Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Page 1 of 29
Keywords
By analyzing the factors that affect the Handover Success Rate (HOSR) on the BSS side, this
document provides a method of quickly locating the cause of low HOSR or slow handover. In
addition, this document provides measures for optimizing the HOSR, thus meeting field engineers'
working requirements for solving handover problems. This document is used for optimizing the
KPIs of network performance and monitoring the network quality.
Acronyms and Abbreviations
Abbreviations
Expansion
AMR
BCCH
BER
BQ
Bad Quality
BSC
BSIC
CDU
CIC
HOSR
KPI
MR
Measure Report
MS
Mobile Station
NE
Network Element
QoS
Quality of Service
RQI
TA
Timing Advance
Page 2 of 29
Table of Contents
1 Basic Principles............................................................................................................................
1.1 Definition..............................................................................................................................
1.2 Theory..................................................................................................................................
1.3 Recommended Formula.......................................................................................................
1.4 Measurement Point..............................................................................................................
2 Influencing Factors.....................................................................................................................
3 Analysis Process and Optimization Method............................................................................
3.1 Process of Analyzing Handover Problems.........................................................................
3.1.1 General Process of Locating a Handover Problem..................................................
3.2 Methods for Optimizing Handover Problems......................................................................
3.2.1 Classification of Handover Problems.......................................................................
3.2.2 Hardware and Transmission Failure........................................................................
3.2.3 Improper Data Configuration....................................................................................
3.2.4 Congestion of the Target Cell...................................................................................
3.2.5 Clock Problems........................................................................................................
3.2.6 Interference Problems.............................................................................................
3.2.7 Coverage Problems, and Uplink and Downlink Imbalance......................................
3.2.8 Failed Inter-BSC/Inter-MSC Handovers...................................................................
3.2.9 Automatic Neighboring Cell Optimization.................................................................
3.2.10 Testing Tool Selection and Testing Suggestions....................................................
3.2.11 Configuration Suggestions for Tests on the Existing Network................................
4 Optimization Cases....................................................................................................................
4.1 A Handover Fails Because the BSIC Cannot Be Decoded.................................................
4.2 A Handover Fails Because Frequency Sequencing of the MS Is Different from That of
the BSC....................................................................................................................................
4.3 A Handover Fails Due to Unreasonable Parameter Configuration.....................................
4.4 The Number of Failed Incoming BSC Handovers Increases Because the Handover
Request Does Not Contain Class Mark 3.................................................................................
4.5 An Incoming BSC Handover Fails Because the A Interface Phase Flag Is Set
Wrongly....................................................................................................................................
4.6 Because the Idle Burst Is Enabled, the Interference Increases, the Receiving Quality
Decreases, and the HOSR Becomes Low...............................................................................
4.7 Different HOSRs Resulting from Different Cause Values Contained in the Clear
Command Messages Sent by Different Switches....................................................................
5 Information Feedback................................................................................................................
5.1 TEMS Log Files About Problem Cells................................................................................
5.2 Requirements of Configuration Data of the Existing Network and Traffic Measurement
Feedback.................................................................................................................................
Page 3 of 29
Page 4 of 29
List of Tables
Table 3-1 List of handover timers commonly used..................................................................
Page 5 of 29
List of Figures
Figure 1-1 Signaling process of intra-BSC handover...............................................................
Figure 1-2 Signaling process of inter-BSC handover.............................................................
Figure 3-1 Flow chart of locating a handover problem...........................................................
Figure 3-2 Flow chart and timer description...........................................................................
Figure 3-3 Flow chart of automatic neighboring cell optimization...........................................
Page 6 of 29
1.2 Theory
The HOSR is an important KPI of the call hold type. According to the processes, this KPI can be
divided into two types: Handover Success Rate and Radio Handover Success Rate. According to
the relations between involved network elements (NEs), this KPI can be divided into three types:
Success Rate of Intra-BSC Handover, Success Rate of Incoming BSC Handover, and Success Rate
of Outgoing BSC Handover. The HOSR is an important KPI assessed by operators because the
value of the HOSR directly affects the user experience.
Page 7 of 29
BTS2
BSC
BTS1
MS
MSC
Measurement Report
CHAN ACT
A1
Handover
Access
Handover detect
PHY INFO
SABM
EST IND
UA
Handover Complete
Handover Performed
C1
Page 8 of 29
MS
BTS2
BSC2
CHAN ACT
MSC
BSC1
Handover
Required
Handover
Request
A2
BTS1
MS
Measurement
Report
A3
Handover
Request ACK
Handover
Command
B2
Handover
Access
Handover
Command
B3
Handover
detect
PHY INFO
PHY INFO
SABM
EST IND
UA
Handover Complete
C2
Handover
Complete
Clear
Command
Clear Complete
C3
The measurement points illustrated in Figure 1.1 and Figure 1.2 are as follows:
A1Measurement point of Incoming Internal Inter-Cell Handover Requests and Internal IntraCell Handover Requests
B1Measurement point of Incoming Internal Inter-Cell Handover Responses (Incoming
Internal Inter-Cell Handovers) and Internal Intra-Cell Handover Commands
C1Measurement point of Successful Incoming Internal Inter-Cell Handovers and Successful
Internal Intra-Cell Handovers
A2Incoming External Inter-Cell Handover Requests
B2Incoming External Inter-Cell Handover Responses (Incoming External Inter-Cell
Handovers)
C2Successful Incoming External Inter-Cell Handovers
A3Outgoing External Inter-Cell Handover Requests
B3Outgoing External Inter-Cell Handover Commands (Outgoing External Inter-Cell
Handovers)
C3Successful Outgoing External Inter-Cell Handovers
Replaced with corresponding measurement points, the formulas for calculating different types of
HOSR can be as follows:
Success Rate of Handover: (C1<Successful Incoming Internal Inter-Cell Handovers> +C3)/
(A1<Incoming Internal Inter-Cell Handover Requests> +A3)
Success Rate of Radio Handover: (C1 <Successful Incoming Internal Inter-Cell Handovers>
Page 9 of 29
Note:
If the BSC receives the Clear Command message sent by the MSC during an
inter-BSC handover, the current version does not count this case as a failed
handover. If a subscriber hangs up the phone during an intra-BSC handover, the
current version counts this case as a failed handover.
2 Influencing Factors
According to the cases and experience of the existing network, the factors that influence the
handover include the following types:
Data configuration
Congestion
Interference
Clock problems
Failed handovers
These problems directly result in poor experience of end users, which is inclined to cause
complaints. Therefore, it is necessary to work out a method for optimizing the HOSR quickly or
even automatically to improve the network quality and user experience.
Page 11 of 29
Page 12 of 29
Congestion problems
Clock problems
Interference problems
faulty cell. From the performance measurement of outgoing external intercell handovers, find out to which cells the handover fails. Analyze counters
of the cells where incoming handovers fail, such as the Failed Incoming
External/Incoming Inter-Cell Handovers (No Channel Available), the Traffic
Volume on TCH, and the Congestion Ratio on TCH(All Channels Busy), to
decide whether the congestion of the target cell causes the failed handover.
(5) Query such counters as the TRX Availability and the TCH Availability of the
target cell to check whether any device is faulty.
(6) Query relevant alarms to analyze whether any terrestrial link device is faulty.
BTS TRXs
Page 14 of 29
I. Handling Process
(1) Check the data configuration of the hardware. If none of the data
configuration of the faulty cell and its neighboring cells is changed recently,
consider whether the handover problem is caused by a BTS hardware
failure.
If the handover problem occurs in only one cell under the BTS, consider
whether the problem is caused by the hardware failure of the cell. If a TRX is
damaged, a call fails to be handed over to this TRX.
If a similar problem also occurs in a co-site neighboring cell of this cell,
consider whether the problem is caused by the failure of the common hardware
of the cells, for example, the TMU failure.
You can block some TRXs to verify the preceding problems. If the HOSR
returns to normal after a TRX is blocked, check whether this TRX is faulty or
whether the CDU or the antenna related to this TRX is faulty.
If the uplink and downlink signals of a TRX are unbalanced, handover
problems such as frequent handover and lower HOSR often occur.
(2) Trace the Abis interface, and observe whether the signaling of the faulty cell
is normal and whether the uplink and downlink receiving quality in the
measure report is good. For detailed operations, refer to the M900&M1800
BSS Signaling Analysis Manual.
If the receiving level quality of half rate or full rate channel in the measurement
report is poor, the hardware of the cell is faulty or signaling cannot interact
normally due to serious interference in the cell. As a result, a handover problem
occurs.
II. Traffic Measurement Analysis
Omitted.
III. Alarm Analysis
Observe whether any alarms with the following IDs are reported. If yes, refer to the BSS Alarm
Guide to handle the alarms.
Whether the parameters related to the handover candidate cell in the data
configuration are set properly
Avoid the case that the MS cannot be handed over to a neighboring cell due to
the missed setting of the neighboring cell.
Whether the N and P counters in the data configuration are set properly
Avoid insensitive handover decision or difficult handovers due to the too large
values of the parameters, or the case that the target cell of a handover is not the
optimal due to the too small values of the parameters.
Avoid configuring the neighboring cells that share the same BCCH or the same
BSIC for a cell.
Abnormal circuit identification code (CIC) circuits may cause failed handovers.
For example, the CIC circuit allocated through a Handover REQ message received by the target
BSC is identified in the BLOCK state in the target BSC. Therefore, the BSC responds to the MSC
with a Handover Failure message whose cause value is Requested Terrestrial Resource
Unavailable. In this case, check the statuses of the circuits at the two sides of the A interface and
ensure that the circuits are in the same state.
You can trace the A interface signaling on the maintenance console to check whether the failed
handover is caused by the inconsistency of the circuit statuses. Do as follows:
(1) Trace the A interface signaling.
(2) Filter the Handover Failure message.
Page 16 of 29
Default
Name
Value (ms)
T7
10000
Description
T8
10000
T3103
10000
T3105
70
T3124
320
Figure 1.2 shows the flow chart and the description of the timers.
Page 17 of 29
The number of users in the cell soars and exceeds the designed number.
prevent the MS from retrying to be handed over to this target cell. It is recommended that Penalty
Allowed be set to Yes.
Check whether the channel the congested cell is normal. If a TRX is faulty or a channel is
abnormal, rectify the relevant faults.
If full rate channels cannot be converted to half rate channels, it is recommended that you change
the channel attributes on the BSC6000 local maintenance terminal (LMT). That is, set the TCH
Rate Adjust Allow of all the TRXs under this cell to Yes. If the full rate channels can be
converted to half rate channels, properly reduce the value of TCH Traffic Busy Threshold(%) to
allocate half rate channels ahead of time and thus increase the system capacity. If the preceding
methods cannot solve the congestion problem, divide the cell or expand the capacity of the cell.
Since capacity expansion cannot be completed in a short time, you can set Channel Type to 1 or 2
to reserve channels for handovers. In this way, the failed handovers caused by congestion can be
reduced, and thus the HOSR improves.
II. Traffic Measurement Analysis
(1) Register the measurement unit Channel Assignment Failure Measurement
per Cell. By analyzing the traffic measurement, you can be familiar with the
number of the times that all the channels are busy or that none of the
channels is configured when the BSC allocates SDCCHs, TCHFs, or
TCHHs in the processes such as immediate assignment, assignment,
internal intra-cell handover, incoming internal inter-cell handover, and
incoming external inter-cell handover.
(2) Change relevant parameters for the target cell according to the cause of the
failed handover.
If the failed handover is caused by the SDCCH congestion, set SDCCH Dynamic Allocation
Allowed to Yes.
If the failed handover is caused by the TCH congestion, reduce the value of the TCH Traffic
Busy Threshold(%) to allocate half rates ahead of time and thus relieve congestion. In addition,
you can set Channel Type to 1 or 2 to reserve channels for handovers.
SN
Measurement Counter
link may be faulty or the clock source is faulty. Rectify the transmission link
fault through link-by-link self-loop until the alarm handling is complete.
(3) If the clock problem is not solved, reset the BTS (level-4) and observe
alarms and the HOSR.
(4) If the problem remains unsolved, replace the TMU.
Change the transmit power and the coverage area of the cell.
You can also register the measurement results of interference fringes by auxiliary means to
estimate downlink interferences.
For more details about the solutions of interference problems, refer to the GSM Interference
Analysis Guide.
II. Traffic Measurement Analysis
Omitted.
III. Alarm Analysis
Omitted.
For example, the coverage area of the serving cell is much larger than that of its
neighboring cells, and the neighboring relation between the serving cell and the
neighboring cells of its neighboring cells is not configured. In this case, failed
handovers easily occur at the fringe of the serving cell.
Make a field test for the cells where the HOSR is always low. That is,
perform a switchover and lock the main BCCH to act as the calling and
called parties respectively. Then decide the uplink and downlink problems
accordingly.
2)
If the uplink loss is large, it is recommended that you replace the combiner
to carry out an observation and a test.
Coverage problems and uplink and downlink imbalance are solved through RF optimization. For
detailed analysis, refer to the GSM BSS Network KPI (Coverage Problems) Optimization Manual
(V1.0).
II. Traffic Measurement Analysis
Register the measurement unit Uplink-and-Downlink Balance Measurement per TRX about the
cells where the HOSR is low. Collect the uplink and downlink balance cases and carry out
analysis.
III. Alarm Analysis
Omitted.
The data of the cells relevant to the inter-BSC handovers is set wrongly.
(2) Check whether the neighboring cells of the source and the destination BSC
are set correctly. If there is any abnormality, correct it and observe whether
handovers succeed.
(3) Trace A interface signaling. Check whether there is any abnormality in the
signaling cooperation of the handover process between the source BSC and
the MSC, and between the MSC and the destination BSC. For example,
check whether such a process that the MSC abnormally releases a
handover exists. If there is any abnormal process, find out the cause and
observe whether handovers succeed after such a problem is solved. For
detailed signaling analysis, refer to the M900&M1800 BSS Signaling
Analysis Manual.
(4) Check whether the source and the destination BSCs relevant to handovers
are locked with the clock of the upper-level MSC. If not, find out the cause
that the clock cannot be locked. Observe whether handovers succeed after
this problem is solved.
The handovers are relatively fewer according to the traffic, for example,
about 30 handovers every hour.
The TA is limited to six times as many as the average distance between sites. Do not consider the
cells with the TA beyond this threshold. You can flexibly set the lower limit of the HOSR and the
fewer limit of handover times.
Page 25 of 29
4 Optimization Cases
4.1 A Handover Fails Because the BSIC Cannot Be
Decoded
During a drive test in an office, it is found that an MS cannot decode the BSIC of a neighboring
cell. As a result, the MS cannot initiate a handover even when the MS detects good levels of the
neighboring cell.
After analysis, it is learned that the PTCCH points to a wrong memory zone. As a result, some
MSs misunderstand that this channel is an FCCH, thus fail to synchronize the SCH and fail to
decode the BSIC. This product problem must be solved through version upgrade.
Handover Request does not contain class mark 3 and the frequency of the other TRXs in the cell is
different from that of the main BCCH, accessing MSs are all allocated to the main BCCH. This
causes congestion and thus handovers fail. After the frequency of the other TRXs is changed to the
PGSM, the number of failed incoming BSC handovers caused by no available channel decreases
to 0. The problem is mitigated. According to the protocol, however, class mark 2 also has a field
for identifying whether an MS supports the EGSM or the RGSM (incapable of identifying the
DCS1800). Such a problem often occurs because some MSCs carry only class mark 2 in the
Handover Request or because an MS in a cell with the EGSM enabled does not report class mark
3.
To solve such a problem, upgrade the software version.
Page 27 of 29
5 Information Feedback
5.1 TEMS Log Files About Problem Cells
Cell information tables of TEMS tests are required to be provided in log files. The tables must be
in the format of *.cel.
Page 29 of 29