Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
v2.1
Exam Skills
Question
An organisation is proposing to move from a health and safety management system based on the International Labour
Organisation ILO-OSH-2001 model to one that aligns itself with BS OHSAS 18001. Outline the possible advantages
AND disadvantages of such a change.
(10)
(Unit IA July 2009)
v2.1
Exam Skills
Possible Disadvantages
Although OHSAS 18001 is a well-known standard, it may produce
a system that significantly exceeds the minimum legal standard.
Regulators, however, tend to prefer the simple and straightforward
approach offered by systems based on ILO-OSH-2001, which
conform more closely to the basic legal requirements
Costs costs involved in changing to this system including
registration, certification, changes to standards/paperwork, etc.
Costs in terms of time changing from one system to the other will
involve a lot of time from management, staff and H&S professionals
Paperwork increased paperwork to get certificated by the awarding
body
Possibly too complicated a system based on OHSAS 18001 may be
more than what a small or medium-sized company really needs and
may be too difficult to implement for that reason
Audits for OHSAS 18001 compliance may not be conducted by
auditors with detailed health and safety knowledge
Audits may not involve the companys H&S professionals if
integrated with other systems such as quality or the environment
An exam candidate would achieve poor marks for an answer that did not:
Demonstrate a clear understanding of the differences between the systems.
Identify BS OHSAS 18001 as an integrated management system.
Outline the possible advantages and disadvantages of moving from one management system to another.
Concentrate on advantages and disadvantages of each system and strayed into providing a description of the
components of each system.
v2.1