R.2940-1.sicpl.01 - Arch Comment MSCP & 8C 2nd Revision

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]
PROPOSED PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT COMPRISING 3 BLOCKS OF 26/28/30-STOREY RESIDENTIA

(TOTAL 808 UNITS), 1 BLOCK OF PART 6/PART 5-STOREY MULTI-STOREY CARPARK WITH COMMERCIAL &
FACILITIES AT UPPER BOON KENG ROAD/ LORONG 1 GEYLANG (KALLANG WHAMPOA C23B)
[THIS TFP IS FOR BLOCK 8 (1ST STOREY TO 2ND STOREY GRID LINES A-E/1-11) & 3RD TO 7TH STOREY (W
FSSD PLAN NOS: RBP/N01901/13 + RBP/N01901/1301
LIST OF RI(A) INSPECTION COMMENTS
S/N
RI(A) COMMENTS
MSCP BLK 8
1
1.1
1ST STOREY
Staircase S3 discharge point
Staircase S3 discharge point at 1st storey lift lobby is approx 8m to safe exterior open space (uncovered area) & sho
be into covered lift lobby & driveway area
QP to review possibility of having direct discharge on the other side of staircase & reposition the exit sign accordingly
apply for waiver for as-built layout. Strictly speaking, Form 2 for TFP cannot be issued till waiver is granted. Alternativ
to propose temporary measure for direct discharge
1.2
Staircase S3
Dead space below staircase should be sealed off to prevent unauthorized storage
Page 1 of 63

S/N
1.3
RI(A) COMMENTS
Breeching Inlet 3/5 next to Lift lobby
1. BI should be located in an external wall. To relocate to G/L A
2. DR piping to label numbering 3/5
1.4
Staircase S5
To provide 1.5m fire wall separation between staircase discharge point & adjoining office window
Page 2 of 63

S/N
1.5
RI(A) COMMENTS
Consumer Switch Room Fire door
To provide door closers & door selector to double leaf fire door
Page 3 of 63

S/N
1.6
RI(A) COMMENTS
Fire engine accessway
To complete up to within 18m of Breeching Inlets
2ND STOREY 5TH STOREYS
Page 4 of 63

S/N
2.1
RI(A) COMMENTS
Staircase S4 & S5 DR coverage of 38m should be based on conservative path line, avoiding the car-parking space
to recheck & provide double standby fire hose at one DRLV to cover any shortfall
2.2
Exit signs & directional exit signs to ensure that the lines of sight to these signs are not blocked by any other signag
Page 5 of 63

S/N
3
3.1
RI(A) COMMENTS
6TH & 7TH STOREYS (ROOF GARDENS)
To provide signages leading to exit staircases at the 3 residential blocks notifying occupants of the alternative means
escape from the landscaped decks eg TO FIRE ESCAPE STAIRCASE AT BLK 8C, with appropriate directional sig
3.2
6th storey roof garden (curved block)

G/L X7 X8/XB at HR to provide alarm bell as some areas are out of 30m coverage
3.3
Staircase S2 7th storey

To relocate Staircase identification signage to avoid blockage by door when opened
GENERAL COMMENTS
Page 6 of 63

S/N
4.1
RI(A) COMMENTS
To complete all signages & zone charts in correct orientation (Temporary paper signages are acceptable for TFP)
To change all temporary main & sub-zone charts to permanent ones, permanently secured to walls, using screws
4.2
To forward Fire door certificates for all fire doors, fire-rated lift doors
4.3
To forward DOC & FSSD FSC-02 for the fire rated board enclosures to DR piping
4.4
QP to regularise in Amendment Plans:

1. as-built layout of Staircase S2 at all levels
2. regularization of new layout or waiver approval for S3 discharge point
3. S5 1st storey discharge point to add fire wall
4. 6th storey roof garden to add alarm bell to comply with 30m coverage
Page 7 of 63
PRISING 3 BLOCKS OF 26/28/30-STOREY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING

OREY MULTI-STOREY CARPARK WITH COMMERCIAL & COMMUNITY FACILITIES ON THE 1ST-STOREY & ESS & AN
1 GEYLANG (KALLANG WHAMPOA C23B)
OREY GRID LINES A-E/1-11) & 3RD TO 7TH STOREY (WHOLE LEVEL) AND BLOCK 8C ONLY]
s approx 8m to safe exterior open space (uncovered area) & should not
the other side of staircase & reposition the exit sign accordingly OR
Form 2 for TFP cannot be issued till waiver is granted. Alternatively, QP
prevent unauthorized storage
Page 8 of 63

ate to G/L A
se discharge point & adjoining office window
Page 9 of 63

f fire door
Page 10 of 63

Page 11 of 63

based on conservative path line, avoiding the car-parking spaces. QP

DRLV to cover any shortfall
e lines of sight to these signs are not blocked by any other signages
Page 12 of 63

3 residential blocks notifying occupants of the alternative means of

SCAPE STAIRCASE AT BLK 8C, with appropriate directional signs
me areas are out of 30m coverage
blockage by door when opened
Page 13 of 63

entation (Temporary paper signages are acceptable for TFP)

permanent ones, permanently secured to walls, using screws
-rated lift doors
oard enclosures to DR piping
r S3 discharge point
ply with 30m coverage
Page 14 of 63
AL BUILDING
& COMMUNITY FACILITIES ON THE 1ST-STOREY & ESS & ANCILLARY
WHOLE LEVEL) AND BLOCK 8C ONLY]
REMARKS
Waiver has been submitted to permit the discharge of Exit Staircase S3 through the
covered circulation at ground level of the MSCP. The Waiver Decision shall be
forwarded once available.
The dead space under staircase has been sealed off. Refer to photo below.
Page 15 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
1. There is no code requirement for breeching inlet to be located at area open to sky.
The Breeching Inlet is within sight and within 18m of the Fire Engine Access Road.
FSSD confirmed the location of Breeching Inlet is complaint.
2. The DR Piping is labeled as indicated in the below photo.
The 1.5 m wall had been installed at the discharge point. Refer to photo below.
Page 16 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
Door closers & door selector are installed. Refer to photo below.
Page 17 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
The Fire Engine Access Road is completed. Refer to photo below
Page 18 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
The other signages affecting the line of sight for the EXIT Signs are relocated. Refer to
photo below
Page 19 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
Fire Alarm provided as per below photo.
Page 20 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
Temporary Signages & Zoning Charts are all done in the correct orientation. Refer to
photo below.
Permanent Zoning Charts shall be completed by FSC. To follow up with photos of
these before FSC.
Refer to attachment.
Refer to attachment.
For FSC
Page 21 of 63
Page 22 of 63
Page 23 of 63
Page 24 of 63
Page 25 of 63
Page 26 of 63
Page 27 of 63
Page 28 of 63
Page 29 of 63
Page 30 of 63
Check if door selector is installed
(Selector is installed)
Page 31 of 63
To send photo of FE Road at each BI
Page 32 of 63
To send photo of 2 Standby Fire Hoses. Fire
(Not ready, our

sub need time for
procurement of double
standby hose reel.)
Hose location TBC.
To send photos of other EXIT signs
Page 33 of 63
(Not ready,
our sub need time for
fabrication of additional
signages)
To confirm location on site
(RI
Commented Staircase S5 but
not S2, the highest storey at
S5 is Deck 6 )
Shouldn't the sign at top reflect 7 sty?
Page 34 of 63
To send photos of all affected signages.

Outside SAC, CCC, ESS etc.
To send the certs
To send the DOC & FSC02
Page 35 of 63


S/N
1
1.1
1.2
RI(A) COMMENTS
RESIDENTIAL BLK 8C
1ST STOREY
Wet riser breeching inlet cabinet

To provide number labeling 1/2 & 2/2
Page 36 of 63


S/N
1.3
RI(A) COMMENTS
Fire Lift
To provide photo showing that firemans switch is provided
Page 37 of 63


S/N
1.4
RI(A) COMMENTS
Fire engine accessway
To complete accessway
2
2.1
2ND STOREY 26TH STOREYS

Exit Staircases 1 & 2
To provide exit signs over the fire rated exit doors
(OR to provide documentation/HDB Directives granting exemption/waiver from FSSD from such provision)
Page 38 of 63


S/N
2.2
RI(A) COMMENTS
Wet riser piping
To label numbering on pipes 1/2 and 2/2
Page 39 of 63


S/N
2.3
RI(A) COMMENTS
Fire Lift Lobbies
To complete storey numbering signages on all storeys
ROOF
Page 40 of 63


S/N
3.1
RI(A) COMMENTS
Catladder escape hatch
1. To provide signage to lead maintenance personnel to escape hatch ALTERNATIVE CATLADDER ESCAPE, with
appropriate directional sign
2. To provide latch on the roof (escape) side of the hatch cover, not at 26th storey level
4
4.1
GENERAL COMMENTS
To forward Fire door certificates for all fire doors, fire-rated lift doors, refuse hoppers
4.2
To forward DOC & FSSD FSC-02 for the fire rated board enclosures to Wet Riser piping at 1st storey
4.3
QP to provide sub-description for Phase 1 works eg PHASE 1 MULTI-STOREY CARPARK BLK 8 (excluding 1st s
commercial areas) & RESIDENTIAL BLK 8C
4.4
QP to forward Unprotected opening computations
Page 41 of 63


S/N
4.5
RI(A) COMMENTS
QP to regularise in Amendment Plans:
1. Stair 2 - as-built discharge point at 1st storey & addition of compartmentation door/wall
2. Roof catladder hatch opening to annotate this on plan as alternative fire escape
Page 42 of 63
ELOPMENT COMPRISING 3 BLOCKS OF 26/28/30-STOREY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING

ART 6/PART 5-STOREY MULTI-STOREY CARPARK WITH COMMERCIAL & COMMUNITY FACILITIES ON THE 1ST-STO
G ROAD/ LORONG 1 GEYLANG (KALLANG WHAMPOA C23B)
TOREY TO 2ND STOREY GRID LINES A-E/1-11) & 3RD TO 7TH STOREY (WHOLE LEVEL) AND BLOCK 8C ONLY]
RBP/N01901/1301
t
& 2/2
Page 43 of 63

RBP/N01901/1301
remans switch is provided
Page 44 of 63

RBP/N01901/1301
YS
e rated exit doors

HDB Directives granting exemption/waiver from FSSD from such provision)
Page 45 of 63

RBP/N01901/1301
and 2/2
Page 46 of 63

RBP/N01901/1301
ignages on all storeys
Page 47 of 63

RBP/N01901/1301
maintenance personnel to escape hatch ALTERNATIVE CATLADDER ESCAPE, with
(escape) side of the hatch cover, not at 26th storey level
for all fire doors, fire-rated lift doors, refuse hoppers
02 for the fire rated board enclosures to Wet Riser piping at 1st storey
or Phase 1 works eg PHASE 1 MULTI-STOREY CARPARK BLK 8 (excluding 1st storey

TIAL BLK 8C
ning computations
Page 48 of 63

RBP/N01901/1301
Plans:
oint at 1st storey & addition of compartmentation door/wall
ng to annotate this on plan as alternative fire escape
Page 49 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
Under Fire Code 2013 CL 2.3.3 (c)(ii) & (iii):

In the case of a Purpose Group II residential building, at least 50% of the
total number of exit staircases shall discharge to the safe exterior space
opened to the sky and the remaining exit staircase is allowed to be
discharged onto the ground level covered circulation space.
There shall be no unprotected openings of occupancy area within 3m
from discharge point of the exit staircase (both internal and external).
This distance can be reduced to 1.5m if the unprotected openings are
along the same plane of the staircase exit.
Based on the above CL 2.3.3 (c) (ii) & (iii), the discharge is compliant as the
other staircase fully complies with discharge requirements.
As the void deck area is of no occupancy use, the discharge can be allow into
the void deck.
Numbering done as indicated in photo below.
Page 50 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
Fireman's Switch is provided as indicated in photo.
Page 51 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
Under Fire Code 2007 CL 2.10.2 Exit and directional sign

In all buildings or parts of building other than those belonging to
Purpose Groups I and II (residential floors only), the location of every
exit on every floor shall be clearly indicated by exit sign and directional
signs to comply with the requirements in Chapter 8.
EXIT Signs are not required for the Residential Blocks.
Page 52 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
The Wet Riser Pipes are labelled as indicated in the photos below.
Page 53 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
The Storey numbering signages are completed as indicated in the photos
below.
Page 54 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
1. Signage is done & indicated in the photo below.
2. Latch is provided at the roof level & not at 26th storey level. Refer to photo
below.
The sub-description is affixed after the project title.

Attached.
Page 55 of 63
AL BUILDING
REMARKS
For FSC
Page 56 of 63
Not complied. Check with Allan

on the comment. Supposed to
(8C
only have one wet
riser breeching
inlet, the
numbering is
correct)
be 2 numbering on 1 BI.
Page 57 of 63
To send clearer photo & seeing

more of the Lift.
Page 58 of 63
To send photos of all the

access road. To include Block
8C & 2 ESSes.
Page 59 of 63
Page 60 of 63
To send photo of 1 mid floor &

ground floor.
Page 61 of 63
To send photo at 26th storey
To send the certs

To send the DOC & FSC02
Page 62 of 63
Page 63 of 63

R.2940-1.sicpl.01 - Arch Comment MSCP & 8C 2nd Revision

Încărcat de

Informații document

Descriere originală:

Titlu original

Drepturi de autor

Formate disponibile

Partajați acest document

Partajați sau inserați document

Opțiuni de partajare

Vi se pare util acest document?

Este necorespunzător acest conținut?

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

R.2940-1.sicpl.01 - Arch Comment MSCP & 8C 2nd Revision

Încărcat de

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

PROPOSED PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT COMPRISING 3 BLOCKS OF 26/28/30-STOREY RESIDENTIA

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

2ND STOREY 5TH STOREYS

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

6th storey roof garden (curved block)

Staircase S2 7th storey

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

QP to regularise in Amendment Plans:

PRISING 3 BLOCKS OF 26/28/30-STOREY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING

prevent unauthorized storage

PRISING 3 BLOCKS OF 26/28/30-STOREY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING

se discharge point & adjoining office window

PRISING 3 BLOCKS OF 26/28/30-STOREY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING

PRISING 3 BLOCKS OF 26/28/30-STOREY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING

PRISING 3 BLOCKS OF 26/28/30-STOREY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING

based on conservative path line, avoiding the car-parking spaces. QP

PRISING 3 BLOCKS OF 26/28/30-STOREY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING

3 residential blocks notifying occupants of the alternative means of

me areas are out of 30m coverage

blockage by door when opened

PRISING 3 BLOCKS OF 26/28/30-STOREY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING

entation (Temporary paper signages are acceptable for TFP)

-rated lift doors

oard enclosures to DR piping

ply with 30m coverage

WHOLE LEVEL) AND BLOCK 8C ONLY]

WHOLE LEVEL) AND BLOCK 8C ONLY]

WHOLE LEVEL) AND BLOCK 8C ONLY]

WHOLE LEVEL) AND BLOCK 8C ONLY]

WHOLE LEVEL) AND BLOCK 8C ONLY]

WHOLE LEVEL) AND BLOCK 8C ONLY]

Fire Alarm provided as per below photo.

WHOLE LEVEL) AND BLOCK 8C ONLY]

Check if door selector is installed

To send photo of FE Road at each BI

To send photo of 2 Standby Fire Hoses. Fire

(Not ready, our

To send photos of other EXIT signs

To send photos of all affected signages.

To send the certs

To send the DOC & FSC02

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

FSSD PLAN NOS: RBP/N01901/13 + RBP/N01901/1301

Wet riser breeching inlet cabinet

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

FSSD PLAN NOS: RBP/N01901/13 + RBP/N01901/1301

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

FSSD PLAN NOS: RBP/N01901/13 + RBP/N01901/1301

2ND STOREY 26TH STOREYS

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

FSSD PLAN NOS: RBP/N01901/13 + RBP/N01901/1301

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

FSSD PLAN NOS: RBP/N01901/13 + RBP/N01901/1301

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

FSSD PLAN NOS: RBP/N01901/13 + RBP/N01901/1301

QP to forward Unprotected opening computations

[Project Reference No: A930-00002-2010]

FSSD PLAN NOS: RBP/N01901/13 + RBP/N01901/1301