Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
◦ This book compares the business investment environment of six major Asian
countries, namely China(Beijing), Hong Kong, Korea, Malaysia, Singapore and
Taiwan. To that end, on-site research by KOTRA's overseas KBCs (Korea Business
Centers) and surveys by potential foreign investors on investment attractiveness was
conducted to explore the investment environments of the six countries.
Summary
◦ Hong Kong offers foreign corporations such attractions as the lowest tax rate of the
countries concerned, a free financial transaction system, and the geographical
advantage of its close proximity to China. It also offers convenient daily living
environments. However, of the six countries, it suffers from the most expensive
location costs and the most expensive residential costs, which together constitute a
great weakness.
◦ Malaysia is one of the more developed countries among Southeast Asian countries,
boasts competitive location and labor costs, and offers good spoken English, making
it favorable for foreign investment. However, its public transportation systems and
other infrastructures are still inferior to those of more developed countries, and its
manpower competitiveness is weak.
◦ China (Beijing) is superior in terms of location and labor costs, and is competitive in
terms of the capability and supply of its human resources. However, the protection
of intellectual property rights is weak, and its public transportation systems, Internet
penetration level, and other infrastructures remain at the levels encountered in
developing countries. Also, China is lagging behind in the reform of various
regulations and systems and remains among the lowest-ranked countries on diverse
international indices, making its investment environment less competitive compared
to other countries. However, it constitutes a large domestic market, and is striving to
create a more favorable investment environment such as rearrangement of corporate
tax rates.
Ⅰ. Introduction / 3
7 1. Korea
7 ▪Business Environment
7 (1) Location Conditions
10 (2) Labor Management
13 (3) Taxation Conditions
15 (4) Protection of Intellectual Property Rights
16 (5) Logistics Environment
18 (6) Public Services
19 (7) Establishment of Corporations and Acquisition of Realty
21 ▪Living Environment
21 (1) Residential Conditions
22 (2) Medical Service System
24 (3) Convenience of Transportation
25 (4) Education Facilities for Foreigners
27 (5) Development of Communication Systems
27 ▪Investment System
27 (1) Investment Law
29 (2) Investment Promotion Agency
30 (3) Major Investment Incentives
34 2. Taiwan
34 ▪Business Environment
34 (1) Location Conditions
37 (2) Labor Management
40 (3) Taxation Conditions
41 (4) Protection of Intellectual Property Rights
42 (5) Logistics Environment
Contents
43 (6) Public Services
44 (7) Establishment of Corporations and Acquisition of Realty
46 ▪Living Environment
46 (1) Residential Conditions
46 (2) Medical Service System
48 (3) Convenience of Transportation
49 (4) Education Facilities for Foreigners
51 (5) Development of Communication Systems
51 ▪Investment System
51 (1) Investment Law
52 (2) Investment Promotion Agency
53 (3) Major Investment Incentives
54 3. Malaysia
54 ▪Business Environment
54 (1) Location Conditions
56 (2) Labor Management
59 (3) Taxation Conditions
60 (4) Protection of Intellectual Property Rights
60 (5) Logistics Environment
61 (6) Public Services
62 (7) Establishment of Corporations and Acquisition of Realty
64 ▪Living Environment
64 (1) Residential Conditions
65 (2) Medical Service System
66 (3) Convenience of Transportation
66 (4) Education Facilities for Foreigners
67 (5) Development of Communication Systems
68 ▪Investment System
68 (1) Investment Law
68 (2) Investment Promotion Agency
69 (3) Major Investment Incentives
71 4. Singapore
71 ▪Business Environment
71 (1) Location Conditions
Contents
108 (3) Major Investment Incentives
110 6. Hong Kong
110 ▪Business Environment
110 (1) Location Conditions
113 (2) Labor Management
119 (3) Taxation Conditions
119 (4) Protection of Intellectual Property Rights
120 (5) Logistics Environment
121 (6) Public Services
122 (7) Establishment of Corporations and Acquisition of Realty
124 ▪Living Environment
124 (1) Residential Conditions
125 (2) Medical Service System
125 (3) Convenience of Transportation
127 (4) Education Facilities for Foreigners
128 (5) Development of Communication Systems
128 ▪Investment System
128 (1) Investment Law
129 (2) Investment Promotion Agency
Ⅴ. Conclusion / 157
References / 164
Introduction
I Introduction
◦ Korea is locked in a fierce competition with other Asian countries to promote foreign
investment. Its major rivals include China, Hong Kong, Malaysia, Singapore, and
Taiwan.
◦ These six Asian countries (including Korea) are vigorously pushing to promote foreign
investment in order to advance the development of their industries and economies.
◦ According to the 2009 IMD World Competitiveness Index, Hong Kong ranked second
among 57 countries, making it the most competitive country of the six Asian
countries. Singapore ranked third, Malaysia 18th, China 20th, Taiwan 23rd, and Korea
27th.
◦ However, the IMD world competitiveness standings do not reflect the specific
strengths and weaknesses of their investment environments, thus making them
unsuitable for an effective comparison or assessment of each individual country's
investment environment.
◦ This book categorizes the six Asian countries' investment environments into business
environment; living environment; and investment systems; and then compares them in
an effort to identify the strengths and weaknesses of Korea's investment environment.
I. Introduction 3
◦ First, business environment encompasses location conditions, labor-management
relations, taxation conditions, the protection of intellectual property rights, logistics
environment, public services, and the establishment of corporations and the acquisition
of realty. Second, living environment encompasses residential conditions, medical
service systems, the convenience of transportation, education facilities for foreigners,
and the development of communication systems. Finally, investment system concerns
the investment laws, investment promotion agencies and major investment incentives.
◦ In the case of China, which is subject to vast regional differences, Beijing, the
country's capital, is compared with the other Asian countries.
1. Korea
2. Taiwan
3. Malaysia
4. Singapore
5. China (Beijing)
6. Hong Kong
II The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors
1 KOREA
Business Environment
- Office purchase and rental costs vary greatly in Korea depending on the region. In Seoul,
the costs are considerably higher than anywhere else. In the case of the Finance Center,
which has the highest rental costs in Gangnam, Seoul, the rental cost per m² is US$ 24.
Office rental costs continue to rise, although they have slowed down remarkably in recent
months due to the economic crisis.
Legal Weekly Working Hours Maternity Leave Annual National Holidays Saturday Holiday System
40 hours Up to 90 days 5 days Being implemented
Source : Ministry of Labor, National Laws Information Center
Note : 1) Certain workplaces implement a 44-hour weekly working system, with the enforcement of the
revised Labor Standards Act deferred.
2) Maternal leave should be over 45 days, and such 45 days may be used before going into
labor.
Sharing Ratios
Insurance Purpose
Employer Employee
Unemployment benefits
Prevention of unemployment,
(0.45% of the total wage)
Employment promotion of employment, and Unemployment benefits
+ Development of job skills
Insurance development of employees' job (0.45% of the total wage)
(0.25~0.85% depending on
skills
the size of the corporation)
Treatments for work-related 7/1,000 ~ 533/1,000
Accident
injuries, disease, physical of the total wage -
Insurance
disability, or death (according to the job)
National Pension support for ageing,
4.5% of the standard monthly remuneration
Pension insurable diseases, and death
Health Prevention, diagnosis and
2.54% of the standard monthly remuneration
Insurance treatment of diseases and injuries
Source : Guide to Foreign Investment (Invest Korea, KOTRA)
□ Labor Power
- The working population of Korea is still increasing, but due to employment difficulties,
the ratio of participation in economic activities has declined slightly.
◦ Education Levels
- Korea has a very low illiteracy ratio of 1.7% (2008), attesting to the nation's high
enthusiasm for education. Every year 490,000 university graduates enter the labor market.
□ Wage Levels
□ Labor Disputes
◦ Labor-Management Relations
<Labor Disputes>
□ Taxation
- Korea's tax ratio from GDP is 22.7% (2007), which is lower than the average tax ratio of
26.9% (2005) among the OECD's member states.
- Korea has continued to implement a policy designed to improve its system of protection
of intellectual property rights. Consequently, in 2009, Korea was removed from the US
government's yearly Watch List for the first time in twenty years.
- The number of appeals over patent disputes filed between domestic and foreign
companies in 2008 stood at 620, among which, appeals over trademark disputes numbered
490 or 79.0% of the total, indicating serious infringements of trademarks. Foreign
companies' appeals filed against domestic ones numbered 400 or 64.52% of the total,
which is higher than the number (220 or 35.48%) of appeals filed by domestic
corporations against foreign companies.
- According to the WIPO's (World Intellectual Property Organization) 2008 PCT (Patent
Cooperation Treaty) international patent application statistics, the total number of PCT
patent applications around the world amounted to 63,600, up 3.2% from 2007. Korea filed
7,908 patent applications, up 847 (12%) from 2007, representing 4.8% of the world's PCT
patent applications, and ranking 4th. As such, Korea is a major applicant for patents.
□ Marine Transportation
- Korea's major harbors are located in Busan, Incheon, Daecheon, Gwangyang, Yeosu,
Gunsan, Jeju, Mukho, Pohang, and Mokpo.
- Busan Port, which boasts Korea's largest harbor, is situated on the major world trunk
lines to and from North America, Asia, the Middle East, Europe and South America. The
world's 5th-ranking container port, Busan Port handled 13.45 million TEUs (Twenty-foot
Equivalent Unit) of cargo in 2008, up 1.4% from 13.26 million TEUs in 2007.
- The Trans-Korea Railway, which originates in Busan Port, is now fully built (a partial test
operation was conducted in May 2007), and will be connected via the Trans-Asia Railway
with China, Russia, Mongolia, Central Asia and Europe. Successful operation of the
railway will boost Korea's aspirations to become a world-class logistics hub.
- The main airport in the Greater Seoul Area, Incheon Port handled 1.7 million TEUs in
2008, up 2.4% from 1.66 million TEUs in 2007. Incheon Port neighbors the world's second
largest air cargo handler - Incheon International Airport, Korea's capital - Seoul, and
Incheon - committed to establishing itself as a high-tech city.
□ Air Transportation
- Korea has 15 airports, with international airports located in Incheon, Gimpo, Gimhae, Jeju,
Daegu, Cheongju, Yangyang and Muan.
- Incheon Airport, located at the center of Northeast Asia, possesses a highly favorable
international logistics hub location. It offers a speedy, accurate logistics processing
system, and simplified customs clearance procedures to help create an efficient, convenient
business environment. Its air cargo system, dubbed AIRCIS, is highly acclaimed by users.
- Incheon Airport is a four-time winner (2005~2009) of the World Best Airport Award
hosted by the Airports Council International on Airport Service Quality. It grew into the
2nd largest air cargo handling airport with a handling volume of 2.42 million tons in 200
◦ Railway
- Korea's railway services include Mugunghwaho, Saemaeulho, and KTX (Korea Train
Express) trains. KTX fares are highest, followed by those of the Saemaeulho and
Mugunghwa services.
- KTX was launched in 2004, making Korea the fifth country to have adopted a high-speed
train system after Japan, France, Germany and Spain.
- KTX trains, which can run at speeds of up to 350km/h, connect Seoul and Busan via the
Gyeongbu Line, and Seoul and Mokpo via the Honam Line. KTX serves major cities such
as Daejeon, Daegu, Busan, and Gwangju. The Seoul-Busan KTX line increased Korea's
railway passenger transport capacity by 3.4 times, and its railway cargo transport capacity
by 7.7 times.
◦ Expressway
- There are four types of companies under the Commercial Act, namely partnership
companies, limited partnership companies, joint-stock companies, and limited companies.
Of these, joint-stock companies constitute the majority.
- Foreigners can establish local companies in accordance with the Foreign Investment
Promotion Act and the Commercial Act. The amount of FDI should exceed KRW 50
million (US$ 40,387.7) in order to benefit from the Foreign Investment Promotion Act.
- Generally speaking, the reporting of the establishment of a corporation and the filing of a
business registration application are conducted simultaneously. The reporting and
application can be conducted at the competent tax service offices or Invest Korea
(KOTRA). The reporting of the establishment of a corporation should be completed within
two months of the corporation registration, and the registration of a business should be
completed within 20 days of the commencement of business.
- Registration tax : 0.4% of capital; a triple tax imposed in cases where the corporation is to
be built within a large city.
- Revenue stamp for the Supreme Court : a fee for registration application
□ Residential Convenience
- Yeouido, Hannam-dong and Gangnam, areas in which many foreigners reside, are very
well equipped with shopping facilities, including large marts and department stores, as
well as schools and hospitals, thereby enhancing the quality of life and daily convenience
of foreign residents
◦ Residential Costs
- Foreigners prefer monthly rental types, but the rental charges in their favorite zones are
expensive.
□ Medical Services
- English-language medical hot lines are operated by the following 6 hospitals: Seoul
National University Hospital, Severance Hospital, Youngdong Severance Hospital, Seoul
Samsung Medical Center, Soonchunghyang University Hospital, and Kangnam Cha Hospital.
Hospital Website
Seoul National University Hospital www.snuh.org
Soonchunhyang University Hospital schuh.ac.kr
Korea University Anam Hospital anam.kumc.or.kr
Youngdong Severance Hospital www.yuhs.or.kr
Kyung Hee University Medical Center www.khmc.or.kr
Severance Hospital www.severance.or.kr
Seoul Samsung Medical Center www.samsunghospital.com
Kangnam Cha Hospital kangnam.chamc.co.kr
Seoul Asan Medical Center www.amc.seoul.kr
Kangnam St. Mary's Hospital www.cmckangnam.or.kr
Jasaeng Hospital of Oriental Medicine www.jaseng.co.kr
Hanyang University International Cooperation Hospital imc.hanyang.ac.kr
Source : Foreigners' Living Guide
- Under the national health insurance system, beneficiaries include company workers and
regional subscribers (workers in the agricultural and fisheries industries, and urban
private business operators). Foreigners are also allowed to subscribe to the system.
□ Transportation System
- Korea possesses a well developed subway system and bus services. Seoul runs nine
extensive subways lines (numbered 1 to 9). A number of these subway lines run between
Seoul and the Greater Seoul Area, including the Gyeongbu, Gyeongin, Gyeongwon,
Ansan, Gwacheon, Ilsan, Bundang, and Jungang lines. Public announcements on the
subway are made in Korean, English, Chinese and Japanese.
- Bus line information is available over the Internet or through city transportation maps,
and bus stops show detailed bus lines. Overall Seoul bus operations can be confirmed
over the Internet and via mobile phones. Some buses provide English-language
announcement services. Reckless driving, incivility, and skipping bus stops have now been
eliminated; the services have improved greatly.
- A transportation card system is operated along with transport card fares and transfer
discount systems. Basic bus fares are applied every 10km, while transfer services are free.
An additional fare of KRW 100 (US$ 0.08) is applied for every 5km after the first 10km.
- Korea's public transport fares are inexpensive, and the services are used by a majority of
citizens.
- In the case of taxi fares, the initial 2km traveled incurs a basic fare of KRW 2,400 (US$
1.93). Beyond the first 2km, KRW 100 (US$ 0.08) is charged for every 144m or 35 seconds.
Also, between 12 am and 4 am, a 20% surcharge is applied.
□ Foreign School
- Korea currently has 45 foreign schools, of which 19 are American and British schools, 18
are Chinese schools, and 8 are other foreign schools (Turkish, Mongol and Norwegian).
- Yearly tuition fees for foreign schools are expensive, generally costing twice as much as
two years of tuition fees for Korean private universities.
Investment System
- The Foreign Investment Promotion Act (the Act) was enacted in 1988 to promote foreign
investment by providing support for and enhancing the convenience of foreign
investment. Furthermore, FDI-related foreign exchange and external transactions must be
governed by the Foreign Exchange Transaction Act unless otherwise specified in the Act.
Tax breaks on FDI must be governed by the Special Taxation Restriction Act and its
enforcement ordinances and rules, and by the regulations on tax breaks for FDI.
- The categories of businesses excluded from FDI are announced under the integrated
regulations and notifications concerning FDI and the introduction of technologies,
although limited FDI is allowed for certain businesses.
- Invest Korea undertakes to perform a diverse range of activities concerned with the
process of investment promotion, ranging from PR, the promotion of direct investment,
and professional consultancy, to the provision of support for and the direct handling of
approvals and permissions, consulting services aimed at helping investors to settle in
Korea, and ex post management.
- Survey investment information : Search for and provide the information necessary for
feasibility studies on investment.
Investment - Explore partners : Explore investment partners through KOTRA's KBCs.
Consulting - Consulting services in professional areas : exclusive investment, joint investment, M&A,
Services realty investment, etc.
- Consulting services in professional areas such as investment systems and laws,
accounting and taxation.
- Ombudsman : The home doctor system helps foreign investment companies to address
various difficulties.
- VISA extension : Help the employees of foreign investment companies with foreign
Ex post
registration and extension of stay.
Support
- Support for settlement in Korea : Assist foreign investment companies' employees and
their families with settling comfortably in Korea by
exploring housing, foreign schools, etc.
- Under the Special Taxation Restriction Act, Korea implements a system of tax breaks
designed to facilitate the transfer of cutting-edge technologies and to promote foreign
investment.
Tax Breaks
Targets of Tax Breaks Period of Tax Investment Requirements for
Detailed Targets
Breaks Tax Breaks
- Highly advanced technology
- Businesses requiring highly : none
advanced technologies, and - 7-year breaks - Investment area
industrial support services ․ 5 years : 100% ․ Manufacturing : US$ 30 million
- Corporations in development - National tax ․ 2 years : 50% ․ Tourism : US$ 20 million
areas requiring investment ․ Corporate tax ․ Logistics : US$ 10 million
․ Income tax ․ R&D : US$ 2 million
- Companies in a complex-type
- Manufacturing, tourism and
FIZs - Local tax
corporate cities : US$ 10 million
- Companies in FEZs ․ Acquisition tax
- Logistics : US$ 5 million
- Companies in FTZs ․ Registration tax - 5-year breaks
- FEZ developers
- Companies in corporate city ․ Property tax ․ 3 years : 100%
: Investment amount of over
development zones ․ 2 years : 50%
US$ 30 million or FDI ratio of
- Developers in FEZs
50%, and total investment of
- Developers in corporate city
over US$ 500 million
development zones
□ Cash Support
- The cash support system is designed as a means of providing cash support to foreign
investors in order to promote foreign investment for the purpose of national economic
development, provided that certain requirements are met, including a guarantee that the
support money be used for specific purposes based on negotiations with the foreign
investors.
- Targets : Candidate corporations with an FDI ratio of over 30% should build or expand
factories for businesses requiring highly advanced technologies or for industrial
support services with an investment amount of US$ 10 million; should build
and expand factories for the production of parts and materials with an
investment amount of over US$ 10 million; or should newly install or expand
research facilities to conduct R&D activities relating to the businesses requiring
highly advanced technologies; and should have a usual workforce of over 10
- Uses : Land purchase costs or rental costs for installing factory facilities or research
facilities; construction costs for factory facilities or research facilities; purchase
costs for capital goods and research materials and items of equipment that are
used for business or research in factory facilities or research facilities; installation
costs for electric and communication facilities that are needed for building factory
facilities and research facilities; and employment subsidies and education and
training subsidies.
- The cash amount and detailed conditions are determined through negotiations between
the government and the investor (5~15% of the FDI amount). The sharing ratios of the
central government and the local government are fixed.
- If a local municipality promotes foreign investment with an FDI ratio of 30% or with the
foreign investor being the largest shareholder, the central government can provide
financial support such as location costs. Location support is provided by leasing, lending
or selling the state's or the local municipality's land or factories or other properties to FDI
corporations or operators of FDI environment improvement facilities.
- Cash support limits including the purchase costs for land are outlined as follows.
⋅New investment : Under 50% of the FDI amount
⋅Investment for facility expansion : 50% of the FDI amount or 25% of the sum of the
FDI amount and the earned surplus.
Business Environment
- Industrial development underpins the economic development of Taiwan. To that end, the
government establshed industrial complexes which are divided into four groups, namely
industrial complexes, science parks, export processing zones, and FTZs.
- National industrial complexes, like private commercial offices, are highly popular among
tenants, and those industrial complexes in northern areas where there are vigorous
economic activities charge relatively high rental costs.
- There is no major difference in the price of office purchase or rental costs between Taipei
and local cities.
Legal Weekly Working Hours Maternity Leave Annual National Holidays Saturday Holiday System
Under 8 hours a day, a total
56 days About 10 days Being implemented
of 84 hours in 2 weeks
Source : Labor Standards Act
□ Labor Power
- Taiwan has seen a steady increase in its working population in recent times.
- Taiwan is also seeing an ongoing increase in its non-working population with the
transition to an aging society.
- Taiwan, a country with scarce natural resources, has a great deal of enthusiasm for
education. Thus, the people are basically university graduates, and a growing number of
people are in master's degree courses.
- Annual number of high school graduates are a little larger than university and college
graduates.
□ Wage Levels
- The minimum monthly wage is NT$ 17,280 (US$ 525.9), and the minimum hourly wage is
NT$ 95 (US$ 2.9), according to the prescribed regulation.
- Wages, lower than Taiwan's per capita GNP, give the country greater labor productivity
than its competitors. However, due to high prices, most married couples both have to
work to earn a living.
- Service industries account for over 70% of Taiwan's economy, thus making a significant
contribution to the country's economic growth. The average wage in this sector is a little
higher than that received by workers in the industrial sector.
□ Labor Disputes
◦ Labor-Management Relations
- As of 2007, 4,588 labor unions had been established in Taiwan, and the number of union
members stood at 3 million.
<Labor Disputes>
(Unit : dispute)
2005 2006 2007
Labor Disputes 14,256 15,464 19,729
Source : Executive Yuan's CLA
- To join the WTO, Taiwan took action to modify its law pertaining to intellectual property
rights, beginning in 1997. Immediately after officially joining the WTO, its Executive Yuan
strongly cracked down on the illegal copying of products for three years from 2002. In
2003, the Intellectual Property Rights Protection Police Force was established to strengthen
crackdowns on illegal copying. On the strength of these efforts, Taiwan was able to lower
its illegal copying ratio from 43% to 40% for three years (2006~2008), thereby achieving
the third lowest ratio in Asia after Japan (23%) and Singapore (37%). Since July 2008, a
court dedicated exclusively to dealing with lawsuits over intellectual property rights has
been handling such lawsuits promptly and efficiently.
- Disputes over IPRs increased remarkably in 2007 from 2006, but decreased somewhat in
2008.
□ Marine Transportation
- Taiwan is ideally located to connect Southeast Asia with Northeast Asia. Notably,
Kaohsiung Port has long served as a logistics hub in Asia. Taiwan has four international
ports, namely Keelung Port, Kaohsiung Port, Taichung Port, and Hualien Port, which are
located in the northern, central, southern, and eastern regions, respectively.
- Kaohsiung Port is Taiwan's most representative port, was once one of the world's six
largest ports, and had a route connecting with Busan Port. However, with China's
international ports undergoing rapid growth since 2007, Kaohsiung Port fell to 12th place
worldwide in 2008, forcing it out of the world's ten largest ports.
□ Air Transportation
- Taiwan has two international airports (Taoyuan International Airport and Kaohsiung
International Airport) and sixteen domestic airports.
- Taipei Songsan Airport has been functioning almost exclusively as a domestic airport
since the opening of Taoyuan International Airport in 1979. Beginning in the second half
of 2008, with the opening of direct air routes between Taiwan and China, flights are
being operated between the two countries.
□ Overland Transportation
- Taiwan has a circular railway network which connects major areas in the eastern and
western regions of the island.
- Taiwan has an expressway network consisting of three South-North lines. Expressways are
concentrated in the western region; however, to balance development between the
mountainous eastern region, the western region and Taipei, the Yiran expressway, among
other expressways, was opened.
- Taiwan's waterworks, electricity and gas services are reliable, as well as somewhat
inexpensive compared with Korea.
- According to Taiwan's Corporation Act, corporations are classified into the following four
groups, while foreign investment corporations are normally established as either a limited
company or a joint-stock company.
<Types of Corporations>
Category Description
A company with over two shareholders who jointly take unlimited responsibility
Unlimited Liability Company
for its liabilities.
A company with over one shareholder who assumes liability within the investment
Limited Company
amount.
Unlimited and Limited Joint A company with over one unlimited-liability shareholder and over one limited-
Company liability shareholder who take liability according to the prescribed liability.
A company with over two shareholders or over one government and one
Joint-Stock Company corporate shareholder wherein the shareholders assume liability within the
scope of their share-holdings.
Description Costs
Stamp Tax 0.1% of the transaction amount
6% of the transaction and gift amount (This tax on realty ownership transfer should
Deed Tax
be fully paid before transferring the realty)
Registration Fee 0.1% of deed tax
Varying tax rates by purposes applied. 1.2~2% for residence; 3~5% for commerce; and
House Tax
1.5~2.5% for public organizations such as hospitals and healthcare centers
Land Value Tax 1% of the transaction amount
According to the rules on realty management enacted by the Minister of the Interior
(Department of Land Administration), the agency fee is jointly shouldered by the
Agency Fee
purchaser and the seller at a ratio of 1~2% to 3~4% of the transaction amount. The
fee should be under 6% of the transaction amount.
□ Residential Convenience
◦ Residential Costs
- The monthly rental fee is calculated in terms of NT$ per 3.3 m², and should be paid in
advance every month, with the administrative cost and the parking fee to be separately
paid every month.
- According to the local practice, a security deposit for rental, usually amounting to 2 to 3
months' rent, should be paid. The security deposit will be returned to the lessee after the
rental period, after any incurred electricity and waterworks charges still owing, and
remedial costs (for any damaged property) have been deducted from the deposit.
<Residential Costs>
(Unit : NT$)
Monthly Apartment Monthly Apartment
Realty Agency Commission Security Deposit
Rental Cost (162~198㎡) Rental Cost (99㎡)
60,000~90,000 32,860~65,720
50% of monthly rental cost 2~3 months of rental cost
(US$ 1,825.9~2,738.9) (US$ 1,000~2,000)
Source : DTZ
Note : Based on the foreigners-clustered district of Tianmu, Taipei
□ Medical Services
- Taiwan's medical service environment is generally good. Medical service facilities and
manpower are abundant, with a total of 20,000 hospitals currently in operation. The
Hospitals
Nation Taiwan University Hospital
Taiwan Adventist Hospital
Taipei Veterans General Hospital
MacKay Hospital
Chang Gung Memorial Hospitals
- Domestic nationals and foreigners in Taiwan are allowed to subscribe to the medical
insurance. Foreigners are required to earn a resident permit and stay for more than four
months to be eligible for the services. Employees, if legally hired, are qualified to
subscribe to the medical insurance upon being employed, regardless of the length of their
period of stay.
- Taiwanese medical services are also characterized by the use of IC cards. When a patient
visits a hospital for the first time, an IC card search is conducted. All information
concerning the patient's medical history, including the diagnosis and treatment of diseases
by various hospitals, is shared to prevent duplicate diagnoses. The Taiwanese government
strictly controls medical costs to prevent them from rising by over 4% each year.
□ Transportation System
- Taiwan is equipped with convenient transportation systems including roads, railway, and
subways.
- In Taipei, people pay with a transportation card (悠遊卡, Easy Card) when using any of
the public transportation systems, and receive a certain discount for transferring from one
bus or subway train to another.
Transportation Description
- The MRT runs in two cities, Taipei and Kaohsiung, from 6 am to midnight.
Mass Rapid - Smoking, drinking and eating are strictly forbidden within the subways to create a
Transit System safe and pleasant environment. Violators are fined NT$ 1,500 (US$ 45.6).
(MRT) - The journey fee of NT$ 20~45 (US$ 0.61~1.4), is calculated according to the
distance traveled, and tickets are effective only on the day of purchase.
- Route information is clearly posted at bus stops, and electronic information boards
are posted along with announcements within the buses, making the services
convenient. However, bus operation intervals are not consistent.
Bus
- Intra-city buses normally run 6am to 11pm, and fees are charged per travel
segment, with one segment costing NT$ 15 (US$ 0.46) and two segments costing
NT$ 30 (US$ 0.91).
- General train and high-speed train services are provided. The high-speed train
service, launched in 2007, currently stops at eight stations, and will eventually stop
at another five stations.
Railway
- On the high-speed train service, a one-way general seat from Taipei to the final
station costs NT$ 1,490 (US$ 45.3), which is NT$ 600 (US$ 18.3) more than the
general train services.
□ Foreign Schools
<Foreign Schools>
- American schools charge higher tuition fees than other foreign schools, whose tuition fees
are generally similar to or somewhat lower than those charged by foreign schools in other
countries.
Investment System
<Taxation Incentives>
Category Description
- 30% corporate tax reduction on the R&D investment expenditure amount is provided
for 5 years starting from the year in which investment commences.
R&D incentives - Costs incurred by new product R&D, improvement of production technologies,
improvement of labor management skills, and improvement of manufacturing
processes.
- Investment costs for fostering talented people
: Costs incurred in the training and educating of employees in relation with company
Fostering human
work.
resources
- 30% corporate tax reduction on the costs incurred by fostering human resources is
provided for 5 years starting from the year in which investment commences.
In the event that a foreign company or a foreign company's Taiwanese branch
Incentives for the establishes an international logistics and distribution center directly or through a
establishment of Taiwanese company in a bid to store or simply to process products for sale in Taiwan
international or for export, the corresponding corporate tax is exempted. (Under the rules on
logistics centers industrial advancement promotion, corporate tax was exempted only on domestic sales
in Taiwan.)
Corporate tax of 20% is basically imposed on the establishment of operations
Incentives for the headquarters. However, corporate tax is exempted on any income and royalties
establishment of generated by the provision of services or R&D to related overseas companies, as well
operations as on the revenue from investment in related foreign companies and any gain from
headquarters disposal thereof. Also, a corporate tax incentive of 15% may apply. However, other tax
incentives are not provided.
Business Environment
- Malaysia does not discriminate favorable conditions between foreign and domestic
companies. Certain industrial complexes are occupied by foreign companies, although no
complexes are exclusively occupied by foreign companies.
◦ Free Zones
- Free Zones (FZs) : Zones which the Finance Minster declares according to the Free Zone
Act enacted in 1990. FZs are being operated for companies which
manufacture or assemble export products for the purpose of
promoting trade mainly through transit ports.
- Free Industrial Zones (FIZs) : FIZs not only provide streamlined customs clearance
procedures to exporters, but also allow the duty-free
importation of raw materials, parts, machines and
equipment for use in manufacturing processes, and
streamlined export procedures for finished products.
Malaysia now has 18 FIZs in operation.
- Kuala Lumpur City Centre (KLCC) charges an office rental fee of RM 66~88 (US$
19.8~26.4) per m², while Kuala Lumpur charges an office rental fee of RM 44~66 (US$
13.2~19.8) per m². However, with further office space covering 88 million m² scheduled to
be supplied in 2011 and 2012, rental costs are expected to fall.
Location RM US$
Kuala Lumpur 54~165 16.2~49.5
Petaling Jaya, Selangor 38~48 11.4~14.4
Seremban, Negeri Sembilan 18.8~26.9 5.6~8.1
Johor Bahru, Johor 17.2~30.1 5.2~9
Georgetown, Penang 16~40 4.8~12
Kuantan, Pahang 13~27 3.9~8.1
Kota Bharu, Kelantan 9.5~35.5 2.9~10.7
Source : CH Williams, Talhar & Wong․Collier Jordan Lee & Jaafar
Note : The above rates are the approximate monthly rental costs per m² including administrative costs
Legal Weekly Working Hours Maternity Leave Annual National Holidays Saturday Holiday System
On Saturdays, civil servants
do not work, while the
48 hours 60 days 10 days
employees of certain private
companies do
Source : Employment Act 1955
Sharing Ratios
Insurance Purpose
Employer Employee
Social Security To protect workers from accidents or 1.25% of the
-
Organization (SOCSO) occupational diseases at work. basic salary
Under the Employees Provident Fund Act 1991
Employees Provident 13% of the 8~11% of the
(Act 452), the fund is designed to provide certain
Fund (EPF) basic salary basic salary
pension benefits to workers after retirement..
General companies insure employees
Varies depending on the
Health Insurance with insurance companies to provide
company
medical service benefits.
Source : Employees Provident Fund (KWSP), Social Security Organization (Perkeso), and insurance companies
- Malaysia has a working population of 10 million, which is relatively low, but foreign
workers from Indonesia, Philippines, and Myanmar number about 3 million.
◦ Education Levels
- Over 80% of Malaysia's population are high school graduates, with the number of higher
educated people remaining low. Public universities set aside certain quotas for Malays,
making it very difficult for members of ethnic minority groups to enter them, which
prompts many people of Chinese origin to study in the UK or Australia.
□ Wage Levels
- Malaysia does not define the minimum wage. Employees start out on low wages at the
initial stage, but their wages increase sharply as they become medium-level employees.
The great majority of employees can communicate in English, and experienced employees
transfer to overseas companies in the UK, Australia, and other English-speaking countries,
leading to a shortage of manpower and a rise in the wages of middle-class employees.
- Few labor disputes occur in Malaysia, and many of the disputes that do take place are
settled before the Labor Ministry intervenes.
- Use of violence in labor disputes is very rare, and strikes are legally forbidden.
<Labor Disputes>
2006 2007
Number of workers involved in disputes 14,579 20,354
Number of disputes seeking arbitration 333 302
Source : Industrial Relations Department, MOHR
Note : 2007 is the latest data
□ Taxation
- Corporate tax was lowered from 28% to 27% in 2007, to 26% in 2008, and to 25% in 2009.
There is no additional tax reduction plan in the near future.
- Despite the government's efforts to protect IPRs, illegal copies of DVDs (movies) and CDs,
fake brand-name bags are still being sold in the black markets, and tighter crackdowns
have yet to be enforced (disputes on IPRs have not been disclosed).
- Applications for domestic patents surged in 2008 from 2006, but activities aimed at
stimulating technology development have yet to be initiatied.
<Patents Application>
(Unit : patent)
2006 2008
International Patents Application (WIPO) - 174
Domestic Patents Application 34 200
Source : PCT Yearly Review 2008 (WIPO), Intellectual Property Corporation of Malaysia
□ Marine Transportation
- Malaysia has seven harbors, namely Port Klang, Penang Port, Johor Port in Pasir Gudang,
Tanjung Pelepas Port, Kuantan Port, Kemaman Port, and Bintulu Port. The Bintulu Port is
the country's first dedicated liquified gas port, while Kemaman Port serves as a supply
base for petroleum companies.
- Malaysia is a crossroads of Southeast Asia, making its location important, and offers such
geographical attractions as a trans-shipment center.
- Kuala Lumpur International Airport in Sepang, Selangor boasts an annual handling
capacity of 25 million passengers and over 650,000 tons of cargoes. Other international
airports include Penang International Airport, Langkawi International Airport, and Johor
International Airport in the Malay Peninsula, Kota Kinabalu International Airport in
Sabah, and Kuching International Airport in Sarawak.
□ Overland Transportation
◦ Railway
- The state-owned railway operator, Keretapi Tanah Melayu Bhd (KTM) operates a railway
line across the Malay Peninsula from the northern terminal in Butterworth to Johor in the
southern region, as well as to Pasir Gudang and Singapore. The northern railway network
connects to the port facilities of Penang Island.
- Malaysia offers low electricity fees and ample electric power. Home electricity fees
normally range from RM 80~300 (US$ 24~90.1), and vary according to the amount of
energy consumed.
- Malaysia's waterworks services are good and very cheap. Water service charges generally
amount to approximately RM 33.3 (US$ 10) per month.
- After obtaining approval, the applicant should submit to the CCM such documents as the
copy of the corporation establishment certification issued in the company's home country,
- Currently, there are no laws pertaining to foreigners' acquisition of realty, but the Foreign
Investment Commission has issued relevant guidelines. Taking effect as of July 2009, a
transaction in excess of RM 20 million (US$ 6.006 million), and which is related to the
interest of the government or the Bumiputra (a Malay race), should obtain the approval of
the Economic Planning Unit. An acquisition of commercial, agricultural or industrial land
worth more than RM 500,000 (US$ 150,000) should comply with the regulations of the
relevant ministries.
- Foreigners are relatively free to purchase realty, but to prevent the purchase of low-priced
houses for general citizens, which would lead to a general rise in house prices, residential
housing purchases should exceed RM 250,000 (US$ 75,000), while non-residential realty
purchases should exceed RM 500,000 (US$150,000). The supply of premium apartments has
been activated, making residential costs for foreigners no higher than in other Southeast
Asian countries, and many retired immigrants are buying such apartments.
□ Residential Convenience
- As the population's income is relatively high, Malaysia continues to build and supply
premium apartments, but no residential areas intended exclusively for foreigners are
available.
◦ Residential Costs
- Realty agency commissions are paid to realty agencies by lessors, so lessees do not need
to shoulder the fees.
- Higher rental fees are charged for apartments with views of Kuala Lumpur City Center
(KLCC), but rental fees vary greatly depending on whether apartments are furnished or
not.
<Residential Costs>
(Unit : RM)
Monthly Detached House Realty Agency
Region Monthly Apartment Rental Cost Security Deposit
Rental Cost Commission
4,000~8,000 5,000~18,000
Mont Kiara
(US$ 1,201.2~2402.4) (US$ 1,501.5~5,405.4) 1 month of 2~3 months of
3,000~6,000 4,000~18,000 rental cost rental cost
Ampang
(US$ 900.9~1,801.8) (US$ 1,201.2~5,405.4)
Source : MIDA, i-Property
□ Medical Services
- Malaysia offers private and public hospitals with relatively good facilities. Foreigners
mainly use the private hospitals. General hospitals offer low-price medical services, but
charge more to foreigners.
- Malaysia's government is pushing to foster the medical tourism sector, and is building
new hospitals in a bid to improve the country's medical services. As such, foreigners do
not experience any great inconvenience with regard to medical services.
- Foreigners can use the medical insurance system in Malaysia, where global insurance
companies such as ING are operating. Normally, employers provide insurance premiums,
and individuals can also additionally subscribe to insurance; provided that foreign workers
who are on a 3-month visa or working as the engineer are not allowed to subscribe to the
insurance services.
- Medical premiums are roughly RM 500~1,000 (US$ 150.2~300.3) per year, although they
vary according to conditions.
□ Transportation System
- Malaysia's public transportation system is not well-developed. There are plans to expand
the light rail system, but public transportation systems alone cannot properly cover the
whole connection, causing inconvenience. As such, many people use private cars,
motorcycles, and taxis.
- Public transportation fares are cheap, although they rose by 30% to reflect the real price
level (as of August 1, 2009).
- Taxi fares consist of a basic charge plus an additional charge of RM 0.10 (US$ 0.03) every
115m traveled or every 21 seconds.
□ Foreign Schools
- Malaysia offers good public and private education centers. Not only foreign schools but
also universities offer TWINNING programs which enable the sharing of credits with
overseas universities, thus giving them internationalized status.
- Foreign schools' tuition fees are expensive to the extent that only upper-class or rich Malays
can afford to send their children to them. In the case of the ISKL (International School of
Kuala Lumpur), Malay students account for 11% of the total.
- The mobile phone penetration rate has exceeded 100%, and quality mobile services are
provided.
- The Internet speed is relatively slow because the existing telephone cable networks are
being used. The government is pushing to increase the home Internet penetration from
25% to 50% by 2010 by expanding the optical cable infrastructures, which will ultimately
improve the Internet speed.
Investment System
- The ICA was enacted to prompt the development and growth of Malaysia's manufacturing
sector. Under the Act, a manufacturing project with capital in excess of RM 2.5 million
(US$ 751,000) or with more than 75 employees is required to obtain approval as a
manufacturing business. Applications should be submitted to the MIDA while approval is
provided by the Malaysian Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI).
- Major incentives for the manufacturing sector include the granting of "pioneer status" and
investment tax allowance (ITA). Recommended activities or recommended products are
selected according to their value-added, technological innovation, industrial linkage levels.
- Companies awarded with "pioneer status" are partially exempted from payment of income
tax for 5 years. Only 30% of the prescribed income tax (calculated by deducting profitable
expenditures and capital from total income) is imposed, and the tax exemption period is
5 years from the day on which production volume reaches 30% of production capacity.
- To promote investment in such recommended areas as the states of Perils, Sabah, and
Sarawak, and the designated eastern corridors in the Malay Peninsula(Kelantan, Terengganu,
- Companies can also apply for the ITA, other than "pioneer status" incentive. ITA companies
can receive a 60% tax credit on deductible capital expenditures incurred within 5 years of
the first deductible capital expenditure(relating to factories, machines, facilities, and
equipment used for the approved project). Companies eligible for the ITA may also offset
up to 70% of their income tax every year by the deductible amount, and transfer an
unused deductible amount to the next year. The remaining 30% of their income is taxed at
the current corporate tax rate.
- Companies located in such recommended regions as the states of Perils, Sabah, and
Sarawak, and the designated eastern corridors in the Malay Peninsula may apply for a
100% investment tax deduction on deductible capital expenditures incurred within 5 years.
Using this deductible amount, they may offset the whole of their income for every tax
year. Applications for this incentive will be accepted up until December 31, 2010.
Business Environment
- Singapore does not differentiate domestic companies and foreign investment companies.
There exists districks where industrial complexes are concentrated, but does not implement
separate incentive programs for these industrial complexes or any particular zones.
◦ Free Zones
- Singapore itself is a free trade zone, and thus does not operate separate Foreign Economic
Zones, or individual or complex Foreign Investment Zones. However, Singapore operates
Free Trade Zones for trans-shipment where manufacturing is strictly banned.
- Sales and rental costs for industrial and factory sites are based on market prices,
regardless of domestic or foreign corporations.
- The submittal of a security deposit applies equally to domestic and foreign investors, and
3-year rental requires a cash deposit consisting of three months' rent (the cash deposit can
be replaced by a bank guarantee or insurance).
- Purchase and rental costs for commercial buildings vary greatly according to regions, and
the rental cost in downtown areas is generally about twice the amount charged in other areas.
□ Labor Laws
- The Labor Act applies to all workers, but regulations on working hours (including overtime
work), leave, holidays, or sick leave apply only to workers whose monthly salary is under
S$ 2,000 (US$ 1,388.9), while in other cases such conditions are determined according to
individual contracts with employers.
- Singapore offers a very flexible labor market, making it easy to lay off even regular
workers by giving a certain amount of prior notice, and employers are not required to
convert non-regular workers into regular employees after a certain period. No minimum
wage regulations are in force at present.
- The Employment Act specifies a standard working time of 8 hours per day and 44 hours
per week. Any time in excess of these working hours is considered overtime, the
compensation for which is more than 1.5 times the normal wage.
Legal Weekly Working Hours Maternity Leave Annual National Holidays Saturday Holiday System
44 hours 12 weeks 11 days Being implemented
- The CPF (Central Provident Fund) is a government-led compulsory saving system for
social welfare. Under the CPF, workers are required to save up to 34.5% of their salary
with the state-led fund; provided that the costs are shared by employers and employees
according to a certain ratio. The targets of this system are those employees who reside in
Singapore or Malaysia and who provide their labor in Singapore. This category includes
self-employed people and company executives.
□ Labor Power
- Of the total population of 4.8 million people, 60% are members of the working
population. At just 2.0~2.5%, Singapore's unemployment rate is very low.
- Compared with Korea's school system, which essentially comprises of elementary, middle
and high school and university, Singapore's education system offers a great diversity of
courses.
- Due to the flexible nature of the system, overall statistics are not announced regarding the
number of college or university entrants among graduates of high school-level education
institutes.
- However, graduates from polytechnic colleges and universities, and holders of master's
and PhD degrees constitute a significant portion of Singapore's population of 4.5 million,
suggesting that the country's overall level of education is very high.
□ Wage Levels
- As the demand for labor continues to exceed the supply, wages continue to rise.
Singapore requires compliance with the National Wage Council's guidelines on yearly
wage negotiations between labor and management, thereby appropriately controlling any
rise in wages.
- Jobs requiring specialist knowledge and knowledge of advanced technologies have seen
greater wage hikes compared to other jobs.
- The average monthly wage across the entire range of industries in Singapore was S$ 3,977
(US$ 2,761.8) in 2008, up 5.4% from the previous year. Due to a chronic lack of labor,
wages have continued to rise over the last few years.
◦ Labor Disputes
- Singapore have very stable labor-management relations, and has not seen a single strike
since the 1980s.
<Labor Disputes>
(Unit : dispute)
Category 2006 2007 2008
Labor disputes 163 133 118
Cause (wage) 74 82 53
Cause (others) 89 51 65
Total Arbitrations 16 16 11
Sucessful Arbitrations 15 14 10
Source : Yearbook of Statistics, Singapore, 2009
□ Taxation
- Singapore's taxes are classified into income tax, corporate tax, tariffs that are under the
National Tax Services' control and taxes for other special purposes such as automobile tax.
- Singapore began improving its protection of intellectual property rights in the late 1990s,
leading to its removal from the US Special 301 Watch List in 2001. However, such
problems as the use of pirated optical disks and software, the trans-shipment of pirated
products through Singapore, and the complicated procedure of removing pirated materials
from the Internet have been addressed over the last few years as one of the conditions of
a free trade agreement with the USA.
- Singapore's IPOS, launched as the Registry of Trade Marks and Patents, is under the
control of the Ministry of Justice. The IPOS was established on April 1, 2001, according to
the Intellectual Property Office of Singapore Act.
- According to the WIPO's PCT international patent applications, Singapore files 150 patent
applications each year, which is very low compared with Korea's annual average of more
than 5,000 patent applications.
- This suggests that Singapore seldom files its IPR applications overseas.
- The transportation and logistics industries account for 9.6% of Singapore's GDP, for a
workforce of 110,000. Over 9,000 logistics companies are registered, and many of them are
headquartered in Singapore. Furthermore, of the world's top 25 third-party logistics (3PL)
operators, 17 are located in Singapore.
- Singapore ranks first globally in terms of cargo handling volume in the logistics category,
and boasts the world's second largest container port, Asia's No. 1 car shipping port. In
the transportation category, Singapore possesses 70% of the world's marine shipping and
handling warehouses, and occupies 70% of the world's jack-up rigs markets.
- According to the World Bank's Logistics Performance Index (2007), which was surveyed by
800 worldwide international cargo transportation operators, Singapore was ranked as the
world's No. 1 logistics hub, outstripping European ports such as the Netherlands and
Germany. This may be attributed to Singapore's efficient and stable supply chain, excellent
price competitiveness, and information network called Portnet.
□ Air Transportation
- Singapore's Changi Airport handled 1.9 million tons of air cargo in 2008. It operates 4,000
flights a week, connecting to 182 cities in 57 countries, making it Asia's fourth-largest air
cargo handling airport.
- Singapore is well equipped with electricity, waterworks and other infrastructures, and
offers high-quality public services.
- Among the business types allowed in Singapore are business firms, limited liability
partnerships (LLP), and companies.
<Corporation Types>
- Anyone who wants to establish a company must follow two steps, company name
approval and establishment procedure. Company registration procedures and the required
documents are complicated, so it is better to use lawyers or certified public accountants to
complete the procedures. It takes 2~4 days for company name approval; 1~2 weeks to
complete the establishment procedures; and an additional 2~4 weeks in the event that it is
necessary to refer to the relevant agencies.
- The relevant agency for establishing a local corporation or branch is the Accounting &
Corporate Regulatory Authority (ACRA).
* Required document
- Application for the Approval and Reservation of Names for a Company to Be
Incorporated Under the Companies Act (Form 14)
- Fee : S$ 15 (US$ 10.4)
- Foreigners, even if not holding denizenship, are not limited as regards the purchase of
private apartments or condominiums. However, the purchase of detached houses
including land by foreigners is limited, except for certain areas on Sentosa Island, and
requires prior approval from the government. Holders of denizenship may purchase a
detached house but only after obtaining prior approval.
- Detached houses may be purchased only for residential purposes, and the land area
should not exceed 1393.5m².
□ Residential Convenience
- In principle, foreigners are not allowed to live in HDB apartments, but may reside in
them if the original occupants have left Singapore to live overseas for over 2 years, either
for work or study, after obtaining HDB approval.
- The housing penetration rate stood at 90% in 2008, and the great majority of Singapore's
nationals (86%) live in HDB apartments.
<Residential Costs>
(Unit : S$)
Monthly Apartment Monthly Apartment Realty Agency
Security Deposit
Rental Costs (Two Rooms) Rental Costs (Three Rooms) Commission
2,800~6,000 4,500~9,500 One month's rent X
Paid by house owners
(US$ 1,944.4~4,166.7) (US$ 3,125~6,597.2) contracted years
Source : Buy Singapore (Realty magazine)
□ Medical Services
- Singapore offers generally good medical services. Hospitals are classified into national,
public, and private ones, and are equipped with advanced medical devices and superior
medical personnel.
- Singapore does not implement a national medical insurance system, but requires
individual nationals to reserve part of CPF with MediSave according to their age. Minor
medical service costs are paid from each individual's MediSave policy. Expensive medical
services can be covered by the selective insurance MediShield. Foreign medical insurance
is not allowed.
□ Transportation System
- Singapore is well equipped with a mass transportation system comprising subway lines,
buses and taxis. During rush hours, buses are operated at very short deployment intervals,
making them highly convenient, and also express buses are operated.
- Mass Rapid Transit (MRT), a major transportation system, runs from 5:30 am until
midnight. The purchase of rechargeable ez Link cards makes using the MRT very
convenient.
□ Foreign Schools
Investment System
◦ Beneficiaries of Incentives
- Singapore does not discriminate between domestic companies and foreign investment
companies with regard to incentives for investment.
- Incentives are provided to cormpanies which introduce new technologies and new
processes, thereby improving productivity and advancing the industrial structure.
- Detailed benefits by incentive are defined, but the door for negotiations with foreign
investors is kept wide open.
- Regardless of the time from which profits are generated, corporate and other tax breaks
are provided according to the provision of incentives by the EDB.
- On the basis of negotiations between foreign investors and the relevant authority,
specific details on tax breaks, subsidies and other investment incentives are determined.
- The industrial officials' appraisal of the economic effects and the feasibility of investment
is the most important factor in determining the provision of incentives.
◦ Major Incentives
- Singapore offers tax breaks as the main incentive, but, depending on the agenda, it may
also provide cash grant share investment by EDBI (EDB Investment Pte Ltd), and other
flexible incentives.
Business Environment
- Beijing offers a diverse range of industrial complexes including state economic and
technology development zones, high-tech science technology complexes, and municipal
economic development zones, but has no complexes intended exclusively for foreign
companies. However, subsidies are provided to facilities rented as headquarters following
relocation to or establishment in Beijing.
- Beijing divides industrial complexes into 9 classes, and applies different land prices
according to classes.
□ Labor Laws
- Major labor laws include the Labor Act, the Labor Contract Act, and the Employment
Promotion Act.
- According to the Labor Act and the Labor Contract Act, employers must give prior notice
before dismissing employees, and unions are not allowed to lodge disagreement with
employers.
- In the event that an employer terminates the labor agreement, it must give prior notice to
the relevant union, which have the right to submit its disagreeing opinion on the matter
if such action is deemed to be unreasonable.
Legal Weekly Working Hours Maternity Leave Annual National Holidays Saturday Holiday System
27 days
5 days 90 days Being implemented
※ As of 2009
Source : Beijing Human Resources and Social Security Bureau
- The figures for China's working population are based on the 2007 census, which is most
recent as of September 2009.
□ Wage Levels
- According to the National Bureau of Statistics' report for the first half of 2009, the national
average annual wage stood at CNY 14,639 (US$ 2,143.2, at the average exchange rate for
the first half of 2009 / US$ 1 = CNY 6.83), representing a year-on-year rise of 12.9%.
□ Labor Disputes
◦ Labor-Management Relations
- Unions have been growing in recent times, but workers have weak cohesion, and are
under the powerful influence of the management and the Communist Party.
- Labor-management conflicts have been growing recently but unions' negotiating power is
still weak. Therefore, conflicts do not easily escalate into strikes.
◦ Labor Disputes
- According to data released by the Beijing Human Resources and Social Security Bureau,
the number of labor disputes has risen sharply since the second half of 2008.
- Attempts should first be made to settle labor disputes through negotiation, but, failing
that, the parties involved (workers or companies) may demand arbitration. However, if
the parties involved are not willing to negotiate, they can directly request arbitration.
- If the parties involved cannot accept the results of arbitration, they may file a lawsuit
with the people's court.
□ Taxation
- Over the last couple of years, the Chinese government has been vigorously pushing for
taxation reform, including corporate income tax and VAT.
- The Chinese government announced a temporary rule on VAT in China, taking effect
from January 1, 2009, under which corporations, when purchasing fixed assets such as
machinery, are allowed to deduct the purchase VAT from the sales VAT.
- After joining the WTO, China refined its laws and systems concerning intellectual
property rights, and strengthened its crackdowns on IPR infringements, thereby
continuing its efforts in this regard. However, China is still on the US Trade
Representative's Watch List.
- China announced a National IPR Strategy Guideline on June 5, 2008, under which it aims
to enhance its procedures for creating, implementing, protecting and managing IPRs by
2020.
- The number of appeals over IPR disputes to be dealt with in the first civil trials, which
were filed with local courts nationwide in 2008, was 24,406, up 36.5% from the previous
- The number of international patent applications has been increasing in the case of
semiconductors, nuclear processes, medical technologies, automotive engines, and audio-
visual technologies.
- The number of PCT international patent applications increased from under 1,000 in 2004
to 6,089 in 2008, up 11.9% from the previous year, thus raising China to sixth place in the
global ranking.
□ Marine Transportation
- In 2008, China had 12 bonded ports, and 17 large ports capable of handling 100 million
tons of cargoes. China ranked first for six straight years worldwide in terms of port cargo
handling volume and container cargo handling volume, with cargo handling volumes
increasing at annual rate of 30%.
□ Air Transportation
- China operates 158 civil airports, of which 152 operate scheduled flights. Airports are
concentrated most heavily in the northern, eastern and southern regions.
- Beijing International Airport operates flights to and from 191 cities in 76 countries, of
which 106 are domestic cities and 85 are overseas cities.
- In 2008, Beijing Airport handled 55.94 million passengers, and 1.37 million tons of cargoes,
ranking 8th among the world international airports.
□ Overland Transportation
◦ Railway
- China operates 79,700km of railway lines. The railway network is centered in Beijing in
the northern region, and in Shanghai in the southern region, and extends to Xinjiang
Uyghur Autonomous Region in the northwest. In 2008, the Beijing railway transported
76.46 million passengers, and 18.36 million tons of cargoes.
- Beijing offers good waterworks, electricity, and gas services. In the case of electricity
outages or temporary stoppages of the water supply, prior notice is given to apartment
complexes and industrial complexes, causing no real inconvenience to people's everyday
life or to corporate operations.
- It takes up to six months to establish an foreign investment corporation, and costs vary
somewhat according to the business types and service agencies.
- If investment areas fall into the encouraged category under the FDI Industries Guidance
List, the Beijing Reform and Development Committee and the Commercial Bureau issue
the corresponding confirmation pursuant to the relevant laws.
- Foreigners who have stayed for more than one year in China to work at the Chinese
branches and the representative offices of foreign companies(excluding the realty business),
and to study in China are allowed to purchase houses suitable for their actual demand under
their real name. A representative office serves as only a liaison office before establishing a
corporation, and is in principle prohibited from conducting profitable activities; it may
only undertake to liaise with its parent company, to gather information, etc.
- When foreign investment company invests more than US$ 10 million when establishing a
realty company in China, its registration capital should be over 50% of the investment
amount. Also, if a foreign investor invests in the Chinese realty market, the investor must
obtain an FDI endorsement certificate and a business license.
- If a foreign realty company fails to fully pay the registration capital and to obtain a
national land use certificate, and if the project development capital is under 35% of the
total investment amount, the extension of loans and the settlement of foreign exchange
will be limited.
- With the implementation of the system of purchasing houses under one's real name,
China actually limits house purchases by foreigners to one house per household.
Living Environment
□ Residential Convenience
◦ Residential Costs
- Housing rental costs in Beijing vary depending on the districts. In Dongcheng District,
Xicheng District, and Haidian District, the central areas of Beijing where many elementary,
middle and high schools are concentrated, housing rental costs have continued to rise.
□ Medical Services
- Beijing has 6,039 general hospitals and specialized hospital, while the number of clinics
and medical service centers located near apartment complexes stands at 3,304. Despite the
large number of hospitals, overall medical services systems are not well equipped,
resulting in visitors having to queue for medical services for a long time. Also, the prices
of medicines are high.
- Diagnostic service fee per visit in Beijing is normally CYN 5 (US$ 0.73), while a specialist
diagnosis fee can cost over CYN 100 (US$ 14.64).
- Foreigners mostly use Beijing Tongeren Hospital and China-Japan Friendship Hospital.
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 101
<Hospitals Available to Foreigners (General Hospitals)>
- Foreigners are not allowed to use the Chinese social insurance services, but can subscribe
to commercial insurance services through insurance companies.
- Even in the case of commercial insurance services, foreigners are not allowed to subscribe
to other insurance services except serious disease insurance and injury insurance services.
□ Transportation System
◦ Subway
- Beijing's subway system consists of lines 1, 2, 5, 8, 10, and 13, as well as the Batong line
and the exclusive airport line.
◦ Bus
- Beijing operates 648 bus lines with a capacity of 20,500 buses, but foreigners do not use
buses very much.
◦ Taxi
- Beijing has 66,600 taxis, of which the main models are the Beijing Hyundai and the
JETTA.
- The basic taxi fare is CYN 10 (US$ 1.46), and the travel fare is CYN 2 (US$0.29) per km.
◦ Railway
- Beijing is the railway network hub of China, and connects to Hong Kong, Shanghai,
Guangzhou, and Harbin. A number of international lines run from Beijing to Russia,
North Korea, and Vietnam.
◦ Airport Accessibility
- Beijing International Airport, the country's largest airport, is 20km from the downtown
area, and can be reached in 40 minutes via the airport expressway.
- Passengers can take the exclusive airport subway to reach the T3 boarding building of
Beijing International Airport. The journey takes 16 minutes, and the fare is CYN 25 (US$
3.66).
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 103
<Public Transportation Fares>
□ Foreign Schools
- Beijing has 12 foreign schools, most of which run kindergartens, and elementary, middle
and high schools.
- American and British international schools occupy the largest share of all foreign schools,
and there are also Korean and Japanese international schools.
- The tuition fees of American international schools and Korean international schools are
cited below.
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 105
(5) Development of Communication Systems
- The number of mobile users is 16 million, which translates into 95.4 users for every 100
people. The number of Internet users reached 4.8 million in 2008, accounting for 28% of
the city's total population.
- Mobile services are provided on a pay-as-you-go basis. No subscription fees are charged
for Internet services but the service fees are relatively high.
17.6/month
34.4 5.1 7.3 7.3 (basic) -
(ADSL)
Investment System
- The Catalogue for the Guidance of Foreign Investment Industries contains the Chinese
government's guidelines on foreign investment promotion by businesses. It categorizes the
businesses into 'encouraged', 'limited', and 'banned' businesses.
□ Company Act
- The Company Act constitutes the Chinese government's basic policy on the establishment
of domestic and foreign companies. With regard to the establishment and management of
an foreign investment company, if the Company Act and the Third Party Act (Foreign
Investment Company Act, and Joint-stock and Joint-Venture Company Act) contradict
each other, the latter will prevail.
- Regarding the requirements for the establishment of an foreign investment company, the
number of investors should be under 50, and the minimum registration capital of a
general limited liability company should be CYN 30,000 (US$ 4,392).
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 107
(2) Investment Promotion Agency
- The Ministry of Commerce deals with investment affairs, including investment statistics
and policies, but no independent investment agency is operated in China.
- If regional headquarters and their R&D centers which are newly established or newly
relocated in Beijing after January 1, 2009 construct or purchase offices, subsidies will be
provided to such facilities.
- Corporate income tax breaks are provided to those incomes generated from investment in
public infrastructures, and from eco-friendly, energy-saving, and water consumption
reduction-related businesses.
- 15% corporate income tax breaks are provided to high-tech corporations that are engaged
in certain high-tech businesses supported by the government.
- Breaks on export tariffs and export VAT are provided to export products manufactured
by foreign investment companies; provided that products which are restricted from
exporting or certain products prescribed under the state's regulations (petroleum, finished
oil, etc.) are excluded from this category.
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 109
6 Hong Kong
Business Environment
- Hong Kong's investment promotion policy basically treats domestic and foreign companies
equally, and thus does not offer incentives exclusively for foreign industrial complexes or
for foreign companies' industrial location conditions.
- Hong Kong has three industrial complexes, each of which is no larger than 80ha, and
most FDI into the country is intended for areas other than manufacturing, thereby
generating little demand for industrial land.
- Foreign companies generally choose the northern commercial districts of Hong Kong,
including Central, Admiralty and Sheung Wan. However, these districts' rental costs are
the highest in Hong Kong (US$ 107, m²/month), and rank among the uppermost groups
of rental costs in Asia and the rest of the world. As such, many businesses have in recent
years been relocating their offices to nearby districts such as Wanchai, Causeway Bay and
Quarry Bay, as well as Tsim Sha Tsui in the Kowloon Peninsula, where rental costs are
lower and convenient transportation is available.
- Land purchase in Hong Kong requires the submittal of an application to the Lands
Department, which discloses information (location, use, area size, etc.) on land available
for transaction according to an annual land sales program under which land is auctioned
off or applications for land purchase are received.
- Applicants for land purchase should submit an application along with the prescribed
documents within two months of the date of land sell-off specified in the announcement.
The required documents are as follows:
․The application, including the minimum bid price
․The agreement to auction or tender
․A check showing a security deposit amount which is 5% of the minimum bid price
proposed in the application (a maximum of HK$ 25 million or US$ 3.247 million)
- If the proposed minimum bid price is appropriate, the Lands Department will sign the
agreement within 2 months, and notify the appliant of sell-off methods, etc. If the
proposed minimum bid price is inappropriate, the paid security deposit will be returned
to the applicant.
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 111
<Commercial (Office) Purchase Costs by Class (per ㎡)>
(Unit : HK$)
Purchase Costs
District
A B C
218,474 121,058 92,443
Central, Admiralty
(US$ 28,373.2) (US$ 15,721.8) (US$ 12,005.6)
124,877 76,900 59,053
Sheung Wan
(US$ 16,217.8) (US$ 9,987) (US$ 7,669.2)
125,607 99,743 74,798
Wanchai/Causeway Bay
(US$ 16,312.6) (US$ 12,953.6) (US$ 9,714)
88,727 57,994 62,586
North Point/Quarry Bay
(US$ 11,523) (US$ 7,531.7) (US$ 8,128.1)
129,545 94,450 62,067
Tsim Sha Tsui
(US$ 16,824) (US$ 12,266.2) (US$ 8,060.6)
156,686 62,852 49,772
Yau Ma Tei/Mong Kok
(US$ 20,348.8) (US$ 8,162.6) (US$ 6,463.9)
Source : Hong Kong's Lands Department
Note : A, B, and C are the classes by which Hong Kong Lands Department classifies buildings, with A being the
highest class.
- Commercial realty rental is normally based on a 2~3 year basis with a renewal being an
option.
- Other costs include administrative expenses and a tax equivalent to 5% of the rental cost.
□ Labor Law
- Hong Kong's Labor Law, also referred to as the Employment Ordinance, comprehensively
specifies the regulations on employment, dismissal, and working conditions, etc.
- Labor unions' activities are protected by law. The Labor-Management Arbitration Office
which belongs to the judiciary branch, arbitrates and judges disputes between employers
and employees. Over 20% of employees have joined unions, but most employees generally
hold negative views with regard to the possibility of strikes leading to economic loss, and
tend to refrain from long-term or violent strike action.
◦ Employment Laws
- In Hong Kong, all employment is arranged through agreements which specify the term of
a work contract, and annual salary, etc., with no differentiation between regular or
non-regular jobs. However, if an employee works for over 18 hours per week, and
maintains employment relations with the employer for over 4 weeks, the employee is
henceforth regarded as being employed under a continuous contract, thereby qualifying
for legally guaranteed holidays, annual leave, sick leave, severance pay, and employer's
tax. (Daily workers do not qualify for these benefits.)
- Hong Kong does not implement a comprehensively applicable minimum wage for
employees. (Since 2007, the implementation of minimum wage system has been discussed.)
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 113
<Obligations for Termination of Employment Contracts>
Obligation to Provide
Employment Contract Conditions Prior Notice Period
Wages
The first full month Not required Not required
The period as specified in the
In the event that the
contract (provided that prior notice
contract specifies the
Probationary After of over seven days is required
notice period
period one before termination of the contract)
month In the event that the Wages are paid on
contract does not specify Over seven days the basis of the
the notice period remaining period in
The period as specified in the terms of days, weeks,
In the event that the contract contract (provided that prior notice and months.
Non- specifies the notice period of over seven days is required
probationary before termination of the contract))
period
In the event that the contract does
Over one month
not specify the notice period
◦ Working Conditions
- Most working conditions comply with labor laws, which specify the minimum guarantees
for workers, but actual working conditions vary depending on the company. Generally,
better working conditions than the minimum standard specified in the regulations are
provided.
- Hong Kong's social insurance system is mainly based on individuals. Hong Kong does
not provide state-supported unemployment insurance, national pension and health
Sharing Ratios
Insurance Purpose
Employers Employees
Compensation for employee The whole amount is
Accident Insurance -
accidents at work shouldered
50% is shouldered
After-retirement income guarantee
National Pension (5% of employees' monthly wage is
(pension accumulated)
shouldered respectively)
The whole amount is
Health Insurance Treatment of diseases -
shouldered (not obligatory)
Source : Hong Kong's Labor Act
□ Labor Power
- In 2008, Hong Kong's working population stood at 3.6 million, or 52% of the total
population of 7 million.
◦ Education Levels
- Hong Kong implements a nine-year obligatory education system, and 43,000 students are
graduating every year from Hong Kong's twelve higher education institutes. Over
one-third of the education budget of Hong Kong's government is allocated to higher
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 115
education (universities and above), and university graduates account for over 20% of the
total number of higher education graduates.
□ Wage Levels
- The wages of workers in Hong Kong vary greatly according to the occupation, position,
and field. For instance, upper financial workers can earn an annual wage of over US$
100,000. The average monthly wages by industry is the highest in the transportation and
warehousing fields.
- Hong Kong does not implement a minimum wage system, and its labor markets' wage
system is very flexible, allowing wages to be determined according to workers'
competence. A new employee's average monthly wage is usually under HK$ 15,000 (US$
1,948.1), but it may surge in a short period of time depending on the individual
employee's competence and experience.
- Average wages vary according to industries and employees' experience in work; as such,
Hong Kong's Labor Department and Statistics Department do not announce average
wages by occupations unilaterally. The average wage of newly employed high school and
university graduates are based on the average wages shown in the wanted ads of
recruitment websites.
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 117
□ Labor Disputes
◦ Labor-Management Relations
◦ Labor Disputes
- In 2008, the Labor Department arbitrated 120 minor and major labor disputes, marking
the lowest level since 1998 and a fall of 3% from 2007. The loss of working days due to
labor disputes amounted to just 0.46 day per 1,000 workers in 2008, the world's lowest
level.
- In 2009, due to the economic recession, increasing numbers of businesses were being shut
down and bankrupted, and employees laid off. And in the first quarter of 2009, the Labor
Department announced 59 labor disputes, up 84% from the previous year.
<Labor Disputes>
□ Taxation
- Hong Kong boasts the world's lowest rates in major taxes, and implements a relatively
simple taxation policy.
- Also, Hong Kong itself is a non-tariff region except for certain product items, making the
trade of products highly convenient.
- During 1997~1998, the Hong Kong government refined its Act on the Protection of
Intellectual Property Rights, and implemented the relevant laws. This resulted in Hong
Kong's removal from the USTR Watch List on December 17, 1999.
- Hong Kong is now one of the Asian countries where IPR protection is the most
thoroughly implemented. Infringements upon patents, copyrights, trademarks, and designs
are strictly regulated by law.
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 119
◦ Intellectual Property Rights Disputes
- IPR disputes in Hong Kong arise mainly in relation with trademarks. As IPRs are
increasingly perceived important and creative industries are being developed, this leads to
an increasing number of IRP disputes each year.
- Hong Kong enjoys a highly favorable strategic location, enabling it to maximize trading
efficiency via diverse modes of transportation including marine, air, railway and overland
systems. It is equipped with infrastructures which effectively connect it to Guangdong
Province and the Pearl River Delta area of southern China.
- Hong Kong Port, which is privately owned, boasts the best operational efficiency and
competitiveness. Notably, Kwai Chung Harbor, an exclusive container wharf located in
Hong Kong New Territories, handles over 60% of Hong Kong's total cargo volume, while
Victoria Harbor handles 30~40% of the city's total cargo volume.
- In 2008, Hong Kong Port handled 2.44 million TEUs (Twenty-foot Equivalent Unit),
ranking 3rd worldwide after Singapore and Shanghai. Hong Kong lost its solid world No.
1 place in cargo handling to Singapore back in 2005, and since then has seen a slowdown
in its cargo handling volume amid the rapid emergence of Shanghai and Shenzhen ports.
Due to a simple taxation system and advanced logistics infrastructures, however, Hong
Kong looks likely to maintain its position as Asia's logistics hub for some time.
□ Air Transportation
- Hong Kong International Airport, which was moved to its current location in 1998, has
been evaluated as one of the world's best airports by the IATA, Skytrax, etc.
- In 2008, the airport handled 47.8 million passengers and 3.62 million tons of cargoes,
ranking 5th and 1st in the world, respectively.
- The Water Supplies Department stably provides waterworks services in compliance with
the WHO's regulations on water treatment processes. Waterworks taxes are paid every
four months on the basis of meter readings.
- Electric power is stably supplied by CLP Power Hong Kong Limited and Hong Kong
Electric Company Limited.
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 121
<Major Public Services Costs>
(Unit : HK$, HK$ cents)
Major Public Services Costs Criteria
Kowloon Peninsula 0.757~0.955 (US$ 0.098~0.124)
Electricity kwh
Hong Kong Island 0.884~1.5 (US$ 0.115~1.948)
MJ
Gas 20.35~21.30 (US$ 2.643~2.76)
※ City gas, HK$ cents
Waterworks 4.16~9.05 (US$ 0.54~1.18) ㎥
Source : Water Supplies Department, CLP Power Hong Kong Limited, Hong Kong Electric Company Limited,
Towngas
Note : 1) MJ (Megajoules) : caloric value
2) 1MJ = 238.7kcal
- Hong Kong claims to be a business-friendly international business hub, enabling the rapid
establishment and operations of corporations at a low cost.
- In Hong Kong, there are various corporation establishment services agencies, including
PWC and KPMG, which also have international branches. Corporations in Hong Kong
need secretaries, agents who communicate with the Hong Kong government and are
residers in Hong Kong with IDs), and this role can also be performed by corporation
establishment consulting services companies. The cost is HK$ 5,000 (US$ 649.4) a year.
- Hong Kong allows foreigners to freely purchase and acquire realty without imposing
particular regulations or restrictions.
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 123
Living Environment
□ Residential Convenience
- In Hong Kong, diverse types of apartments, houses, and other residential facilities are
widely distributed in downtown areas and the suburbs. However, rental charges are high,
and the amount of land available for housing is limited.
- However, apartments, the most common type of housing in Hong Kong, are mostly
available in large complexes with good security and amenities, and easy access to
convenient transportation systems, creating a pleasant overall living environment.
◦ Residential Costs
- Regarding monthly residental rental costs, a detached house on Hong Kong Island costs
HK$ 100,000 (US$ 12,987), while an apartment of 65m² costs over HK$ 20,000 (US$
2,597.4), making them very expensive.
- Most rental contracts are for two years, of which, generally, one year is an optional
period during which the contract may be terminated by giving prior notice.
- For a housing rental contract, the amount of two months' security deposit and one
month's rent should be paid in advance, while the agency commission will be 50% of one
month's rental fee.
<Residential Costs>
(Unit : HK$)
Monthly Apartment Monthly Detached House
Realty Agency Commission Security Deposit
Rental Cost Rental Cost
20,000~38,000 Over 100,000 50% of the
2 months' rental cost
(US$ 2,597.4~4,935.1) (US$ 12,987) monthly rental cost
Source : Midland Realty
Note : Based on apartments sized 66.116~99.174m² in downtown Hong Kong Island and Kowloon Peninsula.
□ Medical Services
- Hong Kong has both national and private hospitals of a high standard. 41 national
hospitals under the management of the Hospital Authority (including specialized and
general hospitals) offer quality services at a low cost. But with many patients visiting
them, they keep patients waiting for a long time, making it inconvenient to users. Private
and individual hospitals are very expensive, but allows use of private health insurance
services.
- Medical institutes in Hong Kong are open to both domestic and foreign nationals, but
non-Hong Kong residents are charged more than Hong Kong residents when using
national hospitals.
- Hong Kong does not implement a national medical insurance system. Group health
insurance services are not mandated for employers. However, national hospitals provide
relatively inexpensive services to citizens of Hong Kong, making them accessible.
- In Hong Kong, which lacks a national health insurance system, most foreigners subscribe
to private medical insurance services, with premiums varying widely depending on the
types of insurance companies and insurance policies offered.
□ Transportation System
- Most of Hong Kong's citizens use public transportation systems (buses, mini buses,
subway, ferries, and trams).
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 125
- Subway : Most commuters use the MTR (Mass Transit Railway) and KCR (Kowloon and
Canton Railway) systems. Both MTR and KCR are operated across New
Territories, Kowloon, and Hong Kong Island, while KCR also operates a line to
and from Shenzhen in southern China (to the north of Hong Kong).
- Bus : Various bus companies (Kowloon Motor Bus Company, New World First Bus
Services Limited, Citybus Limited, Long Win Bus Company Limited, and New
Lantao Bus Company) cover various districts, and bus lines are provided across
Hong Kong. Mini buses with a seating capacity of 16 passengers are used by 1.7
million people each day.
- Taxi : Taxis are categorized according to their color: Red ones run in cities, green ones in
New Territories, and blue ones in Lantau. Taxis are used by one million people per
day.
- Ferry : Ferries are used when crossing between Kowloon and Central (Star Ferry). Ferries
are also operated to and from southern Chinese cities such as Guangzhou,
Shenzhen and Zhuhai.
- Tram : Peak trams run to and from Victoria Peak, while general trams run to and from
Hong Kong Island.
- Prepaid transportation cards known as Octopus cards, are used for all public
transportation systems, and are widely used by citizens.
□ Foreign Schools
- Free education services up to high schools are provided under a public school system.
Regarding the local private education system, kindergartens cost HK$ 20,000~ 36,000 (US$
2,597.4~4,675.3) a year, elementary schools HK$ 30,000 (US$ 34896.1), and middle and
high schools HK$ 14,000~48,000 (US$ 14,818.2~64,233.8), making them relatively expensive.
- The following Table shows the tuition fees of Hong Kong's representative international
schools, namely the English Schools Foundation (ESF) and Yew Chung International
Schools.
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 127
(5) Development of Communication Systems
- Hong Kong boasts world-class communication and information system infrastructures and
technical manpower, adding to its attractiveness as a financial hub. It also expriences
diffusion of advanced technologies in a rapid rate.
- Mobile services fees are charged on a monthly basis or on a contracted period basis (the
basic service time for 3G phones is about 1,200 minutes). Internet service fees are charged
on the basis of the contracted period and Internet speed.
Investment System
- Hong Kong prohibits discrimination between domestic and foreign companies, and thus
does not implement FDI-related laws. It applies the Companies Ordinance and the
Commercial Act equally to both domestic and foreign companies.
- This means that there are no special preferences or incentives applicable only to foreign
companies.
II. The Investment Environments of Korea and Its Asian Competitors 129
Ⅲ
Business Environment
◦ All of the surveyed countries, namely Korea, Taiwan, Malaysia, Singapore, China
(Beijing), and Hong Kong, implement diverse land support systems for corporations.
◦ The city states of Hong Kong and Singapore have expensive land prices due to their
scant land availability, while Taiwan, which is one third the size of Korea in terms of
territorial size, has high factory land prices due to the scarcity of available land.
Regarding factory land purchase prices, land prices per ㎡ with land location
conditions comparable to those of Gyeonggi-do in Korea (capital region) are US$
23~84 for Malaysia, which is by far the lowest level, and US$ 322 for the state city of
Singapore (the mean value of the lowest and highest prices of the three industrial
complexes), the highest level. Beijing's land prices rose to the range of US$ 165 to 248,
while Korea has a land price of US$ 319, lower than those of Hong Kong and
Taiwan, placing its industrial complexes competitiveness in the average of the ranking.
◦ In the case of commercial offices, rental costs per ㎡ with location conditions
comparable to those of Gangnam (center of Seoul, Korea) are US$ 16.5 for Malaysia
and US$ 16 for Korea, making them relatively low, and US$ 20 for Taiwan and
Beijing, similar to the prices of Korea and Malaysia. (In Korea, the highest office
rental cost per ㎡ is US$ 24 for the Gangnam Finance Center.) However, in Singapore
the rental cost is high at US$ 81 in 2009, althought the cost was lowered by 20% than
the previous year, and in Hong Kong the rental cost is US$ 107. As such, these twp
countries' office location conditions remain relatively uncompetitive.
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Notes : 1) The mean value between the lowest and highest prices where applicable.
2) ( ) : Areas on which the office rental fees are based.
3) Factory land criteria : Selangor (Malaysia), Banwol Industrial Complex (Korea), Districts with
Class 1 Industrial Complex (Beijing, China), Daewon Industrial Complex
District (Northern Taiwan), Downtown area (Singapore), and Tai Po
Industrial Estate (Hong Kong).
◦ As regards managers' average monthly wages, Singapore has the highest at US$ 4,444,
while wages in Korea and Hong Kong are similar at US$ 2,800. Taiwan is in the
medium wage bracket at US$ 1,975. Beijing is in the low wage bracket at US$ 1,083,
making its labor costs competitive. And Malaysia has the lowest average monthly
wages at US$ 900, making its labor cost the most competitive.
◦ According to the World Bank's 2010 Doing Business Index, Singapore ranks 1st in
terms of labor market flexibility, followed by Hong Kong in 6th place. Malaysia is
61st, roughly in the middle, while China, Korean and Taiwan rank 140th, 150th, and
153rd respectively.
6 0 0 ,0 0 0
K o rea
5 0 0 ,0 0 0
Y early N um b er
o f U niv ers ity 4 0 0 ,0 0 0 * C h in a in to ta l
G rad uates o f 5 .4 7 m illio n p e o ple Taiw an
b ac helo r's d eg ree 3 0 0 ,0 0 0 C hina (B eijing )
and hig her
2 0 0 ,0 0 0
S ing ap o re
1 0 0 ,0 0 0
M alay s ia H o ng K o ng
0
M o nthly A v erag e W ag e
(U S $, M anag er)
Note : Denotes the mean value between the lowest and highest prices where applicable.
◦ Regarding corporate tax, rates are highest in Taiwan, Malaysia, and Beijing at 25%. In
Korea, the rate is 22%, although there are plans to lower the rate to 20% in 2012.
Singapore implements a low corporate tax rate of 18%, and plans to lower the rate to
17% in 2010. Hong Kong offers the most competitive rate of corporate tax, at 16.5%,
and does not impose tariffs across the territory, making it very competitive in taxation
factor.
◦ According to the World Bank's 2010 Doing Business Index, Hong Kong ranks 3rd in
terms of taxation competitiveness, reducing corporations' tax burden the most.
Singapore is in 5th place, followed by Malaysia in 24th place, Korea in 49th place,
Taiwan in 92nd place, and China, lagging far behind in 130th place, making it least
competitive in terms of taxation. Korea has lowered its effective rates of corporate tax,
VAT and social premiums from 33.7% to 31.9%, but its lowering of income tax will be
reflected next year, and other countries are striving to improve their taxation
conditions, leading to a drop in Korea's ranking.
◦ All of the six Asian countries have implemented policies designed to strengthen the
protection of intellectual property rights, but infringements upon IPRs nevertheless
occur frequently, and disputes over IPRs are on the rise. Each year since 1988, the
USTR (United States Trade Representative) has announced "IPR Watch List" to protect
IPRs. Hong Kong was removed from this list in 1999, followed by Singapore in 2001,
while Korea and Taiwan were not removed from the list until March 2009. However,
China remains on the priority watch list, and Malaysia is also on the watch list.
◦ Hong Kong and Singapore have long been logistics leaders in Asia. China, however,
having recently occupied the world's largest share of cargo volume, has emerged as a
new logistics power. The World Bank surveyed international cargo transportation
companies to examine customs clearance procedures, the quality of infrastructures,
logistics and tracking systems, logistics costs, and so forth. It calculated the logistics
ratings of 150 countries, and announced the Logistics Performance Index (LPI) in 2007.
According to the results of the LPI, Singapore ranks 1st (4.19 points) and Hong Kong
8th (4 points), topping the LPI ranking. Taiwan ranks 21st (3.64 points), Korea 25th
(3.52 points), Malaysia 27th (3.48 points), and China 30th (3.32 points), placing all six
countries among the top 30 countries. Singapore and Hong Kong are outpacing the
other four countries by over 13 places, making their respective logistics environments
outstandingly competitive. Korea finds itself in the middle of the six countries in this
respect.
◦ The six countries all supply good public services such as waterworks, electricity, and
gas. Public services costs are not expensive for the general public.
- Gas fees are most expensive in Singapore, and are similar to those charged in Korea,
Hong Kong, and Taiwan. Beijing and Malaysia have low gas fees, while, notably,
Malaysia's gas fees are only 10% of those of Singapore.
- Electricity fees are high in Singapore and Hong Kong, and are higher in China and
Malaysia than in Korea and Taiwan.
- Waterworks service fees are highest in Singapore, followed by China which charges
higher waterworks fees compared with its other public services fees. Malaysia's
waterworks fees are higher compared with its other public services. Korea charges low
waterworks fees, with Taiwan charging the lowest waterworks fees of the six countries.
◦ None of the six Asian countries regulates foreign corporation establishment and
foreign acquisition of realty. Regarding the establishment of corporations, China,
unlike the other countries, requires, depending on the investment amount, the
municipal or central government's endorsement, and generally six months to complete
the procedure, making it uncompetitive. Regarding the acquisition of realty, some
countries impose limitations on certain districts (Singapore), and over certain amounts
of realty acquisition (Malaysia). Hong Kong does not impose any restrictions on the
acquisition of realty.
◦ According to the business starting conditions of the World 2010 Doing Business Index,
Singapore ranks 4th, making it the most favorable country for business starting among
the six Asian countries. Hong Kong ranks 18th, Taiwan 29th, Korea 53rd, Malaysia
88th, and China 151st, reflecting its business starting procedures the most difficult and
complicated. Five of the countries do not require a minimum amount of capital, while
China requires a minimum amount of capital equivalent to 130.9% of per capita GNP.
Korea abolished the minimum capital system and improved its business starting
conditions, rising 73 places from 126th to 53d place last year, and remarkably
improving the competitiveness of its corporation establishment conditions.
10
0
0 10 20 30 40
N u m b e r o f D a y s R e q u ire d f o r C o rp o ra t io n E s t a b lis h m e n t
(D o in g B u s in e s s 2 0 1 0 )
Living Environment
◦ Regarding monthly housing rental costs which are in areas where foreigners favor (at
a level comparable to that of the Gangnam district), Singapore is the most expensive
at US$ 3,125~6,597, followed by Hong Kong at US$ 2,600~4,935. Malaysia charges US$
1,200~2,400, and Taiwan US$ 1,000~1,200, making the costs not so low. Korea charges
L ivin g E n viro n m en t
6 ,0 0 0
S ing ap o re
5 ,0 0 0 (D o wnto wn
area)
4 ,0 0 0 Ho ng K o ng
A p artm ent Rental (D o wnto wn
Co s t 3 ,0 0 0 K o rea area)
(US $/m o nth) M alay s ia
(K ang nam )
(M o nt K iara)
2 ,0 0 0
1 ,0 0 0 China Taiwan
(X ic heng D is tric t) (Tianm u)
0
0 20 40 60 80 100
Note : 1) The UBS price index is based on the New York price index being 100.
2) Apartment rental cost criteria (Gangnam area's level, 90~120㎡)
: Malaysia(Mont' Kiara), Taiwan(Tianmu), Korea(Gangnam), China(Xicheng District, Beijing)
◦ In Singapore, Hong Kong and Malaysia, English is commonly used in everyday life,
and the Taiwanese doctors also speak good English, making their hospitals accessible
to foreigners. However, hospitals in China are less accessible to foreigners due to poor
overall English proficiency.
◦ In the 2008 World Major Cities' Living Conditions Index (KOTRA), medical costs
without medical insurance benefits applied (initial diagnosis of a cold) are compared.
Singapore is the highest at US$ 70.96, followed by Hong Kong at US$ 51.32. Kuala
Lumpur (Malaysia) charges US$ 21.85, Taipei (Taiwan) US$ 19.03, Seoul (Korea) US$
12.89, and Beijing US$ 1.95. As such, medical costs vary greatly. Korea, compared
with the five other countries, offers advanced medical technologies combined with
low medical costs, making its medical service competitiveness superior.
◦ Singapore, Korea, Taiwan and Hong Kong boast well-developed public transportation
systems and low fares. To boost foreign users' convenience, Korea makes foreign-
language announcements, provides foreign-language road signs, and continues to
improve its transportation system environment; its foreign-language transportation
services are better than the average of six countries. China has a well-developed
public transportation system, but its buses are not easy for foreigners to use, lowering
its competitiveness in this regard. Malaysia does not have a well-developed public
transportation system, lowering its competitiveness in terms of the convenience of
transportation.
◦ Regarding the number of foreign schools, Hong Kong has 50, Malaysia 48, and Korea
45 (24 located in the Greater Seoul Area). Singapore has 30, Taiwan 18, and Beijing
12. In terms of the number of foreign schools per 10,000 foreigners, Korea has the
largest number at 3.6. However, Singapore, Hong Kong and Malaysia have far more
foreign residents than Korea does, and English is generally used in everyday life,
making it easy for foreigners to enroll their children at local public schools. In terms
of foreign education facilities, Korea is better than Taiwan and Beijing, but not as
abundant as other three countries.
◦ Singapore, Hong Kong, Korea, and Taiwan boast high rates of mobile and Internet
service usage, and world-class communication system development. Beijing and
Malaysia have an Internet diffusion rate of 28% and 25%, respectively, considerably
lower than the other four countries. Internet speeds are slow because telephone
networks are used for the Internet, lowering the competitiveness of the
communication sector in those countries.
◦ With the exception of Hong Kong, which in principle does not differentiate domestic
and foreign companies, all countries implement separate laws pertaining to foreign
investment. Hong Kong subjects foreign investment companies to the Corporation Act
and the Commercial Act just as domestic companies are subject to those acts.
◦ Hong Kong does offer an exclusive investment promotion agency. In other countries,
separate foreign investment promotion agencies are operated, such as EDB
(Singapore), MIDA (Malaysia), KOTRA (Korea), and TAITRA (Taiwan). China does
not operate a separate investment agency; instead, local municipalities operate
investment departments. In the case of Beijing, its Investment Promotion Bureau and
Municipal Commission on Development and Reform undertake to perform foreign
investment promotion work.
◦ With the exception of Hong Kong, all the countries offer an incentive system for
foreign investment. Korea, Taiwan, Malaysia, Singapore, and Beijing make the most of
tax breaks as investment incentives, as well as the provision of subsidies and cash
grant. Notably, in the case of Singapore, the investment promotion agency EDB has
the authority to negotiate, allowing it to provide exceptional incentives including cash
to promote important foreign investment. Korea also has a relatively competitive
incentive system.
1. Results by Factor
2. Comprehensive Comparison
by Country
IV Investment Attractiveness Survey of Major Asian Countries
◦ This survey was conducted by KOTRA's overseas KBCs (Korea Business Centers) to
compare the investment attractiveness of six major Asian countries including Korea.
Nineteen factors including market size, location conditions, and tax were evaluated on
a scale of 1 point (very bad) to 10 points (very good).
◦ 261 companies in 17 countries around the world responded to the survey. Of these,
121 were based in Asia and Oceania, accounting for 47% of the total, while 87 or 33%
were from Europe, and 53 or 20% were from North America.
◦ Of the respondents, those in services (finance, realty, consulting, etc.) were the largest
group, with a 54.4% share. This was followed by the manufacturing sector (machines,
semiconductors, electric and electronics, new and renewable energy, etc.) with 40.4%,
and by the public institutions, construction sector, and agricultural sector, with 2.4%,
1.6%, and 1.2%, respectively.
◦ Of the respondents, 31% invested in Korea and entered the Korean market, while
69%, well over twice of invested, did not enter the Korean market.
North
America
20% Entry
31%
Asia-
Oceania
47% Manufacturing
40% Service
Non‐Entry 54%
69%
Europe
33%
SCORE
Market Size SCORE
Market Growth Potential
10 10
8.93
8.59
8 8
6.76 6.6
5.78 5.8 6.08
6 5.36 5.45 5.6 6 5.64 5.57
4 4
2 2
0 0
KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG
KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG
8 7.52 8 7.58
6.56 6.21 6.3
5.86 5.79 5.82
6 5.48 5.14 6
4.87
4.47
4 4
2 2
0 0
KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG
◦ In the category of market, China got high score over 8 points. Korea is followed as
2nd which reflects the Korean market's competiveness. It is very meaningful
considering the difference of territory size between two countries.
◦ In terms of site location, China again got good score. Korea is estimated as 2nd best
in site location availability.
4 4
2 2
0 0
KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG
KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG
7.78 7.92
8 8 7.14
6.51 6.83
6.2 6.37
5.95 5.71 5.9
6 5.34 6 5.25
4 4
2 2
0 0
KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG
◦ In the category of human resources, Korea got high scores, especially in the quality of
human resource. Korea is famous for its enthusiasm for education which results in
572,000 bachelor degree holders and above every year.
8 7.72
8 7.09
6.49 6.48
5.99 6.07 6 6.35 6.38
5.67 6.01
6 6
4 4 3.61
2 2
0 0
KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG
4 4
2 2
0 0
KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG
7.7
8 8 7.05
6.45 6.63 6.67
6.05 6.03 6.08 5.73 6.06
5.7
6 6
4.48
4 4
2 2
0 0
KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG
4 4
2 2
0 0
KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG
◦ The transparency of Korean government's policy and incentives are estimated 2nd best
in comparison with other countries, reflecting development of Korean government's
activity.
◦ Korea got 1st ranking score over 8 points technological maturity and 2nd in
innovation climate. Since these factors cannot be developed in short period, it is a
very encouraging result for Korea.
4 4
2 2
0
0
KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG
KOREA TAIWAN MALAYSIA SINGAPORE CHINA HONG KONG
◦ In the category of infrastructure, Korea got 2nd highest score following Singapore.
However, in language circumstance, Korea ranked 4th among six countries with the
lowest score it has got among the categories.
S co re
6 .9 8
7
6 .8
6 .8
6 .6 6 .5 4
6 .4
6 .2 1 6 .2 2
6 .2 6 .1 4
5 .8
5 .6
K O RE A T A IW A N M A L A Y S IA S IN G A P O R E C H IN A HO NG K O NG
▸ In terms of the total score, Singapore earned 6.98 points out of a possible 10-point
score, ranking 1st among the six countries. Korea earned 6.8 points, ranking 2nd, and
thus surpassing Hong Kong. This is because Korea earned better scores in the
innovative environment and technological maturity categories than Hong Kong.
▸ In terms of the total score, Korea was placed 0.18 points behind Singapore and 0.26
points ahead of Hong Kong. 3rd-placed Hong Kong was a big 0.32 points ahead of
4th-placed China. Although China boasts a high level of investment attractiveness
level to its huge market size, its overall investment environment is less competitive.
◦ The main survey results are shown in radiational graphs and compared, distinctively
showing each country's superior and inferior features.
◦ Taiwan, Malaysia, and China have almost no factor in which they earned a high score
of over 8 points, making the area formed by connecting each apex of the graph very
small compared with Singapore, Korea and Hong Kong. On the other hand,
Singapore, Korea and Hong Kong, having a number of factors with a high score, have
the area formed by connecting each apex of the graph rather large.
◦ Taiwan and Malaysia earned low scores overall, but each category was equally well
developed. Taiwan boasts technological maturity as its greatest strength while
proficiency in foreign languages is a weakness. Malaysia boasts foreign language
proficiency as its greatest strength, while its market size is a weakness.
KOREA TAIWAN
Market Size Market Size
10 10
Site Location
Language 8 Site Location Cost Language 8 Cost
6 6
4 4 Human Resources
Human Resources Education
Education Quality
Quality 2
2
0 0
Technological Human Resources
Technological Human Resources
Maturity Cost
Maturity Cost
Government's Government's
Incentives Incentives for Infrastructure
Infrastructure Investment
for
Investment Transparency of
Transparency of Government's
Government's Policy
Policy
MALAYSIA SINGAPORE
Market Size
Market Size 10
10 Site Location
Site Location Language 8
Language Cost
8 Cost
6
6
4
Human
4 Human Resources Education Resources
Education
2
Quality 2 Quality
0
0
Human
Technological Human Resources
Technological
Resources
Maturity Cost Maturity
Cost
Government's Government's
Incentives for Infrastructure Incentives for Infrastructure
Investment Investment
Transparency of Transparency of
Government's Government's
Policy Policy
Government's Government's
Incentives for Infrastructure Incentives for Infrastructure
Investment Investment
Transparency of Transparency of
Government's Government's
Policy Policy
Conclusion
V Conclusion
◦ This research can offer a comparative - albeit not absolute - evaluation of the
strengths and weaknesses of these countries' investment environments, since it is
based on the research conducted by KOTRA's overseas KBCs and on a survey of
potential foreign investors.
V. Conclusion 157
◦ Korea, overall, has an investment environment of more than average level. Notably,
its high technological maturity, innovative environment, and excellent human
resources - seen as advanced "infrastructures" which cannot be achieved in a short
period of time - are widely recognized as attractive points by foreign investors, which
is distinctively encouraging for Korea. Thus, Korea needs to promote foreign
investment in high technologies and R&D centers which can use the country's major
strengths, such as its excellent human resources and its technological superiority.
◦ Long-term efforts and clarity of vision are required to create a favorable and excellent
business environment to assist and vigorously promote foreign investment. The
promotion of foreign investment will certainly help bring about the transfer of
advanced technologies to the country, create more jobs, and enhance our international
competitiveness. Korean government will make efforts to establish business-friendly
environment consistently.
Business Environment Korea Taiwan Malaysia Singapore China (Beijing) Hong Kong
∙US$ 165~248
Factory Land Purchase Costs ∙US$ 23~843) ∙Land prices rose
(㎡, the level of Gyeonggi-do*) ∙US$ 319 1) ∙US$ 365~4572) ∙Lowest land price ∙US$ 117~5274) sharply, even reaching ∙US$ 312
*Capital Region among the six countries up to 77% of Korea's
level
∙US$ 16
Office Rental Costs ∙US$ 81
∙US$ 24 for Gangnam's
(㎡, the level of Gangnam*) ∙US$ 21.64 ∙US$ 16.5 ※ In 2009, dropped by ∙US$ 20.38 ∙US$ 107
highest rate (Gangnam
*Center of the city 20%
Finance Center)
∙US$ 1,083
∙US$ 900 ∙US$ 4,444 ∙For managers, 38% of
Monthly Wages (Managers) ∙US$ 2,835 ∙US$ 1,975 ∙Lowest labor cost ∙Highest labor cost the Korea's level. Prices ∙ US$ 2,860 5)
among the six countries among the six countries rose, but labor costs
are still competitive
Annual number of university ∙572,000 ∙287,000 ∙97,000 ∙38,000 ∙210,000 ∙43,000
graduates of bachelor's level or ∙76 per every 10,000 ∙120 per every 10,000 ∙35 per every 10,000 ∙83 per every 10,000 ∙121 per every 10,000 ∙62 per every 10,000
higher people people people people people (41 for all China) people
2007 Traffic Volumes of World's Major Ports and Analysis, Korea Container Terminal
Authority
2008 Analysis of Traffic Statistics by Year and Route, Korea Express Corporation
2008 White Paper on Labor, Ministry of Labor
2008 Wage Trend and 2009 Wage Prospects, Monthly Labor Review, Korea Labor
Institute
2008 Korean Industries' Customer Satisfaction Index (KCSI), KMAC
First Quarter 2009 Office Market Report, R2 Korea Real Estate
2009 White Paper on Intellectual Properties, Statistics Korea
2009 Special Resolution 301 Report
An Analysis of Foreign Labor Market, and a Study on the Improvement of Mid- and
Long-Term Management Systems, Korea Labor Institute, 2007
Major countries' Information and Communication Services - Asia/Oceania, KOTRA,
National IT Industry Promotion Agency, 2009
Foreigner Living Guide (2009), Invest Korea (KOTRA)
Foreigner Investment Guide (2008), Invest Korea (KOTRA)
National Education Statistics Information Center (std.kedi.re.kr)
National Legislation Information Center (www.law.go.kr)
NHIC Health Insurance Policy Institute (www.nhic.or.kr)
MLTM Real Estate Industry Division (www.mltm.go.kr)
Gunsan, Daebul and Masan FTZ Management Authority, MKE FEZ Center (www.fez.go.kr)
MOST (www.mosf.go.kr)
Naver Real Estate (land.naver.com)
Naver Regional Information (local.naver.com)
MOL (www.molab.go.kr)
Daum Real Estate (realestate.daum.net)
MOLEG (www.moleg.go.kr)
Real Estate 114 (www.r114.co.kr)
Seoul Foreign School (www.sfs.or.kr)
References 165
KOTRA 09-046