Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
A Bachelors Thesis
Presented to the Department of Arts and Sciences
Mindanao Kokusai Daigaku
Davao City
____________________________
____________________________
by
APPROVAL SHEET
ABSTRACT
THE LEVEL OF EMPOWERMENT OF OVERSEAS
FILIPINO WOMEN WORKERS
by
ELIZAER CHRISTIAN E. CABILAN, WISLEY S. ALCUIREZ, ANGELYC M.
BONIFACIO, CHARADE LAGUNA, NEIZZY ABEGAIL C. MAINIT, and MARIA
CHESSA PAICA
The study deals on determining the level of empowerment of overseas
Filipino women workers who have residence and who reside in Davao City,
Philippines. The research design used in this study is descriptive research
design.
This study used non-random sampling specifically purposive sampling
technique in which overseas Filipino women workers, who work in human care
field, were only surveyed.
Survey questionnaire was used to determine the respondents Age,
Educational Attainment and Range of Wage or Salary. The researchers used
internet by using Facebook (www. Facebook.com) and e-mailed the respondents
by using yahoomail (www.yahoomail.com) who are still in abroad but originally
live in Davao City to disseminate the survey questionnaire. Percentage, mean
and t-test were the statistical treatment used in this study.
Statement of the Problem
Age
1.2
Educational background
1.3
1.4
Occupation?
2.2
Findings
The data gathered revealed the following findings:
1. Respondents belonged to ages 30 years old and above (210 or
63.64%) were greater than those who were 15-29 years old ( 114 or
34.54%) and those who had no information (6 or 1.82%). A greater
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The researchers want to extend their gratitude and appreciation to the
following people who in one way or another contributed and extended their
valuable assistance in the preparation and completion of this study.
To the researchers adviser Estrella Radam-Turingan who exerted her
time and effort amidst of being busy. The researcher would also like to recognize
her great efforts of helping throughout the researchers thesis-writing period. The
researchers
also
appreciated
her
for
providing
good
teachings
and
encouragement to the researchers and for sharing her great ideas to them. The
researchers would have been lost without her guidance. And for having the
outcome of this study interpreted and analyzed on time;
To Dr. Nieto Latorre Vitto for giving the researchers a challenge and
chance to make this study beyond possible;
To Dr. Albert B. Jubilo for his supervision, advice, and guidance from the
very early stage of this research as well as giving the researchers extraordinary
experiences throughout the work;
To Dr. Noel Caballes, without his knowledge and assistance this study
would not have been successful. For his advice, supervision, and crucial
contribution;
To Lanie P. Vergara for exerting time to read and check the grammar of
this study to make it a reliable one and for being one of the panelists;
To the validators who checked and validated this studys survey
questionnaire;
To the POEA staffs who allowed the researchers conduct their survey on
the OFWs;
To all the respondents who were in POEA and in other places here and in
abroad especially those who willingly and patiently answered the survey
questionnaire made by the researchers;
To the researchers ever-supportive parents who always understand at
times when the researchers have to sleep at different houses. Above all and the
most needed, by providing the researchers encouragement and support in
various ways;
To Alcuirez family and Manalo family who were abundantly helpful by
offering invaluable assistance, allowing the researchers to stay at their homes
overnight and for the support and guidance;
And most especially to Almighty God the Father for giving the researchers
different talents, skills, intellect, extra strength which has lead to the making of
this study possible and reliable.
E.C.E Cabilan
W.S Alquirez
A.M Bonifacio
C.A Laguna
N.A.C Mainit
M.C.G Paica
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
TITLE ...............................................................................................................
ii
ABSTRACT ......................................................................................................
iii
ACKNOWLEDGMENT .....................................................................................
INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................
Definition of Terms...........................................................................
Empowerment ........................................................................ 10
Synthesis ............................................................................................ 12
Theoretical Framework ...................................................................... 13
Empowerment Theory ............................................................. 13
Structurist Theory .................................................................... 13
Household Strategy Theory .................................................... 13
Conceptual Framework ...................................................................... 13
III METHODOLOGY .................................................................................. 16
Research Design ................................................................................ 16
Research Locale ................................................................................ 16
Research Respondents ...................................................................... 17
Research Instruments ........................................................................ 17
Research Procedure .......................................................................... 17
Statistical Treatments ......................................................................... 18
IV RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Profile of the Respondents.................................................................. 19
Age........................................................................................... 19
Educational Attainment............................................................ 20
Range of Wage or Salary......................................................... 21
Occupation............................................................................... 22
.......................................................................................... 38
APPENDICES
A.
40
B.
41
C.
D.
E.
F.
G.
H.
CURRICULUM VITAE........................................................................................ 48
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure
1
2
Description
Conceptual Model of the Study
Map of Davao City, Philippines
Page
14
16
LIST OF TABLES
Table
Description
Page
19
20
21
22
23
26
27
28
29
10
30
11
31
12
32
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
Background of the Study
Globalization has contributed to an increasing flow of migrant workers
from countries with limited economic opportunities to fill gaps in nations with a
dwindling labour supply. While globalization may foster the acceleration of trade
and investment, it does not create an environment that protects migrant workers
economic, social and physical security. This is even more so when it comes to
women migrant workers, whose numbers have been increasing, now constituting
50% or more of the migrant workforce in Asia and Latin America.
Yet, while migration can bring new employment and opportunities, it also
bears great risks for women ,Migrant women workers, routinely lack access to
social services and legal protection and are subjected to abuses such as harsh
working and living conditions, low wages, illegal withholding of wages and
premature termination of employment. The worst abuses force women into
sexual slavery.
In line with these facts, the researchers came up to make a study that
would help the country particularly Davao region to determine the level of women
empowerment in the field of human care profession who is working outside the
Archipelago. The level of women empowerment in the study depends on the
factors being mentioned.
Age
1.6
Educational background
1.7
1.8
Occupation?
women OFWs to handle problems regarding to their family when they are outside
the country.
Community. Lastly, this study is for the community for them to have
knowledge about their fellow Filipinos who are working outside the country and
the level of empowerment of women OFWs.
OFWs Working in the Field of Human Care Filipinos who work outside
the country as nurses, care givers, teachers, domestic helpers and other jobs in
line with human care profession.
OFWs Working in the Field of Non- Human care Filipinos who work
abroad as engineers, computer technicians, drafts men, and other jobs that does
not belong to the field of human care.
Chapter II
Malhotra,
Schuler
and
Boender
(2002)
conclude
that
empowerment is a process that marks change over a period of time and requires
that the individual being empowered is involved as a significant agent in that
change process.
Bennett (2002) has developed a framework in which empowerment and
social inclusion are closely related but separate concepts. Drawing on Narayan
(2002), Bennett describes empowerment as the enhancement of assets and
capabilities of diverse individuals and groups to engage, influence and hold
accountable the institutions which affect them. Social inclusion is defined as the
removal of institutional barriers and the enhancement of incentives to increase
the access of diverse individuals and groups to assets and development
date have focused more on civil and political rights, what are known as first
generation human rights, than on second generation economic, social and
cultural rights. In his/her paper, empowerment is defined as a multi-dimensional
process of civil, political, social, economic, and cultural participation and rights.
To analyse these, a framework using six key domains is presented. These are
used to assess womens participation (referring to an active social condition),
rights (referring to a formal, legal condition) and capabilities (preconditions for the
enjoyment of rights and enhancement of participation). The domains are: sociodemographic indicators, bodily integrity and health, literacy and educational
attainment, economic participation and rights, political participation and rights,
cultural participation and rights. Indicators include: life expectancy at birth, sexual
and physical abuse against women, literacy rates, amount of maternity leave,
and number of feminist resources in the print and electronic media.
In the paper of Kabeer, N. (2005), he discusses the third Millennium
Development Goal (MDG) on gender equality and womens empowerment and
highlights ways in which the indicators associated with this goal womens
access to education, share of non-agricultural wage employment, and political
participation can contribute to womens empowerment. Each of these indicators
has the potential to bring about immediate changes in womens lives, along with
long-term transformations in patriarchal power structures. But unless provision is
made to ensure that policy changes are implemented in ways that allow women
themselves to participate, monitor, and hold policy makers and corporations
accountable for their actions, the potential for womens empowerment will be
limited. For example, while womens access to education may improve their
chances of a good marriage, unless it also provides them with the courage to
question unjust practices, its potential for change will be limited. Similarly, while
womens access to paid work may give them a greater sense of self-reliance and
greater purchasing power, if it is undertaken in conditions that damage womens
health its costs may outweigh its benefits. The question, therefore, is to what
extent the international community is prepared to provide support for women at
the grassroots support which will ensure that they have the collective capacities
necessary to participate in the policy process.
Synthesis
Based
on
the
related
literature
and
studies
presented, gender
empowerment is not only own by male but by female as well. And as every
individual possesses empowerment, they must also have the capability to control
and be responsible in every action that they will do.
Furthermore, people are empowered with regards to their individual
strength and self- esteem that may correspond with regards to their age,
educational attainment, income and occupation. These will signify that people
can participate and can control their income as these are some of the indicators
of empowerment.
Theoretical Frameworks
Power Control Theory. The theory has been extended into adult social
roles as well. Stratified behaviors typically associated with males, particularly
those in authoritative positions, are now being seen more frequently in females
attaining powerful roles. And like their male counterparts, their power is used to
control those persons in subordinate roles.
Structurist Theory. This theory views international migration as a form of
exploitation of the peripheral nations by the core nations in the international
system.
utilized as the intervening variable of this study. The manipulative variable in this
study were the Level of Women Empowerment and its two domains that became
factors that measured the level of empowerment namely the Economic and
social participation; and Access to and control over economic resources and its
uses.
As illustrated in Figure 1, the dependent variable was administered to the
independent variable with its two categorized domains. Furthermore, the
intervening variables were correlated if there were significance to the said
variable with regards to the independent variable which then resulted to the level
of empowerment of the respondents and if they were empowered or not.
Level of Empowerment
Overseas Filipino
Women Workers
Age
-18-30 or 31 and above
Educational Background
-High School Graduate and below or
College Graduate and above
Occupation
-Human Care and Non-Human Care
Chapter III
METHODOLOGY
This chapter presents the methods that the researchers used on how the
study has been conducted. It also gave the information about the research
design, research instruments, research locale, sampling technique, statistical
treatments and data analysis method.
Research Design
This study investigated the empowerment of women OFWs. The study
used a descriptive research design that determined the empowerment of women
OFW.
Research Locale
Davao City is part of Region XI and is located and the center of the region.
It is the largest city on the island of Mindanao and can be found in the
Archipelago of the Philippines. The city was also awarded by the department of
Tourism as the Most Livable City in the country.
Research Respondents
This study used a non-random purposive sampling technique to the
respondents. It had a total of 330 women OFW respondents from Davao City.
Research Instruments
The researchers used a survey questionnaire that determined the profile
of the respondents specifically the age, occupation, the respondents educational
background and their respective monthly wage or salary.
Through this instrument the respondents level of empowerment had been
measured by the researchers.
The research instrument has been authenticated by the validators in order
to be reliable before the researchers conducted the survey.
Research Procedures
The steps that the researchers undergone on gathering the data were the
following:
Statistical Treatment
The following statistical treatment have been used in interpreting and
analyzing the data gathered:
Percentage. This statistical treatment was used in determining the profile
of the respondents in terms of Age, Occupation, and Educational Background
and in determining the level of empowerment of women.
Mean. This was used to get the mean scores of the respondents profile
when it was correlated to the dimensions.
T-test. This tool was used to determine if whether or not there is a
significant difference on empowerment of overseas Filipino women workers when
correlated to Age, Educational Attainment, Rage of wage or salary, and
Occupation.
Since the respondents of this study were female OFWs there was no need
to include Sex in this statistical treatment.
Chapter IV
Age
15- 29 years old
30 years old and below
No information
Total
Frequency
114
210
6
330
Percentage
34.54
63.64
1.82
100
With regards to the respondents age, most of the respondents were from
ages 30 years old and above with a total number of 210 or 63.64 percent
followed by 15-29 years of age with a total of 114 respondents which is
equivalent to 34.54 percent. The figure also shows that there were 6 respondents
having a percentage of 1.82 who chose not to check or share their information
regarding this matter. This outcome is unavoidable since the researchers also
respect their own privacy.
Therefore, Overseas Filipino women workers, ages 30 years old and
above had the most number of respondents.
Educational Attainment. Table 2 shows the percentage distribution of the
respondents Educational Attainment. The level is divided into two: those who
were High school graduate and below which means they were not able to finish
tertiary education but were able to graduate in secondary education and/or
elementary graduate and those who were College graduate and above, meaning
to say those who were able to graduate in tertiary education and/ or were able to
be enrolled to a graduate school.
Table 2
Profile of the Respondents by Educational Attainment
Educational Attainment
High School Graduate and Below
Frequency
91
Percentage
27.58
231
8
330
70
2.42
100
Frequency
143
185
2
330
Percentage
43.33
56.06
.61
100
Frequency
Percentage
Human Care
Non-Human Care
No Information
Total
170
154
6
330
51.51
46.67
1.82
100
While, 46.67 percent or 154 respondents were working in non human care, or
those dealing other than the ones mentioned under the field of human care.
Unfortunately there were 6 respondents which is equivalent to 1.82 percent who
did not answer the certain profile.
Respondents Profile According to Empowerment Indicators
Presented in Table 5 are Economic and Social Participation and Access to
and Control over Economic Resources means and its verbal description (VD)
according to the Respondents age classification. The mean scores of two
empowerment indicators and its respective verbal description were also included
in this table.
Table 5
Economic and Social Participation, Access to and Control over Economic
Resources and Empowerment with regards to Respondents Age
Classification
Economic and
Social Participation
Age
Classification
15-29
30 and above
Mean
VD
3.11
3.80
Sometimes 3.42
Often
4.03
Empowerment
Mean
Sometimes 3.27
Often
3.92
VD
Sometimes
Often
full authority in their household and sometimes in work, they are old enough to
decide things and they are more knowledgeable when it comes to decision
making, and free from domestic violence or abuses such as verbal, sexual,
physical and emotional whether they are in household or in work. This could be
the reason why they are active when it comes to participation in our economy
and society.
Access to and Control over Economic Resources. The 15-29 years of age
classification had a mean of 3.42, while the 30 years old and above classification
had a mean of 4.03.
According to the results, those overseas Filipino women workers who
have ages from 30 years old and above can have the access and control over
economic resources or the income. Most of the women who became the
respondents were already married and have their own child/ children and since
the role of the mother is to keep the finances and have the sole authority to
control the income of the family despite of working abroad they still have the
authority of doing their role in their family. Since they are the ones who are
working abroad and gain high income to sustain the family they are given the full
authority of accessing and controlling the income and how the family use the said
income, thus they are entitled to it.
Empowerment. The mean score of the two economic indicators within
accordance to the classification of respondents age were 3.72 and 3.92.
The result argues to the study according to Deshmukh-Ranadive, J.
(2003), stressing that Womens empowerment does not necessarily take place
when incomes are generated, when livelihoods are enhanced or when groups
are formed. This is because within families and households, hierarchies and
structures do not alter. In fact, public interventions which result in new social
activity or new avenues of income generation can actually accentuate tensions
within households. However, it correlates to the study of Moyle, Dollard, &
Biswas (2006), stating that personal empowerment views empowerment as
focused on individual strength and self-esteem to gain control over available
resources and to exercise their right to obtain quality of life for themselves and
their family. It can also be correlated and implied to the theory of power control,
stratified behaviors typically associated with males, particularly those in
authoritative positions, are now being seen more frequently in females attaining
powerful roles. And like their male counterparts, their power is used to control
those persons in subordinate roles.
Table 6 presents the mean scores and their respective verbal description
with regards to Educational Attainment when analyzed with Economic and Social
Participation and Access and Control over Economic Resources.
Educational Attainment. Economic and Social Participation. The mean
score of High school graduate and below was 3.52 and the college graduate and
above had a mean of 3.63 with regards to the Economic and Social Participation.
People who graduated from college and/or continued to study in Masters
or Doctoral are highly participative with regards to the participation in economy
and in society than those who were only High school graduate and below.
People who belonged to the College graduate and above can show great
confidence in showing their skills and sharing their knowledge for the reason that
they graduated tertiary education, moreover since they are well educated they
cannot be easily controlled by the other and they have the authority to decide
whatever decisions are to be made.
Access and Control over Economic Resources. The High school graduate
and below and College graduate and above had a mean scores of 3.38 and 4.05
respectively.
The means for the empowerment levels for the respondents who were
college graduates and above are usually higher than those for the high school
graduates and below.
Table 6
Economic and Social Participation, Access to and Control over Economic
Resources and Empowerment with regards to Respondents Educational
Attainment
.
Economic and
Access and Control
Social
over Economic
Empowerment
Participation
Resources
Educational
Mean VD
Mean
VD
Mean VD
Attainment
H. S. Graduate
3.52
Often
3.38
Sometimes 3.45
Sometimes
and below
College
3.63
Often
4.05
Often
3.84
Often
Graduate and
above
Empowerment. The mean scores of both empowerment domains were
combined with regards to their respective classification namely High school
graduate and below and College graduate and above and their means scores in
terms of empowerment were 3.45 and 3.84.
The result can be correlated to the study of Kishor (2000) that pointed out
to education and employment as the measurement of empowerment. In addition,
it can also be correlated to the study of Vijayanthi (2002) emphasizing that
education is one of the most important means of empowering women and of
giving knowledge, skills and the self-confidence necessary to be full partners in
the developmental process.
Presented in Table 7 are the mean scores and verbal description of the
Empowerment indicators with regards to the respondents range of wage or
salary.
Range of Wage or Salary. Economic and Social Participation. The mean
scores of 5,100-27,000 pesos as their salary and 27,001 pesos and above in
accordance to economic and social participation were 3.45 and 3.67.
Respondents who received 27,001 pesos and above as their monthly
salary get the highest mean score. People who received Php 27,001.00 and
above as their monthly salary can actively participate with regards to economical
and social compared to those who received 5,100 pesos up to 27,000 pesos.
They obviously have more participation because they have bigger amount of
wage.
Access and Control over Economic Resources. With regards to this
domain in terms of salary people who received 27,001 pesos and above had a
mean of 4.14, meanwhile, those who received minimum wage which is 5,100-
27,000 pesos had a mean score of 3.45. Those people who were above the
minimum wage can easily access and control the income of the family because
they were the ones who received the certain amount of money and they can use
the income whatever they want to do it.
Empowerment. The mean scores of both empowerment domains were
combined with regards to their range of wage or salary. Respondents who
received Php 5, 100.00- 27,000.00 had a mean of 3.45 while respondents who
received Php 27,001.00 and above had a mean score of 3.91.
Table 7
Economic and Social Participation, Access to and Control over Economic
Resources and Empowerment with regards to Respondents Range of
wage or Salary
Economic and
Social Participation
Range of Wage
Mean
VD
Php 5,10027,000
Php 27,001
and above
3.45
Sometimes 3.45
3.67
Often
4.14
Empowerment
Mean
VD
Sometimes
3.45
Sometimes
Often
3.91
Often
The results can be implied to the view of Rae Lesser Blumberg (2005),
that economic empowerment of women was the key to achieve gender equality
as well as wealth and well being of nation. The author opined that financial
autonomy would enhance womens capacity of decision making in various
arenas of life. Moreover, it would lead to less corruption, less armed conflict and
less violence against female in the long run.
Table 8 shows the mean scores and their respective verbal description of
Occupation when analyzed with Economic and Social Participation and Access
and Control over Economic Resources.
Occupation. Economic and Social Participation. Human Care had a mean
score of 3.61 while the Non-Human had a mean score of 3.56, making Human
care the greatest. Since most of Filipino women workers were working in line with
human care such as domestic helpers, teachers, teacher aids, nurses, doctors,
caregivers and other allied medical profession, one of their job is to interact with
different people everyday that is why, maybe, they get the highest mean score.
Table 8
Economic and Social Participation, Access to and Control over Economic
Resources and Empowerment with regards to Respondents Occupation
Occupation
Human Care
Non-Human
Care
Economic and
Social
Participation
Mean VD
3.61
3.56
3.68
4.02
Often
Often
Sometimes
Often
Empowerment
Mean
VD
3.64
3.79
Often
Often
Access and Control over Economic Resources. The Human care type
occupation and non human care type had the mean scores of 3.68 and 4.02.
This means those who were working in the non-human care field have the
highest level of empowerment in terms of access and control over economic
resources. It has opposite results with regards to the economic and social
participation. Women who were working in non-human care field mostly received
a high salary with regards to the human care type that is why they are more
empowered to access and control over their income.
Empowerment. The mean scores of both empowerment domains were
combined in terms of their occupation. Respondents who work in Human care
had a mean score of 3.64. On the other hand those who work in Non-human care
had a mean score of 3.79.
The result can be implied to the view of Kishor (2000) who has pointed out
to education and employment as the measurement of empowerment. On the
other hand, it argues to the statement of Mason and Smith (2005), stating that
employment is argued to improve womens empowerment for similar reasons,
i.e., because it gives women access to their own earnings or contributions to
family income that in turn increase their understanding of money, right to
participate in financial decisions, or financial independence.
Significant Difference of the Level of Empowerment and
Age. Presented on Table 9 is the T-test on the significance between Level
of Empowerment and Age.
At .01 percent level of confidence, or a two tailed test of 0.005, the, t table
value is -2.576 on the left tail, and +2.576 on the right tail. While, t computed
values were -7.161, -6.316 and -7.372. Since the t-computed values are in the
rejection region, then, we reject the null hypothesis that there is no significant
difference between the level of women empowerment and age. The researchers,
then, accept the alternative hypothesis that there is a significant difference
between level of empowerment and age group of respondents.Furthermore, the
researchers are 99 percent confident that the older age group of OFWs, above
30 years old, are usually more empowered than the younger age group, 15-29
years old.
Table 9
T- Test on the Significant Difference between Level of Empowerment and Age
Empowerment Indicator
Economic & Access &
Social
Control
Participation over
Economic
Resources
Age
T value
-7.161
-6.316
Decision
Decision
on H0
Empowerment on H0
Reject
-7.372
Reject
school graduate and below, everyone has the right and are oblige to participate
both in economical participation and social participation. This means they have
their important roles as citizens and as migrant workers.
On the indicators access and control, the t-computed values which were 6.793 and -4.064 were in the rejection region of the t distribution at .01 percent
level of confidence. The researchers, then, reject the null hypothesis that there is
no significant difference between level of women empowerment and educational
attainment as measured by access and control of resources and empowerment
indicators. The researchers, then, accept the alternative hypothesis that there is
a significant difference between level of empowerment and educational
attainment of respondents.
Table 10
T- Test on the Significant Difference between Level of Empowerment and
Educational Attainment
Educ.
Att.
Economic &
Social
Participation
T
-1.028
value
Access
&
Decision Control
over E.
R.
Accept
Reject
-6.793
-4.064
Reject
The researchers are 99 percent confident that OFWs with higher the
educational attainment like college graduates are usually more empowered than
those with lower educational attainment such as those who are high school
graduates when we use access and control of resources as indicator.
Range
of Wage
Empowerment Indicator
Economic & Access &
Social
Control
Participation over
Economic
Resources
Decision
Decision
on H0
Empowerment on H0
T value
-2.277
Reject
-7.856
-5.295
Reject
region of the t distribution both for .01 and .05 confidence level. The researchers,
then, accept the null hypothesis that there is no significant difference between
the level of empowerment based on economic and social participation and the
type of occupation of respondents
On the indicators access and control, the t-computed value which is -3.675
was in the rejection region of the t distribution. The researchers reject the null
hypothesis that there is no significant difference between level of women
empowerment as measured by access and control of resources and
empowerment indicators and the type of occupation of the OFWs. We, then,
accept the alternative hypothesis that there is a significant difference between
level of empowerment and type of occupation of respondents.
Table 12
T- Test on the Significant Difference between Level of Empowerment and
Occupation
Occupation
Economic &
Social
Participation
Decision
T value
.571
Accept
Access
&
Control
over E.
R.
-3.675
Decision
Empowerment
Decision
Reject
-1.621
Accept
The researchers are 99 percent confident that OFWs who are engaged in non
human care profession such as computer engineers, consultants, office workers
are usually more empowered than those with human care related occupations
such as those who are nurses, caregiver, when we use access and control of
resources as indicator.
Chapter V
Age
1.10
Educational background
1.11
1.12
Occupation?
2.2
Findings
The data gathered revealed the following findings:
1. Respondents belonged to ages 30 years old and above (210 or
63.64%) were greater than those who were 15-29 years old (114 or
34.54%) and those who had no information (6 or 1.82%). A greater
number of respondents belonged to College graduate and above in
terms of educational attainment (231 or 70%) than those who belonged
to college graduate and below (91 or 27.58%), 2.42% or 8 respondents
were not able to fill up their profile regarding this matter. In addition,
185 respondents or 56.06% said that they were receiving Php
27,001.00 and above for their monthly salary and there were 143
respondents (43.33%) who said that they were receiving Php 5,100.0027,001.00 as their salary, there were also 2 respondents (.61%) were
not able to say their monthly salary. Moreover, 51.51% or 170
respondents said that their occupation are in line with human care field
and 46.67% or 154 respondents said that their work are in non human
care field, only 1.82 % or 6 respondents were not able to say what kind
of occupation they belonged to.
2. The mean of Age under 15-29 years old is 3.11(Sometimes) with
regards to the economic and social participation. And in terms of
access and control over economic income the mean is 3.42
(Sometimes) and when the two domains were combined to get the
REFERENCES
Alsop, Ruth and Nina Heinsohn (2005). Measuring Empowerment in Practice:
Structuring Analysis and Framing Indicators. World Bank Policy Research
Working Paper 3510, February 2005, Washington DC.
Basu, A. M., and G.B. Koolwal (2005) Two concepts of female empowerment:
Some leads from DHS data on women's status and reproductive health,
in S. Kishor (ed.) A focus on gender: Collected papers on gender using
DHS data, pp. 15-53. Calverton, MD: ORC Macro.
Bennett (2002) . Measuring Womens Empowerment as a Variable International
Development. Retrieved January 5, 2011 from
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTGENDER/Resources/Malhorta
SchulerBoender.pdf
Blumberg, Rae Lesser (2005). Women Empowerment in Assam A
Human Development Approach-By: Bidisha Mahanta, December 2008.
Retrieved January 5, 2011 from http:// www.col.org/SiteCollection
Documents/WELL-scan-Uttarakhand.pdf
Deshmukh-Ranadive, J. (2003) Placing Gender Equity in the Family Centre
Stege: Use of Kala Jatha, Economic and Political Weekly, 26 April 2003.
Retrieved January 5, 2011 from http://old.bridge.ids.ac.uk/reports/bb14.pdf
Gustav Ranis and Francis Stewart (2005). Women Empowerment in Assam A
Human Development Approach-By: Bidisha Mahanta, December 2008.
Retrieved January 5, 2011 from http:// www.col.org/SiteCollection
Documents/WELL-scan-Uttarakhand.pdf
Human Development in South Asia (2000). Women Empowerment in Assam A
Human Development Approach-By: Bidisha Mahanta, December 2008.
Retrieved January 5, 2011 from http:// www.col.org/SiteCollection
Documents/WELL-scan-Uttarakhand.pdf
Kabeer, N. (2005) Gender Equality and Womens Empowerment: A Critical
Analysis of the Third Millennium Development Goal, Gender and
Development, 13.1, March 2005. Retrieved January 11, 2011 from
http://old.bridge.ids ac.uk/reports/bb14.pdf
Kishor (2000). The Effect of Womens Socio-demographic
Variables on their Empowerment 2010. Retrieved Janaury 5, 2011
from http://www.jofamericanscience.org/journals/am-
sci/am0611/50_3774am0611_426_434.pdf
Kishore, Lalit. 2009.What is women's empowerment all about? Retrieved
January 6, 2011 fromhttp://www.merinews.com/article/what-is-womens
empowerment-all-about/15751346.shtml
Malhotra, Schuler and Boender (2002). Promises to Keep: Achieving Gender
Equality and the Empowerment of Women, April 18, 2003. Retrieved
January 6, 2011 http://www.unmillenniumproject.org /documents
/tf03genapr18.pdf
Mason and Smith, 2003. The Effect of Womens Socio-demographic
Variables on their Empowerment 2010. Retrieved Janaury 5, 2011
from http://www.jofamericanscience.org/journals/amsci/am0611/50_3774am0611_426_434.pdf
Moghadam, V.M. and Senftova, L. (2005). Measuring Womens Empowerment:
Participation And Rights In Civil, Political, Social, Economic, And
Cultural Domains, International Social Science Journal, 5
pp. 389-412(24). Retrieved January 6, 2011 from
http://old.bridge.ids.ac.uk/reports/bb14.pdf
Moyle, Dollard, & Biswas. 2006. The Effect of Womens Socio-demographic
Variables on their Empowerment 2010. Retrieved Janaury 5, 2011
from http://www.jofamericanscience.org/journals/amsci/am0611/50_3774am0611_426_434.pdf
Nana Oishi, March 2002. Gender and Migration: An Integrative Approach ;
Household Strategy Theory and Structurist Theory, March 2002.
Retrieved Retrieved January 5, 2011 from
Error! Hyperlink reference not valid.
Pradhan, B. (2003). Measuring Empowerment: A Methodological Approach,
Society for International Development (www.sidint.org) 1011-6370 46:2;
51-57; 033500 Palgrave Macmillan. Retrieved January 6,2011 from
http://old.bridge.ids.ac.uk/reports/bb14.pdf
Stromquist (2002). Women Empowerment in Assam A
Human Development Approach-By: Bidisha Mahanta, December 2008.
Retrieved January 5, 2011 from http:// www.col.org/SiteCollection
Documents/WELL-scan-Uttarakhand.pdf
Vijayanthi, 2002. The Effect of Womens Socio-demographic
Variables on their Empowerment 2010. Retrieved Janaury 5, 2011
from http://www.jofamericanscience.org/journals/amsci/am0611/50_3774am0611_426_434.pdf
Appendix A
Letter to the Validators
Appendix B
List of Validators
1.
Sally C. Aro
Masters of Arts in Basic Education Major in English
Davao del Norte State College of Davao City, Inc., 2009
2.
Medilyn B. Utong
Masters in Technology Education
Davao del Norte State College of Davao City, Inc., 2005
3.
Mirasol O. Fabuna
Masters of Science in Technology Major in Mathematics
Davao del Norte State College of Davao City, Inc., 2008
4.
Eleanor A. Mallabo
Masters of Arts in Educational Management
Ateneo de Davao University of Davao City, Inc.
5.
Rosendo M. Aya-ay
Masterrs in Economics
University of South Eastern Philippines
Appendix C
VALIDATION RESULT OF THE SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE
Validator
1. Sally C. Aro
Rating
4.28
Equivalent
Excellent
2. Medilyn B. Utong
Excellent
3. Mirasol O. Fabuna
3.85
Very Good
4. Eleanor A. Mallabo
Excellent
5. Rosendo M. Ayaay
Very Good
Average
4.47
Excellent
Excellent
Very Good
Good
Poor (Unacceptable)
Very Poor (Unacceptable)
Appendix D
Survey Questionnaire
We, the 3rd Year students (BS International Studies major in Japanese Language and
Studies) will be having a research entitled The Level of Empowerment of
Overseas Filipino Women Workers. This study aims to determine the level of
empowerment of women OFW.
IN FORM ATION
1. Name (Optional)
2. Age
1529
30 and above
3
.
Occupation
4.
Educational Attainment
High School Graduate
and Below
5. Address
I have the right to choose and decide who and when will my
children be having a relationship to opposite sex.
I have the right to choose and decide who will be my
child/childrens spouse.
I have the right to choose what kind of religion I /my family will
be engaged in and will practice.
I am free from any domestic violence (sexual abuse, physical
abuse, and emotional abuse).
5
1. I receive my salary on the day it is really given.
2. I am the one who decide when to pay our revenues or taxes.
3. I am the one who decides on my familys consumption
expenditure.
4. I can use the house, lot/s and other valuable possessions as
collateral/s for loans and other purposes.
5. My familys bank account is under my name and I have the
control of it.
6. I have the full control and access of my credit card/s.
7. I have the sole authority in deciding how much money I can
borrow from the bank.
8. The household properties such as land/s, house/s and other
assets are under my name.
9. I can monitor and have full knowledge about the financial
situation of the household.
1 I am the one who must first know where my familys expenses
0. went.
1 I have the full authority of my child/ childrens education.
1.
1 I have the authority of giving my child/childrens baon and
2. how much it will cost.
1 I have the full authority what kind of products will they buy
3. with regards to their basic needs.
I am the one who decide where and when my family spends a
1
vacation.
4.
Appendix E
T-Test Table for Empowerment and Age
Empowerment
Indicator
Age Indicator
Mean Std.
Deviation
T test
Economic &
Social
Participation
Group 1: 15-29
Group 2: above
30
114
210
3.11
3.80
.86
.81
-7.161
With degrees of
freedom = 322
114
210
3.42
4.03
.92
.78
114
3.27
.83
-6.316
With degrees of
freedom = 322
-7.372
Group 2: above
30
210
3.92
.72With degrees of
freedom = 322
Appendix F
T-Test Table for Empowerment and Educational Attainment
Empowerme
nt Indicator
Education
Indicator
Economic &
Social
Participation
Group1: HS
Grad &
Below
Group 2:
College
Grad &
Above
Mean
Std.
Deviation
T test
91
3.52
.84 -1.028
231
3.63
.88
With
degrees of
freedom=
320
Access &
Control Over
Resources
Empowerment
Group1: HS
Grad &
Below
91
3.38
.84
Group 2::
College
Grad &
Above
Group1: HS
Grad &
Below
231
4.05
.78
91
3.45
.78
Group 2::
College
Grad &
Above
231
3.84
.77
-6.793
With
degrees of
freedom=
320
-4.064
With
degrees of
freedom=
320
Appendix G
T-Test Tables for Empowerment and Range of Salary
Empowerme
nt Indicator
Education
Indicator
Mean
Std.
Deviation
Economic &
Social
Participation
Group1:
Php 5,10027,000
143
3.45
.88
185
3.67
.88
Access &
Group 2:
PhP27,001
and above
Group1:
143
3.45
.87
T test
-2.277
With
degrees of
freedom=
326
-7.856
Control Over
Resources
Empowerment
Php 5,10027,000
With
degrees of
freedom=
326
Group 2:
PhP27,001
and above
Group1:
Php 5,10027,000
185
4.14
.73
143
3.45
.81
Group 2:
PhP27,001
and above
185
3.91
.75
-5.295
With
degrees of
freedom=
326
Appendix H
T- Test Tables for Empowerment and Type of Occupation
Empowerme
nt Indicator
Education
Indicator
Mean
Std.
Deviation
Economic &
Social
Participation
Group1:
Human
Care
170
3.61
.83
154
3.56
.95
Access &
Group 2:
Non Human
Care
Group1:
170
3.68
.81
T test
.571
With
degrees of
freedom=
322
-3.675
Control Over
Resources
Empowerment
Human
Care
With
degrees of
freedom=
322
Group 2:
Non Human
Care
Group1:
Human
Care
154
4.02
.90
170
3.64
.75
Group 2:
Non Human
Care
154
3.79
.87
-1.621
With
degrees of
freedom=
322
CURRICULUM VITAE
Name:
Date of Birth:
Civil Status:
Single
Gender:
Male
Religion:
Roman Catholic
City Address:
Parents
Father:
Yacob Uy (Stepfather)
Mother:
Jocelyn Cabilan
EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
Pre-school:
1996-1998
1998 2004
2004 2008
Tertiary:
2008 2012
ORGANIZATIONS
MKD Gakusei Jichikai
Rotaract Club of MKD
2009-2010
2010-2011
Member
2008-2010
Member
2010-2011
Secretary
2009-2010
Member
2010-2011
Member
2008-2009
Member
2008
MKD College Y
Member
2009-2010
President
2010-2011
Member
2010-2011
MKD Civitan
EXAMINATIONS PASSED
Title
Date
December 4, 2008
December 7, 2009
January 14-15,2011
Name:
WISLEY S. ALCUIREZ
Date of Birth:
Civil Status:
Single
Gender:
Female
Religion:
Roman Catholic
City Address:
Parents
Father:
Mother:
Susan Solon
EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
Tertiary:
ORGANIZATIONS
19992002
20022004
2004 2005
2005 2007
2007 2011
Name:
Member
ANGELYC M. BONIFACIO
2008- Present
Date of Birth:
Civil Status:
Single
Gender:
Female
Religion:
Roman Catholic
City Address:
Parents
Father:
Jerry Bonifacio
Mother:
Tertiary:
1998-2003
2003 2007
2007 2011
ORGANIZATIONS
Rotaract Club of MKD
Member
2008- Present
Member
2010-Present
EXAMINATIONS PASSED
Title
Japanese Language Proficiency Test (JLPT) Level 4
Name:
CHARADE A. LAGUNA
Date
December 6, 2009
Date of Birth:
Civil Status:
Single
Gender:
Female
Religion:
City Address:
Parents
Father:
Vismar D. Laguna
Mother:
Elsalyn Alvarez
EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
Tertiary:
ORGANIZATIONS
1998-2004
2004 2008
2008 2012
Gakuse Jichikai
Vice President
2010-Present
Member
2008- Present
Member
2010-Present
Member
2010-Present
Nihongo Club
Member
2009 Present
Member
2009 Present
EXAMINATIONS PASSED
Title
Japanese Language Proficiency Test (JLPT) Level 4
Japanese Language Proficiency Test (JLPT) N4
Date
December 6, 2009
December 5, 2010
Name:
Date of Birth:
Civil Status:
Single
Gender:
Female
Religion:
Roman Catholic
City Address:
Parents
Father:
Ernesto D. Mainit
Mother:
Elenita Castrodes
EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
1996-1998
1998 2004
2004 2008
Tertiary:
2008 2012
ORGANIZATIONS
Rotaract Club of MKD
Member
2008-2010
President
2010-2011
Secretary
2009-2010
Member
2008-2009
Member
2008
Volunteer
2008-present
(AFS) Philippines
MKD College Y
Member
2010-present
EXAMINATIONS PASSED
Title
Date
December 4, 2008
December 7, 2009
December 5, 2010
Name:
Date of Birth:
Civil Status:
Single
Gender:
Female
Religion:
Roman Catholic
City Address:
Parents
Father:
Rogelio Paica
Mother:
Adelfa Gono
EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
1998-2003
Secondary:
University of Mindanao
Tagum City
2003 2007
Tertiary:
2007 2011
ORGANIZATIONS
Kaugmaon Volunteers Club
Member
2008 2010
Nihongo Club
Member
2008 2010
Member
2008-2010
EXAMINATIONS PASSED
Title
Japanese Language Proficiency Test (JLPT) Level 4
Japanese Language Proficiency Test (JLPT) N4
Date
December 7, 2009
December 5, 2010