Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 8 July 2013
Accepted 2 September 2013
Keywords:
Braking energy regeneration
Coordinated control strategy
Fuel cell hybrid electric bus
Fuel economy
Brake safety
a b s t r a c t
This paper presents the braking energy regeneration control of a fuel cell hybrid electric bus. The conguration of the regenerative braking system based on a pneumatic braking system was proposed. To recapture the braking energy and improve the fuel economy, a control strategy coordinating the regenerative
brake and the pneumatic brake was designed and applied in the FCHB. Brake safety was also guaranteed
by the control strategy when the bus encounters critical driving situations. Fuel economy tests were
carried out under China city bus typical driving cycle. And hardware-in-the-loop tests of the brake safety
of the FCHB under proposed control strategy were also accomplished. Test results indicate that the present approach provides an improvement in fuel economy of the fuel cell hybrid electric bus and guarantees the brake safety in the meantime.
2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Due to the shortage of fossil oil sources, along with concerns
about environmental issues, alternative fuels and hybrid technologies are being more widely investigated and utilized. The fuel cell
vehicle (FCV) is favored in automotive applications due to its
characteristics of zero emission, high efciency and low noise
[13]. The research, development, demonstration and commercialization of the FCV are paid massive attention by governments and
automotive manufacturers. As one type of the FCV, fuel cell buses
(FCBs) are especially promising in China since buses are the most
widely used transportation tools. The rst FCB in China was developed in 2002, and three FCBs have been demonstrative serving in
Beijing since 2008.
Some disadvantages brought by the fuel cell technology, such as
the high price and the short lifetime, emerged in the commercialization proceedings. To overcome these shortages, hybrid technology has been widely applied in FCV to enhance the durability of
fuel cell system, and the fuel economy can be improved by utilizing
the braking energy regeneration technology, leading to the prolongation of the lifetime of the fuel cell system and reduction of the
hydrogen consumption [4]. Some FCVs based on hybrid technology
have been developed by ISE, MAN and Daimler [5], and similar
technology has been also applied in fuel cell hybrid electric bus
(FCHB) in China.
As one of the key technology in hybrid electried vehicles,
regenerative braking system (RBS) has been researched throughout
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: jzhzhang@mail.tsinghua.edu.cn (J. Zhang).
0196-8904/$ - see front matter 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.enconman.2013.09.003
1118
Nomenclature
Flf
Flr
Fmot
Ftgt
Abbreviations
ABS
anti-lock braking system
AC
alternating current
BFD
braking force distribution
CAN
controller area network
DC
direct current
FC
fuel cell
FCB
fuel cell bus
FCHB
fuel cell hybrid electric bus
FCV
FD
FL
FR
HIL
LHV
PBS
RBS
regen
RL
RR
TC
the fuel cell system converts the chemical energy into electrical energy directly to drive the vehicle. In the FCHB studied, two fuel cell
stacks, each with a rated power of 40 kW, are connected in parallel.
Table 1
Key parameters of the FCHB.
Parameter
Value
11,980/2550/3400
70
P80
625
P20
68
P200
1119
F lf F lr F mot F tgt
where Flf is the pneumatic braking force of the front wheels, Flr is
pneumatic braking force of the rear wheels, Fmot is regenerative
braking force, Ftgt is the brake demand of the driver.
To describe the coordinated strategy clearly, the correspondence between the brake force and the brake pedal stroke, and
the braking force distribution (BFD) are both shown in Fig. 4. As
shown in the left plot, the regenerative braking force is always applied to its maximum extent based on the brake request of the driver and the power limit of the powertrain, to ensure a high
regeneration efciency of the braking energy. If the regenerative
braking force cannot meet the vehicles brake demand, the pneumatic braking force will applied to supplement the rest of the
brake request. The right plot of Fig. 4 shows the design of the
BFD between the front and the rear axle. The ideal BFD can be gured out based on vehicle dynamics and parameters of the bus. But
to make it easy to be realized, the BFD of a conventional bus is usually implemented as a xed proportion between the braking forces
of the front-axle and the rear-axle. Based on the original one, the
BFD for RBS is designed. To recover more braking energy, a slight
regenerative braking force will be exerted on rear axle during the
free travel of the brake pedal. Since the adopted bus is a rearwheel-drive one, to guarantee the vehicle stability during deceleration process, when friction brake is needed, the pneumatic brake
on front-axle will be applied rstly. If the vehicles braking demand
still cannot be met, the pneumatic brake on rear-axle will be exerted. The overall braking force of the regenerative brake and the
pneumatic brake will always keep consistent with the brake demand of the vehicle.
Fig. 5 shows the conguration of the regenerative braking system applied in FCHBs. When the vehicle brakes with regenerative
braking, the total brake force will be provided by the friction braking devices and the electric motor (or solely from the electric motor in small deceleration conditions). The brake system of the FCHB
is comprised of the existing PBS, the powertrain, the axles, the nal
drive, the electric motor with motor controller, and the energy
1120
storage system, including the battery and ultra capacitors. The PBS
and the powertrain are the basis of the proposed regenerative
braking system.
As mentioned above, a coordinated regenerative braking control
strategy requires the real-time adjustment of the pneumatic braking force. To carry out the control strategy, two RBS modulating
Fig. 9. Vehicle test results under China city bus typical driving cycle.
1121
new type of the battery, the fuel economy has been improved
greatly. The comparison results are listed in Table 3.
According to the results of Table 3, the application of the Li battery results in a better fuel economy, improving the hydrogen consumption of the test bus by 11.5%. The energy loss of the battery
during charging and discharging processes can be regarded as the
main reason for the difference described above. The energy loss of
the Li battery is much lower than the Ni-MH battery. Considerable
energy can be saved when fuel cell system or RBS charge the battery,
and both of the two ways can decrease the consumption of hydrogen.
Fig. 10 shows the energy ow through the various components
of the FCHB during the road test based on China city bus typical
driving cycle. According to the gure, in the power bus, the overall
output energy of the fuel cell system is 54.2 MJ, in which 26.0 MJ of
the energy is delivered to the power bus for diving the electried
drive train, and the other 28.2 MJ is consumed as the energy loss.
Besides, the battery stack outputs 6.1 MJ of the energy to the
power bus during the test cycle. Among the overall energy in the
power bus supplied by the fuel cell system and the battery,
24.4 MJ is utilized to drive the electric motor and 7.7 MJ is consumed by accessories, including the dashboard and lights. During
the test cycle, 6.4 MJ of the energy is recaptured in the electried
drive train by the RBS, but only 4.4 MJ of the regenerated energy
is charged to the battery, mainly due to the efciency of the powertrain. Based on the test data, during the whole driving cycle, the
4.4 MJ of the regenerated braking energy takes up 13.7% of the
overall consumed energy provided by the fuel cell system and
the battery in the power bus.
1122
Table 2
Fuel economy test results of the FCHB under China city bus typical driving cycle.
Control strategy
2200
5100
9.3
8.6
7.8
7.5
16.1
Table 3
Fuel economy test results based on two kinds of batteries.
Battery type
Ni-MH
Li
7.8
6.9
24,000
23,800
2500
600
5100
5400
Table 4
HIL test results based on different motors and different surfaces.
Inertia moment (kg m2)
0
0.63
1.26
2.0
0
0.63
1.26
2.0
0
0.63
1.26
2.0
57.6
141.4
225.2
323.6
57.6
141.4
225.2
323.6
57.6
141.4
225.2
323.6
0.7
0.7
0.7
0.7
0.3
0.3
0.3
0.3
0.7 ? 0.3
0.7 ? 0.3
0.7 ? 0.3
0.7 ? 0.3
6.2
6.22
6.17
6.19
1.3
1.29
1.29
1.3
0.67
0.8
1
1.3
0.5
0.61
0.79
0.875
of brake pedal stroke are used to control the two braking systems.
The ABS active signal controls the modulation of pneumatic braking. This signal will be set high when:
(1) The brake pedal reaches 80% of its maximum position.
(2) The slip ratio of any wheel is higher than the threshold
value.
When each of the two conditions described above occurs, the
vehicle control unit will control the electric motor to remove the
regenerative braking torque at once and only the pneumatic
1123
wheel speed of rear-right wheel of the FCHB. The RBS will only
affect the ABS control in the very beginning of the ABS modulating process. Once the regenerative braking torque of the electric
motor being decreased to zero, the ABS works as a conventional
one. The pneumatic brake takes over all of all the braking operation of the bus, leading to the ABS restricting the slip of the rear
wheels. And during the whole braking process, no wheel was
locked up.
All of the test results satisfy the national regulation of China
(Chinese GB/T 13594-2003 and Chinese GB 12676-1999). And
based on the test results described above, the RBS cooperates well
with ABS, guaranteeing the brake stability and ensuring the brake
safety of the vehicle, which also validates the feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed control strategy.
5. Conclusion
Fig. 12. Vehicle test results on low adhesion road.
The scenarios of the tests are set as: emergent braking procedures on road surface with low adhesion coefcient (the adhesion
coefcient is 0.15), high adhesion coefcient (the adhesion coefcient is 0.15) and the road with transition surface between the
two surfaces mentioned above.
Test results on the road with low adhesion coefcient surface
are shown in Fig. 12. During the test, the brake pedal is depressed
gradually until ABS module starts to work to control the wheel
speed, and under this condition, the pedal stroke is still lower
than 80%. In the beginning, brake force generated by the electric
motor is added gradually according to the pedal stroke, and the
pneumatic braking force is supplemented when it is needed. Once
the slip ration of a wheel reaches a high value, the ABS active signal is set as high. Vehicle control unit controls the RBS modulating valves to be closed immediately, and removes the
regenerative braking force of the electric motor quickly. At the
meantime, the pneumatic braking force controlled by ABS is
added to take over all the brake operation of the vehicle. From
then on ABS module starts to regulate the wheels speed until
the vehicle stops safely.
Fig. 13 shows the variations of the wheel speeds during the
test. The FL Wheel Speed stands for the wheel speed of frontleft wheel of the FCHB and RR Wheel Speed stands for the
The regenerative braking system has been designed and implemented in a fuel cell hybrid electric city bus. By adding only two
modulating valves to the layout of the conventional PBS, the conguration of the RBS is designed.
With the aim of high regeneration efciency, the coordinated
regenerative braking control strategy is proposed. According to
the vehicle test results carried out based on China city bus typical
driving cycle, the improvement of the fuel economy of the FCHB
enhanced by the proposed coordinated control strategy reaches
16% and 9% respectively, compared to bus without regenerative
brake and with the parallel regenerative braking control strategy.
The comparison of the fuel economy between different kinds of
battery under the proposed regenerative braking control strategy
is also accomplished. The test results show that the application
of the Li battery is advantageous over the Ni-MH battery, improving the hydrogen consumption by 11.5%.
Brake safety of the vehicle under the proposed control strategy
is also studied in the HIL tests. The test results indicate that the RBS
will not affect the control performance of the ABS, guaranteeing
the vehicles brake safety and verifying the feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed regenerative braking control strategy.
The FCHB equipped with the proposed RBS has been demonstrative serving in Beijing. Based on the present technology, the
RBS can sufciently recapture the potential braking energy of the
vehicle and decrease the hydrogen consumption, improving the
driving range of the FCHB signicantly.
1124
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the Natural Science Foundation
of China [Project no. 51075225] and National High Tech Project
863 of China [Project no. 2011AA11A243] for funding this work.
References
[1] Hannan MA, Azidin FA, Mohamed A. Multi-sources model and control
algorithm of an energy management system for light electric vehicles.
Energy Convers Manage 2012;62:12330.
[2] Toro A, Delzanno P. Fuel cell stack and fuel cell powertrain for automotive
application. SAE Technical Paper 2004-01-1005; 2004.
[3] Caux S, Hankache W, Fadel M, Hissel D. PEM fuel cell model suiTable for energy
optimization purposes. Energy Convers Manage 2009;51(2):3208.
[4] Jeong K, Oh B. Fuel economy and life-cycle cost analysis of a fuel cell hybrid
vehicle. J Power Sources 2002;105:5865.
[5] Mohrdieck C. Next generation fuel cell technology for passenger cars and
buses. In: EVS24 international battery, hybrid and fuel cell electric vehicle,
symposium; 2009.
[6] Gao Y, Chen L, Ehsani M. Investigation of the effectiveness of regenerative
braking for EV and HEV. SAE Technical Paper 1999-01-2910; 1999.
[7] Sovran G, Blaser D. Quantifying the potential impacts of regenerative braking
on a vehicles tractive-fuel consumption for the U.S., European, and Japanese
driving schedules. SAE Technical Paper 2006-01-0664; 2006.
[8] Zhang J, Lv C, Gou J, Kong D. Cooperative control of regenerative braking and
hydraulic braking of an electried passenger car. Proc Inst Mech Eng, Part D: J
Automob Eng 2012;226(10):1289302.
[9] Silva C, Ross M, Farias T. Evaluation of energy consumption, emissions and cost
of plug-in hybrid vehicles. Energy Convers Manage 2009;50(7):163543.