Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
P u b l i s h e r s
KinderZiekenhuis Brussel, Department of Pediatrics, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Laarbeeklaan 101, 1090
Brussels, Belgium; 2Department of Anaesthesiology, UZ Gent, De Pintelaan 185, 9000 Ghent, Belgium;
yvan.vandenplas@uzbrussel.be
Received: 8 February 2012 / Accepted: 3 May 2012
2012 Wageningen Academic Publishers
Abstract
The cost/benefit ratio of probiotics in the ambulatory treatment of acute infectious gastro-enteritis with or without a
synbiotic food supplement (containing fructo-oligosaccharides and probiotic strains of Streptoccoccus thermophilus,
Lactobacillus rhamnosus, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Bifidobacterium lactis and Bifidobacterium infantis) has been
studied. 111 children (median age 37 and 43 months for the synbiotic and placebo group, respectively) with acute
infectious gastroenteritis were included in a randomised, prospective placebo-controlled trial performed in primary
health care. All children were treated with an oral rehydration solution and with the synbiotic food supplement
(n=57) or placebo (n=54). Physicians were allowed to prescribe additional medication according to what they
considered as necessary. Cost of add-on medication and total healthcare cost were calculated. Median duration of
diarrhoea was 1 day shorter (95% confidence interval -0.6 to -1.9 days) in the symbiotic than in the placebo group
(P<0.005). Significantly more concomitant medication (antibiotics, antipyretics, antiemetics) was prescribed in the
placebo group (39 prescriptions in 28 patients) compared to the synbiotic group (12 prescriptions in 7 patients)
(P<0.001). The difference was most striking for antiemetics: 28 vs. 5 prescriptions. The cost of add-on medication in
the placebo group was evaluated at 4.04/patient (median 4.97 (interquartile (IQ) 25-75: 0-4.97)) vs. 1.13 /patient
in the synbiotic arm (P<0.001). If the cost of the synbiotic is considered, median cost raised to 7.15/patient (IQ
25-75: 7.15-7.15) (P<0.001). The extra consultations needed to prescribe the concomitant medication resulted in a
higher health care cost in the placebo group ( 14.41 vs. 10.74/patient, P<0.001). Synbiotic food supplementation
resulted in a 24 h earlier normalisation of stool consistency. Although use of the synbiotic supplementation increased
cost, add-on medication and extra consultations were reduced, resulting in a reduction of health care cost of 25%.
Keywords: acute diarrhoea, acute gastroenteritis, benefit, cost, prebiotic, probiotic, synbiotic
1. Introduction
Recommended treatment of acute infectious diarrhoea
consists of oral rehydration solution (ORS) to correct
dehydration. ORS has reduced the incidence of mortality
and morbidity caused by diarrhoea but it does not shorten
its duration, as it does not change the consistency of the
stools and does not normalise gastrointestinal flora (Sazawal
et al., 2006). Probiotics are living microorganisms that
survive in the gastrointestinal tract and, when ingested in
sufficiently large amount, confer a health benefit on the
host. The European Society for Paediatric Gastroenterology,
Y. Vandenplas et al.
Table 1. Composition of the synbiotic food supplement.1
Compound
Probiotic species2
Streptococci
Lactobacilli
Streptococcus thermophilus
Lactobacillus rhamnosus
Lactobacillus acidophilus
Bifidobacterium infantis
Bifidobacterium lactis
Bifidobacteria
Weight
Fructo-oligosaccharides
Ascorbic acid
1
20 mg
1.2 mg
2 In
29/28
37 (2-186)
16.4 (5.9-75.0)
1 (1-7)
27/27
43 (1-159)
17.0 (4.9-38)
1 (1-6)
12
11
190
3. Results
No physician reported on day 4 that treatment outcome
was unacceptable or poor in a patient. However, overall,
physicians were more satisfied with the synbiotic food
supplement than with placebo (P=0.005) (Table 3).
Compliance of intake of medication in both treatment
arms was excellent. Prescription of concomitant medication
was limited to antipyretics, antiemetic medication and
antibiotics. Antidiarrhoea medication such as adsorbants,
antisecretory drugs and motility inhibitors, was not used.
Additional medication was significantly prescribed to
more patients in the placebo group (28/54 patients, 52%)
compared to the synbiotic group (7/57 patients, 12%)
(P<0.001). Significantly more concomitant medication was
Table 3. Treatment satisfaction as estimated by the parents
and physicians on day 4.1
n (%)
Synbiotic group
Placebo group
Patients2
Poor
Acceptable
Good
Very good
Excellent
55
0 (0%)
0 (0%)
8 (14.5%)
24 (43.6%)
23 (41.8%)
53
0 (0%)
4 (7.5%)
15 (28.3%)
25 (47.2%)
9 (16.9%)
Synbiotic group
Placebo group
P-value1
1 NS
Antipyretics
n (% patients)
Antiemetics
n (% patients)
Antibiotics
n (% patients)
Total medication
n (% patients)
6 (10%)
5 (9%)
NS
5 (9%)
28 (52%)
<0.001
1 (2%)
6 (11%)
NS
7 (12%)
28 (52%)
<0.001
= not significant.
191
Y. Vandenplas et al.
Table 5. Health care cost (/patient).
Synbiotic group
Cost of add-on medication (mean)
Cost of all medications
Mean
Median
Interquartile 25-75
Range
Cost extra consultation/patient (mean)
Total healthcare cost (mean)
1.13
8.28
7.15
7.15-7.15
7.15-26.49
2.46
10.74
4. Discussion
In Europe, probiotics are advised along with appropriate
rehydration and patient education in the management of
acute diarrhoea in childhood (Guarino et al., 2008). The
number of children with diarrhoea lasting longer than
3 days before inclusion was comparable in both groups.
Data from a study with Saccharomyces boulardii suggest
that the sooner probiotics are started in the course of an
acute gastroenteritis, the better the outcome (Villaruel
et al., 2007). The finding that no physician scored
treatment outcome as poor or unsatisfactory in both
groups, strengthens the hypothesis that outcome of acute
gastroenteritis is excellent in industrialised countries and
supports the idea that probiotics are merely used to fulfil a
parental demand for medication. The fact that in primary
health care hardly ever an adverse event of probiotics has
been reported, seems to justify this choice. However, if
physicians were asked to quantify the degree of satisfaction
as poor, acceptable, good, very good and excellent, outcome
in the synbiotic treatment arm was evaluated significantly
192
Placebo group
4.04
4.04
4.97
0-4.97
0-19.34
10.37
14.41
P-value
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
Acknowledgements
Phacobel Belgium provided the test products (synbiotic
and placebo). The Probiotical study group comprised
of D. Abrassart, F. Adriaens, N. Balduck, G. Biart, J.-M.
Carbonnelle, C. Dauge, P. David, U. Ehrentreich, G. Feron,
F. Garbentz, D. Gob, R. Graindorge, B. Hins, A. Hutsebaut,
S. Jacquart, I. Jacquemart, C. Leblanc, A.-L. Lenoir, C.
Lietaer, K. Logghe, A.-S. Loicq, S. Nouri, J. Poncelet, A. Van
Damme, D. Van Damme, L. Van De Vyver, A. Verbist, M.
Verboven, I. Verheyden and S. Ballard, Belgium.
References
Albano, F., Bruzzese, E., Spagnuolo, M.I. and De Marco, G., 2006.
Antiemetics for children with gastroenteritis: off-label but still
on in clinical practice. Journal of Pediatric Gastroenterology and
Nutrition 43: 402-404.
Basu, S., Chatterjee, M., Ganguly, S. and Chandra, P.K., 2007. Efficacy
of Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG in acute watery diarrhoea of Indian
children: a randomised controlled trial. Journal of Paediatrics and
Child Health 43: 837-842.
DeCamp, L.R., Byerley, J.S., Doshi, N. and Steiner, M.J., 2008. Use of
antiemetic agents in acute gastroenteritis: a systematic review and
meta-analysis. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine
162: 858-865.
Dinleyici, E.C., Eren, M., Yargic, Z.A. and Vandenplas, Y., 2011. Costeffectiveness of add-on probiotics (Saccharomyces boulardii) in
children with acute rotavirus diarrhea in Turkey. In: Abstract book
44th Annual Meeting of ESPGHAN, 25-28 May 2011, Sorrento,
Italy. p. PO-G-0085.
193
Y. Vandenplas et al.
Eren, M., Dinleyici, E.C. and Vandenplas, Y., 2010. Clinical efficacy
comparison of Saccharomyces boulardii and yogurt fluid in acute
non-bloody diarrhea in children: a randomized, controlled, open
label study. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
82: 488-491.
Freedman, S.B., Sivabalasundaram, V., Bohn, V., Powell, E.C., Johnson,
D.W. and Boutis, K., 2011. The treatment of pediatric gastroenteritis:
a comparative analysis of pediatric emergency physicians practice
patterns. Academic Emergency Medicine 18: 38-45.
Grandy, G., Medina, M., Soria, R., Tern, C.G. and Araya, M.,
2010. Probiotics in the treatment of acute rotavirus diarrhoea.
A randomized, double-blind, controlled trial using two different
probiotic preparations in Bolivian children. BMC Infectious Diseases
10: 253.
Guarino, A., Albano, F., Ashkenazi, S., Gendrel, D., Hoekstra, J.H.,
Shamir, R. and Szajewska, H., 2008. European Society for Paediatric
Gastroenterology, Hepatology, and Nutrition/European Society for
Paediatric Infectious Diseases evidence-based guidelines for the
Pfeil, N., Uhlig, U., Kostev, K., Carius, R., Schrder, H., Kiess, W.
and Uhlig, H.H., 2008. Antiemetic medications in children with
presumed infectious gastroenteritis pharmacoepidemiology in
Europe and Northern America. Journal of Pediatrics 153: 659-662.
Sazawal, S., Dhingra, U., Dhingra, P., Hiremath, G., Kumar, J., Sarkar,
A., Menon, V.P. and Black, R.E., 2006. Efficacy of probiotics
in prevention of acute diarrhoea: a meta-analysis of masked,
randomised, placebo-controlled trials. The Lancet Infectious
Diseases 6: 374-382.
Thomas, D.W., Greer, F.R. and Committee on Nutrition; Section on
Gastroenterology, Hepatology, and Nutrition, 2010. Probiotics and
prebiotics in pediatrics. Pediatrics 126: 1217-1231.
Vandenplas, Y., De Hert, S. and the Probiotical-study group, 2011.
Randomized clinical trial with the synbiotic food supplement
Probiotical in acute gastroenteritis in children. Alimentary
Pharmacology and Therapeutics 34: 862-867.
Villarruel, G., Rubio, D.M., Lopez, F., Cintioni, J., Gurevech, R., Romero,
G. and Vandenplas, Y., 2007. Saccharomyces boulardii in acute
194