-EASUREMENTANDSTANDARDIZATIONPROTOCOLSFOR

ANTHROPOMETRYUSEDINTHECONSTRUCTIONOFANEW
INTERNATIONALGROWTHREFERENCE

-ERCEDESDE/NIS!DELHEID7/NYANGO*AN6ANDEN"ROECK7M#AMERON#HUMLEA

AND2EYNALDO-ARTORELLFORTHE7(/-ULTICENTRE'ROWTH2EFERENCE3TUDY'ROUP
!BSTRACT

+EYWORDS!NTHROPOMETRYGROWTHCURVESGROWTH

REFERENCESHEIGHTLENGTHMETHODSSKINFOLDWEIGHT

4HOROUGHTRAININGCONTINUOUSSTANDARDIZATIONANDCLOSE

MONITORINGOFTHEADHERENCETOMEASUREMENTPROCEDURES
DURING DATA COLLECTION ARE ESSENTIAL FOR MINIMIZING
RANDOMERRORANDBIASINMULTICENTERSTUDIES2IGOROUS
ANTHROPOMETRYANDDATACOLLECTIONPROTOCOLSWEREUSEDIN
THE7(/-ULTICENTRE'ROWTH2EFERENCE3TUDYTOENSURE
HIGHDATAQUALITY!FTERTHEINITIALTRAININGANDSTAND
ARDIZATIONSTUDYTEAMSPARTICIPATEDINSTANDARDIZATION
SESSIONSEVERYTWOMONTHSFORACONTINUOUSASSESSMENTOF
THEPRECISIONANDACCURACYOFTHEIRMEASUREMENTS/NCEA
YEARTHETEAMSWERERESTANDARDIZEDAGAINSTTHE7(/LEAD
ANTHROPOMETRISTWHOOBSERVEDTHEIRMEASUREMENTTECH
NIQUESANDRETRAINEDANYDEVIATINGOBSERVERS2OBUSTAND
PRECISEEQUIPMENTWASSELECTEDANDADAPTEDFORFIELDUSE
4HEANTHROPOMETRISTSWORKEDINPAIRSTAKINGMEASURE
MENTSINDEPENDENTLYANDREPEATINGMEASUREMENTSTHAT
EXCEEDEDPRESETMAXIMUMALLOWABLEDIFFERENCES/NGOING
CENTRALANDLOCALMONITORINGIDENTIFIEDANTHROPOMETRISTS
DEVIATINGFROMSTANDARDPROCEDURESANDIMMEDIATECOR
RECTIVEACTIONWASTAKEN4HEPROCEDURESDESCRIBEDINTHIS
PAPERAREAMODELFORRESEARCHSETTINGS

-ERCEDESDE/NISAND!DELHEID7/NYANGOAREAFFILIATED
WITHTHE$EPARTMENTOF.UTRITION7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZA
TION'ENEVA*AN6ANDEN"ROECKISAFFILIATEDWITHTHE!FRICA
#ENTRE FOR (EALTH AND 0OPULATION 3TUDIES -TUBATUBA
3OUTH!FRICA7M#AMERON#HUMLEAISAFFILIATEDWITHTHE
$EPARTMENTOF#OMMUNITY(EALTH,IFESPAN(EALTH2ESEARCH
#ENTER7RIGHT3TATE5NIVERSITY3CHOOLOF-EDICINE+ETTERING
/HIO53!2EYNALDO-ARTORELLISAFFILIATEDWITHTHE$EPART
MENTOF)NTERNATIONAL(EALTH2OLLINS3CHOOLOF0UBLIC(EALTH
%MORY5NIVERSITY!TLANTA'EORGIA53!
0LEASE DIRECT QUERIES TO -ERCEDES DE /NIS 3TUDY #OOR
DINATOR $EPARTMENT OF .UTRITION 7ORLD (EALTH /RGANI
ZATION  !VENUE !PPIA  'ENEVA  3WITZERLAND
4ELEPHONE     FAX     E MAIL
DEONISM WHOINT
-EMBERS OF THE 7(/ -ULTICENTRE 'ROWTH 2EFERENCE
3TUDY'ROUPAND!CKNOWLEDGMENTSARELISTEDATTHEENDOF
THEFIRSTPAPERINTHISSUPPLEMENTPP3n3 
-ENTIONOFTHENAMESOFFIRMSANDCOMMERCIALPRODUCTS
DOESNOTIMPLYENDORSEMENTBYTHE5NITED.ATIONS5NIVERSITY

)NTRODUCTION
4HE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION7(/ -ULTICENTRE
'ROWTH2EFERENCE3TUDY-'23 WASUNDERTAKENTO
GENERATENEWGROWTHCURVESFORASSESSINGTHEGROWTH
ANDDEVELOPMENTOFINFANTSANDYOUNGCHILDRENFROM
AROUNDTHEWORLD4HECHILDRENINCLUDEDINTHESTUDY
CAMEFROMSIXCOUNTRIES"RAZIL'HANA)NDIA.ORWAY
/MANANDTHE5NITED3TATES4HEMETHODOLOGYAND
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR THE STUDY HAVE BEEN DESCRIBED
ELSEWHERE IN THIS SUPPLEMENT ;= )DENTICAL RIGOROUS
DATA COLLECTION PROCEDURES WERE FOLLOWED IN ALL SITES
INORDERTOMINIMIZEMEASUREMENTERRORANDTOAVOID
SYSTEMATICDIFFERENCESAMONGSITES
6ARIABILITY IN INFANT AND CHILD MEASUREMENTS CAN
RESULT FROM A NUMBER OF INFLUENCES THE SETTING IN
WHICHTHEMEASUREMENTSARETAKENSTOMACHANDBLAD
DERVOLUMEINTHECASEOFWEIGHT DIURNALVARIATION
IN LENGTHHEIGHT  THE BEHAVIOR AND COOPERATION OF
THECHILDBEINGMEASUREDTHEACCURACYANDPRECISION
OF THE INSTRUMENTS THE ANTHROPOMETRISTS TECHNICAL
CAPACITYTRAININGEXPERIENCEANDRELIABILITY FITNESS
ANDMOODANDTHEMETHODSOFDATARECORDINGREAD
INGWRITINGDOWN !PPROPRIATETRAININGANDCONTIN
UEDSTANDARDIZATIONADHERENCETOSPECIFIEDMETHODS
AND PROCEDURES AND MONITORING OF DATA QUALITY ARE
ESSENTIALTOREDUCEMEASUREMENTERRORANDMINIMIZE
BIAS IN MULTISITE STUDIES 4HE PURPOSE OF THIS ARTICLE
ISTODESCRIBETHEMEASUREMENTPROTOCOLSANDROUTINE
STANDARDIZATIONSESSIONSTHATWEREUSEDINTHE-'23
4HESTUDYPROTOCOLSANDQUALITYCONTROLPROCEDURESCAN
BE APPLIED IN RESEARCH SETTINGS WITHOUT SUBSTANTIALLY
INCREASINGCOSTSORCOMPLICATINGLOGISTICS

3ELECTIONANDTRAININGOFANTHROPOMETRISTS
4HE FIELD STAFF COLLECTING ANTHROPOMETRIC DATA IN THE

&OODAND.UTRITION"ULLETINVOLNOSUPPLEMENT 4HE5NITED.ATIONS5NIVERSITY

3

3

-DE/NISETAL

ENABLEOBSERVERSTOMEASUREACCURATELYTHATISWITHOUT

BIAS4OACHIEVETHISOBSERVERSNEEDTOBETRAINEDTO
OBTAINMEASUREMENTSTHATAREONAVERAGEEQUALTOTHE
VALUESMEASUREDBYANEXPERTANTHROPOMETRISTWHOIS
CONSIDEREDTHEhGOLDSTANDARDv4HEDEGREEOFACCURACY
CANBEASSESSEDINATESTnRETESTSTUDYINWHICHSEVERAL
CHILDREN ARE MEASURED BY BOTH THE EXPERT AND THE
OBSERVER AND BIAS IS CALCULATED AS THE AVERAGE DEVIA
TIONOFTHEOBSERVERSMEANMEASUREMENTVALUESFROM
THOSEOFTHEEXPERT
)TISEQUALLYIMPORTANTTHATTHEMEASUREMENTSTAKEN
BEPRECISETHATISREPRODUCIBLE(IGHPRECISIONISPOS
SIBLEONLYIFMEASUREMENTPROCEDURESAREHIGHLYSTAND
ARDIZED0RECISIONISASSESSEDONTHEBASISOFDIFFERENCES
BETWEENREPLICATEMEASUREMENTSTAKENONSEVERALSUB
JECTSINTHETESTnRETESTSTUDY4HEMOSTCOMMONLYUSED
PARAMETERFORLACKOFPRECISIONISTHETECHNICALERROROF
MEASUREMENT4%- ;=
&OLLOWING THE INITIAL STANDARDIZATION SESSION AND
THROUGHOUT THE DATA COLLECTION PHASE EACH SITE CON
DUCTEDSTANDARDIZATIONSESSIONSBIMONTHLYEVERYTWO
MONTHS THATCOINCIDEDONCEAYEARWITHTHEVISITOF
THE7(/LEADANTHROPOMETRIST4HEPURPOSEOFTHESE
SESSIONS WAS TO IDENTIFY ANTHROPOMETRISTS DEVIATING
FROMTHE-'23PROCEDURES#ORRECTIVEACTIONSSUCH
ASRETRAININGWERETAKENWHENEVERDEVIATIONSINMEAS
UREMENTTECHNIQUESWERENOTED
4HEINITIALSTANDARDIZATIONSESSIONUSEDGROUPSOF
CHILDRENFOREACHSETOFMEASUREMENTSANDTOOKFIVEOR
SIXDAYSTOCOMPLETEWHEREASTHEBIMONTHLYSESSIONS
REQUIREDONLYCHILDRENANDCOULDBEACCOMPLISHED
INTWOORTHREEDAYS!TTHEINITIALSESSIONTHEOBSERVERS
WERESTANDARDIZEDAGAINSTTHE7(/LEADANTHROPOM
ETRIST WHO SERVED AS THE GOLD STANDARD WHEREAS THE
BIMONTHLY SESSIONS USED THE OBSERVERS OVERALL MEAN
OFEACHANTHROPOMETRICVARIABLEASTHEGOLDSTANDARD
4HELONGITUDINALSCREENINGANDFOLLOW UPTEAMSWERE
STANDARDIZED SEPARATELY BECAUSE OF THE DIFFERENT AGE
GROUPS AND SETTINGS INVOLVED THE SCREENING TEAMS
MEASUREDNEWBORNSINMATERNITYWARDSWHEREASTHE
FOLLOW UPTEAMSMEASUREDINFANTSANDOLDERCHILDREN
DURINGHOMEVISITS
!NALYSESOFACCURACYANDPRECISIONWEREPERFORMED
SOONAFTERTHESTANDARDIZATIONSESSIONSUSINGACENTRALLY
PREPARED %XCEL SPREADSHEET PROGRAM WITH STANDARD
FORMULASFORCALCULATINGRELEVANTSTATISTICS;n=4O
ILLUSTRATEHOWTHEOBSERVERSPERFORMANCEWASASSESSED
TABLEPRESENTSLENGTHDATAFROMTHE2OTTERDAMSES
SIONINWHICHCHILDRENPARTICIPATED&ORPRECISION
4%- THEOBSERVERSPERFORMANCECOMPAREDWELLWITH
THATOFTHELEADANTHROPOMETRISTANDTHEOVERALLMEAN
4HISDEMONSTRATEDTHATTHEPARTICIPANTSINTHESESSION
FOLLOWED CONSISTENT TECHNIQUES IN MEASURING LENGTH
3TANDARDIZATION
AND OBTAINED REPRODUCIBLE VALUES 4HE SIGN TEST FOR
'IVEN THE OBJECTIVES OF THE -'23 STANDARDIZATION PRECISIONASSESSESTHEhMEASUREMENTEFFECTvWHEREAN
WITHINANDAMONGSITESWASAKEYASPECTOFTHESTUDY OBSERVERSRETESTMEASUREMENTSMAYBESYSTEMATICALLY
;=!NIMPORTANTGOALOFSTANDARDIZEDTRAININGISTO LOWERORHIGHERTHANHISORHEROWNFIRSTMEASUREMENTS
-'23REFERREDTOHEREINASOBSERVERSORANTHROPOM
ETRISTS HADTOHAVEATLEASTSECONDARYSCHOOLEDUCATION
BEMOTIVATEDWRITELEGIBLYSPEAKTHELOCALLANGUAGE
AND BE ABLE TO INTERACT APPROPRIATELY WITH THE HIGH
SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS FAMILIES THAT WERE TARGETED FOR
THESTUDY!LLCANDIDATESRECEIVEDSTANDARDIZEDTRAIN
INGANDONLYTHOSEWHOMETTHE-'23PERFORMANCE
CRITERIAWERERETAINEDFORTHESTUDY
4HEMEASUREMENTPROCEDURESANDTRAININGGUIDELINES
WEREPREPAREDBYTHE-'23#OORDINATING#ENTREAT
7(/IN'ENEVABASEDONBESTPRACTICESRECOMMENDED
INANTHROPOMETRYMANUALSANDINTHELITERATURE;n=
4HEINITIALTRAININGOFANTHROPOMETRISTSATEACHSITEWAS
CARRIEDOUTBYANEXPERIENCEDANTHROPOMETRISTFOLLOW
INGTHEPROCEDURESDETAILEDINTHE-'23PROTOCOL!LL
ANTHROPOMETRISTSWERETRAINEDTOINTERVIEWMOTHERS
COMPLETETHESTUDYQUESTIONNAIRESMEASURECHILDREN
ASDESCRIBEDINTHEPROTOCOLAVOIDDIGITPREFERENCEOR
TRANSPOSITIONOFNUMBERSRECORDMEASUREMENTVALUES
IMMEDIATELY AFTER READING THEM AND WRITE LEGIBLY TO
REDUCEMISTAKESDURINGDATATRANSFER3TRICTADHERENCE
TOTHEMEASURINGTECHNIQUESANDRECORDINGPROCEDURES
WAS EMPHASIZED )NSTRUCTIONS WERE ALSO PROVIDED ON
HANDLINGUNCOOPERATIVECHILDRENTAKINGINTOACCOUNT
CULTURALFACTORSANDINDIVIDUALMOTHERSSENSITIVITYTO
THEIRBABIESCRYING
%ARLYINTHESTUDYFOURANTHROPOMETRISTSWERETRAINED
ANDSTANDARDIZEDAGAINSTANEXPERTDESIGNATEDBY7(/
ASLEADANTHROPOMETRISTFORTHE-'237## INA
CROSS SITESESSIONHELDIN2OTTERDAMTHE.ETHERLANDS
4WOOFTHEPARTICIPANTSWERESTUDYSUPERVISORSFROM
SITESONEWASAMEMBEROFTHE#OORDINATING#ENTRE
ANDTHEFOURTH*6D" BECAMETHESECOND7(/ DES
IGNATEDLEADANTHROPOMETRISTFORTHE-'23
&OLLOWING THE INITIAL TRAINING AND BEFORE THE START
OF DATA COLLECTION THE ANTHROPOMETRISTS IN EACH SITE
WERESTANDARDIZEDAGAINSTONEOFTHETWO7(/LEAD
ANTHROPOMETRISTS4HEANTHROPOMETRISTWITHTHEBEST
PERFORMANCEATTHISSESSIONWASDESIGNATEDhLOCALLEAD
ANTHROPOMETRISTv AND WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR RETRAINING
TEAMMATESWHODEVIATEDFROM-'23TECHNIQUESAND
FORTRAININGNEWLYRECRUITEDANTHROPOMETRISTSLATERIN
THESTUDY!7(/LEADANTHROPOMETRISTVISITEDEACH
SITE ANNUALLY TO ENSURE THAT IDENTICAL METHODS WERE
FOLLOWED THROUGHOUT THE SEVEN YEARS OF THE STUDY
4HEMEASUREMENTPROCEDURESFOLLOWEDINTHE-'23
WERE DOCUMENTED ON VIDEOTAPE AVAILABLE TO READERS
ONREQUESTFROMTHEFIRSTAUTHOR ANDVIEWEDDURING
TRAINING AND REGULARLY THEREAFTER TO REINFORCE THE KEY
FEATURESOFTHEMEASUREMENTPROTOCOLS

3

-EASUREMENTANDSTANDARDIZATIONPROTOCOLSFORANTHROPOMETRY

4!",%0RECISIONANDACCURACYFROMTHESTANDARDIZATIONSESSIONIN2OTTERDAMLENGTHDATA

6ARIABLE
4%-ACM
&TEST
,EADANTHROPOMETRISTB
/VERALLMEANB
3IGNTESTC
"IASCM
,EADANTHROPOMETRISTD
&TESTE
3IGNTESTF
"IASCM
/VERALLMEAND
&TESTE
3IGNTESTF

7(/LEAD
ANTHROPO
METRIST

/BSERVER

/BSERVER

/BSERVER

/BSERVER

/VERALLMEAN













P
P

P
P
P

P
P
P

P
P
P

P
P
P


P
P


P
P


P
P


P
P


P
P


P
P


P
P


P
P


P
P

A 4ECHNICALERROROFMEASUREMENT3-DIN WHEREDIISTHEDIFFERENCEBETWEENTHEITHSUBJECTSTESTANDRETESTMEASUREMENTSBYTHEOBSERVER
ANDNISTHENUMBEROFMEASUREDSUBJECTS
B&RATIOFORPRECISION/BSERVER-DI,EADANTHROPOMETRIST-DI7HENOVERALLMEANISTHEGOLDSTANDARDDIINTHEDENOMINATORISTHEDIF
FERENCEBETWEENTHEITHSUBJECTSOVERALLMEANOFTESTANDOVERALLMEANOFRETESTMEASUREMENTS
C0RECISIONSIGNTESTBINOMIALPROPORTIONPWHEREPXNANDXISTHEFREQUENCYOFTHEOBSERVERSRETESTSCORESTHATAREHIGHERORLOWER
THANTHECORRESPONDINGTESTSCORES3IGNIFICANCEISBASEDONEXACTCONFIDENCELIMITSFORPROPORTIONSWHENN)SEE4ABLE"IN$ALY
AND"OURKE;= 
D !VERAGEBIAS/BSERVER-6INWHERE6IISTHEDIFFERENCEBETWEENTHEOBSERVERSMEANANDTHELEADANTHROPOMETRISTSOROVERALL MEAN
MEASUREMENTFORTHEITHSUBJECT
E&RATIOFORBIAS/BSERVER-6ILEADANTHROPOMETRISTSOROVERALLMEANS -DISAMEDENOMINATORASTHEPRECISION&RATIO 
F "IASSIGNTESTBINOMIALPROPORTIONPWHEREPXNANDXISTHEFREQUENCYOFTHEOBSERVERSMEANSTHATAREABOVEORBELOW THELEAD
ANTHROPOMETRISTSOROVERALLMEAN3IGNIFICANCEISBASEDONEXACTCONFIDENCELIMITSFORPROPORTIONSWHENN)SEE4ABLE"IN$ALY
AND"OURKE;= 

;=.OSUCHMEASUREMENTEFFECTWASEVIDENTFORANY
PARTICIPANTINTHISSESSION&ORACCURACYTHEOBSERVERS
SHOWED A SYSTEMATIC TENDENCY TOWARD NEGATIVE BIAS
COMPAREDWITHTHELEADANTHROPOMETRISTCONSEQUENTLY
THETECHNIQUESFORMEASURINGLENGTHWEREREVIEWED!S
EXPECTEDTHENEGATIVEBIASWASNOTEVIDENTWHENCOM
PAREDWITHTHEOVERALLMEANEXCEPTFOROBSERVER"OTH
THE&TESTANDTHESIGNTESTFORACCURACYAREUSEFUL4HE
SIGN TEST CHECKS WHETHER POOR ACCURACY RESULTS FROM
SYSTEMATICOROCCASIONALBIAS;=&OREXAMPLETHE
AVERAGEBIASCOULDBELOWANDNONSIGNIFICANTWHENA
LARGE DEVIATION OVERWHELMS SMALLER BUT SYSTEMATIC
DIFFERENCES )N THIS CASE THE SIGN TEST BUT NOT THE &
TEST WOULD INDICATE BIAS &OR THIS SESSION ONLY ONE
OBSERVERSBIASWASSYSTEMATICANDTHISWASCORRECTED
BYRETRAINING
4HE RESULTS OF THE BIMONTHLY STANDARDIZATION SES
SIONSWERESENTTOTHE#OORDINATING#ENTRESOONAFTER
THEIRCOMPLETION4HEAVERAGE4%-SFOREACHSITEWERE
PLOTTEDTOMONITOROVERALLPERFORMANCEOVERTIMEAS
FIGUREILLUSTRATESFORLENGTH )NGENERALTHE4%-S
WEREHIGHESTATTHESTARTANDFOLLOWINGAPATTERNTHAT
ISCONSISTENTFORALLTHEOTHERMEASUREMENTSPRECISION
IMPROVED AS THE OBSERVERS GAINED EXPERIENCE /NCE
STABILIZEDTHEAVERAGE4%-SREMAINEDLOWREFLECTING
THEHIGHPRECISIONOFTHEMEASUREMENTSTAKENBYTHE
STUDYTEAMS7HENSENDINGTHEBIMONTHLYRESULTSTOTHE

#OORDINATING#ENTRESITESREPORTEDONEXTRANEOUSCIR
CUMSTANCESTHATAFFECTEDTHEOBSERVEDPERFORMANCE&OR
EXAMPLEFIGURESHOWSAPEAKIN4%-FORTHEEIGHTH
BIMONTHLYSESSIONIN"RAZILWHENTHECHILDRENINVOLVED
WEREPARTICULARLYUNCOOPERATIVE/NTHERAREOCCASIONS
WHENAPROBLEMIDENTIFIEDINTHESITESNEEDEDEXTERNAL
ASSISTANCETHE7(/LEADANTHROPOMETRISTVISITEDTHE
AFFECTEDSITETORETRAINTHEOBSERVERS4HISWASTHECASE
FORTRICEPSSKINFOLDMEASUREMENTSATONESITE

!NTHROPOMETRICPROCEDURES
-EASURINGEQUIPMENT

!LL STUDY SITES USED THE SAME MEASURING EQUIPMENT

4HE INSTRUMENTS NEEDED TO BE HIGHLY ACCURATE AND
PRECISEYETSTURDYANDPORTABLEENOUGHTOBECARRIED
BACKANDFORTHONHOMEVISITS
,ENGTH WAS MEASURED WITH THE (ARPENDEN )NFAN
TOMETERRANGEnCMFORPORTABLEUSEWITHDIGIT
COUNTERREADINGSPRECISETOMM "ECAUSETHE-'23
PROTOCOLSPECIFIEDMEASURINGLENGTHINTHECROSS SEC
TIONAL STUDY FOR CHILDREN AGED  TO  MONTHS TO
ALLOWAPRECISEESTIMATIONOFTHESYSTEMATICDIFFERENCE
BETWEENLENGTHANDHEIGHT ALONGER THAN USUALINFAN
TOMETERWASSPECIALLYBUILTFORTHESTUDY

3

-DE/NISETAL



4%- CM








)NITIAL
53!

"I?

"I?
/MAN

"I?

"I?

.ORWAY

"I?

"I?

)NDIA

"I?

"I?

'HANA

"I?
"RAZIL

)NITIAL"I?n"I?)NITIALANDBIMONTHLYSTANDARDIZATIONSESSIONS

&)'4ECHNICALERROROFMEASUREMENT4%- FORLENGTHATINITIALSESSIONAND
UPTOBIMONTHLYEVERYTWOMONTHS STANDARDIZATIONSESSIONSINTHESTUDY
SITES

4HE(ARPENDEN0ORTABLE3TADIOMETERRANGEn
CMDIGITCOUNTERREADING WASUSEDTOMEASUREBOTH
ADULT AND CHILD HEIGHTS!T THE REQUEST OF7(/ THE
MANUFACTURERDESIGNEDAWOODENBASETOREPLACETHE
HEAVYCARRYINGCASETHATSERVESASAMOUNTFORTHETRADI
TIONALPORTABLESTADIOMETER4HISADAPTATIONDECREASED
THEWEIGHTOFTHEPACKAGEDSTADIOMETERBYABOUTKG
ANDREDUCEDTHETIMEREQUIREDTOASSEMBLEIT
!SELF RETRACTING CM WIDEFLATMETALTAPEWITH
BLANKLEAD INSTRIPRANGEnCMCALIBRATEDTO
MM WASUSEDTOMEASURECIRCUMFERENCES-ETALTAPES
WERECHOSENBECAUSETHEYAREMOREROBUSTANDACCURATE
ANDSTAYINASINGLEPLANEAROUNDTHEHEAD4HEYWERE
REPLACED ON A REGULAR BASIS WHEN THE GRADING MARKS
FADED4HE(OLTAIN4ANNER 7HITEHOUSE3KINFOLD#ALI
PERJAWFACEAREAMMPRESSUREBETWEENTHEJAWS
GMMRANGEnMMCALIBRATEDTOMM
WASUSEDTOMEASURESKINFOLDS
4OMEASUREWEIGHTWEUSEDPORTABLEELECTRONICSCALES
THATHAVETARINGCAPABILITYANDARECALIBRATEDTOKG
5.)#%& %LECTRONIC 3CALE  OR 5NISCALE  )DEALLY
NEWBORNSSHOULDBEMEASUREDWITHASCALEOFHIGHER
PRECISION WITHIN  G  (OWEVER THE ADVANTAGES OF
THE 5NISCALE GREATLY OUTWEIGHED THE DISADVANTAGE OF
ITSLOWERPRECISIONFORYOUNGBABIES4HESCALESWERE
SATISFACTORILYPILOTTESTEDINTHE"RAZILIANSITETHEYWERE
EASYTOUSEANDTRANSPORTANDTAREDWEIGHINGALLOWED
THEINFANTSTOREMAININTHEIRMOTHERSARMSWHERETHEY
WEREMORECALMANDRELAXED4HISWASIMPORTANTFOR
THEMOTHERSPOSITIVEPERCEPTIONOFTHESTUDYANDTHUS
PARTICIPATION4HESCALESELECTRONICDISPLAYDECREASED
THEOBSERVERMEASUREMENTERROR)NCOLDCLIMATESTHE
INFANTSCOULDBEWRAPPEDUPINABLANKETFORWEIGH
ING AFTER THE WEIGHT OF THE BLANKET HAD BEEN TARED
!NOTHERADVANTAGEOFTHE5NISCALEWASTHATITALLOWED
THEMOTHERSWEIGHTTOBERECORDEDATEACHVISITTHUS
PERMITTINGTHECOLLECTIONATNOEXTRACOSTOFWEIGHT

DATAFORLACTATINGWOMEN
4HE EQUIPMENT WAS CALIBRATED REGULARLY USUALLY
DAILY BEFORE THE HOME OR HOSPITAL VISITS 4HE SCALES
WERECALIBRATEDWITHLOCALLYAVAILABLESTANDARDWEIGHTS
OVER THE FULL WEIGHT RANGE AND TARED WEIGHING WAS
SIMULATED 4HE INFANTOMETER AND STADIOMETER WERE
CALIBRATED BY USING METAL RODS OF KNOWN LENGTHS
4HESKINFOLDCALIPERSBEINGPARTICULARLYFRAGILEWERE
CHECKEDBEFOREEACHUSEWITHCALIBRATIONBLOCKSOFVARI
OUSWIDTHSFORACCURACYANDTOENSURETHATTHENEEDLE
MOVEDSMOOTHLYANDCONTINUOUSLYWITHTHEOPENING
OFTHECALIPERJAWS
!NTHROPOMETRICDATACOLLECTION

-EASUREMENTSWERETAKENANDRECORDEDBYTWOTRAINED
ANDSTANDARDIZEDANTHROPOMETRISTS"OTHTHEQUESTION
NAIREFORMSANDTHESTANDARDPROCEDURESWEREDESIGNED
TOENSURETHATEACHOBSERVERREADANDRECORDEDMEAS
UREMENTSINDEPENDENTLYOFTHEOTHER!TEACHSESSION
THE TWO EXCHANGED ROLES AShLEADINGv ANDhASSISTINGv
OBSERVERS 4HE ROLE OF THE ASSISTING OBSERVER WAS TO
HELP POSITION THE CHILD CORRECTLY WHILE THE LEADING
OBSERVER TOOK AND RECORDED MEASUREMENTS 4HE FIRST
OBSERVERMEASUREDANDIMMEDIATELYRECORDEDEACHOF
THEMEASUREMENTSANDTHEYTHENEXCHANGEDROLESSO
THAT THE SECOND OBSERVER COULD ALSO TAKE THE FULL SET
OFMEASUREMENTS4HEYTHENCOMPAREDTHEIRVALUESTO
ENSURE THAT DUPLICATE MEASUREMENTS WERE WITHIN THE
MAXIMUM ALLOWED DIFFERENCES !NY MEASUREMENTS
FALLINGOUTSIDETHEMAXIMUMALLOWEDDIFFERENCESWERE
REPEATEDBYBOTHOBSERVERSANDENTEREDINDESIGNATED
BOXESONTHEDATARECORDINGSHEET.OMORETHANTWO
REMEASUREMENTSWEREALLOWEDIEAMAXIMUMOFTHREE
DUPLICATEMEASUREMENTSETSFORAGIVENANTHROPOMETRIC
PARAMETERATANYONEVISIT !LLRECORDEDMEASUREMENTS
WEREENTEREDINTOTHECOMPUTER4HEFINALVALUETOBE

3

-EASUREMENTANDSTANDARDIZATIONPROTOCOLSFORANTHROPOMETRY

USEDFORTHECONSTRUCTIONOFTHEGROWTHCURVESWILLBE
THEAVERAGEOFTHELASTPAIROFMEASUREMENTS)NTHERARE
CASES WHENTHECHILDWASJUDGEDTOBETOOAGI
TATEDFORRELIABLEDUPLICATEMEASUREMENTSTOBETAKEN
ONLYONESETOFMEASUREMENTSWASRECORDED)NPRACTICE
ITWASOBSERVEDTHATLARGEDIFFERENCESOWINGTOREADING
ORRECORDINGERRORSWERERESOLVEDBYAFIRSTREPEATMEAS
UREMENT(OWEVERWHENTHEBABIESWEREUNCOOPERA
TIVEMEASUREMENTSBECAMEINCREASINGLYDIFFICULTAND
HENCETHEDECISIONTODISCONTINUEMEASURINGANDUSE
UNPAIREDMEASUREMENTSINTHEFEWCITEDCASES
4HEMAXIMUMALLOWABLEDIFFERENCESFORACCEPTABLE
PRECISIONUSEDINTHESTUDYFORTHEVARIOUSANTHROPO
METRICVARIABLESWEREBASEDONTHE4%-OBTAINEDIN
THE INITIAL STANDARDIZATION SESSION CONDUCTED AT THE
"RAZILIANSITE4OACHIEVEARATEOFREMEASUREMENTOF
AROUNDTHEMAXIMUMALLOWEDDIFFERENCESWERESET
ATTIMESTHE4%-ACHIEVEDDURINGTHESESSIONIE
MMFORLENGTHMMFORCIRCUMFERENCESANDMM
FORSKINFOLDSTABLE 4HEMAXIMUMALLOWABLEDIFFER
ENCEFORWEIGHTWASSETATGTOALLOWFORROUNDING
OFF WITHIN THE SMALLEST CALIBRATION UNIT OF THE SCALE
"ECAUSESKINFOLDTHICKNESSESWERETHEMEASUREMENTS
WITHWHICHMOTHERSANDCHILDRENWERELEASTFAMILIAR
ANDFELTMOSTUNCOMFORTABLETHEDECISIONWASTAKENTO
RAISETHEMAXIMUMALLOWABLEDIFFERENCEFORSKINFOLDS
TOMM4HISWASCONSIDEREDTOBEAMOREAPPROPRI
ATELIMITASANARROWERMARGINMIGHTLEADTOTOOMANY
REPEAT MEASUREMENTS WITH NEGATIVE IMPLICATIONS FOR
THE ANTHROPOMETRISTS MORALE AND THE PARTICIPANTS
RESPONSIVENESS
-EASUREMENTSCHEDULE

#ONCERTEDEFFORTSWEREMADETOCOLLECTTHEANTHROPO
METRICDATAONSCHEDULEDVISITDATES4HEORETICALLYTHE
MAXIMUMDELAYORADVANCEOFMEASUREMENTSALLOWED
BYTHEPROTOCOLWASOFTHECHILDSAGEEGDAYS
AT  MONTH  DAYS AT  MONTHS  BUT IN PRACTICE
TEAMSWORKEDWITHMORERESTRICTEDTOLERABLEDELAYOR
ADVANCETARGETSANDDAYSFORVISITSATWEEKS
ANDANDATMONTHSRESPECTIVELYDAYSFOR
VISITSTAKINGPLACEATMONTHSONWARDS /FMORETHAN
HOMEVISITSCOMPLETEDBY!PRILONLY
 WERE DONE OUTSIDE THE MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE
DELAYOUTOFTHESE EXCEEDEDTHELIMITBY
LESSTHANONEDAY
-EASUREMENTTECHNIQUES

!COMPREHENSIVEDESCRIPTIONOFTHETECHNIQUESUSEDFOR
THEMEASUREMENTSISFOUNDINTHE-'23-EASUREMENT
AND3TANDARDIZATION0ROTOCOLSANDDOCUMENTEDINTHE
ANTHROPOMETRIC TRAINING VIDEO AVAILABLE ON REQUEST
FROMTHEFIRSTAUTHOR 4HEANTHROPOMETRISTSEXPLAINED
TO THE MOTHERS ALL PROCEDURES TO BE UNDERTAKEN AND
EMPHASIZEDTHATTHESEWEREHARMLESS)NFANTSANDYOUNG
CHILDRENWEREHELDBYTHEIRMOTHERSTOFOSTERASENSEOF
4!",%-AXIMUMALLOWABLEDIFFERENCESBETWEENTHEMEAS
UREMENTSOFTWOOBSERVERS

-EASUREMENT

"RAZIL4%-A
FROMPILOT
STUDY

7EIGHT
,ENGTH
(EADCIRCUMFERENCE
!RMCIRCUMFERENCE
4RICEPSSKINFOLD
3UBSCAPULARSKINFOLD

.OTAVAILABLE






-AXIMUM
ALLOWABLE
DIFFERENCE

G
MM
MM
MM
MM
MM

4HE-'23ANTHROPOMETRICMEASUREMENTSAREWEIGHT
RECUMBENTLENGTHSTANDINGHEIGHTHEADANDARMCIR
CUMFERENCES AND TRICEPS AND SUBSCAPULAR SKINFOLD
THICKNESS&ORTHELONGITUDINALSTUDYNEWBORNSWERE A 4%-4ECHNICALERROROFMEASUREMENTSEEFORMULAINFOOTNOTE
MEASURED AT BIRTH USUALLY WITHIN THE FIRST  HOURS
TOTABLE 
OFLIFEANDNEVERAFTERHOURS ANDVISITEDATHOME
TIMESATWEEKSANDMONTHLYFROMTO 4!",%4IMESCHEDULEFORTHECOLLECTIONOFANTHROPOMETRIC
MONTHSANDEVERYOTHERMONTHDURINGTHESECONDYEAR MEASUREMENTSINTHELONGITUDINALSTUDY
TABLE $ATACOLLECTIONWASMOREFREQUENTATYOUNGER
.OOF
AGESSOTHATTHESEEARLYPHASESOFRAPIDGROWTHCOULDBE -EASUREMENTANDTIMEFRAME
&REQUENCY
VISITS
ADEQUATELYDESCRIBED4HEWEEKVISITWASDONEBYTHE
ALENGTHHEADCIRCUM
7EIGHT
LACTATIONCOUNSELORANDONLYWEIGHTWASMEASUREDFOL
FERENCE
LOWINGTHESTANDARD-'23PROCEDUREUSINGTHE5NIS
"IRTH
/NCE

CALEANDWEIGHINGTHEBABYTWICE 4HEMOTHERSWEIGHT
nWK
%VERYWK

WASRECORDEDATEACHVISITANDTHEFATHERSWEIGHTAND
nMO
-ONTHLY

BOTHPARENTSHEIGHTSWEREMEASUREDONCE
nMO
%VERYMO

)NTHECROSS SECTIONALSTUDYCHILDRENAGEDTO
MONTHSWEREMEASUREDONCEEXCEPTINTHETWOSITESTHAT !RMCIRCUMFERENCESKINFOLD
THICKNESSTRICEPSSUBSCAP
USEDAMIXED LONGITUDINALDESIGN;=INWHICHSOME
ULAR
CHILDRENWEREMEASUREDTWOORTHREETIMESAT MONTH
nMO
-ONTHLY

INTERVALS!LLCHILDRENAGEDTOMONTHSHADBOTH
nMO
%VERYMO


RECUMBENTLENGTHANDSTANDINGHEIGHTMEASUREDAND
PARENTALWEIGHTSANDHEIGHTSWEREMEASUREDONCE
A 7EIGHTWASALSOMEASUREDATWEEKBYTHELACTATIONCOUNSELOR

3

SECURITYFORTHEBABY4HEANTHROPOMETRISTSCONFIDENCE
ANDPOISEWASIMPORTANTFORREASSURINGBOTHMOTHER
ANDCHILDANDINCLUDEDMAINTAININGEYECONTACTAND
TALKINGTOTHECHILDINACALMREASSURINGVOICE
!RMCIRCUMFERENCEANDSKINFOLDMEASUREMENTSWERE
TAKENONTHELEFTSIDEOFTHEBODY4HECHOICEOFWHICH
SIDETOMEASURERIGHTORLEFT MATTERSLITTLETOACCURACY
ANDPRECISION;=HOWEVERTHELEFT HANDSIDEISUSED
MOREOFTEN,ENGTHHEIGHTCIRCUMFERENCESANDSKIN
FOLDSWERERECORDEDTOTHELASTCOMPLETEDUNITRATHER
THAN THE NEAREST UNIT 4O CORRECT FOR THE SYSTEMATIC
NEGATIVE BIAS INTRODUCED BY THIS PRACTICE HALF OF THE
SMALLEST MEASUREMENT UNIT IE HALF OF  MM FOR
SKINFOLDSANDHALFOFMMFORCIRCUMFERENCES WAS
ADDEDTOEACHMEASUREMENTBEFOREANALYSIS4HISCOR
RECTIONDIDNOTAPPLYTOWEIGHTWHICHWASROUNDEDOFF
TOTHENEARESTG
&ORMEASUREMENTOFWEIGHTTHEMOTHERREMOVEDALL
THECHILDSCLOTHESBUTASNOTEDEARLIERUSEOFABLANKET
TOCOVERTHEBABYWASENCOURAGEDINCOLDWEATHER4HE
PARENTSTOOKOFFTHEIRSHOESHEAVYCLOTHINGANDOTHER
HEAVY OBJECTS BEFORE BEING WEIGHED 4HEY WORE LIGHT
CLOTHINGOFKNOWNWEIGHTTHATWASRECORDEDANDLATER
SUBTRACTEDFROMTHESUBJECTSWEIGHT4HISWASDONEBY
USINGALISTOFWEIGHTSOFLOCALCLOTHES)NTHELONGITUDI
NALSTUDYTHEMOTHERWASWEIGHEDFIRSTANDAFTERHER
WEIGHTWASRECORDEDTHESCALEWASTAREDANDTHEBABY
WASGIVENTOHER3HEWASASKEDTOSTANDSTILLUNTILTHE
BABYSWEIGHTHADBEENDISPLAYEDANDRECORDED7HEN
CHILDRENCOULDNOTBEUNDRESSEDTHEYALSOWORESTAND
ARDLIGHTCLOTHINGOFKNOWNWEIGHTTHATWASRECORDED
ANDSUBTRACTEDTOOBTAINTHECHILDSWEIGHT#HILDREN
AGEDTWOYEARSORMOREINTHECROSS SECTIONALSTUDYWERE
WEIGHEDONTHEIROWNSTANDINGWITHTHEIRFEETSLIGHTLY
APARTINTHECENTEROFTHEPLATFORMOFTHESCALE
4OMEASURERECUMBENTLENGTHBRAIDSWEREUNDONE
AND HAIR ORNAMENTS WERE REMOVED IF THEY INTERFERED
WITH POSITIONING OF THE HEAD $IAPERS WERE ALSO
REMOVED BECAUSE THEY MADE IT DIFFICULT TO HOLD THE
INFANTS LEGS TOGETHERANDSTRAIGHTENTHEM4HE LEAD
ING OBSERVER STOOD ON ONE SIDE OF THE BOARD TO HOLD
DOWNTHEBABYSLEGSWITHONEHANDANDMOVETHEFOOT
BOARDWITHTHEOTHER4HEASSISTINGOBSERVERSTOODAT
THEHEADBOARDTOHELPPOSITIONTHECHILDSHEAD4HE
HEAD WAS POSITIONED SO THAT THE CROWN TOUCHED THE
HEADBOARDANDAVERTICALLINEFROMTHEEARCANALTOTHE
LOWERBORDEROFTHEEYESOCKETWASPERPENDICULARTOTHE
HORIZONTALBOARDIETHE&RANKFORTPLANEPOSITIONED
VERTICALLY 4HELEADINGOBSERVERPOSITIONEDTHECHILDS
SHOULDERSANDHIPSATRIGHTANGLESTOTHELONGAXISOF
THEBODY'ENTLEPRESSUREWASAPPLIEDTOTHEKNEESTO
STRAIGHTENTHELEGS4OAVOIDCAUSINGINJURYMINIMAL
BUT PROLONGED PRESSURE WAS APPLIED TO THE KNEES OF
NEWBORNS4OTAKETHEMEASUREMENTTHEFOOTBOARDWAS
POSITIONEDAGAINSTTHECHILDSFEETWITHTHESOLESFLATON
THEBOARDANDTHETOESPOINTINGUPWARDS4HEMEASURE
MENTWASRECORDEDTOTHELASTCOMPLETEDMM

-DE/NISETAL

4O MEASURE STANDING HEIGHT HAIR ORNAMENTS WERE

REMOVEDANDBRAIDSWEREUNDONE4HECHILDSTOODON
THESTADIOMETERWITHBAREFEETPLACEDSLIGHTLYAPARTAND
THEBACKOFTHEHEADSHOULDERBLADESBUTTOCKSCALVES
AND HEELS TOUCHING THE VERTICAL BOARD 4HE ASSISTING
OBSERVERHELDTHECHILDSKNEESANDANKLESTOKEEPTHE
LEGS STRAIGHT AND THE FEET FLAT 4HE LEADING OBSERVER
GOT DOWN TO A FACE TO FACE LEVEL WITH THE CHILD AND
POSITIONED THE CHILDS HEAD SO THAT A HORIZONTAL LINE
DRAWNFROMTHEEARCANALTOTHELOWEREDGEOFTHEEYE
SOCKETRANPARALLELTOTHEBASEBOARDIETHE&RANKFORT
PLANEPOSITIONEDHORIZONTALLY "ECAUSEYOUNGCHILDREN
HAVE DIFFICULTY STANDING TO FULL STATURE A GENTLE PUSH
APPLIEDTOTHETUMMYWASUSEDTOHELPTHEMSTANDTO
FULL HEIGHT 4HE HEADBOARD WAS PULLED DOWN TO REST
FIRMLYONTOPOFTHEHEADANDCOMPRESSTHEHAIRAND
THEREADINGWASTAKENTOTHELASTCOMPLETEDMM
4OMEASUREHEADCIRCUMFERENCEHAIRPINSORHEAD
BANDS WERE REMOVED AND BRAIDS WERE UNDONE !N
INFANTORCHILDBELOWTHEAGEOFTWOYEARSWASHELDON
THEMOTHERSLAPANDOLDERCHILDRENCOULDSTANDORSIT
UNASSISTED4HELEADINGOBSERVERSTOODORSATATTHELEFT
SIDEOFTHECHILDPASSEDTHETAPEAROUNDTHEHEADAND
ANCHOREDITJUSTABOVETHEEYEBROWSANDOVERTHEFULL
ESTPROTUBERANCEOFTHESKULLATTHEBACKOFTHEHEAD
4HEASSISTINGOBSERVERSTOODORSATINFRONTOFTHECHILD
AND HELPED BY POSITIONING THE TAPE CORRECTLY ON THE
SIDE AWAY FROM THE LEAD OBSERVER /NCE POSITIONED
CORRECTLY THE TAPE WAS PULLED TIGHT TO COMPRESS THE
HAIRANDSKINANDTHEREADINGWASRECORDEDTOTHELAST
COMPLETEDMM
4HE MID UPPER ARM POINT IS HALF THE DISTANCE
BETWEENTHEACROMIONPROCESSTHEMOSTLATERALBONY
PROTUBERANCE OF THE BACK OF THE SHOULDER AND THE
OLECRANONTHEBONYSTRUCTURETHATSTANDSOUTWHENTHE
ELBOWISBENT 4HEMIDPOINTWASLOCATEDANDMARKED
FORMEASUREMENTOFTHEMID UPPER ARMCIRCUMFERENCE
-5!# ANDTRICEPSSKINFOLDTHICKNESS/NEOBSERVER
PALPATEDTHESHOULDERTOFINDTHEACROMIONANDMARKED
IT WITH A FELT TIP PEN OR COSMETIC PENCIL 4HE CHILDS
FOREARMWASTHENBENTATTHEELBOWPALMFACING
UPSOTHATTHEOLECRANONSTOODOUTATTHEELBOW4HE
OBSERVERPLACEDTHEZEROPOINTOFTHETAPEONTHEMARK
OVERTHEACROMIONPROCESSANDRANITDOWNWARDALONG
THEBACKOFTHEARMTOTHETIPOFTHEELBOW4HEOTHER
OBSERVERMADEASMALLHORIZONTALMARKATTHEMIDPOINT
ONTHEPOSTERIORASPECTOFTHEARMBEFORETHETAPEWAS
REMOVED
&OR MEASUREMENT OF THE -5!# THE CHILDS ARM
HUNGINARELAXEDPOSITIONORWASHELDINTHEEXTENDED
POSITIONBYTHEASSISTINGOBSERVERCAREWASTAKENNOTTO
FLEXORTIGHTENTHEMUSCLES4HETAPEWASTHENWRAPPED
AROUNDTHEARMOVERTHEMARKEDMIDPOINT4HETAPE
HADTOLIEFLATAROUNDTHEARMWITHOUTCOMPRESSINGTHE
SKINORUNDERLYINGTISSUETHEASSISTINGOBSERVERCHECKED
TOENSURETHATTHEREWASNOGAPORCOMPRESSIONONTHE
INNER PART OF THE ARM BEFORE THE MEASUREMENT WAS

3

-EASUREMENTANDSTANDARDIZATIONPROTOCOLSFORANTHROPOMETRY

RECORDEDTOTHELASTCOMPLETEDMM
! SKINFOLD CONSISTS OF A DOUBLE FOLD OF SKIN AND
SUBCUTANEOUS FAT EXCLUDING THE UNDERLYING MUSCLE
4HE TEAMS WERE TRAINED TO GRASP THE SKINFOLD GENTLY
TOAVOIDCAUSINGUNNECESSARYDISCOMFORTTOTHECHILD
AND COMPRESSING THE FAT 3KINFOLDS WERE RECORDED TO
THELASTCOMPLETEDMM&ORMEASUREMENTOFTRI
CEPSSKINFOLDTHICKNESSYOUNGBABIESWEREHELDBYTHEIR
MOTHERSOLDERCHILDRENSATORSTOODONTHEIROWN4HE
LEFTARMHUNGRELAXEDATTHESIDEORWASHELDDOWNBY
THEMOTHERORASSISTINGOBSERVER4HELEADINGOBSERVER
STOOD BEHIND THE CHILD AND PICKED UP THE SKINFOLD
ABOUTCMABOVETHEMIDPOINTMARKOVERTHETRICEPS
MUSCLE WITH THE FOLD RUNNING DOWNWARD ALONG THE
MIDLINEOFTHEBACKUPPERARM4HECALIPERJAWSWERE
APPLIED AT RIGHT ANGLES TO THEhNECKv OF THE FOLD JUST
BELOWTHEFINGERANDTHUMBOVERTHEMIDPOINTMARK
7HILEMAINTAININGAGRIPONTHESKINFOLDTHEOBSERVER
GENTLYRELEASEDTHECALIPERHANDLESANDALLOWEDTHEJAWS
TOCLOSEONTHEFATFOLDFORTWOSECONDSBEFORETAKING
THEREADINGTOTHELASTCOMPLETEDMM
4HE MEASUREMENT POINT FOR THE SUBSCAPULAR SKIN
FOLD LOCATED IMMEDIATELY BELOW THE INFERIOR ANGLE OF
THESCAPULAWASIDENTIFIEDBYPALPATINGANDMARKING
THEINFERIORANGLEOFTHESCAPULA4HECHILDSTOODORSAT
WITHSHOULDERSRELAXEDORGENTLYHELDDOWNTOPREVENT
MOVEMENTOFTHESCAPULA4HESKINFOLDWASPICKEDUP
CMABOVEANDMEDIALTOTHESUBSCAPULARMARKAND
THECALIPERWASAPPLIEDTOTHEhNECKvOFTHEFOLDOVER
THEMARKSOTHATTHEFOLDRANDIAGONALLYDOWNTOWARD
THE LEFT ELBOW 4HE SAME PROCEDURE AS DESCRIBED FOR
THE TRICEPS SKINFOLD WAS FOLLOWED TO READ AND RECORD
THEMEASUREMENT

MENTS INDEPENDENTLY BY THE TWO OBSERVERS AND TO

COMPARE THEIR MEASUREMENT VALUES FOR MAXIMUM
ALLOWABLEDIFFERENCESWASAKEYSTRATEGYFORDETECTING
ERRORSANDREMEASURINGTHECHILDONTHESPOT
4HEPROPORTIONOFREPEATEDMEASUREMENTSATEACH
SITE WAS CLOSELY MONITORED AS AN IMPORTANT QUALITY
CONTROLMEASURE,OWLEVELSOFREMEASUREMENTSIGNAL
APOSSIBLELACKOFINDEPENDENCEBETWEENTHEOBSERVERS
WHEREASHIGHLEVELSMIGHTINDICATEPOORMEASUREMENT
TECHNIQUESONTHEPARTOFATLEASTONEOFTHEOBSERVERS
4HELEVELSOFMAXIMUMALLOWABLEDIFFERENCESSELECTED
ANTICIPATED REPEAT RATES OF ABOUT  4HE OBSERVED
RATESACCORDINGTOSITEAREREPORTEDFORNEWBORNSFIG
  YOUNG CHILDREN IN THE LONGITUDINAL STUDY FIG  
AND OLDER CHILDREN IN THE CROSS SECTIONAL STUDY FIG
  &OR THE OVERALL STUDY THE RATE OF REPEATED LENGTH
MEASUREMENTS IN THE CROSS SECTIONAL SAMPLE WAS
 AS EXPECTED BUT IT WAS DOUBLE THIS PERCENTAGE
INTHELONGITUDINALSTUDY TABLE 4HELOWEST
PROPORTIONSOFREPEATMEASUREMENTSWEREOBSERVEDFOR
THESKINFOLDSFORTRICEPSANDFORSUBSCAPULAR




 


7EIGHT

(EADCIRCUMFERENCE

,ENGTH

1UALITYCONTROLDURINGDATACOLLECTION
"RAZIL

'HANA

)NDIA

.ORWAY

/MAN

53!

4HEOBSERVERSPERFORMANCEWASMONITOREDINSEVERAL &)'  0ERCENTAGE OF NEWBORN MEASUREMENTS REPEATED

WAYSDURINGTHESTUDY
FOR EXCEEDING THE MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
4HE REQUIREMENT TO TAKE AND RECORD ALL MEASURE OBSERVERS









7EIGHT

(EADCIRCUMFERENCE !RMCIRCUMFERENCE

"RAZIL

'HANA

)NDIA

4RICEPS

.ORWAY

3UBSCAPULAR

/MAN

,ENGTH

53!

&)'0ERCENTAGEOFLONGITUDINALFOLLOW UPMEASUREMENTSREPEATEDFOREXCEEDINGTHEMAXIMUMALLOWABLE
DIFFERENCEBETWEENOBSERVERS

3

-DE/NISETAL










7EIGHT

(EAD
CIRCUMFERENCE

!RM
CIRCUMFERENCE

"RAZIL

'HANA

4RICEPS

)NDIA

.ORWAY

3UBSCAPULAR

/MAN

(EIGHT

,ENGTH

53!

&)'0ERCENTAGEOFCROSS SECTIONALSTUDYMEASUREMENTSREPEATEDFOREXCEEDINGTHEMAXIMUMALLOWABLEDIFFERENCEBETWEEN
OBSERVERS
4!",%3UMMARYOFMEASUREMENTSREPEATEDFOREXCEEDINGTHEMAXIMUMALLOWABLEDIFFERENCE
BETWEENOBSERVERS
.O OFMEASUREMENTS
.EWBORNS
N

-EASUREMENT
7EIGHT
,ENGTH
(EADCIRCUMFERENCE
!RMCIRCUMFERENCE
4RICEPSSKINFOLD
3UBSCAPULARSKINFOLD
(EIGHT




.!B
.!
.!
.!

,ONGITUDINALSTUDY
N







.!

#ROSS SECTIONALSTUDY
N


 A






A NONLYCHILDRENAGEDnMONTHSINTHECROSS SECTIONALSTUDYWEREMEASUREDFORLENGTH

B.!)NDICESNOTMEASURED

SKINFOLDS IN BOTH LONGITUDINAL AND CROSS SECTIONAL

COMPONENTS PROBABLYASARESULTOFTHEADOPTIONOFA
WIDERMARGINOFALLOWABLEDIFFERENCESTHANTHEINITIAL
STANDARDSETIN"RAZILTABLE 
4HECOMPLETEDQUESTIONNAIRESWEREDELIVEREDSOON
AFTERTHEHOMEVISITUSUALLYWITHINONEORTWODAYS
TO THE LOCAL COORDINATION CENTER WHERE THEY WERE
CHECKEDBYTHESUPERVISORFORCOMPLETENESSANDCON
SISTENCYUSINGPROCEDURESDESCRIBEDELSEWHEREINTHIS
SUPPLEMENT ;= &OR ANTHROPOMETRY THE DATA ENTRY
SYSTEMINCLUDEDBUILT INRANGEANDCONSISTENCYCHECKS
THAT FLAGGED MEASUREMENTS EXCEEDING  STANDARD
DEVIATIONSOFAGE ANDSEX SPECIFICREFERENCEVALUESFOR
ATTAINEDSIZE&LAGGEDVALUESWERETHENCHECKEDFORCON
SISTENCYBETWEENTHETWOOBSERVERSCONSISTENCYWITH
OTHERANTHROPOMETRICVARIABLESMEASUREDONTHESAME
VISITCONSISTENCYWITHPREVIOUSMEASUREMENTSOFTHE
SAMECHILDANDPOSSIBLEDATAENTRYERRORS
0ERIODICCOMPUTERCHECKSWEREALSODONEFOREACH
OBSERVERTODETECTDIGITPREFERENCESANDUNUSUALVALUES
&OREXAMPLEBECAUSETHESKINFOLDCALIPERREADSTO
MMUNITSTHERESHOULDBENOODDDECIMALVALUESEG
MMMM RECORDEDFORSKINFOLDS4ABLEISA

SAMPLEDIGITPREFERENCETABLEFORTRICEPSSKINFOLDMEAS
UREMENTSTAKENBYONESITETEAM4HEOUTPUTFROMTHIS
ANALYSISWASEXAMINEDFORTERMINALDIGITPREFERENCEAND
AVOIDANCE!CCORDINGTOTABLEOBSERVERTENDEDTO
AVOIDDIGITBUTTHEREWASNOPATTERNTOSUGGESTBIAS
IN OBSERVED PROPORTIONS OF THE OTHER DIGITS /N THE
OTHERHANDFOROBSERVERTHEPROPORTIONSOFDIGIT
 VERSUS SUGGESTEDATENDENCYTOOVER
ESTIMATEMEASUREMENTS7HENTHEIMBALANCEBETWEEN
TWOCONSECUTIVEDIGITSWASPARTICULARLYLARGETHEDIF
FERENCESBETWEENMEASUREMENTPAIRSWEREANALYZEDTO
DETERMINEWHETHERTHEAFFECTEDOBSERVERWASBIASEDIN
RELATIONTOOTHERSTHATHADBEENPAIREDWITHHIMORHER
1UALITYCONTROLCHECKSWEREPERFORMEDBYRANDOMLY
CALLINGAPPROXIMATELYOFTHEMOTHERSTOREPEATA
SELECTIONOFTHEQUESTIONSONTHESTUDYFORMSANDTO
ASKTHEMOTHERWHETHERTHECHILDHADBEENMEASURED
TWICEBYTHEINTERVIEWERS4HESECALLSALSOPROVIDEDTHE
OPPORTUNITYTOMONITORPARTICIPANTRESPONSIVENESSAND
SATISFACTIONWITHTHESTUDY
"IMONTHLY EVERY TWO MONTHS STANDARDIZATION
SESSIONSSERVEDTOENSURETHATTHEOBSERVERSWERENOT
DEPARTINGFROMTHEMEASURINGTECHNIQUESOFTHESTUDY

3

-EASUREMENTANDSTANDARDIZATIONPROTOCOLSFORANTHROPOMETRY

4!",%3AMPLETABLEOFTERMINALDIGITPREFERENCEANALYSISINLONGITUDINALFOLLOW UPSTUDYTRICEPSSKINFOLDDATAFROM/MAN
.OOF
MEASURE
/BSERVER
MENTS




















4ERMINALDIGITCONFIDENCEINTERVAL

































































































TOMONITORPRECISIONANDACCURACYANDTOTAKECORREC
TIVEMEASURESEGRETRAINING WHENREQUIRED
4OMAINTAINAGOODRAPPORTWITHTHEFAMILIESEACH
PARTICIPANTINTHELONGITUDINALSTUDYHADONEhFIXEDv
FIELDWORKER FOR THE DURATION OF THE FOLLOW UP 4HE
OTHERFIELDWORKERSWEREROTATEDEVERYTWOMONTHSIN
ORDER TO DISTRIBUTE ERROR TERMS AVOID BOREDOM AND
PREVENTCOMPLICITYTHATMIGHTUNDERMINETHEMEASURE
MENTPROTOCOL

$ISCUSSION
4HE RIGOROUS ANTHROPOMETRIC PROTOCOLS DESCRIBED IN
THISPAPERWERESETINPLACETOENSUREHIGHDATAQUALITY
4HESE-'23PROCEDURESSERVEASAMODELFORRESEARCH
SETTINGS4HEMETHODSANDPROCEDURESREVIEWEDWILLBE
APPLICABLETOMULTI ANDSINGLE SITESTUDIES)TWILLNOT
BEPOSSIBLETOBEASRIGOROUSINNONRESEARCHSETTINGS
SUCHASCHILDCLINICS!TTHEVERYLEASTTHEPROCEDURES
SHOULDBECAREFULLYDOCUMENTEDINTRAININGMANUALS
STAFFMEMBERSCOLLECTINGANTHROPOMETRICDATASHOULD
BETRAINEDANDREFRESHERSESSIONSSHOULDBEHELDPERIOD
ICALLYWEIGHINGSCALESANDANYOTHERINSTRUMENTSUSED
SHOULD BE MAINTAINED IN GOOD ORDER AND CALIBRATED
BEFOREUSEANDFIELDWORKERSSHOULDBESUPERVISED
4HESTANDARDIZATIONSESSIONSWEREEFFECTIVEINIDENTI
FYINGFACTORSTHATCONTRIBUTETOLOWACCURACYANDPRECI
SION IN ANTHROPOMETRIC MEASUREMENTS 4RAINING AND
RETRAINING OPPORTUNITIES WERE AVAILABLE TO HELP KEEP
THEANTHROPOMETRISTSSKILLSSHARPASWEREPRINTEDAND
VIDEOTAPEDREFERENCEMATERIALS4HESEWEREPARTICULARLY
USEFULWHENRESERVESTAFFWEREPREPARINGTOTAKEPART

0ROBABILITY
OFEQUAL
PROPORTIONS
















INDATACOLLECTIONANDWHENNEWTEAMMEMBERSWERE
RECRUITED IN THE COURSE OF THE STUDY )N GENERAL NEW
STAFFBEGANTAKINGANTHROPOMETRICMEASUREMENTSFOR
THE -'23 ONLY AFTER BEING STANDARDIZED AGAINST THE
7(/LEADANTHROPOMETRIST
&ACTORS THAT AFFECTED MEASUREMENT ACCURACY AND
PRECISIONINCLUDEDTHEIDENTIFICATIONOFLANDMARKFEA
TURESWHENMEASURINGSOFTTISSUESARMCIRCUMFERENCE
AND SKINFOLDS  )N SOME SITES THE TEAMS EXPERIENCED
DIFFICULTIESINTAKINGMEASUREMENTSBECAUSETHEYDID
NOTMARKTHEUPPER ARMMIDPOINTORTHESUBSCAPULAR
POINT)NTHISRESPECTTHE#OORDINATING#ENTRESONGO
INGMONITORINGOFANTHROPOMETRICDATAANDTHEREGULAR
PARTICIPATIONOFTHE7(/LEADANTHROPOMETRISTSINSITE
STANDARDIZATIONSESSIONSWEREEXTREMELYIMPORTANTFOR
DETECTINGANDCORRECTINGPROBLEMS
&OR RESEARCH AND PROGRAMMATIC ACTIVITIES IT IS
RELEVANTTONOTETHATTHATTHECHILDSAGECOULDAFFECT
THEPRECISIONOFSOMEMEASUREMENTSJUDGINGBYTHE
DIFFERENCESINREPEATRATESFORARMCIRCUMFERENCE
VERSUS ANDHEADCIRCUMFERENCEVERSUS IN
THELONGITUDINALANDCROSS SECTIONALSTUDIESRESPECTIVELY
5SERS WHO ADOPT THE SAME LIMITS OF MAXIMUM
ALLOWABLEDIFFERENCESBETWEENINDEPENDENTLYRECORDED
DUPLICATEMEASUREMENTSCOULDEVALUATEPERFORMANCE
WITHTHE-'23 OBSERVEDPROPORTIONSASAREFERENCE
4HUSFORCHILDRENBELOWTHEAGEOFTWOYEARSABOUT
OFLENGTHMEASUREMENTPAIRSWILLDIFFERBYMORE
THAN  MM )N THE SAME AGE GROUP  OF DUPLICATE
HEADCIRCUMFERENCESWILLDIFFERBYMORETHANMMAS
WILLOFDUPLICATEARMCIRCUMFERENCEMEASUREMENTS
/VERALL THE RATES OF REPEATED MEASUREMENT ARE
EXPECTEDTOBELOWERINOLDERCHILDRENWHOTENDTOBE

3

-DE/NISETAL

CALMERANDMORECOOPERATIVE!TEAMTHATEXCEEDSTHESE TEAMTHATHASSUBSTANTIALLYLOWERRATESMAYBETAKING
PROPORTIONSMAYBEINNEEDOFFURTHERTRAININGANDA NONINDEPENDENTMEASUREMENTS

2EFERENCES
 DE/NIS-'ARZA#6ICTORA#'/NYANGO!7&RONGILLO
%!-ARTINES*FORTHE7(/-ULTICENTRE'ROWTH2EFER
ENCE3TUDY'ROUP4HE7(/-ULTICENTRE'ROWTH2EF
ERENCE3TUDYPLANNINGSTUDYDESIGNANDMETHODOLOGY
&OOD.UTR"ULL SUPPL 3n
 ,OHMAN4'2OCHE!&-ARTORELL2EDS!NTHROPOMET
RIC STANDARDIZATION REFERENCE MANUAL #HAMPAIGN )LL
53!(UMAN+INETICS"OOKS
 #AMERON.!NTHROPOMETRICMEASUREMENTS)N#AM
ERON.ED4HEMEASUREMENTOFHUMANGROWTH,ONDON
#ROOM(ELMn
 'ORDON###AMERON#HUMLEA72OCHE!&3TATURE
RECUMBENTLENGTHANDWEIGHT)N,OHMAN4'2OCHE
!&-ARTORELL2EDS!NTHROPOMETRICSTANDARDIZATION
REFERENCEMANUAL#HAMPAIGN)LL53!(UMAN+INETICS
"OOKSn
 (ABICHT* 09ARBROUGH#-ARTORELL2!NTHROPOMETRIC
FIELDMETHODSCRITERIAFORSELECTION)N!LFIN 3LATER2"
+RITCHEVSKY$SERIESEDS*ELLIFFE$"*ELLIFFE%&0VOLUME
EDS(UMANGROWTHACOMPREHENSIVETREATISE6OL
.UTRITION AND GROWTH .EW9ORK 0LENUM 0UBLISHING
#OMPANYn
 -ARTORELL 2 -ENDOZA & -UELLER 7( 0AWSON )'
7HICHSIDETOMEASURERIGHTORLEFT)N,OHMAN4'
2OCHE!&-ARTORELL2EDS!NTHROPOMETRICSTANDARDI
ZATIONREFERENCEMANUAL#HAMPAIGN)LL53!(UMAN
+INETICS"OOKSn
 4ANNER*-(IERNAUX**ARMAN3'ROWTHANDPHYSIQUE
STUDIES)N7EINER*3,OURIE*!EDS(UMANBIOLOGY!
GUIDETOFIELDMETHODS)"0(ANDBOOK.O/XFORD
5+"LACKWELL3CIENTIFIC0UBLICATIONSn
 7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION0HYSICALSTATUSTHEUSEAND

INTERPRETATION OF ANTHROPOMETRY 2EPORT OF A 7(/

%XPERT #OMMITTEE 4ECHNICAL 2EPORT 3ERIES .O 
'ENEVA7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION
 -ALINA2-(AMILL066,EMESHOW33ELECTEDMEAS
UREMENTSOFCHILDRENnYEARS6ITAL(EALTHAND3TA
TISTICS3ERIES.O53$((37ASHINGTON$#
53'OVERNMENT0RINTING/FFICE
 $ALY,%"OURKE'*)NTERPRETATIONANDUSESOFMEDICAL
STATISTICSTHED/XFORD5+"LACKWELL3CIENCE
 *OHNSON 43 %NGSTROM *, 'ELHAR $+ )NTRA AND
INTEREXAMINER RELIABILITY OF ANTHROPOMETRIC MEASURE
MENTS OF TERM INFANTS * 0EDIATR 'ASTROENTEROL .UTR
n
 -ARKS '# (ABICHT *0 -UELLER 7( 2ELIABILITY
DEPENDABILITY AND PRECISION OF ANTHROPOMETRIC
MEASUREMENTS!M*%PIDEMIOLn
 -ARTORELL2(ABICHT*09ARBROUGH#'UZMAN'+LEIN
2%4HEIDENTIFICATIONANDEVALUATIONOFMEASUREMENT
VARIABILITYINTHEANTHROPOMETRYOFPRESCHOOLCHILDREN
!M*0HYS!NTHROPOLn
 6ILLAR * +ESTLER % 0AREJA ' -EASUREMENT ERROR IN
CLINICALPERINATALDATA!M*/BSTET'YNECOL
n
 7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION-EASURINGCHANGEINNUTRI
TIONALSTATUS!NNEX3TANDARDIZATIONPROCEDURESFOR
THE COLLECTION OF WEIGHT AND HEIGHT DATA IN THE FIELD
'ENEVA7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION
 /NYANGO!70INOL!*DE/NIS-FORTHE7(/-UL
TICENTRE'ROWTH2EFERENCE3TUDY'ROUP-ANAGINGDATA
FORAMULTICOUNTRYLONGITUDINALSTUDYEXPERIENCEFROM
THE7(/-ULTICENTRE'ROWTH2EFERENCE3TUDY&OOD
.UTR"ULL SUPPL 3n