Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Abstract
A. Rotstein, R. Do tan, 0. Bar-Or, and G. Tenenbaum, Effect
of Training on Anaerobic Threshold, Anaerobic Performance,
and Maximal Power of Preadolescent Boys. lnt J Sports Med,
Vol 7, No 5, pp 281286, 1986.
To evaluate the effect of a 9-week interval training program on
aerobic capacity, anaerobic capacity, and indices of anaerobic
threshold of preadolescent boys, 28 10.2- to 11.6-year-old
boys were tested. The test included laboratory evaluation of
anaerobic capacity (Wingate anaerobic test) and evaluation of
V02 max and anaerobic threshold indices from a graded exercise test and measurement of blood lactate. The tests also included a 1200-rn run to investigate the relationship of laboratory fitness indices, V02 max, anaerobic threshold indices, and
indices of anaerobic capacity to the performance of the run.
It was found that in 10- to 11-year-old boys, a 9-week interval training increased the indices of anaerobic capacity: mean
power by 10% and peak power by 14%. No change was found
in percent fatigue. The training also increased V02 max by
7% in absolute terms and by 8%/kg body weight. A significant
increase was also found in the running velocity at the anaerobic threshold (running velocity at inflection point of lactate
accumulation curve), but in relative terms (percent of VO2max),
the anaerobic threshold decreased by approximately 4.4%. It
is concluded that proper training may improve maximal aerobic power and anaerobic capacity of preadolescent boys. It is
also concluded that anaerobic threshold measures are less sensitive to the training regimen than VO2rnax and that the
1200-rn running performance is strongly associated with both
aerobic and anaerobic capacities and less with the anaerobic
threshold, which in preadolescent boys seems to be higher
than in adults.
Key words: preadolescence, anaerobic threshold, ','02 max,
anaerobic capacity, training, running performance
Introduction
It is generally accepted that children's response to exercise is
quantitatively different from that of adults (1, 3, 28).
Among other differences, children have distinctly lower
maximal anaerobic power and capacity than do adolescents
and adults (16). This is in line with children's low levels of
muscle lactate during maximal exercise (12). Most (1, 22,
28, 40), but not all (7) authors have found low maximal
blood lactate concentration in children.
There is also a controversy regarding the aerobic trainability
of children. While some authors (4, 19, 29, 36, 38, 29)
* Present address: Dept. of Pediatrics, Faculty of Health Sciences,
Methods
Sub/ects
Twenty-eight 10.2- to 11.6-year-old boys (mean age 10.79
0.33 years) volunteered for the study. The subjects were
nonathletes but with a normal physical activity level for
their age. They had no overt manifestations of any disease.
Testing Protocol
Day 1: Anthropometric measurements and performance
of the Wingate Anaerobic Test. Following a 45-mm rest,
the ''02max test was performed.
Day 2: Anaerobic threshold test.
The field test of 1200-m run was performed within 38
days of the laboratory test. The same testing protocol was
repeated after a training period of 9 weeks.
Training
During the 9-week period between testing sessions, the experimental group was trained three times per week. Each
45-mm training session included: 1520 mm of warming
up and movement games, one or two series of 3x600 m
runs with 2.5 mm rest in between runs, 5x400 m runs with
2 mm rest in between, and 6x150 m runs with 1.5 mm rest
in between. Each session ended with some less formal
"aerobic" activities and games.
Each subject trained at an intensity suitable for his condition according to the initial test performance. The training intensity was adjusted periodically according to changes
in the physical condition of the subject.
Mean attendance in the training program was 85.5%. The
controls were asked not to change their habitual activity
during the study, but the investigators had no means of
supervising this activity, short of obtaining oral confirmation from the subjects, nor was it possible to control the
physical activities of the experimental group outside the
training sessions.
The differences between the groups and the pre-post measures within each group were obtained by independent
and dependent t tests, respectively. The relationship between
1200-rn run and the physiologic parameters was obtained
by Pearson product-moment correlation procedure.
Results
282
Effect of Training on Anaerobic Threshold, Maximal Aerobic Power and Anaerobic Performance
283
142.313.89
143.454.03
140.946.93
141.882.00
Pre
33.203.18
Post
32.91
32.874.19
33.184.04
Pre
Post
Height (cm)
Control
Indt
062
0.69
Pairedt
Weight (kg)
Paired t
% Fat
Pre
13.6 p.46
Post
12.001.66
Paired t
27.312.15
27.382.03
Paired t
0.81
1.88
12.031.94
11.662.05
2.22
1.43
0.47
0.2
27.122.89
27.563.09
0.18
Control
Ind
*P <0.05;
2.66*
Post
Pre
LMB (kg)
1.91
0.24
0.20
Experimental
1200 m (s)
MPkg'
W.kg
Pre
Post
337.3940.54
303.1221.91
5.46****
Pre
Post
Paired t
6.79 0.71
7.47 0.69
6.94 0.65
7.04 0.64
1.17
0.56
1.67
Pre
7.70 0.78
8.79 0.85
8.12 0.82
8.05 0.75
0.82
1.32
30.73 6.16
28.26 5.49
1.65
1.36
Post
Wkg
Paired t
Fatigue %
Pre
Post
27.02 5.44
30.29 3.95
Pairedt
1.71
btsmin1
0.23
4.16
Pairedt
PP.kg
Max HR
334.7817.32
330.5812.80
1.28
Pre
Post
Paired t
209.14 5.7
205.75 5.55
2.41*
2.29*
1.85
203.54 5.32
204.88 8.15
2.55***
0.51
1.16
Table 3 Aerobic capacity and anaerobic threshold parameters pre- and post-training
Experimental
54.203.67
58.633.85
Control
57.132.5
58.293.79
max '2
Pre
Post
ml'kg min
Pairedt
LA-4-V
Pre
10.36L03
km'h1
Post
10.910.67
10.660.66
10.880.69
Pairedt
2.10
2.11
LA-I-V
kmh
Pre
Post
Pre
Post
Paired t
LA-l-V%
Pre
Post
Paired t
*P<005; **P<001; ***p<OIjjJfJl
2.102
0.23
1.79
10.040.93
10.550.74
Paired t
LA-4-V%
md t
85.076.76
80.643.93
2.22*
82.246.99
77.9
4.00**
10.280.34
10.440.64
0.85
0.24
0.86
0.42
106
82.724.81
0.86
82.622.38
0.10
1.70
79.853.82
79.391.91
0.42
0.89
0.85
Control
Experimental
0.47
PP-kg
max V02
LA-4-V
LA-I-V
LA-4-V%
LA-l-V%
0.43
0.54
0.43
0.49
0.10
0.35
0.80
0.74
0.44
0.14
0.25
< 0.01
284
Acknowledgment
The authors wish to acknowledge the invaluable assistance of Mr. Dan
Griber in all phases of the project and especially in organizing and
coaching the training.
References
1 Astrand P.O.: Experimental Studies of Physical Working Capacity
in Relation to Sex and Age. Copenhagen, Munksgaard, 1952.
2 Bar-Or 0.: The Wingate anaerobic test. Characteristics and applications (in French). Symbioses 13: 157172, 1981.
3 Bar-Or 0.: Pediatric Sports Medicine for the Practitioner: From
Physiologic Principles to ClinicalApplication. New York, Springer Verlag, 1983.
4 Bar-Or 0., Dotan R., Inbar 0., Rotstein A., Karlsson J., Tesch P.:
Anaerobic capacity and muscle fiber type distribution in man.
285
Effect of Training on Anaerobic Threshold, Maximal Aerobic Power and Anaerobic Performance
36 Smit P.J., Daehne H.O.. Von Wyke G., Steyn E.S.: interval
training and the progressive load principle in novice child
swimmers, in Terauds, Bedingfield, Wengy (eds): Swimming II.
Baltimore, University Park Press, 1979, pp 240249.
37 Stewart K.J., Gutin B., Fogle R.K.: The Effects of Physical
Training on Cardiovascular Fitness in Children. Presented at the
Ann. Convention of the Amer. Assoc. for Health, Phys. Ed.,
and Recreat., Anaheim, CA, 1974.
38 Vaccaro P., Clarke D.H.: Cardiorespiratory alterations in 9 to 11
year old children following a season of competitive swimming.
Med Sci Sports 10: 204207, 1978.
Dr. Are Rotstein, Dept. of Research & Sport Medicine, Wingate Institute, Wingate Post 42902, Israel
286