Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Vol.24,aNo. *,a2011
DOI:10.3901/CJME.2011.**.***,availableonlineatwww.cjmenet.comwww.cjmenet.com.cn
1 Introduction*
YYUANShouqi,etal: NumericalInvestigationonFluidStructureInteractionConsideringRotorDeformation
foraCentrifugalPump
simultaneously,andinteractionbetweenfluidandstructure
can be calculated. The calculation models, which are
achieved by Pro/E, are shownin Fig. 1.The grids of fluid
domain in impeller and volute were generated by ICEM
CFD. Unstructured tetrahedral cells were generated to
definethefluidinimpellerandvolutewith110517nodes
and526183 grid elementsin total. In the fluid domain of
impeller,ameshrefinementzonewasdefinednearblades.
Andinthefluiddomainofvolute,ameshrefinementzone
wasdefinednearthetongue.And16457gridsfortherotor
structure, much less than fluid mesh, are generated by
ANSYScode.
2 PumpModel
The model is a singlestage singlesuction horizontal
volute centrifugal pump, of which the inlet diameter of
(b)Structurecalculation domainofthepump
impeller is 75 mm, outlet diameter is 188 mm, and outlet
Fig.1. Sketchmapofthepumpmodel
impeller width is 12 mm. The impeller is enclosed type
with 4 blades. The rotating speed is 1 450 r/min, with
The objective of the combined calculation is to analyze
designed flow rate of 25 m3/h and head of 10 m. The the effect of FSI by both comparing flow fields calculated
impeller structure is made of gray cast iron, of which the withandwithoutFSImethodandstudyingdeformationsof
materialcharacteristicparametersareshowninTable.
therotor calculated by FSI. Thedeflection of rotor can be
analyzed through center point on the shaft end, shown as
Table. Material characteristicparameters
theredpointinFig.1(b).Inaddition,thereare20indicator
points in the volute around impeller outlet as shown in
Density
Elasticmodulus
Poissonratio
Fig. 2 to obtain distribution of static pressure and its
r/(kg m3)
E/ GPa
m
7 000
150
0.25
variation trends. Both Cartesian coordinate used and the
tenth section of volute used for pressure analysis later are
Two calculation domains, fluid calculation domain and alsoshowninFig.2.
structurecalculationdomain,areinvolvedinthecombined
calculation for FSI effect of centrifugal pumps. The fluid
calculation domain is mainly composed of two parts, the
static volute and the rotating impeller. And a sliding
interfaceisusedbetweenvoluteinletandimpelleroutletto
simulate unsteady effect of a stationary and a rotating
component[10]. In addition, for the structure calculation
domain, only the rotor structure, including impeller and
pumpshaft,istakenintoaccount.Fluidsolidinterfacesare
necessarily used on every fluid wetted impeller surface to
establish an effective data transmission between fluid and
structure field. As a result, both deformation of impeller
and fluid pressure distribution can be considered
CHINESEJOURNALOFMECHANICALENGINEERING
Fig.2. Indicatorpositionsinthevolute
4 ResultsandDiscussions
Fig.3. A schemeofFSIsimulationsystem
YYUANShouqi,etal: NumericalInvestigationonFluidStructureInteractionConsideringRotorDeformation
foraCentrifugalPump
withFSI
withoutFSI
Pressurep/kPa
85
80
75
70
0
90
180
Angle a /
270
360
(a) Comparisonsofpressuredistributionsatt1
100
withFSI
withoutFSI
Pressurep/kPa
95
90
85
80
75
0
90
180
Angle a/
270
360
95
withFSI
withoutFSI
(c) 1.2QconditionwithFSI
(d) 1.2QconditionwithoutFSI
Pressurep/kPa
90
85
80
75
70
65
90
180
Angle a/
270
360
(c)Comparisonsofpressuredistributions att3
Fig.5. Comparisonsofpressuredistributions
aroundoutlet ofimpellerwithandwithoutFSI
Fig.6. Pressuredistributionsonthetenthsection
ofvolutewithandwithoutFSI (kPa)
Thedesignatedtimeis0.28152swhenonebladeisjust
passing the cutwater. The same scale legend is used for
CHINESEJOURNALOFMECHANICALENGINEERING
RadialforceF/N
comparingpressuredistributionsundereachcondition.And 0.5Qcondition.Itisclearthatsomecalculatedanglevalues
thechangesexistfortheresultscalculatedwithandwithout with FSI are evidently larger than without FSI, and some
FSI. Under designed condition, the area of low pressure aresmaller.
zone increased considering FSI, while the area of high
withFSI
pressure zone had no visible change. And under 1.2Q
20
withoutFSI
condition,theareaoflowpressurezoneincreasedwithFSI,
whentheareaofhighpressurezonedecreased.Under0.5Q
15
conditioninparticular,thesignificantchangeexists,andall
pressurevaluesincreasedsharplywithFSI.ThatmeansFSI
10
effect on pressure distributions exists not only around
impeller outlet, but also in the diffusion section of volute
5
farfromtheimpeller.TheeffectofFSI,whichisextremely
complex, should be considered on studying pressure
0
pulsationsofinnerflowincentrifugalpumps.
0.25
0.27
0.28
0.29
0.28
0.29
0.28
0.29
Time t/s
(a) Designedcondition
withFSI
withoutFSI
RadialforceF/N
50
40
30
20
0.25
0.26
0.27
Time t/s
(b) 1.2Qcondtion
withFSI
withoutFSI
80
RadialforceF/N
4.2 Analysisofunsteadyradialforce
The unsteady radial force acting onthe impeller created
by timedependent pressure distributions at the outlet of a
closedimpellermustbeknowninordertocalculatebearing
loads, shaft stresses and shaft deflection. The transient
radial force for every timepoint were calculatedusing the
method mentioned in Asuajes research[13]. The program
has been writtenusing LabView software. Both amplitude
andangleofforcewereconsidered.
Amplitudes of radial forces timedependent with and
without FSI under three operating conditions are shownin
Fig. 7, and every step represents the value of force
amplitude for each time point calculated. The amplitudes
are relatively small under designed condition, and are
relatively large under offdesign conditions in one period
rotation. Four obvious peak values of amplitude of radial
force are shown under every condition. It means that the
rotorstatorinteractionisstrong,andmakesanobviousand
dominantimpactonamplitudeofradialforces.Inaddition,
variation trends of peak values of radial force amplitude
calculatedwithandwithoutFSIarenearlysameunderhigh
flow rate and design conditions while the peak value with
FSIisslightlysmallerthanwithoutFSI,anddifferently,the
peak value with FSI is larger than without FSI under low
flowrate.
The variations of radial force angle, represented as b,
between x positive axis and radial force vectors along the
counterclockwise direction with and without FSI under
three operating conditions are shown in Fig. 8. Four
obvious periods of angle value fluctuation can be seen
under every operation condition, and the fluctuation is
relatively unstable under 0.5Q condition. The radial force
vector appears in either the first or the fourth quadrant
under designed condition for different time steps, and
appearsinthefirstquadrantwithlargeflowratewhilethe
vectorappearsinthethirdquadrantwithlowflowratefor
every time point. In addition, change of angles of radial
forcecalculatedwithandwithoutFSIisnotobviousunder
high flow rate condition, and is relatively obvious under
design and low flow rate conditions. The effect of FSI on
theangleofradialforceisquitecomplex,especiallyunder
0.26
70
60
50
0.25
0.26
0.27
Timet/s
(c) 0.5Qcondition
Fig.7. Amplitudesofradialforces
withandwithoutFSI
YYUANShouqi,etal: NumericalInvestigationonFluidStructureInteractionConsideringRotorDeformation
0.010
Angle b/
60
0.005
Deflection S/mm
foraCentrifugalPump
withFSI
withoutFSI
0.26
0.27
Timet/s
0.28
0.29
0.26
withFSI
withoutFSI
30
0.26
0.27
Time t/s
(b) 1.2Qcondtion
withFSI
withoutFSI
0.28
0.29
Equivalentstress s/MPa
Angle b/
40
0.25
co
0.5Q
0.8Q
1.0Q
1.2Q
1.5Q
50
Angle b/
0.28
Fig.9. Variationsofrotortotaldeflection
underfiveoperationconditions
60
272
92
0.27
Time t/s
(a) Designedcondition
70
0.25
Op
era
t
0.25
ion
q
Q
1.2q
Q
1.5q
Q
60
nd
i ti
on
s
0.000
0.5q
Q
0.8q
Q
8
7
6
5
4
0.25
0.26
0.27
Timet/s
0.28
0.29
Fig.10. Fluctuationsofequivalentstress
withtime fordifferentoperationconditions
268
88
264
84
5 Conclusions
CHINESEJOURNALOFMECHANICALENGINEERING
stresswithtimeareobviousunderdifferentconditions,and
stressvalueissmall.
References.
[1] GLICHJF. Centrifugalpumps[M].NewYork:Springer, 2007.
[2] BRENNEN C E. Hydrodynamics and cavitation of pumps[M].
Vienna:Springer,2008.
[3] ZIENKIEWICZOC,TAYLORRL.Thefiniteelementmethod[M].
ButterworthHeinemann:Oxford,2000.
[4] XIAO Ruofu, WANG Zhengwei, LUO Yongyao. Stress analysis of
Francis turbine runners based on FSI[J]. Shuili Fadian
Xuebao/JournalofHydroelectricEngineering,2007,26(3):120123.
(inChinese)
[5] ZHANG Lixiang, GUO Yakun, WANG Wenquan. FEM simulation
of turbulent flow in a turbine blade passage with dynamical
fluidstructure interaction[J]. Int. J. Numer. Meth. Fluids, 2009,
61(12): 1 2991 330.
[6] ZHANG Lixiang, GUO Yakun, WANG Wenquan. Large eddy
simulation of turbulent flow in a true 3D Francis hydro turbine
passage withdynamical fluidstructureinteraction[J].Int.J.Numer.
Meth.Fluids,2007,54(5):517541.
[7] BENRA FK.Numericalandexperimentalinvestigationontheflow
induced oscillations of a singleblade pump impeller[J]. ASME J.
FluidsEng.,2006,128(4):783793.
[8] KATOC,YAMADEY, WANGHong, etal. Prediction ofthenoise
from a multistage centrifugal pump[C]//ASME 2005 Fluids
EngineeringDivisionSummerMeeting,Houston,Texas, USA, June
1923,2005, PART B: 1 2731 280.
[9] LANGTHIEM M A. A numerical study of flowinduced noise in a
twodimensional centrifugal pump, Part: hydrodynamics[J]. J.
FluidandStructures,2004,19(3):349368.
[10]YUAN Shouqi, NI Yongyan, PAN Zhongyong, et al. Unsteady
turbulentsimulationandpressurefluctuationanalysisforcentrifugal
pumps[J].ChineseJournalofMechanicalEngineering,2009,22(1):
6469.
[11]BENRA F K, DOHMEN H J. Comparison of pump impeller orbit
Biographicalnotes
YUAN Shouqi is currently a professor and a PhD candidate
supervisor at Research Center of Fluid Machinery Engineering
and Technology, Jiangsu University, China. He has received 16
prizes of Science and Technology Advancement at Province or
Ministry level. He has published 3 books and more than 240
papers.Hisresearchinterestsincludethetheory,designandCFD
ofpumpsandfluidmachinery.
Tel:+8651188780007Email:shouqiy@ujs.edu.cn
PEI Ji, born in 1984, is currently a PhD candidate at Research
CenterofFluidMachineryEngineeringandTechnology,Jiangsu
University, China. He received his master degree from Jiangsu
University, China, in 2009. His research interests include flow
induced vibration and fluidstructure interaction in centrifugal
pumps.
Tel:+8613776474939Email: peiji1984@163.com
YUAN Jianping is currently an associate professor at Research
CenterofFluidMachineryEngineeringandTechnology,Jiangsu
University,China.Hisresearchinterestisdrainageandirrigation
machinery.
Tel:+8651188780280Email: yh@ujs.edu.cn