Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ABSTRACT
Background: Hypertension is the most prevalent noncommunicable disease causing significant morbidity/mortality through
cardiovascular, cerebrovascular, and renal complications. Objectives: This communitybased study tested the efficacy of
nonpharmacological interventions in preventing/controlling hypertension. Materials and Methods: This is a crossover randomized
controlled trial (RCT) of the earlier RCT (2007) of nonpharmacological interventions in hypertension, conducted in the urban
service area of our Institute. The subjects, prehypertensive and hypertensive young adults (98subjects: 25, 23, 25, 25 in four
groups) were randomly allotted into a group that he/she had not belonged to in the earlier RCT: Control (New Group I), Physical
Exercise (NG II)brisk walking for 50 to 60minutes, three to four days/week, Salt Intake Reduction (NG III) to at least half of
their previous intake, Yoga (NG IV) for 30 to 45minutes/day, five days/week. Blood pressure was measured before and after
eight weeks of intervention. Analysis was by ANOVA with a GamesHowell post hoc test. Results: Ninetyfour participants (25,
23, 21, 25) completed the study. All three intervention groups showed significant reduction in BP (SBP/DBP mmHg: 5.3/6.0
in NG II, 2.5/2.0 in NG III, and 2.3/2.4 in NG IV, respectively), while the Control Group showed no significant difference.
Persistence of significant reduction in BP in the three intervention groups after crossover confirmed the biological plausibility of
these nonpharmacological interventions. This study reconfirmed that physical exercise was more effective than Salt Reduction or
Yoga. Salt Reduction, and Yoga were equally effective. Conclusion: Physical exercise, salt intake reduction, and yoga are effective
nonpharmacological methods for reducing blood pressure in young prehypertensive and hypertensive adults.
Keywords: Crossover randomized controlled trial, hypertension, nonpharmacological interventions
Introduction
Hypertension is the most prevalent noncommunicable
disease in India.(1) Globally, 7.1million deaths (~12.8%
of total deaths) and 64.3million disabilityadjusted life
years (DALYs) (4.4% of global total) are estimated to be
due to hypertension, the prevalence being 972million in
2002, predicted to increase by about 60% (1.56billion) by
Access this article online
Quick Response Code:
Website:
www.ijcm.org.in
DOI:
10.4103/0970-0218.86519
191
Group 1
Into 4 Groups
Group 3
Group 4
BP measured, analysed
Randomization
New Group 2
New Group 3
New Group 4
BP measured
Intervention period (8 weeks)
Present cross-over RCT 2008
BP measured, analysed
Figure1: Methodology
192
Results
Of the 98 randomized subjects, 94(63males, 31females)
completed the study. Age distribution concurred in all
groups, the mean age being 23years in each group (range
21 25years). The malefemale distribution was similar
in all groups except a slight male overrepresentation
in the Physical Exercise group. During the course of
the study four participants from the salt restriction
group were excluded as they had not complied with the
requirements of the intervention. The mean systolic BP in
the four groups ranged between 126 and 132mmHg and
the diastolic blood pressure between 78 and 81mmHg
[Table1].
Comparison of pre, post, and modified postintervention blood pressure values
On comparing the preintervention and postintervention
BPvalues following crossover, using the paired t test,
the mean systolic blood pressure (SBP)/diastolic blood
pressure (DBP) value in the physical exercise group was
reduced by 5.43.1/6.12.9mmHg, in the dietary salt
restriction group the mean SBP/DBPvalue was reduced
by 2.61.5/2.01.6mmHg, in the yoga group there was
reduction by 2.31.2/2.41.6mmHg, and in the control
group, the reduction was 0.241.4/0.51.4mmHg.
The mean differences in SBP and DBP in each of the
three intervention groups were found to be statistically
significant (P<0.05 in each case). However, the mean
Total study
group
98
94
4
23.5
61/33
23
129.211.8
126.510.9
79.98.1
77.27.7
Control
group
25
25
23.32
2.1: 1
3
126.110.3
125.89.9
78.67.3
78.27.1
Physical
exercise group
23
23
23.68
2.8: 1
6
132.311.3
126.99.9
81.16.3
75.05.9
Salt intake
reduction group
25
21
16
23.67
1.1: 1
6
129.713.0
127.112.5
80.010
78.08.9
Yoga
group
25
25
23
1.7: 1
8
126.812.4
126.411.6
79.88.6
77.48.4
Table2: Comparison of pre, post, and modified postintervention blood pressure values
Groups
78.67.3
78.17.1
0.06
Control
Physical
exercise
Salt
129.713.0 127.112.5 <0.000^
reduction
Yoga
126.812.4 126.411.6 <0.000^
127.412.5
<0.000^
80.010
78.09.8
<0.001^
78.59.8
<0.000^
126.711.6
<0.000^
79.848.6
77.48.3
<0.001^
77.98.3
<0.000^
*Paired ttest. ^Statistically significant (P<0.05). #Modified Postintervention BP value: Correction of Postintervention BPvalues with baseline reduction of 0.28mmHg SBP and 0.52mmHg
DBP in the Control Group
193
Discussion
Ninetyfour out of 98subjects completed this crossover
RCT, with a calculated attrition rate of 4.08%. Compared
to the attrition rate of 9.7% in the earlier RCT,(19) the
attrition rate in this study was brought down by more
than 50% by way of randomizing the subjects into groups
and by undertaking additional personal motivation
via the individual/group approach. A comparative
discussion follows.
Physical exercise
The present study showed 5.39mm Hg reduction in SBP
and 6.08mm Hg in DBP in the exercise group against a
reduction of 5.3mm Hg and 6mm Hg in SBP andDBP,
respectively, in the earlier study.(19)Anand(21)through his
metaanalysis showed that moderately intense exercise,
for example, 30 to 45minutes of brisk walking, four to
five days a week, reduces blood pressure. In concordance,
Schwarz etal.,(6) Chiriac etal.,(7) Hagberg etal.,(11) and
Cleroux etal.(12) showed similar results, concurring with
the results of the present study.
However, Cooper etal.,(24) concluded that the magnitude
of the hypotensive effect was not as high as that
found in studies of higher intensity exercise among
hypertensives. Similarly Stewart etal.,(25) in his RCT on
a group of hypertensives with a mean age of 63years
did not find a significant reduction in SBP, in spite of an
exercise regimen spanning 78sessions over six months.
This could be due to the stiff arterial walls seen in the
elderly, as it is known that arterial compliance reduces
with advancing age. Church etal.(26) also did not find a
significant reduction in BP post physical intervention,
done over a period of six months. However, the study
sample comprised of only postmenopausal obese women
with a mean age of 57years, who had a sedentary
lifestyle. Park etal.(27) reported that accumulation of
physical activity appeared to be more effective than
a single continuous session, in the management of
prehypertension.
Many published data have shown the association of
physical exercise with reduction of blood pressure.(6,7,11,12,27)
However, the study designs used in these studies have
not addressed whether physical exercise could reduce
the BP of any subjects or they had an effect only on a
certain group of subjects with some specific characteristic
feature.
Salt intake reduction
A reduction in the dietary salt intake as a strategy to tackle
hypertension has been tried in various studies. The earlier
RCT(19) showed 2.6/3.7mm Hg reduction and the present
study has shown a reduction of 2.57/2.04mm Hg in BP.
Table3: Relative efficacies of physical exercise salt intake reduction and yoga
Group A
Physical exercise
Salt reduction
Yoga
Group B
Salt reduction
Yoga
Physical exercise
Yoga
Physical exercise
Salt reduction
Resultant
reduction (AB)
2.76
2.52
2.76
0.24
2.52
0.24
SBP analysis
P* value 95% confidence
interval
0.003
4.67 to0.85
0.006
4.36 to0.68
0.003
0.85 to 4.67
0.8
0.80 to 1.28
0.006
0.68 to 4.36
0.8
1.28 to 0.80
Resultant
reduction (AB)
3.64
2.96
3.64
0.68
2.96
0.68
DBP analysis
P* value 95% confidence
interval
<0.001
5.64 to1.64
0.003
4.97 to0.95
<0.001
1.64 to 5.64
0.3
0.45 to 1.80
0.003
0.95 to 4.97
0.3
1.80 to 0.45
*ANOVA with GamesHowell post hoc test, DBP: Diastolic blood pressure
194
Acknowledgment
We thank ICMR, NewDelhi and the participants of the study.
Indian Journal of Community Medicine/Vol 36/Issue 3/July 2011
References
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
24. Cooper AR, Moore LA, McKenna J, Riddoch CJ. What is the
magnitude of blood pressure response to a programme of
moderate intensity exercise? Randomized controlled trail among
sedentary adults with unmedicated hypertension. Br J Gen Pract
2000;50:95862.
9.
25. Stewart KJ, Bacher AC, Turner KL, Fleg JL, Hees PS, ShapiroEP,
etal. Effect of exercise on blood pressure in older persons:
Arandomized controlled trial. Arch Intern Med 2005;165:75662.
26. Church TS, Earnest CP, Skinner JS, Blair SN. Effects of different
doses of physical activity on cardiorespiratory fitness among
sedentary, overweight or obese postmenopausal women with
elevated blood pressure: A randomized controlled trial. JAMA
2007;297:208191.
11. Hagberg JM, Park JJ, Brown MD. The role of exercise training
in the treatment of hypertension: An update. Sports Med
2000;30:193206.
12. Cleroux J, Feldman RD, Petrella RJ. Lifestyle modifications to prevent
and control hypertension.4. Recommendations on physical exercise
training. Canadian Hypertension Society, Canadian Coalition for
high blood pressure Prevention and Control, Laboratory Centre for
Disease Control at Health Canada, Heart and Stroke Foundation of
Canada. CMAJ 1999;160(9 Suppl): S218.
13. de Luis D, Aller R, Zarzuelo S. Dietary salt in the era of
antihypertensive drugs. Med Clin (Barc) 2006;127:6735.
14. Sacks FM, Svetkey LP, Vollmer WM, Appel LJ, Bray GA,
HarshaD, etal. Effects on blood pressure of reduced dietary
sodium and the Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension
(DASH) diet. DASHSodium Collaborative Research Group.
NEngl J Med 2001;344:310.
15. Fodor JG, Whitmore B, Leenen F, Larochelle P. Lifestyle
modifications to prevent and control hypertension.5.
Recommendations on dietary salt. Canadian Hypertension
Society, Canadian Coalition for high blood pressure Prevention
and Control, Laboratory Centre for Disease Control at Health
Canada, Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada. CMAJ
1999;160(9 Suppl): S2934.
16. Soudarssanane MB, Karthigeyan M, Stephen S, Sahai A. Key
predictors of high blood pressure and hypertension among
adolescents: A simple prescription for prevention. Indian
JCommunity Med 2006;31:1649.
17. Soudarssanane M, Mathanraj S, Sumanth M, Sahai A,
196
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.