Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Unit 2
Unit 2
Structure:
2.1 Introduction
Objectives
2.2 Emerging Areas of Growth
Shifting patterns of consumption
2.3 Factors that Affect Marketing and Advertising
Industrial growth
The China factor
Elections
Monsoon rains
Disposable income
Employment
Inflation and consumer basket
Economic cycle and managing change
Consumer mind share
Rising prosperity and spending power
Government control on ads
Power of vernacular languages
Innovative media
Happiness quotient
Good advertising is more than hard sell
2.4 Summary
2.5 Glossary
2.6 Terminal Questions
2.7 Answers
2.1 Introduction
In the previous unit, we studied about advertising management. Let us now
study emerging areas of growth in advertising, factors affecting marketing
and advertising, etc. In this unit, we will take a journey into the exciting world
of Indian advertising.
The advertising environment in India is an incredibly complex Web that
works at many levels. It is closely linked with many factors other than what
are seen as advertising. These range from manufacturing to monsoon rains,
employment to religion, beauty contest to diet fads, spirituality industry to
Sikkim Manipal University
Page No. 27
Unit 2
Page No. 28
Unit 2
said in bemused frustration, a rural home may have a large screen colour
television, but no indoor toilet. They no longer believe in safety
investments like gold and land and are out to enjoy and improve
themselves.
Steady growth is now in the rural and semi-rural areas. Yet, very few citybased advertising agencies really understand the rural mind, for example,
what are their dreams and aspirations, what drives their ambitions and
insecurities, what are the collective cultural and emotional pressures that will
lead them to the next level of purchases, etc.
For at least a decade now, urban markets have been inelastic and mature,
often stagnating at replacement level. Unemployed people also do not buy
much. Therefore, consumer durables and other manufactured products
must sell differently now sales, installments, incentives, low interest loans,
exchanges, etc., to accelerate the purchasing decision of a necessary
item.
2.2.1 Shifting patterns of consumption
The market is full of contradictions. Middle class consumers are looking out
for better quality and higher priced products within the category. More
households are using higher priced detergent powders now. Remember the
Nirma phenomenon which started its incredible career priced at only
` 5/kg, even though some claimed that it wrecked coloured clothes? It is
facing stiff competition with Wheel (which is the largest selling detergent
brand in India) and other better quality washing powders. AC Nielsons retail
audit for 200506 for detergents, a product of almost universal penetration,
shows that detergent powders grew 6% in value, but declined by 5% in
volume. This implies that people are buying better detergents, which are
needed in smaller quantity.
This is backed by high advertising pressure. For instance, Hindustan
Unilever Ltds (HUL) ad spend was increased by 45% in the first quarter of
2006, and Colgate-Palmolives by 31%. Similarly, toothpaste is gradually
replacing tooth powder and better quality bath soaps are in demand even in
villages. From 2005 to 2008, thanks to households upgrading from
toothpowder to toothpaste, the toothpaste penetration has grown by 9% and
Page No. 29
Unit 2
Source: ACNielsen
Page No. 30
Unit 2
Page No. 31
Unit 2
them back into India, still at a price cheaper than domestically produced
goods.
China is always trying to flood the Indian market with industrial intermediary
products and cheap consumer products for the lower end of the market. It
provides India with more product options at lower prices, but it curtails our
industrial growth and reduces jobs in India and thus the buying power.
2.3.3 Elections
The election expenditures are a major factor in the Indian economy, but they
are not well documented for obvious reasons. The Lok Sabha and state
legislature elections as well as the smaller local ones like by-elections,
panchayat and municipal ones take place all the time.
Election advertising has come a long way from the erstwhile practice of
sloganeering and propaganda to the use of blogs, Google ads and even
Search Engine Optimisation (SEO) techniques. For the advertising industry,
the amount of print ads, banners, hoardings, posters, plastic danglers,
booklets, CDs, video and music vans, films, SMSes, commercials and press
and electronic communications that are produced is truly mind numbing.
Political advertising has evolved and also become slicker with a greater
number of parties using the services of ad agencies, and mega money has
been flowing for high-decibel rhetoric. One may remember the India Shining
campaign of the previous BJP-led National Democratic Alliance Government
during the 2004 Lok Sabha elections; it set new standards of political
advertising. Reportedly, Rs. 500 crore was spent on this campaign.2
Many agencies work on local election campaigns for individual candidates in
every constituency. These release an enormous amount of unaccounted
cash into the market, which in turn goes into buying goods and services
immediately for a large number of people. And they are all advertised, one
way or another.
2.3.4 Monsoon rains
It was considered that the rain is the real finance minister of India, because
it controls the entire economy. The dependence on rain is not so great now,
2
Page No. 32
Unit 2
partly due to irrigation and partly because agriculture accounts for only 15%
of Indias nearly $2 trillion economy, Asia's third biggest.3 An ETIG analysis
of 10 years of rainfall data and key economic indicators show that during
200406, rainfall had been below normal, yet these years have shown the
highest economic growth. Nevertheless, rain matters a lot, because in the
end even ground-water-based irrigation depends on recharging by
rainwater. India will now probably not see a famine again because of its
ability to import food in difficult years. But the farmers will not buy anything
when their harvest is poor.
If the farmer does not have the money to buy gold to cars, imported
luxuries to aspirational products then urban production will suffer.
However, the Indian market is now becoming more climate-proof and stable.
So, forward planning and budgeting for rural advertising can now be done
with more confidence.
Yet, monsoon rains still wield an enormous power over the Indian market.
Rainfall has been about 25% less than average in 2009, and its
consequences are very visible. Because there is less production of sugar
cane, pulses and oil seeds, prices have shot up in spite of huge import and
government control. Clearly, black-marketing is at work. Exports have also
suffered because of price rise.
When farmers, semi-skilled and industrial workers earn less and spend
more on such essentials like food and clothes, they obviously have little
money left for buying other goods and services, which is the domain of
advertising. The market had grown at a rapid space only in rural areas,
riding on the good monsoon of the past few years, and this can take a
serious knock if the rainfall is poor.
A monsoon with average rains would boost grains output, helping the
government to keep inflation under check and boost the faltering economy.
2.3.5 Disposable income
A great debate goes on about the percentage of Indians living below the
poverty line. But where is the poverty line? As mentioned elsewhere, in
3
Source: (2012, April 17). India sees 2012 monsoon normal, no El Nino threat.
The Times of India.
Page No. 33
Unit 2
200405, it was 21.8% national average; this was based on the consumer
expenditure data collected from a 30-day recall period. Apparently, village
folks do not remember what they did a month ago, and therefore the data
came out skewed. In the last 3 years, researchers have lived with families
and collected data on a 7-day recall basis. Though these people do not buy
advertised products right now, they do aspire to do so in future and are thus
of interest to the advertising industry. In March 2012, the Planning
Commission fixed the poverty line at Rs. 28.65 per capita daily consumption
in cities and Rs. 22.42 in rural areas, bringing India's poverty ratio to 29.8%
in 200910. But, most experts are of the opinion that this threshold is too
low.4 According to the 2010 data from the United Nations Development
Programme, an estimated 37.2% of Indians live below the country's national
poverty line.5
According to the World Bank Survey, 2005, India emerged as the
12th wealthiest nation in the world based on the Purchasing Power Parity
(PPP). However, according to the same report, 41.6% of the total Indian
population was below the international poverty line of USD 1.25 a day.6 In
April 2007, India became a trillion dollar economy, an exclusive club of only
7/8 nations at that time. Great for nationalism, but it just does not seem to
reflect at the micro level, where our buyers of advertised products are.
Poverty and unemployment still plague us, which slows down growth and
thus the purchasing power.
No matter how eagerly the commercial world looks at the great Indian
middle class people, who spend and acquire with the most uninhibited
energy, these people are scattered all over the country and they are diverse
in their habits. To sell in this market, advertisers will need to have a deep
understanding of Indias new consumers today so that they can deliver the
products that meet their aspirations. Advertising agencies will have to be
sensitive to their attitudes and aspirations. People also do not like to spend
much, still being loyal to their age-old thrifty habits. Therefore, low price
4
5
6
Source: (2012, March 19). Planning Commission further lowers poverty line to
Rs.28 per day. India Today.
Source: www.undp.org.in
Source: (2005). New global poverty estimates What it means for India.
Retrieved from http://www.worldbank.org.in.
Page No. 34
Unit 2
points and high expectations, with a tight control over the wallet, are the new
reality of the Indian middle class segment. Table 2.1 depicts the number of
Indian households falling into high-, middle- and low-income categories.
Table 2.1: Number of Indian Households (HHs)
Category of HHs in India
Number of HHs
(in millions)
High-income HHs
(Earning over Rs. 1.80 lakh p.a.)*
46.7
Middle-income HHs
(Earning between Rs. 45,000 and Rs. 1.80 lakh p.a.)*
140.7
Low-income HHs
(HHs earning less than Rs. 40,000 p.a.)*
41.0
Total
228.4
* at 200102 prices
(Source: National Council of Applied Economic Research (NCAER) estimates on
Earnings and Spendings at the end of 200910.)
For the higher income class, sharply higher consumer spending now shifts
to conspicuous consumption, thus changing the face of Indias retail sector.
This leads to attracting some of the worlds market leaders in super luxury
goods. However, selling to this segment is a different technique altogether.
All these statistics are needed to get a grip on where our buyers are, what
their profiles are, what are their disposable income and purchasing pattern,
and how do they think, feel and act. These are necessary so that better
structured marketing and advertising strategies can be worked out on a
more reliable and long-term basis.
2.3.6 Employment
As per the 2011 census, Indian population increased to 1.21 billion from
1.02 billion in 2001, with a decadal growth of 17.64%. Jobs, on the other
hand, have been growing at a slower or more fluctuating rate. Jobs are axed
and salaries are slashed during years of economic downturn because firms
tighten their belts to survive in those times. Unemployed people do not buy
too many things, advertised or otherwise. Therefore, the marketing and
advertising industries have to plan their turnover target and strategy
accordingly.
Sikkim Manipal University
Page No. 35
Unit 2
A massive job loss was evident all over the world for almost a decade,
largely due to automation, and then because of the recession. By one
estimate, there have been nearly 10 million job losses in India alone up to
200809, taking unemployment to over 10% of the employable population.
This does not include partially or inappropriately employed people or people
who just do not even seek work considering the market conditions; but they
are consumers, nevertheless. However, the situation has been improving
lately. According to a finance ministry official, the latest figures based on a
sample survey of eight sectors show that as many as 10.66 lakh jobs have
been added between March 2009 and 2010.
The total employment in the Indian economy during 200910 has been
estimated at 506 million with an average annual growth rate of 1.97% for the
period 200405 to 200910. The total labour force for 200910 has been
estimated at 520 million and the figure is expected to go up to 574 million in
201415, which means that 10 to 11 million new entrants are expected to
join the labour force each year. The estimates indicate that employment
must grow at least at 2.5% a year for the next 5 years so that most of the
open unemployment, including the additions to the labour force due to the
increasing population, may be taken care of. According to projections
worked out by the labour ministry, this would require a 9% economic growth
rate of the Indian economy at the current level of absorption. This definitely
seems a daunting task, casting uncertainties on employment situation in the
future.7
The demographic profile of India has changed drastically. About 45% of
Indians are now below 35 years of age, and they want to possess and
acquire aspirational and advertised goods. They also want power and
control over their own lives and the nations destiny. To do that, they want
to earn lots of money. That will certainly change the way goods and
services are advertised, nurtured and positioned in the market.
Source: Pannu, S.P.S. (2010, September 18). Higher growth produces more jobs
in India. India Today.
Page No. 36
Unit 2
In the first half of this decade, due to easy consumer loans and rising
disposable income, the consumer durables as well as expensive
investments (e.g. real estate, insurance, retirement plans, foreign holidays
all advertised products) were sold in vast quantities. Thus, there was a stiff
competition among durables and luxuries for the consumers wallet. Too
many goods and services were chasing available rupees, so to speak.
Ironically, the recession has swung the market to the opposite direction
Sikkim Manipal University
Page No. 37
Unit 2
loans have become harder to get and jobs have become scarce, leading to
less disposable money. A larger number of unsold goods and services are
still chasing shrinking amount of rupees. Marketing and advertising
professionals are now creating different selling and positioning strategies
altogether.
As far as the consumer is concerned, opportunities have never been so
good. Swanky malls, even in small towns, are loaded with global brands of
luxury items. Wide range of brands available to fit every taste and budget,
etc., are becoming common. The Indian consumer is finally in the drivers
seat. Indian market has moved from the regulated sellers market and
shortage economy to lavish buyers market. All these affect the marketing
strategy. It is a great pity that recession has hit badly and is curtailing
consumers purchasing power. However, the effect of recession is
temporary.
2.3.8 Economic cycle and managing change
The economic cycle of boom and bust is a fact of life, whether at a personal,
national or global level. Since the world started keeping a record of it,
economists have been trying to discover a pattern or, more important, a time
scale of this curious phenomenon. But, there has been no success. It just
happens. Our job on the ground is to deal with it.
The current economic condition is the result of many factors pooling
together, and it affects the advertising and marketing industries hugely. In
lean times, advertising needs to be far more skilful to achieve a satisfactory
amount of sale. Delivering a certain amount of results is not an easy task in
spite of more direct and aggressive creative work, hard-selling strategy,
smaller but effective formats, fewer releases and less expensive media. But
it is possible. It just requires more innovative, out-of-the-box thinking that
engages the target at a more fundamental level. The cycle will turn and
bring in new consumption that is triggered by pent up demand even though
marketers will have to operate on skin-thin margins due to unethical
competition. It is again a different kind of challenge for the advertising
professionals.
During boom time, there is no necessity to use great techniques or
strategies. People are in an upbeat mood to spend non-stop, and
advertising helps to sell the maximum. Advertising has witnessed ups and
Sikkim Manipal University
Page No. 38
Unit 2
downs in ad growth that match these boom and recessionary cycles. For
instance, during the peak of recession in 2009, advertising growth in India
was 10%. In 2010, with the economy picking up, this figure shot up to
27%. In 2011, the year started on a positive note; yet as the global economy
saw another churn, inflation rose above 10% and the rupee weakened
against the dollar; so, advertisers went into a shell and held back their
purses. There was growth, but at a mere 8%. Advertisers had been badly
affected in 2009; hence, only necessary advertising was done.8
2.3.9 Consumer mind share
The core of advertising does not change ever, which is trying to touch the
self-interest of the consumer in order to make him/her buy the advertised
brand. But strategies and tactics have to adapt to changing consumer
attitudes, mindsets and market conditions. For a number of reasons,
consumers are responding lesser than ever to traditional advertising, which
has become more costly and less cost-effective than before, that is,
advertising is able to reach fewer consumers even with the same or higher
spends. With the proliferation of umpteen new brands, real product
differentiation has become small and largely insignificant, making it more
difficult for advertising to create the brand personalities of the past. Besides,
the bar has just risen higher for advertising, and the consumers are not
easily impressed by a concoction of words, visuals and sounds put together
for advertisings sake.
The abbreviation that the advertising fraternity is throwing around is CPA or
Continuous Partial Attention. Due to demanding and stressful lives, people
are forced to live on the one hand, and the countless number of brands
demand their attention on the other; audience apathy and hostility is only
normal. It means everybody is getting lesser and lesser mind share of
his/her target. Gone are the days, when people had to queue up and wait for
several years to get a Bajaj scooter or an Ambassador car (about 30,000
units were produced per year in its heydays); finally gaining one was
considered a divine privilege. Today the struggle to capture the mind share
of the target group is a warfare. Advertising and marketing should take note
8
Source: Dhaleta, S. K. (2012, February 20). Ad spends grow by 8%: PitchMadison report. Pitch.
Page No. 39
Unit 2
Page No. 40
Unit 2
Activity 1
Compare the amount of spending on advertising by companies in India in
1990 with that in 2012. List the reasons for differences in such spending.
2.3.11 Government control on ads
In spite of truly huge liberalisation and globalisation, India remains
government controlled. There is still a ban on advertising of alcoholic drinks
and tobacco products.
Innovative advertising and promotion will be required, and it has been going
on for a decade at least. Sponsoring of sports, visual and performing arts,
culture and music events, adopting schools and childrens programmes,
public donation of high visibility and corporate social responsibility projects
are some of the ways to keep the brand name of these two product groups
in front of the consumers. In addition, there is the phenomenon called
surrogate advertising, where products that are forbidden from advertising
are promoted through another product of the same brand, using the brand
image and advertising the forbidden product.
India also has a ban on advertising of ethical products like prescription
drugs, hospital facilities and professional services such as medical doctors,
lawyers, etc. (This also includes advertising services because selfadvertisement can damage the consumers judgement.) Yet, these are vital
and lifesaving services and the consumer has the right to know what is
available to him/her. If allowed soon, they need highly technical and
responsible presentation in the media through advertising.
2.3.12 Power of vernacular languages
There are over 17 official languages and 4,000 dialects in India. In the last
century, advertising was done in English. Campaigns were written in English
and then translated into respective state languages, often with indifferent
accuracy and result. However, this is not the case anymore. Partly fuelled
by the explosion of regional language media print, radio and television
alike India is today proud of her multilingual culture, and she demands to
be catered to in regional languages. This shift is not patriotism- or culturedriven but market-driven. The natives now have the big time money power,
like in rural and semi-rural regions, and not the minuscule English speaking
city folks.
Sikkim Manipal University
Page No. 41
Unit 2
Page No. 42
Unit 2
humour paid dearly and got poor or even negative response. India is a
young nation today and the youth do not mind laughing at them, because
they are more confident and feel good about them. Humour makes an
instant emotional connect with the reader or viewer and it is totally classless.
There are several examples of brands such as Fevicol, Mentos, Chlor-Mint,
Center Shock, Amaron, Sprite, etc., that have created a likeability for
themselves through the successful use of humour in advertising.
However, other ways of making customers happy are also emerging. How to
make the consumer happy, get him/her to love your product and enable
him/her to become your brand advocate is the marketing challenge now.
Offhand, there are some basic, true-and-tried ways to achieve customer
happiness. They are loyalty programmes like frequent flyer schemes, hotel
gold cards, Shoppers Stops First Citizen, Jet Airways Jet Privilege, Taj
Mahal Hotels Inner Circle and Renaissances Prestige. Even Crossword
book store has Book rewards, each having gradation within, like silver,
gold and platinum, to prevent brand switch. Basic loyalty to the brand is
rewarded with discounts, proactively building relationships to get their
message across.
The pioneers in the field feel that, at the end of the day, a birthday card or a
bottle of wine in the hotel room gives the regular customer not just food or
return on investment, but a happiness quotient. These are long-term
experiential investments and more rewarding to the service industries than a
fat bill.
2.3.15 Good advertising is more than hard sell
To achieve these new modes of subtle communications, it is essential to
connect emotionally with customers to understand their deep emotional
needs and preferences, or may be insecurities and fears. Joy, hope, faith,
desire, longing and confidence are only some of the ways to connect. And
they are eternal in their appeal.
These are not new concepts. Marketing folks have used these concepts
since time immemorial. Only the form and media have changed recently and
advertising is moving with the times. Innovative thinking, connecting
emotionally and being absolutely honest with the customer are the core
concepts that remain evergreen in handling human relationships and
contribute to good advertising.
Sikkim Manipal University
Page No. 43
Unit 2
2.4 Summary
Let us recapitulate the important concepts discussed in this unit:
Advertising, in every country, has to cater to its people and their
environment, be it emotional, cultural or financial and this is an everchanging scene, needing constant adjustments.
The task is even more difficult in India because of its enormous
geographical spread and diversity of nature, for example, woollens need
not be advertised in warmer states of south India. Similarly, rainwear has
a better market in east India where it rains heavily rather than in
Rajasthan.
Good advertising requires the ability to see the buyer as a wellintegrated real person and not statistics made of marketing data. Once
the background of the person is understood, creating a good advertising
campaign gets easier. Here, we have mentioned only some of the
factors that influence the buying decisions of a person.
The real learning is that these factors are not static. They keep changing
all the time, and with it changes their combined power to influence the
buyers mind. Therefore, it is a good idea to start watching and storing
information on these economic and cultural issues through wide reading
of newspapers, financial magazines and cultural niche journals.
Page No. 44
Unit 2
2.5 Glossary
Search Engine Optimisation: technique used to increase the amount of
visitors to a website by obtaining a high-ranking placement in the search
results page
Hoardings: a large board used for displaying advertising posters
Wholesale Price Index: an index showing the rises and falls of prices of
manufactured goods
Disposable income: amount of income left to an individual (which is
available for spending and saving) after taxes have been paid
Heydays: peak days, prime time
2.7 Answers
Self Assessment Questions
1. True
2. True
3. True
4. True
5. consumers in India
6. disposable
7. True
8. traditional
Terminal Questions
1. Consumers are looking out for better quality and higher priced products
within each category. This is backed by high advertising pressure. Refer
section 2.2.1 for further details.
2. Industrial growth, seasons, Disposable income, Employment, Inflation
and consumer basket, Economic cycle, Consumer mind share, spending
Sikkim Manipal University
Page No. 45
Unit 2
Page No. 46