHBEPTEFWFOUBTTFMFTFOTFBDNP
NBOJQVMBSBMPTNEJDPTNTRVFBQSP
QPSDJPOBSJOGPSNBDJPOFTDJFOUmDBT
&MTJTUFNBEFBQSPCBDJOEFNFEJDBDJP
OFT FTU JOnVFODJBEP QPS MB JOEVTUSJB
GBSNBDVUJDB Z QPSMPUBOUP MBNBZPSB
EFMBTOVFWBTESPHBTBQSPCBEBTOPTPO
OVFWBTUFSBQJBTTJOP BNFOVEP JNJUB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DJPOFT EF ESPHBT ZB EJTQPOJCMFT -PT


WFOEFEPSFT FOUSFHBO SFHBMPT B MPT N
EJDPT JOWJUBOBTVTGBNJMJBTBMBTDFOBT
ZPUSPTUJQPTEFEJWFSTJOBRVFMMPTRVF
SFDIB[BONBOJQVMBSFJOTJTUFOFOTFSIP
OFTUPT TPCSF MBT JOGPSNBDJPOFT RVF DP
NVOJDBO TPO  QSJNFSP  BNPOFTUBEPT 
EFTQVTTFMPTCBKBEFDBUFHPSBZ mOBM
NFOUF TFMPTFYPOFSB
6OB GPSNB EF FTDBQBS EF FTUF DPOUSPM
TFSB RVF MPT NEJDPT TF DFOUSFO FO MB
MJUFSBUVSB NEJDB FTUOEBS Z FO MBT JO
GPSNBDJPOFT EF MBT QSJODJQBMFT SFWJTUBT
NEJDBT1FSPJODMVTPFTBSFBEFMBFEV
DBDJO QSPGFTJPOBM OP FT JONVOF B JO
nVFODJBTEFMBJOEVTUSJB-BTDPNQBBT
FNQMFBOBQFSTPOBTQBSBFTDSJCJSBSUDV
MPT QBHBOBNEJDPTBDBENJDPTiQBSB
TFS BVUPSFTw Z FOWJBSMPT B MBT SFWJTUBT
QBSB QVCMJDBDJO &M QPSDFOUBKF EF BS
UDVMPT iNBOVGBDUVSBEPTw EJmFSF TFHO
MB SFWJTUB  QFSP FM IFDIP BUFTUJHVB VOB
NBOJQVMBDJO JODMVTP EF MB DJFODJB EF
MBNFEJDJOB-BTDPNQBBTGBSNBDVUJ
DBTQBHBOQBSBiGBCSJDBSwBSUDVMPT QBSB
JOnVFODJBS FM DPOUFOJEP EF QSPHSBNBT
FEVDBUJWPTZ mOBMNFOUF JOUFOUBOIBDFS
RVFTVTWFOEFEPSFTFOTFFOBNEJDPT
DNPQSBDUJDBSMBNFEJDJOBVTBOEPTVT
QSPEVDUPT
-BDVFTUJOEFMBFRVJEBEZMBKVTUJDJBFO
FMBDDFTPBMPTDVJEBEPTNEJDPTOFDFTJUB
FTQFDJBMBUFODJOFOMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPB
NFSJDBOB -PT QSFDJPT EF MPT NFEJDB
 "OHFMM .BSTIB 
F5SVUIBCPVU%SVH
$PNQBOJFT /: 3BOEPN)PVTF
 .F FOUSFWJTU DPO WFOEFEPSFT EF HSBOEFT mS
NBTGBSNBDVUJDBT RVJFOFTNFEJFSPOFWJEFO
DJBTQBSBQSPCBSMPRVFEJHP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

NFOUPTFYDMVZFOBNJMMPOFTEFQPCSFT
6OBFYQMJDBDJOQBSBFMDPTUPDBEBWF[
NBZPSEFNFEJDBDJPOFTQSFTDSJQUBTWJOP
EF VOB GVFOUF JOVTVBM FM EPDUPS 1FUFS
3PTU BOUJHVPWJDFQSFTJEFOUFEFDPNFS
DJBMJ[BDJOEF1m[FS&OUSFWJTUBEPQPS
VOQFSJPEJTUBEF57 FMEPDUPS3PTUTF
BMRVFMBTDPNQBBTTPOMBDBVTBEFM
DPOUJOVPBVNFOUPEFMPTQSFDJPTEFMBT
ESPHBT-BHFOUFMBTOFDFTJUBZTBDSJmDBS
DVBMRVJFS PUSB DPNQSB  JODMVTP EF BMJ
NFOUPT 4J MPT QBDJFOUFT TF FODVFOUSBO
EFTFTQFSBEPT QPS BGFSSBSTF B MB WJEB OP
TMP BHPUBSO BIPSSPT QPS VOB ESPHB
QSPWFDIPTB  TJOP RVF  QSPCBCMFNFOUF 
OPJSOBMPTUSJCVOBMFTBRVFKBSTF
-BKVTUJDJBTPDJBMFOMPTDVJEBEPTNEJ
DPT IJTUSJDBNFOUFVOGPDPEFBUFODJO
EF MPT UFMPHPT EF "NSJDB -BUJOB  FT
IPZVOBEFMBTNTJNQPSUBOUFTDVFTUJP
OFTFOCJPUJDB-BCJPUJDBTFQSFPDVQB
EFNVDIPTBTQFDUPTEFMBNFEJDJOBDPO
UFNQPSOFB  QFSP FM DPNQPSUBNJFOUP
EF MB JOEVTUSJB GBSNBDVUJDB OP QVFEF
TFSPMWJEBEP

$PODMVTJO
{2VJOQVFEFDFSDJPSBSTFEFRVFMBCJP
UJDBTJHBTJFOEPWJUBMBUSBWTEF"N
SJDB-BUJOB QSPUFHFSMBJOUFHSJEBEEFMPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFT NEJDPT  MB TPMJEF[ EF MB
DJFODJBNEJDB BMPTTVKFUPTEFJOWFTUJ
HBDJOZNBOUFOFSMBNFEJDJOBDFOUSBEB
FO MPT NT OFDFTJUBEPT  {2VJO QVFEF
BZVEBS B MPT NEJDPT B NBOUFOFS TVT
QSPNFTBTQCMJDBTZDFSDJPSBSTFEFRVF
MB FEVDBDJO NEJDB Z MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
 %S3PTU .JOVUFT +VOF





6OBIJTUPSJBQFSTPOBMEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB+BNFT%SBOF

DPOTFSWFO TV JOUFHSJEBE  " NFOPT RVF


MBT BTPDJBDJPOFT NEJDBT QSPGFTJPOB
MFT EFmFOEBO VOB DJFODJB NEJDB TMJ
EB  VOB JOWFTUJHBDJO UJDB TFHVSB  VOB
QSDUJDB DFOUSBEB FO FM QBDJFOUF Z KVT
UJDJBTPDJBMFOMPTTJTUFNBTEFDVJEBEPT
NEJDPT MBQSPGFTJONEJDBFTUBSFO
TFSJPQFMJHSP)BZHSBWFTEFTBGPTQBSBMB
CJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB
-PTMEFSFTEFMB014BDFQUBSPOMBSFT
QPOTBCJMJEBEEFMBTWJPMBDJPOFTUJDBTZ 
FOSFTQVFTUB PSHBOJ[BSPOVOQSPHSBNB
EJTFBEP QBSB USBFS MB EJTDJQMJOB EF MB
CJPUJDBB DBEB OBDJO FO "NSJDB -B

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UJOB Z FM $BSJCF $PO VOB DPOTJTUFOUF


PSJFOUBDJO  TF IBO QSPEVDJEP CVFOPT
FGFDUPT-BCJPUJDBEFCFDPOUJOVBSTJFO
EPFOTFBEBZBQMJDBEBFOUPEPTMPTOJ
WFMFTEFMBNFEJDJOBDPOUFNQPSOFB
&O VO DJFSUP NPNFOUP  MBT QFSTPOBT
RVF UVWJFSPO MB PQPSUVOJEBE EF JOJDJBS
MBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBTFUFOESO
RVFSFUJSBSZEFKBSFMUSBCBKPBPUSPT4JZP
EFTFNQFVOQBQFMBMQSJODJQJP BHSB
EF[DPBRVJFOFTNFEJFSPOFTBPQPSUVOJ
EBE2VJFOFTFTUBNPTFOCJPUJDBBTQJSB
NPTBNFUBTTJNJMBSFTZQBSUJDJQBNPTFO
VOBDPNVOJEBEBMSFEFEPSEFMNVOEP



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



1**
3FnFYJPOFTEFTEFWPDFTQJPOFSBTFOMPT
EJWFSTPTQBTFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





3FGFSFODJBTEFCJPUJDBFO"SHFOUJOB
+PT"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDB1SF[

*OUSPEVDDJO

&

TUB QSFTFOUBDJO EF JOTUJUVDJPOFT


CJPUJDBT BSHFOUJOBT OP QSFUFOEF
TFSFYIBVTUJWBTJOP UBOTMP JMVTUSBUJWB
EFMBDUVBMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBEJTDJQMJOBFO
FM QBT 4F QBTB SFWJTUB B MPT JOTUJUVUPT
BDBENJDPT DFOUSPT EF FTUVEJP  JOWFT
UJHBDJO Z EPDFODJB
 BTJTUFODJBMFT P EF
TFSWJDJP TPDJBM DPNJUT  DPNJTJPOFT Z
DPOTFKPTEFUJDB
ZEFQPMUJDBTQCMJDBT
MFHJTMBDJOZKVSJTQSVEFODJB


$FOUSPTEFFTUVEJP
" QBSUJS EF MPT QSJNFSPT BOUFDFEFOUFT
RVFDPOGPSNBOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJP
UJDB FO "SHFOUJOB  WBMF EFDJS FM *OTUJ
UVUP EF )VNBOJEBEFT .EJDBT EF MB
'VOEBDJO .BJOFUUJ Z TV DPOUJOVJEBE
FOMBDUFESBVOJWFSTJUBSJBIPNOJNB Z
MB&TDVFMB-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF#JPUJDB
&-"#&
TFIBFYUFOEJEPIPZFMDVMUJWP
EFMBEJTDJQMJOBQSDUJDBNFOUFBUPEPFM
QBT&OUSFMPTDFOUSPTEFFTUVEJPEJTUJO
 "HSBEFDFNPTMBJOGPSNBDJOBQPSUBEBQPS1F
ESP')PPGU +VBO$BSMPT5FBMEJZ&EVBSEP-
5JOBOU
 $UFESB EF 'JMPTPGB .EJDB  'BDVMUBE EF
$JFODJBT.EJDBT 6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF-B
1MBUB  mMPTPmBNFEJDB!BUMBTNFEVOMQFEVBS
IUUQXXXNFEVOMQFEVBS

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

HVJNPTMBTBTPDJBDJPOFTQSPGFTJPOBMFT MBT
DUFESBTVOJWFSTJUBSJBTZPUSPTJOTUJUVUPT
ZQSPHSBNBTMJTUBEPTBDPOUJOVBDJO

B
"TPDJBDJPOFTQSPGFTJPOBMFT
t
t
t
t
t

"DBEFNJB "SHFOUJOB EF UJDB FO


.FEJDJOB
"TPDJBDJO"SHFOUJOBEF#JPUJDB
"TPDJBDJO"SHFOUJOBEF*OWFTUJHB
DJPOFTUJDBT
#JP4VS "TPDJBDJOEF#JPUJDBZ
%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT #T"T

'FEFSBDJO-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF*OT
UJUVDJPOFTEF#JPUJDB '&-"*#&


C
$UFESBTVOJWFSTJUBSJBT
t
t

t

t

$UFESBEFUJDB#JPNEJDB 6OJ
WFSTJEBEEFM4BMWBEPS

$UFESB EF 'JMPTPGB .EJDB 'B
DVMUBE EF $JFODJBT .EJDBT  6OJ
WFSTJEBE /BDJPOBM EF -B 1MBUB 


$UFESBEF1PTUHSBEPEF)VNBOJ
EBEFT.EJDBT 'BDVMUBEEF$JFO
DJBT .EJDBT  6OJWFSTJEBE /BDJP
OBMEF-B1MBUB 

.BFTUSBFO#JPUJDBEFMB'BDVMUBE
EF.FEJDJOBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE/B
DJPOBMEF$VZP





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

t

t
t

t

t

t
t

.BFTUSBFO#JPUJDBEFMB'BDVMUBE
EF .FEJDJOB  6OJWFSTJEBE /BDJP
OBMEF$SEPCB
.BFTUSBFO#JPUJDBEFMB1POUJmDJB
6OJWFSTJEBE $BUMJDB "SHFOUJOB
.BFTUSB FO #JPUJDB +VSEJDB
'BDVMUBE EF $JFODJBT +VSEJDBT Z
4PDJBMFT  6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF
-B1MBUB

.BFTUSB FO UJDB "QMJDBEB DPO
PSJFOUBDJO FO #JPUJDB  'BDVMUBE
EF'JMPTPGB 6OJWFSTJEBEEF#VFOPT
"JSFT
.BFTUSB FO UJDB "QMJDBEB DPO
PSJFOUBDJO FO #JPUJDB  6OJWFSTJ
EBEEF-BOT
.BFTUSBFOUJDB#JPNEJDB 6OJ
WFSTJEBE$BUMJDB"SHFOUJOB
6OJEBE "DBENJDB EF #JPUJDB 
'BDVMUBE EF .FEJDJOB  6OJWFSTJ
EBEEF#VFOPT"JSFT

t
t

t
t

t
t

t

UBE EF $JFODJBT #JPNEJDBT  6OJ


WFSTJEBE"VTUSBM

*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDB 6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUMJDBEF-B1MBUB

*OTUJUVUP EF #JPUJDB 6OJWFSTJ
EBE EFM .VTFP 4PDJBM "SHFOUJOP
o6.4"

*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDBZ)VNBOJEB
EFT.EJDBT 'VOEBDJO.BJOFUUJ

*OTUJUVUP EF UJDB #JPNEJDB 'B
DVMUBE EF $JFODJBT EF MB 4BMVE 
1POUJmDJB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUMJDB
"SHFOUJOB #VFOPT"JSFT

1SPHSBNB EF #JPUJDB  'VOEBDJO
'SBUFSOJUBT 3PTBSJP 4BOUB'F
1SPHSBNB 5FNUJDP *OUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJPFO#JPUJDB 6OJWFSTJEBE/B
DJPOBMEF.BSEFM1MBUB

1SPZFDUP #JPUJDB 'BDVMUBE -BUJ
OPBNFSJDBOB EF $JFODJBT 4PDJBMFT 
'-"$40"SHFOUJOB


D
1SPHSBNBTFJOTUJUVUPT
t
t
t
t
t
t

t

t

$FOUSP $VZBOP EF &TUVEJPT


#JPUJDPT
$FOUSPEF#JPUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJ
EBE+VBO"HVTUO.B[B
$FOUSP EF #JPUJDB  6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUMJDBEF$SEPCB
$FOUSP EF &TUVEJPT #JPNEJDPT 
6OJWFSTJEBE$"&$& #VFOPT"JSFT
$FOUSP EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT #JPUJ
DBT 6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEFM4VS
$FOUSP EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT EF 'J
MPTPGB +VSEJDB Z 'JMPTPGB 4PDJBM 
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF3PTBSJP
$FOUSP EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT UJDBT
3J[JFSJ 'SPOEJ[J  6OJWFSTJEBE EF
-BOT
%FQBSUBNFOUPEF#JPUJDB 'BDVM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

$PNJUT DPNJTJPOFTZDPOTFKPT
EFUJDB
-B QSJNFSB OPUJDJB RVF TF UJFOF EF MPT
DPNJUTEFUJDBFO"SHFOUJOBFTBUSBWT
EFMBSUDVMPEF+PT"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJFO
2VJSO     QQ 
 i'JM
TPGPTBM)PTQJUBMMPTDPNJUTIPTQJUBMB
SJPTEFUJDBwTFHVJEPEFPUSPEF+VBO
$BSMPT 5FBMEJ Z +PT "MCFSUP .BJOFUUJ 
i)PTQJUBM &UIJDT $PNJUTw #VMMFUJO PG
1")0 QQ

&O FTUF MUJNP TF JEFOUJmDBSPO DJODP
DPNJUTEFUJDBFMEFM)PTQJUBMEF$M
OJDBTEF#VFOPT"JSFT FMEFM4FSWJDJPEF
/FPOBUPMPHB EFM )PTQJUBM *UBMJBOP EF
#VFOPT"JSFT FMEFM$FOUSP0ODPMHJDP





3FGFSFODJBTEFCJPUJDBFO"SHFOUJOB+PT"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDB1SF[

EF&YDFMFODJBEFMB'VOEBDJO.BJOFUUJ 
FMEFM)PTQJUBM&NJMJP$JWJUEF.FOEP[B
ZFMEFM)PTQJUBMEF&OGFSNFEBEFT*OGFD
DJPTBT'SBODJTDP.VJ[EFMB$JVEBEEF
#VFOPT"JSFT-B&TDVFMB-BUJOPBNFSJDB
OBEF#JPUJDBEFMB'VOEBDJO.BJOFUUJ
BTVNJ MB JOJDJBUJWB OP HVCFSOBNFOUBM
EFMB3FE3FHJPOBMEF$PNJUTEFUJDB

 DVZBT BDUJWJEBEFT DPOTPMJEBSPO
PCKFUJWPTEFDPPQFSBDJODPODPNJUTEF
CJPUJDBZFTQFDJBMJTUBTEFEJTUJOUPTQBTFT
EF "NSJDB -BUJOB )BTUB  MB 3FE
DPOU DPO FM BQPZP JOTUJUVDJPOBM EF MB
'VOEBDJO.BJOFUUJZ BQBSUJSEF 
TUFTFMPIBCSJOEBEPMBBTPDJBDJODJWJM
#JP4VSEF#JPUJDBZ%FSFDIPT)VNB
OPT4JCJFOOPFYJTUFIBTUBIPZ FO"S
HFOUJOB VOTJTUFNBOBDJPOBMEFSFWJTJO
UJDBEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJOCJPNEJDB VOB
OVFWBQSPQVFTUBTFHFOFSSFDJFOUFNFO
UF JNQVMTBEBQPS#JP4VS DPOMBDSFB
DJO EFM $POTFKP EF UJDB Z %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPT QBSB MBT *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT #JP
NEJDBT  FO MB 4FDSFUBSB EF %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPT EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF +VTUJDJB Z
%FSFDIPT )VNBOPT EF MB /BDJO 'J
OBMNFOUF FOMBEDBEBEFMTFDSFBSPO
USFT DPNJTJPOFT OBDJPOBMFT EF CJPUJDB 
VOB FO KVSJTEJDDJO EF MB 4FDSFUBSB EF
$JFODJBZ5DOJDBEFMB1SFTJEFODJBEFMB
/BDJOZEPTFOFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVE
/BDJPOBM QFSPUPEPTFMMPTGVFSPOJOUFO
UPTGSVTUSBEPT"DPOUJOVBDJO MJTUBNPT
SFGFSFODJBT BSHFOUJOBT TPCSF FM QSFTFO
UF SVCSP TFHO FM FTUVEJP &6-"#03
4JTUFNB EF 3FHVMBDJO UJDB EF MB *O
WFTUJHBDJO#JPNEJDBFO&VSPQBZ-B
UJOPBNSJDB &VMBCPS 81 "SHFOUJOB 
1
i3FWJTJOUJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJO
#JPNEJDBFO"SHFOUJOBw

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

t

t

t

t

t

t

t
t
t

t

t

t

(PCJFSOP EF MB DJVEBE EF #VFOPT


"JSFT 3FTPMVDJO 44 
DSFB'PSP"%)0$FO#JPUJDB
1SPWJODJB EF #VFOPT "JSFT -FZ
  TPCSF 1SPUFDDJO EF
1FSTPOBT RVF QBSUJDJQBO FO *OWFT
UJHBDJPOFT#JPNEJDBT
1SPWJODJB EF $BUBNBSDB -FZ
  TPCSF $SFBDJO EFM $P
NJUEFUJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJO
1SPWJODJBEF$IBDP-FZ 
TPCSF $POTFKP 1SPWJODJBM EF
#JPUJDB
1SPWJODJB EF +VKVZ -FZ  
TPCSF $POTFKP 1SPWJODJBM EF
#JPUJDB
1SPWJODJBEF3P/FHSP-FZ
 TPCSF3FHVMBDJOEFMB*OWFTUJ
HBDJO$MOJDB
1SPWJODJBEF3P/FHSP-FZ
 TPCSF%FSFDIPTEFMPT1BDJFOUFT
1SPWJODJBEF5VDVNO-FZ
 TPCSF%FSFDIPTEFMPT1BDJFOUFT
3FQCMJDB "SHFOUJOB  "ENJOJTUSB
DJO /BDJPOBM EF .FEJDBNFOUPT 
"MJNFOUPT Z 5FDOPMPHB  %JTQPTJ
DJOEF#VFOBT1SDUJDBT
EF 'BSNBDPMPHB EF *OWFTUJHBDJO
$MOJDB
3FQCMJDB "SHFOUJOB  %FDSFUP EFM
1PEFS &KFDVUJWP /BDJPOBM 
  DSFB MB $PNJTJO /BDJPOBM
EFUJDB#JPNEJDB
3FQCMJDB"SHFOUJOB -FZ
 1PEFS&KFDVUJWP/BDJPOBM DSFB
MPT$PNJUT)PTQJUBMBSJPTEFUJDB
3FQCMJDB "SHFOUJOB  -FZ 
3FHM "SU  $/
 TPCSF 1SP
UFDDJOEF%BUPT1FSTPOBMFTZ)B
CFBT%BUB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

t

3FQCMJDB "SHFOUJOB  .JOJTUFSJP


EF 4BMVE  %JTQPTJDJO  
i/PSNBTQBSBTPMJDJUBSBVUPSJ[BDJP
OFT QBSB SFBMJ[BS JOWFTUJHBDJO FO
'BSNBDPMPHB$MOJDBw

"$POWFODJPOFTTPCSF%FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTSFDFQUBEBTQPSMB
$POTUJUVDJO/BDJPOBM BSU
JODTZ SFG

t

1PMUJDBTQCMJDBT
&O"SHFOUJOBoDPNPFOUPEPFMNVOEP
Z QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF FO"NSJDB-BUJOBo
TFIBBCJFSUPIPZVOBBHFOEBQPMUJDBEF
BMUB TFOTJCJMJEBE NPSBM IBDJB MB SFWPMV
DJO CJPNEJDB Z TV NBOJQVMBDJO EF
MBWJEBFOHFOFSBMZEFMBWJEBIVNBOB
FOQBSUJDVMBS TPCSFUPEPIBDJBMBTOVF
WBT GPSNBT EF OBDFS  QSPDSFBS Z NPSJS
-PTUFNBTEFVOBUJDBEFMBWJEB ZTJTF
RVJFSFUBNCJOEFVOBWJEBEFMBUJDB

SFRVJFSFO EF GVOEBNFOUBDJO CJPUJDB
FOMBEFMJCFSBDJONPSBMQSPQJBEFVOB
TPDJFEBE DJWJM EFNPDSUJDB Z QMVSBMJTUB
3FHJTUSBNPT FO TFHVJEB BMHVOPT FKFN
QMPTEFMBQSPEVDDJOOPSNBUJWBFOMF
HJTMBDJOZKVSJTQSVEFODJBEFCJPQPMUJDB
BSHFOUJOBEVSBOUFMBMUJNBEDBEB

t

t

t

t

t

t

 1BSB FM QFSPEP   WBTF +PT "


.BJOFUUJ  (VTUBWP 1JT %JF[  +VBO $BSMPT 5F
BMEJ i#JPFUIJDTJO-BUJO"NFSJDBw 
#JPFUIJDT:FBSCPPL WPM 3FHJPOBM%F
WFMPQNFOUT JO #JPFUIJDT  ,MVXFS
"DBEFNJB 1VCMJTIFST   F /FUIFSMBOET
7BTF  UBNCJO  +VBO $BSMPT 5FBMEJ  (VTUBWP
1JT %JF[  BOE 0TDBS &TRVJ[BCFM i#JPFUIJDT JO
-BUJO"NFSJDBw #"OESFX-VTUJH
&E
 #JPFUIJDT :FBSCPPL 7PMVNFO   
  ,MVXFS "DBEFNJB 1VCMJTIFST  F
/FUIFSMBOET

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

%FDMBSBDJO6OJWFSTBMEF%FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTEFMBT/BDJPOFT6OJEBT
EF
%FDMBSBDJO"NFSJDBOBEFMPT%F
SFDIPT Z %FCFSFT EFM )PNCSF EF

$POWFODJO"NFSJDBOBTPCSF%F
SFDIPT)VNBOPTEFi1BDUP
EF4BO+PTEF$PTUB3JDBw BQSP
CBEBQPSMFZ

1BDUP *OUFSOBDJPOBM EF %FSFDIPT
&DPONJDPT 4PDJBMFTZ$VMUVSBMFT
Z 0CTFSWBDJO (FOFSBM 
EFM$PNJU1*%&4$i&MEFSFDIP
BMEJTGSVUFEFMNTBMUPOJWFMQPTJ
CMFEFTBMVEw

1BDUP *OUFSOBDJPOBM EF %FSFDIPT
$JWJMFT Z 1PMUJDPT Z TV 1SPUPDPMP
'BDVMUBUJWP -FZ

$POWFODJO*OUFSOBDJPOBMTPCSFMB
&MJNJOBDJO EF UPEBT MBT 'PSNBT
EF%JTDSJNJOBDJODPOUSBMB.VKFS
-FZ

$POWFODJO TPCSF MPT %FSFDIPT
EFM/JP -FZ
ZPUSBTDPO
WFODJPOFTTPCSFEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT
DPO KFSBSRVB DPOTUJUVDJPOBM BSU
 JODTZ ZDPODT $/


#0USBTOPSNBTMFHBMFTEF
"SHFOUJOB
t
t

#BODPEFEBUPTHFOUJDPT 

%FUFSNJOBDJOEFMNPNFOUPEFMB
NVFSUFEFMBQFSTPOB BSU
SFG EFDSFHM






3FGFSFODJBTEFCJPUJDBFO"SHFOUJOB+PT"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJZ.BSUB-VDB1SF[

t
t
t
t
t
t
t
t
t

t

&KFSDJDJPEFMBNFEJDJOBZBDUJWJEB
EFTEFDPMBCPSBDJO 

&NCBSB[PT JODPNQBUJCMFT DPO MB
WJEB  $"#"

&YQFSJNFOUBDJO DPO TFSFT IVNB
OPT  1#"
FUD
-FZ CTJDB EF 4BMVE EF MB $JVEBE
"VUOPNB#VFOPT"JSFT 

1SFWFODJOZMVDIBDPOUSBFM)*7
4*%" 

1SPHSBNB NEJDP PCMJHBUPSJP
1.0

3HJNFOEFUSBTQMBOUFTEFSHBOPT
ZNBUFSJBMBOBUNJDP 

4BMVETFYVBMZQSPDSFBDJOSFTQPO
TBCMF 

4JTUFNBEFQSFTUBDJPOFTCTJDBTEF
BUFODJOJOUFHSBMBGBWPSEFMBTQFS
TPOBTDPOEJTDBQBDJEBE 

4JTUFNB OBDJPOBM EF TFHVSP EF TB
MVE 


$4FOUFODJBTKVEJDJBMFT
SFMFWBOUFT
t
t

1SPOVODJBNJFOUPTEFMB$4+/ FTQ
FODBVTBTi#BIBNPOEF[w 

i#3&W1PMJDB'FEFSBM"SHFOUJ
OBw 


 $POTVMUBS QVCMJDBDJPOFT TMFZFT ZP KPSOBEBT


QSPWJODJBMFTFOMFHJTMBUVSBCPOBFSFOTF WHS EF
.BJOFUUJ +"Z5FBMEJ +$ i#JPUJDBFJOWFT
UJHBDJOFOTBMVEw Z)PPGU 1' i$PNFOUBSJP
BMB-FZw FE$NBSBEF%JQVUBEPT -B
1MBUB   JE i5SBOTHOJDPT #JPUFDOPMPHB
FOFMBHSPw FE$NBSBEF4FOBEPSFT -B1MBUB 



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

t
t
t
t

i$BNQPEOJDP EF #FWJBDRVBw




i54W(PC$JVEBEEF#T"TT
BOFODFGBMJBw 

i1PSUBMEF#FMOw 

i7[RVF['FSSw 


1VCMJDBDJPOFT
-B QSPEVDDJO BSHFOUJOB FO NBUFSJB
CJPUJDBFTDPOTJEFSBCMF FTUJNVMBEBQPS
FMCPPNEFMPTFTUVEJPTCJPUJDPTFOMB
FOTFBO[B TVQFSJPS  QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF
QPSQBSUFEFMBTGBDVMUBEFTNEJDB KV
SEJDB UFPMHJDBZmMPTmDB RVFTPOMPT
GPSPT EF NBZPS BUSBDDJO &M MBSHP DB
NJOPQSFQBSBUPSJPEFMBCJPUJDBDPOMBT
IVNBOJEBEFTNEJDBTFOMB'VOEBDJO
.BJOFUUJFTVOFKFNQMPEFQSPEVDDJO
CJCMJPHSmDB HSBDJBT B VOB MOFB FEJUP
SJBM JOTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUF TPTUFOJEB -B
SFWJTUB2VJSO DPOTVTWPMNFOFTB
MBGFDIB ZVOBTFSJFEFMJCSPTQPSFMNJT
NPTFMMP TPOQSFDMBSPTUFTUJNPOJPTEFM
QFOTBNJFOUPIVNBOJTUBFOMBNFEJDJOB
EFMBTFHVOEBNJUBEEFMTJHMPQBTBEP

 *HVBMNFOUF EFPUSPTUSJCVOBMFTZNBHJTUSBEPT
OBDJPOBMFTZQSPWJODJBMFT FTQGBMMPTiCJPUJDPTw
EFM KVF[ FO MP QFOBM EF .BS EFM 1MBUB 1FESP
'FEFSJDP)PPGU BQBSUJSEFMBP 3FWJT
UBT&M%FSFDIP -B-FZ -B-FZ#VFOPT"JSFT 
-FYJT /FYPT+VSJTQSVEFODJB "SHFOUJOB
 %F
JHVBMNPEP DPOTVMUBS+VSJTQSVEFODJB&YUSBOKF
SB FTQGBMMPTEFUSJCVOBMFTOPSUFBNFSJDBOPTFO
NBUFSJBEFEFSFDIPBMBWJEB FTUBEPWFHFUBUJWP 
JOUFSSVQDJOEFUSBUBNJFOUPTEFTPQPSUFWJUBMZ
FVUBOBTJB




PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





-BCJPUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT
+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP

1SFDVSTPSFTZBOUFDFEFOUFT
JOJDJBMFT

PIBZSFHJTUSPEFBDUJWJEBECJPUJDB
FO #PMJWJB TJOP B QBSUJS EF  
DVBOEPFMTBDFSEPUFKFTVJUB.JHVFM.BO
[BOFSB QSPQPOF B MBT BVUPSJEBEFT EF MB
6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDB#PMJWJBOB 6$#

MBDSFBDJOEFVO$FOUSPEF#JPUJDB
$BTJFOMBNJTNBQPDB +PT.BSB"M
WBSBEP
 -VJT )VSUBEP (NF[

+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDPZBMHVOPTPUSPT TF
JOUFSFTBOQPSMBTJHOJmDBDJOZBMDBODFT
EFMBCJPUJDBDMOJDB BMFMBCPSBSMPTQSJ
NFSPTCPSSBEPSFTEFMB-FZEFM&KFSDJDJP
1SPGFTJPOBM .EJDP  DPNP VOB OFDF
TJEBE QBSB MB QSFWFODJO EF MB MMBNBEB
iNBMB QSDUJDB QSPGFTJPOBMw  RVF DP
NJFO[BBQSFPDVQBSQPSMBQSFTFOUBDJO
DBEBWF[NTGSFDVFOUFEFDBTPT
0USPBOUFDFEFOUFEFBQSPYJNBDJOBMB
CJPUJDB ZFTUBWF[FTUBUBM TFEBFOTFQ
UJFNCSFEFDVBOEP BQSPQTJUPEFM
FTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFM1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBM
EF #JPUJDB 13#
 EF MB 0SHBOJ[BDJO
1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE0140.4FO
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMFoDPNPSFTVMUBEPEFMB
MOFBQSPHSBNUJDB)#&1SPNPDJOEF
MB#JPUJDBEFMB014o MB4FDSFUBSBEF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

4BMVEEFMHPCJFSOPCPMJWJBOPSFDJCJMB
EPDVNFOUBDJO QFSUJOFOUF  TPMJDJUBOEP
NJ BTFTPSBNJFOUP QBSB JOUFSQSFUBSMB Z
FNJUJSVOBPQJOJOTPCSFMBBQSPCBDJO
EFM1SPHSBNBRVFTFEBSBBDPOPDFSFO
MB 9997** 3FVOJO EFM $POTFKP %J
SFDUJWPEFMB0140.4 DPOWPDBEBFO
8BTIJOHUPOQBSBmOFTEFTFQUJFNCSFEF
FTFBP$VNQMFMFODBSHP NB
OJGFTUBOEPFOFTBPQPSUVOJEBERVFiQPS
MB JNQPSUBODJB RVF SFWJTUF MB DSFBDJO
EFM13# DPOVOBUSBTDFOEFODJBRVFTV
QFSBMPNFSBNFOUFTFDUPSJBM SFGFSJEPB
DBQBDJUBSPEJGVOEJSMBTQPUFODJBMJEBEFT
EFM DPOPDJNJFOUP Z NBOFKP DPUJEJBOP
EF MB CJPUJDB  OP TPMBNFOUF FOUSF MPT
SFDVSTPT IVNBOPT EF TBMVE  TJOP NT
CJFOHFOFSBMJ[BSMPTBMBQPCMBDJOFOTV
DPOKVOUP  TF DPOTJEFSB BMUBNFOUF SFDP
NFOEBCMFBQPZBSDPNPQBTMBJOJDJBUJWB
EF MB 0140.4 Z MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF
$IJMF QBSB QPOFSMP FO QSDUJDB  MP RVF
SFEVOEBSFOVOFOPSNFCFOFmDJPQBSB
MPTQBTFTEFMBSFHJOZ FOQBSUJDVMBS 
QBSB #PMJWJB  EPOEF TF UJFOF FTDBTB FY
QFSJFODJB TPCSF FM UFNB EF CJPUJDBw
3FDPNFOEBCB BEFNT RVFFM13# EF
OVFWBDSFBDJO BQMJDBTFNUPEPTFJOT
USVNFOUPTEFFOTFBO[BPDBQBDJUBDJO
VOJGPSNFT P  BM NFOPT  TJNJMBSFT QBSB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

UPEPT FTUPT QBTFT  DPO FM mO EF GBDJMJ


UBSFMJOUFSDBNCJPEFFYQFSJFODJBTZEF
DPPQFSBDJOUDOJDB EFTUBDBOEPMBVUJ
MJEBE RVF UFOESB MB FMBCPSBDJO EF VO
%JDDJPOBSJP EF #JPUJDB  VO WFSEBEFSP
JOTUSVNFOUP EF USBCBKP Z DPOTVMUB 'J
OBMNFOUF  NJ EPDVNFOUP QSPQPOB
SFRVFSJS BM 13# BTFTPSBNJFOUP QBSB MB
PSHBOJ[BDJOEFM*OTUJUVUP#PMJWJBOPEF
#JPUJDBDBQBDJUBSBVOQSJNFSHSVQPEF
SFDVSTPT IVNBOPT TFMFDDJPOBEPT FO FM
QBT EFBDVFSEPDPOVOTJTUFNBRVFQP
ESBTFSBDPSEBEPFOUSFMB4FDSFUBSBEF
4BMVE MB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDB#PMJWJB
OBZFM$PMFHJP.EJDPBTFTPSBNJFOUP
QBSBFTUBCMFDFSMPTDPNJUTEFUJDBDMOJ
DBZEFSFWJTJOEFJOWFTUJHBDJOCJPN
EJDB ZSFNJTJOEFVOMPUFCTJDPJOJDJBM
EFJOGPSNBDJOCJPUJDB
-BNFOUBCMFNFOUF  UPEBT BRVFMMBT SF
DPNFOEBDJPOFT OP GVFSPO UPNBEBT
FO DVFOUB IBTUB FM BP   DVBOEP 
DPJODJEFOUFNFOUF  MB 0mDJOB EF 3FMB
DJPOFT *OUFSOBDJPOBMFT EFM .JOJTUFSJP
EF4BMVEZ1SFWJTJO4PDJBM .414
EF
#PMJWJBNFQJEFJOUFSQSFUBSFMEPDVNFO
UP $%  EF MB 014 i&WBMVBDJO
EFM 1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPUJDBw 
DPOTUBUOEPTF RVF  EF  BDUJWJEBEFT
RVF IBCSBBQPZBEP FM 13#FO MPTTFJT
BPT USBOTDVSSJEPT oFOUSF TFNJOBSJPT 
UBMMFSFT  DPOGFSFODJBT Z DVSTPT EFTEF TV
FTUBCMFDJNJFOUPo  FM  TF SFBMJ[BSPO
FO $IJMF  TFHVJEP QPS .YJDP  $FOUSP
"NSJDB $BSJCF-BUJOP PUSPTQBTFTEF
4VEBNSJDB F  JODMVTP  /PSUFBNSJDB 
&VSPQB Z $BSJCF *OHMT  QFSP OJOHVOB
FO #PMJWJB &TUB TJUVBDJO GVF NBOJGFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UBEBBOUFMBSFQSFTFOUBDJOEFMB014
0.4FO#PMJWJBZNPUJWMBPSHBOJ[B
DJOEFVOHSVQPEFUSBCBKPJOUFHSBEP
QPS SFQSFTFOUBOUFT EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF
4BMVE Z 1SFWJTJO 4PDJBM  EFM 7JDFNJ
OJTUFSJP EF &EVDBDJO 4VQFSJPS  $JFO
DJB Z 5FDOPMPHB  EF MB 0140.4 FO
#PMJWJB  EF MB "DBEFNJB #PMJWJBOB EF
.FEJDJOB  EF MB "TBNCMFB 1FSNBOFO
UFEF%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT EFM$PMFHJP
.EJDP%FQBSUBNFOUBMEF-B1B[ZEF
MB 'BDVMUBE EF .FEJDJOB EF MB 6OJWFS
TJEBE .BZPS EF 4BO "OEST 6.4"

EF-B1B[ RVJFOFT FMEFTFQUJFNCSF
EF TVTDSJCFOFM"DUBEF$POGPS
NBDJOEFM$PNJU*NQVMTPSEFUJDBZ
#JPUJDBFO#PMJWJB QBSBDPOTUJUVJSVOB
JOTUJUVDJOEFBTFTPSB QSPNPDJO GPS
NBDJO JOWFTUJHBDJOZWJHJMBODJBEFMPT
QSJODJQJPTEFUJDBZCJPUJDB RVFEFTB
SSPMMF Z HFOFSF DVMUVSB JOTUJUVDJPOBM FO
FMTFDUPSTBMVE DPOFMmOEFDPOUSJCVJSB
MBMFHJTMBDJOFOFMNBSDPEFMEFTBSSPMMP
IVNBOPDPOFRVJEBEZKVTUJDJBTPDJBMFT
&OMBPQPSUVOJEBENFOPNCSBODPPSEJ
OBEPSEFEJDIP$PNJU

$POUFYUPJOTUJUVDJPOBMEFMB
CJPUJDBFO#PMJWJB
$BCF EFTDSJCJS DPO NBZPS EFUBMMF MPT
QSJODJQBMFT QSPQTJUPT Z PSJFOUBDJPOFT 
BT DPNP MB PSHBOJ[BDJO Z BDUJWJEBEFT
EFM$PNJU/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB $/#

EFM*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDB *#
EFMB6OJ
WFSTJEBE$BUMJDB#PMJWJBOBEFMBDJVEBE
EF$PDIBCBNCBZEFMB"TPDJBDJO#P
MJWJBOBEF#JPUJDB %FSFDIP(FOUJDPZ
#JPUFDOPMPHB "#*0%(&






-BCJPUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP

$PNJU/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB
"OUFDFEFOUFT
/BDJDPNP$PNJU*NQVMTPSEFUJDB
Z#JPUJDB $*&#
FMEFTFQUJFNCSFEF
  NFEJBOUF BDUB EF DPOGPSNBDJO
mSNBEBQPSSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFM.JOJTUF
SJPEF4BMVE EFM.JOJTUFSJPEF&EVDB
DJO EFMB0140.4 EFMB"TBNCMFB
1FSNBOFOUFEF%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT EF
MB"DBEFNJB#PMJWJBOBEF.FEJDJOB EFM
$PMFHJP.EJDPZEFMB6.4"&M$*&#
HP[B EFM SFDPOPDJNJFOUP JOUFSOBDJPOBM
EFM13#EFMB0140.4 BTDPNPEF
MB'FEFSBDJO-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF*OTUJ
UVDJPOFTEF#JPUJDB '&-"*#&
EFMB
3FE -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z EFM $BSJCF EF
#JPUJDBZEFM$PNJU*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF
#JPUJDB $*#
EFMB0SHBOJ[BDJOEFMBT
/BDJPOFT6OJEBTQBSBMB&EVDBDJO MB
$JFODJBZMB$VMUVSB 6/&4$0

4VTBDDJPOFTFTUOPSJFOUBEBTBVOBCJP
UJDBIVNBOBPNJDSPCJPUJDB ZBVOB
FDPMHJDB P NBDSPCJPUJDB  B USBWT EF
USFT MOFBT QSJODJQBMFT DPOEVDJEBT QPS
MBT DPNJTJPOFT EF $BQBDJUBDJO  *OWFT
UJHBDJOZ1SPZFDDJOBMB$PNVOJEBE 
SFTQFDUJWBNFOUF

"DUJWJEBEFT
 1PDP BOUFT EF DPOTUJUVJSTF FM $*&# 
FMHSVQPRVFMFEJPPSJHFOPSHBOJ[VO
$VSTPEF#JPUJDBJNQBSUJEPQPSMBCJP
FUJDJTUB FTQBPMB *TPMJOB 3JBP (BMO 
EFMBMEFBHPTUPEF
&OOPWJFNCSFEFMMFWBDBCP
VO4FNJOBSJPEF&OTFBO[BEF#JPUJDB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DPNPMBQSJNFSBBDUJWJEBEEFM13#FO
#PMJWJB ZCBKPMPTBVTQJDJPTEFMB3FQSF
TFOUBDJOEFMB0140.4FOFTUFQBT 
DPOUBOEP BEFNT DPOVOB3FTPMVDJO
.JOJTUFSJBMFNJUJEBQPSFM.JOJTUFSJPEF
4BMVEZ1SFWJTJO4PDJBM .414

 &O DPBVTQJDJP DPO FM *OUFSOBUJPOBM
$PMMFHF PG 4VSHFPOT  4FDDJO #PMJWJB  MB
0140.4ZMB"DBEFNJB#PMJWJBOBEF
.FEJDJOB  FM $*&# PSHBOJ[  FOUSF 
ZFMEFBCSJMEF FM4FNJOBSJP
#JPUJDB.EJDB QBSUJDJQBOEPDPNPJO
WJUBEPQSJODJQBM(BCSJFM%&NQBJSF EF
7FOF[VFMB
6OBPEFTQVTEFTVDSFBDJO SFBMJ
[FOMBDJVEBEEF-B1B[ FOUSFBM
EFTFQUJFNCSFEF FM1SJNFS$PO
HSFTP#PMJWJBOPEF#JPUJDB&OMBPQPS
UVOJEBE  TF DPOU DPO MB QBSUJDJQBDJO
EFMQSFTJEFOUFEFMB'&-"*#& &EVBSEP
4PVTB-FOOPY 1BOBN
ZMPTJOWJUBEPT
JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT7PMOFJ(BSSBGB #SBTJM

4FSHJP$FDIFUUP "SHFOUJOB
Z3PCFSUP
.BODJOJ EFM 13# $IJMF
 BEFNT EFM
3FQSFTFOUBOUFEFMB0140.4FO#P
MJWJB+PT"OUPOJP1BHT
 %VSBOUF MB SFBMJ[BDJO EFM 1SJNFS
$POHSFTP#PMJWJBOPEF#JPUJDBTFJOT
UBMBSPOMPTDPNJUTEFQBSUBNFOUBMFTEF
CJPUJDB  DPO FOUSFHB EF EPDVNFOUPT
Z NBUFSJBMFT CTJDPT BQPSUBEPT BMHVOPT
EFFMMPTQPSFM13#BUSBWTEF3PCFSUP
.BODJOJ
&OFTBNJTNBPQPSUVOJEBETFFNJUJ
MBi%FDMBSBDJOEF-B1B[w DPNQSPNF
UJFOEPBMPTDPNJUTEFQBSUBNFOUBMFTB
MBEJGVTJOEFMBCJPUJDBBUSBWTEFMPT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

TJHVJFOUFTDPNQPOFOUFTUJDBBGBWPSEF
MBWJEBCJPUJDBDPOJEFOUJEBECBTBEBFO
FMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFTFSFTIVNBOPTDPO
JHVBMFTEFSFDIPTCTRVFEBEFMCJFO MB
KVTUJDJB Z MB QSFWFODJO EFM EBP FO FM
EFTFNQFPTPDJBM JOTUJUVDJPOBM DJFOU
mDP QPMUJDPZQSPGFTJPOBMQSDUJDBN
EJDBDPNQSPNFUJEBDPOMBCJPUJDBZFM
CJFOFTUBS IVNBOP JOUFHSBM QSPUFDDJO
EFMFOUPSOPOBUVSBMZMBCJPEJWFSTJEBE
&OUSFmOFTEFPDUVCSFZQSJODJQJPTEF
OPWJFNCSFEF FM$*&#PSHBOJ[FM
DVSTPiUJDBFOMB*OWFTUJHBDJOZ#VF
OBT 1SDUJDBT $MOJDBTw  FO DPBVTQJDJP
DPO FM $PMFHJP .EJDP %FQBSUBNFOUBM
EF-B1B[ZDPOUBOEPDPO+BJNF4PUPZ
+VMJB5PMFEP $PMPNCJB
DPNPQSPGFTP
SFTJOWJUBEPT
$POFMBVTQJDJPEFM.414 MB&NCB
KBEBEF'SBODJBFO#PMJWJB FM*OTUJUVUP
#PMJWJBOPEF#JPMPHBEFMB"MUVSBZMB
'BDVMUBE EF .FEJDJOB EF MB 6.4"  FM
$*&# MMFW B DBCP FM TFNJOBSJP iUJDB
FO MB *OWFTUJHBDJO #JPNEJDB FO )V
NBOPTw MPTEBT ZEFNBS[P
EF   DPO MB QBSUJDJQBDJO EF -BV
SB3VFEBZ3PCFSUP.BODJOJEFM13# 
$IJMF
%FMBMEFBHPTUPEFMTFSFB
MJ[ FO $PDIBCBNCB FM 4FHVOEP $PO
HSFTP#PMJWJBOPEF#JPUJDBRVF DPOFM
BQPZPEFMB0140.4 GVFPSHBOJ[BEP
QPSFM$/#FODPSSFTQPOEFODJBDPOMB
6OJWFSTJEBE.BZPSEF4BO4JNO'VF
QSFTJEJEP QPS FM EJSFDUPS EFM *# EF MB
6OJWFSTJEBE $BUMJDB EF $PDIBCBNCB 
.JHVFM.BO[BOFSB ZDPOUDPOMBQBS
UJDJQBDJOEF+PT"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJ 1F

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

ESP')PU 4FSHJP$FDIFUUPZ1BUSJDJB
6SCBOE EF"SHFOUJOB 0TWBMEP$IWF[ 
EF7FOF[VFMB Z3BJNVOEP3JODO EF
&TQBB
 %VSBOUF   FM $/# FGFDUV
VO 'PSP "CJFSUP EF 1PMUJDBT EF 4BMVE
NFEJBOUF EJF[ TFNJOBSJPT -FHJTMBDJO
Z 0SHBOJ[BDJO 4BOJUBSJB .BSDP EF
$PNQFUFODJBT*OTUJUVDJPOBMFTZ(FTUJO
FO4BMVEDPO1BSUJDJQBDJO$JVEBEBOB
/JWFMFT EF "UFODJO Z &TUSVDUVSBDJO
6SCBOP3VSBM EF MBT 3FEFT EF 4FSWJ
DJP3FHVMBDJPOFTQBSBMB$POTUSVDDJO
Z &RVJQBNJFOUP EFM 4FDUPS 4BMVE FO
1SPDVSB EF VOB .BZPS $PCFSUVSB FO
"UFODJO 1SJNBSJB 1PMUJDBT EF 3FDVS
TPT)VNBOPTFO4BMVE4VTUFOUBCJMJEBE
'JOBODJFSB EFM 4FDUPS 4BMVE "DDFTP
6OJWFSTBMEF4BMVEZ+VTUJDJB4BOJUBSJB
1PMUJDBT EF .FEJDBNFOUPT F *OTVNPT
.EJDPT1SFTFSWBDJOZ#FOFmDJPEFMB
1FSTPOBFOFM1SPDFTPEF*OWFTUJHBDJO
Z %FTBSSPMMP 5FDOPDJFOUmDP #BTFT EF
VOB 1SPQVFTUB 'JOBM QBSB VOB /VFWB
1PMUJDBEF&TUBEPFOFM4FDUPS4BMVE
&OTFQUJFNCSFEF 4VTBOB7J
EBM DPPSEJOBEPSBEF#JPUJDBEFM.JOJT
UFSJPEF4BMVEFO$SEPCB "SHFOUJOB 
EFTBSSPMMFM$JDMPEF$POGFSFODJBT5B
MMFSi#JPUJDB$MOJDBZ0SHBOJ[BDJOEF
MPT$PNJUT)PTQJUBMBSJPTEF#JPUJDBw
 -PT EBT  Z  EF OPWJFNCSF EF
 FM$/#SFBMJ[FM$VSTPEF*OUSP
EVDDJO B MB #JPUJDB  PSHBOJ[BEP KVO
UBNFOUF DPO 7PMHB *HVF[  EJSFDUPSB
EFM *OTUJUVUP EF #JPMPHB .PMFDVMBS EF
MB6.4"&MDVSTPDPOUDPOMBTFYQP
TJDJPOFTEF.BSUIB1BDIFDP 3VUI(VJ





-BCJPUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP

MMOEF.BMEPOBEP #FBUSJ[.POUPZBZ
&NNB"QBSJDJP FOUBOUPRVFMBNPEF
SBDJOFTUVWPBDBSHPEF7JPMFUB"SBHO
Z%BZTJ(VUJSSF[ UPEBTJOUFHSBOUFTEFM
$/# $BTJ TJNVMUOFBNFOUF  FM DPPS
EJOBEPS EFM $/# EFTBSSPMM FM NJTNP
DVSTP QBSB QFSTPOFSPT EFM *OTUJUVUP EF
#JPMPHB.PMFDVMBSEFMB6.4" FOUSF
FMZFMEFOPWJFNCSFEF

FO #PMJWJB 'FEFSBDJO %FQBSUBNFOUBM


EF 1SPGFTJPOBMFT EF -B 1B[ 3FTJEFODJB
EFM)PTQJUBM0CSFSPEFMB$/44PDJF
EBE #PMJWJBOB EF 6SPMPHB 4PDJFEBE
#PMJWJBOB EF .FEJDJOB *OUFSOB 4PDJF
EBE.EJDBEF$POTVMUB1SJWBEB 40
.&$01
 Z "TPDJBDJO #PMJWJBOB EF
#JPUJDBZ%FSFDIP(FOUJDPZ#JPUFD
OPMPHB "#*0%(&


&OIPNFOBKFBMBNFNPSJBEFVOP
EFMPTQSJODJQBMFTQSPQVMTPSFTEFMB#JP
UJDBFO#PMJWJB -VJT)VSUBEP(NF[ 
EFMBMEFPDUVCSFEFTFFGFD
UVFO-B1B[FM5FSDFS$POHSFTP#PMJ
WJBOPEF#JPUJDBDPOFMUFNBi#JPUJDB
Z 1MVSBMJEBEw  PSHBOJ[BEP QPS FM $/#
DPOMBDPMBCPSBDJOEFMB6/&4$0EF
.YJDP  MB 3FE -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z EFM
$BSJCF EF #JPUJDB Z MB 0140.4 FO
#PMJWJB &O FTB PQPSUVOJEBE QBSUJDJ
QBSPO MB EJSFDUPSB EF MB 6/&4$0 FO
.YJDP "MZB4BBEB ZFMQSFTJEFOUFEF
MB 3FE -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z EFM $BSJCF
EF#JPUJDB BEFNTEF7PMOFJ(BSSBGB
#SBTJM
 +VBO $BSMPT 5FBMEJ "SHFOUJ
OB
+PT&EVBSEPEF4JRVJFSB #SBTJM
Z
4VTBOB7JEBM "SHFOUJOB

&OUSF FTUBT SFVOJPOFT  GVF QBSUJDVMBS


NFOUFJNQPSUBOUFFM4FNJOBSJP3FHJP
OBM TPCSF #JPUJDB PSHBOJ[BEP QPS FM
.JOJTUFSJP EF +VTUJDJB Z %FSFDIPT )V
NBOPTEF"SHFOUJOBRVF QPSJORVJFUVE
EF+VBO$BSMPT5FBMEJ TFPSHBOJ[FOMB
DJVEBEEF#VFOPT"JSFT FOUSFFMZFM
EFOPWJFNCSFEF QBSBFMBOMJTJT
EFVOUFSDFSFTCP[PEFUFYUPQSFQBSBEP
QPSFMHSVQPEFSFEBDDJOEFMB6/&4
$0 FO UPSOP B VOB %FDMBSBDJO 6OJ
WFSTBM EF #JPUJDB &O MB PQPSUVOJEBE 
MBSFQSFTFOUBDJOCPMJWJBOBFYQVTPVOB
QPOFODJBDPODSFUB DPNPFMSFTUPEFMPT
QBTFTJOWJUBEPT DPOJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFTZ
DPNFOUBSJPTBEJDIPCPSSBEPS EFKBOEP
FODMBSPRVFTUFSFQSFTFOUBCBNTFMJO
UFSTEFM1SJNFS.VOEPFOFMEFTBSSPMMP
UFDOPMHJDPZDJFOUmDPRVFMBJOUFODJO
EFSFTPMWFSMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFQPCSF[B 
FOGFSNFEBE IBNCSFZNJTFSJBRVF QPS
MBJOKVTUJDJBTPDJBMZFDPONJDB HPMQFB
EVSBNFOUF B VO HSBO QPSDFOUBKF EF MB
QPCMBDJOEFOVFTUSPTQBTFT

-PTJOUFHSBOUFTEF$/#QBSUJDJQB
SPO Z QBSUJDJQBO DPNP DPOGFSFODJTUBT
FO DVSTPT  DJDMPT EF DPOGFSFODJBT Z EJ
QMPNBEPTPSHBOJ[BEPTQPSEJWFSTBTJOT
UJUVDJPOFT  FOUSF MBT RVF TF NFODJPOBO
MBTVOJWFSTJEBEFT.BZPSEF4BO"OEST 
/VFTUSB4FPSBEF-B1B[Z%FM7BMMF
$PMFHJP .EJDP %FQBSUBNFOUBM EF -B
1B[$PMFHJPEF#JPRVNJDBZ'BSNBDJB
EF#PMJWJB$PNJTJO&QJTDPQBM1BTUPSBM
4PDJBM3FQSFTFOUBDJOEFMB0140.4

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

1PTUFSJPSNFOUF FM$/#FOWJBM.JOJT
UFSJP EF 3FMBDJPOFT &YUFSJPSFT Z $VMUP
EF#PMJWJBVOJOGPSNFDPNQMFUPEFMTF
NJOBSJP SFBMJ[BEP FO "SHFOUJOB  KVOUP
DPO UPEBT MBT NPEJmDBDJPOFT RVF TF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DPOTJEFSBSPO DPOWFOJFOUFT BM CPSSBEPS


EF MB %FDMBSBDJO EF MB 6/&4$0  MBT
DVBMFT FO CVFOB NFEJEB JODPSQPSBO MB
QPTJDJOSFJWJOEJDBUPSJBEFMUFNBTPDJBM
ZFDPMHJDPRVFQSFPDVQBBMPTQBTFTEFM
5FSDFS.VOEP FYQSFTBEBFOMB$BSUBEF
#VFOPT"JSFT
0USBT SFVOJPOFT EFTUBDBCMFT GVFSPO FM
TJNQPTJP PSHBOJ[BEP FO .POUFWJEFP 
FO QBSBDPOTJEFSBSUFNBTSFMBDJP
OBEPT DPO FM &TUBUVUP &QJTUFNPMHJDP
EF#JPUJDB RVFEJPPSJHFOBVOBQVCMJ
DBDJOEFMNJTNPOPNCSF FEJUBEBQPS
MB6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBM"VUOPNBEF
.YJDP 6/".
ZMB6/&4$0 ZFM
TJNQPTJP TPCSF *OWFTUJHBDJO FO 4FSFT
)VNBOPTZ1PMUJDBTEF4BMVE1CMJDB 
RVFTFMMFWBDBCPFO#PHPUFOUSFFM
ZFMEFNBZPEF
 %FM BM  EFKVOJP EF FM
$/#PSHBOJ[VODJDMPEFDPOGFSFODJBT
ZUBMMFSFTTPCSFQPMUJDBTEFTBMVE UJDB
FOMBJOWFTUJHBDJOZCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNF
SJDBOB BQSPQTJUPEFMBWJTJUBB#PMJWJB
EF%BOJFM1JFESB)FSSFSB EF$VCB
6OBEFMBTQSJODJQBMFTZQFSNBOFO
UFTBDUJWJEBEFTEFM$/# BUSBWTEFTV
$PNJTJOEF*OWFTUJHBDJO
FTMBWBMJEB
DJO UJDB EF USBCBKPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJO
FOWJBEPTQPSEJWFSTBTJOTUJUVDJPOFT FO
USFMBTRVFTFDVFOUBOFM.414 MB014 
JOTUJUVUPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJO  TPDJFEBEFT
DJFOUmDBT 0/(TFJOWFTUJHBEPSFTQBS
UJDVMBSFT
&OMBHFTUJOTFIBJOUFOTJm
DBEPMBMBCPSEFMB$PNJTJOEF1SPZFD
DJOBMB$PNVOJEBE DPOMBFNJTJOEF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

VO QSPHSBNB SBEJBM TFNBOBM RVF QSP


NVFWF VO BDFSDBNJFOUP TFODJMMP EF MB
CJPUJDBBMBQPCMBDJOFOHFOFSBM
0USBHSBONPUJWBDJOEFM$/#FTMB
EFQSPNPWFSMBJODPSQPSBDJOEFMBCJP
UJDBZMBTIVNBOJEBEFTNEJDBTFOMPT
QSPHSBNBT DVSSJDVMBSFT EF MBT DBSSFSBT
QSPGFTJPOBMFTEFTBMVEZEFDJFODJBTTP
DJBMFT&OUBMTFOUJEP TFMPHSVOCVFO
BWBODFFOEJDJFNCSFEFDPOMBSFB
MJ[BDJOEFVOUBMMFSEFMBTDVBUSPGBDVM
UBEFT EF NFEJDJOB EF MBT VOJWFSTJEBEFT
FTUBUBMFTNTJNQPSUBOUFTEFMQBT FOFM
DVBMQBSUJDJQBDUJWBNFOUFMBDPPSEJOB
DJO EFM $/# DPNP OJDB JOTUJUVDJO
JOWJUBEB &O EJDIP UBMMFS TF BDPSE FM
FTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFVOBVOJEBEPEFQBS
UBNFOUPFOMBFTUSVDUVSBGBDVMUBUJWB RVF
EJGVOEBMBFOTFBO[BEFMBUJDB.EJ
DB  #JPUJDB Z )VNBOJEBEFT .EJDBT
EFNBOFSBIPSJ[POUBMFOMBTDBSSFSBTEF
TBMVE ZDPOMBSFTQFDUJWBBEFDVBDJOB
MPT SFRVFSJNJFOUPT EF MBT DUFESBT "D
UVBMNFOUF  FM DPPSEJOBEPS EFM $/#
EJDUB MBT OJDBT DUFESBT EF QSFHSBEP
FYJTUFOUFT FO FM QBT RVF DPSSFTQPOEFO
B)JTUPSJBEFMB.FEJDJOB 6OJWFSTJEBE
/VFTUSB4FPSBEF-B1B[
UJDBZ4P
DJPMPHB .EJDB 6OJWFSTJEBE 1SJWBEB
'SBO[5BNBZP


3FMBDJPOFTJOUFSJOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
&OUSFMBTSFMBDJPOFTOBDJPOBMFTNTJN
QPSUBOUFT  DBCF EFTUBDBS MBT TPTUFOJEBT
DPO MPT NJOJTUFSJPT EF 4BMVE  &EVDB
DJO  +VTUJDJB Z 3FMBDJPOFT &YUFSJPSFT 
BTDPNPDPOMB$BKB/BDJPOBMEF4BMVE
$/4
 TFSWJDJPT EFQBSUBNFOUBMFT EF





-BCJPUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP

TBMVE 4&%&4
 VOJWFSTJEBEFT QCMJDBT
Z QSJWBEBT EFM TJTUFNB  DPMFHJPT QSPGF
TJPOBMFT  $PMFHJP EF "CPHBEPT EF -B
1B[ $BKB1FUSPMFSBEF4FHVSJEBE4PDJBM 
4FHVSP4PDJBM6OJWFSTJUBSJP TPDJFEBEFT
NEJDP DJFOUmDBT  "DBEFNJB /BDJPOBM
EF $JFODJBT  "DBEFNJB #PMJWJBOB EF
.FEJDJOB  JOTUJUVUPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJO
QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF FM *OTUJUVUP #PMJWJB
OP EF #JPMPHB EF MB "MUVSB Z FM *OTUJ
UVUP#PMJWJBOPEF(FOUJDB
$PNJTJO
&QJTDPQBM 1BTUPSBM 4PDJBM EF MB *HMFTJB
$BUMJDB  0/(T FO TBMVE  NFEJPT EF
DPNVOJDBDJO *OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDBEF
MB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDBEF$PDIBCBN
CBZ"#*0%(&
&OFMQMBOPJOUFSOBDJPOBM FM$/#NBO
UJFOFSFMBDJPOFTDPOFM13#EFMB014
0.4  '&-"*#&  MB 3FE -BUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBZEFM$BSJCFEF#JPUJDB FM$PNJU
*OUFSOBDJPOBM EF #JPUJDB $*#
 EF MB
6/&4$0  #*0463 Z MB "TPDJBDJO
EF#JPUJDBEF"SHFOUJOB MB"TPDJBDJO
#SBTJMFSBEF#JPUJDB MB'VOEBDJO+PT
.BSB.BJOFUUJEF-B1MBUBZ QSJODJQBM
NFOUF DPOMBSFQSFTFOUBDJOEFMB014
0.4FO#PMJWJB

3FQSFTFOUBDJPOFT
&OMBBDUVBMJEBE FMDPPSEJOBEPSEFM$/#
GPSNBQBSUFEFMPTEJSFDUPSJPTEF'&-"*
#& EFMB3FE-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM$B
SJCFEF#JPUJDBZEFM$*#EFMB6/&4
$0 QPSVOQFSPEPEFDVBUSPBPT


1VCMJDBDJPOFT
4JCJFO BUSBWTEFTVDPPSEJOBEPSZTVT
NJFNCSPT FM$*&#ZFM$/#UJFOFOWB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

SJBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTFOSFWJTUBTZGPMMFUPT 
EFTUBDBOMBDPOUSJCVDJOQBSBMBFMBCP
SBDJO EFM EPDVNFOUP JOUFSOBDJPOBM
i&UIJDBMBOE1PMJDZ*OTTVFTJO*OUFSOBUJP
OBM 3FTFBSDI $MJOJDBM 5SJBMT JO %FWFMP
QJOH$PVOUSJFTw EFMB/BUJPOBM#JPFUIJDT
"EWJTPSZ$PNNJTTJPO /#"$
64" ZMB
RVFmHVSBFOFM&TUBUVUP&QJTUFNPMHJDP
EF#JPUJDB QVCMJDBEPQPSMB6/".EF
.YJDPZMB3FE-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM
$BSJCFEF#JPUJDBFO&OFMN
CJUPOBDJPOBM UVWPNVDIBJNQPSUBODJB
MBQVCMJDBDJOEFMB3FWJTUB#PMJWJBOBEF
#JPUJDB KVOJPEF
ZMBi.FNPSJB
EFM'PSP"CJFSUPEF1PMUJDBTEF4BMVEw
EF BNCBTDPOMBDPMBCPSBDJOEF
MB0140.4FO#PMJWJB
%FTEFTVTJOJDJPT MBDPPSEJOBDJOHFOF
SBMEFM$*&#ZEFM$/#IBFTUBEPBNJ
DBSHP DPOMBDPMBCPSBDJOEF-VJT)VS
UBEP(NF[
4BM1BOUPKB .BSUIB
1BDIFDP  3VUI (VJMMO EF .BMEPOB
EP  &OSJRVF 7BSHBT 1BDIFDP  #FBUSJ[
.POUPZB +BJNF.PMMJOFEP"WFSBOHBZ
&NNB"QBSJDJP

.PUJWBDJPOFTZPSJFOUBDJPOFT
GVUVSBTEFM$/#
-B SFBMJEBE EFM NVOEP BDUVBM FT BMUB
NFOUFDVFTUJPOBCMF QPSVODPOKVOUPEF
TJUVBDJPOFT BEWFSTBT RVF oDPNFO[BOEP
QPSMBHVFSSBZMBWJPMFODJB DPOTVTDPO
TFDVFODJBTEFNVFSUFZEFTPMBDJOoTPO
VOB DPOTUBOUF IJTUSJDB JOTVQFSBCMF Z
VOBSFBMJEBEBOUJCJPUJDBEFQFSTJTUFODJB
DPUJEJBOB 1PS PUSB QBSUF  FM QPEFS QP
MUJDPUSBEJDJPOBM EFCJMJUBEPQPSFMEFT
HBTUF EF TVT FTRVFNBT  JODBQBDJEBE EF
MPTMEFSFTQMBOFUBSJPTGSFOUFBMPTDBN





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

CJPTFJOKVTUJDJBZDPSSVQDJODSFDJFOUFT
FO CVFOB QBSUF EFM NVOEP  EFUFSNJOB
VODPOKVOUPEFHSBWFTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPT
RVFOPTFYJHFOQFOTBSFOOVFWBTGPSNBT
EFDPOEVDDJOQPMUJDBDPONBZPSDPN
QSPNJTPZQBSUJDJQBDJODJVEBEBOB
&O CVFOB QBSUF EF -BUJOPBNSJDB MPT
NPWJNJFOUPTQPMUJDPTOPUJFOFOMOFBT
DMBSBTEFTPMVDJOEFQSPCMFNBTFTUSVD
UVSBMFT SFTQPOEJFOEPNTBDPZVOUVSBT
PFYJHFODJBTEFSFJWJOEJDBDJOJONFEJB
UBEFHSVQPTQPCMBDJPOBMFTTFDVMBSNFOUF
QPTUFSHBEPT RVF WJWFO FO MB QPCSF[B Z
MBNBSHJOBMJEBE"UPEPFTUPTFTVNBMB
HMPCBMJ[BDJOFDPONJDBZMBTMFZFTEFM
NFSDBEP RVFTPNFUFOBMPTQBTFTCBKP
MB IFHFNPOB EF HSVQPT EF QPEFS RVF
USBTDJFOEFOFMDPOUSPMZTPCFSBOBEFMPT
QSPQJPT&TUBEPT
-BT GPSNBT EF BHSFTJO FOUSF DJVEBEB
OPTWBFOBVNFOUP NVDIBTWFDFTDPNP
GSVUPEFSFJWJOEJDBDJPOFTTFDUPSJBMFTRVF
BUFOUBODPOUSBFMCJFODPNO ZDPNP
FYQSFTJOQBUUJDBEFFTFiTMWFTFRVJFO
QVFEBwRVFDBTJOBEJFDPOUSPMB
1PSPUSBQBSUF MPTBWBODFTUFDOPMHJDPT
QSPWPDBO VO TFDVFTUSP FDPONJDP QPS
QBSUF EF RVJFOFT MPT QVFEFO QBHBS  FO
EFUSJNFOUPEFMPTBWBODFTTPDJBMFT ZTPO
VOBDBVTBBEJDJPOBMEFTPNFUJNJFOUPZ
EFQFOEFODJB FO VOB TPDJFEBE DPOUFN
QPSOFBRVFiDPTJmDBwBMBTQFSTPOBTZ
iTBDSBMJ[Bw MBT DPTBT  DPO QSFPDVQBOUFT
NBOJGFTUBDJPOFT EF EFTIVNBOJ[BDJO 
FHPTNPZIFEPOJTNP
&ONVDIPTMVHBSFT FMMBUJOPBNFSJDBOP
DPOUFNQPSOFP FTU EFTBSSBJHBEP EF MB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UJFSSB  IB QFSEJEP BQSFDJP Z iDPOUJOVJ


EBEwDPOFMMB SFTVMUOEPMF FONVDIPT
TFOUJEPT  BKFOB B TVT JOUFSFTFT  QPS FM
BGO EF PCUFOFS iCJFOFTw NBUFSJBMFT Z
BSUJmDJBMFT &TBT TPDJFEBEFT NBOUJFOFO
QFSNBOFOUF DPOnJDUP FOUSF MPT HSVQPT
IVNBOPTRVFMBTDPOGPSNBO QSPWPDBO
EP YFOPGPCJB  SBDJTNP  NBSHJOBDJO Z
UFOEFODJBT FVHFOTJDBT 4NFTF B UPEP
FTUP MPT GFONFOPT DSFDJFOUFT OP DPO
USPMBEPTEFDPOUBNJOBDJOBNCJFOUBMZ
EFTFRVJMJCSJP EF MPT FDPTJTUFNBT  SFTVM
UBOEPQSFPDVQBOUFMBJOVTJUBEBGSFDVFO
DJBEFEFTBTUSFTOBUVSBMFTRVFOPQBSFDFO
TFSDBTVBMFT
&MBCBOEPOPZPTVCTUJUVDJOEFMNVO
EP OBUVSBM QSPWPDBO RVF MB OBUVSBMF[B
ZFMIPNCSFWBZBOQFSEJFOEPSJRVF[BZ
WBSJFEBE QPSRVFNVDIBTDVMUVSBTEFMB
UJFSSB FUOPDVMUVSBT
FTUOEFTBQBSFDJFO
EP  B MB QBS EF NVDIBT FTQFDJFT WJWBT 
QPSFTBTVFSUFEFiSFWPMVDJOUFDOPMHJ
DBwRVFOPTMMFWBBSFFNQMB[BSMPOBUVSBM
QPSMPOBUVSBMNPEJmDBEPPMPBSUJmDJBM 
QPOJFOEP FO EVEB FM FTUBUVT FTFODJBM 
CJPMHJDP QTJDPNFOUBM TPDJBMFIJTUSJ
DPEFMIPNCSF
"IPSB CJFO  {DVM FT OVFTUSB QFSDFQ
DJOEFMBCJPUJDBJOUFSOBDJPOBMBDUVBM 
$SFFNPT RVF TF IB WJTUP EFTWJSUVBEB
EFTEF TVT JOJDJPT  QPSRVF FM NFOTBKF
GVOEBDJPOBM EF 1PUUFS EF VOB CJPUJDB
HMPCBM IB TJEP QPTUFSHBEP Z PQBDBEP
QPSVOBCJPUJDBSFEVDJEBBMJOUFSTVUJ
MJUBSJPEFMEFTBSSPMMPUFDOPMHJDPZDJFO
UmDP  RVF IB TBCJEP BQSPWFDIBS  DPO
DSFDFT FMQSFUFYUPEFMQSFDFQUPBMUSVJTUB
EFMBiUJDBFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJOwBMTFSWJ





-BCJPUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP

DJP EF FOPSNFT JOUFSFTFT IFHFNOJDPT


EFEJWFSTBOEPMF4JCJFOTFCFOFmDJMB
DJFODJBDPOBEFMBOUPTRVF BTVWF[ TMP
DPOWJFOFOBRVJFOFTQVFEFOBDDFEFSB
FMMPT  MB CJPUJDB FO HFOFSBM UVWP QPDB
P OVMB JOnVFODJB FO FM NFKPSBNJFOUP
EFM NVOEP  B UBM QVOUP RVF FM HSVFTP
EF MB QPCMBDJO IVNBOB EFTDPOPDF TV
FYJTUFODJBPUFSNJOBQPSOPBTVNJSTV
JNQPSUBODJB

DJOFTJHVBMNFOUFJOEJWJEVBMJTUB OPUB
CMFNFOUF JOnVJEB QPS FM QBSBEJHNB EF
MPT DVBUSP QSJODJQJPT FTUBCMFDJEPT QPS
#FBVDIBNQZ$IJMESFTT RVF FOQBSUF 
QVEJFTFOTFSDPOUSBEJDUPSJPTPOPUJFOFO
MBNJTNBBQMJDBDJOQBSBFMFKFSDJDJPEF
VOBCJPUJDBTBOJUBSJB UBOOFDFTBSJBFO
NVDIPT EF OVFTUSPT QBTFT DPO TFSJPT
QSPCMFNBTEFKVTUJDJBFJOFRVJEBEFOFM
BDDFTPBMPTTFSWJDJPTEFTBMVE

"M QBSFDFS  MB CJPUJDB PDDJEFOUBM  NB


ZPSNFOUF WJODVMBEB BM EFTBSSPMMP DJFO
UmDP VOJWFSTBMJ[UFOEFODJBTFJODMVZ
B-BUJOPBNSJDB EPOEFIBQSFWBMFDJEP
IBTUBFMQSFTFOUFTJOQSFPDVQBSTFEFCVT
DBSBEFDVBDJPOFTBMBTEJWFSTBTSFBMJEBEFT
DVMUVSBMFT Z TPDJPBOUSPQPMHJDBT &TUB
TVFSUFEFDPMPOJBMJTNPCJPUJDPTFEFK
QFSDJCJSJODMVTPFOMBTPSJFOUBDJPOFTEF
MPT QSJNFSPT CPSSBEPSFT EF MB %FDMBSB
DJO 6OJWFSTBM EF #JPUJDB Z %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTEFMB6/&4$0 ZFOMBTSF
VOJPOFTRVFTFEJFSPOFO1BSTIBTUBTV
BQSPCBDJO  mOBMNFOUF BMHP NT DPO
TFOTVBEBDPOMPTJOUFSFTFTEFMPTQBTFT
EFM5FSDFS.VOEP

&TUFFTVONPNFOUPEFJOnFYJOEFMB
CJPUJDB P  TJ TF RVJFSF  EF DVFTUJPOB
NJFOUPBMPMJNJUBEPEFTVTSFTVMUBEPT
{IBSFTQPOEJEPMBCJPUJDBBMBSFBMJEBE
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB

-BCJPUJDBTFIBSFEVDJEPNTBMJOEJ
WJEVPRVFBMPTPDJBMZBNCJFOUBM NBO
UFOJFOEPVODBSDUFSBDBENJDPDJFOU
mDPRVF TJCJFOBHSFHNVDIPBOMJTJT
EPDUSJOBM Z mMPTmDP  UVWP NVZ QPDP
JNQBDUPTPDJBM TBMWPQPSBRVFMMPTUFNBT
iOPWFEPTPTw GVFSUFNFOUF QVCMJDJUBEPT 
DPNP TPO MBT BTPNCSPTBT QPTJCJMJEBEFT
EFMBCJPMPHBNPMFDVMBS MBDMPOBDJOV
PUSPT
&OMPRVFTFSFmFSFBMBBQMJDBDJON
EJDPTBOJUBSJBEFMBCJPUJDB TVPSJFOUB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

-B SFTQVFTUB QVFEF TFS EJWFSTB  QPSRVF


MBTSFBMJEBEFTEFMPTQBTFTMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOPTTPOUBNCJOEJTUJOUBT4JOFNCBS
HP  FT OFDFTBSJP TFBMBS MBT DBSBDUFSTUJ
DBTHFOFSBMFTZMPTGBDUPSFTEFWFOUBKBEF
OVFTUSBSFHJORVF QSPCBCMFNFOUF OP
IBOTJEPEFMUPEPDPNQSFOEJEPTPBQSP
WFDIBEPT QBSB DPOTUSVJS VOB CJPUJDB
NTQSPQJB&OUSFTUPT -BUJOPBNSJDB
TVNBMBIFSFODJBEFMBDVMUVSBVOJWFSTBM
ZFTQPTFFEPSBEFDVMUVSBTQSPQJBTRVF
DPOTUJUVZFO HSBOEFT BQPSUFT QBSB WJHP
SJ[BSZEBSMFVODBSDUFSEFSFOPWBDJO
BMBDVMUVSBNVOEJBM DPOTJEFSBOEPRVF
FT BEFNT MBSFHJODPONBZPSSJRVF[B
OBUVSBM  CJPEJWFSTJEBE Z SFTFSWB FDPM
HJDBEFMQMBOFUB NPTUSBOEPVOBNQMJP
BCBOJDPEFQPUFODJBMJEBEFTZQPTJCJMJEB
EFTGVUVSBT BMBTRVFUBNCJOTFTVNBFM
EFTBSSPMMP DJFOUmDP Z UFDOPMHJDP 1PS
PUSBQBSUF FOOVFTUSPTQBTFTTFNBOUJF
OFOMPTWBMPSFTUSBEJDJPOBMFTEFMBGBNJ
MJBDPOHSFHBEBZVOJEB MBDBMJEF[FOFM





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

USBUPZFMUSBCBKPDPNVOJUBSJP RVFTPO
FYQSFTJPOFTEFVOBQPCMBDJOTFOTJCMFB
MPJOEJWJEVBMZMPTPDJBM
$SFP RVF IBZ NBUFSJB QBSB DPOTUSVJS
VOBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBRVFUFOHB
VO TVTUFOUP FQJTUFNPMHJDP EPDUSJOBM
ZmMPTmDP
EFMPHFOFSBMVPDDJEFOUBM
B MP BNFSJDBOP Z BVUDUPOP  FTUVEJO
EPOPTQBSBDPOPDFSOPTNFKPSZBQMJDBS
VOBCJPUJDBEFGVFSUFDPOUFOJEPBOUSP
QPMHJDPZTPDJBM TPCSFMBTIVFMMBTEFMB
UJFSSBFJEFOUJEBE1BSBFTUPTFSFRVJFSF
VOBCJPUJDBEFJOUFSWFODJOZQBSUJDJ
QBDJO DBQB[EFBQSPYJNBSTFBMPTOJ
WFMFT FTUBUBMFT  QSPNPWJFOEP QSPDFTPT
EF FEVDBDJO DJVEBEBOB RVF MPHSFO
BKVTUFTUFNUJDPTZQSPHSBNUJDPTDPO
DPSEBOUFTDPOMBTSFBMJEBEFTZOFDFTJEB
EFTQSPQJBT
&OMPRVFIBDFBMBSFMBDJOEFMBCJP
UJDB DPO MB TBMVE IVNBOB  FT OFDFTBSJP
FYUFOEFSMBCJPUJDBDMOJDBJOEJWJEVBMB
MB CJPUJDB TBOJUBSJB  JODJEJFOEP FO MBT
QPMUJDBTEFTBMVEQBSBVONFKPSBNJFOUP
DPOTUBOUFEFMBDBMJEBEFOMPTTFSWJDJPTZ
VOBNBZPSTBUJTGBDDJOEFMPTVTVBSJPT 
TJOEJTUJODJOBMHVOB
'JOBMNFOUF FTUBQFSDFQDJOMBUJOPBNF
SJDBOB EFCF TFS JODPSQPSBEB FO MB GPS
NBDJOJOUFSOBDJPOBMEFMBCJPUJDB OP
TMPDPOVODSJUFSJPJOUFHSBEPS TJOPQPS
MB OFDFTJEBE Z PCMJHBDJO RVF UFOFNPT
MPT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT EF NPTUSBS VOB
SFBMJEBE NVZ EJGFSFOUF B MB RVF QSFWB
MFDFFOPDDJEFOUFZQSFUFOEFQSJNBSFO
FMNVOEP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&M*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDBEFMB
6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDB#PMJWJBOB
6$#
FO$PDIBCBNCB
&MEFOPWJFNCSFEFFM$POTFKP
%JSFDUJWPEFM*OTUJUVUP4VQFSJPSEF&T
UVEJPT 5FPMHJDPT *4&5
 DPO MB QSF
TFODJB EF TV QSFTJEFOUF  )BOT WBO EFO
#FSH ZMBEFMSFDUPSEFMB6$# -VJT"O
UPOJP #P[B  BQSPCBSPO MB DPOTUJUVDJO
EFM $FOUSP EF #JPUJDB  FM QSJNFSP EF
TVHOFSPFO#PMJWJB OPNCSBOEPDPNP
EJSFDUPS B .JHVFM .BO[BOFSB  RVJFO
DPOUJOB FO FM DBSHP FO MB BDUVBMJEBE
&O FM$FOUSPEF#JPUJDBQBTB
MMBNBSTF*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDB *#

&OUSFTVTPCKFUJWPTTFFODVFOUSB'P
NFOUBSMBJOWFTUJHBDJO MBFEVDBDJOZ
MBEJGVTJOEFMBCJPUJDBFOEFGFOTBEFMB
WJEBIVNBOB EFTEFMBDPODFQDJOIBT
UB TV UFSNJOBDJO OBUVSBM  RVF JODMVZF
FMDVJEBEPEFMFOUPSOPTPDJBMZNFEJP
BNCJFOUBM  DPO QSPZFDDJO VOJWFSTBM Z
UFPMPHBM UFOJFOEPDPNPQVOUPEFSFGF
SFODJBZPSJFOUBDJOMBFOTFBO[BEFMB
*HMFTJB$BUMJDB1SPNPWFSFMEJMPHP
JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP FOUSF DVMUJWBEPSFT EF
MBT DJFODJBT NEJDBT  KVSEJDBT  TPDJBMFT 
DVMUVSBMFT FDPMHJDBT mMPTmDBTZUFPM
HJDBT UFOJFOEPDPNPCBTFVOBBOUSPQP
MPHBEFPSJFOUBDJOIVNBOBZDSJTUJBOB 
SFTQFUBOEPMPTHFOVJOPTWBMPSFTDVMUVSB
MFT GBNJMJBSFTZSFMJHJPTPTWJHFOUFTFOMB
QPCMBDJO CPMJWJBOB  DPO FTQFDJBM QSF
GFSFODJB QPS MBT QFSTPOBT NBSHJOBEBT Z
FNQPCSFDJEBTRVFBEPMFDFOEFVOBFMF
WBEBNPSCJMJEBEZNPSUBMJEBE





-BCJPUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP

6OBEFMBTBDUVBDJPOFTNTJNQPSUBOUFT
EFMBQSJNFSBFUBQBGVFMBPSHBOJ[BDJO
EFM * &ODVFOUSP /BDJPOBM EF #JPUJ
DB $PDIBCBNCB
 FOUSF FM  Z FM  EF
TFQUJFNCSFEF BCPDBEPBMFTUVEJP
EF MB -FZ EF 5SBTQMBOUF EF SHBOPT Z
5FKJEPT  RVF TF FODPOUSBCB CMPRVFBEB
QPS SB[POFT QPMUJDBT FO FM 1BSMBNFOUP
EF#PMJWJB
"QBSUJSEFTFIBEFEJDBEPBMBJO
WFTUJHBDJO  QSPDVSBOEP EBS SFTQVFTUBT
B MPT JOUFSSPHBOUFT NBZPSFT QMBOUFBEPT
B MB CJPUJDB &M IFDIP EF QFSUFOFDFS B
MB 6$# IB NBSDBEP MB MOFB EF PSJFO
UBDJOEFOVFTUSPUSBCBKP&M*#PGSFDF
VO TFSWJDJP EF CJCMJPUFDB DPO NBUFSJBM
CJCMJPHSmDPZEPDVNFOUBDJO
+VOUBNFOUFDPOFM$PNJU/BDJPOBMEF
#JPUJDB MB6OJWFSTJEBE.BZPSEF4BO
4JNO  MB 6OJWFSTJEBE .BZPS EF 4BO
"OEST MB0140.4ZPUSBTJOTUJUVDJP
OFT PSHBOJ[FM**$POHSFTP#PMJWJBOP
EF #JPUJDB  #JPUJDB Z 4VCEFTBSSPMMP 
EFMBMEFBHPTUPEF
)B NBOUFOJEP NVDIPT DPOUBDUPT DPO
NVDIBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT FDMFTJTUJDBT  HV
CFSOBNFOUBMFT  QSPGFTJPOBMFT  FEVDBUJ
WBTZVOJWFSTJUBSJBT mHVSBOEPFOMBCBTF
EF EBUPT EF CJPUJDB EF MB 6/&4$0
&OUSF MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT FDMFTJTUJDBT EFM
7BUJDBOP FT DPOWFOJFOUF NFODJPOBS B
MB 1POUJmDJB "DBEFNJB QPS MB 7JEB  FM
1POUJmDJP $POTFKP QBSB MB 1BTUPSBM EF
MB 4BMVE Z FM 1POUJmDJP $POTFKP QBSB
MB 'BNJMJB %FOUSP EF #PMJWJB DPMBCPSB
DPO MB $POGFSFODJB &QJTDPQBM #PMJWJB
OB  QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF DPO MB $PNJTJO
&QJTDPQBMEF%PDUSJOBZ'F BEFNTEF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

NBOUFOFS FTUSFDIBT SFMBDJPOFT DPO MBT


JHMFTJBTMPDBMFTEF#PMJWJBZTVTEJWFSTPT
PSHBOJTNPT
&M *# FT NJFNCSP GVOEBEPS EF MB 'F
EFSBDJO *OUFSOBDJPOBM EF $FOUSPT F
*OTUJUVUPT EF #JPUJDB EF *OTQJSBDJO
1FSTPOBMJTUB '*#*1
DVZBQSJNFSBBDUB
EFGVOEBDJOTFmSNFMEFKVOJPEF
 FO3PNB TJFOEPSBUJmDBEBTVJO
DPSQPSBDJOFMEFPDUVCSFEF
'VF NJFNCSP GVOEBEPS EF MB 'FEFSB
DJO -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF *OTUJUVDJPOFT
EF #JPUJDB '&-"*#&
 FO MB 7JMMB EF
-FZWB $PMPNCJB
 FO OPWJFNCSF EF

6OPEFTVTPCKFUJWPTEFM*#IBTJEPMB
EJGVTJOEFMBCJPUJDBQPSNFEJPEFQV
CMJDBDJPOFTFOMJCSPT SFWJTUBT GPMMFUPTZ
QFSJEJDPT.FSFDFNFODJOFTQFDJBMMB
$PMFDDJO#*04 JOJDJBEBFO
"QFTBSEFMBFTDBTF[EFSFDVSTPT IBDPO
TFHVJEPEFTBSSPMMBSVOBMOFBEFCJPUJDB
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB  EF JOTQJSBDJO IVNB
OJTUB Z DSJTUJBOB  RVF QVFEF FOSJRVFDFS
BMBDUVBMEFCBUF
-BTNPUJWBDJPOFTZPSJFOUBDJPOFTEFM*# 
TFSFnFKBOFOMBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTEFMB$P
MFDDJO#*04 DPOMBTJHVJFOUFTOUFTJT
#JPUJDBEFMBOPTUSJEBE1PSVOBQBSUF 
DPOUSBTUBDPOMBCJPUJDBOPSUFBNFSJDB
OB  EF DVP QSFEPNJOBOUFNFOUF VUJMJ
UBSJTUB Z QSBHNBUJTUB  RVF TF DFOUSB FO
MBTDPOTFDVFODJBTEFMBBDDJOIVNBOB
ZOPUJFOFFODVFOUBMBWJTJOUSBOTDFO
EFOUFEFMIPNCSF*HVBMNFOUF TJSWFEF
DPOUSBQVOUPBMBCJPUJDBFVSPQFBRVF 





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

TJCJFOQSPGVOEJ[BFOMPTBTQFDUPTmMPT
mDPT  TF PSJFOUB QSFGFSFOUFNFOUF IBDJB
FM EJMPHP DPOTFOTVBMJTUB RVF JNQMJDB
VOBWJTJOSFMBUJWJTUBEFMBWFSEBE
-BCJPUJDBEFMBOPTUSJEBERVJFSFGVO
EBNFOUBS TVT WBMPSFT BYJPMHJDPT Z TVT
QSJODJQJPTUJDPTFOVOBWJTJOJOUFHSBM
EFM IPNCSF DPNP TFS QTJDPTPNUJDP 
JNQVMTBEP B MB USBOTDFOEFODJB IBDJB
FM OPTPUSPT VOJWFSTBM BOUSPQPUFPMPHBM
%FTEFFTUBQFSTQFDUJWB DBCFSFGPSNVMBS
MPTQSJODJQJPTDMTJDPTEFOPNBMFmDFO
DJB KVTUJDJB BVUPOPNBZCFOFmDFODJB
#JPEFSFDIP &O FTUF NCJUP  FT JNQPS
UBOUFQSPNPWFSFMEJTDFSOJNJFOUPZSF
DPOPDJNJFOUP EF MPT BVUOUJDPT CJPEF
SFDIPT IVNBOPT  GVOEBNFOUBEPT FO MB
EJHOJEBEOBUVSBMEFMIPNCSF SFDIB[BO
EP FYDMVTJPOFT F JOUFSQSFUBDJPOFT BCV
TJWBT&OFMBDUVBMEFCBUFJOUFSOBDJPOBM
BERVJFSFJNQPSUBODJBFMSFDPOPDJNJFOUP
EFMBPCKFDJOEFDPODJFODJBZ BTJNJT
NP FMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBUPMFSBODJBDPNP
WJSUVEUJDBUBOUPGSFOUFBMBJOUPMFSBODJB
DPNPBMBVMUSBUPMFSBODJB
0SUPHFOFTJB&TJNQPSUBOUFQSPNPWFSFM
EFSFDIP EF UPEP TFS IVNBOP B TFS HF
OFSBEPQPSMBSFMBDJODPOZVHBMOBUVSBM 
RVF HBSBOUJ[B BM OJP MB QFSUFOFODJB B
VOPTQBESFTJEFOUJmDBEPTZVOJEPTFOFM
BNPSGBNJMJBS-BPSUPHFOFTJBTFPQPOF
OPTMPZFOQSJNFSMVHBSBMBCPSUPZBMB
FVHFOFTJB TJOPUBNCJOBMBEJTHFOFTJB 
JODMVZFOEP MB GFSUJMJ[BDJO FYUSBDPSQ
SFB Z PUSBT UDOJDBT RVF FYQPOFO B MPT
FNCSJPOFT IVNBOPT B NBOJQVMBDJPOFT
DPOUSBSJBTBTVEJHOJEBE

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

1PS FMMP  TF EFCF JNQVMTBS MB JOWFTUJ


HBDJO DPO DMVMBT USPODBMFT BEVMUBT P
VNCJMJDBMFTZSFDIB[BSMBDMPOBDJO TFB
SFQSPEVDUJWBPUFSBQVUJDB ZMBVUJMJ[B
DJO EF DMVMBT USPODBMFT FNCSJPOBMFT
%FOUSPEFMBPSUPHFOFTJB BERVJFSFJN
QPSUBODJBMBQMBOJmDBDJOGBNJMJBSOBUV
SBMDPNPBMUFSOBUJWBIVNBOJ[BOUFGSFOUF
BMBJOWBTJOJOEJTDSJNJOBEBEFBOUJDPO
DFQUJWPT BMHVOPTEFFMMPTJBUSPHOJDPTZ
BCPSUJWPT
3FTQFDUP EFM FTUBUVUP POUPMHJDP EFM
FNCSJO IVNBOP  MB DPODFQDJO OPS
NBMTFDPSSFTQPOEFCJPMHJDBNFOUFDPO
MBQFOFUSBDJOEFMFTQFSNBUP[PJEFFOFM
WVMP PSJHJOBOEPVOOVFWPEJOBNJTNP
FOEHFOPFOUFMRVJDPRVF FOUSNJOPT
NFUBGTJDPT  TF EFOPNJOB iBMNBw %F
BRV FM BQPZP B MB UFPSB EF MB BOJNB
DJO JONFEJBUB EFM FNCSJO IVNBOP 
SFJOUFSQSFUBOEP MB QPTJDJO BSJTUPUMJDB
UPNJTUB
0SUPUFSBQJB&OUSNJOPTEFTBMVEZFO
GFSNFEBE IBZRVFEFGFOEFSFMEFSFDIP
EFM QBDJFOUF B MB PSUPUFSBQJB P TFB B MB
DVSBDJO Z BUFODJO OBUVSBMFT EJHOBT 
QSPQVHOBOEP MB IVNBOJ[BDJO EF MB
NFEJDJOB EFTDBSUBOEPMBNBMBQSBYJTZ
PUSPT BCVTPT NEJDPT  Z QSPNPWJFOEP
FM TFHVSP VOJWFSTBM NEJDP QBSB UPEB
MBQPCMBDJO&TQFDJBMNFODJONFSFDF
MBCJPUJDBEFMPTUSBTQMBOUFTEFDMVMBT 
UFKJEPT Z SHBOPT  QSPNPWJFOEP VOB
NBZPS TPMJEBSJEBE FO MBT EPOBDJPOFT Z
FOMBTNJTNBTPQFSBDJPOFTEFUSBTQMBOUF 
EFGFOEJFOEPFMEFSFDIPEFMPTQBDJFOUFT
BMTFHVSPVOJWFSTBM





-BCJPUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP

0SUPUBOBTJB 1SPQVHOBNPT FM EFSFDIP


B MB PSUPUBOBTJB P NVFSUF OBUVSBM EJH
OB RVFTFPQPOFUBOUPBMBFVUBOBTJB P
NVFSUFQSPWPDBEBBQFUJDJOEFMNJTNP
QBDJFOUF DPNPBMBEJTUBOBTJBPQSPMPO
HBDJO JOEFCJEB P GUJM EF MB WJEB NF
EJBOUFQSPDFEJNJFOUPTEFTQSPQPSDJPOB
EPTPJOFRVJUBUJWPT&OFMEFCBUFTPCSF
MBMMBNBEBNVFSUFDFSFCSBMPFODFGMJDB 
UFOFNPTMBDFSUF[BEFMBWBMJEF[EFMEJBH
OTUJDP OFVSPMHJDP EF NVFSUF CBTBEP
FO QBSNFUSPT TPCSF DFTBDJO UPUBM F
JSSFWFSTJCMFEFMFODGBMP RVFGVFBDFQUB
EBQPSMB*HMFTJB$BUMJDBFO
#JPUJDB FDPMHJDB $PO FTUF USNJOP TF
FYQSFTB VOB SFDUB DPNQSFOTJO EF MB
FDPMPHB  RVF SFDIB[B UBOUP MB BDUJUVE
QBTJWB GSFOUF B MBT BNFOB[BT FDPMHJ
DBT DPNP FM FDPMPHJTNP RVF OP QPOF
BM IPNCSF FO FM DFOUSP EF MB DSFBDJO
'SFOUFBQPTUVSBTFYUSFNBTGBWPSBCMFTP
EFTGBWPSBCMFT FO SFMBDJO DPO MPT PSHB
OJTNPT HFOUJDBNFOUF NPEJmDBEPT  FT
DPOWFOJFOUF NBOUFOFS VOB BDUJUVE EF
QSFDBVDJO BQSPCBDJOZFWBMVBDJOEF
DBEBQSPZFDUP DBTPQPSDBTP
1FEBHPHBTFYVBM'SFOUFBMBFEVDBDJO
MJCFSUBSJB Z IFEPOJTUB EF MB TFYVBMJEBE 
IBZRVFUSBOTNJUJSVOBQFEBHPHBJOUF
HSBM QBSB MB FEVDBDJO Z DPNQSFOTJO
EF MB TFYVBMJEBE DPNP EJNFOTJO BO
USPQPMHJDB  FO TVT USFT DPNQPOFOUFT
GVOEBNFOUBMFT VOJUJWB  QSPDSFBUJWB Z
SFDSFBUJWB &M DPOUSPM SB[POBCMF EF MB
TFYVBMJEBE  DMTJDBNFOUF MB WJSUVE EF
MB DBTUJEBE  QFSNJUF B MPT KWFOFT QSF
QBSBSTF BEFDVBEBNFOUF QBSB FM WFSEB
EFSPBNPS FMNBUSJNPOJPZMBGBNJMJB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&TUBFEVDBDJOFT BMNJTNPUJFNQP FM


NFKPS BOUEPUP QBSB MBT JOGFDDJPOFT EF
USBOTNJTJOTFYVBMZMPTFNCBSB[PTJN
QSFWJTUPT

"TPDJBDJO#PMJWJBOBEF#JPUJDB
Z%FSFDIP(FOUJDP
.PUJWBEPTQPSMBDPOEVDUBIVNBOB TV
SFMBDJOCJPHFOUJDBZTVDPOUFYUPMFHBM 
MPT BCPHBEPT MWBSP .VOHVB #FDLFS
Z(VTUBWP4JWJMB1FBSBOEBEFDJEJFSPO
JODVSTJPOBSFOFMFTUVEJPZEJWVMHBDJO
EF MB CJPUJDB Z TV DPOOPUBDJO MFHBM 
JODMVZFOEPVOBOVFWBSBNBCJPUFDOJm
DBEBEFM%FSFDIPBDPSEFDPOMPTBEFMBO
UPTDJFOUmDPT IFDIPTRVFEJFSPODPNP
SFTVMUBEP MB DPOGPSNBDJO EF MB "TP
DJBDJO#PMJWJBOBEF#JPUJDB %FSFDIP
(FOUJDPZ#JPUFDOPMPHB "#*0%(&

FO   BHSVQBDJO DPOGPSNBEB QPS
QSPGFTJPOBMFTFODJFODJBTTPDJBMFT CJPM
HJDBTZEFMBTBMVE
4FNJOBSJPT DPO QBSUJDJQBDJO EF FY
QPTJUPSFT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT  DPOGFSFODJBT
Z GPSPT OBDJPOBMFT F JOUFSDBNCJP EF
JOGPSNBDJO DPO FOUJEBEFT TJNJMBSFT
FO FM JOUFSJPS Z FYUFSJPS EFM QBT DPOT
UJUVZFO QSJODJQBMNFOUF MBT mOBMJEBEFT
EF "#*0%(& -B QSFQBSBDJO EF BO
UFQSPZFDUPTEFMFZFOCJPUFDOPMPHB SF
QSPEVDDJOIVNBOBBTJTUJEBZHFOUJDB
TPOQBSUFEFMBTUBSFBTFOFMNCJUPMF
HJTMBUJWP-BBDFQUBDJOEFVOBQSPQVFT
UB QBSB MB JODMVTJO EF MBT NBUFSJBT EF
#JPUJDBZ%FSFDIP(FOUJDPFOFMQMBO
EFFTUVEJPTEFMBDBSSFSBEF%FSFDIPEF
MB 6.4"  MB QSFQBSBDJO EFM DVSTP EF
FTQFDJBMJ[BDJOFOBNCBT ZEJWFSTPTTF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

NJOBSJPT PSHBOJ[BEPT EFTEF  IBO


TJEP IBTUB FM NPNFOUP MBT QSJODJQBMFT
BDUJWJEBEFTSFBMJ[BEBT
&MJOUFSTZMBEFEJDBDJOQPSFMNCJUP
CJPMFHBMTFWJPQMBTNBEPFOFOMB
DPOGPSNBDJOEFMB$PNJTJOEF#JPUJ
DBZ%FSFDIP(FOUJDPEFM*MVTUSF$PMF
HJPEF"CPHBEPTEF-B1B[ BDUVBMNFOUF
FODPNQMFUBDPPSEJOBDJODPO"#*0%
(&&TUBTEPTFOUJEBEFTQFSNJUFOMMFOBS
MBTFYQFDUBUJWBTEFQSPGFTJPOBMFTJOUFSF
TBEPTFOMBSFMBDJOFOUSFMBCJPNFEJDJ
OB MPTBWBODFTCJPUFDOPMHJDPT MBDPO
EVDUBIVNBOBZFM%FSFDIP

$PODMVTJPOFT
&MQSJODJQJP EFTBSSPMMPZmOBMCJPMHJDP
EF MB WJEB IVNBOB FTUO JOEJTDVUJCMF
NFOUFDPOEJDJPOBEPTQPSTVDPNQPOFO
UFHFOUJDP ZTUFQPSFMFQJHFOPNB4JO
FNCBSHP  MBT UDOJDBT EF SFQSPEVDDJO
IVNBOBBTJTUJEB FMQSPZFDUPHFOPNBZ
FMNJUPEFMTFSIVNBOPJONPSUBMZQFS

GFDUPFTUOQFSNJUJFOEPMBNBOJQVMBDJO
JOEJTDSJNJOBEBEFOVFTUSPNBUFSJBMQSJ
NJHFOJP FTFODJBEFMBIVNBOJEBE DPO
SJFTHPTZDPOTFDVFODJBT&MMPDPOTUJUVZF
VOBUFOUBEPDPOUSBMBJOUFHSJEBEFJOEJ
WJEVBMJEBECJPHFOUJDBT BTDPNP UBN
CJO FMSFHJTUSPZSFWFMBDJOEFTVFTUSVD
UVSBFTVOBBHSFTJODPOUSBMBJOUJNJEBE
5PEPFTUPGSFOUFBMPTFGFDUPTQPTJUJWPT
EFM NBOFKP EF FTUBT UFDOPMPHBT  DPNP
TPOMBUFSBQJBHOJDBZFMBDDFTPBMFTUB
CMFDJNJFOUPEFMBJEFOUJEBECJPMHJDB
&TUPT MPHSPT DJFOUmDPT CJPNEJDPT Z
CJPUFDOPMHJDPT ZFOCSFWFMBOBOPUFD
OPMPHBZMBDVOUJDB TFSOVOJOOFHB
CMFCFOFmDJPQBSBMBFWPMVDJOCJPQTJDP
TPDJBMEFMBIVNBOJEBE QFSNJUJOEPOPT
USBTDFOEFSMPTMNJUFTEFMDPOPDJNJFOUP
QFSP BTJNJTNP TJOPTPODBOBMJ[BEPTZ
BSNPOJ[BEPTEFOUSPEFVONBSDPCJP
UJDPZMFHBM QVFEFOUSBOTGPSNBSTFFOVO
BUFOUBEPDPOUSBMBEJHOJEBEEFMBFTQF
DJFIVNBOB

#JCMJPHSBGB
#*04*OJDJPEFMB7JEB)VNBOB  FE 
#*04'VOEBNFOUBDJOEFMB#JPUJDBFOMB/PTUSJEBE 
#*04#JPUJDBEFM5SBTQMBOUFEFSHBOPT 
#*04  'VOEBNFOUBDJO EFM %FSFDIP FO MB 'JMPTPGB EF MB /PTUSJEBE    FE 
FE 
#*04#JPUJDBEFMB*OTVGJDJFODJB3FOBM 
#*04%FCBUF#JPUJDP$POUFNQPSOFP1SPCMFNBTZ)PSJ[POUF 
#*04#JPUJDB &DPMPHBZ"HSPCJPUFDOPMPHB 
#*040SUPUBOBTJB#JPUJDBEFMB.VFSUF/BUVSBM%JHOB  FE 
#*04'JMPTPGBEFMB/PTUSJEBE"OUSPQPUFPMPHBM 

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



-BCJPUJDBFO#PMJWJBBOUFDFEFOUFTZQSPZFDDJPOFT+BWJFS-VOB0SPTDP&EVBSEP



#*04.BOJQVMBDJPOFTMJOHTUJDBTFOMB#JPUJDB
#*04-FZ.BSDPTPCSF%FSFDIPT4FYVBMFTZ3FQSPEVDUJWPT
$BSUBEF#VFOPT"JSFT 
3FWJTUB#PMJWJBOBEF#JPUJDB  
FOFSPKVOJP QQ
$PNJU/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDBEF#PMJWJB 
)BDJBVOB%FDMBSBDJO6OJWFSTBMEF
#JPUJDB4FNJOBSJP3FHJPOBMEFMB6/&4$0 #VFOPT"JSFT"SHFOUJOB ZEF
OPWJFNCSF3FWJTUB#PMJWJBOBEF#JPUJDB  
FOFSPKVOJP QQ
(BSSBGB 7 ,PUUPX . 4BBEB " $PPSE
 
&TUBUVUP&QJTUFNPMHJDPEFMB#JPUJ
DB.YJDP 6OJWFSTJEBE"VUOPNBEF.YJDP 3FE-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM$BSJCF
EF#JPUJDBEFMB6/&4$0
4JWJMB1FBSBOEB ( 
#JPUJDBZ%FSFDIP-B1B[ &EJU$SFBUJWB
7BSHBT1BDIFDP & 
*OWFTUJHBDJOFO4BMVE"EFDVBEBZ1SPCBEBUJDBNFOUF
3FWJTUB#PMJWJBOBEF#JPUJDB  
FOFSPKVOJP QQ
7BSTJ3PTQJHMJPTJ & 
%FSFDIP(FOUJDPZ1SPDSFUJDP-B1B[ "#*0%(&$PNJ
TJOEF#JPUJDBZ%FSFDIP(FOUJDPEFM*MVTUSF$PMFHJPEF"CPHBEPTEF-B1B[

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





6OBSBEJPHSBGBEFMBCJPUJDBFO#SBTJMWPDFT
QJPOFSBT QSPHSBNBTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTZFEVDBUJWPT Z
QFSTQFDUJWBT
-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF

*OUSPEVDDJO

BCJPUJDBFO#SBTJMDVFOUBDPOQPDP
NT EF RVJODF BPT EF WJEB BDBE
NJDB Z EF BDUJWJEBEFT JOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
"ERVJFSF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB PSHOJDB EF
DBSDUFS BDBENJDP EFTEF DPNJFO[PT
EFMBEDBEBEF/PIBZNVDIPT
FTUVEJPT IJTUSJDPDSUJDPT BDFSDB EF MB
CJPUJDBCSBTJMFB OJSFTQFDUPEF"N
SJDB-BUJOB EFEJDBEPTBVOBFWBMVBDJO
EFM QSPDFTP IJTUSJDP CSBTJMFP Z MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOP 4DISBNN   (BSSB
GB   "OKPT     1FTTJOJ 
 

-BCJPUJDBFO#SBTJMTFQVFEFDPOTJEF
SBS VOB FNQSFTB SFDJFOUF Z UBSEB  MMF
OBEFBOTJFEBEQPSSFnFKBS FOUFOEFSZ
TPMVDJPOBS MPT WJFKPT Z OVFWPT EFTBGPT
QSPWPDBEPTQPSMBUFDOPDJFODJBBMBTB
MVEIVNBOBZBMBJOWFTUJHBDJOCJPN
EJDB"MBQBS UJFOFRVFIBDFSGSFOUFB
MPTiQSPCMFNBTEFTJFNQSFw QSPQJPTEF
VONVOEPNBSDBEPQPSMBEFTJHVBMEBE
TPDJBMZMBFYDMVTJO ZQPSBRVFMMPTJO
FTQFSBEPT RVF QSPWJFOFO EF MB SFWPMV
DJOCJPUFDOPMHJDB RVFBGFDUBOUPEBMB
HFOUFZBMBWJEBZTBMVEEFMBTPDJFEBE
-B CJPUJDB CSBTJMFB FT KPWFO QPSRVF
IB FNFSHJEP DBTJ NFEJP TJHMP EFTQVT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EF MB BQSPCBDJO EFM DMFCSF $EJHP


EF /VSFNCFSH 
 RVF FTUBCMFDJ
EJSFDUSJDFT UJDBT QBSB MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
DPOTFSFTIVNBOPT ZEPTEDBEBTNT
UBSEFEFMTVSHJNJFOUPEFMBCJPUJDBFO
&&66 BQSJODJQJPTEFMPT
"VORVFBQBSF[DBFOVODPOUFYUPHMPCB
MJ[BEP Z EJONJDP  FO FM DVBM MPT QSJO
DJQBMFTQSPCMFNBTFOFMDPOKVOUPBDUVBM
EF DVFTUJPOFT CJPUJDBT IBCBO TJEP ZB
GPSNVMBEPT QPSFKFNQMP BCPSUP FVUB
OBTJB USBTQMBOUFTEFSHBOPT
MBCJPUJDB
CSBTJMFBDPOUSJCVZQSPQPOJFOEPQSP
CMFNBT FTQFDmDPT Z PSJHJOBMFT  MJHBEPT
BMBSFBMJEBETPDJPFDPONJDB QPMUJDBZ
DVMUVSBM EF MPT QBTFT EF "NSJDB -BUJ
OBZ FTQFDJBMNFOUF EFMBCSBTJMFB1PS
FKFNQMP  QSPCMFNBT EF TBMVE QCMJDB Z
EFTBGPTSFDVSSFOUFTRVFQSPWJFOFOEFTJ
UVBDJPOFTJOKVTUBTZEFFYDMVTJOTPDJBM
-BCJPUJDBCSBTJMFBFTVOFTGVFS[PUBS
EP  QPSRVF DVBOEP FNFSHF PDVSSB ZB
VODBNCJPEFNPEFMPFOFMNPWJNJFOUP
CJPUJDP NVOEJBM 5BM USBOTJDJO QBSB
EJHNUJDB GVF DBSBDUFSJ[BEB  QPS PUSB
QBSUF QPSFMUSOTJUPEFTEFVOBCJPUJDB
NBSDBEBNFOUFJOEJWJEVBMJTUBoDFOUSBEB
FOMPTQSPCMFNBTUJDPTSFTVMUBOUFTEFBD
UPTQFSTPOBMFT FTEFDJS FOMPTEFSFDIPT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

IVNBOPTEFQSJNFSBHFOFSBDJOoBVOB
CJPUJDBQCMJDBoEFDBSDUFSDPMFDUJWP 
NTQSFPDVQBEBQPSMBEJNFOTJOUJDB
EF MPT EFTBGPT QMBOUFBEPT QPS MB TBMVE
QCMJDB CBTBEBFOMPTEFSFDIPTIVNB
OPTEFTFHVOEBHFOFSBDJO FTEFDJS EF
MPT EFSFDIPT TPDJBMFT &O VO DPOUFYUP
EF DSFDJFOUF DPNQMFKJEBE  TF EFTQMJFHB
BCPSEBOEP QSFHVOUBT SFMBDJPOBEBT DPO
MPTEFSFDIPTEFUFSDFSBHFOFSBDJOoDPO
MBTHFOFSBDJPOFTGVUVSBToZEFDVBSUBHF
OFSBDJOoRVFBCBSDBOEFTBGPTBNCJFO
UBMFTZFDPMHJDPT
)VCPQSJNFSPVOBEFQFOEFODJBEFVO
NPEFMP UJDP FYUSBOKFSP oFM QBSBEJHNB
EFM QSJODJQJBMJTNP OPSUFBNFSJDBOPo 
DBTJ IFHFNOJDP FO MPT QSJNFSPT 
BPTEFIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPUJDBNVOEJBM
'VF QPSBTEFDJSMP MBiJOGBODJBwEFMB
CJPUJDB CSBTJMFB  MB FUBQB EF MPT BPT
4VSHJFOUPODFTVONPWJNJFOUPDS
UJDPSFTQFDUPEFNPEFMPTiJNQPSUBEPTw 
QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF EFM NPEFMP QSJODJQJB
MJTUB BDFSDB EF MB TBMVE QCMJDB &OUSB
NPTBRVFOMBiBEPMFTDFODJBwEFMBCJP
UJDBCSBTJMFB.JFOUSBTMMFHCBNPTBMB
GBTFiBEVMUBw DPNFO[BNPTBIBDFSVOB
FWBMVBDJOQSPGVOEB EPOEFFMQSJODJQBM
SFUP JNQMJDBCB iEJTUJOHVJS TJO TFQBSBS
Z VOJS TJO DPOGVOEJSw QSPCMFNBT CJP
UJDPT EF DBSDUFS QFSTPOBM Z QSPCMFNBT
CJPUJDPTQCMJDPT FTEFDJS EJGFSFODJBS
FOUSF HSBEPT EF JNQPSUBODJB Z BMDBODF
EF BMHVOPT QSPCMFNBT QBSB JOUFHSBSMPT
FO VO EPNJOJP NBSDBEP QPS VOB NB
ZPSDPNQSFOTJO1PESBNPTEFDJSRVF
FM NBSDP EF JOJDJP EF MB GBTF BEVMUB EF
MB CJPUJDB CSBTJMFB  FO TV CTRVFEB
QPS MB NBEVSF[  GVF FM QBUSPDJOJP EFM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

7* $POHSFTP .VOEJBM EF #JPUJDB FO


#SBTJMJB 
RVFTFDFOUSFOFMUFNB
i#JPUJDB 1PEFSF*OKVTUJDJBi (BSSBGBZ
1FTTJOJ 


-PTQSJNFSPTDPOHSFTPTEFCJP
UJDBZTBMVEFO#SBTJM
"OUFT EF MB DPOTPMJEBDJO EF MB CJPUJ
DBFOMBTPDJFEBECSBTJMFB IBCBWBSJBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFT Z HSVQPT EF FTUVEJP RVF
EJBMPHBCBO BDFSDB EF FTUBT DVFTUJPOFT
FOFMNVOEPEFMBTBMVE DPOVOOGB
TJT GVFSUF FO MB IVNBOJ[BDJO &O 4P
1BVMP CBKPMBEJSFDDJOEFMPTDBNJMJB
OPT VOBPSEFOSFMJHJPTBRVFUSBCBKBFO
TBMVE
ZFOBTPDJBDJODPOWBSJBTPUSBT
FOUJEBEFT IPTQJUBMBSJBT F JOTUJUVDJPOFT
VOJWFSTJUBSJBTMJHBEBTBFTUFNJTNPN
CJUP  DPOGFTJPOBMFT P OP DPOGFTJPOBMFT 
TFQBUSPDJOVOBTFSJFEFDVBUSPFWFOUPT
BOVBMFTFOCJPUJDBZTBMVE BDPNJFO[PT
ZBNFEJBEPTEFMPTBPT FOMBDJV
EBEEF4P1BVMP 1FTTJOJZ#BSDIJGPO
UBJOF 

&M 1SJNFS $POHSFTP EF #JPUJDB Z 4B
MVE  Z  EF KVOJP EF 
 USBU
QSJODJQBMNFOUF EF DVFTUJPOFT CJPUJ
DBTFNFSHFOUFTTPCSFFMQSJODJQJPEFMB
WJEB FM TFHVOEP  BM  EF NBS[P EF

NBUFSJBTSFGFSFOUFTBMBNVFSUFZ
BMNPSJSFMUFSDFSP BMEFKVOJPEF

QSPQVTPVOBEJTDVTJOQSPGVOEB
TPCSFCJPUJDBZHFOUJDB ZFMDVBSUP 
BMEFBHPTUPEF
EFCBUJTPCSF
CJPUJDBZHMPCBMJ[BDJO
0USBSFBEFUSBCBKPJNQPSUBOUFEFMPT
DBNJMJBOPT FT MB IVNBOJ[BDJO Z MB SF
nFYJO QBTUPSBM FO FM NVOEP EF MB TB





6OBSBEJPHSBGBEFMBCJPUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF

MVE&TBDPOTUJUVZFFMUFNBiCJPUJDB MBT
SFMJHJPOFTZMBUJDBUFPMHJDBw EPOEFTF
QJFOTBO MBT DVFTUJPOFT UJDBT EF MB WJEB
EFTEF MB QFSTQFDUJWB EF WBMPSFT UJDPT
DSJTUJBOPT +VOUP DPO MB 1BTUPSBM EF MB
4BMVEEFMB$POGFSFODJB/BDJPOBMEFMPT
0CJTQPT #SBTJMFPT $/##
 FM *OTUJ
UVUP$BNJMJBOPEF1BTUPSBMEFMB4BMVE
*$"14
IBPSHBOJ[BEPTVDFTJWBNFOUF 
B QBSUJS EF    DPOHSFTPT OBDJP
OBMFTEFIVNBOJ[BDJOZQBTUPSBMEFMB
TBMVE *$"14 

&TBJOJDJBUJWBFYJHFMBIVNBOJ[BDJOFO
MPTDVJEBEPTZTFSWJDJPTNEJDPTFOVOB
QPDB EF DSFDJFOUF EFTQFSTPOBMJ[BDJO
Z UFDOPMPHJ[BDJO EF TUPT  CVTDBOEP
TPMVDJPOFTQBSBMPTQSPCMFNBTRVFIPZ
MMBNBSBNPTEFiCJPUJDBDMOJDBw)BDF
NPTGSFOUFBEJMFNBTUJDPTFNFSHFOUFT
DBVTBEPT QPS MB DJFODJB Z MB UFDOPMPHB
RVF JOUFSGFSJFSFO DPO MB OBUVSBMF[B IV
NBOB Z RVF EFTFBO DBNCJBSMB SFQSP
EVDDJOBTJTUJEB USBTQMBOUFT JOHFOJFSB
HFOUJDB DMPOBDJO FOUSFPUSPT
-BSF
nFYJOTFGVOEBFOVOBQFSTQFDUJWBUJDB
EJBMHJDPUFPMHJDB  SFDFQUJWB B EFCBUJS
DPODJFOUmDPT UFMPHPT mMTPGPTZQSP
GFTJPOBMFTEFTBMVEFOMBWBOHVBSEJBEFM
QSPDFTP
&TF NPWJNJFOUP EF IVNBOJ[BDJO Z
QBTUPSBMFOFMNVOEPEFMBTBMVETJHVF
IPZTVDVSTPOPSNBM

-B4PDJFEBE#SBTJMFBEF#JPUJ
DB 4##

&OFTUFNPNFOUP RVFQSFDFEFBMTVSHJ
NJFOUPEFVOBPSHBOJ[BDJORVFSFOBZ
PSHBOJDF JOJDJBUJWBT CJPUJDBT FYQSFTJWBT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

FO FM QBT  UFOFNPT MB "TPDJBDJO #SB


TJMFB EF UJDB .EJDB "#3"%&.

RVF NTBMMEFMBEJTDVTJOEFDVFTUJP
OFTUJDBTFONFEJDJOB SFnFYJPOBUBN
CJOBDFSDBEFDVFTUJPOFTCJPUJDBT&O
TUB TF EFCF SFDPOPDFS FM MJEFSB[HP EF
"MGPOTP3FOBUP.FJSB
-B4PDJFEBE#SBTJMFBEF#JPUJDB 4##

DPNFO[ DPNP VO HSVQP JOGPSNBM
FM  EF BHPTUP EF   FO #PUVDBUV
41
 6OJWFSTJEBEF &TUBEVBM 1BVMJTUB
6/&41
DPOFMMJEFSB[HPEF8JMMJBN
4BBE)PTTOF ZGVFFTUBCMFDJEBGPSNBM
NFOUFFMEFGFCSFSPEF$VFOUB
DPONTEFNJFNCSPT EFWBSJBEBT
SFBT FO MBT DJFODJBT EF MB WJEB Z EF MB
TBMVE JOWFTUJHBEPSFTEFDJFODJBTIVNB
OBT mMTPGPT UFMPHPT FOUSFPUSPTQPS
MPUBOUPUJFOFDBSDUFSQMVSBMJTUBZNVM
UJEJTDJQMJOBSJP
-B 4## DPNFO[ B QVCMJDBS FO 
TVQFSJEJDPDJFOUmDPUSJNFTUSBM3FWJT
UB#SBTJMFJSBEF#JPUJDB"EFNT WBSJBT
TFDDJPOFTSFHJPOBMFTEFMB4## RVFFYJT
UFOMFHBMNFOUF NBOUJFOFOVOBJOUFOTB
BDUJWJEBE FEVDBUJWB Z EF QVCMJDBDJO
QPSFKFNQMP 3P(SBOEFEP4VM 1PSUP
"MFHSF
 1BSBO -POESJOB
 4P 1BVMP
 -B4##QBUSPDJOTFJTDPOHSFTPTOBDJPOBMFTEF
CJPUJDB FO#SBTJMJB #JPUJDBFOFM4JHMP
7FJOUJVOP
FO1PSUP"MFHSF 34

FO #SBTJMJB  TJNVMUOFBNFOUF DPO FM 7* $PO
HSFTP .VOEJBM EF #JPUJDB  EFEJDBEP B #JP
UJDB 1PEFSF*OKVTUJDJBFO3FDJGF 1&

BDFSDBEF#JPUJDBZ$JVEBEBOBFO'P[
EF*HVB[ 13
DPOFMUFNBDFOUSBM.FEJP"N
CJFOUFZ7JEB)VNBOB1PSMBNJTNBQPDBTF
PSHBOJ[ FM 1SJNFS $POHSFTP EF #JPUJDB EFM
.FSDPTVSZFMGPSPEF3&%#*046/&4$0 
FO4P1BVMP 41
RVFBCPSEBMUFNB
#JPUJDBZ$POTUSVDDJO4PDJBM)PZ





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

41
 3P EF +BOFJSP 3P EF +BOFJSP

#SBTJMJB %'
Z1FSOBNCVDP 3FDJGF

-B CJPUJDB CSBTJMFB QBSUJDJQB FO VO
EJMPHP DPOUJOVP DPO FM NPWJNJFOUP
CJPUJDPNVOEJBM"QBSUJSEFNV
DIPT CJPFUJDJTUBT CSBTJMFPT QBSUJDJQBO
FO MB +VOUB %JSFDUJWB EF MB "TPDJBDJO
*OUFSOBDJPOBM EF #JPUJDB *"#
 -B
4##EJBMPHBJOUFOTBNFOUFDPOPUSBBTP
DJBDJO FVSPQFB EF CJPUJDB FTUBCMFDJEB
FO(JKO &TQBBoMB4PDJFEBE*OUFSOB
DJPOBMEF#JPUJDB 4*#*
o RVF CBKPMB
EJSFDDJOEF.BSDFMP1BMBDJPT IBQBUSP
DJOBEPBMHVOPTDPOHSFTPTJOUFSOBDJPOB
MFT UPEPTFO&TQBB&O-BUJOPBNSJDB
IB FTUBEP QSFTFOUF IBDF NVDIPT BPT
FO MPT DPOHSFTPT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT EF
CJPUJDB QSPNPWJEPT QPS MB 'FEFSBDJO
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF *OTUJUVDJPOFT EF
#JPUJDB '&-"*#&
5BNCJONBOUJF
OFSFMBDJODPOMB3FE#JPUJDB-BUJOPB
NFSJDBOBZEFM$BSJCFEFMB6/&4$0 
FTUBCMFDJEB PmDJBMNFOUF FO $BODO 
.YJDP  FO  .T SFDJFOUFNFOUF 
BQBSUJSEFM7**$POHSFTP#SBTJMFPEF
#JPUJDB EFBHPTUPBMEFTFQUJFN
CSFEF
JOnVZFEFDJTJWBNFOUFFO
FMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEFMB"TPDJBDJO-BUJ
OP"NFSJDBOBEF#JPUJDB "-#"

&O FM EPNJOJP EF MB QSPEVDDJO DJFO
UmDB  MB DPNVOJEBE CJPUJDB CSBTJMFB
TF IB PDVQBEP EF UFNBT EJWFSTPT MJHB
EPTBMBWJEBIVNBOB"MHVOPTUSBCBKPT
IBO TJEP USBEVDJEPT BM QPSUVHVT DPO
MB QBSUJDJQBDJO JNQPSUBOUF EF MB DBTB
FEJUPSJBM &EJFT -PZPMB 1PS FKFNQMP 
i'VOEBNFOUPT EF CJPUJDBw 
 Z
i'VOEBNFOUPTEF#JPUJDB$SJTU0SUP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EPYBw 
EF5SJTUBO&OHFMIBSEU+S
i1SJODJQJPTEFUJDB#JPNEJDBw #FBV
DIBNQZ$IJMESFTT
i*OUSPEVDDJOBMB
#JPUJDBw (VZ%VSBOE
%FMBQSFOTB
EF 6OJWFSTJEBEF EP 4BHSBEP $PSBP
#BVSV41
TFEFTUBDBMBPCSBEF'SBO
DJTDP #FMMJOP i'VOEBNFOUPT EF CJP
UJDB BTQFDUPT BOUSPQPMHJDPT  NPSBMFT
Z POUPMHJDPTw &EVTD  #BVSV  

6OEPDVNFOUPJNQPSUBOUFEF$*0.4 
BQSPCBEP FO   MBT i1BVUBT UJDBT
JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT QBSB MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
CJPNEJDBDPOTFSFTIVNBOPTw GVFQV
CMJDBEPFO#SBTJMFOVOBDPFEJDJOQPS
&EJFT -PZPMB Z $FOUSP 6OJWFSTJUSJP
4P$BNJMP 1SBEP 

*OJDJBUJWBT FTQFDmDBT EF JNQPSUBODJB
JOUFSOBDJPOBM TPO MBT SFVOJPOFT FOUSF
JOTUJUVDJPOFT CJPUJDBT EF 1PSUVHBM Z
#SBTJM MB QSJNFSB SFBMJ[BEB FO -JTCPB
MB TFHVOEB FO #SBTJMJB  FO OPWJFNCSF
EF EVSBOUFFM$POHSFTP.VOEJBM
EF#JPUJDB DVZPUFNBQSJODJQBMGVFMB
FEVDBDJO FO CJPUJDB &M UFSDFSP FO MB
JTMB EF "[PSFT  FO 1POUB %FMHBEB  FO
 DPOFMUFNBi6OBPWBSJBTCJP
UJDBTFOMBFWPMVDJOEFMBTTPDJFEBEFTw
/FWFTZ-JNB 
FMDVBSUPFO4P
1BVMP FO TPCSFFMUFNBi#JPUJDB
Z7VMOFSBCJMJEBEw
&M USBCBKP JOUFHSBEPS Z EJBMHJDP EF MB
4##FOFMQBTQSPQPSDJPODSFEJCJMJEBE
BM#SBTJMBOUFMB"TPDJBDJO*OUFSOBDJPOBM
EF#JPUJDBQBSBFMQBUSPDJOJP FO 
EFM 7* $POHSFTP .VOEJBM EF #JPUJ
DB FO#SBTJMJB%'1SPQPOJFOEPDPNP
UFNB DFOUSBM MBT SFMBDJPOFT FOUSF i#JP
UJDB  1PEFS Z *OKVTUJDJBw  FM DPOHSFTP





6OBSBEJPHSBGBEFMBCJPUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF

JOTDSJCJFOMBBHFOEBEFMBTDVFTUJPOFT
CJPUJDBTNVOEJBMFTMPTUFNBTRVFQSP
WJFOFO EF MB FYDMVTJO  QSFTFOUF FO MB
QFSJGFSJB EFM QMBOFUB Z FO MPT MMBNBEPT
QBTFTFNFSHFOUFTPFOWBTEFEFTBSSPMMP
1FTTJOJ 


'FJSBEF4BOUBOB EPOEFUSBCBKBMBSFQV
UBEBHFOFUJTUB&MJBOFEF"[FWFEP

*OJDJBUJWBTFEVDBUJWBTJOTUJUVDJP
OBMFTCSBTJMFBT

&OFTUBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTTFIBGPSNBEPFM
/DMFP *OUFSJOTUJUVDJPOBM EF #JPUJDB
-BTBDUJWJEBEFTTFEFTBSSPMMBOFOMBTSFBT
EFBZVEB FEVDBDJOFJOWFTUJHBDJO&O
MPRVFDPODJFSOFBFTUBMUJNB MB$PNJ
TJOEF*OWFTUJHBDJOZUJDBFO4BMVE 
BTPDJBEB BM (SVQP EF *OWFTUJHBDJO Z
&TUVEJPT(SBEVBEPTEF)$1" DSFBEP
FO FTSFTQPOTBCMFEFMBFWBMVBDJO
EFBTQFDUPTUJDPT

&O#SBTJMFYJTUFONVDIBTJOJDJBUJWBTEF
EFTBSSPMMPFOCJPUJDB EFDBSDUFSDPOGF
TJPOBMPTFDVMBS FOJOTUJUVDJPOFTQCMJ
DBTPQSJWBEBT"EFNT FMUSBCBKPJOEF
QFOEJFOUFEFFYQFSUPT FOEJWFSTPTTJUJPT
EFMQBT DPNFO[BTFSEFTBSSPMMBEPNT
FYQSFTJWBNFOUF FO MB EDBEB EF 
)BZVOBDPOWJWFODJBTBOBZSFTQFUVPTB
DPO MPT WBMPSFT UJDPT DBSBDUFSTUJDPT EF
DBEB JOJDJBUJWB Z TF CVTDB VO DPOUFYUP
NBSDBEP QPS FM QMVSBMJTNP oDBEB WF[
NTTFDVMBSJ[BEPo MBUPMFSBODJBZFMEJ
MPHP*OOVNFSBCMFTJOJDJBUJWBTEFNVFT
USBOMBWJUBMJEBEEFMBCJPUJDB UBNCJO
OPUPSJB FO MB NPUJWBDJO EF MPT JOWFT
UJHBEPSFTKWFOFTZFOMBSFBMJ[BDJOEF
WBSJBEPT FWFOUPT  KPSOBEBT  TFNJOBSJPT
Z DPOHSFTPT  BEFNT EF NVDIBT QVCMJ
DBDJPOFTFTQFDmDBT QSJODJQBMNFOUFEFM
DBNQPEFMBTBMVE4VSHFOSBNBTSFHJP
OBMFTEFMB4## DPNPMBEF3FDJGF DPO
EVDJEB QPS .BSJB $MBSB "MCVRVFSRVF 
RVFPSHBOJ[VODPOHSFTPCSBTJMFPEF
CJPUJDBVOHSVQPRVFFNFSHJFO#FMP
)PSJ[POUF .(
 GPSNBEP QPS (FSBM
EP%SVNPOE %JSDFV(SFDPZ"OUPOJP
.PUB ZFO#BIB FOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

-B6OJWFSTJEBE'FEFSBMEF3P
(SBOEFEP4VM 6'3(4
)PT
QJUBMEF$MOJDBTEF1PSUP"MFHSF
)$1"

&M $PNJU EF UJDB FO *OWFTUJHBDJO


$&*
EF6'3(4OBDJFO DPPS
EJOBEP QPS +PT 3PCFSUP (PMEJN -BT
BDUJWJEBEFT EF FOTFBO[B DPNFO[BSPO
FO   DPO VO DVSTP JOUFOTJWP FO
CJPUJDB QSPNPWJEP B USBWT FM )$1" 
FO FM DVBM QBSUJDJQ FM QSPGFTPS 3PCFSU
7FBUDI  EFM ,FOOFEZ *OTUJUVUF PG &UIJDT
"QBSUJSEF FMDVSTP$MOJDB.
EJDBEF6'3(4JODMVZFFOTVQMBOEF
FTUVEJPTBTJHOBUVSBTMJHBEBTBMBCJPUJ
DB &O FM SFB EF MB CJPUJDB DMOJDB TF
FTUBCMFDJVOQSPHSBNBFOCBKPMB
DPPSEJOBDJOEF$BSMPT'FSOBOEP'SBO
DJTDPOJ&O FM/DMFPEF#JPUJDB
QSPNPWJFM9*DVSTPEFJOUSPEVDDJOZ
NBOUJFOFVOQPSUBMFO*OUFSOFUDPOTJEF
SBEPVOPEFMPTNFKPSFTFO#SBTJM





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

-B1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BU
MJDBEF3P(SBOEFEP4VM 16$
34
1PSUP"MFHSF&M/DMFPEF
&TUVEJPT#JPUJDPTZFM$PNJUEF
UJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJO
#BKP MB EJSFDDJO EF +PBRVO $MPUFU 
BDUVBM EFDBOP EF MB VOJWFSTJEBE  FYJT
UFO FO 16$34  EFTEF   BTJHOB
UVSBT CJPUJDBT FO QSFHSBEPT EF NFEJ
DJOB&OUSFTVTJOWFTUJHBEPSFTEFCFNPT
NFODJPOBS B %MJP ,JQFS  +VTTBSB EF
"[BNCVKBZ.BSJOHFMB#BEBMPUJ&TMB
QSJNFSB VOJWFSTJEBE CSBTJMFB DPO VO
QSPHSBNBBDBENJDPEFFOUSFOBNJFOUP
FO QSPCMFNBTZEJMFNBTCJPUJDPTQBSB
QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF MB TBMVE &M ODMFP TF
DPOTUJUVZFMEFKVOJPEFKVOUP
DPO FM $PNJU EF #JPUJDB EFM )PTQJ
UBM 4BO -VDBT Z EF MB &TDVFMB .EJDB
EF16$34 BEKVOUPBMBTBENJOJTUSB
DJPOFTEFMBTEPTJOTUJUVDJPOFT ZIBQV
CMJDBEPWBSJPTUSBCBKPT BMHVOPTFTDSJUPT
ZP DPPSEJOBEPT QPS +PBRVO $MPUFU
i#JPUJDB VNB BQSPYJNBPw $MPUFU 

i#JPUJDB.FJPBNCJFOUF TB
EFQCMJDB OPWBTUFDOPMPHBTwi%FPO
UPMPHJB NEJDB  EJSFJUP  QTJDPMPHJB F
NBUFSJBM HFOUJDP IVNBOPw $MPUFU 

 Z i#JPUJDB VNB WJTP QBOPS
NJDBw $MPUFU 'FJK0MJWFJSB 

$MPUFU 'FJK0MJWFJSB 


6OJWFSTJEBEEF4P1BVMP
641
4P1BVMP 41

&M*OTUJUVUPTDBS'SFJSFIBQSPNPWJEP
NVDIBTSFVOJPOFT KPSOBEBTZTFNJOBSJPT
EFCJPUJDBFOMBTVOJWFSTJEBEFTQCMJDBT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

CSBTJMFBT UPEPTTPCSFUFNBTDBOEFOUFT
FO#SBTJM&TDPOPDJEPDPNPFTDVFMBEF
MBCJPUJDBBVUPOPNJTUBPEFMBSFnFYJO
BVUOPNB EFGFOEJEBQPS.BSDP4FHSF 
RVJFOFEJUDPO$MBVEF$PIFOFMMJCSP
i#JPUJDBw 4FHSFZ$PIFO 
.T
SFDJFOUFNFOUF .BSDP4FHSFQVCMJDi"
RVFTUPUJDBFBTBEFIVNBOBw&OMB
QFSTQFDUJWB EF 4FHSF  MB FYQSFTJO iUJ
DBEFMBSFnFYJOBVUOPNBwJOEJDBTV
DBSDUFSQFSTPOBMZJOEJWJEVBM VOBUJDB
FO MB DVBM MPT TVKFUPT  QPS NFEJP EF MB
JOUSPTQFDDJO USBFOBMBTVQFSmDJFTFO
TBDJPOFTRVFNVDIBTWFDFTFTUOFODPO
nJDUP FJOUFOUBOQFOTBSFOTVTQSPQJBT
TPMVDJPOFT QBSB FMMPT TF EFTFB VUJMJ[BS
VOB KFSBSRVB EF WBMPSFT EFUFSNJOBEB
QPSMBQFSTPOBDPOUPEBMBMJCFSUBEQP
TJCMF &T VOB UJDB QBUFOUFNFOUF MJCFS
UBSJB FOMBDVBMFMiCJPFUJDJTUBwJOUFOUB
FMFHJS MP RVF DPOTJEFSB EF NBZPS P EF
NFOPS WBMPS FO DBEB TJUVBDJO  ZB TFB
RVFJNQMJRVFBPUSBQFSTPOB BMBDPNV
OJEBEPBMQMBOFUB
&OFM$PMFHJPEF4BMVE1CMJDBFTEFT
UBDBCMF FM USBCBKP EF 1BVMP 'PSUFT  RVF
MJEFSBMBSFnFYJOFOCJPUJDBZDVFTUJP
OFT EF TBMVE QCMJDB &T DPPSEJOBEPS
BTPDJBEPEFi#JPUJDBF4BEF1CMJDBw
'PSUFTZ;CPMJ 
&MNB;CPMJZ
$SJTUJOB .B[[BSPMP SFnFYJPOBO BDFSDB
EFMBCJPUJDBFOFMDPOUFYUPEFMBQSD
UJDB EF FOGFSNFSB 0HVJTTP Z ;CPMJ 

 %BMUPO 3BNPT FTQFDVMB TPCSF
CJPUJDB FO PEPOUPMPHB Z FT UBNCJO
NJFNCSPDPSSFTQPOEJFOUFEFMB"DBEF
NJB1POUJmDJBQBSBMB7JEB 3PNB






6OBSBEJPHSBGBEFMBCJPUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF

6OJWFSTJEBEEF#SBTJMJB 6O#

/DMFPEF&TUVEJPT.VMUJEJTDJQMJ
OBSJPT"WBO[BEPT/DMFPEF&T
UVEJPTF*OWFTUJHBDJOFO#JPUJDB
/&1&#
#SBTJMJB%'
"QBSUJSEFTVGVOEBDJO FO FTU
CBKP MB EJSFDDJO EF 7PMOFJ (BSSBGB
&O BHPTUP EF  FM /&1&# DSF TV
QSJNFSDVSTPEFQSFHSBEPMBUPTFOTVFO
CJPUJDB1VCMJDBMHVOPTUSBCBKPT FOUSF
MPT DVBMFT TF FODVFOUSBO i0 NFSDBEP
IVNBOP FTUVEP CJPUJDP EB DPNQSB F
WFOEB EF QBSUFT EP DPSQPw #FSMJOHVFS
(BSSBGB 
i"#JPUJDBOPTDV
MP99*w (BSSBGB$PTUB 
i#JP
UJDBDPUJEJBOBw #FSMJOHVFS 

&OBTPDJBDJODPOFMQSPHSBNBEFQPT
HSBEPFODJFODJBTEFMBTBMVEEFMB6O# 
FTUF ODMFP PGSFDF  EFTEF   VOB
NBFTUSBZVOEPDUPSBEP ZMJEFSBMB$
UFESB6/&4$0EF#JPUJDB (BSSBGBZ
$PSEO 

(BSSBGBQSPQPOFFMDPODFQUPEFCJPUJ
DBEFMBTiTJUVBDJPOFTFNFSHFOUFTwPEF
MPTiQSPCMFNBTFYUSFNPTwPEFGSPOUFSB
&MDPODFQUPiFNFSHFOUFwTFSFmFSFBMBT
TJUVBDJPOFTRVFQSPWJFOFOEFMEFTBSSPMMP
BDFMFSBEPEFMBUFDOPDJFODJBFOMPTBPT
 1PS FKFNQMP  USBTQMBOUFT EF SHB
OPTZUFKJEPTIVNBOPTFMQSPZFDUPEFM
(FOPNB)VNBOPZUPEPTMPTBTQFDUPT
EF MB HFONJDB MBT OVFWBT UFDOPMPHBT
SFQSPEVDUJWBT  JODMVZFOEP MB DMPOBDJO
SFQSPEVDUJWB Z UFSBQVUJDB MPT BMJNFO
UPTUSBTHOJDPTMBTQBUFOUFTMBQSFTFSWB
DJO TVTUFOUBCMF Z MB CJPEJWFSTJEBE EFM
BNCJFOUFMBJOWFTUJHBDJODPOBOJNBMFT
IVNBOPTZOPIVNBOPT-BCJPUJDBEF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

iTJUVBDJPOFT QFSTJTUFOUFTw  FO DBNCJP 


QMBOUFB FOGPDBS MPT QSPCMFNBT RVF IJT
USJDBNFOUFQFSNBOFDFOBQFTBSEFUPEB
MBFWPMVDJOEFMBDJFODJBZEFMBTPDJFEBE
EFTEFFMJOJDJPEFMBIJTUPSJBEFMBIVNB
OJEBE&OUSFTUPTQPEFNPTNFODJPOBS
MBFYDMVTJOTPDJBM MBEJTDSJNJOBDJO FM
SBDJTNP JOFRVJEBEFTEFMUSBCBKP MBWVM
OFSBCJMJEBE MBWJPMFODJB MBEJTUSJCVDJO
JOKVTUBEFSFDVSTPTFOFMDBNQPEFMBTB
MVEZFMBCPSUPZMBFVUBOBTJB (BSSBGB 
,PUUPXZ4BBEB 


&M$POTFKP'FEFSBMEF.FEJDJOB
$'.
#SBTJMJB %'

&M QSJNFS QFSJEJDP CSBTJMFP EF FTUBT


NBUFSJBT #JPUJDB BQBSFDFFODPO
VOBBNQMJBDJSDVMBDJOFOFMDBNQPEFMB
TBMVE PDVQOEPTFQSFQPOEFSBOUFNFOUF
EFDVFTUJPOFTEFMSFBEFMBUJDBNEJ
DB"MHVOBTNPOPHSBGBTQVCMJDBEBTTPO
i4*%"Z#JPUJDBwi1BDJFOUFT5FSNJOB
MFTw i"CPSUP &VUBOBTJB &SSPSFT.EJ
DPTwi*OWFTUJHBDJOFOTFSFTIVNBOPTw
iUJDBEFMBFOTFBO[BBMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFT
EFTBMVEwi1PMUJDB%FNPHSmDBwiUJ
DBEFMBBTJHOBDJOEFSFDVSTPTFOTBMVEw
iUJDB Z HFOUJDBw  iUJDB Z WJPMFODJBw 
FOUSFPUSBT5PEBTMBTFEJDJPOFTFTUOEJT
QPOJCMFTFOXXXQPSUBMNFEJDPPSHCS
&OUSF PUSBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT EFM $'.
EFTUBDBNPT EPT USBCBKPT DPMFDUJWPT
i%FTBmPT UJDPTw  QVCMJDBEP FO  
DPPSEJOBEPQPS+PT&CFSJFOPT"TTBE F
i*OJDJBP#JPUJDBw $PTUB (BSSBGBZ
0TFMLB  
 RVF IB UFOJEP VO HSBO
JNQBDUPFOMBSFBEFMBTBMVE





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

-B4PDJFEBE#SBTJMFBEF5FPMP
HB.PSBM
&O FTUB TPDJFEBE IBZ BMHVOPT UFMPHPT
NPSBMFTEFSFQVUBDJOJOUFSOBDJPOBMFO
UJDB UFPMHJDB EFEJDBEPT B MB SFnFYJO
CJPUJDB&OUSFPUSPT .SDJP'BCSJEPT
"OKPT "MGPOTJBOVN  4P 1BVMP  41

RVF USBCBKB FO DVFTUJPOFT EF CJPUJDB
UFPMHJDBFOFMNVOEPEFMBFYDMVTJO 
FOVOBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMBUFPMPHBEFMBMJ
CFSBDJO)BQSPEVDJEPNBUFSJBMEFSF
GFSFODJBQBSBUPEPTMPTQBTFTEF-BUJOP
BNSJDBFOMBDPMFDDJO5FPMPHB.PSBM
FO "NSJDB -BUJOB &OUSF PUSPT UFYUPT
i#JPUJDB FO DMBWF MJCFSBDJPOJTUBw "O
KPT 
"OUPOJP.PTFS EFM*OTUJUVUP
'SBODJTDBOPEF5FPMPHBEF1FUSQPMJT 
QVCMJDi{#JPUFDOPMPHJBFCJPUJDB1BSB
POEFWBNPT w .PTFS 
-FPOBSE
.BSUJO  UFMPHP JSMBOET SFEFOUPSJTUB
RVFWJWJNVDIPTBPTFO#SBTJMZNV
SJFO QVCMJDVOUSBCBKPEFSJWB
EPEFTVUFTJTEPDUPSBMFOUFPMPHBNPSBM
DPO FM UUVMP i" UJDB .EJDB F P 1B
DJFOUF5FSNJOBM-FJUVSBUJDPUFPMHJDB
EPTDEJHPTCSBTJMFJSPTEFUJDBNEJDBw
.BSUJO  
 6OB NFODJO NFSFDF
UBNCJO -FPOBSEP #P  QJPOFSP EF MB
5FPMPHB EF MB -JCFSBDJO FO "NSJDB
-BUJOB  JOUFSOBDJPOBMNFOUF SFQVUBEP
6OB QBSUF TJHOJmDBUJWB EF TV FYUFOTB
QSPEVDDJOBDBENJDBFTVOBSFnFYJO
BDFSDB EF MB UFPMPHB FO TVT SFMBDJPOFT
DPO MB FDPMPHB Z FM NFEJPBNCJFOUF
#PUBNCJOJOUFHSFMHSVQPJOUFSOB
DJPOBMRVFTVTDSJCJMBGBNPTB$BSUBEF
MB5JFSSB EPDVNFOUPRVFMB6/&4$0
VUJMJ[B EFTEF FOUPODFT DPO QSPQTJUPT
FEVDBUJWPT 5SFT USBCBKPT TVZPT EFCFO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

TFS NFODJPOBEPT i(SJUP EPT QPCSFT


HSJUPEB5FSSBw #P 
iUJDBEB
7JEBw #P 
ZiUJDBF.PSBMB
CVTDBEPTGVOEBNFOUPTw #P 


$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUBSJP4P$BNJ
MP 4P1BVMP 41

0SHBOJTNP QJPOFSP FO #SBTJM  QBUSP


DJO MPT DPOHSFTPT EF CJPUJDB Z TBMVE
BOUFEJDIPT FO FM QFSPEP RVF QSFDFEF
FM FTUBCMFDJNJFOUP EF MB 4PDJFEBE #SB
TJMFBEF#JPUJDB&M$FOUSPQVCMJDB0
.VOEPEB4BEF RVFQSFTFOUBJOJOUF
SSVNQJEBNFOUF BQBSUJSEF USB
CBKPT DJFOUmDPT FTQFDJBMJ[BEPT Z RVF
JOUSPEVKP MBT DVFTUJPOFT CJPUJDBT FO
FM QBT B mOBMFT EF MPT  Z DPNJFO
[PT EF MPT  4F IBO QVCMJDBEP DJODP
FEJDJPOFT NPOPHSmDBT  B TBCFS 
i#JPUJDBw W O TFQUJFNCSFPD
UVCSF
  i#JPUJDB VOB QFSTQFDUJ
WB CSBTJMFBw W   O   B KBONBS

i#JPUJDB DVJEBSZTBMVEw W 
O KVMJPTFQUJFNCSF
i#JPUJDB
QSJNFSBT JOTJOVBDJPOFT  GVOEBDJPOFT
Z FYQFSJFODJBT FEVDBUJWBT CSBTJMFBTw
W O KVMTFQU
i#JPUJDB
)VNBOJ[BDJO FO TBMVE  WVMOFSBCJMJ
EBE UFDOPDJFODJBZUJDBFOMBJOWFTUJ
HBDJOw W O PDUEFD
1PSPUSB
QBSUF FOFM$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUBSJP
4P$BNJMPQSPEVKPFMQSJNFSNBOVBM
CSBTJMFP QBSB MPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF TB
MVE PSJHJOBMNFOUFUJUVMBEPi#JPUJDBF
4BEFw ZEFTQVTi1SPCMFNBTEF#JP
UJDBw RVFFOUVWPTVBFEJDJO
BDUVBMJ[BEB Z BNQMJBEB 1FTTJOJ Z #BS
$G0.VOEPEB4BEF WO 






6OBSBEJPHSBGBEFMBCJPUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF

DIJGPOUBJOF 
5BNCJOBDPHJFM
USBCBKPEF)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS BVUPSEF
NVDIPT BSUDVMPT QVCMJDBEPT FO FM QF
SJEJDP0.VOEPEB4BEF ZBMHVOPT
MJCSPT DPNP i#JPUJDB  OPWP DPODFJUP
B DBNJOIP EP DPOTFOTPw -FQBSHOFVS 

 Z EFM UFMPHP .SDJP 'BCSJ EPT
"OKPT #BSDIJGPOUBJOF 

-B JOWFTUJHBDJO TPCSF QSPCMFNBT EF
CJPUJDBFOFMmOBMEFMBWJEBHFOFSMB
QVCMJDBDJOEFVOBUSJMPHBEFUSBCBKPT
EF -FP 1FTTJOJ  USBEVDJEB BM FTQBPM
FO .YJDP QPS &EJDJPOFT %BCBS 4PO
MJCSPT QVCMJDBEPT QPS &EJFT -PZPMB
i%JTUBOTJB BU RVBOEP QSPMPOHBS B
WJEBw 1FTTJOJ  
 i&VUBOBTJB QPS
RVFBCSFWJBSBWJEB w 
Zi)VNB
OJ[BPFDVJEBEPTQBMJBUJWPTw SBFE 

&OFMNCJUPEFMPTQSPCMFNBT
CJPUJDPT EFM QSJODJQJP EF MB WJEB  GVF
QVCMJDBEP VO USBCBKP EF $ISJTUJBO EF
1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOFi#JPUJDBFJO
DJPEBWJEBBMHVOTEFTBmPTw0USPTUSB
CBKPTEFFTUFBVUPSTPOi4BEF1CMJDB
 #JPUJDB w #BSDIJGPOUBJOF  

Z  DPO -FP 1FTTJOJ  i#JPUJDB BMHVOT
EFTBmPTw #BSDIJGPOUBJOF  1FTTJOJ 


&O FTUF$FOUSPDSF QSPQJBNFO
UF MBQSJNFSB.BFTUSBFO#JPUJDBEFM
#SBTJM4VMOFBEFJOWFTUJHBDJOFTCJP
UJDBFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJODPOTFSFTWJWPT
3FTQFDUPEFMBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSOBDJPOB
MFT FM$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUBSJP4P$BNJMP
FTUBTPDJBEPDPOFM$FOUFSGPS$MJOJDBM
#JPFUIJDT EF (FPSHFUPXO 6OJWFSTJUZ Z
F ,FOOFEZ *OTUJUVUF EF 8BTIJOHUPO 
%$ &&66FM1SPHSBNBEF$VJEB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EPT 1BMJBUJWPT EFM $PMFHJP .EJDP EF


6OJWFSTJUZPG5PSPOUPZDPOFM*OTUJUVUP
EF #JPUJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUMJDB
1PSUVHVFTB 1PSUVHBM


6OJWFSTJEBE6OJTJOPT4P-FP
QPMEP 34

&TB VOJWFSTJEBE NBOUJFOF BM *OTUJUV


UP )VNBOJUBT *)6
 DVZP PCKFUJWP
QSJODJQBM FT CVTDBS SFTQVFTUBT QBSB MPT
HSBOEFTEFTBGPTEFOVFTUSPUJFNQPEFT
EFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMIVNBOJTNPTPDJBM
DSJTUJBOP JOUFHSBOEPFOTVFTGVFS[PUSFT
HSBOEFT FKFT RVF CVTDBO MB QSPNPDJO
EFBDUJWJEBEFTUSBOTEJTDJQMJOBSJBTUJDB 
USBCBKPZUFPMPHBQCMJDB
&M *)6 QSFUFOEF DPOUSJCVJS B MB SFBMJ
[BDJOEFMBNJTJOEF6OJTJOPTDPNP
VOJWFSTJEBE KFTVJUB EJBDPOB EF MB GF 
QSPNPDJOEFMBKVTUJDJBZEJMPHPDVM
UVSBMFJOUFSSFMJHJPTP&OUSFPUSBTJOJDJB
UJWBT  QVCMJDB *)6  VO TFNBOBSJP FO
MOFBDPOQSPWPDBEPSFTUFNBTNPEFSOPT
EFMBDJFODJBFOJOUFSGB[DPOMBUJDB
&TBVOJWFSTJEBEQVCMJDFMQSJNFSUSBCB
KPTPCSFCJPUJDBFO#SBTJMMBUSBEVDDJO
EFF.BJO*TTVFTJO#JPFUIJDT -PTUF
NBTQSJODJQBMFTFOCJPUJDB
QPS"OESFX
$7BSHB FEJUBEPFOMPTFO&&66 
USBEVDJEP QPS (VJEP &EHBSE 8FO[FM
DPO FM UUVMP i1SPCMFNBT EF #JPUJDBw
7BSHB 
0USBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTTPO
i#JPUJDB1FSTQFDUJWBTFEFTBmPTw :VO
HFT 
Zi#JPUJDB)FSNFOVUJDBF
DBTVTUJDBw :VOHFT 

5BNCJOUSBEVKPFOVOUSBCBKPTP
CSFUJDBZmMPTPGBNPSBMNVZSFQVUBEP





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

FO'SBODJBi%JDJPOSJPEFUJDBZ'JMP
TPmB .PSBMw  FO EPT WPMNFOFT  PSHB
OJ[BEPT QPS .POJRVF $POUP4QFSCFS
4QFSCFS0USBUSBEVDDJOGVFi#JPUJDB
TFHVOEPPFOGPRVFEBmMPTPmBEPEJSFD
UPw %}"HPTUJOP 


$FOUSPTGFNJOJTUBTEFCJPUJDB
"OJT*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDB %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTZ(OFSP
"OJT  CBKP MB EJSFDDJO EF %FCPSB %J
OJ[  FT MB QSJNFSB PSHBOJ[BDJO OP HV
CFSOBNFOUBM MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB EFEJDBEB
B MB JOWFTUJHBDJO  BTJTUFODJB UDOJDB Z
FEVDBDJO FO CJPUJDB &TUBCMFDJEB FO
#SBTJMJB EFTBSSPMMBTVTBDUJWJEBEFTEFTEF
 " QBSUJS EF  FT PmDJBMNFO
UF VO HSVQP SFDPOPDJEP QPS FM $POTF
KP/BDJPOBMEF*OWFTUJHBDJOEFM#SBTJM
$/1R
&M$FOUSPEF%PDVNFOUBDJO
ZEF*OGPSNBDJOEF"OJTFTVODFOUSP
EF SFGFSFODJB EF CJPUJDB QBSB MB 0S
HBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE
014

"OJTQSPNVFWFMBJOWFTUJHBDJOZMBFEV
DBDJOFOUJDBZCJPUJDB FOTVSFMBDJO
DPOMPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT FMGFNJOJTNP
ZMBKVTUJDJBFOUSFMPTHOFSPT%JGVOEF
MB JOWFTUJHBDJO Z BDDJPOFT FO CJPUJDB
RVFQSPNVFWBOZBTFHVSFOMPTEFSFDIPT
CTJDPT EF MBT NVKFSFT  BDUVBOEP KVOUP
DPO PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT TPDJBMFT  FEVDBUJWBT
ZQPMUJDBTRVFDPNQBSUFOFTPTJEFBMFT
5SBCBKB QPS NFEJP EF DVBUSP QSPHSB
NBT i%FGFOTBw DPPSEJOB MBT BDDJPOFT
QPMUJDBTEF"OJT TVUSBCBKPDPNPHSVQP
EF QSFTJO FO FM QBSMBNFOUP CSBTJMFP 

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

BTJTUJFOEPZDPPQFSBOEPFOMBEJTDVTJO
MFHJTMBUJWB TPCSF UFNBT CJPUJDPT SFMB
DJPOBEPTDPOMBSFQSPEVDDJOIVNBOB
i&EVDBDJOwFTVOBTOUFTJTEFMBNJTJO
JOTUJUVDJPOBMEFQSPNPDJOEFMBUJDB
PGSFDFUSFTUBMMFSFTEFDBMJmDBDJOFOUP
EPTMPTFTUBEPTCSBTJMFPT%FGFOTB #JP
UJDB Z )FSSBNJFOUBT i*OGPSNBDJOw
NBOUJFOFFM$FOUSPEF%PDVNFOUBDJO
Z EF *OGPSNBDJO  DPPSEJOBEP QPS EP
DVNFOUBMJTUBTFTQFDJBMJ[BEPT ZCVTDBEJ
GVOEJSZEFNPDSBUJ[BSMBTJOGPSNBDJPOFT
CJPUJDBTFO#SBTJM&MQSPHSBNBEFi*O
WFTUJHBDJOw FMQSJODJQBMEF"OJT EFTB
SSPMMBMBJOWFTUJHBDJOUFSJDBZFUOPHS
mDB ZUJFOFFMDPNQSPNJTPEFQSPNPWFS
MBQBSUJDJQBDJOBDUJWBEFJOWFTUJHBEPSFT
KWFOFTFOCJPUJDBFO#SBTJM
"OJTQBUSPDJOBMBFEJUPSB-FUSBT-JWSFTZ
MB QSPEVDUPSB EF WJEFP JOEFQFOEJFOUF
*NBHFOT-JWSFT -B QSJNFSB FTUJNVMB MB
EJTDVTJOIVNBOBTPCSFUJDB CJPUJDB 
GFNJOJTNP HOFSP EFSFDIPTIVNBOPT 
KVTUJDJB Z EFTBSSPMMP TPDJBM *NBHFOT-J
WSFTQSPNVFWFZEFNPDSBUJ[BUFNBTSF
MBDJPOBEPTDPOMPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPTZ
MBCJPUJDB
"MHVOBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT EF -FUSBT-JWSFT
TPOi$POnJUPT.PSBJTF#JPUJDBw %J
OJ[ 
i2VFN1PEF5FS"DFTTPT
5FDOPMPHJBT 3FQSPEVUJWBT  %JGFSFOUFT
1FSTQFDUJWBTEP%JSFJUP#SBTJMFJSPw DP
PSEJOBEBQPS%FCPSB%JOJ[F4BNBOUIB
#VHMJPOF i#JCMJPHSBmB #JPUJDB #SB
TJMFJSB w  EF ,UJB 4PBSFT
#SBHBi#JCMJPHSBmB&TUVEPT4PCSF7JP
MODJB 4FYVBM $POUSB B .VMIFS 
w EF,UJB4PBSFT#SBHBiUJDBOB





6OBSBEJPHSBGBEFMBCJPUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF

1FTRVJTB FYQFSJODJB EF USFJOBNFOUP


FN QBTFT TVMBGSJDBOPTw  DPPSEJOBEP
QPS %FCPSB %JOJ[  %JSDF (VJMIFN F
6EP 4DILMFOL i#JPUJDB  SFQSPEVP
FHOFSPOBTPDJFEBEFDPOUFNQPSOFBw 
DPPSEJOBEP QPS .BSJB "OESB -PZPMB
i"ENJSWFM /PWB (FOUJDB CJPUJDB
F TPDJFEBEFw %JOJ[  
 i&OTBJPT
#JPUJDB EF4FSHJP$PTUBF%FCPSB%J
OJ[ "OJT&EJUPSB #SBTJMJFOTF
 &M TJUJP
XXXBOJTPSHCSEFMBPSHBOJ[BDJOQSF
TFOUBMBMJTUBDPNQMFUBEFQVCMJDBDJPOFT
3FEEF*OGPSNBDJOFO#JPUJDB
3*#
#JPUJDB5FPSB'FNJOJTUBZ
"OUJSSBDJTUB#FMP)PSJ[POUF .(

#BKP MB EJSFDDJO EF 'UJNB 0MJWFJSB 


TVPCKFUJWPFTEJGVOEJSZQPQVMBSJ[BSMB
CJPUJDBEFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMBUFPSB
GFNJOJTUB Z BOUJSSBDJTUB &MMB FT BVUPSB
EFi&OHFOIBSJBHFOUJDBPTUJNPEJB
EB DSJBPw 0MJWFJSB  
 Z i#JP
UJDB VNB GBDF EB DJEBEBOJBw 0MJWFJSB 

3*#FTFMTFHVOEPTJUJPGFNJOJTUB
EFM NVOEP FO CJPUJDB FM QSJNFSP FT
'FNJOJTU"QQSPBDIFTUP#JPFUIJDT '"#

,FOOFEZ*OTUJUVUF
ZUBNCJOUSBCBKBFO
UFPSBBOUJSSBDJTUB

&TDVFMB/BDJPOBMEF4BMVE1
CMJDB&/41'*0$36;3PEF
+BOFJSP 3+

&OFTUBJOTUJUVDJOUSBCBKB'FSNJO3P
MBOE4DISBNN RVFoKVOUPDPO.JHVFM
,PUUPXo QSPQPOF MB MMBNBEB iCJPUJDB
QSPUFDUPSBw$VBUSPSBDFTBMJNFOUBOTV
EFTBSSPMMP 
 FM DPNQSPNJTP QPMUJDP
EFUPEPTMPT&TUBEPT
FMGVOEBNFOUP
UJDP EFMB DPOWJWJBMJEBE 
MBTMJNJUB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DJPOFTEFMQBSBEJHNBQSJODJQJBMJTUBOPS
UFBNFSJDBOP  Z 
 MB OFDFTJEBE EF VOB
UJDB BEFDVBEB B "NSJDB -BUJOB RVF
SFnFKFMBSFBMJEBETPDJPFDPONJDBEFMPT
QBTFTFOWBTEFEFTBSSPMMP
%FTEF MB QFSTQFDUJWB EF 4DISBNN  MB
CJPUJDB QSPUFDUPSB TF SFMBDJPOB DPO
MBTNFEJEBTRVFTFEFCFOBEPQUBSQBSB
SFTHVBSEBS B JOEJWJEVPT WVMOFSBCMFT Z
BQPCMBDJPOFTIVNBOBTRVFDBSFDFOEF
SFDVSTPT RVF BTFHVSFO MBT DPOEJDJPOFT
NOJNBTEFVOBWJEBIVNBOBDPOEJH
OJEBEZOPSFTUSJOHJEBBMBTVQFSWJWFODJB
4DISBNN 

-B 'VOEBP 0TXBMEP $SV[ '*0
$36;
 IB IFDIP VOB DPOUSJCVDJO
JNQPSUBOUF B MB SFnFYJO CJPUJDB FO
JOUFSGB[ DPO MB TBMVE QCMJDB "EFNT
EF JOWFTUJHBDJPOFT JNQPSUBOUFT TPCSF
FTUBMUJNB IBQSPNPWJEPJOUFSFTBOUFT
SFVOJPOFTTPCSFCJPUJDBDPOMBQBSUJDJ
QBDJOEFFYQFSUPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT)B
QVCMJDBEP VOB FEJDJO FTQFDJBM FO JO
HMT
EF$BEFSOPTEF4BEF1CMJDBEJT
DVUJFOEP DVFTUJPOFT CJPUJDBT WPM  
4VQMFNFOUP* 
%FCFNPTUBNCJO
NFODJPOBS MB QVCMJDBDJO  PSHBOJ[BEB
FOQPS'FSNJO3PMBOE4DISBNN
Z.BSMFOF#SB[ i#JPUJDBF4BEFOPT
UFNQPTQBSBNVMIFSFTFDSJBOBT w
&MDBQUVMPSFHJPOBMEF4##UJFOFWBSJPT
FYQFSUPTFOCJPUJDB UBMFTDPNP4FSHJP
3FHP .BSMFOF#SB[ .BSJTB1BMDJPTZ
0MJOUP1FHPSBSP&TUFMUJNPIBQVCMJ
DBEP BMHVOPT USBCBKPT TPCSF UJDB mMP
TmDB BMHVOPT EF MPT NT JNQPSUBOUFT
TPOiUJDB+VTUJBw *OUSPEVPUJDB
DPOUFNQPSOFBw Z iUJDB EPT NBJPSFT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

NFTUSFT BUSBWT EB IJTUSJBw 1FHPSBSP 


  


/DMFPEF#JPUJDBEF-POESJOB
/#-
1BSBO
&M/#-SFOFQFSTPOBTEFEJTUJOUBTSFBT
JOUFSFTBEBT FO MB SFnFYJO Z EJTDVTJO
EFDVFTUJPOFTUJDBTSFMBDJPOBEBTDPOMB
WJEB&OTVTJUJP8FCTFQVFEFMFFSi-B
CJPUJDBUJFOFVOQBQFMNVZJNQPSUBOUF
FOMBMVDIBQPSMBEFGFOTBEFMBEJHOJEBE
IVNBOBEFMBQFSTPOBZFOMBCBUBMMBQPS
MB KVTUJDJB -B SFnFYJO Z MB EJTDVTJO
TPOVOBEFMBTNBOFSBTEFMVDIBS&TUB
FT MB QSPQVFTUB EF /#- DVBOEP SFOF
QSPGFTJPOBMFTDPOVOBNFUBDPNOTF
SJFEBEBMUSBUBSMPTQSPCMFNBTUJDPTRVF
QVFEFOBGFDUBSMBWJEBEJBSJBEFUPEBMB
HFOUF  BEFNT EF FTUJNVMBS MB QSPEVD
DJOZEJGVTJOEFMDPOPDJNJFOUPFOFTF
DBNQPw
&M/#-FTDPPSEJOBEPQPS+PT&EVBSEP
EF 4JRVFJSB &OUSF PUSPT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT
TF FODVFOUSBO -FPOBSEP 1SPUB  /JM[B
%JOJ[ Z -PVSFOP ;BODBOBSP 0GSFDF
VODVSTPEFQPTHSBEPFOCJUJDBBQBS
UJSEFmOBMFTEFMPTZPSHBOJ[BM7*
$POHSFTP#SBTJMFPEF#JPUJDB FO'P[
EFM*HVB[ FO&OUSFPUSPTUSBCB
KPT  NFODJPOBNPT FM DPPSEJOBEP QPS
+PT &EVBSEP EF 4JRVFJSB iUJDB  DJO
DJB F SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFw 4JRVFJSB FU BM 


TUPTTPOBMHVOPTEFMPTDFOUSPTCSBTJMF
PTEFCJPUJDBDPOTPMJEBEPTFOMPRVF
DPODJFSOF B QVCMJDBDJPOFT  B JOWFTUJHB
DJO Z B FODVFOUSPT EF EJTDVTJO )BZ
UBNCJOJOJDJBUJWBTJOEJWJEVBMFTSFMFWBO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UFT EF CJPFUJDJTUBT CSBTJMFPT FO WBSJBT


VOJWFSTJEBEFT  RVF DPNJFO[BO B IBDFS
EFFTUBEJTDJQMJOBVODPNQPOFOUFEFMB
GPSNBDJOIVNBOJTUB FTQFDJBMNFOUFFO
MBTDJFODJBTEFMBWJEBZMBTBMVE

UJDBEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJOFOTFSFT
IVNBOPT 

6OP EF MPT MPHSPT NT JNQPSUBOUFT EF


MB CJPUJDB CSBTJMFB IB TJEP FM FTUBCMF
DJNJFOUPEFVOTJTUFNBQBSBFMDPOUSPM
TPDJBMEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJOFOTFSFTIVNB
OPT FO #SBTJM %FTEF PDUVCSF EF 
FMQBTUJFOFTVTQSPQJBTQBVUBTUJDBTFO
MBJOWFTUJHBDJOFOTFSFTIVNBOPTGVF
SPO GPSNVMBEPT CBKP UVUFMB CJPUJDB Z
IPNPMPHBEBT QPS FM $POTFKP /BDJPOBM
EF 4BMVE $/4
 EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF 4B
MVE3FTQFDUPEFFTUFUFNBSFHJTUSBNPT
B(VJMMFSNP4BBE)PTTOFRVJFO FOEJF[
BPTEFUSBCBKP QVEPFTUBCMFDFSVOQSP
DFTPEFDPOUSPMTPDJBMEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJO
CSBTJMFBFOTFSFTIVNBOPTRVFFTVOFT
UNVMPZVONPEFMPQBSBNVDIPTQBTFT
EFMNVOEP
&TF QSPDFTP NFSFDF VO QBOPSBNB IJT
USJDP #SBTJM 
&O FM$/4
DSF VOB GVFS[B EF USBCBKP NVMUJEJT
DJQMJOBSJB  MB DVBM  CBTBEB FO EBUPT EF
MPT NJOJTUFSJPT EF 4BMVE  EF $JFODJB Z
5FDOPMPHB Z EF &EVDBDJO  IB JEFOUJ
mDBEP DFSDB EF  QFSTPOBMJEBEFT
F JOTUJUVDJPOFT  JODMVZFOEP TPDJFEBEFT
DJFOUmDBTZUPEBDMBTFEFDPOTFKPTQSP
GFTJPOBMFT Z BTPDJBDJPOFT EF QFSTPOBT
DPOEFmDJFODJBT RVFGVFSPOJOWJUBEBTB
QBSUJDJQBSFOMBFMBCPSBDJOEFOPSNBT
%FTQVTEFEJF[NFTFTEFBDUJWJEBE TF
QSFTFOUVOBQSPQVFTUBBM$/4RVFGPS





6OBSBEJPHSBGBEFMBCJPUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF

NMBCBTFEFMBSFTPMVDJO-BT
QBVUBTUJFOFOVODBSDUFSFTFODJBMNFOUF
CJPUJDPZGVFSPOFMBCPSBEBTFOVOBBD
UJUVEQMVSBMJTUB/PUJFOFOMBDPOmHVSB
DJOEFDEJHP DPOBSUDVMPTFOMPTRVF
iTF QSPICFw P iTF QFSNJUFw  OJ DBSD
UFS OPUBSJBM OJ NFSBNFOUF CVSPDSUJDP
%FBDVFSEPDPOMBTOPSNBT iOBEBFTB
QSJPSJ QSPIJCJEPw QFSP iOP TF QFSNJUF
DVBMRVJFSB QSDUJDBw UPEP EFQFOEF EF
VOBFWBMVBDJOCJPUJDBEFMQSPZFDUPEF
JOWFTUJHBDJO&MJOWFTUJHBEPSUJFOFSFT
QPOTBCJMJEBEDPNQMFUBFJOUSBOTGFSJCMFZ
EFCFIBDFSRVFTVQSPZFDUPEFJOWFTUJ
HBDJO TFB BQSPCBEP QPS FM $PNJU EF
UJDBEF*OWFTUJHBDJO $&1
EFMBJOT
UJUVDJOFOMBDVBMFMFTUVEJPTFSSFBMJ
[BEP-PT$&1UJFOFOVOBDPNQPTJDJO
NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJBZNTEFMBNJUBEEF
TVT NJFNCSPT QVFEFO TFS EF MB NJTNB
QSPGFTJOEFCFOJODMVJSBHFOUFEFEJ
WFSTPT DBNQPT oCJPNFEJDJOB  DJFODJBT
IVNBOBT  DJFODJBT FYBDUBTo Z B QPS MP
NFOPT VO SFQSFTFOUBOUF EF MB DMJFOUFMB
EF MB JOTUJUVDJO 5JFOFO BVUPOPNB Z
MJCFSUBEQBSBBDUVBS Z QPSMPUBOUP TF
DPOWJFSUFO FO DPSSFTQPOTBCMFT QPS FM
DPNQPOFOUF UJDP EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
DVBOEPBQSVFCBOVOQSPZFDUP

EPDUPSFT  FOGFSNFSBT  EFOUJTUBT  mTJPUF


SBQFVUBT  TPDJMPHPT  KVSJTUBT  mMTPGPT 
JOHFOJFSPT  NBUFNUJDPT  BOUSPQMPHPT
Z SFQSFTFOUBOUFT EF MPT TVKFUPT EF JO
WFTUJHBDJO 'SFJUBT  -PCP Z )PTTOF 

-BTOPSNBTCJPUJDBTTFBQMJDBO
B UPEBT MBT JOWFTUJHBDJPOFT DPO TVKFUPT
IVNBOPT  FO DVBMRVJFS DBNQP EFM DP
OPDJNJFOUP DBQB[ EF DBVTBS iEBPT G
TJDPT  QTRVJDPT  NPSBMFT  JOUFMFDUVBMFT 
TPDJBMFT  DVMUVSBMFT P FTQJSJUVBMFT B MPT
TFSFTIVNBOPT FODVBMRVJFSFUBQBEFMB
JOWFTUJHBDJO Z FO TVT SFTVMUBEPTw  JO
DMVZFOEPMBTDJFODJBTIVNBOBT

-PT $&1 TF EFCFO SFHJTUSBS FO MB $P


NJTJO /BDJPOBM EF UJDB FO *OWFT
UJHBDJO $0/&1
 RVF TF SFMBDJPOB
EJSFDUBNFOUFDPOFM$/4 VOBBHFODJB
MFHBMEFDPOUSPMTPDJBM"T MB$0/&1
ZMPT$&1GPSNBOVOTJTUFNBJOEFQFO
EJFOUFEFDPOUSPMTPDJBMEFMBUJDBFOMB
JOWFTUJHBDJODPOTFSFTIVNBOPT#SBTJM
UJFOFDPNJUTEFUJDB DPOBMSFEF
EPSEFQFSTPOBTDPNPNJFNCSPT

6OBFWBMVBDJOQSPTQFDUJWB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

-B $0/&1  TJFNQSF DPO MB QBSUJDJQB


DJO NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJB EF MB TPDJFEBE
DJWJM Z DJFOUmDB  FMBCPS PUSBT TJFUF
QBVUBT FTQFDmDBT EF EJSFDDJO QBSB
DJFSUBT iSFBT UFNUJDBTw 5PEPT FTUPT
EPDVNFOUPTFTUOEJTQPOJCMFTFOXXX
DPOTFMIPTBVEFHPWCS&OIBCBO
TJEP QSFTFOUBEPT BMSFEFEPS EF 
QSPZFDUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJO EFTEFFTUV
EJPT SFUSPTQFDUJWPT IBTUB QSPZFDUPT EF
GBTFT**Z***DPODMVMBTUSPODBMFT
JOWP
MVDSBOEP BMSFEFEPS EF  QFSTP
OBT IPZEFCJEBNFOUFQSPUFHJEBTQPSFM
TJTUFNB$0/&1$&1 1FTTJOJ 


#SBTJM QPSJODSFCMFRVFQBSF[DB BQF


TBSEFUBOUBWJUBMJEBEFOMBEJTDJQMJOB OP
UJFOF $PNJTJO /BDJPOBM EF #JPUJDB
-B4PDJFEBE#SBTJMFBEF#JPUJDBTFIB
FTGPS[BEP QBSB RVF FTP PDVSSB Z CVTDB
FMNPNFOUPQPMUJDPNTGBWPSBCMFQBSB
FTUBCMFDFSMBZQBSBBTJTUJSBMHPCJFSOP BM
QBSMBNFOUPZBMBTPDJFEBEFOHFOFSBMFO





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

SFMBDJODPOMBTDVFTUJPOFTNTDPNQMF
KBTEFMBCJPUJDB
&M EFTBSSPMMP UFSJDP EF MB CJPUJDB FO
#SBTJMFT TJOEVEB VOHSBOEFTBGP4P
CSFQBT FM MFHBMJTNP UFNQSBOP DPNP
SFGFSFODJBQBSBMBDSFBDJOEFOPSNBTZ 
BDUVBMNFOUF UJFOFVOFTQBDJPFOFMEJ
MPHP JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP FO MB CTRVFEB
EFMDPOTFOTP1PSQBSUFEFMPTQSPGFTJP
OBMFTEFMEFSFDIP IBZFO#SBTJMVOHSBO
JOUFST SFTQFDUP EF DVFTUJPOFT CJPUJDBT
RVF  NVDIBT WFDFT  SFRVJFSFO MB JOUFS
WFODJOEFMPTUSJCVOBMFT)BZVOBHSBO
SFDFQUJWJEBEBMPTBOMJTJTZBMBTEJTDV
TJPOFTTPDJPBOUSPQPMHJDBT mMPTmDBTZ
UFPMHJDBT)BZVOEJMPHPJOUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJPFOUSFMBTEJWFSTBTJOJDJBUJWBTZUBN
CJOTFSJFEBEDJFOUmDB
&MBMDBODFZMPTUFNBTEFMBCJPUJDBCSB
TJMFBOPTIBDFODPODMVJSRVFIBZQPSMP
NFOPTTFJTHSVQPT&MQSJNFSPFTUGPS
NBEP QPS FTUVEJPT NFUPEPMHJDPT RVF
JOUFOUBO FYQMJDBS MB QSPQJB CJPUJDB TV
HOFTJT JNQPSUBODJB NUPEPTZQSJODJ
QJPT ZTVTSFMBDJPOFTDPOMBUFDOPDJFODJB 
CVTDBOEPVOGVOEBNFOUPmMPTmDPBO
USPQPMHJDP&MTFHVOEPFTUDPOTUJUVJEP
FO TV NBZPSB QPS QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF TB
MVEZIVNBOJTUBT NEJDPT FOGFSNFSBT 
QTJDMPHPT  UFMPHPT Z mMTPGPT  FOUSF
PUSPT
TVUBSFBQSJODJQBMFTEJTDVUJSJO
UFSEJTDJQMJOBSJBNFOUFTPCSFUJDBQSPGF
TJPOBM  UJDB NEJDB  DVJEBEPT NEJDPT
ZIVNBOJ[BDJOEFTFSWJDJPT5FMPHPT 
FSVEJUPT F JOWFTUJHBEPSFT FO UFPMPHB
NPSBM DPOTUJUVZFO VO UFSDFS HSVQP FY
QSFTJWPRVFUSBFMBQFSTQFDUJWBUJDBSF
MJHJPTB  MB MMBNBEB iCJPUJDB UFPMHJDBw 

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DPOVOOGBTJTFOMBTSFMJHJPOFTDSJTUJBOBT
ZBGSPCSBTJMFBTFOFMDBTPEF#SBTJM-B
QSFTFODJBEFMBSFnFYJOUFPMHJDBQVFEF
BZVEBS  TFHO FM UFMPHP .SDJP 'BCSJ
EPT"OKPT FOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFVOIPSJ
[POUFEFTFOUJEP VOBiNTUJDBwQBSBMB
CJPUJDB&MMBQVFEFBMJNFOUBSVOBQFST
QFDUJWBTPDJPIVNBOJUBSJBUSBOTGPSNBEP
SB FOMBDVBMTFWFBOUPEBTMBTDSJBUVSBT
DPOBNPSVOBQFSTQFDUJWBRVFTPCSFQB
TFMBEFTJHVBMEBEBUSBWTEFMBKVTUJDJBZ
MBTPMJEBSJEBE ZBZVEFBQSPNPWFSEJT
DVTJPOFTZQSPQVFTUBTRVFUFOHBODPNP
NFUBVOGVUVSPKVTUPZGFMJ[QBSBUPEPT
6ODVBSUPHSVQPFTMBMMBNBEBiCJPUJDB
GFNJOJTUBw  GPSNBEP CTJDBNFOUF QPS
NVKFSFT RVF EFmFOEFO VOB SFnFYJO
TFOTJCMFBTVTQSPQJPTDMBNPSFT RVFTP
CSFQBTFBTJNFUSBTFJOKVTUJDJBTEFHOF
SPZMBTVNJTJOEFMBNVKFSFOFMDPO
UFYUPTPDJPQPMUJDP MBTEJTDSJNJOBDJPOFT
EF SB[B  FUD -PT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT EF VOB
iCJPUJDB TPDJPQPMUJDBw DPOTUJUVZFO BM
RVJOUPHSVQP4POMPTIFSBMEPTEFVOB
iCJPUJDBEFMBJOUFSWFODJOwPiCJPUJDB
EVSBw FOMBTQBMBCSBTEF(BSSBGB)BZ
UBNCJO MB iCJPUJDB QSPUFDUPSBw BOUFT
NFODJPOBEB EFTBSSPMMBEBQPS4DISBNN
Z,PUUPX RVFDPOTJEFSBVOBOMJTJTEF
MBTFTUSVDUVSBTTPDJPQPMUJDBTRVFQSPEV
DFOBTJNFUSBT EFTJHVBMEBEFTZFYDMVTJP
OFT  DPO QSPQVFTUBT EF USBOTGPSNBDJO
FOMBEFGFOTBEFMBHFOUFFYDMVJEBZWVM
OFSBCMF EF MB TPDJFEBE RVF DMBNB QPS
NT KVTUJDJB Z FRVJEBE FO FTB NJTNB
MOFBTFFODVFOUSBOMBTUJDBTBQPSUBEBT
QPS MB 5FPMPHB EF MB -JCFSBDJO B UJF
SSBTCSBTJMFBT&MFTUVEJPEFMBCJPUJDB
UBNCJOIBEFTQFSUBEPFMJOUFSTEFMPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMEFSFDIPZNVDIBTQV





6OBSBEJPHSBGBEFMBCJPUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF

CMJDBDJPOFTFTUOBQBSFDJFOEP-B0SEFO
EF"CPHBEPTEF#SBTJM 0"#
IBDSFBEP
DPNJTJPOFT EF iCJPUJDB Z EFSFDIPw FO
EJWFSTBTTFDDJPOFTSFHJPOBMFT&TUFFTFM
TFYUPHSVQPFTQFDmDP EFEJDBEPBFTUV
EJBSMBTJOUFSSFMBDJPOFTEFMBCJPUJDBDPO
FMEFSFDIP MBMFHJTMBDJOZMBTQPMUJDBT
QCMJDBT
%FCJEPBUPEBFTBWJUBMJEBEEFMBTTFOTJ
CJMJEBEFTCSBTJMFBTZEFMBTQFSTQFDUJWBT
CJPUJDBT UPEBTDPOTVDBSDUFSQSPQJP 
FMEFTBGPEJBSJPFTMBQSDUJDBEFVOEJ
MPHPSFTQFUVPTPZUPMFSBOUF VOEJMPHP
JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP  NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJP Z
USBTEJTDJQMJOBSJPRVFFWJUFUPEPTMPTEPH
NBUJTNPTSFEVDDJPOJTUBTZFYDMVTJWJTUBT
&MEFTBGPNTHSBOEFQBSBMBCJPUJDB Z
QBSBMBCSBTJMFBFOFTQFDJBM FTDPOTUSVJS
DPO IVNJMEBE  SFTQFUBS MBT EJGFSFODJBT
ZQSPNPWFSMBVOJEBEFOMBEJWFSTJEBE
4JOPTPUSPTDPOTFHVJNPTHBSBOUJ[BSFTB
QFSTQFDUJWBEFVOJEBEZEFDPMBCPSBDJO
FOUSFMBTEJWFSTBTQFSTQFDUJWBT MBCJPUJ
DB CSBTJMFB TJO EVEB TF EFTBSSPMMBS Z 
FO VO GVUVSP NVZ QSYJNP  TFS iIV
NJMEFNFOUFwPSHVMMPTBEFTNJTNB
&O QPDP UJFNQP  MB CJPUJDB CSBTJMFB
UVWPYJUPFOGPSKBSVOBJEFOUJEBEZDB
SBDUFSTUJDBT QSPQJBT FO FM DPOUFYUP EFM
NPWJNJFOUP CJPUJDP NVOEJBM  UFOJFO

EP BIPSB VO JOOFHBCMF MJEFSB[HP FO FM


DPOUFYUPEFMPTQBTFTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT
5FOFNPTZBUSBCBKPTEFSFGFSFODJBDSUJ
DB FO MB CTRVFEB EF VO BDFSDBNJFOUP
CJPUJDP PSJHJOBMNFOUF MBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOP  DPOTJHOBEP FO FM MJCSP DPMFDUJWP
i#BTFTDPODFJUVBJTEB#JPUJDBFOGPRVF
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOPw (BSSBGB  ,PUUPX
 4BBEB  
 "M CVTDBS TV FTUBUVUP
FQJTUFNPMHJDP OP TF QPES FOUFOEFS
MB CJPUJDB FO OVFTUSP QBT TJO PCMJHB
UPSJBNFOUFMFFSZSFnFYJPOBSBDFSDBEFM
DPOUFOJEP EF FTUF USBCBKP %FCFNPT
NFODJPOBS RVF  B NFEJBEPT EF MPT  
MPTQSJNFSPTFTUVEJPTDSUJDPTZBIBCBO
BQBSFDJEP "OKPT   %SBOF  
1FTTJOJ (BSSBGB $PTUBZ0TFMLB 
)PTTOF 

&OTVGBTFBEVMUB BMDBO[BOEPMBNBEV
SF[ MBCJPUJDBCSBTJMFBUJFOFVOBPSJHJ
OBMJEBEZVOBJEFOUJEBERVFFTQSFDJTP
SFTDBUBSZWBMPSBS TPCSFQBTBOEPFMDPN
QMFKP IJTUSJDP EF OP QFOTBS QPS OPTP
USPTNJTNPTZEFJOGFSJPSJEBEEFCJEPB
FODPOUSBSOPTFOUSFMPTQBTFTFOWBTEF
EFTBSSPMMP#VTDBNPTQSBDUJDBSVOBCJP
UJDBDPOSB[OZDPSB[O TFOTJCJMJEBE
ZDPNQSPNJTPDPOMPTNTWVMOFSBCMFT
EFMBTPDJFEBE VOBCJPUJDBRVFSFBMJDF
FMTVFPEFVONFKPSZNTTBOPGVUVSP
GFMJ[QBSBUPEPT

3FGFSFODJBT
"OKPT  .' 
 /PUFT PO #JPFUIJDT JO #SB[JM #JPNFEJDBM &UIJDT /FXTMFUUFS PG
&VSPQFBO/FUXPSLGPS#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT  
QQ
"OKPT  .' 
 .FEJDBM FUIJDT JO UIF EFWFMPQJOH XPSME B MJCFSBUJPO UIFPMPHZ
QFSTQFDUJWF5IF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZ  
QQ
"OKPT  .' 
 #JPFUIJDT JO B MJCFSBUJPOJTU LFZ *O %VCPTF  &3 )BNFM  31
0A$POOFMM-+  &ET
"NBUUFSPGQSJODJQMFTGFSNFOUJO64CJPFUIJDT7BMMFZ'PSHF 
5SJOJUZ1SFTT*OUFSOBUJPOBM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

#BSDIJGPOUBJOF $11FTTJOJ- 


#JPUJDBBQBSUJSEF"NSJDB-BUJOB&O-B
WJEBWBMFCJPUJDB OVFWPTDBNJOPT-JNB $FOUSPEF&TUVEJPTZ1VCMJDBDJPOFT QQ

#BSDIJGPOUBJOF $11FTTJOJ- 
#JPUJDBBMHVOTEFTBGJPT4P1BVMP -PZPMB
#BSDIJGPOUBJOF $1 
#JPUJDBFJOJDJPEBWJEBBMHVOTEFTBGJPT"QBSFDJEB *EFJBT
F-FUSBT
#BSDIJGPOUBJOF $1 
1FSTQFDUJWBTEBCJPUJDBOB"NSJDB-BUJOBFPQJPOFJSJTNP
OP FOTJOP EF CJPUJDB OP $FOUSP 6OJWFSTJUSJP 4P $BNJMP 41
 0 .VOEP EB
4BEF  
QQ
#FSMJOHVFS ((BSSBGB 7 
0NFSDBEPIVNBOPFTUVEPCJPUJDPEBDPNQSBF
WFOEBEFQBSUFTEPDPSQP#SBTMJB &EJUPSB6O#
#FSMJOHVFS ( 
#JPUJDBDPUJEJBOB#SBTMJB &EJUPSB6O#
#PGG - 
(SJUPEPTQPCSFTHSJUPEB5FSSB1FUSQPMJT 7P[FT
#PGG - 
UJDBEB7JEB3JPEF+BOFJSP 4FYUBOUF
#PGG - 
UJDBF.PSBMBCVTDBEPTGVOEBNFOUPT1FUSQPMJT 7P[FT
$MPUFU + 
#JPUJDBVNBBQSPYJNBP1PSUP"MFHSF &EJQVDST
$MPUFU  + 0SH
 
 #JPUJDB .FJP BNCJFOUF  TBEF QCMJDB  OPWBT UFDOPMPHJBT
%FPOUPMPHJB NEJDB  EJSFJUP  QTJDPMPHJB F NBUFSJBM HFOUJDP IVNBOP 1PSUP "MFHSF 
&EJQVDST
$MPUFU  +  'FJK  "  0MJWFJSB  .( 
 #JPUJDB VNB WJTP QBOPSNJDB 1PSUP
"MFHSF &EJQVDST
$PTUB 4*' (BSSBGB 70TFMLB ( 
*OJDJBP#JPUJDB#SBTMJB $POTFMIP
'FEFSBMEF.FEJDJOB
%h"HPTUJOP ' 
#JPUJDBTFHVOEPPFOGPRVFEBGJMPTPGJBEPEJSFJUP4P-FPQPMEP 
6OJTJOPT
%JOJ[ % 
$POGMJUPTNPSBJTF#JPUJDB#SBTMJB -FUSBT-JWSFT
%JOJ[ % 
"ENJSWFM/PWB(FOUJDBCJPUJDBFTPDJFEBEF#SBTMJB -FUSBT-JWSFT
6O#
%SBOF +' 
#JPFUIJDBM1FSTQFDUJWFTGSPNJCFSPBNFSJDB5IF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOF
BOE1IJMPTPQIZ  

'PSUFT  1  ;PCPMJ  & 
 #JPUJDB F 4BEF 1CMJDB 4P 1BVMP  -PZPMB$FOUSP
6OJWFSTJUSJP4P$BNJMP
'SFJUBT $#% -PCP .)PTTOF 84 
0JUPBOPTEFFWPMVPVNCBMBOP
EPTJTUFNB$&1$POFQ$BEFSOPTEFUJDBFNQFTRVJTB  QQ
(BSSBGB 7 
"#JPFUIJDBM3BEJPHSBQIPG#SB[JM"DUB#JPFUIJDB  
QQ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



6OBSBEJPHSBGBEFMBCJPUJDBFO#SBTJM-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF



(BSSBGB 7 $PTUB 40TFMLB( 0SHT


 
"CJPUJDBOPTDVMP99*#SBTMJB 
&EJUPSB6O#
(BSSBGB 7$PTUB 4* 
"#JPUJDBOPTDVMP99*#SBTMJB &EJUPSB6O#
(BSSBGB 71FTTJOJ - 0SHT
 
#JPUJDB1PEFSFJOKVTUJB4P1BVMP &EJFT
-PZPMB&EJUPSBEP$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUSJP4P$BNJMP
(BSSBGB  7  ,PUUPX  .  4BBEB  " 0SHT
 
 #BTFT DPODFJUVBJT EB #JPUJDB
&OGPRVF-BUJOPBNFSJDBOP4P1BVMP (BJB
(BSSBGB 7 $PSEO + 0SHT
 
1FTRVJTBTFNCJPUJDBOP#SBTJMEFIPKF4P1BVMP 
&EJUPSB(BJB
)PTTOF 84 
#JPUJDBoQSJODQJPTPVSFGFSFODJBJT0.VOEPEB4BEF  

QQ
*OTUJUVUP $BNJMJBOP EF 1BTUPSBM EB 4BEF #PMFUJN *$"14 *OGPSNBUJWP EP *OTUJUVUP
$BNJMJBOPEF1BTUPSBMEB4BEF/NFSPTFTQFDGJDPTNBJPEF O BOP
9* QNBSPEF OP BOP9** QNBJPEF O BOP9*** 
QKVMIPBHPTUPEF OBOP9***KVMIPEF BOP9*7 O Q
-FQBSHOFVS  ) 
 #JPUJDB  OPWP DPODFJUP B DBNJOIP EP DPOTFOTP 4P 1BVMP 
-PZPMB
.BSUJO - 
"UJDB.EJDBFP1BDJFOUF5FSNJOBM-FJUVSBUJDPUFPMHJDBEPTDEJHPT
CSBTJMFJSPTEFUJDBNFEJDB"QBSFDJEB 4BOUVSJP
.PTFS " 
#JPUFDOPMPHJBFCJPUJDB1BSBPOEFWBNPT 1FUSQPMJT 7P[FT
/BUJPOBM)FBMUI$PVODJM 
/BUJPOBM$PNNJTTJPOGPS3FTFBSDI&UIJDTo$POFQ
o#SB[JM3VMFTPOSFTFBSDIJOWPMWJOHIVNBOTVCKFDUT 3FT$/4BOEPUIFST

#SBTJMJB .JOJTUSJPEB4BEF
/FWFT .$1-JNB . 0SHT
 
#JPUJDBPVCJPUJDBTOBFWPMVPEBTTPDJFEBEFT
$PJNCSB4P1BVMP &E(SGJDBEF$PJNCSB &EJUPSBEP$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUSJP
4P$BNJMP
0HVJTTP 5;PCPMJ & 0SHT
 
UJDBF#JPUJDB#BSVFSJ &E.BOPMF
0MJWFJSB  ' 
 &OHFOIBSJB HFOUJDB P TUJNP EJB EB DSJBP 4P 1BVMP  &EJUPSB
.PEFSOB &E
0MJWFJSB ' 
#JPUJDBVNBGBDFEBDJEBEBOJB4P1BVMP &EJUPSB.PEFSOB
1FHPSBSP 0 
UJDB+VTUJB1FUSQPMJT 7P[FT
1FHPSBSP 0 
*OUSPEVPUJDBDPOUFNQPSOFB3JPEF+BOFJSP 6BQ
1FHPSBSP  0 
 UJDB BUSBWT EPT NBJPSFT NFTUSFT BUSBWT EB IJTUSJB 1FUSQPMJT 
7P[FT
1FTTJOJ -#BSDIJGPOUBJOF $1 
1SPCMFNBTBUVBJTEFCJPUJDBFEJPSFWJTUB
FBNQMJBEB4P1BVMP -PZPMB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

1FTTJOJ - 


#JPFUIJDT 1PXFSBOE*OKVTUJDFTPNFQFSTPOBMUIPVHIUTGSPNB-BUJO
"NFSJDBOQFSTQFDUJWF*BC/FXT  QQ
1FTTJOJ - 
0EFTFOWPMWJNFOUPEBCJPUJDBOB"NSJDB-BUJOB4BEFFN%FCBUF 
 QQ
1FTTJOJ  - 
 0 EFTFOWPMWJNFOUP EB #JPUJDB OB "NSJDB -BUJOB "MHVNBT
DPOTJEFSBFT1BSUF*0.VOEPEB4BEF 
QQ
1FTTJOJ  - 
 0 EFTFOWPMWJNFOUP EB CJPUJDB OB "NSJDB -BUJOB "MHVNBT
DPOTJEFSBFT1BSUF**0.VOEPEB4BEF  
QQ
1FTTJOJ - 
#VJMEJOHB/FX$VMUVSFPG&UIJDTJO3FTFBSDI*OWPMWJOH)VNBOTJO
#SB[JM/PUJ[JFEJ1PMJUJB  QQ
1SBEP  .BVSP . 
 1BOPSBNB EB CJPUJDB OP #SBTJM VN FTUVEP TPCSF B SFGMFYP
CJPUJDBEFTFOWPMWJEBOPQBT#SBTMJB %JTTFSUBPEF.FTUSBEPFN$JODJBT
EB4BEF#SBTMJB 6OJWFSTJEBEFEF#SBTMJB
4DISBNN '3 
"QFTRVJTBCJPUJDBOP#SBTJMFOUSFPBOUJHPFPOPWP$BEFSOPT
"EFOBVFS  
QQ
4FHSF .$PIFO $ 0SHT
 
#JPUJDB4P1BVMP &EVTQ
4FHSF . 
"RVFTUPUJDBFBTBEFIVNBOB4P1BVMP "UIFOFV
4JRVFJSB +&FUBM 
UJDB DJODJBFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEF4P1BVMP -PZPMB$FOUSP
6OJWFSTJUSJP4P$BNJMP
4DISBNN  '3  3FHP  4  #SB[  .  1BMDJPT  . 0SHT
 
 #JPUJDB  SJTDPT F
QSPUFP3JPEF+BOFJSP &EJUPSB6'3+&EJUPSB'JPDSV[
7BSHB "$ 
1SPCMFNBTEF#JPUJDB4P-FPQPMEP 6OJTJOPT
:VOHFT +3 
#JPUJDB1FSTQFDUJWBTFEFTBGJPT4P-FPQPMEP 6OJTJOPT
:VOHFT +3 
#JPUJDB)FSNFOVUJDBFDBTVTUJDB4P1BVMP -PZPMB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





#JPUJDBFO$IJMF
.JHVFM,PUUPX

*OUSPEVDDJO

VSBOUF NVDIP UJFNQP  MPT CJPFUJ


DJTUBTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPTIBOEFGFO
EJEPMBJEFBEFRVFMBTQBSUJDVMBSJEBEFT
SFHJPOBMFTSFRVJFSFOVOBNPEBMJEBEEF
UJDBBEBQUBEBBTVTQSPQJBTJEJPTJODSB
TJBT TPDJBMFT Z DVMUVSBMFT  Z SFTQFUVPTBT
EFMBEJWFSTJEBEUOJDBEFTVQPCMBDJO
6O ONFSP EF DPODPSEBODJBT IJTUSJ
DBT Z TPDJBMFT QFSNJUFO RVF MB NBZPSB
EFMBTOBDJPOFTEFMBSFHJODPNQBSUBO
VOEJTDVSTPCJPUJDPRVF BQFTBSEFWB
SJBDJPOFTMPDBMFT TFBUFTUJNPOJPEFBMHP
RVFTFIBMMBNBEPiGBNJMJBSJEBENPSBMw
8JMEFT  
 %FTDSJCJS MB FTDFOB EF
MBCJPUJDBFOVOQBTEFCFBZVEBSBFO
UFOEFSZBEFTUBDBSUBOUPMBTWBSJBDJPOFT
DPNPMBTTFNFKBO[BT-BUJDBBQMJDBEBFT
FTQFDJBMNFOUFTFOTJCMFBMBTDJSDVOTUBO
DJBTMPDBMFTEFMBTQSDUJDBTTPDJBMFTZOP
FTTPSQSFTBRVFFM7*$POHSFTP.VOEJBM
EF#JPUJDB MMFWBEPBDBCPFO#SBTJMJBFO
 IBZBBDFOUVBEPi#JPUJDB 1PEFS
Z *OKVTUJDJBw DPNP TV UFNB QSJODJQBM 
DPOTJEFSBOEPRVFMBTJOKVTUJDJBTTPDJBMFT
ZEFMPTDVJEBEPTEFTBMVETPOBMUBNFOUF
GSFDVFOUFTQPSUPEB"NSJDB-BUJOB
$IJMFIBTJEPOJDPFOTVNBSDBEPBJTMB
NJFOUPGTJDP TVHFPHSBGBQFDVMJBS VOB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

MBSHB FTUBCJMJEBE QPMUJDB oJOUFSSVNQJ


EBWJPMFOUBNFOUFFOMPTBPToZVO
JOUFST QJPOFSP FO MB MFHJTMBDJO TPDJBM 
FODPOUSBTUFDPOTVBDFQUBDJOFYUSFNB
EBNFOUF WBDJMBOUF EF MFHJTMBDJO TPCSF
DVFTUJPOFT UBMFT DPNP FM EJWPSDJP  MPT
DPOUSBDFQUJWPTZFMBCPSUP1PSPUSBQBS
UF MBOBDJODPNQBSUFDPOTVTWFDJOPT
SFHJPOBMFT VOB EFQFOEFODJB FDPONJ
DB EF QBTFT JOEVTUSJBMJ[BEPT  VO GVFSUF
DPNQSPNJTPDPOMPTWBMPSFTEFNFSDB
EP  DVFTUJPOFT TJO TPMVDJO SFGFSFOUFT
BNJOPSBTUOJDBTZVOOEJDFEF(JOJ
EFTGBWPSBCMF NBSDBEPQPSDPOnJDUPTTP
DJBMFTFOWBTEFJSSVQDJO

'POEPIJTUSJDP
"MHVOBTOPUBTIJTUSJDBTTPCSF$IJMFTJS
WFODPNPJOGPSNBDJOBODJMBSQBSBJMVT
USBSZFOUFOEFSNFKPSFMQSFTFOUF1PDP
EFTQVTEFRVF1FESPEF7BMEJWJBGVO
EBSB MB DJVEBE EF 4BOUJBHP  FO FM TJHMP
97* FMQSJNFSIPTQJUBMGVFDPOTUSVJEP
QPSMBTBVUPSJEBEFTFTQBPMBTZNBOUF
OJEP QPS VOB PSEFO SFMJHJPTB %VSBOUF
NVDIPUJFNQP MBBZVEBNEJDBQCMJDB
DPOUJOV QSFEPNJOBOEP TPCSF MPT TFS
WJDJPT NEJDPT QSJWBEPT " MP MBSHP EF
MPTBPT MPTSFDVSTPTQCMJDPTMMFHBSPOB
TFSFTDBTPTZMBDBSJEBEGVFQSFFNJOFOUF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

EVSBOUF NVDIP UJFNQP FO FM mOBODJB


NJFOUP EF MB HFTUJO EF JOTUJUVDJPOFT
NEJDBT QCMJDBT IBTUB FM TJHMP 99 
DVBOEPMPTBTVOUPTTBOJUBSJPTZNEJDPT
TF DPOWJSUJFSPO FO VOB SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE
MFHBMNFOUF SFDPOPDJEB Z DBEB WF[ NT
DPNQSFOTJWB EFM &TUBEP  DPO MB DSFB
DJOEFVOTFSWJDJPNEJDPOBDJPOBMFO

-PT FTUVEJPT NEJDPT GPSNBMFT TF JOJ
DJBSPO FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF $IJMF FO
 DPOGVFSUFJOnVFODJBFVSPQFB-B
UJDBNEJDBMBFOTFBCBOMPTQSPGFTPSFT
EFNFEJDJOBMFHBMCBKPMBFUJRVFUBEFMB
EFPOUPMPHB PDVQOEPTFQSJODJQBMNFO
UF EFM DEJHP EF UJDB EF MB QSPGFTJO
-BTDVFTUJPOFTRVFTFSFmFSFOIPZBCJP
UJDB  UBMFT DPNP EFSFDIPT BTPDJBEPT B
MB TBMVE  BDDFTP B MB BTJTUFODJB NEJDB 
EJTDSJNJOBDJOTPDJBMZNBSHJOBMJ[BDJO
FSBOEJTDVUJEBTFOFMDBNQPEFMBTBMVE
QCMJDB FODPOUJOVJEBEDPOVOBUSBEJ
DJO RVF TF SFNPOUBCB BM EJTDQVMP EF
37JSDIPX .BY8FTUFOIPGFS RVFFO
TFFO$IJMFQPSNVDIPTBPT&OUSF
TVT BMVNOPT FTUBCB 4BMWBEPS "MMFOEF 
NEJDPRVF DPNPTFDSFUBSJPEF4BMVE 
EFTQVTTFOBEPSZ QPSmO QSFTJEFOUFEF
$IJMF  UVWP VOB JOnVFODJB JNQPSUBOUF
FOQPMUJDBTTBOJUBSJBTQCMJDBTFOFMQBT
8BU[LJO FU BM   1PUUFS  

"VORVFMBCJPUJDBGVFJODPSQPSBEBTMP
MFOUBNFOUFFOFMQMBOEFFTUVEJPTEFMPT
FTUVEJPT NEJDPT HSBEVBEPT  QPS NV
DIPTBPTMBUSBEJDJOIBTJEPFOTFBSMP
FTFODJBMEFMBTUJDBTNEJDBT BTDPNP
IBDFSFTGVFS[PTQBSBEFTBSSPMMBSQPMUJDBT
TBOJUBSJBTQCMJDBTZVODPODFQUPEFKVT
UJDJBTBOJUBSJB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

-PTEJTDJQMJOBEPTNJFNCSPTEFMB"TP
DJBDJO .EJDB $IJMFOB  DPO TV DVPUB
UJDB ZFMGSFDVFOUFDPNQSPNJTPDPOFM
TFSWJDJPQCMJDPFOIPTQJUBMFTEFM&TUB
EPZEFMBVOJWFSTJEBE GVFSPOEFDJTJWPT
QBSB RVF MPT NEJDPT DIJMFOPT NBOUV
WJFTFO TV QSJWJMFHJBEB TJUVBDJO TPDJBM
RVF  B NFOVEP  JNQMJDBCB FM QSFTUJHJP
JOUFSOBDJPOBM-BUJDBNEJDBOPQBSF
DB OFDFTJUBS FYUFOTJO P EFMJCFSBDJO 
UBOUP NT QPSRVF MB DVMUVSB DIJMFOB F
JODMVTP MB QSDUJDB NEJDB IBCBO TJEP
TJFNQSF QBUFSOBMJTUBT EF VOB NBOFSB
BVUPSJUBSJB MPT NEJDPT FTUBCBO  QPS
EFSFDIP QSPGFTJPOBM  NPSBMNFOUF FO
MP DPSSFDUP Z  TJO EVEB  QPEBO UPNBS
EFDJTJPOFTFOOPNCSFEFTVTQBDJFOUFT
&M $PMFHJP .EJDP EF $IJMF oMB "TP
DJBDJO.EJDB$IJMFOBoGVFDSFBEPFO
 DPOVONBOEBUPQBSBFMBCPSBSVO
DEJHPQSPGFTJPOBMEFUJDBZTVQFSWJTBS
MBBEFDVBEBQSDUJDBNPSBMEFMBNFEJ
DJOB -B DBMJEBE EF NJFNCSP FSB PCMJ
HBUPSJB QBSB UPEPT MPT NEJDPT Z DPOT
UJUVB VO SFRVJTJUP MFHBM QBSB SFBMJ[BS
UPEBDMBTFEFBDUJWJEBENEJDB#BKPFM
SHJNFO NJMJUBS EF 1JOPDIFU MB DBMJEBE
EF NJFNCSP EF MB "TPDJBDJO .EJDB
QBT B TFS WPMVOUBSJB Z  BVORVF TV D
EJHPEFUJDBGVFTFBNQMJBEPZBDUVBMJ
[BEPSFHVMBSNFOUF MPTNEJDPTQVFEFO
IBTUBIPZFMVEJSGDJMNFOUFFMDPOUSPMZ
MBT TBODJPOFT TJFOEP OP NJFNCSPT &T
TVHFTUJWPRVFMB"TPDJBDJO.EJDBUFO
HBQPSNVDIPTBPTVO%FQBSUBNFOUP
EF #JP
UJDB FODBSHBEP EF FTUVEJBS MBT
DVFTUJPOFTNPSBMFTDPODFQUVBMFTZQSD
UJDBT FMBCPSBSSFTQVFTUBTBMPTQSPCMFNBT
UJDPTEFHSBOSFMFWBODJB BEFNTEFSF
TPMWFSMPTDPOnJDUPTNPSBMFTFTQFDmDPT





#JPUJDBFO$IJMF.JHVFM,PUUPX

OPDVCJFSUPTQPSFM$PNJUEFUJDBEF
MB"TPDJBDJO
-B BNQMJB NBZPSB EF MPT DMOJDPT USB
CBKBCBBUJFNQPQBSDJBMZ BNFOVEP B
UJFNQP DPNQMFUP FO MPT IPTQJUBMFT Q
CMJDPT RVFFSBONFKPSFRVJQBEPTZDPO
UBCBODPONFKPSFTQSPGFTJPOBMFTRVFFM
TFDUPS QSJWBEP  QPS MP NFOPT IBTUB MPT
BPT  %VSBOUF MBT EDBEBT TJHVJFO
UFT  MPT TFSWJDJPT NEJDPT QSJWBEPT  FO
MB GPSNB EF FKFSDJDJP JOEJWJEVBM EF MB
QSPGFTJOZFOVOQFRVFPONFSPEF
DMOJDBT  DPNFO[BSPO B QSPTQFSBS Z B
SFTUBSDBEBWF[NTNEJDPTEFMTFSWJDJP
EFIPTQJUBM EFNPEPRVFMBNBZPSBEF
FMMPT USBCBKB IPZ FYDMVTJWBNFOUF FO FM
TFDUPSQSJWBEP RVFSQJEBNFOUFTFBN
QMB EPOEFTFDVJEBBOPNTRVFVOB
RVJOUBQBSUFEFMBQPCMBDJOUPUBM"D
UVBMNFOUF MBTJOTUBMBDJPOFTNEJDBTQSJ
WBEBTQSFTFOUBOVOONFSPFYDFTJWPEF
NEJDPTZFTUOEPUBEBTEFJNQPSUBOUFT
SFDVSTPTJOTUSVNFOUBMFTFODPNQBSBDJO
DPOFMTFDUPSQCMJDP-BTVOJWFSTJEBEFT
QSJWBEBT FYDFEFO FO ONFSP B MBT Q
CMJDBT  EF NPEP RVF NT NEJDPT TF
HSBEBOFOFTDVFMBTSFDJODSFBEBTRVF
FOMBTUSBEJDJPOBMFT RVFPGSFDFOFOUSF
OBNJFOUPFOIPTQJUBMFTQCMJDPTZFTUJ
NVMBOGVFSUFTDPNQSPNJTPTTPDJBMFT
-PT DPODFQUPT EF KVTUJDJB TPO TVCTUBO
DJBMNFOUFFMDFOUSPEFMBTQSFPDVQBDJP
OFTCJPUJDBT FTQFDJBMNFOUFFOVOQBT
DPNP$IJMFRVFQSFTFOUBHSBOEFTEJTQB
SJEBEFTTPDJBMFTZEFSFOUB4JOFNCBSHP 
MB KVTUJDJB EJTUSJCVUJWB TF NBOFKB NT
DPNPVOBDVFTUJOQPMUJDBRVFUJDB-B
$POTUJUVDJODIJMFOBQSPDMBNBFMEFSF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DIP B DVJEBEPT NEJDPT P  FO VOB WB


SJBDJOJOUSPEVDJEBEVSBOUFFMSHJNFO
NJMJUBS BMBQSPUFDDJOTBOJUBSJB%FTEF
MPT BPT  TF PSHBOJ[ Z mOBODJ VO
TFSWJDJPOBDJPOBMEFDVJEBEPTNEJDPT 
DPO BQSPYJNBEBNFOUF FM  EFM 1SP
EVDUP*OUFSOP#SVUP 1*#
QBSBDVCSJS
OFDFTJEBEFTEFTBMVEQCMJDBZBTJTUFODJB
NEJDBBMPTQPCSFT MPTEFTFNQMFBEPT 
MBNBOPEFPCSBZTVGBNJMJB)BCB QPS
TVQVFTUP HSBOEFTDBSFODJBTFJOTVmDJFO
DJBT JODMVTPEFTQVTEFMCSFWFQFSPEP
EF MB QSFTJEFODJB EF "MMFOEF 

 DVBOEP FM QSFTVQVFTUP GVF BV
NFOUBEPB EFM1*#
6OBDSJTJTJNQPSUBOUFFOFMBDDFTPBMPT
DVJEBEPT NEJDPT TF EFTFODBEFO MVF
HP EF RVF MB EJDUBEVSB NJMJUBS BDPSU
UPEPT MPT TFSWJDJPT TPDJBMFT  JODMVZFOEP
MBBZVEBNEJDBRVFIBSFDVQFSBEPMFO
UBNFOUF FM NQFUV Z TF IB CFOFmDJBEP
EFMBTSFGPSNBTJOTUJUVJEBTFO-PT
DVJEBEPTNEJDPTIBONFKPSBEPQBSBFM
EFMPTDIJMFOPTQSPUFHJEPTQPS
BTJTUFODJBNEJDBHSBUVJUBPTVCWFODJP
OBEBQPSJNQVFTUPT QFSPMPTQSPHSBNBT
mOBODJBEPT QPS FM &TUBEP UPEBWB TPO
JOGFSJPSFTBMPTTFSWJDJPTNEJDPTDVCJFS
UPTQPSTFHVSPTQSJWBEPTEFTBMVE"IPSB
TF FTUBCMFDF mSNFNFOUF VO TJTUFNB EF
DVJEBEPTEFTBMVEEFEPCMFOJWFM FOFM
DVBM VO ONFSP EF DMOJDBT BMUBNFOUF
TPmTUJDBEBT TF PDVQBO EF MPT BEJOFSB
EPT PGSFDJFOEPBDDFTPBMBTNTOVFWBT
UFDOPMPHBTZMPTBUSBDUJWPTEFMDVJEBEP
IPTQJUBMBSJPMVKPTP
-BQSDUJDBSFBMEFMBNFEJDJOBIBBMDBO
[BEP UBNCJO VO GVFSUF QSBHNBUJTNP 





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

TJFOEP MB GPSNBDJO QFSNBOFOUF PGSF


DJEB FO HSBOEF QBSUF DPO FM QBUSPDJOJP
EJTGSB[BEPEFMBJOEVTUSJBGBSNBDVUJDB
"MHVOBTEFMBTQSJODJQBMFTDMOJDBTQSJWB
EBTTFIBODPOWFSUJEPFOPSHBOJ[BDJPOFT
EFDVJEBEPTEFTBMVEZSFRVJFSFOEFTVT
NEJDPT VO USBCBKP FDPONJDBNFOUF
FmDJFOUF
&OTVNB MBCJPUJDBFNFSHFFOVOQBT
RVF  QPS NVDIBT EDBEBT  IBCB DPOP
DJEPVOBQSPGFTJONEJDBEFEJDBEBBM
TFSWJDJP QCMJDP Z UJDP  SFHVMBEB QPS
VOB BTPDJBDJO NEJDB GVFSUF #BKP FM
SHJNFONJMJUBSEF1JOPDIFUTFEFCJMJUB
SPO MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT QCMJDBT -PT TFS
WJDJPTTPDJBMFT JODMVZFOEPMBFEVDBDJO
ZMBNFEJDJOB IBOTJEPDBTJUPUBMNFOUF
QSJWBUJ[BEPTZMBTBTPDJBDJPOFTQSPGFTJP
OBMFTIBOQFSEJEPFMQPEFSEFTVQFSWJTBS
EFVOBNBOFSBSFHVMBSMBDPOEVDUBUJDB
EFTVTNJFNCSPT"VORVFFTUPTGBDUPSFT
OP GBWPSFDFO VO SQJEP Z GVFSUF DPN
QSPNJTP DPO MB EFMJCFSBDJO CJPUJDB 
IBZVODSFDJNJFOUPDPOTUBOUFEFMJOUF
STQPSFMUFNB

-PTDPNJFO[PTEFMBCJPUJDB
-PT IJTUPSJBEPSFT UJFOFO SBSBNFOUF MB
PQPSUVOJEBE EF SFHJTUSBS FM OBDJNJFOUP
EF VOB EJTDJQMJOB  FTQFDJBMNFOUF TJ OP
FNFSHFFOSFMBDJODPODBNCJPTDJFOU
mDPT JNQPSUBOUFT &M TVSHJNJFOUP EF MB
CJPUJDBGVFMPDBMJ[BEPZTFHVJEPQPSMB
DSFBDJOJONFEJBUBEFJOTUJUVDJPOFT MBT
RVFSFDMVUBSPOBVOONFSPEFDBQBDJ
UBEPTFSVEJUPTRVFTFDPOWFSUJSBOSQJ
EBNFOUFFOTVTQBESFTGVOEBEPSFT&TB
FNFSHFODJB GVMHFOUF FO MPT &&66 OP
TFSFQJUJFOPUSBQBSUF ZFO"NSJDB-B

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UJOBTFEFCFSFMBUBSVOBIJTUPSJBNVDIP
NFOPTFNPDJPOBOUF QPSRVFMBEJTDJQMJ
OBTFJODPSQPSBEFNBOFSBNVZWBDJMBOUF
ZSFTFSWBEBBMBWJEBTPDJBMZBDBENJDB
$IJMF OP NPTUS FO MPT BPT  OJO
HO DBTP EF JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJO EF MB
CJPUJDB DPNPTPDVSSJFO"SHFOUJOB 
$PMPNCJB Z #SBTJM -FO  
 -B
OFDFTJEBE EF VO OVFWP BDFSDBNJFOUP B
MPT EJMFNBT UJDPT QSFTFOUBEPT QPS MBT
QSDUJDBT DMOJDBT Z EF JOWFTUJHBDJO FSB
DBTJJOFYJTUFOUF ZMPTQSPCMFNBTGVFSPO
EJTDVUJEPTEFVOBNBOFSBRVFIJ[PQPDP
NTRVFDPSSPCPSBSMBTPQJOJPOFTUSBEJ
DJPOBMFT&ODPOUSBTUFDPOPUSPTQBTFT 
MPT mMTPGPT OP EFNPTUSBSPO OJOHO
JOUFST UFNQSBOP QPS MB CJPUJDB  Z MB
SFnFYJO UFSJDB BDFSDB EF DVFTUJPOFT
NEJDBTZCJPMHJDBTFSBSFBMJ[BEBQSJODJ
QBMNFOUFQPSOVFTUSPTNTQSPNJOFOUFT
NEJDPT IVNBOJTUBT  RVF FTUVEJBSPO MB
UJDB mMPTmDB QBSB PQJOBS BEFDVBEB
NFOUF TPCSF FMMBT 7JBM $PSSFB  
3PB3FCPMMFEP 
&OTFMMFW
BDBCPVOTJNQPTJPTPCSFMBUJDBNEJDB
CBKPFMMFNBi3FTQFUPZQSPNPDJOEFMB
QFSTPOBIVNBOBFOMBNFEJDJOBNPEFS
OBw-BQBMBCSBiCJPUJDBwGVFJODPSQPSB
EBBMUUVMPEFMPT"OBMFTQFSPMBNBZPSB
EF MPT DIJMFOPT RVF DPOUSJCVZFSPO TMP
SBSBNFOUF MB NFODJPOBSPO -BWBEPT 
.POHF 2VJOUBOBZ4FSBOJ 

-BT FTDVFMBT EF NFEJDJOB FOTFBCBO MB
UJDB NEJDB USBEJDJPOBM Z FTDBTBNFOUF
QFSDJCBO FM DBNCJP IBDJB MB CJPUJDB
-PT QSJNFSPT DFOUSPT EF CJPUJDB  JO
EJWJEVBMFT P DPNCJOBEPT DPO FTUVEJPT
IVNBOJTUBT  TF DSFBSPO FO MBT QSJODJ
QBMFT FTDVFMBT NEJDBT &SBO VOJEBEFT





#JPUJDBFO$IJMF.JHVFM,PUUPX

BDBENJDBT QFRVFBT  EFEJDBEBT QSJO


DJQBMNFOUF B MB FOTFBO[B EF DVSTPT
PQDJPOBMFTRVF NTBEFMBOUF TFJODMV
ZFSPOFOMPTQMBOFTEFFTUVEJPPmDJBMFT
'JHVFSPB Z 'VFO[BMJEB  
 &TUPT
DFOUSPT IBO BNQMJBEP BDUVBMNFOUF TVT
BDUJWJEBEFT  PGSFDJFOEP QSPHSBNBT EF
QPTHSBEPEFNBFTUSBFOCJPUJDB
&O  TF DSF VO DFOUSP JOUFSEJTDJ
QMJOBSJP EF CJPUJDB FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
EF$IJMF CBKPMBTVQFSWJTJOEFMBSFD
UPSB  FO FM DVBM GVF DPODFCJEP VOP EF
MPTQSJNFSPTMJCSPTEFCJPUJDB ,PUUPX 

 -PT JOUFHSBOUFT EFM DVFSQP BDB
ENJDPOPUFOBOCBTUBOUFGBNJMJBSJEBE
DPOMBJEFBEFCJPUJDBQBSBJOUFSBDUVBS
BDUJWBNFOUFDPOFM$FOUSP RVFEFKEF
GVODJPOBS EVSBOUF BMHO UJFNQP Z GVF
SFTUBCMFDJEPDPNP$FOUSP*OUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO#JPUJDB EFEJDBEP
B BDUJWJEBEFT EF JOWFTUJHBDJO Z B QSP
HSBNBTEFFOUSFOBNJFOUPEFHSBEVBEPT 
BQPZBEPQPSGPOEPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
&O  TF BMDBO[ VO BDVFSEP FOUSF
MB0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4B
MVE 0140.4
FMHPCJFSOPDIJMFOPZ
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF $IJMF QBSB DSFBS FM
1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPUJDB 13#

FODBNJOBEP B QSPNPWFS BDUJWJEBEFT
CJPUJDBTFO"NSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCF
&OUSFTVTNMUJQMFTBDUJWJEBEFT FM13#
QVCMJDMPT$VBEFSOPTEFM1SPHSBNB3F
HJPOBMEF#JPUJDB DPOBSUDVMPTFTDSJUPT
QPSFTQFDJBMJTUBTSFHJPOBMFT FJOTUJUVZ
VO DVSTP EF EPT BPT EF .BFTUSB FO
#JPUJDB &TF QSPHSBNB JOUFSOBDJPOBM
GVF SFBMJ[BEP QPS EPT QFSPEPT DPOTF
DVUJWPTFO4BOUJBHPEF$IJMFZFTPGSF
DJEP BDUVBMNFOUF FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EF$VZP "SHFOUJOB&M13#TFIBSF
PSHBOJ[BEP DPNP 6OJEBE EF #JPUJDB 
BTJTUJEBQPSVO$POTFKP$POTVMUJWP*O
UFSOBDJPOBM$POUJOBQVCMJDBOEPVOB
SFWJTUB TFNFTUSBM  BIPSB MMBNBEB "DUB
#JPFUIJDB  Z IB EFTBSSPMMBEP TV QSPQJP
QSPHSBNB BDUJWP Z BMUBNFOUF QSPEVD
UJWP EF JOWFTUJHBDJO Z FOUSFOBNJFOUP
-PMBT 

%VSBOUFMPTBPTMPTFTQFDJBMJTUBTDIJ
MFOPTDPNFO[BSPOBQVCMJDBS BMQSJODJ
QJPFTQPSEJDBNFOUFFOQFSJEJDPTN
EJDPT  FO MBT BOUFEJDIBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT
PmDJBMFTEFMB014Z NTSFDJFOUFNFO
UF FOMBT"DUBTEFMBTSFVOJPOFTDFMFCSB
EBTFO$IJMFZPUSPTQBTFTMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOPT6OONFSPQFRVFPEFBVUPSFT
IBQVCMJDBEPFOSFWJTUBTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
ZBMHVOPTTPONJFNCSPTEFMPTDPNJUT
FEJUPSJBMFT EF QSFTUJHJPTBT SFWJTUBT DJFO
UmDBT FO "SHFOUJOB  #SBTJM  $PMPNCJB 
&&66Z(SBO#SFUBB
-BWJEBDPSQPSBUJWBEFMBCJPUJDBDIJMFOB
FTECJM-B"TPDJBDJO.EJDB$IJMFOB
IB DSFBEP VO (SVQP EF &TUVEJPT Z VO
%FQBSUBNFOUP EF #JPUJDB  RVF BDPO
TFKB B MB +VOUB %JSFDUJWB FO DVFTUJPOFT
UJDBT Z CJPUJDBT 6O 1SFNJP EF UJDB
BOVBM TF PUPSHB BM NFKPS FOTBZP QSF
TFOUBEP P QVCMJDBEP QPS VO NJFNCSP
DPMFHJBEP EF MB QSPGFTJO NEJDB -B
4PDJFEBE$IJMFOBEF#JPUJDB GVOEBEB
IBDF EJF[ BPT  IB TPCSFEJNFOTJPOBEP
TVDBOUJEBEEFNJFNCSPTSFDVSSJFOEPB
QPMUJDBTEFBENJTJOEFNBTJBEPMJCFSB
MFT-BTSFVOJPOFT QSPHSBNBEBTJOJDJBM
NFOUF QBSB TFS BOVBMFT  IBO MMFHBEP B
TFSNVZJSSFHVMBSFT-BSFDJFOUFNVFSUF
QSFNBUVSBEFTVQSFTJEFOUFFOFKFSDJDJP





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

MBO[BVOBTPNCSBEFJODFSUJEVNCSFTP
CSFFMGVUVSPEFFTUB4PDJFEBE
-B DPOEJDJO EF NJFNCSP EF BTPDJB
DJPOFT SFHJPOBMFT  DPNP MB 'FEFSBDJO
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF *OTUJUVDJPOFT EF
#JPUJDB '&-"*#&
 Z FM 'PSP -BUJOP
BNFSJDBOPEF$PNJUTEFUJDBEFMB*O
WFTUJHBDJOFO4BMVE '-"$&*4
IBTJEP
FTQPSEJDB QFSP$IJMFUJFOFSFQSFTFOUB
DJOFOFM$POTFKP%JSFDUJWPEF3&%
#*06/&4$0  FO MB 3FE EF #JPUJDB
QBSB"NSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCF ZFOFM
$POTFKP EFM $BQUVMP -BUJOPBNFSJDBOP
EFMB4PDJFEBE*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB
4*#*
 3FHVMBSNFOUF  TF JOWJUB B BMHV
OPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT DIJMFOPT B QBSUJDJQBS
FOSFVOJPOFTSFHJPOBMFTZBDUJWJEBEFTEF
FOTFBO[B BTDPNPFOFRVJQPTJOUFSOB
DJPOBMFT EF JOWFTUJHBDJO QBUSPDJOBEPT
QPSMB6/&4$0 0.4 014 /BUJPOBM
*OTUJUVUFT PG )FBMUI /*)
 4F IBO QV
CMJDBEP MJCSPT EF UJDB Z CJPUJDB 3PB 

UJDBDMOJDBZCJPUJDB -BWBEPTZ
4FSO 
CJPUJDB -PMBT &T
DSCBS 1SF[Z7JMMBSSPFM ,PUUPX 

 CJPUJDB Z BOUSPQPMPHB NEJDB
-PMBT   ,PUUPX Z #VTUPT  

UFPMPHBZCJPUJDB .JGTVE 
CJP
UJDBZTBMVEQCMJDB ,PUUPX 
CJP
UJDB Z EFSFDIP 6HBSUF  
 ZPUSBT
DVFTUJPOFTFTQFDmDBT #FDB 


*OTUJUVDJPOFT
&M QSJODJQBM DPNQSPNJTP JOTUJUVDJPOBM
EFMBCJPUJDBFTMBDSFBDJOZFMGVODJP
OBNJFOUPBQSPQJBEPEFDPNJUTIPTQJ
UBMBSJPT QBSB MB TVQFSWJTJO EF BTQFDUPT
UJDPT FO MB BTJTUFODJB NEJDB JOTUJUV

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DJPOBM Z MB QSPUFDDJO EF MPT EFSFDIPT


EF MPT QBDJFOUFT -PT QSJNFSPT DPNJUT
FOIPTQJUBMFTDIJMFOPTTVSHFOFO 
QFSP TMP FO  TF QVCMJDB VOB QSJ
NFSB OPSNBUJWB PCMJHBOEP B UPEPT MPT
IPTQJUBMFTJNQPSUBOUFTBGPSNBSVODP
NJUNEJDPEFUJDB1VCMJDBEPQPSFM
.JOJTUFSJP EF MB 4BMVE  FM EPDVNFOUP
IB TJEP DBTJ DPNQMFUBNFOUF JHOPSBEP
TFGPSNBSPOBMHVOPTDPNJUTRVFOVODB
GVODJPOBO PUSPTBMFHBORVFOPFODVFO
USBONJFNCSPTBQSPQJBEPTZEJTQVFTUPT 
Z MPT RVF TF DPOTUJUVZFSPO TJHVFO TJO
BDUVBSEFCJEPBMBDBSFODJBEFFYQFSJFO
DJB .BSUOF[ 
"DUVBMNFOUF MPT
IPTQJUBMFT RVF TJSWFO EF FTDVFMBT IBO
GPSNBEPmOBMNFOUFBTVTDPNJUT BNF
OVEPDPOGVODJPOFTNF[DMBEBTEFBTJT
UFODJBNEJDBFJOWFTUJHBDJO ZCBKPMB
EJGVOEJEBJNQSFTJOEFRVFEFCFOFTUBS
GPSNBEPTQPSVOBNBZPSBEFNEJDPT 
DPOMBQSFTFODJBBJTMBEBEFBMHOQSPGF
TJPOBMEFDVJEBEPTNEJDPTZ TJQPTJCMF 
EFVOBQFSTPOBMBJDBEFMBDPNVOJEBE
-PTDPNJUTIPTQJUBMBSJPTIBOTJEPNVZ
DPOTFSWBEPSFTZ HFOFSBMNFOUF TMPTJ
HVFO MB MFZ  MBT SFHVMBDJPOFT PmDJBMFT P
MBT SFHMBT EF MB DBTB &M SFTQFUP QPS MB
WJEBTFDPOTJEFSBVOQSFDFQUPTVQSFNP
RVF TF TPCSFQPOF B UPEB EFDJTJO SFGF
SFOUFBQSPDFEJNJFOUPTEFBDPSUBNJFOUP
EFMBWJEBPSFDIB[PEFUSBUBNJFOUPEF
QBSUFEFMPTQBDJFOUFT JODMVZFOEPBMPT
5FTUJHPT EF +FIPW &O DBTPT FYUSFNB
EBNFOUF FYDFQDJPOBMFT  VO DPNJU IB
TJEPGBWPSBCMFBVOBQFUJDJOEFEFTWP
EF MB FTUSJDUB MFUSB EF MB MFZ  IPOSBOEP
VOBQFUJDJOEFQBSUPQSFNBUVSPEFVO
OJP BOFODFGMJDP P BDFQUBOEP MB EFDJ





#JPUJDBFO$IJMF.JHVFM,PUUPX

TJOJOGPSNBEBEFVOQBDJFOUFRVFSF
DIB[BUSBUBNJFOUPDSUJDP
1PS NT EF DJODP BPT IB FTUBEP CBKP
FWBMVBDJO FO FM 1BSMBNFOUP VOB MFZ
SFGFSJEBBMPTEFSFDIPTEFMPTQBDJFOUFT 
Z TF FTU SFGPSNVMBOEP  EF UBM NBOFSB
RVF SFRVFSJSO PUSPT EPT P USFT BPT
QBSBRVFTFMMFHVFBVOBDVFSEPEFmOJUJ
WP"VORVFGBWPSBCMFBMCJFOFTUBSEFMB
HFOUF IPTQJUBMJ[BEB  FTB MFZ DPOUJOVBS
TPTUFOJFOEP MB OFHBUJWB EF MPT DPNJUT
QBSBMJCFSBMJ[BSMBTEFDJTJPOFTEFmOBMEF
WJEB
&MFRVJWBMFOUFDIJMFOPEFMPT*3# *OTUJ
UVDJPOBM3FWJFX#PBSET
TPOMPTDPNJUT
EFCJPUJDBFOJOWFTUJHBDJO DBEBWF[NT
PCMJHBUPSJPT  QSJODJQBMNFOUF QPSRVF FM
mOBODJBNJFOUPPmDJBMEFMPTQSPUPDPMPT
DPOTJEFSBSTPMBNFOUFMPTQSPZFDUPTRVF
IBZBOTJEPBQSPCBEPTQPSFMDPNJUEF
MB JOTUJUVDJO EF MPT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT -B
DPNQPTJDJOZMPTBDUPTEFFTUPTDPNJUT
TJHVFO TJFOEP BCTPMVUBNFOUF DBTVBMFT 
QFSP TF QFSDJCFO FTGVFS[PT FO EJWFSTPT
OJWFMFT QBSB JNQPOFSMFT DFSUJmDBDJO Z
BVNFOUBS FM OJWFM EF DBQBDJEBE EF TVT
NJFNCSPT ,PUUPX  
4MP
NVZ SFDJFOUFNFOUF  MBT JOWFTUJHBDJPOFT
DPOTVKFUPTIVNBOPTZFOBOJNBMFTIBO
SFDJCJEPVOBBUFODJOUJDBEJTUJOUBQPS
MPT DPNJUT BE IPD .VDIPT NJFNCSPT
EFDPNJUTBOTFCBTBOFOMB%FDMBSB
DJOEF)FMTJOLJZFTUOBQFOBTFOUFSB
EPTEFMPTDPOnJDUPTTVSHJEPTBSB[EFMB
WFSTJONTSFDJFOUFEFFTFEPDVNFOUP
ZEFTVTNPEJmDBDJPOFT4FIBBQSPCBEP
NVZSFDJFOUFNFOUFVOBMFZRVFSFRVJFSF
MBSFHVMBDJOFTUBOEBSEJ[BEBEFMBJOWFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UJHBDJODPOTFSFTIVNBOPTZTFFTUEJT
DVUJFOEPFOEJWFSTPTOJWFMFTMBTNBOFSBT
QPTJCMFTEFDSFBSPSFGPS[BSBJOTUJUVDJP
OFTEFUJDBEFJOWFTUJHBDJO
&OTFDSFMB$PNJTJO/BDJPOBM
EF *OWFTUJHBDJO $JFOUmDB Z 5FDOP
MHJDB $0/*$:5
 DPO MB NJTJO EF
TVQFSWJTBS Z mOBODJBS JOWFTUJHBDJPOFT
EF BMUB DBMJEBE $0/*$:5 TVQFSWJTB
BM'POEP/BDJPOBMEF%FTBSSPMMP$JFO
UmDP Z 5FDOPMHJDP '0/%&$:5

EFEJDBEPBMBJOWFTUJHBDJOCTJDBFOMBT
DJFODJBTEFMBWJEB&TJOUFSFTBOUFRVFMB
DPOTJEFSBDJO UJDB QSJNFSP BQBSFDJFSB
FO DVBOEP$0/*$:5iTVHJSJw
RVF MPT QSPUPDPMPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJO TF
TPNFUJFSBOBVODPNJUJOTUJUVDJPOBMEF
UJDB EF PUSB NBOFSB  $0/*$:5 QP
EB TPMJDJUBS VOB DPOTVMUB UJDB QSPQJB
&OUSFZMMFHBTFSDBEBWF[
NTPCMJHBUPSJPDPOUBSDPOVOJOGPSNF
EFVO*3#6OBPNTUBSEF TPNFUFS
FMQSPZFDUPBVOJOGPSNFUJDPGVFSFDP
NFOEBEPUBNCJOQBSBMBJOWFTUJHBDJO
BOJNBMZDVBUSPBPTNTUBSEFTFDPO
WJSUJFOPCMJHBUPSJP%FCJQBTBSIBTUB
QBSBRVFVOBDPQJBEFMEPDVNFO
UPEFDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEPUVWJFSB
RVFTFSJODMVJEBFOMBQSPQVFTUBEFDPO
DFTJOEFGPOEPTMPTFTUVEJPTHFOUJDPT
SFRVJFSFO OP TPMBNFOUF MB BQSPCBDJO
TJOP EFUBMMBEPT DPNFOUBSJPT QPS QBSUF
EFVODPNJUEFUJDB
&TB CSFWF TFDVFODJB EF FWFOUPT TVHJFSF
RVFMBUJDBEFJOWFTUJHBDJOGVFJODPS
QPSBEBNVZSQJEBNFOUFBMPTQSPUPDP
MPTEFDPODFTJOEFSFDVSTPTTJOFNCBS
HP  FO  $0/*$:5 EFDJEJ DSFBS





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

TVQSPQJP$PNJU$POTVMUJWPEF#JP
UJDBTUFDVFOUBDPODVBUSPNJFNCSPT
QFSNBOFOUFT FYQFSUPTFOJOWFTUJHBDJO
CJPNEJDBZFODJFODJBTTPDJBMFT DPOFY
QFSJFODJBFOUSBCBKPEFDPNJUTZDPOP
DJNJFOUPEFMBCJPUJDBUFSJDB%FTQVT
EFRVFFMDPNJUIVCJFSBFYBNJOBEPBM
HVOPTEFMPTQSPUPDPMPTBQSPCBEPTZm
OBODJBEPTFOFMQBTBEP BTDPNPTPMJDJ
UVEFTSFDJFOUFT RVFEFOFWJEFODJBRVF
MBNBZPSBEFMPTDPNJUT JODMVTPMPTEF
IPTQJUBMFT Z FTDVFMBT VOJWFSTJUBSJBT  OP
IBDBOVOUSBCBKPDVJEBEPTPFOMBFWB
MVBDJOEFTVTBTQFDUPTUJDPT.VDIPT
EF FMMPT IBCBO EBEP VOB BQSPCBDJO
QSP GPSNB P DPOmSNBEP TVNBSJBNFOUF
MB DPOGPSNJEBE DPO MB %FDMBSBDJO EF
)FMTJOLJ 4JO FNCBSHP  MB NBZPSB EF
FTUPT QSPUPDPMPT TVTDJUBCBO PCKFDJPOFT
RVF SFRVJSJFSPO FONJFOEBT  DPSSFDDJP
OFT JNQPSUBOUFT P  NT SBSBNFOUF  FM
TJNQMFSFDIB[P
4F QVFEF FTQFSBS RVF $0/*$:5
'0/%&$:5 TJFOEPMBJOTUJUVDJOEF
mOBODJBNJFOUPEFJOWFTUJHBDJONTJN
QPSUBOUFFOFMQBT QSPNVFWBQPMUJDBT
Z SFHVMBDJPOFT SFGFSFOUFT B MPT DPNJUT
EFUJDBEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJO QPOJOEP
MPT BM EB Z TPNFUJFOEP B DFSUJmDBDJO
&TPTFTGVFS[PTTFSOBQPZBEPTQPSMBMFZ
SFDJFOUFNFOUF BQSPCBEB  RVF BVUPSJ[B
BM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVEZBMB$PNJTJO
/BDJPOBM EF #JPUJDB oRVF FTU TJFOEP
DSFBEBoBSFHVMBSZTVQFSWJTBSMBJOWFTUJ
HBDJODPOTVKFUPTIVNBOPT
)VCPNVDIBEJTDVTJOTPCSFWFOUBKBTZ
EFTWFOUBKBTEFDSFBSVOB$PNJTJO/B
DJPOBM EF #JPUJDB -PT RVF BQSPCBCBO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

TVGPSNBDJOUPNBCBOB'SBODJBDPNP
FKFNQMP EF VOB DPNJTJO FmDJFOUF 
NJFOUSBTRVFMPTPQPTJUPSFTTFBMBCBOB
BMHVOBT DPNJTJPOFT JOFmDBDFT EF MB SF
HJO-BQPTJDJOGBWPSBCMFBMB$PNJ
TJO/BDJPOBMIBTBMJEP FWFOUVBMNFOUF 
WJDUPSJPTB QFSPNVDIBTEFMBTTVHFSFO
DJBTQSFTFOUBEBTOPGVFSPODPOTJEFSBEBT
Z QPTJCMFNFOUF $IJMFUFOESVOB$P
NJTJOOPUPUBMNFOUFFmDB[

%FMJCFSBDJPOFTCJPUJDBTF
JOnVFODJBTDVMUVSBMFT
6OBIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPUJDBFTNTRVFMB
QSFTFOUBDJO EF TVT QSPUBHPOJTUBT Z EF
TVT QSPEVDUPT .T GVOEBNFOUBM  RVJ
[T FTMBIJTUPSJBEFTVTJEFBT QPSRVFMB
CJPUJDBFTVOBUJDBBQMJDBEBBQSDUJDBT
TPDJBMFTRVFQSFPDVQBOBUPEBMBHFOUFZ
RVFTFFONBSBBODPOMPTQBUSPOFTDVM
UVSBMFTEFMEJTDVSTPNPSBMQSFWBMFDJFOUF
5SFT GVFS[BT JNQPSUBOUFT IBO JOnVFO
DJBEPFMEFTBSSPMMPEFJEFBTCJPUJDBTFO
$IJMF  DPNP TVDFEJ FO NVDIBT PUSBT
OBDJPOFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT &O QSJNFS
MVHBS  MBT CBTFT EF MB CJPUJDB BOHMP
TBKPOB  FO QBSUJDVMBS FM QSJODJQJBMJTNP 
GVFSPOBCTPSCJEBTDPNPMBFTDVFMBNT
DPIFSFOUF EF QFOTBNJFOUP EJTQPOJCMF
&OTFHVOEPUSNJOP MB*HMFTJB$BUMJDB
EFTBSSPMM VO JOUFST UFNQSBOP FO MPT
QSPCMFNBT CJPNEJDPT  FTQFDJBMNFO
UF MPT OUJNBNFOUF SFMBDJPOBEPT DPO
MBEPDUSJOB'JOBMNFOUF MBTGVFS[BTEFM
NFSDBEP IBO BDUVBEP DPO VO JNQBDUP
JNQPSUBOUFTPCSFMBTQSDUJDBTZWBMPSFT
CJPNEJDPT
"VORVF FM QSJODJQJBMJTNP GVF TBMVEBEP
DPNP TJTUFNB OPSNBUJWP USBOTQBSFOUF





#JPUJDBFO$IJMF.JHVFM,PUUPX

Z EF GDJM BDFQUBDJO  QSPOUP TF MMFH B


QFSDJCJSRVFMBJEFBEFDVBUSPQSJODJQJPT
FRVJWBMFOUFT OP TF BDFQUBCB GDJMNFOUF
FOVOBDVMUVSBEPOEFFMDPMPOJBMJTNPZ
MBTEJTUJODJPOFTEFDMBTFIBCBOTJEPQBS
UFJNQPSUBOUFEFMBIJTUPSJBZ FODJFSUP
HSBEP FTUOIPZBDUJWBNFOUFQSFTFOUFT
1PSDPOTJHVJFOUF MBBVUPOPNBOPTFQP
EBBDFQUBSDPNPVOBDVBMJEBEVOJWFSTBM 
QVFTMPTOPFEVDBEPT MPTFOGFSNPT MPT
KWFOFTZ BOFOHSBEPNTHSBOEF MB
QPCMBDJO GFNFOJOB  FSBO DPOTJEFSBEPT
MJNJUBEPT FO TV DBQBDJEBE NFOUBM -B
CFOFmDFODJB UBNCJO GVF DPSSPNQJEB
QPSVOBMBSHBUSBEJDJOEFIFHFNPOBEF
DMBTFZEFDBUFHPSBQSPGFTJPOBM ZMBBTJH
OBDJOZFWBMVBDJOEFWFOUBKBTUPEBWB
GVODJPOB CBKP FM MFNB iFM EPDUPS TBCF
NTw &O GPSNB QBSBMFMB  MB OPNBMFm
DFODJBFSBNVZBNFOVEPSFDIB[BEBQPS
FMNEJDPZTFTJMFODJBCBOMPTSJFTHPTQP
TJCMFT EFGPSNOEPTFBTMBTJOGPSNBDJP
OFTEBEBTBMPTQBDJFOUFTPBMPTTVKFUPT
EFJOWFTUJHBDJO5PEPTFTUPTQSPHSFTPT
PDVSSFO JO BCTFOUJB EF VOB EJTDVTJO F
JMVTUSBOMBJOFmDBDJBEFMBCJPUJDBQBSB
QSPWPDBSVOBEFMJCFSBDJOQCMJDBBDFSDB
EFBMHVOBTEFMBTDVFTUJPOFTTPDJBMNFOUF
NTSFMFWBOUFT DPNPFMBCPSUP MBDPO
USBDFQDJO oJODMVZFOEP MB iQMEPSB EFM
EBEFTQVTwo MBFTUFSJMJ[BDJOWPMVOUB
SJB MBFVUBOBTJBZ QPSTVQVFTUP MBKVTUJ
DJBFOMPTDVJEBEPTNEJDPT5PEBTFTUBT
DVFTUJPOFTZBMHVOBTMFZFTZBFOWJHFODJB
oUSBTQMBOUF EF SHBOPT Z NVFSUF DFSF
CSBMoOPIBOTJEPTPNFUJEBTBEJTDVTJO
QCMJDB &M DPOTFKP Z FM DPOPDJNJFOUP
BDBENJDP FTQFDJBMJ[BEP TPO SBSBNFOUF
CVTDBEPTPSFTQFUBEPT ZOPIBZFWJEFO
DJB EF RVF MPT MFHJTMBEPSFT TF FTGVFSDFO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

QPS BERVJSJS BMHVOB DMBTF EF FEVDBDJO


CJPUJDB BOUFT EF EFDJEJS FO DVFTUJPOFT
EFJOUFSTOBDJPOBM
%FTEFRVFMPTNJTJPOFSPTDBUMJDPTQBS
UJDJQBSBO FO MB DPORVJTUB EF "NSJDB
-BUJOBZFNQSFOEJFSBOWPMVOUBSJBNFO
UF UBSFBT DJWJMFT  DPNP MB FEVDBDJO  FM
DVJEBEP IPTQJUBMBSJP Z MB HFSFODJB EF
DFNFOUFSJPT  MB *HMFTJB $BUMJDB IB HP
[BEP EF VOB QPTJDJO EF QSFFNJOFODJB
FOBTVOUPTQPMUJDPTZDVMUVSBMFT)BTUB
IPZ  BENJOJTUSB VO ONFSP TVTUBODJBM
EF MBT FTDVFMBT Z EF MBT VOJWFSTJEBEFT
NT JNQPSUBOUFT EFM QBT "MHVOPT EF
MPTQBSUJEPTQPMUJDPTQSJODJQBMFTDPOGBO
BCJFSUBNFOUF FO MB EPDUSJOB SFMJHJPTB Z
BQPZBOWJTJPOFTDPOTFSWBEPSBT$VBOEP
TVSHJMBCJPUJDB MB*HMFTJBFTUBCBQSF
QBSBEB ZB QBSB EFGFOEFS QPTJDJPOFT Z
QBSB FEVDBS BM QCMJDP FO USNJOPT EF
OP QFSNJUJS RVF FM MBJDJTNP JOUFSmSJFSB
FO MB EPDUSJOB SFMJHJPTB %F FTF NPEP 
MPT UFNBT NT QPMNJDPT EF MB CJP
UJDB OP IBO QPEJEP BMDBO[BS FM DBNQP
DJWJMZMPTMFHJTMBEPSFTTFIBONPTUSBEP
QPDPEJTQVFTUPTPJODBQBDFTEF BMNF
OPT EJTDVUJSDVFTUJPOFTDSUJDBTDPNPFM
BCPSUP MBFVUBOBTJB FMTVJDJEJPBTJTUJEP 
FM VTP EF DMVMBT USPODPFNCSJPOBSJBT 
MB QSPEVDDJO Z EFTUJOP EF FNCSJPOFT
TPCSBOUFT  FOUSF PUSPT UFNBT 5PEBWB
TF QSPEVDFO JORVJFUBOUFT DPOUSPWFSTJBT
TPCSF FM BDDFTP BM MFWPOPSHFTUSFM DPNP
DPOUSBDFQUJWP QPTUDPJUBM P BDFSDB EF MB
EJTUSJCVDJOEFQSFTFSWBUJWPTQBSBFWJUBS
FMDPOUBHJPQPSFM)*7
0USB JOnVFODJB JNQPSUBOUF FO FM EF
TBSSPMMP EFM QFOTBNJFOUP CJPUJDP IB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

TJEP MB GVFSUF UFOEFODJB OFPMJCFSBM FO


MBFDPOPNB RVFFTUBCMFDFMBTQPMUJDBT
QCMJDBTZUJFOEFBEFTBMFOUBSBVNFOUPT
TVCTUBODJBMFT FO MPT QSPHSBNBT mTDBMFT
SFMBDJPOBEPT DPO NVDIBT OFDFTJEBEFT
TPDJBMFT  JODMVTP MPT DVJEBEPT EF TBMVE
-PT FTUVEJPTPT EF CJPUJDB SFDPOPDFO
RVFTFIBOMMFWBEPBDBCPNFKPSBT QFSP
TFOFDFTJUBNVDIPNTFOVOQBTRVF
UPEBWB DVFOUB DPO NTEFEFTV
QPCMBDJOCBKPMBMOFBEFMBQPCSF[BZ
FOFMDVBMMPTTFSWJDJPTQCMJDPTEFDVJ
EBEPTEFTBMVEUSBCBKBODPOGPOEPTFT
DBTPT QFSTPOBMNBMQBHBEPZNBMFOUSF
OBEP  EFTSEFOFT BENJOJTUSBUJWPT Z VO
HSBEPBMUPEFEFTDPOmBO[BQCMJDB
.JFOUSBTTFFTUFTDSJCJFOEPFTUFDBQUV
MP FTUBETUJDBTOBDJPOBMFTJOGPSNBORVF 
FOFMDBNQPEFMBTBMVE IBBVNFOUBEP
FO BPT SFDJFOUFT MB EJTUBODJB FOUSF MPT
SJDPT Z MPT IBCJUBOUFT FEVDBEPT EF MBT
DJVEBEFTSFTQFDUPEFMPTQPCSFT OPFEV
DBEPT Z HFPHSmDBNFOUF BJTMBEPT &TUB
ETUJDBTPmDJBMFTEFNVFTUSBOUBNCJOVO
BVNFOUP FO MBT EJTQBSJEBEFT SFMBUJWBT B
DVJEBEPTNEJDPTZDPOEJDJOEFTBMVE 

EFCJEPBMBTJOKVTUJDJBTTPDJBMFTZFEVDBUJ
WBT&MDPNQSPNJTPTPDJBMEFMBCJPUJDB
JOUFOUBBMJWJBSFTUBTDBSFODJBT FOUSFOBO
EPQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFTBMVEQBSBRVFFTUO
NTFOUFSBEPTEFMBTJOKVTUJDJBTTPDJBMFT 
QBSUJDJQBOEPFODPNJUTIPTQJUBMBSJPTEF
JOWFTUJHBDJO EBOEPBTJTUFODJBBMQPEFS
MFHJTMBUJWP QBSB NFKPSBS MB DBMJEBE UJDB
EFMFZFTQFSUJOFOUFT BNQMJBOEPMBFOTF
BO[BEFQPTHSBEPQBSBDSFBSHFOFSBDJP
OFTEFQSPGFTJPOBMFTTFOTJCMFTBMPTQSP
CMFNBTUJDPTEFTVEJTDJQMJOB
&OTVNB $IJMFIBFNQF[BEPBFOUFSBSTF
MFOUBNFOUFEFMBJNQPSUBODJBEFMBCJP
UJDB EFTBSSPMMBOEPVOBBDUJWJEBEBDBE
NJDBNPEFSBEBRVFUPEBWBEFCFHBOBS
JOnVFODJB FO DBTPT EF GPSNVMBDJO EF
QPMUJDBTPFOMPRVFDPODJFSOFBMBDPO
DJFODJB QCMJDB -PT MPHSPT QFSTPOBMFT 
OPTJFNQSFEFTQSPWJTUPTEFSJWBMJEBEFT 
IBO QSFEPNJOBEP TPCSF DPNJTJPOFT
JOTUJUVDJPOBMFT  Z FM USBCBKP FO FRVJQP
FTU HBOBOEP NQFUV TMP MFOUBNFOUF 
SFQSPEVDJFOEP DPOEJDJPOFT Z SBTHPT
JHVBMNFOUFQSFTFOUFTFOPUSBTQBSUFTEF
"NSJDB-BUJOB

3FGFSFODJBT
#FDB +1 
&MFNCSJOIVNBOP4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJUPSJBM.FEJUFSSOFP
&TDSCBS " 1SF[ .Z7JMMBSSPFM 3 
#JPUJDB'VOEBNFOUPTZEJNFOTJOQSDUJDB
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJUPSJBM.FEJUFSSOFP
'JHVFSPB 1'VFO[BMJEB ) 
#JPFUIJDTJO*CFSP"NFSJDBBOEUIF$BSJCCFBO
5IF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZ  QQ
,PUUPX . 
*OUSPEVDDJOBMBCJPUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJUPSJBM6OJWFSTJUBSJB
,PUUPX  . 
 *OUSPEVDDJO B MB CJPUJDB B FE 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF  &EJUPSJBM
.FEJUFSSOFP
,PUUPX . 
#JPUJDBFOTBMVEQCMJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJUPSJBM1VFSUPEF1BMPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



#JPUJDBFO$IJMF.JHVFM,PUUPX



,PUUPX  . &E


 
 #JPUJDB F JOWFTUJHBDJO DPO TFSFT IVNBOPT Z FO BOJNBMFT
4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF $0/*$:5
,PUUPX . FE
 
.BSDPTOPSNBUJWPTEFMBUJDBFOJOWFTUJHBDJODJFOUGJDBDPOTFSFT
WJWPT4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF $0/*$:5 &OQSFQBSBDJO

,PUUPX .  #VTUPT 3 
 "OUSPQPMPHB NEJDB 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF  &EJUPSJBM
.FEJUFSSOFP
-BWBEPT . .POHF +* 2VJOUBOB $Z4FSBOJ " &ET
 
1SPCMFNBTDPOUFNQP
SOFPTFOCJPUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJDJPOFT6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDBEF$IJMF
-BWBEPT .Z4FSBOJ " 
UJDBDMOJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJDJPOFT6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUMJDBEF$IJMF
-FO  '+ 
 %JF[ BPT EF CJPUJDB FO "NSJDB -BUJOB IJTUPSJB SFDJFOUF Z SFUPT
BDUVBMFT&O-PMBT ' &E
%JMPHPZDPPQFSBDJOFOTBMVE%JF[BPTEFCJPUJDBFO
MB0144BOUJBHPEF$IJMF 6OJEBEEF#JPUJDB0140.4 QQ
-PMBT ' 
#JPUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJUPSJBM6OJWFSTJUBSJB
-PMBT  ' 
 #JPUJDB Z "OUSPQPMPHB .EJDB 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF  1VCMJDBDJPOFT
5DOJDBT.FEJUFSSOFP-UEB
-PMBT ' 
ZFBST1")0#JPFUIJDT6OJU 
"DUB#JPFUIJDB  

QQ
.BSUOF[ - 
4JUVBDJOEFMPT$PNJUTEF&UJDB)PTQJUBMBSJBFOFM4JTUFNBEF4BMVE
1CMJDBDIJMFOP&O,PUUPX . &E
5FNUJDBZGVODJPOBNJFOUPEFMPT$PNJUT
JOTUJUVDJPOBMFTEFUJDBNEJDBCJPUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF $FOUSP*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP
EF&TUVEJPTFO#JPUJDB 6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
.JGTVE 5 4+ 
&MSFTQFUPQPSMBWJEBIVNBOB CJPUJDB
.PSBMEFEJTDFSOJNJFOUP
UPNP**
SBFE4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJDJPOFT1BVMJOBT$*%&
1PUUFS % 
)PXEJETPDJBMNFEJDJOFFWPMWF BOEXIFSFJTJUIFBEJOH1MP4.FE 
 QQ%JTQPOJCMFFOXXXQMPTNFEJDJOFPSH%FTDBSHBEPFOPDUVCSF
EF
3PB  3" 
 *OWFTUJHBDJO DJFOUGJDB CJPNEJDB GVOEBNFOUPT UJDPT Z
BOUSPQPMHJDPT &O -BWBEPT  .  .POHF  +*  2VJOUBOB $ Z 4FSBOJ " &ET

1SPCMFNBT DPOUFNQPSOFPT FO CJPUJDB 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF  &EJDJPOFT 6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUMJDBEF$IJMF QQ
3PB 3" 
&UJDBZCJPUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJUPSJBM"OEST#FMMP
6HBSUF ++ 
&MEFSFDIPEFMBWJEB#JPUJDBZEFSFDIP4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJUPSJBM
+VSEJDBEF$IJMF
7JBM$PSSFB +EF% 
3FTQFUPZQSPNPDJOEFMBQFSTPOBIVNBOB&O-BWBEPT 
.  .POHF  +*  2VJOUBOB $ Z 4FSBOJ " &ET
 1SPCMFNBT DPOUFNQPSOFPT FO
CJPUJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJDJPOFT6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDBEF$IJMF QQ
7JFM # 
-BNFEJDJOBTPDJBMJ[BEBZTVBQMJDBDJOFO(SBO#SFUBB 6OJO4PWJUJDB
Z$IJMF4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJDJPOFTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

8BJU[LJO ) *SJBSU $ &TUSBEB "-BNBESJE 4 


4PDJBMNFEJDJOFUIFOBOE
OPX-FTTPOTGSPN-BUJO"NFSJDB"N+1VCMJD)FBMUI  QQ
8JMEFT ,8 
.PSBMBDRVBJOUBODFT/PUSF%BNF 6OJWFSTJUZPG/PUSF%BNF
1SFTT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





#JPUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE
+PT3BNO"DPTUB4BSJFHP

VCBFTVOQBTRVF EVSBOUFEDBEBT 
IBSFQSFTFOUBEPVODBTPTVJHOFSJT
FO FM DPOUFYUP EF "NSJDB -BUJOB QPS
RVF BEFTQFDIPEFMPTWBJWFOFTEFMBQP
MUJDB SFHJPOBM  IB QFSNBOFDJEP FOGSBT
DBEPFOMBDPOTUSVDDJOEFVOQSPZFDUP
TPDJBM EF PSJFOUBDJO NBSUJBOB Z NBS
YJTUB1PSFTBSB[O QBSBBMHVOPTIBCS
TJEPVOBTPSQSFTBMBSQJEBFJSSFWFSTJCMF
QSPQBHBDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFOFMNCJUP
DVCBOP  EBEB MB WPDBDJO EFDVMUPQPS
MB MJCFSUBE JOEJWJEVBM RVF QSPNPWJ MB
CJPUJDBNEJDB PSJHJOBMNFOUFQFOTBEB
FOVODPOUFYUPEFFDPOPNBDBQJUBMJTUB
MJCFSBM1BSBPUSPT RVFWJTMVNCSBSPOMPT
JEFBMFTEFKVTUJDJBZFRVJEBEEFMBCJP
UJDB HMPCBM QPUUFSJBOB  MP PDVSSJEP FO
$VCB IB TJEP VOB DPOTFDVFODJB MHJDB
EFMBCTRVFEBEFVOBBMUFSOBUJWBEFTP
DJFEBETVTUFOUBCMF

6OBQFSTQFDUJWBEFTEF$VCBEFM
OVFWPQBSBEJHNBEFSFMBDJPOFT
TBOJUBSJBT
%FTEFMBJOTUBVSBDJOEFmOJUJWBEFM3FBM
5SJCVOBMEFM1SPUPNFEJDBUPEF-B)B
CBOB FO IBTUBMBGVOEBDJOQSJ
NFSPEFMB'FEFSBDJO.EJDBEF$VCB 
FO ZQPTUFSJPSNFOUFEFTVDPOUJ
OVBEPSFM$PMFHJP.EJDP/BDJPOBM FO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

  FM NPEFMP DVCBOP EF SFMBDJPOFT


TBOJUBSJBT TF DPSSFTQPOEJ DPO FM QBSB
EJHNBDMTJDPQBUFSOBMJTUB BVORVFDPO
NBUJDFT QSPQJPT RVF BO FO MBT FUBQBT
DPMPOJBMZSFQVCMJDBOBMFEJTUJOHVJFSPO
&OMBQSPQVFTUBEFSFGPSNBVOJWFSTJUB
SJB EF 'SBODJTDP "SBOHP Z 1BSSFP EF
QSJODJQJPT EFM TJHMP 9*9 FYJTUJ FM QSP
QTJUPEFJODMVJSMBFOTFBO[BEFMBUJDB
QSPGFTJPOBMFOMPTFTUVEJPTEFNFEJDJOB
FO $VCB 4JO FNCBSHP  FTUB JOUFODJO
SFRVJSJEFNVDIPUJFNQPQBSBTFSJN
QMFNFOUBEBFOMBQSDUJDB1BSBTVEFm
OJUJWBDPODSFDJOGVFSPOEFUFSNJOBOUFT
MBTDPOGFSFODJBTEF&OSJRVF+PT7BSP
OB TPCSF MPT 'VOEBNFOUPT EF MB .P
SBM oEJDUBEBT EFOUSP EF MPT DVSTPT RVF
JNQBSUJFOUSFZFOMB3FBM
"DBEFNJBEF$JFODJBT.EJDBT 'TJDBT
Z /BUVSBMFT EF -B )BCBOBo Z MB BDUJ
WJEBE EPDFOUF EF "OUPOJP +PWFS 1VJH 
3BJNVOEPEF$BTUSPZ"MMP 3BJNVOEP
EF$BTUSPZ#BDIJMMFS Z'SBODJTDP-BO
DTZ4ODIF[FOMBFOTFBO[BEFMBUJDB
ZMPTEFCFSFTNPSBMFTEFMNEJDP %FM
HBEP 

&O MB EDBEB EF   MB BDDFTJCJMJEBE
BMPTTFSWJDJPTEFTBMVETFQPMBSJ[DBEB
WF[NTZ NJFOUSBTMBTDMBTFTGBWPSFDJEBT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

EFMPTHSBOEFTODMFPTVSCBOPTEJTGSVUB
SPO EF MPT NBZPSFT Z NFKPSFT SFDVSTPT
IVNBOPT Z UDOJDPT  MB HFOFSBMJEBE EF
MBQPCMBDJOTFWJPPCMJHBEBBBDFQUBSMBT
NJHBKBTQPMJUJRVFSBTEFVOTFDUPSQCMJ
DP DBEB WF[ NT PCTPMFUP  JOTVmDJFOUF
Z EBOUFTDP &O UBOUP FTUP PDVSSB FO
FMTFOPEFMBDPOWVMTBTPDJFEBEDVCBOB
QSFSSFWPMVDJPOBSJB  USBT MBT QVFSUBT EFM
$PMFHJP.EJDP/BDJPOBMTFEFCBUBMB
DVFTUJOEFVOBTVQVFTUBQMUPSBNEJDB
ZMBOFDFTJEBEEFSFDMBNBSMBSFTUSJDDJO
EFMBGPSNBDJOEFOVFWPTQSPGFTJPOBMFT
&M$EJHPEF.PSBMZFM+VSBNFOUPEF
)POPS EFM $PMFHJP .EJDP /BDJPOBM 
iEF JOEJTDVUJCMF WJHFODJB FO TV QPDBw
%FMHBEP 
OPFTDBQBSPOEFMB
FUJRVFUBJNQVFTUBQPSPNBT1FSDJWBM
BMQBUFSOBMJTNPNEJDPNPEFSOP

-BKVTUJDJBDPNPTPMJEBSJEBE
&MBEWFOJNJFOUPEFMQPEFSSFWPMVDJPOB
SJPFOSFWJSUJUPUBMNFOUFFMFTDF
OBSJPOBDJPOBMBMQSFDPOJ[BSFMQSJODJQJP
NBSYJTUBEFJHVBMEBEFOFMBDDFTPBMPT
TFSWJDJPTEFTBMVEDPNPEFSFDIPIVNB
OP Z MB SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE EFM &TUBEP EF
QSPWFFS QSFTUBDJPOFT BEFDVBEBT Z BDDF
TJCMFTBUPEPT&TUPJNQMJD FOMBQSD
UJDB MBBNQMJBDJOZNPEFSOJ[BDJOEF
MBTVOJEBEFTEFTBMVEZ DPOFMMP FMJO
DSFNFOUP FYQPOFODJBM EF MB GPSNBDJO
EFSFDVSTPTIVNBOPT
&M $PMFHJP .EJDP /BDJPOBM EFWJOP
FOUPODFT FO FTDFOBSJP SBNBM EF MB JO
UFOTBMVDIBEFDMBTFTRVFTFEFTBSSPMMB
CB FO UPEB MB TPDJFEBE DVCBOB  MP RVF
DVMNJO FO VOB DSJTJT Z MB BVUPEJTPMV

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DJOEFMBJOTUJUVDJOFO5SBTTV
EFTBQBSJDJO ZQPSDBTJWFJOUFBPT MB
OPSNBUJWJEBE UJDB FO FM DBNQP EF MB
TBMVE RVFE B DBSHP EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF
4BMVE 1CMJDB  IBTUB RVF  B NFEJBEPT
EF MB EDBEB EF   TF QSPNVMHBSBO
MPT1SJODJQJPTEFMBUJDB.EJDBZUVWP
MVHBSMBDPOTUJUVDJOEFMBT$PNJTJPOFT
EFUJDB.EJDBFOUPEBTMBTVOJEBEFTZ
OJWFMFTPSHBOJ[BUJWPTEFM4JTUFNB/BDJP
OBMEF4BMVE
-B DPOTPMJEBDJO EF VO 4JTUFNB /B
DJPOBM EF 4BMVE VOJmDBEP Z QCMJDP 
B mOFT EF MB EDBEB EF   DSF MBT
DPOEJDJPOFT QBSB SFCBTBS FM DSJUFSJP TP
DJBMEFNDSBUBEFCVTDBSMBFRVJEBEFO
USF EFTJHVBMFT  BM FTUJMP EF +PIO 3BXMT
EF PGSFDFS iUSBUBNJFOUPT EFTJHVBMFT B
TVKFUPTEFTJHVBMFTQBSBDSFBSJHVBMEBEEF
PQPSUVOJEBEFTw -B BUFODJO EF TBMVE
SFWPMVDJPOBSJBPQUQPSFMDPNQSPNJTP
NPSBMEFJOTQJSBDJONBSUJBOBEFiDPO
UPEPTZQBSBFMCJFOEFUPEPTw FOFMDVBM
OPTFEPOBMPRVFTPCSBTJOPTFDPNQBS
UFMPRVFTFUJFOF
1BSB FM NPEFMP DVCBOP MB DVFTUJO OP
FTUVWP FOUPODFT FO EFmOJS Z BTFHVSBS
VONOJNPEFDFOUFEFBUFODJOEFTB
MVEQBSBUPEPTZRVF BQBSUJSEFTUF MB
HFTUJOQPSMBQSPQJBTBMVETFSFNJUJFSB
BMJOUFSTZQPTJCJMJEBEFTFDPONJDBTJO
EJWJEVBMFToDPNPTFQMBOUFMBTPDJBMEF
NPDSBDJB BNQBSOEPTFFOFMQSJODJQJP
EF VOJWFSTBMJEBE LBOUJBOPo  TJOP RVF
FM NYJNP EF UPEBT MBT QPTJCJMJEBEFT
UFDOPMHJDBT Z QSPGFTJPOBMFT EJTQPOJ
CMFT FTUVWJFSBO BM BDDFTP KVSEJDP  FDP
ONJDP HFPHSmDPZDVMUVSBMEFUPEPT





#JPUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PT3BNO"DPTUB4BSJFHP

MPTDJVEBEBOPT-PSFMFWBOUFGVFRVFFM
NPEFMPDVCBOPEFBUFODJOEFTBMVEOP
DPQJ FYBDUBNFOUF BM TPWJUJDP V PUSBT
FYQFSJFODJBT EFM EFTBQBSFDJEP iDBNQP
TPDJBMJTUBw  TJOP RVF UPN MP NFKPS EF
MB NFEJDJOB TPDJBM  JOEFQFOEJFOUFNFO
UFEFTVQSPDFEFODJB QBSBBTDPOTUSVJS
VOB BMUFSOBUJWB QSPQJB RVF IB SFTJTUJEP
MBQSEJEBEFSFGFSFOUFTJEFPMHJDPTZMB
DSJTJTRVFBTPMMBFDPOPNBDVCBOBEV
SBOUFMBEDBEBEF

-BNFOUBCMFNFOUF  FO MB NBZPS QBSUF


EFM NVOEP TF IBO DSFBEP IPZ MNJUFT
BSUJmDJBMFT JNQVFTUPT QPS FM NFSDBEP 
NJFOUSBT NJMMPOFT EF QFSTPOBT TVGSFO
Z NVFSFO JOOFDFTBSJBNFOUF EFCJEP B
BWBSPT JOUFSFTFT NFSDBOUJMFT Z B GBMUB
EFTPMJEBSJEBE.VDIPTEFMPTBDUVBMFT
QSPCMFNBTEFTBMVETPOEFNBHOJUVEUBM
RVFUSBTQBTBOMBTGSPOUFSBTOBDJPOBMFTZ
TVQPTJCMFTPMVDJOSFRVJFSFEFMBDPPQF
SBDJOZDPMBCPSBDJOJOUFSOBDJPOBM

i-B FRVJEBE FO TBMVE TJHOJmDB JHVBMFT


PQPSUVOJEBEFT EF BDDFTP B MPT SFDVSTPT
EJTQPOJCMFT VOBEJTUSJCVDJOEFNPDS
UJDB EFM QPEFS Z EF MPT DPOPDJNJFOUPT
FO FM TJTUFNB EF TBMVE  VOB QPMUJDB EF
TBMVERVFCFOFmDJFBUPEPTTJODPOTFOUJS
QSJWJMFHJPTEFCJEPBEJGFSFODJBTEFSB[B 
HOFSP  UFSSJUPSJP  EJTDBQBDJEBE V PUSP
SBTHPEJTUJOUJWPHSVQBMPQFSTPOBMw %F
MB 5PSSF  -QF[  .SRVF[  (VUJSSF[ Z
3PKBT 


"OUF FTUBT SFBMJEBEFT  3BGBFM "SBVKP


(PO[MF[ QSPQVTP VO TJTUFNB EF QSJO
DJQJPT  BMUFSOBUJWP B MB iNBOUSBw EF
(FPSHFUPXOBDDFTJCJMJEBE QBSUJDJQBDJO
Z FRVJEBE SFTVMUBCBO B TV KVJDJP NT
BEFDVBEPT QBSB OVFTUSP DPOUFYUP QFSJ
GSJDP  Z MP BSHVNFOUB EF MB TJHVJFOUF
NBOFSB i&O TPDJFEBEFT EFTBSSPMMBEBT 
EPOEFMBHBSBOUBEFVOFTUBUVTEFWJEB
NFEJP JODMVJEBMBTBMVE OPDPOTUJUVZF
VOBQSFPDVQBDJOQBSBMBNBZPSBEFMB
QPCMBDJO FTBDFQUBCMF DPNPDVFTUJO
QFSFOUPSJB MBEJTDVTJOTPCSFFMFOGSFO
UBNJFOUPCFOFmDFODJBBVUPOPNBKVTUJ
DJB  DPNP QSJODJQJPT RVF DPOEV[DBO B
MB EJTDVTJO CJPUJDB 
 1FSP DVBOEP
TFFWBMBMBOFDFTJEBEEFVODBNCJPFT
USVDUVSBMFOOVFTUSBTTPDJFEBEFTTVCEF
TBSSPMMBEBTZTPDJBMNFOUFEFTQSPUFHJEBT 
FMQSPCMFNBFOEJTDVTJOOPFODVFOUSB
TPMVDJOFOMBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSQFSTPOB
MFT y
TJOPFOFMQMBOPTPDJBMHMPCBMw
"SBVKP 


-PHSBSMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBEEFVOTJTUFNB
EF TBMVE DPO FTUBT DBSBDUFSTUJDBT  QPS
QBSUFEFVOQBTQPCSFZBTFEJBEPDPNP
$VCB IBUFOJEPRVFCBTBSTFOFDFTBSJB
NFOUF FO VOB BNQMJB SFE EF BUFODJO
QSJNBSJBZFOMBQBSUJDJQBDJOEFMBQP
CMBDJOFOMBDPOTUSVDDJOEFTVQSPQJB
TBMVE -B WPMVOUBE QPMUJDB EF PGSFDFS
MBNTBNQMJBZBWBO[BEBDPCFSUVSBIB
SFRVFSJEPEFMBEFMJCFSBDJOZMBDPODFS
UBDJODPOMPTDJVEBEBOPT QBSBBTVNJS
TBDSJmDJPTZDBSFODJBTFOPUSBTFTGFSBTEF
MBWJEBZBMDBO[BSNFUBTTPDJBMFT DPNP
FMQMFOPBDDFTPBMFNQMFP MBFEVDBDJO
ZMBBUFODJOEFTBMVE FOUSFPUSPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&TUF JOUFOUP EF GVOEBNFOUBDJO EFT


EF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB EFM 4VS TF DPSSFT
QPOEB DPO MPT QSJODJQJPT RVF BOJNBO
BMBTBMVEQCMJDBDVCBOB FOMBDVBMMB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DPPQFSBDJOEFTJOUFSFTBEBKVFHBVOJN
QPSUBOUFQBQFM%FTEFMBBZVEBCSJOEB
EBB$IJMFFOPB"SHFMJBFO 
IBTUBMBPGSFDJEBBMPTEBNOJmDBEPTEF
MPT EFTBTUSFT OBUVSBMFT RVF BTPMBSPO MB
$BDIFNJSBQBLJTUBO FO F*OEP
OFTJBEF VOBWPDBDJOEFTFSWJDJP
IBJNQSFHOBEPMBJNQSPOUBIJTUSJDBEF
MBNFEJDJOBDVCBOBFOMBDPOUSJCVDJO
BMUSVJTUBBMBTPMVDJOEFQSPCMFNBTMP
DBMFTZHMPCBMFTEFTBMVE&OUFOEJEPBT 
FMEFCFSEFKVTUJDJBOPQVFEFFODPOUSBS
PUSBNFKPSFYQSFTJORVFMBTPMJEBSJEBE

DJPOBSJPGVFMBDPODFQDJOEFM1MBOEF
&TUVEJPT*OUFHSBEP QVFTUPFOWJHPSFO
 FOFMDVBMMB6OJEBE(FOFSBMi&M
)PNCSFZTV.FEJPwGVOHJDPNPFKF
WFSUJDBMEFMNJTNP&TUBJOOPWBEPSBFO
TFBO[BTJHOJmDVOUSFNFOEPQBTPEF
BWBODF UFSJDP Z NFUPEPMHJDP  UBM WF[
OPTVmDJFOUFNFOUFDPNQSFOEJEPFOTV
NPNFOUP RVFQVTPFOFMDFOUSPEFMEJT
DVSTPBDBENJDPMBDPOTJEFSBDJOEFMPT
TJTUFNBTEFWBMPSFTJOEJWJEVBMFTZHSVQB
MFTFOFMEJBHOTUJDPZUSBUBNJFOUPEFMPT
QSPCMFNBTEFTBMVE

-BCFOFmDFODJBDPNP
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE

-B JODPSQPSBDJO FO FM DVSTP BDBENJ


DP  EF UJDB Z %FPOUPMPHB
.EJDB  QPS QSJNFSB WF[ FO MB IJTUPSJB
EF MB FEVDBDJO NEJDB DVCBOB DPNP
BTJHOBUVSB JOEFQFOEJFOUF  Z FM MJCSP EF
UFYUPEFJHVBMOPNCSFRVFMBBTJHOBUV
SBQVFEFODPOTJEFSBSTFUFNQSBOFSPTFO
SFMBDJODPOFMNPWJNJFOUPEFMBTJEFBT
EFMOVFWPQBSBEJHNBUJDPFOFMDPOUFY
UP JOUFSOBDJPOBM #BTUF SFDPSEBS RVF MB
QSJNFSBFEJDJOEFi1SJODJQMFTPG#JPNF
EJDBM&UIJDTw EF#FBVDIBNQZ$IJMESFTT 
TFQVCMJDFTFNJTNPBPEF

3FTPMWFS FO MP FTFODJBM FM QSPCMFNB EF


MBKVTUJDJBFOFMBDDFTPBMBBUFODJOEF
TBMVEFTSFRVJTJUPJOEJTQFOTBCMFQFSPOP
TVmDJFOUFQBSBRVFFYJTUBVOUSBUPKVTUP
UBNCJOFOFMOJWFMEFMBTSFMBDJPOFTJO
UFSJOEJWJEVBMFT
-BJODPSQPSBDJOEFMPTGBDUPSFTQTJDP
MHJDPTZTPDJBMFTFOMBDPOTJEFSBDJOEFM
QSPDFTP TBMVEFOGFSNFEBE  RVF FTUBCB
UFOJFOEP MVHBS FO FM QMBOP JOUFSOBDJP
OBM  BT DPNP MBT OVFWBT DPOEJDJPOFT
DSFBEBTQPSMB3FWPMVDJO FODVBOUPB
VOJWFSTBMJEBEFOFMBDDFTPBMPTTFSWJDJPT
ZMBQSPHSFTJWBFYUFOTJOEFMBTBDDJPOFT
EFQSPNPDJOZQSFWFODJOEFMTVCTJTUF
NBEFBUFODJOQSJNBSJB SFFOGPDBSPOMB
HFTUJOEFTBMVEIBDJBMBNFEJDJOBTPDJBM
ZGBWPSFDJFSPORVFMBVOJWFSTJEBEDVCB
OB EFTEFDPNJFO[PTEFMBEDBEBEFMPT
 FOTFBSBMBTMMBNBEBTiIVNBOJEBEFT
NEJDBTw P iDJFODJBT TPDJBMFT BQMJDBEBT
B MB TBMVEw 6O QBTP BO NT SFWPMV

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

i%FCFNPTBDFQUBSoTFBmSNBFOAUJDB
ZEFPOUPMPHBNEJDBoRVFMBTDJFODJBT
OBUVSBMFTOPDPOUFNQMBO FOTNJTNBT 
SFHMBTPOPSNBTFTQFDmDBTRVFEFmOBO
FM VTP EF QSPDFEJNJFOUPT B BQMJDBS  FO
MB QSDUJDB  MPT BWBODFT DJFOUmDPT Z FT
QPTJCMF RVF  FO EFUFSNJOBEBT DJSDVOT
UBODJBT MBVUJMJ[BDJOJODPSSFDUBEFOVF
WBTUDOJDBTQVFEBJOUFSQSFUBSTFPDPOT
UJUVZBFOTBDUPTEFEFTIVNBOJ[BDJOw
"MPOTP 7PO4NJUI 3BNSF[Z0SUFHB 







#JPUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PT3BNO"DPTUB4BSJFHP

.T BEFMBOUF  TF QSFDJTB i&M DPOPDJ


NJFOUP  QPS QBSUF EFM FOGFSNP RVF TF
TPNFUFS BM FYBNFO  EF MBT NPMFTUJBT
RVFQVFEBPDBTJPOBSMFZEFMBOFDFTJEBE
EF SFBMJ[BSMP  OP TMP EFCFO HBOBS TV
BQSPCBDJO TJOPUBNCJOTVDPOmBO[BZ
PCUFOFSTVDPMBCPSBDJOw "MPOTP 7PO
4NJUI 3BNSF[Z0SUFHB 

2VFEBQMBOUFBEBBTVOBWJTJOEFMDPO
TFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEPNVZQBSUJDVMBS 
FMDVBMEFCFTFSEFTBSSPMMBEPFOFMNBSDP
EF SFMBDJPOFT JOUFSQFSTPOBMFT DBSBDUFSJ
[BEBTQPSMBDPOmBO[B&TUBQFSTQFDUJWB
DVCBOBFNQJF[BBBMFKBSTFZBEFMQBUFS
OBMJTNP DMTJDP "PT EFTQVT  FO VO
FOTBZPEF EPTQSFTUJHJPTPTBVUP
SFT &ENVOE1FMMFHSJNPZ%BWJEP
NBTNB EFmOJSBOFTUFUJQPEFSFMBDJO
DPNPiCFOFmDFODJBEFDPOmBO[Bw
-B UPNB EF DPODJFODJB SFTQFDUP EF MPT
DBNCJPT EF MB TJUVBDJO EF TBMVE EF MB
QPCMBDJODVCBOB RVFZBFSBOQBUFOUFT
BMmMPEFMBEDBEBEF ZMBDBQBDJ
EBEEFSFTQVFTUB FOHFOFSBMFYJUPTB EFM
TJTUFNB FO DPOEJDJPOFT EF FNFSHFODJB
oQVFTUB B QSVFCB DPO MB JOUSPEVDDJO
UFSSPSJTUB EFM EFOHVF IFNPSSHJDP FO
OVFTUSP QBT 
o  FWJEFODJB
SPO UBNCJO EFUFSNJOBEBT WVMOFSBCJMJ
EBEFT Z  DPO FMMP  MB OFDFTJEBE EF JN
QMFNFOUBSOVFWBTFTUSBUFHJBTZBDDJPOFT
&O FM UFSSFOP EF MB OPSNBUJWJEBE NP
SBM QSPGFTJPOBM TF IJDJFSPO QCMJDPT MPT
i1SJODJQJPTEFMBUJDB.EJDBw 

ZTFDPOTUJUVZFSPOMBTDPNJTJPOFTEFUJ
DBNEJDBFOUPEBTMBTVOJEBEFTZOJWF
MFT EFM 4JTUFNB /BDJPOBM EF 4BMVE &O
MPKVSEJDP TFQSPNVMHMB-FZEF4BMVE

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

1CMJDB 
 &O MB PSHBOJ[BDJO EF
MPTTFSWJDJPT EFTEFTFJOJDJMBFY
QFSJFODJBEFMiNEJDPZMBFOGFSNFSBEF
MBGBNJMJBw DVZPQFSGFDDJPOBNJFOUPEF
WJOPFOFMTJTUFNBEFNFEJDJOBGBNJMJBS
BDUVBM'JOBMNFOUF FOMPBDBENJDP TF
QVTP FO WJHPS VO OVFWP QMBO EF FTUV
EJPT 
FTUSVDUVSBEPTPCSFMBCBTF
EFMPTQSPCMFNBTZOFDFTJEBEFTEFTBMVE
JEFOUJmDBEPT
-PT i1SJODJQJPT EF MB UJDB .EJDBw
DPOTUJUVZFO FM QSJNFS DEJHP EF DPO
EVDUB QSPGFTJPOBM SFEBDUBEP CBKP MBT
DPOEJDJPOFTFDPONJDBTZTPDJBMFTDSFB
EBT QPS MB 3FWPMVDJO Z  TMP QPS FMMP 
UJFOFOVOBMUPWBMPSIJTUSJDPFOTNJT
NPT4JCJFOTVSFEBDDJODPOTFSWBVO
FTUJMPBOQBUFSOBMJTUB BMBEFDVBSTFBMBT
OVFWBTDJSDVOTUBODJBTTFJOUSPEVDFOEF
UFSNJOBEPTQSFDFQUPTRVFSFnFKBOZBVO
DBNCJPEFFOGPRVF
i.BOUFOFS FOMPTDBTPTEFFOGFSNFEB
EFTEFDVSTPGBUBM BCTPMVUBPSFMBUJWBSF
TFSWBTPCSFFMEJBHOTUJDPZQSPOTUJDP
FOSFMBDJODPOFMQBDJFOUFZTFMFDDJPOBS
BRVJOTFEFCFEBSFTBJOGPSNBDJODPO
FMUBDUPOFDFTBSJPw 1SJODJQJPTEFMBUJ
DB.EJDB 

&T EFDJS RVF TMP TF FTUBCMFDF SFTFSWB
SFMBUJWB FO MB JOGPSNBDJO B QBDJFOUFT
Z GBNJMJBSFT QBSB FM DBTP EF FOGFSNF
EBEFT EF DVSTP GBUBM %FKB B EJTDSFDJO
EFMFRVJQPEFTBMVEMBEFDJTJOEFRVJO
TFSEFQPTJUBSJPEFMBNBMBOPUJDJB EFMP
DVBMOPTFFYDMVZFBMQSPQJPQBDJFOUFTJ
MBTDBSBDUFSTUJDBTEFTVQFSTPOBMJEBEBT
MPQFSNJUFO





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

0USPFMFNFOUPFOMBDPOTJEFSBDJOEFM
QSJODJQJP EF BVUPOPNB QPS QBSUF EF
MPT i1SJODJQJPT EF MB UJDB .EJDBw FT
FM EF DPOTFOUJNJFOUP JOGPSNBEP $PO
SFMBDJO B FTUF QBSUJDVMBS TF FYQSFTB
i0CUFOFS  BOUFT EF BQMJDBS DVBMRVJFS
NFEJEB EJBHOTUJDB P UFSBQVUJDB RVF
QVFEB TJHOJmDBS VO BMUP SJFTHP QBSB FM
QBDJFOUF TVDPOTFOUJNJFOUPPFMEFTVT
GBNJMJBSFT FYDFQUPFOMPTDBTPTEFGVFS[B
NBZPSw 1SJODJQJPTEFMBUJDB.EJDB 


&T EFDJS  TF JODMVZF FM DPOTFOUJNJFOUP
WPMVOUBSJP  BVORVF OP TF QSFDJTB DVO
JOGPSNBEPEFCFSTFSTUF ZMPQSFTDSJCF
QBSBMPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTSJFTHPTPTZOP
BUPEPTDPNPZBTFEJTDVUBFOBRVFMMPT
NPNFOUPT &M TMP IFDIP EF RVF VO
EPDVNFOUPJODMVZBFTUBDVFTUJO JOEF
QFOEJFOUFNFOUF EF RVF MP IBZB IFDIP
EF GPSNB MJNJUBEB  EFCF TFS BQSFDJBEP
DPNP VO BWBODF  TJ DPOTJEFSBNPT RVF
WJODVMBUPEPTMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTDVCB
OPTEFMBTBMVEDPOTVDVNQMJNJFOUP
-B FYQBOTJO EF MBT JOWFTUJHBDJPOFT
CJPNEJDBTZMBJOUSPEVDDJOZQSPEVD
DJOBVUDUPOBEFUFDOPMPHBTNEJDBT
EFQVOUBNPUJWRVFMBSFnFYJOUJDB
FOFTUFDBNQPBEPQUBSBEFmOJUJWBNFO
UFUFNBTZDPOnJDUPTEFWBMPSFTRVFMF
IBO TJEP DBSBDUFSTUJDPT IBTUB MB BDUVB
MJEBE %FCFNPT EFTUBDBS MB MBCPS EF
&SOFTUP #SBWP .BUBSB[[P BM QSPNPWFS
FM DPMPRVJP TPCSF i1SPCMFNBT mMPTm
DPT EF MB NFEJDJOBw RVF  DPNFO[BEP
FO TFFYUFOEJQPSWBSJPTDJDMPTZ
BPT-BTQPOFODJBTQSFTFOUBEBTGVFSPO
QVCMJDBEBT FO GBTDDVMPT QPS MB FEJUP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

SJBM EFM *OTUJUVUP 4VQFSJPS EF $JFODJBT


.EJDBTEF-B)BCBOB&TUFDPMPRVJP
OPTJOUSPEVKPFOVOVOJWFSTPUFNUJDP
IBTUBFTFNPNFOUPUSBUBEPGSBHNFOUB
SJBNFOUF P  TJNQMFNFOUF  EFTDPOPDJ
EP  DPNP GVF FM EF MBT DVFTUJPOFT UF
SJDPmMPTmDBT EFM PSJHFO Z FTFODJB EF
MB WJEB  MB HFONJDB  MBT OFVSPDJFODJBT
Z FM EJBHOTUJDP NEJDP BNQBSBEP FO
MBTOVFWBTUFDOPMPHBT FOUSFPUSBT%F
MBT QPOFODJBT QSFTFOUBEBT  i1SPCMFNBT
UJDPT FO FM EFTBSSPMMP EF MB CJPMPHB Z
MBNFEJDJOBDPOUFNQPSOFBTw EF"CF
MBSEP3BNSF[.SRVF[Z3BM)FSSFSB
7BMET FTVOBCVFOBNVFTUSB QPSRVF
TFBEFOUSBFOMPTDPOnJDUPTUJDPTEFMB
JOWFTUJHBDJODJFOUmDBFOIVNBOPT MPT
EFMBHFOUJDBNEJDB FMEJBHOTUJDPEF
MBNVFSUFZMBEPOBDJOZUSBTQMBOUFEF
SHBOPT Z UFKJEPT 3BNSF[ Z )FSSFSB 


-BQSJNFSBSFnFYJOUFSJDBSFBMJ[BEBQPS
VOBVUPSDVCBOPTPCSFMBOVFWBUFOEFO
DJBEFMQFOTBNJFOUPUJDPRVFSFQSFTFO
UBCBMBCJPUJDBGVFFYQVFTUBQPS"OUPOJP
EF "SNBT EVSBOUF FM *** *OUFSOBUJPOBMFT
8JTTFOTDIBGUMJDIFT 4ZNQPTJVN 6CFS -FJ
UVOH6OE1MBOOVOH4PDJMBSF1SP[FTTF*N
5FSSJUPSJVN  DFMFCSBEP FO 3PTUPDL  BO
UJHVB3FQCMJDB%FNPDSUJDB"MFNBOB 
FO ZRVFGVFSBQVCMJDBEPBPTNT
UBSEFFO$VCBCBKPFMUUVMPEFi&OUPS
OPBMBPSJFOUBDJOmMPTmDBEFMB#JP
UJDBi %F"SNBT 

&O   DPNP BDUVBMJ[BDJO EFM BQP
ZPCJCMJPHSmDPEFMBBTJHOBUVSBUJDBZ
%FPOUPMPHB.EJDB TFQVCMJDi5FNBT
EFUJDB.EJDBw&TUFMJCSPDPOTUJUVZF





#JPUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PT3BNO"DPTUB4BSJFHP

VOBDFSDBNJFOUPBMQFOTBNJFOUPCJPUJ
DP QPSRVFPGSFDFVOBWJTJONTIPMTUJ
DBEFMBJOUFSSFMBDJOIPNCSFOBUVSBMF[B
ZEFMPTGBDUPSFTFDPONJDPTZTPDJBMFT
FOFMQSPDFTPTBMVEFOGFSNFEBE
iyMB DPOUSBEJDDJO RVF TF HFOFSB BM
VTBS JOEJTDSJNJOBEBNFOUF FM EFTBSSPMMP
DJFOUmDPUDOJDP QPSMBTDPOTFDVFODJBT
RVF FTUP USBF QBSB FM IPNCSF  UJFOF TV
TPMVDJO DPO FM VTP FOFSHUJDP Z DPOT
DJFOUFEFFTFEFTBSSPMMPDJFOUmDPUDOJ
DPEJSJHJEPBSFBMJ[BSVOBBDUJWJEBEQSP
mMDUJDBQFSNBOFOUFFOFMNFEJPTPDJBM 
QBSBMPHSBSMBSFQPTJDJOZFRVJMJCSJPEF
MBOBUVSBMF[B PCUFOJFOEPBTVOOPSNBM
EFTBSSPMMP EFM BNCJFOUF FDPMHJDP EFM
IPNCSFBQVOUPEFQBSUJEBEFUSBOTGPS
NBDJPOFTFOTVNFEJPTPDJBMw #PSSPUP 
/F[ EF 7JMMBWJDFODJP Z .BSUOF[ 


-PT QSPQJPT BVUPSFT JEFOUJmDBO WBSJPT
QFMJHSPTRVFBDFDIBOBMBDBMJEBEEFMB
SFMBDJONEJDPQBDJFOUF BTBCFS
t

t
t

t

%FTIVNBOJ[BDJO QPS MB JOUFSGF


SFODJB QPTJCMF EF MB UFDOPMPHB FO
MBSFMBDJOBGFDUJWBZFMQSPDFTPEF
DPNVOJDBDJO F JOEJWJEVBMJ[BDJO
EFMBSFMBDJO
3FBMJ[BSVOBQFSDFQDJOOPJOUFHSBM
EFMJOEJWJEVPFOGFSNP
&OGPRVFT OPTPMHJDPT JODPSSFDUPT
EFCJEPBVOBNBSDBEBEFQFOEFODJB
EFMBUFDOPMPHB
&O FM OJWFM EF SJFTHP EF QSPEVDJS
JBUSPHFOJB

5SFTBPTEFTQVT 
DVBOEPTFEJ
TFMBUSBNBDVSSJDVMBSEFMBFOUPODFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

OVFWBDBSSFSBVOJWFSTJUBSJBEF5FDOPMP
HBEFMB4BMVE MBEJSFDDJOEFMSFBEF
%PDFODJBEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVE1CMJ
DBEF$VCB .*/4"1
FTUBCBDPOTDJFOUF
EFMBOFDFTJEBEEFEPUBSBMBGPSNBDJO
EFMPTSFDVSTPTIVNBOPTFOFTFDBNQP
EFVOBBNQMJBDPCFSUVSBEFMBT$JFODJBT
4PDJBMFTBQMJDBEBTBMBTBMVE&OMBNBMMB
DVSSJDVMBSTFJODMVZFSPOUSFTBTJHOBUVSBT
RVFDPOGPSNBSPOVOBEJTDJQMJOBHFOSJ
DBNFOUFEFOPNJOBEB4BMVEMBUFSDFSBZ
MUJNBEFFTUBTBTJHOBUVSBT EFBDVFSEP
DPOTVVCJDBDJOFOFMTFHVOEPBPEF
MBFTQFDJBMJEBEi4BMVE***w DPOTUJUVZFM
QSJNFSQSPHSBNBEFCJPUJDBJNQMFNFO
UBEPFOFEVDBDJOTVQFSJPSEFQSFHSBEP
FOOVFTUSPQBToWJHFOUFEFTEFFMDVSTP
IBTUBFMoZ QP
TJCMFNFOUF  UBNCJO FM QSJNFSP EF TV
UJQP JNQBSUJEP FO "NSJDB -BUJOB &O
FTUF QSPHSBNB TF FOHBS[BSPO UFNBT TF
DVMBSNFOUFUSBUBEPTQPSMBUJDBNEJDB
DPO PUSPT EFM OVFWP FOGPRVF CJPUJDP
-PTSFTVMUBEPTEFMQSJNFSMVTUSPEFBQMJ
DBDJOGVFSPOQVCMJDBEPTFOMBTNFNP
SJBTEFM5FSDFS5BMMFS*OUFSOBDJPOBMEFM
1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPUJDB QBSB
"NSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCF0140.4 
DFMFCSBEPFO-B)BCBOBFOOPWJFNCSF
EF EFEJDBEPBMUFNBEFUJDBEF
MB*OWFTUJHBDJO$JFOUmDB SFBEF%P
DFODJBEFM.*/4"1 

4J CJFO MB FTQFDJBMJEBE EF 5FDOPMPHB
EFMB4BMVE QPSMPFTDBTPEFTVNBUS
DVMB EVSBOUF TVT QSJNFSPT RVJODF BPT
EF FYJTUFODJB  UVWP VO JNQBDUP PCKFUJ
WBNFOUFMJNJUBEPFOFMDPOUFYUPHFOF
SBM EF MB FEVDBDJO NEJDB DVCBOB  FO
 TF BEPQU VO QBTP USBTDFOEFOUF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

BM USBOTGPSNBS FM BOUJHVP QSPHSBNB EF


'JMPTPGB  EF VOJWFSTBM BQMJDBDJO QBSB
UPEBTMBTDBSSFSBTEFMBTDJFODJBTNEJDBT
FOFMQBT FOPUSPEFNBZPSBQMJDBDJO
QSDUJDB'JMPTPGBZ4BMVE
&O FM DBNQP EFM DPOUSPM TPDJBM TPCSF
MBTBQMJDBDJPOFTNEJDBTEFMPTBWBODFT
DJFOUmDPUFDOPMHJDPT SFTVMU EF HSBO
JNQPSUBODJBMBDSFBDJOEFM$FOUSPQBSB
FM$POUSPM&TUBUBMEFMB$BMJEBEEFMPT
.FEJDBNFOUPT 
 Z EFM $FOUSP
QBSB FM $POUSPM &TUBUBM EF MPT &RVJQPT
.EJDPT 
RVFDPOTUJUVZFOOVFT
USBT BHFODJBT FTUBUBMFT  TVCPSEJOBEBT
EFTEF  BM #VS 3FHVMBUPSJP EF MB
4BMVE-BGVOEBDJOEFM$FOUSP$PPS
EJOBEPSEFMPT&OTBZPT$MOJDPT 

QSPNPWJ MB GPSNBDJO EF DPNJUT EF
SFWJTJO UJDB QBSB DBEB FOTBZP DMOJDP
oGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFQBSBMPTNVMUJDO
USJDPTo1PSPUSBQBSUF MBQVFTUBFOWJ
HPSEFMBTi/PSNBTEF#VFOBT1SDUJDBT
$MOJDBTw QSPNVMHBEBTQPSQSJNFSBWF[
FO   NPEJmDBEBT FO  Z QFS
GFDDJPOBEBT OVFWBNFOUF FO   BT
DPNPMBQSPNVMHBDJOEFMi$EJHPEF
UJDB EF MPT 5SBCBKBEPSFT EF MB $JFO
DJBw  FO   FTUJNVMBSPO FM JOUFST
EFMPTJOWFTUJHBEPSFTZEJSFDUJWPTQPSFM
FTUVEJP EF MPT GVOEBNFOUPT UJDPmMP
TmDPTEFMBJOWFTUJHBDJO BTDPNPEF
MPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTFTUBOEBSJ[BEPTQBSB
MB FWBMVBDJO EF QSPZFDUPT Z  DPO FMMP 
QSPNPWJFSPO FM TVSHJNJFOUP EF MPT S
HBOPTRVFWFMBSBOQPSTVDVNQMJNJFOUP
MPTDPNJUTJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTEFUJDBEFMB
JOWFTUJHBDJODJFOUmDB
-B DFMFCSBDJO FO $VCB EFM 1SJNFS
4JNQPTJP *OUFSOBDJPOBM TPCSF .VFSUF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&ODFGMJDB oQPTUFSJPSNFOUF SFOPNCSB


EPDPNPEF.VFSUFZ$PNBo FO 
BUSBKP MB QBSUJDJQBDJO EF JNQPSUBOUFT
QFSTPOBMJEBEFT EF MB CJPUJDB JOUFSOB
DJPOBM %F FTUF JOUFSDBNCJP TVSHJFSPO
MBT JEFBT RVF DPODSFUBSPO MPT EPT QSJ
NFSPTDVSTPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTFGFDUVBEPT
FOOVFTUSPQBTi-BVOJWFSTJEBENEJDB
BOUF MPT QSPCMFNBT CJPUJDPT BDUVBMFTw 
DFMFCSBEP FO  FO MB TFEF EFM FO
UPODFT $FOUSP /BDJPOBM EF 1FSGFDDJP
OBNJFOUP .EJDP oDVZBT BDUJWJEBEFT
EPDFOUFTGVFSPOBTVNJEBTQPSQSPGFTP
SFTDVCBOPTZOPSUFBNFSJDBOPTo Fi*O
USPEVDDJO B MB CJPUJDBw  PGSFDJEP FO
FOMBTFEFEFMBFOUPODFT'BDVMUBE
EF4BMVE1CMJDBQPS+VBO$BSMPT5FBMEJ
FOSFQSFTFOUBDJOEFMB&TDVFMB-BUJOPB
NFSJDBOBEF#JPUJDBDPOTFEFFO#VF
OPT"JSFT "SHFOUJOB
&TBQSJNFSBNJUBEEFMBEDBEBEF
GVFUFTUJHPEFMBDSFBDJOEFDUFESBTEF
CJPUJDBFOMPTDFOUSPTEFFEVDBDJON
EJDB TVQFSJPS  BT DPNP EFM QSPDFTP EF
EJTDVTJOEFMCPSSBEPSEFMB%FDMBSBDJO
6OJWFSTBM EFM (FOPNB Z MPT %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPT RVFEFWJOPFOMBGVOEBDJO
EFM$PNJU/BDJPOBM$VCBOPEF#JP
UJDB FO#BKPFMBVTQJDJPEFJOTUJ
UVDJPOFTDBUMJDBT DPNFO[BDJSDVMBSMB
QSJNFSBQVCMJDBDJOQFSJEJDBEFEJDBEB
B UFNBT EF CJPUJDB  MB IPZ EFTBQBSFDJ
EBSFWJTUB&UIPT ZFOTFGVOEFM
$FOUSP EF #JPUJDB +VBO 1BCMP **  RVF
QSPNPWJMBDFMFCSBDJOEFVOB+PSOBEB
"OVBM EF #JPUJDB Z MB QVCMJDBDJO EF
PUSB SFWJTUB  QSJNFSBNFOUF OPNCSBEB
"OBMFT EFM $FOUSP +VBO 1BCMP ** Z IPZ
SFCBVUJ[BEBDPNP#JPUJDB





#JPUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PT3BNO"DPTUB4BSJFHP

5PEPTFTUPTQSFDFEFOUFTFYQMJDBOMBS
QJEB EJGVTJO Z MB BWJEF[ DPO RVF GVF
SFDJCJEB MB QSJNFSB FEJDJO EFM MJCSP
i#JPUJDB %FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DV
CBOBw RVFTBMJBDJSDVMBDJOBmOFTEF
&TUFUSBCBKPEFNTEFDVBSFOUB
BVUPSFTDVCBOPTSFQSFTFOUBMBDPOUJOVJ
EBEEFMQFOTBNJFOUPOBDJPOBMFOUPSOP
B MBT DVFTUJPOFT UJDBT SFMBDJPOBEBT DPO
MBTBMVEZMBWJEBZ BMBWF[ NBSDBVOB
SVQUVSBDPOFMNPEFMPDMTJDPIFHFN
OJDP EFTEF OVFTUSB USBEJDJO EF QFOTB
NJFOUP RVFOPFYBMUBMBJOEJWJEVBMJEBE 
DPNP IB TJEP UQJDP Z UQJDP FO MB MJ
UFSBUVSB CJPUJDB BOHMPTBKPOB  TJOP RVF
SFDPOPDFFMQBQFMEFMJOEJWJEVPFOUBOUP
QBSUDJQFEFMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEDPMFDUJWB
DPOFMCJFOFTUBSEFUPEPT%Fi#JPUJDB
%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWBDVCBOBwQVFEFO
FYUSBFSTFJOmOJEBEEFFKFNQMPTRVFDPO
mSNBOFTUFQVOUPEFJOnFYJO
"M BOBMJ[BS MB OVFWB EJNFOTJO EF MB
SFMBDJO NEJDPQBDJFOUF FO OVFTUSPT
EBT  3JDBSEP (PO[MF[ BmSNB i-PT
TVTUBODJBMFT Z SFDJFOUFT DBNCJPT FO
FM DPODFQUP  PCKFUJWP Z GVODJPOFT  BT
DPNPFOMBSFMFWBODJBEFMPTEJGFSFOUFT
BTQFDUPTQPSDPOTJEFSBSFOFTUBSFMBDJO 
MBDPMPDBOBDUVBMNFOUFFOVOBTJUVBDJO
EF USOTJUP  EPOEF UBOUP FM QSPGFTJPOBM
DPNPFMTVKFUPZPCKFUPEFTVBUFODJO
oFM IPNCSF TBOP P FOGFSNPo EFCFO JS
NPEJmDBOEPTVTBODFTUSBMFTDPODFQDJP
OFTBDFSDBEFMBHFTUJONEJDB y
4F
USBUB QPSUBOUP EFVOQSPDFTPRVFQPOF
FO UFOTJO OVFTUSBT SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFT
DPNP FEVDBEPSFT NEJDPT  QFSP RVF
UBNCJOTPNFUFBQSVFCBBUPEBTMBTJOT
UBODJBTEFMTJTUFNBEFTBMVEFOOVFTUSP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

NFEJP BTDPNPBMPTQSPQJPTVTVBSJPT 
TJNCPMJ[BEPTBIPSBQPSFMDPMFDUJWPGB
NJMJBSw (PO[MF[ 

3JDBSEP (PO[MF[ USBF B DPMBDJO VO
BTQFDUP RVF  NT BEFMBOUF FO FM UFYUP 
TFSBEFTBSSPMMBEPDPONBZPSOGBTJTQPS
/F[EF7JMMBWJDFODJPMBSFTQPOTBCJMJ
EBEEFMNEJDPDPNPFEVDBEPSPTFB 
RVFFMCFOFmDJPWFSEBEFSPEFMQBDJFOUF
PTBOPTMPTFBMDBO[BTJTFMFIBDFDPOT
DJFOUFEFTVTQSPQJBTOFDFTJEBEFTEFTB
MVE-FKPTEFMBDPFSDJOQSPQJBEFMNP
EFMPQBUFSOBMJTUBPEFMBJOGPSNBDJOOP
DPNQSPNFUJEBEFMNPEFMPBVUPOPNJTUB
NT QVSP  JOWPMVDSBS BM QSPGFTJPOBM EF
MB TBMVE DPO MB FEVDBDJO TBOJUBSJB EFM
VTVBSJPPCMJHBBVOQSPDFTPEFMJCFSBUJWP
ZBEFDJEJSKVOUPTMBTNFKPSFTPQDJPOFT
EFTPMVDJO"DFQUBSFTUPJNQMJDBMBTV
QFSBDJOEFMQBSBEJHNBQBUFSOBMJTUBUSB
EJDJPOBM
-BOFDFTJEBEEFVOBNBZPSTJNFUSBFO
MBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSQFSTPOBMFTQSPQJBTEF
MB BUFODJO NEJDB DPOUFNQPSOFB FT
QSFDJTBEBQPS7BSO7PO4NJUIi%FO
USPEFMBUJDBDMOJDBHBOBVOMVHBSQSF
QPOEFSBOUFFMSFTQFUPBMBJOUFHSJEBEEFM
JOEJWJEVP ZFTUPTFFKFSDFSFODVBMRVJFS
NCJUPDMOJDPEPOEFTFFODVFOUSFZTFB
DVBM GVFSF TV BGFDUBDJOw 7PO 4NJUI 

 &T NVZ TJHOJmDBUJWP RVF
7BSO 7PO 4NJUI VTF FM USNJOP UJDB
DMOJDB DSFBEP QPS .BSL 4JFHMFS Z OP
IBZBQVFTUPMNJUFTBMBPCTFSWBODJBEF
MBJOUFHSJEBEQMFOBZDPOFMMBBMSFTQFUP
EF MB DBQBDJEBE Z DPNQFUFODJB NPSBM
EFM QBDJFOUF P TBOP MB JEFB EF RVF FM
UJQPEFSFMBDJOJOUFSQFSTPOBMFOMBBUFO





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DJOEFTBMVEEFQFOEFEFMNPNFOUPEF
MBTJUVBDJODMOJDB EFGPSNBUBMRVFFO
EJGFSFOUFTNPNFOUPTEFVONJTNPDBTP
QVFEFOBQMJDBSTFEJGFSFOUFTNPEFMPTEF
BUFODJO DPNPGVFQMBOUFBEPQPSP
NBT 4[BT[ Z .BSD )PMMFOEFS 
 Z
EFTBSSPMMBEP QPTUFSJPSNFOUF QPS &[F
RVJFMZ-JOEB&NNBOVFM 
-PJO
UFSFTBOUFFTRVF7PO4NJUISFDPNJFOEB
FKFSDFSMPFODVBMRVJFSNCJUPZDVBMRVJFS
BGFDUBDJOZMPSFMBDJPOBDPOFMFODBSHP
TPDJBMEFMQSPGFTJPOBMEFMBTBMVEDPOTV
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE
3BEBNT#PSSPUP$SV[Z3BNO"OFJ
SPT3JCBQSPGVOEJ[BOFOFMSFTQFUPBMB
EJHOJEBE USBEVDJEPFOVOBDPNVOJDB
DJOSFTQPOTBCMFRVFTVTUFOUFVOBSFMB
DJO TBOJUBSJB EF DBMJEBE Z TBUJTGBHB MBT
FYQFDUBUJWBTEFMPTVTVBSJPTi-BFTFODJB
EFM RVFIBDFS NEJDP TF SFTVNF FO MB
TBUJTGBDDJOEFMBTOFDFTJEBEFTEFTBMVE
EFMIPNCSF/BEJFQVFEFTFSGFMJ[FOMB
JHOPSBODJBZNVDIPNFOPTTJTFUSBUBEF
BRVFMMPSFMBDJPOBEPDPOTVQSPQJBTBMVE
&MQBDJFOUFTMPFTUBSTBUJTGFDIPDVBOEP
DPOP[DBUPEPDVBOUPEFTFFTPCSFTVTB
MVEPTVFOGFSNFEBE/BEJFDPNPFMN
EJDPUJFOFMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFBDFSDBSTFBMP
NTOUJNPZTFOTJCMFEFMTFSIVNBOPw
#PSSPUPZ"OFJSPT3JCB 
&M
EPNJOJPEFMPTQSPDFTPTDPNVOJDBUJWPT
FTMBWBQBSBBDFSDBSTFBiMPNTOUJNP
ZTFOTJCMFw FTUBCMFDJFOEPVOWODVMPFO
USFMPQSPQJBNFOUFUDOJDPZMPNPSBMFO
FMOJWFMEFMBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSQFSTPOBMFT
-B SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE TPDJBM EFM QSPGFTJP
OBMEFMBTBMVEFTIBDFSMBCFOFmDFODJB
TBUJTGBDJFOEP UPEBT MBT OFDFTJEBEFT EF
TBMVEEFMQBDJFOUFZOPTMPMBTCJPMHJ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DBT DPNPIBTJEPUFOEFODJBDPNOEF
MBNFEJDJOBDVSBUJWB
'FSOBOEP/F[EF7JMMBWJDFODJPSFBMJ
[VOBQPSUFDPOTVDPODFQDJOEFRVF
FMQSPDFTPEFDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNB
EP EFCF TFS FTFODJBMNFOUF VOB BDDJO
FEVDBUJWB  FO MB DVBM FM SFTQFUP QPS MB
BVUPOPNB TFB DPODJMJBEP DPO MBT OF
DFTJEBEFTEFTBMVEEFMQBDJFOUFPTBOP
i/PEFCFNPTQMBOUFBSVOMNJUFBIBDFS
FMCJFOPBMVDIBSQPSMBTBMVEoBmSNBo
FMQSPCMFNBFTUFOBMFSUBSBMNEJDPEF
RVFTJQSJPSJ[BTMPMPTBTQFDUPTEFMFRVJ
MJCSP CJPMHJDP IBCS PDBTJPOFT FO RVF
TVTBDDJPOFTEFCFOFmDFODJBFOFTUFTFO
UJEPQVFEBOFTUBSQSPEVDJFOEPEFTFRVJ
MJCSJPTQTJDPMHJDPTZTPDJBMFTEFVOBJO
UFOTJEBENBZPS"VUPSJ[BSMPBJNQPOFS
TVCFOFmDFODJBFOFTUPTDBTPTTFSBBV
UPSJ[BSMPBBDDJPOFTDPOUSBMBTBMVE y

"M BOBMJ[BS FM QSJODJQJP EF BVUPOPNB 
TJOFNCBSHP OPOPTFODPOUSBNPTFOMB
NJTNB TJUVBDJO &TUF EFSFDIP EFM QB
DJFOUF EF TFS JOGPSNBEP  DPOTVMUBEP Z
BQBSUJDJQBSFOMBTBDDJPOFTUPNBEBTFO
SFMBDJODPOTVQSPQJBTBMVE MPDVBMFO
FTFODJBFTJODVFTUJPOBCMF SFRVJFSFEFMJ
NJUBDJPOFTCJFOQSFDJTBTQBSBFWJUBSRVF
TVVTPJOBEFDVBEPDPODMVZBFOVOEF
TBTUSF QBSB FM QSPQJP QBDJFOUFw /F[
EF7JMMBWJDFODJP 

&TUFBVUPSDSJUJDBMBCFOFmDFODJBCJPMP
HJDJTUBBVMUSBO[BRVFPNJUFMPTQSPDFTPT
QTJDPMHJDPTEFMVTVBSJPZ QPSPUSBQBS
UF  TF QSPOVODJB QPSRVF FM QSPDFTP EF
DPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEPZFMSFTQFUP
BMBBVUPOPNBEFMQBDJFOUFPTBOPFT
UOBCTPMVUBNFOUFDPNQSPNFUJEPTDPO





#JPUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PT3BNO"DPTUB4BSJFHP

FM CJFOFTUBS EF TUPT  EPOEF FM DSJUFSJP


UDOJDPEFMQSPGFTJPOBMEFMBTBMVEZTV
TJTUFNB EF WBMPSFT EFCFO BSSJCBS B MB
NFKPS EFDJTJO QBSB UPEPT  B USBWT EF
MBEFMJCFSBDJO/PFMVEFFMEFCBUFDPO
MPTEFGFOTPSFTEFMBVUPOPNJTNPBDFSDB
EFRVF WJTUPBT FMQSPDFTPEFDPOTFOUJ
NJFOUPJOGPSNBEPQVFEFQSFTUBSTFQBSB
MBNBOJQVMBDJOZBQFMBBRVFFMBDUVBS
SFTQPOTBCMF EFM QSPGFTJPOBM EF MB TBMVE
TFBMBTBMWBHVBSEBBOUFQPTJCMFTDPFSDJP
OFTFJNQPTJDJPOFT
&MBOMJTJTEFMPTQVOUPTEFDPOnVFODJB
EF FTUBT Z PUSBT DPOUSJCVDJPOFT B i#JP
UJDB %FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DVCBOBw
FWJEFODJBRVF TJCJFOUPEBTTFBMFKBOEFM
QBUFSOBMJTNP DMTJDP  UBNQPDP DBFO FO
MPTCSB[PTEFVOBVUPOPNJTNPBVMUSBO
[B QBSBQSPQPOFSVONPEFMPBMUFSOBUJWP
FORVFFMCJFOFTUBSEFMVTVBSJPTFBMDBO
[BEFTEFFMBDUVBSSFTQPOTBCMFEFRVJFO
QSFTUBMBBUFODJOEFTBMVEZMBDPOmBO[B
NVUVB
-BDPOTPMJEBDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFOOVFT
USPQBTTFDPOmSNDPOMBGVOEBDJO B
mOFTEFMPT EFOVFWBTJOTUJUVDJPOFT
RVFJODMVBOMBEJTDJQMJOBFOUSFFMPCKF
UPEFTVNJTJO DPNPGVFSPOFM$FOUSP
EF &TUVEJPT EF #JPUJDB EF MB 'BDVMUBE
EF $JFODJBT .EJDBT EF )PMHVO  RVF
DFMFCSBKPSOBEBTDJFOUmDBTBOVBMFTDPO
QBSUJDJQBDJO JOUFSOBDJPOBM FM $FOUSP
EF &TUVEJPT )VNBOTUJDPT EFM *OTUJUV
UP4VQFSJPSEF$JFODJBT.EJDBTEF-B
)BCBOB Z FM $PNJU EF #JPUJDB EF MB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF-B)BCBOBRVF FODP
PSEJOBDJODPOMB&TDVFMB-BUJOPBNFSJ
DBOB EF .FEJDJOB  DPNFO[ B DFMFCSBS

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

BOVBMNFOUF EFTEF VO&ODVFOUSP


EF #JPUJDB EF MB &EVDBDJO 4VQFSJPS
-B GPSNBDJO EF SFDVSTPT IVNBOPT FO
CJPUJDBTFGVFQFSGFDDJPOBOEPUBNCJO
ZBMPTUSBEJDJPOBMFTDVSTPTJOUSPEVDUP
SJPTTFTVNBSPOBTJHOBUVSBTDVSSJDVMBSFT
FO MBT NBFTUSBT EF (FOUJDB .EJDB F
*OGPSNUJDBEFMB4BMVE BTDPNPDVSTPT
EF UJDB EF MB *OWFTUJHBDJO $JFOUmDB
oFM QSJNFSP EF TUPT BVTQJDJBEP QPS FM
*OTUJUVUP'JOMBZEF7BDVOBTZ4VFSPTFO
4FJOJDJMBGPSNBDJOFTQFDJBMJ[B
EBFOCJPUJDBFOFMOJWFMEFEJQMPNBEP 
BCJFSUBDBTJBMVOTPOPEVSBOUFFMDVSTP
BDBENJDPFOFM*OTUJUVUPEF
$JFODJBT#TJDBTZ1SFDMOJDBTi7JDUPSJB
EF(JSOwZMB'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT.
EJDBTEF)PMHVO BMBTRVFTFTVNBSB
NTUBSEFMB'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT.
EJDBTEF4BODUJ4QJSJUVT*NQPTJCMFTPT
MBZBSMBJOUFOTBBDUJWJEBEFEJUPSJBMFOUF
NBTEFCJPUJDBEFM$FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB 
PSHBOJ[BDJOOPHVCFSOBNFOUBMRVFIB
TJEPEFUFSNJOBOUFFOMBEJWVMHBDJOEF
MPTBVUPSFTOBDJPOBMFT
-B CJPUJDB NEJDB DVCBOB OP SFOJFHB
EFM BQPSUF RVF QBSB MB UJDB DMOJDB IB
SFQSFTFOUBEPFMTJTUFNBEFQSJODJQJPTEF
#FBVDIBNQZ$IJMESFTT TJTFMFTBQMJDB
MBKFSBSRVJ[BDJOQSFDPOJ[BEBQPS%JFHP
(SBDJB QFSPMFDPOmFSFVODPMPSQSPQJP
BM EFTUBDBS MB SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE DPO RVF
EFCFTFSFKFSDJEBMBCFOFmDFODJBZMBTP
MJEBSJEBEDPNPNYJNBTFYQSFTJPOFTEF
KVTUJDJB -B EDBEB USBOTDVSSJEB EFTEF
BMBGFDIBIBTJEPUFTUJHPUBOUPEFM
EFCBUFBDFSDBEFMBWBMJEF[EFMEJTDVSTP
CJPUJDPFOOVFTUSPNFEJP DPNPEFMB
FWPMVDJO EFTEF FM SFTUSJDUJWP FOGPRVF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

CJPNEJDP IBDJB VOB NT BCBSDBEPSB


WJTJOBNCJFOUBMJTUBQPUUFSJBOB

"QPSUFTEFTEF$VCBBMBCJPUJDB
HMPCBMTVTUFOUBCMF
i#JPUJDB %FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DV
CBOBw NBSD UNJEBNFOUF FM QVOUP EF
JOnFYJO IBDJB MB CTRVFEB EFM FRVJMJ
CSJP OFDFTBSJP FOUSF CJPUJDB NEJDB Z
CJPUJDB HMPCBM :B FO  TF FTUBCB
QSPEVDJFOEP VOB UPNB EF DPODJFODJB
BDFSDB EF MB JNQPSUBODJB EF MB CJPUJDB
HMPCBMEF1PUUFSQBSBFMEFTBSSPMMPUF
SJDPZNFUPEPMHJDPEFMBEJTDJQMJOBFO
$VCB ZDPNPFEJUPSDJFOUmDPEFFTUB
PCSB  UVWF MB JOUFODJO EF RVF FYJTUJF
SB  BM NFOPT  VOB NPEFTUB QSFTFODJB
EFEJDIPFOGPRVFFOTUB)BTUBDJFSUP
QVOUPFTUPTFMPHSF JODMVTP TFBDPQJ
NBUFSJBM TVmDJFOUF QBSB DPOGPSNBS VO
DBQUVMP UJUVMBEP i$JWJMJ[BDJO  NFEJP
BNCJFOUFZTBMVEw
&O i&M FTDFOBSJP QPTUNPEFSOP EF MB
CJPUJDBw BMSFnFYJPOBSTPCSFMBFODSV
DJKBEB EF MB OPDJO EF QSPHSFTP BM RVF
DPOEVKPFMEFTBSSPMMPNBUFSJBMBVMUSBO
[B  UQJDP EF MB NPEFSOJEBE oZ RVF ZB
FO FTPT NPNFOUPT TVGSB FM EFTCPRVF
EFMDBQJUBMJTNPOFPMJCFSBMo QMBOUFBNPT
DMBSBNFOUF MB OFDFTJEBE EF VOB CJPUJ
DB EF MB JOUFSWFODJO i4J FYJTUF MB SFBM
WPMVOUBE EF TBMWBS B MB IVNBOJEBE EFM
IPMPDBVTUP FDPMHJDP Z EF FNQSFOEFS
FM DBNJOP EFM EFTBSSPMMP TPTUFOJCMF  TF
QSFDJTBEFVOBOVFWBNFOUBMJEBE EFVO
DPNQSPNJTPFmDB[DPOFMIPNCSFZDPO
MBWJEB EFVOBiOVFWBDVMUVSBwQMBOFUB
SJBiDPOUPEPTZQBSBFMCJFOEFUPEPTw

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

y
$SFBSDPODJFODJBFOFMDBNQPFTQJ
SJUVBMZSFDMBNBSDBNCJPTFOMPTPDJBMZ
FDPONJDPFTFMHSBOSFUPEFDPSSJFOUFT
EF QFOTBNJFOUP BDUVBMFT DPNP MB CJP
UJDB  MB FDPTPGB Z MB FDPMPHB QPMUJDB 
QFSP NTRVFEFTUBT FTFMHSBOEFTBGP
EFMBIVNBOJEBEDPOUFNQPSOFB TJOP
RVJFSFEFKBSEFTFSMPw "DPTUBZ(PO[
MF[ 

0USP EF MPT BUJTCPT EF CJPUJDB HMPCBM
TVTUFOUBCMFQSFTFOUFTFOMBTEPTQSJNFSBT
FEJDJPOFTEFi#JPUJDB%FTEFVOBQFST
QFDUJWBDVCBOBw FTFMRVFFYQSFTBO6C
BMEP(PO[MF[1SF[ +PSHF(SBVWBMP
Z.BSB"OUPOJB"NBSJMMP.FOEP[BBM
DSJUJDBSFMOGBTJTFOMBTDVFTUJPOFTEFMB
DBMJEBEEFWJEBJOEJWJEVBMQSFTFOUFTFO
MPT FWFOUPT DMOJDPT BM QSJODJQJP Z mOBM
EF MB WJEB IVNBOB  RVF TPO BO IPZ
UQJDPSFDVSSFOUFEFMBCJPUJDBNEJDB
iyTJ FO CJPUJDB TF SFDPOPDF Z TF USB
CBKBFODPNJTUJDBNFOUFFOSFMBDJODPO
MBDBMJEBEEFWJEBFOFMNPNFOUPEFMB
NVFSUF y
4FEFCFQSJPSJ[BSMBQPMNJ
DBBUPEPTMPTQSPCMFNBTHMPCBMFT TPDJB
MFT HSVQBMFTFJOEJWJEVBMFTRVFBGFDUBO
MBWJEB FMFDPTJTUFNBZMBDBMJEBEEFWJEB
EFMHOFSPIVNBOP Z UBNCJO GPDBMJ
[BS TPCSF RV DPOEJDJPOFT TPDJPFDPO
NJDBTEFWJEB RVHBSBOUBTKVSEJDBTZ
RVFEVDBDJONPSBMOFDFTJUBFMIPNCSF
QBSBRVFTVTEFDJTJPOFTOPDPOTUJUVZBO
VOBWJPMBDJOEFMPTQSJODJQJPTNPSBMFT
EFMBDVMUVSBVOJWFSTBMw (PO[MF[ (SBV
Z"NBSJMMP 

&OTFQVCMJDBOEPTMJCSPTRVFNBS
DBOFMQSPDFTPEFDPOnVFODJBQMFOBEFM
QFOTBNJFOUP BNCJFOUBMJTUB Z CJPUJDP





#JPUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PT3BNO"DPTUB4BSJFHP

DVCBOPFOMBDPOTPMJEBDJOEFVOBWJTJO
QSPQJBEFMBCJPUJDBHMPCBMTVTUFOUBCMF
i&DPMPHBZTPDJFEBE&TUVEJPTw CBKPMB
FEJDJO DJFOUmDB EF $BSMPT +FTT %FM
HBEP %B[ Z BMB . 'VOH 3JWFSO 
Zi$VCBWFSEF&OCVTDBEFVONPEFMP
QBSB MB TVTUFOUBCJMJEBEw  UBNCJO DPO
MBFEJDJODJFOUmDBEF$BSMPT+%FMHB
EP&OMBPDBTJOFWJEFODJMBWPDBDJO
EF MB CJPUJDB NEJDB QPS DPODFOUSBSTF
FOMBDVFTUJOEFMBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSJO
EJWJEVBMFT EF MB BUFODJO EF TBMVE Z MB
JOWFTUJHBDJOCJPNEJDB ZMBOFDFTJEBE
EFBNQMJBSFMIPSJ[POUFCJPUJDPi3FBM
NFOUF QPDPIBSFNPTTJOPTPDVQBNPT
EFMPTQSPCMFNBTQBSUJDVMBSFTEFMBTBMVE
ZOPMPTFOGSFOUBNPTFOTVJOUFHSBMJEBE 
FOMBDPNQMFKBVSEJNCSFEFTVTSFMBDJP
OFTDPOMPTQSPDFTPTFDPONJDPT TPDJB
MFTZDVMUVSBMFTEFMEFTBSSPMMPw "DPTUB 


&OFMNJTNPZBVTQJDJBEPQPSMB
FEJUPSJBM &-'04  EFM $FOUSP EF *OHF
OJFSB(FOUJDBZ#JPUFDOPMPHB TFDFMF
CSFO-B)BCBOBFM1SJNFS5BMMFS/B
DJPOBM TPCSF 0SHBOJTNPT .PEJmDBEPT
(FOUJDBNFOUF 0.(
-BTQPOFODJBT
GVFSPOQVCMJDBEBTFOMBQSFTUJHJPTBSFWJT
UB #JPUFDOPMPHB "QMJDBEB %F NJ BQPS
UF BM FWFOUP FYUSBJHP FTUBT DJUBT  FO MBT
RVF DPOTJEFSP TFFYQSFTBVOJOUFOUPEF
PGSFDFSVOQVOUPNTEFSFGFSFODJBBMB
GVOEBNFOUBDJO UJDB EFM BOMJTJT BDFS
DB EFM JNQBDUP NFEJPBNCJFOUBM EF MPT
PSHBOJTNPT WJWPT BSUJmDJBMNFOUF EJTF
BEPTi-BPCTFSWBODJBEFMQSJODJQJPEF
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE BMGBWPSFDFSMBQSFTFSWB
DJOEFMCJFODPNO DPOUSJCVZFBDSFBS
VODPOUFYUPNBUFSJBMZTPDJBMBEFDVBEP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

BMFRVJMJCSJPEFMIPNCSFZMBOBUVSBMF[B 
HBSBOUJ[BOEPBTRVFMPTWBMPSFTZEFSF
DIPTJOEJWJEVBMFTQVFEBOUFOFSSFBMJ[B
DJOFGFDUJWB y
&MQSJODJQJPEFKVTUJDJB
TFSFGFDUJWP FONBUFSJBEFJOWFTUJHBDJO
ZVUJMJ[BDJOEFMPT0.(ZEFMBTCJP
UFDOPMPHBT FO HFOFSBM  TJ TF BMDBO[B MB
OFDFTBSJBFRVJEBEFODPNQBSUJSMPTCF
OFmDJPT  FWBMVBS Z FOGSFOUBS MPT SJFTHPT
QPUFODJBMFTZFMBDDFTPBMBJOGPSNBDJO
HFOUJDBBDVNVMBEBZMBUSBOTGFSFODJBEF
UFDOPMPHBT&TUFQSPQTJUPTMPTFSQP
TJCMFTJTFFTUBCMFDFMBOFDFTBSJBDPPQFSB
DJO/PSUF4VS MPRVFJNQMJDBSBTVQF
SBS MB JOKVTUB DPODFQDJO OFPMJCFSBM EF
MBKVTUJDJB y
3FTQPOTBCJMJEBEZKVTUJ
DJBDPOTUJUVZFOFMJNQFSBUJWPUJDPQBSB
MBTJOWFTUJHBDJPOFTZVMUFSJPSVUJMJ[BDJO
EFMPT0.(-BPCTFSWBODJBEFBNCPT
QSJODJQJPTFTDPOTVTUBODJBMQBSBRVFFTUF
MPHSP EF MB DVMUVSB SFQFSDVUB FO FM CF
OFmDJPEFMBTPDJFEBEFOTVDPOKVOUPZ
OP TFDPOWJFSUB FO VO BEJUBNFOUP NT
EFMFKFSDJDJPEFVOQPEFSIFHFNOJDPw
"DPTUB "&&

6O FOGPRVF HMPCBM EF MB CJPUJDB OP
QVFEF TPTMBZBS MPT QSPCMFNBT EFM EFTB
SSPMMPZMBTSFMBDJPOFTFDPONJDBTZTP
DJBMFT RVF TVCZBDFO FO MBT BQMJDBDJPOFT
UFDOPMHJDBTBMBWJEBTPDJBM QBSBMPDVBM
FM NBSDP UFSJDPNFUPEPMHJDP RVF IB
GVODJPOBEPFOFMNCJUPEFMBCJPUJDB
NEJDBSFTVMUBBRVJOTVmDJFOUF4JCJFO
ZB "SBVKP IBCB QMBOUFBEP VO TJTUFNB
SFGFSFODJBM BMUFSOBUJWP BM QSJODJQBMJTNP
BOHMPTBKOQBSBFMBOMJTJTZTPMVDJOEF
MPT QSPCMFNBT QSPQJPT EF VOB NBDSP
CJPUJDBNEJDB BDDFTJCJMJEBE FRVJEBE
ZQBSUJDJQBDJO
FOFMQSFTFOUFTFQSFDJ





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

TBRVFFMBDUVBSKVTUPEFCFTFSUBNCJO
SFTQPOTBCMF  EBEP RVF MPT QSPDFTPT FO
KVFHPWBONTBMMEFMBTBMVEIVNBOB
oBVORVFMBJODMVZFoZTFFYUJFOEFOBMB
FTUBCJMJEBEEFMPTFDPTJTUFNBTZMBTVQFS
WJWFODJBEFMBWJEBFOHFOFSBM
&OFMi(MPTBSJPEF#JPUJDBwEF3BGBFM
5PSSFT "DPTUB 
 BQBSFDFO EFmOJ
EPT FOVOBQVCMJDBDJODVCBOB MPTUS
NJOPTEFiCJPUJDBBNCJFOUBMw iCJPUJDB
HMPCBMw Z iCJPUJDB QSPGVOEBw 5PSSFT 

VOFMFNFOUPNTRVFBQVOUB
BMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMBWJTJOIPMTUJDB
EFMBEJTDJQMJOBFOOVFTUSPQBT
i#JPUJDB QBSB MB TVTUFOUBCJMJEBEw  QV
CMJDBEPFO SFQSFTFOUBMBWFSEBEFSB
FDMPTJOEFMBCJPUJDBHMPCBMTVTUFOUBCMF
FO$VCB OPTMPQPSRVFFOUPEPFMMJ
CSPnPUBVOBVSBEFIPNFOBKFB1PUUFS 
TJOPUBNCJO FJOEFQFOEJFOUFNFOUFEF
MBTEFTJHVBMEBEFTEFUPEBPCSBDPMFDUJWB 
QPSTVTBQPSUFTBMBDPOTPMJEBDJOEFMB
QFSTQFDUJWBBNCJFOUBMJTUBEFMBEJTDJQMJ
OB+FTT"SNBOEP.BSUOF[(NF[ FO
TVBSUDVMPi1SPZFDUPTQBSBVOBCJPUJDB
HMPCBMw QFSmMBEFmOJUJWBNFOUFMPTQSJO
DJQJPT RVF EFCFO SFHJS MPT EFTUJOPT EF
VOB JOUFSQSFUBDJO IPMTUJDB EF MB CJP
UJDB i-B CJPUJDB NEJDB IB JOTJTUJEP
NT FO MB TPMJEBSJEBE HSVQBM  GVOEBEB
FO MB UJDB EFM UFOFS  RVF FO MB TPMJEB
SJEBEHMPCBM CBTBEBFOFMNPEPEFTFS
y
%FTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBTFBMBEB TFSB
NVZEJGDJMEFTBSSPMMBSVOBSFTQPOTBCJMJ
EBE HMPCBM TPMJEBSJB 6O QSJODJQBMJTNP
EPOEF FM SFTQFUP B MB BVUPOPNB TFB
DPOTJEFSBEP VO QSJODJQJP EF KFSBSRVB
TVQFSJPSTFSNVZEJGDJMEFJOTFSUBSFO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

FMDPOUFYUPEFVOBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEWFS
EBEFSBNFOUF TPMJEBSJB  DPO QSPZFDDJP
OFTHMPCBMFTZOPJOEJWJEVBMFTPHSVQB
MFT y
&MQVFOUFDPODFCJEPQPS1PUUFS
GVF FM EFTBSSPMMP EF VOB UJDB HMPCBM 
QFSPMBTWJHBTPDJNJFOUPTEFFTUFQVFOUF
OPQVFEFOTFSPUSPTRVFMBTPMJEBSJEBE
Z SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE HMPCBMFTw .BSUOF[ 


&M NBUJ[ BOUFSJPSNFOUF BUSJCVJEP B MB
QFSTQFDUJWB DVCBOB EF MB CJPUJDB N
EJDBoEFJOUFSQSFUBSMBCFOFmDFODJBDPO
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZMBKVTUJDJBDPNPTPMJ
EBSJEBEoRVFEBBIPSBQMFOBNFOUFDPO
TJEFSBEPQPSFTUFBVUPSFOFMDBTPEFMB
CJPUJDBHMPCBMTVTUFOUBCMF BMQSPQPOFS
RVFMPTQSJODJQJPTEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZ
TPMJEBSJEBETPOMPTBEFDVBEPTQBSBTFS
WJSEFQVOUPEFQBSUJEBBVOQSPDFTPEF
EFMJCFSBDJO Z CTRVFEB EF TPMVDJPOFT
NPSBMNFOUF WMJEBT B MPT DPOnJDUPT EF
WBMPSFTNPSBMFTQSPQJPTEFMBBQMJDBDJO
EFMDPOPDJNJFOUPFOMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEF
VONVOEPJOKVTUBNFOUFFTDJOEJEP
-B DPODFQDJO HMPCBM EF MB CJPUJDB Z
TV JOUFSSFMBDJO DPO MB TVTUFOUBCJMJEBE
EFMEFTBSSPMMPDPOEVDFJOFWJUBCMFNFOUF
B MB CJPQPMUJDB BDDJO DJVEBEBOB QBSB
BMDBO[BSRVFMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBETPMJEBSJB
TFNBUFSJBMJDFFOQPMUJDBTRVFJODMVZBO
MBQBSUJDJQBDJOQSPUBHOJDBUBOUPEFMB
TPDJFEBEDJWJMDPNPEFMPT&TUBEPTZMBT
PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT -PHSBS
MB WFSUFCSBDJO Z DPIFSFODJB EF FTUPT
FTGVFS[PTEFQFOEFEFVODBNCJPTVTUBO
DJBMEFMBFEVDBDJOFOWBMPSFT FOFMRVF
MPNPSBMEFKBFTUBSTFQBSBEPEFMDPOPDJ
NJFOUPDJFOUmDPZQBTBBTFSQBSUFDPOT





#JPUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PT3BNO"DPTUB4BSJFHP

UJUVUJWBEFTUF-BCJPUJDB BTJOUFSQSF
UBEB FTVOBDVFTUJOEFUPEBMBTPDJFEBE
ZOPVOBUFNUJDBEFMBEJTDVTJOBDBE
NJDBFOUSFVOBFMJUFEFJOJDJBEPT
i-B CJPUJDB GPSNVMBEB QPS 1PUUFS SF
QSFTFOUBVOBSVQUVSBDVMUVSBMQSPGVOEB
4FFYJHFEFMIPNCSFMBSFDPODJMJBDJOEF
MB NPSBMJEBE Z FM TBCFS DPNP FOUJEBE
OJDBRVFMPNPSBMTFBJODPSQPSBEPBM
DPOPDJNJFOUP DPNP DPNQPOFOUF JN
QPSUBOUFEFMBPCKFUJWJEBEZMFHJUJNJEBE
EFM TBCFS 6OB QSPQVFTUB EF BDDJPOFT
QBSB MB GPSNBDJO EF TVKFUPT SFTQPOTB
CMFTFOVOFOUPSOPDVMUVSBMEFDBNCJP
&MMBFTUMMBNBEBBQSPEVDJSVOBSFWPMV
DJO EFM TBCFS IVNBOP  Z GVF EFmOJEB
QPSTVBVUPSFOUSNJOPTRVFFOGBUJ[BO
FTUFSFDMBNPw %FMHBEP 

-VJT-QF[#PNCJOP FOi&MTBCFSUJDP
EFBZFSBIPZw 
SFUPNBFMUFNB
EFTEF MB MFHJUJNJEBE NPSBM EFM USBCBKP
DJFOUmDP Z TV JOFMVEJCMF DPNQSPNJTP
TPDJBMi1FOTBSFOMBDJFODJBZMBUFDOPMP
HBFTUBNCJONFEJUBSFOMBSFTQPOTBCJ
MJEBEEFRVJFOFTMBIBDFOZMBFKFDVUBO 
QVFT{RVTFSBEFMBDSFBUJWJEBEDJFOU
mDBTJOPTFQJFOTBFOTVTDPOTFDVFODJBT
TPDJBMFTZNPSBMFT /PFTQPSHVTUPRVF
FM DVMUP QPS MB OPWFEBE  QPS MP PSJHJ
OBM  OP QVFEF EFTDVJEBS TV TJHOJmDBEP
BYJPMHJDP  QVFT MB BQFUFODJB QPS DPTBT
OVFWBTIBHVJBEPBMIPNCSFEFDJFODJBB
FYUSFNBTBOHVTUJBT-BDJFODJBOPQVFEF
QFSNBOFDFSBMNBSHFOEFMPTDPOnJDUPT
TPDJBMFTZIVNBOPT QPSFTPMBGVODJO
EFMDJFOUmDPOPFTTMPMBEFQSPEVDJS
TBCFS PCKFUJWP  OFVUSBM  TJO RVF TV USB
CBKPTFBJOnVFODJBEPQPSMBTPDJFEBEFO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

RVFWJWFUSBCBKBZDSFBw -QF[#PNCJ
OP 

&TUBSFWPMVDJODVMUVSBMIBDJBMBSFTQPO
TBCJMJEBETPMJEBSJBFOFMVTPEFMDPOPDJ
NJFOUP JNQMJDB VO SFQMBOUFP EFM QBQFM
TPDJBM EF MB DJFODJB Z MB UFDOPMPHB &O
VOBQPDBFORVFFMDPOPDJNJFOUPCJP
MHJDPZEJHJUBMNBSDBOFMQBTPEFMQSP
HSFTPDJFOUmDP SFTVMUBJOBDFQUBCMFRVF
FTUPTiDPNVOFTwFTUOTJFOEPPCKFUPEF
VO QSPDFTP EF QSJWBUJ[BDJO HBMPQBOUF
RVFNBSHJOBBRVJFOFTDBSFDFOEFBDDF
TP Z OVUSF B EJGVTPT FOUFT DPSQPSBUJWPT
RVFNVFWFOMPTIJMPTEFVOQPEFSBWB
TBMMBEPS
iyMBCJPUJDBGVFQSPNPWJEBCBKPMBDPO
DJFODJBEFFTUBCMFDFSCBSSFSBTNPSBMFTB
MBTOVFWBTGPSNBTEFJOUFSWFODJOFOMPT
QSPDFTPT CJPMHJDPT RVF BDBSSFBCBO TF
SJPTCJPQFMJHSPT1FSPOPTFEFCFPMWJEBS
RVFFOMBDPOOPUBDJORVFIBBMDBO[BEP
MBCJPUJDBFOMBBDUVBMJEBEJOUFSWJFOFO
PUSPTGBDUPSFT QPSFKFNQMPFMJOUFSTFO
RVFFYJTUBVOPSEFONTKVTUPEFEJTUSJ
CVDJOEFMPTCFOFmDJPTEFMBDJFODJBZ
MBUDOJDBw 'SFZSF 

$BSMPT %FMHBEP  FO i)FUFSPHFOFJEBE
TPDJBM FO MB $VCB BDUVBMw  BTFHVSB RVF
USFT EF MPT QVOUPT EF SVQUVSB RVF MB
CJPUJDBIBJOUSPEVDJEPBMQFOTBNJFOUP
UJDP DPOUFNQPSOFP UJFOFO WBMPS NF
UPEPMHJDP QBSB FM BOMJTJT EF MBT EFT
JHVBMEBEFTTPDJBMFT
t

t

-BDPOTJEFSBDJOEFMBOBUVSBMF[BZ
MBTBCJEVSBRVFFNBOBEFTVFTUV
EJPDPNPGVFOUFEFNPSBMJEBE
-BFYJHFODJBEFDPOTJEFSBSJOUFHSB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

t

EBTMBQFSTQFDUJWBTPDJBMHFOFSBM MB
DPNVOJUBSJBZMBJOEJWJEVBM
-BPSJFOUBDJOWBMPSBUJWBFOMBCT
RVFEB EF FTUBEPT TPDJBMFT TVTUFO
UBCMFT RVF TVQFSFO MPT QSFTVQVFT
UPT QPMUJDPT EF MB UJDB DBQJUBMJTUB
%FMHBEP 


-BCJPUJDBHMPCBMTVTUFOUBCMFSFQSFTFOUB
FOUPODFTMBTOUFTJTEFFTUPTQSFTVQVFT
UPTZFOMB[BBMQFOTBNJFOUPCJPUJDPDPO
MB FDPMPHB QPMUJDB FO MB CTRVFEB EF
NPEFMPT EF PSHBOJ[BDJO TPDJBM DPNP
BMUFSOBUJWBBMDBQJUBMJTNPOFPMJCFSBM
&M TJHMP 99*  IBCB BmSNBEP 1PUUFS 
EFCFTFSFMTJHMPEFMBCJPUJDBHMPCBMP 
EFMPDPOUSBSJP QSFTFODJBSFMIPMPDBVT
UPEFMBTFYUBFYUJODJO1FESP-VT4P
UPMPOHPFTPQUJNJTUBFMSFTQFDUPi:RVJ
[TNBSDIBOEPBMPMBSHPEFFTFDBNJOP
FQPDBM BSSJCFNPT B MB UJFSSB QSPNFUJEB
EF VOB WJTJO IPMTUJDB EF MB WJEB IV
NBOBZPUSBT
&OGPRVFJOUFHSBMZHMPCBM
EFMPRVFBUBFBMBWJEB DVZBNFUGPSB
CTJDBTFBOPMBEFMBMVDIBZMBDPNQF
UFODJB MB TVQFSWJWFODJB EFM NT BQUP

TJOPMBEFMBGSBUFSOJEBEZMBDPPQFSBDJO
FOUSF MPT TFSFT IVNBOPT  FO BSBT EF MB
QSFTFSWBDJOHMPCBMEFFTBWJEB1BSBFMMP
UBNCJOIBSGBMUBVOBCJPUJDBHMPCBMw
4PUPMPOHP 

-BCTRVFEBEFVONPEFMPEFTPDJFEBE
TVTUFOUBCMF FT VOP EF MPT QJMBSFT EF MB
DPODFQDJODVCBOBBDFSDBEFMBCJPUJ
DB HMPCBM  JEFBM RVF TMP FT QPTJCMF FO
VOFOUPSOPEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBETPMJEBSJB
FKFSDJEBDPODFSUBEBNFOUFEFTEFUPEBMB
TPDJFEBE  FM &TUBEP Z MB TPDJFEBE DJWJM 
IBDJBEFOUSPZGVFSBEFMBTGSPOUFSBTOB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DJPOBMFT  IBDJFOEP WBMFS DPNP CSKVMB


MB NYJNB NBSUJBOB EF RVF i1BUSJB FT
IVNBOJEBEw USBTNVUBEBUBMWF[FORVF
i1BUSJBFTMBCJPTGFSBw QPSMBDVBMZFOMB
DVBMMBIVNBOJEBEFYJTUF

-BCJPUJDBDPNPOVFWPTBCFS
{UJDBBQMJDBEBPNFUBUJDB
-BJOUSPEVDDJOEFMPTOVFWPTSFGFSFOUFT
EFMBCJPUJDBPSJHJOVOBQSJNFSBMOFB
EFEFCBUFOBDJPOBM DFOUSBEBFOMBWBMJ
EF[EFTVEJTDVSTPQBSBMBTDPOEJDJPOFT
PCKFUJWBTZTVCKFUJWBTEFVOB$VCBRVF 
FOMPTBPT FTUBCBJONFSTBFOQSP
GVOEPT DBNCJPT FDPONJDPT Z TPDJBMFT
FODBNJOBEPT B MPHSBS MB TVQFSWJWFODJB
EFM QSPZFDUP TPDJBM SFWPMVDJPOBSJP 1
SF[ 'MPSFT 4JOHIZ1BSFEFT 

 'JOBMNFOUF  IB QSFWBMFDJEP VOB
UFOEFODJBNBZPSJUBSJBEFBVUPSFTDVCB
OPTRVFSFDPOPDJFSPOFMTJHOPQPTJUJWP
EFMBCJPUJDB BQFTBSEFVOBQBSUJEBEF
OBDJNJFOUP SVCSJDBEB FO VO DPOUFYUP
DFOUSBM EF DVMUVSB BOHMPTBKPOB Z FDP
OPNB DBQJUBMJTUB MJCFSBM  DBSBDUFSTUJDBT
RVFSFRVFSBOTFSSFDSFBEBTEFTEFOVFT
USBJEFOUJEBE
&M SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EFmOJUJWP EF MB WB
MJEF[ EF MB CJPUJDB QBSB $VCB QSPWJOP
EFM DVSTP UFMFWJTJWP iUJDB Z TPDJFEBEw 
USBTNJUJEPFOQPSMBTFNJTPSBTEF
BMDBODFOBDJPOBMEFOUSPEFMQSPHSBNBEF
DVSTPT i6OJWFSTJEBE QBSB UPEPTw &O FM
UBCMPJEFEFBQPZPCJCMJPHSmDP FMBCPSB
EPQPS/BODZ-$IBDO"SUFBHBZRVF
DJSDVM QSPGVTBNFOUF FO UPEP FM QBT 
TFDPOTJHOBMPTJHVJFOUFi-BCJPUJDBTF
FTUDPOWJSUJFOEPFOVOJEJPNBVOJWFS
TBMEFEJNFOTJPOFTUJDBTSFMFWBOUFT&O





#JPUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PT3BNO"DPTUB4BSJFHP

TVFNQFPEFSFTBMUBSFMQBQFMCFOmDP
RVFEFCFEFTFNQFBSMBDJFODJBQBSBFM
CJFOFTUBSEFMBIVNBOJEBE PGSFDFTPMV
DJPOFT JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJBT Z TF PQPOF BM
JSSFTQFUP  B MB DPSSVQDJO Z B DVBMRVJFS
JOUFOUP EJTDSJNJOBUPSJP RVF BGFDUF B MB
IVNBOJEBE BMBEJHOJEBEEFMTFSIVNB
OPZSFQFSDVUBOFGBTUBNFOUFFOFMNFEJP
BNCJFOUF&OFTUBQFSTQFDUJWB DPOTUJUV
ZFVOBOFDFTJEBERVFMBCJPUJDBMMFHVF
BUPEPTMPTDJVEBEBOPTDPNPVOOVFWP
TBCFS1BSBFMMPFTJNQSFTDJOEJCMFFEVDBS
BMBQPCMBDJOTPCSFTVTQSJODJQJPTGVO
EBNFOUBMFTFOMBFTGFSBEFMBFEVDBDJO
ZTVTEFSFDIPTDPNPTVKFUPTQPUFODJBMFT
EFJOWFTUJHBDJOFOUPEPTMPTDBNQPTEFM
TBCFSw WBSJPTBVUPSFT 

"QFTBSEFMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMBMFHJUJ
NJEBEEFMBCJPUJDBDPNPEJTDJQMJOBFO
FMDPOUFYUPDVCBOP MBEJTDVTJOUFSJDB
TPCSF TV MVHBS EFOUSP EF MB FTUSVDUVSB
EF MB UJDB OP FT VO BTVOUP DPODMVJEP
1SFTUJHJPTBT QFSTPOBMJEBEFT EF FTUVEJPT
UJDPT DPNP-VT-QF[#PNCJOP DPO
TJEFSBO RVF DPOmHVSB DPNP VOB UJDB
BQMJDBEB B MPT QSPCMFNBT Z DPOnJDUPT
EFWBMPSFTNPSBMFTQSFTFOUFTFOMPTVTPT
UFDOPMHJDPT EFM TBCFS DJFOUmDP Z TV
JNQBDUPFOMBDVMUVSBZMBTPDJFEBEDPO
UFNQPSOFB4JOFNCBSHP BMB'VOH
FOUJFOEF RVF iyFM TBCFS CJPUJDP FTU
FOQMFOBDPOTUSVDDJO y
VOPEFTVT
FMFNFOUPT DBSBDUFSTUJDPT FT DPOPDFS MB
WJODVMBDJOFOUSFMBDPODFQDJOZMBJOT
USVNFOUBDJO FOMPDVBMTFEJGFSFODJBEF
HSBOQBSUFEFMBmMPTPGBDPOUFNQPSOFB
4VDBSDUFSHMPCBMZMPDBMMPFNQBSFOUBO
EF NPEP DFSDBOP DPO FM iBNCJFOUFw Z
QBEFDF EF MBT NJTNBT EJmDVMUBEFT PQF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

SBDJPOBMFTRVFBRVFKBOBFTUFMUJNP B
MBWF[RVFDPOKVHB UBNCJODPNPM MP
UFSJDP Z MP FNQSJDP  MP BCTPMVUP Z MP
DPOUBNJOBEP DPO DJFODJBT EJWFSTBT  MB
DJSDVMBSJEBEEFTVTDPODFQUPTZTVQBQFM
NFEJBUPSJP  UBOUP IPSJ[POUBM DPNP EF
NPEPWFSUJDBM
&TUF UJQP EF TBCFS FOHMPCB OP TMP MPT
GFONFOPT FTQFDmDPT EF MB WJEB  TJOP
UBNCJO TV JOUFSSFMBDJO DPO MPT DPN
QPOFOUFT OP PSHOJDPT -VFHP  EF
IFDIP  TF IBDF QSFTFOUF FO UPEB MB SF
nFYJO DJFOUmDB Z USBTDJFOEF BM DBSD
UFSOPSNBUJWP QFSPOPQVFEFFYDMVJSMP
&OUPODFT FOFTUBSFEBNBMHBNB{EOEF
FODPOUSBSBNPTTVJEFOUJEBETVTUBOUJWB
ZNFUPEPMHJDB &OMBUPUBMJEBE&OFMMP
TF EJGFSFODJB EF MB HFOFSBMJ[BDJO mMP
TmDB QSPQJBNFOUF EJDIB  QFSP SFDPSSF
MB TVCKFUJWJEBE Z MB OBUVSBMF[B  TJO RVF
QPEBNPT EBSMF QSJPSJEBE B OJOHVOB
EF MBT EPT  QPSRVF BNCBT DPOTUJUVZFO
MP VOP  DPO VOB QSFFNJOFODJB EJWFSTB
DPOUFYUVBMJ[BEB QPS FM EFWFOJSw 'VOH 


&OVOBEFTVTPCSBTNTSFDJFOUFToi)B
DJBVOOVFWPTBCFS-BCJPUJDBFOMBSF
WPMVDJODPOUFNQPSOFBEFMTBCFSw BO
FO QSFOTBo  $BSMPT %FMHBEP SFBMJ[B VO
BOMJTJT MHJDP IJTUSJDP EFM EFTBSSPMMP
EFMBCJPUJDBDPNPEJTDJQMJOBEFTEFTV
EPCMF BMVNCSBNJFOUP  DPNP CJPUJDB
NEJDB Z CJPUJDB HMPCBM  Z QSPGVOEJ[B
FO RVF MP EJTUJOUJWP EF FMMB DPNP UFP
SBZBQMJDBDJOUJDBFTIBCFSTFDPOTUJ
UVJEP FO VO OVFWP UJQP EF TBCFS i-B
CJPUJDBHMPCBMDPNQMFUBMBJOUFHSBDJO
EFMOVFWPTBCFSZMBSVQUVSBDPOMBSB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DJPOBMJEBEDMTJDBSFBMJ[BEBEFDPOKVOUP
FO MB FQJTUFNPMPHB EF TFHVOEP PSEFO 
FM QFOTBNJFOUP EF MB DPNQMFKJEBE Z FM
IPMJTNP BNCJFOUBMJTUB y
 &O mO  MB
TVQFSBDJOEFMBTOPDJPOFTUSBEJDJPOBMFT
EF TVQFSJPSJEBE IVNBOB CBTBEBT FO FM
DPOPDJNJFOUP DJFOUmDP  FM SFTDBUF EFM
IPNCSFDPNPQFSTPOBZMBJOUFHSBDJO
EFTVNVOEPTPDJBMZOBUVSBMw %FMHB
EP 


$PODMVTJO
-BCJPUJDBDPNPEJTDJQMJOBJSSVNQJFO
$VCBJOJDJBMNFOUFDPNPUJDBCJPNEJ
DBZFOTVEFTBSSPMMPIBMPHSBEPDPOmHV
SBSVONPEFMPEFSFMBDJOTBOJUBSJBCB
TBEPFOMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBE MBDPOmBO[B
ZMBTPMJEBSJEBE DPOBQPSUFTDPODSFUPTB
MBUFPSBEFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEP 
MBEFmOJDJOEFNVFSUFZMBDBMJEBEEF
WJEBDPNPDVFTUJOUJDB

%VSBOUF MB MUJNB EDBEB  MB BDFQDJO


EF MB EJTDJQMJOB DPNP CJPUJDB HMPCBM
TVTUFOUBCMFIBSFQVOUBEPDPOUBMGVFS[B
RVFTFIBJEPFRVJQBSBOEPFODVBOUPB
QSPEVDDJODJFOUmDBDPOMBCJPNEJDB
6O QSPEVDUP EF FTUF FTGVFS[P JOUFMFD
UVBM IB TJEP TV DPNQSFOTJO DPNP VO
OVFWPUJQPEFTBCFSRVF USBTDFOEJFOEP
MPTFTUBODPTMFHBEPTQPSMBSBDJPOBMJEBE
NPEFSOB  SFDPODJMJB BM IPNCSF DPO MB
OBUVSBMF[B -B OFDFTJEBE EF VO QVOUP
EF QBSUJEB RVF TF DPSSFTQPOEB DPO MB
QSPCMFNUJDBBNCJFOUBMHMPCBMIBDPOT
UJUVJEPBMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZMBTPMJEBSJ
EBEDPNPTVTQSJODJQJPTSFDUPSFTZHVBT
EFFTUBCJPUJDBHMPCBMBMBDVCBOB DPN
QSPNFUJEB DPO VOB BDDJO CJPQPMUJDB
FODBNJOBEB BM VTP SBDJPOBM Z FRVJUBUJ
WPEFMPTCJFOFTDPNVOFT FOFMNBSDP
EFVOBTPDJFEBETVTUFOUBCMFZVOPSEFO
NVOEJBMKVTUP

3FGFSFODJBT
"DPTUB  + 3 
 #JPUJDB  DJWJMJ[BDJO Z EFTBSSPMMP TPTUFOJCMF &O %FMHBEP  $+
0SH
$VCBWFSEF&OCVTDBEFVONPEFMPQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBE1SJNFSB&EJDJO
-B)BCBOB &EJUPSJBM+PT.BSU $PMFDDJO5JFSSBZ&TQBDJP QQ
"DPTUB +3 "
-PTPSHBOJTNPTNPEJGJDBEPTHFOUJDBNFOUF&MQPEFSCMBOEPEFM
5FSDFS.JMFOJP3FWJTUB#JPUFDOPMPHB"QMJDBEB  /&TQFDJBM
QQ&&
"DPTUB  +3 Z (PO[MF[  .$ 
 &M FTDFOBSJP QPTUNPEFSOP EF MB CJPUJDB &O
"DPTUB  +3 &EJUPS DJFOUGJDP
 #JPUJDB %FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DVCBOB 1SJNFSB
&EJDJO-B)BCBOB 1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP $FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB QQ
"MPOTP % 7PO4NJUI 7 3BNSF[ "Z0SUFHB " 
UJDBZ%FPOUPMPHB.EJDB
UFYUP CTJDP  FEJDJO QSPWJTJPOBM
 -B )BCBOB  .JOJTUFSJP EF 4BMVE 1CMJDB 
$PMFDDJOEFM&TUVEJBOUFEF.FEJDJOB
"SBVKP  3 
 )BDJB VOB CJPUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB &O "DPTUB  +3 &EJUPS
DJFOUGJDP
 #JPUJDB %FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DVCBOB 1SJNFSB &EJDJO -B )BCBOB 
1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP $FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB QQ
#FDB +1 0SH
 
UJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJO$JFOUGJDB5FSDFS5BMMFS*OUFSOBDJPOBM
EFM1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPUJDB0140.4 OPWJFNCSFEF -B)BCBOB
4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF  &EJDJPOFT EFM 1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPUJDB 0140.4 
QQ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



#JPUJDBFO$VCBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEZTPMJEBSJEBE+PT3BNO"DPTUB4BSJFHP



#PSSPUP  3  /F[ EF 7JMMBWJDFODJP  ' Z .BSUOF[ ) 


 3FQFSDVTJO EF MB
SFWPMVDJODJFOUGJDPUDOJDBTPCSFFMQSPDFTPTBMVEFOGFSNFEBEZMBPSHBOJ[BDJO
EF MB TBMVE QCMJDB &O 7BSJPT "VUPSFT 5FNBT EF UJDB .EJDB * -B )BCBOB 
%FQBSUBNFOUPEF1TJDPMPHB *OTUJUVUPEF$JFODJBT#TJDBTZ1SFDMOJDBTi7JDUPSJB
EF(JSOw .JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVE1CMJDB QQ
#PSSPUP  3 Z "OFJSPT3JCB  3 
 -B DPNVOJDBDJO IVNBOB Z MB DBMJEBE EF MB
BUFODJONEJDB&O"DPTUB +3 &EJUPSDJFOUGJDP
#JPUJDB%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWB
DVCBOB1SJNFSB&EJDJO-B)BCBOB 1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP $FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB 
QQ
%F"SNBT " 
&OUPSOPBMBPSJFOUBDJOGJMPTGJDBEFMBCJPUJDB3FWJTUB$VCBOB
EF$JFODJBT4PDJBMFT  
FOFSPBCSJM QQ
%F-B5PSSF & -QF[$ .SRVF[ . FUBM 
4BMVEQBSBUPEPTTFTQPTJCMF
1SJNFSB &EJDJO -B )BCBOB  4PDJFEBE $VCBOB EF 4BMVE 1CMJDB  4FDDJO EF
.FEJDJOB4PDJBM
%FMHBEP  ( 
 3BDFT IJTUSJDBT EFM QFOTBNJFOUP CJPUJDP Z EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
NEJDBFOTVKFUPTIVNBOPTFO$VCB&O"DPTUB +3#JPUJDB%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWB
DVCBOB1SJNFSB&EJDJO-B)BCBOB 1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP $FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB 
QQ
%FMHBEP  $+ 
 $PHOJDJO  QSPCMFNB BNCJFOUBM Z CJPUJDB &O "DPTUB  +3
&EJUPSDJFOUGJDP
#JPUJDBQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBE-B)BCBOB 1SJNFSB&EJDJO
1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP $FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB QQ
%FMHBEP  $+ 
 #JPUJDB  EFTJHVBMEBE Z QPMUJDB &O *JHVF[  - Z 1SF[  0&
0SHT
)FUFSPHFOFJEBETPDJBMFOMB$VCBBDUVBM-B)BCBOB $FOUSPEF&TUVEJPTEF
4BMVEZ#JFOFTUBS)VNBOPT 6OJWFSTJEBEEF-B)BCBOB QQ
%FMHBEP $+ 
)BDJBVOOVFWPTBCFS-BCJPUJDBFOMBSFWPMVDJODPOUFNQPSOFB
EFMTBCFS 1SFNJPi&MFOB(JMi
-B)BCBOB 1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP $FOUSP
'MJY7BSFMB
'SFZSF & 
-BCJPUJDBFOGPRVFJNQSFTDJOEJCMF&O-QF[#PNCJOP -3 %F
"SNBT "Z1PSUP .& 0SHT
1PSVOBOVFWBUJDB1SJNFSB&EJDJO-B)BCBOB 
&EJUPSJBM'MJY7BSFMB QQ
'VOH  5 
 -B CJPUJDB {VO OVFWP TBCFS  &O "DPTUB  +3 &EJUPS DJFOUGJDP

#JPUJDBQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBE1SJNFSB&EJDJO-B)BCBOB 1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP 
$FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB QQ
(PO[MF[ 3 
-BOVFWBEJNFOTJOEFMBSFMBDJONEJDPQBDJFOUFFOOVFTUSPTEBT
&O"DPTUB +3 &EJUPSDJFOUGJDP
#JPUJDB%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWBDVCBOB1SJNFSB
&EJDJO-B)BCBOB 1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP $FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB QQ
(PO[MF[ 6 (SBV +Z"NBSJMMP ." 
-BDBMJEBEEFWJEBDPNPVOQSPCMFNB
EFMBCJPUJDB&O"DPTUB +3 &EJUPSDJFOUGJDP
#JPUJDB%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWB
DVCBOB1SJNFSB&EJDJO-B)BCBOB 1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP $FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB 
QQ
-QF[ #PNCJOP  -3 
 UJDB  DJFODJB Z SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE &O -QF[ #PNCJOP 
-3 $PNQ
&MTBCFSUJDPEFBZFSBIPZ5PNP**1SJNFSB&EJDJO-B)BCBOB 
&EJUPSJBM'MJY7BSFMB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

.BSUOF[  " 


 1SPZFDUPT QBSB VOB CJPUJDB HMPCBM &O "DPTUB  +3 &EJUPS
DJFOUGJDP
 #JPUJDB QBSB MB TVTUFOUBCJMJEBE 1SJNFSB &EJDJO -B )BCBOB 
1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP $FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB QQ
/F[EF7JMMBWJDFODJP ' 
#JPUJDBFMNEJDPVOFEVDBEPS&O"DPTUB +3
&EJUPS DJFOUGJDP
 #JPUJDB %FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DVCBOB 1SJNFSB &EJDJO -B
)BCBOB 1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP $FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB QQ
1SF[  .  'MPSFT  +-  4JOHI  $ Z 1BSFEFT  ( 
 UJDB NEJDB Z CJPUJDB &O
7BSJPTBVUPSFT-FDUVSBTEFGJMPTPGB TBMVEZTPDJFEBE1SJNFSB&EJDJO-B)BCBOB 
&EJUPSJBMEF$JFODJBT.EJDBT QQ
1SJODJQJPTEFMBUJDB.EJDB 
-B)BCBOB &EJUPSB1PMUJDB
3BNSF[ "Z)FSSFSB 3 
1SPCMFNBTUJDPTFOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPMPHBZMB
NFEJDJOBDPOUFNQPSOFBT&O7BSJPTBVUPSFT1SPCMFNBTGJMPTGJDPTEFMBNFEJDJOB
$PMPRVJP 5PNP * -B )BCBOB  *OTUJUVUP 4VQFSJPS EF $JFODJBT .EJDBT EF -B
)BCBOB QQ
4PUPMPOHP  1- 
 -B CJPUJDB DPNP VOB EJTDJQMJOB DSUJDB &O "DPTUB  +3
&EJUPSDJFOUGJDP
#JPUJDBQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBE1SJNFSB&EJDJO-B)BCBOB 
1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP $FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB QQ
5PSSFT  3 
 (MPTBSJP EF CJPUJDB 1SJNFSB &EJDJO -B )BCBOB  1VCMJDBDJPOFT
"DVBSJP$FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB
77 "" 
 UJDB Z TPDJFEBE 5BCMPJEF EFM DVSTP i6OJWFSTJEBE QBSB 5PEPTw -B
)BCBOB &EJUBEPQPS+VWFOUVE3FCFMEF
7PO 4NJUI  7 
 -B UJDB DMOJDB &O "DPTUB  +3 &EJUPS DJFOUGJDP
#JPUJDB
%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWBDVCBOB1SJNFSB&EJDJO-B)BCBOB 1VCMJDBDJPOFT"DVBSJP 
$FOUSP'MJY7BSFMB QQ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





%JOBNJTNPEFMEJMPHPCJPUJDPFO&TQBB
'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT

*OUSPEVDDJO

&

YQPOFNPTFMOBDJNJFOUPZEFTBSSPMMP
EFMBCJPUJDBFO&TQBBEJTUJOHVJFO
EP USFT QFSPEPT VOP RVF TF FYUJFOEF
EFTEF  BP FO RVF GVOEBNPT FM
*OTUJUVUP#PSKBEF#JPUJDB FO4BOU$V
HBUEFM7BMMT #BSDFMPOB
FMQSJNFSPFO
&VSPQB
IBTUB DVBOEPDPODMVZFFM
UFSDFSFODVFOUSPEFM(SVQP*OUFSOBDJP
OBMEF&TUVEJPTEF#JPUJDBEFMB'FEF
SBDJO *OUFSOBDJPOBM EF 6OJWFSTJEBEFT
$BUMJDBT '*6$ *'$6
 PSHBOJ[BEP
UBNCJOFO4BOU$VHBU DPOBNQMJBSF
QFSDVTJO FO EJGFSFOUFT VOJWFSTJEBEFT
FTQBPMBT
&M TFHVOEP BCBSDB EFTEF  IBTUB
mOFTEF4POBPTEFFYQBOTJO 
NBEVSBDJOZDPOTPMJEBDJOEFMBCJP
UJDBFO&TQBBZEFHSBOQSPGVTJOMF
HJTMBUJWB FO SFMBDJO DPO MPT QSPHSFTPT
NEJDPCJPMHJDPT Z TV VUJMJ[BDJO &T
UBNCJOFMNPNFOUPFORVFKVSJTUBTZ
mMTPGPTDPNJFO[BOBJOUFSFTBSTFQPSMPT
EFCBUFTCJPUJDPT"QBSUJSEF MBT
EJWFSTBTFTDVFMBTZPSJFOUBDJPOFTCJPUJ
DBTFO&TQBBDPNJFO[BOBEFmOJSTFZ
EJTUBODJBSTFDMBSBNFOUFFOTVTBDUJUVEFT
BOUF MB UJDB Z MB MFHJTMBDJO FOUSF VOB
UJDBEFDPOWJDDJPOFTZVOBUJDBMBJDB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&M UFSDFS QFSPEP TF FYUJFOEF EFTEF FM


IBTUBIPZ1PESBNPTEFOPNJOBS
MPEFSFWJTJO QSPZFDDJOFJOUFHSBDJO 
DPO QMBOUFBNJFOUPT NVZ QPMBSJ[BEPT
QPS MBT EJGFSFOUFT UFOEFODJBT QPMUJDBT 
GVFSUFNFOUF DPOEJDJPOBEP QPS MPT GBD
UPSFT DJFOUmDPUDOJDPT  FDPONJDPT Z
UJDPSFMJHJPTPT &O DPOKVOUP  VOB TJ
UVBDJO EF NBZPS DPNQMFKJEBE RVF MB
EFMQFSPEPBOUFSJPS DPOVOBFTQFSBO[B
JMJNJUBEB FO MPT QSPHSFTPT DJFOUmDPT Z
UFDOPMHJDPT

*OTUJUVUP#PSKBEF#JPUJDB
*##

4F GVOE FO  QPS JOJDJBUJWB EF TV


BDUVBMQSFTJEFOUF 'SBODFTD"CFM BMSF
HSFTP EF VOB FTUBEB EF DJODP BPT FO
&TUBEPT 6OJEPT %FTEF FTF NPNFOUP 
UVWPMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFBQPSUBSMPTDPOP
DJNJFOUPTZFYQFSJFODJBBERVJSJEPTDPO
FMUSBCBKPEFBMHPNTEFUSFTBPTFOTV
UFTJT EPDUPSBM TPCSF mTJPMPHB GFUPQMB
DFOUBSJB EJSJHJEBQPS"OES)FMMFHFST
 )FMMFHFST  " 
 $JFOUmDP FYDFQ
DJPOBM  QSPGFTPS EF 0CTUFUSJDJB Z (JOFDPMPHB
FO MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF (FPSHFUPXO  8BTIJOH
UPO%$ EPOEFGVOEBFO DPOFMBQPZP
EF MB 'VOEBDJO ,FOOFEZ  FM BDUVBM ,FOOFEZ
*OTUJUVUFPG&UIJDT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

"MMWJWJMBFYQFSJFODJBEFMOBDJNJFOUP
EFMPTEPTQSJNFSPTDFOUSPTEFCJPUJDB
EFMNVOEPFM,FOOFEZ*OTUJUVUF ,*
Z
FM )BTUJOHT $FOUFS 3FHSFT B &TQBB
DPO MB mSNF EFUFSNJOBDJO EF JOJDJBS
VO*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDBMPNTQBSFDJEP
QPTJCMF BM NPEFMP RVF IBCB DPOPDJEP
FO &TUBEPT 6OJEPT  DPO MBT BEBQUBDJP
OFTDPOWFOJFOUFTZHVJBEPQPSUSFTPCKF
UJWPTPQFSBUJWPT
DSFBSVOBCJCMJPUFDB
FTQFDJBMJ[BEB FO CJPUJDB 
 DPNFO[BS
BJOTUJUVJSFMEJMPHPCJPUJDPFOIPTQJ
UBMFT DSFBOEPDPNJUTEFCJPUJDB Z

DPOTFHVJS MB JOEFQFOEFODJB JOTUJUVDJP
OBMGSFOUFBJOTUJUVDJPOFTFDMFTJTUJDBTZ
DJWJMFT5PEPTFTUPTQSPQTJUPTIBOTJEP
MPHSBEPT HSBEVBMNFOUF %FTEF 
FM *## FTU JOUFHSBEP DPNP JOTUJUVUP
VOJWFSTJUBSJPFOMB6OJWFSTJEBE3BNO
-MVMMEF#BSDFMPOB
4J CJFO MPT JOJDJPT GVFSPO EJGDJMFT QPS
GBMUBEFNFEJPT UFOBNPTMBGVFSUFDPO
WJDDJO EF RVF FM NFOTBKF TPCSF MB GF
DVOEJEBE EFM EJMPHP CJPUJDP oFOUSF
MBT DJFODJBT EF MB TBMVE Z MB UJDBo FSB
OFDFTBSJPZVSHFOUF&TUPSFRVFSB BOUF
UPEP  JOUSPEVDJS FM USNJOP iCJPUJDBw
FOMBTPDJFEBEZFYQMJDBSFMDPODFQUPZ
SFRVJTJUPTEFFTFEJMPHP
&O &TQBB FM USNJOP iCJPUJDBw  RVF
FNQF[BNPTBVUJMJ[BSFO GVFBDFQ
UBEPGDJMNFOUFQPSEJGFSFOUFTSB[POFT

 QPSRVF TF EJTUBODJBCB EF MB QFSDFQ
 %BOJFM $BMMBIBO  mMTPGP  EPDUPSBEP FO )BS
WBSE Z8JMMJBSE(BZMJO QSPGFTPSEF1TJRVJBUSB
FOMB'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF
$PMVNCJB /VFWB:PSL
EFDJEJFSPODPNFO[BS
FOFM*OTUJUVUFPG4PDJFUZ &UIJDTBOEUIF-JGF
4DJFODF  NT DPOPDJEP DPNP )BTUJOHT $FOUFS

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DJO EF VOB UJDB SFMJHJPTB  OFHBUJWB 


BVUPSJUBSJBZEPHNUJDB NVZDPOEJDJP
OBEBQPSMBFTUSFDIBWJODVMBDJOFOUSFMB
KFSBSRVBEFMB*HMFTJB$BUMJDBZFM&TUB
EP
QPSFMDMJNBTPDJPQPMUJDPEFVOB
&TQBB FO USBOTJDJO EFTEF MB NVFSUF
EF'SBODJTDP'SBODP FO IBTUBMB
BQSPCBDJOFOMBT$PSUFTFTQBPMBTEFMB
$POTUJUVDJOEF DPOMBRVFTFJOJ
DJBMBEFNPDSBDJBZTVBQSFOEJ[BKF Z

FMDMJNBJOUFMFDUVBMRVFTFSFTQJSBCBFO
MBTVOJWFSTJEBEFT FODPODSFUP FOMPRVF
DPODJFSOFBMB$PNQBBEF+FTT NVZ
QSFQBSBEB QBSB FM EJMPHP JOUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBS Z DPO VOB HSBO DPODFOUSBDJO EF
QSPGFTPSFTVOJWFSTJUBSJPTKFTVJUBT GPSNB
EPTFOVOJWFSTJEBEFT JOHMFTBT GSBODFTBT 
CFMHBT BMFNBOBT JUBMJBOBTZBNFSJDBOBT
&M*##TFDSFBDBTJTJNVMUOFBNFOUFDPO
PUSBTEPTJOTUJUVDJPOFT JOJDJBEBTQPSKF
TVJUBTKVOUPDPOVOFOUPSOPEFQSPGFTP
SFTVOJWFSTJUBSJPT$SJTUJBOJTNPZ+VTUJ
DJB $+
Z"TPDJBDJO*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBS
+PTEF"DPTUB "4*/+"

 'VOEBEPZSFDPOPDJEPBMNJTNPUJFNQPRVFFM
*##&M1*HOBDJP4BMWBUNFEJFOMBBQSPCB
DJOEFBNCPTFTUBUVUPT$+QVCMJDBNFO
TVBMNFOUFVODVBEFSOPTPCSFUFNBTQPMNJDPT
EFBDUVBMJEBE)BTUBFMNPNFOUPTFIBOQVCMJ
DBEPUUVMPT
 -B "TPDJBDJO *OUFSEJTDJQMJOBS +PT EF "DPT
UBGVFGVOEBEBZEJSJHJEBFOQPS"MCFSU
%PV  DPOUJOVBOEP FM USBCBKP RVF SFBMJ[BCB
EFTEFMB$PNJTJOEF1SPGFTPSFT6OJWFS
TJUBSJPT $013*
 DPOTUJUVJEB FO TVT PSHFOFT
QSJODJQBMNFOUFQPSKFTVJUBT)BTUBFMNPNFOUP
TFIBOFEJUBEPWPMNFOFTQPSWBSJPTBVUPSFT
FTQFDJBMJTUBTFOMBTSFTQFDUJWBTNBUFSJBT-PTM
UJNPTUUVMPTTPOi&MQFOTBNJFOUPBMUFSOBUJWP
/VFWB WJTJO TPCSF FM IPNCSF Z MB OBUVSBMF
[Bw 
 i/VFWBT UFDOPMPHBT Z GVUVSP EFM
IPNCSFw 
 i#JPUJDB MB DVFTUJO EF MB
EJHOJEBEw 
i*OWFTUJHBDJO EFTBSSPMMPF
JOOPWBDJODVFTUJPOFTUJDBTw 
i*EFPMP
HBTDPOnJDUPTZUFOTJPOFTw 






%JOBNJTNPEFMEJMPHPCJPUJDPFO&TQBB'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT

-BEFmOJDJOEFCJPUJDBRVFFM*OTUJUVUP
BEPQUGVFMBRVFDPOTUBFOMB&ODJDMP
QFEJBEF#JPUJDBi&TUVEJPTJTUFNUJDP
EFMBDPOEVDUBIVNBOBFOFMNCJUPEF
MBT DJFODJBT EF MB WJEB Z EF MB BUFODJO
BMBTBMVE FYBNJOBOEPFTUBDPOEVDUBB
MBMV[EFMPTWBMPSFTZEFMPTQSJODJQJPT
NPSBMFTw 3FJDI  
 4JO FNCBSHP 
FO TV EB QFOTCBNPT RVF QPEBNPT
FOSJRVFDFS FTUB EFmOJDJO  TFBMBOEP
RVFFMEJMPHPEFCFQSPEVDJSTFFOUSFMBT
DJFODJBTZMBTIVNBOJEBEFTi-BCJPUJDB
FTFMFTUVEJPJOUFSEJTDJQMJOBS USBOTEJTDJ
QMJOBS
PSJFOUBEPBMBUPNBEFEFDJTJPOFT
UJDBTEFMPTQSPCMFNBTQMBOUFBEPTBMPT
EJGFSFOUFT TJTUFNBT UJDPT  QPS MPT QSP
HSFTPT NEJDPT Z CJPMHJDPT  FO FM N
CJUPNJDSPTPDJBMZNBDSPTPDJBM NJDSPZ
NBDSPFDPONJDP ZTVSFQFSDVTJOFOMB
TPDJFEBEZTVTJTUFNBEFWBMPSFT UBOUP
FOFMNPNFOUPQSFTFOUFDPNPFOFMGV
UVSPw "CFM 

&TUB EFmOJDJO UJFOF MB WFOUBKB EF FO
USPODBSDPOMBJEFBEFMPTQSJNFSPTJOT
UJUVUPTZDPOMPTQSPCMFNBTEFMRVFIBDFS
CJPUJDPRVF EFTEF EJTPDJBMBCJP
UJDBDMOJDBEFMBHMPCBM QPSJOJDJBUJWB
EF7BO3FOTTFMBFS1PUUFS 

&OFTFBP1PUUFS NVZNPMFTUPQPSMB
PSJFOUBDJO DMOJDB EF MB CJPUJDB EFTB
SSPMMBEB FO FM ,*  BDV FM USNJOP EF
iCJPUJDBHMPCBMwQBSBTVCSBZBSTVJOUF
STFOFMFOGPRVFFDPMHJDP
&O QBMBCSBT EFM mMTPGP )BOT +POBT TF
USBUB EF TVQFSBS MB EJNFOTJO EF VOB
UJDB EF DFSDBOBT QBSB BCSJSOPT B IP
SJ[POUFT EFM GVUVSP EF MB IVNBOJEBE Z
EF OVFTUSP QMBOFUB  UFOJFOEP FO DVFO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UB FM QSPHSFTP EF MB CJPMPHB NPMFDVMBS


Z MB DPNQSFOTJO EF MB QSPHSBNBDJO
HFOUJDB
&O   FM EPDUPS "CFM  EJSFDUPS EFM
*OTUJUVUP  DPNFO[ B DPMBCPSBS FO MB
FTUSVDUVSBDJO EFM $PNJU EF UJDB
"TJTUFODJBM $&"
 EFM )PTQJUBM 4BOU
+PBOEF%V EF&TQMVHVFT #BSDFMPOB 
DPOUJOVBOEPFMQSPZFDUPEFVODPNJU
RVFDPNFO[TVUSBCBKPEPTBPTBOUFT

&M$&"oQSJNFSPFO&TQBBZ
OJDPEVSBOUFNVDIPTBPT BQFTBSEF
TVBOPOJNBUPoGVFFMGPSPFOFMDVBMTF
SFBMJ[QPSQSJNFSBWF[FMEJMPHPCJP
UJDPUBMDPNP)FMMFHFSTMPQFOTQBSBFM
NCJUPDMOJDP
'VF UBNCJO FO  DVBOEP FM *##
JOJDJ TV QSFTFODJB JOUFSOBDJPOBM QBSUJ
DJQBOEP FO VO EFCBUF TPCSF CJPMPHB Z
UJDB #JPMPHZBOE&UIJDT
BDFQUBOEPMB
JOWJUBDJOEFTVTPSHBOJ[BEPSFT'POEB
UJPO *OUFSOBUJPOBMF )VNBOVN  EF -V
HBOP 4VJ[B
 Z 'POEBUJPO 1SPTQFDUJWF 
EF #SVTFMBT &M EFCBUF DFMFCSBEP FOUSF
FM  Z  EF TFQUJFNCSF DPOHSFH B VO
SFTUSJOHJEP HSVQP EF  QBSUJDJQBOUFT 
DJFOUmDPT  NPSBMJTUBT Z SFQSFTFOUBOUFT
EFMBKFSBSRVBEFMB*HMFTJB$BUMJDB&O
USFMPTJOWJUBEPTFTUBCBOCVFOPTBNJHPT
EFM,* DPOFMEPDUPS)FMMFHFSTBMGSFOUF
&M EFCBUF QVTP EF NBOJmFTUP MB EJGDJM
DPODJMJBDJO EF MBT QPTJDJPOFT GSFOUF B
MPT QSPCMFNBT USBUBEPT MB DPOUSBDFQ
DJO IPSNPOBM  QSPDSFBDJO BTJTUJEB
oEPT BPT BOUFT EF RVF OBDJFSB -FTMFZ
#SPXO HSBDJBTBMBGFDVOEBDJOJOWJUSP
Z USBOTGFSFODJB FNCSJPOBSJBo  FTUBUVUP
EFM FNCSJO IVNBOP Z DVFTUJPOFT EF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

NPSBMGVOEBNFOUBM&MEJMPHPBMDBO[
UBNCJOOJWFMFTQPMNJDPTDVBOEP QBSB
TPSQSFTB EF MPT DJFOUmDPT Z NPSBMJTUBT
FVSPQFPT SFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFMFQJTDPQBEP
OPSUFBNFSJDBOP OP BDFQUBSPO MPT DPO
DFQUPT EF TFDVMBSJ[BDJO EF MB TPDJFEBE
OJ EF UJDB MBJDB  JOUFSQSFUBOEP RVF TF
QSPQVHOBCBMBMBJDJEBEEFMBTPDJFEBEZ
MBOFHBDJOEF%JPT

4F WJP MB OFDFTJEBE EF QSPGVOEJ[BS FO


EJMPHP JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBS MPT DPODFQUPT
RVF VUJMJ[BEPTQPSDJFOUmDPT mMTPGPT
PUFMPHPT UJFOFODPOOPUBDJPOFTEJWFS
TBT 4F UPN DPODJFODJB EFM USBTGPOEP
DJFOUmDP P mMPTmDP TPCSF FM RVF TF
BQPZBO QFSDFQDJPOFT EF TJHOJmDBEP EF
QBMBCSBT GVOEBNFOUBMFT DPNP iWJEBw 
iEJHOJEBEw iQFSTPOBw

&OFMNCJUPNTBNQMJPEFDPMBCPSB
DJOJOUFSOBDJPOBM FM1"SSVQF 

HFOFSBMEFMB$PNQBBEF+FTT 
BOJNEFTEFTVTJOJDJPTFMEJMPHPCJP
UJDP Z MB DSFBDJO EFM (SVQP *OUFSOB
DJPOBMEF&TUVEJPTEF#JPUJDB (*&#
*&(#
DPOVOFTUBUVUPJOEFQFOEJFOUF
FOFMTFOPEFMB'FEFSBDJO*OUFSOBDJP
OBM EF 6OJWFSTJEBEFT $BUMJDBT 'SBO
DFTD "CFM UVWP VO QBQFM DSVDJBM FO TV
PSJHFOFOZGVFDPPSEJOBEPSDPO
FM1&EPVBSE#PO4+ZDPO+PIO$
)BSWFZEFMPTFODVFOUSPTJOUFSOBDJP
OBMFTDFMFCSBEPTBMPMBSHPEFTVFYJTUFO
DJB  QSFTJEJFOEP TV 4UFFSJOH $PNNJUFF
"CFM 


6O OVUSJEP HSVQP EF KFTVJUBT DJFOUm


DPT  RVF PDVQBCBO DUFESBT FO VOJWFS
TJEBEFTQCMJDBTPQSJWBEBTZDPOUUVMPT
VOJWFSTJUBSJPT FO IVNBOJEBEFT mMPTP
GB  UFPMPHB  BOUSPQPMPHB
 QVEJFSPO
FYQFSJNFOUBSMBTQPTJCJMJEBEFTRVFPGSF
DBFMEJMPHPCJPUJDP BMDPOGSPOUBSTVT
QPTJDJPOFTDPOPUSPTKFTVJUBT QSPGFTPSFT
EF mMPTPGB Z EF UFPMPHB  Z QSPGFTPSFT
TFHMBSFTEFMDBNQPEFMBTDJFODJBT-BEJ
NFOTJO EF DPPQFSBDJO JOUFSOBDJPOBM
FOFMEJMPHPFOUSF*HMFTJBZNVOEPZMB
FTUSFDIBDPMBCPSBDJOFOUSFKFTVJUBTZTF
HMBSFTOPOFDFTJUTFSTVCSBZBEB

4BOU $VHBU GVF FM MVHBS FMFHJEP QBSB


DFMFCSBSMBTUSFTQSJNFSBTSFVOJPOFTEFM
(*&#  FOUSF  Z  -BT EJTDV
TJPOFT EF FTUPT USFT FODVFOUSPT HJSBSPO
BMSFEFEPSEFMPTTJHVJFOUFTUFNBT
t

t
t

*OHFOJFSB HFOUJDB FYQFDUBUJWBT Z


SJFTHPTQBSBFMIPNCSFZFMNFEJP
BNCJFOUF 1PMUJDB EF EJSFDDJO Z
DPOUSPMEFMBTJOWFTUJHBDJPOFT
*OJDJPEFMBWJEBIVNBOBZTVNB
OJQVMBDJO
$PODFQUP EF OBUVSBMF[B Z SFWPMV
DJOFQJTUFNPMHJDB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

4JSFQBTBNPTBMHVOPEFMPTOPNCSFTEF
RVJFOFTQBSUJDJQBSPOFOMPTEPTQSJNF
SPTFODVFOUSPTEFM(*&# WFSFNPTRVF
DPOUJOVBSPO Z QPUFODJBSPO DSFBUJWB
NFOUF MB EJONJDB FYQFSJNFOUBEB FO
FM EJMPHP CJPUJDP &OUSF MPT UFMPHPT
FTQBPMFT RVF DSFBSPO FTDVFMB .BOVFM
$VZT +BWJFS(BGP
+VBO.BTJ 4P
QIJB6OJWFSTJEBEEF5PLZP
Z&EVBSEP
-QF[ "[QJUBSUF &OUSF MPT DJFOUmDPT
$BSMPT "MPOTP #FEBUF  .BOVFM (BSDB
%PODFM  3BNO .BSB /PHVT  +VBO
3BNO -BDBEFOB  *HOBDJP /F[ EF
$BTUSP +VMJO3VCJP$BSEJFM
+BDPCP
$SEFOBT
Z+PTFQ&HP[DVF
&OUSF





%JOBNJTNPEFMEJMPHPCJPUJDPFO&TQBB'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT

MPT mMTPGPT "SUVSP +VODPTB  "VHVTUP


)PSUBMZ&VTFCJP$PMPNFS%FTUBDBNPT
B QBSUJDJQBOUFT FYUSBOKFSPT DPNP ,MBVT
%FNNFS  &EPVBSE #PO  -VJT"SDIFS
PNBT + ,JOH Z "OHFMP 4FSSB &OUSF
MPTNEJDPTNFSFDFOVOBNFODJOFTQF
DJBM+PIO$)BSWFZ 7DUPS$POJMM

+PSEJ'POU +PTFQ.BSB%FYFVT 9BWJFS
*HMFTJBT "OUPOJP5FKFEP -VT$BNQPT 
+PBRVO1MB[B 1FSF/#BSSJZ+PTFQ.
$BSSFSB
"DUJWBNFOUFQSFTFOUFFOFTUPTFODVFO
USPT EFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFFOGFSNFSB
Z QBTUPSBM TBOJUBSJB  FTUVWP UBNCJO FM
)OP (BCJOP (PSPTUJFUB  EF MB 0SEFO
)PTQJUBMBSJBEF4BO+VBOEF%JPT RVJFO
GBWPSFDJBMNYJNPMBQVFTUBFONBS
DIBEFM$PNJUEFUJDB"TJTUFODJBMFO
#BSDFMPOB
&M*##GVFUBNCJONJFNCSPGVOEBEPS
EF MB "TPDJBDJO &VSPQFB EF $FOUSPT
EF UJDB .EJDB &"$.&"&$&.

DVZBT CBTFT TF EJTFBSPO FOUSF  Z
-BJOJDJBUJWBEFMBDSFBDJOEFMB
&"$.&TFEFCJBMBHFTUJOEF.BV
SJDF %F 8BDIUFS  RVJFO IBCB USBCBKB
EPEFTEFBFOFM$FOUFSGPS
#JPFUIJDTJOUIF$MJOJDBM3FTFBSDI*OTUJUV
UF PG .POUSFBM  DSFBEP BM NJTNP UJFN
QP RVF FM *## QPS FM %S %BWJE 3PZ 
 -PTOPNCSFTEFMPTBTJTUFOUFTTPMBNFOUFRVF
EBSPOSFDPHJEBTFOMBT"DUBTRVFOPTFIBOQV
CMJDBEP1BSBNTJOGPSNBDJO WBTF"OVBSJP
EFMB$PNQBBEF+FTT&EJDJOFOFTQBPM
+FTVJUBT  QQ
 -BDSFBDJOEF$PNJUTEFUJDB"TJTUFODJBMIB
SFDJCJEPTJFNQSFFMmSNFBQPZPEFMB0SEFOZ
FTQFDJBMNFOUFEFMBDUVBM)OP(FOFSBM1BTDVBM
1JMFT&O#BSDFMPOBDPOUBEFNTDPOMBDPMB
CPSBDJOEFMPTIFSNBOPT'SBODJTDP4PMB +PT
-VJT3FESBEP .JHVFM.BSUO FOUSFPUSPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

WJODVMBEP DPNP QVOUP EF SFGFSFODJB


UJDBBMPTWFJOUJTJTMBCPSBUPSJPTEFJO
WFTUJHBDJOEFFTUFDFOUSPFO.POUSFBM
"CFM 
&O %F8BDIUFS
GVF OPNCSBEP %JSFDUPS EFM .BBTUSJDIU
*OTUJUVUF GPS #JPFUIJDT -PT USFT DFOUSPT
DPNFO[BNPT B JOUFSDBNCJBS PQJOJPOFT
TPCSFDNPQPUFODJBSFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMB
CJPUJDBFO&VSPQB&OFMDVSTPEFEJ
WFSTBTSFVOJPOFT TFJOWJUBPUSPTDFO
USPT RVF QPEBO FTUBS JOUFSFTBEPT FO MB
JEFB Z FM  EF TFQUJFNCSF EF  TF
DFMFCSMBBTBNCMFBDPOTUJUVZFOUFEFMB
"TPDJBDJORVFIPZDVFOUBDPONTEF
DFOUSPT %F8BDIUFS 

3FTVMUBFWJEFOUFRVFMBTSFnFYJPOFTTVS
HJEBT FOUSF  Z  UJFOFO DPNP
NBSDP EF SFGFSFODJB MBT SFTQVFTUBT UJ
DBT BOUF MPT EJTUJOUPT EFTDVCSJNJFOUPT
DJFOUmDPT P UDOJDBT JOOPWBEPSBT EF
JOEVEBCMFJNQPSUBODJBTPDJBMVOJEBEFT
EF DVJEBEPT JOUFOTJWPT 
 DPOUSB
DFQDJO IPSNPOBM 
 USBTQMBOUF
SFOBM 
 Z DBSEBDP 
 EJBH
OTUJDPQSFOBUBMDBSJPUJQPT 
FDP
HSBGB 
$POUPEP FMDBNCJPNT
QSPGVOEPEFMBNFEJDJOBDPOTJTUFFOFM
SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EF MPT EFSFDIPT EF MPT
QBDJFOUFT DPNP BHFOUFT NPSBMFT BVU
OPNPT  RVF PSJFOUB MB USBOTJDJO EF MB
NFEJDJOBEFDPSUFQBUFSOBMJTUBBVOBEF
NPEFMPDPOUSBDUVBM

4FHVOEPQFSPEPEFMBCJPUJDB
FO&TQBB
&TUF QFSPEP  RVF EF NPNFOUP TJUVB
NPTFOUSFZFMmOEFMTJHMP99 OPT
DPMPDBFOFMPKPEFVOIVSBDOoTJBE
NJUJNPTMBNFUGPSBoRVFMMFHBBUPEPT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

MPTDPOmOFTEFMB5JFSSB4FUSBUBEFVO
QFRVFP HSBO EFTDVCSJNJFOUP UDOJDP
DVZP TNCPMP EF BQMJDBDJO QSDUJDB
DPOPDFOIPZUPEPTMPTOJPTRVFWBOB
MBFTDVFMBFOMPTDJODPDPOUJOFOUFT&O
FGFDUP FOTFJOWFOUBFTUFTNCPMP
QSDUJDP!
&M QSPGFTPS -BDBEFOB OPT PGSFDF VOB
JOUFSFTBOUF SFMBDJO TPCSF MPT QSFNJPT
/PCFM FO HFOUJDB FO TV PCSB i)JTUP
SJB/PCFMBEBEFMB(FOUJDB$PODFQUP
Z NUPEPw -BDBEFOB  +3  
 4F
QFSGFDDJPOB FM EJBHOTUJDP QSFOBUBM EF
NBMGPSNBDJPOFT GFUBMFT IBZ QSPHSFTPT
FO JONVOPMPHB Z UDOJDBT RVJSSHJDBT
RVFIBDFOQPTJCMFNFKPSBSOPUBCMFNFO
UFMPTSFTVMUBEPTEFUSBTQMBOUFTEFSHB
OPTZUFKJEPTTFEFmOFMBNVFSUFDFSF
CSBM Z TF EFTDSJCF FM FTUBEP WFHFUBUJWP
QFSTJTUFOUF0DVSSFFMQSJNFSYJUPEFMB
GFDVOEBDJOJOWJUSPZEFMBUSBOTGFSFO
DJBFNCSJPOBSJB '*75&
FO&O
TFQVCMJDBFM*OGPSNF#FMNPOU FO
FM RVF TF GPSNVMBO MPT USFT QSJODJQJPT
CTJDPTCJPUJDPT EFHSBOJOnVFODJBFO
UPEPFMNVOEPPDDJEFOUBMSFTQFUPBMBT
QFSTPOBT CFOFmDFODJBZKVTUJDJB
5SFTIFDIPTDPOEJDJPOBORVFIBZBNPT
TFMFDDJPOBEP FM QFSPEP 
QBSBFONBSDBSFTUFTFHVOEPQFSPEP

FMEJMPHPCJPUJDPTFFYQBOEFZTFIBDF
NTDPNQMFKP
HSBOEFTmHVSBTEFMB
CJPUJDB FO &TQBB FOUSBO FO DPOUBDUP
EF NBOFSB DPNQSPNFUJEB  WBMJFOUF Z
SFTQPOTBCMF  EFTEF MB mMPTPGB  FM EFSF
 
F#FMNPOU3FQPSU&UIJDBM1SJODJQMFTBOE
(VJEFMJOFTGPSUIF1SPUFDUJPOPG)VNBO4VCKFDUT
PG3FTFBSDI64(PWFSONFOU1SJOUJOH0DF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DIP  MB FDPOPNB Z MB QPMUJDB  Z 


 TF
BDFOUBONTMBTEJGFSFODJBTFOMBNB
OFSB EF FOGPDBS MBT USFT SBDJPOBMJEBEFT
oUDOJDPDJFOUmDB  KVSEJDPQPMUJDB Z
UJDBSFMJHJPTBoFOMBCTRVFEBEFMQSP
HSFTPIVNBOP
&TUPQFSNJUFEJTUJOHVJS FO&TQBB USFT
FOGPRVFTUFSJDPQSDUJDPTDPNQMFNFO
UBSJPTEFMRVFIBDFSCJPUJDPZTVGVOEB
NFOUBDJOEFTEFMBUJDB EFTEFMB5FP
MPHBZEFTEFFM%FSFDIP #BSSFBV ) 


$BSBDUFSJ[B B FTUF QFSPEP MB CTRVFEB
EFMPNTFTQFDmDBNFOUFIVNBOPFOMB
BQMJDBDJOEFMPTOVFWPTDPOPDJNJFOUPT
ZUFDOPMPHBTCJPNEJDBT MPRVFTFFY
QSFTBDPONTQSFDJTJODPOFMDPODFQUP
iDBMJEBEEFWJEBwDPNPDPODFQUPCTJDP
EF UPEB JOWFTUJHBDJO NEJDB Z EJTDV
TJOCJPUJDB
$FSSBNPTFTUFQFSPEPDPOMBmSNBEFM
$POWFOJP &VSPQFP EF #JPNFEJDJOB Z
%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT mSNBEPFO0WJF
EP &TQBB
&M1BSMBNFOUPFTQBPMMP
SBUJmDFMEFPDUVCSFEFZFOUS
FOWJHPSFOFTUFQBTFMEFFOFSPEF
 DFSSOEPTFVODJDMPFOFMDVBMMB
CJPUJDBIBQBTBEPEFFWPMVDJPOBS QBSB
CJFOZQBSBNBM IBDJBFMCJPEFSFDIP
*OUFOUBS FODVBESBS MBT EJGFSFOUFT DP
SSJFOUFT CJPUJDBT FO MPT TJHVJFOUFT FQ
HSBGFT 
 CJPUJDB EFTEF VOB GVOEB
NFOUBDJOUJDB
CJPUJDBEFTEFVOB
GVOEBNFOUBDJO UFPMHJDB 
 CJPUJDB
EFTEF VOB GVOEBNFOUBDJO KVSEJDB  Z
 #0& ON NJSDPMFTPDUVCSF





%JOBNJTNPEFMEJMPHPCJPUJDPFO&TQBB'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT


CJPUJDBEFTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJWBUFTUJ
NPOJBMZOBSSBUJWB

#JPUJDBEFTEFVOB
GVOEBNFOUBDJOUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE3BNO-MVMM #BSDFMPOB 
*OTUJUVUP#PSKBEF#JPUJDB *##

&OUSFZ FM*OTUJUVUPIBEBEP
DPOUJOVJEBEZEFTBSSPMMPBTVUSBCBKPFT
QFDJBMNFOUFFODVBUSPNCJUPT
B
 %PDFODJBZGPSNBDJOFOCJPUJDB
C
 *OWFTUJHBDJO FO CJPUJDB &M *##
IB QBSUJDJQBEP FO WBSJPT QSPZFDUPT
EFMB6OJO&VSPQFBFOUSFMPTRVF
EFTUBDBNPT 1SPZFDUP #JPNFE ** 
TPCSF )VNBO FNCSZPOJD BOE 'FUBM
5JTTVF USBTQMBOUBUJPO  DPPSEJOBEP
QPS(VJEPEF8FSUZ3PO#FSHI
NBOT   .FEJDJOF  )FBMUIDBSF
BOE1IZMPTPQIZZ#BTJD&UIJDBM1SJO
DJQMFTJO&VSPQFBO#JPFUIJDTBOE#JP
MBX  DPPSEJOBEP QPS 1FUFS ,FNQ
EF$PQFOIBHFOZDPFEJUBEPQPSFM
*##ZFM$FOUSFGPS&UIJDTBOE-BX
EF $PQFOIBHFO 3FOEUPS  ,FNQ
&ET



"EFNT EF MPT QSPZFDUPT DPMFDUJ
WPT FM*##IBEFTBSSPMMBEPUSBCBKPT
QSPQJPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJOZSFnFYJO
TPCSFEJTUJOUBTUFNUJDBTCJPUJDBT 
DPOUBOEPBDUVBMNFOUFDPONTEF
 UUVMPT "TJNJTNP  EFTEF 
DVFOUBDPOMBSFWJTUBUSJNFTUSBM#JP
UJDB  %FCBU  RVF SFDPHF UFNBT
CJPUJDPT BDUVBMFT FO VO MFOHVBKF
DMBSPZEJEDUJDP
 1BSB NBZPS JOGPSNBDJO  WJTJUBS MPT TJUJPT
XXXJCCJPUJDBPSH XXXDBNQVTJCCJPUJDB
PSHXXXCJPUJDBEFCBUPSH

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

D
 "TFTPSBNJFOUP 1BSUJDJQB Z GPSNB
QBSUF EF DPNJUT EF UJDB BTJTUFO
DJBM oNVDIPT EF FMMPT JNQVMTBEPT
EFTEF TVT JOJDJPT QPS FM *##o  BT
DPNP EF $PNJUT UJDPT EF *O
WFTUJHBDJO $MOJDB FO EJTUJOUPT
DFOUSPT F JOTUJUVDJPOFT TBOJUBSJBT 
QSPNPWJFOEPMBEJTDVTJOEFDBTPT
DMOJDPT 5BNCJO QBSUJDJQB FO FM
$PNJU EF #JPUJDB EFM (PCJFSOP
"VUOPNP EF $BUBMVB &TQBB

EFTEF TVT PSHFOFT FO   Z FO
EJGFSFOUFT DPNJTJPOFT Z HSVQPT EF
USBCBKPQBSBBTFTPSBSBMHPCJFSOPFO
DVFTUJPOFT CJPUJDBT RVF MVFHP QB
TBSOBTFSNBUFSJBMFHJTMBUJWB
E
 $FOUSPEFEPDVNFOUBDJOZCJCMJP
UFDB&MNBOFKPZHFTUJOEFUPEB
FTUB UBSFB SFRVJFSF EF VOB EFEJDB
DJOQMFOB ZGVFMMFWBEPBDBCPQPS
'SBODFTD "CFM EFTEF TVT JOJDJPT Z
IBTUB&OFTFBPTFQSPEVDF
TV SFMFWP DPNP EJSFDUPS  QBTBOEP
BTFSQSFTJEFOUFEFMB'VOEBDJOZ
NJFNCSP JOWFTUJHBEPS Z EPDFOUF
"TVNF FOUPODFT MB EJSFDDJO MB MJ
DFODJBEBFO%FSFDIPZBCPHBEBFO
FKFSDJDJP /VSJB 5FSSJCBT &MMB DP
NFO[BJOUFSFTBSTFQPSMBCJPUJDB
FO DVBOEPFOUSFODPOUBDUP
DPOFM*##&OMBBDUVBMJEBE 5FSSJ
CBTSFQSFTFOUBBM*OTUJUVUPFODVFT
UJPOFTCJPUJDBTDPOSFQFSDVTJOKV
SEJDB DPNPFMSFDJFOUFEPDVNFOUP
TPCSFMBFVUBOBTJBFMBCPSBEPQPSFM
*## Z PUSP USBCBKP TPCSF FM UFNB
FMBCPSBEP EFTEF FM (PCJFSOP EF
$BUBMVB
 $GIUUQXXXVEEDMQSPOUVT@VEETJUFFEJD
CBTFQPSUCJCMJPUFDBIUNM





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

%FOUSP EFM 1BUSPOBUP EFM *##  DBCF


IBDFS FTQFDJBM SFGFSFODJB B +VBO 7JBT 
NEJDP DJSVKBOP  FM QSJNFSP FO JN
QMFNFOUBS VOBT +PSOBEBT EF #JPUJDB
FODPMBCPSBDJODPOFM*## MBTRVFTF
IBONBOUFOJEPMPTMUJNPTWFJOUFBPT
%FTEFTVUBSFBDPNPEFDBOPEFMB'B
DVMUBE EF .FEJDJOB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
EF -SJEB  MPHS RVF TF JOUSPEVKFSB FO
FM DVSSDVMP EF NFEJDJOB MB BTJHOBUVSB
EFCJPUJDB&OMBBDUVBMJEBEFT3FDUPS
.BHOmDPEFEJDIBVOJWFSTJEBEZIBIF
DIPTVJOHSFTPDPNP"DBENJDP/VNF
SBSJPEFMB3FBM"DBEFNJBEF.FEJDJOB
EF$BUBMVB
6OJWFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTF .BESJE
-BQSFTFODJBEFMBCJPUJDBFOMB6OJWFS
TJEBE$PNQMVUFOTFEF.BESJETFEFCF
TJOMVHBSBEVEBTB%JFHP(SBDJB(VJ
MMO&TEJGDJMSFTVNJSFOQPDBTMOFBTTV
USBCBKPDSFBUJWPDPNPNEJDPZmMTPGP
4FJOUFHSBFOFMNCJUPEFMBCJPUJDBFO
 DVBOEPWJTJUBEJWFSTBTVOJWFSTJEB
EFTEF&TUBEPT6OJEPT JOUFOUBOEPFO
DPOUSBSGVOEBNFOUBDJOZNFUPEPMPHB
BMBTEFDJTJPOFTUJDBTFOMBDMOJDB%F
FTUBFYQFSJFODJBSFTVMUBOEPTUFYUPTGVO
EBNFOUBMFT i'VOEBNFOUPT EF MB CJP
UJDBw (SBDJB 
Zi1SPDFEJNJFOUPT
EF EFDJTJO FO UJDB DMOJDBw (SBDJB 

+VOUPBTVTDMBTFTEFTUBDBTVDB
QBDJEBE EF TOUFTJT  DPNP MP NVFTUSBO
BMHVOPT EF MPT NT SFDJFOUFT BSUDVMPT
DVZBMFDUVSBSFDPNFOEBNPTWJWBNFOUF
i%FMBCJPUJDBDMOJDBBMBCJPUJDBHMP
CBMUSFJOUBBPTEFFWPMVDJOw (SBDJB 

Zi$POUSJCVDJOEFMBTIVNBOJ
EBEFTNEJDBTBMBGPSNBDJOEFMNEJ
DPw (SBDJB 


PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&OMBDUFESBEFCJPUJDBEF%JFHP(SB
DJBTFIBOGPSNBEPNVDIPTFTQFDJBMJTUBT 
UBOUPNEJDPTDPNPmMTPGPT&OUSFMPT
QSJNFSPT NFODJPOBNPT B 1JMBS /F[
$VCFSP  RVF DPMBCPS DPO FM *## EV
SBOUF PODF BPT  +PT 4BSBCJB  *TPMJOB
3JBP  "[VDFOB $SVDFJSP  .BOVFM EF
MPT3FZFT +VBO$BSMPT"MWBSF[Z1BCMP
)FSOBOEP &OUSF MPT mMTPGPT  -JEJB
'FJUP +PT3BNO"NPS1BO +PT(BS
DB'SF[Z'BCJP"MCFSUP(BS[O
.FODJO FTQFDJBM NFSFDF +VBO 3BNO
-BDBEFOB RVJFO  TJFOEP ZB NBFTUSP FO
CJPUJDB oEFTEF TV QFSTQFDUJWB DPNP
CJMPHPZSFGFSFOUFQBSBUPEBTMBTFTDVF
MBTEFCJPUJDBFTQBPMBTo RVJTPGPSNB
MJ[BSTVTFTUVEJPTDPOFMHSBEPEFNBHT
UFSEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTF
6OJWFSTJEBEEF7BMFODJB
-B MFDUVSB EFM MJCSP EF "EFMB $PSUJOB
iUJDBNOJNB*OUSPEVDDJOBMBmMPTP
GB QSDUJDBw  QVCMJDBEP FO   BCSJ
FO&TQBBVOBQFSTQFDUJWBRVF TJCJFOTF
JOUVB OPBDBCBCBEFFODPOUSBSMBDPO
DFQUVBMJ[BDJO Z GPSNVMBDJO OFDFTBSJBT
QBSBTVQFSBSFMJNQBDUPEFMJVTOBUVSBMJT
NPEFMBGPSNBDJOmMPTmDBFTDPMTUJDB
(SBDJBTBFMMBFOUSBNPTFOFMNCJUPEF
VOB UJDB EJTDVSTJWB Z EJBMHJDB RVF TF
DVJEBEFIBDFSKVTUJDJBBMTFSBVUOPNPZ
EJBMHJDPEFMIPNCSF ZFYJHFQPSFMMPVO
NOJNP NPSBM RVF TMP TF DPOTJEFSFO
KVTUBTMBTOPSNBTRVFIBOTJEPRVFSJEBT
QPS MPT BGFDUBEPT  USBT VO EJMPHP DFMF
CSBEP FO DPOEJDJPOFT EF TJNFUSB &O
USBNPT QVFT FOVOBUJDBEFPOUPMHJDB
ZVOJWFSTBMJTUBRVFQSPUFHFMBBVUPOPNB





%JOBNJTNPEFMEJMPHPCJPUJDPFO&TQBB'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT

TPMJEBSJBEFMIPNCSFZFT QPSUBOUP CBTF


mSNFQBSBFMEFSFDIPKVTUP QBSBMBQPM
UJDBMFHUJNBZQBSBVOBSFMJHJORVFTF
TPNFUFHVTUPTBBMBDSUJDBEFMBSB[O
6OJWFSTJEBE"VUOPNBEF#BSDFMPOB
$PO VOB MBSHB FYQFSJFODJB DPNP QSP
GFTPSB EF mMPTPGB  7JDUPSJB $BNQT 
$BUFESUJDB EF UJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
"VUOPNB EF #BSDFMPOB Z QSFTJEFOUB
EFM $PNJU $POTVMUJWP EF #JPUJDB EFM
(PCJFSOP "VUOPNP EF $BUBMVB  FO
TV NT SFDJFOUF MJCSP  i-B WPMVOUBE EF
WJWJSw $BNQT    Q 
 FTUBCMFDF
mSNFNFOUF RVF MB CJPUJDB EFCF UFOFS
DPNPDBSBDUFSTUJDBTCTJDBTMBJOUFSEJTDJ
QMJOBSJFEBEZMBMBJDJEBE$PO5SJTUSBN
&OHFMIBSEU  BENJUF RVF OP QPEFNPT
EFTDVCSJSVOBNPSBMJEBETFDVMBSDBOOJ
DB  EPUBEB EF DPOUFOJEP  PCMJHOEPOPT
B iBmOBS FO FM QSPDFEJNJFOUP QBSB RVF
MBT EFDJTJPOFT BMDBODFO MB NYJNB DP
SSFDDJOQPTJCMF6OQSPDFEJNJFOUPRVF
DPOTJTUJSFOFMEJMPHP MBEJTDVTJOZMB
EFMJCFSBDJOw FWJUBOEPBRVFMMBTQPTUVSBT
RVFQVFEBOOPTFSBDFQUBEBTQPSUPEPT
&OEFmOJUJWB MBCJPUJDBBTQJSBBBQMJDBS
VOBiNPSBMNOJNBw DVZPWBMPSOVDMFBS
FTMBEJHOJEBEEFMBQFSTPOBRVFTFFY
QSFTBFOMPTWBMPSFTCTJDPTEFMBNPEFS
OJEBEoMJCFSUBE JHVBMEBEZGSBUFSOJEBEo 
TVTUSBUPEFMPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT

#JPUJDBQSPNPUPSBEFMEJMPHP
JOUFSOBDJPOBMQPMUJDP TPDJBMZ
DVMUVSBM
.BSDFMP1BMBDJPT NEJDP QPMUJDPZQSP
NPUPSEFMBCJPUJDBHMPCBMGVOEBEPSEF
MB4PDJFEBE*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB FO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

MBRVFQSFTJEFTV$PNJU$JFOUmDPEJ
SFDUPSEFMBSFWJTUB4*#*ZVOPEFMPTQBS
UDJQFTFOMBFMBCPSBDJOZmSNBEFM$PO
WFOJP&VSPQFPTPCSF%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT
Z#JPNFEJDJOB FTVOBEFMBTmHVSBTNT
EFTUBDBEBT EF MB CJPUJDB FO &TQBB
#JPUJDBZBUFODJOQSJNBSJBEFTBMVE
/VFTUSP EFTFP FO FTUF QVOUP FT SFOEJS
IPNFOBKFBBRVFMMPTNEJDPToNVDIPT
EF FMMPT BHSVQBEPT FO MB 4PDJFEBE &T
QBPMBEF.FEJDJOB'BNJMJBSZ$PNV
OJUBSJB 4&.'*$
oZFRVJQPTEFTBMVE
RVF TF EFEJDBO B MB BUFODJO QSJNBSJB 
FTQFDJBMNFOUFBRVJFOFTUSBCBKBOFOMPT
QSPHSBNBT EF BUFODJO EPNJDJMJBSJB FO
DVJEBEPTQBMJBUJWPT 1"%&4
&ODVBO
UP TFBO DBQBDFT EF NBOUFOFS FM NFKPS
FTQSJUVEFMBUSBEJDJOIJQPDSUJDB MPT
DPOPDJNJFOUPTCJPUJDPTOFDFTBSJPTZMB
DFSDBOBDPOMPTQBDJFOUFTZDJVEBEBOPT
TPOFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPUJDB

#JPUJDBEFTEFVOB
GVOEBNFOUBDJOUFPMHJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE1POUJmDJBEF$PNJMMBT
61$
.BESJE
-B$UFESBEF#JPUJDBEFMB61$GVF
DSFBEB QPS +BWJFS (BGP 

/PQVEPWFSQVCMJDBEBFOWJEBTVPCSB
EF i#JPUJDB 5FPMHJDBw (BGP  

RVF BHSVQBCB MPT TBCFSFT DJFOUmDPT Z
UFPMHJDPTRVFIBCBEFTBSSPMMBEPFOTVT
DMBTFT MJCSPTZBSUDVMPT
"OVBMNFOUF EFTEF JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ
[EFTEFTV$UFESBVOPTTFNJOBSJPTEF
EJTDVTJO RVFMFTPCSFWJWFOHSBDJBTBTVT
TFHVJEPSFT GPSNBEPTFOMPRVFQPEFNPT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

EFOPNJOBSiCJPUJDBDBUMJDBEJBMPHBO
UFw-BDPMFDDJOi%JMFNBTUJDPTEFMB
.FEJDJOB"DUVBMw QVCMJDBEBFOMB61$ 
TJHVF TJFOEP VO SFGFSFOUF FO UPEPT MPT
UFNBT RVF USBU -BT UFDOPMPHBT EF SF
QSPEVDDJO BTJTUJEB Z MB CJPUFDOPMPHB
HFOUJDB GVFSPO QBSB M UFNBT QSFEJMFD
UPT EFTEFRVFEFGFOEJTVUFTJTEPDUPSBM
TPCSFi&MBCPSUPZFMDPNJFO[PEFMBWJEB
IVNBOBi (BGP  
 FO MB 6OJWFSTJ
EBE(SFHPSJBOBEF3PNB FO

(BMO ZFMQSPGFTPSUJUVMBSEFMB'BDVM
UBE EF .FEJDJOB EF 4FWJMMB  +PT .BSB
3VCJP  DVFOUBO DPO MB DPMBCPSBDJO EF
PUSPTJOTUJUVUPTEFGVOEBNFOUBDJOUJDB
*## 6OJWFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTFZ6OJ
WFSTJEBE EF $PNJMMBT
 &O 1BNQMPOB 
#PTDP$PSEFJSP FO ZFO;BSBHP
[B 'SBODJTDP+BWJFS0CJT FO IBO
PSHBOJ[BEP NFNPSBCMFT +PSOBEBT /B
DJPOBMFTTPCSF$VJEBEPT1BMJBUJWPTFOMBT
RVFIBQBSUJDJQBEPFM*##

&O MB NJTNB MOFB RVF +BWJFS (BGP TF


NVFWF MB &TDVFMB EF 5FPMPHB 'VOEB
NFOUBM Z .PSBM EF (SBOBEB  DPMBCP
SBEPSBEFMPTDVSTPTZFM.TUFSEFMPT
)FSNBOPT EF 4BO +VBO EF %JPT  Z MB
FTDVFMBEFMPT3FEFOUPSJTUBTEF.BESJE 
RVF UJFOFO DPNP QSJODJQBMFT SFQSFTFO
UBOUFTB.BSDJBOP7JEBMZ+BWJFS&MJ[BSJ
"NCPTDPOUSJCVZFODPOMB61$ZDPO
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE $PNQMVUFOTF EF .B
ESJE$POEJGFSFOUFTNBUJDFT TFNVFWFO
FOFMDPOUFYUPEFVOBUJDBBVUOPNBFO
FMDPOUFYUPEFMBGFDSJTUJBOB

6OJWFSTJEBE1SJWBEBEF/BWBSSB

0SEFO)PTQJUBMBSJB4BO+VBOEF%JPT
'PSNBFOCJPUJDBBMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTTB
OJUBSJPTEFTVTIPTQJUBMFT EFDJEJEBNFOUF
JNQVMTBEB QPS FM )OP (FOFSBM 1BDVBM
1JMFT&O&TQBBIBOTFHVJEPUBMJOJDJB
UJWBNEJDPT FOGFSNFSBTZQSPGFTJPOBMFT
TBOJUBSJPT  Z FO UPEPT MPT DFOUSPT EF MB
0SEFOIBZIFSNBOPTZQSPGFTJPOBMFTTB
OJUBSJPTDPOVO.TUFSFOCJPUJDB&TQF
DJBMNFODJONFSFDFFM.TUFSRVFEFT
EFPSHBOJ[BMB1SPWJODJB#UJDBEF
MB0SEFO)PTQJUBMBSJB4BO+VBOEF%JPT 
CBKPFMUUVMPi#JPUJDBZ)VNBOJ[BDJO
EFMB"TJTUFODJBw4VEJSFDUPS +PT.BSB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

-B CJPUJDB DPNP EJTDJQMJOB EPDFOUF  Z


WJODVMBEB B MB JOTUJUVDJO i0QVT %FJw 
FTU OUJNBNFOUF MJHBEB B MB mHVSB EF
(PO[BMP)FSSBO[ DBUFESUJDPEF)JTUP
MPHBZ"OBUPNB1BUPMHJDB EFTEF 
ZEFDBOPEFMB'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOBEF
MB6OJWFSTJEBEEF/BWBSSB FOUSFZ
5SBCBKFOMB0SHBOJ[BDJO.EJ
DB$PMFHJBMEF&TQBB EFTEFIBTUB
 ZIBTJEPNJFNCSPEFM$PNJU*O
UFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPUJDBEFMB6/&4$0
ZEFMB"DBEFNJB1POUJmDJBQPSMB7JEB

#JPUJDBEFTEFVOB
GVOEBNFOUBDJOKVSEJDB
4F DBSBDUFSJ[B QPS MB JNQPSUBODJB DPO
DFEJEBBM%FSFDIPZBMBMFHJTMBDJO TJO
EFTQSFDJBSMPTQSPCMFNBTUJDPTEFCBTF
%JTUJOHVJNPT DMBSBNFOUF MB FTDVFMB EF
.BSB $BTBEP  DVZB PSJFOUBDJO FT FM
%FSFDIPDPNPDPOmHVSBEPSEFMBUJDB
MB EF "OUPOJP #FSJTUBJO 4+  FTQFDJBMJ
[BEB FO %FSFDIP 1FOBM  $SJNJOPMPHB
Z 7JDUJNPMPHB  Z MB EF $BSMPT 3PNFP
$BTBCPOB  FTQFDJBMJ[BEB FO DVFTUJPOFT
KVSEJDBTFOUPSOPBMHFOPNBIVNBOP





%JOBNJTNPEFMEJMPHPCJPUJDPFO&TQBB'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT

&Mi0CTFSWBUPSJEF#JPUJDBJ%SFUwZFM
.TUFSEF#JPUJDBZ%FSFDIPEFMB6OJ
WFSTJEBEEF#BSDFMPOB EJSJHJEPQPS.B
SB$BTBEP JOUFOUBQSPNPWFSFMEJMPHP
VOJWFSTJEBETPDJFEBE  DPO MB mOBMJEBE
EFJOnVJSBOUFMPTPSHBOJTNPTQCMJDPT 
BENJOJTUSBUJWPT P QPMUJDPT RVF SFHVMBO
ZDPOUSPMBOMBTBDUJWJEBEFTEFJOWFTUJHB
DJOZMBBQMJDBDJOEFOVFWBTUFDOPMP
HBT1VCMJDBFODBTUFMMBOPFJOHMT DPO
KVOUBNFOUF DPO BMHVOPT FTQFDJBMJTUBT 
%PDVNFOUPTEFPQJOJO CJFOFMBCPSBEPT
ZDPOVOBBNQMJBEJGVTJOFOMPTDSDVMPT
VOJWFSTJUBSJPT
&TJNQPSUBOUFNFODJPOBSB$BSMPT.B
SB3PNFP$BTBCPOB DBUFESUJDPEF%F
SFDIP 1FOBM EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EFM 1BT
7BTDPZEJSFDUPSEFMB$UFESB*OUFSVOJ
WFSTJUBSJBEF%FSFDIPZ(FOPNB)VNB
OP DVZBBTFTPSBFTSFRVFSJEBGSFDVFOUF
NFOUF QPS PSHBOJTNPT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT 
DPNPMB0SHBOJ[BDJO.VOEJBMEFMB4B
MVE 0.4
ZMB0SHBOJ[BDJOEF/BDJP
OFT6OJEBTQBSBMB&EVDBDJO MB$JFODJB
ZMB$VMUVSB 6/&4$0
%FTVDUFESB
IBOFHSFTBEP"JU[JCFS&NBMEJ 1JMBS/J
DPMTZ4FSHJP3PNFP%FCFNPTEFTUBDBS
UBNCJOMBMBCPSJOWFTUJHBEPSBZEPDFOUF
EFMEJSFDUPSEFMB6OJEBEEF#JPUJDBZ
0SJFOUBDJO4BOJUBSJBEFMB$PNVOJEBE
EF.BESJE +BWJFS4ODIF[$BSP
&O FTUF EJMPHP UJFOFO VO QBQFM SFMF
WBOUFMPTDBUFESUJDPTEF%FSFDIP1FOBM
"OUPOJP #FSJTUBJO  EFM *OTUJUVUP 7BTDP
EF$SJNJOPMPHBZ+PT-VT%JF[3JQP
MMT EFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF.MBHBUBN
CJO&TUIFS(JNOF[4BMJOBT SFDUPSBEF
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE 3BNO -MVMM  &ODBSOB
3PDB  DBUFESUJDB EF %FSFDIP $JWJM EF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

#BSDFMPOB Z NBHJTUSBEB EFM 5SJCVOBM


4VQSFNP  Z 'SBODJTDP +BWJFS #M[RVF[
3VJ[  1SPGFTPS 5JUVMBS EF 'JMPTPGB EFM
%FSFDIP EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE 1CMJDB EF
/BWBSSB RVFFYQMPSBMPTQSPCMFNBTCJP
UJDPTEFTEFVODPNQPOFOUFKVSEJDPZ 
BMSFWT SFnFYJPOBZGVOEBNFOUBMBEJ
NFOTJOUJDBEFMPKVSEJDP
&T OFDFTBSJP NFODJPOBS  BEFNT  BM
.BHJTUSBEP &NSJUP EFM 5SJCVOBM 4V
QSFNP  +PT .BOVFM .BSUOF[1FSFEB 
DVZB PSJFOUBDJO Z NBHJTUFSJP FO MB
$PNJTJO EF #JPUJDB EF MB 4PDJFEBE
&TQBPMB EF (JOFDPMPHB Z 0CTUFUSJ
DJB 4&(0
 IB TJEP GVOEBNFOUBM B
.BOVFM "NBSJMMB (VOEO  QSFTJEFOUF
EFM (SVQP &VSPQFP EF %FSFDIP 'BS
NBDVUJDP  B 3JDBSEP EF -PSFO[P 
QSFTJEFOUF EF MB "TPDJBDJO &TQBPMB
EF %FSFDIP 4BOJUBSJP  Z B 9BWJFS "CFM
-MVDI  QSPGFTPS EF MB &TDVFMB +VEJDJBM

#JPUJDBEFTEFFMUFTUJNPOJPZMB
OBSSBUJWB
4PONVDIPTMPTNEJDPTDVZBWJEBTJSWF
EFNPEFMPEFQSBYJTNEJDBCBTBEBFO
DMBSPTDSJUFSJPTUJDPTQBSBMBTHFOFSBDJP
OFTGVUVSBT+PSEJ4BOT
+PSEJ(PM

"OUPOJP 5FKFEP
 .PJTT #SPHHJ 
'SBODFTD 7JMBSEFMM  $JSJM 3P[NBO  .B
SJVT'P[ &TUBOJTMBP#PSFO 'SBODFTD.
%PNOFDI  +PSEJ 4FUPBJO  %PNJOHP
3VBOP +PTFQ.-BMMB 4BHSBSJP.BUFV 
-ZEJB(VJTBOZ$BSNFO$VBESBEP
 3FDPSEBNPTTMPBBRVFMMPTRVF EFTEFMPTJOJ
DJPT OPTMPFOUSBSPOFOFMBSUFEFMEJMPHPCJP
UJDP TJOPRVFMPQPUFODJBSPOEPDUPSFT.BSJVT
.PSMBOT .BSD"#SPHHJZ-JEJB#VJTO RVF
OPTBOJNBSPOBDPNFO[BSDPOFMMPTMB4PDJFUBU
$BUBMBOBEF#JPUJDB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

1FSPEPEFSFWJTJO QSPZFDDJO
FJOUFHSBDJO
4VPCKFUJWPFTMBFMFDDJOEFWBMPSFTFOFM
QMBOPTPDJBM RVFQFSNJUBODPOTUSVJSVO
NVOEPNFKPSZNTTBMVEBCMF UFOEJFO
EPBTVQFSBSMBTWFSHPO[PTBTEJGFSFODJBT
FOUSFSJDPTZQPCSFTZFOUSFQPEFSPTPTZ
FYDMVJEPT*OUFOUBSFNPTSFTVNJSMPBUSB
WTEFMBTUSFTSBDJPOBMJEBEFTRVFIFNPT
NFODJPOBEP

3BDJPOBMJEBEUDOJDPDJFOUmDB
-BT EPT MUJNBT EDBEBT EFM TJHMP 99
GVFSPO UFTUJHPT EFM FOUVTJBTNP HFOFSB
EP QPS MPT JOHFOJPT DJFOUmDPT oEFCJ
EBNFOUF NBHOJmDBEPT QPS MPT NFEJPT
EFDPNVOJDBDJOTPDJBM DPONPUJWPEF
IBCFSTFDPOTFHVJEPMBTFDVFODJBDJOEFM
HFOPNBIVNBOPoZQPSMBTQPTJCJMJEB
EFT BCJFSUBT QPS MPT USBCBKPT SFMBDJPOB
EPTDPOMBTDMVMBTUSPODBMFT TUFNDFMMT

Z TVT QSPTQFDUJWBT QPTJCJMJEBEFT QBSB
SFHFOFSBS UFKJEPT IVNBOPT MFTJPOBEPT
P EFHFOFSBEPT &M FOUVTJBTNP QPS MBT
QPTJCJMJEBEFT EF RVF VO EB QPEBNPT
QSFWFOJS F JODMVTP DVSBS FOGFSNFEB
EFT EFHFOFSBUJWBT EFM TJTUFNB OFSWJPTP
DFOUSBM QSPEVDF MB JMVTJO EF RVF TJ MP
RVFSFNPTMPMPHSBSFNPT)PZ NTRVF
OVODB DPSSFNPTFMQFMJHSPEFTVCPSEJ
OBS MB EJHOJEBE IVNBOB Z FM SFTQFUP B
MBT QFSTPOBT B MB DPOTFDVDJO EF VOPT
MPHSPT DJFOUmDPT )PZ  NT RVF OVO
DB  UFOFNPT MB PCMJHBDJO EF QFOTBS FM
NPEFMP EF TPDJFEBE RVF RVFSFNPT  BM
IBDFSOVFTUSBTPQDJPOFTUJDBTZKVSEJ
DBT&OMBTPQDJPOFTUJDBT UBOUPMPTRVF
DPOGBONTFOMBOFVUSBMJEBEBYJPMHJDB
EF MB DJFODJB DPNP RVJFOFT DPOTJEFSBO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DPNP QSJODJQJP EF MB DPOEVDUB QSPGF


TJPOBMDPSSFDUBVOBUJDBEFSFTQPOTBCJ
MJEBETPDJBM FTUOEFBDVFSEPFOBQMJDBS
FMQSJODJQJPEFQSFDBVDJO QPOEFSBOEP
MBTDPOTFDVFODJBTEFBQMJDBDJPOFTQSFDJ
QJUBEBTEFOVFWBTUFDOPMPHBTCJPHFOUJ
DBT&TUBBDUJUVE QPSDPOWJDDJOPQPS
FM UFNPS RVF JOTQJSBO MBT QPTJCJMJEBEFT
EFTVVUJMJ[BDJODPOmOFTCMJDPT FTFT
QFSBO[BEPSB
1PTUVMBNPT MB FOUSFHB EF JOGPSNBDJO
BEFDVBEBZTVmDJFOUFFOUPEPTMPTOJWF
MFTEFMBTPDJFEBE QBSBRVFTUBQVFEB
GPSNBSTFVOBJEFBEFWFOUBKBT JODPOWF
OJFOUFTZQPTJCMFTSJFTHPTBMJOWFTUJHBSP
EFTBSSPMMBS VOB OVFWB UFDOPMPHB "EF
NT FTOFDFTBSJPFTQFDJmDBSQBSBRVJ
OFTTFSOMBTWFOUBKBTZQBSBRVJOFTMPT
JODPOWFOJFOUFT

3BDJPOBMJEBEUJDPSFMJHJPTB
-BT QPTJCJMJEBEFT RVF PGSFDFO MBT UFD
OPMPHBT CJPHFOUJDBT DSFBO JORVJFUVE 
BMJNFOUBEB QPS MB QPTJCMF MFHJUJNBDJO
DJFOUmDB TPDJBM UJDBZKVSEJDB1BSUJ
DJQBSFOFMEJMPHPCJPUJDPTVQPOFFTUBS
EJTQVFTUP B IBDFSTF QFSNFBCMF B PUSBT
QFSTQFDUJWBT  SFWJTBS MPT KVJDJPT QSFWJPT
RVF QPSFMUJFNQP MPTDBNCJPTDPODFQ
UVBMFT P MB FWPMVDJO DVMUVSBM  QVFEFO
DPOTJEFSBSTF BOBDSOJDPT &T OFDFTBSJB
VOBQVFTUBBMEBEFMPTDPOPDJNJFOUPT
DJFOUmDPT UJDPTZUFPMHJDPT
&O UPEBT MBT SBDJPOBMJEBEFT  OP FT TPS
QSFOEFOUF RVF FYJTUBO QPMBSJ[BDJPOFT
FOUSF MPT DJVEBEBOPT  USBEVDJEBT FO MBT
DBNQBBTQBSBMBTFMFDDJPOFTEFMPTSF
QSFTFOUBOUFT FO MBT $PSUFT FTQBPMBT





%JOBNJTNPEFMEJMPHPCJPUJDPFO&TQBB'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT

-PRVFSFTVMUBTPSQSFOEFOUFFTRVFMPT
BOUBHPOJTNPT NT GVFSUFT QSPDFEBO EF
MBSFTJTUFODJBBBDFQUBSMBTFQBSBDJOFO
USF*HMFTJBZ&TUBEPQPSQBSUFEFNVDIPT
DJVEBEBOPT  mSNFNFOUF BQPZBEPT QPS
VOTFDUPSEFMFQJTDPQBEP OPTUMHJDPEFM
OBDJPOBMDBUPMJDJTNP Z UFNFSPTP EF MB
UDOJDBZEFTVTQPTJCMFTBCVTPT&WJEFO
UFNFOUF  FTUP JNQSFHOB MBT EJTDVTJPOFT
EFQSPZFDUPTEFMFZ TPCSFUPEPEFBRVF
MMPTRVFNTJODJEFODJBUJFOFOTPCSFMB
WJEBIVNBOBZMBGBNJMJB

3BDJPOBMJEBEKVSEJDPQPMUJDB
&O MPT MUJNPT BPT TF IBO QSPEVDJEP
USBOTGPSNBDJPOFT TVTUBODJBMFT FO MPT
TJTUFNBT TBOJUBSJPT NPEFSOPT 6OP EF
MPT QSJODJQBMFT BHFOUFT EF FTUF DBNCJP
FO &VSPQB  FTQFDJBMNFOUF FO &TQBB 
FTFMDJVEBEBOPDVBOEPTFDPOWJFSUFFO
QBDJFOUF
&TUFQBTIBEFTBSSPMMBEPVOBMFHJTMBDJO
JNQPSUBOUF EF SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EF MPT
EFSFDIPTEFMPTQBDJFOUFTFOMBBTJTUFODJB
TBOJUBSJB DPNPFYQSFTJOEFMQSJODJQJP
EFBVUPOPNBCBKPMBmHVSBEFMEFSFDIP
BMBJOGPSNBDJOZBMDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJO
GPSNBEP -B 'VOEBDJO #JCMJPUFDB +P
TFQ-BQPSUF '#+-
oMJEFSBEBQPS"MCFSU
+PWFMM  B USBWT EF JOJDJBUJWBT DPNP FM
'PSP&TQBPMEF1BDJFOUFT RVFBHSVQB
BNTEFBTPDJBDJPOFTEFQBDJFOUFT
EFEJWFSTBTQBUPMPHBT BTDPNPBGBNJ
MJBSFTZWPMVOUBSJPT
ZMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF
1BDJFOUFTo GBDJMJUB MB GPSNBDJO F JO
DSFNFOUBFMDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMPTDJVEB
 7FSTJUJPXXXXFCQBDJFOUFTPSH
 7FSTJUJPXXXVOJWFSTJEBEQBDJFOUFTPSH

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EBOPT VTVBSJPTEFMBTBOJEBE SFTQFDUP


EFFOGFSNFEBEFTZTFSWJDJPTTBOJUBSJPT
#BKPMBEJSFDDJOEF"MCFSU0SJPM#PTDI
TFIBIFDIPVOHSBOFTGVFS[PFOUPEPT
MPTFTUBNFOUPTQBSBBOBMJ[BSDSUJDBNFO
UFMBTBOJEBEFO&TQBB FMQBQFMEFMBT
QSPGFTJPOFT TBOJUBSJBT Z FM DJVEBEBOP
DPNP OVFWP QSPUBHPOJTUB EFM TJTUFNB
4POJOJDJBUJWBTRVF SFBMNFOUF UJFOEFO
QVFOUFT BOUF VO GVUVSP RVF RVFSFNPT
NTTBMVEBCMFZNFKPS 0SJPM 

&OMBMOFBEFMBFYJHFODJBUJDB 1BCMP
4JNO-PSEBMVDIBQBSBDPOTFHVJSRVF
MBCJPUJDBEFMJCFSFTPCSFMPTWBMPSFTSF
MFWBOUFT EF MB PSHBOJ[BDJO TBOJUBSJB 
RVF MB EFmOFO JOUFSOBNFOUF Z MB EJGF
SFODJBOFYUFSOBNFOUF FOPSEFOBDPO
WFSUJSMBFOVOBJOTUJUVDJOEFFYDFMFODJB
4JNO  
 4JHVF DPO FMMP MB MOFB
USB[BEBQPSMPTDBUFESUJDPTEFUJDBEF
7BMFODJB "EFMB$PSUJOBZ+FTT$POJMM
$PSUJOBZ$POJMM 

%FTEFFMQVOUPEFWJTUBEFMBMFHJTMBDJO 
TPONVDIBTMBTEJTQPTJDJPOFTZOPSNBT
DPOSBOHPEFMFZQSPNVMHBEBTFO&TQBB
EFTEFMPTBPTZRVFBGFDUBOBUFNBT
CJPUJDPT 6OB DBSBDUFSTUJDB DPNO FT
MBEFUPNBSDPNPNPEFMPMPTQSPZFDUPT
EF-FZZMFHJTMBDJPOFTNTQSPHSFTJTUBTZ
MJCFSBMFTEF&VSPQB
t

5SBTQMBOUFT &M 3FBM %FDSFUP


 EFEFEJDJFNCSFEF
  SFHVMB MB EPOBDJO  FYUSBD
DJO Z USBTQMBOUF EF SHBOPT IV
NBOPT  BT DPNP MB DPPSEJOBDJO
UFSSJUPSJBM QBSB MMFWBS B DBCP FTUBT
BDUJWJEBEFT ZTJHVFFOWJHPSMB-FZ





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

t

t

t

  EF  EF PDUVCSF  TPCSF


FYUSBDDJOZUSBTQMBOUFEFSHBOPT
5FSSJCBT 

5FDOPMPHBT EF SFQSPEVDDJO BTJT
UJEB-FZ EFEFNBZP 
TPCSF 5DOJDBT EF 3FQSPEVD
DJO )VNBOB "TJTUJEB 5FSSJCBT 


*OWFTUJHBDJO DPO TFSFT IVNBOPT
&TQBB EJTQPOF EF VOB MFHJTMBDJO
FTQFDmDB RVF SFHVMB UPEB QSDUJDB
EFJOWFTUJHBDJODPOTVKFUPTIVNB
OPT QBSB MB VUJMJ[BDJO EF OVFWPT
GSNBDPT Z QSPEVDUPT TBOJUBSJPT
4F SFDPHJ FO MB -FZ  EFM
.FEJDBNFOUP Z TF EFTBSSPMM QPT
UFSJPSNFOUF FO FM 3FBM %FDSFUP
EFEFGFCSFSPTPCSF&O
TBZPT$MOJDPT DPOFMmOEFBEBQUBS
MB OPSNBUJWB B MB DPSSFTQPOEJFOUF
EJSFDUJWBEFMB6OJO&VSPQFB4JO
FNCBSHP FOFMDBNQPEFMBJOWFT
UJHBDJOCJPNEJDBEFCFNPTNFO
DJPOBS FM 1SPZFDUP EF -FZ RVF TF
FODVFOUSB ZB FO BWBO[BEP USNJUF
EFEJTDVTJOQBSMBNFOUBSJB
%FSFDIPT EF MPT QBDJFOUFT &M QSJ
NFS UFYUP QSPNVMHBEP GVF MB -FZ
(FOFSBM EF 4BOJEBE   EF
EFBCSJM BSUTZ
DPOVOB
FYQMJDJUBDJONBZPSZNTSJHVSPTB
FO MB -FZ  TPCSF MB JOGPS
NBDJO BVUPOPNBEFMQBDJFOUFZ
EPDVNFOUBDJO DMOJDB 5FSSJCBT 

 &O FM NCJUP FTQBPM  MPT
HPCJFSOPTBVUOPNPTDPODPNQF
UFODJBT FO TBOJEBE IBO BCPSEBEP
UBNCJO FTUB DVFTUJO  TJFOEP FM
QSJNFSP FM EF MB $PNVOJEBE "V
UOPNB EF $BUBMVB  DPO MB -FZ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

t

t

t

  RVF SFHVM QPS QSJNFSB


WF[MPTEPDVNFOUPTEFWPMVOUBEFT
BOUJDJQBEBT "EWBODFE %JSFDUJWFT

DPNP JOTUSVNFOUP EF SFTQFUP B MB
BVUPOPNB EFM QBDJFOUF 5FSSJCBT 
  

1SPUFDDJOEFEBUPTQFSTPOBMFT4F
QSPNVMH MB -FZ   EF 
EFEJDJFNCSF TPCSF1SPUFDDJOEF
%BUPT EF $BSDUFS 1FSTPOBM  RVF
BGFDUBBUPEBTMBTDVFTUJPOFTEFDPO
mEFODJBMJEBE 5FSSJCBT 

$EJHP 1FOBM &O FTQFDJBM  BRVF
MMBTmHVSBTRVFDBFOEFOUSPEFMPT
UFNBT EF FTUVEJP EF MB CJPUJDB
&OUSF FMMBT  DJUBNPT "CPSUP BSU
 B 
 "VYJMJP BM TVJDJEJP Z
FVUBOBTJB BSU
 "CFMZ5FSSJ
CBT "SNFOHPMFUBM 

-FTJPOFTBMGFUP BSUTZ

.BOJQVMBDJOHFOUJDB BSUTZ
TT
%FOFHBDJOEFBTJTUFODJBTBOJ
UBSJB BSU
2VJFCSBEFMTFDSFUP
QSPGFTJPOBM BSU

$POWFOJP&VSPQFPTPCSF%FSFDIPT
)VNBOPT Z #JPNFEJDJOB 

SBUJmDBEP QPS FM 1BSMBNFOUP FT
QBPM FO   FOUS FO WJHPS FO
4FUSBUBEFVOBOPSNBEFN
CJUPFVSPQFP ZBRVFMMPTQBTFTRVF
MBIBZBOmSNBEPZSBUJmDBEPEFCFO
BEBQUBSTVTEJTQPTJDJPOFTJOUFSOBTB
TVT DPOUFOJEPT  RVF SFHVMBO DVFT
UJPOFTDPNPFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUP MBT
WPMVOUBEFT BOUJDJQBEBT  MB JOWFTUJ
HBDJO DPO TVKFUPT IVNBOPT  FUD
" MB GFDIB  MB MFHJTMBDJO FTQBPMB
SFGFSFODJBEBZBIBTJEPBEBQUBEBFO
TV JOUFHSJEBE B MPT QSJODJQJPT EFM
$POWFOJP



%JOBNJTNPEFMEJMPHPCJPUJDPFO&TQBB'SBODFTD"CFM4+Z/VSJB5FSSJCBT



3FGFSFODJBT
"CFM ' 
#JPUJDB0SHFOFT QSFTFOUFZGVUVSP.BESJE *OTUJUVU#PSKBEF#JPUJDBZ
'VOEBDJO.BQGSFEF.FEJDJOB
"CFM ' 5FSSJCBT /FUBM 
)BDJBVOBQPTJCMFEFTQFOBMJ[BDJOEFMBFVUBOBTJB
#JPUJDB%FCBU  QQ
"SNFOHPM 3 #PMBEFSBT . FUBM 
*OGPSNFTPCSFMwFVUBOTJBJMwBKVEBBMTVDJEJ
#BSDFMPOB 1SPVT4DJFODF
#BSSFBV ) 
#JPUIJRVFFUUIJRVFEFMBWJF/35-FVWFO )FSW
$BNQT 7 
-BWPMVOUBEEFWJWJS#BSDFMPOB "SJFM
$POJMM  +  
 UJDB Z FNQSFTB TBOJUBSJB &O 'FSSFS ++  .BSUOF[  +- &ET

#JPUJDB 6O EJMPHP QMVSBM )PNFOBKF B +BWJFS (BGP  4+ .BESJE  6OJWFSTJEBE
1POUJGJDJB$PNJMMBT QQ
$PSUJOB " 
UJDB.OJNB*OUSPEVDDJOBMBGJMPTPGBQSDUJDB.BESJE 5FDOPT 4"
$PSUJOB  " $POJMM  + 
 %FNPDSBDJB QBSUJDJQBUJWB Z TPDJFEBE DJWJM VOB UJDB
FNQSFTBSJBM#PHPU 4JHMPEFM)PNCSF 4FSJF$POWFSTBDJPOFT

%F 8BDUIFS  . 
 3FWJTJUJOH UIF 0SJHJOT &"$.& /FXTMFUUFS   "QSJM 
.BBTUSJDIU
(BGP + 
#JPUJDBUFPMHJDB.BESJE 61$Z%FTDMFEF#SPXFS
(BGP + 
&MBCPSUPZFMDPNJFO[PEFMBWJEBIVNBOB4BOUBOEFS 4BM5FSSBF
(SBDJB % 
1SPDFEJNJFOUPTEFEFDJTJOFOUJDBDMOJDB.BESJE &VEFNB
(SBDJB % 
%FMBCJPUJDBDMOJDBBMBCJPUJDBHMPCBMUSFJOUBBPTEFFWPMVDJO
4FMFDDJPOFTEF#JPUJDB#PHPU *OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDB$&/"-#&
(SBDJB % 
$POUSJCVDJOEFMBTIVNBOJEBEFTNEJDBTBMBGPSNBDJOEFMNEJDP
)VNBOJUBT )VNBOJEBEFT .EJDBT %JTQPOJCMF FO IUUQXXXGVOEBDJPONIN
PSHSFWJTUBIUNM$POTVMUBEPFMEFKVOJPEF
(SBDJB % 
'VOEBNFOUPTEF#JPUJDB.BESJE &VEFNB
+POBT ) 
5PXBSEB1IJMPTPQIZPG5FDIOPMPHZ)BTUJOHT$FOU3FQ 'FC 

QQ
-BDBEFOB +3 
#JPUJDBZ3FMJHJO+BWJFS(BGP 4+*O.FNPSJBN&O+BWJFS
(BGP3FMBUPEFVOIPNCSFQPSMBDJFODJB3FWJTUB-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF#JPUJDB/
ONFSPNPOPHSGJDP
$PMPNCJB 6OJWFSTJEBE.JMJUBS/VFWB(SBOBEB
-BDBEFOB +3 
)JTUPSJBi/PCFMBEBwEFMBHFOUJDBDPODFQUPZNUPEP%JTDVSTPEF
JOHSFTPDPNP"DBENJDPEFONFSPFOMB3FBM"DBEFNJBEF'BSNBDJB.BESJE 
3FBM"DBEFNJBEF'BSNBDJB
-BDBEFOB  +3 
 -B -FZ TPCSF UDOJDBT EF SFQSPEVDDJO IVNBOB BTJTUJEB
$POTJEFSBDJPOFTDJFOUGJDBTZUJDBT%FSFDIPZ(FOPNB)VNBOP 

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

0SJPM " 


-MJCSF#MBODEFMFTPSHBOJU[BDJPOTTBOJUSJFT#BSDFMPOB (FOFSBMJUBUEF
$BUBMVOZB
1PUUFS  73 
 #JPFUIJDT 5IF 4DJFODF PG 4VSWJWBM 1FSTQFDUJWFT JO #JPMPHZ BOE
.FEJDJOF  QQ
3FJDI 8 
&ODZDMPQFEJBPG#JPFUIJDT7PM/VFWB:PSL .BD.JMMBO
3FOEUPSGG +%,FNQ 1 &ET
 
#BTJD&UIJDBM1SJODJQMFTJOFVSPQFBOCJPFUIJDT
BOECJPMBX7PM$PQFOIBHFO %FONBSL $FOUFSGPS&UIJDTBOE-BX#BSDFMPOB 
*OTUJUVU#PSKBEF#JPUJDB
4JNPO 1 &E
 
UJDBEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTTBOJUBSJBT/VFWPTNPEFMPTEFDBMJEBE
.BESJE 5SJBDBTUFMB
5FSSJCBT / 
/VFWB-FZEF1SPUFDDJOEF%BUPT1FSTPOBMFT-BCPS)PTQJUBMBSJB 
 
QQ
5FSSJCBT / 
/VFWBSFHVMBDJOTPCSFUSBTQMBOUFEFSHBOPT-BCPS)PTQJUBMBSJB 
 
QQ
5FSSJCBT / 
%FTUJOPTEFMPTFNCSJPOFTTPCSBOUFTEF53)"#JPUJDB%FCBU 
 QQ
5FSSJCBT / 
%FSFDIPTDPOSBOHPEFMFZQSPTZDPOUSBTEFMB-FZCTJDB
#JPUJDB%FCBU  QQ
5FSSJCBT / 
-BTWPMVOUBEFTBOUJDJQBEBTZTVFTQFDJBMDPOTJEFSBDJOFOFMQBDJFOUF
HFSJUSJDP3FWJTUB&TQBPMBEF(FSJBUSBZ(FSPOUPMPHB NPOPHSGJDPEFCJPUJDB

 
EJDJFNCSF QQ
5FSSJCBT / 
-BTWPMVOUBEFTBOUJDJQBEBTZTVQSPCMFNUJDBFOMBBQMJDBDJOQSDUJDB
4BMVE 1CMJDB Z %FSFDIP "ENJOJTUSBUJWP .BESJE  $POTFKP (FOFSBM EFM 1PEFS
+VEJDJBM $VBEFSOPTEF%FSFDIP+VEJDJBM QQ
5FSSJCBT /  
$NPTFFMBCPSBVOEPDVNFOUPEFWPMVOUBEFTBOUJDJQBEBT'PSNBDJO
.EJDB$POUJOVBEB#BSDFMPOBZ.BESJE %PZNB QQ
7JBT + 
3FQUFTEFMBDJSVSHJBBMTFHMF99*#BSDFMPOB 3FBM"DBENJBEF.FEJDJOB
EF$BUBMVOZB
8FSU (EF #FSHINBOT 31- #PFS (+ FUBM 
&UIJDBMHVJEBODFPOIVNBO
FNCSZPOJDBOEGFUBMUJTTVFUSBOTQMBOUBUJPO"&VSPQFBOPWFSWJFX.FEJDJOF )FBMUI
$BSFBOE1IJMPTPQIZ  QQ
8PSME$PVODJMPG$IVSDIFT 8$$
 
8PSME$POGFSFODFPO$IVSDIBOE4PDJFUZ
$ISJTUJBOT JO UIF 5FDIOJDBM BOE 4PDJBM 3FWPMVUJPOT PG PVS 5JNF 4BOUBOEFS  4BM
5SSBF
8$$  
$POGFSFODFPO'BJUI 4DJFODFBOE'VUVSF7PM1MFOBSZ1SFTFOUBUJPO
3FQPSUTBOE3FDPNFOEBUJPOT$BNCSJEHF.BTTBDIVTFUUT 64"  .*5


PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB
-BNFEJDJOBHFONJDBFO.YJDPDPNPVOPEFMPT
NBZPSFTSFUPTCJPUJDPT
(FSBSEP+JNOF[4ODIF[ $TBS-BSBMWBSF[Z"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP.OEF[

1MBOUFBNJFOUPEFMQSPCMFNB

"

VORVFIBOQBTBEPNTEFUSFTEDB
EBTEFTEFRVFJOJDJFTUBOVFWBEJT
DJQMJOB OPFYJTUFVODPODFQUPVOWPDPZ
EFVTPVOJWFSTBM&O"NSJDB-BUJOBIBZ
VODPOTFOTP NTPNFOPTHFOFSBMJ[BEP 
EFRVFMBCJPUJDBFTiFMFTUVEJPEFMPTWB
MPSFTIVNBOPTZTVSFMBDJODPOMBDJFODJB
ZMBUFDOPMPHBBQMJDBEBBEJWFSTPTNCJUPT
EFMBWJEBw ,VUIZ 
&ODJFSUB
GPSNB TFDPOTJEFSBRVFJOUFOUBIVNBOJ
[BSFMEFTBSSPMMPDJFOUmDP FTUBCMFDJFOEP
SFMBDJPOFT EJONJDBT FOUSF MPT EFTBSSP
MMPTDJFOUmDPUFDOPMHJDPTZMBTDJFODJBT
IVNBOTUJDBTQBSBMMFHBSBVOFRVJMJCSJP
FOUSFFMBWBODFEFMBDJFODJBZMPTMNJUFT
FOMPTDVBMFTEFCFEFQSPHSFTBS

-BDPOTUSVDDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFO
.YJDP
0SHFOFTEFMBCJPUJDBFO
.YJDP.BOVFM7FMBTDP4VSF[
4F SFDPOPDF B .BOVFM 7FMBTDP4V
SF[DPNPFMJOJDJBEPSEFMBCJPUJDBFO
.YJDP'VFVOIPNCSFEFDJFODJBZEF
MFUSBT BVUPSEFTFJTMJCSPTZNTEF
USBCBKPTDJFOUmDPTQVCMJDBEPTFOSFWJT
UBTFTQFDJBMJ[BEBT UBOUPOBDJPOBMFTDPNP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT %JDU NT EF 


DPOGFSFODJBTFO.YJDPZFOFMNVOEP
GVFNJFNCSPEFNTEFTPDJFEBEFTZ
BDBEFNJBTEFNFEJDJOB $BSSBTDP3PKBT 

"TJNJTNP SFDJCJNM
UJQMFTDPOEFDPSBDJPOFTZEJTUJODJPOFTEF
BTPDJBDJPOFT VOJWFSTJEBEFT PSHBOJTNPT
QCMJDPTZQSJWBEPT BMSFEFEPSEFMNVO
EP  BEFNT EF IBCFS TJEP HBMBSEPOBEP
DPOWBSJPTUUVMPTIPOPSBSJPTPUPSHBEPT
QPSHPCJFSOPTEFEJGFSFOUFTQBTFT
.BOVFM7FMBTDP4VSF[DSF FONBS[P
EF KVOUPDPOFMFOUPODFT4FDSFUB
SJPEF4BMVE +FTT,VNBUF3PESHVF[ MB
$PNJTJO/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB $/#

1PTUFSJPSNFOUF  FO   GVF NJFN
CSPGVOEBEPSZQSJNFSQSFTJEFOUFEFMB
"DBEFNJB/BDJPOBM.FYJDBOBEF#JP
UJDB "/.#
 .BUFPT 

&TUFFOUVTJBTUBQSPNPUPSEFMBCJPUJDB
FO.YJDPBmSNBCBi-BCJPUJDBJOUF
SBDUBFOUSFMPTTJTUFNBTCJPMHJDPTRVF
PCFEFDFO MFZFT GTJDBT Z MB DPODJFODJB
UJDPNPSBM 4JO UFOFS SFMBDJO DPO MBT
MFZFT GTJDBT  QPOEFSB MB DPOEVDUB EF
RVJFOFT JOUFSWJFOFO P JOUFSmFSFO DPO
MBWJEB/PFTMBAUJDBEFMBWJEB TJOP
EFMFTUVEJPZMBSFnFYJOTJTUFNUJDPTEF
MBDPOEVDUBIBDJBMBWJEB MBTBMVEZMPT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

EFSFDIPTIVNBOPT BMBMV[EFMPTBWBO
DFTEFMBTDJFODJBTCJPMHJDBTZMBTOFDF
TBSJBTSFnFYJPOFTmMPTmDBTEFMBUJDBw
7FMBTDP4VSF[ 

&O  TF JOTUJUVZ MB i#FDB .BOVFM
7FMBTDP4VSF[FO#JPUJDBw DSFBEBQPS
MB'VOEBDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEF4BMVEZ
&EVDBDJO  FO DPPQFSBDJO DPO MB 0S
HBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE 
014  QBSB FTUJNVMBS  FOUSF MPT KWFOFT
EPDFOUFT F JOWFTUJHBEPSFT  FM EFTBSSPMMP
EFTVTDBQBDJEBEFTEFBOMJTJTCJPUJDP

-B$PNJTJO/BDJPOBMEF
#JPUJDB
4MPIBTUBTFMFDPODFEFBMB$/#
FMDBSDUFSEFQFSNBOFOUF&MEFOP
WJFNCSFEF FM4FDSFUBSJPEF4BMVE
FOUVSOPEFTJHOBPmDJBMNFOUFB.BOVFM
7FMBTDP4VSF[ TFDSFUBSJP FKFDVUJWP EF
MBNJTNB1BSBTFQUJFNCSFEF MB
$/#BERVJFSFDBSDUFSEFSHBOPEFT
DPODFOUSBEP EF MB 4FDSFUBSB EF 4BMVE
44"
DPOBVUPOPNBUDOJDBZPQFSB
UJWB-B$/#FTBDUVBMNFOUFMBSFTQPO
TBCMFEFEFmOJSMBQPMUJDBNFYJDBOBRVF
QMBOUFBFTUBEJTDJQMJOB4VTPCKFUJWPTTPO
FTUBCMFDFSMBTQPMUJDBTQCMJDBTEFTBMVE
WJODVMBEBTDPOMBCJPUJDB GVOHJSDPNP
SHBOP EF DPOTVMUB OBDJPOBM TPCSF UF
NBT FTQFDmDPT EF CJPUJDB Z QSPQJDJBS
EFCBUFTTPCSFDVFTUJPOFTCJPUJDBTDPOMB
QBSUJDJQBDJOEFMPTEJWFSTPTTFDUPSFTEF
MBTPDJFEBE FOUSFPUSPT
"MBNVFSUFEFTVQSJNFSQSFTJEFOUFFKF
DVUJWP 'FSOBOEP$BOP7BMMFTFFODBSH
EFTVEJSFDDJO DSFBOEPMBSFWJTUB4VN
NB #JPUJDB  SHBOP PmDJBM EF EJGVTJO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EFMB$/#1PTUFSJPSNFOUF +VBO(BS
[B3BNPTBTVNJEFGPSNBJOUFSJOBTV
TFDSFUBSBFKFDVUJWB IBTUBRVF FO 
(VJMMFSNP 4PCFSO"DFWFEP PDVQ FM
QVFTUPEFEJSFDUPSFKFDVUJWP DBSHPRVF
EFTFNQFBBDUVBMNFOUF
&OUSF MPT MPHSPT NT JNQPSUBOUFT EF
MB $/# TF FODVFOUSBO MB PSHBOJ[BDJO
EFTJFUFDPOHSFTPT FOUSFZ
i#JPUJDB 4BMVE %FSFDIPT)VNBOPTZ
3FTQPOTBCJMJEBE $JFOUmDBw i-B $VM
UVSB #JPUJDB QBSB FM %FTBSSPMMP )V
NBOPwi-B#JPUJDBFO'JOEFM4JHMPZ
)BDJBFM/VFWP.JMFOJPwi-B#JPUJDB
EFMBT$JFODJBTQBSBFM%FTBSSPMMPEFMB
$PODJFODJB )VNBOBw i#JPUJDB EF
MPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTEFMB7JEB)VNB
OB%FMB"VSPSBBM0DBTPEFMB7JEBw
i#JPUJDBFOMB$BMJEBEEFMB"UFODJO
.EJDBw Zi#JPUJDBFOMB$JFODJBZMB
4PDJFEBEw
%F MPT TFJT QSJNFSPT DPOHSFTPT TF QV
CMJDBSPO TVT SFTQFDUJWBT NFNPSJBT Z TF
DPOU DPO MB QBSUJDJQBDJO BDUJWB EF
WBSJBT VOJWFSTJEBEFT NFYJDBOBT Z EFM
FYUSBOKFSP  BEFNT EF VO TJOONFSP
EF PSHBOJTNPT OBDJPOBMFT DPNP MB 4F
DSFUBSB EF 4BMVE 44"
 FM *OTUJUVUP
.FYJDBOPEFM4FHVSP4PDJBM *.44
FM
*OTUJUVUP EF 4FHVSJEBE Z 4FSWJDJPT 4P
DJBMFT EF MPT 5SBCBKBEPSFT EFM &TUBEP 
*4445&
FM4JTUFNB/BDJPOBMQBSBFM
%FTBSSPMMP*OUFHSBMEFMB'BNJMJB %*'

MBT 4FDSFUBSBT EF 4BMVE EF $IJBQBT 
%JTUSJUP'FEFSBM +BMJTDPZ/VFWP-FO 
ZFM$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPTF*OWFTUJHBDJP
OFTEF#JPUJDBEF(VBEBMBKBSB $&*#

FOUSFPUSPT





1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB(FSBSEP+JNOF[ $TBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP

&O FM NCJUP JOUFSOBDJPOBM  DPOUSJCV


ZFSPO B MB SFBMJ[BDJO EF MBT SFVOJPOFT
MB 0SHBOJ[BDJO .VOEJBM EF MB 4BMVE
0.4
 MB 0SHBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJ
DBOB EF MB 4BMVE 014
 FM 'POEP EF
MBT /BDJPOFT 6OJEBT QBSB MB *OGBODJB
6/*$&'
MB'FEFSBDJO-BUJOPBNFSJ
DBOB EF *OTUJUVDJPOFT EF #JPUJDB '&
-"*#&
MB"TPDJBDJO*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF
.EJDPTQBSBMB1SFWFODJOEFMB(VF
SSB/VDMFBS *11/8
ZFM.PWJNJFOUP
6OJWFSTBMEFMB3FTQPOTBCJMJEBE$JFOU
mDB .634.YJDP

%FMBTNFNPSJBTEFMPTFWFOUPTTFJOmF
SFOQVOUPTEFDPOFYJOFOUSFMBCJPUJDB
ZMBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEDJFOUmDB SFTBMUBOEP
RVFVOPEFMPTSBTHPTNTDBSBDUFSTUJDPT
EFMBUFDOPDJFODJBNPEFSOBDPOTJTUFFO
RVFTVEFTBSSPMMPTFEBFONFEJPEFDPO
USPWFSTJBTTPDJBMFTZDPOnJDUPTEFWBMPSFT
FOUSFMPTEJWFSTPTBHFOUFTRVFQBSUJDJQBO
FOTVDPOGPSNBDJO FTEFDJS DPOnJDUPT
FOUSF MPT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT Z MB TPDJFEBE 
QVFTUPRVFMBSFMBDJOEFTUBDPOFMQP
EFSUFDOPDJFOUmDPTFIBNPEJmDBEP EF
MBTJNQMFBDFQUBDJOQBTJWBZMBDPOmBO
[BQMFOB TFIBQBTBEPBMBQSFPDVQBDJO
FJOUFSTQPSDPOUSPMBSTVTQPTJCMFTFGFD
UPTOFHBUJWPT
"VOBT FOMPTEJWFSTPT
DPOHSFTPTTFQVOUVBMJ[RVFFTUFNBSDP
EFDPOUSPWFSTJBTTPDJBMFTOPFTEFMUPEP
OVFWPZRVFUBNCJOIBCBTJEPTJHOJ
mDBUJWPFOFMDBTPEFMPTEFCBUFTBDFSDB
EFMBTFHVSJEBEEFMBJOEVTUSJBOVDMFBS 
MB JOEVTUSJB RVNJDB P MB GBSNBDVUJDB
TFIBBHVEJ[BEPEFCJEPBMNBZPSJOUFST
TPDJBMFOMPTSJFTHPTQBSBFMNFEJPBN
CJFOUFZMBTBMVEIVNBOBRVFDPOMMFWBO
MBTSFBMJ[BDJPOFTUFDOPDJFOUmDBT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&O FTUPT TJFUF DPOHSFTPT QBSUJDJQBSPO


NTEFDPOGFSFODJBOUFTQSPDFEFOUFT
EF MVHBSFT DPNP "MFNBOJB  "SHFOUJOB 
#MHJDB #SBTJM $BOBE $IJMF $PMPN
CJB $PTUB3JDB $VCB &&66 &TQBB 
'SBODJB  (VBUFNBMB  *OEJB  *OHMBUFSSB 
+BQO  .YJDP  /VFWB ;FMBOEB  1BOB
N 1FS 1PSUVHBM 1VFSUP3JDP 3FQ
CMJDB%PNJOJDBOB 6SVHVBZZ7FOF[VF
MBUPEPTFMMPTBDBENJDPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT
Z FTQFDJBMJTUBT QFSUFOFDJFOUFT B MBT NT
EJWFSTBTSFBTEFMTBCFSIVNBOP
-B$/#EF.YJDP CBKPMBEJSFDDJOEF
(VJMMFSNP4PCFSO"DFWFEP IBUFOJEP
BDUVBDJPOFT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT JNQPSUBO
UFTQPSFKFNQMP GVFMBSFQSFTFOUBOUFEF
.YJDPQBSBDPMBCPSBS KVOUPDPOFM$P
NJU *OUFSHVCFSOBNFOUBM EF &YQFSUPT
FO#JPUJDB $*(#
ZMB6/&4$0FOMB
FMBCPSBDJOEFMB%FDMBSBDJO6OJWFSTBM
EF#JPUJDBZ%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT
.T SFDJFOUFNFOUF  MB $/# QBSUJDJQ
FOFMQSPZFDUP-BUJO"NFSJDBOBOE&V
SPQFBO&UIJDBM3FHVMBUJPO4ZTUFNTPG#JP
NFEJDBM3FTFBSDI$PNQBSBUJWF"OBMZTJTPG
UIFJS1FSUJOFODFBOE"QQMJDBUJPOGPS)V
NBO 4VCKFDUT 1SPUFDUJPO &6-"#03

RVFTVSHJBQBSUJSEFMJOUFSTEFEJWFS
TPT QBTFT FVSPQFPT Z MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT
EFFTUVEJBSBGPOEPTVTTJTUFNBTEFUJDB
FOJOWFTUJHBDJO DPNQBSUJSFYQFSJFODJBT
ZEJTFBSOVFWPTFTRVFNBTQBSBSFTPMWFS
MPTEJMFNBTRVFQMBOUFBMBJOWFTUJHBDJO
CJPNEJDB
$SFFNPTRVFFMNBZPSSFUPCJPUJDPFO
.YJDP FT GPNFOUBS MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
Z FOTFBO[B DJFOUmDB FODBV[BEB FO FM
DBNJOP EF MB UJDB 1PS UBOUP  EFCF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

NPT EFTQMFHBS FTGVFS[PT QBSB NFKPSBS


MB DPNQSFOTJO EF MPT QSPHSFTPT DJFO
UmDPTBMDBO[BEPTFOUFSSFOPTUBOOPWF
EPTPTDPNPMPTEFMBHFOUJDBIVNBOB
&T JNQPSUBOUF MB QBSUJDJQBDJO EF MBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFT FEVDBUJWBT  TPCSF UPEP FO
MPTQBTFTFOEFTBSSPMMPDPNPFMOVFTUSP 
QBSB MB QSPNPDJO Z MB NPEFSOJ[BDJO
EFMBFOTFBO[BEFMBDJFODJBZEFMBCJP
UJDB

-BCJPUJDBFOMPTQSPHSBNBTEF
FTUVEJPEFMPTDFOUSPTFEVDBUJWPT
&O.YJDPTFJNQBSUFOUSFTMJDFODJBUV
SBT  PDIP NBFTUSBT Z VO EPDUPSBEP FO
#JPUJDBFMSFTUPEFMPTDVSTPT BVORVF
OPTPOFTQFDmDPTFOCJPUJDB TFSFmFSFO
B NBUFSJBT DVSSJDVMBSFT 4F IBO QPEJEP
JEFOUJmDBS  DVSTPT ZP NBUFSJBT SF
MBDJPOBEBTDPOMBCJPUJDB RVFBQBSFDFO
FO EJGFSFOUFT OJWFMFT EF FTUVEJPT DPNP
TPO FM CBDIJMMFSBUP  MJDFODJBUVSB  NBFT
USB  EPDUPSBEP  QPTHSBEPT  TFNJOBSJPT
ZPDVSTPTEFDBQBDJUBDJOZDVSTPTPO
MJOF%FTUPT DVBUSPTPOBEJTUBODJBZ
FMSFTUPTPOQSFTFODJBMFT JNQBSUJOEPTF
FOEFMPTFTUBEPTEFMB3FQCMJDB
.FYJDBOB
"DFSDBEFMBEJTUSJCVDJOQPSSFBT NT
EFMEFMBTNBUFSJBTTFJNQBSUFOFO
MBTGBDVMUBEFTEF.FEJDJOB &OGFSNFSB 
0EPOUPMPHB  5SBCBKP 4PDJBM Z 1TJDP
MPHBFMSFTUPFOPUSBTDBSSFSBT&OFTUF
TFOUJEP FM*OTUJUVUPEF.FEJDJOB(FO
NJDB */.&(&/
DPOFMmOEFQSP
NPWFSFMDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMPTQSJODJQJPT
CTJDPTEFMBTDJFODJBTHFONJDBTZTVT
BQMJDBDJPOFTQBSBNFKPSBSFMDVJEBEPEF
MBTBMVE IBJNQMFNFOUBEPEPTDVSTPTEF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

BMUBFTQFDJBMJEBE *OUSPEVDDJOBMB.F
EJDJOB(FONJDBZ"QMJDBDJPOFT(FO
NJDBTFO.FEJDJOB*OUFSOB
ZVODVSTP
EFOUSPEFM1SPHSBNBEF.BFTUSBZ%PD
UPSBEPFO$JFODJBT.EJDBT 0EPOUPM
HJDBTZEFMB4BMVEEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE/B
DJPOBM"VUOPNBEF.YJDP 6/".

"QMJDBDJPOFT(FONJDBTFO1FEJBUSB

VOBNBUFSJBEFFTUVEJPTUJDPT MFHBMFTZ
TPDJBMFTRVFQFSNJUFBMFTUVEJBOUFEFTB
SSPMMBS DSJUFSJPT DMBSPT TPCSF MPT MNJUFT
RVFQMBOUFBTVEFTBSSPMMP

%JWFSTPTHSVQPTDPMFHJBEPTEF
CJPUJDB
"QBSUFEFMB$/#FYJTUFOPUSPTHSVQPT
RVF IBO EFTUBDBEP FO MB DPOmHVSBDJO
EFMBCJPUJDBFO.YJDP/PUPEPTFMMPT
TF BVUPEFOPNJOBO DPNP UBMFT  QFSP 
QPSFMUJQPEFDVFTUJPOFTRVFBCPSEBOP
QPSMBFTUSVDUVSBZUBSFBTEFMPTNJTNPT 
CJFO QVFEFO JODMVJSTF DPNP HSVQPT EF
FTUVEJPTCJPUJDPT

 $PNJTJO /BDJPOBM TPCSF FM (F
OPNB )VNBOP 'VF DSFBEB FM 
EF PDUVCSF EF  DPO FM PCKFUP
EF BTFTPSBS BM 4FDSFUBSJP EF 4BMVE
FOEJGVTJOEFQPMUJDBTZBDDJPOFT
SFMBUJWBT B MB JOWFTUJHBDJO Z FOTF
BO[BEFMBTDVFTUJPOFTSFMBUJWBTBM
HFOPNB IVNBOP &TUVWP JOUFHSB
EB QPS TFJT DPNJUT  VOP EF FMMPT
EFEJDBEPBMFTUVEJPEFMPTBTVOUPT
UJDPT MFHBMFTZTPDJBMFT DPOGPSNB
EP QPS MPT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT 3VCO
-:PVSLPXJU[LZ .BSDJB."MCB
.FESBOP .BSDP"OUPOJP"$BT
UJMMP "MFTTBOESB$$BOUPOJZ7D
UPS . .BSUOF[ #VMMF(PZSJ -B





1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB(FSBSEP+JNOF[ $TBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP

$PNJTJOGVFEJTVFMUBFMEFBHPT
UPEFQPSEFDSFUPQSFTJEFODJBM
FO WJSUVE EF MB DSFBDJO EFM */&
.&(&/

 'VOEBDJO .FYJDBOB QBSB MB 4B
MVE "$ '6/4"-6%
 &T VOB
BTPDJBDJO DJWJM  TJO mOFT EF MVDSP
Z BM TFSWJDJP EF MB DPNVOJEBE  JO
DMVJEB FO FM 3FHJTUSP /BDJPOBM EF
*OTUJUVDJPOFT Z &NQSFTBT $JFOUm
DBT Z 5FDOPMHJDBT 3&/*&$:5

EFM$POTFKP/BDJPOBMEF$JFODJBZ
5FDOPMPHB $0/"$:5
4VNJ
TJOFTDPOUSJCVJSBMDPOPDJNJFOUP
DJFOUmDPZUFDOPMHJDPZBMFTUVEJP
EF QPMUJDBT FO NBUFSJB EF TBMVE 
NFEJBOUF FM JNQVMTP EF MB JOWFT
UJHBDJO  MB GPSNBDJO EF SFDVSTPT
IVNBOPTEFBMUPOJWFMZFMEFTBSSP
MMPUFDOPMHJDP

)B SFBMJ[BEP  FTUVEJPT TPCSF FM
iFTUBEP EFM BSUFw FO EJTUJOUPT QSP
CMFNBT EF TBMVE  EFTUBDOEPTF MPT
QSPZFDUPT FO OVUSJDJO  FEVDBDJO
QBSBMBTBMVEZNFEJDJOBHFONJDB
&OFTUFMUJNPUFNB EVSBOUFMBHFT
UJOEF(VJMMFSNP4PCFSO '6/
4"-6% QBSUJDJQ BDUJWBNFOUF 
KVOUPDPO+VMJP'SFOL.PSBoUJUVMBS
EFMB44"FOUSFZoZ(F
SBSEP+JNOF[4ODIF[oQSFTJEFOUF
EFM$POTPSDJP1SPNPUPSEFMB.F
EJDJOB(FONJDBFO.YJDPo FOMB
DSFBDJOEFM*/.&(&/

 (SVQP EFM 1SPZFDUP 6OJWFSTJUBSJP
EFM(FOPNB)VNBOP 16()
EF
MB 6/". $VFOUB DPO VO HSVQP
NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJPEFJOWFTUJHBDJO
TPCSFFMHFOPNBIVNBOP RVFEJSJ
HFZBSUJDVMBMPTFTGVFS[PTRVFWJFOF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

SFBMJ[BOEP FTUB VOJWFSTJEBE TPCSF


FTUFUFNBZPUSPTBmOFT&M16()
JODMVZFQSPZFDUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJO
NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSEFBQPZPUFDOPM
HJDPZBDUJWJEBEFTEFGPSNBDJOEF
SFDVSTPT IVNBOPT  FOUSFOBNJFOUP
Z DBQBDJUBDJO  BT DPNP EJGVTJO
FO MB DPNVOJEBE VOJWFSTJUBSJB EF
UFNBTEFCJPUJDB

 $PNJTJO *OUFSTFDSFUBSJBM EF #JP
TFHVSJEBE EF MPT 0SHBOJTNPT (F
OUJDBNFOUF.PEJmDBEPT $*#*0
(&.
 &T FM HSVQP FTQFDJBMJ[BEP
EFJOGPSNBDJOTPCSFTFHVSJEBEEF
MB CJPUFDOPMPHB RVF TF FODVFOUSB
EFOUSPEFMTJTUFNBEFM$POWFOJPEF
%JWFSTJEBE#JPMHJDB&TUJOUFHSB
EBQPSDJFOUmDPTZFYQFSUPTTPCSF
CJPUFDOPMPHB NPEFSOB Z CJPTFHV
SJEBE ZQPSSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFFN
QSFTBSJPT  TPDJFEBE DJWJM Z DNBSBT
EFDPNFSDJP

 /DMFP EF &TUVEJPT EF 4BMVE Z
%FSFDIP /&4%
 EFM *OTUJUVUP
EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT +VSEJDBT EF MB
6/". 'VOEBEP FO  QPS
'FSOBOEP $BOP 7BMMF  WJODVMB EJ
WFSTPT EJTDVSTPT Z NFUPEPMPHBT
QPS NFEJP EF MB CJPUJDB Z MPT SF
MBDJPOBDPOFM%FSFDIP"MPMBSHP
EF MPT MUJNPT  BPT  FM /&4%
IBMPHSBEPSFVOJSBVOTJOONFSP
EFFTQFDJBMJTUBTEFEJGFSFOUFTQBSUFT
EFM NVOEP FO FWFOUPT JOUFSOBDJP
OBMFT  TFNJOBSJPT  DPMPRVJPT  DVS
TPT DPOGFSFODJBTZDMBVTUSPTBDBE
NJDPT&TUFDFOUSPUJFOFVOBEFMBT
NTQSFTUJHJPTBTDBTBTFEJUPSJBMFTFO
UFNBT KVSEJDPT WJODVMBEPT DPO MB
CJPUJDB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB


 (SVQP*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSEF#JPUJDB
EFMB6OJWFSTJEBE"VUOPNB.F
USPQPMJUBOB $BNQVT 9PDIJNJMDP
6".9
 %FTEF FOFSP EF  
IB SFBMJ[BEP NT EF VOB WFJOUFOB
EFDPOGFSFODJBTSFMBUJWBTBMBDJFODJB
HFONJDB Z B TV JNQBDUP TPDJBM Z
CJPUJDP

 (SVQP EFM *OTUJUVUP 5FDOPMHJDP
"VUOPNP EF .YJDP *5".

$PO VOB JEFOUJEBE BCJFSUBNFOUF
MBJDB TFIBEFTUBDBEPQPSTFSFMQSJ
NFSDFOUSPEFFTUVEJPTKVSEJDPTFO
JNQMFNFOUBS VO DVSTP EF CJPUJDB
EJSJHJEP B BCPHBEPT &TUF NJTNP
HSVQP IB SFBMJ[BEP BMHVOBT QVCMJ
DBDJPOFTFTQFDJBMJ[BEBTFOMBEJTDJ
QMJOB

 (SVQPEF&TUVEJPT#JPUJDPTEFMB
6OJWFSTJEBE 1BOBNFSJDBOB 61

)B SFVOJEP B FTQFDJBMJTUBT FO MBT
SFBT EF NFEJDJOB  mMPTPGB Z %F
SFDIPQBSBIBDFSFTUVEJPTCJPUJDPT
EFTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBDSJTUJBOBQFSTP
OBMJTUB

 (SVQP EF &TUVEJPT EF MB 6OJWFS
TJEBE "OIVBD %F mMPTPGB DPO
TFSWBEPSB  IB TJEP QJPOFSB FO FM
FTUVEJP EF MB CJPUJDB FO OVFTUSP
QBT&TUFHSVQPGVOE EFOUSPEF
TVVOJWFSTJEBE MBTFHVOEBGBDVMUBE
EF CJPUJDB EFM NVOEP  QSFDFEJEB
OJDBNFOUFQPSMBEFM"UFOFP3FHJ
OB "QPTUPMPSVN EF 3PNB  JNQBS
UJOEPTF MJDFODJBUVSB  NBFTUSB Z
EPDUPSBEP

 *OTUJUVUP 1PMJUDOJDP /BDJPOBM
*1/
 +VOUP DPO MB 6/".  FT
VOB JOTUJUVDJO FEVDBUJWB MBJDB 
HSBUVJUB  MEFS FO MB HFOFSBDJO 

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

BQMJDBDJO EJGVTJOZUSBOTGFSFODJB
EFM DPOPDJNJFOUP DJFOUmDP Z UFD
OPMHJDP DSFBEBQBSBDPOUSJCVJSBM
EFTBSSPMMPFDPONJDP TPDJBMZQP
MUJDPEFMBOBDJO'PSNBJOUFHSBM
NFOUF QSPGFTJPOBMFT FO MPT OJWFMFT
NFEJPTVQFSJPS TVQFSJPSZQPTHSB
EP SFBMJ[BJOWFTUJHBDJOZFYUJFOEF
B MB TPDJFEBE TVT SFTVMUBEPT  DPO
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE UJDB  UPMFSBODJB Z
DPNQSPNJTP TPDJBM "VORVF FTUB
JOTUJUVDJOOPUJFOFVOOJDPHSV
QP EF CJPUJDB  SFDJFOUFNFOUF IB
DSFBEP MB .BFTUSB EF $JFODJBT FO
#JPUJDB

 %FQBSUBNFOUPEF&TUVEJPTF*OWFT
UJHBDJPOFT EF #JPUJDB $&*#
 EFM
*OTUJUVUP5FDOPMHJDPZEF&TUVEJPT
4VQFSJPSFTEF0DDJEFOUF *5&40

$VFOUBDPOMBFTQFDJBMJEBEFOCJP
UJDB JNQBSUJEBFOUSFTBPT EFOUSP
EFMQSPHSBNBEFNBFTUSBT

 $FOUSPEF&TUVEJPTUJDPT -FHBMFT
Z 4PDJBMFT EFM *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM
EF .FEJDJOB (FONJDB &-4*
*/.&(&/
4FFODVFOUSBFOQF
SPEPEFJEFOUJmDBDJOZTFMFDDJO
EF SFDVSTPT IVNBOPT QBSB SFBMJ[BS
JOWFTUJHBDJPOFTBMUBNFOUFFTQFDJBMJ
[BEBT1SFUFOEFTFSVOBIFSSBNJFO
UB EF BQPZP EFM */.&(&/ QBSB
BCPSEBSMPTBTQFDUPTUJDPT MFHBMFT
ZTPDJBMFTEFMBNFEJDJOBHFONJDB
EF VOB NBOFSB QSDUJDB Z UFSJDB
&MMPQFSNJUJSJODSFNFOUBSMBDPO
DJFODJBQCMJDBSFTQFDUPEFMPTQSP
DFEJNJFOUPTZQSPEVDUPTBTPDJBEPT
DPOMBFWBMVBDJOFONBUFSJBEFJO
WFTUJHBDJOZEPDFODJBFONFEJDJOB
HFONJDBZSFBTBmOFT





1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB(FSBSEP+JNOF[ $TBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP

%FOUSP EF MPT MPHSPT NT JNQPSUBOUFT


EFM&-4*TFFODVFOUSBMBDPOTPMJEBDJO
EFBMJBO[BTFTUSBUHJDBTDPOFM1SPHSBNB
EF &TUVEJPT -FHBMFT EF MB 'BDVMUBE EF
.FEJDJOBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE7BOEFSCJMU 
EJSJHJEPQPS&MMFO8SJHIU$MBZUPO MEFS
FOFMDBNQPEFMEFSFDIPZMBHFOUJDBZ
VOB EFTUBDBEB BTFTPSB EFM HPCJFSOP EF
&&66DPOFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDBEF
MB0140.4ZFM$FOUSP*OUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO#JPUJDBEFMB6OJ
WFSTJEBEEF$IJMF BNCPTEJSJHJEPTQPS
'FSOBOEP -PMBT 4UFQLF DPO FM 1VCMJD
1PQVMBUJPO 1SPKFDU JO (FOPNJDT 1(

FTQFDJBMNFOUFFOFMHSVQPJOUFSOBDJPOBM
EFUSBCBKP&UIJDT DPOTFEFFO$BOBE Z
DVZBDPPSEJOBDJOTFFODVFOUSBBDBSHP
EF#BSUIB.BSB,OPQQFST
-BTPNJTJPOFTTPOJOFWJUBCMFT QFSPIF
NPTUPNBEPDPNPSFGFSFODJBBMPTHSV
QPTRVFZBUJFOFOVOBUSBEJDJOTMJEBZ
RVFFOUSFTVTBDUJWJEBEFTTFFODVFOUSBMB
EF QVCMJDBS EPDVNFOUPT Z BSUDVMPT FO
SFWJTUBTZMJCSPT-PRVFTUFOFNPTDMBSP
FTRVFUPEPTMPTHSVQPTBZVEBOBDSFBS
VOB DPODJFODJB HFOFSBMJ[BEB EF RVF FT
JNQSFTDJOEJCMF FM EJMPHP JOUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJP FOUSF MPT EJWFSTPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT
QBSBUSBUBSMPTUFNBTEFCJPUJDB

-BCJPUJDBZMPTDFOUSPTEF
JOWFTUJHBDJOFO.YJDP
/P UFOFNPT FM EBUP FYBDUP EF DVO
UPT DFOUSPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJO CJPNEJDB
PQFSBODPOVOB$PNJTJOEFUJDB4F
EFUFDU RVF EFOUSP EF MB 6/". Z FO
FM*1/PQFSBOEJWFSTPTHSVQPTEFJOWFT
UJHBDJO DJFOUmDB RVF NBOUJFOFO VOB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

SFEEFDPNVOJDBDJODPOQSPGFTJPOBMFT
EFEJWFSTBTSFBTZSFBMJ[BOGPSPTEFCJP
UJDB
&OFMTFDUPSEFMPT*OTUJUVUPT/BDJPOBMFT
EF4BMVE EFQFOEJFOUFTEFMB44" FM*OT
UJUVUPEF$BODFSPMPHB FMEF&OGFSNF
EBEFT3FTQJSBUPSJBT FMEF$JFODJBT.
EJDBT Z /VUSJDJO i4BMWBEPS ;VCJSBOi 
FM *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM EF 4BMVE 1CMJDB
Z FM *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM EF .FEJDJOB
(FONJDB */.&(&/
TPOMPTOJDPT
RVFDVFOUBOBDUVBMNFOUFDPODPNJTJP
OFTEFUJDB DPOVOONFSPNOJNPEF
TFJTNJFNCSPTZVONYJNPEFEPDF
'VFSBEFMNCJUPEFMPT*OTUJUVUPT/B
DJPOBMFTEF4BMVEZEFBDVFSEPDPOJO
GPSNBDJOQSPQPSDJPOBEBQPSMB$PNJ
TJO 'FEFSBM QBSB MB 1SPUFDDJO DPOUSB
3JFTHPT 4BOJUBSJPT $0'&13*4
 FYJT
UFOBMSFEFEPSEFJOTUJUVDJPOFTTBOJUB
SJBT UBOUPQCMJDBTDPNPQSJWBEBT RVF
UJFOFOSFHJTUSBEBBOUFMB$0'&13*4TVT
SFTQFDUJWBTDPNJTJPOFTEFUJDB MBTRVF 
FO BMHVOBT PDBTJPOFT  SFBMJ[BO GVODJP
OFTEFDPNJUTBTJTUFODJBMFTEFCJPUJDB
%FCFNPTSFDPOPDFSRVFBOTPOJOTVm
DJFOUFT TJUFOFNPTFODVFOUBRVFFTNV
DITJNPNBZPSFMONFSPEFIPTQJUBMFT
F JOTUJUVDJPOFT RVF SFBMJ[BO JOWFTUJHB
DJODPOTFSFTIVNBOPTFO.YJDP

-BCJPUJDBFOFMTJTUFNBMFHBM
&O.YJDPTPONVDIBTMBTMFZFTRVFTF
SFmFSFOBEJWFSTPTBTQFDUPTDBUBMPHBEPT
QPS MPT FTQFDJBMJTUBT DPNP QSPCMFNBT
CJPUJDPT 4F TFBMBSO MBT NT JNQPS
UBOUFT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

&O MB $POTUJUVDJO 1PMUJDB EF MPT &T


UBEPT 6OJEPT .FYJDBOPT $1&6.

IBZ EJWFSTBT EJTQPTJDJPOFT SFMBUJWBT B
UFNBT CJPUJDPT  UBMFT DPNP FM EFSFDIP
BM EFTBSSPMMP DJFOUmDP  BQFHBEP B MPT
QSJODJQJPTDJFOUmDPTZUJDPT FMDVBMTF
USBEVDFFOMBPCMJHBDJOEFQSPNPWFSZ
BQPZBSMBJOWFTUJHBDJODJFOUmDBZUFD
OPMHJDB "SU   GSBDDJO 7
 -B -FZ
EF$JFODJBZ5FDOPMPHB -$Z5
SFHMB
NFOUBSJBEFMBGSBDDJO7EFMBSUDVMP
EFMB$1&6. UJFOFQPSPCKFUPSFHVMBS
MPTBQPZPTRVFFMHPCJFSOPGFEFSBMFTU
PCMJHBEPBPUPSHBSBMPTJOWFTUJHBEPSFT 
QBSBJNQVMTBS GPSUBMFDFSZEFTBSSPMMBSMB
JOWFTUJHBDJODJFOUmDBZUFDOPMHJDBEFM
QBT
6OP EF MPT QSJODJQJPT RVF FTUBCMFDF MB
-$Z5 FT RVF FM HPCJFSOP GFEFSBM FTU
PCMJHBEPBOPBGFDUBSMBMJCFSUBEEFJO
WFTUJHBDJO DJFOUmDB Z UFDOPMHJDB  TJO
QFSKVJDJPEFMBSFHVMBDJOPMJNJUBDJPOFT
RVF QPSNPUJWPTEFTFHVSJEBE EFTBMVE 
EFUJDBPEFDVBMRVJFSPUSBDBVTBEFJO
UFSTQCMJDP EFUFSNJOFOMBTEJTQPTJDJP
OFTMFHBMFT "SU 'SBDD9

-B-FZ(FOFSBMEF4BMVE -(4
TFBMB
UBNCJORVFFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBFOTFBO
[BZMBJOWFTUJHBDJODJFOUmDBZUFDOPM
HJDBQBSBMBTBMVETPOJNQPSUBOUFTQBSB
MBOBDJO "SU 'SBDD7**
$POUJFOF
VOUUVMPFTQFDJBM EFEJDBEPBMBJOWFTUJ
HBDJO QBSB MB TBMVE  EJWJEJEP FO PDIP
BSUDVMPT  MPT DVBMFT DPOUFNQMBO RVF
FTUBDMBTFEFJOWFTUJHBDJODPNQSFOEFFM
EFTBSSPMMPEFBDDJPOFTRVFDPOUSJCVZBO
BMDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMPTQSPDFTPTCJPMHJ
DPTZQTJDPMHJDPTFOMPTTFSFTIVNBOPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

FMDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMPTWODVMPTFOUSFMBT
DBVTBTEFFOGFSNFEBE MBQSDUJDBNEJ
DBZMBFTUSVDUVSBTPDJBMMBQSFWFODJOZ
DPOUSPM EF MPT QSPCMFNBT EF TBMVE RVF
TFDPOTJEFSFOQSJPSJUBSJPTQBSBMBQPCMB
DJO FM DPOPDJNJFOUP Z DPOUSPM EF MPT
FGFDUPTOPDJWPTEFMBNCJFOUFFOMBTBMVE
FMFTUVEJPEFMBTUDOJDBTZNUPEPTRVF
TFSFDPNJFOEFOPFNQMFFOQBSBMBQSFT
UBDJOEFTFSWJDJPTEFTBMVE ZMBQSPEVD
DJOOBDJPOBMEFJOTVNPTQBSBMBTBMVE
"SU

-B -FZ EF MPT *OTUJUVUPT /BDJPOBMFT EF
4BMVE -*/4
FTUBCMFDFDPNPVOPEFMPT
PCKFUJWPTQSJNPSEJBMFTEFMQBTGPNFOUBS
MBJOWFTUJHBDJOZFOTFBO[BFONBUFSJB
EFTBMVE DPOFMmOEFEFTDSJCJSZFYQMJ
DBS FM PSJHFO EF MBT FOGFSNFEBEFT  TV
QSFWFODJO  EJBHOTUJDP Z USBUBNJFOUP 
BTDPNPQSPDVSBSMBSFIBCJMJUBDJOEFM
BGFDUBEP  FM NBOUFOJNJFOUP Z QSPUFD
DJOEFMBTBMVEEFMBTQFSTPOBT "SU 
'SBDD**

.YJDP IB DSFBEP VOB SFE FGFDUJWB Z
GVODJPOBM EF *OTUJUVUPT /BDJPOBMFT EF
4BMVE  PSHBOJTNPT EFTDFOUSBMJ[BEPT EF
MB BENJOJTUSBDJO QCMJDB GFEFSBM  DPO
QFSTPOBMJEBEKVSEJDBZQBUSJNPOJPQSP
QJPT BHSVQBEPTFOFMTFDUPSTBMVE RVF
UJFOFO DPNP PCKFUP QSJODJQBM MB JOWFT
UJHBDJO DJFOUmDB EF BMUP OJWFM FO FTUF
DBNQP
0USPUFNBCJPUJDPDPOUFNQMBEPDPOT
UJUVDJPOBMNFOUF FT FM EFSFDIP EF UPEB
QFSTPOBBMBQSPUFDDJOEFMBTBMVE "SU
 $1&6.
RVFTFDVNQMFQPSNFEJP
EFM TJTUFNB EF TFHVSJEBE TPDJBM Z  QBSB





1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB(FSBSEP+JNOF[ $TBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP

RVJFOFT OP UJFOFO BDDFTP BM NJTNP  B


USBWT EFM TJTUFNB EFM TFHVSP QPQVMBS
Z MPT *OTUJUVUPT /BDJPOBMFT EF 4BMVE
-B -(4  SFHMBNFOUBSJB EFM BSUDVMP 
$POTUJUVDJPOBM FTUBCMFDFMBDPODVSSFO
DJB EF MB 'FEFSBDJO Z MPT &TUBEPT FO
NBUFSJBEFTBMVE%FUFSNJOBBMHVOBTEF
MBTSFBTDPOTJEFSBEBTDPNPNBUFSJBEF
TBMVCSJEBEHFOFSBM FOUSFMBTDVBMFTQP
EFNPT EFTUBDBS  DPNP UFNBT QSJPSJUB
SJPTEFCJPUJDB MBPSHBOJ[BDJO DPOUSPM
ZWJHJMBODJBEFMBQSFTUBDJOEFTFSWJDJPT
Z EF FTUBCMFDJNJFOUPT EF TBMVE  MB QSP
UFDDJOTPDJBMFOTBMVE KVTUJDJBEJTUSJCV
UJWB
 MB QMBOJmDBDJO GBNJMJBS  MB TBMVE
NFOUBM MBDPPSEJOBDJOEFMBJOWFTUJHB
DJOQBSBMBTBMVEZFMDPOUSPMEFTUBFO
MPT TFSFT IVNBOPT  FM DPOUSPM TBOJUBSJP
EF MB EJTQPTJDJO EF SHBOPT  UFKJEPT Z
TVTDPNQPOFOUFT DMVMBTZDBEWFSFTEF
TFSFTIVNBOPT
-B -*/4 FTUBCMFDF MB JNQPSUBODJB EF
QSPDVSBS MB SFIBCJMJUBDJO  NBOUFOJ
NJFOUP Z QSPUFDDJO EF MB TBMVE EF MBT
QFSTPOBT 6OP EF MPT NBZPSFT MPHSPT
EF MPT *OTUJUVUPT FT FM EF QSPQPSDJPOBS
DPOTVMUBFYUFSOB BUFODJOIPTQJUBMBSJBZ
TFSWJDJPTEFVSHFODJBTBMBQPCMBDJORVF
SFRVJFSBBUFODJONEJDBFOTVTSFBTEF
FTQFDJBMJ[BDJO IBTUBFMMNJUFEFTVDB
QBDJEBEJOTUBMBEB
$POTUJUVDJPOBMNFOUF TFSFDPOPDFUBN
CJO FM EFSFDIP B VO NFEJP BNCJFOUF
BEFDVBEP "SU   $1&6.
 &TUF BS
UDVMPEFMB-FZEF#JPTFHVSJEBEEF0S
HBOJTNPT (FOUJDBNFOUF .PEJmDBEPT
-#0(.
UJFOFFMPCKFUJWPEFSFEVDJS
BMNYJNPMPTQPTJCMFTSJFTHPTEFMBNB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

OJQVMBDJO HFOUJDB Z BT QSFWFOJS RVF


TFBBGFDUBEBMBTBMVEIVNBOB MBEJWFS
TJEBECJPMHJDB FMNFEJPBNCJFOUFZMB
TBOJEBEWFHFUBM BOJNBMZBDVDPMB
&MSFBEF%FSFDIP1FOBMDPOUJFOFEJT
QPTJDJPOFT EJTQFSTBT 1PS FKFNQMP  TF
DPOUFNQMBMBQSPIJCJDJOEFMBFVUBOB
TJBFOUPEPTMPT&TUBEPTEFMB3FQCMJDB
TJO FNCBSHP  FO NBUFSJB EF BCPSUP  FO
USFDFFTUBEPTTFQFSNJUFFMDBVTBEPQPS
NPUJWPT FVHFOTJDPT Z FO EJF[ TF FTUB
CMFDF DPNP BUFOVBOUF P FYJNFOUF EF
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEFMDBVTBEPDPONPUJWPT
EFVOBUDOJDBEFSFQSPEVDDJOBSUJmDJBM
OPDPOTFOUJEBQPSMBNVKFS
&M $EJHP 1FOBM EFM %JTUSJUP 'FEFSBM 
FO TV -JCSP 4FHVOEP  TFBMB EJTQPTJ
DJPOFT RVF DPOUFNQMBO TBODJPOFT QBSB
MPT EFMJUPT CJPUFDOPMHJDPT  QSPIJCJFO
EP DPOEVDUBT DPNP MB EJTQPTJDJO EF
HBNFUPT OP BVUPSJ[BEB  MBT UDOJDBT EF
SFQSPEVDDJOBTJTUJEBOPDPOTFOUJEB MB
NBOJQVMBDJO HFOUJDB DPO mOFT FVHF
OTJDPTZMBDMPOBDJOIVNBOBDPOmOFT
SFQSPEVDUJWPT7FSBDSV[Z$IJBQBTIBO
FTUBCMFDJEP FO TVT SFTQFDUJWPT DEJHPT
QFOBMFTMBTNJTNBTTBODJPOFT
&ONBUFSJBDJWJMTFIBFTUBCMFDJEPRVFFO
MPTKVJDJPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJOEFMBQBUFS
OJEBETFBENJUFOMBTQSVFCBTCJPMHJDBT
"TJNJTNP FODBTJUPEBTMBTEJTQPTJDJP
OFTDJWJMFTEFMQBTTFIBDFBMVTJOBMBT
DPOTFDVFODJBTKVSEJDBTEFSJWBEBTEFMPT
NUPEPTEFGFDVOEBDJOBTJTUJEB
4PONVDIPTMPTSFHMBNFOUPTEFSJWBEPT
EF MBT EJTQPTJDJPOFT NFODJPOBEBT RVF
OP IBO TJEP OPNCSBEPT 1PS FKFNQMP 





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

FM 3FHMBNFOUP FO NBUFSJB EF $POUSPM


4BOJUBSJPEFMBEJTQPTJDJOEFSHBOPT 
5FKJEPTZ$BEWFSFTEF4FSFT)VNBOPT 
FMDVBMFTEFBQMJDBDJOFOUPEBMB3FQ
CMJDBNFYJDBOBZSFHVMBMPTBWBODFTDJFO
UmDPTMPHSBEPTFONBUFSJBEFUSBTQMBOUFT
EFSHBOPTZUFKJEPTFOTFSFTIVNBOPT 
DPNPNFEJPUFSBQVUJDP BWFDFTOJDP 
QBSBDPOTFSWBSMBWJEBZMBTBMVEEFMBT
QFSTPOBT

SJFTHPTBMPTRVFTFTPNFUFS DPOMBDB
QBDJEBEEFMJCSFFMFDDJOZTJODPBDDJO
BMHVOB "SU


&MPUSPSFHMBNFOUPEFTVNBJNQPSUBODJB
FTFMEFMB-(4FONBUFSJBEF*OWFTUJHB
DJOQBSBMB4BMVE FMDVBMQSPWFF FOMB
FTGFSB BENJOJTUSBUJWB  FM DVNQMJNJFOUP
EFMB-(4FOMPSFGFSFOUFBMBJOWFTUJHB
DJOQBSBMBTBMVEFOMPTTFDUPSFTQCMJDP 
TPDJBMZQSJWBEP "SUEFMSFHMBNFOUP

"EFNT FTUBCMFDFMPTMJOFBNJFOUPTUJDPT
RVF EFCFSO TFHVJSTF FO MPT QSPUPDPMPT
EFJOWFTUJHBDJOFOMPTDVBMFTQBSUJDJQFO
TFSFTIVNBOPTDPNPTVKFUPTEFJOWFTUJ
HBDJO "SUEFMSFHMBNFOUP


-BCJPUJDBFOMBKVSJTQSVEFODJB

&OUSFPUSPTQSJODJQJPTRVFJNQPOFFMSF
HMBNFOUPTFFODVFOUSBOFMEFSFTQFUPEF
MBQSJWBDJEBE "SU
EFTFHVSJEBEEF
MBTQFSTPOBTTVKFUBTBJOWFTUJHBDJO "SU

EFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFMPTJOWFTUJHB
EPSFT "SU
ZEFMJCFSUBEQBSBQBSUJDJ
QBSFOVOBJOWFTUJHBDJO "SU
&TUF
MUJNP SFDPHJEPEFEFDMBSBDJPOFTJOUFS
OBDJPOBMFT TFUSBEVDFFO MB USBEJDJPOBM
GSNVMBEFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEP 
FMDVBMFTEFmOJEPFOOVFTUSBMFHJTMBDJO
DPNPFMBDVFSEPQPSFTDSJUP NFEJBOUFFM
DVBMFMTVKFUPEFJOWFTUJHBDJOoP FOTV
DBTP TVSFQSFTFOUBOUFMFHBMoBVUPSJ[BTV
QBSUJDJQBDJO DPO QMFOP DPOPDJNJFOUP
EFMBOBUVSBMF[BEFMPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTZ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

/VFTUSPTJTUFNBGFEFSBMBENJUFRVFDBEB
&TUBEPFMBCPSFTVQSPQJBMFHJTMBDJOMP
DBM MPDVBMQPESBHFOFSBSVOTJOONF
SPEFEJTQPTJDJPOFTMFHBMFTRVF TJOEF
OPNJOBSTF CJPUJDBT  UFOESBO JNQBDUP
PTFSFGFSJSBOBUFNBTCJPUJDPT

)BOTJEPQPDPTMPTUFNBTCJPUJDPTSF
TVFMUPT QPS MB WB EF BNQBSP &O FTUF
TFOUJEP  UFOFNPT SFTPMVDJPOFT SFMBUJWBT
BM BCPSUP  MB QSJWBDJEBE HFOUJDB  MBT
QSVFCBT EJBHOTUJDBT Z EF mMJBDJO  FM
USBTQMBOUFEFSHBOPTZMBFVUBOBTJB
&ONBUFSJBEFBCPSUP FYJTUFOSFTP
MVDJPOFT FOUSFMBTDVBMFTTFEFCFOEFT
UBDBSMPTDSJUFSJPTPSJFOUBEPTBQFSNJUJS
FMBCPSUPFVHFOTJDP1PSDSJUFSJPKVSJT
QSVEFODJBMTFFYJNFEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBE
QFOBM DVBOEP  B KVJDJP EF EPT NEJDPT
FTQFDJBMJTUBT FYJTUBSB[OTVmDJFOUFQBSB
EJBHOPTUJDBS RVF FM QSPEVDUP QSFTFO
UB BMUFSBDJPOFT HFOUJDBT P DPOHOJUBT 
MBT DVBMFT QVFEBO EBS DPNP SFTVMUBEP
EBPT GTJDPT P NFOUBMFT Z QPOHBO FO
SJFTHPMBTPCSFWJWFODJBEFMQSPEVDUP&O
UPEP DBTP TF EFCF PCUFOFS FM DPOTFOUJ
NJFOUP MJCSF  JOGPSNBEP Z SFTQPOTBCMF
EF MB NVKFS FNCBSB[BEB  Z MB EFDJTJO
EFCF GVOEBSTF FO VO EJDUBNFO NEJ
DP RVF DPOUFOHB JOGPSNBDJO PCKFUJWB 
WFSB[ TVmDJFOUFZPQPSUVOB 4FNBOBSJP
+VEJDJBM EF MB 'FEFSBDJO Z TV (BDFUB
5PNP97'FCSFSPEF 5FTJT1
+






1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB(FSBSEP+JNOF[ $TBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP

&O NBUFSJB EF HFOUJDB TF FODPOUSBSPO


WFJOUF SFTPMVDJPOFT  MBT DVBMFT  FO US
NJOPT HFOFSBMFT  USBUBO TPCSF BTQFDUPT
SFMBUJWPT B MB QSJWBDJEBE HFOUJDB  FTUB
CMFDJFOEPRVFEFTEFFMNPNFOUPFORVF
TFPGSFDFMBQSVFCBHFOUJDB QBSBTPMV
DJPOBSBMHVOBMJUJTSFMBUJWBBMBmMJBDJO 
TFEFCFODPOUFNQMBSBMHVOPTNFEJPTEF
TFHVSJEBE EF MB QSJWBDJEBE  UBMFT DPNP
DJUBS BM JOEJWJEVP QBSB MB QSDUJDB EF
FYNFOFTFOVOMBCPSBUPSJPQSFWJBNFO
UF BDSFEJUBEP 4FNBOBSJP +VEJDJBM EF MB
'FEFSBDJO Z TV (BDFUB 5PNP 99*7
"HPTUP EF  5FTJT 7*P$ $ 
1HJOB

&O PUSB UFTJT  BNQMJ FM TFOUJEP EF MB
BOUFSJPS  JNQPOJFOEP DPNP MNJUFT EF
DPOUSPMEFMBDDFTPBMBJOGPSNBDJOHF
OUJDBDVBMRVJFSDSJUFSJPDPOTJEFSBEPQPS
FMKV[HBEPSDPOMBmOBMJEBEEFWFMBSQPS
RVFMBQSDUJDBEFEJDIBQFSJDJBMTFMMFWF
B DBCP DPO MBT NFEJEBT EF EJTDSFDJO 
EFSFTFSWBZTBOJUBSJBTQBSBTBMWBHVBSEBS
FMFTUBEPEFTBMVEEFMPTQSPHFOJUPSFTZ
EFM QSPQJP NFOPS 4F FTUBCMFDF RVF MB
JOGPSNBDJO RVF TF PCUFOHB EF EJDIP
QSPDFEJNJFOUPDJFOUmDPTFSDPODSFUBZ
PCKFUJWB ZTFVTBSTMPQBSBSFTPMWFSMB
DVFTUJODPOUSPWFSUJEB 4FNBOBSJP+VEJ
DJBMEFMB'FEFSBDJOZTV(BDFUB5PNP
99**/PWJFNCSFEF5FTJT**P
$$

1PS MP UBOUP  MB QSVFCB HFOUJDB OP TF
EFCFJNQPOFSGPS[PTBNFOUFBRVJFOTF
MF SFQVUB MB mMJBDJO  UFOJFOEP FM EP
OBOUF EF MB NVFTUSB CJPMHJDB EFSFDIP
B OFHBSTF BM EFTBIPHP EF MB NJTNB  FO
DVZPDBTPTFQSFTVNFMBmMJBDJO 4FNB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

OBSJP+VEJDJBMEFMB'FEFSBDJOZTV(BDF
UB5PNP99***&OFSPEF5FTJT
B $$97** 
 0USB JOUFS
QSFUBDJOEFMBTDPSUFTKVEJDJBMFTFTUBCMF
DFFMEFSFDIPEFMPTNFOPSFTEFFEBEB
UFOFS VOB JEFOUJEBE Z PSJHFO HFOUJDP
4FNBOBSJP+VEJDJBMEFMB'FEFSBDJOZTV
(BDFUB5PNP99***&OFSPEF
5FTJTB$$97***

0USP UFNB CJPUJDP EFCBUJEP BNQMJB
NFOUF Z RVF MMFH IBTUB MBT DPSUFT GVF
FMSFMBUJWPBMPTUSBTQMBOUFTEFSHBOPT
"OUFSJPSNFOUF  MB -(4 TFBMBCB DPNP
DSJUFSJPQBSBSFBMJ[BSFMUSBTQMBOUFEFS
HBOPTFOUSFWJWPTMBOFDFTBSJBSFMBDJOEF
QBSFOUFTDPQPSDPOTBOHVJOJEBE QPSBm
OJEBEPDJWJM FOUSFEPOBOUFZSFDFQUPS
MB4VQSFNB$PSUFEF+VTUJDJBEFUFSNJO
RVFEJDIBEJTQPTJDJOWJPMBCBFMEFSFDIP
BMBQSPUFDDJOEFMBTBMVE RVFZBIFNPT
NFODJPOBEP1BSBVOTFDUPSEFMBEPD
USJOBKVSEJDBZCJPUJDB FTUBSFTPMVDJO
GPNFOUB FM DPNFSDJP JMFHBM EF SHBOPT
4FNBOBSJP+VEJDJBMEFMB'FEFSBDJOZTV
(BDFUB5PNP97***"HPTUPEF
5FTJT1*9

1PS MUJNP  TF FODPOUSBSPO EPT SFTPMV
DJPOFTSFMBDJPOBEBTDPOMBFVUBOBTJBRVF 
FOTOUFTJT SFDPOPDFORVFFTUBQSDUJDB 
EFTEFVOQVOUPEFWJTUBNPSBM UJFOFBN
QMJBKVTUJmDBDJOZSFTQBMEPQPSTVJOEV
EBCMFDPOUFOJEPIVNBOPTJOFNCBSHP 
TF MF TBODJPOB QPS TV SFQFSDVTJO FO MB
DPMFDUJWJEBE FODVBOUPTJHOJmDBVOBUFO
UBEPBMBJOWJPMBCJMJEBEIVNBOB 2VJOUB
QPDB*OTUBODJB1SJNFSB4BMB"QOEJDF
5PNP**5FTJT






1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

-BCJPUJDBFOMPTQSPZFDUPT
MFHJTMBUJWPT
&OUSNJOPTHFOFSBMFT FYJTUFOQSPQVFT
UBT QBSB JODMVJS FO MB $1&6. MB QSP
IJCJDJOEFMBEJTDSJNJOBDJOHFOUJDB
&OMB-(4TFRVJFSFJODMVJSMBPCKFDJO
EFDPODJFODJBZDSFBSVODBQUVMPFTQF
DJBMRVFGPNFOUFMBJOWFTUJHBDJODMOJDB
Z CTJDB EF MBT DMVMBT FTUBNJOBMFT EFM
BEVMUPZEFMSFDJOOBDJEP0USBJOJDJB
UJWBJOUFSFTBOUFFTMBRVFPCMJHBSBBMPT
QSPEVDUPSFTEFBMJNFOUPTUSBOTHOFUJDPT
BFUJRVFUBSTVTQSPEVDUPTEFGPSNBDMBSB
ZBMBWJTUBEFMPTDPOTVNJEPSFT
&O PUSBT JOJDJBUJWBT  TF DPOUFNQMB MB
DSFBDJO EF MFZFT OVFWBT 1PS FKFNQMP 
FYJTUFVOBJOJDJBUJWBQBSBDSFBSMB-FZEF
MPT%FSFDIPTEFMPT&OGFSNPT5FSNJOB
MFT MBDVBM TFDPOTUJUVJSBEF BSUDVMPT
Z QFSNJUJSB B FTUPT FOGFSNPT FMBCPSBS
UFTUBNFOUPTWJUBMFTPFKFSDFSFMEFSFDIPB
TPMJDJUBSMBUFSNJOBDJOWPMVOUBSJBEFTV
WJEB  BDUJWB FVUBOBTJB
 P QBTJWBNFOUF
PSUPUBOBTJB

-PT UFNBT CJPUJDPT HFOFSBO QPMNJDB
FOMPTEJGFSFOUFTHSVQPTQBSMBNFOUBSJPT
$PNPDMBSPFKFNQMPUFOFNPTMBFYJTUFO
DJBEFUSFTJOJDJBUJWBTEFMFZQBSBSFHVMBS
MBT UDOJDBT EF SFQSPEVDDJO BTJTUJEB
-B QSJNFSB EF FMMBT  QSPQVFTUB QPS VO
JOUFHSBOUFEFM1BSUJEP7FSEF&DPMPHJTUB
EF .YJDP 17&.
 DPOTUB EF  BS
UDVMPT &OUSF TVT BTQFDUPT NT JOUFSF
TBOUFT  JOUSPEVDJSB FO OVFTUSP TJTUFNB
MFHBMUSNJOPTDPNPiNBUFSJBMHFOUJDP
IVNBOPw  iNBUFSOJEBE TVCSPHBEBw 
iUSBOTGFSFODJB EF FNCSJPOFTw Z iQSF
FNCSJPOFTw 1FSNJUJSBMB JOWFTUJHBDJO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DPO FNCSJPOFT TVQFSOVNFSBSJPT EF MBT


UDOJDBTEFGFDVOEBDJOJOWJUSP MBDSFB
DJO EF RVJNFSBT DPO mOFT EF JOWFTUJ
HBDJOFOJOGFSUJMJEBEIVNBOB UFTUEFM
IBNTUFS
ZMBBQMJDBDJOEFEJBHOTUJDPT
HFOUJDPTQSFOBUBMFT
&MQSPZFDUPEFMFZQSPQVFTUPQPSFM1BS
UJEP EF "DDJO /BDJPOBM 1"/
 DPN
QSFOEFSBBSUDVMPT JODMVJEPTEFOUSP
EFVODBQUVMPFTQFDJBMEFMB-(4&TUB
MFZ QSPIJCJSB MB FVHFOFTJB QPTJUJWB Z MB
TFMFDDJOEFTFYPFOMPTFNCSJPOFT DPO
MB FYDFQDJO EF FMFHJS FM TFYP TMP FO
BRVFMMPTDBTPTFOMPTRVFFYJTUBMBQPTJCJ
MJEBEEFIFSFEBSVOBFOGFSNFEBEHFOUJ
DBMJHBEBBMTFYPQFSNJUJSBMBJOWFTUJHB
DJOEFJEFOUJEBEEFEBUPTHFOUJDPTFO
MPTDBTPTRVFDPNQPSUFOVOSJFTHPQBSB
MBWJEBEFMOJPTBODJPOBSBMBNBOJQV
MBDJOTPCSFNBUFSJBMHFOUJDPIVNBOPZ
MBDPNFSDJBMJ[BDJOEFDMVMBTHFSNJOBMFT
PFNCSJPOFT ZOPQFSNJUJSBMBDSFBDJO
EFFNCSJPOFTTVQFSOVNFSBSJPT
1PSMUJNP MBJOJDJBUJWBEFMFZEFMHSV
QPQPMUJDPEFM1BSUJEPEFMB3FWPMVDJO
%FNPDSUJDB 13%
UJFOFBSUDVMPT 
RVFTFBEJDJPOBSBOBMB-(41FSNJUJSB
FM EJBHOTUJDP HFOUJDP QSFJNQMBOUBUP
SJP DPOFMmOEFQSFWFOJSFOGFSNFEBEFT
IFSFEJUBSJBT JOUSPEVDJSB MPT USNJOPT
iFNCSJOQSFJNQMBOUBUPSJPwZiFNCSJO
QPTUJNQMBOUBUPSJPwQFSNJUJSBMBJOWFT
UJHBDJO DPO FNCSJPOFT TVQFSOVNFSB
SJPT BVORVFTFBMBDPNPMNJUFQBSBMB
JOWFTUJHBDJO FM EB   Z QSPIJCJSB FM
BMRVJMFSEFUFSPTZMBNPEJmDBDJOEFM
QBUSJNPOJPHFOUJDPDPOmOFTFVHFOTJ
DPT1PSPUSBQBSUF DSFBSBCBODPTEFTF





1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB(FSBSEP+JNOF[ $TBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP

NFOZEFFNCSJPOFT Z BEFNT BMJHVBM


RVFMBTEPTJOJDJBUJWBTBOUFSJPSFT QFSNJ
UJSBMPTEJBHOTUJDPTHFOUJDPTQSFOBUB
MFTQBSBEFUFDUBSEFGFDUPTDPOHOJUPT

-BCJPUJDBZMBQMBUBGPSNBEFMB
NFEJDJOBHFONJDBFO.YJDP
/P QSFUFOEFNPT BOBMJ[BS UPEPT MPT BT
QFDUPT EFM EFTBSSPMMP EF MB DJFODJB HF
ONJDB RVF  FO MPT MUJNPT BPT  IB
HFOFSBEPJOGPSNBDJOBCVOEBOUF UBOUP
FODPNVOJDBDJPOFTDJFOUmDBTFTDSJUBTZ
FMFDUSOJDBT DPNP FO MPT NFEJPT NBTJ
WPTEFDPNVOJDBDJO-PRVFIBSFNPT
TFSVOCSFWFSFDVFOUPEFMPRVFDPOTJ
EFSFNPT MPT SFUPT CJPUJDPT JONFEJBUPT
RVFFOGSFOUBSOVFTUSPDFOUSP&-4*

"TQFDUPTHFOFSBMFTEFMBNFEJDJOB
HFONJDB
&M 1SPZFDUP EFM (FOPNB )VNBOP
1()
TFIBDPOTUJUVJEPFOVOPEFMPT
SFUPT DJFOUmDPUFDOPMHJDPT NT HSBO
EFTRVFIBFOGSFOUBEPMBIVNBOJEBE Z
RVFQFSNJUFVONBZPSDPOPDJNJFOUPEF
OVFTUSB FTQFDJF )PZ TBCFNPT RVF MPT
TFSFT IVNBOPT DPNQBSUJNPT FM  
EF MB TFDVFODJB EFM HFOPNB IVNBOP
TUBTFDPOTUJUVZFEFNJMMPOFTEF
OVDMFUJEPT P MFUSBT "  (  5  $
 GPS
NBOEP MPT DFSDB EF  HFOFT RVF
BITFBMCFSHBO&M SFTUBOUFEFMB
TFDVFODJB WBSB FOUSF DBEB JOEJWJEVP 
TJFOEP MBT WBSJBDJPOFT NT DPNVOFT
BRVFMMBTFORVFDBNCJBVOBTPMBMFUSB FT
EFDJS MPTQPMJNPSmTNPTEFVOTPMPOV
DMFUJEP DPOPDJEPTDPNP4/1TQPSTVT
TJHMBTFOJOHMT&MONFSPEFQPTJCMFT
DPNCJOBDJPOFTRVFSFTVMUBOEFMBWBSJB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DJO HFONJDB EB DPNP SFTVMUBEP RVF


DBEBNJFNCSPEFOVFTUSBFTQFDJFUFOHB
DBSBDUFSTUJDBTHFONJDBTOJDBT
"M USNJOP EFM 1() TF JEFOUJmDBSPO
MPT SFUPT NTJNQPSUBOUFT Z TFEFmOJF
SPODJODPSFBTQSJODJQBMFTFOMBTRVFTF
JOWFSUJSBOFTGVFS[PTZSFDVSTPTEVSBOUF
MPT QSYJNPT EJF[ BPT &TUBT SFBT FT
UBSBOEFEJDBEBTBDPOWFSUJSMBJOGPSNB
DJO HFONJDB FO SFBMJEBEFT UBOHJCMFT
QBSB MB QPCMBDJO HFOFSBM  NFEJBOUF FM
FTUVEJPEFMBFTUSVDUVSBZGVODJOEFMPT
HFOFTZMBTQSPUFOBT4FQVFEFNFODJP
OBS DPNPVOBEFMBTSFBTRVFNTEFCF
JOUFSFTBSBMPTHPCJFSOPT MBFMBCPSBDJO
EFM .BQB EF )BQMPUJQPT )BQ.BQ

QSPZFDUP DVZB mOBMJEBE FT BDFMFSBS FM
EFTDVCSJNJFOUP EF MPT HFOFT SFMBDJPOB
EPT DPO FOGFSNFEBEFT DPNVOFT DPNP
BTNB  DODFS  EJBCFUFT  FOGFSNFEBEFT
DBSEJPWBTDVMBSFT FOUSFPUSBT
"DUVBMNFOUF FM*/.&(&/TFFODVFO
USB EFTBSSPMMBOEP FM )BQ.BQ EF MPT
NFTUJ[PT NFYJDBOPT $PO M TF MPHSB
S JEFOUJmDBS MBT QPTJDJPOFT FO MBT RVF
FYJTUFO WBSJBDJPOFT EFOUSP EFM HFOPNB
IVNBOPEFMPTNFYJDBOPT FTEFDJS MBT
WBSJBDJPOFT RVF DPOmFSFO JOEJWJEVBMJ
EBEBDBEBNJFNCSPEFOVFTUSBQPCMB
DJO &TQFDJBM JOUFST UFOESO BRVFMMBT
SFMBDJPOBEBT DPO MB TVTDFQUJCJMJEBE B
FOGFSNFEBEFTDPNVOFT1PSFMMP FTJN
QPSUBOUF JODPSQPSBSTF FO FM EFTBSSPMMP
EFMBQMBUBGPSNBDJFOUmDBRVFQFSNJUB
HFOFSBS CBTFT TMJEBT QBSB USBOTGPSNBS
MBNFEJDJOBHFONJDB FOUFOEJEBDPNP
VOBNFEJDJOBNTQSFWFOUJWB QSFEJDUJWB
FJOEJWJEVBMJ[BEB&MMBDPOUSJCVJSBNF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

KPSBSMBDBMJEBEEFWJEBEFMPTJOEJWJEVPT
Z SFEVDJS  B MBSHP QMB[P  MPT HBTUPT EF
BUFODJO QFSNJUJFOEPVOBNFKPSEJTUSJ
CVDJOEFSFDVSTPTZBQMJDBOEPFMQSJO
DJQJPCJPUJDPEFKVTUJDJBEJTUSJCVUJWB

3FnFYJPOFTmOBMFT
-BTJNQMJDBDJPOFTEFMBCJPUJDBZMBNF
EJDJOBHFONJDBWBONTBMMEFMBTWB
MPSBDJPOFT DJFOUmDBT "CBSDBO HSBOEFT
SFUPTUJDPT MFHBMFTZTPDJBMFT SB[OQPS
MBDVBMFM*/.&(&/IBDSFBEPTV$FO
USPEF&TUVEJPTUJDPT -FHBMFTZ4PDJBMFT
EFMB.FEJDJOB(FONJDB"EFNT IB
FTUBCMFDJEPVODMBSPEFTMJOEFDPOPUSBT
JNQPSUBOUFT SFBT EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
DJFOUmDBDPOMBTRVFOPHVBSEBSFMBDJO
"T MBNFEJDJOBHFONJDBEFTBSSPMMBEB
FO FM */.&(&/ OP TF SFMBDJPOB DPO
MB DMPOBDJO EF TFSFT IVNBOPT  OJ DPO
MBNBOJQVMBDJOEFDMVMBTNBESF UBN
QPDPDPOMPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTEFSFQSP
EVDDJO BTJTUJEB  NVDIP NFOPT DPO MB
NBOJQVMBDJOEFFNCSJPOFTIVNBOPT
-B NFEJDJOB HFONJDB FO .YJDP FTU
EJSJHJEBBMFTUVEJPEFJOEJWJEVPTZBOB
DJEPT  JEFOUJmDBOEP QSFEJTQPTJDJPOFT
HFOUJDBTBFOGFSNFEBEFTDPNVOFT DPO
FMmOEFGPSNVMBSSFDPNFOEBDJPOFTTP
CSFTVFTUJMPEFWJEBZBTSFUSBTBSPFWJUBS
MBNBOJGFTUBDJOEFFTUBTFOGFSNFEBEFT
FO VOB QSJNFSB FUBQB -B WJODVMBDJO
FOUSFCJPUJDBZNFEJDJOBHFONJDBEF
CFSQMBOUFBSNBSDPTEFSFGFSFODJBQBSB
BWBO[BS FO FM DPOPDJNJFOUP EF MB WJEB
ZMPTCFOFmDJPTQBSBMBIVNBOJEBE FO
QSFWFODJOEFMBFOGFSNFEBEZQSPNP
DJOEFMBTBMVE

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&M EFTBSSPMMP EF MB NFEJDJOB HFONJDB


USBF DPOTJHP NVDIBT DVFTUJPOFT CJPUJ
DBTRVFEFCFSOSFTPMWFSTFUSBTVOEFCBUF
JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP FMDVBMEFCFSFONBS
DBSTF CBKP FM EJTDVSTP EF MPT EFSFDIPT
GVOEBNFOUBMFT  JODMVJEPT FM EFSFDIP BM
EFTBSSPMMP DJFOUmDP Z UFDOPMHJDP Z FM
EFSFDIP B MB TBMVE 6O NBSDP CJPUJDP
QSPHSFTJTUB MF JOEJDBS B MPT DJFOUmDPT
MPTEFSFDIPTZPCMJHBDJPOFTFOFMFKFSDJ
DJPEFTVTGVODJPOFT UBMZDPNPTVDFEF
DPO DVBMRVJFS UJQP EF SFMBDJO TPDJBM 
QFSP SFDPOPDFS MB QSPUFDDJO EF TVT
QSPZFDUPT FYQFDUBUJWBTZFNQSFTBT
&OUSFMPTUFNBTRVFEFCFOTFSEFTBSSPMMB
EPTBNQMJBNFOUFTFFODVFOUSBFMEFDPO
TFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEP&OUPEPUSBCBKP
EFJOWFTUJHBDJOEFCFFYJTUJSMBJOGPSNB
DJOOFDFTBSJBQBSBFMQBSUJDJQBOUF RVJFO
EFCFSDPOPDFSMBmOBMJEBEZDPOTFDVFO
DJBTEFMFYQFSJNFOUPZFYQSFTBSWPMVOUB
SJBNFOUFTVJOUFODJOEFQBSUJDJQBS
0USPUFNBEFHSBOSFMFWBODJBFTFMSFMBUJ
WPBMBJOHFOJFSBHFOUJDB BNQMJBNFOUF
BDFQUBEB EFTEF FM QVOUP EF WJTUB UJDP
QBSB USBUBS FOGFSNFEBEFT IFSFEJUBSJBT 
QFSPOPQBSBNPEJmDBSFMDEJHPHFOUJ
DPDPOmOFTFVHFOTJDPTPQBSBDBNCJBS
MBT DBSBDUFSTUJDBT GTJDBT F JOUFMFDUVBMFT
EFMJOEJWJEVP
6OUFSDFSUFNBFTFMSFMBUJWPBMBJOGPS
NBDJO HFOUJDB 4F EFCF SFTQFUBS FM
QSJODJQJP EF BVUPOPNB QBSB RVF DBEB
JOEJWJEVPEFDJEBBDFQUBSPOPFMFTUVEJP
EFTVHFOPNBBEFNT UPEBMBJOGPSNB
DJOEFCFTFSDPOmEFODJBMZTVFWFOUVBM
EJGVTJOEFCFWFSTBSTPCSFBTQFDUPTFTUB
ETUJDPT





1BOPSBNBNFYJDBOPEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB(FSBSEP+JNOF[ $TBS-BSBZ"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP

6ODVBSUPQSPCMFNBTFSFmFSFBMEFUFS
NJOJTNP HFOUJDP &O DBEB JOWFTUJHB
DJOTFEFCFOUPNBSFODVFOUBOPTMP
MPT GBDUPSFT HFOUJDPT QSFEJTQPOFOUFT 
TJOPUBNCJOMPTGBDUPSFTBNCJFOUBMFT

TPCSFUPEPKVSEJDB-BDJFODJB BMJHVBM
RVF MBT BSUFT  MB mMPTPGB Z MB MJUFSBUVSB
FTVOBDPOTUSVDDJOIVNBOBZEFQFOEF 
QPSUBOUP EFTVTGVFS[BTDSFBUJWBT FTEF
DJS EFMBTQFSTPOBT

&MEFSFDIPEFQBUFOUFTFOFMSFBEFMB
NFEJDJOBHFONJDBFTFMRVJOUPBTVOUP
RVF EFCF DPOTJEFSBSTF  QVFT UJFOF NV
DIBT JNQMJDBDJPOFT FO MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
CJPNEJDBZFOMBJOEVTUSJBFTNVZUJM
FO FM EJBHOTUJDP Z USBUBNJFOUP EF FO
GFSNFEBEFTHFOUJDBTZ QPSPUSBQBSUF 
TFVTBQBSBPCUFOFSTVCTUBODJBTUJMFTFO
MB JOEVTUSJB GBSNBDVUJDB MB HMPCVMJOB
BOUJIFNPGMJDB"Z# IPSNPOBEFMDSF
DJNJFOUP JOTVMJOBIVNBOB JOUFSGFSPO 
GBDUPSEFOFDSPTJTUVNPSBM WBDVOBTDPO
USBMBIFQBUJUJT#Z$ZDPOUSBMBJOnVFO
[B  FOUSF PUSBT &T QFSUJOFOUF SFWJTBS FM
TJTUFNB EF QSPQJFEBE JOUFMFDUVBM QBSB
GPNFOUBSFMEFTBSSPMMPBUSBWTEFMBQSP
UFDDJOEFMBDSFBUJWJEBE&TJOEJTQFOTB
CMFMBSFHVMBDJOMPDBMZUJDBBUSBWTEF
PSHBOJTNPTNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJPT

-B CJPUJDB  TJ RVJFSF EFTBSSPMMBS DBCBM


NFOUFTVNJTJO EFCFBKVTUBSTFBUPEP
MP SFRVFSJEP QPS MPT JOEJWJEVPT EF MBT
TPDJFEBEFT BDUVBMFT  TFBO TUPT DJFOUm
DPTPOP%FCFSFDPOPDFSMBTSFTQVFTUBT
DJFOUmDBTZSFHVMBSMBTEFNBOFSBHFOF
SBMEFOUSPEFMPUJDBNFOUFQFSNJTJCMF
1BSBFMMPEFCFBQSPWFDIBSMBTBQPSUBDJP
OFTEFMBBVUPDPNQSFOTJOEFMIPNCSF 
Z QSPWFFS MPT FMFNFOUPT RVF MB DJFODJB
OPFTUFODPOEJDJPOFTEFPUPSHBS

)PZTPNPTDPOTDJFOUFTEFRVFMBDJFO
DJBOPQVFEFFKFSDFSTVQSPQJPDPOUSPM 
BVORVF EJTQPOHB EF MPT NFEJPT UDOJ
DPTQBSBIBDFSMPGBMUBOMBEFDJTJOZFM
DPNQSPNJTPJNQVFTUPTQPSMBTPDJFEBE
BMBDVBMTFEFTUJOBFMQSPHSFTPDJFOUmDP
-BJOUFSWFODJOEFMBTPDJFEBEFOUSBB
VOBSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEUJDBZTPDJBM QFSP

-BCJPUJDBOPFTUFODPOUSBEFMBUFD
OPDJFODJB TJOPFODPOUSBEFTVEFTBSSP
MMP BM NBSHFO EF WBMPSFT UJDPT  MFHBMFT
Z TPDJBMFT .YJDP ZB UJFOF HBOBEP VO
MVHBSFTQFDJBMFOFMNVOEPEFMBCJPUJ
DBHSBDJBTBMPTEPDUPSFT.BOVFM7FMBTDP
4VSF[ Z (VJMMFSNP 4PCFSO &TUBNPT
TFHVSPTEFRVFFOMPTBPTWFOJEFSPTFTUB
OVFWBEJTDJQMJOBKVHBSVOQBQFMJNQPS
UBOUFFOMBUBSFBEFBQMJDBSMBUJDBBMPT
OVFWPTEFTDVCSJNJFOUPTEFMBNFEJDJOB
HFONJDB4MPBTUFOESFNPTVOBDJFO
DJBDBQB[EFSFTQFUBSMBTFYJHFODJBTEFMB
DPODJFODJBTPDJBMZVOBTPDJFEBEBMBBM
UVSBEFMDPOPDJNJFOUPDJFOUmDP

3FGFSFODJBT
$BSSBTDP3PKBT  + " 
 %JTUJODJO i%S $MFNFOUF 3PCMFT $BTUJMMPw BM %S
.BOVFM 7FMBTDP 4VSF[  IVNBOJTUB VOJWFSTBM $JSVHB Z $JSVKBOPT   

PDUVCSFEJDJFNCSF
3FBM"DBEFNJB&TQBPMB 
%JDDJPOBSJPEFMB-FOHVB&TQBPMB<WFSTJOPOMJOF>
&TQBB 3"&%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXXSBFFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

,VUIZ1PSUFS + 


%FPOUPMPHB UJDBZCJPUJDBFOMBNFEJDJOB&O,VUIZ
1PSUFS + $PPSE
5FNBTBDUVBMFTEFCJPUJDB.YJDP 1PSSB
.BSUOF[ #VMM (PZSJ  7. 
 #JPUJDB Z EFSFDIP &O (BSDB 3BNSF[  4
$PPSE
-PTWBMPSFTFOFMEFSFDIPNFYJDBOP6OBBQSPYJNBDJO.YJDP 6/".
Z'$&
.BUFPT +) 
.BOVFM7FMBTDP4VSF[ NEJDPZNBFTUSP*ONFNPSJBN
(BDFUB.EJDBEF.YJDP  
KVMJPBHPTUP
4BOUPT Z 7BSHBT  - 
 -B CJPUJDB DPNP VOB EJTDJQMJOB DSUJDB &O "DPTUB
4BSJFHP +3 &E
#JPUJDBQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBE-B)BCBOB 1VCMJDBDJPOFT
"DVBSJP
7FMBTDP4VSF[ . 
%FSFDIPZTBMVE TVQSPUFDDJOZGPNFOUP#JPUJDBQBSB
FMSFTQFUPBMEFSFDIPBMBWJEBZMBQSPNPDJOEFMBTBMVE&O.VP[EF"MCB
.FESBOP . $PPSE
5FNBTTFMFDUPTEFTBMVEZEFSFDIP.YJDP 6/".

3FGFSFODJBTMFHBMFT
.YJDP$POTUJUVDJO1PMUJDBEFMPT&TUBEPT6OJEPT.FYJDBOPT
.YJDP-FZEFCJPTFHVSJEBEEFPSHBOJTNPTHFOUJDBNFOUFNPEJGJDBEPT
.YJDP-FZEFDJFODJBZUFDOPMPHB
.YJDP-FZEFMPTJOTUJUVUPTOBDJPOBMFTEFTBMVE
.YJDP-FZHFOFSBMEFTBMVE
.YJDP 3FHMBNFOUP EF MB MFZ HFOFSBM EF TBMVE FO NBUFSJB EF DPOUSPM TBOJUBSJP EF MB
EJTQPTJDJOEFSFHMBNFOUPEFMBMFZHFOFSBMEFTBMVEFONBUFSJBEFJOWFTUJHBDJOQBSB
MBTBMVE
.YJDP$EJHP1FOBMEFM%JTUSJUP'FEFSBM


PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ
.BSUB"TDVSSB

B CJPUJDB FO 1BSBHVBZ OBDF B mOFT


EFMPTZQSJODJQJPTEFMPT FOMB
VOJWFSTJEBE FOFMNCJUPEFMBJOWFTUJ
HBDJOZEFMBTBMVE VOJEBJOJDJBMNFOUF
BMPTQSJODJQJPTEF7BO3FOTTFOMBFS1P
UUFSZTJONVDIBBUFODJOIBDJBMPTWB
MPSFTEFMQBTZMBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT%FTEF
FOUPODFT  TV DSFDJNJFOUP IB TJEP MFOUP
QFSPDPOUJOVP DPOMBGPSNBDJOEFDP
NJUTEFCJPUJDBFOMPTIPTQJUBMFT HSV
QPTEFFTUVEJP DVSTPTBOVBMFTZFMSFDP
OPDJNJFOUPEFVOB$PNJTJO/BDJPOBM
FO)BTUBMBGFDIB MBTQFSTPOBTP
HSVQPT QJPOFSPT TF IBMMBO SFMBDJPOBEPT
EFVOBVPUSBGPSNBBMSFBEFMBTBMVE 
DPNP FM QSPCMFNB EFUPOBOUF RVF MPT
VOF $BCF NFODJPOBS B +VMJB 3JWBSPMB 
NEJDPQFEJBUSB &EVBSEP"RVJOP N
EJDP FTQFDJBMJ[BEP FO "ENJOJTUSBDJO
)PTQJUBMBSJB  3PTBMJOP 1JOUP  NEJDP
HJOFDMPHP Z &OSJRVF EF .FTUSBM  N
EJDPHFSJBUSBB0MHB-QF[EF#FOUF[ 
+VMJB$BSNFO.PSFMEF'FTUOFSZ%FP
MJOEB.BDJFMB"MCFSUP-FO QSFTCUF
SP ZBMBBVUPSBEFFTUFDBQUVMP FOUSF
PUSPT

 "HSBEF[DP B +VMJB 3JWBSPMB  .BSB &VHFOJB


.POUJFM  3PTBMJOP 1JOUP Z &OSJRVF EF .FT
USBM  BM QSFTCUFSP "MCFSUP -FO Z BM BCPHBEP
(VJMMFSNP%VBSUFQPSMBTDPOUSJCVDJPOFTZMB
SFWJTJOEFFTUFNBUFSJBM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

"OUFTEFEFTDSJCJSMPTMPHSPTBDPOUFDJEPT
FODBEBVOPEFMPTNCJUPT QSFTFOUBS
MB TJUVBDJO HFPHSmDB Z EFNPHSmDB 
BTDPNPBMHVOPTJOEJDBEPSFTSFMBDJPOB
EPTDPOMBCJPUJDBZMPTEFSFDIPTIVNB
OPTFOFMQBT&TUPQPSRVFFTOFDFTBSJP
TJUVBSBMMFDUPSFOMBSFBMJEBEEFVOQBT
DPO FTDBTP BDDFTP B MB TBMVE  QPCSF[B 
EFTUSVDDJO EFM NFEJP BNCJFOUF  GBMUB
EFTBOFBNJFOUPCTJDPZEFBHVBQPUB
CMF&OSFTVNFO GBMUBEFEFSFDIPTIV
NBOPT .JFOUSBT UBOUP  MPT UFNBT RVF
TFBCPSEBOEFTEFFMJOJDJPIBTUBMBGFDIB
QPS MPT iFTQFDJBMJTUBT FO CJPUJDB FO FM
QBTwFTUOSFMBDJPOBEPTDPOTJUVBDJPOFT
RVF NT CJFO DPNQFUFO B QBTFT EFTB
SSPMMBEPT Z OP MPT BOUFSJPSNFOUF NFO
DJPOBEPTRVFTPOQFDVMJBSFTBMPTQBTFT
FOEFTBSSPMMP

4JUVBDJOHFPHSmDB
*OEJDBEPSFTEFNPHSmDPTZEF
TBMVE FOUSFPUSPT
-B QPCMBDJO UPUBM EF 1BSBHVBZ  EF
BDVFSEP DPO FM MUJNP DFOTP EF  
FTEFIBCJUBOUFT EFMPTDVB
MFT  QFSUFOFDFO B DPNVOJEBEFT
JOEHFOBT  BHSVQBEBT FO DJODP GBNJMJBT
MJOHTUJDBTZHSVQPTUOJDPT ZEJTUSJ
CVJEPTFODPNVOJEBEFT MBTDVBMFT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

TFIBMMBOFOMPDBMJEBEFTBMFKBEBTZEFEJ
GDJMBDDFTP
&T VO QBT FO FM DVBM  EFTEF TV QSPQJB
HFPHSBGB  MB JOFRVJEBE TF IBDF QSFTFO
UF&MUFSSJUPSJPOBDJPOBMFTEF
LN  EJWJEJEP QPS FM 3P 1BSBHVBZ FO
EPTSFBTCJFOEFmOJEBTFOFM$IBDPP
3FHJO 0DDJEFOUBM  DPO VOB TVQFSmDJF
EF  LN  IBCJUB FM   EF MB
QPCMBDJO ZFOMB3FHJO0SJFOUBM DPO
 LN  FM   SFTUBOUF  EFM
DVBM VO   WJWF FO FM SFB VSCBOB
-BQPCMBDJOGPSNBVOBQJSNJEFDVZP
FYUSFNP TVQFSJPS TF IBMMB PDVQBEP QPS
MBTQFSTPOBTNBZPSFTEFBPT DPOVO
 ZMBCBTFDPOTUJUVJEBQPSQPCMBDJO
KPWFO DPOVOQFSTPOBTDPONFOPT
EFBPT&TFTUFHSVQPFUBSJPFMNT
BCBUJEPQPSQSPCMFNBTDPNPMBQPCSF
[B EFTOVUSJDJO BOFNJB GBMUBEFBDDFTP
B MB TBMVE Z BHVB QPUBCMF $PO WBMPSFT
QBSBMBNPSUBMJEBEJOGBOUJMEF QPS
DBEBOBDJEPTWJWPTQBSBMBQPCMB
DJOHFOFSBM ZEF QPSDBEB
OBDJEPTWJWPTFOMBQPCMBDJOJOEHFOB
6OPTOJPTZOJBTNVFSFODBEB
BPBOUFTEFBMDBO[BSMPTDJODPBPTEF
WJEB&M 
EFMBTOJBTZOJ
PTNFOPSFTEFDJODPBPTQBEFDFOEF
EFTOVUSJDJOHMPCBMZVO 

TF FODVFOUSB FO MB GSBOKB EF SJFTHP EF
EFTOVUSJDJO -B NPSUBMJEBE NBUFSOB
PDVSSF DPO WBMPSFT UBO BMUPT DPNP EF
 QPSDBEBSFDJOOBDJEPT 
BMDBO[BOEPDJGSBTEF FOFMSFBSV
SBM&MQBSUPPDVSSFFOJOTUJUVDJPOFTEF
TBMVEFOTMPFMEFMPTFNCBSB[PT
&M 
EFMBTNVKFSFTFNCB
SB[BEBTQBEFDFEFEFTOVUSJDJO&M

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EFMBQPCMBDJO QFSTPOBT
OP
UJFOFBDDFTPBBHVBQPUBCMFVOOP
DVFOUBDPOOJOHOUJQPEFTBOFBNJFOUP
CTJDP1PSVMUJNP FM 
QFSTPOBT
OPUJFOFDPCFSUVSBBTJTUFODJBM
NEJDBZVUJMJ[BMBNFEJDJOBUSBEJDJPOBM
DPNP QSJNFS USBUBNJFOUP  FO FTQFDJBM
FOFMSFBSVSBM
6OBEFMBTSJRVF[BTEF1BSBHVBZFTRVF
BODPOTFSWBTVMFOHVBOBUJWBZFTVOP
EFMPTQPDPTQBTFTDPOEPTMFOHVBTPm
DJBMFT FMFTQBPMZFMHVBSBO&TUBMUJ
NBFTMBQSFEPNJOBOUFFOFMSFBSVSBM 
IBCMBEBQPSFM EFMPTQPCMBEPSFT
NJFOUSBTRVFFMFTQBPMFOFMSFBVSCB
OBMPIBCMBFM &ONVDIPTDBTPT 
FMHVBSBOOPFOPSHVMMFDFBTVTIBCJUBO
UFT  TJOP RVF DPOTJEFSBO TV FTUVEJP Z
BQSFOEJ[BKF VOB QSEJEB EF UJFNQP 4J
CJFOIBCMBSMPIBCJUVBMNFOUFOPFTNPUJ
WPEFFYDMVTJO FMBOBMGBCFUJTNP FMEFT
FNQMFP FMNBZPSONFSPEFIJKPT BT
DPNP PUSBT GPSNBT EF EJTDSJNJOBDJO 
TFDPODFOUSBOFOQFSTPOBTRVFMPVTBO
&YDMVTJO4PDJBMFO4BMVE 

&MEFMBQPCMBDJOQBSBHVBZBQSP
GFTBMBSFMJHJO$BUMJDB"QPTUMJDB3P
NBOB VOPUSBTJHMFTJBTDSJTUJBOBTZ
MPTSFTUBOUFTMBTEFNTSFMJHJPOFT PTPO
BHOTUJDPT 1PS MUJNP  BVO DVBOEP MB
QSJODJQBM BDUJWJEBE FDPONJDB EF 1B
SBHVBZ FT MB BHSJDVMUVSB Z FM EFTBSSPMMP
GPSFTUBM ZFYJTUBOEJTQPTJDJPOFTFYQSFTBT
EFQSPUFDDJO FMUSBCBKPBHSDPMBTFMMFWB
BDBCPTJOUFOFSFODVFOUBMPTNTNOJ
NPTDVJEBEPT1SVFCBEFFMMPFTMBDBEB
WF[NTQFMJHSPTBDPOUBNJOBDJOEFMBT
BHVBT BTDPNPFMOBDJNJFOUPEFOJPT





)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ.BSUB"TDVSSB

DPONBMGPSNBDJPOFTEFCJEPBMBVUJMJ[B
DJOEFBMHVOPTIFSCJDJEBT

-FZFT EFDSFUPTEFM1PEFS
&KFDVUJWPZSFTPMVDJPOFT
NJOJTUFSJBMFT
"VORVFOPFYJTUFOSFHMBTPQFSBUJWBTEJ
SFDUBTRVFFTUBCMF[DBOMJOFBNJFOUPTCJP
UJDPTBMUSBUBNJFOUPNEJDP TFYJTUFO
SFHMBTQSPHSBNUJDBTEFSBOHPDPOTUJUV
DJPOBMRVFmKBOMBTCBTFTQBSBMBDSFBDJO
EFBRVFMMBT&MMPFTJNQPSUBOUFQVFT TJ
TUBTOPFYJTUJFSBO OPTFQPESBTJRVJFSB
DPOTJEFSBSMFHJTMBSTPCSFFMQVOUPTJOVOB
FWFOUVBMSFGPSNBEFMB$BSUB.BHOB
1PSFKFNQMP FM"SUEFMB$BSUB.BH
OBDPOTBHSBMBQSPUFDDJOEFMBWJEBIV
NBOBFOHFOFSBMEFTEFMBDPODFQDJO Z
QSPQVHOBRVFUPEBQFSTPOBTFBQSPUFHJ
EBQPSFM&TUBEPFOTVJOUFHSJEBEGTJDB
ZTRVJDB QBSBMPDVBMPCMJHBRVFFYJTUB
VOBMFZDPODSFUBRVFSFHVMFiyMBMJCFS
UBEEFMBTQFSTPOBTQBSBEJTQPOFSEFTV
QSPQJPDVFSQP TMPDPOmOFTDJFOUmDPT
PNEJDPTw
0USB EF MBT BSJTUBT EFM NBSDP DPOTUJUV
DJPOBMTFFODVFOUSBFOFM$BQUVMP7*EF
FTFDVFSQPMFHBM FOFMDVBMTFDSJTUBMJ[BO
MBT OPSNBT iQSPHSBNUJDBTw RVF EFCFO
TFSPQFSBDJPOBMJ[BEBTDPOFMmOEFRVF
MPTEFSFDIPTBMBTBMVEDPOTBHSBEPTFOMB
$POTUJUVDJOOPTFBOMFUSBNVFSUBFOFM
NYJNPPSEFOOBDJPOBM
 "SUDVMP%FMEFSFDIPBMBWJEB
 $BQUVMP7*EFMB4BMVE"SUDVMP%FMEFSF
DIPBMBTBMVE"SUDVMP%FMTJTUFNBOBDJP
OBMEFTBMVE"SUDVMP%FMSHJNFOEFCJFO
FTUBS TPDJBM "SUDVMP  %FM OBSDPUSmDP  EF
MBESPHBEJDDJOZEFMBSFIBCJMJUBDJO"SUDVMP
%FMDPOUSPMEFDBMJEBE

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

"MPFYQVFTUPTFEFCFBHSFHBSRVFFYJT
UF PUSP UJQP EF OPSNBT QSPHSBNUJDBT
EF SBOHP DPOTUJUVDJPOBM RVF EFCFO TFS
BUFOEJEBT BM NPNFOUP EF DPOTJEFSBS B
MBCJPUJDB ZRVFBUBFOBFMMBQPSRVFTF
SFMBDJPOBO QPSFKFNQMP BMBMJCFSUBEP
BMBJHVBMEBEEFUPEPTMPTIBCJUBOUFTEF
MB3FQCMJDB PBMEFSFDIPBMBNCJFOUF
TBMVEBCMFRVFUJFOFOUPEPTMPTIBCJUBO
UFT QPSDJUBSTMPBMHVOPTFKFNQMPT
4JHVJFOEPFMPSEFOEFQSFMBDJOEFMFZFT
EFMEFSFDIPQPTJUJWPQBSBHVBZP OPQVF
EFOTPTMBZBSTFMPTUSBUBEPTJOUFSOBDJPOB
MFTRVF EFVOBVPUSBNBOFSB IBDFOBMB
NBUFSJB BOBMJ[BEB  DPNP  QPS FKFNQMP 
MPTNFODJPOBEPTFOMB$POWFODJO*O
UFSOBDJPOBMTPCSFMPT%FSFDIPTEFM/JP
ZEFMB/JB SFGSFOEBEBQPS1BSBHVBZ
FOPDUVCSFEF
&OFTUFPSEFOEFJEFBT FYJTUFOOPSNBT
RVF PQFSBDJPOBMJ[BO EJSFDUBNFOUF  FO
QBSUF  B MBT OPSNBT DPOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
SFGFSFODJBEBT  FOUSF MBT DVBMFT TF QVFEF
DJUBS
B
 $EJHP 4BOJUBSJP  QSPNVMHBEP FO
 Z%FDSFUP RVFSF
HMBNFOUB FM "SU  EFM $EJHP
4BOJUBSJP
 $BQUVMP**%FMB-JCFSUBE"SUDVMP%FMB
MJCFSUBEZEFMBTFHVSJEBEEFMBTQFSTPOBT"S
UDVMP%FMBQSPTDSJQDJOEFMBFTDMBWJUVEZ
EFPUSBTTFSWJEVNCSFT"SUDVMP%FMBMJCFS
UBESFMJHJPTBZMBJEFPMHJDB
 $BQUVMP***%FMB*HVBMEBE"SUDVMP%F
MB JHVBMEBE EF MBT QFSTPOBT "SUDVMP  %F
MBTHBSBOUBTEFMBJHVBMEBE"SUDVMP%FMB
JHVBMEBEEFEFSFDIPTEFMIPNCSFZEFMBNVKFS
 4FDDJO**%FM"NCJFOUF"SUDVMP%FMEF
SFDIPBVOBNCJFOUFTBMVEBCMF"SUDVMP%F
MBQSPUFDDJOBNCJFOUBM





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

C
 -FZ   RVF DSFB FM 4FSWJDJP
/BDJPOBMEF4BOFBNJFOUP"NCJFO
UBM 4&/"4"

D
 -FZ   RVF NPEJmDB Z BD
UVBMJ[B MB -FZ /   RVF SF
QSJNFFMUSmDPJMDJUPEFFTUVQFGB
DJFOUFT Z ESPHBT QFMJHSPTBT Z PUSPT
EFMJUPT BmOFT  Z FTUBCMFDF NFEJEBT
EF QSFWFODJO Z SFDVQFSBDJO EF
GBSNBDPEFQFOEJFOUFT
E
 -FZ RVFDSFBFM#BODP/B
DJPOBMEFSHBOPT
F
 -FZ RVFFTUBCMFDFOPSNBT
TPCSFDPOUSPMEFM4*%"
G
 -FZ RVFSFHMBNFOUBMBFY
USBDDJOZUSBTQMBOUFEFSHBOPT
H
 -FZ RVFDSFBFM4JTUFNB
/BDJPOBMEF4BMVE
I
 -FZ EFQSPEVDUPTQBSBMB
TBMVEZPUSPT
1BSBMPTBUBRVFTEJSFDUPTBMPTEJTUJOUPT
CJFOFT KVSEJDPT DVZB QSPUFDDJO GVF
DPOTBHSBEBQPSMB$BSUB.BHOBTFQSF
WJFSPOFOFM$EJHP1FOBMTBODJPOFTEF
NVMUBZPQFOBQSJWBUJWBEFMJCFSUBEEF
IBTUBBPT BUSBWTEFEJTUJOUBTOPS
NBTEFDPOEVDUB DPNP QPSFKFNQMP
t

t

-PTBUBRVFTBMBWJEBEFMTFSIVNB
OP TF FODVFOUSBO QSFWJTUPT FO MPT
BSUDVMPTBEFM$EJHP1F
OBM
-PTBUFOUBEPTBMBTBMVEZBMBJOUF
HSJEBE GTJDB FTUO QSPTDSJQUPT QPS
MPTBSUDVMPTBEFM$EJHP

 "SUDVMP)PNJDJEJPEPMPTP"SUDVMP
)PNJDJEJPNPUJWBEPQPSTQMJDBEFMBWDUJNB
"SUDVMP  )PNJDJEJP DVMQPTP "SUDVMP
4VJDJEJP"SUDVMP.VFSUFJOEJSFDUB
QPSFTUBEPEFOFDFTJEBEFOFMQBSUP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

t

t

t

1FOBM  Z FM OJDP QFSNJTP RVF TF


PUPSHBBMPTNEJDPT QPSFKFNQMP 
QBSB TPNFUFS B VOB DJSVHB B VO
QBDJFOUF FTUDPOUFOJEPFOFM"SU
EFMNJTNPDVFSQPMFHBM
&M USBUBNJFOUP NEJDP TJO FM EF
CJEP DPOTFOUJNJFOUP TF FODVFOUSB
DPONJOBEP DPO TBODJO QFOBM  FO
WJSUVE MP QSFWJTUP QPS FM "SU 
EFM$EJHP1FOBM
-PTBUBRVFTBMBTCBTFTOBUVSBMFTEF
MBWJEBIVNBOBTFFODVFOUSBOQSF
WJTUPTFOMPTBSUDVMPTBEFM
$EJHP1FOBM
"RVFMMPTBUFOUBEPTDPOUSBMBQSVFCB
EPDVNFOUBMZRVFTFSFmFSFOBMSFB
EFMBTBMVEUBNCJOTFFODVFOUSBO
QSFWJTUPTFOFM$EJHP1FOBM

7BSJPTHSVQPTEFMFZFTSFHVMBOMBTBMVE 
QFSPOPBCPSEBOFMUFNBEJSFDUBNFOUF
QPS FKFNQMP  FM $EJHP EF MB /JF[ Z
EF MB "EPMFTDFODJB  FM $EJHP -BCPSBM 
FOUSFPUSPT EFMPTRVF1BSBHVBZIBTJEP
TJHOBUBSJP
 "SUDVMP.BMUSBUPGTJDP"SUDVMP-F
TJO"SUDVMP-FTJOHSBWF"SUDVMP
-FTJODVMQPTB
 "SUDVMP  $POTFOUJNJFOUP /P IBCS MF
TJO FOFMTFOUJEPEFMPTBSUDVMPTZ 
DVBOEPMBWDUJNBIBZBDPOTFOUJEPFMIFDIP
 "SUDVMP5SBUBNJFOUPNEJDPTJODPOTFO
UJNJFOUP
 "SUDVMP&OTVDJBNJFOUPZBMUFSBDJOEFMBT
BHVBT "SUDVMP  $POUBNJOBDJO EFM BJSF
"SUDVMP.BMUSBUPEFTVFMPT"SUDVMP
1SPDFTBNJFOUP JMDJUP EF EFTFDIPT "SUDVMP
*OHSFTPEFTVTUBODJBTOPDJWBTFOFMUFSSJUP
SJPOBDJPOBM"SUDVMP1FSKVJDJPBSFTFSWBT
OBUVSBMFT
 "SUDVMP&YQFEJDJOEFDFSUJmDBEPTEFTB
MVEEFDPOUFOJEPGBMTP"SUDVMP1SPEVD
DJOJOEFCJEBEFDFSUJmDBEPTEFTBMVE"SUDVMP
6TPEFDFSUJmDBEPTEFTBMVEEFDPOUFOJEP
GBMTP





)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ.BSUB"TDVSSB

%FVOBSFWJTJODVJEBEPTBEFMB$POT
UJUVDJOTFBQSFDJBRVFTUBOPDPOTJHOB
OPSNBFYQSFTBRVFSFHVMFMPSFGFSJEPB
JOWFTUJHBDJO DJFOUmDB Z UFDOPMHJDB
FONBUFSJBEFTBMVE&TUBBVTFODJBoFO
FTQFDJBM MB CJPNEJDB FO TFSFT IVNB
OPTo DPOTUJUVZF VO HSBWF QSPCMFNB  TJ
DPOTJEFSBNPTFMDPOUFYUPTPDJBMEFMQBT
Z RVF MBT JOWFTUJHBDJPOFT UJFOFO DPNP
TVKFUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJOHFOFSBMNFOUFB
HSVQPTWVMOFSBCMFT
-PT TJHVJFOUFT BQBSUBEPT TF SFmFSFO B
HSVQPT EF BDUJWJEBEFT EFTBSSPMMBEBT FO
FM QBT 5PEBT FMMBT TF FOUSFMB[BO FO TV
DPOUSJCVDJOBMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB
FO1BSBHVBZ

"TPDJBDJPOFTDJWJMFT
-B QSJNFSB JOTUJUVDJO DJWJM GVF 130
#*05*$" FOUJEBETJOmOFTEFMVDSP 
DSFBEBFOKVOJPEF'VFDPODFCJEB
DPNP JOTUJUVDJO QFSNBOFOUF EF FTUV
EJP BOMJTJTZDBQBDJUBDJO QBSBDPPQF
SBS FO FM QSPDFTP EF OPSNBMJ[BDJO EFM
DPNQPSUBNJFOUPEFMPTUSBCBKBEPSFTEF
MBTBMVE PUSPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTZMBQPCMB
DJOFOHFOFSBM DPNQSPNFUJEPTDPOFM
SFTQFUPBMBWJEBZFMEFSFDIPBMBQSPUFD
DJOEFMBTBMVE MBJOUFHSJEBE BVUPOP
NBZEJHOJEBEEFMBQFSTPOBIVNBOB Z
MBQSFTFSWBDJOEFMPTFDPTJTUFNBT
4VT GVODJPOFT TPO FMBCPSBS QSPHSBNBT
EFFEVDBDJOQFSNBOFOUFZSFBMJ[BSFKFS
DJDJPT EF EJTDVTJO FO MB QSPCMFNUJDB
QSDUJDBEFMPTEJMFNBTCJPUJDPT QSPUFD
DJOEFMBOBUVSBMF[B TBOFBNJFOUPBN
CJFOUBM FDPMPHBZSFTQFUPBMBEJHOJEBE
IVNBOB PSHBOJ[BS Z BQPZBS MB SFBMJ[B

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DJOEFUPEPUJQPEFFWFOUPTEFFEVDB
DJOQFSNBOFOUFDPOUFNBTEFCJPUJDB
DPOHSFTPT DVSTPT UBMMFSFT TFNJOBSJPTZ
PUSPT
QSPNPWFSFJNQVMTBSFMEFTBSSP
MMPEFMBCJPUJDBFOMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTEF
TBMVE NJOJTUFSJPTZDFOUSPTNEJDPT Z
BQPZBSMBDSFBDJOEFDPNJUTEFCJPUJDB
FOIPTQJUBMFT GBDVMUBEFTZPUSPTQBSUJDJ
QBSDPOPSHBOJTNPTOBDJPOBMFTFJOUFS
OBDJPOBMFT  JOUFSDBNCJBOEP FWFOUPT EF
GPSNBDJO DBQBDJUBDJOZBDUVBMJ[BDJO
FOCJPUJDBQSPNPWFSFOMBTGBDVMUBEFTZ
FTDVFMBTVOJWFSTJUBSJBTEPOEFTFJNQBSUF
GPSNBDJO QSPGFTJPOBM QBSB MB BUFODJO
Z FM DVJEBEP EF MB TBMVE  MB FOTFBO[B
EFMBCJPUJDBDPNPPCMJHBUPSJBFOQSFZ
QPTHSBEPDPPSEJOBSBDDJPOFTZSFnFYJP
OFTDPOPSHBOJTNPTOBDJPOBMFTQCMJDPT
Z QSJWBEPT NJOJTUFSJPT  JOTUJUVDJPOFT 
DPNJTJPOFT  TJOEJDBUPT  BHSVQBDJPOFT 
FOUSFPUSPT
RVFUFOHBOSFMBDJODPOMB
CJPUJDB QBSBTVTUFOUBSDSJUFSJPTZFNJ
UJS PQJOJPOFT TPCSF UFNBT HFOFSBMFT EF
CJPUJDBZUFNBTFNFSHFOUFTPQSJPSJUB
SJPT 4*%" ESPHBEJDDJO QMBOJmDBDJO
GBNJMJBS SJFTHPTSFQSPEVDUJWPT UJDBEF
MBFEVDBDJOTFYVBM MFHJTMBDJOFOTBMVE
DPODPOTJEFSBDJOEFKVTUJDJBZFRVJEBE 
USBTQMBOUFZEPOBDJOEFSHBOPT FOUSF
MPTNTBDUVBMFT
FJOTUBMBSFM$FOUSPEF
*OGPSNBDJOZ#BODPEF%BUPTFO#JP
UJDBDPNPVOBEFMBTQSJNFSBTBDDJPOFT
BSFBMJ[BSTF
&MBDUBEFGVOEBDJOGVFmSNBEBFMEF
KVOJPEFQPSFM1SFTCUFSP"MCFSUP
-FO ZQPS$BSMPT.3BNSF[#PFUU
OFS  3BNO $PSWBMO  .BSB &VHFOJB
.POUJFM EF %PMEO  .BSUB "TDVSSB EF
%VBSUF  $BSMPT "EPMGP 3JBSU  &EVBSEP





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

"RVJOP EFM 1VFSUP  ;FOO (PO[MF[


3PNFSP  .JHVFM 4ODIF[ (PO[MF[ 
+VMJP .POUU .PNCFSH  .BOVFM 'SFT
DP /BSDJTP(PO[MF[3PNFSP +PT7
"MUBNJSBOP Z $BSMPT .FSTBO $BOBMF 
EVSBOUFVODVSTPEFCJPUJDBRVFUVWP
DPNP PSBEPS BM FTQBPM .JHVFM 4O
DIF[(PO[MF[%VSBOUFNTEFDVBUSP
BPT TVT NJFNCSPT TF EFEJDBSPO BM FT
UVEJP EF UFNBT EF CJPUJDB B USBWT EF
SFVOJPOFT NFOTVBMFT EF MFDUVSB  FO MPT
DVBMFTUBNCJOTFPSHBOJ[BSPOEPTHSBO
EFTDPOGFSFODJBT1BTBEPTFTUPTBPT TVT
NJFNCSPToRVFGPSNBCBOQBSUFEFPUSBT
PSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFCJPUJDBo EFKBSPOEF
SFVOJSTFZFMHSVQPTFEJTPMWJ
&O MB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDB/VFT
USB4FPSBEFMB"TVODJO EFMBNBOP
EF 3PTBMJOP 1JOUP  EPDUPS FO .FEJDJ
OBZQSPGFTPSEFUJDB1FSTPOBM DSFBFM
$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPT#JPUJDPTRVF JOT
UJUVDJPOBMNFOUF EFQFOEFEFM%FQBSUB
NFOUPEF5FPMPHBZ"DDJO1BTUPSBMEF
MBVOJWFSTJEBE5JFOFFOUSFTVTBDUJWJEB
EFTQSJODJQBMFTMBQSPNPDJOZFMFTUVEJP
EF MB CJPUJDB DPO WJTJO QFSTPOBMJTUB
DVFOUB FOUSF TVT JOUFHSBOUFT B QSPGFTP
SFTEFEJTUJOUBTSFBTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUMJDB QFSTPOBTEFFYQFSJFODJBFOFM
DBNQPCJPUJDPDPNPMPTTBDFSEPUFT"M
CFSUP-FOZ4JMWJP4VSF[ZMPTEPDUPSFT
.JHVFM 'SFTDP I
 NEJDP QTJRVJBUSB 
"OUPOJB #FOUF[ 3JWBT  NEJDP QFEJB
USBZEPDFOUFEFMB6OJEBE1FEBHHJDB
EF 7JMMBSSJDB  Z FM QSPGFTPS *MEF 4JMWF
SP  QFSJPEJTUB Z EFDBOP EF MB 'BDVMUBE
EF'JMPTPGBZ$JFODJBT)VNBOBTEFMB
NJTNBVOJWFSTJEBE'VFSPOTVNOEPTF
B FTUF HSVQP $BSPMJOB 3PESHVF[  BCP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

HBEB Z.BHEBMFOB(FOFTU FOGFSNFSBZ


EJSFDUPSBEFMB&TDVFMBEF1PTUHSBEPEF
&OGFSNFSBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDB
5BNCJO  IB EFTBSSPMMBEP DPOGFSFODJBT
FOFMSFBEFMBNBDSPCJPUJDB
0USPTHSVQPTEFBTPDJBDJPOFTDJWJMFT ZB
OPSFMBDJPOBEPTDPOFMSFBEFMBTBMVE 
GVFSPOGPSNBEPTEVSBOUFFTUPTMUJNPT
BPT MPDVBMFTVOJOEJDBUJWPEFMBJN
QPSUBODJBRVFFTUBEJTDJQMJOBWBDPCSBO
EPFOFMQBT

$PNJUTEFUJDBZEFCJPUJDB
-BGPSNBDJOEFDPNJUTOPFTFTUJNV
MBEBOJSFDPOPDJEBQPSMBTBVUPSJEBEFT
" QFTBS EF FMMP  FYJTUFO FO 1BSBHVBZ
USFT UJQPT EF DPNJUT  DPOTUJUVJEPT FO
TV NBZPSB QPS QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF MB TB
MVEBVUPEJEBDUBTFOFMUFNBMPTDPNJUT
EF CJPUJDB IPTQJUBMBSJPT  DSFBEPT QBSB
FM BOMJTJT EF MPT EJMFNBT UJDP DMOJDPT
EFMPTQBDJFOUFTZFMFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPEF
OPSNBUJWBT P QSPUPDPMPT BTJTUFODJBMFT 
FOFTQFDJBMQBSBBRVFMMPTUFNBTEFDPO
nJDUP GSFDVFOUF  TVQFSBEPT DPO DSFDFT
FOONFSPQPSMPTFTUBCMFDJNJFOUPTEF
TBMVEQCMJDBZQSJWBEBMPTEFUJDBFO
JOWFTUJHBDJO  FODBSHBEPT EF MB FWBMVB
DJOEFMPTQSPUPDPMPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJO 
ZVOB$PNJTJO/BDJPOBMQBSBFM%FTB
SSPMMPEFMB#JPUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ"DBS
HPEFFTUPTDPNJUTmHVSBOUBNCJOMBT
UBSFBTEFEPDFODJBZEJGVTJOEFMBCJP
UJDB EFOUSPZGVFSBEFTVTJOTUJUVDJPOFT 
QBSB MP DVBM TF PSHBOJ[BO TFNJOBSJPT 
KPSOBEBTVPUSPTFWFOUPT DPOFYQPTJUP
SFTOBDJPOBMFTPFYUSBOKFSPT&OBMHVOPT
DBTPTTFJOWPMVDSBOUBNCJOBDUJWJEBEFT
SFMBDJPOBEBTDPOUJDBQSPGFTJPOBM





)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ.BSUB"TDVSSB

&OUSF MPT DPNJUT EF UJDB IPTQJUBMBSJB


TFQVFEFOOPNCSBSoQPSPSEFOEFDSFB
DJOoFMEFM)PTQJUBM.BUFSOP*OGBOUJM
3FJOB4PGB EFMB$SV[3PKBQBSBHVBZB 
DSFBEPFMEFBHPTUPEF RVFUJFOF
BTVDBSHPFMBTFTPSBNJFOUPFODBTPTEF
EJMFNBTUJDPT TPCSFUPEPFOFMSFBNB
UFSOPJOGBOUJM ZEFTBSSPMMBBOVBMNFOUF
DIBSMBTZDVSTPTQBSBTVTQSPGFTJPOBMFT
&M  EF NBS[P EF  TF DSF  FO MB
$UFESBZ4FSWJDJPEF1FEJBUSBEFM)PT
QJUBMEF$MOJDBTEFMB'BDVMUBEEF$JFO
DJBT .EJDBTEFMB 6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJP
OBMEF"TVODJO 6/"
VO$PNJUEF
#JPUJDB TJFOEPTVQSFDVSTPS+PT-VJT
%FMHBEJMMP &TUBCB EFEJDBEP BM BOMJTJT
EFEJMFNBTUJDPTSFGFSFOUFTBMSFBEFMB
QFEJBUSB Z TVT NJFNCSPT QBSUJDJQBCBO
FO MB EJTDVTJO EF DBTPT DMOJDPT 3F
DJOFO MVFHPEFMBWJTJUBEF&MFOB
-VHPZEFSFVOJPOFTEFBVUPFEVDBDJO 
TFDPOGPSNFM$PNJUEF#JPUJDBEFM
)PTQJUBM EF $MOJDBT  FODBCF[BEP QPS
&OSJRVFEF.FTUSBM
&OPDUVCSFEFGVFDSFBEPFM$P
NJUEFUJDBEFM$SDVMP1BSBHVBZPEF
.EJDPT &OUSF TVT GVOEBEPSFT TF FO
DPOUSBCBOFMQSFTCUFSP"MCFSUP-FO Z
MPT EPDUPSFT +VMJB 3JWBSPMB  .BSB &V
HFOJB.POUJFMEF%PMEO *HOBDJP*SB
NBOZPUSPT4VTQSJODJQBMFTGVODJPOFT
TPOBCPSEBSTJUVBDJPOFTUJDBTQVOUVBMFT
BTPMJDJUVEEFMPTTFSWJDJPTBTJTUFODJBMFT
ZSFBMJ[BSBOMJTJTEFMFZFTPSFHMBNFOUPT
SFMBDJPOBEPTDPOFMUFNB&M$PNJUTF
SFOFSFHVMBSNFOUFZIBSFBMJ[BEPEPT
DVSTPTFOMPTMUJNPTBPTi"OMJTJTEF
4FSWJDJPT"TJTUFODJBMFTZ&TUVEJPZ1SP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

QVFTUBTTPCSFMB-FZ/BDJPOBMEF"CMB
DJOZ5SBTQMBOUFTw Zi3FEBDDJOEFMB
/PSNBUJ[BDJOEFMPT$SJUFSJPTEF"E
NJTJOEF1BDJFOUFTFOMBT6OJEBEFTEF
5FSBQJB*OUFOTJWBEF/JPTZ"EVMUPTw
&M*OTUJUVUPEFM$ODFS MVFHPEFVODVS
TPJNQBSUJEPQPSNJFNCSPTEFM$PNJU
EF #JPUJDB EFM )PTQJUBM EF $MOJDBT 
DPOGPSNB TV QSPQJP $PNJU  FM DVBM 
BVORVF JOJDJB TVT BDUJWJEBEFT PmDJBM
NFOUFFMEFKVOJPEF BOOP
IBTJEPSFDPOPDJEPQPSMBTBVUPSJEBEFT
EFMBJOTUJUVDJO'PSNBOQBSUFEFM$P
NJU &MFOB 0TOBHIJ  CJPRVNJDB  3P
CFSUP3JFDIFSU FTQFDJBMJTUBFONFEJDJOB
QBMJBUJWB 8BMUFS$DFSFT NEJDP (VT
UBWP (VHJBSJ  NEJDP FTQFDJBMJ[BEP FO
PODPMPHB %FPMJOEB#FOUF[EF.BDJFM 
FOGFSNFSB -BVEFMJOB#PSKB FOGFSNFSB 
Z3BRVFM.PMJOBT QTJDMPHB&OUSFTVT
GVODJPOFTTFFODVFOUSBO BEFNTEFMBT
RVFDPNQFUFOBVODPNJUEFCJPUJDB 
CSFHBSQPSVOBNVFSUFEJHOB TJOEPMPS
Z  QPS UBOUP  FM TVNJOJTUSP EF NFEJDB
NFOUPTDPNPMBNPSmOB
&OTFDPOGPSNFM$PNJUEF#JP
UJDBEFM)PTQJUBM#BSSJP0CSFSP DPOMB
QBSUJDJQBDJOEF3JDBSEP3JWFSPT NEJ
DP DJSVKBOP  +FSOJNP #BVEP  NEJDP
QFEJBUSB .JHVFMOHFM3PMO NEJDP
QFEJBUSB 1BVMJOB$VM[POJ FOGFSNFSB Z
.BSB4BOUBOEFS TJDMPHB&TUFFTVOP
EFMPTIPTQJUBMFTEF"TVODJORVFBUJFO
EF MB NBZPS QPCMBDJO EF QFSTPOBT EF
FTDBTPT SFDVSTPT  QVFT TF IBMMB VCJDBEP
DFSDBEFVOPEFMPTQSJODJQBMFTDPSEPOFT
EFQPCSF[BEFMQBT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

&M*OTUJUVUPEF1SFWJTJO4PDJBM FOUJEBE
FODBSHBEBEFMBTFHVSJEBETPDJBMEFMPT
USBCBKBEPSFT EFM NCJUP QSJWBEP  MVFHP
EF WBSJBT SFVOJPOFT Z BPT EF USBCBKP
FOQSPEFMBCJPUJDB MPHSTVSFDPOPDJ
NJFOUPFONBZPEFM&OFTUFHSV
QPTFEFTUBDBO4BSB'MPSFOUO $BSNFO
'SVUPTEF"MNBEB $BSMPT0SUJ[ &TUFMB
&MBT *NFMEB.BSUOF[EF/F[ 'SBO
DJTDP 1FSSPUB  7JDFODJB 5FKFSB Z 0MHB
#FOUF[
&M)PTQJUBM/BDJPOBMEF*UBVHVBFTVO
IPTQJUBM EF BMUB DPNQMFKJEBE  EFQFO
EJFOUF EFM .JOJTUFSJP EF 4BMVE .BH
EBMFOB 5BUUFS  FHSFTBEB EF MPT DVSTPT
EF .BFTUSB FO #JPUJDB  EJDUBEPT QPS
MB 0SHBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB
4BMVE 0140.4 FO 4BOUJBHP EF $IJ
MF  USBCBKB FO GVODJO EF MB BDFQUBDJO
JOTUJUVDJPOBMEFM$PNJUEF#JPUJDB FM
RVF oEFCJEP BM FMFWBEP ONFSP  MB EJ
WFSTJEBE DVMUVSBM Z  QSJODJQBMNFOUF  MB
TJUVBDJO EF QPCSF[B EF MB NBZPSB EF
TVTQBDJFOUFToDPOTUJUVZFVOBOFDFTJEBE
BMBIPSBEFQSFWFOJSZSFTPMWFSDPOnJD
UPTRVFQVFEFOBGFDUBSMPTEFSFDIPTEF
TUPT
&M QSJNFS $PNJU EF UJDB FO *OWFTUJ
HBDJO EFM *OTUJUVUP EF *OWFTUJHBDJPOFT
FO$JFODJBTEFMB4BMVE PSHBOJTNPEF
QFOEJFOUF EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE /BDJPOBM
EF"TVODJO **$46/"
TFDPOGPSN
FM  EF NBS[P EF  QPS SFTPMVDJO
EFM FOUPODFT EJSFDUPS .BSUO $IJPMB
4VT GVODJPOFT DPNQSFOEFO FM BOMJTJT
Z BQSPCBDJO EF QSPUPDPMPT EF JOWFT
UJHBDJO  MB SFWJTJO EF BSUDVMPT BOUFT
EFTVQSFTFOUBDJOBDPOHSFTPTPEFTV

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

FOWPQBSBQVCMJDBDJO MBGPSNBDJOEF
QSPGFTJPOBMFTEFM*OTUJUVUPPEFBRVFMMBT
FOUJEBEFTPQFSTPOBTRVFMPTPMJDJUFO B
USBWTEFMBSFBMJ[BDJOEFTFNJOBSJPTZ
DVSTPTTPCSFFMUFNB-PTNJFNCSPTEFM
$PNJUGPSNBOQBSUFEFMDVFSQPEPDFO
UFEFMDVSTPEFQPTHSBEPTPCSF.FUPEP
MPHB EF MB *OWFTUJHBDJO  EFTBSSPMMBEP
EFTEFIBDFWBSJPTBPTFOMBJOTUJUVDJO
6OTFHVOEP$PNJUEFUJDBFO*OWFT
UJHBDJO DPOTUJUVJEPQPS&TUFCBO'FSSP 
"OUPOJP$VCJMMBTZ"HVFEB$BCFMMP TF
GPSNFODPNPQBSUFEFMB'BDVM
UBE EF $JFODJBT .EJDBT EF MB 6/"
4F SFFTUSVDUVS MVFHP QPS 3FTPMVDJO
EFM)POPSBCMF$POTFKP%JSFDUJWPEFMB
'BDVMUBE EVSBOUF   JODMVZFOEP B
*NFMEB /F[  'UJNB "ZBMB  &OSJRVF
EF.FTUSBMZ$SJTUJOB+JNOF[
&M*OTUJUVUP/BDJPOBMEF4BMVE EFQFO
EJFOUFEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVE1CMJDB 
FTVOPSHBOJTNPEFEJDBEPBMBFOTFBO
[BDPOUJOBEFMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFT$VFOUB
DPOVO$PNJUEF#JPUJDB FOUSFMPTRVF
mHVSBO +PT .BSO .BTTPMP  (VTUBWP
$SJTUBMEP -VJT4JNBODBTZ-VJT1BWFUUJ 
RVFUJFOFFOUSFTVTGVODJPOFTMBFWBMVB
DJOEFQSPZFDUPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJO
" QBSUJS EF MB DSFBDJO EFM 1SPHSBNB
3FHJPOBMEF#JPUJDB 13#
EFMB0SHB
OJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE FO
  TV QSJNFS EJSFDUPS  +VMJP .POUU
.PNCFSH  JNQVMT OPUBCMFNFOUF MBT
BDUJWJEBEFTEFCJPUJDBTFO1BSBHVBZ TF
HVJEPQPS)FSOO.MBHB NEJDPTB
MVCSJTUBRVJFO EVSBOUFTVFTUBEBDPNP
3FQSFTFOUBOUFEFMB0140.4FO1BSB
HVBZ PSHBOJ[FOKVOJPEFM DPO





)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ.BSUB"TDVSSB

KVOUBNFOUF DPO FM *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM


EF"TVODJO EFQFOEJFOUFEFM.JOJTUF
SJPEF4BMVE1CMJDBZ#JFOFTUBS4PDJBM
.41Z#4
VO5BMMFSEF"OMJTJTEF4J
UVBDJO Z &MBCPSBDJO EF VO 1SPZFDUP
QBSBFM%FTBSSPMMP/BDJPOBMEFMB#JPUJ
DB&MFWFOUPJOWPMVDSBEJGFSFOUFTJOT
UJUVDJPOFTEFMQBT DVZPTSFQSFTFOUBOUFT
TJHVJFSPOSFVOJOEPTFEVSBOUFUSFTBPT
NT IBTUBTFSSFDPOPDJEPTDPNPNJFN
CSPT EF MB $PNJTJO /BDJPOBM QBSB FM
%FTBSSPMMP EF MB #JPUJDB  QPS 3FTPMV
DJOEFM.41Z#4/EFMEF
PDUVCSF EF   B QFEJEP EF )FSOO
.MBHBBMFOUPODFT.JOJTUSPEF4BMVE 
+VMJP$TBS7FMTRVF[$POGPSNBOFTUB
DPNJTJO.BSUB"TDVSSB TFDSFUBSJBEFMB
$PNJTJO  FO SFQSFTFOUBDJO EFM *OTUJ
UVUPEF*OWFTUJHBDJPOFTFO$JFODJBTEFMB
4BMVE $PNJUEFUJDBFO*OWFTUJHBDJO
**$4
&TUFMB&MBT NEJDBQFEJBUSBEFM
$PNJUEF#JPUJDBEFM*OTUJUVUPEF1SF
WJTJO4PDJBM.BSB.BHEBMFOB5BUUFS 
NEJDB QFEJBUSB  .BHTUFS EF #JPUJDB 
)PTQJUBM /BDJPOBM EF *UBVHVB &MFOB
0TOBHIJ%PSJB CJPRVNJDBEFM$PNJU
EF #JPUJDB EFM *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM EFM
$ODFS +VMJB .BSB EFM 1JMBS 3JWBSPMB 
NEJDBQFEJBUSBEFM$PNJUEF#JPUJDB
EFM )PTQJUBM EF $MOJDBT Z EFM $SDVMP
1BSBHVBZPEF.EJDPT0MHBEF-QF[ 
FOGFSNFSB  EFM $PNJU EF #JPUJDB EFM
*OTUJUVUPEF1SFWJTJO4PDJBM"TDFODJO
%FPMJOEB #FOUF[ EF .BDJFM  FOGFSNF
SB PCTUFUSB EFM $PNJU EF #JPUJDB EFM
*OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM EFM $ODFS +VMJB
$BSNFO .PSFM EF 'FTUOFS  FOGFSNFSB
PCTUFUSB EF MB &TDVFMB EF &OGFSNFSB
EFM *OTUJUVUP %S "OEST #BSCFSP FM
QSFTCUFSP&EHBS#PCBEJMMB .BHTUFSEF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

#JPUJDBZ5FMPHP VONJFNCSPEFMB
4PDJFEBE $JFOUmDB EF &TUVEJBOUFT EF
.FEJDJOB EF MB 6/" Z VO SFQSFTFO
UBOUFEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVE1CMJDBZ
#JFOFTUBS4PDJBM5JFOFMBUBSFBEFFMBCP
SBS MBT OPSNBT OBDJPOBMFT  BDUVBMNFOUF
FO QSPDFTP EF DPOTUSVDDJO  UFOJFOEP
FO DVFOUB FM DSFDJFOUF ONFSP EF QFS
TPOBTRVFUSBCBKBOFOJOWFTUJHBDJO FO
NVDIPTDBTPTDPOHSVQPTWVMOFSBCMFT

&OTFBO[B
&O FM NCJUP FTDPMBS GPSNBM QSJNBSJP
Z TFDVOEBSJP MB FOTFBO[B FT FTQPSEJ
DBZMBQSEJEBEFWBMPSFTDPOTUJUVZFVO
HSBWF QSPCMFNB FO FTUB QPCMBDJO &O
QSFHSBEP VOJWFSTJUBSJP MB UJDB FT USBUB
EBTMPFOBMHVOBTDBSSFSBT FOFTQFDJBM
FOMBTSFGFSJEBTBMBTDJFODJBTEFMBTBMVE
-PT SFGFSFOUFT BDBENJDPT UFOFNPT MB
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFMJEFSBSMBFEVDBDJO
EFQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBTEJGFSFOUFTDBSSF
SBTZEFMQCMJDPFOHFOFSBMDPNPMBOJ
DB GPSNB EF BTFHVSBS RVF MPT EFSFDIPT
IVNBOPTTFBOSFTQFUBEPT
&O FOMBDBSSFSBEF.FEJDJOBEF
MB6/" MBUJDB.EJDBFSBDPOTJEFSB
EBVOPEFMPTUFNBTFOMBTDUFESBTEF
.FEJDJOB-FHBMZ%FPOUPMPHB.EJDB
%VSBOUF FTF NJTNP BP  FO MB &TDVFMB
EF&OGFSNFSBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJ
DBTFFNQJF[BOBEFTBSSPMMBSMBTDUFESBT
EFUJDB1SPGFTJPOBM UJDB(FOFSBM UJ
DB .EJDB Z #JPUJDB  DPNP DVSTPT EF
QPTHSBEP&OTFJODPSQPSBMBDUF
ESBEF#JPUJDBDPNPNBUFSJBDVSSJDVMBS
FOMB&TDVFMBEF&OGFSNFSBZ0CTUFUSJ
DJB *OTUJUVUP "OEST #BSCFSP  FOUJEBE
EFQFOEJFOUFEFMB6/"





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

%FTEF TFEFTBSSPMMBSPODVSTPTEF
QPTHSBEP FO CJPUJDB QBSB MPT NEJDPT
SFTJEFOUFTEFMBDUFESBEF1FEJBUSBEF
MB 'BDVMUBE EF $JFODJBT .EJDBT EF MB
6/"  Z QBSB MPT NEJDPT SFTJEFOUFT
FO 1FEJBUSB EFM *OTUJUVUP EF 1SFWJTJO
4PDJBM  QSPWFOJFOUFT EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUMJDB EF 7JMMBSSJDB  %FQBSUBNFOUP
EFM(VBJSB
$POMBSFGPSNBDVSSJDVMBSEF FO
MB 'BDVMUBE EF $JFODJBT .EJDBT EF MB
6/"  F JNQVMTBEP QPS FM $PNJU EF
#JPUJDB EFM )PTQJUBM EF $MOJDBT  TF
JOUSPEVKFSPOFOFMQMBOEFFTUVEJPTMBT
NBUFSJBTEFUJDB.EJDBZ#JPUJDBFO
FMTFHVOEPDVSTPZDPOVOBDBSHBEF
IPSBT

1VCMJDBDJPOFT
(JMEBEF'BUJNB#VSHTUBMMFSEF+VTUJOJB
OPFEJU FO FMMJCSPi3FTQPOTB
CJMJEBE 1FOBM EF MPT .EJDPT -FHJTMB
DJO %PDUSJOBZ+VSJTQSVEFODJBw FOFM
DVBM WBSJPT EF TVT DBQUVMPT TF SFmFSFO
BUFNBTEFCJPUJDB DPNPFMBCPSUP MB
FVUBOBTJB  MB FVHFOFTJB  BZVEB BM TVJDJ
EJP Z DPOTFOUJNJFOUP 4J CJFO NVDIPT
EF FTUPT UFNBT OP TF IBMMBO UJQJmDBEPT
FOMBMFHJTMBDJOQBSBHVBZB MBBVUPSBMPT
FODBSBOPTMPEFTEFQVOUPEFWJTUBMFHBM
TJOPCJPUJDP #VSHTUBMMFS 

&OKVOJPEFFM$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPT
EF #JPUJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUMJDB
/VFTUSB 4FPSB EF "TVODJO MBO[ MB
QVCMJDBDJO FTQFDJBMJ[BEB #JPUJDB  DPO
VOB QFSJPEJDJEBE EF EPT ONFSPT QPS
BPZBSUDVMPTEFBVUPSFTOBDJPOBMFTF
JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

%VSBOUF FM 7* $POHSFTP #SBTJMFSP EF


#JPUJDB *$POHSFTPEFM.&3$0463
Z'PSVNEFMB3FE#JPUJDBEF6/&4
$0 GVFMBO[BEBMBQSJNFSBQVCMJDBDJO
DJFOUmDB EF FTUB SFE i&TUBUVUP &QJTUF
NPMHJDP EF MB #JPUJDBw  DPPSEJOBEB
QPS 7PMOFJ (BSSBGB  EF #SBTJM  .JHVFM
,PUUPX  EF $IJMF  Z "MZB 4BBEB  SFT
QPOTBCMFEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDBEFMB
0mDJOBEF6/&4$0FO.YJDP
&O KVMJP EF   FO FM .JOJTUFSJP EF
4BMVE 1CMJDB Z #JFOFTUBS 4PDJBM  GVF
QSFTFOUBEPFMMJCSPi4BMVE1CMJDB&O
GPRVF #JPUJDPw  EF )FSOO .MBHB Z
DPMBCPSBEPSFT&TUFWPMVNFODVFOUBDPO
MBDPOUSJCVDJOEF+VBO$BSMPT;BOPUUJ 
RVNJDPJOEVTUSJBMQBSBHVBZP
&O  GVF QSFTFOUBEB MB UFSDFSB QV
CMJDBDJO EF MB 3FE -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z
EFM$BSJCF#JPUJDB 6/&4$0 i1BOP
SBNBTPCSFMBMFHJTMBDJOFONBUFSJBEF
HFOPNB IVNBOP FO "NSJDB -BUJOB Z
FM$BSJCFw DPPSEJOBEBQPS"MZBB4BBEB
Z%JFHP7BMBET$POUJFOFMBDPOUSJCV
DJO EF +PSHF 4FBMM4BTJBJO  DBUFESUJDP
EF %FSFDIP $POTUJUVDJPOBM /BDJPOBM
Z$PNQBSBEPFOMBTGBDVMUBEFTEF%F
SFDIP EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE /BDJPOBM EF
"TVODJOZEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDB
EF"TVODJO BDFSDBEFMBMFHJTMBDJOFO
NBUFSJB EF HFOPNB IVNBOP FO 1BSB
HVBZ
&MEFNBS[PEFMTFQSFTFOUFM
i.BOVBMEF#JPUJDBi BEBQUBEPBM1SP
HSBNBEF1SFHSBEPEF#JPUJDB FTDSJUP
QPS&OSJRVFEF.FTUSBMZDPMBCPSBEPSFT
&OFTUFQVFEFOMFFSTFDBQUVMPTTPCSFFM
JOJDJPZmOBMEFMBWJEB QMBOJmDBDJOGB





)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ.BSUB"TDVSSB

NJMJBS DVJEBEPTQBMJBUJWPT HFOPNBIV


NBOP  FDPMPHB  UJDB FO JOWFTUJHBDJO 
FOUSFPUSPT

$VSTPT KPSOBEBTZDPOHSFTPT
%FTEFMBTBDUJWJEBEFTSFGFSFOUFTB
CJPUJDBIBOJEPFOBVNFOUP PSHBOJ[B
EBTFOTVNBZPSBQPSMPTDPNJUTEFUJ
DBZCJPUJDBEFOUSPEFTVTGVODJPOFTEF
FEVDBDJO DPOUJOVB &O VO JOJDJP GVF
SPOEJSJHJEBTBQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBTBMVE
TJO FNCBSHP  EVSBOUF MPT MUJNPT BPT
IBOTJEPBCJFSUBTBMQCMJDPFOHFOFSBM
&OKVOJPEFTFMMFWBDBCPFOMB
'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOBEF7JMMBSSJDB %F
QBSUBNFOUPEFM(VBJSB FMQSJNFSDVSTP
EFCJPUJDB$POMBEPDFODJBEFMPTEPD
UPSFT +VMJB 3JWBSPMB Z %BOJFM %PNJOJ 
Z EFM QBESF "MCFSUP #FSUBDDJOJ FTUVWP
EJSJHJEPFTQFDJBMNFOUFBFTUVEJBOUFTEF
.FEJDJOB 0CTUFUSJDJBZ&OGFSNFSB
&M1SJNFS4FNJOBSJPEF#JPUJDBTFMMFW
BDBCPFOUSFFMZFMEFOPWJFNCSF
EF0SHBOJ[BEPQPSFM$PNJUEF
UJDB FO *OWFTUJHBDJO EFM *OTUJUVUP EF
*OWFTUJHBDJPOFTFO$JFODJBTEFMB4BMVE
EF MB 6/"  DPOU DPO MB BTJTUFODJB EF
OVNFSPTPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBTBMVE
-B "DBEFNJB EF .FEJDJOB  SFDPOPDJEB
FOUJEBEEFEJDBEBBMBEJGVTJOEFDPOP
DJNJFOUPT B NEJDPT HSBEVBEPT  QSFTJ
EJEBQPS$BSMPT.FSTO$BOBMF EJPVO
GVFSUFSFTQBMEPBMBCJPUJDBDPOFMEFTB
SSPMMPEFWBSJBTDPOGFSFODJBTFOUSF
Z
"QBSUJSEF BJOTUBODJBTEFMB"TP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DJBDJOEF1SPGFTPSFTEFMB'BDVMUBEEF
$JFODJBT.EJDBTEFMB6/" FTJOWJUB
EBMBQSPGFTPSB.BSB&MFOB-VHP RVJFO
oEFTEFFOUPODFToIBQBSUJDJQBEPBOVBM
NFOUFDPNPDPOGFSFODJTUBJOWJUBEBDPO
UFNBTTPCSFMBDPOGPSNBDJOEFDPNJUT
EF CJPUJDB  BVUPFEVDBDJO Z EJMFNBT
UJDPTBTPDJBEPTPOPBQSPCMFNBTIPT
QJUBMBSJPT FOMPTOVNFSPTPTTFNJOBSJPT
Z KPSOBEBT PSHBOJ[BEPT QPS FM $PNJU
EF #JPUJDB EFM )PTQJUBM EF $MOJDBT
-PT QSPGFTPSFT $BSMPT %B[ Z +PT %P
NOHVF[ BNCPTFTQBPMFT QBSUJDJQBSPO
FOBHPTUPEFMFOFMTFNJOBSJPi-B
#JPUJDBZFMWBMPSEFMBWJEB)VNBOB
.BOJQVMBDJO(FOUJDB)VNBOBZ&Y
QFSJNFOUBDJODPO4FSFT)VNBOPT$F
NFOUFSJPEF$PODJFODJBTw&TUFFWFOUP
GVFPSHBOJ[BEPQPSFM*OTUJUVUP&NNB
OVFM.PVOJFSEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJ
DBEF"TVODJO FM$PNJUEF#JPUJDB
EFM)PTQJUBMEF$MOJDBTZMB$PNJTJO
/BDJPOBM QBSB FM %FTBSSPMMP EF MB #JP
UJDB
&OUSFFMZFMEFKVMJPEF DPO
FMmOEFGPSUBMFDFSMPTDPNJUTEFUJDB
FOJOWFTUJHBDJOFOFM)PTQJUBM#BVUJTUB
EF "TVODJO  TF MMFW B DBCP VO DVSTP
EFCJPUJDBEFPDIPIPSBTEFEVSBDJO 
EJDUBEPDPONUPEPTEFFTUVEJPEF*OT
UJUVUJPOBM 3FWJFX #PBSE  6OJWFSTJUZ PG
/FX.FYJDPZ0DFPG)VNBO3FTFBSDI
1SPUFDUJPO
-B$PNJTJO/BDJPOBMQBSBFM%FTBSSP
MMPEFMB#JPUJDBFO1BSBHVBZIBPSHBOJ
[BEPMBTSBZEBKPSOBEBTOBDJPOBMFT FM
EFPDUVCSFEFZFMOPWJFNCSF
EFM SFTQFDUJWBNFOUF&OBNCBTTF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

IBDPOUBEPDPONTEFQBSUJDJQBO
UFT  FOUSF MPT RVF TF EFTUBDBO QSPGFTJP
OBMFTEFMBTBMVE FTUVEJBOUFTEFOJWFMTF
DVOEBSJPZNJFNCSPTEFMBDJVEBEBOB
%FTEFIBDFWBSJPTBPT FMUFNBCJPUJDP
WJFOFTJFOEPJODMVJEPFTQFDJBMNFOUFFO
MPTDPOHSFTPTEF1FEJBUSB (JOFDPMPHB 
&OGFSNFSB Z &OGFSNFSB 0ODPMHJDB 
QPS OPNCSBS TMP BMHVOPT &OUSF MPT
JOWJUBEPTTFFODVFOUSB7DUPS1FODIBT
[BEFI NEJDPHFOFUJTUBBSHFOUJOP RVF
QBSUJDJQ DPO WBSJPT UFNBT EVSBOUF FM
$POHSFTPEF1FEJBUSBEF
1BSBHVBZGVFQBTDPPSHBOJ[BEPSEFM7*
$POHSFTP#SBTJMFSPEF#JPUJDB *$PO
HSFTPEFM.&3$0463Z'SVNEFMB
3FE -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z EFM $BSJCF EF
#JPUJDB6/&4$0 CBKPFMMFNBi#JP
UJDB .FJP"NCJFOUFF7JEB)VNBOBw 
MMFWBEP B DBCP FO 'P[ EF *HVB[  #SB
TJM FOUSFFMEFBHPTUPZFMEFTFQ
UJFNCSFEF/VNFSPTPTGVFSPOMPT
QBSBHVBZPTRVFQBSUJDJQBSPO DPOUFNBT
DFOUSBMFTZUFNBTMJCSFT
&MFS$POHSFTP*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JP
UJDB PSHBOJ[BEP FO 1BSBHVBZ  i#JPUJDB
1FSTPOBMJTUB FO VO .VOEP (MPCBMJ[B
EPw  GVF PSHBOJ[BEP QPS FM $POTPSDJP
EF .EJDPT $BUMJDPT Z MB 1POUJmDJB
"DBEFNJB QPS MB 7JEB 4F MMFW B DBCP
FOUSFFMZFMEFKVMJPEFZBTJT
UJFSPO NT EF RVJOJFOUPT QBSUJDJQBOUFT
EF MPT NCJUPT SFMJHJPTP  FEVDBUJWP  EF
MB TBMVE  FOUSF PUSPT JOUFSFTBEPT 1BSUJ
DJQBSPO.POT&MJP4HSFDDJB QSFTJEFOUF
EF MB 1POUJmDJB "DBEFNJB QPS MB 7JEB
1"7
 EFM 7BUJDBOP  .POT .BVSJDJP
$BMJQBSJ  PmDJBM EF FTUVEJP EF MB 1"7 

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

.POT'FSOBOEP$IPNBM EF$IJMF Z


3VCO3FWFMMP EF"SHFOUJOB

%FDMBSBDJO6OJWFSTBMTPCSF
#JPUJDBZ%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT
&M  EF OPWJFNCSF EF  TF SFBMJ[
FM 4FNJOBSJP 3FHJPOBM i#JPUJDB VO
%FTBGP *OUFSOBDJPOBM )BDJB VOB %F
DMBSBDJO 6OJWFSTBMw  DPOWPDBEP QPS FM
.JOJTUFSJP EF +VTUJDJB Z %FSFDIPT )V
NBOPTEF"SHFOUJOB EVSBOUFFMDVBMTF
SFEBDUMB$BSUBEF#VFOPT"JSFTTPCSF
#JPUJDBZ%FSFDIPT)VNBOPT VOQSP
OVODJBNJFOUP TPCSF DVFTUJPOFT GVO
EBNFOUBMFT EFTEF FM DPOUFYUP QPMUJDP 
TPDJPFDPONJDP Z DVMUVSBM EF "NSJDB
-BUJOBZFM$BSJCF-BNJTJWBGVFFOWJBEB
BMB4FDSFUBSBEFM$PNJU*OUFSOBDJPOBM
EF#JPUJDBEFMB6/&4$0 DPOTJEFSBO
EPRVFVOJOTUSVNFOUPEFCJPUJDBDPO
QSFUFOTJPOFT EF VOJWFSTBMJEBE OP QP
ESBEFKBSEFMBEPFMEFSFDIPBMBTBMVE 
BMBHVBQPUBCMF MBQPCSF[B OJBWBMBSMB
JOFRVJEBEZMBEFTJHVBMEBERVFBGFDUBB
MBNBZPSBEFOVFTUSPTQBTFT-B$BSUB
GVF BDPNQBBEB EF PUSBT FOWJBEBT QPS
MBTDBODJMMFSBTEFMPTQBTFTEFMBSFHJOB
MBTFEFEFMB6/&4$0-B%FDMBSBDJO
6OJWFSTBM TPCSF #JPUJDB Z %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTGVFBQSPCBEBQPSMBVOBOJNJ
EBEEFMPTQBTFTDPNQPOFOUFTEFMB
PSHBOJ[BDJOFMEFPDUVCSFEF 
EVSBOUF MB $POGFSFODJB (FOFSBM EF MB
6/&4$0 SFBMJ[BEB FO 1BST  'SBODJB
$PO TVT  BSUDVMPT  RVF JODMVZFO MBT
NPEJmDBDJPOFT TPMJDJUBEBT  DPOTUJUVZF
VO JOTUSVNFOUP FO FM RVF TF QFSDJCF FM
DPNQSPNJTPDPOMBTQPCMBDJPOFTWVMOF
SBCMFTZMPTEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT





)JTUPSJBEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDBFO1BSBHVBZ.BSUB"TDVSSB

$PODMVTJO
&O 1BSBHVBZ  EFTQVT EF DBTJ RVJODF
BPTEFEFTBSSPMMP MBCJPUJDBTFFOGSFO
UBOPTMPBMBGBMUBEFEJGVTJOEFTVUF
NUJDBFOFMNFEJPSVSBM EFGPSNBDJO
EFSFGFSFODJBMFTBDBENJDPT EFDPNJUT
EF CJPUJDB IPTQJUBMBSJPT  EF SFDPOPDJ
NJFOUPQPSQBSUFMBTBVUPSJEBEFTFOUP
EPTMPTNCJUPT EFVOTJTUFNBOBDJPOBM

EF FWBMVBDJO UJDB EF JOWFTUJHBDJO 


TJOP UBNCJO BPUSPTEFTBGPTDPNPMB
EFTOVUSJDJO MBQPCSF[B MBEFTUSVDDJO
EFMNFEJPBNCJFOUFZMPTFMFWBEPTJOEJ
DBEPSFTEFNPSUBMJEBEJOGBOUJMZNBUFS
OB&TUBTDBSFODJBTFTQFSBOVOBSFTQVFT
UB CBTBEB FO MB CJPUJDB Z MPT EFSFDIPT
IVNBOPT

3FGFSFODJBT
"TDVSSB ."3PTBMFT $ 
"OMJTJTZ1FSGJM#JPUJDPEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJOFO
4BMVE 1CMJDB &O .MBHB  )FSOO 4BMVE 1CMJDB &OGPRVF #JPUJDP $BSBDBT 
%*4*/-*.&% QQ
"TDVSSB ."3PTBMFT $ 
'PSNBDJOZ$BQBDJUBDJOEF3FDVSTPT)VNBOPT
EF MB #JPUJDB FO 4BMVE 1CMJDB &O .MBHB  )FSOO 4BMVE 1CMJDB &OGPRVF
#JPUJDP$BSBDBT %*4*/-*.&% QQ
"TDVSSB  ." 
 $PNFOUBSJPT B MB 1POFODJB EF -FO 0MJW &O (BSSBGB  7 
,PUUPX .4BBEB "&TUBUVUP&QJTUFNPMHJDPEFMB#JPUJDB.YJDP 6/".
6/&4$0  Q
#VSHTUBMMFSEF+VTUJOJBOP ( 
3FTQPOTBCJMJEBE1FOBMEFMPT.EJDPT-FHJTMBDJO 
%PDUSJOBZ+VSJTQSVEFODJB"TVODJO (SBQIJT
%F.FTUSBM &OSJRVF 
.BOVBMEF#JPUJDB"TVODJO &EJDJOEFM"VUPS
%JSFDDJO (FOFSBM EF &TUBETUJDBT  &ODVFTUBT Z $FOTPT %(&&$
 
 1SJODJQBMFT
3FTVMUBEPT&ODVFTUB*OUFHSBEBEF)PHBSFT1BSBHVBZ 'FSOBOEPEFMB.PSB
014 SFBEF"OMJTJTEF4BMVEZ4JTUFNBTEF*OGPSNBDJO4BOJUBSJB
 
*OJDJBUJWB
3FHJPOBM EF %BUPT #TJDPT FO 4BMVE 4JTUFNBT EF *OGPSNBDJPOFT 5DOJDBT FO 4BMVE
8BTIJOHUPO%$ &E014
1BSBHVBZ$POTUJUVDJO/BDJPOBMEFM1BSBHVBZ+VOJP 
1BSBHVBZ&YDMVTJO4PDJBMFO4BMVE0DUVCSF 
1BSBHVBZ3FTPMVDJOEFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4BMVE1CMJDBZ#JFOFTUBS4PDJBMEFPDUVCSFEF

1SP#JPUJDB"DUBEF'VOEBDJOEF1SP#JPUJDB+VOJP 
4FBMM4BTJBJO + 
1BOPSBNBTPCSFMBMFHJTMBDJOFONBUFSJBEFHFOPNBIVNBOP
FO1BSBHVBZ&O4BBEB "7BMBET (1BOPSBNBTPCSFMBMFHJTMBDJOFONBUFSJB
EFHFOPNBIVNBOPFO"NSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCF1VCMJDBDJO$JFOUGJDB/ 3FE
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM$BSJCF#JPUJDB 6/&4$0 QQ
6/&4$0 
 %FDMBSBDJO 6OJWFSTBM TPCSF #JPUJDB Z %FSFDIPT )VNBOPT 1BST 
6/&4$0

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





#JPUJDBFO1FS
3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHB

*OUSPEVDDJO

&

O 1FS MB CJPUJDB OP IB BERVJSJEP


UPEBWB JEFOUJEBE QSPQJB &MMB FT
BMHPNTRVFMPTQSPCMFNBTUJDPTEFMB
QSDUJDBNEJDB6OBEFTVTDPORVJTUBT
FT RVF FO UPEBT MBT FOUJEBEFT EF TBMVE
FYJTUB FM $PNJU )PTQJUBMBSJP EF UJDB
$)&
 NJFOUSBT RVF  FOUSF OPTPUSPT 
UPEBWBTFEFTFBRVFFMDPNJUEFUJDB
EFM $PMFHJP .EJDP SFTVFMWB UPEPT MPT
QSPCMFNBT JHVBMNFOUF  RVF MB $PNJ
TJO/BDJPOBMEF-VDIBDPOUSBFM4*%"
TPMVDJPOFUPEPMPSFMBUJWPBFTUBQBOEF
NJB
-BQSJNFSBUFTJTTPCSFFVUBOBTJBZMBQV
CMJDBDJO EFM MJCSP DPOTJHVJFOUF QPS MB
6OJWFSTJEBE 1FSVBOB $BZFUBOP )FSF
EJBZBFTVOBSFBMJEBE .POUPSJ5VEF
MB 
1PSPUSBQBSUF MPTNFEJPTEF
DPNVOJDBDJO  DPO SFMBUJWB GSFDVFODJB 
USBUBO EF NFOUBMJ[BS B MB QPCMBDJO FO
TVT QSFKVJDJPT EF OP QFSNJUJS RVF TVT
SHBOPTTFBOFYUSBEPTQBSBTBMWBSPUSBT
WJEBT&TQFSBNPTMMFHBSBTFSUFTUJHPTEF
MPTGSVUPTEFFTUFNPWJNJFOUP
&T OFDFTBSJP DSFBS DPNJUT EF CJPUJDB
RVF SFHVMFO MBT BDDJPOFT NEJDBT SFMB
DJPOBEBTDPOMPTUSBTQMBOUFTEFSHBOPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&TUF IFDIP  VOJEP B PUSPT OVNFSPTPT 


IBDFOWFSRVFFO1FSTFIBJOJDJBEPMB
FUBQB EF SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EF FTUB EJTDJ
QMJOB
-BUFDOPMPHBNEJDBTFIBUPSOBEPTV
NBNFOUFDPTUPTBFOTVBDDJO BNCJHVB
FODVBOUPBBZVEBTPDJBMFJODJFSUBDPO
SFMBDJOBTVFmDBDJB)BQSPEVDJEPJO
UFOTB QPMNJDB FO MPT QBTFT EFM PSCF
)BEBEPMVHBSBMOBDJNJFOUPEFMBCJP
UJDBNPEFSOBZIBDSFBEPDPODJFODJBEF
MBVSHFODJBEFTVSFHVMBDJO1FSOPTF
FYDMVZFEFMBUPNBEFDPODJFODJBOJEF
MB VSHFODJB EF FTUB SFHVMBDJO -MBOPT 


-BUSJQMFEJNFOTJOEFMBNFEJDJOBEJP
PSJHFOBMBCJPUJDBTPCSFMBTCBTFTEFMB
UJDB NEJDB  MB DVBM  WJTUB EFTEF PUSP
OHVMP  FT FM FTUVEJP TJTUFNUJDP EF MB
DPOEVDUB IVNBOB FO FM DBNQP EF MBT
DJFODJBTEFMBWJEBZMBBUFODJOEFMBTB
MVE EFTEFFMGVOEBNFOUPEFMPTWBMPSFT
ZQSJODJQJPTNPSBMFT
-BCJPUJDBFO1FSOPIBEBEPMVHBSBM
FKFSDJDJP QSPGFTJPOBM FYDMVTJWP EF FTUB
SBNBEFMTBCFSIVNBOP4VFOTFBO[BTF
JNQBSUF FO MBT GBDVMUBEFT EF .FEJDJOB 
1TJDPMPHB 'JMPTPGBZ5FPMPHBZIBJEP





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

HBOBOEPUFSSFOPZDPOTFHVJEPTVQSPQJB
JEFOUJEBE 5BNCJO IB FMFWBEP MB JN
QPSUBODJBEFNBUFSJBTUBMFTDPNP'JMPTP
GBEFMB.FEJDJOB "OUSPQPMPHB.EJDB
Z&QJTUFNPMPHB.EJDB$POTFHVJEBTV
QSPQJBJEFOUJEBE RVFEBQFOEJFOUFFMDB
NJOPEFTVSFDPOPDJNJFOUPZEJGVTJO
"DDJPOFT NEJDBT FTFODJBMFT FO MB DB
MJEBE EF WJEB RVFEBO B MB FTQFSB EF MB
CJPUJDB-BMFZEFUSBTQMBOUFTFTVOBEF
FMMBT JHVBMNFOUF  VOB NBZPS DSFBDJO
EFDPNJUTEFUJDBJOTUJUVDJPOBMFTZEF
JOWFTUJHBDJO-BUJDBQSFWFOUJWBFTUB
MBFTQFSBEFTVQFSBSBMBiUJDBEFTBMWB
WJEBTw  QSPQJB EF QBTFT DPO QPCMBDJO
DSFDJFOUFZSFDVSTPTFDPONJDPTEFDSF
DJFOUFT 'FMJ[NFOUF  FM DPOTFOUJNJFOUP
JOGPSNBEPBWBO[BEBBEBFOTVBDFQ
UBDJO -B QBUFSOJEBE SFTQPOTBCMF Z MB
QMBOJmDBDJOGBNJMJBSTFEFTBSSPMMBOMFO
UBNFOUFZOPBMDBO[BOBOOJWFMFTQUJ
NPT&MONFSPEFBEPMFTDFOUFTFNCB
SB[BEBTZEFNBESFTTPMUFSBTTFNBOUJFOF
BMSFEFEPSEFMZMMFHBSBMBBEVMUF[
QSFTVQPOF NVDIBTWFDFT UFOFSZBUSFT
IJKPTZVOQBSEFBCPSUPTFOMBIJTUPSJB
QFSTPOBM-BQMEPSBBOUJDPODFQUJWBZMB
EFMEBTJHVJFOUFTFNBOUJFOFOFOMBQP
MNJDB Z MB PQJOJO EF MB NVKFS OP FT
UPEBWBNBZPSJUBSJB
&MBCPSUPJMFHBMTFTJHVFQSBDUJDBOEPFO
NFEJPEFHSBWFTEFmDJFODJBTEFBTFQTJBZ
DPOQFMJHSPEFNVFSUFFONVKFSFTKWF
OFT -PT DSDVMPT BDBENJDPT Z TPDJBMFT
NBOUJFOFO TJMFODJP GSFOUF B MB WBTFDUP
NB MJHBEVSBZTFDDJOEFUSPNQBT$PO
NBZPS SB[O  MB NVKFS HVBSEB TJMFODJP
GSFOUFBUPEPTFTUPTBDUPTEFTBMVE

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&OSFMBDJODPOMBFVUBOBTJB TFEJTDVUF
BDUVBMNFOUF TJ FM BTFTJOBUP DPNQBTJWP
DSFBSNTQSPCMFNBTRVFMPTRVFQVFEB
TPMVDJPOBS *HVBMNFOUF  FM iUFTUBNFOUP
WJUBMw TF FODVFOUSB FO EJTDVTJO .VZ
FTQPSEJDBNFOUF TF SFBMJ[BO NFTBT SF
EPOEBTPTFTJPOFTDJFOUmDBTTPCSFFTUF
UFNB
1SPCMFNBBQBSUFFTMBFOTFBO[BBMPTOJ
PTEJTDBQBDJUBEPTFTEJGDJMMPHSBSTVJO
UFHSBDJOFOFTDVFMBTDPNVOFT OPFYJTUF
VO ONFSP TVmDJFOUF EF FTDVFMBT FTQF
DJBMFTZUPEBWBRVFEBVODBNJOPQPSSF
DPSSFSFOMBBDFQUBDJOZBZVEBTPDJBM
$PO SFMBDJO BM 4*%"  TF CVTDB oDPO
YJUPQBSDJBMoRVFTFTVQFSFMBEJTDSJNJ
OBDJOTPDJBMZEFBUFODJOIPTQJUBMBSJB
EF FTUPT QBDJFOUFT &M UFNPS Z MB JHOP
SBODJBIBDJBFTUBFOGFSNFEBEFTUPEBWB
NVZMMBNBUJWP

)POPSJP%FMHBEP QSFDVSTPS
)POPSJP%FMHBEP QSPGFTPSQFSVBOPEF
1TJRVJBUSB QSJNFSSFDUPSEFMB6OJWFS
TJEBE1FSVBOB$BZFUBOP)FSFEJB BOUF
SJPSNFOUF EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE /BDJPOBM
.BZPSEF4BO.BSDPTF JHVBMNFOUF FY
NJOJTUSPEF&EVDBDJOFO1FS SFQSF
TFOUoEFTEFIBTUBoMBWJTJO
IVNBOTUJDBEFMB.FEJDJOBZMBTJEFBT
FVSPQFBT FO MB DVMUVSB EF MB TBMVE 1B
SBGSBTFBCB TJFNQSF B 4DIJMMFS  Z BDUVBM
NFOUF TF QVFEF QSPCBS GDJMNFOUF RVF
BQMJDBCBTVBOMJTJTNPSBMFOFMFTUVEJP
EFMQBDJFOUFQTJRVJUSJDP
)POPSJP%FMHBEPTJOUJVOBHSBOJEFO
UJmDBDJO DPO MB DVMUVSB Z QTJRVJBUSB





#JPUJDBFO1FS3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHB

BMFNBOBT &O TV BSUDVMP i&O UPSOP BM


BMNBBKFOBwDJUBB4DIJMMFS SFmSJOEPTF
BMQSPDFTPEFDPNQSFOTJOi4JRVJFSFT
DPNQSFOEFSUFBUNJTNP NJSBDPNPTF
DPOEVDFOMPTPUSPTw
&YQMJD TJFNQSF oFO TVT DMBTFT  MJCSPT 
ZFOMBDPNVOJDBDJOQFSTPOBMoRVFMB
NFEJDJOB UJFOF VOB EJNFOTJO USJQMF
DJFOUmDB  QSPGFTJPOBM Z BTJTUFODJBM  Z 
BEFNT KVFHBVOSPMEFDJTJWPFOFMDBN
CJPUFDOPMHJDPZBYJPMHJDPEFOVFTUSB
DVMUVSB
&TUPTQSJODJQJPT RVFSFTQPOEBOBMQFO
TBNJFOUP IVNBOTUJDP EF TV UJFNQP 
PGSFDBO MB CBTF QBSB RVF  IBDF USFJOUB
BPT  FO FM SFTUP EFM NVOEP FNQF[BSB
B EFTBSSPMMBSTF MB QPTJDJO QPMNJDB EF
MB CJPUJDB &MMB FT FM DPOKVOUP EF DP
OPDJNJFOUPTDJFOUmDPTRVFFTUVEJBOMB
USBOTGPSNBDJOUFDOPMHJDBEFMBNFEJ
DJOB"EFNT FTMBSFTQVFTUBSBDJPOBMB
MPTQSPCMFNBTNPSBMFT QPMUJDPTZTPDJB
MFTRVFQMBOUFBOMBTGPSNBTEFBUFODJOB
MBTBMVEIVNBOB DPOMBOJDBmOBMJEBE
EF QSPEVDJS CFOFmDJPT FO MBT JOUFSWFO
DJPOFTCJPNEJDBT
)POPSJP %FMHBEP CSJOE FO DMBTFT Z
MJCSPT MB JOGPSNBDJO OFDFTBSJB QBSB
DPOTJEFSBS MP RVF IPZ FO EB TF DPOP
DF DPNP MPT USFT OJWFMFT EF MB CJPUJDB 
BTBCFS
NBDSPUJDB UJDBBNCJFOUBM 
FDPMHJDB  CJPNEJDB Z QMBOFUBSJB 

NFTPCJPUJDB  UJDB EF MB JOUFSWFODJO
CJPUDOJDBTPCSFMBWJEBIVNBOB JODMV
ZFOEP QSJODJQBMNFOUF BM OBDJNJFOUP 
EFTBSSPMMPIVNBOP MBNVFSUF FMBCPS
UPZBMBFVUBOBTJB Z
NJDSPCJPUJDB 
UJDB NEJDB QSPQJBNFOUF EJDIB  RVF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DPNQSFOEF MB SFMBDJO UFSBQVUJDB Z MB


BUFODJOEFMBTBMVE
"USBWTEFTVTFOTFBO[BTTPCSFMBTSFMB
DJPOFTFOUSFmMPTPGB NFEJDJOB FQJTUF
NPMPHBZBOUSPQPMPHBNEJDBJOHSFTB
BMBCJPUJDB QSJODJQBMNFOUFBMBNFTP
Z NJDSPCJPUJDB "MHVOBT EF TVT FOTF
BO[BTQSJODJQBMFTUVWJFSPOSFMBDJODPO
MB NFEJDJOB Z MB mMPTPGB &TUB MUJNB 
DVBOEPJOHSFTBBMBNFEJDJOB SFDPSSFMPT
QMBOPTDMTJDPTEFMBPOUPMPHB HOPTFP
MPHBZUJDB TFHOTFUSBUFEFQBUPMPHB
DMOJDBPUFSBQVUJDB)POPSJP%FMHBEP
QSPQJDJFTUBFOTFBO[BFO1FS ZEFK
FMSFUPEFTVDPOUJOVBDJOBMBTVOJWFSTJ
EBEFTQFSVBOBT
-FHMBFOTFBO[BEFRVFNFEJDJOBTJH
OJmDBNFEJUBDJOZDVSBEFMIPNCSFFO
GFSNP -B WJEB NEJDB TJO NFEJUBDJO
OPFTWJEB-BWJEBNEJDBFTNFUBGTJDB 
MHJDBZNPSBM WBMFEFDJS mMPTPGBN
EJDB FO FKFSDJDJP .JFOUSBT FYJTUB NT
UFDOPMPHB NTJNQPSUBOUFTFSFMQFO
TBNJFOUPDSUJDP.JFOUSBTFYJTUBNFOPT
QFOTBNJFOUP DSUJDP  NT QFMJHSPTP Z
DPTUPTPTFSFMFKFSDJDJPEFMBNFEJDJOB

*OJDJPTEFMNPWJNJFOUPCJPUJDP
QFSVBOP
&MNPWJNJFOUPCJPUJDPFO1FSTFJOJ
DJBFO DVBOEPMB+VOUB%JSFDUJWB
EFM$PMFHJP.EJDPJOJDJMBDPOWPDBUP
SJBBNFTBTSFEPOEBTBVOBWFJOUFOBEF
NEJDPT DPO WPDBDJO UJDB  CJPUJDB Z
EFPOUPMHJDBFOSFBMJEBE TFGPSNVOB
DPNJTJOJOUFHSBEB FOUSFPUSPT QPS(VJ
MMFSNP$POUSFSBTZ4BMPNO;BWBMB QFSP
RVF OP DPOUJOVBSPO MB MBCPS JOJDJBEB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

&OKVOJPEFTFGVOEFO$BSBDBT
MB 'FEFSBDJO -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF *OT
UJUVDJPOFT EF #JPUJDB '&-"*#&
 QPS
JOUFSWFODJO EF 1BCMP 1VMJEP  NEJDP
WFOF[PMBOP EJSFDUPSFKFDVUJWPEFMB'F
EFSBDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF 'BDVMUBEFT
Z &TDVFMBT EF .FEJDJOB +PT "MCFSUP
.BJOFUUJ IVNBOJTUBBSHFOUJOP EJSFDUPS
EFM $FOUSP 0ODPMHJDP EF &YDFMFODJB
$0&
 Z "MGPOTP -MBOP &TDPCBS  4+ 
EJSFDUPSEFM$FOUSP/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJ
DB $&/"-#&
EF$PMPNCJB
)BTUB  1FS OP UFOB SFQSFTFOUB
DJO DPOUJOFOUBM Z TMP DPO QPTUFSJPSJ
EBEBM$POHSFTPEF1TJRVJBUSBFO$IJ
MF FTFNJTNPBP FM%JSFDUPSEFM$0& 
QPS SFDPNFOEBDJO EF MPT FTQFDJBMJTUBT
DIJMFOPT 'FSOBOEP-PMBT FOUSFPUSPT

NFJOWJUBQBSBFMTJHVJFOUFFODVFOUSP
&OEJDJFNCSFEFTFSFBMJ[FO"S
HFOUJOB CBKPMPTBVTQJDJPTEFM$0& FM
QSJNFSFODVFOUSP"MMSFDJC EFMB0S
HBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE
014
FMQFEJEPEFSFEBDUBSVOBSUDVMP
TPCSFMBCJPUJDBFO1FS RVFGVFQVCMJ
DBEP FOJOHMTZFTQBPM FOFM#PMFUO
EFMB0mDJOB4BOJUBSJB1BOBNFSJDBOBFO

4FHVJEBNFOUF SFDJCFMFODBSHPEFEJDUBS
DIBSMBTTPCSFCJPUJDBFO1FSZEFPSHB
OJ[BSFMHSVQPEFUSBCBKPEFNJQBT
&OTFMMFWBDBCPFM**&ODVFOUSP
FO7JMMBEF-FZWB $PMPNCJB FOEPOEF
TFUFSNJOFMQSPDFTPEFGVOEBDJOZTF
IJ[PVO1MBO5SJFOBMEF5SBCBKP&OTUF
TFNFQJEJRVFPSHBOJ[BTFMBTJHVJFOUF
SFVOJO$POFTUFNPUJWPGVOEMB"TP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DJBDJO1FSVBOBEF#JPUJDB "41&#*0

FOUJEBE RVF SFDJCJ MB SFQSFTFOUBDJO
PmDJBMEF1FSBOUF'&-"*#&
&O  TF SFBMJ[ FO -JNB FM *** &O
DVFOUSP FOFMDBNQVTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EFM 4BHSBEP $PSB[O &O   FM *7 
FO (VBOBKVBUP  .YJDP  PSHBOJ[BEP
QPS (BCSJFM $PSUT (BMMP &M 7 TF MMF
WBDBCPFOFO4BP1BVMP #SBTJM 
PSHBOJ[BEPQPS"MGPOTP3FOBUP.FJSB
$PJODJEJFOEPDPOFTUBSFVOJO TFSFB
MJ[FM1SJNFS$POHSFTPEF#JPUJDBEF
"NSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCF ZTFBEPQU
MBEFDJTJOEFTFHVJSSFBMJ[BOEPFODVFO
USPTQPSMPNFOPTDBEBEPTBPT

-B"TPDJBDJO1FSVBOBEF
#JPUJDB "41&#*0

#VTDBGPNFOUBSFMFTUVEJPJOUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJP EF MPT QSPCMFNBT DSFBEPT QPS MB
UFDOPMPHBNPEFSOBZTVTPMVDJOUJDB
QSPNVFWF BQPZBZEJGVOEFMBFOTFBO[B
EF MB CJPUJDB FO MBT GBDVMUBEFT EF .F
EJDJOB F JOTUJUVDJPOFT EF TBMVE %FTEF
 GPNFOUBMBDSFBDJOEFJOTUJUVUPT
ZDFOUSPTEFCJPUJDB ZMBJOWFTUJHBDJOZ
EJGVTJOEFFTUFNPWJNJFOUPIVNBOJTUB
&ONBS[PEFTFSFBMJ[MBQSJNFSB
SFVOJO QSFQBSBUPSJB EF "41&#*0 &M
EFNBZPEFTFBDPSEGVOEBSMB
"TPDJBDJO BmMJBEBBM'&-"*#&ZBMB
"TPDJBDJO*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB"
QBSUJS EF FOUPODFT TF IBO WFOJEP SFBMJ
[BOEP  FO GPSNB JOJOUFSSVNQJEB  DPO
GFSFODJBTDJFOUmDBTNFOTVBMFTFMQSJNFS
MVOFTEFDBEBNFT&OVODPNJFO[PTF
MMFWBSPO B DBCP FO FM BVEJUSJVN EF MB
$MOJDB 4BOUB *TBCFM Z EFTEF  FO





#JPUJDBFO1FS3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHB

FMEFMB$MOJDB3JDBSEP1BMNBZEFMPT
-BCPSBUPSJPT(MBYP 5FDOPGBSNBZ'BS
NJOEVTUSJB-BTDPOGFSFODJBTJOUFSOBDJP
OBMFTGVFSPOEJDUBEBTQPSMPTQSPGFTPSFT
+PBRVO $MPUFU #SBTJM
 3VUI .BDLMJO
&&66
 .BIBM %BDPTUB  'FSOBOEP
-PMBTZ3PCFSUP.BODJOJ $IJMF
%BG
OB'FJOIPM[ .YJDP
Z&EVBSEP4PV[B
-FOOPY 1BOBN

-PTUFNBTUSBUBEPTIBOTJEPMPTTJHVJFO
UFT5DOJDBTSFQSPEVDUJWBTFOJOHFOJFSB
HFOUJDB%FSFDIPTEFMQBDJFOUF#JPUJDB
ZNPSJS5SBTQMBOUFEFSHBOPT#JPUJDB
EFJOWBMJEF[4JHMP99*ZCJPUJDB"OUJ
DPODFQDJO'BSNBDPEFQFOEFODJBZESP
HBTQMBDFOUFSBT'VOEBNFOUPTEFMBCJP
UJDB#JPUJDB WJPMFODJB QTJDPTJTZTBMVE
NFOUBM &DPMPHB  'JMPTPGB Z CJPUJDB
7JEB )VNBOB Z CJPUJDB 1TJDPUFSBQJB
"VUPOPNB  DPOTFOUJNJFOUP JOGPSNBEP
ZCJPUJDB"CPSUP%JBHOTUJDPQTJRVJ
USJDP%BOUF -B%JWJOB$PNFEJB#JP
UJDBFOFMQBDJFOUFQTJRVJUSJDPJOTUJUV
DJPOBMJ[BEP "VUPQTJB NEJDB 5FSDFSB
FEBE *OWFTUJHBDJO FO TFSFT IVNBOPT
4JEBUJDBNEJDBZBOBUPT%JMPHPT
EFMDVFSQPZCJPUJDB)POPSJP%FMHBEP
ZMBIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPUJDB3FQSPEVDDJO
BTJTUJEB)VNBOJTNPWJUBM TVCWFSTJOZ
EFTBSSPMMP7JPMBDJOZCJPUJDB1VFCMPT
BNB[OJDPT 4FDSFUP QSPGFTJPOBM /BDFS
DPO EJHOJEBE 1SPZFDUP HFOPNB 4BMVE
NFOUBMJOGBOUJM
&M 5FSDFS &ODVFOUSP -BUJOPBNFSJDBOP
EF#JPUJDBUVWPMVHBSFO-JNBFOUSFFM
ZFMEFTFQUJFNCSFEF FOFM
DVBMTFUSBUBSPOMPTUFNBT#JPUJDB.
EJDB Z 1TJDPMPHB  'FDVOEBDJO  "CPS

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UP 3FUBSEP.FOUBM 5SBTQMBOUFEFS
HBOPT &VUBOBTJB *OHFOJFSB(FOUJDBZ
.PSJSDPOEJHOJEBE4FMMFWBDBCPFO
FMDBNQVTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEFM4BHSB
EP$PSB[OZMB"TPDJBDJO1FSVBOBEF
#JPUJDBDPOUDPOFMBQPZPEFMB"TP
DJBDJO .EJDB 1FSVBOP"MFNBOB  MB
6OJWFSTJEBE EFM 4BHSBEP $PSB[O Z FM
$PMFHJP.EJDPEFM1FS'VFSPOJOWJ
UBEPTQPS"SHFOUJOB3FZOBEF,MPUJL 
$FMJB #PSEJN  .BSUB 'SBDBQBOJ  -JMJB
OB (JBOODBSJOJ  +VBO $BSMPT 5FBMEJ Z
"MCFSUP #PDIBUFZ QPS #SBTJM "MGPOTP
3FOBUP.FZSB +'SBODJTDPOJZ+PBRVO
$MPUFU QPS $PMPNCJB "MGPOTP -MBOP 
$TBS4ODIF[ .BSB.BSDIBOE .B
SB .FSDFEFT )BDLFTQJFHFM  3JDBSEP
$FMZZ)4FNJOBSJP3FQSFTFOUBSPOB
.YJDP+PSHF)FSOOEF[Z-VJT%B[
-B "TPDJBDJO 1FSVBOB EF #JPUJDB IB
FTUBCMFDJEP SFMBDJPOFT DPO EJWFSTBT FO
UJEBEFTGPSOFBT%FFTUBGPSNB SFDJCF
QVCMJDBDJPOFT QFSJEJDBT  UBMFT DPNP
.FEJDJOB Z UJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF
"OBIVBD  FEJUBEB DPOKVOUBNFOUF DPO
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EFM 4BHSBEP $PSB[O
EF3PNB #JPUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF
3P(SBOEFEP4VM #SBTJM #JPUJDBEFM
$POTFKP'FEFSBMEF.FEJDJOBEF#SBTJ
MJB #SBTJM Z"DUB#JPFUIJDBEFM1SPHSBNB
EF#JPUJDBEF0140.4
-B$PNJTJOEF#JPUJDBEFM4FOBEPEF
&TUBEPT6OJEPTSFDJCFJOGPSNBDJOQF
SJEJDBEFOVFTUSBTBDUJWJEBEFTZFM1SP
HSBNBEF#JPUJDBEFMB014 4BOUJBHP
EF$IJMF
FOWBTVTQVCMJDBDJPOFTQFSJ
EJDBT*HVBMNFOUFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF1B
EVB FO*UBMJB ZEF1BST FO'SBODJB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

"TQFDUPTMFHBMFT
4POOVNFSPTBTMBTMFZFTBQSPCBEBTFOMB
MUJNBEDBEBDPOSFMBDJOBMBCJPUJDB
FO1FS1PSFKFNQMP MBQSPQVFTUBEF
MFHJTMBDJOJOEHFOBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBEF
DPOTVMUBDPMFDUJWBQBSBFTUVEJPTHFOUJ
DPTTFTFBMFMEFSFDIPEFMPTQVFCMPT
JOEHFOBT B QSPUFHFS Z EJTGSVUBS EF TV
QBUSJNPOJP DVMUVSBM  CBTOEPTF FO MB
%FDMBSBDJO 6OJWFSTBM EF %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPT  MPT 1BDUPT *OUFSOBDJPOBMFT
EF %FSFDIPT &DPONJDPT  4PDJBMFT Z
$VMUVSBMFTZEF%FSFDIPT$JWJMFTZ1P
MUJDPT ZFM$POWFOJP/EFMB0S
HBOJ[BDJO*OUFSOBDJPOBMEFM5SBCBKP
-B-FZ/ EFKVMJPEF 
FTUBCMFDF VO SHJNFO EF QSPUFDDJO EF
MPTDPOPDJNJFOUPTDPMFDUJWPTEFMPTQVF
CMPTJOEHFOBTWJODVMBEPTBMPTSFDVSTPT
CJPMHJDPT -PT JOUFSFTBEPT FO BDDFEFS
B MPT DPOPDJNJFOUPT DPMFDUJWPT DPO m
OFTEFBQMJDBDJODJFOUmDB DPNFSDJBMF
JOEVTUSJBMEFCFSOTPMJDJUBSFMDPOTFOUJ
NJFOUPJOGPSNBEPEFMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFT
SFQSFTFOUBUJWBTEFMPTQVFCMPTZDPNV
OJEBEFT JOEHFOBT RVF MP QPTFBO -B
JOGPSNBDJO RVF TF QSPQPSDJPOF TF MJ
NJUBSBMSFDVSTPCJPMHJDPTPCSFFMDVBM
WFSTB FM DPOPDJNJFOUP DPMFDUJWP PCKFUP
EFMBOFHPDJBDJO FOTBMWBHVBSEBEFMB
DPOUSBQBSUF

-PTDPNJUTEFUJDBEFMB
JOWFTUJHBDJOFOTBMVEFO1FS
%FTEFIBRVFEBEPDPOTUJUVJEBMB
$PNJTJO /BDJPOBM EF UJDB FO *OWFT
UJHBDJO 4V DPNQPTJDJO FT NMUJQMF
ZUSBOTEJTDJQMJOBSJB&MNBOEBUPEFTVT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

NJFNCSPTFTEFEPTBPTZFMONFSPEF
TUPTFTEFWFJOUF4VTBUSJCVDJPOFTTPO
FTUJNVMBSMBDSFBDJOEFDPNJUTEFUJDB
FOJOWFTUJHBDJOZSFHJTUSBSBMPTDPNJUT
JOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
-BTDJODVFOUBQFSTPOBTRVFTFEFEJDBO
B MB CJPUJDB FO 1FS TF IBO SFQBSUJEP
TV BDDJO FO DJODP HSVQPT EF USBCBKP
BDDJO QPMUJDB  FODBSHBEB BM $PMFHJP
.EJDPEFM1FSGPSNBDJOFOSFDVS
TPT IVNBOPT BDBENJDPT
 FODBSHBEB
B "MCFSUP 1FSBMFT QSFTUBDJO EF TFSWJ
DJPT EF TBMVE  FODBSHBEB B $TBS 3J
WFSB JOWFTUJHBDJO TF IB EJWJEJEP FO
CJPUJDBFOJOWFTUJHBDJOoFODBSHBEBB
$TBS.PMFSPoFJOWFTUJHBDJOFOCJP
UJDBoFODBSHBEBB3PCFSUP-MBOPToDP
NVOJDBDJOCJPUJDB FODBSHBEBB&MTB
#FOBWFOUF
-BT JOTUJUVDJPOFT RVF TF IBO DPNQSP
NFUJEP B USBCBKBS DPOKVOUBNFOUF QPS
MBUJDBFOJOWFTUJHBDJOFO1FSTPOMBT
VOJWFSTJEBEFT/BDJPOBMEF4BO.BSDPT 
*OHFOJFSB $BZFUBOP)FSFEJB 4BHSBEP
$PSB[O  $BUMJDB Z 3JDBSEP 1BMNB
-VFHP  FM $PMFHJP .EJDP EF 1FS  MB
0SEFO EF 4BO $BNJMP MB 0/( 4BO
$ISJTUPQIPSVT  MB "TPDJBDJO 1FSVBOB
EF#JPUJDB MPTIPTQJUBMFT&EHBSEP3F
CBHMJBUJ  (VJMMFSNP "MNFOBSB  %PT EF
.BZP Z "S[PCJTQP -PBZ[B FM $FOUSP
1FSVBOP EF #JPUJDB  MPT -BCPSBUPSJPT
.FSDL 4IBSQ BOE %PINF Z MBT 0/(T
1SJTNBZUJDBQPSMB7JEB
*OUFHSBOUFTEFM(SVQP1FSVBOPEFUJDB
FO *OWFTUJHBDJO TPO MPT EPDUPSFT 3P
CFSUP-MBOPT 3BGBFM"SDF 1FESP3VJ[ 
'SBODJTDP3JWFSB #FSUB3FZFT $BSNFO





#JPUJDBFO1FS3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHB

#SBWP  (VTUBWP "SBVKP  3PCFSUP &TQJ


OP[B .BOVFM1B[Z"MPJT,FOOFSOFDIU
%FTEFFYJTUFFO1FSMB$PNJTJO
/BDJPOBM EF #JPUJDB )BTUB FTB GFDIB
FYJTUBO OVFWF DPNJUT BTJTUFODJBMFT EF
UJDB &O  FSBO  Z BDUVBMNFOUF
TPO&OIBCBTFJTDPNJUTEF
UJDBEFJOWFTUJHBDJOFOTBMVE FO
FSBOoBPFORVFTFDSFBFM$BQUVMP
1FSVBOP EFM 'PSP -BUJOPBNFSJDBOP EF
$PNJUT EF UJDB EF *OWFTUJHBDJO FO
4BMVE '-"$&*4
&O1FSFYJTUFO FO
DPOTFDVFODJB WFJOUJUSTDPNJUTEFUJDB
EFMBJOWFTUJHBDJO
B
 $PNJU EF UJDB EF *OWFTUJHBDJO
EFM )PTQJUBM &EHBSEP 3FCBHMJBUUJ
.BSUJOT &TUF IPTQJUBM QFSUFOFDF
B MB SFE IPTQJUBMBSJB EF MB TFHVSJ
EBE TPDJBM &44"-6%
 &O 
DPOUBCB DPO  QSPZFDUPT EF JO
WFTUJHBDJO&M$PNJUEFUJDBFO
*OWFTUJHBDJO TF JOTUBM FO BHPTUP
EF  Z FTU GPSNBEP QPS PODF
NJFNCSPT DJODPEFMPTDVBMFTTPO
NEJDPT  EPT FOGFSNFSBT  VO BCP
HBEP  VO TBDFSEPUF  VO BTJTUFOUF
TPDJBMZVOSFQSFTFOUBOUFEFMBDP
NVOJEBE )B SFWJTBEP QSPUPDPMPT
EFPUSBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTFOFMEF
TVTTFTJPOFT
C
 *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM EF 4BMVE 4F
JOTUBMFOGFCSFSPEFZTFSF
FTUSVDUVSFOKVOJPEFM&TU
GPSNBEPQPSJOUFHSBOUFT IBSF
WJTBEPQSPUPDPMPTZTFIBOBQSP
CBEP4FIBBEFDVBEPBM3FHJT
USP*OUFSOBDJPOBMZFEJUBMB3FWJTUB
1FSVBOBEF.FEJDJOB&YQFSJNFOUBM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

Z4BMVE1CMJDB4VJOGPSNBDJOTF
FODVFOUSBFO-*-"$4Z.&
%-*/&
D
 $FOUSP 1FSVBOP EF #JPUJDB $&
1&#*0
4VDPNJUEFUJDBTFJOT
UBM FM  EF KVMJP EF  Z FTU
GPSNBEP QPS DJODP QFSTPOBT )B
DPMBCPSBEP FO MPT USFT DPOHSFTPT
PSHBOJ[BEPTQPS$&1&#*0oFOUSF
 Z o F  JHVBMNFOUF  FO
FM UBMMFS QBSB GPSNBDJO EF WPMVO
UBSJPTEJDUBEPBQFSTPOBTMBJDBT
ZBTBDFSEPUFT)BEJDUBEPDVB
USPDVSTPTEFUJDBFOJOWFTUJHBDJO
oFOUSFZoZVODVSTPEF
GVOEBNFOUPTEFCJPUJDB DPOBTJT
UFODJBEFUSFJOUBQBSUJDJQBOUFT
E
 0mDJOB(FOFSBMEF&QJEFNJPMPHB
0(&3&/"$&
 4V DPNJU FTU
DPOGPSNBEP QPS DVBUSP QFSTPOBT
)BTUB  IBCB SFWJTBEP 
QSPZFDUPT mOBODJBEPT )B SFBMJ[B
EPBDUJWJEBEFT EFMBTDVBMFTFM
 TFEFEJDBSPOBJOWFTUJHBDJO
F
 0/( 1SJTNB 'VOEBEB FO  
JOTUBMB TV DPNJU EF UJDB FO JO
WFTUJHBDJOFO4VFTUSVDUVSB
BDUVBMTFEFEJDBBMFTUVEJPQSJWBEP
EFQSPUPDPMPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJO BTF
TPSBZNPOJUPSFP

&M*OTUJUVUPEF4BMVE$SJTUGPSJT
%FOFLF *4%&/
QPSMBTFOEB
EFMBCJPUJDB 

-BSFMJHJPTB.BSB7BOEFS-JOEF EJSFD
UPSBEF*4%&/EFTEFTVGVOEBDJO FO
 TFBMBi-BJORVJFUVEQPSMBIV
NBOJ[BDJOFOTBMVE MBUJDB MBCJPUJDB
BOUFMBSFBMJEBETBOJUBSJBEFMQBT FTUBCB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

QSFTFOUFFOOPTPUSPTEFTEFBOUFTEFRVF
FM *4%&/ TF DPOTUJUVZFSB 5SBCBKCB
NPTFOUPODFTFOMB1BTUPSBMEFMB4BMVE
EF MB $POGFSFODJB &QJTDPQBM 1FSVBOB
%FTEFBMMZEFTEFMBQSFPDVQBDJOQPS
MPTFOGFSNPTEFUVCFSDVMPTJTFOMPTBPT
BEFTBSSPMMBNPTPDIPUBMMFSFTGPS
NBUJWPT WJWFODJBMFT DPOFMQFSTPOBMEF
TBMVE EFM 1SPHSBNB EF $POUSPM EF 5#
EF MBT 6OJEBEFT 5FSSJUPSJBMFT EF 4BMVE
EF$PNBTZEFM)PTQJUBM4FSHJP&#FS
OBMFT  BCBSDBOEP BMSFEFEPS EF  FTUB
CMFDJNJFOUPT EF TBMVE Z DJODP EJTUSJUPT
EF-JNB/PSUFZ$BOUBEFM.*/4"DPO
FM UFNB EF i7BMPSFT FO FM QFSmM EF MB
BUFODJOJOUFHSBMEF5VCFSDVMPTJTw

ZOPQPESBTFSEFPUSBNBOFSB&TUPOPT
BOJN B PSHBOJ[BS VO FODVFOUSP FO FM
RVFNTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBTBMVEZEF
PUSPTDBNQPTQVEJFSBOOVUSJSTFEFFTUBT
SFnFYJPOFT QVFTIBCBNVZQPDBEJGV
TJOZEFCBUFEFFTUPTUFNBTFOFMQBT
QPSFOUPODFT
&OGFCSFSPEF FOFMBVEJUPSJPEFMB
$MOJDB4UFMMB.BSJT SFBMJ[BNPTVOQSJ
NFSGPSPTPCSFi"TQFDUPT*OUSPEVDUPSJPT
EF#JPUJDBw DPOMBQBSUJDJQBDJOEF-FP
1FTTJOJ FM1-VEPMGP0KFEB EF1FS Z
QFSTPOBMEFTBMVEZEFPUSBTEJTDJQMJOBT
BmOFTQSPWFOJFOUFTEF-JNBZ$BMMBP

&O DPOPDBTJOEFMBWJTJUBB1FS
EF 1BPMP .PDBSFMMJ  CJPFUJDJTUB JUBMJBOP
JOWJUBEP QPS FM QSPZFDUP i&EVDBDJO
Z DVMUVSB EF QB[w  RVF EFTBSSPMMBCB MB
1POUJmDJB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUMJDB EFM
1FS  TF PSHBOJ[ FO FM BVEJUPSJP EF MB
.VOJDJQBMJEBEEF+FTT.BSB FODPPS
EJOBDJODPOMB"TPDJBDJOEF.EJDPT
$BUMJDPT VOBDPOGFSFODJBGSVNUJUVMB
EBiUJDBEFMB7JEBw-BQSFTFOUBDJO
EFMEPDUPS.PDBSFMMJBCSJMBQFSTQFDUJ
WBIBDJBMBCJPUJDB)VCPTJOUPOBDPO
MBTJEFBTQSFTFOUBEBTFOTVJOUFSWFODJO 
RVFOPTMPUPDBCBMPUJDPFOSFMBDJO
DPOMBUFDOPMPHBZFMIPTQJUBM TJOPUBN
CJOMPDPNVOJUBSJPZTPDJBM

&OUSFZMMFWBNPTBDBCPMPT
UBMMFSFT TPCSF i7BMPSFT FO FM QFSmM EFM
USBCBKBEPS EF TBMVE QBSB VOB BUFODJO
EFDBMJEBEwFOWBSJPTMVHBSFTEF-JNBZ
QSPWJODJBT  QPS NFEJP EF VO DPOWFOJP
DPO FM 4FHVSP 4PDJBM EF 4BMVE EF 1FS
IPZ MMBNBEP &44"-6%
 Z IBDJOEP
MP FYUFOTJWP B QFSTPOBM EFM .JOJTUFSJP
EF4BMVEFOPUSBTDJVEBEFT&ONTEF
UBMMFSFTMPHSBNPTJOWPMVDSBSB
QFSTPOBT HSVQPT NVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJPT 
QSPGFTJPOBMFT  UDOJDPT Z  FO PDBTJPOFT 
QFSTPOBM BENJOJTUSBUJWP  UPEPT FO VO
NJTNPFTQBDJPEFSFnFYJO1PSMBTFWB
MVBDJPOFT  DPOTUBUBNPT RVF MPT QBSUJDJ
QBOUFTWBMPSBCBONVDIPMBPQPSUVOJEBE
EFNJSBSTVUSBCBKPFOVOBQFSTQFDUJWB
IVNBOJTUB

&O   FO 2VJUP  &DVBEPS  DPOPDJ


NPTB-FP1FTTJOJ EF#SBTJM RVFZBUSB
CBKBCBFMUFNBCJPUJDPFOVOBQFSTQFD
UJWBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB FOMBDVBMMPTUFNBT
TPDJBMFTZEFTBMVEQCMJDBTPOPCMJHBEPT

%FTEF ZBDPOMBSB[OTPDJBMEFM
*OTUJUVUP  TF EFDJEJ USBCBKBS FO MB GPS
NBDJOFOUJDBZCJPUJDBEFTEFFMiSFB
EF)VNBOJ[BDJOFO4BMVEw

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





#JPUJDBFO1FS3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHB

$PODMVTJPOFT
-B CJPUJDB FO 1FS IB FYQFSJNFOUBEP
HSBOEFTBWBODFT4FIBODSFBEPEJWFSTBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFT RVF USBCBKBO JOUFOTBNFO
UFTFDVFOUBDPOVOHSVQPIVNBOPEF
QPS MP NFOPT DJODVFOUB QFSTPOBT DPO
MJEFSB[HPCJPUJDPEFFMMPT QPSMPNF
OPTMBNJUBEUJFOFOFMNSJUPEFIBCFS
DVSTBEP MB NBFTUSB FO CJPUJDB  ZB TFB
FO1FS 4VEBNSJDBP&VSPQB/PPCT
UBOUF FYJTUFOBMHVOPTSFUPT
t

t

t

&OFMBTQFDUPTPDJBMTPDJBM TFFTQFSB
RVFMPTHSVQPTEFQPCMBDJOQBSUJDJ
QFOZQSPQVHOFOEJTDVTJPOFTTPCSF
UFNBT DPNP EPOBDJO EF SHBOPT
QBSBUSBTQMBOUFT BCPSUP FVUBOBTJB 
NFEJPBNCJFOUF GFDVOEBDJOBTJT
UJEB USBOTHOJDPT FOUSFPUSPT
&O MP BDBENJDP  TF FTQFSB VOB
NBZPSSFTQVFTUBVOJWFSTJUBSJBZEF
FOUJEBEFT EF FOTFBO[B  DPNP MB
6OJWFSTJEBE EF 4BO .BSDPT Z MB
1BTUPSBMEF4BMVEEFMPT)FSNBOPT
EF4BO$BNJMP
3FTQFDUP EF MP DJFOUmDP  DPOTUJ
UVJEPT MPT  DPNJUT EF UJDB EF
JOWFTUJHBDJO Z FM DBQUVMP QFSVB
OP EFM 'PSP -BUJOPBNFSJDBOP EF
$PNJUT EF UJDB EF MB *OWFTUJ

t

t

t

HBDJO  GPSNBEP IBTUB BIPSB QPS


 JOUFHSBOUFT  TF IB JOJDJBEP VOB
HSBO MBCPS DPO MB PSHBOJ[BDJO EF
TFNJOBSJPT  FOTFBO[B  FTUVEJP Z
BQSPCBDJO EF QSPUPDPMPT  NPOJ
UPSFPEFJOWFTUJHBDJPOFTZMBCPSEF
DPOTFKFSBZBTFTPSB
4F IB JOHSFTBEP MFOUBNFOUF B MPT
NFEJPT EF DPNVOJDBDJO DPO FM
MFOHVBKF CJPUJDP :B QFSJEJDPT 
SBEJPT Z DBOBMFT EF UFMFWJTJO TP
MJDJUBO FOUSFWJTUBT  DPNFOUBSJPT P
BSUDVMPTRVFQFSUFOFDFOBFTUFMFO
HVBKFZRVFTFSVTBEPQSPHSFTJWB
NFOUFQPSMBDPNVOJEBE
3FTQFDUPEFMJOWPMVDSBNJFOUPEFMB
TPDJFEBE DJWJM  IBTUB IPZ TF FTQFSB
RVFMB$PNJTJO/BDJPOBMEF#JP
UJDB DPNQSPNFUB B MBT JOTUJUVDJP
OFTEJSFDUBNFOUFPJOEJSFDUBNFOUF
JOWPMVDSBEBTDPOMBWJEBZPCUFOHB
EFFMMBTFMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFMBJN
QPSUBODJBEFMBCJPUJDB
4PCSF MB NPUJWBDJO DPNVOJUBSJB 
TFIBMPHSBEPJOGPSNBSBMPTHSVQPT
DJWJMFTEFBVUPBZVEB&OMBNFEJEB
FO RVF MPT MEFSFT SFDJCBO JOGPS
NBDJO BDBENJDB TF HBSBOUJ[B MB
QPTJCJMJEBE EF JOJDJBS Z NBOUFOFS
DPNVOJDBDJOEFCVFOBDBMJEBE

3FGFSFODJBT
"MDBM;BNPSB +FUBM 
0CUFODJOEFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEP $*
FONFEJDJOB
JOUFOTJWB#VFOPT"JSFT "OBMFT
#VOHF  . 
 .FEJDJOB Z 'JMPTPGB &M $PNFSDJP  4FDDJO %PNJOJDBM   EF
TFQUJFNCSF -JNB Q
$FMZ ( 
#JPUJDBZ6OJWFSTJEBE#PHPU $FOUSP&EJUPSJBM+BWFSJBOP QQ
$&1 $FOUSP EF &TUVEJPT Z 1VCMJDBDJPOFT
 
 -B 7JEB 7BMF #JPUJDB OVFWPT
DBNJOPT-JNB 6OJWFSTJEBEEFM1BDGJDP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

$MPUFU + 


{2VUJQPEFDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEPQVFEFTFSVTBEPQBSBMBTQFSTPOBT
EFMPTQBTFTFOWBTEFEFTBSSPMMP #VFOPT"JSFT "OBMFT
%FMHBEP) 
&MNEJDP MBNFEJDJOBZFMBMNB-JNB 61$)
%JBT . 
#JPUJDBVNBOPWBWJTPJOUFSEJTDJQMJOBS#SBTMJB +PSOBMEP$'.
'JOT + 
&YQFSJFODJBOPSUFBNFSJDBOBEFMBFOTFBO[BEFMB#JPUJDB$VBEFSOPTEF
#JPUJDB QQ
(FWFST 4 
1IZTJDJBOBTTJTUFETVJDJEFOFXEFWFMPQNFOUTJOUIF/FUIFSMBOET*O
"OBMFTEFM**$POHSFTP*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB #VFOPT"JSFT Q
(SBDJB % 
1SJODJQJPTEFMB#JPUJDB"OBMFTEFM**$POHSFTP.VOEJBMEF#JPUJDB 
#VFOPT"JSFT QQ
(SPT ) 
3FQPSUPGUIF-FHBM$PNNJTTJPOPGUIF*#$*O*OUFSOBUJPOBM#JPFUIJDT
$PNNJUUFFPG6OFTDP1BSJT 6OFTDP 7PM* Q
-FO#BSB3 
#BTFTCJPMHJDBTEFMBUJDB%JBHOTUJDP  
TFQUJFNCSFPDUV
CSF QQ
-MBOP " 
&M.PSJSIVNBOPIBDBNCJBEP#PMFUOEFMB0GJDJOB4BOJUBSJB1BOB
NFSJDBOB  
NBZPKVOJP QQ
-MBOPT 3 
#JPUJDBFOFM1FS#PMFUOEFMB0GJDJOB4BOJUBSJB1BOBNFSJDBOB 

NBZPKVOJP QQ
.JS 2VFTBEB  0 
 #JPUJDB NPNFOUP EF EFGJOJDJPOFT &M $PNFSDJP   EF
OPWJFNCSFEF Q
/PWPB  ' 
 $POTJEFSBDJPOFT UJDBT FO QBDJFOUFT DPO EBP DFSFCSBM .YJDP  &E
*OUFSBNFSJDBOB
1FSBMFT " 3JWFSB'8V % 
$JWJMJ[BDJOZ.FEJDJOB-JNB 6/.4. 
QQ
4BSUPSJVT / 
5IF.FOUBM)FBMUI1SPHSBNNFPGUIF8PSME)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO
*O"OBMFTEF4BMVE.FOUBM 7PM-JNB 6/.4.

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





#JPUJDBFO1PSUVHBM
+PSHF#JTDBJBZ8BMUFS0TTXBME

J DPOTJEFSBNPT MBT GBTFT UFNQSBOBT


EFM EFTBSSPMMP EF MB CJPUJDB  DPNP
OVFWB SFB EF MB DJFODJB Z EF MB NPSBM
FO BDFMFSBEP DSFDJNJFOUP  MB DVBM  JO
EFQFOEJFOUFNFOUFEFTVTTFNJMMBTOPS
UFBNFSJDBOBT  IB NPTUSBEP VOB NBSDB
EB UFOEFODJB B EJGVOEJSTF FO EJWFSTPT
DPOUJOFOUFT  EFCFNPT JOEJDBS RVF TVT
DPNJFO[PTFO1PSUVHBMIBOTJEPSFMBUJ
WBNFOUFUBSEPT&OFGFDUP FMQSJNFSP
HSVQP EF FTUVEJP  PSHBOJ[BEP Z FTUSVD
UVSBEP RVFTFEFEJDBDVFTUJPOFTCJP
UJDBT GVF FTUBCMFDJEP FO $PJNCSB  FO
 DPNPVOBPSHBOJ[BDJOOPMVDSB
UJWBJOEFQFOEJFOUF $FOUSPEF&TUVEJPT
EF #JPUJDB
 EFTQVT EF RVF FM HSVQP
GVOEBEPS TF SFVOJFSB JOGPSNBMNFOUF
EVSBOUF EPT BPT %FTEF FOUPODFT  TJO
FNCBSHP IVCPVOBFWPMVDJOOPUBCMF 
VOBSQJEBEJTFNJOBDJO DPOVOONF
SP SFMBUJWBNFOUF HSBOEF EF HSBEVBEPT
RVFTFBMJTUBOFOFTUVEJPTEFQPTHSBEP
/VFTUSBNFUBOPFTQSFTFOUBSVOBQFST
QFDUJWBIJTUSJDBPVOBSFWJTJOFYIBVT
UJWB EF MB USBZFDUPSJB EF MB CJPUJDB FO
1PSUVHBM  TJOP SFBMJ[BS VOB BQSPYJNB
DJOBUFNBTRVFIBOTJEPZTJHVFOTJFO
EPQSPNJOFOUFTFOMBEJTDVTJOCJPUJDB 
BMHVOPTEFFMMPTBUSBZFOEPFMJOUFSTEF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

HSBOEFT TFDUPSFT EF MB QPCMBDJO 1BSB


FTUP  UFOFNPT RVF EFTDSJCJS MBT JOTUJUV
DJPOFTFOEPOEFTFEJTDVUF TFFOTFBP
TFJOWFTUJHBMBCJPUJDBZTVTNVDIBTBD
UJWJEBEFT $PNP SFTVMUBEP  MB DPODJFO
DJBQCMJDBEFMPTQSPCMFNBTCJPUJDPTFT
NVDIPNTBNQMJBZMBTPQJOJPOFTEFM
DJVEBEBOP FO FTUBT NBUFSJBT FTUO FO
QSPDFTPEFUFOFSDPOTFDVFODJBTQPMUJDBT
Z MFHBMFT EF TVQSFNB JNQPSUBODJB &O
FTUBDPOUSJCVDJOOPTDFOUSBSFNPTQSJO
DJQBMNFOUFFOMBTJUVBDJOEFMBEDBEB
QBTBEB  QVFTUP RVF MBT JOGPSNBDJPOFT
SFGFSFOUFT B BPT BOUFSJPSFT TF QVFEFO
FODPOUSBSFOUFYUPTQBOPSNJDPTZBQV
CMJDBEPT /VOF[Z"CFM #JTDBJBZ
0TTXBME 


*OTUJUVDJPOFT
-PTGPSPTQSJODJQBMFTEFEJTDVTJOCJP
UJDBFTUOFOJOTUJUVDJPOFTBDBENJDBTZ
FOTPDJFEBEFTRVFSFOFOHFOUFJOUFSFTB
EB$VSJPTBNFOUF MBVOJWFSTJEBE DPNP
VOUPEP IBSFDPOPDJEPTMPMFOUBNFOUF
MBOFDFTJEBEEFDSFBSJOTUJUVDJPOFTCJP
UJDBTFOTVQSPQJBFTUSVDUVSB-BQSJO
DJQBMZQSJNFSBJOTUJUVDJOSFTQPOTBCMF
EFTVBDFQUBDJOZEJGVTJOFO1PSUVHBM
GVF  DPNP EJKJNPT  FM $&#  VOB PSHB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

OJ[BDJOJOEFQFOEJFOUF OPDPOGFTJPOBM 
OPMVDSBUJWB DPOVOMBSHPDVSSDVMPEF
BDUJWJEBEFT WBTFNTBEFMBOUF

&M $POTFKP /BDJPOBM EF UJDB FO MBT
$JFODJBT EF MB 7JEB $/&$7
 FT VO
SHBOP DPOTVMUJWP QBSB FM HPCJFSOP FO
UPEBT MBT DVFTUJPOFT CJPUJDBT  FM 1BSMB
NFOUP/BDJPOBM MB"TTFNCMJBEB3FQ
CMJDB
 Z FM QSFTJEFOUF 'VF GVOEBEP FO
ZNVDIPTEFTVTNJFNCSPT JODMV
TP USFT QSFTJEFOUFT
 TF SFDMVUBSPO FOUSF
MPT NJFNCSPT EFM $&# &M $/&$7
IBQSPEVDJEPIBTUBBIPSBQBSFDFSFT
TPCSF VOB WBSJFEBE EF UFNBT  EFTEF MB
SFQSPEVDDJONEJDBNFOUFBTJTUJEBPFM
VTPEFFNCSJPOFTFOFYQFSJNFOUPTDJFO
UmDPT  IBTUB MB QSVFCB PCMJHBUPSJB EF
)*7"*%4EFTEFMBHFSFODJBEFEBUPT
HFOUJDPT IBTUB MBT DVFTUJPOFT EFM mOBM
EF MB WJEB EFTEF MB QPMUJDB SFMBUJWB BM
BCVTPEFESPHBTIBTUBMPTDSJUFSJPTEFMB
NVFSUFZUSBTQMBOUFT
&TVOSHBOPBMUBNFOUFSFTQFUBEPZIB
FKFSDJEPJOnVFODJBBQSFDJBCMFFOMBTMF
ZFTBQSPCBEBTQPSFMQBSMBNFOUP&MQSJ
NFSNJOJTUSPOPNJOBBMQSFTJEFOUF MPT
PUSPTNJFNCSPTTPOOPNJOBEPTQPS
 FOUJEBEFT EJTUJOUBT FM 1BSMBNFOUP 
MPTNJOJTUFSJPTZBTPDJBDJPOFTEFBCPHB
EPT NEJDPT CJMPHPT MB"DBEFNJBEF
$JFODJB PSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFDJVEBEBOPT 
FOUSFPUSPT

&M $FOUSP EF %FSFDIP #JPNEJDP
$%#
JOTUJUVUPEFJOWFTUJHBDJOEFMB
'BDVMUBEEF%FSFDIPEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EF$PJNCSB UJFOFVOBQSFTFODJBSFMBUJ
WBNFOUFFYUFOTBZ EFTEF IBDPO
USJCVJEP B SFTPMWFS DVFTUJPOFT DPNP FM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DPOnJDUPEFJOUFSFTFT MPTDEJHPTEFMBT
QSPGFTJPOFT NEJDBT Z GBSNBDVUJDBT

Z MPT BTQFDUPT MFHBMFT RVF HPCJFSOBO FM
FKFSDJDJPEFFTUBTQSPGFTJPOFT
-BTFTDVFMBTEF.FEJDJOBTJUVBEBTFOMB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF-JTCPB EF$PJNCSBZEFM
1PSUPUFOBOEJWFSTPTUJQPTEFFOTFBO
[BEFMBUJDBNEJDBTMPIBDJBMB
&TDVFMBEF.FEJDJOBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EFM1PSUPDSFVO4FSWJDJPEF#JPUJDBZ
UJDB.EJDB 4#&.
ZGVFMBQSJNFSB
WF[RVFMBQBMBCSBiCJPUJDBwBQBSFDJFO
FMQMBOEFFTUVEJPTZFOMBPSHBOJ[BDJO
EFVOBFTDVFMBNEJDB-FTJHVJMB&T
DVFMBEF.FEJDJOBFO-JTCPB DSFBOEP 
FO VO$FOUSPEF#JPUJDB
4JO FNCBSHP  FM OJDP EFQBSUBNFOUP
VOJWFSTJUBSJPRVFTFPDVQBEFMBCJPUJDB
FOVOTFOUJEPNTBNQMJP FTEFDJS TJO
BDPQMBNJFOUPT DPODFQUVBMFT OJ JOTUJUV
DJPOBMFTDPOMBFOTFBO[BNEJDB FTFM
*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUMJDB 1PSUVHVFTB  DSFBEP FO 
EFTEFVOHSVQPQSFFYJTUFOUFEFJOWFTUJ
HBDJOCJPUJDBGVOEBEPFO
&TUPOPFYDMVZFRVFPUSPTEFQBSUBNFOUPT
EFMBVOJWFSTJEBEDPOUSJCVZBOEFNBOFSB
DBMJmDBEBBMQFOTBNJFOUPCJPUJDP1PEF
NPTNFODJPOBS QPSFKFNQMP MPTEFQBS
UBNFOUPT EF mMPTPGB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
EF"[PSFT FO1POUB%FMHBEB
ZFMEFMB
'BDVMUBE EF 'JMPTPGB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
$BUMJDB1PSUVHVFTB TJUVBEPFO#SBHB

"NCPT UJFOFO VO QMBO EF FTUVEJPT RVF
JODMVZFMBCJPUJDBZIBOQVCMJDBEPMJCSPT
BDFSDB EF MB NBUFSJB FM EF "[PSFT UBN
CJOIBBZVEBEPBMPTDPNJUTEFUJDBZ
BMBTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFTEFFOGFSNFSPT





#JPUJDBFO1PSUVHBM+PSHF#JTDBJBZ8BMUFS0TTXBME

-B "TPDJBDJO 1PSUVHVFTB EF #JPUJDB


"1#
 TF GPSN FO VOB NPNFOUP SF
MBUJWBNFOUF UBSEP 
 Z NBOUJFOF
WODVMPT QFSTPOBMFT F JOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
NVZDFSDBOPTDPOFM4#&.5PEBTFTBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFTEFTBSSPMMBOBDUJWJEBEFTEF
DJTJWBTQBSBMBFWPMVDJOOBDJPOBMEFMB
CJPUJDB  MBT RVF JOUFOUBSFNPT SFTVNJS
FOMBTFDDJOTJHVJFOUF

"DUJWJEBEFTQSJODJQBMFT
-BT SFVOJPOFT PSHBOJ[BEBT QPS FM $&#
ZFM*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDBFODVFTUJPOFT
EF JNQPSUBODJB OBDJPOBM Z DPO JNQMJ
DBDJPOFT JNQPSUBOUFT FO MBT QPMUJDBT
QCMJDBT TPO QBSBEJHNUJDBT EF FTUF
BDFSDBNJFOUP B MB QPCMBDJO FO HFOF
SBM"EFNT FM$&#PSHBOJ[FO
FM $POHSFTP &VSPQFP EF $FOUSPT EF
UJDB .EJDB &O TV TFEF FO $PJNCSB
ZFOMBTEFMFHBDJPOFTEF-JTCPB 1PSUP 
"[PSFT  WPSB  .BEFJSB Z #SBHB  IVCP
SFVOJPOFTSFHVMBSFTTPCSFDVFTUJPOFTEF
JOUFSTCJPUJDP1PSPUSBQBSUF FM$PO
HSFTP/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB DPOMBTM
UJNBTDVBUSPFEJDJPOFTPSHBOJ[BEBTQPS
MB "TPDJBDJO 1PSUVHVFTB EF #JPUJDB 
BTDPNPMPTTFNJOBSJPTBOVBMFTPSHBOJ
[BEPTQPSFM$POTFKP/BDJPOBMEFUJDB
FOMBT$JFODJBTEFMB7JEB SFQSFTFOUBO
PUSPTBDPOUFDJNJFOUPTJNQPSUBOUFTRVF
HFOFSBMNFOUFDVFOUBODPOVOHSBOQ
CMJDP5PEBWBIBZVOBHSBODBOUJEBEEF
SFVOJPOFT Z EF UBMMFSFT NT QFRVFPT 
PDVQOEPTFEFSFBTFTQFDJBMJ[BEBT QPS
FKFNQMP WVMOFSBCJMJEBEBMQSJODJQJPZBM
mOBMEFMBWJEB FOTFBO[BEFMBCJPUJDB
FOFTDVFMBTTFDVOEBSJBT QSPCMFNBTFOFM
DVJEBEPEFOJPTQSFNBUVSPT QBDJFOUFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UFSNJOBMFT Z DVJEBEPT QBMJBUJWPT  DPO


TFSWBDJOEFMPTSFDVSTPTEFBHVB FOUSF
PUSPT

" NFOVEP  MBT TPDJFEBEFT DJFOUmDBT 
BTPDJBDJPOFT EF MPT BCPHBEPT Z PSHBOJ
[BDJPOFTMBJDBTZDPOGFTJPOBMFTJODMVZFO
FOTVTDPOHSFTPTTFTJPOFTRVFTFPDVQBO
EFDVFTUJPOFTCJPUJDBT JOWJUBOEPBCJP
FUJDJTUBTRVFQSFTFOUBOZEJTDVUFOUFNBT
SFMFWBOUFT

1VCMJDBDJPOFT
/PFTTPSQSFTBRVFFMBVNFOUPEFBDUJ
WJEBEFTZFMJOUFSTQPSMBCJPUJDBIBZBO
EBEPMVHBSBVOONFSPDSFDJFOUFEFQV
CMJDBDJPOFT$BEFSOPTEF#JPUJDB 3FWJT
UB1PSUVHVFTBEF#JPUJDB
DPPSEJOBEB
QPSFM$&# FTMBOJDBQVCMJDBDJOQF
SJEJDBSFHVMBSEFEJDBEBBMBCJPUJDB 
ONFSPT
1PSTVQVFTUP DPOUSJCVDJPOFT
RVF TF PDVQBO EF DVFTUJPOFT CJPUJDBT
TFQVCMJDBOSFHVMBSNFOUFFOQFSJEJDPT
NEJDPT SHBOPTEFMBTBTPDJBDJPOFTEF
NEJDPT Z BCPHBEPT  QFSJEJDPT DPOGF
TJPOBMFTZSFWJTUBTDVMUVSBMFT-PTEJBSJPT
ZDBOBMFTEFUFMFWJTJOTFPDVQBO BWFDFT
EFNBOFSBTFOTBDJPOBMJTUB
EFMPTDBTPT
DPOTJEFSBEPTQBSBEJHNUJDPT DPNPQPS
FKFNQMP FM DBTP 4DIJBWP P MB EFDMBSBEB
DMPOBDJO EF TFSFT IVNBOPT "VORVF
QFSTPOBT DPO DPOPDJNJFOUP CJPUJDP
TPO FOUSFWJTUBEPT HFOFSBMNFOUF FO FTUF
DPOUFYUP MBNBZPSBEFFTUPTJOGPSNFT
UJFOFNBMBDBMJEBE
$POTJEFSBEPT FO VO TFOUJEP FTUSJDUP
DPNPQFSUFOFDJFOUFTBMBCJPUJDB TFQV
CMJDBSPODBTJMJCSPTFOMBEDBEBQBTB
EB&TUPTUSBCBKPTWBOEFTEFNBOVBMFTB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

MJCSPTFTQFDJBMJ[BEPTZBCPSEBOWBSJBEPT
UFNBT  DPNP CJPUJDB QBSB FOGFSNFSPT 
QBSB MPT NJFNCSPT EF DPNJUT JOTUJUV
DJPOBMFT EF UJDB PCMJHBUPSJPT FO UPEP
IPTQJUBM
 EF MB HFOUJDB  EF MBT FUBQBT
JOJDJBMFTEFMBWJEBIVNBOB EFMBDMPOB
DJO EFMCJFODPNOZEFMJOUFSTJOEJ
WJEVBM FOTBZPTDMOJDPT UJDBBNCJFOUBM 
SFQSPEVDDJOBTJTUJEB QPSFKFNQMP
%PT WPMNFOFT EF DPNFOUBSJPT B MB
$POWFODJO&VSPQFBEF%FSFDIPT)V
NBOPTZ#JPNFEJDJOB SFTVMUBOUFTEFMPT
UBMMFSFT PSHBOJ[BEPT QPS FM *OTUJUVUP EF
#JPUJDB SFnFKBOFMJOUFSTQPSMBEJTDV
TJOEFEPDVNFOUPTKVSEJDPT 1PSUVHBM
IBBEPQUBEPEJDIBTDPOWFODJPOFT
DPO
BNQMJBT JNQMJDBDJPOFT FO MPT DVJEBEPT
EF TBMVE Z MB TBOBDJO 1PS MUJNP  BM
HVOBTNPOPHSBGBT QSFTFOUBEBTFODPO
HSFTPT P RVF SFQSFTFOUBO FM USBCBKP EF
VOOJDPBVUPS DPNQMFUBOFMDPOKVOUP
EFQVCMJDBDJPOFT&OFTUBSFB FM$/&
$7 IB MBO[BEP VOB TFSJF EF PDIP FEJ
DJPOFT RVF JODMVZFO MBT DPOUSJCVDJPOFT
QSFTFOUBEBT FO TVT TFNJOBSJPT BEFNT
EF OVFWF MJCSPT RVF DPOUJFOFO MBT PQJ
OJPOFTQSFTFOUBEBTQPSFTUFDVFSQP


-BFOTFBO[BEFMBCJPUJDB
$PNP IFNPT BmSNBEP  MB VOJWFSTJEBE
IB TJEP BMHP MFOUB FO FM SFDPOPDJNJFO
UPEFTVNJTJOEFFOTFBSZEJGVOEJSFM
DPOPDJNJFOUP CJPUJDP &O FGFDUP  TMP
FO  TF DSF FM QSJNFS DVSTP EF
QPTHSBEPFOCJPUJDB RVFTFPDVQBEFM
UFNB EF MB SFQSPEVDDJO NEJDBNFOUF
BTJTUJEB
 FO MB 'BDVMUBE EF 'JMPTPGB EF
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUMJDB %FTEF FOUPO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DFT MBTVOJWFSTJEBEFTBOUFEJDIBTPSHBOJ
[BODVSTPTEFQPTHSBEPZNBFTUSBTRVF
BCBSDBOVOBHSBOWBSJFEBEEFDVFTUJPOFT
CJPUJDBT&M*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDBEFMB
6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDBZFM4FSWJDJPEF#JP
UJDBZUJDB.EJDBEFMB&TDVFMB.EJ
DB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF 1PSUP DVFOUBO
DBEB DVBM DPO TJFUF NBFTUSBT NJFOUSBT
RVFMB'BDVMUBEEF'JMPTPGBEFMB6OJ
WFSTJEBE $BUMJDB Z FM $FOUSP EF UJDB
EFMB&TDVFMB.EJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EF -JTCPB DPO DJODP DVSTPT DBEB VOP
&O FM OJWFM EF QPTHSBEP  MBT FTDVFMBT
NEJDBT  MB NBZPSB EF MPT DPMFHJPT EF
BCPHBEPT Z MBT FTDVFMBT EF FOGFSNFSBT
SFTFSWBOVOMVHBSFOTVQMBOEFFTUVEJPT
QBSB MB FOTFBO[B EF MB CJPUJDB $V
SJPTBNFOUF MBTGBDVMUBEFTEFCJPMPHBZ
DJFODJBTBmOFTTMPJODMVZFOMBFOTFBO
[BEFMBCJPUJDBFOBMHVOPTDVSTPTEFTVT
QMBOFTEFFTUVEJPTSFTQFDUJWPT
"MHVOBTJOWFTUJHBDJPOFTIBOJOTJTUJEPFO
MB OFDFTJEBE EF FOTFBS FTUBT NBUFSJBT 
B NPEP EF JOUSPEVDDJO  FO MBT FTDVF
MBT TFDVOEBSJBT Z TF IBO IFDIP BMHVOBT
QSPQVFTUBT DPODSFUBT BM .JOJTUFSJP EF
&EVDBDJO QFSPOPIBOUFOJEPFGFDUPBM
HVOP4FFTQFSBRVFMBTBVUPSJEBEFTSFDP
OP[DBORVFPGSFDFSEFNPEPUSBOTWFSTBM
VOQSJNFSDPOUBDUPDPOMPTUFNBTQSJODJ
QBMFTEFMBCJPUJDBHFOFSBMTFSBEFHSBO
WBMPS QPS FKFNQMP  DVFTUJPOFT RVF TF
QVFEBOBCPSEBSEFTEFMBTBTJHOBUVSBTEF
CJPMPHB mMPTPGB SFMJHJOPDJVEBEBOB

*OWFTUJHBDJOCJPNEJDB
-BFMBCPSBDJOEFVOBUFTJTEFNBFTUSB
JNQMJDBDJFSUPHSBEPEFJOWFTUJHBDJOZ





#JPUJDBFO1PSUVHBM+PSHF#JTDBJBZ8BMUFS0TTXBME

FTP DJFSUBNFOUF TVDFEF DPO MBT UFTJT ZB


BQSPCBEBT4FFTQFSBRVFVOHSBEPNV
DIPNTBMUPEFJOWFTUJHBDJOEFDBMJEBE
TFBBTVNJEPQPSMBTFTDVFMBTRVFPGSFDFO
VOQSPHSBNBEFEPDUPSBEP"DUVBMNFO
UF FMOJDPJOTUJUVUPRVFDPODFEFFMHSB
EPEF%PDUPSFO#JPUJDBFTFM*OTUJUVUP
EF#JPUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDB
"EFNT EF MB JOWFTUJHBDJO JOEJWJEVBM
JNQMJDBEBFOMBQSFQBSBDJOEFVOBUF
TJTEFNBFTUSBPEFEPDUPSBEP BMHVOPT
QSPZFDUPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJO UBOUP EF
OBUVSBMF[B OBDJPOBM DPNP JOUFSOBDJP
OBM Z DPPQFSBUJWB
 TPO DPOEVDJEPT QPS
EPT JOTUJUVDJPOFT FM *OTUJUVUP EF #JP
UJDB 6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDB
ZFM4FSWJDJP
EF#JPUJDBZUJDB.EJDB &TDVFMBEF
.FEJDJOBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF1PSUP

&MMPTJOWFTUJHBO QPSFKFNQMP MBNVFS
UFEFOJPTQSFNBUVSPT FMTOESPNFEF
EFTHBTUFFOEFQBSUBNFOUPTEFDVJEBEPT
QBMJBUJWPT F JOUFOTJWPT  MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
EF DMVMBT NBESF  MB FOTFBO[B EF MB
CJPUJDB FO FTDVFMBT TFDVOEBSJBT  MB OB
UVSBMF[B Z MB UJDB  MB SFDVQFSBDJO EF
TPSEPNVEPT Z MPT QSPCMFNBT UJDPT  FM
YFOPUSBTQMBOUF MBUJDBEFMBBTJHOBDJO
EF SFDVSTPT B MPT TFSWJDJPT EF DVJEBEPT
NEJDPT FOUSFPUSPTUFNBT
-BQFSTQFDUJWBEFMBEFEJDBDJOQSPHSF
TJWBEFCJPFUJDJTUBTQPSUVHVFTFT ZFTQF
DJBMNFOUFEFMPTNTKWFOFT BMBJOWFT
UJHBDJOFOUJDBGVOEBNFOUBMZBQMJDBEB
QVFEFKVTUJmDBSVODJFSUPPQUJNJTNP

JNQPSUBODJBCJPUJDB/VFTUSBJOUFODJO
FT NFODJPOBS TMP BRVFMMBT EF FYUSFNB
JNQPSUBODJB FO MB NBUFSJB ZP RVF TF
IBO TPNFUJEP BM QBSFDFS EF $/&$7 
SHBOP EF OBUVSBMF[B DPOTVMUJWB Z OP
WJODVMBOUF  QFSP RVF FKFSDF DMBSBNFOUF
VOBJOnVFODJBFOFMUFYUPMFHBM
%FFTUBNBOFSB FMBCPSUPFTDPOTJEFSBEP
VODSJNFO DBTUJHBEPDPOQSJTJO EFB
BPT
FYDFQUPCBKPDJFSUBTDPOEJDJPOFT
QFMJHSPEFEBPGTJDPTPNFOUBMFTQBSB
MB NVKFS FNCBSB[BEB  QSFTFODJB EF FO
GFSNFEBEHSBWFZOPDVSBCMFFOFMGFUP 
FNCBSB[P EFTQVT EF DSJNFO TFYVBM

&M USBTQMBOUF FT QPTJCMF TJ MPT EPOBOUFT
FTUO NVFSUPT EFTQVT EF MB EJBHOPTJT
EFNVFSUFDFSFCSBM
PWJWPT MJNJUBEPB
QBSJFOUFT QSYJNPT
 Z IBZ VO SFHJTUSP
EFOPEPOBOUFT QVFTUPRVFTFQSFTVNF
RVFUPEPTBDFQUBOEPOBSTVTSHBOPT

-PT FOTBZPT DMOJDPT TF SFHVMBO FTUSJD
UBNFOUFZMB%JSFDUJWB&VSPQFBIBTJEP
BEPQUBEB SFDJFOUFNFOUF QPS FM QBT MB
-FZFTVOBUSBTDSJQDJOEFFTUB
%JSFDUJWB$&

-PTDBEWFSFTTFQVFEFOVUJMJ[BSQBSBMB
FOTFBO[B Z JOWFTUJHBDJO CBKP DPOEJ
DJPOFTCJFOSFTUSJOHJEBTZFTOFDFTBSJPFM
QSFWJPDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEPEFMB
QFSTPOBWJWB
-B SFQSPEVDDJO NEJDBNFOUF BTJTUJEB
3."
 IB TJEP mOBMNFOUF SFHVMBEB 
EFTQVTEFEDBEBTEFQSDUJDBTJONBS
DPMFHBM-BBDUVBMMFZSFTUSJOHFMB3."

-FZFTEFJNQPSUBODJBCJPNEJDB
&TDPNQSFOTJCMFRVFUPEBTMBTMFZFTRVF
BGFDUBO MB TBMVE Z FM BNCJFOUF TFBO EF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

 &MEFNBS[PEFFM1BSMBNFOUPEF1PSUV
HBMBQSPCFMBCPSUPIBTUBMBEDJNBTFNBOBEF
FNCBSB[P/5





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

BMPTQBSFTIFUFSPTFYVBMFT DBTBEPTPOP

QFSP QFSNJUF  FO DBTPT FYDFQDJPOBMFT 
MB GFDVOEBDJO IFUFSMPHB F JODMVTPMBT
NBESFT TVTUJUVUBT -PT FNCSJPOFT EF
TPCSB QVFEFO TFS VUJMJ[BEPT QBSB MB JO
WFTUJHBDJO DPOMBBVUPSJ[BDJOQBSFOUBM
Z EFTQVT EF EPT BPT EF FTUBS DPOHF
MBEPT
-BBEPQDJO DPNPMFZOBDJPOBMEFSJWBEB
EFMB$POWFODJO&VSPQFBEF%FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTZ#JPNFEJDJOB SFQSFTFOUBVO
KBMOJNQPSUBOUFFOMBUSBZFDUPSJBEFMB
CJPUJDBFO1PSUVHBM$POTVJOTJTUFODJB
SFTQFDUPEFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEP 
MB EJHOJEBE EF MB QFSTPOB IVNBOB  MB
QSJPSJEBE EFM JOUFST JOEJWJEVBM GSFOUF
BMJOUFSTDPNOZMBQSPIJCJDJOEFMB
QSPEVDDJOEFFNCSJPOFTIVNBOPTQBSB
QSPQTJUPT EF JOWFTUJHBDJO  JODPSQPSB
VO DPOKVOUP JNQPSUBOUF EF OPDJPOFT
CJPUJDBTRVFJOnVFODJBSOGVFSUFNFOUF
MBMFHJTMBDJOGVUVSB

7ODVMPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
%FCJEPBTVTDBSBDUFSTUJDBT MBCJPUJDB
UJFOEFBTFSNTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFOTVBM
DBODFRVFNVDIBTPUSBTEJTDJQMJOBT-B
NFUB RVFNVDIPTUJMEBSOEFVUQJDB 
EF MPHSBS VO DPOTFOTP VOJWFSTBM FO MB
CJPUJDB RVF QVFEB EJSJHJS BDUJUVEFT Z
BDDJPOFT FO SFBT FYUFOTBT EF MBT DJFO
DJBT EF MB WJEB Z MB QSFTFSWBDJO EF MB
CJPTGFSB OPFTBMDBO[BCMFTJMBHFOUFEF
EJWFSTPT QBTFT Z DPOUJOFOUFT OP JOUFS
DBNCJB TVT PQJOJPOFT  OP EJTDVUF TVT
CBTFTDVMUVSBMFT OPDPNQBSBTVTQJMBSFT
CTJDPT Z OP JOUFOUB FODPOUSBS BMHO
UFSSJUPSJPDPNO&OFTUFDPOUFYUP OP
FTTPSQSFTBRVFEFTEFFMQSJODJQJPEFMB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

iFSB CJPUJDBi RVF FO 1PSUVHBM PDVS


SJBNFEJBEPTEFMPTPDIFOUB
FSVEJUPT
QPSUVHVFTFTIBZBOJOUFOUBEPFTUBCMFDFS
ZNBOUFOFSWODVMPTDPODPMFHBTFJOTUJ
UVDJPOFTEFPUSPTQBTFT
1PS NPUJWPT EF MFOHVB Z DVMUVSB  TF
FTUBCMFDJFSPO DPOUBDUPT SFHVMBSFT DPO
#SBTJMZQBTFTMBUJOPT &TQBBF*UBMJB

-PTFTUVEJPTPTQPSUVHVFTFTZCSBTJMFPT
IBO DPNQBSUJEP DPOGFSFODJBT Z DVSTPT
Z EF FTB DPPQFSBDJO TVSHJ MB TFSJF EF
FODVFOUSPT -VTP#SBTJMFSPT EF CJPUJDB
RVF  SFDJFOUFNFOUF  IBO BMDBO[BEP ZB
TVDVBSUBFEJDJO TFQUJFNCSFEF

FO 4P 1BVMP &T VOB PDBTJO QBSB JO
UFSDBNCJBSQVOUPTEFWJTUB DPOMBWFO
UBKB EF UFOFS VO QBUSJNPOJP DVMUVSBM Z
MJOHTUJDP DPNVOFT 1PS PUSB QBSUF 
BMHVOPT FTUVEJBOUFT HSBEVBEPT WJTJUBO
PUSPT QBTFT 4P 1BVMP oZ FO &VSPQB 
#BSDFMPOB 3PNB 1BEPWBZ1BSToIBO
TJEP MPT QVOUPT DFOUSBMFT EF FTUF JOUFS
DBNCJPJOUFSOBDJPOBM
$PNPTFIBEJDIP FM$&#FTNJFNCSP
EFM $POTFKP EF MB "TPDJBDJO &VSPQFB
EFMPT$FOUSPTEFUJDB.EJDB#JPFUJ
DJTUBT QPSUVHVFTFT IBO TJEP EFTUJOBEPT
SFHVMBSNFOUF B MPT DVFSQPT FTQFDJBMJ[B
EPTEFM$POTFKPEF&VSPQB EFMB6OJO
&VSPQFBZEFMB6/&4$0 RVFTFPDV
QBOEFDVFTUJPOFTCJPUJDBT $PNJU%J
SFDUFVS QPVS MB #JPUIJRVF (SVQP &V
SPQFPEFUJDBEFMB$JFODJBZ/VFWBT
5FDOPMPHBT Z$PNJU*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF
#JPUJDB

6O ONFSP JNQPSUBOUF EF CJPFUJDJT
UBT EF PUSPT QBTFT IBO TJEP JOWJUBEPT
B EJDUBS DPOGFSFODJBT Z TFNJOBSJPT FO





#JPUJDBFO1PSUVHBM+PSHF#JTDBJBZ8BMUFS0TTXBME

1PSUVHBM Z  EF FTF NPEP  DPOUSJCVJS


FO MB EJSFDDJO EF FTUVEJBOUFT HSBEVB
EPT RVF QSFQBSBCBO TVT UFTJT "EFNT 
DJFOUmDPTQPSUVHVFTFTQBSUJDJQBOEFMPT
DPOTFKPTEFTPDJFEBEFTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTP
BTPDJBDJPOFTEFCJPUJDB ZVOPEFFMMPT
FTNJFNCSPEFMBQSFTUJHJPTB"DBEFNJB
1POUJmDJBQPSMB7JEB

6OB DPOUSJCVDJO NVZ JNQPSUBOUF BM


SFDPOPDJNJFOUP JOUFSOBDJPOBM EFM USB
CBKP EF MPT QPSUVHVFTFT FO FTUB SFB
EFQFOEF EF MB QVCMJDBDJO FO QFSJEJ
DPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT&TUPTVDFEFBDUVBM
NFOUFFOVOBFTDBMBBMHPNPEFTUBZ QPS
MPUBOUP OFDFTJUBTFSBOJNBEPZGPNFO
UBEP

3FGFSFODJBT
#JTDBJB  + Z 0TTXBME  8 
 #JPUJDB JO 1PSUVHBM  &O -VTUJH  #
"OESFX $PPSE
 #JPFUIJDT :FBSCPPL 7PM  "NTUFSEBN  ,MVXFS "DBEFNJD
1VCMJTIFST QQ
/VOF[ .1"CFM ' 
#JPFUIJDTJO1PSUVHBM-VTUJH #" $PPSE

#JPFUIJDT:FBSCPPL7PM"NTUFSEBN ,MVXFS"DBEFNJD1VCMJTIFST QQ

%JSFDDJPOFT
$FOUSP EF #JPUJDB  'BDVMEBEF EF .FEJDJOB EB 6OJWFSTJEBEF EF -JTCPB %JSFDUPS
" #BSCPTB
 "W 1SPGFTTPS &HBT .POJ[   -JTCPB 5FMGPOP 

 'BY 
&NBJMGNM!GNVMQU
$FOUSP EF %JSFJUP #JPNEJDP  'BDVMEBEF EF %JSFJUP EB 6OJWFSTJEBEF EF $PJNCSB
%JSFDUPS(EF0MJWFJSB
1UJPEB6OJWFSTJEBEF  $PJNCSB 1PSUVHBM
5FMGPOP 
  'BY 
    &NBJM GEVD!GE
VDQU
$FOUSP EF &TUVEPT EF #JPUJDB %JSFDUPS +PSHF #JTDBJB
 3VB (FOFSBM )VNCFSUP
%FMHBEP %  $PJNCSB5FMGPOP 
&NBJM
KPSHFCJTDBJB!OFUDBCPQU
$POTFMIP /BDJPOBM EF UJDB QBSB BT $JODJBT EB 7JEB $/&$7  1SFTJEFOUF 1BVMB
.BSUJOIP EB 4JMWB
 1SPG (PNFT 5FJYFJSB  &EJG 1$.     -JTCPB
5FMGPOP 
'BY 
&NBJMQSFTDOFDW!THQDN
HPWQU
*OTUJUVUP EF #JPUJDB EB 6OJWFSTJEBEF $BUMJDB 1PSUVHVFTB %JSFDUPS "OB 4PGJB
$BSWBMIP
 3VB EF %JPHP #PUFMIP    1PSUP  1PSUVHBM 5FMGPOP

'BY 
&NBJMJC!QPSUPVDQQU
'BDVMEBEFEF'JMPTPGJBEB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUMJDB1PSUVHVFTB #JPUJDB(FSBM %JSFDUPS
+)4JMWFJSBEF#SJUP
1SBBEB'BDVMEBEF #SBHB5FMGPOP 

'BY 
&NBJMTFDSFUBSJBGBDGJM!CSBHBVDQQU
4FSWJPEF#JPUJDBFUJDB.EJDBEB'BDVMEBEFEF.FEJDJOBEB6OJWFSTJEBEFEP1PSUP
%JSFDUPS3VJ/VOFT
"MBNFEB1SPG)FSOOJ.POUFJSP 1PSUP 1PSUVHBM
5FMGPOP 
  'BY 
  &NBJM SVJOVOFT!NFE
VQQU

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

6OJWFSTJEBEFEPT"PSFT %FQBSUBNFOUPEF'JMPTPGJB %JSFDUPS.BSJBEP$V1BUSP


/FWFT
$BNQVTEF1POUB%FMHBEB "QBSUBEP  1POUB%FMHBEB 4
.JHVFM "PSFT 1PSUVHBM5FMGPOP 
'BY 

&NBJMQBUSBP!OPUFTVBDQU

#JCMJPHSBGB
"MNFJEB ' 
UJDBFN1FEJBUSJBVNBOPWBEJONJDBOVNSFMBDJPOBNFOUPWJUBM 
1PSUP &EJPEP"VUPS
"OUVOFT + 
4PCSFB.PF0VUSPT&OTBJPT-JTCPB (SBEJWB
"SDIFS - 
%B(FOUJDB#JUJDB$PJNCSB (SGJDBEF$PJNCSB
"SDIFS - #JTDBJB +Z0TTXBME 8 $PPSET
 
#JPUJDB-JTCPB &EJUPSJBM7FSCP
"SDIFS - #JTDBJB + 0TTXBME 83FOBVE . $PPSET
 
/PWPTEFTBGJPT
#JPUJDB1PSUP 1PSUP&EJUPSB
#JTDBJB  + $PPSE
 
 #FN EB 1FTTPB  #FN $PNVN $PJNCSB  (SGJDB EF
$PJNCSB
#JTDBJB + 
1FSEFSQBSBFODPOUSBS$PJNCSB (SGJDBEF$PJNCSB
#JTDBJB + 
"PFODPOUSPEBUFSOVSB$PJNCSB (SGJDBEF$PJNCSB
#SJUP +)4JMWFJSB $PPSE
 
#JPUJDBRVFTUFTFNEFCBUF#SBHB 'BDVMEBEFEF
'JMPTPGJBEB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUMJDB1PSUVHVFTB
$BCSBM 3 
5FNBTEFUJDB#SBHB 6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUMJDB1PSUVHVFTB
$BSWBMIP  " 4 $PPSE
 
 $MPOBHFN P SJTDP F P EFTBGJP 1PSUP  (BCJOFUF EF
*OWFTUJHBPEF#JPUJDBEB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUMJDB1PSUVHVFTB
$PVUJOIP 7 
#JPUJDBF5FPMPHJB2VFQBSBEJHNBEFJOUFSBDP $PJNCSB (SGJDB
EF$PJNCSB
$VOIB +5FJYFJSB 
#JPUJDBCSFWF"QFMBP 1PSUVHBM
1BVMVT&EJUPSB
-FPOF 4 1SJWJUFSB 4$VOIB +5 
%JDJPOSJPEF#JPUJDB7JMB/PWB(BJB 
&EJUPSJBM1FSQUVP4PDPSSP
/FWFT .$1BUSP $PPSE
 
$PNJTTFTEFUJDBEBTCBTFTUFSJDBTBDUJWJEBEF
RVPUJEJBOB$PJNCSB (SGJDBEF$PJNCSB
/FWFT .$1BUSP1BDIFDP 4 $PPSET
 
1BSBVNUJDBEB&OGFSNBHFN
%FTBGJPT$PJNCSB (SGJDBEF$PJNCSB
/FWFT  .$ 1BUSP $PPSE
 
 #JPUJDB PV #JPUJDBT $PJNCSB  (SGJDB EF
$PJNCSB
/VOFT  3 
 2VFTUFT UJDBT EP EJBHOTUJDP QSOBUBM EB EPFOB HFOUJDB 1PSUP 
&EJPEP"VUPS
/VOFT  3  .FMP  )  /VOFT  $ $PPSET
 
 (FOPNB F EJHOJEBEF IVNBOB
$PJNCSB (SGJDBEF$PJNCSB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



#JPUJDBFO1PSUVHBM+PSHF#JTDBJBZ8BMUFS0TTXBME



/VOFT  3  .FMP  )  /VOFT  $ $PPSET


 
 (FOPNB F SFQSPEVP IVNBOB
$PJNCSB (SGJDBEF$PJNCSB
/VOFT 3 .FMP )/VOFT $ $PPSET
 
"UJDBFPEJSFJUPOPJODJPEBWJEB
IVNBOB$PJNCSB (SGJDBEF$PJNCSB
/VOFT 33FHP ( $PPSET
 
1SJPSJEBEFTOBTBEF-JTCPB .D(SBX)JMM
0MJWFJSB ( 
5FNBTEF%JSFJUPEB.FEJDJOB$PJNCSB $PJNCSB&EJUPSB
0TTXBME 8 $PPSE
 
%JSFJUPTEP)PNFNF#JPNFEJDJOB1PSUP 6OJWFSTJEBEF
$BUMJDB&EJUPSB
0TTXBME 8 
6NGJPEFUJDB$PJNCSB (SGJDBEF$PJNCSB
1JOUP +3$PTUB 
2VFTUFTBDUVBJTEBUJDB.EJDB&EJP#SBHB &EJUPSJBM"0
4FSSP  %   /VOFT 3 $PPSET
 
 UJDB FN DVJEBEPT EF TBEF 1PSUP  1PSUP
&EJUPSB
4JMWB +3JCFJSP #BSCPTB "7BMF ' $PPSET
 
$POUSJCVUPTQBSBB#JPUJDBFN
1PSUVHBM-JTCPB $PTNPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





-BIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPUJDBFO3FQCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
.JHVFM4VB[P

"OUFDFEFOUFTFMOBDJNJFOUP

&

O  TF QSPEVDF FM JOJDJP EF MB


CJPUJDBQBSBFMQBT1BSBFTBGFDIB 
MB0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4B
MVE 014
 FO 3FQCMJDB %PNJOJDBOB
DPOWPDBMNVOEPBDBENJDPZEFMBTB
MVEQBSBDPNQBSUJSDPOVOJOWJUBEPRVF
IBCMBSBTPCSFVOUFNBoCJPUJDBoOVF
WPZBKFOPQBSBOPTPUSPT&MJOWJUBEPFSB
&EVBSEP EFM $BP  BSHFOUJOP -B DPO
WPDBUPSJBDBMGVOEBNFOUBMNFOUFFOUSF
MPTBDBENJDPT RVJFOFTFTUVWJNPTFOMB
QSJNFSBMOFBMVFHPFM.JOJTUFSJPEF4B
MVE JOUFSFTBEPT SFMJHJPTPT GVODJPOBSJPT
QCMJDPT Z QSJWBEPT -B QSPQVFTUB OP
GVFDPNQSFOEJEBFOUPEBTVNBHOJUVE
EFTEFFTUFQSJNFSNPNFOUPTJOFNCBS
HP  IPZ QPEFNPT BmSNBS RVF DBZ FO
UFSSFOPGSUJM
-PT BSHFOUJOPT UFOBO ZB NVDIB FYQF
SJFODJBFOFTFNPNFOUP/PNCSFTDPNP
MPTEF+".BJOFUUJFSBOIJTUPSJBDVBOEP
OPTPUSPTBQFOBTJOUFOUCBNPTBTPNBSOPT
B FTUB WFOUBOB -PT JOTUJUVUPT Z DFOUSPT
BSHFOUJOPTEFCJPUJDBFSBOVOBSFBMJEBE
BQBSUBEBZEJTUBOUFQBSBOPTPUSPT
%VSBOUFFTUPTBPTMBCBUBMMBIBTJEPMBS
HB3FVOJPOFT TFNJOBSJPT FODVFOUSPT 

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

IBTUBDPOGPSNBSVOB$PNJTJO/BDJP
OBMEF#JPUJDB $/#
JOJDJOEPTFDPO
VODPNJUHFTUPSRVFEFCBDPOEVDJSB
VOBT FMFDDJPOFT FOUSF MPT JOUFSFTBEPT Z
MBT JOTUJUVDJPOFT QSFTFOUFT &TUP USBKP
DPNPSFTVMUBEPBTVQSJNFSQSFTJEFOUF 
.JMDJBEFT "MCFSU  EJSFDUPS FKFDVUJWP FO
FTF FOUPODFT EFM *OTUJUVUP "DDJO 1SP
&EVDBDJO Z $VMUVSB "1&$
 EF FEV
DBDJO TFYVBM  Z "OEST 1FSBMUB  DPNP
WJDFQSFTJEFOUF
"MPTQPDPTNFTFTTFJOJDJVOQSPDFTP
EFDPOTPMJEBDJOZVOBTFSJFEFFODVFO
USPTFOVOJWFSTJEBEFTZNJOJTUFSJPTQ
CMJDPT IBTUBDPODMVJSFOFM1SJNFS$PO
HSFTP%PNJOJDBOPEF#JPUJDB
5PEP FTUF UJFNQP DPOEVKP B MB FMBCP
SBDJO EF SFHMBNFOUPT  JODPSQPSBDJO
MFHBMQPSFMQPEFSFKFDVUJWP DPNJTJPOFT
EF USBCBKP  JOWJUBEPT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT Z
DPOHSFTPTOBDJPOBMFT IBTUBMMFHBSBMNP
NFOUPEFMBDBQBDJUBDJOBMJOUFSJPSEF
MBQSPQJBDPNJTJO BMBRVFZBTFIBCB
EBEPVOBFTUSVDUVSBGPSNBMZSFTQPOTB
CJMJEBEFTQPSSFBTDPNJUTEFCJPUJDB
BTJTUFODJBM  NFEJP BNCJFOUF  JOWFTUJHB
DJO EPDFODJB SFMJHJO mMPTPGB FOUSF
PUSBT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

&TUPTJOJDJPTGVFSPOGVOEBNFOUBEPTDPO
FMBVUPFTUVEJPZMBUPNBEFDPOUBDUPDPO
PSHBOJTNPT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT  DPNP FM
1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPUJDB 13#

EFMB014FO$IJMFZTVTEJSFDUJWPT

EBT QSFTUBSPO VO BQPZP JNQPSUBOUF B


FTUF QSPDFTP EF CTRVFEB Z FODVFOUSP
4JSWJFSPO EF TFEF  EF BQPZP  EF mOBO
DJBEPSBTZBMHVOBTBOTJHVFOTJOEPMP
IBTUBIPZ

&UBQBEFGPSNBMJ[BDJO

EFTBSSPMMP

*OUFSOBDJPOBMJ[BDJO

"FTUBGFDIBZBIBCBOPDVSSJEPFWFOUPT
EFJNQPSUBODJBFOMBWJEBEFMBCJPUJDB
EPNJOJDBOB  FO DVBOUP TF IBCB MPHSB
EPTFOTJCJMJ[BSBEJTUJOUPTTFDUPSFT IBDFS
DPOUBDUPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTDPOMB'FEFSB
DJO -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF *OTUJUVDJPOFT
EF#JPUJDB '&-"*#&
DPOFM13#EF
MB014FO$IJMFZDPOPUSBTJOTUJUVDJP
OFTEFFTFNCJUP4FIBCBODFMFCSBEP
EPT DPOHSFTPT OBDJPOBMFT NT Z IBCB
NPT UPNBEP QBSUF FO VO DPOTPSDJP EF
DPNJTJPOFTEFCJPUJDBEFM$BSJCF GPS
NBOEP MB $POGFEFSBDJO $BSJCFB EF
#JPUJDBKVOUPB$VCBZ1VFSUP3JDP
&OFTFBPNFQSFTFOUDPNPDBOEJEBUP
EFM *OTUJUVUP 5FDOPMHJDP */5&$
 BM
.BHTUFSEF#JPUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EF$IJMFoDPOMPTBVTQJDJPTEFM13#o 
NJFOUSBT "OEST 1FSBMUB  QSFTJEFOUF EF
MB $/#  QBSUJDJQBCB FO DVSTPT JOUFS
OBDJPOBMFT EF CJPUJDB DPO DPOOPUBEPT
QSPGFTPSFTFO1VFSUP3JDP TJFNQSFDPO
FMBQPZPEFM13#EF014
1PEFNPTEFDJSRVFFOFTUBFUBQBEFGPS
NBDJOFNQF[BNPTBEBSOPTDVFOUBEF
RV FSB MB CJPUJDB  TPCSF UPEP FOUFO
EJFOEPRVFIBCBNPTFNQF[BEPBPSHB
OJ[BSOPTBUSBWTEFMPBDBENJDP
"MHVOBTEFMBTVOJWFSTJEBEFTJOWPMVDSB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&O   FM $POTFKP "DBENJDP EFM


*OTUJUVUP 5FDOPMHJDP EF 4BOUP %P
NJOHPBDPHFVOBTPMJDJUVEEFMSFBEF
4BMVE Z NB oRVF IBCB TJEP TV EFDB
OPoQBSBDPOGPSNBSFM$FOUSP*OUFDEF
#JPUJDB $&/*/#*0
FMDVBMDPODJUB
MB QBSUJDJQBDJO EF WBSJPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT
WJODVMBEPTBMSFB4VPCKFUJWPFSBTFSWJS
EFBQPZP DPOTVMUBZSFGFSFODJBQBSBMB
EJTFNJOBDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFOFMNFEJP
EPNJOJDBOPZQBSBJOJDJBSVOQSPDFTPEF
TFOTJCJMJ[BDJOZEJWVMHBDJOFOFMQBT
"M USNJOP EFM TFHVOEP .BHTUFS EF
#JPUJDB FO $IJMF Z CBKP MB EJSFDDJO
EF%JFHP(SBDJBZTVFRVJQPEFMB6OJ
WFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTFZEFPUSPTQBTFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT  FM */5&$ EF 3FQ
CMJDB %PNJOJDBOB BDFQU TFS TFEF EFM
QSJNFSPEFFTUPTNBHTUFSFTGVFSBEFUF
SSJUPSJPDIJMFOP
"M $FOUSP EF #JPUJDB TF MF FODBSHB MB
SFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFBTVNJSMBDPPSEJOB
DJO UDOJDB EFM OVFWP NBHTUFS  PCUF
OJFOEP MB QBSUJDJQBDJO EF FTUVEJBOUFT
EF $PMPNCJB  $IJMF  1FS  &DVBEPS 
"SHFOUJOB &M4BMWBEPS .YJDP $VCB 
3FQCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB FOUSFPUSPT
-B $PNJTJO /BDJPOBM EF #JPUJDB 
QSFTJEJEB FO FTF NPNFOUP QPS "OEST
1FSBMUB  KVFHB VO QBQFM QSFQPOEFSBOUF





-BIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPUJDBFO3FQCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB.JHVFM4VB[P

FO MBT OFHPDJBDJPOFT Z HBSBOUBT QBSB


JOTUBMBSFMNBHTUFSFO3FQCMJDB%PNJ
OJDBOB TPCSFUPEPQPSRVFEJDIBVOJWFS
TJEBE FT QSJWBEB Z 014 TJFNQSF IBCB
DPPSEJOBEPBDUJWJEBEFTDPOVOJWFSTJEB
EFTQCMJDBT

$SFDJNJFOUP FYUFOTJOZ
EFTBSSPMMP
&M$FOUSPEF#JPUJDBSFDJCFVOFTQBMEB
SB[PEFQBSUFEFMBSFDUPSBEFM*/5&$
FO FTF QFSPEP  "MUBHSBDJB -QF[  EO
EPMFBUSJCVDJPOFTEFHFSFOUFBDBENJDP
DPNP DPOUSBQBSUF BM DVFSQP EPDFOUF Z
UDOJDPEFMB014
$PNP QBSUF EF TVT UBSFBT TF MF BTJHOB
CBO
t

t
t

t
t

t
t

$PPSEJOBS FM .BHTUFS *OUFSOBDJP


OBMFO#JPUJDBDPOFM13#EVSBOUF
FMQFSPEPB
$BQBDJUBSBMPTDPNJUTEFCJPUJDB
IPTQJUBMBSJB
'PSNBS FM 'PSP */5&$ EF #JP
UJDB FOFMOJWFMEFQSFHSBEPFOMB
DBSSFSBEF.FEJDJOBEFM*/5&$

0SHBOJ[BSDPOGFSFODJBTFOFMNFEJP
EPNJOJDBOP
*NQMFNFOUBSFMDVSSDVMPEFMBCJP
UJDBDPNPFKFUSBOTWFSTBMEFMBDB
SSFSBEF.FEJDJOBEFM*/5&$
&TUBCMFDFSBDVFSEPTDPOFM13#EF
014
"QPZBSBMB$PNJTJO/BDJPOBMEF
#JPUJDB

%FTEF FTB GFDIB FM $FOUSP TF DPNQSP


NFUJDPOFTUPTBTVOUPT DPOWJSUJOEPTF
FOQVOUPEFSFGFSFODJBOBDJPOBM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

.JFOUSBTTFEFTBSSPMMBCBOFTUPTQSPDFTPT
BDBENJDPT  MB $PNJTJO /BDJPOBM EF
#JPUJDB DPOUJOV TV EFTBSSPMMP %FT
QVT EF EPT NBOEBUPT DPOTFDVUJWPT EF
"OEST 1FSBMUB  GVF FMFDUP DPNP QSFTJ
EFOUFFMSFDUPSEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$BU
MJDB4BOUP%PNJOHP .POTFPS3BNO
"MPOTP RVJFOEJPTFEFBMB$PNJTJO
&OFTUFQFSPEPFMHPCJFSOPEPNJOJDB
OPFNJUFVOEFDSFUP SFDPOPDJFOEPBMB
$/# DPNP FOUJEBE BTFTPSB EFM QPEFS
FKFDVUJWPFONBUFSJBEFCJPUJDBZ BMB
WF[ TPMJDJUBOEPMBFMBCPSBDJOEFVOSF
HMBNFOUPQBSBTUB
1PTUFSJPSNFOUFZIBTUBMBGFDIBMB$PNJ
TJONFIBFMFHJEPDPNPTVQSFTJEFOUF
 "DUJWJEBE BDBENJDB */5&$  DPO
FM BQPZP EF MB $/#  BTVNF FM SFUP EF
EBS DPOUJOVJEBE BM QSPDFTP BDBENJDP
JOJDJBEPZMBO[BTV.BFTUSBFO#JPUJ
DBDPNPUUVMPQSPQJP FTUBOEPFOFTUF
NPNFOUP FO TV TFHVOEP QFSPEP DPO
VO HSVQP EF BMVNOPT QSPWFOJFOUFT EF
NMUMJQMFTEJTDJQMJOBTBmOFT&OMBNF
EJEBFORVFFTUPTQSPDFTPTTFGVFSPOEF
TBSSPMMBOEP MPTFHSFTBEPTTFJOUFHSBSPO
EFTEFMB$PNJTJO/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJ
DBZ FOMBTSFDJFOUFTFMFDDJPOFT RVFE
DPOTUJUVJEBVOBQMBUBGPSNBDPOGPSNBEB
QPSFHSFTBEPTZQSFTJEJEBQPS5PHBSNB
3PESHVF[
3FQSFTFOUBDJO$PNPMB$/#FTZB
SFDPOPDJEB OBDJPOBM F JOUFSOBDJPOBM
NFOUF  MBT SFMBDJPOFT DPO MB 014 IBO
TJEPUBOFTUSFDIBTRVFFTUBMUJNBBDUB
DPNP BTFTPSB Z TFEF EF EJDIB $PNJ
TJO





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

&OMBTBDUJWJEBEFTEF6/&4$0IFNPT
UFOJEP GSFDVFOUF SFQSFTFOUBDJO  UBOUP
FO NMUJQMFT FWFOUPT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT 
EPOEF TF IBO EJTDVUJEP TVT QSPQVFTUBT
SFMBUJWBTBCJPUJDBZEFSFDIPTIVNBOPT 
DPNPFOFMQMBOPMPDBM DPOTVTFEFFO
FMQBT
&O TVT SFMBDJPOFT DPO FM HPCJFSOP  MB
$/# IB TJEP MMBNBEB B IBDFS BTFTPSB
FOMB4FDSFUBSBEF4BMVEZFOFM$POTFKP
/BDJPOBMEF*OWFTUJHBDJPOFTFO4BMVE
 $PNJTJO $BSJCFB EF #JPUJDB 3F
HJPOBMNFOUF TFMFIBEBEPWJHFODJBBMB
$PNJTJO $BSJCFB EF #JPUJDB  BHSF
HOEPTFBMBNJTNB7FOF[VFMB BEFNT
EF1VFSUP3JDP $VCBZ3FQCMJDB%P
NJOJDBOB

"TQFDUPTMFHBMFT
-B $/# BQPZB TV NBSDP MFHBM FO TVT
FTUBUVUPT  FTUBCMFDJEPT FO TV BTBNCMFB
EFMEFPDUVCSFEFM ZTVSFDPOP
DJNJFOUPQPSQBSUFEFMQPEFSFKFDVUJWP
NFEJBOUFEFDSFUPEFMQSFTJEFOUF-FPOFM
'FSOOEF[
#BKPFTUBDPOTJEFSBDJOMFHBMTFBNQMJB
FMNBSDPEFBDDJOEFMBCJPUJDBBNQB
SBEBFOMB$/# RVFSFOFCBKPTVUF
DIPBUPEBQFSTPOBWJODVMBEBPJOUFSFTB
EBFOFMUFNB$PNPUBM MBCJPUJDBOBDF
ZFODVFOUSBVOQBOPSBNBIVSGBOPEF
MFHJTMBDJPOFTNPEFSOBTFOMPSFGFSFOUFB
MBWJEBPBUFNBTDPNPFMBCPSUP JOWFT
UJHBDJPOFTFOTFSFTIVNBOPT SFQSPEVD
DJOBTJTUJEB FOUSFPUSPT
&OTFBQSVFCBMB-FZ(FOFSBMEF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

4BMVE  MB DVBM SFTQBMEB MPT EFSFDIPT EF


MPTQBDJFOUFTZ FOUSFFMMPToBVORVFTJO
MMBNBSMPQPSTVOPNCSFo FMEFSFDIPEF
MPTQBDJFOUFTBTFSJOGPSNBEPT"MUPDBS
FM UFNB CJPUJDP MP SFEVDF EF NBOFSB
FYDMVTJWBBMNVOEPEFMBTJOWFTUJHBDJP
OFT FO TFSFT IVNBOPT  TFBMBOEP  FO
VOBSFGFSFODJBNVZBNQMJB RVFEFCFO
BDPHFSTFBMPTDEJHPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTEF
UJDB DPNP/VSFNCFSH )FMTJOLJ FOUSF
PUSPT
-PTUFNBTWJODVMBEPTBMBWJEBTFYVBMZ
SFQSPEVDUJWB Z BM BCPSUP GVFSPO PCKFUP
EF HSBOEFT EFCBUFT Z QSFTJPOFT  TPCSF
UPEP EF UJQP SFMJHJPTP  MP RVF JNQJEJ
RVF JOHSFTBSBO FO MB MFHJTMBDJO DPO
OPNCSFQSPQJP&MBCPSUP QPSFKFNQMP 
TF WJODVMB EF JONFEJBUP BM $EJHP 1F
OBM EFTEFFMNPNFOUPRVFTBODJPOBDPO
DSDFMBUPEBTMBTQFSTPOBTJNQMJDBEBT-P
DSJNJOBMJ[B QFSP BMBWF[ EFKBFYDMVJEB
MBQPTJCJMJEBEEFMBCPSUPUFSBQVUJDP
-B HSBO QBSBEPKB EFM UFYUP FT RVF VOB
TPMB EF MBT NBUFSOJEBEFT EF MB DBQJUBM
MMFH B SFQPSUBS NT EF  DBTPT
BMDBCPEFVOBP MPTDVBMFTMBMFZOP
DPOUFNQMBOJTBODJPOBQPSRVFFTMDJUP
DPODMVJSMPTDPOMBJOUFODJOEFTBMWBSMB
WJEBEFMBNBESF&TUPUSBKPDPNPDPO
TFDVFODJBRVFNVDIBTEFMBTFNCBSB[B
EBT JOUFSFTBEBT FO JOUFSSVNQJS FM FN
CBSB[P QPS FTB WB JOJDJBSBO NBOJPCSBT
BCPSUJWBTQBSBQPEFSPCUFOFSMBBUFODJO
NEJDBZFMBNQBSPEFMBMFZ
:BFOZFO SFTQFDUJWBNFOUF 
TF IBCBO FNJUJEP MFZFT SFGFSFOUFT B MB
EPOBDJOEFSHBOPT -FZ
ZTPCSF
EPOBDJO Z USBTQMBOUF EF DSOFBT -FZ





-BIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPUJDBFO3FQCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB.JHVFM4VB[P


 %JDIPT DVFSQPT MFHBMFT TJHVFO
WJHFOUFT QFSPBOOPIBODBMBEPFOMB
QPCMBDJO QSPEVDJFOEP MPT SFTVMUBEPT
FTQFSBEPT -MFWBS UJFNQP NPEJmDBS MB
DVMUVSB EF MB EPOBDJO  ZB RVF FYJTUFO
NJUPT SFMJHJOZDSFFODJBTRVFTFNVF
WFO FO FTUF NBSDP UBNQPDP IBZ VOB
DBNQBB FmDB[ QBSB EFWFMBS FTUBT TV
QFSTUJDJPOFT

MBTSFBTEFJOWFTUJHBDJO QPMUJDBZCJP
UJDB

-B$/#IBFTUBEPCBTUBOUFEFTMJHBEBEF
FTUPTUFNBT QPSRVFOBDFNVZBMVOTP
OPEFFTUPTDBNCJPTZFMMBNJTNB DPNP
UBM OPUJFOFVOOPNCSFFOMBTPDJFEBE
OJMBCJPUJDBVOFTUBUVUPQSPQJPRVFTFB
TV DBSUB EF QSFTFOUBDJO &T VO QSPDF
TPMFOUPEFJODPSQPSBDJOBMBWJEBDJWJM
RVFZBFNQJF[BBUFOFSSFDPOPDJNJFOUP

&MQSPQJPNJOJTUSPEF4BMVEIBFODBSHB
EPBMB$/#IBDFSVOBQSPQVFTUBTPCSF
NFEJDBDJPOFT Z NBOFKP EF DBTPT QPS
FKFNQMP FMEFFNCBSB[PTNMUJQMFTTJO
TFS VOB PQDJO CVTDBEB P EFTFBEB QPS
MPTQBESFT

1SPCBCMFNFOUF  FM SFB EF 4BMVE Z MB


4FDSFUBSBEF&TUBEPEF4BMVE1CMJDBZ
"TJTUFODJB4PDJBM 4&41"4
IBOTJEPFM
FTDFOBSJPEPOEFIBDSFDJEPZTFIBSFDP
OPDJEPBMBCJPUJDB:BIFNPTTFBMBEP
DPNP IJUPT FM OBDJNJFOUP ZEFTBSSPMMP
EF VOB JOTUBODJB PmDJBM EF FWBMVBDJO
CJPUJDBEFQSPUPDPMPTEFJOWFTUJHBDJO
FOFM$POTFKP/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDBFO
4BMVE $0/"#*04
 MB BQBSJDJO EF
BDQJUFTRVFMFHJUJNBOBMBCJPUJDBFOMB
MFZHFOFSBMEFTBMVE UBOUPQBSBMPDMOJ
DPDPNPFOFMDBTPEFMDPOTFOUJNJFOUP
JOGPSNBEPZFMSFTQFUPBMBEJHOJEBEZ
WBMPSFTFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJO
&M$0/"#*04UJFOFVOBJEFOUJEBEMF
HBMRVFMFBDSFEJUBQBSBFWBMVBSUPEBTMBT
JOWFTUJHBDJPOFTFOTFSFTIVNBOPTEFTEF
MBQFSTQFDUJWBCJPUJDB$VFOUBDPOVOB
QSFTFODJB PmDJBM FO FM NFEJP Z DPO VO
HSVQP FRVJMJCSBEP EF QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&HSFTBEPT Z QSPGFTPSFT EF MB .BFTUSB


FO #JPUJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE */5&$
IBOJOUFHSBEP$0/"#*04FOMBUBSFB
EF FWBMVBS FTUPT QSPUPDPMPT Z IBO DP
PQFSBEPFOMBGPSNBDJOUDOJDBEFTVT
NJFNCSPT

%BEBT MBT GVFSUFT SBDFT SFMJHJPTBT EF MB


QPCMBDJO Z FM QPEFS EF MBT DQVMBT SF
MJHJPTBT  IBZ UFNBT OP UPDBEPT EFTEF FM
QVOUPEFWJTUBMFHBM UBOUPRVFFOFTUPT
NPNFOUPTIBZVOOVFWP$EJHP1SPDF
TBM1FOBMZUBNQPDPIBDFOJOHVOBDPODF
TJOBMBCPSUPUFSBQVUJDP DSJNJOBMJ[BO
EPDVBMRVJFSBEFTVTGPSNBT-PNJTNP
TVDFEFDPOMBFVUBOBTJBIBOTVSHJEPBM
HVOBTWPDFTTPMJDJUBOEPRVFFMUFNBTFB
EFCBUJEPPMMFWBEPBM$POHSFTP TJOPCUF
OFSTFSFTVMUBEPT NTCJFOTJMFODJP
-B QSPQJB $/# IB QMBOUFBEP BCSJS FM
EFCBUF TJSWJFOEP EF QMBUBGPSNB QBSB MB
HFOFSBDJOEFVOQFOTBNJFOUPTFDVMBS 
QFSPOPTFIBQPEJEPQBTBSEFMBTJOUFO
DJPOFT EBEBMBQMVSBMJEBEEFTVTNJFN
CSPT

-BTJUVBDJOBDUVBMEFMBCJPUJDB
FO3FQCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
&OFTUPTNPNFOUPTDPOUBNPTDPOVOB
DJFSUB IJTUPSJB Z VO SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

MB EJTDJQMJOB FO FM NFEJP EPNJOJDBOP


&YJTUFO TVCDPNJUT EFQFOEJFOUFT EF MB
$/# FO SFBT DPNP NFEJP BNCJFOUF 
DPNJUT EF UJDB Z CJPUJDB  FEVDBDJO 
FOUSFPUSBT EBOEPVOBWJTJOJOUFSEJTDJ
QMJOBSJBEFMUFNB
&O FM NCJUP BDBENJDP  B EJGFSFODJB
EF MPT JOJDJPT  IBZ QPS MPT NFOPT TFJT
DBSSFSBTEF.FEJDJOB EFJHVBMONFSP
EF VOJWFSTJEBEFT  RVF IBO JNQMBOUBEP
MB CJPUJDB DPNP BTJHOBUVSB DPO NP
EBMJEBEFT QFEBHHJDBT Z NFUPEPMHJDBT
JOOPWBEPSBT-BVOJWFSTJEBEEFM&TUBEP
"VUOPNBEF4BOUP%PNJOHP
IBSFB
MJ[BEPEJQMPNBEPTFOCJPUJDBQBSBTVT
QSPGFTPSFTMBTTPDJFEBEFTNEJDBTFTQF
DJBMJ[BEBTEFM$PMFHJP.EJDPEPNJOJ
DBOPIBOJODMVJEPFMUFNBFOTVTDPO
HSFTPT BTDPNPFOPUSBTJOTUBODJBTEFM
NVOEPBDBENJDPZMBTPDJFEBEDJWJM
5BOUP FM $FOUSP */5&$ EF #JPUJDB
DPNPMB$/#TPOSFGFSFOUFTPCMJHBEPT
EFM UFNB FO FM DPOUFYUP OBDJPOBM "D
UVBMNFOUF  VOB HFOFSBDJO VOB HFOF
SBDJO EF QSPGFTJPOBMFT FTU DVSTBOEP
MB .BFTUSB FO FM */5&$ TF FTU BTF
TPSBOEP BM HPCJFSOP EPNJOJDBOP FO MB
IVNBOJ[BDJOEFMPTTFSWJDJPTEFTBMVE
BDBCBO EF DFMFCSBSTF FMFDDJPOFT FO MB
$/#ZTVEJSFDUJWBFTUDPNQVFTUBQPS
FHSFTBEPTEFEJDIBNBFTUSB MPRVFDPO
mFSFNBZPSDBMJEBEBTVTFSWJDJP
1PS NFEJP EFM BQPZP EF PSHBOJTNPT
JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT IFNPTEFTBSSPMMBEPUB
MMFSFTEFGPSNBDJOEFDPNJUTEFUJDB
BTJTUFODJBMFOFMJOUFSJPSEFMQBTZBTFTP
SBTFTQFDJBMJ[BEBT QBTBOEPQPSVOUBMMFS
JOUFSOBDJPOBM BVTQJDJBEPQPSMB014Z

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

TV1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDB TPCSFMBEJED
UJDBEFMBFOTFBO[BEFMBCJPUJDBFO3F
QCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
/VFTUSPTTPDJPTZFHSFTBEPTIBODPOUSJ
CVJEPDPOVOBDFSWPCJCMJPHSmDPFOUSF
MPT RVF DPOUBNPT i#JPUJDB QBSB OVF
WPTw EF .JHVFM 4VB[P i$PBVUPSB FO
#JPUJDBQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBEwEF"O
EST 1FSBMUB Z .JHVFM 4VB[P i#JPUJDB
Z(FTUJOEFMPT4FSWJDJPTEF4BMVEiEF
3BGBFM.POUFSP .JHVFM4VB[PZ'SBO
DJB 3FZOPTP  Z i"EPMFTDFS 6O OVFWP
NBSDPBYJPMHJDPwEF.JHVFM4VB[P
4JCJFOFOFMNVOEPMFHJTMBUJWPMBCJP
UJDBOPUJFOFBDUVBMNFOUFVOBQSFTFODJB
QVOUVBM FOMPTMUJNPTRVJODFBPTIB
DSFDJEP FO MB GPSNBDJO EF VOB NBTB
DSUJDB EFVOHSVQPEFFTQFDJBMJTUBTFO
FMUFNBZEFVOHFSNFOQPUFODJBMQBSB
EFTBSSPMMBSFMUFNBFOFMNCJUPQSPGF
TJPOBMZTPDJBM
4BCFNPT RVF MB CJPUJDB OP FT TMP VO
JOTUSVNFOUP QBSB FM SFB EF MB TBMVE 
TJOPUBNCJOQBSBFMNVOEPEFMBTQSP
GFTJPOFTZTVJOUFSBDDJODPOFMNVOEP
EFMPTWBMPSFT
&M JOWFOUBSJP BDUVBM EF MB CJPUJDB FO
3FQCMJDB %PNJOJDBOB UJFOF RVF DPO
UBCJMJ[BSTVTNBZPSFTMPHSPTFOFMNCJUP
BDBENJDP DPOMBGPSNBDJOEFQSPGF
TJPOBMFTQBSBFOUSBSFOFTUFQSPDFTPTP
DJBM ZBQPSUFTFOFMNCJUPFTUBUBMQPS
RVF  VOB WF[ MPHSBEB TV JODPSQPSBDJO
MFHBM MB$/#GVFEFTJHOBEBDPNPBTF
TPSB EFM QPEFS FKFDVUJWP FO NBUFSJB EF
CJPUJDB5SFTHPCJFSOPTDPOTFDVUJWPTMF
IBOJEPEBOEPFTQBDJPMFHBM ZBRVFFO





-BIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPUJDBFO3FQCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB.JHVFM4VB[P

MBQSDUJDBOPIBTJEPTPMJDJUBEPTVKVJ
DJPFYQFSUPNTRVFJOEJSFDUBNFOUFQPS
NFEJPEFMB4FDSFUBSBEF4BMVE


/VFTUSBIJTUPSJBIBIFDIPVOSFDPSSJEP
MHJDPZEFVOBJOJDJBUJWBMFKBOB4JODFS
UF[BT IFNPT QPEJEP DPOTUSVJS VO QSP
ZFDUPRVFZBFMQBTSFDPOPDF

3FGFSFODJBT
"TPDJBDJOEF#JPUJDB'VOEBNFOUBMZ$MOJDB 
-B&EVDBDJOFO#JPUJDBEFMPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFTTBOJUBSJPTFO&TQBB.BESJE
$PNJTJO /BDJPOBM EF #JPUJDB 
 &TUBUVUPT 4BOUP %PNJOHP  3FQCMJDB
%PNJOJDBOB
$PVDFJSP " 
#JPUJDBQBSB$MOJDPT.BESJE &EJUPSJBM5SJBDBTUFMB
'BDVMUBEEF&EVDBDJO 6OJWFSTJEBE&M#PTRVF 
#JPUJDB 0SJHFOZ5FOEFODJBT
#PHPU 6OJWFSTJEBEB%JTUBODJB 1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDB
(SBDJB % 
1SPGFTJONEJDB JOWFTUJHBDJOZKVTUJDJBTBOJUBSJB#PHPU &EJUPSJBM
&M#IP
1JDIBSEP " 
3FTQPOTBCJMJEBEDJWJMZQFOBMEFMNEJDP4BOUP%PNJOHP &EJUPSB
*NQSFUVS4"
1SFTJEFODJBEFMB3FQCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB 
3FHMBNFOUPTEFMB-FZ(FOFSBMEF4BMVE

7PMVNFO**$&3444BOUP%PNJOHP 3FQCMJDB%PNJOJDBOB
3FCPSFEP + 
*OTFSDJOEFMPTDPNJUTEFUJDBFOMPT)PTQJUBMFT1CMJDPT#VFOPT
"JSFT
4FDSFUBSB EF &TUBEP EF 4BMVE 1CMJDB 
 -FZ (FOFSBM EF 4BMVE EF MB 3FQCMJDB
%PNJOJDBOB
4FDSFUBSB EF &TUBEP EF 4BMVE 1CMJDB 3FHMBNFOUP )PTQJUBMBSJP EF MB 3FQCMJDB
%PNJOJDBOB
4VB[P . 
#JPUJDBQBSBOVFWPT4BOUP%PNJOHP *OTUJUVUP5FDOPMHJDPEF4BOUP
%PNJOHP
4VB[P . 
"EPMFTDFS VOOVFWPNBSDPBYJPMHJDP4BOUP%PNJOHP *NQSFOUB-B
6OJO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



1***
$VFTUJPOFTFTQFDmDBTSFMJHJOZNVKFSFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





#JPUJDBZSFMJHJOFO"NSJDB-BUJOB
.SDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT

BSFMBDJOFOUSFCJPUJDBZSFMJHJOFT
VOUFNBJOUSJHBOUFEJWJEJEPFONV
DIBTQSFHVOUBT6TBOEPFTUFUUVMPEFTFP
NPEFTUBNFOUF EJTDVUJS BQFOBT BMHVOPT
BTQFDUPT EPOEF MB SFMJHJO TF FOUSFMB[B
DPOMBCJPUJDBFOFTUBGBTFEFDPOTPMJ
EBDJOEFTUBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB$PO
MPTPKPTEFVOUFMPHPDSJTUJBOP NJUFO
EFODJBFTBDFOUVBSMBTDPOUSJCVDJPOFTEF
MBSFMJHJOBMBCJPUJDB QFSPVOBNJSBEB
DSUJDBOPTFPMWJEBSBEFMPTQVOUPTEPO
EFFTUOFOEFTBDVFSEPZTFJOUFSSPHBO
4JOFNCBSHP MBTHSBOEFTQSFHVOUBTQBSB
BNCBT WJFOFO EF VO NPWJNJFOUP NT
BNQMJP  EF DBSDUFS DVMUVSBM  RVF FYJHF
VOB SFEFmOJDJO EF MBT SB[POFT EF MBT
UJDBTZMPTGVOEBNFOUPTEFMBSFMJHJO
&O WJSUVE EF FTUP  QBSB MBT EPT PDVSSF
TJNVMUOFBNFOUF VO DBNCJP FO MPT FT
QBDJPTTPDJBMFTZDVMUVSBMFT
&OUJFOEPRVFVOQVOUPEFQBSUJEBTFSB
EFTDVCSJS MPT EFTBGPT DPNVOFT Z  EFT
QVT DPNQSPCBSFORVHSBEPQVFEFO
USBCBKBS KVOUBT QBSB FOGSFOUBS MPT SFUPT
EFMBWJEBBDUVBM
-BCJPUJDB DPNPUJDBFOHFOFSBM QSF
TFOUB NVDIBT DPSSJFOUFT Z UFOEFODJBT
EF VOB NBOFSB FTQFDmDB  MP NJTNP MB
EJWFSTJEBESFMJHJPTB&OFTUFFTUVEJP FT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UPZ JODMJOBEP B QSFHVOUBSNF BDFSDB EF


MB DMBTF EF CJPUJDB RVF TFB BQSPQJBEB
BMDPOUFYUPMBUJOPBNFSJDBOP:DVBOEP
IBCMP EF SFMJHJO  NF SFmFSP QBSUJDV
MBSNFOUFBMDSJTUJBOJTNP FOVOBMFDUVSB
UFPMHJDBDBUMJDB QFSPBCJFSUBBMEFTB
GPEFMBSFOPWBDJORVFFTDPNOBMBT
EJWFSTBTDPOGFTJPOFTSFMJHJPTBT5BNCJO
JOUFOUBSDPOTJEFSBSMBSJRVF[BEFUSBEJ
DJPOFTSFMJHJPTBTRVFQSFDFEFOBMDSJTUJB
OJTNPFOFMDPOUJOFOUF

i1VFOUFTBMGVUVSPwQVFOUFT
DPNVOFT
4J DPOTJEFSBNPT MBT QSFPDVQBDJPOFT EF
1PUUFS 
 SFTQFDUP EF MB TVQFSWJ
WFODJBEFMBIVNBOJEBE MBCJPUJDBFO
DVFOUSBFOMBTSFMJHJPOFTFOHFOFSBMBMHP
RVF FMMBT FTUO BDPTUVNCSBEBT B IBDFS
QFOTBS BDFSDB EF MB WJEB Z DPOTJEFSBSMB
FOSFMBDJODPOFMGVUVSP"VORVFQSPO
UPBQBSF[DBOFOPSNFTEJGFSFODJBTFOMP
RVFDPODJFSOFBMBTNBOFSBTEFPDVQBSTF
EFFTUBQSFHVOUB OPTFQVFEFOFHBSMB
JNQPSUBODJB EF FTUF IFDIP -MFHB B TFS
NT QPEFSPTP BVO DVBOEP TF QFSDJCF
RVFMBTSFMJHJPOFTQBSUJDJQBOBDUJWBNFO
UFFOMBDPOTUSVDDJODVMUVSBMDPOMBDVBM
MBHFOUFFOUJFOEFFMNVOEP MBWJEBZTV
IJTUPSJBIBDJBFMGVUVSP&TUFFTUBNCJO





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

FMDPOUFYUPFOEPOEFMBCJPUJDBJOTFSUB
TVT JOUFSSPHBOUFT .JFOUSBT MBT SFMJHJP
OFT QFSTJTUFO FO FTUB UBSFB  MB CJPUJDB
EFCJFSBDPOTJEFSBSMP
%FTEF FTUB QPTJDJO FTQFDmDB  "NSJ
DB-BUJOBSFDJCJEFTVTBCPSHFOFTVOB
IFSFODJBDVMUVSBMZSFMJHJPTBFYUSFNBEB
NFOUFSJDB&OEJDIBIFSFODJBFODPOUSB
NPTMPTWBMPSFTRVFMBCJPUJDBBDUVBMDP
NJFO[B B EFTBSSPMMBS  FTQFDJBMNFOUF FO
MBNBOFSBDPNPUSBUBNPTMBJOUFHSBDJO
EFMPTTFSFTIVNBOPTFOFMTJTUFNBNT
BNQMJP EFM NVOEP Z DPO FM BNCJFOUF
-BTDVMUVSBTNBZBTZB[UFDBT QPSFKFN
QMP EFTBSSPMMBSPOTJTUFNBTEFDPNQSFO
TJO  JODMVZFOEP QSDUJDBT DVMUVSBMFT Z
SFMJHJPTBT FOMPTDVBMFTMPTTFSFTIVNB
OPTTFJOUFHSBOZEJTGSVUBODPNPQBSUJ
DJQBOUFTEFFTUFNVOEPNTBNQMJP%F
MBNJTNBNBOFSB NVDIPTPUSPTQVFCMPT
BNFSJOEJPT TPTUJFOFO IBTUB IPZ VOB
DPNQSFOTJONTBCBSDBEPSBEFMBWJEB
4VTDPODMVTJPOFTUJDBTMMFHBSPOBTFSFm
DJFOUFTFODVJEBSZQSPUFHFSFMBNCJFOUF
Z DVMUJWBS SFMBDJPOFT TPDJBMFT GBWPSBCMFT
BMBWJEB/PTFQVFEFTFSUBOJOPDFOUF
F JHOPSBS BTJNFUSBT F JOKVTUJDJBT FO MBT
DVMUVSBT Z SFMJHJPOFT EF MPT BCPSHFOFT
QFSPTVT TJTUFNBTTPO UBNCJO QSPGVO
EBNFOUF BENJSBCMFT FO HBSBOUJ[BS MB
FRVJEBEZDVMUJWBSMBSFDJQSPDJEBEFOMBT
SFMBDJPOFT
4JOEVEB IPZIBDFNPTGSFOUFBVOBSB
EJDBMUSBOTGPSNBDJODVMUVSBM5PEBTMBT
SFGFSFODJBT TF QPOFO FO DVFTUJO Z MBT
DVMUVSBTPSJHJOBSJBT MPTTJTUFNBTSFMJHJP
TPTBCPSHFOFTFOFTQFDJBM
TPO FOHSBO
NFEJEB  TPCSFQBTBEBT QPS VOB DVMUVSB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

IFHFNOJDBNBSDBEBQPSMBDJFODJBZMB
UFDOPMPHB 1FSP QVFEF EFDJSTF RVF  FO
FMJNBHJOBSJP UPEBWBQFSNBOFDFMBTB
CJEVSBEFTVTPSHBOJ[BDJPOFT-BCJPUJ
DBBOFTNVZKPWFOQBSBIBDFSVOBMFD
UVSBRVFTFCFOFmDJFEFFTUBTBCJEVSB
4JO FNCBSHP  TVSHFO BMHVOBT TFBMFT
FOUSF PUSBT  MB DBQBDJEBE EF MB CJPUJDB
QBSBIBDFSVOBDSUJDBEFMBEFWBTUBDJO
EFM BNCJFOUF Z EF QPTUVMBSMB DPNP VO
SFRVJTJUPUJDPQBSBEFGFOEFSMP
-B DPOUSJCVDJO EFM DSJTUJBOJTNP FO
"NSJDB-BUJOBUPNBVOBGPSNBJODJFSUB 
QPSRVFTVDFEFFOVODMJNBEFDPORVJTUB
ZEFDPMPOJ[BDJOFDPONJDBZQPMUJDB
&O FTUF DPOUFYUP  BMHVOPT BOBMJTUBT OP
UFNFO DPOTJEFSBS MB BQBSJDJO DSJTUJBOB
FO FM DPOUJOFOUF DPNP iDPORVJTUB FT
QSJUVBMw 4VFTT 
-BDSUJDBBFTF
QSPDFTPGVFEJTDVUJEBFYUFOTBNFOUFDPO
PDBTJOEFMPTBPTEFMBMMFHBEBEF
$PMO B MBT "NSJDBT 
 &O FTUB
Z PUSBT DSUJDBT B MPT TJTUFNBT SFMJHJPTPT
WFNPT BMHP JHVBMNFOUF GSFDVFOUF FO
PSHBOJ[BDJPOFTIVNBOBTVOBBTJNFUSB
FOUSFMPRVFTFFOTFBZMPRVFTFQSBD
UJDB.TBEFMBOUFQPESFNPTSFWJTBSFTUF
BTQFDUP QBSB DPOTJEFSBS MB SFOPWBDJO
UFPMHJDBFOQPDBTSFDJFOUFT
4JO FNCBSHP  NT BMM EF MBT TPNCSBT 
PBOSPEFBEPQPSFMMBT FMDSJTUJBOJTNP
TFDPOWJFSUFFOVOJNQPSUBOUFBNCJFOUF
QBSBMBCJPUJDBNPEFSOBFOFMDPOUFYUP
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP1PSNFEJPEFMDSJTUJB
OJTNP TF DPOTPMJEB MB UJDB EF MB WJEB 
JOTQJSBEBQPSVOIPSJ[POUFNTBMMEF
MBNVFSUF-PTNBOEBNJFOUPTEFMBNPS
Z FM SFTQFDUP B MB WJEB QFSTJTUFO DPNP





#JPUJDBZSFMJHJOFO"NSJDB-BUJOB.SDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT

SFGFSFODJBT QBSB MBT SFMBDJPOFT Z  TPCSF


UPEP  MB JNBHFO TVGSJEPSB EFM TBMWBEPS
DSJTUJBOPTFSFQJUFFOFMTVGSJNJFOUPEF
MBHFOUFDPMPOJ[BEB"VORVFMBTPMVDJP
OFTSFMBDJPOBMFTQBSBFMTVGSJSUFOHBOVO
DBSDUFS BTJTUFODJBM  QSPEVDFO VOB TFO
TBDJOEFTPMJEBSJEBEZDPNQBTJO)PZ
TFSBEJGDJMFOUFOEFSQSPGVOEBNFOUFFM
BMDBODFEFMPTDPODFQUPTEFiEJHOJEBEw
Z iTPMJEBSJEBEw FO "NSJDB -BUJOB TJO
FDIBSNBOPEFMPTDPODFQUPTSFMJHJPTPT
RVFTPOQBSUFEFFTBDPOTUSVDDJO
%FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB UFSJDB  FM DSJT
UJBOJTNP EF JOTQJSBDJO DBUMJDB BQPS
UB MPT NBOVBMFT EF UFPMPHB NPSBM RVF
DPOUJFOFOOFDFTBSJBNFOUFMBQSPUFDDJO
EFMBWJEB"VORVFHFOFSBMNFOUFSFQSP
EV[DBOMPTNBOVBMFTFVSPQFPTZTFSFT
USJOKBOCTJDBNFOUFBMDMFSP IBDFOOF
DFTBSJB TJOFNCBSHP VOBSFnFYJOUJDB
BDFSDB EF MBT DVFTUJPOFT SFMBDJPOBEBT
DPOMBWJEB"T MBMMFHBEBEFMBCJPUJDB
NPEFSOBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBFODPOUSBS 
QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF FOUSF FM DMFSP  VOB SF
nFYJOUJDBTPCSFMBWJEBUFSJDBNFOUF
BMJNFOUBEBZGPSNVMBEB BVORVFEFOUSP
EFTVTMNJUFTFTQFDmDPT
&TBNJTNBUSBEJDJOSFnFYJWBIBQFSNJ
UJEPMBFYQMPSBDJO RVFPDVSSFUBNCJO
BDUVBMNFOUF  EF BMHVOPT EJMPHPT EFM
1BQB1P9* 
DPOMPTEPD
UPSFTZMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBTBMVEEFTV
UJFNQP QBSUJDVMBSNFOUFBDFSDBEFUFNBT
DPNPMBFVUBOBTJBZFMNPSJS1FSNJUF 
JHVBMNFOUF  FOUFOEFS mHVSBT DPNP MB
EFM UFMPHP BMFNO #FSOIBSE )SJOH 
RVFTFDPOWJFSUFFOVOBSFGFSFODJBQBSB
FMEJMPHPUFPMHJDPDPOMPTQSPHSFTPTEF
MBNFEJDJOBFOMPTBPTZ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

4JOQSFQPOFSNFIBDFSVOBTOUFTJTIJT
USJDB DPOFTUPTQPDPTCPTRVFKPTEFTFP
TPMBNFOUF SFDPSEBS DNP MB SFMJHJO
oEFOUSPEFMPTQSPDFTPTDVMUVSBMFT QP
MUJDPT Z FDPONJDPTo DPOUSJCVZF B MB
GPSNBDJO EF VO FUIPT QBSB MB CJPUJDB
NPEFSOB FO "NSJDB -BUJOB &O HSBO
NFEJEB  MPT iQVFOUFT QBSB FM GVUVSPw
RVFFTBCJPUJDBJOUFOUBDPOTUSVJSUJFOFO
WBSJPTBTQFDUPTDPNVOFTDPOMBSFMJHJO
RVFEFCFOTFSDPOTJEFSBEPT

{&YJTUFVODPOnJDUPFOUSFMB
SB[OZMBSFMJHJOFOMBCJPUJDB
-PT BSHVNFOUPT UFSJDPT EF MB CJPUJDB
DVFTUJPOBO TVT SFMBDJPOFT DPO MB SFMJ
HJONJFOUSBTMBSFMJHJOTJHVFMBGF MB
CJPUJDB TJHVF MB SB[O 1PS MP NFOPT 
FTBEJWFSHFODJBFOTVTSBDFTMMFWBSBBMB
CJPUJDBBEJTUJOHVJSSBEJDBMNFOUFFOUSF
VOB CJPUJDB MBJDB Z PUSB SFMJHJPTB UFO
ESBO TJNJMJUVEFT P EJWFSHFODJBT FO MP
RVF DPODJFSOF B TV TJTUFNB EF SFHMBT 
QFSP  FO TVT CBTFT  TFSBO TJFNQSF iFY
USBPT NPSBMFTw &TB DVFTUJO QBSFDF
DSVDJBM QBSB TV SFMBDJO NVUVB &GFD
UJWBNFOUF  MB DVFTUJO TF EFTEPCMB FO
EPTQSFTVQVFTUPTMBGFFTEJTUBOUFEFMB
SB[OZMBSB[OFTUTFQBSBEBEFNPUJ
WBDJPOFTFTQSJUVBMFTPEFMBGF1FSP {FO
RVHSBEPPNFEJEBTPOWFSEBEFTFTUPT
TVQVFTUPT 
&TDJFSUPRVFFMDSJTUJBOJTNP BMSFWFMBS
TVFYQFSJFODJBEFMBGF UJFOFVOBMBSHB
IJTUPSJB EF EJWFSTPT MVHBSFT DPNP QBSB
NPTUSBS MB SB[O FO MBT DSFFODJBT Z MBT
DSFFODJBTFOMBSB[O&OTVJOJDJP EFCJ
EPBMDPOUFYUPDVMUVSBMEPOEFOBDJ FM
DSJTUJBOJTNPGVFNBSDBEPQPSVOOGBTJT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

FOFMTFHVJNJFOUPEFM.BFTUSP UBOUPFO
TVTQSDUJDBTEFWJEBDPNPFOMPTIPSJ
[POUFTEFTJHOJmDBEP1FSP NVZQSPOUP 
UPNBDPOUBDUPDPOFMQFOTBNJFOUPmMP
TmDPHSJFHP MPRVFMBPCMJHBBDMBSJmDBS
MBT SB[POFT EF MB GF QBSB UPNBS OVFWBT
SVUBT "VORVF BMHVOPT BVUPSFT  &OHFM
IBSEU 
FOQBSUJDVMBS BSHVNFOUBO
DPOUSB FTUF BDFSDBNJFOUP  FM DSJTUJBOJT
NP  QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF FO 0DDJEFOUF 
DPNJFO[B B GPSNVMBS EBUPT EF MB GF FO
VOBJOUFSBDDJOOUJNBDPOMBmMPTPGB
&OUSF UBOUPT QFOTBEPSFT JNQPSUBOUFT 
TF EFTUBDBO 4BO "HVTUO 
 Z
4BOUP5PNTEF"RVJOP 

"HVTUO  SFGPSNBOEP MB IFSFODJB EFM
QFOTBNJFOUPHSJFHP DPOUSJCVZEFDJEJ
EBNFOUFBMBiTOUFTJTEFVOBNFUBGTJDB
EF MB OBUVSBMF[B DPO VOB NFUBGTJDB EF
MB MJCFSUBE  QVFTUP RVF MB MJCFSUBE  QPS
NFEJP EFM DSJTUJBOJTNP  SFDPOWJFSUF MB
NBUFSJBNJTNBEFMBmMPTPGBw 0MJWFJSB 

"RVJOPTFEFTUBDBEFCJEPBMB
TOUFTJTEFTVFMBCPSBDJOUFPMHJDB RVF
CVTDBVOBDPNQSFOTJOEFMBUPUBMJEBE
EFMPTTFSFT EFMNVOEPZEFTVSFMBDJO
DPOFMUSBTDFOEFOUF5PNTFTUBCMFDFVO
EJMPHPQSPGVOEPDPOMPTQFOTBEPSFTFO
HFOFSBMZ QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF DPOFMQFO
TBNJFOUP BHVTUJOP Z MB mMPTPGB BSJTUP
UMJDB 0MJWFJSB 
$POP
DJEP QPS TVT GSBTFT CJFO FMBCPSBEBT  ZB
FO FM TJHMP 7 "HVTUO BmSNBCB i-FKPT
EFOPTPUSPTQFOTBSRVFMBGFOPTJNQF
MFBSFDIB[BSPQBSBSEFCVTDBSMBSB[O 
QPSRVF OP QPESBNPT OJ TJRVJFSB DSFFS
TJOTFSSBDJPOBMFTw&OOVFTUSPUJFNQP 
FM1BQB#FOFEJDUP97* 
FOVO
EJTDVSTPBMBDPNVOJEBEDJFOUmDBEFMB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

6OJWFSTJEBEEF3FHFOTCVSH "MFNBOJB 
EFDMBSBCBiOPBDUVBSTFHOMBSB[O OP
BDUVBS TFHO FM MPHPT  FT DPOUSBSJP B MB
OBUVSBMF[BEF%JPTw
-B IJTUPSJB NVFTUSB MBT UFOTJPOFT RVF
TJHVFO B MBT NBOFSBT DPODSFUBT EF MMF
WBS FTB JOUFSBDDJO &MMBT IBO PDVSSJEP
ZIBDFOEJGDJMUPEBWBFOOVFTUSPTEBT
FMEJMPHPEFMBGFDSJTUJBOBDPOFMQFO
TBNJFOUPNPEFSOP1FSPFMDSJTUJBOJTNP
OPTFSFTUSJOHFBMPTHSVQPTRVFSFDIB[BO
MBSBDJPOBMJEBE QPSRVFTFEFTBSSPMMBQFS
DFQUJCMFNFOUFFOPUSPTFOUJEP%FVOB
NBOFSBBONTBNQMJB MBJOUFSBDDJO
FOUSF GF Z SB[O TF UPNB FO OVFTUSPT
EBTDPNPVOBJOUFSSPHBDJOOPTMPB
MBT SFMJHJPOFT  TJOP UBNCJO B MB SB[O
NPEFSOB  DPNP EFNVFTUSB CJFO  FOUSF
PUSPT BVUPSFT  . 0MJWFJSB 
 /P
EJTDVUJSFNPTBRVMBTEFOTBTDVFTUJPOFT
RVFFMUFNBJNQMJDB QFSPEFTFPTVHFSJS
RVF MB GF Z MB SB[O OP TPO OFDFTBSJB
NFOUF iFYUSBPT NPSBMFTw  FYDFQUP FO
MBTDPZVOUVSBTRVFJNQFMFOTVTSFTQFDUJ
WPTEJTDVSTPTFOTFOUJEPTEJTUJOUPT
&MDSJTUJBOJTNPFO"NSJDB-BUJOBQBS
UJDJQBEFFTBBNQMJBFGFSWFTDFODJBEFMB
GFRVFCVTDBSB[POFT-BUFPMPHBEFMB
MJCFSBDJOoGPSNVMBEBBQBSUJSEFo
FT VOB FYQSFTJO DMBSB EF FTF EJMPHP 
DPNP WFSFNPT NT BEFMBOUF 4VT PQJ
OJPOFTZQSPQVFTUBTQBSFDFODPOUSJCVJS
QFSDFQUJCMFNFOUF FO BMHVOBT SVUBT RVF
MBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBTJHVF FTQF
DJBMNFOUFFOTVSFDFQUJWJEBEBUFNBTTP
DJBMFTZBMBTDVFTUJPOFTQFSTJTUFOUFTRVF
MBEFTBGBO





#JPUJDBZSFMJHJOFO"NSJDB-BUJOB.SDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT

3FMJHJOZCJPUJDBFOVO
DPOUFYUPEFJOKVTUJDJBT
QFSTJTUFOUFT
3FMJHJOZCJPUJDBOPTFQVFEFOFOUFO
EFS FO FM DPOUFYUP MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP TJO
DPOTJEFSBSVOBIJTUPSJBNBSDBEBQPSJO
KVTUJDJBTTPDJBMFTQSPGVOEBT.FODJPOB
NPTZBMBFYQFSJFODJBEFMDPMPOJBMJTNP
&TDJFSUPRVFOPTFQVFEFSFEVDJSTMPB
TVTBTQFDUPTOFHBUJWPT QFSPFTEJGDJMPM
WJEBSMBTNBSDBTEFMBTBTJNFUSBTTPDJBMFT
QSPGVOEBTRVFTFEFSJWBOEFTUF&MWFS
EBEFSPHFOPDJEJPBMDVBMTFIBTPNFUJEP
B MBT HFOUFT BCPSHFOFT  MB FYQMPUBDJO
EFMUSBCBKPFTDMBWJ[BEP MBWPSBDJEBEDPO
MB DVBM FM DPMPOJBMJTNP MMFHB BM DPOUJ
OFOUFQBSBFYQMPUBSTVBCVOEBODJB TPO
BMHVOPTQVOUPTTBMJFOUFTRVFNBSDBOMB
IJTUPSJBZDSFBOVOBQFTBEBIFSFODJBDVM
UVSBMRVFBMDBO[BOVFTUSPUJFNQP 4VFTT 
$IBTUFFO 

"T  FM DPOUFYUP MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP  EF
UBOUBDPSEJBMJEBE BMFHSBZDFMFCSBDJO 
QSFTFOUB  BM NJTNP UJFNQP  VOB JMJNJ
UBEB DPSSVQDJO F JOKVTUJDJBT TPDJBMFT
RVF BGFDUBO EJSFDUBNFOUF MBT DPOEJDJP
OFTEFWJEBEFMBHFOUFZTVTBMVE IB
CJUBDJO  FEVDBDJO  USBCBKP  TBMBSJPT Z
FTQFSBO[B EF WJEB &T TJOUPNUJDP RVF
QPSMPNFOPTMBNJUBEEFMBTQPCMBDJP
OFT QPS EFCBKP EF MB MOFB EF QPCSF[B
FO "NSJDB -BUJOB TFBO BCPSHFOFT P
BGSPEFTDFOEJFOUFT &M #BODP *OUFSBNF
SJDBOP EF %FTBSSPMMP #*%
 

DPODMVZFRVFiMBQPCSF[BEFMPTHSVQPT
TPDJBMFT FYDMVJEPT FT QFSNBOFOUF Z OP
USBOTJUPSJBw"NSJDB-BUJOBOPFTDJFS
UBNFOUF VO DPOUJOFOUF QPCSF  TJOP VO
DPOUJOFOUFEFJOKVTUJDJBTQSPGVOEBT-BT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

BTJNFUSBTQVFEFOUBNCJOSFnFKBSTFFO
MBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT VOBMBSHB
IJTUPSJB EF EFQFOEFODJB  EFVEBT JOUFS
OBDJPOBMFTZQSPNFTBTOVODBSFBMJ[BEBT
EFFTUBSiFOEFTBSSPMMPw-BBDUVBMJEBE 
QPDB EF OGBTJT FO MB BVUPOPNB  BM
BGFDUBS B TPDJFEBEFT EFCJMJUBEBT FO US
NJOPTEFDJVEBEBOBFT BMmOBM OFPMJ
CFSBMJTNP RVF TF PMWJEB UPUBMNFOUF EF
MBT QFSTPOBT Z MFHJUJNB JOKVTUJDJBT -B
WJPMFODJBBVNFOUBZIBZVOBSFEVDDJO
EFMBDPOmBO[BFOUSFMBHFOUFZFOUSFMBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFT&TJNQPSUBOUFOPPMWJEBS
TFEFFTBSFBMJEBE BVORVFBRVOPFTMV
HBSQBSBIBDFSMBNTFYQMDJUB
{$NPMBUFPMPHBEFMBMJCFSBDJOZMB
CJPUJDBBDUBOEFTEFGVFSBZEFTEFEFO
USPEFFTBSFBMJEBE -BQSJNFSBBDFOUB 
EFOUSP EF MB FYQFSJFODJB SFMJHJPTB  MB
QSFHVOUBTPCSFMBDPIFSFODJBFOUSFMBGF
QSPGFTBEB Z MBT QSDUJDBT EF MB WJEB TP
DJBM:IBCMBFOUPODFTDPOJOEJHOBDJO
EFVOBSFBMJEBEGPSNBEBQPSJOKVTUJDJBT
TPDJBMFTF JODMVTP SFMJHJPTBT4VBDDJO
TF FOUJFOEF EFOUSP EF VO QSPDFTP NT
BNQMJPZNVOEJBMFOMPRVFDPODJFSOFB
NBOFSBTEFDPOPDFSMBSFBMJEBE/PQSF
HVOUBNPTTJMBUFPMPHBDSJTUJBOBJOUFSBD
UBDPOMBTDJFODJBTZ QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF 
DPOMBmMPTPGBTJOPDVMFTTPOMBTmMP
TPGBT Z DJFODJBT DPO MBT RVF EJBMPHB Z
B QBSUJS EF MBT DVBMFT DPOTUSVZF FM GVO
EBNFOUP SBDJPOBM EF MB GF -B UFPMPHB
QFSDJCFRVFOPTFQVFEFEFTFONBTDBSBS
MBSFEEFMBIJTUPSJBIVNBOBZEFMBTJO
KVTUJDJBT TPDJBMFT TPMBNFOUF DPO mMPTP
GBTFTFODJBMJTUBT&OUPODFT TFBQSPYJNB
BMBTmMPTPGBTDBQBDFTEFEFTFONBTDBSBS
NT HJMNFOUF MBT FTUSVDUVSBT JOKVTUBT 





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

OP QFSDJCJEBT QPS PUSPT BDFSDBNJFOUPT


UBNCJO  DBQBDFT EF DPOUSJCVJS FO VOB
QPDB NBSDBEB QPS UFOEFODJBT JOEJWJ
EVBMJTUBTZEFQFSDJCJSMPTWODVMPTJOOF
HBCMFTFOUSFMBJOUFSTVCKFUJWJEBEIVNB
OBZTVTDPNQSPNJTPTTPDJBMFT
/PFTEJGDJMQFSDJCJSRVFFTFQBTPUFP
MHJDPUBNCJOTFSFMBDJPOBGVFSUFNFOUF
DPOMBDPOTUSVDDJOEFMPTGVOEBNFOUPT
EFMBCJPUJDB RVFTFUSBEVDFFODVFTUJP
OBSMPTDPODFQUPTDPOMPTRVFTFBDFSDB
BMBSFBMJEBE$VBOEPFMQSJODJQJBMJTNP
OPSUFBNFSJDBOP DPNFO[ B TFS DSJUJDB
EP NFQJEJFSPORVFQSFTFOUBTFFTBPQJ
OJO MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z UFPMHJDB QBSB
FOSJRVFDFS MPT GVOEBNFOUPT EF MB CJP
UJDB "OKPT 
1FSPUBMFT
DPOUSJCVDJPOFT UBNCJO FNFSHFO FO MB
NFUPEPMPHBQBSBBDFSDBSTFBUFNBTFT
QFDmDPT  DPNP TVDFEF FO MBT MFDUVSBT
RVF1FTTJOJIBDFBDFSDBEFMBEJTUBOBTJB

ZMBFVUBOBTJB 

&OFTFTFOUJEP MBUFPMPHBMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOB QPSMPNFOPTDPNPFMFNFOUPEF
DPOTPMJEBDJO IBDPOUSJCVJEPBMBGPS
NBDJO EF MB CJPUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
)BBZVEBEPDJFSUBNFOUFBHBSBOUJ[BSMB
TVmDJFOUFJOEJHOBDJOUJDBGSFOUFBJO
KVTUJDJBT DPOFMDPSPMBSJPEFCVTDBSNF
EJPT BEFDVBEPT QBSB EFTFONBTDBSBS MBT
HSBOEFTJOFRVJEBEFTBSSBJHBEBTQSPGVO
EBNFOUF FO MB TPDJFEBE &M QBUSPDJOJP
EFM 7* $POHSFTP .VOEJBM EF #JPUJDB
FO#SBTJM FO DPOFMUFNBi#JPUJ
DBQPEFSFJOKVTUJDJBw (BSSBGBZ1FTTJ
OJ 
DBSBDUFSJ[BCJFOFTUFQFSmM OP
TMPEFCJEPBMBPQDJOQPSFTUFUFNB 
TJOPUBNCJOBMUPOPBHVEPEFMBTDPO
GFSFODJBTQSPOVODJBEBTBMM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

.TBMMEFMEPHNBUJTNP
"VORVFOPQSFUFOEPQSFTFOUBSVOBTO
UFTJT EF MB UFPMPHB EF MB MJCFSBDJO  FT
CFOFmDJPTPPCTFSWBSRVFFMEJMPHPDJFO
UmDPIBEBEPBMBUFPMPHBDPOEJDJPOFT
QBSB SFMFFS TVT QSPQJPT QVOUPT EF SFGF
SFODJBZGVOEBNFOUPT&OFTUVEJPTEFMB
#JCMJB QPSFKFNQMP MBUFPMPHBUPNBMB
IJTUPSJBEFMBDPOTUSVDDJOEFMPTUFYUPT
DPNPQBTPCTJDPFJNQSFTDJOEJCMFQBSB
FOUFOEFS FM DPOUFOJEP EF TV NFOTBKF
-PTDPOUFYUPTTPDJPDVMUVSBMFTTPOEFDJTJ
WPTQBSBFWBMVBSFMBMDBODFEFMPTUSNJ
OPTZEFMBTEFDMBSBDJPOFT&OSFTVNFO 
FMUFYUP FMDPOUFYUPZFMNFOTBKFTFQSFTFO
UBODPNPUSFTBTQFDUPTJOTFQBSBCMFTQBSB
MB FYQMPSBDJO UFPMHJDB EF SFGFSFODJBT
CCMJDBT&TPTJHOJmDBRVFFMEFTDPOPDJ
NJFOUP EF MPT DPOUFYUPT TPDJPDVMUVSBMFT
MBTUSBEJDJPOFTWFSCBMFT
QSFTFOUFTFOMB
FMBCPSBDJOEFMPTUFYUPTDPOEVDFBGVO
EBNFOUBMJTNPTSFMJHJPTPT1PSPUSBQBSUF 
BMBOBMJ[BSMPTDPOUFYUPT QBSUJDVMBSNFO
UFMPTBSSBJHBEPTNTQSPGVOEBNFOUFFO
TJTUFNBTZFTUSVDUVSBTTPDJPDVMUVSBMFT FM
BMDBODFQBSBMBWJEBEFMBTQSPQVFTUBTEF
MBGFMMFHBBTFSNTDMBSP
&TF QSPDFTP FTU QSFTFOUF UBNCJO FO
MB DPNQSFOTJO EF MPT NJTNPT EPHNBT
EFMBGFTUPTDFTBOEFTFSFYQSFTJPOFT
EFM GVOEBNFOUBMJTNP DVBOEP VOP FTU
FOUFSBEP EFM DPOUFYUP TPDJPDVMUVSBM EF
TV GPSNVMBDJO  QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF DVBO
EP TF DPOTJEFSBO MBT QSFHVOUBT FTQFD
mDBT RVF TF QSPQVTJFSPO DPOUFTUBS 4F
SFDPOPDFIPZ JODMVTPPmDJBMNFOUF RVF
FYJTUF VOB FWPMVDJO FO MPT EPHNBT Z 
UBNCJO  MPT MNJUFT Z FM DBSDUFS QSP
HSFTJWPEFMDPOPDJNJFOUPIVNBOPZEF





#JPUJDBZSFMJHJOFO"NSJDB-BUJOB.SDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT

TVTPQJOJPOFT&TUPTCSFWFTDPNFOUBSJPT
QFSNJUFO RVF DPOTJEFSFNPT DNP MB
UFPMPHB  FO DVBOUP NPNFOUP SBDJPOBM
EFMBGF QFSNJUFVOBDFSDBNJFOUPDFSDB
OPBMBTDJFODJBTQBSBFOUFOEFSMPTEJWFS
TPTQSPDFTPTEFMBWJEB&OTVNUPEP 
MBUFPMPHBEFMBMJCFSBDJOIBDPOTBHSB
EPDPNPJOEJTQFOTBCMFFMNPNFOUPEF
iBOMJTJTEFMBSFBMJEBEwTUFFNQMFBMBT
NFEJBDJPOFTTPDJPBOBMUJDBT FTEFDJS MBT
DJFODJBTDPOMBTDVBMFTTFQVFEFFOUFOEFS
BEFDVBEBNFOUF MB SFBMJEBE Z  EFTQVT 
IBDFSVOBMFDUVSBSFMJHJPTBDSUJDBZVOB
QSPQVFTUB
4JDSJUJDBNPTEPHNBUJTNPTFOMBSFMJHJO
ZMBUFPMPHB QPEFNPTUBNCJOQSFHVO
UBS TJ IBZ EPHNBUJTNPT FO MB CJPUJDB
1BSFDFWFOUBKPTPDPOTJEFSBSFTBQSFHVO
UB QPSMPNFOPTDPNPSFDVSTPNBZVUJ
DPQBSBBMHVOBTDJSDVOTUBODJBT

#JPUJDBZUFPMPHBFOMBDVFTUJO
EFMBUSBTDFOEFODJB
-B DVFTUJO EF MB USBTDFOEFODJB FT VO
QVOUPEPOEFMBCJPUJDBZMBUFPMPHBTF
FODVFOUSBOFOFMDPOUFYUPMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOP 1PEFNPT UPNBS BRV FM DPODFQ
UP EF iUSBTDFOEFODJBw FO TFOUJEP NVZ
BNQMJPoBCBSDBOEPUPEPMPRVFWBNT
BMMEFMTFSoZMMFHBNPTBMBDVFTUJOEF
DNPMPTTFSFTIVNBOPTTPCSFWJWFOZTF
BVUPSSFBMJ[BO"VORVFOPWBNPTBFYB
NJOBS QSPGVOEBNFOUF MBT NVDIBT UFP
SBT RVF  EFTEF MB BOUJHFEBE  CVTDBO
VOB SFTQVFTUB QBSB FTP  FT JNQPSUBOUF
TFBMBS MBT QPTJCJMJEBEFT EF FOSJRVFDJ
NJFOUPNVUVPFOUSFMBUFPMPHBZFMEJT
DVSTPEFMBCJPUJDBFOMPRVFDPODJFSOF
BFTUFQVOUP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&TCJFOTBCJEPRVFFMDSJTUJBOJTNPUPNB
QPS DJFSUP RVF MB WJEB TMP TF BDUVBMJ[B
SFBMJ[B
 DPNQMFUBNFOUF NT BMM EF MB
IJTUPSJB FOVOFODVFOUSPEFmOJUJWPDPO
FMBCTPMVUP1BSBMPTRVFOPUFOHBOUBM
DFSUF[B P GF  FTF OGBTJT FO MB BDUVBMJ
[BDJO EF MB WJEB NT BMM EF MB NVFS
UF IBDF FM EJMPHP EJGDJM  TJO OJOHVOB
EVEB -B UFPMPHB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB EB
VO QBTP JNQPSUBOUF EF QSPNPDJO EFM
EJMPHP QSFDJTBNFOUF QPSRVF SFTDBUB FM
OGBTJTFOSFBMJ[BDJPOFTIVNBOBTEFOUSP
EFMBQSPQJBIJTUPSJB FOMPTQSPDFTPTEF
WJEBJOEJWJEVBMZTPDJBM*ODMVTP TJOQFS
EFSEFWJTUBFMIPSJ[POUFEFMBWJEBEFT
QVT EF MB NVFSUF  PUPSHB B MB SFMJHJO
VOBWJHPSPTBGVFS[BJOUSBIJTUSJDBUSBOT
GPSNBEPSB  RVF FT KVTUBNFOUF MB SB[O
EF TFS EF VOB UFPMPHB EF MB MJCFSBDJO 
ZFTFFTVOFTQBDJPQSPEVDUJWPQBSBRVF
TFBDFSRVFMBCJPUJDB7FBNPTBMHVOPT
QVOUPT TJHOJmDBUJWPT EF BQSPYJNBDJO
FOFTUFTFOUJEP
-BUFPMPHBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBCVTDBJEFO
UJmDBS KVOUPDPOMBTDJFODJBT FMEFTBGP
EF MB TVQFSWJWFODJB EF MPT TFSFT IVNB
OPT OPTMPFOTVDPOEJDJOEFmOJUVE
TJOP UBNCJO FO MBT TJUVBDJPOFT GBWPSB
CMFTPBEWFSTBTFOTVTSFMBDJPOFTTPDJBMFT
ZBNCJFOUBMFT*OUFSQSFUBFTBDPOEJDJO
IVNBOBDPNPFMHSBOFTQBDJPEFMBHFT
UBDJOEFMBWJEBNJTNB EFMBBVUPQPJFTJT 
FOFMDVBMMPTTFSFTIVNBOPTTPODSJBUV
SBTZDSFBEPSFTBMNJTNPUJFNQP&OFTUF
TFOUJEP MBFYQSFTJOiIBDFSFMQBQFMEF
%JPTwOPTFEFCFFOUFOEFSDPNPVTVS
QBDJOEFMBFOFSHBEJWJOBQPSFMDPO
USBSJP MBQPUFODJBMJEBEDSFBUJWBFT DJFS
UBNFOUF VOBQSFSSPHBUJWBIVNBOB VOB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

RVFMBQSPQJBUFPMPHBDPOTJEFSBVOBE
EJWBBMPTTFSFTIVNBOPT%FFTUPTFEF
EVDFOPVOBQSPIJCJDJOTJOPVOEFTBGP
BBDUVBSSFTQPOTBCMFNFOUF{RVWBNPT
BIBDFSDPOVOQPEFSUBOHSBOEF +VOUP
DPOMBTDJFODJBT MBUFPMPHBFYBNJOBMBT
EJWFSTBT UFOUBUJWBT IVNBOBT EF PDVQBS
TFEFFTFQPEFSBUSBWTEFMBIJTUPSJB:
SFQBSB FO HSBOEFT DPODFOUSBDJPOFT EF
QPEFS EFPQSFTJOZEFGPSNBTEFTUSVD
UJWBT EF WJPMFODJB &O MUJNP BOMJTJT 
TPONBOFSBTEFCVTDBSMBBVUPBmSNBDJO
QBSBHBSBOUJ[BSFTBBVUPQPJFTJT GPSNBTEF
BDUVBMJ[BDJOZTVQFSWJWFODJB
-B DPOUSJCVDJO FTQFDmDB EF MB UFPMP
HB DSJTUJBOB FT BRV NVZ TPSQSFOEFOUF
"OKPT  
 QPSRVF JOWJUB
BRVFFOUFOEBNPTFMFKFSDJDJPEFMQPEFS
FOVOTFOUJEPFNJOFOUFNFOUFDPNVOJ
DBUJWPZOPDPODFOUSBEPS7BDPOUSBMB
DPODFOUSBDJO EFM QPEFS Z MB PQSFTJO
"RVMBWVMOFSBCJMJEBEOPFTVODBNQP
RVF EFCBNPT FYQMPUBS  TJOP VO EFTBGP
BM FTQSJUV DSFBUJWP Z QPUFODJBEPS -P
PUSP RVF FODPOUSBNPT FO MBT SFMBDJPOFT
OPEFCFTFSUPNBEPDPNPDPNQFUJEPS 
QFSPTCVTDBEPDPNPDPNQBFSP QVFT
TVT DBSFODJBT Z TVGSJNJFOUPT TPO VOB
QSPUFTUB QSPWPDBUJWB -B TVQFSWJWFODJB 
QPS MP UBOUP  OP TJHOJmDB FYQMPUBS P
FYDMVJSFMPUSP TJOPTVJODMVTJOSFTQF
UVPTBZTPMJEBSJB GVOEBEBFOSFMBDJPOFT
NVUVBTZEJSJHJEBQPSFMBNPS"RVFTU
VODPODFQUPDMBWFRVFSFTVNFFMTJTUF
NB EF TVT QSPQPTJDJPOFT +PO 4PCSJOP

 BM DPOTJEFSBS PQSFTJPOFT Z TV
GSJNJFOUPT MPEFDMBSBDPNPFMQSJODJQJP
EFMBNJTFSJDPSEJB0CWJBNFOUF TFUSBUB
EFVOQSJODJQJPRVFFTUBCMFDFVOBEJSFD

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DJOQBSBUPEBTMBTBDUJUVEFTZPQDJPOFT
RVFQSFTJEFOMBBDDJO
&TOFDFTBSJPFOGBUJ[BSRVFFTBQFSTQFDUJ
WBUFPMHJDBJNQMJDBMBJNBHFORVFUFOF
NPTEF%JPT&MBCTPMVUPOPFTJNQPTJ
UJWP TJOPDPNVOJDBUJWP/PHPCJFSOBMB
IJTUPSJB IVNBOB EFTEF GVFSB  TJOP RVF
MB JODPSQPSB QBSB NBOJGFTUBSTF EFOUSP
EFFMMBDPOTVTTJHOPT4FQPTUVMBDPNP
FTQSJUVRVFEJSJHFZEFTQJFSUBQPUFODJB
MJEBEFTIVNBOBTZMJCFSUBEFTGSHJMFTFO
MBDPOTUSVDDJOEFNPEPTEFWJEB
&OFTUFTFOUJEP TFEFCFIBDFSVOBDSUJ
DBBMBUSBOTGPSNBDJOEFMBmHVSBEF+F
TT$SJTUPFOMFHJTMBEPSZDPORVJTUBEPS
P NVDIBTWFDFTUBNCJO FOFMFYQJBEPS
EFMBTEFTPCFEJFODJBTEFMBIVNBOJEBE
GSFOUFBVO%JPTFOPKBEP&ODPOUSBQP
TJDJO FTU  FO QSJNFS MVHBS  MB JNBHFO
EF VO NBFTUSP RVF FOTFB  QPS NFEJP
EFTVTQSDUJDBTZUFPSBT MBTNBOFSBTFO
RVFFMFTQSJUVQSPQPOFBMBIVNBOJEBE
MBDPOTUSVDDJOEFMBWJEB
1BSB VOB QFSTQFDUJWB CJPUJDB  QPS MP
UBOUP FTWBMJPTPDPNFOUBSRVFFMUFNB
EF MB USBTDFOEFODJB OP IBDF OFDFTBSJB
NFOUFEFMBSFMJHJOFNQSFTBQBSBFMNT
BMM EJTUBOUFZFYUSBBBMBIJTUPSJDJEBE
4V DPNQSPNJTP DPO MB IJTUPSJB  JHVBM
RVFDPOMBWJEBEFDBEBEB QFSNJUFRVF
JEFOUJmRVFNPT CJPUJDB Z SFMJHJO FO
VOB CVFOB DPOnVFODJB EF PQJOJPOFT Z
EFQSPQVFTUBT1PSPUSBQBSUF MBSFMJHJO
JOUFSSPHB B MB QSPQJB CJPUJDB TPCSF TV
NBOFSBEFUSBUBSMBUSBTDFOEFODJB TPCSF
FMFTQSJUVRVFQSFTJEFTVTDSJUFSJPTQBSB
FWBMVBSZQSPQPOFSFMFKFSDJDJPEFMBBV
UPOPNBZMBMJCFSUBE





#JPUJDBZSFMJHJOFO"NSJDB-BUJOB.SDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT

{)BCSVOBSFMJHJOJNQMDJUBFO
MBCJPUJDB
"M QSPQPOFS FTUB QSFHVOUB FTUBNPT UP
NBOEPMBSFMJHJOFOVOTFOUJEPBNQMJP 
RVFQSFDFEFBDBEBJOTUJUVDJOSFMJHJPTB
FTQFDmDB $POTJEFSBOEP RVF MB DPO
EJDJO IVNBOB TF TJUB FO FM UJFNQP 
SPEFBEB EF DBSFODJBT EF UPEBT DMBTFT Z
EJSJHJEBIBDJBFMEFTFPEFBDUVBMJ[BDJO 
VOPQVFEFBENJUJSMBOFDFTJEBERVFUJF
OFOMPTTFSFTIVNBOPTEFJSNTBMMEF
TNJTNPTP QPSMPNFOPT NTBMMEF
MBTJUVBDJOFOMBDVBMFTUO)BZFOFTP
VOBDMBTFEFUSBTDFOEFODJB-B#JCMJBIB
CMBEFVOBTFEEF%JPT-BBOBMPHBEF
MB TFE FT EPCMFNFOUF JOUFSFTBOUF  QPS
RVFSFDVFSEB QSJNFSP MBOFDFTJEBERVF
UFOFNPTEFTBMJSEFOPTPUSPTNJTNPTZ
CVTDBSMBBMJNFOUBDJO Z MVFHP QPSRVF
QPTUVMBMBDVFTUJOEFRVPRVJOQVFEF
SFBMNFOUFTBUJTGBDFSOPTZBDUVBMJ[BSOPT
&TF QSPDFTP JODMVZF EJNFOTJPOFT EF
DJFODJB Z EF VO UJQP EF GF 1PSRVF FM
DPOPDJNJFOUPIVNBOPFTMJNJUBEPZFM
EFTBGPEFWJWJSOPTFYJHFJSNTBMMEF
FTUF DPOPDJNJFOUP Z FOUSBS FO FM FTQB
DJP EF MB BEIFTJO DPOmEFOUF  EPOEF
MBT FWJEFODJBT DJFOUmDBT TPO QSFDBSJBT
%FFTUPTFEFEVDFVOTJTUFNBFOFMDVBM
DSFFNPT  JOEJWJEVBMNFOUF P DPMFDUJWB
NFOUF &O FTUB DPOEJDJO  RVF JOUFHSF
DJFODJB Z GF  DPOTUSVJNPT QSPZFDUPT EF
WJEB OPTPDVQBNPTEFOVFTUSPTEFTFPT 
UPNBNPT PQDJPOFT Z OPT QSPQPOFNPT
PCKFUJWPT1BVM5JMMJDIUJFOFSB[ODVBO
EPEJDF 
RVFMBiSFMJHJOFTUB
JODPOEJDJPOBMNFOUFVOJEBBMTFOUJEPEF
MBWJEBEFMJOEJWJEVPwZ BMNJTNPUJFN

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

QP MBDPOEVDFBUFOFSFYQSFTJOFOVO
iHSVQP TPDJBM DPO TNCPMPT EF QFOTB
NJFOUPZEFBDDJOw
+FBO#BSUPMJ 
SFBMJ[FOMBDJVEBE
EF4P1BVMP #SBTJM
VOBJOUFSFTBOUFJO
WFTUJHBDJOTPCSFMBTQSPQVFTUBTEFWJEB
QBSBMPTFKFDVUJWPT QVCMJDBEBFOFMFEJUP
SJBMEFVOBSFWJTUBFTQFDJBMJ[BEB-PTSF
TVMUBEPTEFNVFTUSBORVFMBTQSPQVFTUBT 
BQBSFOUFNFOUFMBJDBTZQSBHNUJDBT EJ
SJHJEBTBMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFMBFNQSFTB
UJFOFODPNQPOFOUFTSFMJHJPTPTRVFUSBT
DJFOEFOVOBTJNQMFBMFHPSB"MMVOPWF
RVFMPTJEFBMFTEFQFSGFDDJOQSPQVFTUPT
QBSB DPOEVDJS MB WJEB EF FKFDVUJWPT MFT
JNQPOFOVOBKFSBSRVBEFWBMPSFT VOB
SVUB BTDUJDB MMFOB EF SFTJHOBDJO Z TB
DSJmDJPF JODMVTP SJUVBMJEBETJNJMBSBMB
RVFQSPQPOFOMBTSFMJHJPOFTDPOWFODJP
OBMFT4VHFTUJWBNFOUF FMBVUPSUJUVMBTV
USBCBKPDPOMBQSFHVOUBi{&TTFSFKFDVUJ
WPVOJEFBM VOBSFMJHJO w
-B UFPMPHB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB EFTBSSPMM
VOB BOUJHVB USBEJDJO RVF DPOTJTUB FO
MBSFQSFTFOUBDJOFOUSNJOPTEFEJPTFT
EF MPT JEFBMFT RVF QSFTJEFO PQDJPOFT 
QSPZFDUPTZSFBMJ[BDJPOFTIVNBOPT3V
CFN"MWFT 
IBPCTFSWBEPRVF
iMBTNJTNBTDVFTUJPOFTSFMJHJPTBTEFMQB
TBEP BIPSB TF BSUJDVMBO  BMUFSBEBT  QPS
TNCPMPT TFDVMBSJ[BEPT -PT OPNCSFT
QBTBOQPSVOBNFUBNPSGPTJT-BNJTNB
GVODJOSFMJHJPTBQFSTJTUF 
4JFTUPFT
WFSEBE  OPT WFNPT GPS[BEPT B DPODMVJS
OPRVFOVFTUSPNVOEPTFIBTFDVMBSJ[B
EP TJOPRVFTFIBOEBEPOVFWPTOPN
CSFTZOVFWBTFUJRVFUBTBMPTEJPTFTZB
MBTFTQFSBO[BTSFMJHJPTBT ZSPQBTOVFWBT 





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

OVFWPT MVHBSFT Z OVFWPT USBCBKPT B TVT


TBDFSEPUFTZQSPGFUBTw
&OUSFMBTUBSFBTSFMFWBOUFTRVFFTPJNQMJ
DBFTUOMPTEFTBGPTEFJEFOUJmDBSBMPT
EJPTFTZBTVTQSPNFTBTZSFRVJTJUPT QFSP
UBNCJO TVT DBQBDJEBEFT EF TBUJTGBDFS
TVTQSPNFTBT-BUFPMPHBMMBNBMBBUFO
DJO BM MBEP JMVTPSJP EF MBT QSPNFTBT 
RVFTPOBUSBDUJWBTQFSPRVFOVODBTFSO
TBUJTGFDIBTZMPTEJPTFTEFFTUPTEPMPT EF
MBQBMBCSBEFMHSJFHPJEPMPO TJNVMBDSPT 
JNBHJOBDJPOFT  FTQFDUSPT
 TPO FOHBP
TPT EF MBT QSPNFTBT &TB MFOHVB NBS
DBEBNFOUF SFMJHJPTB PDVMUB QSFHVOUBT
FYUSFNBEBNFOUF QSDUJDBT RVF FYJHFO
FYBNFOZSFnFYJOBDFSDBEFMBDPOTJT
UFODJB EF MPT TFOUJEPT Z EF MPT JEFBMFT
RVF EJSJHFO MB WJEB JOEJWJEVBM Z TPDJBM
&MMBIBBOJNBEPBMBUFPMPHBMBUJOPBNF
SJDBOBBEFTFONBTDBSBSFMTBDSJmDJBMJTNP
DPOFMDVBMBMHVOPTKVTUJmDBOMBTHSBOEFT
JOKVTUJDJBTFOMPTTJTUFNBTTPDJBMFT ZRVF
TFNBOJmFTUBOFOQPCSF[B IBNCSF EJT
DSJNJOBDJOZFYDMVTJO
-B CJPUJDB  DPNP EJTDVSTP SBDJPOBM 
QVFEF DPOTJEFSBS DPOWFOJFOUFNFOUF
FTPT WFTUJHJPT JOFWJUBCMFT EF MB SFMJHJO
JNQMDJUPT FO MPT TJTUFNBT TPDJBMFT :
DPNP MBT DJFODJBT OP TPO TJNQMFNFOUF
OFVUSBMFT OPTFSBNBMPRVF FOFMDBN
QPEFMBCJPUJDB UVWJTFNPTFMDPSBKFEF
EJTDVUJS BDFSDB EF MPT EJPTFT RVF QSFTJ
EFOOVFTUSBTDFSUF[BTZEJTDVSTPT

#JPUJDBMBJDBZCJPUJDB
SFMJHJPTBFMEFTBGPEFMEJTDVSTP
&OVOBEFMBTSFVOJPOFTEPOEFTFQSFQB
SMBGVOEBDJOEFMB4PDJFEBE#SBTJMFB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EF #JPUJDB  TVDFEJ VO IFDIP JOUFSF


TBOUF UJMBMJOUSPEVDJSFTUFUFNB&OMBT
EJTDVTJPOFTBQBSFDJMBQSFHVOUBBDFSDB
EF MB SFMJHJO FO MB CJPUJDB  Z BMHVJFO
GVF FOGUJDP FO EFDJS iDPNP QBSB N
%JPTOPFYJTUFZPOPWFPQPSRVDPOTJ
EFSBSMBSFMJHJOFOMBCJPUJDBw&OVOB
SFBDDJO DPSEJBM  PCTFSW TJNQMFNFOUF
iFOUPODFT CJFOWFOJEPBMDMVCEFMBUFP
MPHBw6OUBOUPTPSQSFOEJEP DPOUJOV
i{RVEJDFT w0CTFSWRVFMBUFPMPHBFT
VOEJTDVSTPTPCSF%JPT BHSFHBOEPRVF
OFHBSMBFYJTUFODJBEF%JPTFTVOBDMBTF
EFEJTDVSTPUFPMHJDP"DFQUBOEPMBM
HJDBEFMDPNFOUBSJP MDPSSJHJi#VFOP 
FTEFDJS TPZVOBHOTUJDPOPDPOP[DPB
%JPTw1FSPMBTFHVOEBDPODMVTJOGVF
iTJFTUFFTFMDBTP `CJFOWFOJEPBMEJMPHP
*OUFSDBNCJFNPTFMDPOPDJNJFOUPBDFSDB
EFFTUPFOFMDBNQPEFMBCJPUJDBw
-B QPMBSJ[BDJO FOUSF VO CJPUJDB MBJDB
Z PUSB SFMJHJPTB NFSFDF VOB BUFODJO
QBSUJDVMBS  FTQFDJBMNFOUF FO FM DPO
UFYUP MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP )BCMBS EF FTP
SFRVJFSF  TPCSF UPEP  MB DPOTJEFSBDJO
EF DNP MB CJPUJDB EFTBSSPMMB TV SF
nFYJOEFTEFFMDPOUFYUPQBSUJDVMBSRVF
MB DBSBDUFSJ[B TB FT MB GVODJO EF MPT
BEKFUJWPT RVF DBMJmDBO PDBTJPOBMNFOUF
MB CJPUJDB "DFOUBO HFOFSBMNFOUF FM
UJQPEFSFGFSFODJBTVTBEPQPSMPTTVKFUPT
RVFMBFMBCPSBOZPTFBMBOFMSFBIBDJB
EPOEFMBSFnFYJODPOWFSHF&TBFTVOB
DPOEJDJO EFM QFOTBNJFOUP IVNBOP 
VO QVOUP EFTEF FM DVBM WB B CVTDBS MBT
EJNFOTJPOFTEFVOJWFSTBMJEBE&MEJMP
HPFOUSFMPTEJGFSFOUFTNPEPT GVFOUFTZ
DPOUFYUPTEFDPOPDJNJFOUPTFDPOWJFSUF
FOVOSFDVSTPCTJDPQBSBMBDPOTPMJEB





#JPUJDBZSFMJHJOFO"NSJDB-BUJOB.SDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT

DJO EF DPODFQUPT &O FTF TFOUJEP  MB


EJTUJODJOFOUSFCJPUJDBMBJDBZSFMJHJP
TBOPTFSBFYDMVZFOUF TJOPBCJFSUPBMB
DPNQMFNFOUBSJFEBE
4JOFNCBSHP FYJTUFOMMBNBTWJWBTQPSEF
CBKPEFFTBTDFOJ[BT-BIJTUPSJBNVFTUSB
VOB MBSHB IFHFNPOB EFM QFOTBNJFOUP
SFMJHJPTPFOMBDPOTUSVDDJOEFTFOUJEPT
FJOUFSQSFUBDJOEFSFBMJEBEFT DPOVOB
JOnVFODJBQSPGVOEBFO MB PSHBOJ[BDJO
TPDJBM&TBIFHFNPOBOPIBDPOMMFWBEP
TPMBNFOUFFMQPEFSEFMQFOTBNJFOUPSF
MJHJPTP TJOPUBNCJOFMQPEFSQPMUJDP
-FPOBSEP#PQMBOUFMBDVFTUJOEFTEF
EFOUSPEFMBQSPQJBDPNVOJEBESFMJHJP
TB-BIFHFNPOBEFMQPEFSSFMJHJPTPIB
TJEPRVFCSBEBQPSMBJSSVQDJOEFMBNP
EFSOJEBE RVF BUSJCVZF B MB BVUPOPNB
EFMBSB[OMBDPOTUSVDDJOEFMVOJWFSTP
EFTJHOJmDBDJPOFTRVFEJSJHFOMPTTFOUJ
EPTEFMBFYJTUFODJB FMQFOTBNJFOUPZFM
BDUVBSEFTPDJFEBEFTZEFJOEJWJEVPT-B
SFMJHJOTFSFMFHBBMBFTGFSBQSJWBEB
&O"NSJDB-BUJOBFTBJSSVQDJOBQBSF
DFDPOBMHOSFUBSEPEFCJEP QSJODJQBM
NFOUF  B MB VOJO FOUSF MB *HMFTJB Z FM
&TUBEP RVFIBQFSTJTUJEPEFTEFQPDBT
DPMPOJBMFTIBTUBFMTJHMP9*9-PTBKVT
UFTRVFFTBUSBOTGPSNBDJOIBSFRVFSJEP
UPEBWBFTUOFODVSTPFOFMDPOUJOFOUF
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP  BO QSFTFOUBO DJFSUB
WBSJBDJO FO MBT EJWFSTBT FYQFSJFODJBT
SFHJPOBMFT"T FTDPNQSFOTJCMFZKVTUP
RVF BUSBWTEFMBPQPTJDJOFOUSFMBJDP
ZSFMJHJPTP TFQPTUVMFMBBVUPOPNBEFMB
SB[O GSFOUF BM BVUPSJUBSJTNP SFMJHJPTP
FOMBSFnFYJOCJPUJDB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

1BSBTPCSFQBTBSFTFDPOnJDUPFOMBTSFMB
DJPOFT MBUFPMPHBEFCFTFSoFOMBCJPUJ
DBZFOMBTPDJFEBEQMVSBMoVOBiUFPMPHB
QCMJDBi  FT EFDJS  VOB UFPMPHB RVF TF
QSFTFOUF DPO TVT SB[POFT FOUFOEJEBT Z
EJTDVUJEBTBCJFSUBNFOUFZ QPSMPUBOUP 
DPO VO EJTDVSTP BCJFSUP B DPOUSBBSHV
NFOUPT&MEJTDVSTPEFMBTDPNVOJEBEFT
EFGFoFOMBTRVFFMQFTPEFSFGFSFODJBT
SFMJHJPTBTZBVUPSJEBEEFTVTMEFSFTUJF
OFOPUSPWBMPSoOPFTQBSBMBCJPUJDBVO
EJTDVSTP BSHVNFOUBUJWP  BVORVF QVF
EB FWFOUVBMNFOUF DMBSJmDBS BDUJUVEFT Z
DPNQPSUBNJFOUPT
&T OFDFTBSJP  FOUPODFT  SFDPOPDFS RVF
OP UPEPT MPT EJTDVSTPT UFPMHJDPT QVF
EFO EJBMPHBS FO CJPUJDB  QFSP  UBN
CJO  FT JOEJTQFOTBCMF EJTUJOHVJS  BVO
RVF TPMBNFOUF VO QPDP  MPT EJWFSTPT
NPEFMPTUFPMHJDPT QBSBOPJEFOUJmDBS
UPEPTFTUPTEJTDVSTPTDPNPBVUPSJUBSJPT
Z DFSSBEPT 1PS PUSB QBSUF  NF QBSFDF
JHVBMNFOUF JNQSFTDJOEJCMF TPCSFQBTBS
FM EPHNBUJTNP DJFOUmDP  QPSRVF IBZ
DPODJFODJB EF RVF MBT DJFODJBT OP TPO
OFVUSBMFT Z OP DPOTUJUVZFO MBT OJDBT
GPSNBTEFDPOPDJNJFOUPIVNBOP

#JPUJDBZSFMJHJOFMEFTBGPEF
TVTMVHBSFTFOMBTPDJFEBE
&YJTUFBRVVOQSPDFTPNTQSPGVOEPZ
SBEJDBMRVFEFTBGBMBCJPUJDBZMBSFMJ
HJO(BVDIFU  BQVE/FVU[MJOH 

 PCTFSWB RVF FM DSJTUJBOJTNP
FT MB SFMJHJO EF MB TBMJEB EF MB SFMJHJO
QPSQFSNJUJSHSBEVBMNFOUFRVFMBFTGFSB
QPMUJDB SFOVODJF B TV MFHJUJNBDJO SF
MJHJPTB Z FODVFOUSF PUSPT NPEFMPT QBSB
MFHJUJNBSTF&MQSPUFTUBOUJTNPIJTUSJDP





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

IB DPOUSJCVJEP HSBOEFNFOUF B FTP


/FVU[MJOH 
BDFOUBMBJN
QPSUBODJB EF MBT OVFWBT EJSFDDJPOFT TF
HVJEBTQPSFMDBUPMJDJTNPSPNBOPFOMB
TFHVOEBNJUBEEFMTJHMP99ZQPSMBUFP
MPHBEFMBMJCFSBDJOFOTVDPOUBDUPDPO
MBDVMUVSBNPEFSOB&TFQSPDFTPMMFWBBM
mOEFMBTFYQMJDBDJPOFTZMBTMFHJUJNBDJP
OFT SFMJHJPTBT QBSB MBT FTUSVDUVSBT EF MB
WJEBTPDJBM)FSWJFV-HFS 
IBCMB
EFVOQSPDFTPEFFYDVMUVSBDJOEFMDSJT
UJBOJTNP ZEFMBTSFMJHJPOFTFOHFOFSBM

FO MB TPDJFEBE QPTNPEFSOB /FVU[MJOH

QSFTFOUBVOBTOUFTJTEFMQFO
TBNJFOUPEF)FSWJFV-HFSEJDJFOEP
i1BSB)FSWJFV-HFS MBMHJDBEFMBFY
DVMUVSBDJO DPOTJTUF  BT  FO FM QSPDFTP
QPS FM RVF MPT TJHOJmDBEPT SFMJHJPTPT
EBEPT DPMFDUJWBNFOUF B MB BDDJO FO FM
NVOEP QJFSEFO HSBEVBMNFOUF UPEB MB
DPOTJTUFODJB QBSB MPT QSPQJPT BHFOUFT 
RVF QPSBTEFDJSMP TPOJOIBMBEPTQPS
MB MHJDB FDPONJDB F JOFYPSBCMFNFOUF
TFDVMBSEFMBBDDJO&TPOPTJHOJmDBRVF
FTPTBHFOUFTIBOQFSEJEPOFDFTBSJBNFO
UFDPNPJOEJWJEVPTUPEPFMJOUFSTSFMJ
HJPTP TJOPRVFMPTEJTQPTJUJWPTRVFQFS
NJUJFSPORVFEJFSBOVOTFOUJEPSFMJHJPTP
BTVFYQFSJFODJBFOFMNVOEPoZ FOQSJ
NFSMVHBS BTVFYQFSJFODJBQSPGFTJPOBMo
IBOQFSEJEPTVDBQBDJEBEEFEBSMFTVO
TJHOJmDBEP DPMFDUJWP  QFSDJCJEP DPNP
UBMQPSFMMPTZQPSMBTPDJFEBEw
)BZ BRV  FOUPODFT  VOB JNQMPTJO EF
MPT TJHOJmDBEPT DPMFDUJWPT HBSBOUJ[B

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

EPTQSFWJBNFOUFQPSMBSFMJHJO4FHO
#MVNFOCFSH  BQVE /FVU[MJOH 

 FTF QSPDFTP IBDF RVF FM TJO
TFOUJEP TFB DPOTUSVJEP DPO VO OVF
WP DPOUFOJEP : MB TPMVDJO QBSB FTF
iOVFWPwFTUFOFMBOMJTJTCBTBEPFOMB
BVUPBmSNBDJO EFM JOEJWJEVP 4FMCTCF
IBVQUVOH
UPNBEPEFTEFFTFNPNFOUP
DPNPSFGFSFODJBQBSBMBDPOTUSVDDJOEF
TJHOJmDBEPT
&TUPQSFTFOUBVOEFTBGPSBEJDBMOPTMP
BMBSFMJHJOTJOP BIPSBQBSUJDVMBSNFO
UF BMBCJPUJDB DVBOEPTUB TJHVJFOEP
MBQSJNFSBJOUVJDJOEF1PUUFS 

TFQSPQPOFTFSFOMBTPDJFEBEQMVSBMVO
BHFOUFEFMBTBCJEVSBDPNPHVBQBSBMB
BDDJO EFMDPOPDJNJFOUPEFDNPVUJ
MJ[BSFMDPOPDJNJFOUPFOCFOFmDJPEFMB
TPDJFEBE{2VMVHBSPDVQBSFBMNFOUFMB
CJP
UJDBFOMBTPDJFEBEQMVSBM &ONV
DIPTDPOUFYUPTTFWFDPNPVOPCTUDVMP
BM EFTBSSPMMP DJFOUmDP P DPNP VO NBM
OFDFTBSJP EF UPMFSBSTF EFCJEP B MB QSF
TJOEFHSVQPTTPDJBMFT
&WJUBOEP DBFS FO FM JOEJWJEVBMJTNP  MB
UFPMPHB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB Z MB CJPUJDB
WBO IBDJB VOB JOUFSTVCKFUJWJEBE DBQB[
EFEJBMPHBS EFTFSQBSUFEFVOBSFE EF
CVTDBSZEFFODPOUSBSOVFTUSBTSB[POFT
DPNQBSUJEBT  DPNQBSUJS TJHOJmDBEPT Z
WJWJSMPT FO MB TPDJFEBE "RV TF EJCVKB
VO FTQBDJP EPOEF MB UFPMPHB Z MB CJP
UJDBQVFEFOBQSFOEFSVOBEFMBPUSBZ
USBCBKBSFOMBTPDJFEBEQBSBFMCJFOEFMB
IVNBOJEBE



#JPUJDBZSFMJHJOFO"NSJDB-BUJOB.SDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPT



3FGFSFODJBT
"MWFT 3VCFN 
0RVF3FMJHJP4P1BVMP $SDVMPEP-JWSP
"OKPT .' 
#JPFUIJDTJOB-JCFSBUJPOJTU,FZ*O%V#PTF&3 )BNFM3
0w$POOFMM-+ &E
".BUUFSPG1SJODJQMFT 'FSNFOUJO64#JPFUIJDT7BMMFZ'PSHF 
5SJOJUZ1SFTT*OUFSOBUJPOBM QQ
"OKPT .' 
#JPUJDBFNQFSTQFDUJWBEFMJCFSUBP&O(BSSBGB 71FTTJOJ 
-FP 0SH
#JPUJDBQPEFSFJOKVTUJB4P1BVMP 4##-PZPMB4$BNJMP QQ

#BODP*OUFSBNFSJDBOPEF%FTFOWPMWJNFOUPOB"NSJDB-BUJOB 
*ODMVTPTPDJBMF
EFTFOWPMWJNFOUPFDPONJDPOB"NSJDB-BUJOB3JPEF+BOFJSP $BNQVT
#BSUPMJ +FBO 
4FSFYFDVUJWPVNJEFBM VNBSFMJHJP "QBSFDJEB *EJBT-FUSBT
#MVNFOCFSH )BOT 
-BMHJUJNJUEFT5FNQT.PEFSOFT1BSJT (BMMJNBSE
#PGG -FPOBSEP 
*HSFKBDBSJTNBFQPEFS1FUSQPMJT &E7P[FT
$IBTUFFO +$ 
"NSJDB-BUJOB VNBIJTUSJBEFTBOHVFFGPHP5FSDFSB&EJDJO
3JPEF+BOFJSP $BNQVT
(BSSBGB 71FTTJOJ -FP 0SH
 
#JPUJDBQPEFSFJOKVTUJB4P1BVMP -PZPMB
(BVDIFU .BSDFM 
-BDPOEJUJPOIJTUPSJRVF1BSJT 4UPDL
)FSWJFV-HFS %BOJMF 
$BUIPMJDJTNF MBGJOEwVONPOEF1BSJT #BZBSE
4PCSJOP +PO 
&MQSJODJQJPNJTFSJDPSEJB#BKBSEFMBDSV[BMPTQVFCMPTDSVDJGJDBEPT
4BOUBOEFS 4BM5FSSBF
/FVU[MJOH *ODJP 
5FPMPHJBFTPDJFEBEFSFMFWODJBFGVOFT"MHVNBTBOPUBFT
&O 'SFJUBT  . $BSNFMJUB 0SH
 5FPMPHJB F 4PDJFEBEF SFMFWODJB F GVOFT 4P
1BVMP 1BVMJOBT QQ
0MJWFJSB .BOGSFEP"SBKP 
%JMPHPTFOUSFSB[PFG4P1BVMP &E1BVMJOBT
1BQB #FOUP 97* $POGFSODJB FN 3FHFOTCVSH 0TTFSWBUPSF 3PNBOP &E 1PSUVHVT

 
EFTFUFNCSPEF QQ 

1FTTJOJ - 
&VUBOTJBQPSRVFBCSFWJBSBWJEB 4P1BVMP &E-PZPMB
1PUUFS  7BO 3FOTTFMBFS 
 #JPFUIJDT CSJEHF UP UIF GVUVSF &OHMFXPPE $MJGGT  /FX
+FSTFZ 1SFOUJDF)BMM
4VFTT 1BVMP 
"$PORVJTUBFTQSJUVBMEB"NSJDB&TQBOIPMBEPDVNFOUPTTDVMP
97*1FUSQPMJT &E7P[FT
5JMMJDI  1BVM 
 5IF TQJSJUVBM TJUVBUJPO JO PVS UFDIOJDBM TPDJFUZ .BDPO  (FPSHJB 
.FSDFS6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





-BCJPUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NSJDB-BUJOBVO
FOTBZPCJPHSmDPZHFOFBMHJDP
%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN

BCJPUJDBTFDPOTPMJEFO#SBTJMBm
OFTEFMBEDBEBEFMPT6OGFO
NFOPTFNFKBOUFTVDFEJFOPUSPTQBTFT
EF "NSJDB -BUJOB  FTQFDJBMNFOUF FO
"SHFOUJOB  $IJMF Z .YJDP  EPOEF FT
OPUBCMFTVJOTFSDJOBDBENJDB %JOJ[ 
(VJMIFN  (BSSBGB   
014   6/&4$0   7FMBT
DP4VSF[  
 &O FTF QSPDFTP EF
DPOTPMJEBDJO  MBT NVKFSFT BTVNJFSPO
EJGFSFOUFT QBQFMFT  ZB TFB DPNP QSPUB
HPOJTUBTBDBENJDBTPDPNPJOUFSMPDV
UPSBTFOFMFTQBDJPQCMJDP&TUBEPCMF
JOTFSDJO FT DBSBDUFSTUJDB FO MB CJPUJ
DBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBZGPSNBQBSUFEFMB
CJPHSBGBEFMBTBVUPSBTEFFTUFFOTBZP
&TUFDBQUVMPFTVOBQJF[BCJPHSmDBZ
HFOFBMHJDBEFMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBZ QBSUJDVMBSNFOUF EFMBCSBTJMFB
4FCBTBFOFYQFSJFODJBTWJWJEBTQPSMBT
BVUPSBT Z  FO NFOPS JOUFOTJEBE QFSP
OP NFOPT JNQPSUBOUF  FO MPT SFMBUPT
EF PUSBT NVKFSFT TPCSF FTF QSPDFTP EF
DPOTPMJEBDJO BDBENJDB FO "NSJDB

 -BT BVUPSBT BHSBEFDFO MPT DPNFOUBSJPT EF


$SJTUJBOP (VFEFT  'BCJBOB 1BSBOIPT Z 4FSHJP
$PTUB5SBEVDDJO7BMFOUJOB'FSSB[3FWJTJO
"EBJM4PCSBM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

-BUJOB BVODVBOEPMBJOUFSQSFUBDJOEF
MPTIFDIPTFTEFOVFTUSBDPNQMFUBSFT
QPOTBCJMJEBE

6OQBOPSBNBHFOFBMHJDP
&YJTUFVOBDSFDJFOUFGFNJOJ[BDJOEFMBT
BDUJWJEBEFTBDBENJDBTFO"NSJDB-BUJ
OB-BTNVKFSFTZBTPONBZPSBFOHSBO
QBSUF EF MBT DBSSFSBT VOJWFSTJUBSJBT  DPO
FYDFQDJO EF mMPTPGB Z UFPMPHB EFO
USP EF MBT IVNBOJEBEFT FO UBOUP RVF
MBT JOHFOJFSBT HSBEVBMNFOUF IBO DFEJ
EP FTQBDJPT B MBT NVKFSFT .FEJDJOB  B
QFTBSEFMDSFDJFOUFONFSPEFNVKFSFT 
FTUNBSDBEBQPSFMHOFSP&OHFOFSBM 
MBTNVKFSFTNEJDPTTFEFEJDBOBMBTBD
UJWJEBEFTEFDVJEBEPZQPDBTPQUBOQPS
FTQFDJBMJEBEFT DPNP MB NFEJDJOB MFHBM 
MBUJDBNEJDBP JODMVTP MBQPMUJDBEF
DMBTF %JOJ[  
 &TB EJ

 1BSB DPOPDFS MBT QVCMJDBDJPOFT EF MBT NVKFSFT


MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBTFOCJPUJDB GVFSFBMJ[BEBVOB
JOWFTUJHBDJOFOEPTCBTFTEFEBUPT-JUFSBUVSB
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM$BSJCFFO$JFODJBTEFMB
4BMVE -JMBDT
ZFMF4DJFOUJmD&MFDUSPOJD-J
CSBSZ 0OMJOF 4DJFMP
 'VFSPO SFDVQFSBEBT 
QVCMJDBDJPOFT EF NVKFSFT BVUPSBT FO CJPUJDB
"QBSUJSEFBMMGVFSPOJEFOUJmDBEBTBVUPSBTDMB
WFQBSBMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBZDPOFMMBT
GVFSPO SFBMJ[BEBT FOUSFWJTUBT FO QSPGVOEJEBE
"SHFOUJOB #SBTJM $IJMFZ.YJDP






1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

WJTJO TPDJBM EFM USBCBKP BDBENJDP FO


NFEJDJOB HFOFS DBSBDUFSTUJDBT JNQPS
UBOUFTFOMBQBSUJDJQBDJOEFMBTNVKFSFT
FOMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
-B HOFTJT EF MB CJPUJDB CSBTJMFB GVF
CBTUBOUF TFNFKBOUF B MB EF PUSPT QBTFT
EF MB SFHJO (FOFSBMNFOUF  FM JNQVM
TPJOJDJBMTFEJPBUSBWTEFEPTDBNQPT
NBTDVMJOPTMBQPMUJDBEFMBDMBTFNEJ
DBZMBUFPMPHBDBUMJDB -PZPMB 
$PSSB 
-BTQSJNFSBTJOJDJB
UJWBTEFDPOTPMJEBDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFO
#SBTJMGVFSPOEFSFTQPOTBCJMJEBEEFFO
UJEBEFTNEJDBT FOFTQFDJBMEFM$POTFKP
'FEFSBMEF.FEJDJOB-BSFWJTUB#JPUJDB 
QPSFKFNQMP FTMBRVFUJFOFNTBPTFO
DJSDVMBDJOFOFMQBTZFTUCBKPMBSFT
QPOTBCJMJEBEFEJUPSJBMEFFTUF$POTFKP
%FMPTNJFNCSPTEFMBDUVBMDPOTFKP
FEJUPSJBM TPOIPNCSFT MBNBZPSB
NEJDPT $.'  
 6OB JOJDJBUJWB
QJPOFSBEFFEVDBDJOCJPUJDBBEJTUBO
DJB QPSNFEJPEFMBUFMFWJTJO GVFUBN
CJOQSPNPWJEBQPSFM$POTFKPBmOBMFT
EFMBEDBEBEFMPT %JOJ[(VJM

 -PTDPODFQUPTEFDBNQP DBNQPFOEJTQVUBF
JOUFSFTFT TPO EF 1JFSSF #PVSEJFV 7BTF  QPS
FKFNQMP MBTJEFBTEFMBVUPSFOMPTMJCSPTUJUV
MBEPT&M1PEFS4JNCMJDP 
Z-B&DPOPNB
EFMPT$BNCJPT4JNCMJDPT 

 &MQSJNFSONFSPEFMBSFWJTUBGVFQVCMJDBEP
FO  /P IBZ OJOHVOB SFWJTUB DJFOUmDB
FTQFDJBMJ[BEBFOCJPUJDBFO#SBTJMDPOJOEFYB
DJOJOUFSOBDJPOBM ZMBQFSJPEJDJEBEEFUPEBTFT
CBTUBOUFJSSFHVMBS4FHO,UJB4PBSFT#SBHB FM
DBSDUFSBNBUFVSEFMBDPNVOJDBDJODJFOUmDB
FO CJPUJDB FO #SBTJM oZ FO DJFSUB NFEJEB FO
"NSJDB-BUJOBoJNQSJNFNBSDBTJNQPSUBOUFT
BMDBNQP #SBHB 


PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

IFN  
 1PS PUSP MBEP  FM QSJNFS
DVSTPEFNBFTUSBFOCJPUJDBGVFPGSFDJ
EPQPSVOBJOTUJUVDJOEFFOTFBO[BTV
QFSJPSDBUMJDB&OMBQSJNFSBEDBEBEF
FTUSVDUVSBDJOEFMBCJPUJDBFO#SBTJM MB
USBEBNFEJDJOB UFPMPHBDBUMJDBZCJP
UJDBIJ[PEJGDJMMBEJGFSFODJBDJOEFMPT
EJTDVSTPTFJOUFSFTFTEFMPTBDUPSFT
-BBQSPYJNBDJOEFMBCJPUJDBBMBNF
EJDJOBZ NTQBSUJDVMBSNFOUF BMBQP
MUJDB NEJDB  EFMJOF VOB EPCMF JEFO
UJEBEBMBCJPUJDBCSBTJMFBEFMPTBPT
FSBVOUFNBEFJOUFSTEFMBNFEJDJ
OBZQSBDUJDBEBQPSNEJDPTEFEJDBEPT
BMBQPMUJDBNEJDBPQSPGFTPSFTFOWBT
EFKVCJMBDJO%VSBOUFVOCSFWFQFSP
EP MBCJPUJDBGVFFOUFOEJEBDPNPVOB
FTQFDJBMJEBEEFMBUJDBNEJDBZOPGVF
DBTVBMJEBE MB NJHSBDJO EFM DBNQP EF
MB NFEJDJOB MFHBM Z EF MB UJDB NEJDB
IBDJB MB CJPUJDB -B JOTFSDJO VOJWFS
TJUBSJB EF MB CJPUJDB FTUVWP WJODVMBEB
QSJODJQBMNFOUF DPO QSPHSBNBT EF QPT
HSBEPFONFEJDJOBMFHBM 4JRVFJSBFUBM 



 %VSBOUFEPTBPT FM$POTFKP'FEFSBMEF.FEJ
DJOBQSPEVKPVOQSPHSBNBEFUFMFWJTJOi#JP
UJDB $JFODJBZ$JVEBEBOBw DVZPPCKFUJWPFSB
TFOTJCJMJ[BSBUPEPTMPTNEJDPTEFMQBTQBSBMBT
DVFTUJPOFTCJPUJDBT%FCPSB%JOJ[GVFVOBEF
MBTSFTQPOTBCMFTQPSFMQSPHSBNB
 $FOUSP6OJWFSTJUBSJP4P$BNJMP .BFTUSBFO
#JPUJDB&MDVSTPTFJOJDJFOBHPTUPEF
Z UPEBWB FT FM OJDP FO FM QBT 4P $BNJMP 


 &TBDPNQSFTJOEFMBCJPUJDBDPNPVOBFTQF
DJBMJEBEEFMBUJDBNEJDBFTUPEBWBIFHFN
OJDB3FDJFOUFNFOUF MBSFWJTUB#JPUJDBFNQF[
BMMBNBSTF#JPUJDBVOBSFWJTUBEF#JPUJDBZUJ
DB.EJDB





-BCJPUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN

-B DPNQSFOTJO JOJDJBM EF MB CJPUJDB


DPNPVOBDVFTUJOEFGPSNBDJONEJ
DB Z EF QPMUJDB EF MB NFEJDJOB JNQSJ
NJ USFT DBSBDUFSTUJDBT RVF UPEBWB TF
NBOUJFOFO GVFSUF OGBTJT FO FM SBDJP
DJOJP UJDP QBSB MB TPMVDJO EF QSPCMF
NBT  QPS FTP MB GBTDJOBDJO QPS UFPSBT
EF GDJM BQSFOEJ[BKF Z EPNJOJP QPS OP
FTQFDJBMJTUBTFOIVNBOJEBEFT DPNPGVF
FMDBTPEFMBUFPSBEFMPTDVBUSPQSJODJ
QJPTDPNQSFOTJOEFMBCJPUJDBDPNP
NBUFSJBEFJOUFSTEFMPTNEJDPTZEFM
FKFSDJDJP QSPGFTJPOBM EF MB NFEJDJOB  Z
BHFOEBCJPUJDBNPEFMBEBQPSFMRVFIB
DFSNEJDP
&TUB BSUJDVMBDJO GVF NT NBSDBEB FO
MPTQSJNFSPTBPT FOFTQFDJBMDVBOEPMB
BDUVBDJO EF MBT FOUJEBEFT NEJDBT FSB
IFHFNOJDB4JOFNCBSHP EBEBMBJOTFS
DJOQPMUJDBEFMBQSPGFTJONEJDBFO
MBTPDJFEBECSBTJMFB FMFOUFOEJNJFOUP
EF MB CJPUJDB DPNP VOB DVFTUJO N
EJDB Z OP DPNP VO DBNQP BOBMUJDP Z
UFSJDPTPCSFMBCJPNFEJDJOBZMBDJFODJB
UPEBWBQFSTJTUF %JOJ[ (VJMIFN(B
SSBGB 

1FSPMBBQSPYJNBDJOEFMBCJPUJDBBMB
NFEJDJOBGVFJNQPSUBOUFQBSBMBDPOTP
MJEBDJOEFBRVFMMB3QJEBNFOUFBTDFO
EJ B EJTDJQMJOB EF FMJUF  DPNQSFOTJO
RVF TF WJP GPSUBMFDJEB QPS MB QSFTFODJB
EF MB UFPMPHB DBUMJDB "M DPOUSBSJP EF
MPRVFPDVSSJFOPUSPTQBTFTEF"N
SJDB -BUJOB  MPT HSVQPT UFPMHJDPT RVF
TFJOUFSFTBSPOQPSMBCJPUJDBGVFSPOEF
WBOHVBSEJBZDPOFTQSJUVQMVSBMQBSBFM
EFCBUFQCMJDP1FSP UBMDPNPMPTN
EJDPT MPTUFMPHPTDBUMJDPTUBNCJOFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UBCMFDJFSPOTVBHFOEBEFJOWFTUJHBDJOF
JOUFSWFODJOCBTBEBFOMPTJOUFSFTFTEF
TV DPNVOJEBE DJFOUmDB  MP RVF EFUFS
NJO USFT DBSBDUFSTUJDBT SFUPSOP EF MB
CJPUJDB B MBT IVNBOJEBEFT BQMJDBEBT B
MBTBMVEBHFOEBUFNUJDBBNQMJBEBIB
DJBUFNBTSFMBDJPOBEPTDPOMBQB[Z TJO
FNCBSHP SFTUSJDUJWBFODVFTUJPOFTSFMB
DJPOBEBTDPOMBSFQSPEVDDJOCJPMHJDB 
FJODFOUJWPBMBFTUSVDUVSBDJOBDBENJ
DBEFMBCJPUJDB MPRVFSFQSFTFOUVOB
QSEJEBEFMBIFHFNPOBEFMBTFOUJEB
EFTNEJDBTEFDMBTFDPNPEJTDVSTPMFHJ
UJNBEPSEFMBCJPUJDB
" QFTBS EF MBT SFTUSJDDJPOFT UFNUJDBT
JOIFSFOUFTBMBEPHNUJDBDBUMJDBFOFM
EFCBUFCJPUJDP MBFOUSBEBZQFSNBOFO
DJB EF MPT UFMPHPT GPS[ FM SFHSFTP EF
MB CJPUJDB B MBT IVNBOJEBEFT "M DPO
USBSJPEFMPTQBTFTEF"NSJDB$FOUSBM 
EPOEFFTVOBFTQFDJBMJEBEEFMBmMPTPGB
BOUFT RVF EF MB NFEJDJOB  FO "NSJDB
EFM4VSFMGFONFOPGVFJOWFSTP "OESF 
 (BSSBGB  %JOJ[   (VJM
IFN 
*OJDJBMNFOUF FTUVWP
FONBOPTEFMBUFPMPHBNBOUFOFSBDUJWP
FTFWODVMPUFSJDP
4J FM FODVFOUSP FOUSF MB NFEJDJOB Z MB
UFPMPHBDBUMJDBGBDJMJU QPSVOMBEP FM
TVSHJNJFOUP EF MB CJPUJDB FO MB FTGFSB
EF MPT QPEFSFT TJNCMJDPT EF FTBT EPT
EJTDJQMJOBTFOMBTPDJFEBECSBTJMFB QPS
PUSP GVFVOBBMJBO[BFTUSBUHJDBQBSBMPT
QSJNFSPT BPT EF MB CJPUJDB FO #SBTJM
RVF HSBEVBMNFOUF TFIBJEPEJMVZFOEP
-BFOUSBEBZQFSNBOFODJBEFMBTNVKF
SFTFOMBCJPUJDBGVFDSVDJBMQBSBMBSF
EFTDSJQDJOEFMBUSBEBJOJDJBMCJPUJDB 





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

UFPMPHBDBUMJDBZNFEJDJOB&OMPTQSJ
NFSPTBPTEFTVSHJNJFOUPFO"NSJDB
-BUJOB MBTNVKFSFTUSBKFSPOUBNCJOFM
GFNJOJTNPDPNPVOBIFSSBNJFOUBBOB
MUJDBZQPMUJDB BMUFSOBUJWBBMBTUFPSBT
EPNJOBOUFTQBSBMBDPNQSFOTJOEFMPT
DPOnJDUPTNPSBMFT

&OUSFNEJDPTZUFMPHPT MBT
NVKFSFTGFNJOJTUBT
&YJTUF MB GBMTB QSFTVODJO EF RVF TFS
VOB NVKFS BDUJWB FO MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
CJPUJDB TJHOJmDB TFS GFNJOJTUB FTQF
DJBMJ[BEB FO UFNBT SFMBDJPOBEPT DPO MB
SFQSPEVDDJO CJPMHJDB Z TPDJBM P  BM
NFOPT VOBJOWFTUJHBEPSBEFDVFTUJPOFT
SFMBUJWBTBMDVJEBEPZMBWVMOFSBCJMJEBE
&TUP QSPWPDB VOB EJTUSJCVDJO EF H
OFSP EF MBT FTQFDJBMJEBEFT DVFTUJPOFT
SFMBDJPOBEBT B MP GFNFOJOP  DPNP MB
SFQSPEVDDJO Z MB TFYVBMJEBE  TFSBO
MPTUFNBTEFMBTNVKFSFTFOMBCJPUJDB
)VCP FGFDUJWBNFOUF VOB DPOWFSHFODJB
EFJOUFSFTFTEFMBTQSJNFSBTNVKFSFTFO
MBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBDPOFTPTUF
NBT  QFSP FTP OP TJHOJmDB RVF FTB TFB
VOB SFHMB DPNO B UPEBT MBT JOWFTUJHB
EPSBT $PSSB   $PSSB 
 %JOJ[  7FMF[  
%JOJ[  7FMF[   %J
OJ[  (VJMIFN   %J
OJ[  (VJMIFN   %J
OJ[  (PNFT   (VJMIFN 
 -VOB  
 &T QPTJCMF SFDPOPDFS MB QSFTFODJB EF BMHVOBT
NVKFSFTFOMBHOFTJTEFMBCJPUJDBRVFOPTF
DPOGVOEBO DPO FM GFNJOJTNP 4JO FNCBSHP 
FMMBTOPGVFSPONVKFSFTQSPUBHPOJTUBTPJOUFSMP
DVUPSBTEFMBCJPUJDBRVFQFSNBOFDJFSBOFOMB
MUJNBEDBEB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

0MJWFJSB 4PNNFS 


3PUBOJB   Z  7BMEFCFOJUP FU
BM  
 1FSP FTB GBMTB QSF
TVODJOGVFUBNCJOFTUSBUHJDBQBSBMB
SFVCJDBDJO EFM NCJUP QSPWPDBEP QPS
MB FOUSBEB EF MBT NVKFSFT  FO FTQFDJBM
EF MBT NVKFSFT FGFDUJWBNFOUF GFNJOJT
UBT"TVNJSRVFUFNBTDPNPFMBCPSUP 
UFDOPMPHBT SFQSPEVDUJWBT V IPNPTF
YVBMJEBEFSBODVFTUJPOFTEFMBTNVKFSFT
GFNJOJTUBT FO MB CJPUJDB SFTPMWJ VOB
TFSJF EF QSPCMFNBT QPMUJDPT QBSB MPT
QJPOFSPT EF MB EJTDJQMJOB  UBOUP EF MPT
NEJDPToQVFTTPOUFNBTEFQPDPDPO
TFOTPNPSBMZTPCSFDVFTUJPOFTQPMUJDBT
EJTPOBOUFToDPNPEFMPTUFMPHPTDBU
MJDPT QPSUSBUBSTFEFDVFTUJPOFTCTJDBT
EFMBEPHNUJDBDPOQPDPFTQBDJPQBSB
MBBSHVNFOUBDJO6OBFWJEFODJBEFFTB
OVFWBEJTUSJCVDJOUFNUJDBQPSHOFSP
FOCJPUJDBGVFSPOMBTQSJNFSBTQVCMJDB
DJPOFTEFNVKFSFTFO#SBTJM 1FTTJOJ
#BSDIJGPOUBJOF $PTUB 0TFMLB
(BSSBGB   4PSPLJO  
 (FOF
SBMNFOUF  FSBO PCSBT SFDPQJMBUPSJBT  FO
MBT DVBMFT MPT DBQUVMPT BOBMUJDPT TPCSF
SFQSPEVDDJOCJPMHJDBZTPDJBMFSBOIF
DIPTQPSNVKFSFT NJFOUSBTRVFQBSBMPT
IPNCSFT TF SFTFSWBCBO MBT EJTDVTJPOFT
UFSJDBT
$PO MB FOUSBEB EF MBT NVKFSFT MB CJP
UJDBFO#SBTJMFYQFSJNFOUVOBSFEJTUSJ
CVDJOQPMUJDBZUFNUJDBMPTUFMPHPT
DBUMJDPT BTVNJFSPO QBSB T MB UBSFB EF
BDBEFNJ[BDJOZMBDPOGSPOUBDJOEFUF
NBT DPNP FM FOWFKFDJNJFOUP QPCMBDJP
OBM Z FM mO EF MB WJEB #BSDIJGPOUBJOF 
"OKPT 1FTTJOJ
#FSUBDIJOJ  
 MPT NEJ





-BCJPUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN

DPT SFTJTUJFSPO FM EJTUBODJBNJFOUP EF MB


CJPUJDB DPO SFMBDJO B MB UJDB NEJDB
Z TF FTGPS[BSPO QPS NBOUFOFS TV DPO
USPMQPMUJDPGSFOUFBMBJOWBTJOKVSEJDB
(SJTBSE  
 Z MBT NVKFSFT
GFNJOJTUBTTFQPTJDJPOBSPODPNPQSPUB
HPOJTUBTBDBENJDBTEFMBFQJTUFNPMPHB
GFNJOJTUB F JOUFSMPDVUPSBT QCMJDBT EF
MB CJPUJDB  JOUSPEVDJFOEP VOB OVFWB
JEFOUJEBEBMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
DPNPIFSSBNJFOUBEFBEWPDBDZZEFDS
UJDB TPDJBM %JOJ[  7FMF[  
0MJWFJSB.PUB 

&TP OP TJHOJmDB  TJO FNCBSHP  RVF
UFMPHPTDBUMJDPTPNEJDPTEFEJDBEPT
B MB QPMUJDB EF DMBTF TF IBZBO DBMMBEP
EFMBOUF EF UFNBT DPNP FM BCPSUP P MBT
UFDOPMPHBT SFQSPEVDUJWBT -B SFEJTUSJ
CVDJO EF DPNQFUFODJBT FO MB NBUFSJB
PDVSSJ FO FM JOUFSJPS EF MB FNFSHFOUF
DPNVOJEBEEFFTQFDJBMJTUBTFOCJPUJDB 
FOMBDVBMTFWFSJmDBDPONTOJUJEF[FTB
PSHBOJ[BDJOEFMBTFTQFDJBMJEBEFT
-BQFSNBOFOUFDPOTUSVDDJOEFMBCJP
UJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBQFSNJUFRVFMBT
GSPOUFSBTFOUSFFTPTEJGFSFOUFTBDUPSFTOP
TFBOUBOOUJEBT/PTJHOJmDB UBNQPDP 

 -B DVFTUJO EF MB BOFODFGBMJB FO #SBTJM FT VO


FKFNQMPEFFTBSFEJTUSJCVDJOEFDPNQFUFODJBT
-PTUFMPHPTDBUMJDPTRVFTFQSPOVODJBSPOFO
FMEFCBUFQCMJDPOPTPOFTQFDJBMJTUBTFOCJP
UJDB&TFEFCBUFJOWPMVDSBMPTSFQSFTFOUBOUFT
PmDJBMFTEFMB*HMFTJB$BUMJDBCSBTJMFBZOPB
MPTJOUFMFDUVBMFTDBUMJDPTEFMBDPNVOJEBEEF
CJPUJDB
 -B 4PDJFEBE #SBTJMFB EF #JPUJDB FT VOP EF
FTPT FTQBDJPT EF PSHBOJ[BDJO EF MBT DPNQF
UFODJBT FO FM NBSDP EF MB CJPUJDB CSBTJMFB
&M'PSP-BUJOPBNFSJDBOPEF$PNJUTEFUJDB
FO*OWFTUJHBDJOFO4BMVE '-"$&*4
FTPUSP
FKFNQMPFOFMNCJUPSFHJPOBM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

RVF TMP FYJTUBO FTPT HSVQPT  FTQFDJBM


NFOUFDPOTJEFSBOEPFMDSFDJNJFOUPEFMB
CJPUJDBFOFMVOJWFSTPKVSEJDP&O#SB
TJM IVCPDBTPTEFNVKFSFTGFNJOJTUBTFO
CJPUJDBRVFFSBOUBNCJOBDUJWBTQBSUJD
JQBOUFTEFMBQPMUJDBFOTBMVE PEFNV
KFSFTGFNJOJTUBTUFMPHBTDVZBTPCSBTGVFS
PO SFGFSFODJB QBSB FM TVSHJNJFOUP EF MB
CJPUJDB (FCBSB Z0MJWFJSB 
 0MJWFJSB  
0MJWFJSB  'FSSB[  'FSSFJSB  

/PPCTUBOUF FTQPTJCMFSFDPOPDFS
EJGFSFODJBTEFJOUFSFTFTFOUSFMPTHSVQPT 
ZRVFFMDBSDUFSUPEBWBFOGPSNBDJOEF
MBTGSPOUFSBTEJTDJQMJOBSJBTEFMBCJPUJDB
GBWPSFDFFMBOMJTJTEFTEFFTBTEJGFSFOUFT
QFSTQFDUJWBT

&OUSFQSPUBHPOJTUBTBDBENJDBT
FJOUFSMPDVUPSBTQCMJDBT
-BCJPUJDBFTVOOVFWPTBCFSFOMBJO
UFSGB[ EFM DPOPDJNJFOUP BDBENJDP Z
EFMBBDDJOQPMUJDB1PSTFSVONCJUP
UPEBWBFOGPSNBDJO MBTEJTQVUBTFQJT
UFNPMHJDBTTPOJOUFOTBT FTQFDJBMNFOUF
FO QBTFT EPOEF MB JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJO
BDBENJDBFTSFDJFOUF&O"NSJDB-B
UJOBFTQPTJCMFJEFOUJmDBSEPTFTDFOBSJPT
EJGFSFOUFT EF EJTQVUBT QPS MB DPOmHV
SBDJO EJTDJQMJOBSJB EF MB CJPUJDB Z FO
BNCPT FM QBQFM EF MBT NVKFSFT IB TJEP
GVOEBNFOUBM
&OFMFTDFOBSJPBDBENJDP FMQSPUBHP
OJTNPEFMBTNVKFSFTTFFYQSFTBEFEPT
NBOFSBT1PSVOMBEP DPNPQBSUFEFMB
DPNVOJEBEEFEJDBEBBJOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BS
MB CJPUJDB FO MBT VOJWFSTJEBEFT $PNP
VOB QSPGFDB BVUPDVNQMJEB  HSBO QBSUF
EFMBTNVKFSFTEFEJDBEBTBMBCJPUJDBTF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

FTQFDJBMJ[FOUFNBTSFMBDJPOBEPTDPOMB
SFQSPEVDDJOCJPMHJDBZTPDJBM&MQSJ
NFSDPODVSTPQCMJDPQBSBMBEPDFODJB
FO CJPUJDB FO #SBTJM GVF SFBMJ[BEP FO
 FOMB6OJWFSTJEBEEFM&TUBEPEF
3P EF +BOFJSP  QBSB MB DUFESB EF 3F
QSPEVDDJO #JPMHJDB  4PDJBM  .FEJDB
MJ[BDJO Z #JPUJDB  Z FM TFHVOEP QBSB
#JPUJDB 7VMOFSBCJMJEBEZUJDBFO*O
WFTUJHBDJO DPO 4FSFT )VNBOPT  QBSB
MB 6OJWFSTJEBE $BUMJDB EF #SBTJMJB  FO
 &O "NSJDB -BUJOB  MB QSJNF
SB UFTJT EF EPDUPSBEP FTQFDmDBNFOUF
TPCSF CJPUJDB oi/VFWBT 5FDOPMPHBT
3FQSPEVDUJWBTZ(FOUJDBT UJDBZ'F
NJOJTNP-B$FMFCSBDJOEFM5FNPSwo
GVF EFGFOEJEB FO  &O   MB
0SHBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF 4BMVE
JOTUJUVZ FM QSFNJP i.BOVFM 7FMBTDP
4VSF[ EF #JPUJDBw  DPO FM QSPQTJUP
EF QSFNJBS KWFOFT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOPTEFCJPUJDB&MQSFNJPZB
IBTJEPPUPSHBEPDVBUSPWFDFT TJFNQSF
QBSBNVKFSFT
 &OFMQSJNFSDPODVSTPGVFBQSPCBEB.BSJMFOB
$PSSB  Z %FCPSB %JOJ[ GVF VOB EF MBT FWB
MVBEPSBT EFM KVSBEP &O FM TFHVOEP DPODVSTP 
%FCPSB%JOJ[GVFMBDBOEJEBUBBQSPCBEB-PT
DPODVSTPT SFQSFTFOUBO VO NBSDP JNQPSUBOUF
QBSB MB JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJO EF MB EJTDJQMJOB 
QVFT TJHOJmDB FM SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EF MB DPNV
OJEBEBDBENJDBBMTVSHJNJFOUPEFVOBOVFWB
FTQFDJBMJEBE
 3PUBOJB  " 
 /PWBT 5FDOPMPHJBT 3FQSP
EVUJWBTF(FOUJDBT UJDBF'FNJOJTNP"$FMF
CSBPEP5FNPS3JPEF+BOFJSP6'3+*OTUJ
UVUP"MCFSUP-VJ[$PJNCSBEF1PT(SBEVBP
F1FTRVJTBEF&OHFOIBSJBo$011&<5FTFEF
%PVUPSBEP  1SPHSBNB EF 1PT(SBEVBP FN
&OHFOIBSJB>
 &OMBQSJNFSBFEJDJO FO %FCPSB%JOJ[ 
CSBTJMFB GVFMBHBOBEPSBDPOFMUFNBi*OGPSNB
DJOHFOUJDBZKVTUJDJBVOEFTBGPCJPUJDPwFO
MBTFHVOEB 3PTB"OHFMJOB1BDF BSHFOUJOB DPO
FMUFNBi5SBTQMBOUFTEFSHBOPTZMBFOTFBO[B

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

0USP BTQFDUP EFM QSPUBHPOJTNP BDBE


NJDPEFMBTNVKFSFTQBSBMBQSPNPDJO
EF MB CJPUJDB BDFSDB B #SBTJM B PUSPT
QBTFT EF MB SFHJO  FO FTQFDJBM "SHFO
UJOB  $IJMF Z $PMPNCJB %FCJEP B MB
FTDBTBQSPEVDDJOEFMJUFSBUVSBCJPUJDB
FO "NSJDB -BUJOB  MB QSJNFSB EDBEB
EF JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJO GVF EF JOUFOTP
JOUFSDBNCJP EF JEFBT FOUSF MB SFHJO Z
MPT QBTFT DFOUSBMFT EF MB EJTDJQMJOB  FO
FTQFDJBM&TUBEPT6OJEPT&OFMDBTPFT
UBEPVOJEFOTF MBCJPUJDBOPTPMBNFOUF
FTUBCBDPOTPMJEBEBFOMBTVOJWFSTJEBEFT
Z FO FM EFCBUF QCMJDP  TJOP RVF  UBN
CJO MBEFJOTQJSBDJOGFNJOJTUBFSBZB
QBSUFEFMBPSHBOJ[BDJOZEJTUSJCVDJO
EFMDBNQP-BEJTUSJCVDJOSFHJPOBMEFM
DPOPDJNJFOUP BTPDJBEB B MB JNQPSUB
DJO EF UFPSBT DSUJDBT GFNJOJTUBT IJ[P
RVF SQJEBNFOUF MBCJPUJDBGFNJOJTUB
UBNCJO DSFDJFSB FO "NSJDB -BUJOB 
FTQFDJBMNFOUF FO MPT QBTFT DPO QPT
HSBEPFTUSVDUVSBEP "SHFOUJOB #SBTJMZ
.YJDP

&M JOUFSDBNCJP EF JEFBT PDVSSJ  CTJ
DBNFOUF  QPS NFEJP EF MBT FOUJEBEFT
DJFOUmDBTFOCJPUJDBRVFTVSHBOFOMPT
BPT-PTFODVFOUSPTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFT
FSBO FTQBDJPT QSPQJDJPT QBSB MB GPSNB
DJO EF BMJBO[BT -B 3FE *OUFSOBDJPOBM
EF1FSTQFDUJWBT'FNJOJTUBTQBSBMB#JP
UJDB '"#
QBSUJDJQBBDUJWBNFOUFFOMB
EF MB CJPUJDBw FO MB UFSDFSB  .BSB (SBDJFMB
0SU[BS BSHFOUJOB DPOi+VTUJDJBJOUFSOBDJPOBM 
EFSFDIP B MB TBMVE  QSPQJFEBE JOUFMFDUVBM Z FM
HFOPNBIVNBOPw ZFOMBDVBSUB FO MB
BSHFOUJOB1BUSJDJB4PSPLJODPOMBQSPQVFTUBEF
USBCBKPUJUVMBEBi5SBUBNJFOUPEFMPTEBUPTQFS
TPOBMFTFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJOHFONJDBBTQFDUPT
CJPUJDPT MFHBMFTZTPDJBMFTw 1")&' 






-BCJPUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN

QSJODJQBM FOUJEBE DJFOUmDB JOUFSOBDJP


OBM EF CJPUJDB MB "TPDJBDJO *OUFSOB
DJPOBMEF#JPUJDB *"#
EFTEFTVGVO
EBDJOFO:BFO MB'"#
PSHBOJ[ FM QSJNFS DPOHSFTP TBUMJUF BM
DPOHSFTP EF MB *"# Z  EFTEF FOUPODFT 
FTMBSFENTBDUJWBZDPONTQBSUJDJ
QBOUFT-BFOUSBEBEF'"#FO"NSJDB
-BUJOB BDPNQB MB QSPQJB GPSNBDJO
EFMBSFE DPO"MFKBOESB3PUBOJBDPNP
QSJNFSBSFQSFTFOUBOUFFO)BTUB
BIPSB  '"# DVFOUB DPO SFQSFTFOUBOUFT
EF"SHFOUJOB #SBTJM $IJMF $PMPNCJBZ
.YJDPBEFNT #SBTJMGVFTFEFEFVOP
EFMPTDPOHSFTPTNVOEJBMFTFO
-B JOTFSDJO EF MBT JOWFTUJHBEPSBT MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOBT FO '"# GVF VO QBTP EF
DJTJWPQBSBMBQSPGFDBBVUPDVNQMJEBEF
MBTNVKFSFTDPNPFTQFDJBMJTUBTFOUFNBT
SFQSPEVDUJWPT'"#FTVOBSFEEFJOWFT
UJHBEPSBT Z BDBENJDBT EFEJDBEBT B MB
UFNUJDBEFMBSFQSPEVDDJO MBUJDBZMB
CJPUJDB CBKPMBQFSTQFDUJWBUFSJDBEFM
GFNJOJTNP
&M GFNJOJTNP  DPNP VOB IFSSBNJFOUB
FQJTUFNPMHJDB QBSB MBT IVNBOJEBEFT 
FNFSHJ FO MPT BPT  Z MPT DBNQPT
EF MB UJDB Z EF MB mMPTPGB NPSBM GVF
SPO MPT NT EJSFDUBNFOUF QSPWPDBEPT
QPS TVT QFSTQFDUJWBT DSUJDBT )BSEJOH 
 )BZVOJOUFOTPJOUFSDBNCJPEFJEFBTFOUSFMB
*"# Z MB '"# 'MPSFODJB -VOB  QPS FKFNQMP 
FTVOBEFMBTFYQSFTJEFOUBTEF*"#ZQBSUJDJQB
BDUJWBNFOUFEF'"#
 "NSJDB-BUJOBZBDPOUDPOSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEF
QBT %FCPSB %JOJ[ #SBTJM
 GVF SFQSFTFOUBOUF
EFMBEJSFDUJWBEFB 4VTBOB4PN
NFS "SHFOUJOB
EFBZ BDUVBMNFO
UF  "OB $SJTUJOB (PO[MF[ 7FM[ $PMPNCJB

'"# 


PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

 )BSBXBZ   )BSBXBZ FU BM 



 3QJEBNFOUF  MBT DPOUSJCVDJP
OFT GFNJOJTUBT DPNFO[BSPO UBNCJO
B GPSNBS QBSUF EFM EFCBUF CSBTJMFP FO
CJPUJDB MPRVFSFQSFTFOU BTVWF[ VOB
SFTJTUFODJBBMBNBTJmDBDJOEFMBUFPSB
EFMPTDVBUSPQSJODJQJPTEF5PN#FBV
DIBNQZ+BNFT$IJMESFTT 8PMG 
%JOJ[  (VJMIFN   #FBVDIBNQ
 $IJMESFTT  
 $PO MB BDUVBDJO
EFMBTJOWFTUJHBEPSBTFO'"#ZFO*"#
TFBNQMJFMIPSJ[POUFEFEFCBUFUFSJDP
ZUFNUJDP MPRVFGPSUBMFDJFMFTGVFS[P
EFMPTUFMPHPTDBUMJDPTEFEFWPMWFSMB
CJPUJDBBMBTIVNBOJEBEFT FOFTQFDJBM
BMBUJDBTPDJBM
1FSP VOP EF MPT QSJODJQBMFT EFTBGPT
QBSB MB FOUSBEB EF MBT QFSTQFDUJWBT GF
NJOJTUBTFOMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
GVF TVQFSBS MB SFTJTUFODJB B MB DBUFHPSB
iGFNJOJTNPw %JOJ[  
 &M NPWJ
NJFOUP GFNJOJTUB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP QP
TFF VOB BNQMJB IJTUPSJB EF DPORVJTUBT
TPDJBMFT  FTQFDJBMNFOUF BM QBSUJDJQBS FO
DPOUSPWFSTJBT RVF HBSBOUJ[BO MPT EFSF
DIPTQPMUJDPTZTPDJBMFT4JOFNCBSHP MB
FTUSBUFHJBEFBDDJOEFMPTNPWJNJFOUPT
TPDJBMFTGVFNBZPSJUBSJBNFOUFQPMUJDBZ
FMFTQBDJPEFBDUVBDJOGVFMBTPDJFEBE
DJWJMZMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTCTJDBTEFM&TUB
EP -B JOTFSDJO EFM GFNJOJTNP FO MBT
VOJWFSTJEBEFT OP GVF DPOTJEFSBEB VOB
QSJPSJEBEFOMBTBDDJPOFTQPMUJDBTEFMBT
NVKFSFT EVSBOUF VO MBSHP QFSPEP /P
FTFYBHFSBEPBmSNBSRVFMBFOUSBEBEF
MBCJPUJDBGFNJOJTUBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB
DPJODJEJDPOFMTVSHJNJFOUPEFMBFQJT
UFNPMPHB GFNJOJTUB FO MBT VOJWFSTJEB
EFT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

&OUSFZ VOBFTUSBUFHJBBEPQ
UBEB QPS BMHVOPT HSVQPT EF NVKFSFT FO
MBTVOJWFSTJEBEFTGVFEFmOJSTFDPNPFT
QFDJBMJTUBTFOHOFSP FWJUBOEPBTMBSF
GFSFODJBBMGFNJOJTNP %JOJ['PMUSBO 

 -B TVCTUJUVDJO EF MB
DBUFHPSB iGFNJOJTNPw QPS MB EF iHOF
SPwQFSNJUBMBEFCJEBJOTFSDJOEJTDJQMJ
OBSEFMBTJOWFTUJHBEPSBTFOMPTFTUVEJPT
TPCSF NVKFSFT  QFSP EFTWJBCB FM FOGSFO
UBNJFOUP BSHVNFOUBUJWP QSPWPDBEP QPS
MBSFGFSFODJBBMGFNJOJTNP&TBGVF QP
TJCMFNFOUF VOBEFDJTJOEFTVQFSWJWFO
DJBBDBENJDBDPNOBWBSJBTJOWFTUJHB
EPSBTMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT FOFTQFDJBMBMBT
JOTFSUBT FO VOJWFSTJEBEFT DPOGFTJPOBMFT
%JOJ[ 
-BFOUSBEBEFMB
CJPUJDBGFNJOJTUBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBDP
JODJEJDPOVOBGBTFEFSFDPOPDJNJFOUP
EFMBTGSPOUFSBTFQJTUFNPMHJDBTFOUSFFM
GFNJOJTNPZFMHOFSP MPRVFGBDJMJUMB
QSPQJBJEFOUJmDBDJOEFMBTKWFOFTJOWFT
UJHBEPSBTEFCJPUJDBDPNPGFNJOJTUBT
)BZ EJGFSFODJBT JNQPSUBOUFT FOUSF MBT
QFSTQFDUJWBTGFNJOJTUBTZEFHOFSPFOFM
QFOTBNJFOUPDJFOUmDP 8PMG 
&M
GFNJOJTNPQBSUFEFVODPNQSPNJTPEF
DSUJDBQPMUJDBBMBTVQVFTUBOFVUSBMJEBE
EFHOFSPEFMBDJFODJBZBTVNFMBUBSFB
EF SFEFTDSJCJS FM EJTDVSTP BDBENJDP
FOUSNJOPTNTKVTUPTQBSBMPTHSVQPT
TVCBMUFSOPT 1PS FTP  MB DBUFHPSB WVM
OFSBCJMJEBEFTUBOTFEVDUPSBQBSBMBTJO
WFTUJHBEPSBTGFNJOJTUBTEFMBCJPUJDBBM
NJTNPUJFNQPRVFSFTVNFMBGSBHJMJEBE
EFBMHVOPTHSVQPT EFNBOEBQSPUFDDJO
ZDVJEBEPBMPTRVFWJWFOFTBEFTJHVBM
EBE (VJMIFN  
 "M DPOUSBSJP EF
MPT FTUVEJPT EF HOFSP  MBT QFSTQFDUJWBT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

GFNJOJTUBT TPO DPNQSPNFUJEBT DPO MB


JOUFSWFODJO FO FM NVOEP SFBM : GVF
FYBDUBNFOUFFTFFOGPRVFUFSJDPZNFUP
EPMHJDPEFMBCJPUJDBGFNJOJTUBMPRVF
MBIJ[PUBOTFEVDUPSBBMBTKWFOFTJOWFT
UJHBEPSBTEFMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
-BTQFSTQFDUJWBTGFNJOJTUBTEFMBCJPUJDB
GPSUBMFDJFSPOFMFTGVFS[PEFEJMPHPQPM
UJDPZBJOJDJBEPQPSMPTNPWJNJFOUPTEF
NVKFSFTFO"NSJDB-BUJOB-BCJPUJDB
GFNJOJTUB TF USBOTGPSN FO VOB OVFWB
IFSSBNJFOUBBSHVNFOUBUJWB FOFTQFDJBM
QPSMBDSFDJFOUFMBJDJ[BDJOEFMPTFTQB
DJPTQCMJDPTFOMBSFHJO"MDPOUSBSJP
EFMPTQBTFTDFOUSBMFTEFMBCJPUJDB FO
MPTDVBMFTFMTVSHJNJFOUPEFMBEJTDJQMJ
OBTFEJPFODPOUFYUPTDPOTUJUVDJPOBMFT
EF TFDVMBSJ[BDJO EFM &TUBEP  FO "N
SJDB -BUJOB FYJTUFO QBTFT FO MPT RVF FM
FKFSDJDJP EF MB QMVSJDPOGFTJPOBMJEBE EFM
&TUBEPEFTFTUBCJMJ[BBMBEFNPDSBDJB&O
FTUFDPOUFYUP MPTUFNBTCJPUJDPTEFFT
QFDJBMJEBEEFMBTJOWFTUJHBEPSBTGFNJOJT
UBTTPOMPTRVFFYJHFONTFTGVFS[PEF
JOUFSMPDVDJOQCMJDB
-BEFmOJDJOEFVOBBHFOEBSFHJPOBMEF
JOWFTUJHBDJO Z QSPEVDDJO JOUFMFDUVBM
GFNJOJTUB FO MB CJPUJDB DPOTJEFS FTB
EPCMF JOTFSDJO EF MBT JOWFTUJHBEPSBT
QSPUBHPOJTUBT BDBENJDBT F JOUFSMPDV
UPSBTQCMJDBT$JFSUPTUFNBT DPNPFM
 6OFTQBDJPQSJWJMFHJBEPQBSBBOBMJ[BSFTBEPCMF
JOTFSDJOEFMBTNVKFSFTFOMBCJPUJDBCSBTJMF
BQVFEFTFSMBIJTUPSJBEFMBQBSUJDJQBDJOFO
MPT DPNJUT EF UJDB FO JOWFTUJHBDJO Z FO MB
$PNJTJO/BDJPOBMEFUJDBFO*OWFTUJHBDJO
#SBTJM   Z 
 -BT NVKFSFT UVWJFSPO
QBSUJDJQBDJO EFDJTJWB EFTEF MB GPSNBDJO EFM
HSVQPNVMUJEJTDJQMJOBSJPEFUSBCBKP JOTUJUVJEP
QBSBFMBCPSBSMB3FTPMVDJO





-BCJPUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN

BCPSUP TJFNQSFFTUVWJFSPOFOFMFTDFOB
SJPEFMBTEJTDVTJPOFTCJPUJDBTJOUFSOB
DJPOBMFT QFSPMBSFBMJEBEMBUJOPBNFSJDB
OB FYJHB EF MBT NVKFSFT FO MB CJPUJDB
VOB SFEFTDSJQDJO EF MBT QFSTQFDUJWBT
JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT "M DPOUSBSJP RVF FO FM
EFCBUF CJPUJDP FTUBEPVOJEFOTF P GSBO
DT TPCSF FM BCPSUP  EPOEF TF BWBO[B
FOVOBBSHVNFOUBDJOSB[POBCMFTPCSF
FM FTUBUVUP EFM FNCSJO Z EFM GFUP  FO
"NSJDB-BUJOBFMNBSDPUFSJDPUPEBWB
FTMBOFDFTJEBEEFMBJDJ[BDJOEFM&TUBEP
QBSBFMEFCBUFQCMJDPTPCSFDVFTUJPOFT
SFQSPEVDUJWBT0TFB BMNJTNPUJFNQP
RVF NVZQSFDP[NFOUF TFFTUSVDUVSBCBO
MB[PT BDBENJDPT FOUSF JOWFTUJHBEPSBT
GFNJOJTUBT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT Z PUSBT EF
QBTFT DFOUSBMFT  UBNCJO TF QSPNPWB
VO FTQSJUV DSUJDP Z QMVSBM GSFOUF B MBT
FTUSBUFHJBTBSHVNFOUBUJWBT6OBQPTJCMF
DPOTFDVFODJBEFFTFFKFSDJDJPBSHVNFO
UBUJWPTFOTJCMFBMBTQBSUJDVMBSJEBEFTDVM
UVSBMFT FT MB BQSPYJNBDJO DSFDJFOUF EF
KWFOFT JOWFTUJHBEPSBT QSPWFOJFOUFT EF
MBT IVNBOJEBEFT B MB CJPUJDB MBUJOPB
NFSJDBOB

.VKFSFTZOVFWPTEFTBGPT
&MIFDIPEFRVFMBCJPUJDBTFBVODBN
QP FNFSHFOUF  BCSF FTQBDJP QBSB RVF
EJGFSFOUFTHSVQPT MFOHVBKFTZEJTDVSTPT
CVTRVFO SFDPOPDJNJFOUP FO MB DPNV
OJEBE&TFDBSDUFSMBUSBOTGPSNBFOVO
FTQBDJP JMJNJUBEP EF QPTJCJMJEBEFT EF
EJMPHPZEFFYQSFTJOBSHVNFOUBUJWB
&T DSFDJFOUF TV UFOUBUJWB EF EFmOJSTF
DPNP VOB EJTDJQMJOB BDBENJDB Z  QPS
UBOUP  FM FTGVFS[P QFSNBOFOUF EF MBT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

NVKFSFT FO MB CJPUJDB FT UBNCJO QPS


HBSBOUJ[BS MB JODMVTJO EFM GFNJOJTNP
DPNPIFSSBNJFOUBBOBMUJDB)PZ HSBO
QBSUFEFMPTQSPHSBNBTEFQPTHSBEPFO
TBMVE P IVNBOJEBEFT DPO BTJHOBUVSBT
EF CJPUJDB FO MPT DVSSDVMPT JODMVZF
SFGFSFODJBT GFNJOJTUBT JOUFSOBDJPOBMFT Z
SFHJPOBMFT &TB FT VOB USBOTGPSNBDJO
JNQPSUBOUFFYQFSJNFOUBEBFOMBMUJNB
EDBEBEFJOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJOEFMBCJP
UJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB
&O FTUF FTGVFS[P EF QFSNBOFODJB Z FY
QBOTJO VOBEFMBTQSJODJQBMFTDPOUSJCV
DJPOFT EF MBT NVKFSFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT
IBTJEPFMSFDPOPDJNJFOUPEFEJGFSFOUFT
FTQBDJPT EF EJTDVTJO Z FTUSBUFHJBT EF
EJMPHP ZOPTPMBNFOUFMBTVOJWFSTJEB
EFTZMBTQVCMJDBDJPOFTFOUSFQBSFT*OJ
DJBUJWBTDPNPMBTCSBTJMFBTZNFYJDBOBT
EFQSPEVDDJOEFWJEFPTZEPDVNFOUB
MFTTPOVOFKFNQMPEFFTFFTGVFS[PQPS
BNQMJBS FM IPSJ[POUF EF QSPUBHPOJTNP
BDBENJDP Z EF JOUFSMPDVDJO QCMJDB 
GBDJMJUBOEP MB DPNQSFOTJO EF MPT BS
HVNFOUPT CJPUJDPT %JOJ[  #SVN 
 $''  
 0USP FKFNQMP EF
FTB EJWFSTJEBE EF MFOHVBKFT FT MB JOTFS
DJO FO JOTUJUVDJPOFT EF JOWFTUJHBDJO 
VOJWFSTJEBEFT  NPWJNJFOUPT TPDJBMFT Z
PSHBOJ[BDJPOFTOPHVCFSOBNFOUBMFT VO
GFONFOPPCTFSWBEPFOUSFUPEBTMBTJO
WFTUJHBEPSBTGFNJOJTUBTNTBDUJWBTEFMB
CJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
$PO UPEP  MB BDUJWJEBE DVFOUB UPEBWB
DPO QPDBT NVKFSFT &TB FYQSFTJO EF
TJHVBM EF HOFSP FT VO SFTRVJDJP EF TV
HOFTJT DVZBBQSPYJNBDJODPOMBTEJT
DJQMJOBT NEJDBT Z UFPMHJDBT SFTUSJOHB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

MB QBSUJDJQBDJO EF MBT NVKFSFT 0USB


QPTJCMFFYQMJDBDJOFTRVFMBBDUVBDJO
QSPGFTJPOBMFYDMVTJWBFOCJPUJDBFTSBSB
UPEBWBFOMBSFHJOMBmHVSBEFMCJPFUJ
DJTUBQSPGFTJPOBMFTUQPSTFSJOTUJUVJEB
-B QSJNFSB HFOFSBDJO EF FTQFDJBMJTUBT

FO CJPUJDB  PSJVOEB EF VOJWFSTJEBEFT


MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT  FTU TJFOEP GPSNB
EB$POMBFYQBOTJOFOMBSFHJOZMB
DSFDJFOUFQSPGFTJPOBMJ[BDJOEFMBTNV
KFSFT FTEFFTQFSBSVOSQJEPDBNCJPFO
MBDPOmHVSBDJOEFHOFSP

3FGFSFODJBT
"OESF + 
#JPFUIJDTBTTPNFUIJOHOFX #JPFUIJDTBTBUFSSJUPSZBOBMMFHPSZ5IF
MBOHVBHFPGCJPFUIJDT #JPFUIJDTBTQSBDUJDF *O"OESF +#JPFUIJDTBT1SBDUJDF/PSUI
$BSPMJOB 5IF6OJWFSTJUZPG/PSUI$BSPMJOB1SFTT QQ
"OKPT .' 
0DPSQPOPFTQFMIPEBEJHOJEBEFFEBWVMOFSBCJMJEBEF0.VOEP
EB4BEF  
QQ
#BSDIJGPOUBJOF $1 
#JPUJDBF*ODJPEB7JEB"MHVOT%FTBGJPT4P1BVMP *EJBT
F-FUSBT
#FBVDIBNQ 5$IJMESFTT + 
1SJODJQBMTPG#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT0YGPSE 0YGPSE
6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT
#PVSEJFV 1 
"HOFTFEPTDPODFJUPTEFIBCJUVTFDBNQP&O#PVSEJFV1 0
1PEFS4JNCMJDP3JPEF+BOFJSP #FSUSBOE#SBTJM QQ
#PVSEJFV  1 
 $BNQP EP QPEFS  DBNQP JOUFMFDUVBM F IBCJUVT EF DMBTTF &O
#PVSEJFV1 "&DPOPNJBEBT5SPDBT4JNCMJDBT4P1BVMP 1FSTQFDUJWB QQ

#SBHB  ,4 
 " $PNVOJDBP $JFOUGJDB F B #JPUJDB #SBTJMFJSB #SBTMJB  6O# 
%FQBSUBNFOUPEF$JODJBEB*OGPSNBPF%PDVNFOUBP<1SPKFUPEF%PVUPSBEP 
1SPHSBNBEF1T(SBEVBPFN$JODJBEB*OGPSNBP>
#SBTJM .JOJTUSJP EB 4BEF $POTFMIP /BDJPOBM EF 4BEF 
 /PSNBT
3FHVMBNFOUBEPSBT4PCSF1FTRVJTBT&OWPMWFOEP4FSFT)VNBOPT#SBTJM $/4
#SBTJM.JOJTUSJPEB4BEF$POTFMIP/BDJPOBMEF4BEF 
$PNPGVODJPOBB
$POFQ$BEFSOPTEFUJDBFN1FTRVJTB  
$BUIPMJDJTGPSB'SFF$IPJDF 
/P&TUT4PMB8BTIJOHUPO%$ $BUIPMJDJTGPSB
'SFF$IPJDF<%PDVNFOUSJP>
$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUSJP4P$BNJMP 
$VSTPTEF1T(SBEVBP<0OMJOF>%JTQPOJCMF
FOIUUQXXXTDBNJMPFEVCS
$POTFMIP'FEFSBMEF.FEJDJOB 
3FWJTUB#JPUJDB<0OMJOF>%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQ
XXXQPSUBMNFEJDPPSHCSSFWJTUBCJPWJOEFYIUN

 %FCFFOUFOEFSTFQPSFTQFDJBMJTUBTFOFTUBEJTDJQMJOBBMPTKWFOFTJOWFTUJHBEPSFTDPOEPDUPSBEPFOCJP
UJDBPTPCSFCJPUJDB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



-BCJPUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN



$PSSB . 


/PWBTUFDOPMPHJBTSFQSPEVUJWBTEPBPEFWVMPT0RVFQPEFTFS
OPWPOFTTFDBNQP $BEFSOPTEF4BEF1CMJDB  
QQ
$PSSB . 
/PWBT5FDOPMPHJBT3FQSPEVUJWBT-JNJUFTEB#JPMPHJBPV#JPMPHJB4FN
-JNJUFT 3JPEF+BOFJSP &E6&3+
$PSSB . 
1FSTQFDUJWBTEBCJPUJDBOP#SBTJM1PMNJDB  QQ
$PTUB 4*' 0TFMLB ((BSSBGB 7 
*OJDJBP#JPUJDB#SBTMJB $POTFMIP
'FEFSBMEF.FEJDJOB
%JOJ[  % &EJUPSJBM
 
 &EVDBP NEJDB UBNCN  VNB RVFTUP EF HOFSP
3FWJTUBEF&EVDBP.EJDB  
QQ
%JOJ[ % 
2VBOEPBWFSEBEFQPTUBFNEWJEB&O%JOJ[ % #VHMJPOF 4
3JPT33 0SHT
&OUSFB%WJEBFP%PHNB-JCFSEBEFEF$UFESBF6OJWFSTJEBEFT
$POGFTTJPOBJT#SBTMJB -FUSBT-JWSFT1PSUP"MFHSF -JWSBSJBEP"EWPHBEP QQ
%JOJ[ % 
0%FTBGJPEB#JPUJDB'FNJOJTUBOP#SBTJM/PQSFMP
%JOJ[  %  #SVN  & 
 6NB )JTUSJB 4FWFSJOB #SBTMJB  *NBHFOT-JWSFT
<%PDVNFOUSJP>
%JOJ[ %(PNFT 3 
*OGFSUJMJEBEFJOGFDVOEJEBEBDFTTPBOVFWBTUFDOPMPHBT
SFQSPEVDUJWBT &O $DFSFT  $  $BSFBHB  (  'SBTDB  5  1FDIFOZ . 0SHT

4FYVBMJEBE  &TUJHNB Z %FSFDIPT )VNBOPT %FTBGJPT QBSB FM "DFTTP B MB 4BMVE FO
"NSJDB-BUJOB-JNB '"41"61$) QQ
%JOJ[ %'PMUSBO 1 
(OFSPFGFNJOJTNPOP#SBTJMVNBBOMJTFEB3FWJTUB
&TUVEPT'FNJOJTUBT3FWJTUBEF&TUVEPT'FNJOJTUBT  /FTQFD
QQ
%JOJ[ %(VJMIFN % 
#JPUJDBGFNJOJTUBPSFTHBUFQPMUJDPEPDPODFJUPEF
WVMOFSBCJMJEBEF#JPUJDB  
QQ
%JOJ[ %(VJMIFN % 
'FNJOJTNP CJPUJDBFWVMOFSBCJMJEBEF3FWJTUB&TUVEPT
'FNJOJTUBT  
QQ
%JOJ[ %(VJMIFN % 
02VF#JPUJDB4P1BVMP #SBTJMJFOTF
%JOJ[ % (VJMIFN %(BSSBGB 7 
#JPFUIJDTJO#SB[JM#JPFUIJDT  QQ

%JOJ[ %7FMF[ "$( 
#JPUJDBGFNJOJTUBBFNFSHODJBEBEJGFSFOB3FWJTUB
&TUVEPT'FNJOJTUBT  
QQ
%JOJ[ %7FMF[ "$( 
"CPSUPZSB[OQCMJDBFMEFTBGPEFMBBOFODFGBMJB
FO#SBTJM&O$IFDB 4 0SH
3FBMJEBEFTZ$PZVOUVSBTEFM"CPSUP#VFOPT"JSFT 
1BJET QQ
'FNJOJTU"QQSPBDIFTUP#JPFUIJDT 
/FXTMFUUFS<0OMJOF>%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQ
XXXGBCOFUPSH
(BSSBGB 7 %JOJ[ %(VJMIFN % 
#JPFUIJDBMMBOHVBHFBOEJUTEJBMFDUTBOE
JEJPMFDUT$BEFSOPTEF4BEF1CMJDB  TVQM
QQ
(FCBSB * 
3PNQFOEPP4JMODJP1FUSQPMJT 7P[FT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

(FCBSB * 


/PWBTSFMBFTEFHOFSPTPQPTTWFJT<0OMJOF>%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQ
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBPSHUFYUPTQPSUVHVFT(FCBSBIUN
(SJTBSE / 
UJDBNEJDBFCJPUJDBBEJTDJQMJOBRVFGBMUBOBHSBEVBPNEJDB
#JPUJDB  
QQ
(VJMIFN % 
#JPUJDBGFNJOJTUBFPDPODFJUPEFWVMOFSBCJMJEBEFOBTQFTRVJTBT
CJPNEJDBTFOWPMWFOEPTFSFTIVNBOPT&O4PSPLJO1 0SH
#JPUJDB&OUSF6UPQBT
Z%FTBSSBJHPT-JCSP)PNFOBKFBMB1SPG%SB(MBEZT+.BDLJOTPO#VFOPT"JSFT 
&EJUPSB"E)PD QQ
(VJMIFN % 
&TDSBWBTEP3JTDP#JPUJDB .VMIFSFTF"*%4#SBTMJB &EJUPSB6O#
'JOBUFD
)BSBXBZ % 
4JNJBOT $ZCPSHT BOE8PNFO5IF3FJOWFOUJPOPG/BUVSF/FX
:PSL 3PVUMFEHF
)BSBXBZ % 4IFMMFZ . 1FSLJOT ( FUBM 
6OGBNJMJBM#POET5FDIOPMPHJDBM
'JDUJPOBOEUIF3FJNBHJOBUJPOPG(FOEFS"OO"SCPS 1SP2VFTU6.*
)BSEJOH 4 
4DJFODFBOE4PDJBM*OFRVBMJUZ'FNJOJTUBOE1PTUDPMPOJBM*TTVFT 3BDF
BOE(FOEFSJO4DJFODF
$IJDBHP$IBNQBJO6OJWFSTJUZPG*MMJOPJT1SFTT
-PZPMB  . 
 1JFSSF #PVSEJFV &OUSFWJTUBEP QPS .BSJB "OESB -PZPMB 3JP EF
+BOFJSP &E6&3+
-VOB ' 
3B[POFTJOUFSOBTZMBEJTDVTJOBDFSDBEFMBCPSUP.PSB  
QQ
<6OJWFSTJEBEEF#VFOPT"JSFT>
0MJWFJSB  ' 
 'JMIPT EB 5FDOPMPHJB RVFTUFT UJDBT EB QSPDSJBP BTTJTUJEB 0
.VOEPEB4BEF  
QQ
0MJWFJSB  ' 
 "T OPWBT UFDOPMPHJBT SFQSPEVUJWBT DPODFQUJWBT B TFSWJP EB
NBUFSJBMJ[BPEFEFTFKPTTFYJTUBT SBDJTUBTFFVHOJDPT #JPUJDB  
QQ
0MJWFJSB  ' 
 'FNJOJTNP  SBBFUOJB  QPCSF[B F CJPUJDB B CVTDB EB KVTUJB EF
HOFSP BOUJSBDJTUBFEFDMBTTF&O(BSSBGB71FTTJOJ- 0SHT
#JPUJDB1PEFS
F*OKVTUJB4P1BVMP -PZPMB QQ
0MJWFJSB ' 'FSSB[ 5$'FSSFJSB -$0 
*EJBTGFNJOJTUBTTPCSFCJPUJDB
3FWJTUBEF&TUVEPT'FNJOJTUBT  
QQ
0MJWFJSB '.PUB +"$ 
#JPUJDBFBTNVMIFSFT&O3FEF/BDJPOBM'FNJOJTUB
EF4BEFF%JSFJUPT3FQSPEVUJWPT4BEFEB.VMIFSF%JSFJUPT3FQSPEVUJWPT%PTTJT
4P1BVMP 3FEF4BEF QQ
0SHBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE 
 1SPHSBNB EF #JPUJDB <0OMJOF>
%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXXQBIPPSHTQBOJTICJPIPNFIUN
1BO "NFSJDBO )FBMUI BOE &EVDBUJPO 'PVOEBUJPO 
 1SFNJP .BOVFM 7FMBTDP
4VSF[%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXXQBIFGPSHBXBSETCJPFUIJDT@FTPWFSWJFX
1FTTJOJ -#BSDIGPOUBJOF $1 
'VOEBNFOUPTEF#JPUJDB4P1BVMP -PZPMB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



-BCJPUJDBZMBTNVKFSFTFO"NSJDB-BUJOB%FCPSB%JOJ[Z%JSDF(VJMIFN



1FTTJOJ -#FSUBDIJOJ - 


/PWBTQFSTQFDUJWBTFNDVJEBEPTQBMJBUJWPTUJDB 
HFSJBUSJB HFSPOUPMPHJB DPNVOJDBPFFTQSJUVBMJEBEF0.VOEPEB4BEF  

QQ
3PUBOJB  " 
 /PWBT 5FDOPMPHJBT 3FQSPEVUJWBT F (FOUJDBT  UJDB F 'FNJOJTNP "
$FMFCSBPEP5FNPS3JPEF+BOFJSP 6'3+*OTUJUVUP"MCFSUP-VJ[$PJNCSBEF1T
(SBEVBPF1FTRVJTBEF&OHFOIBSJB$011&<5FTFEF%PVUPSBEPo1SPHSBNBEF
1T(SBEVBPFN&OHFOIBSJB>
3PUBOJB  " 
 'PSNBT BUVBJT EF JOUFSWFOP OP DPSQP EBT NVMIFSFT VN
RVFTUJPOBNFOUP$BEFSOPEB4FNQSF7JWB.VMIFSFT $PSQPF4BEF QQ<0O
MJOF>%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXXCPFMMMBUJOPBNFSJDBPSHEPXOMPBE@QU
4JRVFJSB +& 4BLBJ .)&JTFMF 3- 
0&OTJOPEBUJDBOPDVSTPEF.FEJ
DJOBBFYQFSJODJBEB6OJWFSTJEBEF&TUBEVBMEF-POESJOB 6&-
#JPUJDB  

QQ
4PNNFS 4 
(FOUJDB $MPOBDJOZ#JPUJDB{$NP"GFDUBMB$JFODJB/VFTUSBT7J
EBT #VFOPT"JSFT #JCMPT
4PSPLJO 1 
#JPUJDB&OUSF6UPQBTZ%FTBSSBJHPT-JCSP)PNFOBKFBMB1SPG%SB
(MBEZT+.BDLJOTPO#VFOPT"JSFT &EJUPSJBM"E)PD
6OJUFE/BUJPOT&EVDBUJPOBM 4DJFOUJGJDBOE$VMUVSBM0SHBOJ[BUJPO 
6/&4$0
$IBJST<0OMJOF>%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQQPSUBMVOFTDPPSHFEVDBUJPOFTFW
7BMEFCFOJUP $ -BNB "-PMBT ' 
3FMBDJONVKFSZCJPUFDOPMPHBBQSPYJ
NBDJOBMJNQBDUPEFMBCJPUJDB"DUB#JPFUIJDB  
QQ
7FMBTDP4VSF[ . 
*9"OJWFSTBSJPEFMB$PNJTJO/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB$JVEBE
EF .YJDP <0OMJOF> %JTQPOJCMF FO IUUQXXXTBMVEHPCNYVOJEBEFTEHDT
TBMB@OPUJDJBTEJTDVSTPT
8PMG 4 
'FNJOJTN#JPFUIJDT#FZPOE3FQSPEVDUJPO0YGPSE 0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ
1SFTT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



1*7
1BTBEP QSFTFOUFZEFTBGPTGVUVSPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





6OBMFDUVSBDSUJDBEFMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
(FSNO$BMEFSO-FHBSEB

*EFOUJmDBOEPVOBQFSTQFDUJWBEF
BDFSDBNJFOUP

&

MUUVMPEFFTUFBSUDVMPQVFEFQBSF
DFS QSFUFODJPTP Z FM DBSHP OP TFSB
EFM UPEP JOGVOEBEP UBMWF[ TF QVFEB
NBUJ[BS EJDJFOEP RVF MB JOUFODJO OP
DPOTJTUFFOIJTUPSJBSMBCJPUJDBFO"N
SJDB-BUJOBTJOPFOEFTUBDBSBMHVOPTEF
TVT SBTHPT TPCSFTBMJFOUFT Z DNP TVT
GPSUBMF[BTPEFCJMJEBEFTIBOJOnVJEPFO
EFTBSSPMMPT QPTUFSJPSFT $VBMRVJFS WFS
EBEFSPJOUFOUPTFSJPEFDSUJDBUJFOFRVF
TFS  OFDFTBSJBNFOUF  EJBMHJDP Z  QPS
UBOUP FTUFOEFVEBEFTEFFMDPNJFO[P
DPORVJFOFTOPTQMBOUFBOMBTQSFHVOUBT
%FCFFOUFOEFSTFRVFTJTFQSPQPOFVOB
MFDUVSBDSUJDB UBNCJOFTVOIPNFOB
KFBUPEPTBRVFMMPTRVFFTUBCMFDJFSPOMB
SFnFYJO CJPUJDB FO "NSJDB -BUJOB
/P TF BTVNF RVF TFSB JOUFSFTBOUF OJ
UBNQPDP QPTJCMF BDPOTFKBS B FTUPT BV
UPSFT TPCSF DNP iEFCJ IBCFS TJEP FM
DPNJFO[P EF TV USBCBKP FO CJPUJDB FO
FTUFDPOUJOFOUFw-BWBRVFTFTJHVFFT
EJGFSFOUF TF QSPQPOF RVF  QBSUJFOEP
EFM SFDPOPDJNJFOUP EF MB JNQPSUBODJB
EFTVMBCPS SFDPNFOEFNPTVOBMFDUVSB
EFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB
-BUJOB DPO TVT GPSUBMF[BT Z EFCJMJEBEFT
Z TPCSFUPEP TJFOEPQSPQPTJUJWPTTPCSF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

MBGPSNBZDPOUFOJEPTRVFFTFEFTBSSPMMP
EFCFBEPQUBS-BIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPUJDB
FOOVFTUSPDPOUJOFOUFTFIBDPNFO[BEP
ZBBFTDSJCJSZBSFFTDSJCJS ZIPZUFOFNPT
MBQPTJCJMJEBEEFFTDVDIBSiPUSBTWPDFTw
-PMBT 4UFQLF  
 RVF DPOTUJUV
ZFO TV QSFIJTUPSJB /P QPEFNPT TJOP
TFOUJSBENJSBDJOZSFTQFUPQPSBRVFMMPT
RVFMBJOJDJBSPO QFSP QSFDJTBNFOUFQPS
FTP MFSFOEJSBNPTVOQPCSFIPNFOBKF
TJDPOWJSUJSBNPTOVFTUSBSFWFSFODJBFO
TBDSBMJ[BDJO Z OVFTUSBT QSFHVOUBT FO
GSNVMBTZBDPOWFOJEBT4JQPSBMHPFTU
QSFTFOUFMBCJPUJDBFOOVFTUSBSFHJOFT 
QSFDJTBNFOUF QPSRVFRVJFOFTMBJOJDJB
SPO CVTDBCBO QSPGVOEJ[BS FM FKFSDJDJP
EFMBDBQBDJEBEDSUJDB-BNJTNBDPOMB
RVFQPEFNPTIBDFSIPZVOBMFDUVSBEF
TVUSBCBKP

&MUSBCBKPEFMPTQJPOFSPTEFM
IVNBOJTNPNEJDP
.TRVFVOBUFOEFODJBEFmOJEB MPRVF
TFQVFEFWFSFOMBGBTFJOJDJBMFTVOBTJ
UVBDJOFOMBDVBMMBCJPUJDBTFWBHFT
UBOEP EJTDSFUBNFOUF DPNP VO NPWJ
NJFOUPZRVFSFTQPOEFBVOBJORVJFUVE
KVTUJmDBEB EF DPOUFTUBS OP TMP B QSP
CMFNBTiBDBENJDPTw TJOPBQSPCMFNBT
iSFBMFTw FO VO FTDFOBSJP DPNQMFKP  OP





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

BKFOP B DPOnJDUPT TPDJBMFT Z QPMUJDPT


1PSDPOTJHVJFOUF OPFTDBTVBMJEBERVF
MB UFOTJO FOUSF VOB QPTJCMF BEPQDJO
DSUJDBEFVOBCJPUJDBOPSUFBNFSJDBOB 
DPOTVOGBTJTFOMBBVUPOPNBZMPTEF
SFDIPTJOEJWJEVBMFTEFMQBDJFOUF ZVOB
BDUJUVE NVDIP NT QBUFSOBMJTUB  FO MB
RVF QSFEPNJOBCB VOB WJTJO DBUMJDP
SPNBOBFOMBQSDUJDBNEJDB TFIJDJFSB
QSFTFOUFBMDPNJFO[PEFFTUFNPWJNJFO
UP  DPNP CJFO MP BOPUB + " .BJOFUUJ
.BJOFUUJ 

-BCTRVFEBEFVOiIVNBOJTNPNEJ
DPwoOPTJFNQSFPSJHJOBEPFOVOBUSBEJ
DJOBOHMPTBKPOBoBMJNFOUMBSFnFYJO
TPCSF MB QSDUJDB TPDJBM EF MB NFEJDJOB
&TNSJUPEFRVJFOFTMJEFSBSPOFTUFNP
WJNJFOUP IBCFS JOWPMVDSBEP FO MB SF
nFYJO UBOUP MB USBEJDJO NFEJUFSSOFB
EF VOB BOUSPQPMPHB NEJDB mMPTmDB
-BO &OUSBMHP
 DPNP MPT BQPSUFT NT
FTQFDmDBNFOUF CJPUJDPT EF RVJFOFT 
EFTEF/PSUFBNSJDB TFPDVQBCBOEFMBT
IVNBOJEBEFTNEJDBT +5&OHFMIBSEU 
& 1FMMFHSJOP
 /P FT TUF FM MVHBS QBSB
DBMJmDBS FTF JOUFOUP EF DPOTUJUVJS VOB
GPSNB EF QFOTBNJFOUP  TJOP NT CJFO
QBSBTFBMBSRVFBRVFMMPRVF DPOFMQBTP
EFMUJFNQP TFDPOTUJUVZDPNPVOBCJP
UJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB MBFYQSFTJOQVF
EF UFOFS WBSJPT TFOUJEPT
 UVWP EFTEF FM
DPNJFO[PVOBMUPDPOUFOJEPEFSFnFYJO
UFSJDPmMPTmDBZ FOPDBTJPOFT mMPT
mDBKVSEJDB NEJDPTIVNBOJTUBT

&TUBQFSDFQDJOHFOFSBMDPOUSPWJFSUFVO
QPDPMBUFTJTEFRVFMBBVTFODJBEFVOB
USBEJDJO mMPTmDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB SF
UBSEBSBMBMMFHBEBEFMBCJPUJDB 'JHVF
SPBZ'VFO[BMJEB 


PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

t

t

t

2VJFOFT FTUBCMFDJFSPO FM NPWJ


NJFOUPEFMBTIVNBOJEBEFTNEJ
DBT Z  QPTUFSJPSNFOUF  MB CJPUJDB
OP FSBO mMTPGPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT  FO
FMTFOUJEPFORVFTFFOUFOEFSBIPZ
OPPCTUBOUF FSBOQFSTPOBTDPOVOB
CVFOB GPSNBDJO JOUFMFDUVBM  FO
NBSDBEB FO VOB USBEJDJO IVNB
OJTUB FOTVTFOUJEPDMTJDP
-PT FMFNFOUPT UFSJDPT FTUVWJFSPO
QSFTFOUFTEFTEFFMDPNJFO[PZFTUP
TFIBSFnFKBEPFOFMNPEPEFIBDFS
CJPUJDBFO-BUJOPBNSJDB VOQPDP
NTnFYJCMFZBNQMJB DPOMBTGPSUB
MF[BTZEFCJMJEBEFTRVFFTUPPGSFDF
-BT SFBMJEBEFT QPMUJDBT Z TPDJBMFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT OP GVFSPO BKFOBT
BFTUFUJQPEFSFnFYJO QPSNVDIP
RVFBMHVOPTEFMPTQSPUBHPOJTUBTEF
MBOBDJFOUFCJPUJDBRVJTJFSBOBEPQ
UBSFMNPEFMPEFMBCJPUJDBOPSUF
BNFSJDBOB

6O FUIPT QBSUJDVMBS oOP TJFNQSF DPO


EVDFOUF B MB EFNBSDBDJO FTUSJDUB EF
QSPCMFNBTOJBMBFTQFDJBMJ[BDJOEJTDJ
QMJOBSJB OJBKFOPBMBJODMVTJOEFQSP
CMFNBTTPDJBMFTRVFFOPUSBTMBUJUVEFTOP
TFSFDPOPDBODPNPQFSUFOFDJFOUFTBMB
CJPUJDBoMFEJPBFTUFUJQPEFSFnFYJO
DJFSUB BQFSUVSB FO OVFTUSP DPOUJOFOUF
"VORVF QVFEF SFTVMUBS QPMNJDP Z TV
GSJS MPT SJFTHPT EF VOB HFOFSBMJ[BDJO
TJONT TFQPESBOEFTDSJCJSUSFTSBTHPT
DBSBDUFSTUJDPTEFMBOBDJFOUFCJPUJDBMB
UJOPBNFSJDBOBRVF BVORVFNVDIPNT
NBUJ[BEPT  TF NBOUJFOFO IPZ FO EB 
QBSBCJFOPQBSBNBM
t

4V DBSDUFS UFSJDP FTUSFDIBNFOUF


WJODVMBEPBMBTiIVNBOJEBEFTw





6OBMFDUVSBDSUJDBEFMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB(FSNO$BMEFSO-FHBSEB

t

t

4FSCBTUBOUFJODMVZFOUF MPRVFGB
WPSFDF MB QBSUJDJQBDJO EF VO BN
QMJPHSVQPEFUFNBTZQSPCMFNBT
4FS VO NPWJNJFOUP TPDJBM RVF
BDPNQBBDJFSUBTGPSNBTEFBDUJWJT
NP"RVTFQVFEFOFODPOUSBSEJT
DVSTPTEFEJGFSFOUFUFOPS RVFWBO 
QPSFKFNQMP EFTEFQFSTQFDUJWBTGF
NJOJTUBTPEFRVJFOFTEFmFOEFOMPT
EFSFDIPTEFMBTNJOPSBTUOJDBT MBT
QSFPDVQBDJPOFTFDPMHJDBT IBTUBMB
EFGFOTBEFMPTHSFNJPT QBSUJDVMBS
NFOUF EF MPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF MB
TBMVE RVJFOFTTFWJFSPOBCPDBEPTB
SFnFYJPOBSTPCSFFMVOJWFSTPTPDJBM
ZQPMUJDPRVFBMCFSHBCBMBQSDUJDB
EFTVTQSPGFTJPOFT FOQBSUFDPNP
DPOTFDVFODJB EF  DPNP FMMPT NJT
NPTMPEFOPNJOBSPO MBQSPMFUBSJ
[BDJOEFMBNFEJDJOB

&O PDBTJPOFT  MPT JOUFSFTFT RVF BMJNFO


UBOFMFKFSDJDJPEFMBCJPUJDBOPIBOTJEP
QVSBNFOUF JOUFMFDUVBMFT  TJOP RVF IBO
UFOJEPRVFWFSDPOPUSPTGBDUPSFT1FSP
FTUPOPMFSFTUBJNQPSUBODJBBMFKFSDJDJP
EFSFnFYJO OJKVTUJDJBBMBTDBVTBTRVFTF
IBZBOEFGFOEJEPBRV)FNPTEJDIPZB
RVFMBIJTUPSJBEFMBCJPUJDBFO"NSJDB
-BUJOBIBTJEPP QPSMPNFOPT IBDP
NFO[BEPBTFSFTDSJUBEFTEFEJWFSTPTBV
UPSFTZQPDBT+BNFT%SBOF 1FESP-BO
&OUSBMHP %JFHP(SBDJB "MGPOTP-MBOP 
+PT".BJOFUUJZ'FSOBOEP-PMBT

6OBSFTQFUVPTBNJSBEB
SFUSPTQFDUJWB
4FHVSBNFOUF BMNJSBSFOSFUSPTQFDUJWB 
MBSFTUBVSBDJOEFMBEFNPDSBDJBGBWPSF
DJ FM SFTVSHJS EF EFCBUFT NT BNQMJPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

Z EFMJCFSBDJPOFT TPCSF FM FUIPT NEJDP


Z MPT TJTUFNBT EF TBMVE  EF MB NJTNB
NBOFSB RVF MB JOUSPEVDDJO EF OVFWBT
UFDOPMPHBTNEJDBTQPTJCJMJUBCBVOFT
DFOBSJP RVF SFnFKBCB FM EF MB CJPUJDB
OPSUFBNFSJDBOB 1FSP  QPS TVQVFTUP 
TMPQBSDJBMNFOUF QVFTMBDPOTUBUBDJO
EFMBTSFBMJEBEFTEFFTUFDPOUJOFOUFoEF
QSPGVOEBTJOFRVJEBEFTZEJGFSFODJBTFO
DBMJEBEEFWJEB EPOEFFTQPTJCMFFODPO
USBSFOVOBNJTNBDJVEBEVOBVOJEBEEF
DVJEBEPTJOUFOTJWPTBMUBNFOUFTPmTUJDB
EBZVOIPTQJUBMFO[POBTEFQSJNJEBTTJO
FMFNFOUPTCTJDPTQBSBMBBUFODJOoEF
CJIBCFSHFOFSBEPBMHOUJQPEFDPO
nJDUPNPSBMTFHVSBNFOUFGVFDMBSPQBSB
RVJFOFTMJEFSBCBOMBSFnFYJOFOBRVFMMB
QPDBRVFVOBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
OPQPESBTFSVOTJNQMFSFnFKPEFMBRVF
TFIBDBFO/PSUFBNSJDB&MMP TJODPO
UBSDPORVFJODMVTP&TUBEPT6OJEPTEF
"NSJDBUJFOFTVQSPQJPVOJWFSTPUFSDFS
NVOEJTUB DPNPRVFEDMBSPEFTQVTEF
/VFWB 0SMFBOT EF TJNJMBS NBOFSB  VO
CVFOONFSPEFDJVEBEBOPTFTUBEPVOJ
EFOTFTOPFTUOQSPUFHJEPTQPSFMTJTUF
NB EF TBMVE &TUP QBSB BOPUBS RVF MPT
QSPCMFNBTEFQPCSF[BFJOKVTUJDJBUJFOFO
MVHBSFOFMNVOEPEFTBSSPMMBEP
1FSPWPMWJFOEPBMVOJWFSTPEF"NSJDB
-BUJOB EFCJTFOUJSTFMBJOFWJUBCMFUFO
TJOFOUSFVOBBQVFTUBQPSMPTEFSFDIPT
JOEJWJEVBMFT EF DPSUF NBSDBEBNFOUF
MJCFSBM  UBO JNQPSUBOUFT QBSB FM FUIPT
NEJDPOPSUFBNFSJDBOP ZMPTEFSFDIPT
FDPONJDPTZTPDJBMFTEFOPNJOBEPToEF
NBOFSB VO QPDP JNQSFDJTBo EF TFHVO
EBHFOFSBDJO ZRVFDPOTUJUVBOCVFOB
QBSUFEFMBTQSFPDVQBDJPOFTEFMEFWFOJS





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

QPMUJDP MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP 2VJFOFT MV


DIBCBOQPSJOTUBVSBSMBCJPUJDBOPDBSF
DBOEFTFOTJCJMJEBENPSBM4FHVSBNFOUF
TBCBORVFOPQPEBOQMBOUFBSVOBRVF
GVFSBTJNQMFSFnFKPEFMBOPSUFBNFSJDBOB
PMBFVSPQFB BKFOBBMBTSFBMJEBEFTEFTVT
QBTFT 1FSP UBNQPDP QPESBO BCBOEP
OBSMBQPTJCJMJEBEEFCFOFmDJBSTFDPOVO
OVFWPDBNQPRVF BMNFOPT JOUFOUBCB
BDPSUBSMBTEJTUBODJBTFOUSFMBTDJFODJBTZ
MBTIVNBOJEBEFT
&O SFBMJEBE  FT NSJUP EF IPNCSFT
DPNP.BJOFUUJ FO"SHFOUJOB "VHVTUP
-FO  FO 7FOF[VFMB  "MGPOTP -MBOP Z
'FSOBOEP 4ODIF[ 5PSSFT  FO $PMPN
CJB "SNBOEP3PB FO$IJMF Z.BOVFM
7FMBTDP4VSF[ FO.YJDP%FTBGPSUV
OBEBNFOUF  RVFEBO NVDIPT TJO NFO
DJPOBSBRVZMBOJDBNBOFSBEFEFGFO
EFSTF EF FTB PNJTJO FT EFDJS RVF FTUB
IJTUPSJB IB TJEP NVDIP NFKPS DPOUBEB
FO PUSB QBSUF -PMBT 4UFQLF  
 Z
RVF FM QSPQTJUP EF FTUF BSUDVMP OP FT
IJTUPSJBSMBCJPUJDB1FSPFTUPTIPNCSFT
UVWJFSPOMBJOUVJDJOCTJDBEFJOUFHSBS
MBT IVNBOJEBEFT Z MBT DJFODJBT TPDJBMFT
BMBUFPSBZMBQSDUJDBNEJDBTFOTVT
QSPQJPT DPOUFYUPT QPMUJDPT Z HFPHSm
DPT BMBWF[RVFCFOFmDJBSTFEFMOVFWP
GFONFOPDVMUVSBMEFMBCJPUJDB"VO
RVF EBEB TV QBSB FOUPODFT
 SFDJFOUF
DSFBDJO OPTJFNQSFTFQPESBEFNBSDBS
TVmDJFOUFNFOUFFMNCJUPEFTVQSPCMF
NUJDB
" QBSUJS EF BRV TF QPESBO WJTVBMJ[BS
DJFSUBT UFOEFODJBT RVF SFTQPOEFO B MB
OFDFTJEBE EF TJUVBS JOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJB
NFOUFFMBOMJTJTEFBMHVOPTQSPCMFNBT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DPNVOFTBOVFTUSPTQBTFT7FJOUFBPT
EFTQVT  RVJ[T TF QVFEF JOUFOUBS FM
FKFSDJDJP SFUSPTQFDUJWP EF NJSBS DVOUP
TF IB FWPMVDJPOBEP FO FTF QSPZFDUP EF
DPOTPMJEBS VO NPWJNJFOUP CJPUJDP MB
UJOPBNFSJDBOP
&TFFKFSDJDJP DMBSPFTU EFCFIBDFSTFEF
GPSNB SFTQFUVPTB RVJFOFT DPNFO[BSPO
MB SFnFYJO CJPUJDB OP UFOBO MBT WFO
UBKBTDPNQBSBUJWBTEFRVJFOFTTFJOJDJBO
IPZ FO EB JOTUJUVDJPOFT EFEJDBEBT B
MBFOTFBO[BEFMBNBUFSJB QPSUBMFTFO
MBSFE CBTFTEFEBUPT CJCMJPUFDBTFTQF
DJBMJ[BEBT  DPOHSFTPT Z TFNJOBSJPT EF
CJPUJDB FOUSFPUSBT&TEFDJS UPEBVOB
OPSNBMJ[BDJOEFMBEJTDJQMJOB FOQBSUF
DPNP DPOTFDVFODJB EF TV JNQVMTP JOJ
DJBMFOFMRVF JOEVEBCMFNFOUF TIVCP
HSBO DPSBKF Z QFSTJTUFODJB &M FKFSDJDJP
SFUSPTQFDUJWP EFCF TFSWJSOPT UBNCJO
QBSBSFnFYJPOBSTPCSFFMQSFTFOUFEFMB
CJPUJDBZQSPTFHVJSIBDJBVOBQSPTQFD
UJWB RVF DPOUFOHB MPT FMFNFOUPT DSUJ
DPTOFDFTBSJPToJODMVTPRVFQPTUVMFVO
EFCFS TFS EF MB CJPUJDBo  QFSNJUJFOEP
RVFDPFYJTUBOEJWFSTBTDPODFQDJPOFTFO
EJMPHPZBQSPWFDIFOMBFYQFSJFODJBEFM
DBNJOPSFDPSSJEP

-BFNFSHFODJBEFMBSFnFYJO
CJPUJDBBDFSDBEFDVFTUJPOFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT
&O FTUF TFOUJEP  FT JOEVEBCMF RVF MB
CJPUJDB DPOGSPOU B MPT NEJDPT Z  FO
HFOFSBM  B MPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF MB TBMVE
DPO MBT SFBMJEBEFT QPMUJDBT Z FDPONJ
DBTFOMBTRVFFTUBCBJONFSTBTVQSDUJDB
QSPGFTJPOBM&OBMHVOPTDBTPT DPNPFO
$PMPNCJB MBTBTPDJBDJPOFTEFFOGFSNF





6OBMFDUVSBDSUJDBEFMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB(FSNO$BMEFSO-FHBSEB

SBTQSPGFTJPOBMFTKVHBSPOoZDPOUJOBO
IBDJOEPMPo VO QBQFM GVOEBNFOUBM 4J
CJFOFTDJFSUP MBSFnFYJOCJPUJDBQFS
NJUJQPOFSFOFMDFOUSPEFMBQSFPDV
QBDJO FM UFNB EF MPT EFSFDIPT EF MPT
QBDJFOUFT Z MPT BTVOUPT EF BVUPOPNB
Z CFOFmDFODJB  MPT UFNBT NT HMPCBMFT
EFKVTUJDJBTBOJUBSJBoBDDFTPBMPTTFSWJ
DJPTCTJDPT QPMUJDBTEFTBMVEQCMJDBo 
BVORVF OP DPNQMFUBNFOUF EFTBUFOEJ
EPT  OP MPHSBSPO  OJ IBO MPHSBEP  BSUJ
DVMBSTF FO VOB SFnFYJO NT QSPGVOEB
ZEVSBEFSB NFEJBEPSBEFMEJMPHPFOUSF
MBFDPOPNB MBTBMVEDPNPCJFOQCMJDP
QVCMJD HPPE
 Z MBT UFPSBT EF MB KVTUJDJB
(BSHBSFMMB 
2VJ[TVOFYDFTJWP
OGBTJTFOFMQSJODJQJBMJTNPPFODJFSUBT
MFDUVSBTEFTUFIBDPOGVOEJEPVOQPDP
MBNJSBEB QVFTOPIBQFSNJUJEPQFSDJCJS
RVFUPEBEJTDVTJOTPCSFKVTUJDJBTBOJUB
SJB EFCF TFS SFGFSJEB Z DPOUFYUVBMJ[BEB
SFTQFDUPEFMBTSFBMJEBEFTEFMNVOEPFO
EFTBSSPMMPZMBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSOBDJPOB
MFT-BKVTUJDJBOPQVFEFWFSTFDPNPVO
QSJODJQJPFOUSFPUSPT TJOPRVFoEFKBOEP
QSPWJTJPOBMNFOUFEFMBEPFMUFNBEFMBT
KFSBSRVBT FOUSF QSJODJQJPTo FT FM HSBO
UFNBQPSSFTPMWFSFOOVFTUSBTTPDJFEBEFT
#FSMJOHVFS 

%FNBOFSBJOEFQFOEJFOUF BMHVOPTBV
UPSFT IBO TPTUFOJEP RVF MB CJPUJDB OP
SFBMJ[B VOB TVNB TJNQMF EF EPT P NT
DPOPDJNJFOUPTQBSBPCUFOFSVOUFSDFSP
$BMEFSO  
 4F SFRVJFSF NVDIP
NTZ FOFMDBTPFTQFDmDPEFMBKVTUJDJB
TBOJUBSJB  IBDF GBMUB NBZPS BSUJDVMBDJO
Z QSPGVOEJ[BDJO FO MB SFMBDJO FOUSF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

FDPOPNB  GSNBDPFDPOPNB  mMPTPGB


QPMUJDB  TBMVE QCMJDB  FOUSF PUSBT &T
DJFSUP RVF MB CJPUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB
NPTUSEFTEFFMDPNJFO[PDJFSUBJODMJOB
DJOQPSMPTBTVOUPTHMPCBMFT1FSPFTUP
OPEFCFTPSQSFOEFSOPTZFT TJOMVHBSB
EVEBT VOTJHOPFTQFSBO[BEPSIBDJBEF
TBSSPMMPTGVUVSPT"VORVFTVFOFUSJWJBMo
ZTFIBSFQFUJEPUBOUBTWFDFToRVFMBCJP
UJDBFTiVOBUJDBEFMBWJEBw FMMPOPT
PCMJHBBUFOFSVOBNJSBEBJOUFHSBEPSBZ
MMFHBBDPOTUJUVJSTFFOVOBBDUJUVENP
SBMMPBCMF%FTQVTEFUPEP MBCJPUJDB
EFCFTFSWJSBMPTDJVEBEBOPTEFMBQPMJTZ
DPOUSJCVJSBMBDSFBDJOEFVOiFUIPTDP
NVOJUBSJPw4JOFNCBSHP IBZRVFUFOFS
QSFTFOUFRVFMBTPMBBQFMBDJOBJEFBMFT
NPSBMFT  DPNP MB FRVJEBE Z MB KVTUJDJB
TPDJBM  OP DPOTUJUVZF FO T NJTNB VO
BOMJTJTSJHVSPTPEFMBSFBMJEBERVFTJSWB
QBSBQSPGVOEJ[BSFOTVDPOPDJNJFOUPZ
RVF FWFOUVBMNFOUF OPTBZVEFBUSBOT
GPSNBSMB/PMFGBMUBSB[OB'FSOBOEP
-PMBT DVBOEP FYQSFTB RVF MB iTJNQMF
FOVODJBDJOEFCVFOPTmOFToMBCJPUJDB
MPT UJFOFo QBSFDF CBTUBS QBSB BUSJCVJSMF
QVSF[BEFNFEJPTBRVJFOFTEJDFODVMUJ
WBSMBw MPDVBMOPTJFNQSFFTFMDBTP-B
OPDJOEFVOBEJTDJQMJOBJOUFMFDUVBMDPO
TVT DPSSFTQPOEJFOUFT iTBCJPT  FYQFSUPT
Z QPMUJDPTw OFDFTJUB TFS DMBSJmDBEB FO
VODBNQPUBOMCJMDPNPFMRVFMBCJP
UJDB IB EFNPTUSBEP TFS -PMBT 4UFQLF 

ZRVFiMBTMVDFTJOUFMFDUVBMFT
OPTPOHBSBOUBEFCPOEBENPSBM1FSP
TUBUBNQPDPMPFTEFQFOTBNJFOUPSJHV
SPTPw -PMBT4UFQLF 






1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

-BBmSNBDJOEFJEFBMFTNPSBMFT
ZFMSJFTHPEFMiQBOnFUJTNPw
CJPUJDP
-BBQFMBDJOBQSJODJQJPTNVZHFOFSBMFT
Z  TPCSF UPEP  MB TVQMBOUBDJO EFM BO
MJTJTUJDPQPMUJDPSJHVSPTPoBTTFIBHB
DPO MBT QFTBEBT IFSSBNJFOUBT EF VOB
QMVSBMJEBEEFMFOHVBKFTZTBCFSFTRVFOP
TFDPNVOJDBOFOUSFTDPOGBDJMJEBEoQPS
MBNFSBFOVODJBDJOEFJEFBMFTNPSBMFT
oDPNP MB DPOEFOB B MB JOKVTUJDJB Z MB
EFOVODJBEFMBJOFRVJEBEo OPTJFNQSF
DPOEVDFOBVOBWBODFSFBM.TUPEBWB
DJFSUP QBOnFUJTNP UFSDFSNVOEJTUB RVF
UPEPMPDPOEFOBTJONTQVFEFTFSTV
NBNFOUFEBJOP QVFTOPTMMFWBBMFOHB
PEFDSFFSRVFMBTJNQMFEFOVODJBEFMB
QPCSF[BRVFQBEFDFOMPTQBTFTEFMTVS 
FM EBP NFEJPBNCJFOUBM P MB JOKVTUJDJB
FOMBTSFMBDJPOFTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTTFDPOT
UJUVZFOTJONTFOVOBQPSUFJOUFMFDUVBM
/PCBTUBDPOSFQFUJSVOMFOHVBKFiQPM
UJDBNFOUFDPSSFDUPwQBSBDPOTJEFSBSRVF
TFIBBWBO[BEPFOFMBOMJTJT PRVFFTUP
SFBMNFOUF DPOUSJCVZF B EJOBNJ[BS MPT
NPWJNJFOUPTTPDJBMFTBGBWPSEFBMHVOB
DBVTB4PSQSFOEFFODPOUSBS BWFDFT FO
BMHVOPT GPSPT Z DPOHSFTPT EF CJPUJDB
oQPSGPSUVOBOPFOUPEPTo MBSFQFUJDJO
EF MVHBSFT DPNVOFT  BDPNQBBEPT EF
FYQSFTJPOFT EF BQBSFOUF BTPNCSP QPS
MPT BUBRVFT B MB EJHOJEBE F JOUFHSJEBE
IVNBOB FO BMHVOB QBSUF EFM QMBOFUB P
FOOVFTUSPTQSPQJPTQBTFT
/PPCTUBOUF FTUPOPEFCFTFSNPUJWPEF
EFTBMJFOUP MBT QSFPDVQBDJPOFT HMPCBMFT
MFIBOQFSNJUJEPBRVJFOFTTFPDVQBOEF
CJPUJDBTJUVBSTFNVDIPNTFOFMDPO
UFYUPEFVOBSFBMJEBEEJGDJM BWFDFTJO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DMVTPB[BSPTB RVFOPQVFEFTJNQMFNFOUF
TFSQFOTBEBEFTEFFMFUIPTMJCFSBMOPSUF
BNFSJDBOP$VBOEPTFIBCMFFO"NSJDB
-BUJOBEFFRVJEBEEFSFDVSTPTTBOJUBSJPT
oBENJUJFOEPRVFMPHSBSQSFDJTJOBDFSDB
EFFTUPTFSBZBVOBHBOBODJBo FMUFNB
EFMBKVTUJDJBOPQVFEFTFSVOQSJODJQJP
FOUSFPUSPT DPNPQBSFDFSBOTVHFSJSBM
HVOBTMFDUVSBTEFMQSJODJQJBMJTNP2VJ[T
FMHSBOUFNBEFMBKVTUJDJBEFCBJODMVJSOP
TMP TV TFOUJEP EJTUSJCVUJWP  TJOP  UBN
CJO TVTFOUJEPSFTUBVSBUJWPZSFQBSBUJ
WP BMNFOPTFOBRVFMMBTSFHJPOFTFOMBT
DVBMFTMPTDJVEBEBOPTIBOTJEPWJDUJNJ
[BEPTQPSMBWJPMFODJBEFVODPOnJDUPBS
NBEPRVFDJFSUPTJEFBMFTNPSBMFToQBSB
EFKBSEFIBCMBSQPSBIPSBEFQSJODJQJPT
ZWBMPSFToFTUOQSFTFOUFTFOFMEFTBSSP
MMPEFMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBOPTFB
VOEFGFDUPTJOPNTCJFOVOBWJSUVE-P
QSFPDVQBOUFFTRVFFTUPDPOEV[DBBDJFS
UBTGPSNBTEFQSPTFMJUJTNPBWFDFTEFNB
HHJDP RVFQSFUFOEFSBTVQMBOUBSFMBO
MJTJTTFSJPZTFSFOPEFMPTQSPCMFNBTQPS
MBSFQFUJDJOEFNFSBTDPOTJHOBT1PSMP
EFNT  FO UBOUP QVFEB IBDFSTF VO VTP
BEFDVBEP EFM BOMJTJT oQSPEVDUP EF MBT
EJWFSTBT EJTDJQMJOBT RVF TF JNCSJDBOo Z
TFNBOUFOHBFMSJHPSEFMPTEJTDVSTPTBDB
ENJDPT OPTFWFQPSRVMBCJPUJDBOP
IBEFBMJNFOUBSDJFSUPUJQPEFBDUJWJTNP
PDJFSUBTBTQJSBDJPOFTEFSFGPSNBTPDJBM 
P JODMVTP DPOUSJCVJSBMPHSBSVOBMFHJT
MBDJONTBEFDVBEBTPCSFDJFSUPTUFNBT
"FTUFSFTQFDUP FTZBNVZDPOPDJEPFM
NBMDBTJFOENJDPEFOVFTUSBTTPDJFEB
EFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOBT Z RVF TF QSFTFOUB
EFTEFMPTBMCPSFTEFOVFTUSBTSFQCMJDBT
MPTEFTBSSPMMPTKVSEJDPTOPDPJODJEFOP
OPQBSFDFOFTUBSQFOTBEPTQBSBMBTSFBMJ





6OBMFDUVSBDSUJDBEFMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB(FSNO$BMEFSO-FHBSEB

EBEFTRVFTFWJWFO/PTJOSB[OFYQSF
TBCBVOSFQVUBEPHFOFUJTUBDPMPNCJBOP
RVF TF FTUBCB MFHJTMBOEP FO FTF QBT oZ
QSPCBCMFNFOUF FO PUSPTo TPCSF DMPOB
DJO EF TFSFT IVNBOPT TJO IBCFS PCUF
OJEPVOBDPNQSFOTJOCTJDBEFMPRVF
TJHOJmDBSBOFTUPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTZTVT
QPTJCJMJEBEFTSFBMFTEFBQMJDBDJO"OFD
EUJDPFJOFYBDUPDPNPQVFEFBQBSFDFS 
SFnFKB  TJO FNCBSHP  VOB SFBMJEBE RVF
BDPNQBB MB GPSNB DPNP TF QSPDFEF B
EJTDVUJS EFDJEJSZ BWFDFT MFHJTMBSTPCSF
DJFSUPT UFNBT 5BNQPDP FT BDPOTFKBCMF
FODPHFS MPT IPNCSPT BOUF FM QFTP EF
OVFTUSP TVQVFTUP iSFBMJTNP NHJDPw OJ
BQFMBSBOVFTUSPiUSPQJDBMJTNPw QVFTFT
UBTTPODBSJDBUVSBTRVFSFTVMUBOEBJOBT
1FSPTFTOFDFTBSJPSFDPSEBSRVFNVDIPT
EFMPTEFCBUFTRVFMMFWBOFMBEKFUJWPEF
CJPUJDPT  BEFNT EFM TFOTBDJPOBMJTNP
NFEJUJDPRVFTVFMFOUSBFSDPOTJHP EFT
DPOPDFO FO CVFOB NFEJEB MPT IFDIPT
DJFOUmDPTSFMFWBOUFTZMPTQSPCMFNBTUJ
DPTJOWPMVDSBEPT

-BBQFSUVSBEFMBCJPUJDBIBDJB
MPTHSBOEFTUFNBTEFMBWJEB
-BJODMJOBDJOBFYBNJOBSMPTUFNBTEF
CJPUFDOPMPHB FMJNQBDUPNFEJPBNCJFO
UBMZMBTJNQMJDBDJPOFTEFMBTQSDUJDBTEF
MPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF MB TBMVE EFOUSP EF
TJTUFNBT FTUBUBMFT P QSJWBEPT QFSNJUF
RVF MB CJPUJDB TF FYQSFTF DPNP NPWJ
NJFOUPDVMUVSBMZQPMUJDPZPCUFOHBVOB
HSBOSFQFSDVTJONFEJUJDBRVFQVFEF 
BWFDFT DBVTBSDPOGVTJO&OFTUFTFOUJ
EP EFCFDFMFCSBSTFRVFZBIBZBUFOJEP
MVHBS MB FUBQB RVF .BJOFUUJ EFOPNJOB
iSFDSFBDJOw Z RVF DPSSFTQPOEF BM DP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

NJFO[P EF MB JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJO EF MB


CJPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBBMDPNJFO[P
EFMPTBPTOPWFOUBVOQSPDFTPDPOSBT
HPT DPNVOFT  QFSP RVF UBNCJO SFWFMB
MBTQBSUJDVMBSJEBEFTEFDBEBQBT
.BJOFUUJ QPSPUSPMBEP TPTUJFOFRVFMB
iCJPUJDBTFIBDPOWFSUJEPFOMBBSFOBEF
OVFWPTEFTBGPTFO"NSJDB-BUJOB6OB
BQBSFOUF VOJGPSNJEBE FTDPOEF SJDBT Z
IFUFSPHOFBT BDUJWJEBEFTw /P TMP MBT
JOnVFODJBTFVSPQFBTZDSJTUJBOBTJOPMBT
USBEJDJPOFT JOUFMFDUVBMFT JOEHFOBT TPO
NVZJNQPSUBOUFTFOFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMB
CJPUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB /P UJFOF TV
QSPQJBmMPTPGB DPNPMBBOHMPBNFSJDBOB
QBSFDFUFOFS QFSPTTVQSPQJBMJUFSBUVSB
ZFTUJMPOBSSBUJWPw .BJOFUUJ 

6OBGPSNBEFEBSMFWJBCJMJEBEBFTUBMFD
UVSBQPESBTFSJOUFSQSFUOEPMBDPNPVO
MMBNBEPEFBUFODJOTPCSFMBOFDFTJEBE
EFJOUFHSBSEJWFSTPTFOGPRVFTZBCPSEBS
MBCJPUJDBDPOMBBDUJUVESFTQFUVPTBEF
RVJFO FTU EJTQVFTUP B QFOTBS Z BDUVBS
FO VOB TPDJFEBE NVMUJDVMUVSBM "QBSUF
EFM EJTDVSTP EF MBT DJFODJBT NFEJPBN
CJFOUBMFToIPZNVDIPNTBSUJDVMBEPo 
MBBOUSPQPMPHBDVMUVSBMZFMFTGVFS[PEF
BMHVOPTTFDUPSFTFOBSBTEFDPNQSFOEFS
MB NFEJDJOB Z QSDUJDBT DPNVOJUBSJBT
EF MPT QVFCMPT JOEHFOBT  OP TF QVF
EFEFDJSRVFFTUBTUSBEJDJPOFTTFIBZBO
DPOWFSUJEPFOQBSUFEFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMB
CJPUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB $JFSUBNFOUF 
FT NVZ JNQPSUBOUF MMBNBS MB BUFODJO
TPCSF FMMP  QFSP IBCSB RVF SFDPOPDFS
RVF FT VOB UBSFB BO QFOEJFOUF .T
JOUFSFTBOUFFTRVFTFQSPQPOHBMBMJUFSB
UVSB Z FM FTUJMP OBSSBUJWP DPNP GVFOUFT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

EFDPOPDJNJFOUP%FTEFVOBQFSTQFDUJ
WBDFSDBOB QFSPOPJEOUJDB 'FSOBOEP
-PMBT IB QSPQVFTUP RVF MB CJPUJDB TFB
DPOTJEFSBEB DPNP OBSSBUJWB DSUJDB -B
CJPUJDBTFDPODJCFBT BOUFUPEP DPNP
VOEJTDVSTPBOUJEPHNUJDP FTEFDJS VO
EJTDVSTP FTFODJBMNFOUF DSUJDP  DBSBD
UFSJ[BEP QPS VOB BDUJUVE EJBMHJDB RVF
QFSNJUFMBQMVSBMJEBEZMBEJTDSFQBODJB
%FTEFFTUBQFSTQFDUJWB MBCJPUJDBEFTB
SSPMMBSBVOBNFUBOBSSBUJWBRVFQVFEF
iIPSJ[POUBMJ[BSw MPT BSHVNFOUPT Z  QPS
UBOUP EFWFMBSMBBSRVJUFDUVSBBYJPMHJDB
EFRVJFOFTQBSUJDJQBOFOFMEJMPHP
1PS DJFSUP  DPOTUJUVZF VO SFUP NVZ TV
HFSFOUF QFOTBS RVF FM CJPFUJDJTUB FT VO
FYQFSUPRVFTBCFiUSBEVDJSEJTDVSTPTw4F
USBUBTJOEVEBEFVOBCFMMBJNBHFOZ FO
SFBMJEBE  VO QSPZFDUP QSPCBCMFNFOUF
BMDBO[BCMF
QBSBMPTCJPFUJDJTUBTEFMGVUV
SPNTRVFVOBSFBMJEBEQSFTFOUF QFSP
FTEJGDJMOPFTUBSEFBDVFSEPDPO-PMBT
FODVBOUPBMQBQFMNFEJBEPSEFMBCJPUJ
DB-BCJPUJDBQPTJCJMJUBFMEJMPHPFOUSF
TBCFSFT Z EJTDJQMJOBT Z  TF QPESB EFDJS
UBNCJO  iFOUSF SFBMJEBEFTw $BMEFSO 

 &O FTUF TFOUJEP  FT QPS MP NF
OPT DPNQSFOTJCMF FM UFNPS EF 7JDUPSJB
$BNQTBMFYQSFTBSRVFFMUSNJOPiCJP
FUJDJTUBwTFBVOICSJEPRVFRVJFSFVOJS
BMDJFOUmDPZBMIVNBOJTUB QVFT TFHO
FMMB  MP RVF FO SFBMJEBE EFCF IBDFSTF 
EFTEFMBCJPUJDB FTNBOUFOFSFMEJMPHP
iQSPQJDJBOEPMBDPNQSFOTJOFOUSFMFO
HVBKFTZNVOEPTRVFIBOFWPMVDJPOBEP
JOEFQFOEJFOUFNFOUF FM VOP EFM PUSPw
$BNQT 
*OEFQFOEJFOUFNFOUFEF
RVFBDFQUFNPTPOPFTUBTEVEBT FTNT
EJGDJMUFOFSMBTTPCSFFMQBQFMEFMBCJP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UJDBFOMBJNCSJDBDJOQSDUJDBEFIFDIPT
Z WBMPSFT  Z SFTVMUB FTUJNVMBOUF Z oQPS
RVOPEFDJSMPoMJCFSBEPSRVFTFQJFOTF
MBCJPUJDBDPNPVODPOKVOUPEFIFSSB
NJFOUBT DPODFQUVBMFT RVF QFSNJUFO FM
EJMPHPFOUSFEJTDJQMJOBTZFOUSFEJWFSTPT
TFDUPSFTEFMBSFBMJEBE1PSFMMP OPQVF
EF TFS MB NFSB BQMJDBDJO EF QSJODJQJPT
BCTUSBDUPT B TJUVBDJPOFT DPODSFUBT &M
USNJOPUJDBBQMJDBEBDJFSUBNFOUFDPO
GVOEF MBT DPTBT UBNQPDP CBTUB BRV MB
TJNQMF BQFMBDJO BM SFMBUJWJTNP DVMUVSBM
P B GPSNBT EF DPOUFYUVBMJTNP TJO NT 
QVFT VO SFMBUJWJTNP UJDP DVMUVSBM FY
USFNPQVFEFSFTVMUBSUBOWBDPDPNPMB
BCTPMVUJ[BDJOEFQSJODJQJPTDPOQSFUFO
TJPOFT EF WBMJEF[ VOJWFSTBM -B CJPUJDB
EFCFPQFSBSDPODPODFQUPTRVFBENJUBO
NBUJDFT [POBTHSJTFT JOUFSQSFUBDJPOFTZ
OGBTJT EJGFSFOUFT 4BCFNPT RVF OPDJP
OFTDPNPMBEJHOJEBEZFMSFTQFUPNVUVP
FTUO QSFTFOUFT FO UPEBT MBT TPDJFEBEFT 
ZRVFMBTSFMBDJPOFTmMJBMFT QPSFKFNQMP 
KVFHBOVOQBQFMNVZJNQPSUBOUF QFSP
MBFTUSVDUVSBZGPSNBRVFFTUBTBTVNFO
WBSBOHSBOEFNFOUFEFVODPOUFYUPDVM
UVSBMBPUSP"VORVFFMFKFNQMPFTNVZ
FMFNFOUBM OUFTFMPTNMUJQMFTTJHOJmDB
EPTRVFQVFEFUFOFSFMUSNJOPiGBNJMJBw
FODPOUFYUPTHFPHSmDPTEJGFSFOUFTZ FO
PDBTJPOFT EFOUSPEFVONJTNPQBT%F
TJNJMBS NBOFSB  IBZ TPDJFEBEFT FO MBT
RVF MPT BODJBOPT TPO DPOTVMUBEPT QBSB
MBT EFDJTJPOFT NT JNQPSUBOUFT Z PUSBT
FOMBTRVFOPTPOUFOJEPTFODVFOUBCBKP
OJOHVOBDJSDVOTUBODJBMPRVFTVDFEFFT
RVFEJGFSFOUFTTPDJFEBEFTUJFOFOQFSDFQ
DJPOFT EJGFSFOUFT EF MP RVF DPOTJEFSBO
WBMJPTP  QFSP UPEBT IBDFO WBMPSBDJPOFT
EFBMHOUJQP



6OBMFDUVSBDSUJDBEFMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB(FSNO$BMEFSO-FHBSEB

&TUBOPFTMBJOTUBODJBBQSPQJBEBQBSBEF
mOJSVOEFCFSTFSEFMBCJPUJDB QFSPIBZ
RVF UFOFS QSFTFOUF RVF OVFTUSPT DPOP
DJNJFOUPT TJFNQSFGBMJCMFTFJOTVmDJFO
UFT FO EJGFSFOUFT DPOUFYUPT DVMUVSBMFT 
EFCFOQFSNJUJSOPTPQUBSQPSVOSFMBUJ
WJTNP NPEFSBEP  QVFT MBT BTQJSBDJPOFT
DPNVOFTEFMBIVNBOJEBEoRVFTVFMFO
EFOPNJOBSTF iWBMPSFT VOJWFSTBMFTwo FT
UOQSFTFOUFTEFBMHVOBNBOFSB"RVMB
SFnFYJOCJPUJDBFKFSDFTVQSJNFSBHSBO
NFEJBDJO BMOPBDFQUBSMBJNQPTJDJO
EF QSJODJQJPT BCTPMVUPT  QFSP UBNQPDP
QBSBMJ[OEPTF P FYUSBWJOEPTF BOUF MB
QMVSBMJEBEEFDVMUVSBTZNPEPTEFWJEB
/VTTCBVN .BDLMJO 

4FQVFEFDPNQSFOEFSRVFVOBCJPUJDB
GPSNVMBEB EFTEF FM FUIPT MJCFSBM DMTJDP
EFM QSJODJQJBMJTNP OPSUFBNFSJDBOP SF
TVMUB VO UBOUP FYUJDB  BVORVF OP QPS
FMMPEFCFEFKBSEFFTUVEJBSTFFOVODPO
UFYUP MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP  NT QSYJNP B
MBTUSBEJDJPOFTDBUMJDBTZNFEJUFSSOFBT
$PNPCJFOMPBOPUB-PMBT iVOPEFMPT
HSBOEFTQSPCMFNBTEFSJWBEPTEFAJNQPS
UBSEJTDJQMJOBTJOUFMFDUVBMFTDPOTJTUFQSF
DJTBNFOUFFORVFQVFEFOTFSEJGDJMNFOUF
BSNPOJ[BCMFTDPOMBUSBEJDJOZDVMUVSB
MPDBMFTw -PMBT4UFQLF 

/UFTFRVFBRVOPTFUSBUBEFVOBUFPSB
EFMBWFSEBE EFEFDJEJSTJMBWFSEBEFTU
FO FM QSJODJQJBMJTNP P FO VOBiUJDBEF
TJUVBDJOw TJOPEFMJOUFOUPEFEFMJCFSBS
TPCSFBRVFMMPRVFQVFEFJMVNJOBSPOP
VOBTPDJFEBEPVOBQPDBEFUFSNJOBEB B
WFDFTTVFMFPMWJEBSTFMBEJNFOTJOUFNQP
SBMFOMPTEFCBUFTUJDPT
EFTEFVOBUFPSB
QBSUJDVMBS%JNFOTJPOBSEFTEFPUSPTDPO
UFYUPTDVMUVSBMFTRVFQVFEBODPNQBSBSTF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



FOUSFT FYBNJOBSTVTGPSUBMF[BTZEFCJMJ
EBEFTBSHVNFOUBUJWBT EJMVDJEBSQPSRV
GVODJPOBFODJFSUPTDPOUFYUPTDVMUVSBMFT
Z OP FO PUSPT  DPNQBSBS DNP TF IBDF
DPNQBUJCMF P OP DPO PUSBT USBEJDJPOFT
JOUFMFDUVBMFTFTVOFKFSDJDJPIPOFTUPRVF
OPTMPEFCFTFSDFSDBOPBMBCJPUJDBTJOP
RVF RVJ[T TFBFTUFFKFSDJDJPEFMJCFSBUJWP
MBGVODJOQSJODJQBMEFTUB
1PSPUSPMBEP TFPCTFSWBRVFFOMBMJUF
SBUVSBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBoFJODMV
TP FO MB FVSPQFBo DPOUJOB VOB GVFSUF
UFOEFODJB B VUJMJ[BS FM USNJOP iEJMFNB
UJDPw-PTEJMFNBT PCJFODPOEVDFOB
OVFWPT QSPCMFNBT  FO DVZP DBTP TF EJ
MVZFO  P CJFO DPMPDBO B RVJFO JOUFOUB
SFTPMWFSMPT FO TJUVBDJPOFT RVF JNQMJDBO
VO TBMEP USHJDP OJOHVOP EF MPT SFTVM
UBEPTDPOTJEFSBEPTQBSFDFTFSTBUJTGBDUP
SJP&TUSJDUBNFOUFIBCMBOEP MBCJPUJDB
FYBNJOBQSPCMFNBTRVFDPOUJFOFOUBOUP
FMFNFOUPT WBMPSBUJWPT DPNP FMFNFOUPT
FNQSJDPT  UBOUP MFOHVBKF EFTDSJQUJWP
DPNP QSFTDSJQUJWP 2VJFOFT EF FOUSBEB
CBVUJ[BO UPEPT MPT QSPCMFNBT CJPUJDPT
DPNP iEJMFNBTw DPSSFO FM SJFTHP EF UP
NBSSVUBTTJOTBMJEB)BDFBMHVOPTBPT 
VOP EF MPT NT BMUPT GVODJPOBSJPT EFM
.JOJTUFSJP EF 4BMVE EF VO QBT MBUJOP
BNFSJDBOPBmSNRVFTJMMMFHBSBBFO
DPOUSBSTF FO FM iEJMFNBw EF QSPWFFS MB
EPTJT OFDFTBSJB EF NFEJDBNFOUPT B VO
QBDJFOUF BEVMUP DPO 7*)4*%" P EF
BQMJDBSWBDVOBTBVOHSVQPEFOJPTQBSB
QSFWFOJSMBPDVSSFODJBEFBMHOUJQPEF
FOGFSNFEBEDPOPDJEB MPQUBSBQPSFTUP
MUJNP 2VJ[ NVDIPT QFOTBCBO DPNP
FM GVODJPOBSJP TF USBUBCB EF VO EJMFNB
CJPUJDP1FSPTJTFBOBMJ[BNTDVJEBEP





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

TBNFOUFTFWFSRVFOPFYJTUFOJOHOEJ
MFNB  TJOP MB EFTDPOUFYUVBMJ[BDJO TJN
QMFZMMBOBEFQSPCMFNBTRVFUJFOFORVF
WFSDPOMBEJTUSJCVDJOEFSFDVSTPTFOHF
OFSBM%FJHVBMNBOFSB FMNFODJPOBEP
GVODJPOBSJPQPESBIBCFSUFOJEPVOEJ
MFNBFOUSFQSPWFFSTJTUFNBTEFBHVBQP
UBCMFQBSBBMHVOBTQPCMBDJPOFTPJOWFSUJS
FOMPTFTUVEJPTEFFTQFDJBMJEBEFTNEJDBT
EFBMHVOPTFTUVEJBOUFTEFMBTVOJWFSTJEB
EFT FTUBUBMFT &M NBOFKP DBTJ ESBNUJDP
EF FTUPT EJMFNBT iJOTPMVCMFTw  BVOBEPT
DPO MB FTQFDUBDVMBSJEBE NFEJUJDB  OP
DPOUSJCVZFBVOBNFKPSDPNQSFOTJOEF
MBSFBMJEBE-PTQSPCMFNBTRVFFOGSFOUB
MB CJPUJDB TPO EF OBUVSBMF[B DPNQMFKB 
SFRVJFSFO EFM DPODVSTP EF NT EF VOB
EJTDJQMJOB DPOGSFDVFODJBQSFTFOUBODJFS
UBiVSHFODJBwQPSTFSSFTVFMUPTZMPRVFTF
CVTDB OP FT TMP SFBMJ[BS VOB EJTDVTJO
UFSJDBTPCSFQSJODJQJPTHFOFSBMFT MPRVF
FOTNJTNPFTNVZJNQPSUBOUF
TJOP 
ZTPCSFUPEP PGSFDFSDSJUFSJPTQBSBPQUBS
QPSDJFSUPTDVSTPTEFBDDJO
1PSPUSPMBEP TJTFIBCMBEFMPTEJMFNBT
DPNP MPT QSPCMFNBT RVF RVFEBO VOB
WF[ BOBMJ[BEB MB TJUVBDJO JOJDJBM  FO
UPODFT FM QBQFM EF MB CJPUJDB TFS UJM
FO UBOUP EFTQMJFHVF MBT IFSSBNJFOUBT
DPODFQUVBMFT OFDFTBSJBT QBSB BOBMJ[BS Z
SFTQPOEFSBTJUVBDJPOFTQBSUJDVMBSNFOUF
EJGDJMFT FOMBTDVBMFTTFNF[DMFOKVJDJPT
WBMPSBUJWPT OPSNBUJWPTZEFFYQFSJFODJB
.PVMJOFTT 3FTDIFS 


-BCTRVFEBEFMFTUBUVUP
FQJTUFNPMHJDPEFMBCJPUJDB
2VFEBONVDIPTPUSPTBTVOUPTQPSFYB
NJOBS6OPEFFMMPT RVFNVFTUSBBMFO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UBEPSFT TJHOPT EF NBEVSF[ B USBWT EF


VOEFCBUFIPZNVDIPNTFOGPDBEPFO
MPTBTVOUPTEFGPOEP FTFMEFMFTUBUVUP
FQJTUFNPMHJDP EF MB CJPUJDB 4PCSF
FTUPZBQVFEFSFHJTUSBSTFMBFYJTUFODJBEF
QSPEVDUPT EF SFnFYJO DPMFDUJWB (B
SSBGB  ,PUUPX Z 4BBEB  
 4J CJFO
EFTQVTEFNTEFUSFJOUBBPTEFFYJT
UFODJB EF MB EJTDJQMJOB FO FM NVOEP  Z
DFSDBEFWFJOUFBPTFO"NSJDB-BUJOB 
TFSBEFNBTJBEPJOHFOVPQSFUFOEFSFO
DPOUSBSVOBFQJTUFNPMPHBEFMBCJPUJDB
DPODFCJEB EF NBOFSB VOWPDB 1SJNF
SP QPSRVFFTUBFTVOEJTDJQMJOBUPEBWB
FO DPOTUSVDDJO QFSP  BEFNT Z TPCSF
UPEP QPSRVFOPIBZVOTPMPPCKFUPEF
DPOPDJNJFOUPEFmOJEPEFMRVFTFPDVQF
MBCJPUJDBZRVFFYDMVZBBMPTPUSPT
5BNQPDP MPT QSPCMFNBT EF MPT RVF TF
PDVQBTPOFYDMVTJWBNFOUFTVZPT QVFTFT
DMBSPRVFOFDFTJUBEFMDPODVSTPEFPUSBT
EJTDJQMJOBT4JMBCJPUJDBEFCFSFnFYJP
OBS TPCSF TV FTUBUVUP FQJTUFNPMHJDP Z
TVRVFIBDFSDPNPEJTDJQMJOBUFOESRVF
IBDFSTFFOMBEJONJDBEFVONPWJNJFO
UPQSPHSFTJWP FOFMRVFTFBQPTJCMFSFWJ
TBSQSFTVQVFTUPTZ TJFTFMDBTP GPSNVMBS
OVFWBTQPTJCJMJEBEFTFQJTUNJDBTTJORVF
TFUFOHBRVFQBSBMJ[BSFMSJHPSZFMWBMPS
EFMPTBOMJTJT OJFMDPOUBDUPnVJEPDPO
PUSBTEJTDJQMJOBT"MJHVBMRVFMBTPCSBT
FODPOTUSVDDJO IBZRVFQSPDVSBSRVF
QVFEBOIBDFSTFTJOBGFDUBSFMUSmDPEF
MBDJVEBE
&M FTUBUVUP FQJTUFNPMHJDP EF MB CJP
UJDBOPFTSFTVMUBEPEFVOBDVFSEPOJ
MMFHBTFSQSPEVDUPEFVOFKFSDJDJPRVF
MB PSJFOUBSB FYQMDJUBNFOUF IBDJB FTUP





6OBMFDUVSBDSUJDBEFMBCJPUJDBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB(FSNO$BMEFSO-FHBSEB

.TCJFOFTVOFODVFOUSPEFEJGFSFOUFT
EJTDVSTPTRVFUJFOEFOBIPSJ[POUBMJ[BSTF 
MP DVBM QFSNJUF VOB BNQMJBDJO EF MPT
IPSJ[POUFTDPHOJUJWPT QFSPRVFOPEFCF
JEFOUJmDBSTF DPO MB JNQMFNFOUBDJO
BDBCBEB EF VOB QSDUJDB JOUFSEJTDJQMJ
OBSJBDPNPUBM-BFTUSFDIBDPOFYJOEF
MBCJPUJDBDPOMBTDJFODJBTEFMBWJEB MB
mMPTPGBEFMBNFEJDJOB MBUSBEJDJOEF
VOB BOUSPQPMPHB mMPTmDB Z MB OFDFTJ
EBEEFSFnFYJPOBSTPCSFMPTEFTBSSPMMPT
CJPUFDOPMHJDPT IBO QFSNJUJEP MB QSP
EVDDJOEFVOEJTDVSTPRVFQVFEFNT
PNFOPTJEFOUJmDBSTFPRVFFTJEFOUJm
DBCMF QFSPRVFOVODBSFTPMWJEFTEFFM
DPNJFO[P FM QSPCMFNB EF MB JODMVTJO
RVQPESBDPOTJEFSBSTFDPNPQFSUFOF
DJFOUFBMBCJPUJDBZRVOP
1FSPMBQSFHVOUBTPCSB/BEJFSFTVFMWF
EFVOBTPMBWF[MBJORVJFUVEEFMPRVF
QVFEFPOPQVFEFTFSQBSUFEFVOBOB
DJFOUF EJTDJQMJOB FTP TF WB EFDBOUBOEP
DPOFMUJFNQPZMPRVFMBEFmOFDPNP
UBMFTFOCVFOBQBSUFFMSFTVMUBEPEFMPT
JOUFSFTFTZQSPCMFNUJDBTDPNVOFTRVF 
FOVONPNFOUPEBEP TFDPODSFUBOFO
VO DBNQP EF FTUVEJPT Z FO EJTDVSTPT
RVFMPHSBOBmODBSSBDFT1SPCBCMFNFO
UF  DPNP EJTDJQMJOB  MB CJPUJDB UFOHB
BOUFDFEFOUFT NT QSPGVOEPT Z MF EFCB
NTBPUSBTDPSSJFOUFTJOUFMFDUVBMFTEFMP
RVFOPSNBMNFOUFTFIBBENJUJEP -PMBT
4UFQLF 

4FIBEJDIPZBRVFMBCJPUJDBOPFTVOB
TVNBTJNQMFFOMBDVBMEPTPNTEJTDJ
QMJOBTQSPEVDFOVOBUFSDFSB4FSFRVJFSF
NVDIP NT QBSB BSUJDVMBS VO DPOPDJ
NJFOUP RVF TFB  QPS VO MBEP  QSPEVD

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UP EFM EJMPHP FOUSF EJTDJQMJOBT Z  QPS


PUSP  NFEJP QBSB BDPSUBS MBT EJTUBODJBT
FOUSFUFPSBZQSDUJDB6OBNVFTUSBEF
FTUF UJQP EF SFnFYJO OPT MB EBO BVUP
SFTDPNP.JHVFM,PUUPX RVFFOGSFOUB
FM QSPCMFNB EF MB FQJTUFNPMPHB NPSBM
ZFMBCPSBVOBDSUJDBTPCSFMBBEPQDJO
TJO NT EFM QSJODJQJBMJTNP FO "NSJDB
-BUJOB 7PMOFJ (BSSBGB  RVJFO JOUFOUB
QSFWFOJSOPTTPCSFDJFSUBTGPSNBTEFSF
EVDDJPOJTNPTJNQMF DPOUSBSJPBMOVFWP
QBSBEJHNBEFMBDPNQMFKJEBE-FO0MJ
W  RVF BM IBCMBS EF MB EJNFOTJO EFT
DSJQUJWBZOPSNBUJWBEFMBUJDB CJPUJDB
ZFQJTUFNPMPHB EFmFOEFVOBGPSNBEF
iOPSNBUJWJTNP OBUVSBMJ[BEPw  RVF SF
DPOPDFRVFMBTOPSNBTDBNCJBOZFTUO
EFOUSPEFVOEFTBSSPMMPQPSUBOUP UPEP
BQSJPSJFTSFMBUJWPFIJTUSJDP RVFEBOEP
MBCJPUJDBWJODVMBEBBQSDUJDBTDPHOJ
UJWBT'FSNJO3PMBOE4DISBNNBENJUF
RVFIBZNVDIBTWFSTJPOFTMFHUJNBTEF
MBCJPUJDB QFSPCVTDBVOBFTQFDJmDJEBE
FO"NSJDB-BUJOB:FTUPTFDPOTUJUVZF
FOVOBNVFTUSBEFRVFSFDPOPDFSMBSFB
MJEBEEFOVFTUSPTQBTFTEFMTVSOPTJH
OJmDBQFSEFSFMSJHPSBDBENJDPOJDBFS
FOFMQBSSPRVJBMJTNPEFSFDIB[BSUPEPMP
RVFWFOHBEFMNVOEPEFTBSSPMMBEP DPO
FMBSHVNFOUPTJNQMJTUBEFRVFFTUPPCF
EFDFBGPSNBTEFJNQFSJBMJTNP TFBTUF
QPMUJDP FDPONJDPPDVMUVSBM

6OBPCTFSWBDJOmOBM
3FTVMUBNVDIPNTNFSJUPSJPSFnFYJP
OBS Z FOUSBS FO EJMPHP DSFBUJWP DPO
PUSBT USBEJDJPOFT Z PUSBT OBSSBUJWBT  Z
CFOFmDJBSTF EF MP RVF  DPNP QSPEVDUP
EFVOBBQSPQJBDJOSFBM QVFEBFOSJRVF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

DFSOVFTUSBNJSBEBZOPTQFSNJUBoIBTUB
EPOEF TFB QPTJCMFo DPNQSFOEFS PUSPT
DPOUFYUPT DVMUVSBMFT 4JO RVFSFS FYUFO
EFSMBNFUGPSBNVZMFKPT TFQPESBEF
DJSRVFFMEJMPHPFOUSFDVMUVSBTFTUBO
EJGDJM DPNP FOUSF EJTDJQMJOBT  QFSP OP

JNQPTJCMF -B CJPUJDB MBUJOPBNFSJDB


OBUJFOFIPZNVDIBNTDPODJFODJBEF
FTUFSFUPZ QPSGPSUVOB DVFOUBDPOVO
CVFO ONFSP EF DVMUPSFT DBMJmDBEPT Z
EJTQVFTUPTBBTVNJSMP

3FGFSFODJBT
#FSMJOHVFS  ( 
 #JPFUIJDT  1PXFS BOE *OKVTUJDF *O (BSSBGB  7  1FTTJOJ  -
0SHT
#JPUJDB 1PEFSFJOKVTUJB4P1BVMP &E-PZPMBF$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUSJP
4P$BNJMP QQ
$BMEFSO-FHBSEB ( 
-BBNCJWBMODJBEFMB#JPUJDBDJODPUFTJTQBSBTVQFSBSMB
WFSHVFO[B0SJFOUBDJPOFT6OJWFSTJUSJBT  NBSP
$BNQT 7 
6NBWJEBEFDBMJEBESFGMFYJPOFTTPCSFCJPUJDB#BSDFMPOB "SF[Z.BSFT
'JHVFSPB 13BOE'VFO[BMJEB ) 
#JPFUIJDTJO*CFSP"NFSJDBBOEUIF$BSJCCFBO
5IF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOFBOE1IJMPTPQIZ  
%FDFNCFS QQ
(BSSBGB 7 ,PUUPX .Z4BBEB " 
&TUBUVUPFQJTUFNPMHJDPEFMB#JPUJDB.YJDP 
*OTUJUVUPEFJOWFTUJHBDJPOFT+VSEJDBT 3FE-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM$BSJCFEF#JPUJDB
EFMB6/&4$0
(BSHBSFMMB  3 
 -BT UFPSBT EF MB KVTUJDJB EFTQVT EF 3BXMT VO CSFWF NBOVBM EF
GJMPTPGBQPMUJDB#BSDFMPOB 1BJET
)FMMFS " 
.TBMMEFMBKVTUJDJB#BSDFMPOB $SUJDB QQ
-PMBT4UFQLF ' 
#JPUJDBFMEJMPHPNPSBMFOMBTDJFODJBTEFMBWJEB4BOUJBHPEF
$IJMF 6OJWFSTJUBSJB
-PMBT 4UFQLF  ' 
 #JPUJDB Z BOUSPQPMPHB NEJDB 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF 
.FEJUFSSOFP
-PMBT4UFQLF ' 
3FIJTUPSJBSMB#JPUJDBFO-BUJOPBNSJDB-BDPOUSJCVDJOEF
+BNFT%SBOF"DUB#JPFUIJDB  
Q
.BJOFUUJ +" 
%FTBSSPMMPEFMB#JPUJDBFO"NSJDB-BUJOB3FWJTUB&MFDUSOJDB
EF#JPUJDB  
BHPTUP
.BDLMJO 3 
"HBJOTUSFMBUJWJTNDVMUVSBMEJWFSTJUZBOEUIFTFBSDIGPSFUIJDBMVOJWFSTBMT
JONFEJDJOF/FX:PSL 0YGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT Q
.PVMJOFTT  6 
 )FDIPT F WBMPSFT GBMBDJBT F NFUBGBMBDJBT 6O FKFSDJDJP
JOUFHSBDJPOJTUB*TFHPSJB 3FWJTUBEFGJMPTPGBNPSBMZQPMUJDB  
BCSJM
/VTTCBVN .$ 
8PNFOBOE)VNBO%FWFMPQNFOUUIFDBQBCJMJUJFT"QQSPBDI
/FX:PSL $BNCSJEHF6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT QQ
3FTDIFS / 
3B[OZWBMPSFTFOMBFSBDJFOUmDPUFDOPMHJDB#BSDFMPOB 1BJET Q

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWBQBSBJEFOUJmDBSEFTBGPTB
QBSUJSEFMDPOUFYUPIJTUSJDPIJTQBOPBNFSJDBOP
)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS

*OUSPEVDDJOTJUVBOEPFM
DPOUFYUPIJTUSJDP
1BSB DPNQSFOEFS NFKPS MPT JOJDJPT EF
MB CJPUJDB FO )JTQBOPBNSJDB Z #SBTJM
SFTVMUB JOEJTQFOTBCMF DPOPDFS MBT QFDV
MJBSJEBEFTEFMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFWJEBEF
FTUFTVCDPOUJOFOUF BENJSBCMFNFOUFFY
QVFTUBTFOMBTSFnFYJPOFTEF%JFHP(SB
DJB " QFTBS EF MPT SFDJFOUFT QSPHSFTPT 
MB NBZPSB EF MBT QPCMBDJPOFT WJWBO Z
DPOUJOBOWJWJFOEPCBKPMBMOFBEFQP
CSF[BPDFSDBEFFMMB MPRVFTJHOJmDBRVF
MBQSFPDVQBDJOQSJNPSEJBMDPOTJTUFFO
MB TVQFSWJWFODJB TPDJPFDPONJDB  RVF
BOUFDFEFBDVBMRVJFSEJTDVTJODJFOUmDB
TPCSFCJPUJDB BMFTUJMPEFMPTDPNJUTBE
IPDEFMIFNJTGFSJPOPSUF
&OFTUFDPOUFYUP FTJNQPTJCMFSFGFSJSOPT
FYQMDJUBNFOUFBMBTDPOEJDJPOFTDVJEB
EPTBNFOUFEFTDSJUBTFOFTUBTQHJOBQPS
FTQFDJBMJTUBT EFM UFNB 1PS FTP OVFTUSB
DPODMVTJO GPS[PTBNFOUFTJOUUJDB UFO
ESQSJNFSPMBUBSFBEFDPODMVJS QBSBFM
QSFTFOUF Z QBSB FM GVUVSP  BMHVOBT MFD
DJPOFTDVZBCBTFBOBMUJDB TJUVBEBFOMB
IJTUPSJBQBTBEBZBEFTDSJUB OPEFCFTFS
SFQFUJEB%FFTUFNPEPQPEFNPTWJTVB
MJ[BS VOB PSJFOUBDJO NT QSPTQFDUJWB 
FT EFDJS  DPOTUSVDUJWB UPEP GVUVSP TF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DPOTUSVZFTPCSFMPTYJUPTZMBTGBMMBTEFM
QBTBEP
TJOEFTDPOPDFSRVFQBSUFEFFT
UBTUJFSSBTBOUJFOFONVDIBTEJmDVMUB
EFTQBSBFYUJSQBSMPTGVOFTUPTNFBOESPT
EFMQBTBEP4FFTQFSBRVFOJOHODBQ
UVMPSFTVMUFJOUJMQBSBOVFTUSBQSFTFOUF
FEJmDBDJO  UFOJFOEP TJFNQSF DVJEBEP
EF SFGFSJSOPT B MBT QBSUJDVMBSJEBEFT EFM
DPOUFYUPFTUVEJBEP/PPDVMUBNPTRVF
MBNFKPSMFDDJOEFMBIJTUPSJBFTTJFNQSF
MBEFSFBOJNBSFMJEFBMJTNPQBSBBMDBO[BS
VONFKPSGVUVSP

-BQFSTQFDUJWBVOJWFSTBMJTUBEFMB
CJPUJDBSFTVSHFSFMBUJWJ[BEBQFSP
DPOGVFS[B
%FUST EF MPT JEFBMJTNPT  VUPQBT  TV
QVFTUBT SFMJHJPOFT VOJWFSTBMFT  GSBUFS
OJEBEFT Z DPNQBTJPOFT JMJNJUBEBT  TF
FOUSFWVOJEFBMPFMTVFPEFVOBIV
NBOJEBE NT IVNBOJ[BEB Z TPMJEBSJB 
BKFOB B UPEB HMPCBMJ[BDJO mOBODJFSB
Z DPNVOJDBDJPOBM  NFKPS SFDPODJMJBEB
DPO TV QSPQJB EJWFSTJEBE &O FTUB IJT
UPSJB NVMUJTFDVMBS  MB CJPUJDB JOJDJB EF
BIPSB FO BEFMBOUF VOB JNQPSUBOUF FUB
QB  DPO DBTJ NFEJP TJHMP EF QSPHSFTJWB
QSFQBSBDJOPBOUJDJQBDJO-PTDSJTUJB
OPTQPTFFOVOBQBMBCSBQBSBTJNCPMJ[BS
MB TVQSFNB VOJEBE EF VOB IVNBOJEBE





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

UPUBMNFOUF SFDPODJMJBEB  QFSP i1MFSP


NBw TMP UJFOF TFOUJEP FO MB SCJUB EF
MBGFDSJTUJBOB&OTVMBSHBDBNJOBUB MB
CJPUJDB TF FODVFOUSB FO VOB FUBQB EF
FYDFQDJPOBM SFMFWBODJB /BDJ DPNP
VOB WJTJO BCBSDBEPSB  VOJWFSTBMJTUB 
EFTFBOEPNFKPSBSMBWJEBTPCSFOVFTUSP
QMBOFUB  MP RVF TVQPOB NFKPS DBMJm
DBDJO Z FYQBOTJO EF MB WPMVOUBE EFM
CJFODPNODVBOEPOPTJFNQSFFTUBCB
TVmDJFOUFNFOUFBTFHVSBEPFOFMTFMMPEF
DBEBOBDJO/PQPDBTEFDFQDJPOFTOPT
QSPCBSBORVFFTUFDPODFQUPOPFSBUBO
BDDFTJCMFOJHFOFSBMJ[BEP)BMMFHBEPFM
NPNFOUPEFSFUPNBSFMUFNBDPOBZVEB
EFUPEBTMBTCVFOBTWPMVOUBEFTDJFOUm
DBT QPMUJDBT DVMUVSBMFT SFMJHJPTBTVOB
DBNJOBUBTJOmO
&MQSFTFOUFUSBUBEPEFMDBNJOPSFDPSSJ
EPQPSMBCJPUJDBJCFSPBNFSJDBOBEFTEF
 BVORVFOPTFBFYIBVTUJWP NFSFDF
VOBBDPHJEBFYDFQDJPOBMQPSTVBMDBODF
ZTFSJFEBE&TUPTEPDVNFOUPTTFSOEF
BZVEBFOVOGVUVSPQSYJNP UBOUPQBSB
MBJOWFTUJHBDJODPNPQBSBJOUFSDBNCJPT
EFJOGPSNBDJOZDPMBCPSBDJO1FSDJCJS
MBSJRVF[BZMBEJWFSTJEBEEFMBTUSBZFDUP
SJBTZBSFDPSSJEBTBOJNBBDVBMRVJFSHSV
QPEFQFSTPOBTJOUFSFTBEBTFOCJPUJDB 
FTEFDJS FOFMGVUVSPEFMBIVNBOJEBE
-PT NFEJPT RVF OP TF EFTUSVZFO P TF
DPNCBUFO  TF BZVEBO QPS NFEJP EF MB
DPNQMFNFOUBDJO
/P EFCFNPT FYUSBBS MB QPMBSJEBE EF
VOB UJDB VOJWFSTBM  BDUJWB FO FM TFDUPS
CJPUJDP BVORVFUBMJEFBMQBSF[DBMFKBOP
ZVUQJDP QPSRVFMBCJPUJDBTFSFMBDJPOB
DPOUPEPTMPTEFNTTFDUPSFTEFMBDVM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UVSB FYQSFTJOEFWJEBEFMTFSIVNBOP
*ODMVTPJOBMDBO[BCMF FYDFQUPFOTFDUP
SFTMJNJUBEPT UBMJEFBMFYJHFJOUFOTPTZ
DPOTUBOUFTFTGVFS[PTEFMBTDPNVOJEBEFT
CJFOJOUFODJPOBEBT"QSFDJBNPTVOBFY
QSFTJOJOUFSSPHBUJWBEFMDBQUVMPEFMB
CJPUJDB FO $VCB i-B CJPUJDB DPNP
OVFWP TBCFS  {UJDB BQMJDBEB P NFUBUJ
DB w &M DPODFQUP EF NPSBM DPNO SF
NJUFBMBJEFBEFVOBOBUVSBMF[BIVNBOB
VOJWFSTBMZ BQBSUJSEFFTP EFVOCJFO
DPNO QSPNPUPSEFVOEFSFDIPOBUV
SBMRVFEFCFTFSDPOTUSVJEPFJOWFTUJHB
EP JODFOUJWBEPZBDUVBMJ[BEP
-BIJTUPSJB UBOUPMBBOUJHVBDPNPMBSF
DJFOUF FYIJCFTFSJBTEVEBTFOFTUBSFB 
FTQFDJBMNFOUFDVBOEPFOMBMVDIBFOUSF
QBMFTUJOPTFJTSBFMFTOPTFDPOTJHVFVO
DPOTFOTPUFSJDPZQSDUJDPQBSBVODFTF
EFMGVFHPRVFQFSNJUBUSB[BSMBTDPOEJ
DJPOFTEFVOBQB[EFMBSHPBMDBODF DPO
EJDJPOFT BMJBO[BT WBSJBTWFDFTBDMBSBEBT
Z QPDP SFTQFUBEBT
 #BTUB DPNQSPCBS
MBPCTUJOBDJOEFMQBSUJEP)BNBT QSF
QPOEFSBOUFBIPSBFOMBJEFPMPHBQBMFT
UJOB FOOPBDFQUBSMBTUSFTDPOEJDJPOFT
ZFYJHFODJBTJOUFSOBDJPOBMFTRVFQPTJCJ
MJUBSBOVOBDVFSEPEFQB[FMSFDPOPDJ
NJFOUP EF MB FYJTUFODJB EF *TSBFM DPNP
OBDJO SFBM F JOEFQFOEJFOUF  SFOVODJB
BTVNJEBBMUFSSPSJTNPZBMBWJPMFODJB Z
BEIFTJOBMPTBDVFSEPT QPMUJDBZKVS
EJDBNFOUFDPODMVJEPT OPTJOFTGVFS[PT 
FOUSFMPTSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFMBTEPTFOUJ
EBEFT
{$NP BWBO[BS FO BHVBT NT QSPGVO
EBT TJ SPDBT UBO TFEJNFOUBEBT JNQJEFO
MPTQSJNFSPTQBTPTDPOmBCMFT &MBNPS





6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS

FTVOBGVFS[BDPOTJEFSBCMFZKVTUBNFOUF
DFMFCSBEB  QFSP MB PCTUJOBDJO DFSDBEB
QPSFMPEJPOPBDPTUVNCSBTFSSFDPOP
DJEB FO TV SFBM GVFS[B IJTUSJDB 5BMWF[
IBCSB NFOPT HVFSSBT FO MB IJTUPSJB TJ
MBT NFOUBMJEBEFT oMBT QTJDPMPHBTo GVF
TFOEJGFSFOUFT-BCJPUJDBQVFEFZEFCF
DPOUSJCVJSFOMBBQSPYJNBDJOBVOJEFBM
EFFOUFOEJNJFOUPZQB[
&OVOBEFDMBSBDJOEF FMFTDSJUPS
4BMNBO3VTIEJFBQVOUBi)PZDPNQSP
CBNPTVOBQSPMJGFSBDJOEFWJTJPOFTEFM
NVOEPJSSFDPODJMJBCMFT RVFEJTQVUBOFM
NJTNPFTQBDJP"TJTUJNPTBVODPOnJDUP
RVFPQPOFNFOPTDVMUVSBTPSFMJHJPOFT
RVF QFSDFQDJPOFT EJTNJMFT EF MP SFBM
7JWJNPTVONVOEPGSBDUVSBEP/PTPZ
DSFZFOUFFOUSFMBSB[OZMBGFSFMJHJPTB
FTDPKPTJFNQSFMBSB[O.BT DSFZFOUFT
P BUFPT OP QPEFNPT DPOUFOUBSOPT DPO
VOB WJTJO EFM IPNCSF DPNP DSJBUVSB
SBDJPOBM5BNCJOTPNPTTPBEPSFT MP
RVFOPTBCSFBPUSBEJNFOTJO{$NP
JOUFHSBS FTUB JEFB EF RVF FYJTUF PUSB
DPTB BEFNT EF MB DBSOF Z MB TBOHSF w
3VTIEJF 

-BTEFTJHVBMEBEFTOPFTUOBVTFOUFTFO
MB[POBJCFSPBNFSJDBOB-BCJPUJDBFYJ
HFTPCSFQBTBSMPTBTQFDUPTFTUSJDUBNFOUF
mTJPMHJDPT EFM TFS IVNBOP QBSB FN
QMFBSMBDBQBDJEBETJNCMJDBEFMBQBMB
CSB Z FM QFOTBNJFOUP IVNBOPT  DPO FM
mOEFSFnFYJPOBSTPCSFMBTWJSUVBMJEBEFT
JSSFEVDJCMFT B NBUFSJB RVF DPOEVDFO B
VOPTQPDPTBBTDFOEFSIBDJBMVDFTSFMJ
HJPTBT:BFOFMQMBOPEFMIVNBOJTNP 
OPGVFSPOSFBMJ[BEBTUPEBTMBTDPOFYJP
OFTPQPSUVOBT DPNPOPTSFDVFSEB9JDP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

(SBDJBOPBMBmSNBSRVFiMBTFOTJCJMJEBE
BNCJFOUBMEFMPTNPWJNJFOUPTMMBNBEPT
TPDJBMFTBMDBO[BDBTJBDFSPw (SB[JBOP 


1BSB#PMJWJBQBSFDFNVZJNQPSUBSUFSF
TBMUBS MB IFUFSPHFOFJEBE EF MB CJPUJDB
OBDJPOBM P MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB &YJTUJSB
BRV VOB PQPSUVOJEBE QBSB QSPGVOEJ
[BS MP FRVWPDP EFM USNJOP iTBMVEw P
iWJEB CVFOBw /P UPEPT DPNQBSUJNPT
MPT NJTNPT FMFNFOUPT 1PS FKFNQMP 
{RV FT NFKPS  {6OB WJEB JOUFOTBNFO
UF GFMJ[  QFSP DPSUB  P VOB WJEB NFEJP
DSF Z MBSHB  {1SFGFSJNPT GVNBS NVDIP 
DPOMPTSJFTHPTBOFYPTZNPSJSKWFOFT 
POPTJNQPSUBVOBWJEBBTDUJDBZWJWJS
NT  0USP QVOUP RVF EJGDJMNFOUF PC
UFOESVOBOJNJEBE BNFOPTRVFFYJTUB
JOUFSWFODJPOJTNP iMB CJPUJDB EVSBw

UJMQBSBFMCJFODPNOOBDJPOBMPJO
UFSOBDJPOBM -BT DPODFQDJPOFT EFM CJFO
DPNO EJWFSHFO Z SFQFSDVUFO TPCSF MB
JOTUJUVDJPOBMJ[BDJOEFMBCJPUJDB{2V
QFOTBS QPSFKFNQMP EFMBHSBEVBMQSP
IJCJDJO FVSPQFB EF GVNBS FO MPDBMFT
QCMJDPT {&TDPODFCJCMFQSPIJCJSFMVTP
EF DPDB FO #PMJWJB P MB QSPEVDDJO EF
BNBQPMBTFO5BJMBOEJBPFO"GHBOJTUO
&TWFSEBERVF EFTEF MB0SHBOJ
[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE FMHP
CJFSOPDIJMFOPZMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJ
MF DSFBSPO VO i1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF
#JPUJDBw EFTUJOBEPFOQSJODJQJPBUPEB
"NSJDB -BUJOB Z FM $BSJCF  QSFWJFOEP
WBSJBT BDUJWJEBEFT Z QVCMJDBDJPOFT -B
4PDJFEBE $IJMFOB EF #JPUJDB FT BOUF
SJPSBMSFHJTUSPEFMPTQSJNFSPTDPNJUT
EF CJPUJDB FO MPT IPTQJUBMFT DIJMFOPT 





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

RVF TF SFNPOUB BM JOJDJP EF MB EDBEB 


QFSPEFNPSBSPOCBTUBOUFFOGVODJPOBS
0CTFSWBNPT BTJNJTNP RVFTJCJFOMBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFTDBUMJDBTEF$IJMFTFJOUF
SFTBSPOSQJEBNFOUFQPSMBCJPUJDB MBT
FTUSFDIBT OPSNBT DBUMJDBT DPOmFSFO B
FTUFQBTiNVZDBUMJDPwVOTFMMPCBTUBO
UFDPOTFSWBEPS QBSBNFKPSPQBSBQFPS
QSPUFDDJO EF MB GBNJMJB Z PQPTJDJO BM
BCPSUP  Z EJTUBODJB BOUF MBT JOWFTUJHB
DJPOFTNTBWBO[BEBTFOFTUFTFDUPSEF
MB SFQSPEVDDJO P FO MB JOWFTUJHBDJO
FO DMVMBT USPODP FNCSJPOBSJBT
 -B
$PNJTJO /BDJPOBM EF #JPUJDB FYJTUF
FO$IJMFEFTQVTEFNVDIPTEFCBUFTZ
PQPTJDJPOFT QFSPFTQPDPSFQSFTFOUBUJWB
ZTVGVODJPOBNJFOUPEFKBRVFEFTFBS&M
QSJODJQJBMJTNPOPSUFBNFSJDBOPGVFSFDJ
CJEPBOUFTRVFFOPUSPTQBTFT QFSPMB
BQBUB EFM FYUSFNP DPOTFSWBOUJTNP OP
FTU DPNQFOTBEB QPS MB JSSVQDJO EF
HSBOEFTGVFS[BTEFMNFSDBEP6OBDPTB
FT FM DPNQPSUBNJFOUP EF MBT FMJUFT EFM
QPEFSNEJDPZPUSBMBFWPMVDJO NT
MFOUB EFMBTNFOUBMJEBEFTQPQVMBSFT"M
mOBM DBEBVOBEFMBTOBDJPOFTMBUJOPB
NFSJDBOBT FTU NVZ TVCEJWJEJEB TPDJBM
ZDVMUVSBMNFOUFQPSMPTSFDVSTPTFDPO
NJDPT  B QFTBS EF BQSFDJBCMFT FTGVFS[PT
IVNBOJUBSJPT
.JFOUSBT UBOUP OP EFCFNPT FYUSBBS
MBBUSBDDJOEFMBUJDBVOJWFSTBM KVTUB
NFOUFJODFOUJWBEBQPSMBTPCSBTZNP
WJNJFOUPTJOJDJBEPTQPS)BOT,OH Z
RVF QSFDJTBNFOUF QFSNFBOBMBCJPUJ
DB QVFTUPRVFFTUBMUJNBFTUSFMBDJP
OBEBDPOUPEPTMPTPUSPTTFDUPSFTEFMB
DVMUVSB IVNBOB  WJSUVBM Z SFBMNFOUF 
JODMVTPTJOTVmDJFOUFDPPSEJOBDJOTJO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UUJDB 5BM JEFBM  DBTJ JOBMDBO[BCMF  OP


QPSFTPFYJHFNFOPTFTGVFS[PTJOUFOTPT
Z DPOTUBOUFT FO UPEBT MBT DPNVOJEBEFT
FOJOUFSDBNCJP$VOQPTJUJWPTFSBEBS
UFTUJNPOJPEFVOBDPNQFUFODJBBNJHB
CMFFOUSFMPTFTGVFS[PTEFDPPSEJOBDJO
RVFMMFWBBDBCPMB6OJO&VSPQFBoOP
TJOEJmDVMUBEFT QJPOFSBFOFTUPFOSFMB
DJODPOPUSPTDPOUJOFOUFToZVONPWJ
NJFOUPTJNJMBSTVTDJUBEPPJODFOUJWBEP
QPS MB QSFTFOUF PCSB  TJO NFOPTQSFDJBS
MPT JOTVTUJUVJCMFT TFSWJDJPT EF MB 0SHB
OJ[BDJO .VOEJBM EF MB 4BMVE Z EF MPT
PSHBOJTNPT RVF ZB FTUO BDUVBOEP FO
"NSJDB-BUJOB
-BT FNCFTUJEBT EF MBT DPOUSBGVFS[BT EF
MBIJTUPSJBOPPDVMUBOMBTDPOWFSHFODJBT
EFNVDIPTUSBCBKPTEFCJPUJDBFGFDUVB
EPTFTQFDJBMNFOUFFOFMHSVQPIJTQBOP
BNFSJDBOPZQPSUVHVT FOFMTFOUJEPEF
JNQVMTBS FM QSPHSFTP EF VOB DJFODJB Z
VOBSUFRVFFTUOSFBMNFOUFBMTFSWJDJP
EFMIPNCSFZ FOMPQPTJCMF EFUPEPTMPT
TFSFTIVNBOPT ZRVF BOUFFMPCTUDVMP
oMBEJmDVMUBERVFTVSHFGSFOUFBMBDSFB
UJWJEBEOVODBFTHSBUVJUBo FTUTJFNQSF
QSFQBSBEB QBSB MPT DPNCBUFT  FO HFOF
SBM  TJMFODJBEPT 1PS FTP WBMPSJ[BNPT FM
USBCBKPEFIPSNJHBTRVFDVNQMFOUBOUPT
JOWFTUJHBEPSFTZFRVJQPTEFCJPUJDB TB
CJFOEPRVFVOEB EFTQVTEFNVDIBTZ
EJTDSFUBTFUBQBT TVSHJSVOOVFWPQSP
HSFTPQBSBMBIVNBOJEBE{/PTBCFNPT
BDBTP RVF UPEB TOUFTJT TFSJB EFCF TFS
QSFDFEJEBQPSNVDIPTEFUBMMFTZBOMJTJT
EFDBTPT -PRVFEJTUJOHVFBMTFSIVNB
OPEFMBNBZPSBEFMPTBOJNBMFTFTTV
HSBO DBQBDJEBE EF BDVNVMBS TV DBQJUBM
EFTBCFSZEFLOPXIPXEFHFOFSBDJO





6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS

FO HFOFSBDJO 4BMUPT EFDJTJWPT GVFSPO


FGFDUVBEPT DBTJ QPS DBTVBMJEBE  CBKP MB
QSFTJO EF VSHFODJBT JOTPTMBZBCMFT RVF
OP IVCJSBNPT JNBHJOBEP QSPWPDBS 
QFSPRVFFYJTUJSOTJFNQSF%FTUBDBNPT
RVF  FO UBMFT FNCBUFT  FM DFSUBNFO OP
FTBQFOBTFOUSFQSPGFTJPOBMFTZMBOBUV
SBMF[B CJPGTJDB  TJOP UBNCJO FOUSF MPT
EJWFSTPTDSJUFSJPTEFWBMPSBDJOFOUSFMPT
QSPGFTJPOBMFT  UPDBOEP BIPSB MPT mOFT 
BIPSBMPTNFEJPTEFTVUSBCBKP

-BDPNQMFNFOUBDJOZFM
QBSBMFMJTNPEFMPTODMFPT
CJPUJDPTJEFOUJmDBEPT
&TQSPCBCMFRVFFODBEBOBDJOPSFHJO
MBCJPUJDBSFnFKF NFKPSEFMPRVFQBSF
DF MBDVMUVSBEFMQBTPEFMNFEJP PCWJB
NFOUFTJOOFHBSMPTPCKFUJWPTDPNVOFT
4JOFYQMJDJUBSFMQMVSBMJTNPEFMBTDPNV
OJEBEFT  DBEB VOB QVFEF SFDJCJS BMHP 
BTDPNPQVFEFQSPQPSDJPOBSBMHPRVF
QPTFB /JOHVOB QVFEF FOGSFOUBS TPMB
FMDPOKVOUPEFVOBTJUVBDJODPNQMFKB
5BM QMVSBMJTNP TF QSFmHVSB GSFDVFOUF
NFOUFFOMPTNJFNCSPTQBSUJDJQBOUFTFO
FMDPNJUEFCJPUJDB QFSPOPTJFNQSF
MPTQBTFTQPCSFTMPHSBOSFVOJSVOFRVJ
QP EJWFSTJmDBEP Z BEFDVBEP .VDIPT
NEJDPTQSFmFSFOEJTDVUJSFOUSFT EFT
DPOmBOEP EF MBT BCFSSBDJPOFT RVF QP
ESBOTVSHJSEFMBCPDBEFFYUSBPT-B
QSDUJDBEFMBCJPUJDBFTVOBFTDVFMBEF
IVNJMEBE 5PEB DVMUVSB FT QPMJWBMFOUF
ZMBCJPUJDBUSBCBKBQSFDJTBNFOUFDPO
VO DPOKVOUP EF DVMUVSBT -B NJOVDJB
BOBMUJDBEFMBTNVKFSFTEFCFDPNQMFUBS
MBTWJTJPOFTTJOUUJDBTRVFDPOTUJUVZFOFM
GVFSUFEFMIPNCSF-BQSFTFODJBEFKVSJT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

UBTSFDVFSEBRVFMPTOFHPDJPTIVNBOPT
TPO TPDJBMNFOUF DPNQMFKPT FO DPSUP
UJFNQP BMBCJPUJDBTFHVJSVOCJPEF
SFDIP QFSPMBQSJTBTFEFTBDPOTFKB TPCSF
UPEPFOVODMJNBNVZQPMJUJ[BEP
4FSB BSSJFTHBEP FWPDBS BRV B FDPOP
NJTUBT  QPSRVF MB CJPUJDB BDPTUVNCSB
QMBOFBS QPS FODJNB EF MBT DPOUJOHFO
DJBT QSFTVQVFTUBSJBT &T JOUJM NFODJP
OBS DVOUP TF OFDFTJUBSB MB QSFTFODJB
EFSFQSFTFOUBOUFTEFWBSJBTSFMJHJPOFTP
BOUSPQPMPHBT WJWFODJBEBT FO MB SFHJO 
EFUFSBQFVUBTEFPUSPTFTUJMPTPEFPUSBT
FTQFDJBMJEBEFTUFSBQVUJDBTZQSPGFTJPOB
MFT-BSFQSFTFOUBDJOEFMPTFOGFSNPTFT
NTFTDBTBZEJGDJMEFFODPOUSBS DVBOEP
OPFTEFTDBSUBEBBQSJPSJTJOFNCBSHP 
{OPTPOFMMPTMPTRVFDPOPDFOTVTNBMFT
QPSEFOUSPZOPFTUOEFTFPTPTEFNFKP
SBS 3FTVMUBGPS[PTPBENJUJSRVF DVBOUP
NBZPS TFB FM ONFSP EF QBSUJDJQBOUFT 
TFS NT EJGDJM P JNQPTJCMF BMDBO[BS
VOBOJNJEBE B WFDFT QBSFDF TVmDJFOUF
VO DJFSUP HSBEP EF DPOWFSHFODJB QBSB
KVTUJmDBSEFUFSNJOBEBEFDJTJO6OBEF
DJTJONVZSQJEBQVFEFTVHFSJSRVFMB
TPMVDJOOPPGSFDFVOBSFTQVFTUBTMJEB
P DPNPPDVSSFFOBTBNCMFBTEJQMPN
UJDBT RVFTVTUSNJOPTTPOMPTVmDJFO
UFNFOUF nFYJCMFT DPNP QBSB QFSNJUJS
WBSJBTJOUFSQSFUBDJPOFT
-BQSDUJDBQBSFDFSFWFMBSRVFFMFNCB
UFFOUSFNEJDPTZKVSJTUBTFTGSFDVFOUF
TJOFNCBSHP FTJOFWJUBCMFPUSBDPOGSPO
UBDJOTFUSBUBEFMBEJTDPSEBODJBFOUSF
DJFSUBT QPTJDJPOFT SFMJHJPTBT Z MB NBZP
SBEFMPTDJFOUmDPTRVF EFIFDIP TPO
BHOTUJDPT -B SB[O EFM DPOnJDUP FT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

PCWJB Z TF NBOJGFTUBS DBEB WF[ NT B


NFEJEB RVF QSPMJGFSFO FTQFDJBMNFOUF
MPT GVOEBNFOUBMJTNPT SFMJHJPTPT  DPNP
MB FYQBOTJO EF MB JOnVFODJB JTMNJ
DB 6OB SFMJHJO JNQPOF EPHNBT DVZB
GVFOUFEFTVTUFOUBDJOFTVOBSFWFMBDJO
iTPCSFOBUVSBMwRVFFMDSFZFOUFOPQVF
EFDPOUSBEFDJS QFSPRVFOPUJFOFWBMPS
BQPEDUJDPQBSBFMDJFOUmDP EBEPRVFMB
CBTFEFTVTUFOUBDJOEFMBDJFODJBFT DPO
BZVEBEFMBNBUFNUJDB MBPCTFSWBDJO
EF IFDIPT GDUJDPT  MB DPNQSPCBDJO
QPSMBFYQFSJFODJBPMBFYQFSJNFOUBDJO
$BCF PCTFSWBS RVF IPZ  GVFSB EF BMHV
OPTSFEVDUPTEFMDJFOUJTNPEFDBEFOUF MB
DJFODJBFTUNVDIPNFOPTTFHVSBEFTV
QPTJDJOiEFmOJUJWBwRVFFMDSFZFOUFTV
NJTPEFTVTEPHNBTEFSFMJHJO1FSPFM
DJFOUmDPDPNPUBMOVODBBENJUJSMBJO
UFSWFODJOEFTVGF TJMBUVWJFSB TPCSFFM
TBCFSDJFOUmDP DVBOEPFMMBJOUFSWFOHB
FO MB JOUFSQSFUBDJO EF EBUPT PGSFDJEPT
QPSMBIJTUPSJBPQPSMBOBUVSBMF[B
-BDPNQMFNFOUBDJOEFFOGPRVFTEFCF
QSFWFOJSPDPSSFHJSBNFOB[BTEFNJPQB
FOFMUSBUBNJFOUPTCJPUJDP PBWFOUVSBT
CJPHFOUJDBT RVF QSFUFOEFSBO TPCSF
QBTBS MP HFOUJDB P NPSGPMHJDBNFOUF
EBEPQPSMBOBUVSBMF[BIVNBOB-PTN
UPEPT QSPQJPT EF MB CJPUJDB EFQFOEFO
EFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBEFNPDSBDJBDVBOUP
NT EFNPDSUJDB TFB MB DVMUVSB EF VOB
OBDJO  NT QSFQBSBEB FTUBS QBSB FN
QSFOEFS MPT DBNJOPT EF MB CJPUJDB -B
NBZPSB EF MPT HSBOEFT EFTDVCSJNJFO
UPT DPOUFNQPSOFPT OP TPO QSPEVDUP
EFM DFSFCSP EF VO TPMP IPNCSF  BVO
RVFVOPTDVBOUPTDJFOUmDPTSFDJCBOFM
QSFNJP /PCFM QPS UBM P DVBM EFTDVCSJ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

NJFOUPTPOFMSFTVMUBEPEFMUSBCBKPEF
FRVJQPT EF JOWFTUJHBEPSFT RVF TF DPN
QMFNFOUBO USBCBKBOEPPOPFODPOKVO
UP%FFTUFNPEP FMFKFSDJDJPNJTNPEF
MBCJPUJDBPCMJHBBCVTDBSMBDPOWFSHFO
DJBEFMPTIBMMB[HPTJOEJWJEVBMFTPDPMFD
UJWPT BM TFSWJDJP EF MB JOUFHSJEBE EF MBT
QFSTPOBT&TUPOPOPTMMFWBBDPOGVOEJS
MBTDJFODJBTCJPNEJDBTDPOMBmMPTPGBP
DPOMBSFMJHJO TPCSFUPEPQPSRVFDJFSUP
DPODFQUPBOUSPQPMHJDP FTEFDJS EFMB
OBUVSBMF[BQSPGVOEBEFMTFSIVNBOP TF
FODVFOUSB TJFNQSF QSFTFOUF -B EJWFS
TJEBE EF QVOUPT EF WJTUB EF DVBMRVJFS
FRVJQP  FTQFDJBMNFOUF FO FM DPNJFO[P
EFMFYBNFOEFEFUFSNJOBEPTEFTBGPT FT
OPSNBM  EFTFBCMF Z  QPS MP HFOFSBM  GF
DVOEB TJFNQSFRVFFMBOUBHPOJTNPOP
EFHFOFSFFOIPTUJMJEBEPFOQSFDPODFQUP
TFEJNFOUBEP 5PEPT EFCFO FNQMFBS MB
SB[O VOBSB[OBCJFSUBBUPEBWFSEBE 
JODMVTPDVBOEPOPTJFNQSFTFBJHVBMMB
CJPUJDBFTFTDVFMBEFUPMFSBODJBRVFOP
EFCFPCTUSVJSMBBQFSUVSBBMBWFSEBEEF
DVBMRVJFSPSJHFO TJFNQSFRVFTFQSFTFO
UFDPOTFSJFEBE/BEJFQPTFFMBWFSEBE
UPUBM Z DPNQMFUB FTUB DPODJFODJB FWJUB
DPOTUSVJSCBSSFSBTQBSBMBBDFQUBDJOEF
MPOVFWP
2VFEFWF[FODVBOEPMBTJOOPWBDJPOFT
OPTDPOEV[DBOBIBCMBSEFVOOVFWPQB
SBEJHNBEFQFOTBNJFOUPPEFPSHBOJ[B
DJOFOMBJOWFTUJHBDJOFTNVZOPSNBM 
QFSPFMQSPHSFTPOVODBTVSHFEFMBOBEB 
Z MB IJTUPSJB JODMVZF DJFSUB NFNPSJB
RVFOPDPSUBGDJMNFOUFTVQSPQJPIJMP
&YJTUFDJFSUBTBCJEVSBFOSFDPOPDFSFTUB
DPOUJOVJEBEEFMBTEJTDPOUJOVJEBEFTIJT
USJDBT BTDPNPMBFMFWBDJOEFMBUSBT





6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS

DFOEFODJBSFMJHJPTBBUSBWTEFMQMVSBMJT
NPEFMBTSFMJHJPOFT PMBTFSJFEBEEFMPT
JOWFTUJHBEPSFTEFTFDUPSFTNVZEJGFSFO
UFTEFMBSFBMJEBE-BIJTUPSJBOVODBSF
QJUFFYBDUBNFOUFMPTNJTNPTQBTPTQPS
FTPDPOmBNPTFORVF EFBMHONPEP 
FMQPSWFOJSTJFNQSFTFSNTJOUFSFTBO
UF&MCJPFUJDJTUBTBCFSFDPOPDFSFMGPO
EPDPNOFOUSFEFTBGPTNVZEJTUJOUPT 
TFBO P OP EF MB NJTNB SFB  BT DPNP
MBTDBSBDUFSTUJDBTQSPQJBTEFDBEBDBTP 
RVFFYJHFVOBSFQVFTUBBQSPQJBEBZOP
VOBEFDPOGFDDJOQSFFTUBCMFDJEB5PEP
TFSFTPSJHJOBM UBOUPNTUPEBQFSTPOB
'SFOUF B DVBMRVJFS DBTP MB QSFHVOUB FT
{DVMFTMBFYQFSJFODJBRVFQVFEFBQPSUBS
BFTUFFWFOUPZDPORVOPWFEBEPGBDUP
SFTFYDFQDJPOBMFTDPOUSJCVZF

$PTUPTFDPONJDPTZTPDJBMFT
%FBMHVOBNBOFSBGVFTBCJPQSPDMBNBS
VO OVFWP PSEFO TPDJPTBOJUBSJP B QBSUJS
EFM MFJUNPUJW FM DJVEBEBOP iUJFOF EF
SFDIP B MB TBMVEw FYBHFSBDJO VUQJ
DB QFSPDPOWFODJPOBM
ZDPNQFUFBMBT
JOTUJUVDJPOFT QCMJDBT QSPWFFS  TJ GVFTF
OFDFTBSJP ZmOBODJBSUBMFTTJTUFNBT-B
QSDUJDBSFWFMBRVFFTUFQSPZFDUPSBEJDBM
TPDJBMJTUB FT QSDUJDBNFOUF JSSFBMJ[BCMF
FOFMNVOEPBDUVBM/PGVFFYJUPTPFO
MB 6OJO 4PWJUJDB Z TVT MPHSPT  UBMWF[
SFMBUJWPT FO $VCB  TPO EVSBNFOUF QB
HBEPTQPSPUSPTTFDUPSFTEFOFDFTJEBEFT
TPDJBMFTZEFMBWJEBQCMJDB-BTNJTNBT
JOUFSSPHBOUFTCJPUJDBTOPQVFEFOJHOP
SBSTVTJODJEFODJBTFDPONJDBT JODMVTP
TJMBIBCJMJEBEQPMUJDBPMBJODPOTDJFODJB
QSFTVQVFTUBSJBSFDPNJFOEFODBMMBSTPCSF
UBMFT BTQFDUPT EF MPT EFTBGPT CJPUJDPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

{"RVJOMFJNQPSUBOSFBMNFOUFMPTNJ
MMPOFTPCJMMPOFTEFMBEFVEBEFTFHVSJ
EBE TPDJBM  5PEP QSPHSFTP TPDJBM UJFOF
VODPTUPFDPONJDPFMQSPCMFNBSFTJEF
FOBDFSUBSDVMFTGVFOUFTQBHBEPSBTTPO
MBTNTDPOWFOJFOUFTZFmDBDFT
"T  VOB WF[ RVF SFQBSBNPT FO MB IJT
UPSJBEFMBCJPUJDB BQSFDJBNPTVOWBJ
WOFOUSFFMQSPZFDUPZMBSFBMJ[BDJO FM
JEFBMZMBGBDUJCJMJEBE MBWJTJOmOBMEF
MBSHP QMB[P Z MBT DPOEJDJPOFT DPODSFUBT
EFNFKPSBJONFEJBUBPSQJEBEFMDBTP
RVFFOGSFOUBNPTIPZFOEB4JMBTBMVE
FYJHFDBEBWF[NTJOWFSTJPOFTZHBTUPT 
VSHFFTDPHFSDNPEJTDFSOJSZTFMFDDJP
OBSMBTGVFOUFTQBHBEPSBTZDNPFYJHJS
FDPOPNBT FO TFDUPSFT NBSHJOBMFT &O
NVDIPTQBTFTTFPCTFSWBVOBNVMUJQMJ
DBDJOJOUJMEFFYNFOFTSFQFUJUJWPTZ
DPOTVMUBT JOTJHOJmDBOUFT 6O QBT DVZB
EFVEB FYUFSOB TVQFSB FM  P  EF
TV1*#OPEFCFSBEFTQSFDJBSNPEFTUPT
BIPSSPTTVQSJNJFOEPWJBKFTJOUJMFT)BZ
RVFJNBHJOBSTFDUPSFTGVFSBEFMBTBMVE
QCMJDB DPNPFMEFFEVDBDJOZGPSNB
DJO FOMPTDVBMFTMPTBIPSSPTEFCFSBO
DVNQMJSTFTJOQSFKVJDJPT-BNBEVSF[EF
VOBOBDJOEFTBSSPMMBEBTFNJEFNVDIP
QPSMBUBTBEFTVJOWFSTJOFOJOWFTUJHB
DJODJFOUmDB FTQFDJBMNFOUFCJPNEJ
DB  QFSP FMMB FTU DBTJ QPS DPNQMFUP BM
TFSWJDJPEFMPTNTSJDPT
3FDPSEFNPTMBTPMJEBSJEBEEFMBCJPNF
EJDJOBDPOMBTEFNTEFQFOEFODJBTQ
CMJDBT UBMDPNPTFSFDVFSEBOMBTQSPQP
TJDJPOFTHVCFSOBNFOUBMFTEFMFDPMPHJTUB
GSBODT/JDPMBT)VMPUQPOFSFMNFEJP
BNCJFOUFFOFMDPSB[OEFM&TUBEP DPO





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

VO WJDFQSJNFS NJOJTUSP FODBSHBEP EFM


EFTBSSPMMP TVTUFOUBCMF DSFBS VOB UB[B
EFDBSCPOPIBTUBSFEVDJSQPSDVBUSPMBT
FNJTJPOFT EF HBT DBSCOJDP DPOTVMUBS
B MB HFOUF BDFSDB EF MB PSJFOUBDJO EFM
EFTBSSPMMPTVTUFOUBCMFQSPNPWFSMBTFO
TJCJMJ[BDJO FEVDBUJWB EFM QCMJDP SFMB
DJPOBEB DPO MB FDPMPHB Z MB TBMVE Q
CMJDB5BMDPNPEJDF4HPMOF3PZBMiFM
WFSEBEFSP EFTBGP DPOTJTUF FO DPODJMJBS
MBMVDIBQPSVONFKPSBNCJFOUFDPOVOB
VSHFODJBTPDJBMZVOEFTBSSPMMPTVTUFOUB
CMFw MPRVFQFSNJUJSBTVQSJNJSSFHBMBT
QSPEJHJPTBT QBSB QBHBS B QSFDJP EF PSP
BMHVOPT NFTFT P BPT EF TVQFSWJWFODJB
BSUJmDJBM B CFCT EF GBNJMJBT QPMUJDB Z
FDPONJDBNFOUF TPCSFQSPUFHJEBT -B
FY DBOEJEBUB TPDJBMJTUB B MB QSFTJEFODJB
EFMBSFQCMJDBGSBODFTBUFOBUSFTUFNBT
QSJPSJUBSJPT MB FYDFMFODJB EFM NFEJP
BNCJFOUF Z MBT QSFPDVQBDJPOFT TPDJBMFT
ZFDPONJDBT FOMBTDVBMFTMBTBOJUBSJB
PDVQBCBVOBQPTJDJODSFDJFOUF3FTVMUB
DVSJPTPDPOTUBUBSMPTQSFKVJDJPTMBUJOPB
NFSJDBOPTDPOUSB$IJMF QBTEFMBNFKPS
TBMVE QPMUJDPTPDJBM MPT FSSPSFT DSJNJ
OBMFTEF1JOPDIFUOPFOUSBOBRV
DPO
MB NT EJGVOEJEB PQJOJO EF SFDIB[BS
MBQSFWJTJOTPDJBMQPSDBQJUBMJ[BDJO MB
GSNVMB FYJUPTB FO $IJMF  Z RVF FYJHF 
FWJEFOUFNFOUF  VOB DPNQMFNFOUBDJO
FTUBUBMQBSBMPTNTQPCSFT

NVOEJBMEFMBQSPEVDDJOEFBVUPNWJ
MFTFWJUBMPTHSBWFTJODPOWFOJFOUFTQBSB
FMQSFTFOUFZFMGVUVSPEFMBTBMVE-BTP
DJFEBE#PFJOH4QFDUSPMBC BQPZBEBQPSFM
EFQBSUBNFOUPOPSUFBNFSJDBOPEFFOFS
HB  JOOPW DPO NPEFMPT GPUPWPMUJDPT
RVFUSBOTGPSNBOMBSBEJBDJOTPMBSDPO
VO JODSFCMF SFOEJNJFOUP EF   
DVBOEP FM SDPSE FVSPQFP OP TPCSFQB
TBCBFM&WJEFOUFNFOUFUPEPFTUP
UJFOFTVDPTUPZEFQFOEFEFPQDJPOFTEF
JOWFTUJHBDJOFJOWFSTJORVFOPTPOBD
DFTJCMFTQBSBUPEPTMPTQBTFT

$POFMQSPQTJUPEFQSPUFHFSTVNFEJP
BNCJFOUF  *TMBOEJB EFDJEJ FNQMFBS FM
USBOTQPSUF QCMJDP B IJESHFOP  CVFO
DBOEJEBUP QBSB TVTUJUVJS BM QFUSMFP
DVBOEPTUFTFUFSNJOF&OQPDPUJFNQP
UBMFTJOOPWBDJPOFTWBOBUFOFSTVTDPTUPT 
BIPSBZBFMFWBEPT5BNQPDPFMBVNFOUP

"QFTBSEFVOPTDVBOUPTHFTUPTOPCMFT 
BMHVOPT EF MPT DVBMFT TPO KVTUBNFOUF
DMFCSFT QPS DSFBS GVOEBDJPOFT EF BZV
EB TPDJBM JOUFSOBDJPOBM V PSHBOJTNPT
OPHVCFSOBNFOUBMFT 0/(
FTQSFDJTP
SFDPOPDFSRVFMPTBWBODFTNPEFSOPTEF
MBCJPNFEJDJOBCFOFmDJBONTSQJEBZ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

-B DPODFOUSBDJO EF GPSUVOBT Z SFOUBT 


UBOUP FOUSF OBDJPOFT DPNP EFOUSP EF
DBEBQBT DPOTUJUVZFVOGBDUPSQPDPBOJ
NBEPSQBSBOVFTUSBQSPTQFDUJWB&YJTUF
FMSJFTHPEFUFOFSBGVUVSPEPTNFEJDJ
OBT VOB QBSB MPT SJDPT Z PUSB QBSB MPT
QPCSFT #BTUB PCTFSWBS MB FWPMVDJO EF
MBEJTUSJCVDJOEFMBTSFOUBT TPCSFUPEP
FOMPTQBTFTNTEFTBSSPMMBEPTRVJFOZB
UJFOFNVDIP NBBOB TJOEVEB UFOES
NVDIPNT PQFSBDJOBDFMFSBEBDVBO
EP MPT HSBOEFT QBUSPOFT TF BVUPBUSJCV
ZFO VO TUPDL EF PQDJPOFT B QSPGVTJO
&MNVOEPFDPONJDPDBNCJMBTSFHMBT
MPRVFNTJNQPSUBQBSBMBTHSBOEFTmS
NBTZBOPFTMBSFMBDJOFOUSFQBUSPOFT
ZBTBMBSJBEPT TJOPFMSFOEJNJFOUPEFTVT
BDDJPOFTFOMBTCPMTBT





6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS

BNQMJBNFOUFBMBTGBNJMJBTNTBEJOFSB
EBT -B TPMJEBSJEBE TF FYQBOEF NT G
DJMNFOUFFOMPTEJTDVSTPTRVFFOMBTBZV
EBTNTOFDFTJUBEBT-BNJTNBSFMBDJO
FOUSF MPT TFDUPSFT QCMJDPT Z QSJWBEPT 
FODBEBQBTZFOFMNVOEP OPFTFTUB
CMF ZSFTVMUBQFMJHSPTPNBOJGFTUBSBMHO
EPHNBUJTNP TPCSF MB NFKPS TPMVDJO 
RVF EFQFOEF EF MPT DPOUFYUPT /VODB 
GVFSBEF.OBDPZEFVOBTQPDBTJTMBT
EF FYUSFNB SJRVF[B  VO &TUBEP QPES
QSPNFUFSBTVTSFTJEFOUFTPDJVEBEBOPT 
Z DVNQMJS SFBMNFOUF  UPEPT MPT DPTUPT
FYJHJEPT QBSB MB NBOVUFODJO EF UPEB
TV QPCMBDJO FO VO OJWFM SB[POBCMF EF
CJFOFTUBS
-BSJHVSPTBJHVBMEBEEFUSBUPOPQBTBEF
TFSVOTVFPPVOBQSPNFTBEFDBNQB
B-PTJOEVTUSJBMFTPQSPGFTJPOBMFTEFM
TFDUPSQCMJDPPQSJWBEPRVFHBOBO QPS
NFT NTEFVONJMMOEFFVSPTPUSFT
NJMMPOFT EF EMBSFT  TPO FWJEFOUFNFO
UFFTDBTPTFOMB[POBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOB TJ
FT RVF FYJTUFO "MHVOPT EF MPT EVFPT
EF HSBOEFT GPSUVOBT EF PSHFOFT CJFO
EJWFSTPT  USBEJDJPOBMFT P SFDJFOUFT  IP
OFTUPT P GSBVEVMFOUPT
 QSPQJDJBO  TJO
FNCBSHP  PCSBT P GVOEBDJPOFT DVZB
VUJMJEBE Z HFOFSPTJEBE QPESB FYQBO
EJSTFFODVBMRVJFSOBDJO&TQFSBSUPEP
EF VO HPCJFSOP  FTQFDJBMNFOUF DVBOEP
TVTNJFNCSPTTFTJFOUFOHBOBEPSFT OP
TJSWF B MB EJONJDB EFM EFCJEP QSPHSF
TPTBOJUBSJPZTPDJBM%PN'SBHPTP RVF
GVF PCJTQP EF $SBUFVT  FO FM OPSEFT
UF EF #SBTJM  SFRVJT MBT EPOBDJPOFT EF
VOBSJDBEJDFTJTBMFNBOBRVF TFHOM 
USBOTGPSNBSBBTVTQBSSPRVJBOPTQPCSFT
FONFOEJHPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

{"RVUJQPEFFYQMPTJOTFFYQPOFOMBT
CPMTBTEFDPODFOUSBDJOEFSJRVF[BTRVF
TF GPSNBO FO UPSOP EF BMHVOBT mSNBT 
QFSTPOBMJEBEFT P GBNJMJBT  5SBT FM BHP
UBNJFOUP EF MBT SFTFSWBT EF QFUSMFP Z
MB QSEJEB EF FOFSHB Z EJOBNJTNP EF
MB OPUBCMF DJWJMJ[BDJO OPSUFBNFSJDBOB 
EFTEFZBBGFDUBEBQPSMBUJOPTOPTJFNQSF
UBODSFBUJWPTZHFOJBMFT {DNPTFDPN
QPSUBSMBEPNJOBDJODIJOB {$NPTF
DPNQPSUBSFMJNQFSJBMJTNPGVOEBNFO
UBMJTUBEFVO*TMBNDVZPTPQMPOPEBTF
BMFTEFBHPUBNJFOUP 0 {RVPDVSSJS
DPO FM FODVFOUSP  JOFWJUBCMF  EF FTUBT
EPTGVFS[BTFOVOGVUVSPSFMBUJWBNFOUF
QSYJNP {2VDVMUJWPIBS VOBZPUSB 
EF MBT DPORVJTUBT ZB SFBMJ[BEBT QPS MB
CJPUJDB 
#JPUJDB  FDPMPHB Z FDPOPNB TF FO
DVFOUSBODPOFDUBEBT%FCFONPTUSBSTF 
BMBSHPQMB[P DPNPGBDUPSFTEFQSPNP
DJOEFVOCJFODPNOVOJWFSTBM QFSP
QBMQBCMF  B QFTBS EF MB USBEJDJPOBM DF
HVFSBEFMPTQPUFOUBEPT1PSMPHFOFSBM 
FYJTUFVOBNJTUFSJPTBDPOFYJOFOUSFMP
NTDFSDBOPZMPNTMFKBOPNTEFVOB
JOWFODJOTVSHFEFMBSFQFOUJOBZDBTVBM
BQSPYJNBDJOEFEBUPTRVFOPBDPTUVN
CSBNPTBDPOTJEFSBSKVOUPT
&O TV DBQUVMP EF JOUSPEVDDJO IJTU
SJDB  %JFHP (SBDJB MMBNB MB BUFODJO
BDFSDB EF MB FWFOUVBM PQPSUVOJEBE EF
QSPGVOEJ[BS MPT QSJODJQJPT EF KVTUJDJB
ZEFOPNBMFmDFODJB RVFQBSFDFONT
BQSPQJBEPT BM DPOUFYUP BRV FTUVEJBEP
&TUBQFSUJOFOUFSFnFYJONFSFDFDPOTJ
EFSBDJO QFSPOPFTEFDJTJWB/PTPUSPT
NJTNPT IFNPT QMBOUFBEP BRV FM UFNB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

FDPONJDPRVFQFTBDBEBWF[NTTPCSF
FMEFTBGPTBOJUBSJP OPUBOUPFOSB[OEF
MBNVMUJQMJDBDJOEFMBQPCMBDJO FTQF
DJBMNFOUFEFMPTJOGPSUVOBEPTFNJHSBO
UFT RVF IVZFO EF TV QBT  NJTFSBCMF P
HPCFSOBEPQPSQPMUJDPTTJOFTDSQVMPT 
DPO MPT DVBMFT MPT HPCJFSOPT EFM OPSUF
OP QVFEFO FWJUBS USBUBS
 DPNP EF MPT
DSFDJFOUFT DPTUPT TBOJUBSJPT  DVSBUJWPT Z
QSFWFOUJWPT&MUFNBEFMBKVTUJDJBFTVO
UFNB EF UJDB HFOFSBM EF MB QPCMBDJO 
QPSUBOUPDPNQMFKBZQSDUJDBNFOUFJO
TPMVCMF TJ FM QVFCMP DPNQSVFCB MB JN
QVOJEBE EF MPT HSBOEFT  EF MPT JNQPS
UBOUFT EFMPTQPMUJDPTVPUSPTTFPSFT 
JODMVTP DVBOEP TPO TPSQSFOEJEPT DPO
iMBTNBOPTFOMBNBTBwZTPOUSBUBEPTFO
FMUSJCVOBMPFOMBDPNJTJOEFUJDB FO
TFTJPOFTRVFUFSNJOBOUSBEJDJPOBMNFOUF
FOOBEB.JFOUSBTUBOUP BRVTFFYQMJDJ
UBVOBWF[NTMBSFMBDJOFOUSFVOBTB
CJBQSFWJTJOTPDJBM VOSFTHVBSEPKVTUP
EFMPTQSFTVQVFTUPTTBOJUBSJPTQBSBSJDPT
ZQPCSFT FOMPQPTJCMFTJOFMUSBEJDJPOBM
QSJWJMFHJPEFMPTSJDPTRVFQPESBOQBHBS
EFTVCPMTJMMPDVFOUBTHSBOEFTPQFRVF
BT/PQPEFNPTBCSJSBRVVOEPTTJFS
GVOEBNFOUBM EF QSFWJTJO TPDJBM  EF TV
DPTUPZPSHBOJ[BDJOGVODJPOBMFGFDUJWP
PEFmDJFOUF&MEFTBGPEFCFTFSUSBUBEP
QBT QPS QBT  &TUBEP QPS &TUBEP  DPO
QFSJDJBTQSPQJBT
&ODVBOUPBMBSHVNFOUPEFMBiOPNBMF
mDFODJBw UBNQPDPTFUSBUBEFVOBTVOUP
TJNQMFQPSRVFHSBOEFTNBMFmDFODJBTEF
MPTQPUFOUBEPTQBSFDFONTTPQPSUBCMFT
RVF NOJNBT JOGSBDDJPOFT EF HFOUF TJO
QPEFS OJ EJOFSP QBSB SFTQBMEBSTF -PT
QSPDFTPTEFJOEFNOJ[BDJPOFTTPOEJGDJ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

MFT MBSHPTZBSSJFTHBEPTQBSBMPTQPCSFT
&M UFNB DPNQSFOEF BNQMJPT NSHFOFT
EFQSPDFTPQFOBMZOPFYDFQUBMBTSFBD
DJPOFT EFGFOTJWBT EF MBT PSHBOJ[BDJPOFT
NEJDBT 5BNCJO JOWPMVDSB FM QSJODJ
QJPEFBVUPOPNBEFMQBDJFOUF"MIBCMBS
EFBVUPOPNBEFCFNPTQSFTUBSBUFODJO
BMBJNQPSUBODJBEFMDPOUFYUPTPDJPMHJ
DPZBMBTDPOEJDJPOFTEFMQBDJFOUF RVF
MJNJUBO TV SFBM BVUPOPNB  MB DVBM  EF
DVBMRVJFS NPEP  EFQFOEF EF MBT JOGPS
NBDJPOFTRVFIBZBSFDJCJEPFOSFMBDJO
DPOTVDBTP&ODVBOUPBMBTDPOEJDJPOFT
EFNJTFSJBTBOJUBSJBEFMQVFCMPIVNJMEF
EFUJFNQPTQBTBEPT FYJTUFBCVOEBOUFF
JOUFSFTBOUFCJCMJPHSBGBRVF GBUBMNFOUF 
QPS PCWJPT DPOEJDJPOBNJFOUPT DVMUV
SBMFT FTNTDPNQMFUBZBCVOEBOUFFO
QBTFTEFMIFNJTGFSJPOPSUF -FQBSHOFVS 


&M QSJODJQJBMJTNP QFOFUS FO MB $VCB
EF 'JEFM TJO NVDIB EJmDVMUBE  TPCSF
UPEPBQBSUJSEFMBFEJDJO FO EF
i#JPUJDBQBSBMBTVTUFOUBCJMJEBEw PCSB
DPMFDUJWB DPPSEJOBEB QPS + 3 "DPTUB 
EFTUBDBOEP FM DBQUVMP i1SPZFDUPT QBSB
VOBCJPUJDBHMPCBMw EF+".BSUOF[
(NF[ %JDIB BTJNJMBDJO TF QSPEVKP
OP TJO QSPUFDDJPOFT HMPCBMFT F JOEJWJ
EVBMFT FTEFDJS NBUJ[BOEPFMQSJODJQJP
EFBVUPOPNBJOEJWJEVBMZQVOUVBMJ[BO
EPRVFMPTQSJODJQJPTEFCFOFmDFODJBZ
EF TPMJEBSJEBE DPOTUJUVZFO MB NYJNB
FYQSFTJO EF KVTUJDJB &M SHJNFO TBOJ
UBSJPDPOTUJUVZFFMSFBGVFSUFEF$VCB 
QPTJCMFNFOUFFOQFSKVJDJPEFPUSPTTFD
UPSFTTPDJPFDPONJDPTEFMBNJTNBDVM
UVSB QFSPFMSHJNFONFSFDFNTEFVOB
NFEBMMBQPSTVBMUSVJTNPBMBZVEBSTBOJ





6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS

UBSJBNFOUF FONPNFOUPTEFEJmDVMUBE 
BPUSPTQBTFTDPODBSFODJBEFNEJDPT
$IJMF FO   "SHFMJB FO   $B
DIFNJSB FO   *OEPOFTJB FO  
7FOF[VFMB FO 
 "SBVKP QSPQVTP
TVTUJUVJSMBUSBEBiCFOFmDFODJB BVUPOP
NBZKVTUJDJBwQPSiBDDFTJCJMJEBE QBSUJ
DJQBDJOZFRVJEBEw QFSPTPOEFUBMMFT

&WBMVBDJOHFOFSBM
4FSB TVQFSnVP  BM USNJOP EF UBO EF
NPSBEBJOWFTUJHBDJOIJTUSJDB EFTUBDBS
MBPQPSUVOJEBEZDBMJEBEEFFTUFBDVDJP
TPQSPZFDUP DPODMVJEPFOUJFNQPPQPS
UVOP USFJOUB BPT EF EFOTB Z GFDVOEB
JOWFTUJHBDJO JOOPWBEPSB FO "NSJDB
IJTQBOPCSBTJMFB5SFJOUBBPTEFDPO
RVJTUBTFOUFSSFOPTOPTJFNQSFQSFQBSB
EPTQBSBUBMFNQBMNFEFJOWFTUJHBDJOZ
EJTDVTJOQSPWFDIPTBT DPOMBmOBMJEBE
EFVOCJFODPNORVFFYJKBBOOVFWPT
FTGVFS[PTEFFYQBOTJO4JOEVEB UBMFT
FTGVFS[PT ZB UVWJFSPO BMHVOB FmDBDJB 
OPTMPFODVBOUPBMBTBMVEEFMBTQP
CMBDJPOFT TJOPUBNCJOFOFMEFTBSSPMMP
QPMUJDPDVMUVSBMEFFTBTTPDJFEBEFT-BT
NPOPHSBGBTZCJPHSBGBTEFUBMMBEBTQSF
TFOUBO ZB VOB TPCFSCJB EFOTJEBE Z VO
IPOSPTP WPMVNFO FO UPSOP EF MBT USFT
QSJODJQBMFTMFOHVBT
)BZBPOPMBJOnVFODJBEFMBOUJBNFSJDB
OJTNPRVFQSFWBMFDJFOOVFTUSBQPDB
FO FM NVOEP QPS EJWFSTBT SB[POFT  FM
DBSDUFSMBUJOPTJFNQSFGVFEJGFSFOUFEFM
OPSUFBNFSJDBOP
FTFWJEFOUFMBEJmDVM
UBE BDUVBM FO WBSJPT QBTFT EF "NSJDB
-BUJOB QBSB SFDJCJS  FOUFOEFS Z BQMJDBS
MPT GBNPTPT DVBUSP iQSJODJQJPTw EF MB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

QSDUJDB CJPUJDB FO &TUBEPT 6OJEPT


BVUPOPNB  CFOFmDFODJB  OP NBMFm
DFODJB Z KVTUJDJB 4PO EF DBSDUFS NT
JOEJWJEVBMJTUB Z BOBMUJDP RVF MP RVF
BDPTUVNCSBFMDPNVOJUBSJTNPMBUJOP Z
UBNCJOBGSJDBOPZBTJUJDP
$BEBQBT
QPTFF DPODFQUPT Z QSFDPODFQUPT QSP
QJPT$BNCJBSWBMPSFTFTNTEJGDJMRVF
BDFQUBS VOB JOWFODJO UFDOPMHJDB FO
DBTPEFRVFIVCJFTFVOmOBODJBNJFOUP
PQPSUVOP

&OFTUBPCSBTPCSFMBIJTUPSJBEFMBCJP
UJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB DPNPFSBQSFWJ
TJCMFZOPSNBM NTEFVODPMBCPSBEPS
EFTUBDBMBPSJHJOBMJEBEEFTVQBT EFTV
SFHJOZ FWFOUVBMNFOUF TVQSPQJBDPO
USJCVDJO IBDJFOEPOPUBSMBTBCJBFMFD
DJO EF RVJFOFT BDFQUBSPO QBSUJDJQBS
%FFTUPTQBTPTTVEBNFSJDBOPTOPTFQP
ESBEFTDPOPDFSFMUSJCVUPJOJDJBMEFMIF
NJTGFSJPOPSUF FNJOFOUFNFOUFEFMBGF
EFSBDJOOPSUFBNFSJDBOB TPCSFUPEPFO
OVFTUSBQPDBEFHMPCBMJ[BDJOFOMBDVBM
FMDPOPDJNJFOUPUFDOPMHJDPTFEJGVOEF
SQJEBNFOUF  OP TJO VOB EFQFOEFO
DJBEFMBTJOWFSTJPOFTEJTQPOJCMFT QFSP
UBNCJOHSBDJBTBMONFSPDSFDJFOUFEF
SFWJTUBT Z DPOHSFTPT FTQFDJBMJ[BEPT  Z B
PUSBT JOTUBODJBT EF JOUFSDBNCJP  DPNP
TPO*OUFSOFU RVFMMFHBBBOUJDJQBSZDBTJ
QFSKVEJDBS MBT OPWFEBEFT PGSFDJEBT QPS
MBT SFWJTUBT FTQFDJBMJ[BEBT *OnVFODJBT
DVMUVSBMFTZUBNCJOIJTUSJDBTJOUFSmF
SFOGBUBMZBGPSUVOBEBNFOUFDBEBQBT 
DBEB DPOUSJCVZFOUF  TF TJFOUF PSHVMMPTP
EFMQBUSJNPOJPRVF QPSWFOUVSB MBZV
E B JOJDJBS Z EFTBSSPMMBS  Z EFM DVBM TF
TJFOUFTPMJEBSJP





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

"EFNT EF "SHFOUJOB oRVF FO FM DPO


UJOFOUF GVF FM QJPOFSP JOTUJUVDJPOBM EF
MB CJPUJDBo  NFSFDFO EFTUBDBSTF 7FOF
[VFMB Z $PMPNCJB  FTUB MUJNB QPS TVT
FTGVFS[PT QSFDPDFT QBSB BQSPYJNBS FM
IVNBOJTNPBMFKFSDJDJPEFMBNFEJDJOB
ZBMBGPSNBDJOJOUFHSBMEFMPTNEJDPT
" QFTBS EFM BMUP JOUFST EFM JEFBM EF MB
NFEJDJOBDPNO FMQMVSBMJTNPDVMUVSBM
TJFNQSF JNQFEJS DPNQMFUBSMP FO SB
[O QSFDJTBNFOUF EFMQBQFMDFOUSBMEF
MB NFEJDJOB FO DVBMRVJFS DVMUVSB UPEP
IPNCSF UPEPQVFCMPEFCFEFGFOEFSTV
QSPQJB WJUBMJEBE Z TVQFSWJWFODJB &TUBT
DVMUVSBT FTUO EJWFSTBNFOUF QSFQBSBEBT
QBSBBDFQUBSZFOUFOEFSMPTBWBODFTNT
SFDJFOUFTEFMBCJPUJDB&MSQJEPYJUP
EFMPTUSBTQMBOUFTFO"NSJDB-BUJOBZ 
TPCSF UPEP  FO #SBTJM OP FSB FWJEFOUF
M TF EFCF OP QPDP B MB JODVFTUJPOBCMF
IBCJMJEBE NBOVBM EF DJFSUPT DJSVKBOPT 
BT DPNP BM HVTUP QPS FM SJFTHP  NT
QSPOVODJBEPBRVRVFFOFMDPOUJOFOUF
FVSPQFP
-B JOnVFODJB EF MB NPSBM DBUMJDB FO
"NSJDB -BUJOB UBNCJO QPESB TFS
DVFTUJPOBEB ZBTFBQBSBBZVEBS BUSBWT
EF MB DPOUSJCVDJO QPTJUJWB EF BMHVOBT
GBDVMUBEFTZEFBMHVOPTUFMPHPT
ZBTFB
QBSBJNQPSUVOBS%FDVBMRVJFSNBOFSB 
QBSFDFoTFHOMBOPUBCMFTOUFTJTEF"M
GPOTP -MBOP &TDPCBSo RVF FM PSEFO EF
BQBSJDJO EF MB CJPUJDB FO FTUB SFHJO
GVFFMTJHVJFOUF"SHFOUJOB RVFSFBMJ[
FM**$POHSFTP.VOEJBMEF#JPUJDBFO

$PMPNCJB 1FS $IJMF .YJDP
Z#SBTJM QBTRVFTFEFTUBDBMIPTQFEBS
FM 1SJNFS $POHSFTP -BUJOPBNFSJDBOP
EF #JPUJDB FO M Z FM 7* $POHSFTP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

.VOEJBMEF#JPUJDBFO #SBTJMJB 
%'
-B0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEF
MB4BMVEUJFOFGVFSUFJOnVFODJBQPTJUJWB 
KVOUPDPO$IJMFZTVQSJODJQBMVOJWFSTJ
EBEFOEPOEFmKTVTFEF
&M NVOEP FOUFSP OFDFTJUB DPMBCPSB
DJOEFMDPOUJOFOUFBRVFOFYBNFOFO
DVBOUPBTVQBTBEPSFDJFOUF QPSRVFMPT
MVHBSFT NT BWBO[BEPT EF MB UJFSSB TF
FODVFOUSBO  DPNP UPEP FM QMBOFUB  FO
TJUVBDJO EF SJFTHP #JPUJDB Z QSFPDV
QBDJPOFTFDPMHJDBT BVORVFTFBBUUVMP
EFQSFWFODJOEFTBMVEQCMJDB BDBCBO
QPSUPSOBSTFTPMJEBSJBT/PIBDFNVDIPT
BPT VOBHSOPNPEFWBTUBFYQFSJFODJB 
3FO%VNPOU FTDSJCBi-BTBNFOB[BT
TFFTUOQSFDJTBOEP4POTFSJBTZQPOFO
FO QFMJHSP MB  FYJTUFODJB NJTNB EF MPT
IPNCSFT FO MB 5JFSSB &M BHPUBNJFOUP
EFMPTSFDVSTPTFTUJMVTUSBEPQPSFMBM[B
EFMQSFDJPEFMQFUSMFPZEFMBTNBUFSJBT
QSJNBT-PTTVFMPT FMBJSFZFMBHVBFTUO
DPOUBNJOBEPT  B WFDFT EF NBOFSB JSSF
WFSTJCMF FTQFDJFT WFHFUBMFT Z BOJNBMFT
JOEJTQFOTBCMFTQBSBMBWJEBEFTBQBSFDFO
FO ONFSP DSFDJFOUF #JMMPOFT EF TFSFT
IVNBOPT NT EF TFJT CJMMPOFT BDUVBM
NFOUF
USFTDVBSUPT WJWFOFOHSBOQP
CSF[B DVBOEPMPTQBTFTSJDPTDBTJNP
OPQPMJ[BOMPTSFDVSTPTIVNBOPTw
.TSFDJFOUFNFOUFi1BSBDVBUSPCJMMP
OFTEFTFSFTIVNBOPT MBGBMUBEFBHVBZ
PUSPTTPOQSPWPDBEPTQPSJOVOEBDJPOFT
4VHFSFODJBT FYJTUFO  QPS FKFNQMP  EFM
FDPMPHJTUB /JDPMT )VMPU  DPNP OPN
CSBS VO WJDFQSJNFSNJOJTUSP FODBSHBEP
EFMEFTBSSPMMPTVTUFOUBCMFJOTUBVSBSVOB
iUBTBDBSCPOPwIBTUBEJWJEJSQPSDVBUSP





6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS

MBTFNJTJPOFTEFHBTDBSCOJDPSFGPSNBS
MPTTJUJPTBHSDPMBTDPOTVMUBSBMQCMJDP
BDFSDBEFMBTPSJFOUBDJPOFTEFMEFTBSSP
MMPJOGPSNBOEPTPCSFTVBEIFTJOBMBT
SFTUSJDDJPOFT NFKPSBS P HFOFSBMJ[BS MB
FEVDBDJO Z MB GPSNBDJO QSPGFTJPOBMw
)VMPU 
5PEPFTUPUPSOBOPNF
OPT FWJEFOUF MB JOUFSEFQFOEFODJB FOUSF
MBCJPUJDBZMBQPMUJDBFOHFOFSBM RVF
EFCF BCBSDBS DPNP FM UFN NT JOD
NPEPEFMBQPMUJDBEFTBMVEFMBVNFO
UP BMBSNBOUF EF TV DPTUP FO UPEPT MPT
QBTFT MPT JOWFTUJHBEPSFT QJEFO  NBZPS
QSFTVQVFTUPQBSBMBNBOUFODJOEFTVT
USBCBKPT Z EF TVT MBCPSBUPSJPT /UFTF
RVFBISFTJEFO QSFDJTBNFOUF MBTFOUJ
EBEFTGBSNBDPMHJDBT QFSPOPUFOFNPT
RVFDPNFOUBSBRVTVTSHJEBTQFSTQFDUJ
WBTEFBVUPEFTBSSPMMPFDPONJDP
0CTFSWBNPT  BTJNJTNP  MB WJODVMBDJO
FOUSFMBTQSDUJDBTDBTJDPOTFOTVBMFTRVF
NBOUJFOF MB CJPUJDB DPO MBT FWPMVDJP
OFT TPDJPQPMUJDBT  FO HFOFSBM GBWPSB
CMFT QPSMPNFOPTFOBMHVOPTQBTFTEF
"NSJDB -BUJOB /UFTF  QPS FKFNQMP 
DNP FO CJPUJDB MB HFTUJO BVUPSJUBSJB
EFMFTQBDJPEFMBTBMVEDFEFMVHBS QPDP
B QPDP  B QSDUJDBT EFNPDSUJDBT 4JO
FYBHFSBS QPSRVF  DPNP EJDF 'SBODJT
DP #BUJTUB +S  i&M DPOUSPM TPDJBM FT VO
QSPZFDUP FO DPOTUSVDDJOw *E
 Z RVF 
USBUOEPTFEF"*%4 FO#SBTJMiUFOFNPT
 NVDIBDIBT QBSB EJF[ NVDIBDIPTw
%F DVBMRVJFS NBOFSB i&T QSFDJTP GPS
NBS VOB QFSTQFDUJWB EF TPMJEBSJEBE MB
UJOPBNFSJDBOBDPOQSPZFDUPTDPODSFUPT 
DPNPFMQSPCMFNBBNCJFOUBMRVFBGFD
UBFTQFDJBMNFOUFBMBQPCMBDJOQPCSFw
"SZ$BSWBMIP *E
{$POTFHVJSOUBMFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

QSFPDVQBDJPOFT JOUFHSBS BMHO EB VO


QSPHSBNBNTFYUFOTJWPEFM.FSDPTVS 
3BEJT 

$POMBEPDVNFOUBDJORVFZBDPOTFHVJ
NPT QFSDJCJNPTRVFMBTQSJODJQBMFTEJ
GFSFODJBTFOUSFVOQBTZPUSPUJFOFORVF
WFSTPCSFUPEPDPOMBJOTFSDJOTPDJPKV
SEJDB FTEFDJS JOTUJUVDJPOBMEFMBCJP
UJDB UPNBOEPFODVFOUB QPSTVQVFTUP 
MBTQSPQPSDJPOFTSFMBUJWBTEFMBTEJWFSTBT
EPMFODJBTVPQFSBDJPOFTPQPSUVOBT/P
NFOPT FWJEFOUFT TPO MBT EJGFSFODJBT FO
MBGSFDVFODJBEFMBTSFVOJPOFTQSPGFTJP
OBMFT Z MB EFOTJEBE EF MPT ODMFPT  BT
DPNPMBSBQJEF[EFMBTUSBOTGPSNBDJPOFT
RVFQVFEFUSBOTDVSSJSEFTEFMBFWPMVDJO
EFMBTNFOUBMJEBEFTBMBBQFSUVSBBOVF
WBT WJTJPOFT DJFOUmDBT  MB BDDFTJCJMJEBE
B OVFWPT BQSFOEJ[BKFT Z MB nFYJCJMJEBE
EFMBTJOTUJUVDJPOFTQBSBBDPHFSOPWFEB
EFTRVFRVJFCSFOMBSVUJOB&YJTUJSMV
HBSQBSBNPOPHSBGBTDPNQBSBUJWBTRVF
DPNQMFUBSO MBT JOGPSNBDJPOFT MPDBMFT
ZOBDJPOBMFT0CTFSWBOEPBEFNTBMPT
QJPOFSPT RVF DPNFO[BSPO DPO MB CJP
UJDB FO FM DPOUJOFOUF MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP 
DPNP "SHFOUJOB Z #SBTJM  FODPOUSBNPT
OPSNBMRVFFTUBEJTDJQMJOBTFBTPMJEBSJB
DPOFMSFTUPEFMBFWPMVDJOFDPONJDP
DVMUVSBM $PO MB NVMUJQMJDBDJO EF MPT
DPNJUT DPOTFKPTPDPNJTJPOFT
OBDJP
OBMFT EF CJPUJDB TVSHJS  UBSEF P UFN
QSBOP  VOB $PNJTJO  *OUFSBNFSJDBOB 
*CFSPCSBTJMFB EFJOUFSDBNCJPEFJOGPS
NBDJPOFT Z SFHMBNFOUPT DPNVOFT  UBM
DPNPFYJTUFFOMB6OJO&VSPQFB DVZB
BDUJWJEBESFWFMBMBEJmDVMUBEEFDPODJMJBS
EJGFSFOUFTUSBEJDJPOFTTBOJUBSJBTZIBTUB
UJDBT&OUSFUBOUP FMMFDUPSTBCFRVFZB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

FYJTUF VOB 0SHBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB


EFMB4BMVERVFSFBMJ[BVOCVFOUSBCBKP
TJONVDIBQSPQBHBOEBMBVEBUPSJB
&O&TUBEPT6OJEPTFYJTUFBNQMJBMJUFSB
UVSBTPCSFMPTQSPDFEJNJFOUPTEFTFBCMFT
QBSBSFQBSUJSMBTTJFNQSFFTDBTBTBTJHOB
DJPOFT EF SFDVSTPT TBOJUBSJPT FO EFUFS
NJOBEPTDPOUFYUPTPDJSDVOTUBODJBT%F
NPEP RVF OP OPT QBSFDF FWJEFOUF RVF
GBMUFO DPOTJEFSBDJPOFT UFSJDBT Z QSJO
DJQJBMJTUBT TPCSF MB NBUFSJB &O "N
SJDB-BUJOB OPTQBSFDFRVFFMOVEPEF
MBDVFTUJOFTQPMUJDPFYJTUFOQSDUJDBT
FWBTJWBTDVBOEPTFUSBUBEFBQMJDBSPOP
SFHMBTFYJTUFOUFTQBSBBUFOEFSOFDFTJEB
EFT PCWJBT -BT QPCMBDJPOFT FTUO EFT
JHVBMNFOUFSFQSFTFOUBEBTZFMQPEFSEF
MPT MPCCJFT FT UBO JNQPSUBOUF DPNP FO
&TUBEPT 6OJEPT  BVORVF OP FTU SFHMB
NFOUBEP DPNP FO FTF QBT 4F QSJWJMF
HJBNTBDJFSUBTDBUFHPSBTTPDJBMFTRVF
B MPT NT OFDFTJUBEPT  GSFDVFOUFNFOUF
FTDPOEJEPT GBWPSFDJFOEPBDJFSUPT&TUB
EPTNTRVFBPUSPTEFMNJTNPQBT P
BDBTPTJOEJWJEVBMFT UPDBOEPBQPMUJDPT
QPEFSPTPT P B QSPQBHBOEB EF EFUFSNJ
OBEPQBSUJEP&OUPODFT FONJPQJOJO 
FM QSPCMFNB FT FTFODJBMNFOUF QPMUJDP
Z DVMUVSBM QPS UBOUP  MJHBEP B MB FEV
DBDJO
ZOPTFDBNCJBOGDJMNFOUFMPT
ICJUPTQPMUJDPT OJTJRVJFSBDPOMFZFTP
SFHMBNFOUPT DPOPTJOBQMJDBDJO JOUFS
QSFUBEPTBMHVTUPEFMBTDPODJFODJBTEF
MPTKVFDFTZEFMPTQPMUJDPT OPTJFNQSF
NVZQSPCPTFJOPDFOUFT
&M DPOUFYUP EF MB BQMJDBDJO EFM QSJO
DJQJP EF OP NBMFmDFODJB BM FOGFSNP P
BMDJVEBEBOPFTFMNJTNP-PTSFDVSTPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DPOUSB NEJDPT TPO HFOFSBMNFOUF KV[


HBEPTFODPNJTJPOFTQSPGFTJPOBMFT DVZB
BVUPJOEVMHFODJB DPSQPSBUJWB OP QSFDJ
TB EFNPTUSBDJO QBSUJDVMBS &O WBSJPT
QBTFT QSDUJDBTBTJEVBTEFUPSUVSBCBKP
DPCFSUVSBEFHPCJFSOPTBVUPSJUBSJPT JO
DMVTPEFTQVTEFMmOEFUBMFTHPCJFSOPT 
JODMVTP DPO TPNFUJEPT B QSPDFTPT  BDB
CBOFOBNOJTUBTPBCTPMVDJPOFT PBQMB
[BNJFOUP JOEFmOJEP EFM KV[HBNJFOUP
mOBM BOUFTEFMBNVFSUFEFMPTDVMQBCMFT
PEFMmOEFMPTQMB[PTEFMBQSFTDSJQDJO
&MUFNBEFMBTQSVFCBT FMDPTUPZMBQSP
MPOHBDJOEFJOUFSSPHBUPSJPTFTUSJMFT MB
QSPUFDDJOZMBWFSBDJEBEEFMPTUFTUJNP
OJPT ZMPTDIBOUBKFTEFWBSJPTUJQPTEJm
DVMUBORVFMPTQPCSFTBGFDUBEPTTFBOEF
CJEBNFOUFBTJTUJEPT UBOUPRVFBMHVOPT
BCPHBEPTDPOTJHVFOQBSBMFTJPOFTJOTJH
OJmDBOUFTPiQFSKVJDJPTMMBNBEPTNPSB
MFTwJOEFNOJ[BDJPOFTEFNPOUPDPMPTBM
&MBTVOUPUBNCJOUJFOFSFMBDJODPOFM
QSJODJQJPEFBVUPOPNB SFTQFUPQPSFM
DVBMUVWFMBPQPSUVOJEBEEFEFTUBDBSFO
PUSBPCSB TFHOMBJNQPSUBODJBEFMDPO
UFYUPTPDJPMHJDPFOFMRVFWJWFPWJWJ
FMQBDJFOUF -FQBSHOFVS 

/PFTJNQPTJCMFRVFMBDVFTUJOFDPO
NJDBJOUFSWFOHBFOFMGVUVSPFO"NSJDB
-BUJOBUBMDPNPFTUJOUFSWJOJFOEPBIP
SBFO*OEJB BVODVBOEPMBNBZPSBEF
TVQPCMBDJOFTUBCBZBCBKPMBMOFBEF
QPCSF[B&O#SBTJM BQFTBSEFMBTMJTUBT
EFFTQFSB MPTUSBTQMBOUFTEFSHBOPTZB
TPOOPUPSJBNFOUFOVNFSPTPT UBOUPRVF
TVT DPTUPT  JOGFSJPSFT B MPT OPSUFBNFSJ
DBOPT TPOBQSPQJBEPTQBSBBUSBFSBFO
GFSNPTFYUSBOKFSPT%FTEFZB FO*OEJB 
VOBUSFJOUFOBEFIPTQJUBMFTQSJWBEPTEF





6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS

CVFOQSFTUJHJPBDPHJFSPOFOBDFS
DBEFiUVSJTUBTTBOJUBSJPTwRVF
RVFSBO CFOFmDJBSTF DPO TVT QSFDJPT  
B  WFDFT JOGFSJPSFT RVF MPT DPCSBEPT
FO&TUBEPT6OJEPTPFO(SBO#SFUBB
4FFTUJNBRVFFODJODPBPTFMiUVSJTNP
NEJDPwQSPQPSDJPOBSBMB*OEJBEPTP
USFTCJMMPOFTEFEMBSFT FTEFDJS MBNJ
UBEEFMPRVFJOHSFTBIPZQPSTViUFSDF
SJ[BDJOwJOGPSNUJDB

'SFOUFBMBTBNFOB[BT
QMBOFUBSJBTNFEJBOUFMBCJPUJDB
ZBEFNTEFFMMB
3FUPNBNPT MB JEFB RVF FYQSFTBNPT BM
JOJDJPEFMUFYUP SFTQFDUPEFMBWVFMUBBM
IJQPUUJDP IPSJ[POUF EF VOB NPSBM DP
NO EFMBDVBMMBCJPUJDBDPOTUJUVJSB
VOTFSJPGVOEBNFOUPQPSRVFFTNFOPT
NBOJQVMBCMF QPS JEFPMPHBT RVF PUSPT
TFDUPSFTEFMBDVMUVSB$POTVBNQMJBJO
GPSNBDJOZTVKVJDJPTFHVSP FMQFSJPEJT
UBFJOWFTUJHBEPSFDPMHJDP8BTIJOHUPO
/PWBT OPT IB BEWFSUJEP TPCSF BMHVOPT
QVOUPT  SFDPSEBEPT FTQFDJBMNFOUF QPS
,Pm"OOBOQPDPBOUFTEFRVFEFKBSBFM
DBSHPEFTFDSFUBSJPHFOFSBMEFMB0/6
FYJTUFO QFMJHSPT QPUFODJBMFT EF SQJEP
DSFDJNJFOUP EF MB JOEVTUSJB  CJPUFDOP
MHJDB WJODVMBEPTBMDPNCBUFEFMFWFO
UVBMCJPUFSSPSJTNP4FSFGFSBBQPTJCMFT
iSFTVMUBEPT DBUBTUSmDPTw EF SFDJFOUFT
BWBODFTEFMBCJPUFDOPMPHBRVFQPESBO
DBFS FO NBOPT FSSBEBT  QSJODJQBMNFOUF
EF NBOJQVMBDJO HFOUJDB Z EF JOWFT
UJHBDJPOFT DPO WJSVT 4FHO "OOBO  FO
FOFSPEFUBMFTBNFOB[BTDSFDFSBO
FYQPOFODJBMNFOUFZOPIBCSBQBT QP
CSFPSJDP QSPUFHJEPBQSJPSJ-BEJTUSJ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

CVDJOFOUJFNQPUJMEFMPTJOTUSVNFO
UPTQSFWFOUJWPTPMPTSFNFEJPTBDFSUBEPT
OP FTU BTFHVSBEB -PT SJFTHPT EF MBT
NJTNBTJOWFTUJHBDJPOFTZMBEJTQPTJDJO
EFMBTHSBOEFTmSNBTGBSNBDVUJDBTQBSB
BZVEBSBMBTSFHJPOFTQPCSFTFOTVTQF
MJHSPTQSPQJPTFTUMFKPTEFFTUBSBTFHV
SBEB BQFTBSEFOPQPDBTDPOWFODJPOFT
Z SFVOJPOFT -B NJTNB 0SHBOJ[BDJO
.VOEJBM EF MB 4BMVE TF TJFOUF VO UBO
UPBJTMBEBFOTVQSFPDVQBDJOQPSFWJUBS
VOBQBOEFNJBEFMUJQPEFMBHSJQFBWJBS
"OUF MB EFCJMJEBE EF MB BVUPEFGFOTB EF
MPT QBTFT SJDPT FO NBUFSJB EF SJFTHPT
QBOENJDPT  {DNP FTQFSBS VOB HSBO
BZVEB EJSJHJEB FTQFDJBMNFOUF IBDJB MPT
QBTFTNFOPTQSTQFSPTEF"NSJDB-B
UJOBPEFGSJDB 0USPTQFMJHSPTWJFOFO
EF MB OFPOBOPUFDOPMPHB  RVF FTDBQB
EF OVFTUSP NCJUP QSFTFOUF /PWBFT 


-B JOFWJUBCMF MJNJUBDJO EF MB CJPUJDB
JODFOUJWB OVFTUSB SFnFYJO BDFSDB EF
DNPTBMWBSMBWJEBGTJDB DMBWFFWJEFO
UF QBSB VO NBZPS P NT FMFWBEP OJWFM
EFWJEBRVFTFQVFEBQFSNJUJSBMPTTF
SFT IVNBOPT .BT  {DVM FT FM NPUJWP
QSPGVOEP QBSB SFDPOPDFS UBOUB JNQPS
UBODJBBOVFTUSPTQPDPTBPTCJPMHJDPT
EFQFSNBOFODJBTPCSFFTUFQMBOFUB &O
MB JOGBODJB EF NVDIPT TFSFT IVNBOPT
TVSHF MB JOUVJDJO EF RVF EFCF FYJTUJS
BMHVOB mOBMJEBE NT FMFWBEB  RVF MB
QFSNBOFODJB FO CVFOB TBMVE GTJDB  VO
NVOEP JOWJTJCMF EF WBMPSFT FTQJSJUVBMFT
RVF FMFWFO BM IPNCSF QPS FODJNB EF
MBT PUSBT FTQFDJFT  RVF MP UPSOF NT GF
MJ[ZPNTJOGFMJ[ NTFYJHFOUFZNT
TPBEPS VOBUSBTDFOEFODJBRVFBMHVOPT





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

SFDPOPDFOFOMBSFMJHJPTJEBE OPSFEVDJ
EB B FNPUJWJEBE EF VO TVFP VUQJDP 
Z RVF BMHVOPT FODVFOUSBO DPOWFOJFOUF
JOWFSUJS FO BMHVOB SFMJHJO DPOTUJUVJEB
&MBSHVNFOUPEFMTFOUJEPEFMBWJEBZEF
QPSRVMBCJPUJDBEFCFSBTFSFYUSBBB
UBM QFSTQFDUJWB  FMMB RVF TBCF RVF UPEP
TFSIVNBOPWVFMWFBMBUJFSSBEFEPOEF
QSPWJFOF7VFMWFQPSFOUFSPPOP TUF
FTFMQSPCMFNB PNFKPS FMNJTUFSJP RVF
MBSB[OPMBDJFODJBOPQVFEFSFTPMWFSZ
RVFDPOmBNPTBOVFTUSBJOUVJDJONT
UJDBPBOUJNTUJDB BUSBWTEFMBGFPEF
MBOPDSFFODJB OPQPDPTQSFmSJFOEPMB
QSVEFODJB Z EFDMBSBSTF  DPNP EF GBDUP
MB NBZPSB NVOEJBM EF MPT DJFOUmDPT 
BHOTUJDPT
-BEJmDVMUBEQBSBBEIFSJSBVOBGFSFMJ
HJPTBSFTJEFFORVFFMMPTJFNQSFJNQMJDB
FYJHFODJBTUJDBTZSJUVBMFTRVFTPCSFQB
TBO MP RVF EFNBOEB VOB TJNQMF  QFSP
OFDFTBSJB Z CTJDB  UJDB TPDJBM QSPGBOB 
UJDBEFDPOWJWFODJBZBSNPOBFOVOB
DPNVOJEBE 5BM JOUVJDJO FT DBQB[ EF
BZVEBSQPEFSPTBNFOUFBDPOGFSJSTFOUJ
EPBMBWJEB BVORVFMFKPTEFFYQMJDBSZ
KVTUJmDBSUPEPMPRVFOPTSPEFB&TUBJO
UVJDJORVFQVFEFWFOJS TFSSFDIB[BEBZ
OPWPMWFSDPOGBDJMJEBEQBSFDFTFSDPNP
FM WJFOUP OP TBCFNPT EF EOEF WJFOF
OJBEOEFWB&TMBQSPQJBZNJTNTJNB
QSFHVOUBQPSFMTFOUJEPEFMBWJEBZ UBM
WF[ EFMNVOEP5PEPQBSFDFEFQFOEFS 
EFTEFFMJOJDJP EFOVFTUSBQFSDFQDJOF
JOUFSQSFUBDJOEFMBCFMMF[BZEFMBWJEB 
PEFMTVGSJNJFOUP EFMBFOGFSNFEBE EFM
DBSDUFSGBUBMEFMBNVFSUF/BEJFOFHBS
RVFUBMFTJOUFSSPHBOUFTFTUOJNQMDJUPT
FOMBCJPUJDB FOMBTPQFSBDJPOFTZDPO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

WJWFODJBTEFMBTBMVEZEFMBFOGFSNFEBE 
QFSP FOFMUFSSFOPQSPQJPEFMBCJPUJDB 
DPOWJFOF BMFKBS TV PCDFDBDJO QBSB OP
DPOGVOEJSFMUSBCBKPPFMDVFTUJPOBNJFO
UP JONFEJBUP  QBSB OP JOUSPEVDJS EJ
WFSHFODJBTRVFQFSKVEJDBSBOFMTFSWJDJP
NTVSHFOUF
%VSBOUFMB&EBE.FEJBMBUFPMPHBGVF
DPOTJEFSBEB MB SFJOB EF MBT EJTDJQMJOBT 
MBNTBOUJHVB KVOUPDPOMBNFEJDJOB 
FO MB GPSNBDJO EF MBT QSJNFSBT VOJ
WFSTJEBEFT 1PS VOB QBSUF  KV[HBOEP FM
EVBMJTNPNJTUFSJPTPEFMTFSZEFMBOBEB
FOFMDPOUFYUPEFMBNFUBGTJDBQPSPUSB 
PQJOBOEP TPCSF FM EVBMJTNP OP NFOPT
NJTUFSJPTPEFMBWJEBZMBNVFSUF&OUSF
MPTEPTQPMPTTFFYUJFOEFFM5JFNQP FM
NJTUFSJPTP UJFNQP EFM TFS Z EF MB WJEB
{/PQPESBNPTJNBHJOBSRVFMBCJPUJ
DB GVFTF QBSB MB DVMUVSB NPEFSOB  FTUF
DFOUSP EF MBT EJTDJQMJOBT RVF JSSBEJBSBO
EFTEFFMMB DPNPEFVOBFTUSFMMBQSJNPS
EJBMEFMBHBMBYJBEFMTFSZEFMTBCFS "M
UFTUJNPOJBSMPTQSPHSFTPTEFMBTJSSBEJB
DJPOFT EF MB CJPUJDB Z TVT SBNJmDBDJP
OFT oFTQFDJBMNFOUF EF MB FDPMPHB  RVF
UBOUPQSFPDVQBBOVFTUSBDJWJMJ[BDJOZ
DPOEJDJPOB MB TBMVE Z TVQFSWJWFODJB EF
MB IVNBOJEBEo  JNBHJOFNPT FM FGFDUP
EFFTUFMVHBSEFTUBDBEPEFMBCJPUJDBBM
MBEPEFMBGTJDBEFMBTQBSUDVMBTFMFNFO
UBMFT FMMBNJTNBSFMBDJPOBEBDPOMBDPT
NPMPHB FWPMVUJWB  FT EFDJS  FM NJTUFSJP
EFM$PTNPTFOTVUPUBMJEBEZFWPMVDJO
-BCJPUJDBFYQSFTBEFNBOFSBQBSUJDV
MBSNFOUF PCWJB MB USBOTJUPSJFEBE Z GSB
HJMJEBEEFOVFTUSBTDPOEJDJPOFTUFNQP
SBMFTEFWJEBFODPOTUBOUFMVDIBDPOUSB
MBTGVFS[BTEFEFTUSVDDJOZNVFSUFRVF





6OBNJSBEBQSPTQFDUJWB)VCFSU-FQBSHOFVS

OPBDPTUVNCSBOTPTFHBSTF5PEPMPRVF
TF SFWFMB QSPHSFTJWBNFOUF EFTDVCSF VO
QPDPNTDVOUPOPTBCFNPT QBSBFO
USFUFOFSOPTMPOVFTUSBDVSJPTJEBETJOP
UBNCJO OVFTUSPT FTGVFS[PT EF JOWFTUJ
HBDJOZDJFODJB ZRVJ[TOVFTUSBBTQJ
SBDJOSFMJHJPTBEFDSFFSFOBMHOiBMMw
RVF FTUBS TJFNQSF PDVMUP DPNP WJTJO
EJSFDUBBMPTWJBKBOUFTEFFTUFUJFNQPZ
QMBOFUB
{/PTFSBUPOUFSBDSFFSRVFMBCJPUJDB 
RVF VOF UBM DPNP VOB JOWFTUJHBDJO
GBSNBDPMHJDB  QFSP TJO TV TFTHP RV
NJDP
VOBQFSTQFDUJWBCJPMHJDBGVOEB
NFOUBM EF DPOPDJNJFOUP Z VOB BDDJO

EFTBMWBWJEBT WJEBTTBOBTFOMPQPTJCMF

QBSBEFSSPUBSBMBNVFSUFPBMBEFDSFQJ
UVE FOFMGPOEPSFBMJ[BFMJEFBMEF)FOSJ
#FSHTPO  RVF DPOTJTUF FO MPHSBS RVF FM
IPNCSF EF BDDJO QJFOTF Z FM IPNCSF
EF QFOTBNJFOUP BDUF  "M DPODJMJBS FM
QFOTBNJFOUP SBDJPOBM Z DSUJDP DPO MB
BDDJO  {OP TFS RVF  UBOUP FO MB EJT
DVTJOBCTUSBDUBTPCSFMBWJEBDPNPFO
EFDJTJPOFT DPODSFUBT FO MPT DPNJUT  FM
WFSEBEFSPCJPFUJDJTUBQJFOTBFOFMOJWFM
EFIVNBOJEBE BTQJSBDJOBMBVOJWFSTB
MJEBE
QFSPBDUBQBSBQSFTFSWBSMBWJEB
PMBTBMVEEFEFUFSNJOBEB T
QFSTPOB T

IVNBOB T

3FGFSFODJBT
%F-BWPS " 
"TBEFOBQPMUJDBFBQPMUJDBOBTBEF3BEJT  KBOFJSP QQ

(SB[JBOP 9 
1PCSF[BFFDPMPHJB0&TUBEPEF4P1BVMP EFKBOFJSP
)VMPU //PVWFM0CTFSWBUFVS 
-FQBSHOFVS ) 
1SJODQJPEBBVUPOPNJB&O6SCBO $" 0SH
#JPUJDBDMOJDB
3JPEF+BOFJSP 3FWJOUFS QQ
/PWBFT 8 
"TBNFBBTRVFWNEPNVOEPJOWJTWFM0&TUBEPEF4P1BVMP 
EFKBOFJSP
3VTIEJF 4 
-F/PVWFM0CTFSWBUFVS EFKBOFJSP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





"MHVOPTSFUPTQBSBFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPUJDBFO
*CFSPBNSJDB
-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF

VBOEP FYBNJOBNPT SFUSPTQFDUJWB


NFOUF FM EFTBSSPMMP EF MB CJPUJDB
FO"NSJDB-BUJOB RVFTFEJGFSFODJBFO
BMHVOPTBTQFDUPTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBEFMB
1FOOTVMB *CSJDB &TQBB Z 1PSUVHBM

QPEFNPTQFSDJCJSVOBDPOUJOVJEBE OP
TJOPCTUDVMPT RVFBCBSDBUSFTGBTFTJN
QPSUBOUFTMPTBPT FOMPTRVFMBCJP
UJDB OPSUFBNFSJDBOB GVF USBTQMBOUBEB
ZBDFQUBEBMPTBPT EFBTJNJMBDJO
Z FWPMVDJO DPO VOB QFSTPOBMJEBE MBUJ
OPBNFSJDBOB  Z  B QBSUJS EF MPT   EF
SFDPOTUSVDDJO MB QSPQPTJDJO EF VO
QFOTBNJFOUPZEFVOBQSDUJDBPSJHJOB
MFTRVF TJOSFDIB[BSMBTDPOUSJCVDJPOFT
EFPUSBTQBSUFTEFMNVOEP MBTJOUFSQSFUB
BTVNBOFSBZDPOUSJCVZFBDBNCJBSMBT 
FO VO FOSJRVFDFEPS QSPDFTP EJBMHJDP
1PSFTP FTGVOEBNFOUBMVOBDPNQSFO
TJOQSPGVOEBEFMBTCBTFTFQJTUFNPMHJ
DBTEFMBQFSTQFDUJWBBTDSFBEB (BSSBGB 
,PUUPXZ4BBEB 
QBSBEFUFSNJOBS
DVMFTTPOMPTWFSEBEFSPTSFUPTRVFEF
CFNPTFOGSFOUBS&OUSFTUPT MBFDPMPHB
ZFMBNCJFOUF MBJOWFTUJHBDJOFOTFSFT
IVNBOPT QPMUJDBTQCMJDBT MFHJTMBDJO
Z EFSFDIP Z  FO VO DPOUFYUP TJFNQSF
NTQMVSBMJTUB FMEJMPHPNVOEPTFDV
MBSNVOEPSFMJHJPTP

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&O TVT QSJODJQJPT FO MPT &&66  MB


CJPUJDBFOGSFOUEJMFNBTUJDPTDSFBEPT
QPS MPT FYUSBPSEJOBSJPT QSPHSFTPT UFD
OPDJFOUmDPT FO MBT DJFODJBT EF MB WJEB
ZEFMBTBMVE-BJOWFTUJHBDJOFOTFSFT
IVNBOPT  FM VTP IVNBOP EF MB UFDOP
MPHB MBTDVFTUJPOFTEFMBNVFSUFZEFM
NPSJSGVFSPOBMHVOBTSFBTTFOTJCMFTFO
MPT BPT  -BT DVFTUJPOFT PSJHJOBMFT
TFBNQMJBSPOBQSPCMFNBTEFWBMPSFTFO
EJWFSTBTSFBT UBMFTDPNPNFEJDJOB FO
GFSNFSB  TBMVE QCMJDB  TBMVE NFOUBM 
FOUSFPUSBT.VDIBTDVFTUJPOFTTPDJBMFT
GVFSPOJOUSPEVDJEBTFOFMBNQMJPUFNB
EFMBCJPUJDB DPNPMPTSFDVSTPTQCMJ
DPT MBTBMVEEFMBTNVKFSFT MBTDVFTUJP
OFTEFMBTQPCMBDJPOFTZMBFDPMPHB QPS
TMPNFODJPOBSBMHVOBT
4F EJDF RVF MB UFDOPMPHB NEJDB JN
QVMTFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDBDMOJDB 
ZFTPTVDFEJUBOUPFO"NSJDB-BUJOB
DPNPFO&TUBEPT6OJEPT"MQSJODJQJP 
MBTQSFHVOUBTNTGSFDVFOUFTTFSFGFSBO
B MB JOWFTUJHBDJO FO TFSFT IVNBOPT Z
OVFWBTUFDOPMPHBT FMVTPEFEJTQPTJUJ
WPTNEJDPT MBBDFQUBDJOPOPEFMDPO
TFOUJNJFOUPJOGPSNBEP





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

&O BMHVOPT QBTFT MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT  MB


TJNQMF FYJTUFODJB EF DFOUSPT BWBO[BEPT
EF BTJTUFODJB NEJDB RVF PGSFDFO BMUB
UFDOPMPHB PSJHJOB DVFTUJPOFT BDFSDB EF
MB EJTDSJNJOBDJO  MB JOKVTUJDJB Z MB FY
DMVTJOFOFMDVJEBEPNEJDP-BTDVFT
UJPOFT NT EJGDJMFT EF SFTQPOEFS FO MB
SFHJO OP TF SFmFSFO B DNP TF VUJMJ[B
MB UFDOPMPHB NEJDB  TJOP RVJO UJFOF
BDDFTPBFTBUFDOPMPHB6OGVFSUFQFO
TBNJFOUP TPDJBM JNQSFHOB MB CJPUJDB
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOB "SSBJHBEPT DPODFQUPT
DVMUVSBMFT oKVTUJDJB  FRVJEBE Z TPMJEBSJ
EBEoEFCFOUFOFSVOMVHBSFOFTUBCJP
UJDB VODPOUSBQVOUPBMBBVUPOPNBFO
MPT&TUBEPT6OJEPT
4FHO +BNFT %SBOF  MPT MBUJOPBNF
SJDBOPT OP TPO UBO JOEJWJEVBMJTUBT Z 
DJFSUBNFOUF  FTUO NFOPT JODMJOBEPT BM
DPOTVNJTNP FO TVT SFMBDJPOFT DPO MPT
NEJDPT RVF MPT OPSUFBNFSJDBOPT 4JO
FNCBSHP TFSBVOFSSPSQFOTBSRVFFTF
DPOTFOUJNJFOUP JOGPSNBEP Z UPEP MP
RVF FYJHF OP TFB JNQPSUBOUF QBSB OP
TPUSPT &M EFTBGP FT BQSFOEFS DPO MPT
&&66 Z MPT FVSPQFPT TJO JOUFOUBS
JNJUBS JOHFOVBNFOUF F JNQPSUBS TVT
QSPHSBNBT BEFDVBEPTQBSBVOBSFBMJEBE
EJWFSTB %SBOF 


"MHVOPTQVOUPTEJHOPTEF
SFnFYJO
B
"NQMJBSMBSFnFYJOUJDBEFM
OJWFMiNJDSPwBMOJWFMiNBDSPw
4FEFCFQSPQPOFSVOBCJPUJDBQFOTBEB
EFTEFVOOJWFMiNBDSPw MBTPDJFEBEFO
TV UPUBMJEBE
 DPNP BMUFSOBUJWB B PUSB
EFTEF VO OJWFM iNJDSPw TPMVDJO EF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

DVFTUJPOFT DMOJDBT
 EF MB USBEJDJO BO
HMPBNFSJDBOB&TEFDJS VOBCJPUJDBSFT
USJOHJEBBVOBiCJPTwEFBMUBUFDOPMPHB
ZBVOiFUIPTwJOEJWJEVBMJTUB QSJWBDJEBE 
DPOTFOUJNJFOUP JOGPSNBEP
 OFDFTJUB
TFS JOUFHSBEB FO "NSJDB -BUJOB B VOB
iCJPTwIVNBOJTUBZVOiFUIPTwDPNVOJ
UBSJP TPMJEBSJEBE FRVJEBE FMPUSP

&MHSBOEFTBGPFTEFTBSSPMMBSVOBCJPUJ
DBMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBRVFSFQBSFMBTFYBHF
SBDJPOFTEFPUSBTQFSTQFDUJWBTZFOBMUF[
DBMBDVMUVSBMBUJOBFOTVTBTQFDUPTNT
QFDVMJBSFT  VOB WJTJO WFSEBEFSBNFOUF
BMUFSOBUJWBQBSBVOEJMPHPNVMUJDVMUV
SBM/PQPEFNPTPMWJEBSRVFFTUBCJP
UJDBTVGSFFMJNQBDUPEFMBQPCSF[BZEF
MBFYDMVTJOTPDJBM&MBCPSBSMBTPMBNFOUF
FOFMOJWFMiNJDSPwoFOFTUVEJPTEFDBTP
PSJFOUBEPT BM BOBMJTJT EFPOUPMHJDP  TJO
DPOTJEFSBS FTUB SFBMJEBEo OP IBDF KVT
UJDJB B MPT EFTFPT Z OFDFTJEBEFT EF VOB
WJEBEJHOJmDBEB/PTFEJTDVUFFMWBMPS
JOOFHBCMF RVF NFSFDFO UPEBT MBT WJEBT
IVNBOBT UPEBT EFCFO TFS NBOUFOJEBT 
DVJEBEBT Z QSPUFHJEBT -P RVF OP QP
EFNPTIBDFS TJOFNCBSHP FTPMWJEBSMB
WJTJOHMPCBMEFMBSFBMJEBEMBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOBVOBSFBMJEBEEFFYDMVTJOZMJNJ
UBDJPOFT
&OFMNPNFOUPFORVF QBSBMBTBDUVB
MFT DVMUVSBT  MB NFEJDJOB NPEFSOB TF
DPOWJFSUFFOMPRVFGVFMBSFMJHJOFOMB
&EBE.FEJB MBTDVFTUJPOFTRVFBGFDUBO
BMBCJPUJDBTFIBDFONTDFOUSBMFTZHF
OFSBO VO JOUFST QCMJDP DBEB WF[ NB
ZPS &O FM VNCSBM EF MBT DPOUSPWFSTJBT
CJPUJDBT  MPT TJHOJmDBEPT CTJDPT FTUO
DBNCJBOEPFOUPEPFMQMBOFUBFMTJHOJ





"MHVOPTSFUPTQBSBFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF

mDBEPEFMBWJEBZMBNVFSUF MBGBNJMJB 
MBFOGFSNFEBE RVJOFTVOQBESFPVOB
NBESF QPSFKFNQMP-BNBZPSDPNVOJ
DBDJO Z FM EJMPHP FOUSF QFSTPOBT DPO
EJWFSTPT QVOUPT EF WJTUB TPO JONFOTB
NFOUFWFOUBKPTPT QPSRVFDPOUSJCVZFOB
VOBDPNQSFOTJONTQSPGVOEBEFDBEB
DVMUVSBZQSPQPOFONFKPSFTTPMVDJPOFT
B QSPCMFNBT DSUJDPT TJNJMBSFT -B HFO
UFEFEJWFSTBTSFHJPOFTZDVMUVSBTQVFEF
USBCBKBSQBSBJOUFHSBSEJGFSFODJBTTPDJP
MHJDBT  IJTUSJDBT Z mMPTmDBT  Z UBMWF[
VO EB HFOFSBS VO TJTUFNB EF FTUOEB
SFT CJPUJDPT SFTQFUVPTPT Z DPIFSFOUFT 
DPNQBSUJEPTJHVBMNFOUFQPSUPEPT
4FHO + " .BJOFUUJ 
 "NSJDB
-BUJOBQVFEFPGSFDFSVOBWJTJOCJPUJDB
EJTUJOUBEFMBEFPUSBTSFHJPOFTEFMHMPCP
EFCJEPBTVTUSBEJDJPOFTIVNBOJTUBTZB
DBVTBEFTVTDPOEJDJPOFTTPDJBMFTDPNP
HSVQP EF QBTFT QFSJGSJDPT 1BSB FTUF
CJPFUJDJTUBBSHFOUJOP MBEJTDJQMJOBFVSP
QFB EF MB mMPTPGB NEJDB DPO TVT USFT
SBNBTQSJODJQBMFT BOUSPQPMPHB FQJTUF
NPMPHBZBYJPMPHBNEJDBT
QPESBTFS
WJSQBSBUSBOTGPSNBSMBNFEJDJOBDJFOU
mDBZBDBENJDBFOVOOVFWPQBSBEJHNB
CJPNEJDPIVNBOJTUB5BMBDFSDBNJFO
UPFWJUBSBMBTBDVTBDJPOFTEJSJHJEBTDPO
GSFDVFODJBBMBNFEJDJOBTFHOMBTDVBMFT
QBSFDFPMWJEBSPOPTFDFOUSBFOMBWFS
EBEFSB EFTIVNBOJ[BDJO EFM TJTUFNB
1PSFKFNQMP FMEJTDVSTPCJPUJDPTPCSF
MBBVUPOPNBQVFEFFONBTDBSBSMBEFT
QFSTPOBMJ[BDJOEFMBBTJTUFODJBNEJDBZ
TVTSJFTHPTEFJBUSPHFOJB FYQMPUBDJOEFM
DVFSQPZFOBKFOBDJOEFMBTBMVE$PNP
SFTQVFTUBBMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPNFEJDJOB
FOVOBFSBUFDOPMHJDB MBCJPUJDBEFCF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

TFSNFOPTPQUJNJTUBDPOSFMBDJOBMQSP
HSFTPZEFTFNQFBSVOQBQFMDSUJDPFO
FTUFDPOUFYUP
-BSFBMJEBEMBUJOPBNFSJDBOBEFMBCJP
UJDBFOVOBQPDBEFDMFSB )*7ZTB
SBNQJOFYJHFVOQVOUPEFWJTUBTPDJBM
RVF EFmFOEB FM CJFOFTUBS  MB KVTUJDJB Z
MBFRVJEBEBOUFTRVFMPTEFSFDIPTJOEJ
WJEVBMFT Z MBT WJSUVEFT QFSTPOBMFT 6OB
iNBDSPUJDBwFOTBMVEQCMJDBTFQVFEF
QSPQPOFSDPNPBMUFSOBUJWBBMBUSBEJDJO
BOHMPBNFSJDBOBEFiNJDSPUJDBwPUJDB
DMOJDB/VFTUSBOFDFTJEBENTJNQFSJP
TBFOQBTFTQPCSFTFTMBFRVJEBEFOMB
BTJHOBDJOEFSFDVSTPTZMBEJTUSJCVDJO
EFMPTTFSWJDJPTNEJDPT
%JFHP (SBDJB BDMBSB i-PT MBUJOPBNFSJ
DBOPT TF TJFOUFO QSPGVOEBNFOUF JOD
NPEPT DPO FM EJTDVSTP EF MPT EFSFDIPT
Z MPT QSJODJQJPT 5JFOFO MB DPTUVNCSF
EFKV[HBSMBTDPTBTZMBTBDDJPOFTDPNP
ACVFOBT P ANBMBT FO WF[ EF ADJFSUBT P
AFSSBEBT1SFmFSFOMBCFOFWPMFODJBBMB
KVTUJDJB MBBNJTUBEBMSFTQFUPNVUVP MB
FYDFMFODJBBMPTEFSFDIPT y
#VTDBOB
MB WJSUVE Z MB FYDFMFODJB /P DSFP RVF
SFDIBDFO P EFTQSFDJFO MPT QSJODJQJPT
y
 $PNP MBT DVMUVSBT MBUJOBT GVFSPO
PSJFOUBEBTUSBEJDJPOBMNFOUFQPSMBUJDB
EFMBTWJSUVEFT FMBDFSDBNJFOUPQSJODJ
QJBMJTUBQVFEFTFSNVZQSPWFDIPTPQBSB
FWJUBSBMHVOPTEFGFDUPTUSBEJDJPOBMFTEF
OVFTUSBWJEBNPSBMUBMFTDPNPFMQBUFS
OBMJTNP  MB DBSFODJB EF SFTQFUP QPS MBT
MFZFT Z MB UPMFSBODJB &O MB CTRVFEB
EF MB WJSUVE Z MB FYDFMFODJB  MPT QBTFT
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOPT IBO TJEP USBEJDJPOBM
NFOUFJOUPMFSBOUFT-BUPMFSBODJBOPTF





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

IBJODMVJEPDPNPWJSUVEFOFMDBUMPHP
BOUJHVPEFMBTWJSUVEFTMBUJOBT-BWJSUVE
WFSEBEFSB FSB MB JOUPMFSBODJB  Z MB UPMF
SBODJBFSBDPOTJEFSBEBVOWJDJP 
-PT
BOHMPTBKPOFTIBOEFTDVCJFSUPMBUPMFSBO
DJBDPNPWJSUVEFOFMTJHMP97**2VJ[T
FTUBFTMBEJGFSFODJBNTTJHOJmDBUJWBSFT
QFUPEFPUSBTDVMUVSBT-BDVFTUJONP
SBMNTJNQPSUBOUFOPFTMBMFOHVBRVF
VUJMJ[BNPT FO MB FYQSFTJO EF OVFTUSBT
TFOTBDJPOFTNPSBMFT TJOPFMSFTQFUPQPS
MB EJWFSTJEBE NPSBM  MB PQDJO FOUSF FM
QMVSBMJTNPZFMGBOBUJTNP&MGBOBUJTNP
BmSNB RVF MPT WBMPSFT TPO UPUBMFT  BC
TPMVUPTZPCKFUJWPTZTFEFCFOJNQPOFS
QPSMBGVFS[BBPUSPT NJFOUSBTMBUPMFSBO
DJBEFmFOEFMBBVUPOPNBZMBMJCFSUBE
NPSBM QBSB UPEPT MPT TFSFT IVNBOPT Z
MB CTRVFEB EF VO BDVFSEP NPSBM QPS
DPOTFOTPw
%BOJFM 8JLMFS  BOUJHVP QSFTJEFOUF EF
MB "TPDJBDJO *OUFSOBDJPOBM EF #JP
UJDB *"#
 FO FM EJTDVSTP EF DJFSSF EFM
***$POHSFTP.VOEJBMEF#JPUJDB 4BO
'SBODJTDP &&66 
RVFUSBUFM
UFNB i#JPUJDB Z SFTQPOTBCJMJEBE TP
DJBMw IBEJDIPRVFDVBOEPNJSBNPTFM
OBDJNJFOUPZFMEFTBSSPMMPEFMBCJPUJDB 
EFUFDUBNPTDMBSBNFOUFDVBUSPGBTFT
 5FOFNPTMPTDEJHPTEFDPO
EVDUBEFMPTQSPGFTJPOBMFT-B
CJPUJDB TF FOUJFOEF QSDUJDB
NFOUFDPNPUJDBNEJDB
 -B SFMBDJO NEJDPQBDJFOUF
FOUSBFOFTDFOB$PNCBUJNPT
FMQBUFSOBMJTNPZMPTEFSFDIPT
EF MPT QBDJFOUFT DPNJFO[BO B
TFS EJTDVUJEPT BVUPOPNB  MJ
CFSUBE WFSEBE FUD


PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

 4F QSFHVOUB TPCSF MPT TJTUF


NBT EF TBMVE  JODMVZFOEP TV
FTUSVDUVSB Z PSHBOJ[BDJO  m
OBODJBNJFOUP Z HFSFODJB -PT
CJPFUJDJTUBT EFCFO FTUVEJBS MB
FDPOPNB Z MB QPMUJDB EF MB
TBMVE $BMMBIBO 

 $PNFO[BNPTFTUBGBTFBMmOBM
EF MPT BPT  -B CJPUJDB
TF PDVQB QSJPSJUBSJBNFOUF EF
MB TBMVE EF MBT QPCMBDJPOFT  Z
TF JODPSQPSBO BM FTDFOBSJP MBT
DJFODJBT TPDJBMFT  MBT IVNBOJ
EBEFT MBTBMVEQCMJDB MPTEF
SFDIPTIVNBOPT MBFRVJEBEZ
MBBTJHOBDJOEFSFDVSTPT FO
USFPUSBTDVFTUJPOFTDBOEFOUFT
&TFQSPHSBNBFTQFSUJOFOUFFO
FMNPNFOUPUJDPEF"NSJDB
-BUJOB

C
&MEFTBGPEFEFTBSSPMMBSVO
IPSJ[POUFEFTFOUJEPQBSBMB
CJPUJDB
/VFTUSBSFnFYJOTFSBJODPNQMFUBTJOP
NFODJPOSBNPT MB OFDFTJEBE EF EFTB
SSPMMBSVOIPSJ[POUFNTBNQMJPPVOB
NTUJDB QBSB MB CJPUJDB 1VFEF QBSFDFS
FYUSBP QBSBVOBMOFBEFQFOTBNJFOUP
NBSDBEBQPSFMQSBHNBUJTNPZFMDVMUP
EFMBFmDBDJB TVHFSJSRVFMBCJPUJDBOF
DFTJUBNTUJDB-BCJPUJDBQSFDJTBVOIP
SJ[POUFEFTFOUJEPoPEFTJHOJmDBEPoZ
OPJNQPSUBTJFTFTUSFDIPPBNQMJPQBSB
EFTBSSPMMBSTVTSFnFYJPOFTZQSPQVFTUBT
4JNVMUOFBNFOUF  OP QPEFNPT IBDFS
CJPUJDBTJOPQUBSQPSVONVOEPEFSF
MBDJPOFTIVNBOBT&TPFT FOTNJTNP 
JOEJDBDJOEFMBOFDFTJEBEEFVODJFSUP





"MHVOPTSFUPTQBSBFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF

UJQPEFNTUJDBPEFVOTJTUFNBEFTJHOJ
mDBEPT GVOEBNFOUBMFT RVF BDFQUBNPT
#BTBEPT FO TUF DVMUJWBSFNPT OVFTUSP
JEFBMJTNP IBSFNPTOVFTUSBTPQDJPOFTZ
PSHBOJ[BSFNPTOVFTUSBTQSDUJDBT
/P FT GDJM EFmOJS FO QPDBT QBMBCSBT
FTUF IPSJ[POUF NT BNQMJP EF TFOUJEP
QBSBMBCJPUJDB*ODMVZFOFDFTBSJBNFOUF
MB DPOWJDDJO FO MB USBTDFOEFODJB EF MB
WJEB RVFSFDIB[BMBOPDJOEFFOGFSNF
EBE EFTVGSJNJFOUPZEFNVFSUFDPNP
BCTPMVUPTRVFOPQVFEFOTFSUPMFSBEPT
*ODMVZF MB PQJOJO EF MPT PUSPT DPNP
DPNQBFSPTDBQBDFTEFWJWJSFOTPMJEB
SJEBE Z EF FOUFOEFS Z BDFQUBS MB WJEB
DPNP VOB EEJWB &TUF IPSJ[POUF FT 
TJO EVEB  VO UFTUJNPOJP  FO FM TFOUJEP
EF OP QFSNJUJS RVF QSFWBMF[DBO JOUFSF
TFT JOEJWJEVBMFT FHPTUBT OJ TJMFODJBS MB
WP[ EF MPT WVMOFSBCMFT P MPT FYDMVJEPT 
OJFONBTDBSBSTVTOFDFTJEBEFT&TUFIP
SJ[POUFQSPDMBNBBOUFUPEPTMPTEFTDV
CSJNJFOUPT EF MBT DJFODJBT EF MB WJEB Z
EFM DVJEBEP NEJDP RVF FM JNQFSBUJWP
UFDOPDJFOUmDP iZP QVFEP IBDFSw UFO
ESB RVF EFQFOEFS OFDFTBSJBNFOUF EF
iQPSMPUBOUP {EFCPIBDFSMP w.TRVF
FTUP NPUJWBBMBHFOUFZBHSVQPTEFMBT
NT EJWFSTBT TJUVBDJPOFT TPDJBMFT  QPM
UJDBT  FDPONJDBT Z DVMUVSBMFT B VOJSTF
FOMBUBSFBEFHBSBOUJ[BSVOBWJEBEJHOB
QBSBUPEPT DPOTUSVJSVOQBSBEJHNBFDP
ONJDP UDOJDPZDJFOUmDPSFHJEPQPS
MBTEFNBOEBTEFMBTPMJEBSJEBEIVNBOB
"OKPT  


D
.TBMMEFMQSJODJQJBMJTNP
&MNPEFMPQSJODJQJBMJTUBEFBOMJTJTUF
SJDP JOJDJBEPDPOFM*OGPSNF#FMNPOUZ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

QVFTUP FO FKFDVDJO QPS #FBVDIBNQ Z


$IJMESFTT FTTMPVOPFOUSFPUSPTJEJP
NBTUJDPT-BFYQFSJFODJBUJDBTFQVFEF
FYQSFTBS FO EJWFSTPT JEJPNBT  QBSBEJH
NBT P NPEFMPT UFSJDPT 0CWJBNFOUF 
DPOWJWJS DPO FTUF QMVSBMJTNP FYJHF VO
EJMPHPSFTQFUVPTPEFMBTEJGFSFODJBTFO
FMRVFMBUPMFSBODJBFTFTFODJBM&TUPTNP
EFMPTPJEJPNBTTFDPSSFMBDJPOBOJOUSO
TFDBNFOUF  QFSP DBEB VOP FT UBNCJO
JOUSOTFDBNFOUFJODPNQMFUPZMJNJUBEP
6ONPEFMPQVFEFPDVQBSTFCJFOEFVO
BTQFDUPEFmOJEPEFMBWJEBNPSBM QFSP
OPTJNVMUOFBNFOUFEFUPEPT/PQPEF
NPTDPOTJEFSBSMPTFYDMVTJWPT TJOPDPN
QMFNFOUBSJPT&TUPOPEFCFTPSQSFOEFS
QPSRVFMBBNQMJUVEZMBBCVOEBODJBEF
MB FYQFSJFODJB IVNBOB FTUO TJFNQSF
NTBMMEFMBMDBODFEFDVBMRVJFSTJTUFNB
mMPTmDP P UFPMHJDP %JDIB NPEFTUJB 
RVFWJFOFEFMBTBCJEVSB OPTIBSMJCSFT
EFMWJSVTEFMPTiJTNPTi EFMBTJEFPMP
HBTRVFUPNBOVOBQBSUFEFMBSFBMJEBE
QPSUPEBMBSFBMJEBE

E
-BKVTUJDJBZMBFRVJEBEFOFM
SFBEFMDVJEBEPNEJDP
-PTQSPCMFNBTCJPUJDPTEFJNQPSUBODJB
FYUSFNBFO"NSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCF
TFSFMBDJPOBODPOMBKVTUJDJB MBFRVJEBE
ZMBBTJHOBDJOEFSFDVSTPTFOFMSFBEFM
DVJEBEPNEJDP
-BCJPUJDBEFMNVOEPEFTBSSPMMBEP &&
66Z&VSPQB
IJ[PDBTPPNJTPEFDVFT
UJPOFTCTJDBTRVFBnJHFOBNJMMPOFTEF
FYDMVJEPTFOFTUFDPOUJOFOUFZTFFOGPD
FOBMHVOBTRVFQBSBOPTPUSPTTPONBS
HJOBMFT P JOFYJTUFOUFT 1PS FKFNQMP  FO
FMNVOEPEFTBSSPMMBEPTFIBCMBNVDIP





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

EFNPSJSDPOEJHOJEBEBRVOPTJNQVM
TBOBQSPDMBNBSRVFMBEJHOJEBEIVNB
OBEFCFQSJNFSPHBSBOUJ[BSMBWJEBZOP
TJNQMFNFOUFVOBTVQFSWJWFODJBRVFEF
HSBEB&OUSFOPTPUSPT MPRVFTVDFEFFT
MBNVFSUFQSFNBUVSB RVFFTJOKVTUB RVF
FOMVUBZEFTUSVZFNJMMBSFTEFWJEBTEFT
EFMBOJF[ NJFOUSBTRVFFOFMNVOEP
EFTBSSPMMBEPTFNVFSFEFTQVTEFWJWJSZ
HP[BS MB WJEB DPO FMFHBODJB  JODMVTP FO
MB WFKF[ {6OB TVQFSWJWFODJB EPMPSPTB
HBSBOUJ[BSBMBEJHOJEBEBMNPNFOUPEF
NPSJS 
3FnFYJPOBOEP QSPTQFDUJWBNFOUF DPO
"MBJTUBJS7$BNQCFMM 
oBOUJHVP
QSFTJEFOUFEFMB"TPDJBDJO*OUFSOBDJP
OBM EF #JPUJDB 
o SFTQFDUP
EF MB CJPUJDB EFM GVUVSP  VOB DVFTUJO
DMBWF B FOGSFOUBSFTMB KVTUJDJBFOTBMVE
ZFODVJEBEPTNEJDPT-BCJPUJDBOP
QVFEF DPOWFSUJSTF FO VOB FTQFDJF EF
iDBQFMMO FO FM SFJOBEP EF MB DJFODJBw 
QFSEJFOEPTVQBQFMDSUJDPGSFOUFBMQSP
HSFTPUFDOPDJFOUmDP

F
#JPUJDBZSFMJHJO
6OB DBSBDUFSTUJDB EF MBT SFHJPOFT MB
UJOPBNFSJDBOB Z DBSJCFB FT MB IFSFO
DJB DSJTUJBOP DBUMJDB  IPZ GVFSUFNFOUF
BGFDUBEB QPS TFDUBT GVOEBNFOUBMJTUBT Z
TV BSTFOBM EF NFEJPT FMFDUSOJDPT &M
QSPDFTP EF TFDVMBSJ[BDJO IB BMDBO[B
EP B MB CVSHVFTB FEVDBEB  NBT OP BM
QVFCMP -B NPSBM TPDJBM DPOUJOB TJFO
EPCTJDBNFOUFSFMJHJPTBZDPOGFTJPOBM
&TB TPDJFEBE OP DPOPDF FM QMVSBMJTNP 
DBSBDUFSTUJDB GVFSUF EF NVDIPT QBTFT
EFTBSSPMMBEPT4JOEVEB BRVTFQSFTFO
UBVOEFTBGPBMEJMPHPFOUSFMBCJPUJDB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

ZMBUFPMPHB FOUSFFMVOJWFSTPCJPUJDP
TFDVMBS oDJWJM  QMVSBMJTUB  BVUOPNP Z
SBDJPOBMoZFMSFMJHJPTP QSPGVOEBNFOUF
BSSBJHBEPFOFTUBTUJFSSBT
&ENVOE%1FMMFHSJOP &&66
QMBO
UFBUSFTQSFHVOUBT{DNPEFDJEJSFOUSF
MBEJWFSTJEBEEFPQJOJPOFTTPCSFRVFT
CJPUJDBZTVDBNQP {$NPSFMBDJPOBS
WBSJPT NPEFMPT CJPUJDPT  {$VM FT FM
MVHBSEFMBSFMJHJOZEFMBCJPUJDBUFP
MHJDB FO MPT EFCBUFT QCMJDPT TPCSF FM
BCPSUP FMDVJEBEPBENJOJTUSBEP MBFV
UBOBTJB FUD )BTUBBIPSB MBCJPUJDBSF
MJHJPTBFTUBCBFOMBQFOVNCSBEFMBCJP
UJDBmMPTmDBPNBTNBZ1FMMFHSJOP

QSFEJDFOMBBQBSJDJOEFWBMPSFT
SFMJHJPTPT FO MB EJTDVTJO QCMJDB FO MB
NFEJEBFORVFOVFTUSBDPODJFODJBEFMB
EJWFSTJEBE DVMUVSBM BVNFOUB /PT BE
WJFSUFOEFMBOFDFTJEBEEFVOBNFUPEP
MPHBDBQB[EFPDVQBSTFEFMBDPOUJOVB
QPMBSJ[BDJORVFUSBFOMBTDPOWJDDJPOFT
BVUOUJDBTZQSPQPOFORVFEFCFNPTWJ
WJS Z USBCBKBS KVOUPT DPNP JHVBMFT BVO
DVBOEP MBNBZPSBEFMBTWFDFT OVFTUSBT
DPOWJDDJPOFTmMPTmDBTZSFMJHJPTBTTPCSF
MPWFSEBEFSPZMPGBMTPFTUOFODPOnJDUP
PTFBOJSSFDPODJMJBCMFT

6OBPCTFSWBDJOmOBM
)BZOFDFTJEBEEFDVMUJWBSVOBTBCJEVSB
RVF EFTBGF QSPGUJDBNFOUF FM JNQFSJB
MJTNPUJDPEFRVJFOFTVUJMJ[BOMBGVFS
[BQBSBJNQPOFSTVQSPQJBNPSBMDPNP
TJ GVFSB MB OJDB WFSEBE Z  UBNCJO  FM
GVOEBNFOUBMJTNP EF RVJFOFT SFDIB[BO
FOUSBSFOVOEJMPHPBCJFSUPZHFOVJOP
DPOPUSPT FOVODPOUFYUPNTQMVSBMJTUB
ZTFDVMBS





"MHVOPTSFUPTQBSBFMGVUVSPEFMBCJPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB-FP1FTTJOJZ$ISJTUJBOEF1BVMEF#BSDIJGPOUBJOF

2VJO TBCF TJ MB JOUVJDJO QJPOFSB EF


73 1PUUFS 
 DVBOEP BDV MB
CJPUJDBDPNPVOQVFOUFIBDJBFMGVUVSP 
OFDFTJUFTFSPUSBWF[FTUVEJBEBZUSBCBKB
EB EF PUSBT NBOFSBT FO FM OVFWP NJMF
OJPQBSBTFSUBNCJOVOQVFOUFIBDJBFM
EJMPHPNVMUJDVMUVSBMZUSBTDVMUVSBM VO

QVFOUFQBSBSFDVQFSBSOVFTUSBUSBEJDJO
IVNBOJTUB OVFTUSPTFOUJEPEFMBWJEBZ
OVFTUSPSFTQFUPQPSMBUSBTDFOEFODJBEF
MBWJEBFOTVNBHOJUVENYJNB DTNJ
DBZFDPMHJDB
ZHP[BSEFFMMBDPNPVOB
EEJWBZVOBDPORVJTUBDPOEJHOJEBEZ
TPMJEBSJEBE

3FGFSFODJBT
"OKPT .' 
#JPFUIJDTJOBMJCFSBUJPOJTULFZ*O%VCPTF &3 )BNFM 31
0$POOFMM  -+ $PPSET
 " NBUUFS PG QSJODJQMFT GFSNFOU JO 64 CJPFUIJDT 7BMMFZ
'PSHF 1FOOTZMWBOJB5SJOJUZ1SFTT*OUFSOBUJPOBM QQ
"OKPT  .' 
 .FEJDBM FUIJDT JO UIF EFWFMPQJOH XPSME B MJCFSBUJPO UIFPMPHZ
QFSTQFDUJWF 5IF +PVSOBM PG .FEJDJOF BOE 1IJMPTPQIZ   
 %FDFNCFS  QQ 

#BSDIJGPOUBJOF $EF1Z1FTTJOJ - 
#JPUJDBBQBSUJSEF"NSJDB-BUJOB&O
-BWJEBWBMF#JPUJDBOVFWPTDBNJOPT-JNB $FOUSPEF&TUVEJPTZ1VCMJDBDJPOFT
$&1
QQ
$BNQCFMM "7 
"#JPUJDBOPTDVMP99*4BEF)FMJQPMJT "QSJM.BJ QQ
%SBOF +' 
#JPFUIJDBM1FSTQFDUJWFTGSPN*CFSP"NFSJDB5IF+PVSOBMPG.FEJDJOF
BOE1IJMPTPQIZ  
%FDFNCFS QQ
(BSSBGB 7 ,PUUPX . 4BBEB " &ET
 
#BTFTDPODFJUVBJTEB#JPUJDBFOGPRVF
MBUJOPBNFSJDBOP4P1BVMP &EJUPSB(BJB
(SBDJB %)BSE5JNFT IBSEDIPJDFTGPVOEJOHCJPFUIJDTUPEBZ#JPFUIJDT  
+VMZ 
QQ
.BJOFUUJ +" 
)JTUPSZPGNFEJDBMFUIJDT5IF"NFSJDBTE-BUJO"NFSJDB*O
3FJDI  85 &E
 &ODZDMPQFEJB PG #JPFUIJDT  SFWJTFE FEJUJPO 7PM  /FX :PSL 
.D.JMMBO QQ
1FTTJOJ - 
#JPFUIJDT 1PXFSBOE*OKVTUJDFTPNFQFSTPOBMUIPVHIUTGSPNB-BUJO
"NFSJDBO QFSTQFDUJWF *"# /&84  *TTVF   'FCSVBSZ  QQ  "WBJMBCMF BU
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTJOUFSOBUJPOBMPSHOFXTJBCOFXTGFCQEG
1FTTJOJ -#BSDIJGPOUBJOF $EF1 &ET
 
'VOEBNFOUPTEB#JPUJDBOE&E
4P1BVMP 1BVMVT QQ
1FTTJOJ  - 
 #JPFUIJDT B IPSJ[PO PG IPQF GPS B OFX UJNF 0 .VOEP EB 4BEF 
 
4FQU0DU QQ
1FTTJOJ - 
#VJMEJOHB/FX$VMUVSFPG&UIJDTJO3FTFBSDI*OWPMWJOH)VNBOTJO
#SB[JM/PUJ[JFEJ1PMJUJB  
QQ
1FTTJOJ  - 
 #JPUJDB F TFV GVUVSP BMHVOT EFTBGJPT B QBSUJS EF VNB QFSTQFDUJWB
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOB &O /FWFT  .  -JNB  . 
 #JPUJDB PV #JPUJDBT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

OB FWPMVP EBT TPDJFEBEFT &EJP -VTPCSBTJMFJSB  (SGJDB EF $PJNCSB$FOUSP


6OJWFSTJUSJP4P$BNJMP QQ
5IPNBTNB  %$ BOE 1FMMFHSJOP &% 
 5IF 'VUVSF PG #JPFUIJDT 2VBSUFSMZ PG
)FBMUIBOE&UIJDT  QQ
8JLMFS % 
#JPFUIJDTBOETPDJBMSFTQPOTJCJMJUZ#JPFUIJDT  
QQ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



"QOEJDFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





4FMFDDJOEFQSPHSBNBTGPSNBUJWPTFOCJPUJDB

"3(&/5*/"

.BFTUSBFO#JPUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF$SEPCB 
'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT.EJDBT 
4FDSFUBSBEF(SBEVBEPTFO$JFODJBTEF
MB4BMVE
5FM 
JOUBM
THDT!GDNVODFEVBS
1SPHSBNBEF.BFTUSBFO#JPUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF$VZP 
4FDSFUBSBEF1PTHSBEP 'BDVMUBEEF
$JFODJBT.EJDBT5FM
'BY
CJPFUJDB!GDNVODVFEVBS
$)*-&

.BHTUFSFO#JPUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF 'BDVMUBEEF
'JMPTPGBZ)VNBOJEBEFT
$BQJUO*HOBDJP$BSSFSB1JOUP 
QJTP VPB 4BOUJBHP
5FMGPOP 

'BY 

BMSFZFT!VDIJMFDM
.BHTUFSFO#JPUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF 'BDVMUBEEF
.FEJDJOB
"W*OEFQFOEFODJB 
*OEFQFOEFODJB 4BOUJBHP
5FMGPOP 

'BY 

QHBNFE!NFEVDIJMFDM

.BHTUFSFO#JPUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBEEFM%FTBSSPMMP 'BDVMUBE
EF.FEJDJOBEF$MOJDB"MFNBOB
"W7JUBDVSB7JUBDVSB 4BOUJBHP
5FMGPOP
SFEFT!VEEDM
IUUQXXXVEEDMQSPOUVT@
QPTUHSBEPT
.BHTUFSFO#JPUJDB
1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDBEF
$IJMF 'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOB $FOUSP
EF#JPUJDB
"MBNFEB FEJmDJP
(BTUSPFOUFSPMPHB UPQJTP 4BOUJBHP
5FMGPOP'BY 


CJPFUJDB!NFEQVDDM
1SPHSBNB*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF'PSNBDJO
UJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJO#JPNEJDBZ
1TJDPTPDJBM
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF $FOUSP
*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO
#JPUJDB
%JBHPOBM1BSBHVBZ 5PSSF 0G
 4BOUJBHP
5FMGPOP
DCJP!VDIJMFDM
IUUQXXXVDIJMFDMCJPFUJDBDVSTPT
QSPHSBNBIUN
$0-0.#*"

%PDUPSBEPFO#JPUJDB

6OJWFSTJEBE&M#PTRVF

 5PEBFTUBTFDDJOEF"QOEJDFTGVFQSFQBSBEBQPS"OESFBHVJMB CJCMJPUFDBSJBEPDVNFOUBMJTUBEFM1SP
HSBNBEF#JPUJDB0140.4

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

%JSFDDJO$BSSFSBE#JT/P 
#PHPU
5FMT'BY
$PONVUBEPS&YUT

CJPFUJDB!VOCPTRVFFEVDP
IUUQXXXVOCPTRVFFEVDP
.BHTUFSFO#JPUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE&M#PTRVF
$BSSFSBE#JT/P #PHPU
5FMT'BY

$PONVUBEPS&YUT

CJPFUJDB!VOCPTRVFFEVDP
IUUQXXXVOCPTRVFFEVDP
&41""

.BHTUFSFO#JPUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTFEF.BESJE 
'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOB 6OJEBEEF
)JTUPSJBEFMB.FEJDJOB %FQBSUBNFOUP
EF.FEJDJOB1SFWFOUJWB 4BMVE1CMJDB
F)JTUPSJBEFMB$JFODJB
$JVEBE6OJWFSTJUBSJB  .BESJE
5FMT
NTUCJPFU!NFEVDNFT
IUUQXXXVDNFTJOGPCJPFUJDB
JOEFYNIUN

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

.BHTUFSFO#JPUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTFEF.BESJE
"WEB$PNQMVUFOTFTO7JDFSSFDUPSBEP
EF"MVNOPT.BESJE
5FMGPOP'BY

JOGPDPN!VDNFT
IUUQXXXVDNFT
1&3

.BFTUSBFO#JPUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBM.BZPSEF4BO
.BSDPT
"W1F[FU .BHEBMFOBEFM.BS 
-JNB
3FGFSFODJB"MU$ESBEF"WFOJEB
4BMBWFSSZ

5FMGPOPT"OFYP

FQHBENJTJPO!VONTNFEVQF
IUUQXXXVONTNFEVQF&QH
7&/&;6&-"

1PTUHSBEP#JPUJDB$MOJDB
'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOB $FOUSP
/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB &TDVFMB
&YQFSJNFOUBMEF&OGFSNFSB
"W.JHVFM0UFSP4JMWB4FCVDO 
$BSBDBT
5FMGPOP 

NFEJDJOB!QPTUHSBEPVDWWF
IUUQXXXQPTUHSBEPVDWWFDVSTP
DVSTPBTQ JENFE





4FMFDDJOEFJOTUJUVDJPOFTEFCJPUJDB

"-&."/*"

%FVUTDIF(FTFMMTDIBGUGS
3FDIUTNFEJ[JO %(3.
 (FSNBO
4PDJFUZGPS-FHBM.FEJDJOF

'SBVFOMPCTUSBTTFB .VODIFO
IUUQXXXEHSNEF
EHSN!VOJNVFOTUFSEF
%FVUDIFT3FGFSFO[[FOUSVNGS&UIJL
JOEFO#JPXJTTFOTDIBGUFO(FSNBO
3FGFSFODF $FOUSFGPS&UIJDTJOUIF-JGF
4DJFODFT %3;&

/JFCVISTUSBTTF% #POO
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXES[FEF
JOGP!ES[FEF
(FSNBO/BUJPOBM&UIJDT$PVODJM
/BUJPOBMFS&UIJLSBU
(FTDIBGUTTUFMMF
EFT/BUJPOBMFO&UIJLSBUFT 4JU[#FSMJO
#SBOEFOCVSHJTDIF"LBEFNJFEFS
8JTTFOTDIBGUFO
+BHFSTUSBTTF
#FSMJO 
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXFUIJLSBUPSH
LPOUBLU!FUIJLSBUPSH
*OTUJUVUGS(FTDIJDIUFEFS.FEJ[JO 
"LBEFNJFGS&UIJLJOEFS.FEJ[JO
)VNCPMEUBMMFF % (PFUUJOHFO
5FM 
'"9 
IUUQXXXBFNPOMJOFEFNBJOIUN
TJNPO!BFNPOMJOFEF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

6OJWFSTJUZPG5FCJOHFO $FOUFS
GPS&UIJDTJOUIF4DJFODFTBOEUIF
)VNBOJUJFT *OUFSGBLVMUSFT;FOUSVN
GS&UIJLJOEFO8JTTFOTDIBGUFO

*;&8

8JMIFMNTUS %5VFCJOHFO
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXJ[FXVOJUVFCJOHFOEF
J[FXEPLVNFOUBUJPO!VOJUVFCJOHFOEF
;FOUSVNGSNFEJ[JOJTDIF&UIJL
3VIS6OJWFSTJUBFU#PDIVN 
6OJWFSTJUBFUTTUS(FCBFVEF(" 
&CFOF
;JNNFS %#PDIVN
5FM  
 
'BY 
.FE&UIJDT!SVISVOJCPDIVNEF
"3(&/5*/"

"TPDJBDJO"SHFOUJOBEF#JPUJDB
$BMMFEFNBZP 1JTP 'BDVMUBE
EF%FSFDIP
 
.BSEFM1MBUB
IUUQXXXBBCJPFUJDBPSH
IPPGUQG!JOGPWJBDPNBS
#JP4VS3FE3FHJPOBMEF$PNJUTEF
UJDBFO4BMVE
SFECJPTVS!ZBIPPDPNBS
$FOUSPEF*OWFTUJHBDJOZ&OTFBO[B
IUUQXXXCJPFUJDBPSH
TDZQV!BSHFOFUDPNBS
*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDBZ)VNBOJEBEFT
.EJDBT
-B1MBUB 1SPWJODJBEF#VFOPT"JSFT







1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

IUUQXXXFMBCFCJPFUJDBPSH
FMBCF!TBUMJOLDPN
1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDB
"SHFOUJOB *OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDB
"W"MJDJB.EF+VTUP #VFOPT
"JSFT
5FM 
'BY 


IUUQXXXVDBFEVBSFTQTFDCJPFUJDB
JOEFYQIQ
CJPFUJDB!VDBFEVBS
6OJWFSTJEBE"VTUSBM 'BDVMUBEEF
%FSFDIP %FQBSUBNFOUPEF#JPUJDB
GFC!DBTBVTUSBMFEVBS
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF$VZP
'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT.EJDBT
.BFTUSBFO#JPUJDB
QPTHSBEP!GDNVODVFEVBS
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF-BOT
.BFTUSBFOUJDB"QMJDBEB
EF4FQUJFNCSF 
3FNFEJPT
EF&TDBMBEB -BOT 1SPWJODJBEF#VFOPT
"JSFT
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF.BSEFM1MBUB 
&TQFDJBMJ[BDJOFO#JPUJDB
IUUQXXXNEQFEVBS
"6453"-*"

"VTUSBMJBO#JPFUIJDT"TTPDJBUJPO "#"

,PLJMB%F4JMWB "#"4FDSFUBSZDP
3FTFBSDI
0DF #ME&"
.BDRVBSJF6OJWFSTJUZ
/FX4PVUI8BMFT
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXBVTUSBMBTJBOCJPFUIJDTPSHBV
LEFTJMWB!WDNRFEVBV
"VTUSBMJBO$BUIPMJD6OJWFSTJUZ +PIO
1MVOLFUU$FOUSFGPS&UIJDTJO)FBMUI
$BSF
4U7JODFOUT)PTQJUBM 7JDUPSJB4USFFU 
%BSMJOHIVSTU /FX4PVUI8BMFT
5FM 'BY 

QMVOLFUU!QMVOLFUUFEVBV

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

"VTUSBMJBO)FBMUI&UIJDT$PNNJUUFF 
/BUJPOBM)FBMUIBOE.FEJDBM3FTFBSDI
$PVODJM /).3$
.%1(10
#PY $BOCFSSB "$5
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXIFBMUIHPWBVOINSD
FYFDTFD!OINSDHPWBV
$ISJTUJBO$FOUSFGPS#JPFUIJDT 4ZEOFZ
"EWFOUJTU)PTQJUBM
'PY7BMMFZ3PBE -FWFM 
8BISPPOHB /FX4PVUI8BMFT
5FM'BY

IUUQXXXTBIPSHBVFEVDBUJPOMJCSBSZ
BTQ
MJCSBSZ!TBIPSHBV
-BUSPCF6OJWFSTJUZ )FBMUI*TTVFT
$FOUSF -FWFM )FBMUI4DJFODFT
.FMCPVSOF 7JDUPSJB
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXIFBMUIJTTVFTDFOUSFPSHBV
IJD!MBUSPCFFEVBV
-+(PPEZ#JPFUIJDT$FOUSF
+VHBO4USFFU (MFOEBMPVHI 8FTUFSO
"VTUSBMJB
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXMKHCDQFSUIDBUIPMJDPSHBV
MKHCD!QFSUIDBUIPMJDPSHBV
.POBTI6OJWFSTJUZ
$FOUSFGPS)VNBO#JPFUIJDT
$MBZUPO .FMCPVSOF 7JDUPSJB
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXBSUTNPOBTIFEVBV
CJPFUIJDT
+VTUJO0BLMFZ!BSUTNPOBTIFEVBV
2VFFOTMBOE#JPFUIJDT$FOUSF
10#PY 4PVUI#SJTCBOF 2
5FM'BY

IUUQXXXCOFDBUIPMJDOFUBVRCD
JOEFYQIQ
RCD!NBUFSPSHBV



"QOEJDFT

4PVUIFSO$SPTT#JPFUIJDT*OTUJUVUF
.BSJPO3PBE10#PY /PSUI
1MZNQUPO 4PVUI"EFMBJEF
5FM 'BY 

TFXJOH!CJPFUIJDTPSHBV
6OJWFSTJUZPG2VFFOTMBOE 4U+PIOT
$PMMFHF$PMMFHF3PBE "VTUSBMJBO
*OTUJUVUFPG&UIJDTBOEUIF1SPGFTTJPOT
4U-VDJB 2VFFOTMBOE
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXVRFEVBVBJFQ
INVOSP!NBJMCPYVRFEVBV
"6453*"

"VTUSJBO$PNNJTTJPOPO#JPFUIJDT
#VOEFTLBO[MFSBNU )PIFOTUBVGFOHBTTF 
7JFOOB
5FM 'BY 

SPCFSUHNFJOFS!CLBHWBU
HBCSJFMBTDIXFIMB!CLBHWBU
#-(*$"

$PNJU$POTVMUBUJGEF#JPUIJRVFEF
#FMHJRVF
$"&#BUJNFOU7FTBMFNFFUBHF#VS
DP.NF.POJRVF#PTTPO#E
1BDIFDPCUF #SVYFMMFT
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXIFBMUIGHPWCFCJPFUI
CJPFUIJOGP!IFBMUIGHPWCF
.POJRVF#PTTPO!IFBMUIGHPWCF
&VSPQFBO$PNNJTTJPO &VSPQFBO
(SPVQPO&UIJDTJO4DJFODFBOE/FX
5FDIOPMPHJFT &(&

#SFZ ##SVTTFMT
5FM'BY
HPQBFUIJDTHSPVQ!DFDFVJOU
$ISJTUJBOF#BSEPVY!DFDFVJOU
&VSPQFBO.FEJDBM4UVEFOUT"TTPDJBUJPO 
$PNNJUUFFPO.FEJDBM&UIJDT &.4"

1FSNBOFOU0DFDP$1.& 4UBOEJOH
$PNNJUUFPG&VSPQFBO%PDUPST
3VFEF$IBUFBV #SVTTFMT
5FM 
FUIJDT!FNTBFVSPQFPSH

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



,BUIPMJFLF6OJWFSTJUFJU-FVWFO 'BDVMUFJU
EFS(FOFFTLVOEF $FOUSVNWPS#JP
.FEJTDIF&UIJFLFO3FDIU$FOUSFGPS
#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDTBOE-BX
,BQVDJKOFOWPFS -FVWFO
5FM  4FDSFUBSJBBU'BY

IUUQXXXLVMFVWFOBDCFDCNFS
6OJWFSTJU-JCSFEF#SVYFMMFT 'BDVMU
EF1IJMPTPQIJFFU-FUUSFT $FOUSFEF
3FDIFSDIFT*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBJSFTFO
#JPUIJRVF $3*#
 6OJU6-#

$1 BWFOVF'%3PPTFWFMU 
#SVYFMMFT
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXVMCBDCFSFDIJOWFOUBJSF
VOJUFT6-#IUNM
DSJC!VMCBDCF
#0-*7*"

$PNJU/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDBEF#PMJWJB
5FM 
JOU
CJPFUJDB!DPMNFEMQPSH
6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDB#PMJWJBOB4BO
1BCMP $FOUSPEF#JPUJDB
"W(SBM(BMJOEPFTR"W"NSJDB
5FM 'BY

IUUQXXXVDCDCBFEVCP
#3"4*-

$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUSJP4P$BNJMP
"W/B[BS #BJSSP*QJSBOHB41
$FQ 4P1BVMP
5FM 
'BY 

IUUQXXXTDBNJMPCS
SFJUPSJB!TDBNJMPFEVCS
*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDB %FSFDIPT
)VNBOPTZ(OFSP
$BJYB1PTUBM  #SBTMJB%'
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXBOJTPSHCS
*OTUJUVUP0TDBS'SFJSF
3VB5FPEPSP4BNQBJP  #BJSSP
1JOIFJSPT4P1BVMP
$FQ
5FM 






1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

IUUQXXXVTQCSGNNFEMFHJOEFY
IUNM
NMT!JPGGNVTQCS
.JOJTUSJPEB4BEF $PNJTTP/BDJPOBM
EFUJDBFN1FTRVJTB $0/&1

&TQMBOBEBEPT.JOJTUSJPT#M(&E
"OFYP"MB#4MTB#SBTMJB
o%' $FQ
5FM 
5FMFGBY 


DPOFQ!TBVEFHPWCS
1POUJGDJB6OJWFSTJEBEF$BUMJDB 16$

1PSUP"MFHSF 'BDVMEBEFEF.FEJDJOB 
/DMFPEF&TUVEPTFN#JPUJDB
"WFOJEB*QJSBOHB 1PSUP"MFHSF
$FQ
QFEJBUSJB!QVDSTCS
&TDPMB/BDJPOBMEF4BEF1CMJDB
&/41
%FQBSUBNFOUPEF$JODJBT
4PDJBJT /DMFPEFUJDB"QMJDBEBF
#JPUJDB 'JPDSV[
3VB-FPQPMEPEF#VMIFT 
BOEBS TBMB .BOHVJOIPT 3JPEF
+BOFJSP
$FQ
5FM 

SPMBOE!FOTQmPDSV[CS
4PDJFEBEF#SBTJMFJSBEF#JPUJDB
$BJYB1PTUBM#SBTMJB
$FQ
5FM 
'BY


IUUQXXXTCCJPFUJDBPSHCS
TCCJPFUJDB!TCCJPFUJDBPSHCS
6OJWFSTJEBEFEF#SBTMJB$BNQVT
6OJWFSTJUSJP%BSDZ3JCFJSP
$FQ
5FM 
'BY 

CJPFUJDB!VOCCS
6OJWFSTJEBEFEF4P1BVMP 'BDVMEBEF
EF.FEJDJOB '.641
$PNJTTPEF
#JPUJDBEP)PTQJUBMEBT$MOJDBT
*OGPSNBFT 
 


'BY 

DPNJTTBPCJPFUJDB!IDOFUVTQCS

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

6OJWFSTJEBEF&TUBEVBMEF-POESJOB 
)PTQJUBM6OJWFSTJUSJP3FHJPOBMEP
/PSUFEP1BSBO /DMFPEF#JPUJDB
"W3PCFSU,PDL 7JMB0QFSSJB 
-POESJOB
$&1
5FMGBY 

IUUQXXXVFMCSVFMIPNFQUQPSUBM
IUNM
IVSOQ!VFMCS
6OJWFSTJEBEF'FEFSBMEP3JP(SBOEFEP
4VM *OTUJUVUPEF'JMPTPGJBF$JFODJBT
)VNBOBT 6'3(4

$BNQVTEP7BMF"WFOVF#FOUP
(PODBMWFT $BJYB1PTUBM
"HSPOPNJB
1PSUP"MFHSF
5FMFQIPOF 'BY 

IUUQXXXVGSHTCSQQHmM
QQHmMP!JGDIVGSHTCS
6OJWFSTJEBEF'FEFSBMEP3JP(SBOEFEP
4VM )PTQJUBMEF$MOJDBTEF1PSUP"MFHSF 
/DMFP*OUFSJOTUJUVDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB
3VB3BNJSP#BSDFMMPT  TBMBG 
1PSUP"MFHSF
$FQ
IUUQXXXCJPFUJDBVGSHTCS
HPMEJN!PSJPOVGSHTCS
$"/"%

$BOBEJBO#JPFUIJDT4PDJFUZ $#4

DP-ZEJB3JEEFMM $PSSFTQPOEJOH
4FDSFUBSZ
3PDLZ3JEHF#BZ/8 $BMHBSZ 
"MCFSUB5(&
5FM 
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTDB
MNSJEEFMM!TIBXDB
$BOBEJBO$BUIPMJD#JPFUIJDT*OTUJUVUF
*OTUJUVU$BOBEJFO$BUIPMJRVFEF
#JPFUIJRVF
4U.BSZ4USFFU 5PSPOUP 0OUBSJP
.4+
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXVUPSPOUPDBTUNJLFT
CJPFUIJDT
CJPFUIJDTVTND!VUPSPOUPDB



"QOEJDFT

$BOBEJBO*OTUJUVUFTPG)FBMUI3FTFBSDI 
$*)3 *OTUJUVUEFSFDIFSDIFFOTBOUEV
$BOBEB *34$
-BVSJFS"WFOVF8 UI'MPPS 
"EESFTT-PDBUPS"0UUBXB 
0OUBSJP ,"8
5FM
'BY
IUUQXXXDJISJSTDHDDBJOEFYIUNM
JOGP!DJISJSTDHDDB
$MJOJDBM3FTFBSDI*OTUJUVUFPG.POUSFBM 
$FOUFSGPS#JPFUIJDT
1JOF"WFOVF8FTU .POUSFBM 
2VFCFD)83
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXJSDNRDDBCJPFUIJRVF
SPZE!JSDNRDDB
$PNNJTTJPOEFMUIJRVFEFMBTDJFODFFU
EFMBUFDIOPMPHJF
 SPVUFEFM&HMJTF SEnPPS4VJUF
 4BJOUF'PZ 2VFCFD(7;
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXFUIJRVFHPVWRDDB
FUIJRVF!FUIJRVFHPVWRDDB
%F7FCFS*OTUJUVUFGPS#JPFUIJDTBOE
4PDJBM3FTFBSDI
#BUIVSTU4USFFU 4VJUF 
5PSPOUP 0OUBSJP.""
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXEFWFCFSPSH
CJPFUIJDT!EFWFCFSPSH
.D(JMM6OJWFSTJUZ 'BDVMUZPG-BX 
.D(JMM$FOUSFGPS.FEJDJOF &UIJDTBOE
-BX
1FFM4USFFU .POUSFBM 2VFCFD
)"8
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXJJSFCPSH
JOGPMBX!NDHJMMDB
/BUJPOBM$PVODJMPO&UIJDTJO)VNBO
3FTFBSDI /$&)3
-F$POTFJM/BUJPOBM
EUIJRVFFOSFDIFSDIFDIF[MIVNBJO
$/&3)

&DIP%SJWF 0UUBXB 0OUBSJP,4/

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



5FM 'BY 



IUUQODFISDOFSIPSH
PDF!ODFISDOFSIPSH
F)PTQJUBMGPS4JDL$IJMESFO 
%FQBSUNFOUPG#JPFUIJDT
6OJWFSTJUZ"WFOVF 5PSPOUP 
0OUBSJP.(9
5FM 'BY 

NJDIFMJOFDPY!TJDLLJETDB
F3PZBM$PMMFHFPG1IZTJDJBOTBOE
4VSHFPOTPG$BOBEB #JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT
$PNNJUUFF
&DIP%SJWF 0UUBXB 0OUBSJP,4
/
5FM 'BY 

IUUQSDQTDNFEJDBMPSHJOEFY
QIQ QBTT
KIJDLFZ!SDQTDFEV
6OJWFSTJUFEF.POUSFBM $FOUSFEF
SFDIFSDIFFOESPJUQVCMJD *OTUJUVU
*OUFSOBUJPOBMEF3FDIFSDIFFOUIJRVF
#JPNFEJDBMF **3&#

$1 4VDDVSTBMF$FOUSF7JMMF  


DIFNJOEFMB5PVS.POUSFBM 2VFCFD 
)$+
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXJJSFCPSH
DPPSE!JJSFCPSH
6OJWFSTJUEF.POUSFBM 1SPHSBNNFTEF
CJPUIJRVF
$1 TVDDVSTBMF$FOUSFWJMMF 
.POUSFBM 2VFCFD)$+
5FM  
'BY 
IUUQXXXGFTVNPOUSFBMDBCJPFUIJRVF
BOESFFEVQMBOUJF!VNPOUSFBMDBPEFUUF
MBOHMPJT!VNPOUSFBMDB
6OJWFSTJU-BWBM'BDVMUEF1IJMPTPQIJF 
(SPVQFEFSFDIFSDIFFOUIJRVF
.FEJDBMF
#VSFBV 2VFCFD$JUZ 2VFCFD(,
1
5FM  





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

'BY 
IUUQXXXGQVMBWBMDBGQEFGBVMU
BTQ CIDQ
GQ!GQVMBWBMDB
6OJWFSTJUZPG"MCFSUB -BX$FOUSF 
)FBMUI-BX*OTUJUVUF
&ENPOUPO "MCFSUB5()
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXMBXVBMCFSUBDBDFOUSFTIMJ
IMJ!MBXVBMCFSUBDB
6OJWFSTJUZPG"MCFSUB +PIO%PTTFUPS
)FBMUI&UIJDT$FOUSF
6OJWFSTJUZ&YUFOTJPO$FOUSF 
&ENPOUPO "MCFSUB5(5
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXVBMCFSUBDB#*0&5)*$4
%PTTFUPS$FOUSF!VBMCFSUBDB
6OJWFSTJUZPG5PSPOUP
+PJOU$FOUSFGPS#JPFUIJDT
$PMMFHF4USFFU 5PSPOUP 0OUBSJP
.(-
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXVUPSPOUPDBKDCIPNFNBJO
IUN
KDCJOGP!VUPSPOUPDB
$)*-&

1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDBEF$IJMF 
$FOUSPEF#JPUJDB
"W-JCFSUBEPS#0)JHHJOT 4BOUJBHP
5FM
IUUQFTDVFMBNFEQVDDMEFQUPT
#JPFUJDB
CJPFUJDB!NFEQVDDM
6OJWFSTJEBE"MCFSUP)VSUBEP
$FOUSPEFUJDB
"MNJSBOUF#BSSPTP 4BOUJBHP
5FM'BY
IUUQFUJDBVBIVSUBEPDMOVFTUSP@DFOUSP
DPOUFYUPIUN
UNJGTVE!VBIVSUBEPDM
6OJWFSTJEBEEFM%FTBSSPMMP 'BDVMUBEEF
.FEJDJOB $FOUSPEF#JPUJDB

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

"W7JUBDVSB 7JUBDVSB 4BOUJBHP


5FM
IUUQXXXVEEDM
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF 'BDVMUBEEF
.FEJDJOB %FQBSUBNFOUPEF#JPUJDBZ
)VNBOJEBEFT.EJDBT
"WEB*OEFQFOEFODJB/ DVBSUP
QJTP *OEFQFOEFODJB 4BOUJBHP
5FM
IUUQXXXNFEVDIJMFDM
EFQBSUBNFOUPTCJPFUJDB@IVNBOJEBEFT@
NFEJDBTIUNM
EFQUPCJPFUJDB!NFEVDIJMFDM
NCSBWP!NFEVDIJMFDM
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF $FOUSP
*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO
#JPUJDB $*&#

%JBHPOBM1BSBHVBZ 5PSSF PG


 4BOUJBHP
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXVDIJMFDMCJPFUJDB
DCJP!VDIJMFDM
6OJWFSTJEBEEF4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF 
1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDB
"WFOJEB-JCFSUBEPS#FSOBSEP0)JHHJOT
 &TUBDJO$FOUSBM 4BOUJBHP
5FM
IUUQXXXGDNVTBDIDM
JCBSSVFU!VTBDIDM
8PSME)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO 8)0

1BO"NFSJDBO)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO
1")0
1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDB
1SPWJEFODJB 1JTP 4BOUJBHP
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXQBIPCJPFUJDB
CJPFUJDB!DIJPQTPNTPSHMPMBTG!DIJ
PQTPNTPSH
$)*/"

$IJOFTF.FEJDBM"TTPDJBUJPO %JWPG
*OUFSOBUJPOBM.FEJDBM$POWFOUJPOT 
'PSFJHO3FMBUJPOT%FQBSUNFOU
%POHTJ9JEBKJF #FJKJOH 
5FM ==
'BY 
IUUQXXXDIJOBNFEDPNDO
JOGPS!DIJOBNFEDPNDO



"QOEJDFT

6OJWFSTJUZ)FBMUI4DJFODF $FOUFS
%JWJTJPOPG4PDJBM4DJFODFTBOE
)VNBOJUJFT #FJKJOH.FEJDBM6OJWFSTJUZ
1FLJOH %FQBSUNFOUPG.FEJDBM&UIJDT
9VFZVBO3PBE )BJEJBO%JTUSJDU 
#FJKJOH 
IUUQXXXCKNVFEVDOJOEFY
IUN
$0-0.#*"

"DBEFNJB/BDJPOBMEF.FEJDJOBEF
$PMPNCJB *OTUJUVUP$PMPNCJBOPEF
&TUVEJPT#JPFUJDPT *$&#

$SB/P #PHPUB
5FM 
IUUQBONFODPMPNCJBDPNJDFCIUN
JDFC@DPMPNCJB!IPUNBJMDPN
"TPDJBDJO/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB
5SBOTW/RVJOUPQJTP
BOBMCF!IPUNBJMDPN
1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE+BWFSJBOB 
*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDB
5SBOTWFSTBM/P 2VJOUP1JTP 
&EJmDJP+PT3BGBFM"SCPMFEB 

#PHPU
5FM 
&YUFOTJO
IUUQXXXKBWFSJBOBFEVDPCJPFUJDB
CJPFUJDB!KBWFSJBOBFEVDP
6OJWFSTJEBEEFMB4BCBOB $IB
$FOUSP
EF#JPUJDB
CJPUJDB!VOJTBCBOBFEVDP
6OJWFSTJEBE&M#PTRVF *OTUJUVUPEF
#JPUJDB
5SBOTW#JT/ #PHPU
5FM
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBMEF$PMPNCJB 3FE
EF#JPUJDB
&EJmDJP.BOVFM"OD[BS
5FM 
&YU
IUUQXXXVOBMFEVDPCJPFUJDB
SFEC@CPH!VOBMFEVDP
$03&"

4FPOHTBO$FOUFSGPS#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT
JO,PSFB
5FM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTPSLS
TDCF!CJPFUIJDTPSLS
6OJWFSTJUZPG6MTBO $PMMFHFPG
.FEJDJOF %FQUPG.FEJDBM)VNBOJUJFT
BOE4PDJBM4DJFODFT ,PSFBO#JPFUIJDT
"TTPDJBUJPO ,#"

4FPVM
5FM  
'BY 
IUUQXXXLPSFBCJPFUIJDTOFU
FUIJDT!OFUTHPDPN
TPOHTZ!IPUNBJMDPN
$6#"

"DBEFNJBEF$JFODJBTEF$VCB $PNJU
/BDJPOBM$VCBOPEF#JPUJDB
$BQJUPMJP/BDJPOBM 1SBEPZ4BO+PT 
)BCBOB7JFKB -B)BCBOB
QJFESB!DFOJBJJOGDV
%*/"."3$"

%BOJTI$PVODJMPG&UIJDT
3BWOTCPSHHBEF  %,
$PQFOIBHFO
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXFUJTLSBBEELTXBTQ
JOGP!FUJTLSBBEEL
&$6"%03

1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUMJDBEF
&DVBEPS (SVQPEF#JPUJDB
&EJmDJPEFMB'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT
&YBDUBTZ/BUVSBMFT
1JTP"WEF0DUVCSFZ"W1BUSJB 
2VJUP
IUUQXXXQVDFFEVFD
4PDJFEBE&DVBUPSJBOBEF#JPUJDB
IUUQXXXCJPFUJDBPSHFDNPEVMFT
OFXT
&41""

*OTUJUVUP#PSKBEF#JPUJDB
-MBTFSFTD4BOUB3PTB  
&TQMVHVFTEF-MPCSFHBU #BSDFMPOB


5FM 





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

IUUQXXXJCCJPFUJDBPSH
CJPFUJDB!JCCITKECDOPSH
*OUFSOBUJPOBM4PDJFUZPG#JPFUIJDT
4PDJFEBE*OUFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB

1MB[BEFM)VNFEBM &EJG(PUBEF
-FDIF
(JKPO "TUVSJBT
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXTJCJPSH
CJPFUJDB!TJCJPSH
&45"%046/*%04

"NFSJDBO/VSTFT"TTPDJBUJPO $FOUFS
GPS&UIJDTBOE)VNBO3JHIUT
4VJUF8FTU .BSZMBOE"WFOVF 
48 8BTIJOHUPO %JTUSJDUPG$PMVNCJB

5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXOVSTJOHXPSMEPSHFUIJDT
"NFSJDBO4PDJFUZGPS#JPFUIJDTBOE
)VNBOJUJFT "4#)

8FTU-BLF4USFFU (MFOWJFX 
*MMJOPJT
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXBTCIPSH
JOGP!BTCIPSH
"[VTB1BDJmD6OJWFSTJUZ $FOUFSGPS
3FTFBSDIPO&UIJDTBOE7BMVFT
&"MPTUB"WF10#PY 
"[VTB $BMJGPSOJB
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXBQVFEVFEVDBCTDSFW
TUBOGPSE!BQVFEV
#BMM4UBUF6OJWFSTJUZ %FQBSUNFOUPG
#JPMPHZ )VNBO(FOFUJDTBOE#JPFUIJDT
&EVDBUJPOBM-BCPSBUPSZ )("#&-

6OJWFSTJUZ"WF .VODJF *OEJBOB 



5FM 'BY 

+3)FOESJY!#467$#46&EV
$FOUFSGPS#JPFUIJDTBOE$VMUVSF
10#PY 0BLMBOE $BMJGPSOJB


PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

5FM'BY

IUUQXXXUIFDCDPSH
KFOOJGFSMBIM!UIFDCDPSHCBSCBSB
RVJHMFZ!UIFDCDPSH
$FOUFSGPS&UIJDTBOE"EWPDBDZJO
)FBMUIDBSF
8BVLFHBO3PBE10#PY 
5FDIOZ *MMJOPJT
5FM 
IUUQXXXIFBMUIDBSFFUIJDTPSH
$FOUFSGPS#JPFUIJDTBOE)VNBO
%JHOJUZ
)BMG%BZ3PBE #BOOPDLCVSO 
*MMJOPJT
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXDCIEPSH
JOGP!DCIEPSH
$PVODJMGPS3FTQPOTJCMF(FOFUJDT
$3(

6QMBOE3PBE 4VJUF $BNCSJEHF 


.BTTBDIVTFUUT 
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXHFOFXBUDIPSH
DSH!HFOFXBUDIPSH
%F1BVM6OJWFSTJUZ$PMMFHFPG-BX 
)FBMUI-BX*OTUJUVUF
&BTU+BDLTPO#MWE $IJDBHP *- 

5FM 'BY 

NHPPEXJO!EFQBVMFEV
&NPSZ6OJWFSTJUZ $FOUFSGPS&UIJDT
%FOUBM#VJMEJOH$MJGUPO3PBE /& 
"UMBOUB (FPSHJB
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXFUIJDTFNPSZFEV
KGPXMFS!FNPSZFEV +BNFT'PXMFS

LLJOMBX!FNPSZFEV ,BUIMFFO,JOMBX

'MPSJEB#JPFUIJDT/FUXPSL '#/

10#PY .
.JBNJ 
'MPSJEB 



"QOEJDFT

5FM  


IUUQXXXNJBNJFEVFUIJDTGCO
GCO!DIGNVnFEVFUIJDT!NJBNJFEV
(FPSHFUPXO6OJWFSTJUZ ,FOOFEZ
*OTUJUVUFPG&UIJDT
#PY 8BTIJOHUPO %JTUSJDUPG
$PMVNCJB 
5FM 'BY 

IUUQLFOOFEZJOTUJUVUFHFPSHFUPXO
FEVJOEFYIUN
LJDPVSTF!HFPSHFUPXOFEV
(FPSHFUPXO6OJWFSTJUZ .FEJDBM$FOUFS 
$FOUFSGPS$MJOJDBM#JPFUIJDT
3PPN#VJMEJOH%3FTFSWPJS
3E /8 8BTIJOHUPO %JTUSJDUPG
$PMVNCJB
5FM 'BY 

IUUQDMJOJDBMCJPFUIJDTHFPSHFUPXOFEV
QBUDIFMN!HFPSHFUPXOFEV
)BSWBSE6OJWFSTJUZ.FEJDBM4DIPPM 
%JWJTJPOPG.FEJDBM&UIJDT
)VOUJOHUPO"WFOVF #PTUPO 
.BTTBDIVTFUUT 
5FM 
'"9 
%.&!INTIBSWBSEFEV
+PIOT)PQLJOT6OJWFSTJUZ 1IPFCF3
#FSNBO#JPFUIJDT*OTUJUVUF
#SPBEXBZ)BNQUPO)PVTF 
#BMUJNPSF .BSZMBOE 
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXIPQLJOTNFEJDJOFPSH
CJPFUIJDT
CJPFUIJDT!KITQIFEV
-PZPMB.BSZNPVOU6OJWFSTJUZ #JPFUIJDT
*OTUJUVUF
6OJWFSTJUZ)BMM0OF-.6%SJWF 4VJUF
 -PT"OHFMFT $BMJGPSOJB
5FM  
'BY 
KXBMUFS!MNVFEV

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



.JDIJHBO4UBUF6OJWFSTJUZ %FQBSUNFOU
PG1IJMPTPQIZ *OUFSOBUJPOBM/FUXPSL
PO'FNJOJTU"QQSPBDIFTUP#JPFUIJDT
DP)JMEF/FMTPO4PVUI,FE[JF)BMM 
-BOTJOH .JDIJHBO
5FM 
IMOFMTPO!NTVFEV
/BUJPOBM*OTUJUVUFTPG)FBMUI 
%FQBSUNFOUPG$MJOJDBM#JPFUIJDT
$FOUFS%SJWF #MEH 3PPN
$ #FUIFTEB .BSZMBOE 

5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTOJIHPW
CJPFUIJDT!OJIHPW
/FX:PSL.FEJDBM$PMMFHF #JPFUIJDT
*OTUJUVUFPG/FX:PSL.FEJDBM$PMMFHF
"ENJOJTUSBUJPO#VJMEJOH 7BMIBMMB 
/FX:PSL
5FM 
IUUQXXXOZNDFEV')1JOTUJUVUFT
#JPFUIJDTNJTTJPOBTQ
1BDJmD4DIPPMPG3FMJHJPO 1SPHSBNJO
#JPFUIJDT
4DFOJD"WFOVF #FSLFMFZ 
$BMJGPSOJB 
5FM  

IUUQXXXQTSFEV
QTSJOGP!QTSFEV
1SFTJEFOUT$PVODJMPO#JPFUIJDT
1FOOTZMWBOJB"WFOVF /8 4VJUF
 8BTIJOHUPO %JDUSJDUPG$PMVNCJB

5FM 
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTHPW
JOGP!CJPFUIJDTHPW
4UBOGPSE6OJWFSTJUZ $FOUFSGPS
#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT
8FMDI3PBE #VJMEJOH" 4VJUF
 1BMP"MUP $BMJGPSOJB 
5FM 'BY 

IUUQTDCFTUBOGPSEFEV
4$#&JOGP!NFETUBOGPSEFEV





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

5IF)BTUJOHT$FOUFS
3PVUF% .BMDPMN(PSEPO3E 
(BSSJTPO /FX:PSL 
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXUIFIBTUJOHTDFOUFSPSH
NBJM!UIFIBTUJOHTDFOUFSPSH
5IF)BTUJOHT$FOUFS 8FTUFSO0GGJDF
)PMZPLF4USFFU 4BO'SBODJTDP 
$BMJGPSOJB 
5FM 
IUUQXXXUIFIBTUJOHTDFOUFSPSH
NBJM!UIFIBTUJOHTDFOUFSPSH
6OJWFSTJUZPG$POOFDUJDVU 4DIPPMPG
.FEJDJOF %FQBSUNFOUPG$PNNVOJUZ
.FEJDJOFBOE)FBMUI$BSF %JWJTJPOPG
.FEJDBM)VNBOJUJFT )FBMUI-BXBOE
&UIJDT
'BSNJOHUPO"WFOVF .$ 
'BSNJOHUPO $POOFDUJDVU 
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXDPNNFEVDIDFEV
NFEJDBMIVNBOJUJFT
EQTNJUI!OTPVDIDFEV
6OJWFSTJUZPG'MPSJEB $PMMFHFPG
.FEJDJOF %FQBSUNFOUPG$PNNVOJUZ
)FBMUIBOE
'BNJMZ.FEJDJOF 1SPHSBNJO#JPFUIJDT 
-BXBOE.FEJDBM1SPGFTTJPOBMJTN
1#-.1

10#PY (BJOFTWJMMF 'MPSJEB 



5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXDIGNVnFEVQSPHSBNT
CMNQ
6OJWFSTJUZPG.JBNJ #JPFUIJDT1SPHSBN
10#PY .
.JBNJ 
'MPSJEB
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXNJBNJFEVFUIJDT
CJPFUIJDT@QSPHSBNIUN
FUIJDT!NJBNJFEV
6OJWFSTJUZPG4PVUI'MPSJEB $PMMFHF
PG.FEJDJOF %FQBSUNFOUPG*OUFSOBM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

.FEJDJOF %JWJTJPOPG.FEJDBM&UIJDT
BOE)VNBOJUJFT
.%$#PY#SVDF#%PXOT
#PVMFWBSE5BNQB 'MPSJEB 
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXNFEVTGFEV*/5.&%
FUIJDT
SPXBMLFS!DPNNFEVTGFEV
6OJWFSTJUZPG4PVUI'MPSJEB $PMMFHF
PG.FEJDJOF %FQBSUNFOUPG*OUFSOBM
.FEJDJOF 1SPHSBNJO#JPFUIJDTBOE
.FEJDBM)VNBOJUJFT
.%$#PY#SVDF#%PXOT 
#PVMFWBSE5BNQB 'MPSJEB 
5FM 
IUUQITDVTGFEVNFEJDJOF
JOUFSOBMNFEJDJOFCJPFUIJDT
L[BIO!ITDVTGFEV
64%FQBSUNFOUPG&OFSHZ0DFPG
4DJFODF &UIJDBM -FHBM BOE4PDJBM*TTVFT
*OEFQFOEFODF"WFOVF 48 
8BTIJOHUPO %JTUSJDUPG$PMVNCJB

5VTLFHFF6OJWFSTJUZ /BUJPOBM$FOUFS
GPS#JPFUIJDTJO3FTFBSDIBOE)FBMUI
$BSF
%SFX)BMM3PPN 5VTLFHFF 
"MBCBNB
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXUVTLFHFFFEV(MPCBM
DBUFHPSZBTQ
CJPFUIJDT!UVTLFHFFFEV
64%FQBSUNFOUPG)FBMUIBOE)VNBO
4FSWJDFT 0GGJDFGPS)VNBO3FTFBSDI
1SPUFDUJPOT
*OEFQFOEFODF"WFOVF 48 
8BTIJOHUPO%$ 
5FM
IUUQXXXIITHPWPISQ
8PSME)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO 8)0

1BO"NFSJDBO)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO
1")0
1BO"NFSJDBO4BOJUBSZ
#VSFBV%JWJTJPOPG)FBMUIBOE)VNBO
%FWFMPQNFOU1SPHSBNPO#JPFUIJDT
5XFOUZUIJSE4USFFU /8 



"QOEJDFT

8BTIJOHUPO %JTUSJDUPG$PMVNCJB 

5FM'BY
IUUQXXXQBIPPSH
XFCNBTUFS!QBIPPSH
'*-*1*/"4

%FQBSUNFOUPG4DJFODFBOE5FDIOPMPHZ 
1IJMJQQJOF$PVODJMGPS)FBMUI3FTFBSDI
BOE%FWFMPQNFOU 1$)3%

'%045.BJO#MEH %045
$PNQPVOE (FO4BOUPT"WF #JDVUBO 
5BHJH .FUSP.BOJMB
5FM%- 
UP'BY
5- 
MPDBMUP

IUUQXXXQDISEEPTUHPWQI
OFXQDISE
JOGP!QDISEEPTUHPWQI
6OJWFSTJUZPGUIF1IJMJQQJOFT #JPFUIJDT
5SBJOJOH1SPKFDU $VSSJDVMVN
%FWFMPQNFOUBOE*OUFOTJWF5SBJOJOHJO
3FTFBSDI&UIJDT
OE'MPPS#FOUPO)BMM10#PY 
%JMJNBO 2VF[PO$JUZ
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTUSBJOJOHPSH
DPOUBDU!CJPFUIJDTUSBJOJOHPSH
CJPFUIJDTUSBJOJOH!LTTQVQEFEVQI
'*/-"/%*"

'JOOJTI/BUJPOBM1VCMJD)FBMUI
*OTUJUVUF /BUJPOBM"EWJTPSZ#PBSE
GPS#JPUFDIOPMPHZ #JPUFLOJJLBO
/FVWPUUFMVLVOUB
.BOOFSIFJNJOUJF '*/ 
)FMTJOTLJ
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXCJPUFLOJJLBOOFVWPUUFMVLVO
UBm
TJIUFFSJ!CJPUFLOJJLBOOFVWPUUFMVLVOUBm
/PSEJD$PNNJUUFFPO#JPFUIJDT
/PSEJTL,PNNJUFGPS#JPFUJL
DP4FDSFUBSZ)FMFOBWPO5SPJM3JLIBSE 
/ZNBOTWBH#  )FMTJOHGPST
5FM 'BY 


PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



IUUQXXXODCJPPSH
TFDSFUBSZ!ODCJPPSH
4FDSFUBSZ(FOFSBM4BMMB-PUKPOFO 
/BUJPOBM"EWJTPSZ#PBSEPO
3FTFBSDI&UIJDT 5VULJNVTFFUUJOFO
/FVWPUUFMVLVOUB
.BSJBOLBUV '*/ )FMTJOLJ
5FM 'BY 

IUUQQSPUTWmUFOL
TBMMBMPUKPOFO!UTWm
'3"/$*"

$PVODJMPG&VSPQF 4UFFSJOH$PNNJUUFF
PO#JPFUIJDT$PNJUF
%JSFDUFVSEF#JPFUIJRVF $%#*

1JFDF  4USBTCPVSH$FEFY


5FM 
IUUQXXXDPFJOU
DBSMPTEFTPMB!DPFJOU
*OTUJUVU/BUJPOBMEFMB4BOUFUEFMB
3FDIFSDIF.FEJDBMF */4&3.
$FOUSF
EF%PDVNFOUBUJPOFOUIJRVFEFT
4DJFODFTEFMB7JFFUEFMB4BOU
SVF4BJOU%PNJOJRVF 1BSJT
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXDDOFFUIJRVFGSGSBODBJT
IUNQSFTFOUIUN
DEFJ!LCJOTFSNGS
*OTUJUVU/BUJPOBMEFMB4BOUFUEFMB
3FDIFSDIF.FEJDBMF */4&3.
$PNJU
$POTVMUBUJG/BUJPOBMEUIJRVFQPVSMFT
4DJFODFTEFMB7JFFUEFMB4BOU
 SVF4BJOU%PNJOJRVF 1BSJT
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXDDOFFUIJRVFGS
DPOUBDU!DPNJUFFUIJRVFGS
6OJUFE/BUJPOT&EVDBUJPOBM 4DJFOUJmD
BOE$VMUVSBM0SHBOJ[BUJPO 6/&4$0

*OUFSOBUJPOBM#JPFUIJDT$PNNJUUFF
 1MBDFEF'POUFOPZ 1BSJT
5FM 'BY 






1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

(3&$*"

/BUJPOBM#JPFUIJDT$PNNJTTJPO
&WFMQJEPO  "UIFOT
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTHS
TFDSFUBSJBU!CJPFUIJDT
HS57JEBMJT!CJPFUIJDTHS
,.BOPMBLPV!CJPFUIJDTHS
)6/(3"

$FOUSBMBOE&BTU&VSPQFBO"TTPDJBUJPO
PG#JPFUIJDT $&&"#

1FDT #VEBJ/BHZ"V 


5FM 
'BY 


$IFMB!NBJMNBUBWIV
*/%*"

"MM*OEJB"TTPDJBUJPOPG#JPFUIJDT
"*#"

/P UI-BOF UI$SPTT4USFFU *OEJSB


/BHBS $IFOOBJ 
'BY 
KB[BSJBI!VOJNBEFSOFUJO
'PSVNGPS.FEJDBM&UIJDT4PDJFUZ
1SBCIV%BSTIBO  44BJOJL
/BHBS "NCPMJ "OEIFSJ 8
.VNCBJ 

5FM 
*OEJBO$PVODJMPG.FEJDBM3FTFBSDI
*$.3

73BNBMJOHBTXBNJ#IBXBO "OTBSJ
/BHBS 10#PY/ /FX%FMIJ 

5FM  
  
'BY
IUUQJDNSOJDJO
JDNSIRET!TBOTBEOJDJO
4U1JVT9$PMMFHF *OUFSOBUJPOBM
'FEFSBUJPOPG$BUIPMJD.FEJDBM
"TTPDJBUJPOT '*".$
#JP.FEJDBM
&UIJDT$FOUSF
"BSFZ3PBE (PSFHBPO&BTU .VNCBJ 

5FM  

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

IUUQNFNCFSTSFEJDPNGCNFD
GCNFDCJP!CPNWTOMOFUJO
*3-"/%"

*SJTI$PVODJMGPS#JPFUIJDT$PNIBJSMF
#JUIFJUJDFOBI&JSFBOO
"DBEFNZ)PVTF%BXTPO4USFFU 
%VCMJO
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTJF
JOGP!CJPFUIJDTJF
*43"&-

#FO(VSJPO6OJWFSTJUZ /FHFW'BDVMUZ
PG)FBMUI4DJFODFT -PSE*NNBOVFM
+BDPLPWJUT$FOUFSPG+FXJTI.FEJDBM
&UIJDT
1PTU0DF#PY #FFS4IFWB 
5FM
HTIJNPO!CHVNBJMCHVBDJM
%S'BML4DIMFTJOHFS*OTUJUVUFGPS
.FEJDBM)BMBDIJD3FTFBSDI
4IBBSF;FEFL.FEJDBM$FOUFS +FSVTBMFN 
 #BZJU4USFFU 10#PY
+FSVTBMFN
5FM'BY

IUUQXXXNFEFUIJDTPSHJM
JOGP!NFEFUIJDTPSHJM
*TSBFM"DBEFNZPG4DJFODFTBOE
)VNBOJUJFT #JPFUIJDT"EWJTPSZ
$PNNJUUFF
DP%FQBSUNFOUPG4DJFODF5FBDIJOH 
F8FJ[NBOO*OTUJUVUFPG4DJFODF
3FIPWPU
5FM'BY

IUUQXXXBDBEFNZBDJMCJPFUIJDT
IFCSFXJOEFYIUNM
JMBOBIPQGFME!XFJ[NBOOBDJM
6OJWFSTJUZPG)BJGB 'BDVMUZPG-BX 
*OUFSOBUJPOBM$FOUFSGPS)FBMUI-BX
BOE&UIJDT
10#*#.#VJMEJOH 0DFT/PT
 )B$BSNFM.PVOUBJO 
5FM 'BY 




"QOEJDFT

IUUQNFEMBXIBJGBBDJM
TJFHBM!SFTFBSDIIBJGBBDJM %S(JM4JFHBM

6OJWFSTJUZPGUIF/FHFW 'BDVMUZPG
)FBMUI4DJFODFT#FO(VSJPO $FOUFSGPS
"TJBOBOE*OUFSOBUJPOBM#JPFUIJDT
#FFS4IFWB
5FM
ZFSVIBN!CHVNBJMCHVBDJM
8PSME"TTPDJBUJPOGPS.FEJDBM-BX
4UFJS(SPVQ-UE)BZFU[JSB4USFFU 
3BNBU(BO 
5FM 
'BY  

IUUQXBNMIBJGBBDJM
XBNM!SFTFBSDIIBJGBBDJM
*5"-*"

$PNJUBUP/B[JPOBMFQFSMB#JPFUJDB
7JB7FOFUP  3PNF
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXQBMB[[PDIJHJJUCJPFUJDB
DOCJPFUJDB!QBMB[[PDIJHJJU
$POTJHMJP/B[JPOBMFEFMMF3JDFSDIF
1JB[[BMF"MEP.PSP 3PNB
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXDOSJUTJUPDOSIPNFIUNM
VSQ!VSQDOSJU
'BDPMUB5FPMPHJDBEJ4JDJMJB *OTUJUVUP
4JDJMJBOPEJ#JPFUJDB
1JB[[B4%PNFOJDP "DJSFBMF
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXHUFJUJTC
TBMQSJJTC!NBJMHUFJU
'POEB[JPOF-BO[B
7JB%BOUF  1BEPWB 
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXGPOEB[JPOFMBO[BJU
JOGP!GPOEB[JPOFMBO[BJU

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



/BUJPOBM#JPFUIJDT$PNNJUUFF
$PNJUBUP/B[UJPOBMF*UBMJBOPEJ
#JPFUJDB
7JB7FOFUP   3PNB
5FM'BY

DOCJPFUJDB!QBMB[[PDIJHJJU
+"1/

"TJBO#JPFUIJDT"TTPDJBUJPO "#"

,VEBO.JOBNJ $IJZPEBLV 
5PLZP
5FM 'BY 

TBLBNPUP!DITOJIPOVBDKQ
+BQBOFTF"TTPDJBUJPOGPS1IJMPTPQIJDBM
BOE&UIJDBM3FTFBSDIJO.FEJDJOF
DP,ZPJDIJ0;",*4BJUBNB(BLVFO
6OJWFSTJUZ
,JTPSP ,BXBHVDIJTIJ
IUUQQMB[BVNJOBDKQ_QFNFEJOEFY@
FOHIUNM
LP[BLJ!TBJHBLVBDKQ
6OJWFSTJUZPG5TVLVCB *OTUJUVUFPG
#JPMPHJDBM4DJFODFT &VCJPT&UIJDT
*OTUJUVUF
10#PY 5TVLVCB4DJFODF$JUZ 
*CBSBLJ
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXVOFTDPCLLPSHFVCJPT
NBDFS!TBLVSBDDUTVLVCBBDKQ
8BTFEB6OJWFSTJUZ"EWBODFE3FTFBSDI 
$FOUFSGPS)VNBO4DJFODFT #JPFUIJDT
3FTFBSDI1SPKFDU
 /JTIJXBTFEB4IJOKVLZLV 5PLZP 

5FM  FYU
'BY 
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTKQ
SJIJUP!XBTFEBKQJOGP!CJPFUIJDTKQ
-*56"/*"

-JUIVBOJBO#JPFUIJDT$PNNJUUFF
-JFUVWPT#JPFUJLPT,PNJUFUBT
7JMOJBVTH 7JMOJVT
5FM 'BY 
MCFL!TBNMU





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

."-5"

%FQBSUNFOUPG)FBMUI #JPFUIJDT
$POTVMUBUJWF$PNNJUUFF
 .FSDIBOUT4USFFU 7BMMFUUB
5FM'BY
NDBV!VNFEVNU
.9*$0

"DBEFNJB/BDJPOBM.FYJDBOBEF
#JPUJDB "$
"OUJHVP$MBVTUSPEFM)PTQJUBM+VSF[
1"1MB[B4BO1BCMP$FOUSP.YJDP
%' 
5FMT 
 


WTVBSF[!TFSWJEPSVOBNNY
"TPDJBDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEF#JPUJDB 4$
"QBSUBEP1PTUBM .YJDP%' 
$1
IUUQXXXBOBIVBDNYBQBCFJOEFY
IUN
FIBNJMM!BOBIVBDNY
$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPTF*OWFTUJHBDJOFO
#JPUJDB $&*#

"W&TQBB$PM.PEFSOB 
(VBEBMBKBSB 0/(+BMJTDP 
5FM 
 

DFJO!JOGPTFMOFUNY
$PMFHJPEF#JPUJDBEF/VFWP-FO
5FM 

IUUQXXXCJPFUJDBDPNNYJOEFY
QIQ *UFNJE
OFMMZDBSMPT!CJPFUJDBDPNNY
$PNJTJO.FYJDBOBEF%FSFDIPT
)VNBOPT
5FIVBOUFQFD $PM3PNB4VS 
%FMFHBDJO$VBVIUNPD
5FMrr
'BY
IUUQXXXMBOFUBBQDPSHDNEQEI
EJSFDDJPO!DNEQEIPSH
$0/"4*%"
$PNFSDJPZ"ENJOJTUSBDJO/ $PM
$PQJMDP 6OJWFSTJEBE$JVEBEEF.YJDP 
0USB%FQFOEFODJB(VCFSOBNFOUBM%'

5FM 
 


PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

'BDVMUBE.FYJDBOBEF.FEJDJOB 
"DBEFNJB.FYJDBOBEF#JPUJDB "$
Z"W4BO'FSOBOEP 5MBMQBO
'-"$&*4 -BUJO"NFSJDBO'PSVNPG
&UIJDT$PNNJUUFFTJO)FBMUI3FTFBSDI

5FMGBY 


IUUQXXXnBDFJTPSH
6OJWFSTJEBE"OBIVBD 'BDVMUBEEF#JPUJDB
"W-PNBT"OIVBDTO-PNBT
"OIVBD .YJDP $1
5FM 
 &YU
IUUQXXXBOBIVBDNYCJPFUJDB
PKNBSUJO!BOBIVBDNY
6OJWFSTJEBEEF(VBOBKVBUP $FOUSPEF
*OWFTUJHBDJPOFTFO#JPUJDB
EF&OFSP $PMPOJB0CSFHO 
(VBOBKVBUP *OTUJUVDJO&EVDBUJWB
-FO

5FM 
 

/6&7";&-"/%"

.JOJTUSZPG)FBMUI /BUJPOBM&UIJDT
$PNNJUUFFPO"TTJTUFE)VNBO
3FQSPEVDUJPO /&$")3

.PMFTXPSUI4U10#PY 
8FMMJOHUPO
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXOFXIFBMUIHPWUO[OFDBIS
IUN
6OJWFSTJUZPG0UBHP #JPFUIJDT3FTFBSDI
$FOUSF
10#PY %VOFEJO
5FM 'BY 

IUUQCJPFUIJDTPUBHPBDO[
CJPFUIJDT!PUBHPBDO[
/036&("

#JPUFDLOPMPHJOFNOEB /PSXFHJBO
#JPUFDIOPMPHZ"EWJTPSZ#PBSE

1SJOTFOTHU #PLT4FOUSVN 
 0TMP
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXCJPOOP
CJPUFLOPMPHJOFNOEB!CJPOOP



"QOEJDFT

/BUJPOBM$PNNJUUFFGPS.FEJDBM
3FTFBSDI&UIJDT /&. /BUJPOBM
$PNNJUUFFTGPS3FTFBSDI&UIJDT
1SJOTFOTHBUF10#PY4FOUSVN 
/ 0TMP
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXFUJLLPNOP&OHFMTL/&.
QPTU!FUJLLPNOPLOVUSVZUFS!FUJLLPN
OP
/BUJPOBM$PNNJUUFFGPS3FTFBSDI&UIJDT
JO4DJFODFBOE5FDIOPMPHZ /&/5 
/BUJPOBM$PNNJUUFFTGPS3FTFBSDI&UIJDT
1SJOTFOTHBUF10#PY 4FOUSVN 
/ 0TMP
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXFUJLLPNOP&OHFMTL/&/5
QPTU!FUJLLPNOPNBUUIJBT
LBJTFS!FUJLLPNOP
/BUJPOBM$PNNJUUFFGPS3FTFBSDI
&UIJDTJOUIF4PDJBM4DJFODFTBOE
UIF)VNBOJUJFT /&4) /BUJPOBM
$PNNJUUFFTGPS3FTFBSDI&UIJDT
1SJOTFOTHBUF10#PY 4FOUSVN 
/0TMP
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXFUJLLPNOP&OHFMTL/&4)
&NBJMQPTU!FUJLLPNOPIJMEF
OBHFMM!FUJLLPNOP
/PSXFHJBO#JPUFDIOPMPHZ"EWJTPSZ
#PBSE#JPUFLOPMPHJOFNOEB
1SJOTFOTHU #PLT 4FOUSVN 
0TMP
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXCJPOOP
CJPUFLOPMPHJOFNOEB!CJPOOP
6OJWFSTJUZPG0TMP 4FOUFSGPS.FEJTJOTL
&UJLL $FOUFSGPS.FEJDBM&UIJDT

1PTUCPLT#MJOEFSO  0TMP


5FM'BY
IUUQXXXNFEVJPOPJBTBNTNF
KITPMCBLL!NFEFUJLLVJPOP
1"4&4#"+04

$FOUSVNWPPS.FEJTDIF&UIJFL $FOUSF
GPS.FEJDBM&UIJDT
1SPG%S("

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



-JOEFCPPN*OTUJUVU
1PTUCVT 10#PY
/-
#&&EF
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXMJOEFCPPNJOTUJUVVUOM
MJOEJOTU!DIFOM
&VSPQFBO"TTPDJBUJPOPG$FOUSFTPG
.FEJDBM&UIJDT &"$.&
"TTPDJBUJPO
&VSPQFOOFEFT$FOUSFTEUIJRVF
.FEJDBMF
DP.ST"OHFMJRVF)FJKOFO *OTUJUVVU
WPPS
(F[POEIFJETFUIJFL
10#PY .%.BBTUSJDIU
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXFBDNFXFCDPN
TFDSFUBSJBBUJHF!JHFVOJNBBTOM
)FBMUI$PVODJM 4UBOEJOH$PNNJUUFF
PO.FEJDBM&UIJDTBOE)FBMUI-BX
10#PY ##F)BHVF
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXHSOM
XKEPOEPSQ!HSOM %S8+%POEPSQ

*OUFSOBUJPOBM"TTPDJBUJPOPG#JPFUIJDT
*"#

6USFDIU6OJWFSTJUZ $FOUSFGPS#JPFUIJDT
BOE)FBMUI-BX
)FJEFMCFSHMBBO $4 6USFDIU
5FM 'BY 

*"#!UIFPVVOMNNPMFOLBNQ!UIFP
VVOM
6OJWFSTJUZ.FEJDBM$FOUSF/JKNFHFO 
%FQBSUNFOUPG&UIJDT 1IJMPTPQIZ BOE
)JTUPSZPG.FEJDJOF
10#PY &'(
)#
/JKNFHFO )#
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXVNDOOMTDJFOUJTU
TFDSFUBSJBBU!FGHVNDOOM
6USFDIU6OJWFSTJUZ $FOUSVNWPPS#JP
&UIJFLFO(F[POEIFJETSFDIU $FOUFSGPS
#JP&UIJDTBOE)FBMUI-BX





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

)FJEFMCFSHMBBO 1PTUCVT /-


 $46USFDIU
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXFUIJDTVVOM
DCH!UIFPVVOM
1"/".

'FEFSBDJO-BUJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM
$BSJCFEF*OTUJUVDJPOFTEF#JPUJDB
'&-"*#&

1JTP 0mDJOB
5FM 
 5FMFGBY


IUUQXXXGFMBJCFPSH
'&-"*#&!DXQBOBNBOFU
1&3

*OTUJUVUPEF.FEJDJOB-FHBMi-FPOJEBT
"WFOEBP6SFUBw
%JSFDDJO&TRVJOBEF"W3BZNPOEJ
DPO"W1BTFPEFMB3FQCMJDBTJO/ -B
7JDUPSJB -JNB
5FM'BY
IUUQXXXNQGOHPCQFJNM
EFDMJG!ZBIPPFT
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBM.BZPSEF4BO
.BSDPT 'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOB $PNJU
EFUJDBFO*OWFTUJHBDJO
"W(SBV-JNB
5FM"Y
QFSBMFTBMCFSUP!UFSSBDPNQF
6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJPOBM.BZPSEF4BO
.BSDPT 'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOB *OTUJUVUP
EFUJDBFO4BMVE
"W(SBV-JNB
5FM"Y
QFSBMFTBMCFSUP!UFSSBDPNQF
6OJWFSTJEBE1FSVBOB$BZFUBOP)FSFEJB 
'BDVMUBEEF.FEJDJOB 6OJEBEEF
#JPUJDB
"W)POPSJP%FMHBEP 6SC
*OHFOJFSB 4.1-JNB 1FS
5FM 
 BOFYP
IUUQXXXVQDIFEVQFGBNFEBDFSDB
QSFTFOUBDJPOBTQ
!VQDIFEVQF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

10356("-

$POTFMIP/BDJPOBMEF&UJDBQBSBBT
$JFODJBTEB7JEB /BUJPOBM&UIJDBM
$PVODJMGPSUIF-JGF4DJFODFT

3VB1SPGFTTPS(PNFT 5FJYFJSB / 


-JTCPB
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXDOFDWHPWQU$/&$7
4JUF&OUSZ
DOFDW!THQDNHPWQU
3&*/06/*%0

#SJUJTI.FEJDBM"TTPDJBUJPO .FEJDBM
&UIJDT$PNNJUUFF
#.")PVTF 5BWJTUPDL4RVBSF -POEPO 
8$)+1
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXCNBPSHVLBQOTG
$POUFOU@@)VC FUIJDT
JOGPXFC!CNBPSHVL
$FOUSBM0GGJDFGPS3FTFBSDI&UIJDT
$PNNJUUFFT $03&$

3PPN ##MPDL&BTUCPVSOF
5FSSBDF -POEPO 823
5FM'BY

IUUQXXXDPSFDPSHVL
RVFSJFT!DPSFDPSHVL
$FOUSFGPS#JPFUIJDTBOE1VCMJD1PMJDZ
$#11

3PNOFZ4USFFU -POEPO 4813'


5FM
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTBDVL
mPOBHSFHTPO!CJPFUIJDTBDVL
$&3&4 $POTVNFSTGPS&UIJDTJO
3FTFBSDI
10#PY -POEPO /#8
5FM 
IUUQXXXDFSFTPSHVL
JOGP!DFSFTPSHVL
$ISJTUJBO.FEJDBM'FMMPXTIJQ $.'

1BSUOFSTIJQ)PVTF8BUFSMPP3PBE 
-POEPO 4&9/
5FM 'BY 




"QOEJDFT

IUUQXXXDNGPSHVL
BENJO!DNGPSHVLJOGP!DNGPSHVL
)VNBO'FSUJMJTBUJPOBOE&NCSZPMPHZ
"VUIPSJUZ )'&"

1BYUPO)PVTF"SUJMMFSZ-BOF 
-POEPO &-4
5FM'BY

IUUQXXXIGFBHPWVL)PNF
BENJO!IGFBHPWVL
,JOHT$PMMFHF-POEPO ,$-
$FOUSFPG
.FEJDBM-BXBOE&UIJDT
4USBOE -POEPO 8$3-4
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXLDMBDVLEFQTUBMBX
SFTFBSDIDNMF
DNMFFOH!LDMBDVL
-BODBTUFS6OJWFSTJUZ 'VSOFTT$PMMFHF 
*OTUJUVUFGPS&OWJSPONFOU 1IJMPTPQIZ
BOE1VCMJD1PMJDZ *&111

-BODBTUFS -":(
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXMBODTBDVLGTTJFQQQJOEFY
IUN
KQFBSDZ!MBODBTUFSBDVL
DEVOEBT!MBODBTUFSBDVL
OQBSLFS!MBODBTUFSBDVL
-JOBDSF$FOUSFGPS)FBMUI$BSF&UIJDT
(SPWF&OE3PBE4U+PIOT8PPE 
-POEPO /8/)
5FM  

IUUQXXXMJOBDSFPSH
BENJO!MJOBDSFPSHEJSFDUPS!MJOBDSFPSH
/VGGJFME$PVODJMPO#JPFUIJDT
#FEGPSE4RVBSF -POEPO 8$#+4
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXOVFMECJPFUIJDTPSH
CJPFUIJDT!OVFMEGPVOEBUJPOPSH
4FDSFUBSJBU%FQBSUNFOUPG)FBMUI 6, 
9FOPUSBOTQMBOUBUJPO*OUFSJN3FHVMBUPSZ
"VUIPSJUZ 6,9*3"

3PPN 8FMMJOHUPO)PVTF 
8BUFSMPP3PBE -POEPO 4&6(

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



5FM'BY

EINBJM!EPIHTJHPWVL .BLFJUDMFBS
UIBUNFTTBHFJTGPS6,9*3"

6OJWFSTJUZPG-JWFSQPPM -JWFSQPPM-BX
4DIPPM *OTUJUVUFPG.FEJDJOF -BX BOE
#JPFUIJDT *.-"#

-JWFSQPPM -;4
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXMJWBDVLMBXVOJUTJNMBCIUN
MBX!MJWFSQPPMBDVL
6OJWFSTJUZPG.BODIFTUFS $FOUSFGPS
4PDJBM&UIJDTBOE1PMJDZ
0YGPSE3PBE .BODIFTUFS .15FM 
IUUQXXXMBXNBODIFTUFSBDVL
SFTFBSDIDTFQIUN
HFNNBHSJNTIBX!NBOBDVL
6OJWFSTJUZPG0YGPSE *OTUJUVUFPG)FBMUI
4DJFODFT 0YGPSE$FOUSFGPS&UIJDTBOE
$PNNVOJDBUJPOJO)FBMUI$BSF1SBDUJDF
F&UIPY$FOUSF

0ME3PBE 0YGPSE 09-'


5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXFUIPYPSHVL
BENJO!FUIPYPYBDVL
4*/("163

#JPFUIJDT"EWJTPSZ$PNNJUUFF #"$

#JPQPMJT8BZ $FOUSPT 


'BY
IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTTJOHBQPSFPSH
DPOUBDUVT!CJPFUIJDTTJOHBQPSFPSH
.JOJTUSZPG)FBMUI $PMMFHFPG.FEJDJOF 
/BUJPOBM.FEJDBM&UIJDT$PNNJUUFF
/.&$

#VJMEJOH$PMMFHF 3PBE 


5FM'BY
1SFEFFCIB@,BOOBO!NPIHPWTH %S
1SFEFFCIB,BOOBO

46%'3*$"

.FEJDBM3FTFBSDI$PVODJMPG4PVUI
"GSJDB
10#PY 5ZHFSCFSH





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

5FM 'BY 



IUUQXXXNSDBD[BFUIJDT
FUIJDTIVNBOIUN
JOGP!NSDBD[B

4UPDLIPMN
5FM'BY

IUUQXXXHFOUFLOJLTF
HFOUFLOJL!HFOUFLOJLTF

6OJWFSTJUZPG$BQFUPXO %FQBSUNFOUPG
.FEJDJOF #JPFUIJDT$FOUSF
+'MPPS 0ME.BJO#VJMEJOH (SPPUF
4DIVVS)PTQJUBM $BQF5PXO
0CTFSWBUPSZ 
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXFCVDUBD[BEFQUTNFEJDJOF
NBJOCJPFUIJDTIUN
DEFLPLFS!VDUHTIVDUBD[B

4XFEJTI/BUJPOBM$PVODJMPO.FEJDBM
&UIJDT 4.&3
4UBUFOT.FEJDJOTL
&UJTLB3BE.JOJTUSZPG)FBMUIBOE4PDJBM
"BJST
4& 4UPDLIPMN
5FM
IUUQXXXTNFSHPWTF
BOODIBSMPUUFTNFEMFS!TPDJBMNJOJTUSZTF
MPUUBFSJLTTPO!TPDJBMNJOJTUSZTF

46&$*"

(PUFCPSH6OJWFSTJUZ $FOUSFGPS
3FTFBSDI&UIJDT$FOUSVNGPS
'PSTLOJOHTFUJL
#PY  (PUFCPSH
5FM 'BY 

TXFMJO!DSFHVTF 4UFMMBO8FMJO

FIBHCFSH!DSFHVTF &JOB)BHCFSH

-VOE6OJWFSTJUZ &OIFUFOGPS.FEJDJOTL
&UJL %FQBSUNFOUPG.FEJDBM&UIJDT

4UPSB(SBCSPEFSTHBUBO )4 4&


 -VOE
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXNFEFUJLMVTF
*MHB-JMKFOCFSH!NFEFUJLMVTF
CJCMJPUFLFU!NFEFUJLMVTF
.JOJTUSZPG)FBMUIBOE4PDJBM"BJST 
4UBUFOT.FEJDJOTL&UJTLB3BE 4.&3

4XFEJTI/BUJPOBM$PVODJMPO.FEJDBM
&UIJDT

4 4UPDLIPMN
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXTNFSHPWTF
MPUUBFSJLTTPO!TPDJBMNJOJTUSZTFCJSHJUUB
TKPP!TPDJBMNJOJTUSZTF
4XFEJTI(FOF5FDIOPMPHZ"EWJTPSZ
#PBSE
(FOUFLOJLOBNOEFO 3FU[JVTWBH" 

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

6QQTBMB6OJWFSTJUFU %FQBSUNFOUPG
1VCMJD)FBMUIBOE$BSJOH 3FTFBSDI
1SPHSBN&UIJDTJO#JPNFEJDJOF
4& 6QQTBMB
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTVVTF
JOGP!CJPFUIJDTVVTF
46*;"

$PVODJMGPS*OUFSOBUJPOBM0SHBOJ[BUJPOT
PG.FEJDBM4DJFODFT $*0.4

DP8PSME)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO
$) (FOFWB
5FM  
 'BY

IUUQXXXDJPNTDI
DJPNT!XIPJOU
4PDJU4VJTTFEUIJRVF#JPNFEJDBMF
4DIXFJ[FSJTDIF(FTFMMTDIBGUGS
#JPNFEJ[JOJTDIF&UIJL
44&#4(#&
4FLSFUBSJBU4(#&44&# 3&)"##BTFM
1PTUGBDI $)#BTFM
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXCJPFUIJDTDIDPOUFOUEFGBVMU
IUN
TTFC!CJPFUIJDTDI
4XJTT/BUJPOBM"EWJTPSZ$PNNJTTJPO
PO#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT
DP4XJTT'FEFSBM0DFPG1VCMJD)FBMUI
#FSOF 



"QOEJDFT

5FM 'BY 



IUUQXXXOFLDOFDI
OFLDOF!CBHBENJODI
6OJUFEF3FDIFSDIFFUE&OTFJHOFNFOU
FO#JPFUIJRVF $FOUSF.FEJDBM
6OJWFSTJUBJSF
3VF.JDIFM4FSWFU (FOFWF
5FM 'BY 

8PSME)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO 8)0

&UIJDTBOE)FBMUI &5)

"WFOVF"QQJB (FOFWB
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXXIPJOUFUIJDTFO
JOG!XIPJOU
5"*-"/%*"

"4&"/*OTUJUVUFGPS)FBMUI
%FWFMPQNFOU  "*)%
.BIJEPM
6OJWFSTJUZBU4BMBZB $FOUFSGPS
#JPFUIJDT3FTFBSDI
1IVUUIBNPOUIPO /BLIPSO1BUIPN

5FMT
'BY

EJSFDUBE!NBIJEPMBDUIBETMT!NBIJEPM
BDUI
6OJWFSTJUZ3BOHTJU$BNQVT )FBMUI
4DJFODF$FOUFS'BDVMUZPG"MMJFE)FBMUI
4DJFODFT 'PSVNGPS&UIJDBM3FWJFX
$PNNJUUFFTJO"TJBOBOE8FTUFSO

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



1BDJGJD3FHJPO '&3$"1

1BIPMZPUIJO3PBE,MPOH-VBOH 
1SBUVNUBOFF
5FM 'BY 

IUUQXXXGFSDBQTJEDFSPSHIPNFBTQ
OLFTBSB!UVBDUIOLFTBSB!IPUNBJMDPN
56326"

#JPFUIJDT"E)PD$PNNJUUFFGPSUIF
5VSLJTI/BUJPOBM$PNNJTTJPOGPS
6/&4$0
#JZPFUJL:IUJTBT,PNJUFTJ
(PSFNF4PLBL,BWBLMJEFSF  
"OLBSB
5FM 
'BY 
IUUQXXXVOFTDPPSHUS
XFCNBTUFS!VOFTDPPSHUS
636(6":

6OJWFSTJEBE$BUPMJDBEFM6SVHVBZ 
'BDVMUBEEF$JFODJBT)VNBOBT *OTUJUVUP
EF#JPUJDB
"WEF0DUVCSF/P 
.POUFWJEFP $1
5FM JOU'BY

FUJDB!VDVFEVVZ
7&/&;6&-"

&TDVFMBEF&OGFSNFSB
$FOUSP/BDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB
6SC4FCVDO TVCJFOEPQPSMB"W
1SJODJQBM "W.JHVFM0UFSP4JMWB 1JTP 
$BSBDBT
5FM



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





4FMFDDJOEFQVCMJDBDJPOFTQFSJEJDBTEFCJPUJDB

"DUB#JPFUIJDB3FWJTUBEFM1SPHSBNBEF
#JPUJDB 0140.4  4BOUJBHP EF $IJ
MF *44/ *NQSFTP   *44/
&O MOFB 9 %JTQPOJCMF FO
IUUQXXXQBIPPSH4QBOJTICJPQV
CMJDBIUN
"NFSJDBO +PVSOBM PG #JPFUIJDT 5BZMPS
BOE 'SBODJT (SPVQ  #JPFUIJDT &EV
DBUJPO /FUXPSL &EJUFE JO UIF "MEFO
.BSDI #JPFUIJDT *OTUJUVUF PG "MCBOZ
.FEJDBM $FOUFS 6OJUFE 4UBUFT *44/
 "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXX
CJPFUIJDTOFUKPVSOBM
"ST.FEJDB3FWJTUBEF&TUVEJPT.EJ
DPT )VNBOTUJDPT 1POUJmDJB 6OJWFSTJ
EBE$BUMJDB4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF*44/
%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQFTDVF
MBNFEQVDDMQVCM"ST.FEJDB"ST
.FEJDBIUNM
#JPFUIJDT +PVSOBM PG UIF *OUFSOBUJPOBM
"TTPDJBUJPO PG #JPFUIJDT &EJUFE CZ
3VUI $IBEXJDL BOE 6EP 4DILMFOL
"WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXXCMBDLXFMMQV
CMJTIJOHDPNKPVSOBMT#*0&5)*$4
#JPFUIJDT#VMMFUJO6OJWFSTJUZPG#VBMP 
$FOUFSGPS$MJOJDBM&UIJDTBOE)VNBOJ
UJFTJO)FBMUI$BSF/FX:PSL6OJUFE
4UBUFT "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXXXJOHT
CVBMPFEVGBDVMUZSFTFBSDICJPFUIJDT
OFXTIUNM
#JPUJDB3FWJTUBEF#JPUJDBFUJDB.
EJDBQVCMJDBEBQFMP$POTFMIP'FEFSBM
EF.FEJDJOB4("4o-PUF#SB
TMJB%'$&1
%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXXDGNPSHCS

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

#JPUJDB  %FCBU 6OJWFSTJUBU 3BNO


-MVMM$BUBMVB &TQBB%JTQPOJCMFFO
IUUQXXXCJPFUJDBEFCBUPSH
FNBJMSFWJTUBCJPFUJDB!HXDGNPSHCS
#JPUJDB 4FMFDDJPOFT 6OJWFSTJEBE +BWF
SJBOB $PMPNCJB%JTQPOJCMFFOXXX
KBWFSJBOBFEVDPCJPFUJDBQVCMJDBDJP
OFT@SFWJTUBTIUN
#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT/FXTMFUUFSPGF&V
SPQFBO/FUXPSLGPS#JPNFEJDBM&UIJDT
*OUFSGBLVMUSFT ;FOUSVN GS &UIJL JO
EFO 8JTTFOTDIBGUFO PG UIF 6OJWFSTJUZ
PG 5CJOHFO  (FSNBOZ *44/ 

#VMMFUJO PG .FEJDBM &UIJDT 3PZBM 4PDJF
UZ PG .FEJDJOF 1SFTT -POEPO 6OJUFE
,JOHEPN*44/"WBJMBCMFBU
IUUQXXXCVMMNFEFUIJOGPDVSSFOU
IUN
$BNCSJEHF 2VBSUFSMZ PG )FBMUIDBSF
&UIJDT F *OUFSOBUJPOBM +PVSOBM GPS
)FBMUIDBSF&UIJDTBOE&UIJDT$PNNJU
UFFT &EJUFE CZ PNBTJOF ,VTIOFS
6OJWFSTJUZPG$BMJGPSOJB#FSLFMFZ 64"
Z4UFWF)FJMJH 4BO'SBODJTDP.FEJDBM
$FOUFS  6OJUFE 4UBUFT 1SJOU *44/
0OMJOF *44/ 
"WBJMBCMFBUIUUQKPVSOBMTDBNCSJEHF
PSHBDUJPOEJTQMBZ+PVSOBM KJE$2)
$VBEFSOPTEF#JPUJDB&EJUPSJBM"E)PD
"SHFOUJOB *44/  %JTQPOJ
CMF FO IUUQXXXDVBEFSOPTCJPFUJDB
PSH





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

&UIJDT.FEJDJOF"O*OUFSOBUJPOBM+P
VSOBM PG #JPFUIJDT F #JPFUIJDT 1SFTT
*MMJOPJT   6OJUFE 4UBUFT "WBJMB
CMF BU IUUQXXXFUIJDTBOENFEJDJOF
DPN
&VCJPT +PVSOBM PG "TJBO BOE *OUFSOBUJP
OBM#JPFUIJDT &+"*#
"TJBO#JPFUIJDT
"TTPDJBUJPO  +BQBO *44/ 
"WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXXVOFTDPCLL
PSHJOEFYQIQ JE^
)BTUJOHT $FOUFS 3FQPSU )BTUJOHT $FO
UFS /FX :PSL  6OJUFE 4UBUFT *44/
 "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQXXX
UIFIBTUJOHTDFOUFSPSHQVCMJDBUJPOTIDS
IDSBTQ
)FBMUI.BUSJY+PVSOBMPG-BX.FEJDJOF
'MPSJEB 4UBUF 6OJWFSTJUZ -BX 3FWJFX 
6OJUFE 4UBUFT "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQMBX
DBTFFEVTUVEFOU@MJGFKPVSOBMTIFBMUI@
NBUSJYEFGBVMUIUN
)VNBO3FTFBSDI3FQPSU%FFN$PSQP
SBUJPO 0NBIB /FCSBTLB 6OJUFE4UB
UFT"WBJMBCMFBUIUUQXXXIVNBOSF
TFBSDISFQPSUDPN
*OWFTUJHBDJO $MOJDB Z #JPUJDB 4PDJF
EBE&TQBPMBEF'BSNBDPMPHB$MOJDB
&TQBB*44/%JTQPOJCMF
FOIUUQXXXJDGVBCFTJDCEJHJUBM
*3# &UIJDT  )VNBO 3FTFBSDI )BT
UJOHT$FOUFS/FX:PSL 6OJUFE4UBUFT
*44/  "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQ
XXXUIFIBTUJOHTDFOUFSPSHQVCMJDBUJP
OTJSCJSCBTQ
+PVSOBM PG $MJOJDBM &UIJDT )BHFSTUPXO 
.BSZMBOE 6OJUFE4UBUFT*44/
"WBJMBCMFBUIUUQXXXDMJOJDB
MFUIJDTDPN
+PVSOBM PG -BX  .FEJDJOF  &UIJDT
"NFSJDBO 4PDJFUZ PG -BX  .FEJDJOF
 &UIJDT 6OJUFE 4UBUFT "WBJMBCMF BU
IUUQXXXBTMNFPSHQVCKMNF
+PVSOBM PG .FEJDBM &UIJDT #.+ 1VCMJT
IJOH(SPVQBOEUIF*OTUJUVUFPG.FEJDBM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

&UIJDT  6OJUFE ,JOHEPN 1SJOU *44/


0OMJOF"WBJ
MBCMFBUIUUQKNFCNKKPVSOBMTDPN
,FOOFEZ *OTUJUVUF PG &UIJDT +PVSOBM +P
IOT )PQLJOT 6OJWFSTJUZ 1SFTT ,FO
OFEZ *OTUJUVUF PG &UIJDT (FPSHFUPXO
6OJWFSTJUZ 8BTIJOHUPO 6OJUFE4UBUFT
1SJOU*44/0OMJOF*44/
 "WBJMBCMF BU IUUQNVTF
KIVFEVKPVSOBMTLFOOFEZ@JOTUJUVUF@
PG@FUIJDT@KPVSOBM
.FEJDBM )VNBOJUJFT #.+ 1VCMJTIJOH
(SPVQ BOE UIF *OTUJUVUF PG .FEJDBM
&UIJDT  6OJUFE ,JOHEPN 1SJOU *44/
90OMJOF"WBJ
MBCMFBUIUUQKNFCNKKPVSOBMTDPN
.FEJDJOBZUJDB6OJWFSTJEBEEF"OB
IVBD  .YJDP *44/  %JT
QPOJCMF FO IUUQXXXBOBIVBDNY
DPOUFOJEPTIUNM
/VSTJOH &UIJDT "SOPME &E 6OJUFE
,JOHEPO 1SJOU *44/  
0OMJOF*44/"WBJMBCMFBU
IUUQXXXBSOPMEQVCMJTIFSTDPNKP
VSOBMTQBHFTOVS@FUIIUN
1FSTPOB Z #JPUJDB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF MB
4BCBOB  $PMPNCJB *44/ 
%JTQPOJCMF FO IUUQHFNNBVOJTB
CBOBFEVDPQVCMJDBDJPOFTQTJOPQTJT
BTQ JE
3FWJTUB $VBEFSOPT EF #JPUJDB "TPDJB
DJO&TQBPMBEF#JPUJDBZUJDB.EJ
DB &TQBB*44/%JTQPOJ
CMFFOIUUQXXXBFCJPFUJDBPSH
3FWJTUB EF %FSFDIP Z (FOPNB )VNB
OP 'VOEBDJO ##7"  &TQBB *44/
%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXX
EFSFDIPVOFYFTCJCMJPUFDB4VNBSJPT
HFOPNBIUN
3FWJTUB -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF #JPUJDB
&EJUBEB QPS FM 1SPHSBNB EF #JPUJDB 
%FQBSUBNFOUPEF&EVDBDJO )VNBOJ
EBEFT &TUVEJPT"WBO[BEPTZ1SPHSBNBT
&TQFDJBMFT EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE .JMJUBS





"QOEJDFT

i/VFWB(SBOBEBw$BSSFSB/
  #PHPU  $PMPNCJB %JTQPOJCMF FO
IUUQXXXVNOHFEVDPXXXTFD
UJPOKTQ
FNBJMSFWCJP!VNOHFEVDP
3FWJTUB1FSTQFDUJWBTEF#JPUJDB'BDVMUBE
-BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF $JFODJBT 4PDJBMFT
'-"$40
 "SHFOUJOB *44/ 
 %JTQPOJCMF FO IUUQXXX
nBDTPPSHBSBSFBTZQSPZFDUPTQSPZFDUPT
QCSFWJTUBKTQ
3FWJTUB 2VJSO *OTUJUVUP EF #JPUJDB Z
)VNBOJEBEFT.EJDBT 'VOEBDJO%S
+PT..BJOFUUJQBSBFM1SPHSFTPEFMB
.FEJDJOB $0&"SHFOUJOB%JTQPOJ
CMF FO XXXGVOEBDJPONBJOFUUJDPN
BSCJPFUJDBIUN
3FWJTUB 4*#* 'VOEBDJO 4PDJFEBE *O
UFSOBDJPOBMEF#JPUJDB &TQBB*44/

%JTQPOJCMFFOIUUQXXXTJCJPSH
4PDJBM4DJFODF.FEJDJOF&MTFWJFS-UE 
/FUIFSMBOET *44/  "WBJ

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

MBCMFBUIUUQXXXTDJFODFEJSFDUDPN
TDJFODFKPVSOBM
4VNNB #JPUJDB EJTDPOUJOVBEB
 $P
NJTJO /BDJPOBM EF #JPUJDB EF .YJ
DP *44/  %JTQPOJCMF FO
IUUQCJPFUJDBTBMVEHPCNYSFWJTUB
IUNM
FPSFUJDBM.FEJDJOFBOE#JPFUIJDT 1IJ
MPTPQIZPG.FEJDBM3FTFBSDIBOE1SBDUJDF
4QSJOHFS 4DJFODF  #VTJOFTT .FEJB
#7  /FUIFSMBOET 1SJOU *44/ 
0OMJOF"WBJMBCMFBU
IUUQXXXTQSJOHFSMJOLDPN
7JEB Z UJDB *OTUJUVUP EF #JPUJDB 'B
DVMUBEEF$JFODJBT.FEJDBT 6$" "S
HFOUJOB %JTQPOJCMF FO IUUQXXX
VDBFEVBSFTQTFDCJPFUJDBFTQQBHF
QIQ TVCTFDQVCMJDBDJPOFT
:BMF+PVSOBMPG)FBMUI1PMJDZ -BX BOE
&UIJDT :BMF 6OJWFSTJUZ  /FX )BWFO 
$POOFDUJDVU  6OJUFE 4UBUFT "WBJMBCMF
BUIUUQXXXZBMFFEVZKIQMF



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





1VCMJDBDJPOFTEFM1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDB0140.4

"DUB#JPFUIJDB
)BTUB   MB QVCMJDBDJO PmDJBM EFM
1SPHSBNB 3FHJPOBM EF #JPUJDB QBSB
"NSJDB-BUJOBZFM$BSJCFFSB$VBEFS
OPTEFM1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPFUJDB-B
SFWJTUB TFNFTUSBM "DUB #JPFUIJDB *44/

 FT  EFTEF   MB DPOUJ
OVBEPSB EF MPT $VBEFSOPT $POTUJUVZF
VOB GVFOUF QMVSBMJTUB EF QFSTQFDUJWBT Z
USJCVOBRVFBDPHFMBTDPOUSJCVDJPOFTEF
DBMJmDBEPTBVUPSFT DPNQSPNFUJEPTDPO
MBFNQSFTBCJPUJDB
-PT ONFSPT EF FTUB SFWJTUB FTUO
EJTQPOJCMFTFOGPSNBUP1%'FOIUUQ
XXXQBIPPSH4QBOJTICJPQVCMJDB
IUN Z FO 4DJFOUJmD &MFDUSPOJD -JCSBSZ
0OMJOF4DJ&-0IUUQXXXTDJFMPDM
"P 7PM / 5UVMP
 7*

 $VJEBEPT1BMJBUJWPTZ
#JPUJDB

 7*

 1FSTQFDUJWBT#JPUJDBTZ
1VCMJDBDJPOFT#JPNEJDBT

 7**

 &OWFKFDJNJFOUPZ$BMJEBE
EF7JEB

 7**

 /PDJWJEBE"NCJFOUBMZ
"MJNFOUBSJB

 7***

 %FCBUFUJDPZ$JFODJBT
4PDJBMFT

 7***
 *9
 *9

 %FSFDIPZ#JPUJDB
 #JPUFDOPMPHBZUJDB
 #JPUJDBZ4BMVE1CMJDB



 #JPUJDBF*OWFTUJHBDJOFO
4FSFT)VNBOPT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

 9
 9*

 #JPUJDBZ(FONJDB
 1PMUJDBT1CMJDBT

 9*

 5FDOPMPHBTEFMB
*OGPSNBDJO

 9**

 #JPUJDBZ
0EPOUPFTUPNBUPMPHB

 9**

 #JPUJDBZ(OFSP

 9***

 &YQFSJNFOUBDJODPO
"OJNBMFTZ#JPUJDB

#JPUJDB*OGPSNB
#PMFUORVFBQBSFDFUSFTWFDFTFOFMBPZ
RVFEJGVOEFBHFOEBEFBDUJWJEBEFT QV
CMJDBDJPOFTFJOGPSNBDJOEFMBDPOUFDFS
CJPUJDPEFMPTQBTFTEF-BUJOPBNSJDB
ZFM$BSJCF *44/
%JTQP
OJCMF EFTEF FM ONFSP   DPSSFTQPO
EJFOUFBEJDJFNCSFEF FOGPSNBUP
1%' FOFMTJUJPIUUQXXXQBIPPSH
4QBOJTICJPQVCMJDBIUN

4BMVE0SBM#JPUJDB
#PMFUO BOVBM EF EJWVMHBDJO  EJSJHJEP
B MPT QSPGFTJPOBMFT EF MB 4BMVE 0SBM
FO -BUJOPBNSJDB  JOUFSFTBEPT FO MB
JOUFSSFMBDJOFOUSFDJFODJB JOWFTUJHBDJO
ZTFSWJDJPBMBDPNVOJEBE UFOJFOEPBMB
CJPUJDBDPNPJOUSQSFUF *44/

&TFMBCPSBEPFODPOKVOUPDPOFM
$FOUSP*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO
#JPUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF4F
FODVFOUSBOEJTQPOJCMFTTVTEPTQSJNFSPT
ONFSPT FO FM TJUJP IUUQXXXQBIP
PSH4QBOJTICJPQVCMJDBIUN





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

4FSJF1VCMJDBDJPOFT
i*OWFTUJHBDJO FO 4VKFUPT )VNBOPT
&YQFSJFODJB *OUFSOBDJPOBM3FTFBSDI PO
)VNBO 4VCKFDUT *OUFSOBDJPOBM &YQF
SJFODFw"MCFSUP1FMMFHSJOJ'JMIPZ3VUI
.BDLMJO FEJUPSFT
 
 *4#/

*ODMVZFMPTBSUDVMPTQSFTFO
UBEPTFOMBQSJNFSBSFVOJOEFM$PNJU
"TFTPS *OUFSOBDJPOBM FO #JPUJDB EF MB
0SHBOJ[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE
0140.4
DFMFCSBEBFOUSFFMZFM
 EF NBZP EF   FO 8BTIJOHUPO
%$

i#JPUJDBZ$VJEBEPEFMB4BMVE&RVJ
EBE  $BMJEBE  %FSFDIPTw 'FSOBOEP
-PMBT 4UFQLF FEJUPS
 
 *4#/

 1POFODJBT EF BMHVOPT
QBSUJDJQBOUFTFOMBTFHVOEBSFVOJOEFM
$PNJU "TFTPS *OUFSOBDJPOBM FO #JP
UJDB EF MB 0SHBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB
EFMB4BMVE 0140.4
SFBMJ[BEPFO
USFFMZEFNBZPEFFO$JVEBE
EF1BOBN
i*OUFSGBDFT #FUXFFO #JPFUIJDT BOE UIF
&NQJSJDBM 4PDJBM 4DJFODFTw 'FSOBOEP
-PMBT4UFQLF-PSFO[P"HBS$PSCJOPT
FEJUPST
 
 *4#/

 JSE .FFUJOH PG UIF *OUFSOBUJPOBM
"EWJTPSZ #PBSE PO #JPFUIJDT  1BO
"NFSJDBO)FBMUI0SHBOJ[BUJPO 8PSME
)FBMUI 0SHBOJ[BUJPO  0DUPCFS OE
oUI  #VFOPT"JSFT "SHFOUJOB
i1BVUBT UJDBT EF *OWFTUJHBDJO FO 4V
KFUPT )VNBOPT /VFWBT 1FSTQFDUJWBTw
'FSOBOEP -PMBT 4UFQLF Z MWBSP 2VF
[BEB 4 FEJUPSFT
 
 *4#/ 

 3FFEJDJO BNQMJBEB EF
i*OWFTUJHBDJO FO 4VKFUPT )VNBOPT
&YQFSJFODJB *OUFSOBDJPOBMw *ODMVZF SF
nFYJPOFT Z DPNFOUBSJPT TPCSF SFWJTJO
 EF MBT i1BVUBT UJDBT *OUFSOBDJP
OBMFT QBSB MB *OWFTUJHBDJO #JPNEJDB
FO 4FSFT )VNBOPTw $*0.4 

*4#/
USBEVDDJOEFM
UFYUP FO JOHMT  SFBMJ[BEB QPS QSPGFTJP
OBMFTEFM1SPHSBNB3FHJPOBMEF#JPUJDB
0140.4

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

i%JMPHPZDPPQFSBDJOFO4BMVE%JF[
BPTEF#JPUJDBFOMB014w'FSOBOEP
-PMBT 4UFQLF FEJUPS
 
 *4#/

3FDPHFMBTQSFTFOUBDJP
OFTEFMPTJOUFHSBOUFTEFM$PNJU"TFTPS
*OUFSOBDJPOBMFO#JPUJDBEFMB0SHBOJ
[BDJO1BOBNFSJDBOBEFMB4BMVE 014
0.4
FOTVDVBSUBSFVOJO DFMFCSBEB
DPOPDBTJOEFMPTEJF[BPTEFM1SPHSB
NB3FHJPOBMEF#JPUJDB0140.4
4FSJF&TDSJUPTEF#JPUJDB1VCMJDBEB
FODPOKVOUPDPOFM$FOUSP
*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPTFO
#JPUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
$*&#

i*OWFTUJHBDJO FO 4BMVE %JNFOTJO


UJDBw 'FSOBOEP -PMBT  MWBSP 2VF
[BEB Z &EVBSEP 3PESHVF[ FEJUPSFT

/   
 *4#/  

 $PNQSFOEF MPT USBCBKPT EF VO HSV
QP EF DPMBCPSBEPSFT Z EF MPT CFDBSJPT
Z CFDBSJBT EFM 1SPHSBNB EF 'PSNBDJO
FOUJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJO#JPNEJDB
Z1TJDPTPDJBM mOBODJBEPQPSFM'PHBSUZ
*OUFSOBUJPOBM $FOUFS Z PUSPT JOTUJUVUPT
EF MPT /BUJPOBM *OTUJUVUFT PG )FBMUI EF
MPT &TUBEPT 6OJEPT  Z SFBMJ[BEP QPS FM
$*&# FO 4BOUJBHP EF $IJMF FO DVBUSP
WFSTJPOFTDPOTFDVUJWBT
iUJDB Z 0EPOUPMPHB 6OB *OUSPEVD
DJOw $BSNFO $BSEP[P  &EVBSEP
3PESHVF[  'FSOBOEP -PMBT Z MWBSP
2VF[BEB PSHBOJ[BEPSFT
 /

*4#/
1VCMJDBEPTMP
FO GPSNBUP 1%' QPS FM NPNFOUP  SF
OFDPOUSJCVDJPOFTEFFTQFDJBMJTUBTUBMFT
DPNP $TBS "CBEB  $BSPMJOB MWBSF[
EF MB $BEFOB  $MFNFODJB #FSNEF[ 
#MBODB #PISRVF[  "OB #VFOEB  -VJT
$JPDDB  $SJTUJOB %FBOHFMJMMP  'SBODZ
(BSDB 3JOB(VFSSB 3PCFSUP*SSJCBSSB 
"MJDJB-PTPWJ[ 'FSOBOEP3PNP .BSB
"OHMJDB 5PSSFT2VJOUBOB  +PSHF 5SJB
OBZ$BSPMJOB7BMEFCFOJUP





"QOEJDFT

0USPTMJCSPTQVCMJDBEPTFO
DPMBCPSBDJODPOFM$*&#EFMB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
iUJDBF*OOPWBDJO5FDOPMHJDBw'FS
OBOEP -PMBT 4UFQLF FEJUPS
 

*4#/ 
 *ODMVZF MBT
QSFTFOUBDJPOFTEFEFTUBDBEPTFTQFDJBMJT
UBTRVFQBSUJDJQBSPOFOMBTEPTKPSOBEBT
EFM TFNJOBSJP iUJDB EF MB *OOPWBDJO
5FDOPMHJDBw SFBMJ[BEPFMEFBHPTUP
ZFMEFOPWJFNCSFEFFOFMNBS
DPEFM1SPZFDUP#JDFOUFOBSJPFO$JFODJB
Z5FDOPMPHB QBUSPDJOBEPQPS$0/*
$:5$IJMFZFM#BODP.VOEJBM
i&M BOJNBM DPNP TVKFUP FYQFSJNFOUBM
"TQFDUPT UDOJDPT Z UJDPTw $BSNFO
$BSEP[P  "mGF .SBE  $POTUBO[B .BS
UOF[  &EVBSEP 3PESJHVF[ Z 'FSOBOEP
-PMBT 
 *4#/ 

 3FDPHF BMHVOPT DPODFQUPT
GVOEBNFOUBMFT oFO MP UDOJDP Z FO MP
UJDPo QBSB VO BEFDVBEP USBUBNJFOUP
EFM TVKFUP FYQFSJNFOUBM iBOJNBMw FO FM
USBCBKPDJFOUmDP
5PEPT MPT MJCSPT NFODJPOBEPT TF
FODVFOUSBO EJTQPOJCMFT HSBUVJUBNFOUF 
FO GPSNBUP 1%'  FO MPT TJUJPT IUUQ
XXXQBIPPSH4QBOJTICJPQVCMJDB
IUNZIUUQXXXVDIJMFDMCJPFUJDB

)JTUPSJFUBTJMVTUSBEBT DPNJDT

i7JBKFSPT WJSUVBMFT &YQMPSBDJO CJPUJ


DBQPSMBIJTUPSJBEFMBTDJFODJBTw$MBSB
.JTSBDIJ 'FMJQF"MMJFOEF %BSP0TFTZ
'FSOBOEP -PMBT *4#/ 

 3FnFYJPOB TPCSF FM TFOUJEP NPSBM
RVFFODJFSSBOTFJTDBTPTQBSBEJHNUJDPT
FOMBIJTUPSJBEFMBDJFODJB
i&OUSFUFDIP $POWFSTBDJPOFT CJPUJ
DBT TPCSF TFYVBMJEBEw 'FSOBOEP -PMBT 
(VJMMFSNP 'VFOUFT  MWBSP 2VF[BEB 
%BSP0TFT 3BGBFM/BOHBSZ(FSNO
"ESJB[PMB *4#/
"OB
MJ[BMPTEJMFNBTUJDPTQSFTFOUFTFODJODP
UFNBTEFTFYVBMJEBEIVNBOB
4JUJPT8FCSFDPNFOEBEPT
#JCMJPUFDB7JSUVBM#JPUJDB
IUUQCJPFUJDBCWTBMVEPSHIUNMFT
IPNFIUNM
$FOUSP *OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP EF &TUVEJPT
FO#JPUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF
IUUQXXXVDIJMFDMCJPFUJDB
1SPHSBNB EF #JPUJDB EF MB 0SHBOJ[B
DJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE 014
0.4
IUUQXXXQBIPPSH4QBOJTICJP
IPNFIUN
F*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PNQJMBUJPOPG)V
NBO4VCKFDU3FTFBSDI1SPUFDUJPOT
IUUQXXXIITHPWPISQJOUFSOBUJPO
BMJOEFYIUNM/BUM1PM

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD



PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD





4PCSFMPTBVUPSFTZUSBEVDUPSFT

"VUPSFT
'SBODFTD"CFMFTKFTVJUB EPDUPSFO.F
EJDJOB &&66
ZBVUPSEFVOBUFTJTFO
mTJPMPHB GFUBMQMBDFOUBSJB 'VOEBEPS Z
QSFTJEFOUF BDUVBM EFM QSJNFS JOTUJUVUP
FVSPQFP EF CJPUJDB  FM *OTUJUVUP #PSKB
EF#JPUJDB 
&M$FOUSPFTUTJUVB
EPFO4BOU$VHBUEFM7BMMT #BSDFMPOB 
&TQBB
ZFT EFTEF DPNPJOTUJUV
UPBDBENJDP VOBVOJEBEEFMB6OJWFS
TJEBE3BNO-MVMM #BSDFMPOB

+PT 3BNO "DPTUB 4BSJFHP  NEJDP 
FTQFDJBMJTUB FO TBMVE QCMJDB  $UFESB
EF #JPUJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE .EJDB
EF -B )BCBOB .BFTUSP FO #JPUJDB 
1SPHSBNBEF#JPUJDBEF014 4BOUJB
HP $IJMF
&EJUPSDJFOUmDPEF#JPUJDB
%FTEF VOB QFSTQFDUJWB DVCBOB  1VCMJ
DBDJPOFT "DVBSJP  $FOUSP 'MJY 7BSFMB
-B)BCBOB 
&TVOQJPOFSPFOMB
FEVDBDJOCJPUJDBFO$VCB
"MCFSUP"SFMMBOP.OEF[FTHSBEVBEP
EFM$PMFHJPEF"CPHBEPTEFMB6OJWFS
TJEBE "VUOPNB /BDJPOBM EF .YJDP
6/".
FJOWFTUJHBEPSFOFMDBNQPEF
MB TBMVE Z EFM EFSFDIP EFM *OTUJUVUP EF
*OWFTUJHBDJPOFT +VSEJDBT **+6/".

'VFDPOGFSFODJTUBFOFM$PMFHJPEF"CP
HBEPTEF6/".

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

.BSUB "TDVSSB FT CJPRVNJDB FTQFDJB


MJ[BEBFOHFOUJDB*OWFTUJHBEPSBZQSP
GFTPSBEFM*OTUJUVUPEF*OWFTUJHBDJOFO
$JFODJBT EF MB 4BMVE EF "TVODJO  1B
SBHVBZ NJFNCSP EF MB $PNJTJO /B
DJPOBMQBSBFM%FTBSSPMMPEFMB#JPUJDB
FO1BSBHVBZ$POTVMUPSBEFMB3FE-B
UJOPBNFSJDBOBZEFM$BSJCFEF#JPUJDB
3&%#*046/&4$0

$ISJTUJBO EF 1BVM EF #BSDIJGPOUBJOF
FTFOGFSNFSP .BFTUSPEF(FTUJO)PT
QJUBMBSJBZ(FSFODJBEFMB4BMVE&TBV
UPSEFWBSJPTMJCSPT FOUSFFMMPT#JPUJDBF
*ODJPEB7JEB"MHVOT%FTBmPT 4P1BV
MP  *EJBT F -FUSBT  
 DPBVUPS EFM
QSJNFSUSBCBKPEJEDUJDPTPCSFCJPUJDB
FO #SBTJM 1SPCMFNBT BUVBJT EF CJPUJDB
&E-PZPMB &E 
DPPSEJOB
EPSEF#JPUJDB BMHVOTEFTBmPT 4P1BV
MP  -PZPMB  SP &E  
 1SFTJEFOUF
EFM $FOUSP 6OJWFSTJUSJP 4P $BNJMP 
41$PPSEJOBEPSEFFTUFWPMVNFO
+PSHF #JTDBJB  NEJDP  EJSFDUPS EFM
$FOUSPEF&TUVEJPT#JPUJDPTEF$PJN
CSB 1PSUVHBM
"VUPSZDPPSEJOBEPSEF
WBSJPT USBCBKPT EF #JPUJDB  JODMVZFOEP
/PWPTEFTBmPT#JPUJDB /FX$IBMMFO
HFT UP #JPFUIJDT  1PSUP &EJUPSB  1PSUP 

 #FN EB 1FTTPB  #FN $PNVN





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

1FPQMFT(PPE $PNNPO(PPE (SmDB


EF $PJNCSB  $PJNCSB  
 1FSEFS
QBSBFODPOUSBS -PTFUP'JOE0VU $PJN
CSB(SmDBEF$PJNCSB 
"PFO
DPOUSP EB UFSOVSB 5PXBSET 5FOEFSOFTT 
(SmDBEF$PJNCSB $PJNCSB 

(FSNO$BMEFSO-FHBSEBFTEJSFDUPS
EFM*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJ
EBE+BWFSJBOBEF#PHPU'JMTPGP 5SJ
OJUZ $PMMFHF  6OJWFSTJEBE EF %VCMO 
*SMBOEB
 HSBEVBEP QPS MB 6OJWFSTJEBE
/BDJPOBM EF $PMPNCJB Z .BFTUSP FO
#JPUJDB 1SPHSBNB EF #JPUJDB  0SHB
OJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE F
*/5&$EF4BOUP%PNJOHP 3FQCMJDB
%PNJOJDBOB
 5SBCBKB QSJODJQBMNFO
UF FO MBT SFBT EF UFPSB UJDB  CJPUJDB
Z EFSFDIPT IVNBOPT Z KVTUJDJB 3FBMJ[B
BDUVBMNFOUFJOWFTUJHBDJPOFTEFCJPUJDB
ZNVMUJDVMUVSBMJTNP
%FCPSB %JOJ[ FT %PDUPSB FO "OUSP
QPMPHB  QSPGFTPSB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE EF
#SBTJMJBZEJSFDUPSBEFMBPSHBOJ[BDJOOP
HVCFSOBNFOUBM"OJT*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJ
DB %FSFDIPT)VNBOPTZ(OFSP&TBV
UPSBEFBSUDVMPTDJFOUmDPT MJCSPTZEP
DVNFOUBMFT TPCSF CJPUJDB "DUVBMNFOUF
QFSUFOFDFBMDPOTFKPEJSFDUJWPEFMB*OUFS
OBUJPOBM"TTPDJBUJPOPG#JPFUIJDT *"#

+BNFT%SBOFFTEJSFDUPSEFM$FOUSPEF
#JPUJDB EF MB 6OJWFSTJEBE &EJOCPSP
1FOOTZMWBOJB  &&66
 &T DPOGFSFO
DJTUB JOUFSOBDJPOBM  BVUPS EF WBSJPT MJ
CSPTEF#JPUJDB NJFNCSPEFM$PNJU
"TFTPS EFM 1SPHSBNB TF #JPUJDB EF MB
014 EFTEF TV FTUBCMFDJNJFOUP 

&T BVUPS EF .PSF )VNBOF .FEJDJOF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

"-JCFSBM$BUIPMJD#JPFUIJDT &EJOCPSP 
&EJOCPSP6OJWFSTJUZ1SFTT 1" 

.SDJP'BCSJEPT"OKPTFTUFMPHPNP
SBM JOWFTUJHBEPSZQSPGFTPSEF#JPUJDB
EFM $FOUSP 6OJWFSTJUBSJP 4P $BNJMP
.JFNCSP EF MB 4PDJFEBE #SBTJMFB EF
#JPUJDBZBOUJHVPQSFTJEFOUFEFMB4P
DJFEBE#SBTJMFBEF5FPMPHBZ$JFODJBT
EFMB3FMJHJO$PPSEJOBEPSZBVUPSEF
WBSJBEPT MJCSPT  FOUSF FMMPT  5FPMPHB Z
OVFWPT QBSBEJHNBT 
 /PWBT (F
SBFT F 7JEB 3FMJHJPTB 
 i1PXFS
BOE7VMOFSBCJMJUZ"DPOUSJCVUJPOPGEF
WFMPQJOHDPVOUSJFTUPUIFFUIJDBMEFCBUFPO
HFOFUJDTw *O $BIJMM  -JTB 4PXMF (FOF
UJDT FPMPHZ &UIJDT"OJOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSZ
DPOWFSTBUJPO 

%JFHP (SBDJB (VJMMO FT QSPGFTPS EF
MB $UFESB EF )JTUPSJB EF MB .FEJDJOB
Z UJDB .EJDB FO MB &TDVFMB .EJDB
EFMB6OJWFSTJEBE$PNQMVUFOTFEF.B
ESJE &TQBB
&TNJFNCSPEFM$PNJU
"TFTPS EFM 1SPHSBNB EF #JPUJDB EF MB
0SHBOJ[BDJO 1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4B
MVE 0SHBOJ[BDJO.VOEJBMEFMB4BMVE
4BOUJBHP  $IJMF
 &T BVUPS EF WBSJPT
USBCBKPT EF SFGFSFODJB TPCSF CJPUJDB 
FOUSF FMMPT  'VOEBNFOUPT EF MB CJPUJDB

1SPDFEJNJFOUPTEFEFDJTJOFOUJ
DB$MOJDB 
Z$POUSJCVDJOEFMBT
)VNBOJEBEFT.EJDBTBMBGPSNBDJOEFM
NEJDP 

%JSDF(VJMIFNFTEPDUPSBFO$JFODJBT
EFMB4BMVEZQSPGFTPSBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EF#SBTJMJB&TBVUPSBEFBSUDVMPTDJFOU
mDPTZMJCSPTTPCSFCJPUJDB"DUVBMNFO
UFFTEJSFDUPSBEFM'PSP-BUJOPBNFSJDBOP





"QOEJDFT

EF$PNJUTEFUJDBFO*OWFTUJHBDJOFO
4BMVE '-"$&*4
 "VUPSB EF &TDSBWBT
EP3JTDP#JPUJDB .VMIFSFTF"JET #SB
TMJB &EJUPSB6O#'JOBUFD 

(FSBSEP +JNOF[ 4ODIF[ FT EPDUPS
FO .FEJDJOB  +PIOT )PQLJOT 6OJWFSTJ
UZ .JFNCSP BmMJBEP EFM *OTUJUVUP EF
.FEJDJOB(FOUJDBEFMB+PIOT)PQLJOT
6OJWFSTJUZ #BMUJNPSF &&661SPGFTPS
EF(FONJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE/BDJP
OBM "VUOPNB EF .YJDP 6/".
 F
JOWFTUJHBEPS SFTJEFOUF EF MB 'VOEBDJO
.FYJDBOBEFMB4BMVE '6/4"-6%

.JHVFM ,PUUPX  mMTPGP  QSPGFTPS EFM
%FQBSUBNFOUPEF'JMPTPGBEFMB'BDVM
UBE EF 'JMPTPGB Z )VNBOJEBEFT EF MB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF 4BOUJBHP
"VUPS
EFNVDIPTBSUDVMPTZMJCSPTFOFMSFB
EFCJPUJDB6OPEFTVTUSBCBKPTNTSF
DJFOUFT RVFMUBNCJOPSHBOJ[FT#BTFT
DPODFJUVBJT EB CJPUJDB FOGPRVF MBUJOP
BNFSJDBOP 4P1BVMP (BJB 

$TBS'SBODJTDP-BSBMWBSF[FT.BFT
USPFOUJDBEFMB*OWFTUJHBDJO#JPN
EJDB 6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF-FDPODFEJ
VOBCFDBFM'PHBSUZ/BUJPOBM*OTUJUVUFTPG
)FBMUI /*)
64"%JSFDUPSEFQSPHSB
NBT FEVDBUJWPT EFM *OTUJUVUP /BDJPOBM
EF .FEJDJOB (FONJDB */.&(&/

.YJDP$PPSEJOBEPSEFJOWFTUJHBDJPOFT
EFDVFTUJPOFTUJDBT MFHBMFTZTPDJBMFTEFM
$FOUSP EF .FEJDJOB (FONJDB  .YJ
DP 1SPGFTPS EFM 1SPHSBNB EF .BFTUSB
FO#JPUJDB *1/ $JVEBEEF.YJDP
)VCFSU -FQBSHOFVS %PDUPS FO 5FP
MPHB.PSBMZ%FSFDIPQPSMB6OJWFSTJ
EBEEF1BST'VFVOPEFMPTGVOEBEPSFT

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

Z QSJNFS FEJUPS FO KFGF EF MB SFWJTUB 0


.VOEPEB4BEF EFM$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUB
SJP4P$BNJMP 4P1BVMP
"VUPSEFVO
TJOONFSPEFBSUDVMPTZPCSBTEFUFPMP
HBNPSBMZCJPUJDB&OUSFPUSBT0MVHBS
BUVBM EB NPSUF 
 "OUSPQPMPHJB EP
TPGSJNFOUP 
#JPUJDB OPWPDPODFJ
UPBDBNJOIPEFVNDPOTFOTP 

'FSOBOEP-PMBTFTQSPGFTPSUJUVMBSFOMB
6OJWFSTJEBEEF$IJMF%JSFDUPSEFM1SP
HSBNB EF #JPUJDB EF MB 0SHBOJ[BDJO
1BOBNFSJDBOB EF MB 4BMVE 4BOUJBHP 
$IJMF
 Z EFM $FOUSP *OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJP
EF &TUVEJPT FO #JPUJDB EF MB 6OJWFS
TJEBE EF $IJMF "VUPS EF WBSJPT MJCSPT 
FOUSF FMMPT #JPUJDB Z NFEJDJOB BTQFDUPT
EFVOBSFMBDJO 4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF #J
CMJPUFDB "NFSJDBOB  
 Z .T BMM
EFMDVFSQPMBDPOTUSVDDJOOBSSBUJWBEFMB
TBMVE 4BOUJBHPEF$IJMF &EJUPSJBM"O
EST#FMMP 

"MGPOTP -MBOP &TDPCBS FT UFMPHP KF
TVJUB  BOUJHVP %JSFDUPS Z GVOEBEPS EFM
$FOUSPEF#JPUJDBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE+B
WFSJBOB #PHPU $PMPNCJB
'VOEBEPS
EF MB 'FEFSBDJO -BUJOPBNFSJDBOB EF
*OTUJUVDJPOFTEF#JPUJDB '&-"*#&

3PCFSUP-MBOPT;VMPBHBFTQTJRVJBUSB
Z QTJDPUFSBQFVUB  FTQFDJBMJTUB FO QTJ
RVJBUSB DMOJDB  KFGF EFM %FQBSUBNFOUP
EF 1TJDPUFSBQJB EF MB $MOJDB 3JDBSEP
1BMNB 'VOEBEPS Z QSFTJEFOUF BDUVBM
EF MB "TPDJBDJO 1FSVBOB EF #JPUJDB
&TQSPGFTPSZDPPSEJOBEPSEFM%PDUPSB
EPFO1TJDPMPHBEFMB6OJWFSTJEBEEFM
4BHSBEP$PSB[O1SPGFTPSJOWJUBEPEF
#JPUJDB FO MB VOJWFSTJEBEFT /BDJPOBM
EF4BO.BSDPTZ$BZFUBOP)FSFEJB





1FSTQFDUJWBTEFMB#JPUJDBFO*CFSPBNSJDB

+PT"MCFSUP.BJOFUUJ EPDUPSFO.F
EJDJOBZ'JMPTPGB1SFTJEFOUFEFMB'VO
EBDJO +PT .BJOFUUJ #POOFU  #VFOPT
"JSFT  "SHFOUJOB
 %JSFDUPS Z QSPGFTPS
EFM*OTUJUVUPEF#JPUJDBZ)VNBOJEB
EFT.EJDBTEFMB'VOEBDJO+PT.BJ
OFUUJ QBSB FM 1SPHSFTP EF MB .FEJDJOB
FO-B1MBUB "SHFOUJOB
'VFVOPEFMPT
GVOEBEPSFTEF'&-"*#&0SHBOJ[DPO
+VBO$BSMPT5FBMEJFM**$POHSFTP.VO
EJBMEF#JPUJDBFO#VFOPT"JSFT 
8BMUFS0TTXBME FYEJSFDUPSEFM*OTUJ
UVUP EF #JPUJDB  6OJWFSTJEBE $BUMJDB
1PSUVHVFTB 1PSUP
 Z FY QSFTJEFOUF EF
MB"TPDJBDJO.VOEJBMEF.EJDPT$B
UMJDPT FTBVUPSZDPPSEJOBEPSEFNV
DIPTUSBCBKPTFOFMSFBEFUJDBNEJDB
ZCJPUJDB FOUSFFMMPT%JSFJUPTEP)PNFN
F#JPNFEJDJOB 1PSUP 6OJWFSTJEBEF$B
UMJDB &EJUPSB 
6NmPEFUJDB
$PJNCSB (SmDBEF$PJNCSB 

.BSUB-VDB1SF[FTMJDFODJBEBFO'JMP
TPGB EFTBSSPMMBUSBCBKPTMJHBEPTBMB$
UFESBEF'JMPTPGB.EJDBEFMB'BDVMUBE
EF$JFODJBT.EJDBTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
/BDJPOBMEF-B1MBUB "SHFOUJOB
-FP1FTTJOJ%PDUPSFO5FPMPHB.P
SBM*OWFTUJHBEPSZQSPGFTPSFOFMDVSTP
EF.BFTUSBTUSJDUPTFOTVFO#JPUJDBEFM
$FOUSP6OJWFSTJUBSJP4P$BNJMP7JDF
QSFTJEFOUFEFMB4PDJFEBEEF#JPUJDBEF
4P 1BVMP 
 .JFNCSP EFM
DPNJU PSHBOJ[BEPS EFM 7* $POHSFTP
.VOEJBMEF#JPUJDBFO#SBTJMJB 

RVF BCPSE FM UFNB i#JPUJDB  QPEFS F
JOKVTUJDJBw "VUPS EF EJWFSTPT MJCSPT FO
FMSFBEFUJDB CJPUJDBZUFPMPHBNP
SBM BMHVOPTUSBEVDJEPTBMFTQBPMFOUSF

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

PUSPT%JTUBOTJBBURVBOEPQSPMPOHBSB
WJEB 41BVMP &E-PZPMB 
&VUB
OTJBQPSRVFBCSFWJBSBWJEB 41BVMP 
&E-PZPMB 
DPBVUPSEF)VNBOJ
[BP F DVJEBEPT QBMJBUJWPT )VNBOJ[B
UJPOBOEQBMMJBUJWFDBSF 41BVMP -PZP
MB  
 DPBVUPS EF 1SPCMFNBT BUVBJT
EF CJPUJDB 4 1BVMP  -PZPMB  B &E 

$PPSEJOBEPSEFFTUFWPMVNFO
.JHVFM 4VB[P  NEJDP  FTUVEJ FO MB
6OJWFSTJEBE "VUOPNB EF 4BOUP %P
NJOHP 3FQCMJDB %PNJOJDBOB
 4F
FTQFDJBMJ[ FO FEVDBDJO TFYVBM Z FT
.BFTUSP FO 4FYPMPHB 3FQCMJDB %P
NJOJDBOB
 &T .BFTUSP FO #JPUJDB
6OJWFSTJEBE EF $IJMF  014  

&TBDUVBMNFOUFEFDBOPEFM*OT
UJUVUP5FDOPMHJDPEF4BOUP%PNJOHP
*OUFD
 Z FT EJSFDUPS EFM $FOUSP *OUFD
EF#JPUJDBZDPPSEJOBEPSEFMDVSTPEF
&TQFDJBMJ[BDJOFO#JPUJDBFOMBNJTNB
JOTUJUVDJO
/VSJB5FSSJCBTFTBCPHBEBFJOWFTUJHB
EPSBFONBUFSJBTEFEFSFDIP%JSFDUPSB
EFM *OTUJUVUP #PSKB EFM #JPUJDB *##

EFTEF   TVDFEJFOEP B 'SBODFTD
"CFM &OTFB FO FM *## Z DPPSEJOB FM
DVSTP EF .BFTUSB FO #JPUJDB %FTEF
 FEJUBMBSFWJTUB#JPUJDBZ%FCBU Z
FTDPOTVMUPSBEF%FSFDIPFODPNJTJPOFT
EFM (PWFSOP "VUOPNP EF $BUBMVB
QBSBDVFTUJPOFTCJPUJDBT

5SBEVDUPSFT
"EBJM4PCSBMFTUSBEVDUPSEFJOHMT GSBO
DT Z FTQBPM  QSJODJQBMNFOUF FO DJFO
DJBTIVNBOBT mMPTPGBZTBMVE%PDUPS
FO -JOHTUJDB "QMJDBEB Z DPO FTUVEJPT





"QOEJDFT

EFMMFOHVBKF 1POUJmDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$B
UMJDBEF4P1BVMP
FTBVUPSEFMJCSPT
BDFSDB EFM EJTDVSTP Z EF MB USBEVDDJO 
Z USBEVDUPS EF MB SFWJTUB 0 .VOEP EB
4BEF QVCMJDBEBQPSFM$FOUSP6OJWFS
TJUBSJP4P$BNJMP&TUBNCJOSFWJTPS
EF MFOHVB JOHMFTB EF MB SFWJTUB "QQMJFE
$BODFS3FTFBSDI QVCMJDBEBQPS)PTQJUBM
EFM$ODFS"$$BNBSHP
.BSJB4UFMB(POBMWFTFTUSBEVDUPSBEF
FTQBPM GSBODTFJOHMT QSJODJQBMNFO
UFFOFMSFBEFMBTDJFODJBTIVNBOBTZEF
MBTBMVE.BFTUSBFO-JOHTUJDB 6/*

PERSPETIVADELABIOETICAINDD

$".1
 FT USBEVDUPSB EF MB SFWJTUB 0
.VOEPEB4BEF QVCMJDBEPQPSFM$FO
USP6OJWFSTJUBSJP4P$BNJMP
.BSUB(MVLNBO4BMJUBFTQSPGFTPSBEF
'SBODT  7JTJUJOH  1SPGFTTPS %VLF 6OJ
WFSTJUZ %VSIBN /PSUI$BSPMJOB%FT
FNQF EJWFSTPT DBSHPT FO MB 'BDVMUBE
EF'JMPTPGBZ-FUSBTEFMB6OJWFSTJEBE
EF $IJMF Z  BDUVBMNFOUF  DPMBCPSB DPO
FM$FOUSP*OUFSEJTDJQMJOBSJPEF&TUVEJPT
FO#JPUJDBEFMBNJTNBVOJWFSTJEBEZFO
MBFEJDJOEF"DUB#JPFUIJDB SFWJTUBEFM
QSPHSBNBEF#JPUJDBEF0140.4



S-ar putea să vă placă și