Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
G.Y.Zhou*
Mechanics of Machines Lab, School of Mechanical & Production Engineering
Nanyang Technological University(NTU), 50 Nanyang Avenue, 639798, Singapore
Z.Y.Jiang
Department of Mechanics and Mechanical Engineering
University of Science and Technology of China(USTC), Hefei, Anhui, 230027, P.R.China
ABSTRACT
Magnetorheological Elastomer (MRE) is a new class of smart materials, whose modulus can be controlled by applied
magnetic field. In this paper, we first show the field-dependant dynamic mechanical properties including shear and stretch
of the MRE, cured by ourselves. By white light speckle method for deformation analysis, we present the dynamic
deformation progress (the vector diagram of displacement or the whole-field quantitative displacement distribution, at varies
time) of the MRE and the elastomer-ferromagnet composite (EFC) while the magnetic field turns on. The real-time
deformation progress gives us a deep understanding to MRE and EFC.
Keywords: Magnetorheological elastomer, elastomer-ferromagnet composite, white light speckle method,
1. INTRODUCTION
Magnetorheological materials, including magnetorheological fluids (MRF), which are liquid and operate in the post-yield
[1,2]
and magnetorheological elastomers (MRE), which are solid and operate in the pre-yield
regime in application
regime [1,3,4,5] , are promising smart materials in engineering due to their real-time controllable mechanical property
responded to the applied magnetic field. Normally, they are composed of iron particles and carrier with low permeability.
For MRF, the particles are suspended in the carrier liquid desultorily and, when the magnetic field applies, the mechanical
behavior of MRF will change owing to the structures formed by the particles. This effect is so called the magetorheological
effect, which is characterized by dynamic yield stress and utilized for designing energy dissipation part in engineering, such
as damper [2] For MRE, the structures formed by the particles are embedded in the host elastomer since it is cured under
strong magnetic field. Therefore, owing to the magnetic interaction between the particles, the modulus or stiffness of MRE
will be changed with the applied magnetic field.
In literature, the research on MRF, covering the structure formed by the particles, the pattern of the particles accumulated
in the structure, the model describing the dependence of the strength of structure or the dynamic yield stress of MRF on the
applied magnetic field, the flow in MRF valves, the design and mechanical property of MRF damper, the vibration
damping, etc, takes a longer history than that on MRE. But, owing to the instability of MRF, many technical problems do
hind the application of MRF [2] In contrast to MRF, MRE is solid which makes its mechanical property more stable and,
hence, many researches began to introduce it to application in these years1451 . Since MRE is cured under magnetic field
(the mixture of iron particles and liquid elastomer solidifies gradually under magnetic field), many research achievements
on MRF, such as structure accumulated by particles, can be expanded to MRE directly. Therefore, the research on MRE is
focused on the field induced shear modulus in current literature. But, for a solid controllable material, only knowing the
mechanical behavior of shear is not enough. To design a qualified smart device based on such materials, one must know the
constitutive equation or the magnetic induced deformation and the mechanical properties of shearing, stretching, impacting
etc. Toward this goal, recently, some scholars investigated the microscopic relaxation of EFC (they called it MRE, but we
think it is not MRE since they reported that the sample is cured at 140 in the absence ofan applied magnetic field), whose
iron particles are with average diameter of O.2um, through the scattering intensity pattern of synchrotron radiation161.
However, they only presented the change of the scattering intensity while magnetic field turns off and the deformation of
MRE caused by field switching, which is just the engineers are eager to know, did not given. Thus, after studying the shear
*
gangyizhouhotmail.com
Smart Structures and Materials 2003: Active Materials: Behavior and Mechanics,
Dimitris C. Lagoudas, Editor, Proceedings of SPIE Vol. 5053 (2003)
2003 SPIE 0277-786X/03/$15.00
603
property and extensional property of a kind of MRE cured by ourselves, in this paper, we introduce the white light speckle
method to obtain such deformation. Further, by this method, we also examine the deformation of EFC under the case of
field switching, which has been studied theoretically by L.Borcea recently [7]
r
4
magnetic riu
guider
Accelero-
meter
Ferrous
Frame
Accelerometer
Coil
Cuprous
mass
MRE
1agnetic flu
8 suider
Though, in current literature, there are some techniques to investigate the shear property of MRE, such as sandwich
structure [5] and free vibration technique [1,3] the extensional behavior of MRE along the direction of the chains has not
appeared yet. In reference [8], a method to reveal the unreported property of MRE under different applied magnetic field is
introduced. In the method, the stress-strain curve of MREunder harmonic excitation is obtained by measuring the excitation
and the harmonic response (the accelerations of A, the ferrous base, and B, the cuprous mass, respectively) of a vibration
system, which is illustrated in figure 2. By the technique, the energy dispersion of MRE is found to be controlled with the
applied magnetic field.
604
3. EXPERIMENT
3.1 White light speckle method for deformation analysis
The method, utilizing white (or any incoherent) light illumination in conjunction with an artificial speckle pattern printed
on the object, has a long history in measuring in-plane displacement and strains in engineering structures [9,10] For this
method, a speckle pattern, which is a random array of black and white dots, has to be first created on the surface of the
object. This can be accomplished in a variety of ways, such as painting the surface white and then spraying a fine mist of
black paint from an aerosol, painting the surface with the mixture consisting of small glass beads suspended in a liquid,
coating the surface with the film on which a laser-generated speckle pattern is created, etc. In some cases, the natural grainy
surface of a rough object, when properly illuminated in white light, can itself serve as the speckle pattern. The final is also
the case for our experiment (the microscopic image ofthe surface ofMRE, illuminated by white light).
The second step is to retrieve the in-plane displacement of the object from the series images recording the speckle
pattern during deformation. It has been wildly addressed that the speckle movement calculated by the intensity correlation
of consequent images relates to the displacement distribution on the surface of the object9'10. Therefore, by calculating the
correlation of a series of recorded images numerically, one can obtain the in-plane displacement of an object at different
time. In the following, we want to stress the algorithm for calculating the correlation of consequent images. Suppose two
images denoted as I and '2' which are recorded at t1 and t1 + At respectively. The images are all divided into
for 1 m M and 1 n N
M x N regions. Each region of image I, for i = 1,2 is denoted by
Following reference [10], the digital correlation ofregion Rmn can be defined as:
Cmn(p,q)=
p,lq)
where the summation is over the minute area Rmn ' which is carefully selected to ensure that the maximum peak location in
Cmn (p, q) can represent the average displacement of Rmn in the time interval from t1 to t1 + At. To obtain a precise
location of the correlation peak, the Gaussian curve-fitting method1111 is also employed. Therefore, the location of the peak
c (pt, q)
Prnn Pmn
,,
+ Cq
,i
(p q)
o
Cn1nq Pnrn ,
q
o
(1)
605
where
to p
and
q coordinates,
4.1 The deformation of MRE with the volume fraction around 27%
Figure 5 represents the evolution of the displacement distribution when the field turns on (The power supply turns on).
When the field is off, the displacement is rather small and distributed disorderly (See figure 5a). Along with the change of
the magnetic field, the displacement in the equal-length interval becomes larger and orderly. Further, the displacement
distribution represents the material is compressed during this progress (Figure5(b)-(e) represent each minute area tends to
move toward the opposite direction of z axis). When the field becomes stable (The output voltage of the power supply
reaches the stable value of 36V), the displacement becomes small and disorder again, which represents the deformation
progress ofthe material corresponding to the change ofthe magnetic field reaches its end. Therefore, the whole deformation
progress takes about 150 to 200 millisecond (Consult figure (b) to figure (e)). As stated above, this time interval includes
the response time ofthe power supply. Hence, the response time ofMRE should be much less than several tens millisecond.
4.2 The deformation of MRE with the volume fraction around 50%
Figure 6 represents the evolution of the displacement distribution when the field turns on (The power supply turns on).
The six figures are much similar to that of figure 5, which reveals that the deformation progress of the MRE with the
volume fraction around 50% is much alike to that ofthe MRE with the volume fraction around 27%.
4.3 The deformation of EFC with the volume fraction around 27%
Figure 7 represents the evolution of the displacement distribution of EFC with the volume fraction around 27% when
the field turns on (The power supply turns on). The components of the material are just as that of the MRF used for the
experiment reported in subsection 4. 1 . The only difference between these two materials is that MRE is cured under strong
magnetic field while EFC is not. From figure 7(a), we can see the displacement is distributed disorderly when the field is
off From figures 7(b)-7(e), along with the change of the magnetic field, the displacement changes more violently compared
with that of MRE. On the contrast to MRE, the minute areas of EFC sample tend to move toward the positive direction of z
axis, which indicates that EFC is expanded along z axis under such case. From figures 7(b)-7(e), we can also find that the
606
400
: :H
400
350
300
I_
250
200
. 200
150
150
100
100
I I
1/
'
'
50
50
300
400
0 directionlpixel)
200
100
500
450
,/ \___)
400
'
350
300 '
100
-'
'
'
/ I
'
-- I
'
I '
/ I
/////
//"
-I /
/ '
/ '
'-
'
'
''
'
' '
400
1OCI
'
T
500
?'
'II
45C
40C
'
' '
35C
'
\)
'
I I I
I ' I
I
/
'
25C
20C
15C
I /
1
100
) I
' I
50
'
i
'
)
)
\ )
'
'
'
'
/j
'
'
'
'
'
100
)I
I
'
I /
I
I
200
'
,I
1
1
) '1
)
'
300
, ., -
'
'
.,
.-
'
'
, ,
600
500
'/
'
/ '.
(d)
'
1 1' i// )
I
I
I / I
)/
\ I
'
'
"I
'
/
'
'
200
400
300
500
600
500
450
400
'
.,
'
'
'
'
- '
'
',
'
'
'
(f)
'
350
250
' 200
150
'
'
'
400
'
'
300
'
(e)
1/
l''\' '
I I
/ '')'ll' I/ Il
I
100
\/ ''
'
x direction)pixel)
30C
'
I//
' I
600
.''.',',''.'I
)
'
50
'
'- - '
400
300
xdirection)pixel)
x direction(pixel)
',
150
'
)/
. 200 )
'
\l ) I \
300'
''j
300
200
130
' '
\'l)l/
\/
350
'
',--
.'
\' I
, 1) 11/ '//'/ J'' I4/)
'I )
/ )/
I
ii
/ )/ ' 1 // ' I )/ I
I
400
' ''S"
' ''''
200
'
450
1/1.'-'''
'
4 /V
'/
'
100
(c)
'
I- ?'
'25C
('
50
'
'
//
'',xf-'-,-.-,--.I
'
totolf5s
'
''
-
'I' /
I
I
600
.--l,//
'
-.
'
150
'-
I-__'_I. '
/
/ '
250
200
' -'
'1/
'
'
__
'250
'
.
350
300
'
'', -/
'
450
450
(b)
('a)
100
I
50
600
100
200
xdirection)pixel)
300
400
500
600
x direction(pixel)
Figure 5. The evolution ofthe whole field displacement corresponding to the field switching (MRE sample with volume fraction of 27%)
607
(h
(R'
450
450
400
400
350
350
300
300
250
250
0200
200
150
150
100
100
50
200
600
500
400
300
(c)
/ /
450
-
13
200
/
1
--
/
I
//I-l-/-.
%/
/
-/
- //
/
400
'250
/ /
- I
'
--
I -
,--
/ /
-
--
- I- / /
/ /
/ -, / /
--
//
I I
450
--
/
/
-/
//
I/
50
250
100
50
400
300
500
I )
1 \\'
I
)
1/ I/ j ' I I
1
400
/
I
200
150
100
1
-
1/
/ \/ /
1
/ J- /
(e)
\/
/ I I /
I
I I \ I ) ) / 1
) I 1 I I I l
/ / / I
) I
-
/ //I//
I
I,
I /
- )//// l
I I
I I I I
I / I
I 1 1 )
.1
I/
50
I
200
I -
300
// 'I I/
/ 1/ /
'
I
I
1
1
I
/ )
/
-
/ I /
'
II
I /
I I
/ I
I I
I /
//
(d)
1
I
I
/ )
' /
I
I
I
I/I/I
-// I I I
/
/
\\1
-
/-
/ 11 1/1/1111 /
200
300
400
x direclion(pixel)
500
600
(f)
450
400
'
I
I
I /
/
I I /
I \
300
I
/
400
250
200
150
100
600
500
350
I///I-
/ Il1 /
I
.--
100
- I'
I
I
- /1/1/1
/
600
13
n//,'\ 1 // I/ /
/ /
I /
I )
100
300
x direclion)pixel)
250
300
400
xdirection(pixel)
350
200
'
I
/
150
100
300
200
I
-
'250
-
400
350
'/'i'
- ---I,-,-,
/
150
450
'
100
0 directionlpixel)
305
50
100
350
-I
/ I-
/-
/ I
/ -
500
lox
50
600
100
200
0 direction)pixel)
400
300
x direction)pixel)
60
Figure 6. The evolution ofthe whole field displacement corresponding to the field switching (MRE sample with volume fraction of 50%)
(a)the displacement distribution when the field is off;
608
( j)
450
.
,,
400
400
350
350
300
300
250
'250
200
200
150
150
100
.
50
--
'
- .,-- .,.
100
: . - ',
-:
200
100
-.- , I
300
400
500
./
450
-
400
'250
. 200
/,
.,
,,
,7/,
,,
450
'
350
300
'250
I / A i / / / / / ..' / , / / I /4 t . ,
/
/! /'.-/ , / I 7/ /
. 200
.s
150
100
100
50
/ ,f / ,O / ,
/-
t\ /1
,7
\ . \ . Th
-*
t/t,
---*100
300
400
x direction(pixel)
200
500
'
400
350
300
1250
'
\ - '- \
\
' \
t\
I I
,-.
1
150
'
I .
100
_r
'
I
I
'
\
50
'
.
200
-.
I
I
I
I '. .
I I
\\
i
t. I
I
r\I
'
S
100
I \
I
'
.
-
200
1
'..
\.1
'
I \ /1\
\
\
s
\.
400
'
'
,.
'
,_ .
300
400
x direction(pixel)
'
'
500
600
1 7/ 1
,'/7
,/
i
IIi
/,i , , Ii
, I I 7 1 t , .- t I .'
t -.
t , I . /1 , I , t ,
1 /., ,
.'
.-
(d)
IiI/,/ ,/t7//
till,/t/t//'/-/
I,
tI
/ , t 1 t 7/ t I I
f71/t
t727/
tt
//
t , 7 t / /1 7 7 /
//II,
t7/'
///t-t///,/\:'tt
'
t //t // / /,
I/. t /
,/, 1, ,t/, -
, ,,\ t
.
I t
100
200
400
300
500
600
0 direcUon(pioel)
(f)
( e)
450
400
I
. I
350
250
.,
50
I\
500
200
150
I
100
'..
300
1\
300
x directionlplcel)
\ \ \,
1
..
200
,t
600
450
_,.
- 'F .' ,,
'S
tt /t/ ,////
,fi////
//f /1t
'7 /////
, ..-
1'
150 -I
I ,,\
r
'
(c)
400
/4
..
,'
100
/ / 7 , / // / /
//
.-- / //
!_
..,
600
, 7 7 /1 7 /',
./ / I / i ,
.- .- , , / / /4 / 7 / 7 / /7 .1 , /
350
300
/
I
/ /'.-' / 7 /
/'
50
, I
..
x directIor(pixel)
/,
..
(b)
_1l
450
50
600
100
200
300
x direclionlpixel)
400
500
600
Figure 7. The evolution ofthe whole field displacement corresponding to the field switching (EFC sample with volume fraction of 27%)
(a)the displacement distribution when the field is off;
(b)-(e) the evolution of displacement
(f)the displacement when the deformation progress is finished
609
displacement of each minute area sometimes has an x-direction component. This is caused by the non-uniformity of the
magnetic field.
It should be pointed out that, in figures 5-7, a scaling factor of 70 is employed in drawing the displacement distribution
because the displacement is much tiny. Therefore, in figure 7, there are some overlapped arrows.
4.4 Discussion
Based on the description presented in subsections 4. 1 & 4.2, it can be concluded that, for uniaxial magnetic field, MilE
will be compressed along the direction of the magnetic field when the field is applied. This conclusion is quite obviously
and it can be explained by single ferrous-particle chain model, which is used to analyze the field-induced shear modulus of
MRE and dynamic yield stress of magnetorheological fluid in literature. This phenomenon is also discussed in a theoretical
way in reference [2].
Comparing figure 5 with figure 6, since they are very alike, we can find an interesting phenomenon that the absolute
values of the deformation of this two kinds of MRE, corresponding to the field switching, are equal. Does this phenomenon
indicate that the deformation of MRE corresponding to field switching is not affected by volume fraction? This would be
studied further.
Based on the description ofthe deformation of EFC driven by magnetic field in subsection 4.3, it can be concluded that
the material is dilated along the direction of the magnetic field. Borcea etc has predicated such phenomenon from a
.
theoretical way in their recent published paper [6] . They reported that EFC will be compressed in the directions orthogonal
.
to the direction of the applied field while it will be dilated slightly in the direction of the magnetic field. The reason lies in
the average magnetic interaction between particle pairs, since the particles are embedded in the matrix randomly.
The deformation of EFC is larger to that of MRE, when they are driven by magnetic field. This is also reasonable
because the particles in MRE are highly compact in the chain-like structure, which is formed during curing the material and
embedded in the rubber matrix, while the particles in EFC are distributed randomly. If we regard those ferrous particles to
be rigid, it indicates that the allowable compression along the direction ofthe chains ofMRE is smaller than that ofEFC or,
in such direction, MRE is stiffer than EFC.
Since the deformation characteristics of MRE and EFC are opposite, it can also be concluded that the field-induced
physical properties of the two materials along the direction of the chain-like structure embedded in MilE, such as wave
propagation, electrical conductivity etc, are different.
We also have done a lot of experiments for different magnetic fields. We find the deformations for MREand EFC
driven by magnetic field are controlled by the strength of the magnetic field. Therefore, it is possible to utilize such
materials to design tiny actuator. Limited by the length of the paper, the experimental results are not presented here.
5. CONCLUSIONS
MRE is a new kind of smart materials due to its stable and controllable mechanical properties. In this study, after
obtaining the field-induced shear and tension property of MRE, we presented the field-induced deformation of MIlE and
EFC via white light speckle techniques. The experiment reveals the following main results:
DMRE is compressed along the direction ofthe applied magnetic field while EFC is dilated.
the same volume fraction, the deformation of MRE driven by magnetic field is smaller than that of EFC or MRE is
stiffer than EFC in the direction of the chain-like structure embedded in MRE.
deformation of MRE, driven by magnetic field, changes slightly with the volume fraction.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The principle author gratefully appreciates all the members, especially Mr. Yaowen Zhan, who made the program to
evaluate the correlation, of the lab of photomechanics of the department of USTC for assisting him to do the experiment
during the half year of waiting offer after he obtained the PhD degree.
REFERENCES
1. G.Y.Zhou, Mechanical Behavior of MR Elastomer and the Structure of MRF Driven by Rotating Fields, PhD dissertation,
University of Science and Tecimology of China, Apr. 2002
610
2. G.Y.Zhou and P.Q.Zhang, "Investigation of the dynamic mechanical behavior of the double-barreled configuration in a
magnetorheological fluid damper", Smart Mater. Struct. ,Vol. 11, pp23O-238, 2002
3 . G.Y.Zhou, "Shear Property of MR Elastomer", Smart Mater. Struct .(in press)
4. L.C.Davis, "Model of Magnetorheological Elastomers", Journal ofApplied Physics, Vol.85, No.6, pp3348-3 35 1, 1999
5. J.M.Ginder, M.E.Nichols, L.D.Elie, and J.L.Tardiff, "Magnetorheological Elastomers: Properties and Applications",
SPIE Conference on Smart Materials Technologies, Vol.3675, ppl3l-l38, 1999
6. W.F. Schlotter, etc, "The dynamics of magnetorheological elastomers studied by Synchrotron Speckle Analysis",
International Journal ofModern Physics B, Vol. 16, Nos 17&18, p2426-2432, 2002
7. L.Borcea and O.Bruno, "On the magneto-elastic properties of elastomer-ferromagnet composites", J Mech. & Phy. of
Solids, Vol.
8. G.Y.Zhou and J.R.Li, "Dynamic Tension and Compression Experiment on MR Elastomer", SmartMater. Struct (to be
submitted)
9. I.Yamaguchi, "Speckle displacement and decorrelation in the diffraction and image fields for small object deformation",
OpticaACTA, Vol. 28, No. 10, ppl359-l376, 1981
10. W. Peters, W. Rason, "Digital imaging techniques in experimental stress analysis", Opt. Eng., Vol. 21, No. 3, p427-43 1,
1982
11. H. Huang, D. Dabiri and M. Ghiarib, "On errors of digital particle image velocimetry", Meas. Sci. Technol., Vol. 8,
p1427-1440, 1997
611