Sunteți pe pagina 1din 182

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Control Systems
PHYSICAL SYSTEMS:
INTRODUCTION:

First step towards analysis of a control system is preparation of a mathematical


model which is linear over a satisfactory range operating conditions giving us the
property of linearity and superposition.
A model may be defined as a representation of the essential aspects of the system
which presents knowledge of the system in a usable manner.
To be useful, the model must not so complicated that it cannot be understood and
thereby be unsuitable for analysis.
The components of a control system are diverse in nature and may include
electrical, mechanical, thermal and fluidic devices.
At the same time, it must not so complicated that it cannot be understood and
thereby be unsuitable for analysis.
At the same time, it must not be oversimplified and trivial.
While dealing with control systems, we shall be concerned mostly with dynamic
systems. The behavior of such systems is described in the form of differential
equations.
Although these will normally be nonlinear, it is customary to linearize them about
an operating point to obtain linear differential equations.
The components of a control system are diverse in nature and may include
electrical, mechanical, thermal and fluidic devices. The differential equations
relating the input and output quantities for these devices are obtained using the
basic law of physics. These include balancing forces, energy and mass. In
practice, some simplifying assumptions are often made to obtain linear
differential equations. With constant coefficients, although in most cases exact
analysis would lead to nonlinear partial differential equations. For most physical
devices one may classify the variables as either THROUGH or ACROSS
variables, in the sense that the former refer to a point while the latter are measured
between two points.
The input , output relations of various physical components of a system is
governed by differential equation. The mathematical model of a control system
constitutes a set of differential equation.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 1

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

SYSTEM
Electrical
Mechanical
(translational)
Mechanical
(rotational)
Thermal
Fluidic

THROUGH
VARIABLE
Current I
Force, F
Torque, T
Rate of flow of
heat energy,q
Volumetric rate
of fluid flow,Q

IV Semester ECE

ACROSS
VARIABLE
Potential difference
or voltage V.
Relative velocity,v
Relative angular
velocity ,
Difference in temp.
T
Difference in
pressure,P

A mathematical model will be linear if the differential equations describing the


system have constant coefficients. If the coefficients of the differential equations
describing the system are constants, then the model is linear time invariant. If the
coefficients of the differential equations governing the system are functions of time, then
the model is linear time varying.
The differential equations of a linear time invariant system can be reshaped into
different form for the convenience of analysis. One such model for single input and
single output system analysis is transfer function of the system. The transfer function of a
system analysis is transfer function of the system. The transfer function of a system is
defined as the ratio of laplace transfer function of the system. The transfer function of a
defined as the ratio of laplace transfer function of a system is defined as the ratio of
laplace transform of output to the laplace transform of input with zero initial conditions.

An equation describing a physical has integrals and differentials. The response can be
obtained by solving such equations. The steps involved in obtaining the transfer function
are:

Write differential equation of the system.


Replace terms involving d/dt by s and integral of dt by 1/s.

Advantages of open loop system.


The advantages of open loop system are
1. Such systems are simple in construction.
2. Very much convenient when input is difficult to measure.
3. Such systems are easy for maintenance point of view.
4. Generally these are not troubled with problems of stability.
5. Such systems are simple to design and hence economical.
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 2

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Disadvantages of open loop system.


The disadvantages of open loop system are
1. Such systems are inaccurate and unreliable because accuracy of such
systems are totally dependent on the accurate precalibration of the
controller.
2. Such systems give inaccurate results if there are variation in the
external environment i.e. systems cannot sense environmental changes.
3. Similarly they cannot sense internal disturbances in the system, after
the controller stage.

Advantages of closed loop system.


The advantages of closed loop system are:
1.accuracy of such system is always very high because controller modifies
and manipulates the actuating signal such that error in the system will be zero.
2. Such systems senses environmental changes, as well as internal
disturbances and accordingly modifies the error.
1. In such system, there is reduced effect of non-linearites and
distortions.
Comparison between open loop system and closed loop system
OPEN LOOP SYSTEM
Output measurement is not required
for operation of the system.
Highly affected by non-lineariteis
Highly sensitive to the disturbances
and environmental changes
Feedback element and error detector
are absent
Generally stable in nature

CLOSED LOOP SYSTEM


Output measurement is
necessary.
Reduced effect of nonlinearities.
Less sensitive to disturbances
and environmental changes.
Feedback element and error
detector are absent
Stability is the major
consideration while designing.

Linear system.
A system is said to be linear if it obeys the principle of superposition and
homogeneity. The principle of superposition states that the response of the system to a
weighted sum of the responses of the system to each individual input signals.
The system is said to be linear, if it satisfies the following two properties:
Adaptive property that is for any x and y belonging to the
domain of the function f, we have
F(x+y) = f(x) +f(y)
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 3

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Homogeneous property that is for any x belonging to the


domain of the function f and for any scalar constant
We have

F(x) = f(x)
These two properties together constitute a principle of superposition.
Most of the systems are non-linear in nature because of different non-linearities
such as saturation, friction, dead zone etc. present in the system.

Definition of Transfer Function


Transfer function of a given system is defined as the ratio of the laplace transform
of output variable to laplace transform of input variables at zero input conditions.

Properties of transfer functions.


The properties of transfer function are as follows:

The transfer function of a system is the laplace transform of its


impulse response. I.e. if the input to a system with transfer
function P(s) is an impulse and all initial conditions are zero, the
transform of the output is P(s).

The roots of the denominator are the system poles and the roots of
the numerator are system zeros. The system stability can be
described in terms of the location of the roots of the transfer
function.
Advantages of transfer function.

It helps in the stability analysis of the system.

It helps in determining the important information about the system


Poles, zeros, characteristic equation etc.

Once transfer function is known, output response for any type of


reference input can be calculated.

The system differential equation can be easily obtained by


replacing variable s by d/dt.
Disadvantages of transfer function.
The disadvantages of transfer function approach are:

Only applicable to linear time invariant systems.

It does not provide any information concerning the physical


structure of the system. From transfer function, physical nature of
the system, whether it is electrical, mechanical, thermal or
hydraulic cannot be judged.
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 4

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Effects arising due to initial conditions are totally neglected. Hence


initial conditions loose importance.

Important features of feedback.

Reduced effects of non-linearities and distortion.

Increased accuracy.

Reduced sensitivity of the ratio of the output to input to variations


in system characteristics.

Tendency toward oscillation or instability.

The basic elements used for modeling mechanical translational system:


The model of mechanical translational system can be obtained by using three
basic elements mass spring and dashpot.
Translational system
Consider a mechanical system in which motion is taking place along a straight
line. Such systems are of translational type. These systems are characterized by
displacement, linear velocity and linear acceleration.
Definition of torque.
This is the motion about a fixed axis. In such systems, the force gets replaced by a
moment about the fixed axis. I.e. {force x distance from fixed axis} which is called
torque.
Definition of friction.
Whenever there is a motion, there exists a friction. Friction may be between
moving element and fixed support or between two moving surfaces. Friction is also nonlinear in nature.
The types of friction.
Friction can be divided into three types. They are
Viscous friction.
Static friction.
Coulomb friction.
The two types of analogies for mechanical system are force-voltage analogy and
force-current analogy.
Analogous systems
Systems whose differential equations are identical form are called analogous
systems.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 5

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Two types of variables in physical system.


The two variables in physical systems are through variables and across variable.
Through variables refer to a point, the across variable is measured between two points.
The other names for force voltage analogy and force current analogy are
Force voltage analogy- Loop analysis.
Force current analogy- nodal analysis.

BLOCK DIAGRAM ALGEBRA;


INTRODUCTION:
In block diagram, the system consists of so many components. These components
are linked together to perform a particular function. Each component can be represented
with the help of individual block.
NEED FOR BLOCK DIAGRAM REDUCTION:
Block diagrams of some of the systems turn out to be complex, such that the evaluation
of their performance required simplification (or reduction) of block diagrams which is
carried out by block diagram rearrangements.
DEFINITION:
A block diagram of a system is a pictorial representation of the functions
performed by each component of the system and shows the flow of signals.
ADVANTAGES OF BLOCK DIAGRAM:
Very simple to construct the block diagram for complicated systems.
Individual as well as overall performance of the system can be studied by using
transfer functions shown in the block diagram.
Overall closed loop transfer function can be easily calculated using block diagram
rules.
The function of the individual element can be visualized from the block diagram.
DISADVANTAGES OF BLOCK DIAGRAM:
The disadvantages of block diagram are:
Block diagram does not include any information about the physical construction
of the system.
Source of energy is generally not shown in the block diagram, so block diagram
for a given system is not unique.
The basic components of block diagram are block, branches, summing point, arrows.
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 6

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

BLOCK:
It indicates the function of particular system. R(s) is the reference or controlling
variable.
G(s) is the transfer function of the particular system.C(s) is output or controlled variable.

R(S)

C(S)
G(S)

SUMMING POINT:
It is used to add or subtract one or more signals. + indicates the add or subtract function.
+ indicates the signal is added to reference signal. -indicates the signal is subtracted to
reference signal. It is called negative feedback. The signal which is added or subtracted to
the reference signal is called feedback signal.
Summing point
R(S)

C(S)
+

TAKE OF POINT
Some of the signal at the top are bypass and it is given to other block for further
performance.
Take off point
R(S)

C(S)

G(s)

The steps to reduce the block diagram.


Reduce the series blocks.
Reduce the parallel blocks.
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 7

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Reduce minor feedback loops.


As for as possible shift summing point to the left and take-off point to the right.
Repeat the above steps till canonical form is obtained.

BLOCK DIAGRAM FOR A CANONICAL SYSTEM:


R(s) = reference or controlling variable.
C(S) = Output or controlled variable.
E(S) = Error actuating signal.
B(S) = Feedback signal
H(S) = Feedback element.
G(S) = transfer function for the system.
G(S) = C(S)
E(S)
Closed loop transfer function is
C(S) .
R(S)
C(S) = G(S) E(S).
Consider a negative feedback signal is applied
Actuating signal E(S) = R(S) B(S)

(1)

(2)

Feedback signal C(S)H(S) = B(S)


Put equation (3) in eq.(2)
E(S) = R(S)- C(S)H(S)
Put eq (4) in eq.(1)
C(S) = G(S){R(S) C(S)H(S)}
C(S)[ 1+ G(S) H(S)] = G(S)R(S)

(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)

(transfer function for negative feedback signal


C(S) = G(S)______
R(S)
1+G(S) R(S)
(transfer function for positive feedback signal.)
C(S) = G(S)______
R(S)
1-G(S) R(S)

Rules for reduction of block diagram


Rule 1: If the blocks are in cascade then
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 8

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

R(S)

R(S)

C(S
)

G2

G1

C(S)

G1G2

Rule 2: if the blocks are in parallel then, the blocks are added or subtracted
depending on the summing point signal.

G2

R(S)

G1+G2

C(S)

G1
R(S)

+
+

C(s)

Rule 3: Moving the take-off point after the block

R(S)

R(S)

C (S)

C(S)

=
1/G

Rule 4: moving the take-off point ahead of the block

G
G
G
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 9

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Rule 5: Moving summing point after the block, then

Rule 6: Moving the summing point ahead (before) the blockff

Rule 7: Eliminating feedback loop, then

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 10

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

1. Using block diagram reduction techniques find C(s) / R(s) as in fig. Fig1.2.1.1
R(s)

G1
-

C(s)

I
H1

II
H2
Fig1.2.1.1

Step 1: eliminating feedback loop I


R(s)

C(s)

G1

1+G1H1

II
H1

Step2: eliminating feedback loop II

G(s) = G1 / 1 +G1H1 H(s) = H2


G1
G1 / 1 +G1H1
C(s) / R(s) =

=
1 +G1H1 + G1H2

1 + (G1 / 1 +G1H1 )(H2)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 11

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

G1
R(s)

C(s)
1 + G1H1+G1H2
Fig1.2.1.2
Answer.

2. Using block diagram reduction technique find closed loop transfer


function C(s) / R(s) shown in fig 1.2.2.1

G3
+ C(S)

R(S)
G1
-

G4

G2

H1

H2
Fig 1.2.2.1

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 12

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 1: Combine the blocks G1 &G2 which are in cascade and combine the
blocks G2 &G3 which are in parallel as shown in fig 1.2.2.2.

R(S)

C(S)
G1 G4
-

G2 +G3
I

H1
II
H2
Fig 1.2.2.2

Step 2: Eliminate feedback loopI and combine the blocks (G1G4 / 1+ G1G4H1) &
(G2 + G3) which are in parallel as shown in fig. Fig 1.2.2.3
C(S)

G1G4
G2+G3

R(S)
1+ G1G4H1

II
H2

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 13

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 3: eliminate feedback loop II

G1G4
G2 +G3
C(s)

1 +G1G4H1

=
R(s)
1+

G1G4

G2 +G3
1 + G1G4H1

G1G4

G2 +G3

=
1 + G1G4H1

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

G1G4 (G2 +G3)

Page 14

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

3.Find the transfer function C(s) / R(s) for the block diagram shown below
as shown in (fig 1.2.3.1)
(A.U.2004)

R(s)

C(s)
G1(s)
-

G2(s)
I

II

(fig 1.2.3.1)

Step 1: Eliminating feedback loopI (as in fig.1.2.3.2)


R(s)

C(s)
G1(s)

G2(s)__
1 + G2 (s)

II

(fig 1.2.3.2)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 15

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 2: Combining blocks G1(s) & {G2(s) / 1+ G2(s)} which are in


cascade (as in fig 1.2.3.3)
C(s)

R(s)

G1(s)G2(s)__
1 + G2 (s)
II

Fig 1.2.3.3

Step 3: Eliminating feedback loop II (as in fig 1.2.3.4)


G1(S) G2(S)
1 + G2(S)
C(s)
R(S)

=
1 +

G1(S) G2(S)
1 + G2(S)

G1(S) G2(S)
C(s)
R(S)

R(S)

=
(1 + G2(S)) + G1(S) G2(S)

C(S)
G1(S) G2(S)
(1 + G2(S)) + G1(S) G2(S)
Answer.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 16

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

4. Determine the transfer function C(s) / R(s) of the system shown in


fig.1.2.4.1 by block diagram reduction method.
(AU: Dec.2003)

H3
T1

R(s) S1
+

G1

C(s)

S3

G2

G3

S2

G4
T2

H1

H2
Fig.1.2.4.1.

Step:1.
Shifting the summing point S2 before the block G1 and shifting the
take off point T2 after the block G4

1 / G1

1 / G4

R(s) S1
+

+
G2

G1
-

C(s)

S3
G3

G4

S2
H1

H2
Fig.1.2.4.2.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 17

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step:2.
Exchange the summing points and take off points using associative law
and combining the series blocks we get

H3 / G1G4
III
R(s)
+

S2

+
G1 G2

+ S1

C(s)

S3
G3 G4

H1

II
H2

Fig.1.2.4.3.

Step:3
Eliminating inner feedback loops I, II
H3 / G1G4
III
R(s)
+
+

G1 G2______
1 + G1G2H1

C(s)

G3 G4______
1 + G3G4H2

S1
Fig.1.2.4.4.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 18

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step:4
Combine the blocks in series
H3 / G1G4
III
R(s)
+
+

C(s)

G1 G2 G3 G4____________
(1 + G1G2H1)( 1 + G3G4H2)
S1
Fig.1.2.4.5.

Step 5:
Eliminate the feedback loop III

G1 G2 G3 G4_________
(1 + G1G2H1)( 1 + G3G4H2)
C(s) =
R(s)
1 + G1 G2 G3 G4____________
(1 + G1G2H1)( 1 + G3G4H2)

C(s) =
R(s)

__H3___
G1G4

______G1G2G3G4_________________
(1 + G1G2H1)( 1 + G3G4H2) +G2G3H3
Answer.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 19

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

5. Using block diagram reduction technique, find the transfer function from
each input to the output C(s) for the system shown in fig.1.2.5.1.
(AU: 2005)
X(s)

R(s)

G4

+
G1

G2
-

G3

G5
+

C(s)

H5

Fig.1.2.5.1.

With X(s) = 0, the given block diagram reduces as

R(s)

+
G1

G2
-

G3

G5
+

C(s)

II

I
III

H5

Fig.1.2.5.2.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 20

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 1: eliminate feedback loops I, II

R(s)

C(s)

+
__G2____
(1 + G2)

G1

G5______
(1 + G5H5)

G3

III

Fig.1.2.5.3.

Step 2: Combine the blocks in series

R(s)

C(s)
__G2 G3 G5_____
(1 + G2) (1 + G5H5)

G1
-

III

Fig.1.2.5.4.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 21

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 3: Eliminate feedback loop III

R(s)
G1

__G2 G3 G5_________________
{ (1 + G2) (1 + G5H5)}+ {G2G3G5)

C(s)

Fig.1.2.5.5.

Step 4: Combine the blocks in series.

R(s)
_ G1G2 G3 G5_________________
{ (1 + G2) (1 + G5H5)}+ {G2G3G5)

C(s)

Fig.1.2.5.6.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 22

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

With R(s) = 0, G1 vanishes, but minus sign at summing point must be


considered by introducing block of -1 as shown
G4

X(s)

C(s)

-1

G2

G3

G5
+

II

I
H5

Fig.1.2.5.6.

Step 5: eliminate feedback loops I, II


G4

X(s)
-1

C(s)

+
G2____
( 1+ G2 )

G3
+

G5_______
( 1+ G5H5)

Fig.1.2.5.7.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 23

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 6: Combine the blocks in series

X(s)

C(s)

G5_______
( 1+ G5H5)

G4
+

III
- G2G3____
( 1+ G2 )

Fig.1.2.5.8.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 24

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 7: Combine the blocks in series

X(s)

C(s)

G5_______
( 1+ G5H5)

G4
+

III
- G2G3____
( 1+ G2 )

Fig.1.2.5.8.

Step 8: eliminate feedback loop III and combine the blocks in series

X(s)
G4G5(1 +G2)_____________
(1+ G5H5 )(1 +G2)+ G2G3H5

C(s)

Answer.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 25

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

6. Reduce the block diagram shown in fig.1.2.6.1. and obtain C(s) / R(s)
(AU: may 2007)

G5
R(s)

S1

S2

S3

C(s)
+

G1
+

G2

G3

G4

H1

H2
Fig. 1.2.6.1.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 26

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step :1
Shifting the take off point between the blocks G2 and G3 to after the
block G3
1/G3
R(s)

S1

G5

S2

S3

C(s)
+

G1

G2

G3

G4

H1

H2
Fig. 1.2.6.2

Step :2
Combine the blocks G2 and G3, 1/G3 and G5 which are in series

G5/G3
R(s)

S1

S2

S3

C(s)
+

G2 G3

G1
-

G4

I
H1
H2
Fig. 1.2.6.3

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 27

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step :3
Eliminate feed back loop I, and then combine blocks G4 and G5 / G3
which are in parallel

R(s)

C(s)

S1

G1

G4 + (G5/G3)

G2 G3_____
1 + G2G3H1

H2
Fig. 1.2.6.4

Step :4
Combine the blocks which are in series
R(s)

S1

C(s)
-

(G1G2 G3)( G3G4 + G5)__


G3(1 + G2G3H1)
II
H2
Fig. 1.2.6.5

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 28

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step :5
Eliminate the feed back loop II

C(s)
R(s)

(G1G2 G3)( G3G4 + G5)__


G3(1 + G2G3H1)
=

1+

C(s) =
R(s)

G1G2G3(G3G4 + G5 )
G3(1 + G2G3H1)

H2

G1G2G3 (G3G4 + G5 )___________


G3(1 +G2G3H1) + [G1G2G3 (G3G4 + G5)] H2
Answer.

7. Determine the overall transfer function of the block diagram shown in


fig. 1.2.7.1.
(AU: Nov. 2005)
G3

R(s)

S1

S2

G1
-

C(s)

G2
I

S3

H1

Fig.1.2.7.1.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 29

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step :1 eliminate feed back loop I

G3

R(s)

S1

C(s)

G1____
1 +G1H1

G2

S3

Fig.1.2.7.2.

Step :2 Shifting the summing point S3 before the block (G1 / 1+G1H1) and
Combine the blocks G2 & (G1 / 1 +G1H1) which are in series.
G3

R(s)

1 + G1H1
G1
+

C(s)

+
+
S3

G2G1___
1 +G1H1
S1

II

Fig.1.2.7.3.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 30

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step :3 Eliminate feedback loop II and combine the blocks in parallel

R(s)

{G3(1 + G1H1)}
1+
G1

C(s)
G1G2________
(1 +G1H1) +G1G2

Fig.1.2.7.4.

Step 4: Combine the blocks in series

C(s) = { G1 +G3(1 + G1H1)}


R(s)
G1

___G1G2________
1+G1H1 +G1G2

C(s) = { G1 +G3(1 + G1H1)}G2


R(s)
1+G1H1 +G1G2
Answer.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 31

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

8. Use block diagram reduction technique obtain the equivalent transfer


function C(s) /R(s)

G2
R(s)

+
+

C(s)

G5

G4

G3

G1

I
II

H2

H1

Fig.1.2.8.1

Step 1:
Eliminate the feed back loops I ,II and combine the blocks G2 and G3
which are in parallel
R(s)

C(s)

G5

G4____
1 +G4H2

(G2+G3)

G1____
1 +G1H1

III

Fig.1.2.8.2

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 32

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 2:
Combine the blocks in series
R(s)

C(s)

G1(G2+G3) G4 G5___
( 1 +G4H2) (1 +G1H1)
III

Fig.1.2.8.3

Step 2:
Eliminate the feed back loop III

C(s) =
R(s)

G1(G2+G3) G4 G5___
( 1 +G4H2) (1 +G1H1)
1+
__G1(G2+G3) G4 G5___
( 1 +G4H2) (1 +G1H1)

C(s) = ______ G1(G2+G3) G4 G5_________________


R(s)
( 1 +G4H2) (1 +G1H1) + G1(G2+G3) G4 G5
Answer.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 33

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Signal flow graph:


The graphical representation of the variables of a set of linear algebraic equations
representing the system is called signal flow graph.
The properties of signal flow graph
The signal in the system flows along the branches and along the arrows associated
with the branches.
The value of variable represented by any node is an algebraic sum of all the
signals entering at the node.
The signals gets multiplied by the branch gain or branch transmittance when it
travels along it.
Applicable only to linear time invariant systems.
Need for signal flow graph:
Block diagrams are very successful for representing control systems, but for
complicated systems, the block diagram reduction process is tedious and time consuming.
So signal flow graphs are needed which does not require any reduction process because
of availability of a flow graph formula, which relates the input and output system
variables.
The transmittance is the gain acquired by the signal when travels from one node
to another node in the signal flow graph.
Node represents a system variable, which is equal to the sum of all incoming
signals at the node, outgoing signals from the node do not affect the value of the node
variable.
A signal travels along a branch from one node to another in the direction
indicated by the branch arrow and in the process gets multiplied by the gain or
transmittance of the branch.
A node having incoming and outgoing branches is known as chain node.
A feedback loop consisting of only one node is called self loop.
The product of all the gains of the branches forming a loop is called loop gain.
A path from the input to output node is defined as forward path.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 34

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

1..Using Masons gain formula obtain C(s)/R(s) for the signal flow graph shown in
fig1.3.1

By Masons Gain formula


K
PK K
1

C(S)
=
R(S)

Here K = 2
Forward paths
P1 = G1G2
P2 = G1G3

Individual loops
L1 = - G1H1
L2 = - G1G2H2
L3 = - G1G3H2

There are no two non touching loops.


= 1 (L1 +L2+L3) = 1 (- G1H1 G1G2H2 - G1G3H2)
= 1 + G1H1+ G1G2H2 + G1G3H2

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 35

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

1 = 1
2 = 1

P1 1 + P22

C(S)

R(S)

(G1G2)(1) + (G1G3)
=
= 1 + G1H1+ G1G2H2 + G1G3H2
Ans.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 36

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

2. Using Masons gain formula, determine C(S) / R(S) for the figure 1.3.5
2.Using Masons gain formula obtain C(s)/R(s) for the signal flow graph
shown in fig1.3.2

K
PK K
1

By Masons Gain formula


C(S)
=
R(S)

Here K =1
Forward paths
P1 = G1G2G3
Individual loops
L1 = - G1H2
L2 = - G2G3H3
L3= - G1G2H1
There are no two non touching loops.
= 1 (L1 +L2+L3) = 1 (- G1H2 - G2G3H3 - G1G2H1)
1 = 1
C(S) = P11
R(S)

____ (G1G2G3)(1)______________
1 + G1H2 + G2G3H3 + G1G2H1
Ans.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 37

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

3. Using Masons gain formula, determine C(S) / R(S) for the figure 1.3.3

By Masons Gain formula

K
PK K
1

C(S)
=
R(S)

Here K =2

Forward paths
P1 = G1G2G3
P2 = G4

Individual loops
L1 = - G2H1
L2 = G1G2H1

There are no two non touching loops


= 1 (L1 +L2+L3) = 1 (- G1H2 + G1G2H1)
= 1 + G1H2 - G1G2H1
1 = 1
2 = 1

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 38

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

C(S)

R(S)

(G1G2G3)(1) + (G4)(1)

P1 1 + P22
=

IV Semester ECE

1 + G1H2 - G1G2H1
Ans.

4. Using Masons gain formula, determine C(S) / R(S) for the


figure 1.3.4

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 39

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

By Masons Gain formula

K
PK K
1

C(S)
=

R(S)
Here K =2
Forward paths
P1 = G1G2G3G4
P2 = G5G6G7G8

Individual loops
L1 = G2H2
L2 = G3H3
L3 = G6H6
L4 = G7H7

Two pairs of two non touching loops are


there. They are
L1 L3 = G2H2 G6H6
L2 L4 = G3H3 G7H7
= 1 (L1 +L2+L3 + L4 ) +( L1 L3 + L2 L4)
= 1 (G2H2 + G3H3 + G6H6 + G7H7) + (G2H2 G6H6+ G3H3 G7H7)
1 = 1 (G6H6 + G7H7) = 1 - G6H6 -G7H7
2 = 1 (G2H2+ G3H3) = 1 G2H2- G3H3
P1 1 + P22

C(S)
=

R(S)

(G1G2G3G4)( 1 G6H6 -G7H7) + (G5G6G7G8)( 1 G2H2- G3H3)


=
1 (G2H2 + G3H3 + G6H6 + G7H7) + (G2H2 G6H6+ G3H3 G7H7)
Ans.
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 40

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

5. Using Masons gain formula, determine C(S) / R(S) for the figure 1.3.5

Fig.1.3.5
By Masons Gain formula
K
PK K
1

C(S)
=
R(S)

Here K = 2
Forward paths
P1 = G1G2G4G5
P2 = G1G2G3

Individual loops
L1 = - G4 G5H2
L2 = - G2G4G5H1
L3 = - G1 G2G4 G5
L4 = - G1 G2G3
L5 = - G2G3H1
L6 = - G3H2
There are no two non touching loops
= 1 - ( L1 + L2 + L3 + L4 + L5+ L6 )
= 1 (- G4 G5H2 - G2G4G5H1 - G1 G2G4 G5 - G1 G2G3 - G2G3H1 - G3H2)
= 1 + G4 G5H2 + G2G4G5H1 + G1 G2G4 G5 + G1 G2G3 + G2G3H1 + G3H2)
1 = 1
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE
2 = 1

Page 41

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

P1 1 + P22

C(S)
=

R(S)

(G1G2G4G5)(1) + (G1G2G3)(1)
=
1 + (G4 G5H2 + G2G4G5H1 + G1 G2G4 G5 + G1 G2G3 + G2G3H1
+ G3H2)
G3H2)
Ans.

6.Find the transfer function for the signal flow graph as shown in fig 1.3.6

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 42

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

By Masons Gain formula

K
PK K
1

C(S)
=
R(S)
Here K =3
Forward paths
P1 = G1G2G3G4 G5G6
P2 = G1G2G7G6
P3 = G1G2G3G4 G8

Individual loops
L1 = - G4H4
L2 = - G5 G6H1
L3 = -G2G3G4 G5G6 H2
L4 = - G1G2G3G4 G5G6 H3
L5 = - G8H1
L6 = - G1G2G7 G6H3
L7 = -G1G2G3 G4G8 H3
L8 = -G2G3 G4G8 H2
L9 = - G2G7 G6H2

There are two pairs of two non touching loops. They are
L1L6 = G1G2 G4G6G7H3H4
L1L9 = G4 G2G6G7H2H4
= 1 (L1 +L2+L3 + L4 + L5 + L6 + L7 +L8 + L9) + (L1L6 + L1L9)
= 1 ( - G4H4 - G5 G6H1 - G2G3G4 G5G6 H2 - G1G2G3G4 G5G6 H3 - G8H1
- G1G2G7 G6H3 - G1G2G3 G4G8 H3 - G2G3 G4G8 H2 - G2G7 G6H2)
+( G1G2 G4G6G7H3H4 + G4 G2G6G7H2H4)
1 = 1
2 = 1 ( - G4H4)
3= 1

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 43

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

P1 1 +P12 + P33

C(S)
=
R(S)

= (G1G2G3G4 G5G6)(1) + (G1G2G7G6)( 1 + G4H4)+ (G1G2G3G4 G8)(1)


1 + G4H4 + G5 G6H1 +G2G3G4 G5G6 H2 + G1G2G3G4 G5G6 H3
+G8H1 + G1G2G7 G6H3 +G1G2G3 G4G8 H3 + G2G3 G4G8 H2
+G2G7 G6H2 + G1G2 G4G6G7H3H4 + G4 G2G6G7H2H4
Ans.

7.Determine the transfer function C(S)/R(S) for the signal flow graph
shown in fig.1.3.7.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 44

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

By Masons Gain formula

K
PK K
1

C(S)
=
R(S)
Here K =2

Forward paths

Individual loops

P1 = G1G2G3

L1 = - G1 G2H1

P2 = G1G4

L2 = - G2 G3H2
L3 = -G1G2G3
L4 = - G4 H2
L5 = - G1G4

There are no two non touching loops.

= 1 (L1 +L2+L3 + L4 + L5 )
= 1 ( - G1 G2H1 - G2 G3H2- G1G2G3 - G4 H2- G1G4)
= 1 + G1 G2H1 + G2 G3H2+ G1G2G3 + G4 H2+G1G4
1 = 1
2 = 1

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 45

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

P1 1 +P12

C(S)
=
R(S)

(G1G2G3)(1) + (G1G4)( 1 )
1 + G1 G2H1 + G2 G3H2+ G1G2G3 + G4 H2+G1G4

Ans.

8.Find C(S)/R(S) for the following system using masons gain formula
for the signal flow graph shown in fig.1.3.8.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 46

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

By Masons Gain formula

K
PK K
1

C(S)
=
R(S)
Here K =5

Forward paths

Individual loops

P1 = G1G2

L1 = G9

P2 = G4

L2 = G3

P3= G7G8

L3 = G5G6

P4 = G1G5 G8
P5 = G7G6 G2
There is one pair of two non touching loops. It is
L1L2 = G9 G3
= 1 (L1 +L2+L3 ) + (L1L2)
= 1 ( G9 + G3 + G5G6) + (G9 G3)
= 1 - G9 - G3 - G5G6 + (G9 G3)
1 = 1 L1 = 1 G9
2 = 1 (L1 +L2+L3 ) + (L1L2) = 1 - G9 - G3 - G5G6) + (G9 G3)
3 = 1 L2 = 1 G3
4 = 1
5 = 1

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 47

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

P1 1 +P12 +P3 3 +P44 +P5 5

C(S)
=
R(S)

(G1G2)( 1 G9) + (G4)(( 1 - G9 - G3 - G5G6) + (G9 G3) ) + (G7G8)


(1 G3) + (G1G5 G8)(1) + (G7G6 G2)(1)
=
1 - G9 - G3 - G5G6 + (G9 G3)
Ans.

9. Determine the transfer function C(s)/ R(s) for the signal flow
graph shown in fig. 1.3.9.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 48

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

By Masons Gain formula

K
PK K
1

C(S)
=
R(S)

Here K =2
Forward paths

Individual loops

P1 = G1G2 G3

L1 = - G1G2H1

P2 = G4

L2 = - G2G3H2
L3 = - G1G2 G3
L4 = - G4
L5 = G2G4 H1 H2

There are no two non touching loops.

= 1 (L1 +L2+L3 L4 +L5)


= 1 (- G1G2H1 - G2G3H2- G1G2 G3 - G4 + G2G4 H1 H2)
= 1 + G1G2H1 + G2G3H2 + G1G2 G3 + G4 - G2G4 H1 H2

1 = 1
2 = 1

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 49

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

P1 1 +P12

C(S)
=
R(S)

(G1G2 G3)(1) + (G4) (1)

1 + G1G2H1 + G2G3H2 + G1G2 G3 + G4 - G2G4 H1 H2


Ans.

10.Determine the transfer function C(S) /R(S) using Masons gain formula
for the signal flow graph shown in fig.1.3.10

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 50

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

By Masons Gain formula

K
PK K
1

C(S)
=
R(S)

Here K =2
Forward paths

Individual loops

P1 = G1G2 G3 G4

L1 = - G1G2 G3 G4H1
L2 = - G3G4H2

P2 = G1 H3 G4
L3 = - G1G4 H3 H1
L4 = - G3G4

There are no two non touching loops.

= 1 (L1 +L2+L3 L4)


= 1 (- G1G2 G3 G4H1 - G3G4H2 - G1G4 H3 H1 - G3G4 )
= 1 + G1G2 G3 G4H1 + G3G4H2 + G1G4 H3 H1 + G3G4
1 = 1
2 = 1

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 51

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

P1 1 +P12

C(S)
=
R(S)

(G1G2 G3 G4)(1) + (G1 H3 G4)( 1 )


1 + G1G2 G3 G4H1 + G3G4H2 + G1G4 H3 H1 + G3G4

Ans.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 52

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

13.For the signal flow graph given in fig.1.3.13. Valuate the closed loop
transfer function of the system.
(A.U.April.2006)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 53

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

By Masons Gain formula

K
PK K
1

C(S)
=
R(S)
Here K =2

Forward paths
P1 = a12a23a34a45

Individual loops
L1 = a23a32
L2 = a23a34a45 a52

P2 = a12a23a35

L3= a23a34a45 a42


L4 = a44
L5= a23a35

There are no two non touching loops.

= 1 (L1 +L2+L3 L4 + L5 )
= 1 (a23a32 + a23a34a45 a52 + a23a34a45 a42 + a44 + a23a35)
= 1 a23a32 - a23a34a45 a52 - a23a34a45 a42 - a44 - a23a35

1 = 1
2 = 1 L4 = 1- a44

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 54

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

P1 1 +P12

C(S)
=
R(S)

(a12a23a34a45)(1) + (a12a23a35)( 1- a44 )


1 a23a32 - a23a34a45 a52 - a23a34a45 a42 - a44 - a23a35

Ans.

14. Using Masons gain formula find C(S) /R(S) for the fig. 1.3.14.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 55

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

By Masons Gain formula

K
PK K
1

C(S)
=
R(S)
Here K =2

Forward paths

Individual loops

P1 = G1G2 G3 G4 G5

L1 = H1
L2 = G3H2

P2 = G1 G2 G3 G4 G6
L3 = G4 H3
L4 = H4
The combination of two non touching loops:
L1 L2 = H1G3H2
L1 L3 = H1 G4 H3
L1 L4 = H1H4
L2 L4 = G3H2 H4

The combination of three non touching loops:


L1 L3 L4 = H1 G4 H3 H4
L1 L2 L4 = H1G3H2 H4

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 56

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

= 1 (L1 +L2+L3 L4) + (L1 L2 + L1 L3 + L1 L4 + L3 L4) (L1 L3 L4 + L1 L2 L4)


= 1 ( H1 + G3H2+ G4 H3 + H4 ) + (H1G3H2 + H1 G4 H3 + H1H4 + G3H2 H4)
(H1 G4 H3 H4 + H1G3H2 H4 )

1 = 1
2 = 1

P1 1 +P12

C(S)
=
R(S)

(G1G2 G3 G4 G5)(1) + (G1 G2 G3 G4 G6 )(1)

1 ( H + G H2+ G4 H3 + H4 )
)(1) + (a12a23a351)( 1- 3a44
)
+ (H1G3H2 + H1 G4 H3 + H1H4 + G3H2 H4)
(H1 G4 H3 H4 + H1G3H2 H4 )

Ans.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 57

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

1. Obtain the analogous electrical network for the system shown in fig.5. (AU:Nov./Dec.2007)

The Mass M1 is under the displacement x1(t).


The friction B1 is responsible to change the displacement from x1(t) to x2(t)
The Mass M2 is under the displacement x2(t).
The friction B2 and spring K1 are responsible to change the displacement from x2(t) to
x3(t)
The Mass M3 and spring K2 are under the influence of displacement x3(t).
The equivalent Mechanical system is shown in fig.5.a.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 58

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

The equilibrium equations are


F(t) = M1(d2x1(t)/ dt2) + B1d(x1(t)- x2(t))/dt ------------------------------------------------(1)
0 = B1d(x2(t)- x1(t))/dt + M2(d2x2(t)/ dt2) + K1(x2(t)- x3(t)) + B2d(x2(t)- x3(t))/dt --------(2)
0 = K1(x3(t)- x2(t)) + B2d(x3(t)- x2(t))/dt + M3(d2x3(t)/ dt2) + K3x3(t) ---------------------(3)

Using force- voltage analogy ,


Mass is replaced by inductance, friction or dashpot is replaced by resistance, spring is
replaced by reciprocal of capacitance, displacement is replaced by charge. Rate of change
of displacement is replaced by current, force is replaced by voltage.

V(t) = L1di1(t)/dt + R1 (i1(t) i2(t) ) ---------------------------------------------------------------(4)


0 = R1 (i2(t) i1(t) ) + L2di2(t)/dt + 1/C1(i2(t) i3(t))dt + R2 (i2(t) i3(t) )--------------------(5)
0 = 1/C1(i3(t) i2(t)) dt + R2 (i3(t) i2 +(t) ) + L3di3(t)/dt + 1/C2(i3(t)dt.---------------------(6)
The analogous electrical network is shown in fig.5.c.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 59

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

2. Draw the equivalent mechanical system of the system shown in fig.6. write the set of
equilibrium equations for it and obtain electrical analogous circuits using i) F-V analogy
ii)F-I analogy.
( AU: May2009)

As shown in fig.6. M1,K1,and B1 are under the displacement x1 as K1 and B1 are with
respect to rigid support. K2 is between x1 and x2 as it is responsible for the change in
displacement. While M2 , K3 and B2 are under the displacement x2. Hence the equivalent
mechanical system is as shown in fig.6.a.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 60

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

The equilibrium equations are


F(t) = M1(d2x1(t)/ dt2) + B1dx1(t)/dt + K1x1(t) + K2(x1(t)- x2(t)) -----------------------------(1)
0 = M2(d2x2(t)/ dt2) + B2dx2(t)/ dt + K2(x2(t)- x1(t)) + K3x2(t) -----------------------------(2)

Using force- voltage analogy ,


Mass is replaced by inductance, friction or dashpot is replaced by resistance, spring is
replaced by reciprocal of capacitance, displacement is replaced by charge. Rate of change
of displacement is replaced by current, force is replaced by voltage.

V(t) = L1di1(t)/dt + R1 i1(t) + 1/C1(i1(t) dt + 1/C2(i1(t) i2(t)) dt -----------------------------(3)


0 = L2di2(t)/dt + R1 i2(t) +1/C2(i2(t) i1(t))dt + 1/C3(i2(t) dt---------------------(
4)
The analogous system for force voltage analogy is shown in fig.6.c.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 61

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Using force- current analogy ,


Mass is replaced by capacitance, friction or dashpot is replaced by reciprocal of
resistance, spring is replaced by reciprocal of inductance, displacement is replaced by
flux. Rate of change of displacement is replaced by voltage, force is replaced by current.

The analogous system for force current analogy is shown in fig.6.d.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 62

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

I(t) = C1dV1(t)/dt + 1/R1 V1(t) + 1/L1(V1(t) dt + 1/L2(V1(t) V2(t)) dt --------------------------(5)


0 = C2dV2(t)/dt + 1/R2 V2(t)+1/L2(V2(t) V1(t))dt + 1/L3(V2(t) dt------------------------------(6)

3.Write the equations for mechanical system shown in figure 7.a.


( AU: April 2005, Dec 2005)

Due to force f(t) applied to M1, it will displace by the displacement x1(t).
As K1 and B1 are between M1 and fixed support, both are under same
displacement x1(t)
Due to friction B3, the force transferred to M2 is different than f(t), hence M2 will
displace by the displacement x2(t).
As K2 and B2are between M2 and fixed support, both are under same displacement
x2(t)
The equivalent system is shown in fig.7.b.

The node equations for the system are


At node x1
f(t) = M1(d2x1(t)/ dt2) + B1dx1(t)/dt + K1x1(t) + B3d(x1(t)- x2(t))/dt ----------------------(1)
At node x2

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 63

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

0 = M2(d2x2(t)/ dt2) + B2dx2(t)/dt + K2x2(t) + B3d(x2(t)- x1(t))/dt ----------------------(2)


Taking laplace transforms of equations(1) and (2) we get
F(s) =M1s2X1(s) + B1sX1(s) + K2X1(s) + B3s(X1(s) X2(s)) -----------------------(3)
0 =M2s2X1(s) + B2sX2(s) + K2X2(s) + B3s(X2(s) X1(s)) -----------------------(4)
4.Obtain the mathematical model of the following mechanical system shown
in figure 8.a
( AU:April 2004)
The displacement is x(t) as shown if fig.8.a.

Both B1 and B2 are between mass M and fixed support. Hence under the
influence of x(t). the spring k between mass M and fixed support. Hence under the
influence of x(t).
The equivalent mechanical model is shown in fig.8.b.

f(t) = M(d2x(t)/ dt2) + (B1 + B2)dx1(t)/dt + Kx (t) -------------------(1)


This equation represents the mathematical model.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 64

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

5. Obtain the differential equations of the following mechanical systems as


shown in fig.9.a.

The equivalent nodal diagram for the given mechanical system is shown in
fig.9.b.

At node x1
0 = M2(d2x1(t)/ dt2) + K1x1(t) + K1x1(t) + K2(x1(t)- x2(t)) -----------------------------(1)
F(t) = M1(d2x2(t)/ dt2) + K2(x2(t)- x1(t)) ----------------------------(2)
Taking Laplace transforms of equations(1) and (2) we get
0 =M2s2X1(s) + K1X1(s) + K2(X1(s) X2(s)) -----------------------(3)
F(s) =M2s2X1(s) + K2 (X2(s) X1(s)) -----------------------(4)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 65

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

6. For the spring, damper and mass system shown in fig.10.a. Obtain the
differential equations governing the system. F(t) is the force applied
(Au:2005).

The equivalent nodal diagram for the given mechanical system is shown in
fig.10.b.

The differential equations governing the system are


f(t) = M2(d2x2(t)/ dt2) + B2d(x1(t)- x2(t))/dt + K1(x2(t)- x1(t)) + B1d(x2(t)- x1(t))/dt ---(1)

0 = M1(d2x1(t)/ dt2) + B1d(x1(t)- x2(t))/dt +K1(x1(t)- x2(t))

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 66

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

7. Show that the systems shown in fig.11.a and fig.b are analogous system. (AU:
April-2007)

There are three displacements xi(t) xo(t) and xy(t). The input is xi(t) and output is
xo(t). So transfer function of the mechanical system is X0(s) / Xi(s). The
equilibrium equations are
B1d(xo(t)- xi(t))/dt + K1(xo(t)- xi(t)) + B1d(xo(t)- xy(t))/dt = 0 ---------(1)
B2d(xy(t)- xo(t))/dt + K2xy(t) = 0 ------------------------------------ (2)
Taking Laplace transform of both equations, neglecting initial conditions,
B1sXo(s) - B1sXi(s) + K1Xo(s) - K1Xi(s) + B2sXo(s) B2sXy(s) = 0
Therefore Xo(s)[sB1 + k1 +s B2] + Xi(s)[sB1 + k1] B2sXy(s) = 0 --------------------- (3)
B2sXy(s) - B2sXo(s) + K2Xy(s) = 0
Therefore Xy(s)[sB2 + k2 ] = B2s Xo(s)
Therefore Xy(s) = {B2s / [sB2 + k2 ]} Xo(s)} ------------------------------------------(4)
Substitute equation 4 in equation 3,
Xo(s)[sB1 + k1 +s B2] - Xi(s)[sB1 + k1] - B2s{B2s / [sB2 + k2 ]} Xo(s)}
Therefore Xo(s)[ sB1 + k1 +s B2 s2B22 / (sB2 + k2) = Xi(s)[sB1 + k1]
Xo(s) / Xi (s) = [sB1 + k1][ sB2 + k2] / {s2B1B2 + sB1K2 + sK1B2 + K1K2 + s2B22 +
sK2B2 s2B22}
Xo(s) / Xi (s) =
___________ k2K1 ( 1 + B1/K1) ( 1 + B2/K2) ___________
k2K1 [( 1 + s2B1B2/K1K2 +s B1/K1 + s B2/K2) + s B2/K1
Xo(s) =
__________ ( 1 + B1/K1) ( 1 + B2/K2) ____ ------------Required transfer function.
Xi (s)
( 1 + B1/K1) ( 1 + B2/K2) + s B2/K1
The s domain network for the given electric network is

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 67

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

Now I (s) = ____ Ei(s) ________


Z(s) + R1 + 1/sC1
And Eo(s) = I(s)[ R1 + 1 /sC1]
Therefore Eo(s) =
Eo(s) =

IV Semester ECE

with Z(s) = R2 parallel 1 /sC2

Ei(s) [ R1 + 1 /sC1]
Z(s) + R1 + 1/sC1
Ei(s)( 1 + sR1C1)
sC1Z(s) + sC1R1 +1

substituting Z(s) = R2 x 1/sC2


R2 + 1/sC2
Eo(s) = __________ ( 1 + sR1C1) ( 1 + sR2C2) ____
Ei(s)
( 1 + sR1C1) ( 1 + sR2C2) + sC1 R2
As spring is replaced by reciprocal of capacitance, friction is replaced by
Resistance, the two transfer functions are identical , hence the two systems are
analogous in nature.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 68

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

22. Find the impulse response of the second order system whose open loop transfer
function
G(S)=

____9_____
S2+4S+9

(AU may 2009)

Comparing the denominator term with S2+2ZnS+n2


n2 =9

2Zn = 4.

n=3

Z= __4_ _ =
2n

___4__ = 0.667
23

The impulse response for Z<1 is given by


C(t)= _n___ e-Z n t sin(n1-Z2 )t
1-Z2
= __3_____ e-2t sin(31-(0.667)2)t
1-(0.667)2
=4.035 e-2tsin2.235t

Obtain the unit step response of a second order system [under damped condition]
[AU: nov/dec
06]

Response of the second order system


__C(S) =
R(S)

___n2_______
S2+2ZnS+n2

For unit step input R(S)=1


For under damped systems Z<1
S2+2ZnS+n2 =0 has two roots
S1,2 = - Zn jn1-Z2
Now let
And

Zn=
n1-Z2 = d

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 69

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

S1,2= +j d
For unit step input R(S)=1/s
C(S)= R(S) [
___n2_______ ] = [ ___n2_______ ]
2
S +2ZnS+n2
S(S2+2ZnS+n2)
C(S)=A + __BS+C____
S
S2+2ZnS+n2
___n2_______ =A(S2+2ZnS+n2)+(BS+C)S
S2+2ZnS+n2
S2+2ZnS+n2
n2= AS2+2AZnS+An2+BS2+CS
n2=S2(A+B)+S( 2AZn+C)+A n2
equvating constant term
n2= A n2
A=1
Equvating S term
0= 2AZn +C
C=2AZn
C=2Zn
2
Equvating S term
0=A+B
0=1+B
B=-1
Zn=
C(S)= 1 + ___-S-2___
S
S2+2S+n2

C(S)= 1 - { ___S+2___}
S
S2+2S+n2

Now consider S2+2S+n2

Add and subtract 2 term to the above eq


S2+2S+ 2 + n2- 2
2

=(S+ )+ n -Z n

(Zn=

2= Z2 n2

=(S+ 2 )+ n2(1 -Z2)

WKT

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 70

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

d = n1-Z2
d2 = n(1-Z2)
= (S+ ) 2+ d2> put this expression in the denominator ofC(S) we get
C(S)= 1 - { ___S+2___}
2
2
S
(S+) +d

Now
L-1 { ___S+___} = e-atcost
(S+)2 +2
L-1 { ______ } = e-atsint
(S+)2 +2
Adjusting for C(s) we get
C(S)= 1 - { ___S+_ _ + ____ ____ }
S
(S+)2 +d2 (S+)2 +d2
Multiply and divide by d to the last term
C(S)= 1 - { ___S+_ _ + _ _ _ d ___ }
S
(S+)2 +d2 d (S+)2 +d2

Taking inverse laplace


C(t)=1- e-tcosd t- e-tsind t
d

Now put

Zn=
And

n1-Z2 = d
C(t)=1- e-tcosd t- e-tsind t
d
C(t)=1- e- Zn tcosd t+ e-Zn t sind t
n1-Z2
C(t)=1- e-Zn t

(1-Z2 d t+Zsin d t)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 71

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

n1-Z2
by trigonometry
sin ( d t +)= sin ( d t)cos +cos + cos ( d t) sin

compare this equation with the above expression,


sin = 1-Z2

we can write

cos =Z

1-Z2
cos
Z
= tan-11-Z2 radians.
Z
Hence using this in the expression
sin = tan=

C(t)=1- e-Zn t (sin (d t+)


n1-Z2

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 72

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Find kp , kv , ka and steady state error for a system with open loop transfer function as
G(S)H(S)= 15(S+4)(S+7)__
S(S+3)(S+6)(S+8)
Where the input is r(t)=4+t+t2
The given open loop transfer function in time constant form
G(S)H(S)= 15(S+4)(S+7)__
S(S+3)(S+6)(S+8)
=15 4 7(1+S) (1+s)
4
7
S 3 6 8(1+s_) (1+s_) (1+s_)
3
6
8
= 35(1+0.25s)(1+0.14s)______
12s(1+0.3s)(1+0.16s)(1+0.125s)

=2.9(1+0.25S)(1+0.14S)
s(1+0.3s)(1+0.16s)(1+0.125s)
Now

kp= Lt
S->0

G(S)H(S)=

KV= Lt
S G(S)H(S)= 2.9(1+0.25S)(1+0.14S)
S-> 0
s(1+0.3s)(1+0.16s)(1+0.125s)
KV=2.9
Ka= = Lt S2 G(S)H(S)=0
S->0
Input is =4+t+t2=4+t+2.t2
2
Now input combination of three standard inputs
A1=4 step of 4
A2=1 ramp of 1
A3=2, parabolic input of 2.
a) For step 3 the error is
Ess 1=A1___ = 4___ = 0
1+kp
1+
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 73

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

b) For ramp of 1 the error is


Ess 2=A2___ = 1___
KV
2.9
c) For parabolic of 2, the error is
Ess 3=A3___ = 2___ =
Ka
0
Then the steady state error is
Ess=e ss1+ess2+ess3
=0+1___ +
2.9
=

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 74

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Steady state analysis:


Steady state error is an important measure of the accuracy of a control systems.
Basically these errors occur from the nature of inputs, non-lineraities present in the
system
Etc. the steady state error ess is the difference between the input (or desired value )and
the
Output of a closed loop system input as t->
Mathematically
Ess =Lt e(t) =Lt [ r(t)-c(t)]
t->
t->
by using the final value theorem
ess = Lt e(t) =Lt SE(S)
t->
s->0
This is valid provided that SE(S) has no poles on the j axis,
No multiple poles on the j axix and is in the right half of S-plane.
Consider is a closed loop signal shown below
E(s)=error signal
B(S)=feed back signal
Closed loop transfer function = C(S) = G(S)___
R(S)
1+G(S)H(S)
C(S) =

G(S)___. R(S)
1+G(S)H(S)

E(S)=R(S)-B(S)----- >1
WKT
B(S)=R(S)-B(S)------ >2
Put eq 2 in eq1
E(S)=R(S)-C(S)H(S)------ >3
WKT
C(S)=E(S)G(S)------- >4
Put 4 in eq 3
E(S)=R(S)-E(S)G(S)H(S)
E(S)+E(S)G(S)H(S)=R(S)
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 75

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

[1+G(S)H(S)]E(S) =R(S)
E(S)=___R(S)___
1+G(S)H(S)

E(S)=___R(S)__
1+G(S)

for non unity feed back

For unity feed back

ESS= Lt SR(S)_____
s->0 1+G(S)H(S)
Steady state error deoends on
(i)

R(S) i.e reference i/p its type and magnitude.

(ii)

G(S)H(S) i.e open loop transfer function.

(iii)

Dominant non linearities if any.


Effect of input on steady state error:
(static error co efficient method)
(a) Reference i/p is step of magnitude A
R(S) = __A__
S
ESS= Lt SR(S)_____
s->0 1+G(S)H(S)

= Lt S.A/S_____
s->0 1+G(S)H(S)
= Lt A_____
s->0 1+G(S)H(S)
ESS=_____A___
1+ Lt G(S)H(S)
s->0
For a system selected Lt

G(S)H(S) is constant and called

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 76

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

s->0
positional error co_efficient of the system denoted as Kp.
Kp= Lt G(S)H(S) =positional error co-efficient
s->0
and corresponding error is
ess=__A__
1+kp
Reference i/p is ramp of magnitude A
R(S)=A/S2.
ESS= Lt SR(S)_____
s->0 1+G(S)H(S)
= Lt S.A/S2_____
s->0 1+G(S)H(S)
= Lt A_____
s->0 S[1+G(S)H(S)]
ESS =_____A___
Lt S G(S)H(S)
s->0
for a seleted system Lt S G(S)H(S) is constant an called velocity error co efficient as
Kv.
s->0
ESS=A/Kv
Kv= Lt S G(S)H(S) =velocity error effect.
s->0
reference input is parabolic of magnitude A
R(t)=__A__ t2
2
R(S)= _A__
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 77

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

S3

ESS= Lt SR(S)_____
s->0 1+G(S)H(S)
= Lt S.A/S3_____
s->0 1+G(S)H(S)
= Lt A_____
s->0 S2[1+G(S)H(S)]
ESS =_____A___
Lt S2 G(S)H(S)
s->0
for a seleted system Lt S2 G(S)H(S) is constant an called velocity error co efficient as
Ka.
s->0

ESS=A/Ka
Ka= Lt S2 G(S)H(S) =acceleration error effect.
s->0

types of feed back control systems:


The open loop transfer function G(S) of a unity feed back system can be
written in two standard forms namely the time constant form and polr zero form.
G(S)=K(TZ1S+1) (TZ2S+1) (TZ3S+1).. (TZmS+1)
Sn(TP1S+1) (TP2S+1) (TP3S+1).. (TPmS+1) (TIME CONSTANT FORM)
= _K(S+Z1) (S+Z2) (S+Z3).. (S+Zm)
Sn (S+P1) (S+P2) (S+P3).. (S+Pm)

(POLE ZERO FORM)

Where the relation between K and K is


Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 78

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

K=K(product of all zeros)


Product of all poles.
In both respresentatiom, the terms Sn in the denominator represent the n
poles at the origin, which represent the type number of the system. If n=0,
the system is known as type 0 system and if n=1 the system is known as
type 1 system and so on.

The type number of a system is defined as the number of poles of G(S) at


the origin or number of integrators present in the systems.
For example

G(S)=(S+5)____ is a type 0 system


(S+4)(S+8)
G(S)=(S+9)___ is a type 1 system
S(s+3)(s+7)
G(s)=(s+10)____ is a type 2 system
S2(S+2)(S+9)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 79

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Steady state errors of type 0 unity feedback system.


Let G(S) be an open loop transfer function of a system with no poles at the
origin (n=0).the steady state errors for standard inputs are as follows.
Positional error essp(t)= Lt
s->0

s.1/s__
1+G(S)

= ____1____
1+
Lt G(S)
s->0
____1__ = __1___
1+kp
1+k
Velocity error essv(t) = Lt
s->0

s.1/s2__
1+G(S)

= ____1____
1+
Lt s G(S)
s->0

= 1/0=

acceleratiom error essa(t) = Lt


s.1/s3__
s->0 1+G(S)
= ____1____
= 1/0=
1+
Lt s2 G(S)
s->0
steady state error of type1 unity feed back system:
Let G(S) be an open loop transfer function of a system with one poles at the
origin (n=1).the steady state errors for standard inputs are as follows.

Positional error essp(t)= Lt


s->0

s.1/s__
1+G(S)

= ____1____
1+
Lt G(S)
s->0
____1__ = 0
1+
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 80

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

Velocity error essv(t) = Lt


s->0

IV Semester ECE

s.1/s2__
1+G(S)

= ____1____
Lt s+ s G(S)
s->0

= ____1____
Lt s G(S)
s->0

= 1/k

acceleratiom error essa(t) = Lt


s.1/s3__
s->0 1+G(S)
= ____1____
= 1/0=
2
2
Lt s +s G(S)
s->0
for tupe 1 system

Lt
s->0

G(S)=k(Tz1S+1) (Tz2S+1).
S(Tp1S+1) (Tp2S+1).
G(S) ==kp

Lt s G(S) =k=kv
s->0
Lt s2 G(S) =0=ka
s->0

steady state errors of type 2 unity feedback system.


G(S) be an open loop transfer function of a system with two poles at the origin (n=2).the
steady state errors for standard inputs are as follows.
Positional error essp(t)= Lt
s->0

s.1/s2__
1+G(S)

= ____1____
1+
Lt G(S)
s->0
____1__ = 0
1+

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 81

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System


Velocity error essv(t) = Lt
s->0

IV Semester ECE

s.1/s2__
1+G(S)

= ____1____
Lt s G(S)
s->0

= 1/=0

acceleratiom error essa(t) = Lt


s.1/s3__
s->0 1+G(S)
= ____1____
= 1/k
2
2
Lt s +s G(S)
s->0
for tupe 2 system

Lt
s->0

G(S)=k(Tz1S+1) (Tz2S+1).
S2(Tp1S+1) (Tp2S+1).
G(S) ==kp

Lt s G(S) ==kv
s->0
Lt s2 G(S) =k=ka
s->0

generalized error coefficient method (or dynamic error co efficients)


E(S)=___R(S)__
1+G(S)H(S)
Let us assume that is the product of two polynomial of s
E(S)=F1(S)F2(S)
Where f1(s)=__1___ .
1+G(S)H(S)

F2(S) =R(S)

F(S)=F1(S).F2(S) then using convolution integral


t
-1
L { F(S)}= F(t)= F1() F2(t-)d
0
t
t
Similarly e(t)= F1() F2(t-)d =
F1() R(t-)d
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 82

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System


0

IV Semester ECE

R(t-) can be expanded by using taylor series form as


R(t-)=R(t)-R(t)+2 R(t)+2 R(t)+..

2!

3!

Substituting e(t)= t
F1() [R(t)-R(t)+2 R(t)+ 2 R(t)+..]d
0
2!
3!

t
=

t
F1() R(t) d - F1() R(t)d+.
0

Ess=lt
e(t)
t->
=

lt
t
t
t-> [ F1() R(t) d - F1() R(t)d+]
0

= R(t) F1() d - R(t) F1() d+ R(t) F1() 2 d]

2!

Where ko= = F1() d


0

K1= - F1() d

K2= - F1() 2 d

0
Substituting these values we have
Ess= k0R(t)+k1R(t)+k2 R(t)+.
2!

Where ko, k1,k2 are called dynamic error coeff


To calculate these values co efficient use the following method
According to the definition of laplace transform
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 83

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

F(s)= F1()e-sd
0

Now k0= F1()d


0
Multiplying by e-s to both sides

e-s k0= F1() e-s d = F1(s)


0
Taking limit as s->0 of both sides
k0 e-s = lt F1(s)

Lt

s->0

s->0

where F(S)= ___1__


1+G(S)H(S)
TAKING derivative of k0 e-s w.r.t s we get
-s

- k0 e

substituting

= dF1(S)
ds

k0 = F1() d
0

F1() e-s d= dF1(S)


0
ds
Taking limit as s->0 of both side

K1=

lt

s->0

dF1(S)
ds

in general
Kn=

lt

dn F1(S)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 84

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System


s->0

IV Semester ECE

ds

Introduction to PID controllers:


A controller is a device which when introduced in feed back or forward path of system,
controls the steady state and transient response as per the requirement. This controller
converts the applied input to some other form of error which is proportional to the error due to
which steady state and transient response gets improved. The output of the controller is
proportional to the amount of error generated by that device.
The performance of this controlling phenomena may be done by means of electrical,
mechanical, pneumatic or hydraulic medium.
Classification of controllers:
1.ON-OFF controller
2. proportional controller
3. integral controller
4. derivative controller
5. proportional plus integral controller
6. proportional plus derivative controller
7. proportional +integral+derivativecontroller
ON-OFF controller:
This type of controller is the simplest and cheapest typehere the actuating device
(controller)
Is the capable of assuming only one two positions, with either zero(or) maximum input to the
process.
Proportional controller:
It is defined as the action of a controller in which the output signal m(t) is proportional to
the measured actuating error signal e(t).
M(t) e(t)
M(t) =kpe(t)
Where kp is proportional sensitivity or the gain
Taking laplace transform we get
M(s)=kpE(S)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 85

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Kp= M(S) = change in controller output


E(S)
change in derivation
So the proportional controller is essentially an amplifier with an adjustable gain.
Integral controller:
It is denoted by the term I in the PID controller. In a controller with integral action,
the value of the output m(t) is propprtional to the measured actuating error signal e(t).
dm(t) = kie(t)
ds
t
m(t) = ki e(t) dt
0
Where ki is an adjustable constant the transfer function of the integral controller is
M(S) = ki
E(S)
s
The integral controller increases the type number of system by one. This integral control
overcomes the drawback of proportional control by reducing the steady state error to zero
without the use of excessive large control gain. The integral control action is also called as reset
control action.
Derivative controller:
Derivative controller do not affect state error but effect transient response. The output of
derivative controller depends on the rat e of change of error signal. The main drawback of
derivative controller is that it amplifies the noise signal. Therefore it is not possible for us to use
the derivative control action alone. We can use this derivative controller along with integral or
proportional controller
In time domain m(t)= kd dl(t)
Dt
In laplace domain m(S)=kds E(S)
The output of the derivative controller is zero when the error signal constant. That is the
derivative control has no input when it is acting on constant signal.

Proportional plus integral controller (PI controller)


In PI controller the controller output m(t) is proportional to a linear combination of
actuating signal e(t) plus integral of the error signal.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 86

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

M(t) =kpe(t) +ki e(t) dt.


Taking laplace transform
M(s) = kpE(S)+kI E(S)
S

=E(S)[kp+ki_]
S
Assuming kp=1 we can write
G(S)=(1+ki ) n2 =
___s_

S(s+2z n)

(ki+s) n2
s2(s+s2z n)

i.e the system becomes type 2 in nature


and C(S) =
R(S)

(ki+s) n2
s3+2z ns2+s n2+ki n2

i.e it becomes third order


that is it integral is included along with proportional controller means the system
relatively becomes less stable as ki must be designed in such a way that system will remain in
stable condition. Second order system will always stable.
The transient response of of system gets affected badly if PI controller is not designed
properly. By including I controller along with p controller, steady state the system gets
improved and we can get the accurate output from the system.
In general PI controller improves steady state part but it affects transient part of the
system.
Proportional plus derivative controller (PD controller)
A controller in a forward path which changes the controller output corresponding to
the proportional plus derivative of error signal is known as PD controller
M(T) =kpe(t) +kpTd de(t)
Dt
Taking laplace transform
M(S) = kpE(S) +kpTd s E(S) =E(S)[kp+TdS]
Assuming kp=1
G(S) = (1+sTd) n2
S(s+2z n)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 87

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

C(S) = (1+sTd) n2
R(S) s2+2[2zn+ n2Td] + n2
C0mparing the denominator with standard form s2+2z ns+ n2
n2 term is same as in the standard form
but 2z n =2z n+ n2Td
z= 2z n + n2Td
z n
z n
because of this derivative controller the damping ratio increases by a factor nTd
2

Kp= lt G(S)H(S) =
S->0
KV= LT S G(S)H(S) = n
s->0
2z
as there is no change in co efficient, the error will also remain same.
PD controller has following effects on the system.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

It reduces settling time


It reduces peak overshoot
Steady state error remains unchanged.
Type of the system remains unchanged
It increases damping ratio

PD controller improves transient part without affecting steady state.


Proportional+integral +derivative controller(PID controller)
A PID controller is the combination of proportional control action and derivative
control action with an adjustable gain for each action.
t
M(t)= kpe(t)+kpTdde(t) + kp e(t) dt
dt
TI 0
taking laplace transform
M(S)= kpE(S)+kpTdSE(S) + kp E(S)
TiS
M(S)= kpE(S)[1+Td + kp ]
Ti S

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 88

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Pd controller improves transient portion, pi controller improve steady state portion combination
of two may be used to improve overall time response of the system.

G(s) =(K+STd+KI ) n2
S____
S(S+2Z n)
C(S) =
R(s)

(K+STd+KI ) n2/ S(S+2Z n)


S_________
1+
(K+STd+KI ) n2
S____
S(S+2Z n)

Transient response and steady state response.


The time response of a system consists of two parts.
Transient response
Steady state response
This can be denoted by equation as
Total time response =transient response +steady state response
C(t)=ctr(t)+css(t)
Transient response of the system is the portion of total time response during which output
Changes from one value to another value. In other words, it is the response before the output
reaches
the steady state value.
Steady state response of the system for a given input after a very long time. In steady
state, the output response settles to its final steady state value or steady oscillations.
Derivation of steady state error:
Definition: steady state error : it is the difference between the actual output and the desired
output.
Consider a simple closed loop system using negative feedback us shown.
Where E(s)=error signal and B(s)=feed back signal.
Now E(S)=R(S)-B(S)
BUT B(S)=C(S)H(S)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 89

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

E(S)=R(S)-C(S)H(S)
C(S)=E(S)G(S)
E(S)=R(S)-E(S)G(S)H(S)
E(S)+E(S)G(S)H(S)=R(S).
E(S)=R(S)___
1+G(S)H(S) for non unity feed back .
E(S)=R(S)___
1+G(S) for unity feed back.
This E(S) is the error in laplace domain and is expression in s. we want to calculate the error
value. In the time domain corresponding error will be e(t). now steady state of the system is that
state. Which remains as t-> .
Steady state error ess=Lt e(t)
t->
standard test signals:
the impulse signal has zero amplitude every where expect at the origin as shown in fig.
mathematically the impulse signal can be represented by
A (t)=0 for t#0 and

A (t) dt= A
-
Where tends to zero. Here the value a represents the area of the signal or energy content of
the signal and the laplace transform of the impulse is given by.
L[ A (t)] =A

Unit impulse signal:


If A=1, then the signal is called unit impulse signal that is for a unit impulse signal.
(t)=0 for t#0 and

A (t)dt = 1
-
The laplace transform of the unit impulse signal is

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 90

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

L[ (t)] =1.

Step signal:
Step signal of size A is a signal that changes from zero level to another level A is a zero
time and stays there for ever as shown fig. the step signal is applied to the system to study the
behavior of the system for a sudden change in input.
Mathematically
r(t) = A for t> 0
= 0 for t< 0
The laplace transform of the the step signal is R(S)=L[r(t)]=A/s.

Unit step signal:


If the the magnitude a of the step signal is unity, then the step signal is shown and is
denoted bt u(t). that is
U(t) =1 for t > 0
=0 for < 0.
The laplace transform of the unit step msignal u(t) is
L[u(t)] =1/s.

Ramp signal:
The ramp signal increases linearly with time from an initial value of zero at t=0.
Mathematically representation of the ramp signal is given by
R(t) = At for t> 0
= 0 for t=0
Where A represents the slope of the line
The laplace transform of the ramp signal is known as unit ramp signal.
Parabolic signal:
The instantaneous value of a parabolic signal varies as square the time from an initial
value of zero at t=0.
Mathematically representation of the

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 91

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Parabolic signal is
r(t)=At2 t>0.
= 0 t<0.
The laplace transform of the parabolic signal is given by
R(s)= L[At2 ] =2A/s3
To have a convinent form for laplace transform of parabolic signal is A/s3 . the parabolic signal
in time domain is often defined as At2/2.
Steady state erroer and error constants
The stady state error ess is the difference between the input (or desired value ) and the
output of a closed loop system for a known input as t->.
Mathematically
Ess = Lt e(t)
t->
= Lt [r(t)-c(t)]
t->0
bu using final value theorem

Ess = Lt e(t) = Lt s E(S)


t->
s->0
this is valid provided that SE(S) has no poles on the j axis no multiple poles on the j axis and
is the rignt half of s plane. The steady state error is a measure of system accuracy. With the help
of step ramp and paroboic inputs it is passible for us to judge te steady state behavior of the
system.

Analysis of first order system:


Order: order of system is the highest power of s in the denominator of a closed loop
transfer funttion. Consider a simple system shown in fig. find v0(t)
i.e response if it is excited by unit step input.
Vi(t)=1 t>0
=0 t<0

Vi(s)=1/s.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 92

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Now first calculate system T.F using laplace T.f


Vi(t) = R i(t)+ 1 i(t) dt
C

V0(t) = 1 i(t) dt
C

Vi(s) = R I(s)+ 1 I(s)


Cs
V0(s) = 1 I(s)
Cs
I(S)=CSV0(S)
Vi(S)=I(S)[R + 1 ]
SC
Vi(S)=CSV0(S)[R + 1 ]
SC

V0(S) = ___1__
VI(S)
1+SRC
V0(S) = ___1__
VI(S)
1+TS where T=RC

The step response of first order system .


Let input applied vi(t) is the unit step voltage substituting vi(s)=1/s is the transfer function
V0(S) = ___1__
S( 1+SRC)

= A + __b__
s
1+SRC

1= A(1+SRC) +BS
1=A+ASRC+BS
1=A+S(B+ARC)
Equate constant term
1=A
Equate s term
0=S(B+ARC)
Put A=1
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 93

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

B+RC=0
B=-RC
V0(S) = 1 + __-RC__
S 1+SRC

= 1 + __-RC__
RC (S+1/RC)

= 1 + __-1_____
S
(S+1/RC)
Taking laplace inverse
V0(t) =1- e-t/RC
=css+ct(t)
Closed loop transfer function of a system is given by
C(S) = G(S)___
R(S)
1G(S)R(S)
The equation which gives poles of system is called characteristics equation which is
1+G(S)H(S)=0
For the first order system this equation is also first order is general of the form
1+TS=0
AS closed loop poles are the roots of characteristics equation so for first order system there is
only one closed loop pole i.e s=-1/T
The time taken for the step response of a system to reach 63.2% of the final value is known as
the time constant of the system.
Unit ramp response of a first order system:
The transfer function of a first order system is given by
C(S) = ___K__
R(S)
(TS+1)
For a ramp input r(t)=t; t>0; R(S)=1/S2. There fore
C(S) = ___K__
S2 (TS+1)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 94

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

C(S)= K [A +B + __C__]
S S2 TS+1
__K__ = K[AS(TS+S)+BTS+B+CS2 ]
S2(TS+1)
S2(TS+1)
__K__ = K[AS(TS+S)+BTS+B+CS2 ]

1=AS(TS+S)+BTS+B+CS2

Equate constant term


A=1

equate s term
A+BT=0
1+BT=0
BT=-1
B=-1/T

equate s2 term
AT+C=0
C=-AT
C=-T

C(S)= K [1 +-1/T + __-T__]


S S2
TS+1

Taking inverse laplace transform


C(s)=k [-T+t+e=t/T]; t>0
22) A unity feed back heat treatment system has open loop transfer function
G(s)= ____10000______ . the output of set point is 5000c. what is the steady state
temperature.
(1+S)(1+0.5S)(1+0.02S)
Here h(s)=1
R(S)=500/s
Steady state error =Lt S.R(S)
S->0 1+G(S)
=Lt S.500/S
S->0 1+ ____10000______ .
(1+S)(1+0.5S)(1+0.02S)
500/1+10000 =0.040
STEADY STATE ERROR ESS=0.040C
STEADY state temperature c(t)=r(t)-ess
=5000c- 0.040c
= 499.960c
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 95

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

1. Determine the stability of the following system using Rouths criterion.


(AU:May/ June 2008)
(a) G(s)H(s) =______1______
(s +2)(s +4)
(b) G(s)H(s) =______9______
s2(s +2)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 96

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

1.a.)G(s)H(s) =______1______
(s +2)(s +4)
The characteristic equation is
1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1 + ___1______ = 0
(s +2)(s +4)
( s + 2 ) ( s+4 ) + 1 =0
s2 + 6s + 9 = 0
a0 =1 a1 = 6 a2 =9
Rouths array
s2

s1

s0

No sign change in the first column of the Rouths array, hence the
system is stable.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 97

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

1.b.)G(s)H(s) =_____9______
s2(s +2)
The characteristic equation is
1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1 + ___9______ = 0
s2(s +2)
s2(s +2) + 9 =0
s3 + 2s2 +9 = 0
a0 =1 a1 = 2 a2 =0 a3 =9
Rouths array
s3
1

b1 = 2 x 0 1x 9 = - 4.5
s

b2 = 0

S0

- 4.5
9

c1 = - 4.5 x 9

=9

- 4.5

There are two sign changes in the first column of the Rouths array. Hence
the system is unstable.

2. Utilize the Routh table to determine the number of roots of the following
polynomials in the right half of the s-plane. Comment about the stability of the
system.
(AU:May/June 2006)
( i ) s5 + 2s4 + 3s3 + 6s2 + 10s + 15
( ii ) s5 + 6s4 + 15s3 + 30s2 + 44s + 24

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 98

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

2) i) s5 + 2s4 + 3s3 + 6s2 + 10s + 15 = 0


a0 =1 a1 = 2 a2 = 3 a3 = 6 a4 =10 a5 = 15

Rouths array:
s5

10

15

s4

s3

2.5

s3

s2

6-5

s1

2.5

Replace the 0
by small
positive
number

15

6 5 2.5
____ _________ - 15
6-5

s0

15

as tends to zero, the rouths array becomes

s5

s4

s3

2.5

15

s1

2.5

s0

15

10
15

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

There are two sign


changes in the first
column of the rouths
array. There fore there
are two roots on the
right half of the s- plane.

Page 99

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

2) ii ) s5 + 6s4 + 15s3 + 30s2 + 44s + 24 = 0


a0 =1 a1 = 6 a2 = 15 a3 = 30 a4 =44 a5 = 24

Rouths array:
s5

15

44

24

s4

30

s3

10

40

s2

s1

24
Replace the 0
by small
positive
number

s1

s0

24

as tends to zero, the rouths array becomes


s5

15

44

s4

30

24

s3

10

s1

s0

24

40
24

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

There is no sign change in


the first column of the
rouths array.
No roots of the
polynomial are in the
right half of the s- plane.
Hence the system is
stable.

Page 100

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

3. for a system with, F(s) = s4 + 22s3 + 10 s2 + s + K = 0. obtain the marginal value


of K, and the frequency of oscillations of that value of K (AU May/june 2007)

F(s) = s4 + 22s3 + 10 s2 + s + K = 0
a0 = 1 a1 = 22 a2 = 10 a3 = 1 a4 = K
Rouths array

s4

10

s3

22

s2

9.95

s1

9.95 22K
9.95
s0

For a stable system, the first column of the rouths array must be
positive.
Therefore K > 0 , And 9.95 22K > 0
0 < K < 0.452.
The marginal value of K is 0.452.
Consider 9.95s2 + K = 0. when K = 0.452, to find the frequency of
oscillations s= + j 0.913 or j = + j 0.913. = 0.213 rad/sec.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 101

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

4. Using Rouths criterion for stability, discuss the stability of the system whose
characteristic equation is s3 + 10s2 + 50s + 500 = 0
(AU: April/ may 2005)

s3 + 10s2 + 50s + 500 = 0


a0 = 1 a1 = 10 a2 = 50 a3 = 500
Rouths array
s3

50

s2

10

500

s1

by special case 2, replace zero row by the derivative of the


auxiliary equation ( the auxiliary equation is the row, just above the
zero row)
Auxilary equation is
A(s) = 10s2 + 500
dA(s) = 20s
ds
s3

50

s2

10

500

s1

20

s0

500

No sign change in the first column of the Rouths array. But due to
special case 2, system , may not be stable. For sufficient conditions
solve A(s) = 0.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 102

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

10s2+ 500 = 0
s2 = - 50
s = + j 50.
as dominant roots are on imaginary axis, and no root in right half of s-plane
because no sign change in first column of rouths array. the system is
marginally stable. It oscillates with the frequency 50 rad./ sec.

5. Using Routh Hurwitz criterion, determine the relation between K and T so that unity
feedback control system whose open loop transfer function given below is stable.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 103

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

1.Sketch the root locus diagram of the following open loop transfer function
G(s)H(s) =________K_____
s(s+2)(s+5)

(AU: Nov/DEC:2005)

Step 1:
Number of poles P = 3
At s
0,-2,-5
Number of Zeros Z= 0
Step 2:
Number of separate root loci (branches)= Number of poles (P) = 3

Step 3:
The starting point of the root locus branches are from poles 0,-2,-5.
Terminating point of the root locus branches are at ZEROs. But here we have
no ZEROs. So The root locus branches terminates at infinity.

+j

+
-

P2

P3

-5

P1

-2

-j

Consider P1. to the R.H.S. of P1 the sum of poles and zeros are
odd. So P1 is the part of root locus. Consider P2. to the R.H.S. of
P2 the sum of poles and zeros are even. So P2 is not the part of
root locus. Consider P3. to the R.H.S. of P3 the sum of poles and
zeros are odd. So P3 is the part of root locus.
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 104

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 4:
Number of asymptotes Na = P-Z = 3- 0 = 3
Angle of asymptotes : n = (2n+1) ( n = 0,1,2,.P-Z-1)
PZ
Here n = Na = P-Z = 3-0 = 3 n = 0,1,2.
For n =0 0 = (2(0)+1) = 60
30
For n =1 1 = (2(1)+1) = 180
30
For n =2 2 = (2(2)+1) = 300
30
Step 5:
Centroid ( )
= ( real parts of poles) - ( real parts of zeros)
PZ
= (0 -2-5) (0)
30
= -7 = -2.3
3
Step 6:
Breakaway point:
1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1+
K_________ = 0
s(s+2)(s+5)
s(s2 + 7s + 10) +K= 0
K = - s(s2 + 7s + 10)
K = - (s3 + 7s2 + 10s)
to find breakaway point, differentiate k with respect to s and equate to
zero.
dk = 0
ds
dk = - 3s2 - 14s 10 = 0
ds
i.e. 3s2+ 14s +10 = 0
now solve the above quadratic equation, we get s = - 0.88 , -3.78.
The valid breakaway point is 0.88. because breakaway point must be
a part of root locus.
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 105

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 7:
Intersection of root locus with imaginary axis (j)
Characteristic equation = 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
s3 + 7s2 + 10s + k = 0
a0 = 1 a1 = 7 a2 = 10 a3 = k
Rouths array

s3

10

s2

s1

7(10) K
7

s0

To have intersection on imaginary axis, any one row should be zero.


Let us make s1 row = 0
70 K
7
70- K

= 0
= 0
K = 70

Now , consider auxiliary equation


7s2 +K = 0
Put

K = 70 in above equation.

7s2 +70 = 0
s2 +10 = 0
s = + j 10 = + j 3.2
The complete root locus is shown in fig.4.1
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 106

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

fig. 4.1

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 107

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

2.Sketch the root locus diagram of the following open loop transfer function
G(s)H(s) =________K_____
s(s+1)(s+3)

(AU: Nov/DEC:2006)

Step 1:
Number of poles P = 3
At s

0,-1,-3

Number of Zeros Z= 0
Step 2:
Number of separate root loci (branches)= Number of poles (P) = 3

Step 3:
The starting point of the root locus branches are from poles 0,-1,-3
Terminating point of the root locus branches are at ZEROs. But here we have
no ZEROs. So The root locus branches terminates at infinity.

+j

+
-

P2

P3

-3

P1

-1

-j

Consider P1. to the R.H.S. of P1 the sum of poles and zeros are
odd. So P1 is the part of root locus. Consider P2. to the R.H.S. of
P2the sum of poles and zeros are even. So P2 is not the part of
root locus. Consider P3. to the R.H.S. of P3 the sum of poles and
zeros are odd. So P3 is the part of root locus.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 108

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 4:
Number of asymptotes Na = P-Z = 3- 0 = 3
Angle of asymptotes : n = (2n+1) ( n = 0,1,2,.P-Z-1)
PZ
Here n = Na = P-Z = 3-0 = 3 n = 0,1,2.
For n =0 0 = (2(0)+1) = 60
30
For n =1 1 = (2(1)+1) = 180
30
For n =2 2 = (2(2)+1) = 300
30
Step 5:
Centroid ( )
= ( real parts of poles) - ( real parts of zeros)
PZ
= (0 -1-3) (0)
30
= -4 = -1.33
3
Step 6:
Breakaway point:
1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1+
K__________ = 0
s(s+1)(s+3)
s(s+1)(s+3) +k = 0
K = - s(s2 + 4s + 3)
K = - (s3 + 4s2 + 3s)
to find breakaway point, differentiate k with respect to s and equate to
zero.
dk = 0
ds
dk = - 3s2 - 8s 3 = 0
ds
i.e. 3s2+ 8s +3 = 0
now solve the above quadratic equation, we get s = - 0.451 , -2.22
The valid breakaway point is - 0.451. because breakaway point must
be a part of root locus.
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 109

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 7:
Intersection of root locus with imaginary axis (j)
Characteristic equation = 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
s3 + 4s2 + 3s + k = 0
a0 = 1 a1 = 4 a2 = 3 a3 = k
Rouths array

s3

s2

s1

12 K
4

s0

K
0

To have intersection on imaginary axis, any one row should be zero.


Let us make s1 row = 0
12-K
4
12 - K

= 0
= 0

K = 12
Now , consider auxiliary equation
4s2 +K = 0
Put

K =12 in above equation.

4s2 +12 = 0
s2 +3 = 0
s = + j 3= + j 1.714
The complete root locus is shown in fig.4.2
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 110

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

fig. 4.2

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 111

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

3.Obtain the root locus for a unity feedback system with open loop transfer
function G(s)H(s) =________K_____
(AU: may/june:2006 )
2
s(s +6s+25)

Step 1:
Number of poles P = 3
At s

0,-3+j4, -3 j4

Number of Zeros Z= 0
Step 2:
Number of separate root loci (branches)= Number of poles (P) = 3
Step 3:
The starting point of the root locus are from poles 0, -3+j4, -3 j4. the
terminating point of the root locus is at ZERO. Here we have no
ZEROs. So the root locus terminates at infinity.

+j

-3+j4

P1

-
0

-j

-3-j4
Consider P1. to the R.H.S. of P1 the sum of poles and zeros are odd.
So P1 is the part of root locus.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 112

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 4:
Number of asymptotes Na = P-Z = 3- 0 = 3
Angle of asymptotes : n = (2n+1) ( n = 0,1,2,.P-Z-1)
PZ
Here n = Na = P-Z = 3-0 = 3 n = 0,1,2.
For n =0 0 = (2(0)+1) = 60
30
For n =1 1 = (2(1)+1) = 180
30
For n =2 2 = (2(2)+1) = 300
30
Step 5:
Centroid ( )
= ( real parts of poles) - ( real parts of zeros)
PZ
= (0 -3-3) (0) = -2
30
Step 6:
Breakaway point:
1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1+

K__________ = 0
s(s2+6s+25)

s(s2+6s+25)+K = 0
K = - s(s2+6s+25)
K = - (s3 + 6s2 + 25s)
to find breakaway point, differentiate k with respect to s and equate to
zero.
dk = 0
ds
dk = - 3s2 - 12s 25 = 0
ds
i.e. 3s2+ 12s +25 = 0
now solve the above quadratic equation, we get
s = - 2 + j0.539
this point is not on the root locus. Therefore there is no breakaway
point.
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 113

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 7:
Intersection of root locus with imaginary axis (j)
Characteristic equation = 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1+

k__________ = 0
s(s2+6s+25)

s3 + 6s2 + 25s + K = 0
a0 = 1 a1 = 6 a2 = 25 a3 = K.
Rouths array
s3

s2

s1

150 K
6

s0

25

To have intersection on imaginary axis, any one row should be zero.


Let us make s1 row = 0
150-K
6
150 - K

= 0
= 0

K = 150
Now , consider auxiliary equation
6s2 +K = 0
Put

K =150 in above equation.

6s2 +150= 0
s2 +25 = 0
s= + j5
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 114

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 8:
We have complex poles. So angle of departure has to be calculated.

Angle of Departure calculation diagram.

P2

+j4

p1
-3

p2
-j4
P3
Consider point P2.
p1 = -180 tan-(3/4)
= - 143.13
p3= -90
p = p1 + p3 = - 143.13 - 90 = -233.13
z = 0
= p - z = -233.13 - 0 = -233.13
Angle of departure = 180- -233.13 = - 53.13
Similarly for point P3. the angle of departure is - 53.13
The complete root locus is shown in fig.4.3.
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 115

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Fig.4.3

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 116

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

4.Determine the root locus of the system whose open loop gain is
G(s)H(s) =________K_______
(AU: Nov/Dec:2006 )
2
S(s+4)(s +4s+20)

Step 1:
Number of poles P = 4
At s

0, -2+j4, -2 j4 , -4

Number of Zeros Z= 0
Step 2:
Number of separate root loci (branches)= Number of poles (P) = 4
Step 3:
The starting point of the root locus are from poles 0, -2+j4, -2 j4 , -4 .
The terminating point of the root locus is at ZERO. Here we have no
ZEROs. So the root locus terminates at infinity.

-2+j4

P2

+j

P1

-4

-
0

-j

-2-j4
Consider P1. to the R.H.S. of P1 the sum of poles and zeros are odd.
So P1 is the part of root locus. Consider P2.To the R.H.S of the P2
the sum of poles and zeros are even. So p2 is not the part of root
locus.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 117

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 4:
Number of asymptotes Na = P-Z = 4- 0 = 4
Angle of asymptotes : n = (2n+1) ( n = 0,1,2,.P-Z-1)
PZ
Here n = Na = P-Z = 4-0 = 4 n = 0,1,2,3
For n =0 0 = (2(0)+1) = 45
4 0
For n =1 1 = (2(1)+1) = 135
40
For n =2 2 = (2(2)+1) = 225
40
For n =3 3 = (2(3)+1) = 315
40
Step 5:
Centroid ( )
= ( real parts of poles) - ( real parts of zeros)
PZ
= (0 -4-2 -2) (0)
40
= -8 = - 4
4
Step 6:
Breakaway point:
1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1+

k__________ = 0
s(s+4) (s2+4s+20)
s(s+4) (s2+4s+20) + K = 0

k = - (s 2 +4s)( (s2+4s+20)
k = - (s4 +8s3 + 36s2 +80s)
to find breakaway point, differentiate k with respect to s and equate to
zero.
dk = 0
ds
dk = - ( 4s3 +24s2+72s +80) = 0
ds
i.e. s3 +6s2+18s +20 = 0
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 118

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

-2

1
0

6
-2

18
-8

10

IV Semester ECE

20
-20
0

When s= 0, dk/ds =80 (+v)


When s =-4, dk/ds = -80 (-ve)
When s=0, dk/ds = 0. the breakaway point is -2.
The roots of s2 + 4s +10 = 0 are
-2 + j2.45
The other break away points are -2 + j2.45

Step 7:
Intersection of root locus with imaginary axis (j)
Characteristic equation = 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1+

k__________
s(s+4)(s2+4s+20)

=0

s(s+4) (s2+4s+20) + K = 0
s4 +8s3 + 36s2 +80s + K = 0
a0 = 1 a1 = 8 a2 = 36 a3 = 80 a4 = K

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 119

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Rouths array
s4

36

s3

80

s2

26

s1

2080 8 K
26

s0

To have intersection on j axis, any one row should be zero.


So make s1 row to be zero.
2080 8K = 0
K = 260.
Now , consider auxiliary equation
26s2 +K = 0
Put

K =260 in above equation.

26s2 +260= 0
s2 = - 10
s = + j 10 = + j 3.16
The complete root locus is shown in fig.4.3

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 120

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 8:
Angle of departure:

p3

p2

p1

p4

Angle of departure d = 180 + p


Consider point P3
p = - p1 - p2 -p4
= - (180 tan-14/2 ) - tan-14/2 - 180
= - 270
Angle of departure d = 180 + p
= 180- 270
= - 90
The complete root locus is shown in fig.4.4.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 121

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Fig.4.4.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 122

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

5. Sketch the root locus for the unity feedback system whose open loop
transfer function is
G(s)H(s) =________K_____
s(s+3)(s+8)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 123

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 1:
Number of poles P = 3
At s

0,-3,-8

Number of Zeros Z= 0
Step 2:
Number of separate root loci (branches)= Number of poles (P) = 3

Step 3:
The starting point of the root locus branches are from poles 0,-3,-8.
Terminating point of the root locus branches are at ZEROs. But here we have
no ZEROs. So the root locus branches terminates at infinity.

+j

P2

P3

P1

-
-8

-3

-j

Consider P1. to the R.H.S. of P1 the sum of poles and zeros are
odd. So P1 is the part of root locus. Consider P2. to the R.H.S. of
P2 the sum of poles and zeros are even. So P2 is not the part of
root locus. Consider P3. to the R.H.S. of P3 the sum of poles and
zeros are odd. So P3 is the part of root locus.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 124

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 4:
Number of asymptotes Na = P-Z = 3- 0 = 3
Angle of asymptotes : n = (2n+1) ( n = 0,1,2,.P-Z-1)
PZ
Here n = Na = P-Z = 3-0 = 3 n = 0,1,2.
For n =0 0 = (2(0)+1) = 60
30
For n =1 1 = (2(1)+1) = 180
30
For n =2 2 = (2(2)+1) = 300
30
Step 5:
Centroid ( )
= ( real parts of poles) - ( real parts of zeros)
PZ
= (0 -3-8) (0)
30
= -11 = -3.66
3
Step 6:
Breakaway point:
1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1+
K__________ = 0
s(s+3)(s+8)
s(s2 + 11s + 24) +k = 0
K = - s(s2 + 11s + 24)
K = - (s3 + 11s2 + 24s)
to find breakaway point, differentiate k with respect to s and equate to
zero.
dk = 0
ds
dk = - 3s2 - 22s 24 = 0
ds
i.e. 3s2+ 22s +24 = 0
now solve the above quadratic equation, we get s = - 1.3, - 6.
The valid breakaway point is 1.3. Because breakaway point must be
a part of root locus. But -6 is not the part of the root locus.
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 125

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 7:
Intersection of root locus with imaginary axis (j)
Characteristic equation = 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
s3 + 11s2 + 24s + K = 0
a0 = 1 a1 = 11 a2 = 24 a3 = K
Rouths array

s3

s2

11

s1

11(24) K )
11

s0

24

To have intersection on imaginary axis, any one row should be zero.


Let us make s1 row = 0
264 K
11
264 K

= 0
= 0

K = 264
Now , consider auxiliary equation
11s2 +K = 0
Put

K =264 in above equation.

11s2 +264 = 0
s2 +24 = 0
s = + j 24 = + j 4.9
The complete root locus is shown in fig.4.5
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 126

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Fig.4.5.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 127

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

6.Determine the root locus of the system whose open loop gain is
G(s)H(s) =________K_______ ;
S(s+4)(s2+8s+32)
k > 0. Sketch the root locus of the system. Hence find the value of K so that
system has a damping factor of 0.707

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 128

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 1:
Number of poles P = 4
At s

0, -4+j4, -4j4 , -4

Number of Zeros Z= 0
Step 2:
Number of separate root loci (branches)= Number of poles (P) = 4
The starting point of the root locus are from poles 0, -4+j4, -4j4 , -4
The terminating point of the root locus is at ZERO. Here we have no
ZEROs. So the root locus terminates at infinity.

-4+j4
+j

P2

-4

P1

-
0

-j

-4-j4
Consider P1. to the R.H.S. of P1 the sum of poles and zeros are odd.
So P1 is the part of root locus. Consider P2.Tothe R.H.S of the P2
the sum of poles and zeros are even. So p2 is not the part of root
locus.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 129

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 4:
Number of asymptotes Na = P-Z = 4- 0 = 4
Angle of asymptotes : n = (2n+1) ( n = 0,1,2,.P-Z-1)
PZ
Here n = Na = P-Z = 4-0 = 4 n = 0,1,2,3
For n =0 0 = (2(0)+1) = 45
4 0
For n =1 1 = (2(1)+1) = 135
40
For n =2 2 = (2(2)+1) = 225
40
For n =3 3 = (2(3)+1) = 315
40
Step 5:
Centroid ( )
= ( real parts of poles) - ( real parts of zeros)
PZ
= (0 -4-4 -4) (0)
40
= -12 = - 3
4
Step 6:
Breakaway point:
1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1+

K__________ = 0
s(s+4) (s2+8s+32)
s(s+4) (s2+8s+32) + K = 0

K = - (s 2 +4s)( (s2+8s+32)
K = - (s4 +12s3 + 64s2 +128s)
to find breakaway point, differentiate k with respect to s and equate to
zero.
dk = 0
ds
dk = - ( 4s3 +36s2+128s +128) = 0
ds
i.e. s3 +9s2+32s +32 = 0
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 130

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

1
0

-2

IV Semester ECE

9
32
32
-1.57 -11.25 -31.92
7.43

20.35

0.08

If s =-1.57, then the value of k is nearly zero. So s=-1.57 is the


valid breakaway point.

Step 7:
Intersection of root locus with imaginary axis (j)
Characteristic equation = 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1+

k__________
s(s+4)(s2+8s+32)

=0

s(s+4) (s2+8s+32) + K = 0
s4 +12s3 + 64s2 +128s + K = 0
a0 = 1 a1 = 12 a2 = 64 a3 = 128 a4 = K .

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 131

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Rouths array
s4

64

s3

12

128

s2

53.3

s1

6826.7 12K
53.3

s0

To have intersection on j axis, any one row should be zero.


So make s1 row to be zero.
6826.7 -12K= 0
53.3
K = 568.9
Now , consider auxiliary equation
53.3s2 +K = 0
Put

K =568.9 in above equation.

53.3s2 +568.9= 0
s2 = - 568.9
53.3
s = + j 3.26

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 132

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 8 :
Angle of Departure
-4+4j
P3

p2

P2

p1

-4
p4

P4
-4-4j
Angle of departure d = 180 + p
Consider point P3
p = - p1 - p2 -p4
= - (135 + 90 + 90 )
= - 335
Angle of departure d = 180 + p
= 180- 335
= - 135
Similarly at P4
d = + 135
The complete root locus is shown in fig. 4.6.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 133

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

G(S)H(S) =________K_______
S(s+4)(s2+8s+32)

Fig.4.6.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 134

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Calculation of the value of k at damping factor = 0.707


= cos-1 = cos-10.707 = 45
K = __Mp1_ Mp2 Mp3 Mp4____
1
Where Mp1 = magnitude of pole P1 i.e. the distance of pole P1 from K

+j4

-4

-j4

K = 2.1 * 3 *3.6 *6.2


1
K = 140.62

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 135

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

7.Sketch the root locus diagram of the following open loop transfer
function
G(s)H(s) =________K_(s+4)____
s(s2 +8s + 13)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 136

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 1:
Number of poles P = 3
At s

0,-3+2j,-3-2j

Number of Zeros Z= 1
s

-4

Step 2:
Number of separate root loci (branches)= Number of poles (P) = 3
Step 3:
The starting point of the root locus branch are from poles 0,-3+2j,-3-2j
. the terminating point of the root locus at ZEROs. Here we have one
ZERO. So one branch terminates at ZERO. The other poles terminate
at infinity.

+j

- 3+ 2j

+
P2

P1

-
-4
0

- 3 - 2j

-j

Consider P1. to the R.H.S. of P1 the sum of poles and zeros are
odd. So P1 is the part of root locus. Consider P2. to the R.H.S. of
P2 the sum of poles and zeros are even. So P2 is not the part of
root locus.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 137

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 4:
Number of asymptotes Na = P-Z = 3- 1 = 2
Angle of asymptotes : n = (2n+1) ( n = 0,1,2,.P-Z-1)
PZ
Here n = Na = P-Z = 3-1 = 2 n = 0,1,
For n =0 0 = (2(0)+1) = 90
31
For n =1 1 = (2(1)+1) = 270
31
Step 5:
Centroid ( )
= ( real parts of poles) - ( real parts of zeros)
PZ
= (0 -3-3) (-4)
31
= -2 = -1
2
Step 6:
Breakaway point:
In this problem, no poles are adjacent to each other. The pole at origin
terminates at ZERO s = -5. the complex poles move to infinity along 90
And 270 asymptotes. Hence there is no valid breakaway point.
Step 7:
Intersection of root locus with imaginary axis (j)
Characteristic equation = 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1+

K_(s+4)____
s(s2 +6s + 13)

=0

s3 +6s2 + 13s + K(s+4) = 0


s3 +6s2 + (13 + K)s + 4K = 0
a0 = 1 a1 = 6 a2 = 13 + k a3 =4K

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 138

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Rouths array

s3

s2

s1

s0

78 + 2K
8

13 + K

4K

4K

To have intersection on j axis, any one row should be zero.


So make s1 row to be zero.
78 + 2 K = 0
6
K = -39.
K value is negative. But to have intersection on j axis, k
value should be positive. So root locus does not intersect on
j axis.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 139

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 8 :
Angle of Departure for complex poles:
Consider Point P2
Angle of departure d = 180 - p + z
= 180 ( - p1 - p3) + z1
= 180 (146 + 90 ) + 63
= + 7 .
Similarly for P3, the angle of departure is - 7

-3 +j2
P2

z1

p1

-5
p3

P3
-3 - j2
The complete root locus is shown in fig.4.7.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 140

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

IV Semester ECE

Page 141

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

8. Sketch the root locus for the system and comment on stability
G(s)H(s) = K(s + 4)(s + 5) , K > 0
(s+3)(s+1)

(AU: Nov/Dec. 2007)

Step :1
Number of poles P =2
At s

-3,-1

Number of ZEROs = 2
At s

-4 , -5

Step 2:
Number of separate root loci (branches)= Number of poles (P) =2
Step 3
The starting point of the root locus are from poles -3,-1.terminating
point of the root locus is at ZEROs i.e. -4,-5

P4

P3

-5

P2

-4

P1

-3

-1

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 142

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Consider P1. to the R.H.S. of P1 . the sum of poles and zeros are odd. So P1 is
the part of root locus. Consider P2. to the R.H.S. of P2 . the sum of poles and
zeros are even. So P1 is not the part of root locus. Consider P3. to the R.H.S. of
P3 . the sum of poles and zeros are odd. So P3 is the part of root locus.
Consider P4. to the R.H.S. of P4 . the sum of poles and zeros are even. So P4 is
not the part of root locus.
Step 4:
Number of asymptotes Na = P-Z = 2- 2 = 0
When number of asymptotes = 0, then the root locus plot is circular. So no
need to find the intersection of asymptotes on real axis. Because asymptotes
are required only when number of poles is not equal to number of zeros. i.e.
P >z.

Step 5:
There is no need to find centroid. Because P Z = 2 2 = 0.
Step 6:
Breakaway point
1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1 + K(s + 4)(s + 5) = 0
(s+3)(s+1)
(s+3)(s+1) + K(s + 4)(s + 5) = 0
(s2 +4s+3)+ K(s2 + 9s +20) =0
K = - (s2 + 4s +3)
(s2 + 9s +20)
To find breakaway point, differentiate k with respect to s and equate
to zero.
dk = 0
ds

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 143

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

dk = ( s2 + 9s + 20)(2s + 4) (s2 + 4s + 3)(2s + 9) = 0


ds
(s2 + 9s + 20)2
= 5s2 + 34s +53 = 0
Solving the above quadratic equation, we get
Breakaway point at - 2.42
Breakin point - 4.38
Step: 7
Intersection on j axis.
Characteristic equation = 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1 + ___K_(s+4)(s + 5)____
( s + 3)(s + 1)

=0

( s + 3)(s + 1) + K( s + 4)(s + 5)
S2(1 + K) + s(9K + 4) + (20K + 3) = 0
a0 = 1 + K a1 = 9K + 4 a2 = 20K + 3
Rouths array
s2

1+K

s1

9K + 4

s0

20K + 3

20K + 3

To have intersection on j axis, any one row should be zero. Make s1


row to be zero.
(9K + 4)s = 0
9Ks + 4s = 0
9K = - 4
K = - (4 / 9) = - 0.44

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 144

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

As K is negative, there is no intersection on j axis. Mean of two


breakaway points as centre, and mean of two break points as radius
draw the root locus.
Centre = -2.4 - 4.4 = -3.4
2
radius = -2.4 + 4.4 = 1
2
Entire root locus lies on the left half of the s plane. Hence the system is
absolutely stable in nature.
The complete root locus is shown in fig.4.8.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 145

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Fig.4.8.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 146

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

9. The open loop transfer function G(S) = K(s + b) / s(s+a) and H(s) =1. for the
system shown below, prove that a part of root locus is a circle. (AU: April:2004).

R(s)

+
G(s)

C(s)

H(s)

G(s)H(s) = K(s + b)
s(s + a)
For a complex point on the root locus s = + j
G(s)H(s) = ____K( + j + b)_____
( + j ) ( + j + a)
At that point

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 147

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

G(s) H(s)

IV Semester ECE

tan -1 ( / +b)___________
tan -1 ( / ) tan -1 ( / +a)

Angle of positive K is 0

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 148

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

G(s) H(s)

IV Semester ECE

tan -1 ( / +b) - tan -1 ( / ) tan -1 ( / +a)

= tan -1 ( / +b) tan-1 _ ( / ) +( / +a)_


1 ( / ) ( / +a)
i.e. tan-1A + tan-1B = tan-1

= tan -1 ( / +b) - tan -1

_ A +B____
1 AB

(2 + a)______
( + a) 2

( / +b) - (2 + a)______
( + a) 2
= tan-1
1 + ( / +b)

(2 + a)______
( + a) 2

This angle must be 180 for a point on the root locus.


( / +b) - (2 + a)______
( + a) 2
180 =

tan-1
1 +( / +b) (2 + a)______
( + a) 2

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 149

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Taking tan on both sides and using tan (180) = 0, we get


_____ - (2 +a)__
+b
( +a) - 2

= 0

(2 + a - 2) ( 2 +a )( +b) = 0
{ (2 + a - 2) - ( 2 +a ) ( +b)} = 0
0
therefore { (2 + a - 2) - ( 2 +a ) ( +b)} = 0
i.e. 2 + a - 2 - 22 - 2 - 2b - ab = 0
(adding and subtracting b2 we get)
+ 2b + b + - b - ab = 0
2

( +b)2 + ( 0)2 = ( b(b a) )2


This is the equation of a circle with centre as (-b , 0) which is the location of open loop
zero and radius ( b(b a)). This proves that part of the root locus is a circle.

10. Prove that the breakaway points of the root locus are the solutions of dK/ds = 0.
where K is the open loop gain of the system whose open loop transfer function is
G(s)
(AU: April-2004)

The characteristic equation 1 +G(s)H(s) = 0 is the combination of s terms and K terms. It


can be arranged as
F(s) = P(s) + KQ(s) = 0 -------------------------- (1)
Where P(s) = polynomial containing s terms.
KQ(s) = polynomial containing K and s terms.
Taking K outside from KQ(s), it can be noted that both P(s) and Q(s) are
polynomials in s.

Now at breakaway points, multiple roots occur.


Mathematically this is possible if (dF(s) / ds ) = 0
From equation (1),

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 150

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

dF(s) = dP(s) + KdQ(s) = 0


ds
ds
ds

therefore K = - {dP(s) / ds} ------------------------------------(2)


dQ(s) / ds
put equation(2) in equation (1),
at breakaway point, we can write
P(s)

- {dP(s) / ds} Q(s) = 0


dQ(s) / ds

dQ(s) P(s)+ KdP(s) Q(S) = 0 ----------------(3)


ds
ds
solving equation(3), for value of s, breakaway point can be obtained.
Now from equation(1)
K = - P(s)
Q(s)

Therefore dK(s) = ds

Q(s){dP(s) / ds} - P(s){dQ(s) / ds}------- (4)


[Q(s)]2

if dK / ds is equated to zero, we get


dK = P(s) dQ(s) - Q(s) dP(s) = 0 --------------(5)
ds
ds
ds
compare (3) and equation(5).
Equation(5) is same as equation(3) which yields breakaway points. This
proves that the roots of ( dK / ds ) = 0 are the actual breakaway points.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 151

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System


11) An unity feedback system has G(s)

IV Semester ECE

G(s)) =________K__________
s(s + 1)(s + 3)(s + 4)

draw the complete root locus.

Step 1:
Number of poles P = 4
At s
0,-1, -3, -4
Number of Zeros Z= 0
Step 2:
Number of separate root loci (branches)= Number of poles (P) = 4

Step 3:
The starting point of the root locus branches are from poles 0,-1,-3, -4.
Terminating point of the root locus branches are at ZEROs. But here in this
problem, we have no ZEROs. So the root locus branches terminates at
infinity.

Consider P1. to the R.H.S. of P1 the sum of poles and zeros are odd. So P1 is
the part of root locus. Consider P2. to the R.H.S. of P2 the sum of poles and
zeros are even. So P2 is not the part of root locus. Consider P3. to the R.H.S. of
P3 the sum of poles and zeros are odd. So P3 is the part of root locus. Consider
P4. to the R.H.S. of P4 the sum of poles and zeros are even. So P4 is not the
part of root locus.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 152

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 4 :
Number of asymptotes Na = P-Z = 4- 0 = 4
Angle of asymptotes : n = (2n+1) ( n = 0,1,2,.P-Z-1)
PZ
Here n = Na = P-Z = 4-0 = 2 n = 0,1, 2,3.
For n =0 0 = (2(0)+1)
40

= 45

For n =1 1 = (2(1)+1)
40

= 135

For n =2 2 = (2(2)+1)
40

= 225

For n =3 3 = (2(3)+1)
40

= 315

Step 5:
Centroid ( )
= ( real parts of poles) - ( real parts of zeros)
PZ
= (0 -1-3 4 ) - (0) = - 8__ = -2
31
4
Step 6:
Breakaway point:
1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1+

K__________ = 0
s(s+1)(s+3)(s + 4)

s(s+1)(s+3)(s + 4)+ K = 0

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 153

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

K = - { s(s+1)(s+3)(s + 4)}
= -{ s4 +7s3 +13s2 +7s +12}
dK = 0
ds
dK = -{4s3 +21s2 +26s +7} = 0
ds
4s3 +21s2 +26s +7= 0

-0.4

21

26

-1.6

7.76

-7.2

19.4

18.24

-0.2

If s = -0.4, then the value of s is nearly zero. So s = -0.4 is valid


breakaway point.
4s2 +19.4s +18.24 = 0
On solving the above quadratic equation, we get
s = -0.64,-1.78
so the valid breakaway points are -0.4, -0.64

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 154

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 7:
Intersection on j axis.
Characteristic equation = 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1 + ___ K___________ = 0
s( s + 1)(s + 3) (s+4
s( s + 1)(s + 3) ( s + 4) + K = 0
s4 +7s3 +13s2 +7s +12 + K = 0
a0 = 1 a1 = 7 a2 = 13 a3= 7a4 = 12 + K
Rouths array

s4

13

12 + K

s3

s2

12

12+ K

s1

12*7 7(12+K)
12

s0
12 + K
To have intersection on j axis, any one row should be zero. Make s1
row to be zero.
12*7 7(12+K) = 0
12
84 7(12+K) = 0
K=0
Put K = 0 in s2 row.
12 s2 + 12 + K = 0
s2 = - 1; therefore s = + j1
the root locus intersects on j axis at + j1.
The complete root locus is shown in fig. 4.9.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 155

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Fig.4.9.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 156

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

12. Sketch the root locus of the system having G(s)H(s) =______K(s + 2)_____
(s +1)(s + 3+j2)(s+3- j2)
(AU:Nov/Dec:2007)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 157

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 1:
Number of poles P = 3
At s

-1,-3+2j,-3-2j

Number of Zeros Z= 1
s

-2

Step 2:
Number of separate root loci (branches)= Number of poles (P) = 3
Step 3:
The starting point of the root locus branch are from poles -1,-3+2j,-3-2j
. the terminating point of the root locus at ZEROs. Here we have one
ZERO. So one branch terminates at ZERO. The other poles terminate
at infinity.

- 3+ 2j

+j

P2

P1

-
-2
0

- 3 - 2j

-j

Consider P1. to the R.H.S. of P1 the sum of poles and zeros are
odd. So P1 is the part of root locus. Consider P2. to the R.H.S. of
P2 the sum of poles and zeros are even. So P2 is not the part of
root locus.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 158

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 4:
Number of asymptotes Na = P-Z = 3- 1 = 2
Angle of asymptotes : n = (2n+1) ( n = 0,1,2,.P-Z-1)
PZ
Here n = Na = P-Z = 3-1 = 2 n = 0,1,
For n =0 0 = (2(0)+1) = 90
31
For n =1 1 = (2(1)+1) = 270
31
Step 5:
Centroid ( )
= ( real parts of poles) - ( real parts of zeros)
PZ
= (-1-3-3) (-2)
31
=
-2.5
Step 6:
Breakaway point:
In this problem, no poles are adjacent to each other. So no breakaway point
is there.
Step 7:
Intersection of root locus with imaginary axis (j)
Characteristic equation = 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1 + ___K_(s+2)________
( s+1)(s2 +6s + 13)

=0

( s+1)(s2 +6s + 13) + K(s+2) = 0


s3 +6s2 + 13s + s2 + 6s + 13 + Ks +2K = 0
s3 +7s2 + (19 + K)s + 13 + 2K = 0
a0 = 1 a1 = 7 a2 = 19 + k a3 = 13 +2K

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 159

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Rouths array

s3

19 + K

s2

13+2K

s1

s0

7(19+K) - (13+2K)(1)
7

13 + 2K

To have intersection on j axis, any one row should be zero.


So make s1 row to be zero.
7(19+K) - (13+2K)(1)
7
K = -24.

= 0

K value is negative. But to have intersection on j axis, K


value should be positive. So root locus does not intersect on
j axis.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 160

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 8 :
Angle of Departure for complex poles:
Consider Point P2
Angle of departure d = 180 - p + z
= 180 (p1 +p3) + z1
= 180 (135 +90 ) + 116.5
= + 7 1.56.
Similarly for P3, the angle of departure is - 7 1.56

-3 +j2
P2

z1

-2

p1

-1

-3 - j2
P3

The complete root locus is shown in fig.4.10.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 161

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Fig.4.10.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 162

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

13. For a feedback system with loop transfer function


G(s)H(s) =________K(s +1)______ draw the root locus.
s(s+4)(s2+6s+10)

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 163

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 1:
Number of poles P = 4
At s

0, -3+j1, -3 j1 , -4

Number of Zeros Z= 1
At s

-1

Step 2:
Number of separate root loci (branches)= Number of poles (P) = 4
Step 3:
The starting point of the root locus are from poles 0, -3+j1, -3 j1, -4.
the simple pole at the origin terminates at ZERO (i.e at s= -1). Two complex
poles go to infinity along 60 ,300 asymptotes. The simplepole at s = - 4 go
to infinity along 180 asymptote.

+j

-3 + j
P3

-4

P2

P1
+

-1
-3 - j

-j

Consider P1. to the R.H.S. of P1 the sum of poles and zeros are odd.
So P1 is the part of root locus. Consider P2.To the R.H.S of the P2
the sum of poles and zeros are even. So p2 is not the part of root
locus. Consider P3.to the R.H.S. of P3, the sum of poles and zeros
are odd. So P3 is the part of root locus.

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 164

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Step 4:
Number of asymptotes Na = P-Z = 4- 1 = 3
Angle of asymptotes : n = (2n+1) ( n = 0,1,2,.P-Z1)
PZ
Here n = Na = P-Z = 4-1 = 3 n = 0,1,2,
For n =0 0 = (2(0)+1) = 60
4 1
For n =1 1 = (2(1)+1) = 180
41
For n =2 2 = (2(2)+1) = 300
41
Centroid ( )
= ( real parts of poles) - ( real parts of zeros)
PZ
= (0 -4-3 -3) (-1)
41
= -9 = - 3
3
Step 6:
Breakaway point:
In this problem, no poles are adjacent to each other. So no breakaway
point is not there.
Step 7:
Intersection of root locus with imaginary axis (j)
Characteristic equation = 1 + G(s)H(s) = 0
1+

K(s +1)__________
s(s+4)(s2+6s+10)

=0

s(s+4) (s2+6s+20) + K = 0
s4 +10s3 + 34s2 + ( 40 + K )s + K = 0
a0 = 1 a1 = 10 a2 = 34 a3 = 40 + K a4 = K

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 165

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

Rouths array

s4

s3

10

34

40 + K

s2

( 300 - K)
10

s1

(300- K)(40-K) 100K


300 - K

s0

To have intersection on j axis, any one row should be zero.


So make s1 row to be zero.
(300 K)(40 K) 100K = 0
300 - K
12000 + 300K 40K K2 -100K =0
K2 160K -12000 =0
On solving the above quadratic equation, we get
K = +215.65 , K = -55.65

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 166

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

IV Semester ECE

Page 167

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

IV Semester ECE

Page 168

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

IV Semester ECE

Page 169

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

1. The Transfer function of the system is used to determine:


A. The output for a given input
B. The type of the system
C. The input for a given output
D. The steady state gain
Answer: A
2. The transfer function of a system is defined as:
A. The laplace transform of the impulse response
B. Laplace transform of the step response
C. Laplace transform of the ramp response
D. Laplace transform of the sinusoidal input
Answer: A
3. The transfer function has the main application in the study of __ behavior of the
system
A. Steady
B. Transient
C. Both steady and transient
D. None of the above
Answer: A
4. Transfer function of the control system depends on
A. Initial conditions of input and output
B. System parameters alone
C. Nature of the input
D. Nature of the output
Answer: B
5. The ON-OFF controller is a __ system
A. Linear
B. Non linear
C. Discontinuous
D. Digital
Answer: B
6. The impulse function is a derivative of __ function:
A. Parabolic
B. Step
C. Ramp
D. Linear
Answer: B

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 170

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

7. Control Systems are normally designed with damping factor:


A. Less than unity
B. More than unity
C. Zero
D. Unity
Answer: A
8. Error Constants of a system are measure of:
A. Relative stability
B. Transient state response
C. Steady state response
D. Steady state as well as transient state response
Answer: C

1. A transfer function of a system is a Laplace transform of its:


A. Square wave response
B. Step response
C. Ramp response
D. Impulse response
Answer: D
2. Laplace transform method has the advantage of:
A. Corporation of initial conditions in the very first step
B. Providing total solution more systematically
C. Providing solutions in frequency domain only
D. All the above
E. Both (a) and (b)
Answer: E
3. Transfer function of a control system depends on:
A. Initial conditions of input and output
B. System parameters alone
C. Nature of input
D. Nature of output
Answer: B
5. Bimetallic thermostat is __ Controller
A. Zero
B. One term
C. Two term
D. On-off
Answer: D
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 171

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

6. Two stator windings of the ac servo motors are oriented __ electrical degrees apart
a) 90
b) 60
c) 120
d) 180
A
7. Which of the following is not true for an ac servo motor:
a) Has low inertia rotor
b) Is a single phase motor
c) Has slip torque characteristics as straight line with negative slope
d) Reference voltage frequency is high compared to signal frequency
B
8. A gyroscope operates on the principle of:
a) Law of conservation of energy
b) Law of conservation of momentum
c) Electro-mechanical conversion
d) Newton's third law of motion
B
9. AC Servo motor is basically a:
a) Universal motor
b) Capacitor motor
c) 2 phase induction motor
d) 3 phase induction motor
C
10. The output of synchro error detector is a:
a) Voltage signal of the receiver
b) Voltage signal of constant amplitude
c) Suppressed carrier modulated signal
d) Angular displacement of the control transformer rotor
C

Control Systems Objective Test Questions Answers

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 172

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

1. __ can be used for converting the angular the angular position of a shaft into electrical
signal:
a) LVDT
b) Synchros
c) DC Servo motor
d) AC Servo motor
A
2. Synchros are widely used for transmission of __ data:
a) Angular
b) Digital
c) Mathematical
d) Computed
A
3. The input to a controller is always a/an __
a) Error
b) Servo
c) Amplifier
d) Sensor
A
4. The thermocouple directly converts temperature into:
a) dc voltage
b) ac voltage
c) direct current
d) alternating current
A
5. Potentiometers are used in control systems:
a) To improve frequency response
b) To improve time response
c) To improve stability
d) As error sensing transducer
D
6. Tachometer is employed to measure
a) Rotational speed
b) Displacement
c) Torque developed
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 173

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

d) Driven shaft speed


A
7. In a control system the comparator measures the differences between:
a) Output and input
b) Actual and desired performance
c) Controller and system
d) None of the above
B
8. A signal other than the reference input that tends to affect the value of controlled
variable is termed as:
a) Command
b) Error signal
c) Disturbance
d) Actuating signal
C
9. The weighting function of the control system is called the __ response
a) Impulse
b) Transient
c) Steady state
d) None of the above
A
10. In a control system the comparator compares the output response and reference input
and actuates the:
a) Transducer
b) Signal Conditioner
c) Control element
d) Primary sensing element
C

Control Systems Objective Test Questions Answers


1. A Closed loop system is basically different from open loop control system due to:
A. Feedback
B. Servomechanism
C. Actuating signal
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 174

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

D. Error Signal
Answer: A
2. Introduction of the feedback reduces the effects of:
A. Noise signal
B. Disturbances
C. Error signals
D. Error and noise signals
E. Noise signals and disturbances
Answer: E
3. A control system in which control action depends on the output is called the __
control system
A. Open loop
B. Closed loop
C. Stable
D. Unstable
Answer: A
4. In a control system the use of negative feedback:
A. Eliminates the chances of instability
B. Increases the reliability
C. Reduces the effects of disturbance and noise signals in the forward path
D. Increases the influence of variations of component parameters on the system
performance
Answer: C
5. A controller essentially is a:
A. Comparator
B. Sensor
C. Amplfier
D. Clipper
Answer: B
6. In a control system, the controller output is given to:
A. Sensor
B. Comparator
C. Amplifier
D. Final Control element
Answer: D
7. The deviation of the primary feedback signal from the reference input is called
the:
A. Actuating signal
B. Error signal
C. Command
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 175

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

D. Manipulated variable
Answer: A

8. The transient response of a system is mainly due to:


A. Friction
B. Inertia forces
C. Stored energy
D. Internal forces
Answer: C
9. Regenerative feedback:
A. Implies feedback with positive sign
B. Is sometimes used to increase the loop gain of the feedback system
C. Has the transfer function with a negative sign in the denominator
D. All the above
Answer: D
10. In a hybrid feedback control systems carrier signals are:
A. ac only
B. dc only
C. both ac and dc
D. none of the above
Answer: C

PID Controller Objective Questions Answers


1. Proportional band of a controller is defined as the range of:
a) Measured variable to the set variable
b) Air output as the measured variable varies from maximum to minimum
c) Measured variables through which the air output varies from maximum to minimum
d) None of the above
C
2. Proportional band of the controller is expressed as:
a) Gain
b) Ratio
c) Percentage
d) Range of control variables
C
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 176

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

3. The term reset control refers to:


a) Proportional
b) Integral
c) Derivative
d) None of the above
B
4. The integral control:
a) Increases the steady state error
b) Decreases the steady state error
c) Increases the noise and stability
d) Decreases the damping coefficient
A
5. In a proportional temperature controller, if the quantity under the heater increases the
offset will:
a) Increase
b) Reduce
c) Remain uneffected
d) None of the above
A
6. When derivative action is included in a proportional controller, the proportional band:
a) Increases
b) Reduces
c) Remains unchanged
d) None of the above
C
7. The number of operational amplifiers require for designing of electronic PID controller
is:
a) 1
b) 2
c) 3
d) 6
A
8. Which of the following system provides excellent transient and steady state response:
a) Proportional action
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 177

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

b) Proportional + Integral action


c) Proportional + Differential action
d) Proportional + Integral + Differential action
D
9. In a PID controller, the offset has increased. The integral time constant has to be ___
so as to reduce offset:
a) Reduced
b) Increased
c) Reduced to zero
d) None of the above
B
10. In a PID controller, the overshoots has increased. The derivative time constant has to
be __ so as to reduce the overshoots:
a) Increased
b) Reduced
c) Reduced to zero
d) None of the above
A
Control System Objective Questions: Part-1
Control System Objective Questions From Competitive Exams
[1] A system is described by the following state and output equations
[dx1(t)/dt] =-3x1(t)+x2(t)+2u(t)
[dx2(t)/dt]=-2x2(t)+u(t)
y(t)=x1(t)
where u(t) is the input and y(t) is the output
The system transfer function is [GATE 2009]
A. (s+2)/(s2+5s-6)
B. (s+3)/(s2+5s+6)
C. (2s+5)/(s2+5s+6)
D. (2s-5)/(s2+5s-6)

[2] A two-port network is defined by the relation: [IES 2010]


I=5V1+3V2
I2=2V1-7V2The value of Z12 is
A. 3

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 178

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

B. -3
C. 3/41
D. 2/31
Ans: C
[3] The Z-transform of x(K) is given by [IES 2010]
x(Z)= {(1-e-T)z-1} / {(1-z-1)(1-e-Tz-1)}
The initial value of x(0) is
A. Zero
B. 1
C. 2
D. 3
Ans:
[4] Consider the following statements with reference to the phase plane:
1. They are general and applicable to a system of any order.
2. Steady state accuracy and existence of limit cycle can be predicted.
3. Amplitude and frequency of limit cycle if exists can be evaluated.
4. Can be applied to discontinuous time system.
Which of the above statements are correct? [IES2010]
A. 1,2,3 and 4
B. 2 and 3 only
C. 3 and 4 only
D. 2,3 and 4 only

[5] For the circuit shown below, the natural frequencies at port 2 are given by s+2=0 and
s+5=0,without knowing which refers to open-circuit and which to short-circuit. Then the
impedences Z11 and Z22 are given respectively by [IES2010]

A.
B.
C.
D.

K1{(s+5)/(s+2)}, K2{(s+2)/(s+5)}
K1{(s+2)/(s+5)}, K2{(s+5)/(s+2)}
K1{(s)/(s+2)}, K2{(s+2)/(s+5)}
K1{(s+2)/(s+5)}, K2{(s+2)/(s+5)}

Ans: C
[6] Consider the following statements in connection with two-position controller:
1.If the controller has a 4% neutral zone,its positive error band will be 2% and negative
error band will be 8%.
2.The neutral zone is also known as dead band.
3.The controller action of a two-position controller is very similar to that of a pure on-off
Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 179

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

IV Semester ECE

controller.
4.Air-conditioning system works essentially on a two-position control basis.
Which of the above statements are correct? [IES2010]
A. 1,2 and 3 only.
B. 2,3 and 4 only.
C. 2 and 4 only.
D. 1,2,3 and 4

[7] The polar plot of an open loop stable system is shown below. The closed loop system
is [GATE 2009]

A.Always stable
B.Marginally stable
C.Unstable with one pole on the RH s-plane
D.Unstable with two poles on the RH s-plane

[8] The open loop transfer function of a unity feedback system is given by G(s) =(e 0.1s
)/s.The gain margin of this system is
[GATE 2009]
A. 11.95 dB

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

Page 180

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

IV Semester ECE

Page 181

EC2255- Solved Problems in Control System

Solved by A.Devasena., Associate Professor., Dept/ECE

IV Semester ECE

Page 182

S-ar putea să vă placă și