Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Nepean Hospital, Sydney, Australia
University of Sydney, Australia
The Whiteley-Martin Research Centre, The University of Sydney, Nepean Hospital, Sydney, Australia
a r t i c l e i n f o
a b s t r a c t
Article history:
Paper received 12 December 2014
Accepted 3 March 2015
Available online 20 March 2015
Introduction: Osteoradionecrosis of the mandible is a devastating complication of radiotherapy in patients with head and neck cancer. Many cases present at a late stage, from months to years following
completion of radiation therapy. When medical treatment fails, surgery may be required with a variety of
free aps available for microvascular reconstructive techniques.
Objective: To conduct a systematic review of the literature investigating the outcomes of free ap
reconstruction of the jaw in mandibular osteoradionecrosis and determine the failure rates of different
ap tissue.
Methods: A systematic literature search was performed using Medline (Ovid) Pubmed and Embase databases and Google Scholar. Primary outcome measures were ap failures and complications, with donor
site complications representing the secondary outcome measure. Analysis of pooled outcomes was
undertaken for different aps.
Results: 333 articles were identied and 15 articles met the nal inclusion criteria, detailing 368 primary
free tissue ap transfers. There was a ap failure rate of 9.8%. There were 146 post-operative complications (39.7%), the most common being stula formation (8.4%), hardware plate exposure (7.1%) and ap
wound infections (6.5%).
Conclusion: The bula is the workhorse free ap for reconstruction in mandibular osteoradionecrosis.
Evidence to date is largely limited with the need for larger powered multi-institutional prospective
studies to determine the ideal ap donor tissue and evaluate patient and treatment predictors of free
ap outcomes in order to tailor the best patient-based surgical approach for mandibular
osteoradionecrosis.
Crown Copyright 2015 Published by Elsevier Ltd on behalf of European Association for Cranio-MaxilloFacial Surgery. All rights reserved.
Keywords:
Osteoradionecrosis
Mandible
Free Tissue Flaps
Surgical aps
Head and neck neoplasms
1. Introduction
Osteoradionecrosis (ORN) is one of the most debilitating complications of radiation therapy in patients undergoing treatment for
head and neck cancer. It is dened as exposed irradiated bone that
fails to heal over a three-month period in the absence of residual or
recurrent tumour (Epstein et al., 1987) and can affect any bony
component of the craniomaxillofacial skeleton (Teng and Futran,
2005).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jcms.2015.03.006
1010-5182/Crown Copyright 2015 Published by Elsevier Ltd on behalf of European Association for Cranio-Maxillo-Facial Surgery. All rights reserved.
2027
3. Results
3.1. Study characteristics
Table 1 shows selected characteristics of the identied studies
(Ioannides et al., 1994; Nakatsuka et al., 1996; Curi and Dib, 1997;
Santamaria et al., 1998; Chang et al., 2001; Celik et al., 2002; Store
et al., 2002; Militsakh et al., 2005; Bozec et al., 2006; Suh et al.,
2010; Baumann et al., 2011; Cannady et al., 2011; Chandarana
et al., 2013; Sawhney and Ducic, 2013; Hillerup et al., 2014).
Eight studies examined populations from North America, one
from South America, four from Europe and two from Asia. Of the
11 studies that reported follow-up periods, the average duration
was 35.4 months. Mean age was 57.4 years, and the reported
percentage of males was 68% (58%e72%), I2 37.52, p 0.07 and
smokers 55% (18%e88%), I2 92.07, p < 0.001. Squamous cell
carcinoma comprised the majority of cases, 83% (77%e89%),
I2 0.00, p 0.61 and the mean radiotherapy dose 67.71 gray
(Gy).
2028
2029
The overall ap failure rate was 9.8% (n 36). Flap tissue type
was identied in 21 aps across 11 studies. 4 of the 15 studies did
not identify the types of aps that failed, leaving 15 ap failures
unaccounted for.
In mandibular reconstruction, restoration of bone continuity is
not the only key to success. The surgery needs to achieve adequate
bone height and width and supporting of overlying soft tissue
structures to restore jaw motion (McAllister and Haghighat, 2007).
The masseter muscle is the strongest muscle in the body and does
not stretch uniformly for major jaw movement thus a good supportive bone and soft tissue structural graft is crucial to maintain
the functional integrity of the jaw. The soft tissue needs to be
forgiving in both size as quality thus when considering the use of
non-vascularised bone grafts, the ideal tissue should have enough
bulk, vascularity and cellularity to achieve good graft application
(Arotiba et al., 2012).
Four osteocutaneous aps are commonly used for mandible
reconstruction: bula ap, iliac crest ap, scapula ap and the
radial ap. Li et al. (Li et al., 2012) conducted a cohort study in
which 116 patients underwent latissimus dorsi free ap and plate
reconstruction following advanced oro-mandibular tumour resection. The series demonstrated a very good survival rate (99.1%).
Despite favourable results, the use of latissimus dorsi along with
serratus anterior and upper arm (humerus) aps is becomingling
increasingly less common, largely due to the limited available bone
to repair mandible defects, and the short pedicle available, which
make the aps difcult to anastomose.
The iliac crest ap is usually considered when there is a
contraindication to the bula ap. Patients with signs of lower limb
vascular insufciency or a history of lower limb fracture are
deemed unsuitable for the bula ap. It does offer certain unique
advantages over the bula ap in the quality and quantity of bone
available, whereby the resting shape of the iliac crest bone resembles the mandible anatomically, requiring minimal osteotomy.
The major drawback is that whilst it has robust blood supply to the
bone and internal oblique muscle, issues can arise in the blood
supply to the skin, whereby the supplying perforators of the deep
circumex iliac artery can tear easily as they pass through the layers
2030
of the abdominal wall (Chepeha and Teknos, 2001). The iliac crest
ap had a success rate of 76.6%, with the most common failure
reason attributed to venous thrombosis (Ioannides et al., 1994).
The scapula ap is a reasonable option with its main feature
being that of its abundant soft tissue and its two discrete skin
paddles, which allows for greater exibility in repairing complex
facial defects. A recent retrospective institutional study found the
free scapula/parascapular ap to be a versatile and reliable ap for
head and neck reconstructions with a good success rate (96%) and a
low complication rate (2.3%) (Mitsimponas et al., 2014). One limitation of this ap is its limited length, and the thin and ne nature
of the bone. Another disadvantage is the need for patient repositioning during the surgery in order to harvest the ap, precluding
simultaneous harvesting at the time of tumour resection and prolonging the operating time (Miles et al., 2010).
The radial forearm free ap is a reasonable alternative in its key
property of superior blood supply compared to other tissue options. It offers a large, thin and pliable skin segment that is widely
favored for soft tissue reconstruction of pharyngoesophageal defects as a fasciocutaneous ap. Additional bulk can be included
with use of the brachioradialis muscle and it has good nerve
supply for optimal recovery of sensory function (Disa and
Cordeiro, 2000). As an osteocutaneous ap however, the radius
in limited in the lack of bone available for osteotomy (Abdel-Kader
et al., 2013). There is approximately 10 cm of bone available to be
taken and although it is cortical bone, only one third of the crosssectional area can be taken without increasing the risk of mechanical stress fracture (Clark et al., 2004). This compromises the
thickness of the bone and thus only a small bony defect can be
repaired using the radial ap, unless combined with other donor
sites (Rinaldo et al., 2002). Of the total 31 radial free aps, no ap
failures were reported. However, it is unclear whether those undertaken in the studies included osteotomy or if they were fasciocutaneous aps only.
The bula microvascular free ap for head and neck reconstruction was rst introduced by Hidalgo in 1989 (Hidalgo, 1989)
and is now considered as the workhorse for mandible reconstruction (George and Krishnamurthy, 2013; Succo et al., 2014) (Ang
et al., 2003). The bula osteocutaneous free ap has quickly
gained popularity over other vascularized bone aps in recent years
for several reasons. The bula benets from its quality of bone, with
good cortical thickness, and the generous length of bone available
(up to 25e30 cm), which permits multiple osteotomies even whilst
the pedicle is still attached (Urken et al., 1991) (Hao et al., 1999). The
vasculature is also ideal. The ap's dominant arterial supply is from
the peroneal artery and venous drainage via the 2 venae comitantes, which have an average caliber of 1.5 mm and 3 mm
respectively. These vessel diameters closely match that of most
recipient vessels in the neck facilitating effective anastomoses. Its
long and reliable vascular pedicle (up to 12e15 cm) is useful when
confronted with recipient vessels that are difcult to locate in
heavily irradiated tissue (Wallace et al., 2010). Furthermore, the
bula provides the bony platform for eventual prosthetic rehabilitation, allowing the placement of intraosseous dental implants. The
bula free ap offers considerable advantages over its counterparts
as the ideal ap of choice for mandibular reconstruction and it was
by far the most common free ap tissue used (n 215) and, from
the free ap failure data reported, had a good success rate (95.3%).
With the great variations across the studies, and the small
numbers of some e.g. humerus (n 5) sufciently powered subset
analyses to determine the best donor ap site were unable to be
conducted.
The purpose of this systematic review was to summarize the
reported literature to date in the variety of free ap reconstructions
used and the outcomes of different practice across different institutions. We appreciate that this review is a retrospective pooling
of case series predisposed to the drawbacks associated with such
studies. We also acknowledge the assumed limitations in the
outdated nature of some articles, particularly those predating the
new millennium (Ioannides et al., 1994; Curi and Dib, 1997;
Santamaria et al., 1998), with which current practice may now
vastly differ to that carried out in the older studies. In the 15 studies
included in this review, all retrospective case series, there were a
total 368 primary microvascular free aps studied with a 9.8%
failure rate. Flap failure requires a revision operation and in most
instances, necessitates a secondary free ap from another donor
site. This leads to further morbidity and a longer hospital stay,
which calls for measures in acquiring a better understanding of the
factors associated with ap loss. Direct associations between clinical and patient factors with ap loss overall were not explored in
the included articles in this systematic review, thus pooled outcomes of such could not be reported. In the literature, important
factors that have been associated with graft survival include the
length of mandibular defect, timing of the reconstruction (immediate or delayed), cancer diagnosis, intraoral communication, estimated blood loss and the duration of post-operative antibiotics
(August et al., 2000). Furthermore, longer close follow-up periods
are needed. All of the 11 studies that reported follow-up period
durations reported outcomes within a 5 year post-operative period.
Long-term outcomes and potential adverse consequences are not
known.
This is the rst systematic review looking at the surgical outcomes of reconstruction with microvascular free aps used in patients with mandibular osteoradionecrosis. The results show the
challenges inherent in successful microvascular free ap reconstruction in patients with mandibular osteoradionecrosis, however
the systematic review is limited in the retrospective nature of all
studies and the inherent selection bias in the patient populations.
The lack of randomized trials, variability in the donor ap site used
and the potential for confounding factors e.g. adjuvant medical
treatment and surgical technique, limit an objective analysis. As
institutional practices in relation to ap choice and surgical technique and consistencies in follow-up reporting of outcomes are
likely to vary, future prospective studies with in-depth analyses of
the predictors of ap survival are needed. Recommendations for
future research directions include the investigation of predictive
patient and clinical factors and determination of the ideal donor
ap site associated with the best outcomes.
5. Conclusions
Osteoradionecrosis of the mandible is an uncommon but signicant complication of radiotherapy, where surgical treatment
for advanced disease can carry great morbidity with postoperative complications. Whilst a number of free ap tissue
types can be used, the bula free ap continues to be the gold
standard and workhorse ap in the reconstruction of mandibular
defects with a good success rate. Higher-powered prospective
studies that closely examine patient and clinical factors associated
with ap outcomes will lead to greater understanding of predictors of ap survival and help guide individualized patient approaches to appropriate microvascular reconstruction in
mandibular osteoradionecrosis.
Conicts of interest
None.
2031
Appendices
Table 1
Study characteristics.
Author and date
Study type
Continent
Total no.
primary aps
Flap type
North America
63
18.2
Europe
North America
6
53
Asia
27
North America
12
North America
30
South America
Europe
Europe
5
15
33
North America
Asia
9
9
North America
North America
12
37
Europe
17
North America
40
31.0
Not reported
Not reported
41.0
33.0
25.0
Not reported
32.0
36.0
Not reported
45.0
54.0
57.0
17
Table 2
Free ap failures.
Study
Type of ap
63
4 (6.3)
Not stated
Vessel thrombosis (n 3)
Carotid artery rupture (n 1)
6
53
27
0 (0)
7 (13.2)
3 (11.1)
13
30
4 (3.1)
4 (1.4)
5
15
33
1 (20.0)
1 (6.7)
5 (15.2)
N/A
Not stated
Fibula n 2
Anterolateral thigh n 1
Not stated
Fibula n 1
Iliac n 2
Scapula n 1
Fibula n 1
Latissimus dorsi n 1
Iliac n 5
9
9
0 (0)
1 (11.1)
N/A
Scapula n 1
Fistula (n 3)
Not stated
Venous thrombosis (n 2), infection (n 1), other (n 1)
Fistula (n 1)
Plate exposure (n 1)
Venous thrombosis (n 4)
Technical error (n 1)
2032
Table 2 (continued )
Study
Type of ap
12
2 (16.7)
Fibula n 2
37
17
40
2 (5.4)
2 (11.8)
0 (0)
Fibula n 2
Fibula n 2
N/A
Vessel thrombosis (n 1)
Fistula (n 1)
Skin paddle necrosis (n 2)
Infection (n 2)
Table 3
Free ap complications.
Study
Reason
20
Infection (n 8)
Fistula (n 6)
Haematoma (n 2)
Vessel thrombosis (n 3)
Vessel rupture (n 1)
Infection (n 1)
Fistula (n 1)
Skin paddle necrosis (n 1)
Fistula (n 2)
Vessel thrombosis (n 4)
Vessel rupture (n 1)
Other (n 5)
Fistula (n 3)
Infection (n 1)
Skin paddle necrosis (n 1)
Fistula (n 6)
Non-union (n 4)
Plate exposure (n 5)
Haematoma (n 1)
Other (n 3)
Infection (n 1)
Skin paddle necrosis (n 2)
Vessel thrombosis (n 2)
Fistula (n 1)
Vessel thrombosis (n 1)
N/A
Infection (n 3)
Fistula (n 2)
Haematoma (n 2)
Vessel thrombosis (n 4)
N/A
Skin paddle necrosis (n 1)
Fistula (n 1)
Non-union (n 1)
Skin paddle necrosis (n 1)
Fistula (n 2)
Vessel thrombosis (n 1)
Skin paddle necrosis (n 1)
Non-union (n 4)
Plate exposure (n 3)
Infection (n 3)
Plate exposure n 1
Infection n 7
Fistula n 6
Plate exposure n 17
13
3
20
0
13
0
3
15
7
38
References
Abdel-Kader MS, Tamam AA, Elderwy AA, Gad M, El-Gamal MA, Kurkar A, et al:
Management of symptomatic ureteral calculi during pregnancy: experience of
23 cases. Urol Ann 5(4): 241e244, 2013
Adamo AK, Szal RL: Timing, results, and complications of mandibular reconstructive
surgery: report of 32 cases. J Oral Surg 37(10): 755e763, 1979
Alam DS, Nuara M, Christian J: Analysis of outcomes of vascularized ap reconstruction in patients with advanced mandibular osteoradionecrosis. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 141(2): 196e201, 2009
Ang E, Black C, Irish J, Brown DH, Gullane P, O'Sullivan B, et al: Reconstructive
options in the treatment of osteoradionecrosis of the craniomaxillofacial skeleton. Br J Plast Surg 56(2): 92e99, 2003
Annane D, Depondt J, Aubert P, Villart M, Gehanno P, Gajdos P, et al: Hyperbaric
oxygen therapy for radionecrosis of the jaw: a randomized, placebo-controlled,
double-blind trial from the ORN96 study group. J Clin Oncol 22(24):
4893e4900, 2004
Arotiba GT, Efom AO, Ayodele AS, Ogundana MO, Gbotolorun MO, Olasoji HO, et al:
A classication system for recurrent ameloblastoma of the jawsereview of 30
cases in Nigerians. Nig Q J Hosp Med 22(1): 44e51, 2012
August M, Tompach P, Chang Y, Kaban L: Factors inuencing the long-term outcome
of mandibular reconstruction. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 58(7): 731e737, 2000
discussion 738
Baumann DP, Yu P, Hanasono MM, Skoracki RJ: Free ap reconstruction of osteoradionecrosis of the mandible: a 10-year review and defect classication. Head
Neck 33(6): 800e807, 2011
Bozec A, Poissonnet G, Converset S, Vallicioni J, Demard F, Dassonville O: Fibula free
ap for reconstruction of extensive mandibular osteoradionecrosis. Ann Otolaryngol Chir Cervicofac 123(2): 98e106, 2006
Buchbinder D, St Hilaire H: The use of free tissue transfer in advanced osteoradionecrosis of the mandible. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 64(6): 961e964, 2006
Cannady SB, Dean N, Kroeker A, Albert TA, Rosenthal EL, Wax MK: Free ap
reconstruction for osteoradionecrosis of the jawseoutcomes and predictive
factors for success. Head Neck 33(3): 424e428, 2011
2033