Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
dstallworth@ofsoptics.com
David Stallworth
and
RFOG
CENTRALIZED OR
DISTRIBUTED SPLITTER
SPLITTER
CONNECTORS
DROP CONNECTORS
PON DISTRIBUTION
CABLE
FIBER
TERMINATION
CENTRALIZED CABINET
FEEDER CABLE
HEADEND
ELECTRONICS
(Optical Line
Card)
CUSTOMER
END
ELECTRONICS
FIBER DROP
PON DROP
CLOSURES
GEOGRAPHY
FUSION SPLICING
S P L IT T E R L O C A T IO N
D RO P C O NTR A C T C O STS
F IB E R D R O P
P O N D IS T R IB U T IO N
CABLE
PON DESIGN
HELP!
FEEDER CABLE
DISTRIBUTED SPLITTERS
SPLITTER LOCATION
CENTRALIZED CABINET
TAKE RATE
HEADEND ELECTRONICS
INSTALLATION LABOR
DROP
CONNECTORS
CONSTRUCTION LABOR
SPLITTER
CONNECTORS
OPTICOST MODELS
PROVIDE
THE ANSWER
study technique)
(classic cost
Ideal Location?
EACH SQUARE IS
500 LONG AND
500 WIDE
EACH SQUARE IS
A 32 HOME PON
AN IDEAL AREA
Drop Closure
Pedestal
(Drop
Closure)
Drop Cable
Aerial
Distribution
Cable
MDU
Termination
MDU
Residential
Family
Single
10
10
10
10
Cost
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
Cost increase
from Ideal
20 km
Hub/
Node
Why?
Provide 20km reach to all subscribers
Hub/
Node
Why?
Minimize cable lengths
and sizes
20 km
Hub/
Node
Why?
Provide 20km reach to all subscribers
Why?
Minimize cable lengths
and sizes
20 km
Hub/
Node
Ideal Location
Ideal Location
Phase 2
Phase 3
The problem:
Developments built in phases
Phase 1
10
32 HOME
PON AREAS
USE
160 HOME
CABINET
10
32 HOME
PON AREAS
EACH SQUARE IS
500 LONG AND
500 WIDE
EACH SQUARE IS
A 32 HOME PON
AN IDEAL AREA
256
Homes/
cabinet
512
Homes/
cabinet
1024
Homes/
cabinet
32
Homes/
cabinet
64
Homes/
cabinet
128
Homes/
cabinet
Cabinet Size:
Overall Costs
1024
512
128
Cabinet Size
256
64
Cabinet Size:
$/S UB
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
PLAN NUMBER
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
35%
30%
20%
10%
200
100
400
300
600
500
800
700
900
MDUs
6
500'
3
1028
512
256
128
64
32
0.6
0.3
0.2
Single Family
700'
15
100' 300'
CONCLUSIONS
OUTSIDE VALIDATION:
CO OR
HEADEND
MAIN
FEEDER
BRANCH
FEEDER
FEEDER DESIGN
Definitions
CO OR
HEADEND
FEEDER
FEEDER
BOUNDARY
10
10
10
10
Cost
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
Cost increase
from Ideal
Ultimate needs
At least 10 years
Design to last
CO OR
HEADEND
MAIN
FEEDER
BRANCH
FEEDER
FEEDER DESIGN
Definitions
For FTTH:
Decentralized/
Distributed
Centralized
Home Run
Economic Justification
splitters in a cabinet
Cabinet
At what
Cost?
Use
Efficiently
Centralized
Economic Reasons
to place a Cabinet
O
N
T
O
N
T
O
N
T
O
N
T
O
N
T
O
N
T
O
N
T
O
N
T
O
N
T
O
N
T
O
N
T
O
N
T
O
N
T
O
N
T
20 HOMES
O
N
T
TAKE RATE = 15 / 20 OR
O
N
T
TAKE RATE
DEFINITION
$ P E R S U B S C R IB E R
2400
2200
2000
1800
1600
1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
100
90
80
INCREMENTAL
ELECTRONICS $/SUB
70
50
TAKE RATE %
60
40
30
20
10
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
$ P E R S U B S C R IB E R
100
90
CENT. CABINET
$/SUB
80
70
TAKE RATE %
60
50
40
30
20
10
1200
1400
1600
200
400
600
800
1000
$ PER SUBSCRIBER
100
90
CENT. CABINET
$/SUB
INCREMENTAL
ELECTRONICS $/SUB
80
70
60
50
TAKE RATE %
40
30
20
10
LOW
100
HOUSING DENSITY
HIGH
90
80
60
TAKE RATE
70
50
40
30
CABINETS
20
SPLITTERS IN
8 KFT
Economic Justification
or
Cabinet or Headend/Node
Optical Splitters in a
6000
1-12 fiber cable
6000
1000
1-12 fiber cable
1 shelf to terminate
12 fibers
1 shelf to terminate
12 fibers
Central Office
6000
2-144 fiber cables
9-1x32 splitters
Cent. Cabinet
9-1x32 splitters
In field in drop
closures
Bay to terminate
288 fibers
Central Office
Shelf with 9
x32 splitters
Central Office
PLAN 1- CO SPLITTERS
288
homes
288
homes
288
homes
$/S u b
20
40
60
80
100
1000'
2000'
3000'
4000'
Distance to CO
5000'
CO VS. CABINETS
Centralized
Cabinet
Cost
CO Splitter
Cost
DISTANCE TO CO
8KFT
CABINETS
CO
SPLITTERS IN
SPLITTERS IN
CO vs. CABINETS
LOW
100
HOUSING DENSITY
HIGH
90
80
60
TAKE RATE
70
50
40
CO
30
20
SPLITTERS IN
CABINETS
SPLITTERS IN
8 KFT
Economic Justification
or
or Distributed
Cabinet /Headend/Node
Optical Splitters in a
Closure
Assembly
Closure Trays
DISTRIBUTED SPLITTING
DESIGN
STEP:
DEFINE
PON AREAS
CONFIDENTIAL
AND PROPRIETARY
PROPERTY OF BUCKEYE CABLEVISION INC.
DO NOT DISTRIBUTE OR DUPLICATE
STEP:
DETERMINE
SPLITTER
LOCATIONS
CONFIDENTIAL
AND PROPRIETARY
PROPERTY OF BUCKEYE CABLEVISION INC.
DO N OT DISTRIBUTE OR DUPLICATE
STEP:
DETERMINE
FIBER CABLE
ROUTES AND
SIZES
CONFIDENTIAL
AND PROPRIETARY
PROPERTY OF BUCKEYE CABLEVISION INC.
DO NOT DISTRIBUTE OR DUPLICATE
6000
2-144 fiber cables
1 shelf
terminate
1 shelf
to to
terminate
1212
fibers
fibers
6000
1000
1-12
fiber
cable
1-12
fiber
cable
9-1x32
splitters
9-1x32
splitters
Cabinet
InCent.
field in
drop
closures
PLAN
FIELD
SPLITTERS
PLAN
3- 2FIELD
SPLITTERS
Bay to terminate
288 fibers
Central
Office
Central
Office
Shelf with 9
1x32 splitters
Central Office
PLAN 1- CO SPLITTERS
CO vs. SPLITTERS IN
EACH PON
(DISTRIBUTED)
288
288
homes
homes
288
homes
DISTANCE TO CO
EACH PON
SPLITTERS IN
CO vs. SPLITTERS IN
EACH PON
8KFT
1200
1400
1600
200
400
600
800
1000
$ P E R S U B S C R IB E R
100
90
CENT. CABINET
$/SUB
INCREMENTAL
ELECTRONICS $/SUB
80
70
60
50
TAKE RATE %
40
30
20
10
LOW
100
HOUSING DENSITY
HIGH
90
80
60
TAKE RATE
70
EACH PON
SPLITTERS IN
50
40
CO
30
20
SPLITTERS IN
CABINETS
SPLITTERS IN
8 KFT
Home
Run
1
2
2
2
Issue
Upgrade
New Install
Troubleshoot
Reliability
Centralized Distributed
Operational Concerns:
Density
Labor Rate
Fundamental Design
2 factors affect
DAP Design
(inside 32 home PON area)
Labor Rate:
PON Design
(inside 32 home PON area)
250
300
Connectors on Drop
SplicedDouble
SplicedQuad
Direct- Mid
Split
Spliced
Direct Feed
Conventional
Conclusion:
Conventional Design is the most economical
when fusion splicing is used
up to a labor rate of $65-75/hr
50
100
150
200
$/SUBSCRIBER
Design?
How does
PON Design
(inside 32 home PON area)
Housing Density:
Subdivisions
Normal Density:
High Rises
Apartments
Most Dense:
Housing Density:
High Rises
OSP
Closure
Cable
Riser
Combiner
FDH
Drop
Terminal
ONT
Floor
Ceiling
Drop Cable
Terminal
Combiner
FDH
Four Components:
cabling:
FDH
Housing Density:
apartments)
(campus-style
Units (MDU)
Multi- Dwelling
400
200
100
90
80
70
50
TURNOVER %
60
TRUCK ROLL
40
ADD'L ELECTRONICS
$/SUB
30
20
10
600
$ PER SUBSCRIBER
MDU CONCLUSIONS
Housing Density:
Subdivisions
Normal Density:
PON Design
(inside 32 home PON area)
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
100'
200'
400'
SplicedDouble
SplicedQuad
Direct- Mid
Split
Spliced
Direct Feed
Conventional
Conclusion:
Conventional Design is the most economical
For all SFR densities
50' Lots
$/SUBSCRIBER
11
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
12
10
ORANGE
BLUE
Distributed Splitting
Housing Density:
Least Dense:
Rural Areas
1x16
1x2
1x8
1x4
1x4
1x8
1x32
1x2
1x4
1x8
1x2
1x4
1x2
12 fiber
1x4
12 fiber
1x8
12 fiber
1x32
24 fiber
1x2
1x4
1x2
1x4
1x8
1x2
1x4
1x2
1x4
5000
6000
7000
0 0
1000
2000
3000
4000
TO TAL CO S T
3
5
7
9
PON DISTANCE IN KFT
11
1X4/1
X8
SPLI
TTER
1X32
SPLI
TTER
8
8
8
8
Rural Area
LOW
100
HOUSING DENSITY
HIGH
90
80
70
60
50
TAKE RATE
EACH PON
SPLITTERS IN
40
30
CO
20
10
SPLITTERS IN
CABINETS
SPLITTERS IN
RURAL AREA
8 KFT
6
4
2
0
PON Design
(inside 32 home PON area)
build dates
Lessens Learned:
1 Fiber to each
unit in towm
fromCOor node
Splitters in
COor node
Vertical quick
connect design
HIgh Rise
No
SIngle Family
Connectorized
Drop
Design
Conventional
Design
Fusion Splice Drops
Yes
Yes
1x32 Distributed
Splitting
Optional
Inside Small Towns
loop cable
Distribute
Splitters
Campus Style
Multi-Dwelling
Housing Density
Conventional
Design
Fusion Splice Drops
1x4/8 Distributed
Splitting
No
Yes
No
Vertical quick
connect design
HIgh Rise
>50%
Take Rate
Yes
Yes
1x32 Splitters
in 256home
cabinets
1 Fiber to each
unit from
cabinet or node
Splitters in
cabinet or
onsite node
Campus Style
Conventional
Design
Fusion Splice Drops
Multi-Dwelling
Yes
No
SIngle Family
Connectorized
Drop
Design
1 Fiber to each
unit from
COor node
Splittersin
COor node
Customers >
4000' fromCO
or node
No
Housing Density
Conventional
Design
Fusion Splice Drops
1x4/8 Distributed
Splitting
No
Flow Chart
Design Decision
FTTH ACTUAL
EXAMPLES
32
19
64
13 0 0'
2 4 fib er
SS
31
S
35 0'
1 2 fib er
32
27 00 '
2 4 fib er
22 00 '
2 4 fib er
32
S
14 00 '
3 6 fib er
30 0'
2 4 fib er
60 0'
2 4 fib er
45 0 '
1 2 fib er
32 00 '
3 6 fib er
90 0'
3 6 fib er
12 0'
er
1 2 fib
16
15 50 '
3 6 fib er
17 00 '
2 4 fib er
32
30 0'
er
1 2 fib
1 50 0'
3 6 fib er
29
To Headend/CO
12 50 '
2 4 fib er
64
32
13 00 '
er
3 6 fib
60 0'
1 2 fib er
12 00 '
3 6 fib er
S
19
SS
S
S
3S2
64
65 0'
1 2 fib er
17 5'
er
1 2 fib
70 0 '
er
2 4 fib
90 0'
1 2 fib er
3 1S
17 50 '
2 4 fib er
12 00 '
er
2 4 fib
11 00 '
3 6 fib er
32
15 00 '
er
2 4 fib
15 50 '
er
2 4 fib
10 00 '
2 4 fib er
70 0'
1 2 fib er
23 50 '
2 4 fib er
32
12
2S7
Amount
4245
20100
12150
18
126
83000
Fiber Cable:
Size
12 FIBER
24 FIBER
36 FIBER
CLOSURES
Fiber Drop
AT-3BE8T7X-002
300524378
Order Code
AT-3BE12YT-012
AT-3BE12YT-024
AT-3BE12YT-036
0.284
0.35
Grand Total:
Cost per home passed including drop:
0.14
$42,340
total
$53,960
$98.29
$11,620
$77
18900
12600
Cost
$879
$5,708
$4,253
150
700
0.207
Description
R1-1X32-FULL-UNC-00-BAL
Planning
Price
1800'
24 FIBER
CABLE
32
24
FIBER
CABLE
32
2300'
24 FIBER
CABLE
32
32
32
32
36 FIBER
CABLE
900'
24 FIBER
CABLE
1200'
24 FIBER
CABLE
275'
12 FIBER
CABLE
32
32
32
32
250'
12 FIBER
CABLE
36 FIBER
CABLE
95'
12 FIBER
CABLE
2500'
36 FIBE
CABLE
30
32
36 FIB
CABL
650'
12 FIBER
CABLE
2750'
24
FIBER
CABLE
36 FIBER
CABLE
2000'
24 FIBER
CABLE
3100'
36 FIBER
CABLE
AMOUNT
2170
10476
7100
2600
11
73
12 FIBER
24 FIBER
36 FIBER
144 FIBER
32 SPLITTER
CLOSURES
300524378
Part#
AT-3BEH2YT-012
AT-3BEH2YT-024
AT-3BEH2YT-036
AT-3BEH2YT-144
3,124
3,380
0.44
1.3
$29,704
total
FOR PLANNING
PURPOSES ONLY
10,950
7,425
3,981
0.38
675
694
0.32
cost
150
$/unit
Description
LIGHT ARMOR_12F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
LIGHT ARMOR_24F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
LIGHT ARMOR_36F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
LIGHT ARMOR_144F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
100
1x32 splitter
CLOSURES
300524378
Part#
AT-3BE12YT-012
AT-3BE12YT-024
AT-3BE12YT-036
AT-3BEH2YT-048
73800 AT-3BE8T7X-002
24
12 FIBER
24 FIBER
36 FIBER
48 FIBER
FIBER DROP
AMOUNT
1800
13400
5500
1200
564
0.47
$35,599
total
0.14
$62
$10,332
$48
FOR
PLANNING
PURPOSES ONLY
12,500
125
PRICES ARE
2,035
0.37
16,200
3,886
0.29
675
414
cost
0.23
$/unit
Description
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_12F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_24F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_36F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_48F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
Per home
passed =
$146
Per home
passed =
$86
CONFIDENTIAL
AND PROPRIETARY
Material
cost
Material
cost
CONFIDENTIAL
AND PROPRIETARY
PROPERTY OF BUCKE YE CABLEVISION INC.
DO NOT DISTRIBUTE OR DUPLICATE
14700
48
AT-3BE8T7X-002
(meters)
AMOUNT
50
2480
1700
900
Part#
AT-3BE12YT-012
AT-3BEH2YT-036
AT-3BEH2YT-072
AT-3BEH2YT-192
14700
48
AT-3BE8T7X-002
FIBER DROP
CLOSURES
$30,387
0.47
$152
$6,909
$124
FOR
PLANNING
PURPOSES ONLY
total
4,800
6,000
5,600
150
125
6,000
3,537
3.9300
700
2,635
1.5500
6000
30
1,786
0.7200
cost
$90
$6,909
$61
0.5900
$/unit
$/mtr)
Description
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_12F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_36F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_72F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_192F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
Note: when comparing costs, add splicing cost for 84 additional splices
12 FIBER
36 FIBER
72 FIBER
192 FIBER
SPLITTER CABINET
PLAN
0.47
$15,037
total
FOR
PLANNING
PURPOSES ONLY
6,000
125
5,200
30
3,658
0.7200
650
cost
$/unit
0.5900
$/mtr)
PRICES ARE
R1-1X32-FULL-UNC-00-BAL
300524378
Description
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_12F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_24F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
Part#
AT-3BE12YT-012
AT-3BE12YT-024
FIBER DROP
CLOSURES
DISTRIBUTED SPLITTING
PLAN
(meters)
AMOUNT
12 FIBER
50
24 FIBER
5080
5130
1x32 splitter
8
ALCALU TRIAL
26
1x32 splitter
CLOSURES
300524378
LPS1-A-SCAUNC-BR-072-07-50F
Allwave Advantage MW1LC-SC-20
Part#
AT-3BE8T7X-012
AT-3BE12YT-036
AT-3BE12YT-060
AT-3BE12YT-072
29700 AT-3BE8T7X-002
2
99
Fiber Shelves
Fiber jumpers
FIBER DROP
AMOUNT
15400
9100
17000
12700
12 FIBER
36 FIBER
60 FIBER
72 FIBER
Hancock Tel
29700 AT-3BE8T7X-002
26
CLOSURES
FIBER DROP
4
14
AMOUNT
Part#
54200
AT-3BE8T7X-012
1x4 splitter
1x8 splitter
$6,850
total
0.14
PRICES ARE
$25,420
total
FOR
PLANNING
PURPOSES ONLY
2,600
100
2,800
1,485
700
3,000
15
0.48
1500
6,800
6,096
0.4
0.14
$299
$4,158
2,639
0.29
cost
3,234
0.21
$/unit
$111
$4,158
$69
FOR
PLANNING
PURPOSES ONLY
2,600
100
600
3,500
250
Description
Mini LT 12 fiber Flat drop cable
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_36F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_60F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
SINGLE JACKET-DCM_72F A W _.35/.25@1310/1550
99 living units
PRICES ARE
cost
11,382
150
0.21
$/unit
Description
Mini LT 12 fiber Flat drop cable
CO OR
HE
CO OR
HE
96
96
96
72
X
X
96
60
X
48
40
WORKING
96
72
X
48
X 96
48
30 WORKING
24
Options
15
16
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
RF
1591
1611
1471
1491
1511
1531
1550
1571
1411
1431
1451
1271
1291
1311
1331
1351
1371
1391
O1
O2
O3
O4
O5
E1
E2
E3
E4
E5
S1
S2
S3
C1
C2
L1
L2
L3
18 wavelengths
Full Spectrum-CWDM
Technology Roadmap:
Figures 1 and 2 show SEM micrographs of fiber endfaces. In both cases the cleaved fiber surface was
briefly etched in acid (48% HF for 3 minutes).
SEM micrographs taken by OFS.
FTTH Designer
770-798-2423
dstallworth@ofsoptics.com
David Stallworth
Thank You!