Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
2
Abstract
Epilepsy is a neurological condition that affects many children. Epilepsy, seizures, and antiepilepsy medications can all affect a childs learning and development. Specifically, the
cognition of children with epilepsy is frequently different from that of children without seizure
disorders. Children with epilepsy often have deficits in attention, memory, and executive
functioning. These children can also have social and emotional struggles such as anxiety,
depression, and altered behavior. These specific cognitive implications and school-based
interventions to address the deficits are discussed.
genetic mutation (Iliescu & Craiu, 2013). Iliescu and Craiu (2013) also wrote about the use of
metabolic testing to determine the etiology of an epilepsy diagnosis.
Types of Seizures
Seizures can be categorized as either primary generalized seizures or partial seizures
(Schachter, 2013). According to Solomon and McHale (2012), in generalized seizures the
whole brain is affected by changes in electrical activity and the child becomes unconscious of
their surroundings (p. 29). Generalized seizures affect both sides of the brain at once
(Schachter, 2013). Generalized seizures include tonic-clonic seizures, tonic seizures, atonic
seizures, myoclonic seizures, and absence seizures (Solomon & McHale, 2012).
Tonic-clonic seizures, once called grand mal, involve the entire brain (e.g. McCandless,
2012). Tonic-clonic seizures involve full-body convulsions, muscle rigidity, and strong muscle
contractions. Following a tonic-clonic seizure comes a long period of unconsciousness, amnesia,
and drowsiness (McCandless, 2012).
Tonic seizures are generally short in duration (under one minute), come on quickly, and
involve stiffened muscles (McCandless, 2012). If the child is not seated at the onset of the tonic
seizure, a fall is likely, as is possible head-injury (Solomon & McHale, 2012). There is no
jerking or convulsing during a tonic seizure (Solomon & McHale, 2012).
Atonic seizures typically involve a sudden and complete loss of muscle tone, causing the
body to fall to the ground. For some, atonic seizures may only involve a dropped head or
slumped body, rather than complete loss of muscle control (McCandless, 2012).
Myoclonic seizures involve muscle jerks and brief loss of consciousness. Myoclonic
seizures typically happen immediately after waking or shortly before going to sleep at night
(Solomon & McHale, 2012).
Absence seizures typically present as staring spells or a general unresponsiveness and last
for a maximum of 30-s (McCandless, 2012). In some cases, an absence seizure may include lip
smacking or minor tongue movements (McCandless, 2012). According to McCandless (2012),
absence seizures account for 5% of all epilepsy and affect girls more than boys. Because
children recover quickly from absence seizures, and there is not a prolonged loss of
consciousness, many absence seizures go unnoticed or are treated as inattention (Solomon &
McHale, 2012).
Partial seizures are caused by an electrical discharge in one specific part of the brain
(Schachter, 2013). Forms of partial seizures include simple partial seizures and complex partial
seizures (Schachter, 2013). McCandless (2012) wrote, A complex partial seizure involves
impaired consciousness, whereas patients exhibiting simple partial seizures do not have impaired
consciousness. They are able to answer questions, respond, etc. during the seizure (p. 143).
Simple partial seizures often occur with an aura, a special sensory sign and may evolve into a
complex partial seizure (McCandless, 2012). These sensory signals generally relate to the
affected area of the brain; if the auditory cortex is the seizures location, one might hear strange
sounds during the seizure. McCandless also wrote that the etiology of simple partial seizures can
usually be identified. Causes may include hypoxia, infections, syphilis, and viral infections
(McCandless, 2012).
Complex partial seizures occur in approximately one-third of epilepsy patients
(McCandless, 2012). Complex partial seizures generally are preceded by an aura and
involuntary tics and involve a loss of consciousness (McCandless, 2012). Auras may include
sensory illusions, auditory or visual hallucinations, a sense of fear, or a particularly strong
emotion (happiness, anger) and older patients learn to recognize these auras as a sign of
Treatment Options
Consultation with a neurologist or epileptologist (a neurologist specializing in epilepsy)
is necessary for the management of epilepsy. Most practitioners will not begin treatment for
epilepsy until a patient has experienced two unprovoked seizures (Titus & Thio, 2009). In some
cases, epilepsy may have minimal effect on the childs quality of life, and a doctor may decide
not to utilize drug therapy (Titus & Thio, 2009). According to McCandless (2012),
approximately 70% of people with epilepsy have achieved treatment success (p. 3).
For many patients with epilepsy, antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) are utilized to treat seizures.
Approximately 90% of epilepsy patients in the United States take AEDs to manage their
condition (McCandless, 2012). In many cases, two or more AEDs are required to obtain seizure
control; this approach is known as polytherapy (Titus &Thio, 2009). McCandless (2012) noted
that 56% of US epilepsy patients receive monotherapy, 26% take two AEDs, 6% take three
AEDs, and 2% take four AEDs.
Approximately two-thirds of people with epilepsy achieve full seizure control with
medication (CDC, 2013). While the remaining one-third of people may experience a reduction
in seizures through medication, some will require further intervention (CDC, 2013). Surgical
intervention is another treatment option for patients with seizures not controlled by medications.
For some patients with partial epilepsy the focal point of seizures can be identified in the brain,
making surgical removal of the area a possible treatment (CDC, 2013). A ketogenic diet, high in
fat and low in carbohydrates, is sometimes used as treatment for epilepsy. MGH (2006)
explained the process of ketosis:
As the body metabolizes high-fat foods, it produces chemical compounds called ketone
bodies, resulting in a physiologic state known as ketosis. It also increases the acidity of
the blood. Experts hypothesize that the presence of ketone bodies may be involved in the
reduction of the abnormal brain activity responsible for seizures, but still very little is
known as to the actual mechanisms of this process. (para. 21)
Vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) also is used to successfully treat some cases of epilepsy. VNS
involves a small pacemaker-like device is implanted under a persons skin and wired to direct
short electrical pulses to the vagus nerve (MGH, 2006)
Developmental and Educational Outcomes
There are approximately two million people in the United States with epilepsy
(McCandless, 2012). Seventy percent of epilepsy cases develop during childhood, the majority
during the first year of life (McCandless, 2012). Researchers have determined that
approximately 50% of children with epilepsy have school-related difficulties (e.g. Beghi,
Cornaggia, Frigeni, & Beghi, 2006). Berg, Caplan, Baca, and Vikery (2013), in their
longitudinal study of young children diagnosed with epilepsy, found that over half of the children
in their study group experienced difficulty at school, which they classified as referral for special
education services, grade retention, or both. In addition to seizure-related difficulties, antiepileptic drugs may also affect childrens learning abilities.
Selassie, Viggedal, Olsson, and Jennische (2008) conducted a study of children with
epilepsy in Sweden. The authors focused on preschool children who had not been identified as
having a neuroimpairment other than epilepsy (e.g., cerebral palsy, autism, or intellectual
disability). The authors also identified children for their reference group from the same
preschools attended by the children with epilepsy. Study participants were evaluated by a speech
and language pathologist in multiple language domains, as well as evaluated by a
neuropsychologist with multiple intelligence tests. Individual results of these tests will be
addressed in the coming sections; however, Selassie et al. (2008) summarized their results:
Preschool children with epilepsy and without [intellectual disability], CP, and/or autism
may have specific speech-language, auditory attentional, and visuoperceptual difficulties.
However, the usual measures of verbal intelligence and comprehension revealed results
within normal range. (p. 437)
Comorbidity
Epilepsy occurs at a significant rate in a number of disability and disease populations.
According to McCandless (2012), 30% of children with cerebral palsy and 10% of children with
autism also have epilepsy. Oguni (2013) reported that between 7.1% and 32% of children with
epilepsy have autism spectrum disorders (ASD).
Intellectual Disability
The relationship between intellectual disability (ID) and epilepsy has not been fully
explored. Oguni (2013) reported that 5-10% of individuals with epilepsy also have ID and
developmental disabilities (DD). Vasconcellos et al. (2001) conducted a study of children with
intractable epilepsy (seizures which cannot be controlled by medication) who were diagnosed
before the age of two. The authors found that children in this study group were more likely to
have an IQ less than 70 than were children diagnosed after age two. This link between
uncontrolled seizures and intellectual disability underscores the need to stop the seizures through
medical intervention as quickly as possible.
Learning Disorders
Beghi, et al. (2006) found that 25% of children with epilepsy have a learning disorder,
while 50% of children with learning disorders have epilepsy. The authors also noted that earlier
10
onset of seizures correlates with a higher likelihood of learning disorder. Additionally, they
noted that children with temporal lobe epilepsy (complex partial seizures) may face specific
learning disabilities based on the location of their seizures. For example, Beghi, et al. (2006)
wrote that children with right-hemisphere involvement may be impaired in visual tests, while
those with left-hemisphere involvement may struggle with verbal tests.
Attention and Memory
Oguni (2013) wrote that 30-40% of children with epilepsy have co-occurring attention
deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Selassie et al. (2008) reported similar data. The authors
wrote, attention problems have been found in 42% of children with epilepsy (p. 432). In the
researchers study they found that children with epilepsy have a poorer performance on attention
measures of the Dichotic Listening Test than their non-epileptic peers. Timmel (2006) wrote of
children with epilepsy, disturbances in their brain that result from seizures make it difficult for
students to focus their attention and thus acquire new information (p. 1). Timmel further
explained, Seizures can also compromise their working memory, making it difficult for them to
store and retrieve any information that they were able to learn (p. 1).
Titus and Thio (2009) found in their review of literature that older AEDs (e.g., Dilantin,
Tegretol, and Depakote) are associated with memory problems in epilepsy patients. The authors
also found that some newer AEDs may cause executive function-related memory problems.
Svoboda (as cited in Selassie et al., 2008, p. 437) found that 61% of children with epilepsy at the
Kansas City Epilepsy Center have difficulties with short-term memory.
Executive Dysfunction
Executive function can be described as metacognitive capacities that allow an individual
to perceive stimuli from his or her environment, respond adaptively, flexibly change direction,
11
anticipate future goals, consider consequences, and respond in an integrated manner (Rzezak,
Guimaraes, Fuentes, Gerreiro, & Valente, 2012, p. 577). Rzezak et al. (2012) found that children
with temporal lobe epilepsy, complex partial seizures localized in the temporal lobe, performed
poorly on multiple measures of executive function. The authors also found that executive
dysfunction was highly correlated with impaired memory.
Titus and Thio (2009), in their review of AEDs and children, found that executive
function can be impacted by epilepsy medications. They wrote, The effects of AEDs on
executive functioning have been a more consistently reported finding in the literature and have
the potential to directly affect school performance in the classroom in more subtle ways (p.
889). As with memory functioning, executive functioning is more strongly impacted in children
undergoing polytherapy (Titus & Thio, 2009).
Anxiety and Depression
Emotional issues can be a major factor in the quality of life of children with epilepsy.
Multiple hospitalizations and medical procedures may trigger anxiety in young children with
epilepsy. Solomon and McHale (2012) wrote that children with epilepsy might develop a fear of
their seizures and the sense of being out of control. Seyfhashemi and Bahadoran (2013), in their
review of literature, found that 23-33% of children with epilepsy were depressed, compared to 15% of the general population. Titus and Thio (2009) wrote that anxiety and emotional problems
can affect a childs performance in school. The authors noted that issues with school
performance are particularly common in newly diagnosed children or those who have recently
experienced their first seizure.
There is conflicting information about the relation between multiple AEDs and
depression in children, but there may be a correlation between polytherapy and increased
12
depressive symptoms (Seyfhashemi & Bahadoran, 2013). Titus and Thio (2009) found the
antiepileptic drug phenobarbital was strongly tied to depression in children, with 40% of patients
on the drug showing depressive symptoms. Another drug, Levetiracetam (Keppra) has been
linked to a greater occurrence of behavior problems such as irritability and personality change in
children (Titus & Thio, 2009).
Educational Interventions
While there is ample research regarding medical interventions for childhood epilepsy,
intervention studies on best educational practices for this specific population could not be found.
Children with epilepsy are a significant population, yet their struggles in school tend to follow
the patterns of other childhood disabilities, which may account for the lack of disease-specific
research. Intervention studies on childhood executive function, attention and attention deficit
disorder were located in lieu of a variety of epilepsy-specific interventions.
Best Practices
As stated above, children with epilepsy who have been identified as having average or
above average intelligence may still struggle with the tasks required of them in school (Selassie
et al., 2008). Timmel (2006) provided many strategies for teachers of children with epilepsy,
including adapting curriculum, thematic teaching, and using tutorials. Particularly relevant for
young children is the use of thematic teaching. Thematic teaching helps children with epilepsy
by providing repeated exposure to concepts and information throughout the school day (Timmel,
2006). Timmel (2006) suggested collaboration between teachers, interventionists, and families,
so that all the adults in a childs life work to incorporate the thematic concepts into their routines.
This practice aligns with Division for Early Childhood (DEC) of the Council for Exceptional
Childrens Recommended Practice C.18, Practices are used systematically, frequently, and
13
consistently within and across environments (e.g. home, center, community) and across people
(i.e. those who care for and interact regularly with the child) (Sandall, Hemmeter, Smith, &
McLean, 2005, p. 87).
Titus and Thio (2009) wrote that children with epilepsy may struggle with verbal tasks in
school; some of these problems may be linked to anti-epilepsy medications. The authors
recommended giving these children extended time to respond verbally, limiting performance
expectations, and rewording verbal instructions when needed. This practice aligns with DEC
Best Practice C.22, Systematic naturalistic teaching practices such as models, expansions,
incidental teaching, mand-model procedure, and naturalistic time delay are used to promote
acquisition and use of communication and social skills (Sandall et al., 2005, p. 89).
Titus and Thio also wrote that children with epilepsy may exhibit symptoms typical of
children with ADHD. The authors explained that classroom interventions for children with
ADHD are relevant for children with epilepsy-related attention issues. Specific strategies
mentioned included frequent repetition, redirection, cueing, one-on-one instruction, and highly
structured and organized environments (Titus & Thio, 2009). This approach aligns with DEC
Best Practice C.25, Specialized procedures (e.g., naturalistic strategies and prompt/prompt
fading strategies) are embedded and distributed within and across activities (Sandall et al.,
2005, p. 91).
Tools of The Mind
According to Titus and Thio (2009), classroom accommodations designed to address
deficits in executive functioning are often sufficient to help with AED-related memory issues
(p. 888). The Tools of The Mind curriculum was designed to address executive functioning in
young children, as well as symbolic representation and early math and literacy skills. According
14
to Barnett et al. (2008), the Tools of the Mind curriculum focuses on broad foundational skills,
including childrens ability to regulate their own social and cognitive behaviors, to attend and
remember on purpose, the use of symbolic representation, and early math skills (p. 301). The
curriculum was designed to help children create their own set of psychological tools which
will help them in social and cognitive situations. Barnett et al. (2008) wrote, The Tools
curriculum incorporates 40 Vygotsky-inspired activities designed to promote mature dramatic
play, encourage the use of self-regulatory private speech, and teach the use of external aids to
facilitate attention and memory (p. 301).
One such tool is the use of mediators, something that stands as an intermediary between
an environmental stimulus and an individual response to that stimulus (Bordova & Leong,
2007, p. 51). Mediators are used to develop attention and memory in young children. Examples
of mediators may include being given a carpet square to sit on during circle time to help the child
remember where to sit, a song that cues an activity being nearly over, or a picture symbol to hold
while remembering to listen (Bordova & Leong, 2007). Another tool in the curriculum is the
guided use of private speech to support thinking. Teachers encourage and model using private
speech while working through challenging tasks.
Barnett et al. (2008) conducted a randomized trial comparing 88 children in Tools of the
Mind classrooms to 122 children in control group classrooms in a single school district. The
authors found that children in Tools classrooms showed improvements in social and cognitive
development. Diamond, Barnett, Thomas, and Munro (2007) also found that children in Tools of
the Mind classrooms preformed better on tests of executive functioning than did their peers in
typical preschool classrooms. Diamond et al. (2007) summarized their results, Tools
successfully moves children with poor [executive functions] to a more optimal state (p. 1388).
15
16
have some concerns about his attention/engagement in class as well as his memory skills.
Maliks Leiter IQ score was 89 (23rd percentile).
Malik was put on an antiepileptic drug at 18 months, after experiencing several additional
complex partial seizures. He took the medication for about two years, at which time his
parents and his neurologist determined that Maliks condition was stable and that he could
temporarily stop taking the medication. He has been off of his medication and seizure-free for
one month. Maliks doctors are pleased that the medication worked so well for Malik and are
cautiously optimistic that his seizures may not return. Currently, he has no specific diagnosis
beyond epilepsy, as it remains to be seen whether he will continue to have seizures and what
the frequency and severity of the seizures might be. His parents continue to monitor him closely.
Intervention Plan
Maliks teachers can make a number of changes to help Malik be successful in school.
School-based interventions should be utilized because his parents did not report any troubles at
home. By utilizing best practices for children with disabilities and specifically for those with
epilepsy, it is likely that Malik will have an easier time with the tasks required of him.
Specifically, interventions are needed to help Malik develop his attention, memory, and direction
following ability. Because Maliks IQ falls within the range of normal, interventions should be
used to combat these specific deficits rather than cognition in general.
Maliks memory may have been affected by his epilepsy or by the medication he took. As
Malik is no longer on an AED, he may experience improved attention and memory with time.
AEDs affect children in a variety of ways, and it is possible that his medication had a negative
impact on his cognitive skills.
17
To support Maliks memory his teachers should implement thematic teaching practices.
Repetition of concepts throughout the school day and across settings will help Malik.
Collaboration amongst teachers and interventionists who work with Malik will help him learn
new concepts. For example, if Maliks class is learning about insects, the teachers can read
stories about insects, observe insects during science class, act like insects during movement
periods, sing insect songs during music class, and complete insect-themed art projects.
Receiving this information throughout his day and across environments makes it more likely that
new concepts will be learned.
Adults working with Malik should also strive to keep his routines and behavioral
expectations consistent across settings. Maliks day should be highly structured, with visual
scheduling prompts to help reinforce the order of activities. When the demands of the day are
consistent and known, it is likely that Maliks attention will be stronger during demanding tasks.
Because his teachers find that Malik struggles with following directions, tasks should be
broken down to simple parts and directions should be short and involve non-verbal prompts.
Along with clear and consistent expectations, using visual prompts will help Malik as he moves
through his school day. Tools such as an individual picture schedule and other visual or physical
prompts can be utilized to support Malik.
In addition to these classroom-based interventions, Maliks teachers and family should
incorporate adequate physical activity into Maliks day. If playground or gross motor play is not
available during the school day, his parents should try to have him ride a bike or scooter to
school or visit the playground shortly before the school day begins. This burst of physical
activity may help Malik with attention at school.
18
19
References
Barnett, W. S., Jung, K., Yarosz, D. J., Thomas, J., Hornbeck, A., Stechuk, R., & Burns, S.
(2008). Educational effects of the Tools of the Mind curriculum: A randomized trial.
Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 23, 299-313.
Beghi, M., Cornaggia, C. M., Frigeni, B., & Beghi, E. (2006). Learning disorders in epilepsy.
Epilepsia, 47(Suppl. 2), 14-18. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1167.2006.00681.x
Berg, A. T., Caplan, R., Baca, C. B., & Vickery, B. G. (2013). Adaptive behavior and later
school achievement in children with early-onset epilepsy. Developmental Medicine &
Child Neurology, 55, 661-667. doi: 10.1111/dmcn.12143
Bordova, E. & Leong, D. J. (2007). Tools of the mind: The Vygotskian approach to early
childhood education. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2013). Epilepsy: Frequently asked questions.
Retrieved from: http://www.cdc.gov/epilepsy/basics/faqs.htm
Corkum, V., Byrne, J. M., & Ellsworth, C. (1995). Clinical assessment of sustained attention in
preschoolers. Child Neuropsychology, 1(1), 3-18.
Diamon, A., Barnett, W. S., Thomas, J., & Munro, S. (2007). Preschool program improves
cognitive control. Science, 318, 1387-1388.
Iliescu, C. & Craiu, D. (2013). Diagnostic approach of epilepsy in childhood and adolescence.
Maedica- a Journal of Clinical Medicine, 8(2), 195-199.
Massachusetts General Hospital (2006). Growing up with epilepsy. Retrieved from:
http://www2.massgeneral.org/childhoodepilepsy/index.htm
McCandless, D. W. (2012). Epilepsy: Animal and human correlations. New York, NY:
Springer Science + Business Media.
20
21
Solomon, N. & McHale, K. (2012). An overview of epilepsy in children and young people.
Nursing Children and Young People, 24(6), 28-36.
Timmel, G. (2006). Teaching students with epilepsy: Strategies for educators. Retrieved from:
http://www2.massgeneral.org/childhoodepilepsy/pdf/strategies_for_educators.pdf
Titus, J. B. & Thio, L. L. (2009). The effects of antiepileptic drugs on classroom performance.
Psychology in the Schools, 46, 885-891. doi: 10.1002/pits.20428
Vasconcellos, E., Wyllie, E., Sullivan, S., Stanford, L., Bulacio, J., Kotagal, P., & Bingaman,
W. (2001). Mental retardation in pediatric candidates for epilepsy surgery: The role of
early seizure onset. Epilepsia, 42(2), 268-274. doi:10.1046/j.1528-1157.2001.4220268.x