Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Collegiate
Case
Study www.usatodaycollege.com
© Copyright 2007 USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Co., Inc. All rights reser ved.
AS SEEN IN USA TODAY’S NEWS SECTION, AUGUST 28, 2007
accredited by the American Academy of Durand sold the idea of a forensics By the time of O.J. Simpson's trial in
Forensic Sciences, says Jim Hurley, major to colleagues last December, after 1995, the field had "exploded," Siegel
director of accreditation. He expects the the Albuquerque Journal published says. "I've been waiting for the boom to
number to rise as more programs adopt several investigative stories detailing a level off and it hasn't."
the rigid science course work required. 10-year backlog of cases awaiting DNA
analysis in the state crime lab. Since the forensic science program
Although no one seems to know why, launched in 2002 at West Virginia
the field is increasingly dominated by The stories prompted New Mexico University, it has grown to 500 students
women. At Indiana University-Purdue Gov. Bill Richardson to ask legislators to from 35 countries, Director Keith Morris
University Indianapolis, 90% of the increase the lab's budget by $751,000 says.
forensic science students are female. and approve construction of a $350
million lab. Despite all that appeal, many of the
At Metropolitan State College in programs have high dropout rates, Siegel
Denver, which is one of the smallest "Labs are really struggling. Prosecutors says.
programs, 13 of 15 students are women. are having problems," Durand says.
"We have a number of students who
"I don't know why," says Charles The study of forensic science has only come in each year thinking they're going
Tindall, who directs Metropolitan's recently bloomed, largely as a result of to crime scenes in Hummers and Armani
forensic science program. "When you ask expansion of DNA analysis as an suits and then find out there's a lot of
them, they say: 'I've always wanted to do investigative tool and the televising of big science involved here," he says.
this.' Like they were born to it. None of trials. Before 1980, when Jay Siegel set up
them will say they watch CSI." one of the first programs at Michigan
State University, "there were just a
Starting pay for beginning forensic handful of people who could even tell
scientists averages $35,000-$45,000 a you what forensic science was," he says.
year, according to industry estimates.
Irvine and a critic of lax laborator y The few courts that have ruled on the DNA that was "voluntarily and freely"
procedures, says storing DNA in issue have given conflicting opinions. obtained, even if it was given in an
prevention databases "substantially unrelated case.
raises the risk of errors and frame-ups." In March 2003, a trial court judge in
Brooklyn upheld Midgley's rape In Brooklyn in 2004, Troy Hendrix
Joseph Lentol, a Democratic New York indictment after he was caught with the sought a court order to prevent DNA he
state assemblyman, is author of a bill that help of a New York City database. gave during a murder, torture and rape
would ban the databases in his state. investigation from being added to the
Using DNA taken during one A week later, a different Brooklyn judge suspect database. He was ultimately
investigation to solve another crime, he ruled the same database was not convicted of rape and murder, but not
says, is "just wrong." authorized by state law. He ordered before he and a co-defendant sneaked
authorities to return a rape suspect's sharpened plastic sticks into the
Police should at least be forced to tell DNA profile without including it in the courtroom and stabbed a lawyer and a
suspects who give their DNA voluntarily database. court officer in an unsuccessful attempt
that it may be used against them, he to escape.
says. Last year, the American Bar Association
recommended that suspect databases be "I told my colleagues 'Hey look, here's
The databases exist in a legal gray area. banned and that labs that use them be our client on the news,'" recalls Beth
Most states neither authorize nor forbid prosecuted. Haroules, a New York Civil Liberties
them, says Lisa Hurst, who maintains the Union attorney who helped Hendrix
website dnaresource.com for Gordon In Florida, a 2000 opinion from the seek the court order. "It was pretty
Thomas Honeywell Governmental state crime lab's counsel says suspect disturbing, but I still think we were right"
Affairs, a Tacoma, Wash., firm. databases are legal because they use to oppose the suspect database.
2. This case study mentions other kinds of DNA aside from human nuclear DNA. Explain how mitochondrial and animal
DNA are currently being used to solve crimes. What are the limitations of each?
3. Although DNA and forensic science are important tools in crime solving, they are not always foolproof. What are some
of the problems that have arisen in recent years with these tools? Write a one-page paper describing at least three
examples. Conclude with a recommendation for avoiding such problems in the future.
4. Based on the articles in this case study, how would you say real-life forensic science compares to its portrayal in
movies and on television? Within your class, form small groups (3-4 per group) and discuss. Brainstorm the similari-
ties and differences and then pick someone in your group to share your findings with the rest of the class.
5. Labs have made egregious DNA testing or results interpretation errors, causing innocent men and women to go to
prison for years. As a class, compile a list of suggests for ensuring that DNA forensic labs are more carefully regulated.
2. Should local DNA databases of suspects or persons of interest be used to prevent crimes? If so, what legal limitations
should be placed on database use in order to protect the rights of law-abiding citizens? Using evidence from the case
study, as well as current issues of USA TODAY to support your opinion, you and a peer should prepare a sixty-second
argument to present to your class.
3. Using a current issue of USA TODAY, find an example illustrating the use of forensic science that could be added to this
case study. Does the example provide information on new advances in forensic science? Does it highlight potential pit-
falls? Write a brief summary of the article and evaluate it in light of the issues discussed in this case study.
4. With the technological advances in forensic science, a host of legal and ethical issues has arisen. At what point does
society’s need to maintain order come into conflict with an individual’s rights to privacy? What do you believe the
future holds? Using USA TODAY to cite other examples of privacy issues in relation to advances of science and technol-
ogy, write a one-page persuasive essay stating your opinion. When done, share your essay with the class as a whole
and debate with those who hold differing opinions.
5. Most states neither legislate for or against the DNA issues addressed in these case study articles. But with DNA
testing taking on a more prominent role, states may need to legislate how DNA is tested, used in courts, and stored
in databases. As a small group, select one of the following controversial DNA issues below, and discuss the legal and
ethical ramifications of it. Take on the role of a state governor, and in a two-minute prepared speech, announce what
stand you’ll take on the issue and “next steps” you’ll be taking to ensure that your state follows your recommended
guidelines.
Additional Resources