Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
(Bidangkuasa Rayuan)
Rayuan Sivil No: J-02-3114 Tahun 2009
Antara
1.
PerayuPerayu
dan
1.
2.
3.
4.
RespondenResponden
Disatu Dengan
Rayuan Sivil No: J-02-3112 Tahun 2009
Dan
Rayuan Sivil No: J-02-3113 Tahun 2009
2.
-1-
3.
4.
5.
PlaintifPlaintif
DefendanDefendan
dan
1.
2.
3.
Disatu Dengan
Guaman Sivil No: 22-412 Tahun 2002
Dan
Guaman Sivil No: 22-413 Tahun 2002
CORAM:
Zainun binti Ali, JCA (now FCJ)
Sulaiman bin Daud, JCA (as he then was)
Ramly bin Hj. Ali, JCA
-2-
In this triple suits involving the same parties who are related
to each other, the High Court after a full trial, dismissed the
Plaintiffs (Appellants) three actions with costs. However
Defendants counter claim in Suit 413 was allowed with
costs. Hence these appeals before us.
3.
4.
Hamid
-3-
5.
ii)
iii)
-4-
6.
7.
8.
Kee
The PA was
-6-
12.
Hassans
The High Court dismissed with all the 3 (three) cases with
costs. However, only the Defendants counterclaim in Suit
413 was allowed with costs. Hence this appeal.
As an
-9-
18.
Hamids
The
In Suit 412 the Plaintiffs assert that upon obtaining the PA,
Badariah
and
Shariffah
Fatimah
(Fatimah)
wrongly
who
personally
handles
matters
for
the
and
relationship
ward
which
relationship
produce
and
fiduciary/trustee
presumption
that
the
(iii)
(iv)
his
judgment
independently
and
gave
(vi)
Hamid
cash
that the
Therefore, the
- 15 -
26.
27.
28.
- 16 -
29.
30.
31.
- 17 -
- 18 -