Bahishti Zewar Proofs

9/30/2015
Home
BahishtiZewarMUSTREADAshrafAliThanwi
Fiqh
Articles
Islamophobes
Dawah
UserRating:
/40
Poor
Best Rate
CreatedonTuesday,31December201300:08
WrittenbyAbdulBaseer
Hits:6912
Send
Like
35
Tweet
Share
Share
Bismillahhirrahmaan
nirraheem,
BahishtiZewarisoneofthefamousbooksofdeobandiswrittenontheissuesofWomen.Theauthorofthis
bookisMolanaAshrafAlithanwisahabandhewasoneofthepioneersofdeoband.Deobandisrecommend
thisbooktoprobablyeverydaughter,motherorsisterthatexistamongstdeobandis.Theyhighlypraisethis
bookandtheyregarditasoneofthetopandreliablebookonhanafifiqh.Thereisgoodinthisbookwithouta
doubt.ForexampleAshrafAlithanwisahabwritesabouttheimportanceoffollowingQuranandSunnah:
http://www.systemoflife.com/articles/taqleed/2000060bahishtizewarmustreadashrafalithanwi
1/28
9/30/2015
Translation:"ToActupontheHukmofQuranandHadeeth:TheProphetsalAllahualeyhiwasallamsaid:
"Whoeveradherestomysunnahwhenmyummahiscorrupt,(he)willhavetherewardofa100martyrs".and
theprophetsalAllahualeyhiwasallamsaid:IamleavingbehindtwothingsamongyouYouwillnevergo
astrayifyouholdfasttothem:OneisthebookofAllaahwhichmeansQuran,thesecondistheprophet's(s.a.w)
sunnahwhichmeanshadeeth."BahishtiZewarPart7QuranoHadeeskeHukmperChalna
Thisreferenceproves2thingsA)Ifweabidebythe
Quranandsunnah,wewillnevergoastrayandAlhamdulillahthis
dawahofcallingpeopletoQruanandSunnahisonlygivenanddone
byAhlulhadeethbutunfortunatelyalotofdeobandibrotherobjectto
thisdawahforuselessreasons.B)SunnahmeansHadeeth.Some
deobandibrothersobjectthatAhlulhadeethdoesnotmeanAhlu
SunnahbecausehadeethdoesnotmeanSunnah.Thisreferenceis
enoughfordeobandibrothersasaresponsetotheirobjection.
InAnotherplaceAshrafAliThanwisahbwrites:
2/28
9/30/2015
Translation:"AllahandhisRasoolsalAllahualeyhiwasallamhaveshownallthematterspertainingtodeenin
theQuranandHadith.Tobringsomenewthingintothedeenisnotpermitted.Suchnewthingsareknownas
bid'aat(innovations).AninnovationisaMajorsin."BahishtiZewarPart1,AqeedokaBayaanMasla22
Thisisexactlythedawah,aqeedahandmanhajofteAhlulhadeethbutalotofourdeobandibrothersoftodaydo
notadheretothisatallandopposeusfortheexactsamemessageasmentionedbyAshrafAlithanwisahb.
Theyarebyfarfromthisbeliefwhichisveryverydangerous,Allaahknowsbestbutihaveseenpeoplethanking
ImamAbuHanifarahimahullahforgivingthemtheCOMPLETESALAHbecausetheybelievethatthesalah
wasntcompleteatthetimeoftheprophets.a.w.Comingbackthepoint,Webelievethatthemattersofdeenare
completeinQuranandHadeethanditisnicetoseethetruthbeingtoldtotheawaambuttruthofthematteris
thateventhisbookitselfi.eBahishtizewarhassomanythingsthatarenotfromQuranandhadeeth.
BahishtiZewarcontainsissuesthatareoutright
Blaspheme,issuesthatcontradicttheSunnah,issuesthatareno
3/28
9/30/2015
wherefoundanywhereintheQuranandSunnahyettheyhave
beenmadeapartofdeen,thisbookcontainsinnovations,Xrated
stuffandmanymore.Ithasinnovationsandeveryinnovationis
misguidanceandmisguidanceleadstohellfire.Alotofour
deobandibrothersdonthavethisaqeedahandhencetheyindulge
invariousinnovationswhichyoucanseeintheotherreferences
thatihaveprovided.MolanaAshrafAlithanvihimselfsaysitsa
majorsinandyetthebookhassomanyinnovationsinitthat
havenothingtodowithQuranorhadeeth.
Idecidedtodothisarticleonlytoallowthepublictoopentheireyesandseetherealityofthisbook.
LetmemakeitclearthatmyintentionisnottohurtanyoneinshaAllahandyouarefreetoletmeknow
mymistakes.Iknowthatmajorityofthelaymanamongstdeobandiswontlikethisarticleonlydueto
theirloveforBahishtiZewarandAshrafAliThanwi,butItellyouinshaAllahthatbytheendof
thisarticleyouwillhavesomethingtothink.Onemustnotforgetthatourpriorityistofollowprophet
MuhammadsalAllahualeyhiwasallamandAllaahhasguaranteedJannahtousbyfollowingAllah
himselfandtheProphetsalAllahualeyhiwasallam.AshrafAlithanwisahbwillnotbebenefityouon
thedayofjudgementnorcanhedoyouanygoodinyourgrave.Mydutyistoonlyletyouknowthetruth
ofthisbooksoyoucangetridofthisdisturbingbookandgiveyourselvesanopportunitytostudythe
purebooksbasedonQuranandSahiHadeeth.MayAllaahhelpus,guideusandopenourheartsto
acceptthetruthfromQuranandSunnahandactuponit,Ameen.
IfIsayanythingcorrectinthisarticle,thenitisfromAllaah(subhanahuwataa'ala),andifIerred,then
thatisfrommeandshaytan.
Note:PagenumbersmayvaryfrompublishertopublishersoiwillinshaAllahonlymentionthepart,
headingandmaslanumbers.Theenglishtranslationofthisbookistremendouslyforgedtohidethe
reality.Theyhaventtranslatedagoodpartofthebookandonmanyocassionstheyhavetwistedthe
traslationSoiwillnotrelyingcompletelyonthetranslation.AnyonecancrosschecktheUrdureference
providedandcheckbacktheenglishtranslationtoknowtheforgeriesdoneoverthere.
ReturntoTop
ArticleContents
1)SevereInsulttotheQuranofAllaah
2)HowtoEnlargePrivatePartsRecipefromBahishtiZewarofAshrafAlithanwi
3)StepbyStepguidetoleavesalaah
4)RecipeforZina
5)InnovationsinWudhooA
4/28
9/30/2015
6)InnovationsinWudhooB
7)FourrakaatsunnatbeforetheFardofIsha:Absolutelyprooflessandbaseless
8)WomenShouldprayNaked
9)InnovationsinFuneralPrayerJanazah
10)ReverseWudhoo
11)AmazingMajorsins
12)ConfusiononUtteringintentions
13)WritingDuaonKafanwithfingersonthechest&forehead
1)SevereInsulttotheQuranofAllaah
Translation:LabourPain:Writethisaayahonapieceofpaper,wrapitinacleanclothandtieitontheleft
thighofthewomanorReaditonasweetandallowhertoeatit.InshaAllahthechildwillbedeliveredeasily.
TheAayahis:
BahishtiZewarPart9,JhaarrPhoonkKaBayaan
5/28
9/30/2015
ItriedalottofindthetranslationofthispartfromtheenglishtranslationofBahishtiZewarbutifailedand
couldntfinditanywhere.DeobandishavenottranslatedthispartandAllahknowsbest.Iamspeechlessabout
thetaweezbeingwrittenontheleftthighofawomanandthereaderiswiseenoughtorejectthisridiculousact
butIaskmybrothersandsistersthatadheretothisbooktopleasehelpmeincreasemyknowledgeforthesake
ofAllaahandtellmeifitsalrighttotiequranicaayahonthighsofwomen.
ThisblasphemoustaweezhasnothingtodowithQuran,sunnahorImamAbuHanifa(rahimahullah).Yetthis
bookisregardedasoneofthebestbooksonhanafifiqhandthisbooksaysallmatterspertainingtodeenare
mentionedinQuranandhadeethsoifthisisdeenthenitmustbesomewhereinQuranandhadeethbutitisnt.
2)HowtoEnlargePrivatePartsRecipefromBahishtiZewarof
AshrafAlithanwi
Translation:"Gotograveyardandbringback7bigants,killthemonebyoneandputtheminJasmineoilina
6/28
9/30/2015
bottlethenburythatbottleingoat'sdroppingfordayandnight.Nextdaytakeitoutandmixtheseants
properlyintheoil.Rubyourprivatepartwiththickclothuntilitisreddishthenmassagethisoilonitandleave
itfor20mins."BahishtiZewarPart11,ChandMutafarrikNuskhay
Nowcananydeobandionearthtellmeifhecanshowthistohismother,daughterorsister?Leaveasidethem,
wecantevenshowittomeneither.SuchshamelessnesswallahiandallthisisdoneinthenameofFIQHand
Masaailofwomen.IsthisQuran,SunnahorImamAbuhanifa'sfiqh?
ThereareothernonsenselikethisinBahishtiZewarbutthisoneisenough.
Thiswasneversupposedtobedeen..Howhavethesepeoplemadeamockeryofwhatwassupposedtobea
revelationfromAllaah.WeasmuslimsarguewithChristiansandshowthemtheXratedstoriesinthebiblebut
whataboutthis?
3)StepbyStepguidetoleavesalaah
7/28
9/30/2015
Translation:
"Masla9)Afterstandingupfromruku,apersondidnotrecite:SamiAllahulimanHamidaRabbanaLakal
HamdORinrukuhedidnotrecite:SubhaanaRabbiAlAdheemORinsajdahhedidnotrecite:Subhaana
RabbiAlAlaaORinthelastsittingpositionhedidnotreciteduroodafterattahiyyaat.Theninalltheabove
caseshissalaatwillbevalid,butitwillbecontrarytotheSunnah.Similarly,ifafterthedurood,hedidnotread
anydua,butmadesalaamimmediatelyafterrecitingdurood,thentoohissalaatwillbevalidbutcontrarytothe
Sunnah.
Masla10)ItisSunnahtoraisethehandsatthetimeofmakingintention.Ifonedoesnotraisehishands,itwill
stillbeproperbutcontrarytotheSunnah.
Masla17)IfapersondoesnotreadSurahFaatihahinthelattertworakaatsbutmerelyreadsSubhaanAllah
threetimes,eventhenhissalaatwillbeproper.However,itispreferabletoreciteSurahFaatihah.Andifhe
readsnothingatallandmerelyremainssilent,eventhenthereisnoharmandthesalaatwillbeproper.
BahishtiZewarPart2,NamaazParrhnaykaTareeqa(Methodofperformingsalaah).
SubhanAllah,thisistheirmethodofperformingfardsalaahandtheydebateusonRafayadain,sayingameen
8/28
9/30/2015
loudlyandrecitingsurahalfaatihabehindtheimam.
StepbyStepGuideonhowtoleavenamaaz:
a)FirstleaveSamiAllaahuLimanHamida
b)ThenleaveSubhaanaRabbiAlAdheem
c)ThenleaveSubhaanaRabbiAlA'laa
d)Thenleaveoutduroodshareef
e)Thenleavetheduaafterduroodshareef
f)Andthenfinallyleavesurahfaatehaaswell.
Thebottomline,ifyoudontreadanythinginyoursalaah,stillitwillbeproperandcorrect.SubhanAllaah,this
isfardsalaahandiwonderwhatsleftbehindtoreciteinSalaah??
Heevensaysthatthisis"contrarytothesunnah"butheforgotthebasicusoolthatAllaahdoesnotaccepta
formofworshipifitsnotinaccordancetoQuranandSunnah.TheydebateusonRafayadain,ameenbiljahr,
recitingsurahalfatehabehindtheimaam...Whatstheuseofallthesedebateswhensuchrecipesaregivento
makeamockeryoftheworshipofAllaah?
SomedeobandissaythisisaboutapersonthatisnewtoIslamordoesntknowtheduas.Thatisnotthecase
hereatallandnorisitmentioned.TheissueisaboutrecitingandNOTreciting,ReadingandNOTReading.It
isntaboutsomeoneUnabletoreciteORCannotrecite.IfsomeoneisnewtoIslamandifheisunabletorecite
anythingthenAllaahwillinshaAllahaccepthissalaahevenifhedoesntknowanythingandstandsforprayer.
Further,thereferencestatesthattheprophets.a.wraisedhishandswhilemakingintentions.Thisisabuhtaan
onRasoolAllahsalAllahualeyhiwasallambecausetheprophetsalAllahualeyhiwasallamdidnotraisehis
handsatthetimeofmakingtheintentionforsalaahasstated.TheEnglishtranslationofBahishtiZewarhas
mistranslatedthispartas:
ItisSunnahtoraisethehandsATTHETIMEOFCOMMENCINGSALAAT
ThisisafailedattempttohidethetruthwhichdeobandisalwaysdototheonesthatCannotunderstandorread
urdu.TheyhaveforgedtranslationsoftheirownonoccasionstohidethetruthfromtheEnglishspeaking
public.
9/28
9/30/2015
Iaskmydeobandibrothersagain..whichquranicaayahorhadeethorsayingofimamabuhanifamentionsall
this?
4)RecipeforZina
Translation:"Apersonhadsexualintercoursewithawomanaftermistakingherforhiswife.Hewillhaveto
givehermahrulmithlaswell,andthisintercoursewithherwillnotberegardedasadultery(zind)norwillthere
beanysin.Infact,ifthewomanfallspregnant,thelineageofthechildwillbeinorder.Itwillnotbetaintedand
itisnotpermissibletolabelthechildasbeingabastard.Themomentthemanrealizesthatthisisnothiswife,
heshouldimmediatelyseparatehimselffromheranditwillnotbepermissibleforhimtocontinuewiththe
intercourse.Itisalsowdjibonthiswomantoobservetheiddah.Itisnotpermissibleforhertostaywithher
husbandortoengageinsexualintercoursewithhim."BahishtiZewarPart4,Mahrkabayaanmasla16
10/28
9/30/2015
Mydeobandibrothersandsisters,iaskyouforthesakeofAllaahtousesomebasiccommonsenseonthis
reference.WetakethefollowingteachingsfromthisrulingofAshrafalithanwiinbahishtizewar:
a)Apersonismistakenandhassexwithsomeoneelse'swife.ThisiscalledZinainanylanguagebutthisbook
'BahishtiZewar'saysitshouldnotbecalledZina.
b)HewillhavetogiveherMahrulmithlaswellwhichisapartofNikaah.
c)ThechildthatisbornwiththiszinashallnotbecalledHaraami(Bastard).
d)Thenwhenthemanrealisesthatsheisntmywife,thenheshouldstophavingsexwithherandleaveher.
e)ThewomanhowevermustnowobserveIddahandshecannotgobacktoherhusbandwithouttheIddahafter
havingdonezina.
Howonearthcansomeonehavingintercoursewithsomeone'swifenotbetermedasZina?Howonearthis
MahrulMithlapplicableandgiventotheonethatyouhadzinawith?Andhowonearthisthatchildbornnot
illegitimate?Whatshallicallthis....?IcanthelpbutcallthisarecipeforZina.Whatwasthewomandoingall
thistime?Wasshemistakenaswell?
Onebrother,mayAllaahguidehim,hetoldme"YOUDIDNTPRESENTANYTHINGFROMQURANAND
SUNNAHAGAINSTTHIS.THEREISWISDOMBEHINDTHISFIQH!!WHATIFTHISTAKESPLACEINAN
AREAWHERETHERE2COUPLESLIVING?!!"etcetc
Iwaswonderingthefollowingharshresponsebutididntgiveittohimbackthenbutnowimforcedtoshareit
coztheremightbepeoplelikehimreadingthisrightnow.SosomeonewanttojustifythisactofZinathenjust
putmeintheplaceofthat"mistakenperson"andputyourmotherinplaceofthatwoman.Orjustsupposethat
themistakenpersonisyourveryownbrotherandthewomanisurwifeormother.Willyouthengoaround
justifyingthis...?
ImverysorryimharshbutemotionscantbecontrolledwhenthesethingsarebeingattributedtoIslamwhenas
theyhavenothingtodowithIslam.ThisbookBahishtizewarisbeingdistributedinourwomenbythepeople
thathaveneverbotheredreadingitthemselves.They'vejustheardacertainsectarianmullahpraisingthebook
becausehiselderwroteit.Andhencewebeingtheblindfollowersthatweare,wejusttakethebookandsay
'WOWWHATABOOK'whereasithasabsolutelynoreferencefromwhereitstakingthesefatwasandmasaail.
Allthisisdoneinthenameof"Hanafifiqh".ThisdirthasnothingtodowithIslamorimamabuhanifa(rah)
andwerejectthisfabricateddirt.
MybrothersandsistersthisisnotfromanyQuranicaayatoranyhadeethinthetreasuresofahadeethtodothis
practiceandimsureinshaAllahthatthisisntevenmentionedbyImamAbuHanif(rah).
11/28
9/30/2015
5)InnovationsinWudhooA
Translation:Whilemakingwudu,wordlytalkshouldbeavoided.Instead,BismillahandtheKalimashouldbe
readonwashingeachandeverypart
Afterhavingperformedthewudu,Surahalqadrshouldberecited.[BahishtiZewar,Wuzooka
Bayaan,Maslano.9andmaslano.13]
Brothersandsisters,theprophetsalAllahualeyhiwasallamnevertaughthisUmmahanythingtoberecited
duringWudhoonordidhetaughtustoreciteSurahAlQadrafterwudhoo.
12/28
9/30/2015
TheProphets.a.wtaughtustosay"Bismillah"beforeWudhoo,thereisnoDuaduringtheWudhoo,thereafter
onehascompleteddoingWudhoohemustsay:
OR
OR
ThereisnosuchthingasRecitingSurahAlQadrorrecitingbismillahandKalimauponwashingeachandevery
partduringwudhoo.ItsnotintheQuran,sunnahoranywherebyImamabuhanifarahimahullah.
MayAllahguideusallandmayAllahprotectusfromeverykindsofinnovations(Bidat)inIslam.Ameen.
TheProphets.a.wsaid:"everyinnovationismisguidanceandallmisguidanceisintheHellfire."Sunanan
Nasaa'ee(1/224)
6)InnovationsinWudhooB
13/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarPart1WuzooKa
BayaanMasla4
Translation:"AfterhavingmadeWudhooifonehasadoubtthataparthasnotbeenwashedbuthedoesnot
knowexactlywhichpartitwas.Inordertogetridofthisdoubt,heshouldwashhisleftfoot."BahishtiZewar
Part11,HadaseAsgharYaaniBayWuzooHonaykiHaalatkeAhkaam,Maslano.6
Mybrothersandsisters,thisisnotfromanyQuranicaayahoranyhadeethinthetreasuresofahadeethandim
sureinshaAllahthatthisisntevenmentionedbyImamAbuHanifa(rahimahullah).Fromwhereisthanwisahb
gettingthesethings?
7)FourrakaatsunnatbeforetheFardofIsha:Absolutelyproofless
andbaseless
14/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarPart2SunnatAur
NafalNamaazoKaBayaan
Translation:Ateshatime,itisbetterandmustahabtofirstofferfourrakaatsofSunnah,thenthefour
rakaatsoffard[BahishtiZewar,Part2,SunnataurNafalNamazokabayaanMaslano.5]
Alotofourbelovedbrothersanddearsistershavemade4rakaatsunnahbeforeIshaasapartofDeenandthey
callitSunnahorratherSunnatGhairMuwakkada.WeknowthatSunnatGhairmuwakkadaisthesunnahwhich
theprophets.a.wdidntdoregularly.Thatmeansifthese4rakaatareSunnatGhairMuwakkadathenSurely
thereshouldbejustoneproofatleasttoshowthattheprophetsalAllahualyhiwasallamprayedthese4rakaat
butwallahithereisnotasinglehadeethwithSahiorHasanchainwhichevenindicatesthattheprophetsal
Allahualyhiwasallamoffered4rakaatsunnahbeforeIshafard.
MolanaYusufBinoriwritesinMaarifusSunanSharhJaamiTirmidhi,Pagenumber115that:
15/28
9/30/2015
MaarifAlSunan
Roughtranslation:Afteralotofhardwork,Icouldnotfindanyhadeethinthehadeethbookswhich
mentions4rakaahbeforeIsha
ThenonPage116hehaswrittenthat:
Roughtranslation:Thehanafibooksarefilledwiththementionof4rakaatbeforeIshasoMaybethereis
proofforitinthebooksthatareAimatnalMakhtootaorthebooksthathavebeenwasted.
ImunabletotranslateAimatnalmakhtootafornowsopleasepardonme.
Muftitaqiusmanitriedtojustifythese4rakaatwithaproofofhisbutAlhamdulillahattheendhemakeitclear
thattheprophets.a.wdidntdeterminetheserakaatandthatsmywholepoint.Hesaysattheendofhisfatwa
that:
However,itshouldbeborneinmindthatthese4rakatsshouldnotbetakenasdeterminedby
Nabi(SallallahuAlaihiWasallam),norasaspecificSunnah.
http://www.askimam.org/public/question_detail/15881
Withthisstatementhehasbasicallydismissedthepositionofnearlyallofthehanafifiqhwhichholdstheview
16/28
9/30/2015
thattheprophets.a.wprayed4rakaatsunnahghairmuwakkada.
However,Idohavedoubtsoverhisattempttojustifythis4rakaatwiththehadeethofSahiAlBukhari.Thelink
providedsays:
OnthebasisofthisHadith,MuslimJuristshaveinferredthatitismustahab(desirable)to
performsomeprayer,naflorsunnah,beforeeveryobligatoryprayer,exceptbeforeMaghrib,
accordingtotheHanafiMazhab.
Youcanseehowheaddedtheexceptionbeforemaghrib.ThehadeethofSahiAlBukhariwhichmuftiTaqi
UsmaniusedisnarratedbyAbdullahbinMughaffalAlMuzani.NowthesameSahabinarratesanothersimilar
hadeethwhichismentionedinSahiAlBukhari.
Chapter:The(optional)Salat(prayer)beforethe(compulsory)Maghribprayers,Hadeeth#1183
NarratedAbdullhAlMuzani:
TheProphet,said,Perform(anoptional)Salat(prayer)beforethe(compulsory)Maghrib
prayers.He(repeateditthrice)andthethirdtime,hesaid,Whoeverwantstoofferit,candoso,lest
thepeopleshouldtakeitasaSunnah.
Theexactsamesahabimakesitclearthatthereisanafalprayerbeforemaghribsalahandhedidnotgiveany
exceptiontomaghribSalaahbutmuftitaqiusmaniusedahadeethnarratedbytheexactsamesahabiandgives
anexceptiontothemaghribsalaah.ItslikeJustifyingsomethingthathasnoproofanywhereandleavingout
somethingthathasprooffromthesameproofthatonehaspresented.Thenafalbeforemaghribsalaahhas
itsdaleelandthe4rakaatSunnatghairmuwakkadahasnodaleel.Thereisnoexceptionformaghribsalaahin
thishadeethatallandthedaleelprovidedbyhimappliestothenafalbeforemaghribsalaahaswell.Itdoesnot
haveanyexceptionformaghribsalaaheitherwhichnegatesthemajorityoftheposition
ofhanafifiqh.Allaahknowsbest.
8)WomenShouldprayNaked
17/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarPart2NamazKiSharto
KaBayaanMasla6
Translation:Iftheentireclothingisimpure,ormostofitisimpure,i.elessthanaquarterofitispureand
thebalanceofitisimpure,theninsuchacaseonecouldeitherofferthesalahwhilewearingthoseimpure
clothesorREMOVETHECLOTHESANDOFFERTHESALAHWHILENAKED.However,itispreferableto
offertheSalahwiththeimpureclothes.BahishtiZewarPart2,NamazkiSharokaBayaan,Maslano.6
Thebrothersthatadheretothisbook,theysaytheirImaminPeripherals(Furoo'Masaail)isImamAbuHanifa,
theysaytheproofofa(deobandi)muqallidisonlythesayingofhisImam(AbuHanifa)andthatBahishtiZevar
isOneofthebestbooksonHanafifiqh.Howevertheabovereferenceofwomenprayingsalaahwhilenakedis
notmentionedanywherebyImamAbuHanifa(rahimahullah).Thisisnothanafifiqh,thisisnotwhatImam
AbuHaneefaeversaidoreverwrote.ThisissueisalsonotmentionedanywhereintheQuranandSunnah.
ItshouldbenotedhoweverthatImamshaf'eehasmentionedasimilarfatwainHisKitaabulUmmbutitisnot
endorsedandthemajorityoftheUlamadonotadheretothatfatwaofImamShaf'ee.
ShaykhAlIslaamIbnTaymiyyahrahimahullahsays:
"Whatifapersoncannotfindanythingbutanimpuregarment?Itwassaidheshouldpraynaked,orheshould
praywearingitandrepeattheprayer,orheshouldprayinitandnotrepeattheprayer,andthisisthemost
18/28
9/30/2015
correctofthescholarlyviews.."IbnTaymiyyah[Majmoo'Alfataawa22/34,35]
DeobandiulamadonotconsiderImamShafeeasproofnordotheygiveaniotaofimportancetohim.Ifthey
hadgivensomeimportancetoImamShafee,ImamMaalikorImamAhmadbinHanbalrahimahullahthen
surelytheywouldneverhaveobjectedtotheirAqeedahofTawheedorviewssuchasRafaYadain(Raisingofthe
hands)beforeRukooandafterRukooorsayingAameenloudlyorprayingSurahAlFatehabehindtheImam.
Allofthese3imamsdidrafayadainbeforerukooandafterrukooastheyregardeditastheSunnahofthe
prophetsalAllahualeyhiwasallambutdeobandisinreturnattacktheonesthatdorafayadain,theyridicule
them,mockthem,makefunofthemandtheytrytorefutetheminvainaswell.
SothemostcorrectviewisthatOneshouldprayinitandnotrepeattheprayer.Allaahknowsbest.Offering
salaatnakedisnotfromhanafifiqhorImamAbuHanifaneitherisitanywherementionedinQuranand
Sunnah.
9)InnovationsinFuneralPrayerJanazah
BahishtiZewarPart11JanaazayKe
NamazKeMasaail
19/28
9/30/2015
Translation:"TheSunnahandMustahabMethodofJanazahsalaatisasfollows:Thedeceasedshouldbe
placedinthefrontandtheImamshouldstandinlinewithhischest.Everyoneshouldmakethefollowing
intention:

"IintendofferingtheJanaazahsalaatforthepleasureofAllahTa'alaandasaduaforthedeceased."Bahishti
ZewarPart11,JanaazaykiNamazkeMasaail,Maslano.13
AshrafAliThanwisahbmentionsthe"SUNNAHANDMUSTAHABMETHOD"ofSalatulJanaazahbutthenhe
startsoffwithanintentionthatisnowherementionedinAnySunnah.Therearenowordsofintentionfor
salaatuljanaazahoranyformofsalaahanywhereintheQuranorhadeeth.AshrafAlithanwiincludedthisas
thesunnahwhereasitisnotthesunnahbyanymeanswhatsoever.
10)ReverseWudhoo
20/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarPart1WuzooKa
BayaanMasla4
Translation:Sunnahistomakewuduexactlyashasbeenmentionedabove.butifanyonealtersorreverses
theprocedureofwudhu,eg.bywashingthefeetfirst,thenmakingmasah,andthenwashingthehands,and
thereafterwashingtheface,oralterstheprocedureinanyotherwayThenwuduwillstillberegardedas
complete.However,itwillnotbeconsideredtobeinaccordancewiththesunnah,andthereisalwaysthefearof
havingsinned.Similarly,Ifthelefthandortheleftfootiswashedfirst,wuduwillbecompleted,butitwillbe
contrarytobeingmustahab.BahishtiZewarPart1,WuzookaBayaaan,Maslano.4
OncetherewasoneofourbrotherswhojustaskedadeobandibrotherhowitistoperformWudutheotherway
around?(asmentionedinBahishtiZewar).TheDeobandibrothergaveanemotionalanswerthat"Thisisthe
WudhooofShias".TheDeobandibrotherdidntknewthatAshrafAliThanwihadthesamereverseprocedure
ofWudooinhisbook.Khair,AllaahcompletedHisDeen1400yearsbackandOneofTheCrucialCriteriasof
AllaahacceptingourA'maalisthatithastobeaccordancetotheSunnah.IfitsnotinaccordancetotheSunnah
thennomatterhowsugarcoatedtheactlookslike,Allaahdoesnotacceptit.Thisreversemethodisnowherein
thedeenofAllaahandthisisaninnovationinthedeenofAllaah.TheProphets.a.wsaid:
"everyinnovationismisguidanceandallmisguidanceisintheHellfire."SunananNasaa'ee(1/224)
Somedeobandisjustifythisbyreferringtothevariantofmethodofwudhoowhichtheprophets.a.wdidon
21/28
9/30/2015
occasions.TheyalsoquotesomeulamasayingthatthesequenceofWudhooisntnecessary.
Wetellthemthatthesemethodsoftheprophets.a.whavenothingtodowiththeforged"ReverseWudoo".
RathertheyaretheVariousmethodsofdoingwudoofromtheprophets.a.w.Alhamdulillahourmadhabas
AhlulhadeethisnottoholdontoOnemethodfromtheProphets.a.wanddismissothersbylabellingitwitha
sect.WeaccepteverySunnahthatisprovenfromtheprophets.a.w.Weacceptthevariantmethodsbutwedont
fabricateamethodofourownratherwesticktothevariantmethodswhichtheprophets.a.wdidtoshowus
thatthesequenceisntnecessary.
11)AmazingMajorsins
BahishtiZewarPart1BaazBarray
BarrayGunaah
BahishtiZewarPart1,BaazBarraybarrayGunaahjinkekarnewaalayperbohtsakhtiaayihai.
Thetitleofthissectiontranslatedintoenglishmeans"SomeMajorSinsregardingwhichsevere
22/28
9/30/2015
warningshavebeenmentioned".InthissectionAshrafAlithanwisahbmadealistedsuchmajorsins
andinthislistheincluded:
a)ToComplainorlistentocomplain.
b)Tobejoyfuluponriseofpricesofgood.
c)Somewomenplayandgirlsplay"Budbudkeguttay"oranyothergame.ThisisalsoGambling.
Mybrothersandsistersthese3actsareincludedinBahishtiZevar'slistofMajorSins.BahishtiZevaris
supposedtobeabookofHanafifiqh.Ifailtorealiseastohowarethesethingsevenlistentobesinsandiwould
lovetoknowanyQuranicAayahoranyauthentichadeethoranyauthenticreferencetoImamAbuHanifaabout
these3thingstobeMajorsins.AtleastinshaAllahwecanhavecluethatComplainingorlisteningtoaComplain,
expressingjoyontheincreaseofpriceofgoodsorgirlsplayingareMajorsins.InshaAllahiwillappreciateyour
timeandefforttohelpmeunderstandbutfornowidontthinkthesethingsareanywhereneartobecalledasin
anywhereinQuran,SunnahorAnySayingofImamAbuHanifarahimahullah.
Isitasintocomplainandtolistentoit?
CheckthislinkinshaAllahtohaveanideaofhowmuchthesahabacomplainedandhowmuchtheprophetsal
Allahualeyhiwasallamheardtheircomplainsonvariousissues:www.sunnah.com/search/complain
Isitasinifthemarketvalueofmygoodsareincreasedandiexpressjoyoveritsoicanearnafewmorerupees?
Istillrememberthatmydearfriendwasworkinginautilitystoreandhewouldbehappythedaythepricesgot
increasedbarely5rupeesormoreonacertainRunningproduct.Itwouldhelphimearnmoreandpayoffhis
rentseasily.Sobasicallythepoorguywascommittingamajorsin?
Ifsomegirlsplay"budbudkeguttay"oranyothergame,isthatgambling?
Ihonestlycannottranslatebudbudkeguttaysopleasepardonmeformyshortcomingsbutifgirlsplayany
game...isthatgambling?
Note:TheenglishtranslationofBahishtiZewarhasforgedthetranslationofthesewordsandtheyhavetranslateditas
follows:
Tocomplainagainstsomeone,ortohearsuchacomplaint.
Toexpressjoyontheriseandinflationofthevalueofcommoditiesorgoods.
Togamble.Somewomenandgirlsplaycertaingameswithstakesonthem.Thisisalsoakindofgambling.
Thisisanabsolutelyfalsetranslationandanyonethatcanunderstandandreadurdu,hecanseeitforitself.
23/28
9/30/2015
12)ConfusiononUtteringintentions
BahishtiZewarPart2NiyyatKarneKaBayaan
Translation:"Itisnotnecessarytomakeaverbalintention.IfapersonthinksinhisheartthatIamreading
thefardofZuhrfortoday,orifitisaSunnah,thenIamreadingtheSunnahofzuhrthenthiswillbesufficient.
Allthoselengthyintentionswhicharepopularamongthepeoplearenotnecessaryatall.
Ifsalaatofseveraldayshasbeenmissedthenoneshouldalsospecifythedayanddatewhenmakingthe
intention..
Ifheismakingqadaforseveralmonthsoryears,heshouldalsospecifythemonthandyearandsay:Iam
offeringtheqadaoffajrsalaatofaparticulardayinaparticularmonthandinaparticularyear"Bahishti
ZewarPart2,Niyyatkarnekabayaan.
24/28
9/30/2015
Scholarshaveagreedthatintentionisessentialconditionforanyworshippingacttobeaccepted.RasoolAllah
salAllahualeyhiwasallamsaid:"Deedsdependuponintentions,andeverypersongetsbutwhathehas
intended..."[SahiBukhari,SahiMuslim].Ihavecollectedbasically2pointsfromthesectionof"Niyyatka
bayaan"fromBahishtiZevar.Thequestionhereisnotabouttheintentionbutitisabout"UTTERING"the
intentionverballylike"Niyyatkartahoon4rakaatfarzmoomerakaabakitarafetcetc".
TheMaslano.1asstatedbyMolanathanviisveryrightwithoutadoubt.Theplaceofintentionistheheart,not
thetongue.Thereisnoneedfortheverbalintentiontobemadeforsalaah.TheprophetsalAllahualeyhi
wasallamdidntteachthistousnorwasitdonebythesahaba.Nothingisprovenaboutthisfamousverbal
intentionfromQuranandSunnahatall.
Butthenalmostalloftheremainingsectionof"Niyyatkabayaan"fromBahishtiZevarisfullofintentions,what
tosayorhowtoutteretcetc.Ijustsharedonereferencei.eMaslano.6togiveanexample.Allthesewordsfor
intentionsandexampleshavenothingtodowithQuranandSunnah.TheyarenttaughttousintheQuran,nor
aretheyanywherepresentinthesacredSahiAhadeethofRasoolAllahsalAllahualyhiwasallam.
ShaikhulIslamibnTaymiyyahrahimahullahthrowslightonthisissueofverbalintention:
http://www.islamqa.com/en/ref/13337
Alsosomereferencesfromthehanafi,shafi,hanbaliandmaalikischoolofthoughts:
http://www.ahlalhdeeth.com/vbe/showthread.php?t=133
AllamaIbnHammaam,AllamaIbnAlQayyimandAllamaIbnbaazhavealsoagreedanddeclaredtheverbal
intentiontobeaninnovation.
UtteringtheintentionverballyisdefinetelynotfromtheSunnahanditoughttobeavoided.Itshouldbedonein
theheartasstatedbytheoverwhelmingmajorityoftheUlama.
13)WritingDuaonKafanwithfingersonthechest&forehead:
25/28
9/30/2015
BahishtiZewarPart11JanaazayKe
MutafarrikMasaail
Translation:"ItispermissibletowriteadualikeEhadNaamaonthekafanofthemayyatjustbymovingthe
fingerswithoutusingapenORbismillahirrahmaanirraheemonhischestortheKalma"LailaahailAllah
MuhammadurRasoolullah"onhisforehead(bymovingthefingers),however,thispracticehasnoprooffrom
anysahihhadith.Therefore,thispracticeshouldnotberegardedassunnahormustahab".BahishtiZewar
Part9,JanaazaykeMutafarrikMasaailno.13
Thanwisahbhimselfsaysthatthismethodofwritingkalmaorbismillahisnotinanysahihhadeethnorisit
mustahabyethesaysitispermissible.Thanwisahbpreviouslysaidthatallmatterspertainingtodeenare
mentionedinQuranandHadeeth.SoifthisisapartofdeenthenwhichQuranicaayahorhadeethisusedto
justifythis??
None.
Therearemanymanyotherreferencesbutiwillendmyarticleoverhere.Iaskthereaderstopleasethinkover
thepointsihavementioned.MyintentionisinshaAllahtocallyoutoQuranandSunnah,idontintendtohurt
youbutexposingthetruthismyduty.Ifihaveerredthenyouhavetherighttocorrectmebutifiamrightthen
26/28
9/30/2015
itisObligatoryuponyoutocorrectyourselfaccordingtoQuranandSunnah.ByAllahweaskyoutocorrect
youraffairsaccordingtoQuranandSunnah,ifyoursectorthanwisahbismoredeartoyouthennothingwill
haveaneffectonyou.butifAllaahorhisprophetsalAllahualeyhiwasallamorthedeenofAllaharemore
importantthenyouwilldefinetelythinkofcomingtotherightpathofQuranandSunnahwhichisnothingbut
thepathofAhlulhadeeth.IntheendiaskAllahtoforgivemyshortcomings.IaskAllahtoaccepttheseefforts,
Ameen.
BahishtiZewarbyAshrafAliThanwiisnotabookforanymanorwoman.Allahknowsbest.
Deoband
hanafifiqh
<PreviousArticleInshallah:DebatebetweenIbnalMubarakandahlalkufa
NextArticleInshallah:DeobandRejectSahabaSayings>
Newernewsitems:
DebatebetweenIbnalMubarakandahlalkufa12/04/201520:37
Oldernewsitems:
DeobandRejectSahabaSayings18/09/201315:34
DeobandRejectsIjmaConsensus02/09/201302:29
DeobandProofs:AhlulHadeetharenotonlyMuhadditheen28/07/201321:49
MirzaGhulamAhmadQadianiwasHanafi07/07/201307:30
TaqleedProhibitedMuhadditheenwerenotMuqallidpart205/06/201311:40
Randomnewsitems:
TaqleedProhibited:100ProofsSalafusSaliheenwerenotMuqallideen07/05/201210:26
Read14226times
MirzaGhulamAhmadQadianiwasHanafi07/07/201307:30Read10613times
TaqleedProhibited:MuhadditheenwerenotMuqallidpart130/05/201316:00Read3497
times
ImamAbuDawoodwasnotaMuqallid13/12/201211:57Read2952times
DeobandrejectsImamAbuHanifainFiqh24/06/201212:28Read17603times
27/28
9/30/2015
Who'sOnline
Wehave57guestsandnomembersonline
DISCLAIMER::Copyrights20082014SystemofLife!ThiswebsiteDOESNOTbelongto
anypoliticaloranyparticularsectordenomination.Thecontentsonthiswebsitedonot
necessarilyreflecttheviewsofsystemoflife.com.Wearenotaffiliatedwithanyofthe
organizations.Itisanindependentsitewithoutanydirectorindirectlinktoanyofthe
organizations.Youarenotonlygivenpermission,butencouragedtocopy,printandotherwise
reproduceanddistributeinanyformat,articlesfromthiswebsitetoteachothersaboutIslam,
aswidelyaspossible.WebelievethatALLIslamicKnowledgeisPropertyofAllah,andassuch
itisourduty,asMuslimstospreadknowledge.Wejustaskthatyouractivityshouldbefor
spreadingAllahAlmighty'sTruthandnotformakingprofits.IfyouhaveanyqueryonIslam,
thenpleaseforwarditto:Thisemailaddressisbeingprotectedfromspambots.Youneed
JavaScriptenabledtoviewit.WeareNOTSCHOLARS.Wequoteopinions&fatwasof
Scholars&fromtheirbooks.IfyouwanttocontactaScholarthengohere:Islamqa,
AssimAlHakeem,IslamwebJazakallahKhayran(MayAllahrewardyouwithgooddeeds).
AssalamualaikumwaRahmatullahiWaBarkatahu(MayPeaceBlessings&MercyofAllahbe
onYou)
SearchIslamicArticlesbyCloudTagsInshallah
abudawudabuwalidaddarAhlulBidahAhlulhadeethAllahAboveArsh
AskingfromDead
Aqeedah
BareilvisbelowtheanklesBidahCreedDeoband
draggingDreamsFiqhForbiddengraveworshiphanafifiqhHanafischolarsHazirNazirHijabibnabdulbarr
ibndihyaibnhajaribnjareerIbnKathirIbnTamiyaIlmeGhayb
ImamAbuHanifaImamAbuShaamah
imammaalikIntercessionisbaalistegathaistigathaJaalHaqknowledgeofunseenLifeofIbnTaymiyyahmaaliki
scholarsMadhabmalikmalikaddarmarzooqmarzuqMawlidmilaad
Muhadditheen
MuqallidmuqallideenNajdiProphetofmercyProphetomnipresentqaahirahQadiyanisRamadan
SalafSalafiSalahSectsShaitanshiaShirkSufisSunnahTahirulQuadriTakfeer
taqlidTaraweeh
Taqleed
TawassulvisitinggravesWahdatulwajoodwaseelaWaseelahwasilaWeak
hadeethzawawi
28/28

Bahishti Zewar Proofs

Încărcat de

Informații document

Drepturi de autor

Formate disponibile

Partajați acest document

Partajați sau inserați document

Opțiuni de partajare

Vi se pare util acest document?

Este necorespunzător acest conținut?

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

Bahishti Zewar Proofs

Încărcat de

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

9/30/2015

S-ar putea să vă placă și