Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Copyright 2010 by the University of Virginia Darden School Foundation, Charlottesville, VA. All
rights reserved. For customer service inquiries, send an e-mail tosales@dardenbusinesspublishing.com. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, posted to the Internet,
or transmitted in any form or by any meanselectronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwisewithout the permission of the Darden School Foundation.
Rev. Mar. 20, 2013
Exhibit 9
SUN MICROSYST
IT Companies Financi
(market data as of April
Ticker
Stock
Price
($)
Shares
Out
(MM)
Market
Cap
($MM)
Primarily Hardware
Advanced Micro Devices
Apple
Dell
EMC
Hewlett-Packard
Intel
International Business Machines
NetApp
Sun Microsystems
AMD
AAPL
DELL
EMC
HPQ
INTC
IBM
NTAP
JAVA
3.56
123.42
11.06
12.81
36.30
15.60
101.27
17.59
6.69
609
889
1,944
2,041
2,416
2,562
1,343
330
739
2,168
109,713
21,505
26,142
87,708
39,967
136,052
5,808
4,941
Primarily Software
Adobe Systems
Microsoft
Novell
Oracle
Red Hat
ADBE
MSFT
NOVL
ORCL
RHT
24.70
19.20
3.94
19.06
18.32
524
8,896
343
5,046
190
12,944
170,795
1,353
96,180
3,482
Exhibit 9
SUN MICROSYSTEMS
IT Companies Financial Data
(market data as of April 17, 2009)
BV
Debt
($MM)
Levered
Beta
4,988
2,011
3,404
20,458
1,988
33,925
1,265
1,257
2.19
1.11
1.12
1.39
1.25
1.20
0.93
1.80
1.73
350
2,000
122
11,238
-
1.32
0.99
1.50
1.27
1.20
Bond
Rating
B
A2
A2
A1
A1
Ba1
Aaa
B1
A2
BB
Cash &
Investments
($MM)
LTM
Sales
($MM)
LTM
EBIT
($MM)
LTM
EBITDA
($MM)
933
24,490
9,546
6,446
10,140
8,840
12,907
2,604
3,061
5,808
37,096
61,101
14,876
118,697
37,586
103,630
3,464
13,438
(1,955)
7,984
3,190
1,569
10,354
8,954
16,715
116
(2,231)
(732)
8,739
3,959
2,626
14,175
13,570
22,165
286
(1,757)
2,018
31,447
1,067
12,624
663
3,476
961
22,128
10
8,406
80
1,231
24,485
55
10,291
119
61,981
940
23,630
628
LTM
Earnings
($MM)
EBITDA
MULTIPLE
(3,098)
5,728
2,478
1,346
8,050
5,292
12,334
101
n/a
(8.5)
9.8
3.5
8.8
6.9
2.4
7.1
15.6
(1.8)
1.07
2.30
0.23
1.55
0.83
0.88
1.52
1.29
0.23
(3.18)
10.67
4.38
14.72
9.47
3.70
9.40
38.37
(1.41)
809
17,232
(15)
5,739
85
9.2
5.8
7.4
9.2
23.7
3.24
2.28
0.43
4.01
4.49
11.74
6.39
41.04
11.28
35.04
7.0
1.5
12.3
Average
Exhibit 10
SUN MICROSYSTEMS
Relevant Security Yields, April 2009
5.50%
5.77%
6.27%
6.35%
6.50%
7.54%
7.62%
8.64%
11.42%
11.49%
11.70%
13.28%
14.70%
15.46%
0.34%
0.54%
1.22%
1.71%
2.82%
3.66%
Data sources: Mergent Bond Record, U.S. Treasury, and Ibbotson Associates.
Exhibit 11
SUN MICROSYSTEMS
Sun Microsystems Historical and Projected Balance Sheet
(in millions of U.S. dollars)
Fiscal Year-End June 30
###
Assets
Current Assets
Cash(1)
Marketable Debt Securities
Net Receivables
Inventory
Deferred Prepaid Taxes(2)
Other Current Assets
Total Current Assets
Property, Plant, & Equipment, Net
Goodwill
Intangible Assets
Other Noncurrent Assets
Total Assets
3,620
2,322
2,964
524
200
1,058
10,688
1,504
2,514
633
499
15,838
2,222
1
2,047
1,182
5,451
1,264
659
1,285
8,659
Stockholders Equity
Common Stock
Treasury Stock
Retained Earnings
Other Stockholders Equity
Total Stockholders Equity
6,987
(311)
189
314
7,179
15,838
(1) (Sun Microsystems) long-term strategy is to maintain a minimum amount of cash and cash equivalents in subsidiaries for operational pu
invest the remaining amount of our cash in interest-bearing and highly liquid cash equivalents and marketable debt securities.
(2) Deferred taxes and related accounts are not expected to vary with sales or continue to accumulate as a company growth.
(3) Includes deferred settlement income from Microsoft as of June 30, 2009, 2008, 2007, and 2006, long-term tax liabilities as of June 30, 20
2007, and 2006 and long-term restructuring liabilities.
nce Sheet
2009E
2,272
1,038
3,019
680
216
1,218
8,443
1,611
3,215
565
506
14,340
1,876
1,185
2,258
566
188
995
7,068
1,616
1,743
269
536
11,232
2,121
2,236
1,311
5,668
1,265
683
1,136
8,752
1,600
554
2,341
1,126
5,621
695
635
976
7,927
7,391
(2,726)
430
493
5,588
7,582
(2,569)
(2,055)
347
3,305
14,340
11,232
as a company growth.
Exhibit 12
SUN MICROSYSTEMS
Oracle Historical and Projected Balance Sheet
(in millions of U.S. dollars)
7,020
4,589
1,274
12,883
1,603
13,479
5,964
643
34,572
11,043
5,799
1,261
18,103
1,688
17,991
8,395
1,091
47,268
12,624
4,430
1,527
18,581
1,922
18,842
7,269
802
47,416
315
1,358
7,714
9,387
6,235
1,121
910
17,653
383
1,001
8,645
10,029
10,235
1,218
2,761
24,243
271
1,001
7,877
9,149
9,237
480
3,460
22,326
Stockholders Equity
Common Stock
Treasury Stock
Retained Earnings
Other Stockholders Equity
Total Stockholders Equity
10,293
6,223
403
16,919
12,446
9,961
618
23,025
12,980
11,894
216
25,090
34,572
47,268
47,416
Exhibit 13
SUN MICROSYSTEMS
Oracle Historical and Projected Income Statement
(in millions of U.S. dollars)
Software Revenues
Services Revenues
Net Revenue
Selling, General, & Administrative
Research & Development
Amortization of Intangible Assets
Other Operating Expense
Total Operating Expense
Operating Income
Income Tax on Operations
Net Operating Profit After Tax
Effective Corporate Tax Rate
Data sources: Company filings and case writer estimates.
2007
14,211
3,785
17,996
8,790
2,195
878
159
12,022
5,974
1,709
4,265
165
14,586
7,844
2,316
5,528
234
14,931
8,321
2,380
5,941
28.6%
29.5%
28.6%
Exhibit 14
SUN MICROSYSTEMS
Sun Microsystems Historical and Projected Inc
(in millions of U.S. dollars)
2007
13,873
7,608
6,265
3,851
2,008
97
5,956
309
###
13,880
7,425
6,455
3,955
1,834
###
294
6,083
372
517
34.4%
476
29.5%
Net PP&E
1,611
11.6%
1,616
11.6%
Net Revenue
Cost of Sales
Gross Margin
Selling, General, & Administrative
Research & Development
Impairment of Goodwill
Other Operating Expense
Total Operating Expense
Operating Income
as % of Sales
Data sources: Company filings and case writer estimates.
Exhibit 14
SUN MICROSYSTEMS
stems Historical and Projected Income Statement
(in millions of U.S. dollars)
2009E
11,449
6,718
4,731
3,461
1,648
1,460
398
6,967
(2,236)
2012E
13,526
7,735
5,791
2013E
13,885
7,889
5,996
4,839
141
4,992
472
5,121
670
5,249
747
474
29.3%
536
30.0%
456
30.0%
470
30.0%
487
30.0%
1,788
15.6%
1,520
12.0%
1,566
12.0%
1,623
12.0%
1,666
12.0%
2014E
14,243
8,075
6,168
5,372
796
500
30.0%
1,709
12.0%
Exhibit 14
SUN MICROSYSTEMS
(in millions of U.S. dollars)
Net Revenue
Cost of Sales
Gross Margin
Selling, General, & Administrative
Research & Development
Impairment of Goodwill
Other Operating Expense
Total Operating Expense
Operating Income
EBIT*(1-T)
PPE
Net PPE
NWC
as % of Sales
Net NWC
Depreciation & Amortization
as % of Prior Year PP&E
Net PP&E
as % of Sales
Without Synergy
FCF
Terminal Value
Enterprise Value
Interest
Tax*(EBIT-Interest)
Equity Cash Flow
Equity Value of Firm
With Synergy
Net Revenue
Cost of Sales
Gross Margin
Selling, General, & Administrative
Research & Development
Impairment of Goodwill
Other Operating Expense
Total Operating Expense
2007
13,873
7,608
6,265
3,851
2,008
97
5,956
309
201
1,611
1,142
###
13,880
7,425
6,455
3,955
1,834
###
294
6,083
372
242
1,616
5
1,485
517
34.4%
1,611
11.6%
343
476
29.5%
1,616
11.6%
13,873
7,608
6,265
3,851
2,008
97
5,956
13,880
7,425
6,455
3,955
1,834
###
294
6,083
Customer Attrition
Integration Charges
Increase in Operating Income
Operating Income
EBIT*(1-T)
FCF
Terminal Value
Enterprise value
Interest
Tax*(EBIT-Interest)
Equity Cash Flow
Equity Value of Firm
Synergy Effect
Using Multiple
Industry EBIT multiple
Industry EBITDA multiple
Industry Sales Multiple
Using EBIT Multiples from Intel
Using EBIT Multiples from IBM
12931
4187 The companies given in exhibit 9 are b
19222 good idea to stick to industry averages
3895
9897
Exhibit 14
SUN MICROSYSTEMS
(in millions of U.S. dollars)
2009E
11,449
6,718
4,731
3,461
1,648
1,460
398
6,967
(2,236)
(1,453)
1,788
172
1,093
2012E
13,526
7,735
5,791
2013E
13,885
7,889
5,996
(392)
474
29.3%
1,788
15.6%
4,839
141
92
1,520
(268)
1,209
10.6%
116
536
30.0%
1,520
12.0%
4,992
472
307
1,566
46
1,246
3.0%
36
456
30.0%
1,566
12.0%
5,121
670
436
1,623
57
1,291
3.7%
46
470
30.0%
1,623
12.0%
5,249
747
486
1,666
43
1,326
2.7%
34
487
30.0%
1,666
12.0%
(759)
780
680
802
895
11,693
9,269
142.64
-832.52
(852)
7,335
79.37
21.57
174
Share Price
79.37
137.42
629
12.54
79.37
206.72
750
79.37
233.67
844
12,665
7,685
4,980
2,248
1,545
13,047
7,583
5,464
2,319
1,594
13,526
7,735
5,791
2,379
1,635
13,885
7,889
5,996
2,438
1,676
143
3,936
148
4,061
152
4,166
155
4,270
11,449
6,718
4,731
3,461
1,648
1,460
398
6,967
45
750
350
(2,236)
(1,453)
(759)
249
162
850
1,053
685
1,058
900
1,625
1,056
1,423
15,777
144.46
-833.16
(853)
13,209
144.46
36.47
202
Share Price
142.64
318.69
965
21.35
79.37
541.06
1,371
900
1,726
1,122
1,532
19794
79.37
576.37
1,480
6,508
companies given in exhibit 9 are bigger than Sun Microsystem and hence we may end up over valuing the firm. Hence it might b
d idea to stick to industry averages.
Tax Rate
2014E
14,243
8,075
6,168
5,372
796
517
1,709
43
1,360
2.6%
34
500
30.0%
1,709
12.0%
940
79.37
250.82
889
14,243
8,075
6,168
2,495
1,715
159
4,370
35%
Staff Expense
SG&A
25%
22%
60%
Sun MicroSystem
Debt (BV)
Shares
Share Price
Equity(MV)
Beta (Levered)
Rf
kd
Rp
ke
WACC
Oracle
Debt (BV)
Shares
Share Price
Equity(MV)
Beta (Levered)
Rf
kd
Rp
ke
Unlevered Beta
New Beta Levered
WACC
Growth Rate
R&D
32% 27% 4%
32%
2009
1257 Wd
739
6.69
4944 We
1.73 Given
3.66% 30 year bond
11.42% Rating - Ba1
5%
12.31%
11.32%
20%
80%
Exhibit 9
Exhibit 10
Exhibit 10
>2014
11238 Wd
5046
19.06
96177 We
1.27 Given
3.66% 30 year bond
6.35% Rating - A2
5%
11.65%
1.48
1.60
10.86%
2.82%
10%
90%
Exhibit 9
Exhibit 10
Exhibit 10
900
1,798
1,169
1,591
79.37
601.55
1,540
2011-2014
Debt
703 W'd
Equity
4944 W'e
Unlevered Beta
New Beta
New ke
12%
88%
1.48
1.62
11.77%
Net Revenue
Cost of Sales
Gross Margin
Selling, General, & Administrative
Research & Development
Impairment of Goodwill
Other Operating Expense
Total Operating Expense
Operating Income
EBIT*(1-T)
PPE
Net PPE
NWC
as % of Sales
Net NWC
Depreciation & Amortization
as % of Prior Year PP&E
Net PP&E
as % of Sales
Without Synergy
FCF
Terminal Value
Enterprise Value
Interest
Tax*(EBIT-Interest)
Equity Cash Flow
Equity Value of Firm
With Synergy
Net Revenue
Cost of Sales
Gross Margin
Selling, General, & Administrative
Research & Development
Impairment of Goodwill
Other Operating Expense
Total Operating Expense
###
13,873
7,608
6,265
3,851
2,008
97
5,956
309
201
1,611
1,142
###
13,880
7,425
6,455
3,955
1,834
294
6,083
372
242
1,616
5
1,485
517
34.4%
1,611
11.6%
343
476
29.5%
1,616
11.6%
Exhibit 14
SUN MICROSYSTEMS
(in millions of U.S. dollars)
Fiscal Yea
2009E
11,449
6,718
4,731
3,461
1,648
1,460
398
6,967
(2,236)
(1,453)
1,788
172
1,093
(392)
474
29.3%
1,788
15.6%
(1,233)
3,239
142.64
-832.52
(1,326)
1,741
13,873
7,608
6,265
3,851
2,008
97
5,956
13,880
7,425
6,455
3,955
1,834
294
6,083
11,449
6,718
4,731
3,461
1,648
1,460
398
6,967
Customer Attrition
Integration Charges
Increase in Operating Income
Operating Income
EBIT*(1-T)
FCF
Terminal Value
Enterprise value
Interest
Tax*(EBIT-Interest)
Equity Cash Flow
Equity Value of Firm
(2,236)
(1,453)
(1,233)
9,747
144.46
-833.16
(1,327)
7,615
Synergy Effect
Using Multiple
Industry EBIT multiple
Industry EBITDA multiple
Industry Sales Multiple
Using EBIT Multiples from Intel
Using EBIT Multiples from IBM
6,508
12931
4187 The companies given in exhibit 9 are bigger than Su
19222 be a good idea to stick to industry averages.
3895
9897
Exhibit 14
MICROSYSTEMS
llions of U.S. dollars)
Fiscal Year-End June 30
2010E
2011E
12,665
13,047
7,685
7,583
4,980
5,464
2012E
13,526
7,735
5,791
2013E
13,885
7,889
5,996
2014E
14,243
8,075
6,168
4,839
141
92
1,520
(268)
1,209
10.6%
116
536
30.0%
1,520
12.0%
4,992
472
307
1,566
46
1,246
3.0%
36
456
30.0%
1,566
12.0%
5,121
670
436
1,623
57
1,291
3.7%
46
470
30.0%
1,623
12.0%
5,249
747
486
1,666
43
1,326
2.7%
34
487
30.0%
1,666
12.0%
5,372
796
517
1,709
43
1,360
2.6%
34
500
30.0%
1,709
12.0%
243
224
332
408
5,476
440
79.37
21.57
(362)
Share Price
79.37
137.42
173
4.38
79.37
206.72
281
79.37
233.67
357
79.37
250.82
389
12,665
7,685
4,980
2,248
1,545
13,047
7,583
5,464
2,319
1,594
13,526
7,735
5,791
2,379
1,635
13,885
7,889
5,996
2,438
1,676
14,243
8,075
6,168
2,495
1,715
143
3,936
148
4,061
152
4,166
155
4,270
159
4,370
45
750
350
249
162
313
1,053
685
602
900
1,625
1,056
953
144.46
36.47
(335)
Share Price
142.64
318.69
510
13.19
79.37
541.06
902
900
1,726
1,122
1,045
13577
900
1,798
1,169
1,092
79.37
576.37
993
79.37
601.55
1,040
n exhibit 9 are bigger than Sun Microsystem and hence we may end up over valuing the firm. Hence it might
to industry averages.
Tax Rate
Staff Expense
35%
SG&A R&D
25%
32% 22%
27% 60%
4%
32%
Sun MicroSystem
Debt (BV)
Shares
Share Price
Equity(MV)
Beta (Levered)
Rf
kd
Rp
ke
WACC
2009
1257 Wd
739
6.69
4944 We
1.73 Given
3.66% 30 year bond
11.42% Rating - Ba1
5%
12.31%
11.32%
Oracle
Debt (BV)
Shares
Share Price
Equity(MV)
Beta (Levered)
Rf
kd
Rp
ke
Unlevered Beta
New Beta Levered
WACC
Growth Rate
>2014
11238 Wd
5046
19.06
96177 We
1.27 Given
3.66% 30 year bond
6.35% Rating - A2
5%
11.65%
1.48
1.60
10.86%
2.82%
2011-2014
20% Debt
703 W'd
80% Equity
Exhibit 9
Exhibit 10
Exhibit 10
10%
90%
Exhibit 9
Exhibit 10
Exhibit 10
4944 W'e
Unlevered Beta
New Beta
New ke
12%
88%
1.48
1.62
11.77%