Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Introduction
In recent years, some failures have occurred
in trenches and slopes cut into boulder clay in
the west central valley of Scotland. This relatively recent build up of problems may be
explained by the fact that in urban areas, such
as the City of Glasgow, the earliest development
was confined to the low lying areas around the
River Clyde, then in the early 1800's expansion
took place into the surrounding hills which are
composed of glacial till and sometimes bedrock
(Price 1971 ) . These developments were
gradual, and generally in sympathy with the
topography. Main roads, railways, and canals
were all constructed around and between the
many glacial drumlins which were then used to
accommodate housing and commercial building developments.
In the last 10 to 15 years the City has been
subjected to major redevelopment on a vast
scale. A new urban road system based on traffic
flow patterns is being built, and widespread
commercial and municipal office and housing
regeneration and redeployment is well underway. Geological considerations, however, inCan. Geotech. J., I?., 84 (1975)
Description
of soil
Water
Top Soil
Weat hered
Boulder
clay
D a r k Grey
Boulder
Clay
W = w a t e r conten
W L = liquid l i m i t
W P = plastic l i m i t
50
(ALDERMAN)
Upper L i m i t of G l a c i a l C l a y s
40
(CASAGRANOE)
30
L i m i t s for GI
L o w e r L i m i t of Boulder Clay
20
10
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
Liquid
I Loa
Settling V e l o c i t y
clay
'~raction
1
1
- Cm
Per s e c
F i n e I ~ e d i u m lC o a r s e
Si ~t F r a c t i o n
FIG. 3.
70
60
for glacial
BS Sieve N u m b e r
Fine
80
90
100
L i m i t , WL%
1 Medium 1 C o a r s e
Sand F r a c t i o n
deposits.
Aperture
1
1
Fine
M e d i u m Coarse
~ravbl ~ractibn
Size i n i n c h e s
__L
and a pointed knife. Where a fissure is encountered the strike of the fissure is established,
the orientation of the strike and the magnitude
of the dip is measured. From this data alone
it is possible to establish the spatial orientation
of fissures.
Several types of plots for presenting orientation data are available but the type used is the
equal angle lower hemisphere plot. This is
considered the most suitable as it gives true
angular relationships and, with the large number of fissure readings, 200 to 500 in each
cavity, it does not become inaccurate nor imprecise like other types of diagrams (Denness
1969). The data are analyzed and drawn out
by computer and a typical data output is as
shown in Fig. 7a. From this a very much simplified plot may be drawn, Fig. 7b, to indicate
approximate relative orientations of dominant
FIG.7. (a). Contoured polar diagram representing fissures from North Hanover St., Glasgow. (b)
Stereogram of main fissure sets, North Hanover St.,
Glasgow.
CAVITY
ml
X- Axis
CO-ORDINATES
of M i n i n t u m
Y- Axis
Element Block
Ave S P.
= l84mm
3 280 000
cu.mm
820
CU.
Spacing- m m
000
mm
Soacing -mm
FIG. 8. Fissure spacing in boulder clay from North Hanover St., Glasgow.
TABLE
1. References on fissuring in boulder clays
Author
Features studied
Area of study
Chamberlin, T. C. 1895
Richter, K. 1929
Wentworth, C. K., and Delo, D. M. 1931
Biilow, K. V. 1939
Harrison, P. W. 1957
Elson, J. A. 1960
Penny, L. F., and Catt, J. A. 1967
Westgate, J. A. 1969
Kaczynski, R., and Wysokinski, L. 1970
Krajewska-Pininska, J. 1970
Boulton, G. S. 1970
Flint, R. F. 1971
Rowe, P. W. 1972
Kazi, A., and Knill, J. L. 1973
Pusch, R. 1973
McGown, A. et al. 1974
Sub-horizontal joints/deposition
Divisional planeslshear layers/compaction
Sub-horizontal joints/deposition
Latent and visible shear layerslground moraine
Fabriclstone orientation joints
Deposition/structure/fissility/joints
Jointslstone orientation/fold
Fracture/colurnnar structure
Strength/discontinuities
Strengthlwater contentlfissures
Deposition/fracture/tectonic shear
Joints/structure/fabric
Fissures/permeability
Fissures/orientation/stress conditions
Macrofa bric/microfabric/fissures/permeability
Macrofabric/fissures/strength anisotropy1
orientation
Slope stability/fissuring
Greenland
Germany
United States
Germany
United States
Canada
England
Canada
Poland
Poland
Norway
United States
England
England
Sweden
Scotland
Scotland
Em
IE
I,
F1
Asperity
Coating
e ear
::]Near
Horizontal
Vertical
mm
Stains
Fissures
N a t u r e of Fissure Surface
constituent particles. The influence of the presence of a macrofabric (fissures) was not fully
analyzed at this point, and in any case, taking
larger samples was considered to cover this,
assuming previous investigations into the relationship of the presence of fissures to engineering properties were acceptable and applicable
to boulder clay (Bishop and Little 1967;
Marsland 1971 ) .
(ii) Consolidation Properties
If the fissures lie in definite directions and if
the fissures have different permeabilities then
anisotropy (directional dependency) of all
properties controlled by permeability will result. Measurement of this is a major task and
the first step is to determine the size of representative specimens for testing. This is in fact
the stage reached at Strathclyde. Various sizes
of vertical samples (102, 152, 254 mm diameter samples) have been taken and tested at
various specimen sizes using the standard
76 mm oedometer and 76, 154, and 254 mm
Rowe cells.
From the e-log p curves of the same soil
tested at different specimen sizes, Fig. 10, it is
possible to conclude that the compression behavior is not directly influenced by macrofabric, hence by specimen size, and providing
careful sampling is carried out, sample size is
not significant either. The influence of different
size specimens on the rate on consolidation has,
however, not been found to be a constant. In
some cases 152 and 254 mm diameter specimens are significantly different whilst in others
they are not, or indeed, they can be in juxtaposition, Fig. 11. Nevertheless, in general the
152 and 254 mm diameter specimens give
much higher coefficients of consolidation than
the standard 76 mm specimen and this is particularly so at the lower consolidation pressures. It appears, therefore, that 254 mm
diameter specimens, or at least 152 mm diameter specimens, should be tested for consolidation data and that a reasonable number of
samples will still be required to account for
the variability between specimens which is
evidenced in the consolidation data so far measured. Also, the importance of sample size and
so by inference the importance of the macrofabric would appear to become greater at consolidation pressures at or below the overburden
Effective
' S't r e s~s ,
( l o g scale) ( A f t e r ~nderson1973)
FIG. 10. Void ratio - log effective stress curves for different size specimens from Grassyards Road, Kilmarnock.
values of permeability etc., principally according to the intensity of fissures in the particular
direction tested, the nature of the fissures surfaces and lastly with the confining pressure.
Effective
Stress, k d m 2
( A f t e r Anderson 1973)
FIG. 11. Variation of the coefficient of consolidation with applied effective stress for
different size specimens from Craufurdland, Kilmarnock.
As can be seen, the minimum strengths measurable from this in any direction at any size
were very much lower than the vertical strength
measurements and close to the fissure strength.
The explanation for this is that during testing
in particular directions formation of the shear
plane was occurring along a plane or set of
planes of weakness, that is shearing along fissures which have definite preferred orientations.
Fig. 14a and b are lower hemisphere plots
of the strengths measured in different directions
using 102 and 225 mm diameter test specimens, respectively.
The average vertical strength has been taken
as unity and the relative strengths only are
given for the various directions. From this, the
Sample
Settlement
6 - 1 A --0.-
A--a--
It
6-2
B--0---
-C
50
100
Effective
150
200
Pressure
-0-
6-2
250
(P')
300
350
400
k~/m'
FIG.12. Variation of the coefficient of permeability with applied effective stress for specimens from North Hanover St., Glasgow.
Behavior of Slopes
Slope failure may occur due to deficiency of
one or more of the strength components within
the soil mass but the type generally found in
94
1.0
C
*
m
.
w
j;
-,m
0.8
*.
c
0
d
.
;0.6
C
zu
2
*
.y.
0.4
.-0
#
.
0.2
10
10
10
A r e a of P o t e n t i a l F a i l u r e P l a n e
6
10
7
10
- rnm 2
FIG.13. Strength size relation of blue London clay and boulder clay from Strathclyde
University drumli;, Glalasgow.
boulder clay is structure type failure (Hagerman 1966). In structure type failure, 'blocks'
of soil fail as units and the failure is generally
quite shallow initially but can progress to
greater depth and extend with time. The
controlling factor is the orientation of the cut
slope to the basal surface of the block. In the
case of boulder clays these basal surfaces are
the near horizontal fissures with the sides of
the block bounded by the near vertical fissures.
Depending on relative orientation of fissures
and slopes then a critical situation may arise.
Figure 15 shows a cross section of a cavity
cut into a slope and the possibility of slip out
of the cut surface is obvious. Figure 16 shows
the fissure orientation at Hurlford, Ayrshire
with the controlling basal fissure set shown as
F1 and the slope shown as S. There is a measure of sympathy between the two, hence a
partial failure occurred, as shown in Fig. 17.
At Hanover Street in central Glasgow the F1
fissure was never more in sympathy than at
right angles to the orientation of the slope
surface hence no failure was evident, Fig. 7.
But at a site to the north of Glasgow, the condi-
Conclusions
Some instabilities of cuttings in the boulder
clays in west central Scotland have been shown
to be directly attributable to the presence of
fissures in the soil. These fissures have from
field investigations been shown to exhibit
definite preferred orientations and to be of
two distinct types. The first are near horizontal
fissures, often coated in silt or silty clay, and
the second are near vertical fissures either
clean or weathered and held tight by the action
of stones cutting across them. The deviation
of the coated fissures from the horizontal
( a E p e c i m . Diam
( A f t e r MCGown e t a l 1 9 7 4 )
FIG. 14. Stereographic projection showing directional dependency of undrained strength, Hurlford,
Ayrshire.
influence of fissures on the directional permeabilitv of stress relieved soils around excavations 6 a s yet to be considered. everth he less, the
present study has revealed the presence and
nature of the fissures in the Scottish boulder
clays and inferred some of the engineering
implications of these. As many other investigators have previously observed the presence
of fissures in boulder clays from other widespread geographical locations, it is suggested
that the findings of this study could be applicable to many boulder clays in areas other than
west central Scotland.
FIG.19.
gow.
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to acknowledge the permission to publish data given by Mr. J. F.
Clark, Mr. D. Hossain. Acknowledgment is
also made of the financial assistance given to
the project and personnel by the Natural Environment Research Council and the University
of Assiut, Egypt.
ALDERMAN,
J. K. 1959. The geotechnical properties of
glacial deposits of North West England. Ph.D. thesis,
Univ. Manchester, Manchester, Engl.
ANDERSON,
W. F. 1972. Thegeotechnical properties of the
till of the Glasgow region and the development of a
constant rate of expansion pressure meter suitable for
measuring the undrained strength and deformation
characteristics of this till. Ph.D. thesis, Univ.
Strathclyde, Glasgow, Scotland.
BISHOP,A. W., and LITTLE,A. L. 1967. The influence of
the size and orientation of the sample on the apparent
strength of the London clay at Maldon, Essex. Proc.
Geotech. Conf., Oslo, 1, pp. 89-96.
BOULTON,
G. S. 1970. On the deposition of subglacial and
melt out tills at the margins of certain Svalbard
glaciers. J. Glaciol. 9, pp. 23 1-245.
BULOW,K. V. 1939. Einfluss von Eis und Untergrund auf
Gefiige and Formen der Grundmorane. Zeitschr. f.
deutsche geol. Gesell. 91, pp. 318-326.
BUSBRIDGE,
J. R. 1968. In-situ geotechnical characteristics
of glacial till in the Glasgow area. M.Sc. thesis, Univ.
Strathclyde, Glasgow, Scotland.
CASAGRANDE,
A. 1947. Classification and identification of
soils. Proc. Am. Soc. Civ. Eng. June, pp. 783-810.
CHAMBERLIN,
T. C. 1895. Recent glacial studies in Greenland. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 6, pp. 199-220.
DENNESS,B. 1969. Fissures and related studies in selected
cretaceous rocks of South East England. Ph.D. thesis,
Univ. London, London, Engl.
ELSON,J. A. 1960. The geology of tills. Proc. 14th Can.
Soil Mech. Conf., Section 3, pp. 5-17.
FLINT,R. F. 1971. Glacial and quarternary geology. John
Wiley, New York, N.Y.
FOOKES,P. G., and DENNESS,B. 1969. Observational
studies on fissure patterns in Cretaceous sediments of
South ~ a s~t n ~ l a nGeotechnique,
d.
19, pp. 453-477.
97
M c G o w ~A.,
, SALI,A.,and RADWAN,
A. M. 1974. Fissure
patterns and slope failures in till at Hurlford, Ayrshire.
Quart. J. Eng. Geol. 7, pp. 1-26.
M c G o w ~ A,,
, and RADWAN,A. 1974. Cutting slopes in
fissured Scottish boulder clay. 2nd Int. Congr. Eng.
Geol., Brazil, Theme V , No. 8.
PENNEY,L. F., and CATT,J. A. 1967. Stone orientation
and other structural features in tills in East Yorkshire.
Geol. Mag. 104, pp. 344-360.
PRICE,D. G. 1971. Engineering geology in the urban environment. Quart. J. Eng. Geol. 4, pp. 191-208.
PUSCH,R. 1973. Structural variation in boulder clay. Proc.
Int. Symp. Soil Struct., Gothenburg, pp. 113-121.
RICHTER,
K. 1929. Studien uber fossile Gletscher Struktur.
Zeitschrf. Gletscherk. 17, pp. 3 3 4 6 .
ROWE, P. W. 1972. The relevance of soil fabric to site
investigation practice. Geotechnique, 22, pp..
195-300.
WENTWORTH,
C. K., and DELO, D. M. 1931. Dinwoody
glaciers, Wind River Mountains, Wyoming. Geol.
Soc. Am. Bull. 42, pp. 605-620.
WESTGATE,J. A. 1969. The Quaternary geology of the
Edmonton area, Alberta. Pedology and Quaternary
Res., Symp., Edmonton, ALberta, pp. 129-151.