Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
THREE-SPAN CONTINUOUS
STRAIGHT COMPOSITE
I GIRDER
Load and Resistance Factor Design
(Third Edition -- Customary U.S. Units)
by
Michael A. Grubb, P.E.
Bridge Software Development International, Ltd.
Cranberry Township, PA
and
Robert E. Schmidt, E.I.T.
SITE-Blauvelt Engineers
Pittsburgh, PA
B S D I
DESIGN PARAMETERS
SPECIFICATIONS: LRFD Third Edition (2004)
STRUCTURAL STEEL:
- ASTM A 709 Grade HPS 70W
for flanges in negative-flexure regions
- ASTM A 709 Grade 50W
for all other girder and cross-frame steel
CONCRETE: f'c = 4.0 ksi
REINFORCING STEEL: Fy = 60 ksi
ADTT: 2,000 trucks per day
B S D I
Design Example
3-1
BRIDGE CROSS-SECTION
B S D I
CROSS-FRAMES
(Article 6.7.4.1)
The need for diaphragms or cross-frames shall be
investigated for all stages of assumed construction
procedures and the final condition. The investigation
should include, but not be limited to the following:
w Transfer of lateral wind loads from the bottom of the girder
compression,
w Stability of the top flange in compression prior to
structure.
B S D I
Design Example
3-2
B S D I
CROSS-SECTION PROPORTIONS
Web Depth
Span-to-Depth Ratios (Table 2.5.2.6.3-1)
(t w )min. = D = 69 = 0.46 in .
150
150
B S D I
Design Example
3-3
CROSS-SECTION PROPORTIONS
(continued)
Flange Width (Article 6.10.2.2)
(b f )min. = D / 6 = 69. 0 / 6 = 11 .5 in .
(b fc )min. = L = 100(12) = 14. 1 in.
85
85
B S D I
B S D I
Design Example
3-4
CROSS-SECTION PROPORTIONS
(continued)
Flange Width-to-Thickness (Article 6.10.2.2)
bf
18
=
= 10.3 < 12 .0 ok
2t f 2(0.875 )
I yc
Iyt
B S D I
DEAD LOADS
(Article 3.5.1)
Component Dead Load (DC1)
DC1 = component dead load acting on the
noncomposite section
-
Concrete deck
Overhang tapers
Deck haunches
SIP forms
Cross-frames
& details
TOTAL
B S D I
Design Example
3-5
DEAD LOADS
(continued)
Component Dead Load (DC2)
DC2 = component dead load acting on the
composite section
- Barriers = 0.520/2 = 0.260 k/ft
Note: Distributed equally to exterior girder & adjacent
interior girder
superimposed on
Design Lane Load
0.64 KLF uniformly
distributed load
B S D I
Design Example
3-6
placed in a single
lane
B S D I
Design Example
3-7
WIND LOADS
(Article 3.8)
2
2
V
VDZ
PD = PB DZ = PB
10,000
VB
Eq. (3.8.1.2.1-1)
B S D I
Design Example
3-8
WIND LOADS
(continued)
V Z
VDZ = 2.5 Vo 30 ln
VB Z o
Eq. (3.8.1.1-1)
B S D I
WIND LOADS
(continued)
100 35
VDZ = 2.5 (8 .20 )
= 103 .0 mph
ln
100 0.23
(103 .0 )2
PD = 0.050
= 0.053 ksf
10,000
ok
B S D I
Design Example
3-9
1
D R I 0.95 for minimum s
Load factor
Resistance factor
Nominal force effect
=
Nominal resistance
Factored resistance = Rn
B S D I
LL
IM
CE
BR
PL
LS
WA
STRENGTH-I
?p
1.75
1.00
1.00 0.50/1.20
STRENGTH-II
?p
1.35
1.00
1.00 0.50/1.20
STRENGTH-III
?p
1.00
1.40
1.00 0.50/1.20
STRENGTH-IV
EH, EV, ES, DW
DC ONLY
?p
1.5
1.00
1.00 0.50/1.20
STRENGTH-V
?p
1.35
1.00
0.40
0.40
EXTREME-I
?p
?EQ
1.00
1.00
?p
1.00
Load Combination
Limit State
EXTREME-II
WL
FR
TU
CR
SH
IC
CT
CV
?TG ?SE
?TG ?SE
?TG ?SE
1.00 0.50/1.20
0.50
1.00
SERVICE-I
1.00 1.00
1.00
0.30
0.30
1.00 1.00/1.20
SERVICE-II
1.00 1.30
1.00
1.00 1.00/1.20
SERVICE-III
1.00 0.80
1.00
1.00 1.00/1.20
FATIGUE-LL, IM & CE
ONLY
Design Example
WS
0.75
1.00
?TG ?SE
?TG ?SE
-
?TG ?SE
-
3-10
Maximum
Minimum
1.25
0.90
DD: Downdrag
1.80
0.45
1.50
0.65
1.50
1.35
0.90
0.90
1.35
1.35
1.30
N/A
1.00
0.90
1.35
1.95
0.90
0.90
B S D I
B S D I
Design Example
3-11
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
Summary -- Live-Load Distribution Factors:
Strength Limit State
Bending Moment
Shear
Interior Girder
0.807 lanes
1.082 lanes
Exterior Girder
0.950 lanes
0.950 lanes
Interior Girder
0.440 lanes
0.700 lanes
Exterior Girder
0.750 lanes
0.750 lanes
B S D I
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
(continued)
Distribution Factor for Live-Load Deflection:
N
DF = m 3 L
Nb
3
= 0.85 = 0.638 lanes
4
B S D I
Design Example
3-12
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
(continued)
Dynamic Load Allowance Impact (IM)
COMPONENT
Deck Joints All Limit States
IM
75%
15%
33%
B S D I
B S D I
Design Example
3-13
B S D I
B S D I
Design Example
3-14
B S D I
Design Example
3-15
B S D I
SECTION PROPERTIES
Section 1-1 (@ 0.4L1)
Effective Flange Width (Article 4.6.2.6):
Interior Girder
L 100 .0 x 12
=
= 300 .0 in.
4
4
or
1 2.0 t s +
16 .0
b tf
= 12 .0 (9.0 ) +
= 116 .0 in. (governs)
2
2
or
average spacing of girders = 144 .0 in.
B S D I
Design Example
3-16
t c Pw + Pt Ps
+ 1
2
Pc
B S D I
Design Example
3-17
M D 1 MD 2 M AD
+
+
S NC SLT S ST
9.0
(43 .0) + 2 1 3.0 + 0 .5 3. 5 18 2 = 33.17 ft 2 = 4,776 in.2
12
12
12 2
0.01( 4,776 ) = 47 .76 in.2
47 .76
= 1.11 in.2 ft = 0.0926 in.2 in.
43.0
B S D I
Design Example
3-18
Constructibility
B S D I
DECK-PLACEMENT SEQUENCE
B S D I
Design Example
3-19
1360
1822
1870
1850
1528
1038
335
53
Design Example
3-20
Pier 1
Pier 2
Abut. 2
Steel Weight
-13.
-53.
-53.
-13.
sum
-13.
-53.
-53.
-13.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SIP Forms (SIP)
-6.
-21.
-21.
-6.
sum
-19.
-74.
-74.
-19.
Cast 1
-80.
-55.
-55.
-80.
sum
-99.
-129.
-129.
-99.
Cast 2
13.
-75.
-75.
14.
sum
-85.
-204.
-204.
-85.
Cast 3
-1.
-110.
-110.
-1.
sum
-86.
-314.
-314.
-86.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Sum of Casts + SIP -73.
-261.
-261.
-73.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DC 2 + DW
-26.
-90.
-90.
-26.
=====================================================
Total
-112.
-404.
-404.
-112.
Deck, haunches
+ SIP
-74.
-261.
-261.
-74.
DECK-PLACEMENT ANALYSIS
(continued)
Calculate fbu: (at Section 1-1 -> 56-0 from abut.)
For STRENGTH I:
1.0(1.25)(2,889)(12)
= 27.41 ksi
1,581
1.0(1.25)(2,889)(12)
= 21.96 ksi
Bot. flange: fbu =
1,973
1.0(1.5)(2,889)(12)
= 32.89 ksi
1,581
1.0(1.5)(2,889)(12)
= 26.36 ksi
1,973
B S D I
Design Example
3-21
DECK-OVERHANG LOADS
F = P tan
3. 5 ft
= tan 1
= 31 .3o
5.75 ft
B S D I
P = 255 lbs/ft
Construction loads:
Overhang deck forms:
Screed rail:
Walkway:
Railing:
Finishing machine:
P = 40 lbs/ft
P = 85 lbs/ft
P = 125 lbs/ft
P = 25 lbs/ft
P = 3000 lbs
B S D I
Design Example
3-22
L b 1.2L p
Otherwise:
Or:
CbR b
fbm Fyc
then, no amplification
0. 85
fl =
f f
fbm l1 l1
1 F
cr
Eq. (6.10.1.6-4)
fl = ( AF)fl1 fl1
B S D I
CbR b
fbm Fyc
Eq. (6.10.1.6-2)
Rb = 1.0
Cb = 1.0
fbm = fbu = -32.89 ksi (STRENGTH IV)
L p = 1.0rt
E
Fyc
Eq. (6.10.8.2.3-4)
where: rt =
b fc
1 Dc t w
12 1 +
3 b fc t fc
Eq. (6.10.8.2.3-9)
B S D I
Design Example
3-23
1 38 .63(0.5 )
12 1 +
3 16(1)
rt =
Lp =
1.2(7. 83 )
1.0(1.0 )
= 11.59 ft < Lb = 24 .0 ft
32 .89 50
B S D I
Fcr =
CbR b 2E
Lb
rt
1.0(1.0) 2 (29,000)
= 52.49 ksi
Fcr =
2
24(12 )
3 .90
Eq. (6.10.8.2.3-8)
Note:
Fcr may exceed
RbRhFyc in this
calculation.
Design Example
3-24
AF =
0.85
= 1.78 > 1. 0 ok
27.41
1
52.49
AF =
0.85
= 2.28 > 1. 0 ok
32.89
1
52. 49
B S D I
Bot. flange: fl =
Ml
21 .34 (12 )
=
= 3 .45 ksi
S l 1 .375 (18 )2 6
B S D I
Design Example
3-25
M
8.21(12 )
= 1.33 ksi
Bot. flange: fl = l =
Sl 1.375 (18)2 6
B S D I
ok
B S D I
Design Example
3-26
B S D I
B S D I
Design Example
3-27
CONSTRUCTIBILITY - FLEXURE
(Article 6.10.3.2)
Determine if the section is a slender-web section:
2Dc
E
5 .7
tw
Fyc
Eq. (6.10.6.2.3-1)
E
29,000
= 5 .7
= 137 .3 < 154.5
Fyc
50
CONSTRUCTIBILITY - FLEXURE
(Article 6.10.3.2)
For discretely braced compression flanges:
Eq. (6.10.3.2.1-1)
fbu + fl f R hFyc
1
fbu + fl f Fnc
3
Eq. (6.10.3.2.1-2)
fbu f Fcrw
Eq. (6.10.3.2.1-3)
Design Example
3-28
pf = 0.38
FLB
Eq. (6.10.8.2.2-1)
B S D I
Fnc=RbRhFyc
Fnc=RbRhFyc
Fyr f pf
RbRhFyc
Fnc = 1 1
RhFyc rf pf
Anchor point 1
Fyr Lb Lp
R R F RbRhFyc
Fnc = Cb 11
RhFyc Lr Lp b h yc
Anchor point 2
Mr r
Fr or M
noncompact
CbRb2 E
(inelastic buckling)
Lb
rt
compact
nonslender
slender
(elastic buckling)
B S D IL p o r p pf
Design Example
Lr
o rr r f
L b o r b f c/ 2 t fc
3-29
where:
E
Fyr
Eq. (6.10.8.2.3-5)
Therefore: L r =
B S D I
Fnc = Cb 1 1
L L RbR hFyc RbR hFyc
R
F
h
yc
r
p
Eq. (6.10.8.2.3-2)
35.0 24.0 7.83
Fnc = 1.0 1 1
Therefore:
B S D I
Design Example
3-30
Fnc=RbRhFyc
Fnc=RbRhFyc
Anchor point 1
Fyr f pf
R R F
Fnc = 1 1
R Fyc rf pf b h yc
h
Fyr Lb Lp
RbRhFyc RbRhFyc
Fnc = Cb 11
RhFyc Lr Lp
Anchor point 2
Fr or M
Mr r
noncompact
CbRb2 E
(inelastic buckling)
Lb
rt
compact
nonslender
slender
(elastic buckling)
B S D IL p o r p pf
Lr
o rr r f
L b o r b f c/ 2 t fc
CONSTRUCTIBILITY - FLEXURE
Top Flange
For STRENGTH I:
fbu + fl fR hFyc
Eq. (6.10.3.2.1-1)
fbu +
ok
1
fl f Fnc
3
(Ratio = 0.844 )
Eq. (6.10.3.2.1-2)
1
14 .79
fl = 27 .41 ksi +
ksi = 32.34 ksi
3
3
f Fnc = 1.0(38 .75) = 38 .75 ksi
fbu +
ok
(Ratio = 0.835 )
B S D I
Design Example
3-31
WEB BEND-BUCKLING
RESISTANCE (Article 6.10.1.9)
Fcrw =
0.9Ek
D
tw
k=
k=
Fcrw =
(38.63 69.0 )2
0.9(29,000)(28.7)
69 .0
0.5
(D c D)2
= 28 .7
B S D I
CONSTRUCTIBILITY - FLEXURE
Web & Top Flange (continued)
fbu f Fcrw
Eq. (6.10.3.2.1-3)
ok
fbu + fl f R hFyc
(Ratio = 0.697)
Eq. (6.10.3.2.1-1)
ok
(Ratio = 0.955)
B S D I
Design Example
3-32
CONSTRUCTIBILITY - FLEXURE
Top Flange (continued) & Web
1
fbu + fl fFnc
3
Eq. (6.10.3.2.1-2)
14.87
1
ksi = 37.85 ksi
fbu + fl = 32.89 ksi +
3
3
fFnc = 1.0(38.75) = 38.75 ksi
37.85 ksi < 38.75 ksi ok
(Ratio = 0.977)
fbu f Fcrw
Eq. (6.10.3.2.1-3)
ok
(Ratio = 0.836)
B S D I
CONSTRUCTIBILITY
Wind Load - Section 1-1
Calculate fbu due to the steel weight within the
unbraced length containing Section 1-1:
For STRENGTH III:
Top Flange:
Bottom Flange:
1.0(1.25)(352 )(12)
= 3.34 ksi
1,581
1.0(1.25)(352 )(12)
=
= 2.68 ksi
1,973
fbu =
fbu
B S D I
Design Example
3-33
B S D I
CONSTRUCTIBILITY
Wind Load - Section 1-1 (continued)
Assume Span 1 of the structure resists the lateral
wind force as a propped cantilever with an
effective span length of 120-0 (i.e. assume top
lateral bracing provides an effective line of fixity
20-0 from the pier):
M11 =
9
9
WL2e =
(0.403)(120.0)2 = 408.0 kip ft
128
128
B S D I
Design Example
3-34
CONSTRUCTIBILITY
Wind Load - Section 1-1 (continued)
Proportion total lateral moment to top & bottom flanges
according to relative lateral stiffness of each flange. Then,
divide total lateral moment equally to each girder:
Top Flg: Il =
1(16) 3
= 341.3 in.4
12
Bot Flg: Il =
1.375(18)3
= 668 .3 in.4
12
Top Flange: Ml =
408.0(341 .3)
= 34.48 kip ft
(341 .3 + 668 .3)4
Bottom Flange: Ml =
408.0(668 .3)
= 67.52 kip ft
(341 .3 + 668 .3)4
B S D I
CONSTRUCTIBILITY
Wind Load - Section 1-1 (continued)
Separate calculations indicate that lateral bending stresses
in the top (compression) flange may be determined from a
first-order analysis (i.e. no amplification is required).
Top Flange: fl =
Bottom Flange: fl =
34.48(12)
= 9.70 ksi < 0.6Fyf = 30.0 ksi ok
1(16) 2 6
67.52(12)
= 10.91 ksi < 0.6Fyf = 30.0 ksi ok
1. 375(18 )2 6
B S D I
Design Example
3-35
B S D I
CONSTRUCTIBILITY
Wind Load - Section 1-1 (continued)
Calculate the shear in the propped cantilever at the assume
effective line of fixity:
Vf f =
5
5
WL e = (0.403 )(120.0 ) = 30.23 kips
8
8
= 58.76 kips
B S D I
Design Example
3-36
CONSTRUCTIBILITY
Wind Load - Section 1-1 (continued)
Separate calculations (see example) indicate a
compressive force of -19.04 kips in the diagonal
to the self-weight of the steel. Therefore, the total
compressive force in the bracing diagonal is:
(-58.76 kips) + (-19.04 kips) = -77.80 kips
(Note: refined 3D analysis => -67.0 kips)
B S D I
CONSTRUCTIBILITY
Wind Load - Section 1-1 (continued)
Estimate the maximum lateral deflection of Span 1 of the
structure (i.e. the propped cantilever) due to the factored
wind load using the total lateral moments of inertia of the
top & bottom flanges of all four girders at Section 1-1:
l max. =
WL4e
0.403(120.0 )4 (1,728 )
=
= 6.7 in.
185EI 185 (29,000 )(341 .3 + 668.3) 4
max. =
12.3 inches
B S D I
Design Example
3-37
CONSTRUCTIBILITY
Performance Ratios
POSITIVE-MOMENT REGION, SPAN 1 (Section 1-1)
B S D I
CONSTRUCTIBILITY
Shear (Article 6.10.3.3)
Interior panels of stiffened webs must satisfy:
Vu v Vcr
Eq. (6.10.3.3-1)
Vn = Vcr = CVp
Eq. (6.10.9.3.3-1)
(Ratio = 0.447)
B S D I
Design Example
3-38
CONSTRUCTIBILITY
Section 2-2 (Interior Pier)
In regions of negative flexure, the constructibility checks
for flexure generally do not control because the sizes of the
flanges in these regions are normally governed by the sum
of the factored dead and live load stresses at the strength
limit state. Also, the maximum accumulated negative
moments during the deck placement in these regions
typically do not differ significantly from the calculated DC1
negative moments. Deck overhang brackets and wind
loads do induce lateral bending into the flanges, which can
be considered using the flexural design equations.
Web bend-buckling and shear should always be checked in
these regions for critical stages of construction (refer to the
design example).
B S D I
CONSTRUCTIBILITY
Concrete Deck (Article 6.10.3.2.4)
Unless longitudinal reinforcement is provided
according to the provisions of Article 6.10.1.7,
fdeck fr = 0.9fr
fr = 0.24 fc' = 0.24 4.0 = 0.480 ksi
B S D I
Design Example
3-39
1360
1822
1870
1850
1528
1038
335
53
CONSTRUCTIBILITY
Concrete Deck (continued)
Calculate the longitudinal concrete deck tensile
stress at the end of Cast 1 (use n = 8):
fdeck =
Design Example
3-40
Service
Limit State
B S D I
140 .0(12 )
= 2.10 in. > 0 .91 in. ok
800
175 .0(12 )
= 2.63 in. > 1.23 in.
800
ok
B S D I
Design Example
3-41
ff 0 .95RhFyf
Eq. (6.10.4.2.2-1)
f
+ l 0.95 RhFyf
2
Eq. (6.10.4.2.2-2)
fc Fcrw
Web bend-buckling:
Eq. (6.10.4.2.2-4)
B S D I
ok
(Ratio = 0.469)
B S D I
Design Example
3-42
B S D I
Design Example
3-43
B S D I
WEB BEND-BUCKLING
RESISTANCE (Article 6.10.1.9)
Fcrw =
0.9Ek
D
tw
where:
k=
9
(D c D )2
Eq. (6.10.1.9.1-1)
Eq. (6.10.1.9.1-2)
Design Example
3-44
WEB BEND-BUCKLING
RESISTANCE (Article 6.10.1.9)
Check the bottom-flange transition (controls):
1 .0 ( 2,656 ) 1 .0( 373 + 358 ) 1 .3 ( 2,709 )
f f = 1 .0
+
+
12 = 38 .88 ksi
1,789
2,246
2 ,463
( 38 .88 )
71 .0 1 . 0 = 43 . 25 in . > 0
D c =
38
.
88
+
23
.
51
9
k=
= 22 .9
(43 .25 69 .0 )2
Fcrw =
0.9(29,000)(22.9)
= 39.72 ksi
2
69. 0
0.5625
ok
38 . 88 < 39 . 72 ksi
ok Ratio = (0.979)
B S D I
0.433
0.469
0.775
0.415
0.368
0.604
0.609
0.898
0.979
B S D I
Design Example
3-45
1. 0 [1 . 0( 87 ) + 1 . 0( 83 ) + 1. 3 ( 1,701) ]( 23 . 20 )( 12 )
= 0 . 440 ksi
161,518 ( 8 )
> 0.90f r = 0.432 ksi
Fatigue &
Fracture Limit
State
B S D I
Design Example
3-46
B S D I
FATIGUE RESISTANCE
FIRST PRINCIPAL
For lower traffic volumes, fatigue resistance is
inversely proportional to the cube of the effective
stress range.
B S D I
Design Example
3-47
FATIGUE RESISTANCE
SECOND PRINCIPAL
For higher traffic volumes, fatigue resistance is
infinite if the maximum stress range is less than
the constant-amplitude fatigue threshold.
B S D I
FATIGUE LOAD
(Article 3.6.1.4)
The specified load condition for fatigue is a single
truck; the current HS20 truck with a fixed rearaxle spacing of 30-0.
The truck occupies a single lane on the bridge -not multiple lanes.
The fatigue load produces a lower calculated
stress range than the Standard Specifications.
B S D I
Design Example
3-48
LL
IM
CE
BR
PL
LS
WA
STRENGTH-I
?p
1.75
1.00
1.00 0.50/1.20
STRENGTH-II
?p
1.35
1.00
1.00 0.50/1.20
STRENGTH-III
?p
1.00
1.40
1.00 0.50/1.20
STRENGTH-IV
EH, EV, ES, DW
DC ONLY
?p
1.5
1.00
1.00 0.50/1.20
STRENGTH-V
?p
1.35
1.00
0.40
0.40
EXTREME-I
?p
?EQ
1.00
1.00
?p
1.00
Load Combination
Limit State
EXTREME-II
WS
WL
FR
TU
CR
SH
EQ
IC
CT
CV
?TG ?SE
?TG ?SE
?TG ?SE
1.00 0.50/1.20
0.50
1.00
SERVICE-I
1.00 1.00
1.00
0.30
0.30
1.00 1.00/1.20
SERVICE-II
1.00 1.30
1.00
1.00 1.00/1.20
SERVICE-III
1.00 0.80
1.00
1.00 1.00/1.20
FATIGUE-LL, IM & CE
ONLY
0.75
1.00
?TG ?SE
?TG ?SE
-
?TG ?SE
-
B S D I
Design Example
3-49
3
(F)n = A 1 (F)TH
N 2
Eq. (6.6.1.2.5-1)
Eq. (6.6.1.2.5-2)
B S D I
Design Example
3-50
B S D I
3
(F)n = A 1 (F)TH Eq. (6.6.1.2.5-1)
N 2
N = ( 365 )( 75 )n( ADTT ) SL Eq. (6.6.1.2.5-2)
Design Example
3-51
( f )e
N
( )
( )
f max F TH
----------------------------------------------------------------------
(f )max = 2.0(f )e
(f )e
1
(F)TH
2
B S D I
B S D I
Design Example
3-52
B S D I
Eq. (3.6.1.4.2-1)
Design Example
3-53
B S D I
fDC 1 =
fLL + IM =
Design Example
3-54
? (?f ) =
A
1
(F)n = 3 (F)TH
2
N
Eq. (6.6.1.2.5-1)
B S D I
B S D I
Design Example
3-55
( F )n = 2 ( F )TH
For a Category C detail, (F)TH = 12.0 ksi (Table 6.6.1.2.5-3). Therefore:
( f ) (F )n
Eq. (6.6.1.2.2-1)
ok
(Ratio = 0.993)
B S D I
0.993
0.208
0.618
0.113
0.636
B S D I
Design Example
3-56
Eq. (6.10.5.3-1)
Vn = Vcr = CVp
Eq. (6.10.9.3.3-1)
ok
(Ratio = 0.618)
B S D I
Strength
Limit State
B S D I
Design Example
3-57
3.76
ok
ok
ok
Fyc
Eq. (6.10.7.3-1)
ok
B S D I
Design Example
3-58
Eq. (6.10.7.1.1-1)
B S D I
W =
PDd
2
Eq. (C4.6.2.7.1-1)
WL2b
10
Eq. (C4.6.2.7.1-2)
Mw =
= 1.0 Lb = 24-0 WL = 0
AF = 1.0 for tension flanges
B S D I
Design Example
3-59
Mw =
fl =
0.221(24.0) 2
= 12.73 kip ft
10
Mw
12. 73(12 )
=
= 2. 06 ksi * AF = 2.06 (1 .0) = 2.06 ksi
Sl 1.375 (18 )2 6
< 0. 6Fyf = 30 .0 ksi ok
B S D I
Mw =
fl =
0.063(24 .0)2
= 3.63 kip ft
10
Mw
3 .63(12)
=
= 0 .587 ksi * AF = 0.587 (1.0) = 0 .587 ksi
Sl 1.375(18 )2 6
< 0.6Fyf = 30 .0 ksi ok
B S D I
Design Example
3-60
Otherwise:
Mn = Mp
Dp
Mn = Mp 1.07 0.7
Dt
Eq. (6.10.7.1.2-1)
Eq. (6.10.7.1.2-2)
Eq. (6.10.7.1.2-3)
B S D I
Design Example
3-61
Dp
Mn = Mp 1. 07 0.7
Dt
Eq.(6.10. 7.1.2 2 )
11.94
Mn = 14 ,199 1.07 0 .7
= 13,761 kip ft
82 .88
S xt =
Myt
Fyt
10,171(12)
= 2,441 in3
50
B S D I
Eq. (6 .10.7.1 .1 1)
For STRENGTH I:
1
Mu + flS xt = 9,797 kip ft + 0 = 9,797 kip ft
3
f Mn = 1.0(13,222 ) = 13,222 kip ft
9,797 kip ft < 13,222 kip ft
ok
(Ratio = 0.741)
1
1 (2.06 )(2,441)
Mu + flS xt = 3,654 kip ft +
= 3,794 kip ft
3
12
3
f Mn = 1.0(13,222 ) = 13,222 kip ft
3,794 kip ft < 13,222 kip ft
ok
(Ratio = 0.287)
B S D I
Design Example
3-62
Eq. (6 .10.7.1 .1 1)
1
Mu + flS xt = 4,289 kip ft + 0 = 4,289 kip ft
3
f Mn = 1.0(13,222 ) = 13,222 kip ft
4,289 kip ft < 13,222 kip ft
ok
(Ratio = 0.324)
For STRENGTH V:
1
1 (0.587 )(2,441)
Mu + flS xt = 8,393 kip ft +
= 8,433 kip ft
3
12
3
f Mn = 1.0(13,222 ) = 13,222 kip ft
8,433 kip ft < 13,222 kip ft
ok
(Ratio = 0.638)
B S D I
0.343
0.741
0.287
0.324
0.638
0.995
B S D I
Design Example
3-63
SHEAR
(Article 6.10.9)
Highlights:
n
B S D I
SHEAR
End Panels (Article 6.10.9.3.3)
End panels must satisfy:
Vu vVn
Eq. (6.10.9.1-1)
V p = 0 . 58 F yw Dt
Eq. (6.10.9.3.3-1)
= 1,001 kips
B S D I
Design Example
3-64
SHEAR
Interior Panels (Article 6.10.9.3.2)
For interior panels of hybrid & nonhybrid
members with the section along the entire panel
proportioned such that:
2Dt w
2.5
(b fc t fc + b ft t ft )
Eq. (6.10.9.3.2-1)
0.87(1 C)
Vn = Vp C +
2
1 + o
Eq. (6.10.9.3.2-2)
B S D I
SHEAR
Interior Panels (continued)
For interior panels of hybrid and nonhybrid
members with the panel proportioned such that:
2Dt w
(b fc t fc + b ft t ft )
> 2.5
Eq. (6.10.9.3.2-1)
0.87(1 C)
Vn = Vp C +
1 + do + do
D
D
Eq. (6.10.9.3.2-8)
B S D I
Design Example
3-65
B S D I
SHEAR
Interior Panels (continued)
do = 16.75 ft = 201.0 in. < 3D = 207.0 in.
Vu = 1. 0[1 .25 (74 + 11) + 1.5 (11) + 1. 75 (127 )] = 345 kips
int . girder at 87 in. from abutment
Eq. (6.10.9.2-1)
C = 0.239 (calculated w/ k = 5)
Vp = 0. 58(50)(69.0)(0.5 ) = 1,001 kips
Vn = Vcr = 0.239(1,001) = 239 kips
v Vn = 1.0(239) = 239 kips < 345 kips stiffeners are required
B S D I
Design Example
3-66
SHEAR
Interior Panels (continued)
Calculate Vn for the stiffened panel:
2(69.0)(0.5 )
[16(1.0) + 18(0.875 )]
k =5+
1 .40
5
201 .0
69.0
Ek
29,000(5.59)
D 69 .0
= 1.40
= 79 .7 <
=
= 138 .0
Fyw
50
tw
0. 5
B S D I
SHEAR
Interior Panels (continued)
Calculate Vn for the stiffened panel (contd):
C=
1.57 Ek
2
D Fyw
tw
1.57 29,000(5.59)
= 0.267
=> C = (138 .0 )2
50
Vp = 0. 58(50)(69.0)(0.5) = 1,001kips
0.87(1 0.267 )
Vn = 1,0010.267 +
= 475 kips
2
201 .0
1+
69 .0
Design Example
3-67
29,000
= 116.0
70
2(36.55)
= 130.0 > 116.0
0.5625
Eq. (6.10.8.1.1-1)
Eq. (6.10.8.1.3-1)
B S D I
Design Example
3-68
Bottom flange:
B S D I
12 + 3 3
12+ 2
=
=
2Dnt w
Afn
Fyw
fn
Eq. (6.10.1.10.1-1)
Eq. (6.10.1.10.1-2)
1.0
B S D I
Design Example
3-69
2(36.55 )(0.5625 )
2Dnt w
= 1. 028
=> =
40 .0
Afn
Fyw
fn
1.0 =>
50 .0
= 0.714
70 .0
B S D I
Design Example
3-70
Rh =
12 + 3 3
12+ 2
B S D I
2D c
R b = 1
rw 1 .0
1200
300
a
t
+
wc w
a wc =
Eq. (6.10.1.10.2-3)
2D c t w 2(36.55 )(0.5625 )
=
= 1.028
20(2)
b fc t fc
1 .028
Rb = 1
(130.0 116.0 ) = 0.990
+
1200
300
(
1
.
028
)
B S D I
Design Example
3-71
Fnc
FLB
E
29,000
= 0 .38
= 7.73
Fyc
70
Eq. (6.10.8.2.2-1)
B S D I
Fnc=RbRhFyc
Anchor point 1
Fnc=RbRhFyc
Fyr f pf
RbRhFyc
Fnc = 1 1
RhFyc rf pf
Fyr Lb Lp
R R F RbRhFyc
Fnc = Cb 11
RhFyc Lr Lp b h yc
Anchor point 2
Mr r
Fr or M
noncompact
CbRb2 E
(inelastic buckling)
Lb
rt
nonslender
slender
(elastic buckling)
B S D IL p o r p pf
Design Example
Lr
o rr r f
L b or b f c/ 2 t fc
3-72
B S D I
B S D I
Design Example
3-73
E
Fyc
where:
Eq. (6.10.8.2.3-4)
rt =
Therefore:
rt =
b fc
1 Dc t w
12 1 +
3 b fc t fc
20
= 5.33 in.
1 36.55(0. 5625 )
12 1 +
20 (2 )
3
Lp =
1.0(5.33 ) 29,000
= 9.04 ft
12
70
B S D I
where:
E
Fyr
Therefore:
Eq. (6.10.8.2.3-5)
Lr =
(5.33) 29,000
= 33.95 ft
12
49.0
B S D I
Design Example
3-74
Eq. (6.10.8.2.3-6)
Otherwise:
f
f
Cb = 1.75 1.05 1 + 0.3 1 2 .3
f
2
f2
f1 = 2fmid f2 fo
Eq. (6.10.8.2.3-7)
Eq. (6.10.8.2.3-10)
B S D I
Examples:
f1 = 2fmid f2 fo
f1
f0
f mid
f2
f 1/f 2 = 0.75
Cb = 1.13
Lb
f mid /f 2 = 0.875
f1 /f 2 = 0.375
f1 = f0
f0
fm i d
fmid
f0
f2
f2
C b = 1.40
fmid > f 2
Cb = 1
f2 = 0
f mid
Cb = 1
f0 < 0
f1
f2
f1 /f 2 = 0.5
C b = 1.3
B S D I
Design Example
f0 = 0
3-75
31.34
31.34
Cb = 1. 75 1.05
+ 0 .3
= 1.25 < 2. 3
55
.
64
55.64
Note: fo is positive for compression. f2 is always positive.
B S D I
R hFyc L r L p
Eq. (6.10.8.2.3-2)
49.0 17.0 9.04
Fnc = 1.25 1 1
Therefore:
B S D I
Design Example
3-76
Fnc=RbRhFyc
Anchor point 1
Fnc=RbRhFyc
Fyr f pf
R R F
Fnc = 1 1
R Fyc rf pf b h yc
h
Fyr Lb Lp
RbRhFyc RbRhFyc
Fnc = Cb 11
RhFyc Lr Lp
Anchor point 2
Fr or M
Mr r
noncompact
CbRb2 E
(inelastic buckling)
Lb
rt
nonslender
slender
(elastic buckling)
B S D IL p o r p pf
Lr
o rr r f
L b or b f c/ 2 t fc
Design Example
3-77
B S D I
Design Example
3-78
Fnc = Cb 1 1
L L RbR hFyc RbR hFyc
R
F
h yc r
p
Eq. (6.10.8.2.3-2)
49 .0 20.0 8. 40
Fnc = 1.0 1 1
Therefore:
B S D I
2-2
= 61.14 ksi
B S D I
Design Example
3-79
b fc
20
E
=
= 10. 0 > pf = 0.38
= 7.73
2t fc 2(1)
Fyc
rf = 0.56
E
Fyr
Eq. (6.10.8.2.2-5)
Therefore:
rf = 0.56
29 ,000
= 13.62
49 .0
B S D I
R bRhFyc
Fnc = 1 1
R hFyc rf pf
Eq. (6.10.8.2.2-2)
49 .0
10.0 7 .73
Fnc = 1 1
Therefore:
B S D I
Design Example
3-80
Fnc=RbRhFyc
Fyr f pf
R R F
Fnc = 1 1
R Fyc rf pf b h yc
Anchor point 1
Fnc=RbRhFyc
Fyr Lb Lp
RbRhFyc RbRhFyc
Fnc = Cb 11
RhFyc Lr Lp
Anchor point 2
Fr or M
Mr r
noncompact
CbRb2 E
(inelastic buckling)
Lb
rt
nonslender
slender
(elastic buckling)
Lr
o rr r f
B S D IL p o r p pf
L b or b f c/ 2 t fc
Top Flange:
Bottom Flange:
Bottom Flange:
1 . 25 ( 2 ,656 ) 1 . 25 ( 373 ) 1 . 5 ( 358 ) 1 . 75 ( 2 ,709 )
+
+
+
f = 1 .0
12 = 57 . 54 ksi
1,789
1,862
1, 862
1,975
B S D I
Design Example
3-81
Eq. (6.10.8.1.1-1)
1
fbu + fl = - 57.54 ksi + 0 = 57.54ksi
3
fFnc = 1.0(57.11)= 57.11ksi
57.54 ksi > 57.11ksi say ok
(Ratio = 1.008)
B S D I
fbu fRhFyf
Section 2-2:
Eq. (6.10.8.1.3-1)
ok
(Ratio = 0.792)
Flange transition:
fbu = 52.86 ksi
fR hFyf = 1.0(0.971)(70 .00) = 67. 97 ksi
52.86 ksi < 67.97 ksi
ok
(Ratio = 0.778)
B S D I
Design Example
3-82
1.008
0.792
0.778
0.536
0.460
0.445
0.617
0.541
0.524
0.896
0.716
0.700
B S D I
Design Example
3-83
QUESTIONS
Michael A. Grubb, P.E.
BSDI, Ltd.
724-709-8349
m.grubb@comcast.net
B S D I
Design Example
3-84