Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
of 4% is a rate of 1.2%. The tax is imposed on assets in excess of 21,139 (2012). See Income tax
in the Netherlands.
In practice
Norway: 0.7% (municipal) and 0.3% (national) a total of 1.0% levied on net assets exceeding 1,000,000 kr as of 2014.[7] For tax purposes, the
value of real estate assets are estimated to approximately 50% of the market value (25% if it is the
taxpayers primary residence).[8] The Conservative
and Progress parties in the current government and
the Liberal Party have stated that they aim to reduce
and eventually eliminate the wealth tax.[9]
France: There is a solidarity tax on wealth on to some extent the Council Tax, and a new Mansion Tax
any net assets above 800,000, if your total net proposed by some political parties.
worth is 1,300,000 or more. Marginal rates range
from 0.5% to 1.5%.[2] In 2007, it collected 4.07
2 Rationale
billion, accounting for 1.4% of total revenue.[3]
India: Wealth tax is 1% on net wealth exceeding 1 Crores (Rs 1,00,00,000). However, non- 2.1 Concentration of wealth
residents returning to India are exempt for seven
years.[5] In February 2015, abolition of the tax from Main article: Wealth concentration
FY15-16 was announced in the Union Budget.[6]
Netherlands: Interest income is taxed like a In 2014, French economist Thomas Piketty published a
wealth tax, i.e. a xed 30% out of an assumed yield book entitled Capital In The Twenty-First Century that
posits the theory that economic inequality was worsening and proposes wealth taxes as a solution. The central thesis of the book is that inequality is not an accident, but rather a feature of capitalism, and can only be
reversed through state interventionism. The book thus
argues that unless capitalism is reformed, the very democratic order will be threatened. At the core of this thesis
is the notion that when the rate of return on capital (r) is
greater than the rate of economic growth (g) over the long
term, the result is concentration of wealth, and this unequal distribution of wealth causes social and economic
instability. Piketty proposes a global system of progressive wealth taxes to help reduce inequality and avoid the
vast majority of wealth coming under the control of a
tiny minority. This analysis was hailed as a major and
important work by some economists. Pikettys work is
not without its critics, however. Other economists have
challenged key aspects of Pikettys proposals and interpretations, stating that they are often inconsistent and/or
awed.[11][12][13][14][15][16]
2.2
Fairness
According to the beneciary pay criterion of tax fairness, a tax on property rights can be seen as a use fee.
Specically, protection of property rights is a primary
purpose of government. Holders of property rights enjoy
the existence of government more than those who hold no
property rights do and thus Capital In The Twenty-First
Century argues that those who benet the most owe the
most back to the society that permits the capitalist system
to exist. This is also true of ownership interests or stock.
2.3
Revenue
2.4
Economic growth
A wealth tax that decreases other tax burdens, such as income, capital gains, sales, value added and inheritance,
increases the time horizon for investment and can increase the return on investments over that time. The
increased time horizon of investment results from the
competition for investment between the risk-free asset
of modern portfolio theory, and commercial assets. The
higher return on investment results from the removal of
taxes on prots.
RATIONALE
2.5 Investment
A wealth tax serves as a negative reinforcer (use it or
lose it), which coerces the productive use of assets. According to University of Pennsylvania Law School Professors David Shakow and Reed Shuldiner, A wealth
tax also taxes capital that is not productively employed.
Thus, a wealth tax can be viewed as a tax on potential income from capital.[18] Because a net wealth tax can be
the equivalent of an annual tax on imputed income, the
capital gains, estate and gift taxes are not necessary.
3.4
Disadvantages
3.1
Capital ight
3.2
Economic eects
3
i.e., vehicles, boats, real estate, and (most importantly)
private business. Private businesses account for nearly
40% of their wealth and are the largest single category.
A particular issue for small business owners is that they
cannot accurately value their private business until it is
sold. Furthermore, business owners could easily make
their businesses look much less valuable that they really are, through accounting, valuations and assumptions
about the future. Even the rich dont know what exactly
what theyre worth in any given moment.[25]
More dicult questions arise as to the equitable valuation of homes and real estate by geographic area, where
values per square foot of home and per acre of land can
vary by more than 400 percent in the United States. In
addition, critics claim that the inherent diculty of evaluating personal property would create a labyrinth of bureaucracy and potential for fraud, and perhaps the emergence of a class of tax-exempt and special-consideration
assets that would only further cloud and burden an already
overwhelmed tax system. Analysts predict that the process of appraisal of personal property, with some items
appreciating and others depreciating, would be onerous
and the costs of dispute resolution with the IRS would
skyrocket.[26] Examples of such fraud and malfeasance
were revealed in 2013, when French budget minister
Jerome Cahuzac was discovered shifting nancial assets
into Swiss bank accounts in order to avoid the wealth tax.
After further investigation, a French nance ministry ofcial said, A number of government ocials minimised
their wealth, by negligence or with intent, but without exceeding 5-10 per cent of their real worth ... however,
there are some who have deliberately tried to deceive the
authorities.[27] Yet again, in October 2014, Frances Finance Chairman and President of the National Assembly, Gilles Carrez, was found to have avoided paying the
French wealth tax (ISF) for three years by applying a 30
percent tax allowance on one of his homes. However, he
had previously converted the home into an SCI, a private, limited company to be used for rental purposes.
The 30 percent allowance does not apply to SCI holdings. Once this was revealed, Carrez declared, if the
tax authorities think that I should pay the wealth tax, I
won't argue. Carrez is one of more than 60 French parliamentarians battling with the tax oces over 'dodgy' asset declarations.[28]
401K, IRA, and other deferred and retirement-related accounts ... as well as the accumulated value of their real estate. In addition, there may be the possibility that the tax
value of life insurance policies and charitable remainder
trusts could be included in these wealth calculations.[29]
Wealth taxes would have maximum impact just as retirees
are shifting and adjusting to xed-income living. Others
have pointed out that a progressive wealth tax would only
aect those with a net worth in excess of ten million dollars, thus making it less important at what stage of the
taxpayers life the obligation was incurred.[30][31]
3.5
3.6
LEGAL IMPEDIMENTS
4 Legal impediments
4.1 Germany
The Federal Constitutional Court of Germany in Karlsruhe found that wealth taxes would need to be conscatory in order to bring about any real redistribution In
addition, the court held that the sum of wealth tax and
income tax should not be greater than half of a taxpayers
income. The tax thus gives rise to a dilemma: either it
is ineective in ghting inequalities, or it is conscatory
and it is for that reason that the Germans chose to eliminate it. Thus nding such wealth taxes unconstitutional
in 1995.[38]
Past failures
5
tax or capital gains tax) unless the revenue collected [9] NTB (13 February 2014). Politisk ertall for fjerne
formuesskatten (in Norwegian). Dagens Nringsliv. Reis apportioned among the states on the basis of their
trieved 19 March 2014.
population.[39][40][41] Although a federal wealth tax is prohibited unless the receipts are collected from the States by [10] Switzerland Wealth Tax, Lowtax.net
their populations, state and local government property tax
amount to a wealth tax on real estate.[42] There is su- [11] Thomas Piketty Is Wrong: America Will Never Look
Like a Jane Austen Novel, New Republic, 2014
cient question about its Constitutionality that the issue is
[43]
debatable.
[12] Thomas Pikettys Wealth Illusion, Barrons, August 5,
2014
See also
Ad valorem tax
References
[1] Edward N. Wol, Time for a Wealth Tax?", Boston Review, Feb-Mar 1996 (recommending a net wealth tax for
the US of 0.05% for the rst $100,000 in assets to 0.3%
for assets over $1,000,000
[2] Worldwide personal tax guide 20132014: France
(PDF). HSBC. 1 July 2013. Retrieved 11 December
2014.
[3] French wealth tax explained in full in The Connexion
[4] Spanish Wealth Tax (Patrimonio)
[5] http://law.incometaxindia.gov.in/DIT/
other-income-tax-acts.aspx?page=ODTA&TabId=
tab_WTA
[6] Budget 2015: Wealth tax abolished; applicability of
GAAR deferred by two years. The Economic Times. 28
February 2015. Retrieved 28 February 2015.
[15] Thomas Pikettys Wrong Conclusions on Rising U.S. Income Inequality, U.S. News & World Report, June 5,
2014
[16] Inequality A Piketty problem?, Economist, May 24, 2014
[17] Trump proposes massive onetime tax on the rich CNN,
November 9, 1999
[18] Shakow, David and Shuldiner, Reed, Symposium on
Wealth Taxes Part II, New York University School of Law
Tax Law Review, 53 Tax L. Rev. 499, 506 Summer, 2000
[19] Mulligan, Casey B., How Payroll Tax Cuts Can Create
Jobs, New York Times, 14 September 2011
[20] Fair Share Taxes Essay, 2010
[21] Washington Post. Old Money, New Money Flee France
and Its Wealth Tax, 16 July 2006
[22] The Economic Consequences of the French Wealth Tax,
papers.ssrn.com, 05/04/07
[23] What A Wealth tax and Lindsay lohan Have In Common,
Forbes, November 20, 2012
[24] Why The IMF Wealth Tax Simply Will Not Work,
Forbes, October 23, 2013
[25] The Problem with a Wealth tax, Wall Street Journal January 11, 2012
[26] What A Wealth Tax and Lindsay Lohan Have In Common, Forbes November 20, 2012
[27] Chazan, David (October 22, 2014). French MPs face
investigation over tax scandal. The Telegraph.
[28] France Medias Monde. Frances Finance Chairman facing tax nightmare. RFI News (National French Radio).
[29] The Coming Global Wealth Tax, National Liberty Federation, December 4, 2013
[30] An Immodest Proposal: A Global Tax on the Super Rich,
Businessweek, October 23, 2013
[7]
[8] 3.1 Endringer i formuesskatten (in Norwegian). Department of Finance. Retrieved 19 March 2014.
REFERENCES
7.1
Text
Wealth tax Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_tax?oldid=676009420 Contributors: Wesley, B4hand, Edward, Rl, Jake Nelson,
Mark Blackburn, David Koller, Bnn, Masken, Jabowery, Ben Arnold, Gdm, Beland, Sam Hocevar, Anirvan, Neutrality, Rich Farmbrough, Jerryseinfeld, Guy Harris, John Quiggin, DreamGuy, Dan100, Jghaines, Josh Parris, Sjakkalle, Toi, WouterBot, YurikBot, RussBot, Bovineone, Morphh, Pegship, Intershark, SmackBot, Tarret, Lawrencekhoo, Chris the speller, JzG, Breno, TastyPoutine, Turkguy,
AdjustablePliers, Joseph Solis in Australia, Boreas74, Blehfu, Peter1c, CRGreathouse, CmdrObot, Pmyteh, SteveMcCluskey, Thijs!bot,
Z10x, MyPOV, Nick Number, Mmortal03, Fedayee, NByz, LeedsKing, RubyQ, Magioladitis, Mikhailfranco, Roy Langston, Bibliophylax,
Christian424, Jeepday, JayJasper, Matthardingu, Redtigerxyz, Philaweb, Anylayman, FinnWiki, SieBot, Grundle2600, ClueBot, Auntof6,
Megiddo1013, TaalVerbeteraar, MystBot, Addbot, Tharyps the Molossian, Download, Lightbot, Zorrobot, Legobot, Luckas-bot, Darx9url,
AnomieBOT, Altgeld, Carolina wren, MauritsBot, Xqbot, Caceo, Howsa12, FrescoBot, Varmapak, Sweet Million, LilyKitty, Stalwart111,
Conorbrady.ie, EmausBot, John of Reading, Dewritech, Imagerock123, ZroBot, Mindful123, Tallenuk, Adrianw61, Neil P. Quinn,
Artnesten, Guest2625, BG19bot, Steinarbe, Cifart, Majorbolz, Nasmith1234, Dingopromotheus, Mwren1, Cupco, EugenePatrickDevany,
Rubyjac, Vanamonde93, Ildottoreverde, Globalcooling400, EllenCT, Comp.arch, Tolinjr, Colonycat, Plokmijnuhbygvtfcdxeszwaq, Highfever2015, KasparBot and Anonymous: 111
7.2
Images
7.3
Content license