Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Disclaimer: The views presented are the opinion/work of the individual author and The Finance Club of IIM Shillong bears
no responsibility whatsoever.
CONTENTS
Niveshak Times
04 The Month That Was
SHe Speaketh
09 Ms. Deepali Bhargava
Fingyaan
15 Catastrophe Bond Market
RBI reviews monetary policy yet again IRDA-SEBI war takes new turn
The RBI raised the two key policy rates—re- Last year, life insurance companies, including
verse repo and repo—by 25 basis points each, and LIC, were served show-cause notices by SEBI, ques-
left banks with Rs 12,500 crore less to lend with a tioning them on sale of Ulips without obtaining the
25 bps increase in the cash reserve ratio (CRR). This market regulator’s approval. The insurance regula-
rate hike is seen as moderate by any standard in tor responded broadly saying SEBI did not have the
the current circumstances. Therefore, most bankers remit or the jurisdiction to regulate Ulips. The turf
think RBI will have to raise rates as well as increase war took a fresh twist when on April 9 Sebi issued
the CRR in small doses during the year. orders to 14 life insurance companies, banning them
from selling new policies or renewing existing ones.
Banks borrow from RBI at the repo rate while
The market regulator said these companies have to
parking (or lending) surplus funds at the reverse
register with SEBI for marketing and servicing such
repo rate. After the increase, the repo and reverse
products. SEBI’s order may compel investors to sur-
repo rates are 5.25% and 3.75%, respectively. The
render their policies prematurely, leading to a sig-
CRR, which is like a tax on lenders, is the slice of
nificant loss to both investors and insurers.
customer deposit that banks have to set aside as
cash with RBI. After the 25 bps CRR hike, from 5.75% The issue came to a boil over IRDA telling insur-
to 6%, banks will have Rs 12,500 crore less to lend ance firms to continue selling Ulips, a day after capi-
from the fortnight beginning April 24. tal market watchdog Sebi barred 14 insurers from
selling these products without its approval.
RBI began tightening in January when it raised
the CRR by 50 bps in two stages. This was followed What makes the issue complicated is the fact
by the 25 bps increase in repo and reverse repo in that both the regulators have armed themselves
March. While RBI has been slower than its counter- with legal opinions supporting their case to regulate
parts in Australia and Israel in raising rates, it has Ulips. Following the meeting between the chiefs of
been quicker in reversing the cycle than the Chinese Sebi and Irda and senior finance ministry officials,
central bank and monetary authorities in many ad- both the regulators have decided to restore status
vanced economies. quo and keep in abeyance the orders issued by both
during the weekend.
IRDA tells postal dept to fall in line This means that the insurance industry will not
The insurance regulator has demanded that be staggering for now from selling Ulips. But the pre-
the country’s postal department adhere to its norms vailing uncertainty might put off new investors.
while selling insurance products, triggering a poten-
tially damaging row between the two and forcing the
finance ministry’s intervention.
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SHILLONG 5
B NKING THE UNBANKED
Abhishek Sarkar & Sreejit Gopinathan
Welingkar Institute of Management
AoM
ing biometric identification implemented in Andhra
Pradesh should encouraged further. Also, the same
channel can be used for providing other financial
services such as insurance.For this we need to scale
up our IT & telecom infrastructure as traffic of finan-
cial transactions is going to increase in tandem with
coverage of more & more villages. However the pace
at which the technology is being is used to provide
such facilities needs to be at a faster rate or else the
dream of complete financial inclusion will remain
mere on paper.
Niveshak: There are talks that the Ms. Bhargava: RBI recently raised its
Global and Indian economy are key rates – repo, reverse repo and Deepali Bhargava,
on the recovery path. What do CRR – by 25 bps to each to 5.25%, in this interview
you have to say about it? How 3.75%, 6.00% respectively. Though with, Team Nive-
do you see the Indian macroeco- the recent rhetoric by RBI may have
nomic scenario panning out in hinted at a policy shift towards con- shak opines about
the next couple of years? taining inflation, the April policy the state of the
She Speaketh
report seems to be more balanced economy at present
Ms. Bhargava: Indian economy is well with a focus on risks to growth. RBI
sustaining the growth momentum is not in a hurry to move ahead of and the trajectory it
entering in to 2010-11. Leading in- the curve in the wake of uncertain- is expected to tra-
dicators are hinting at continued ties both on the inflation and growth
recovery. Services sector is likely to
verse. In light of the
front RBI sees monsoons as a key
catch up with the industry sector uncertainty as both inflation soften- RBI annual policy
in 2010-11 when we expect it to re- ing and growth pick-up are contin- attempting to deli-
cord over 9% growth. The big boost gent on a normal monsoon.
is likely to come from 1) enablers
cately balance the
like the arrival of 3-G facilitating A low rate hike now also gives RBI rising inflation and
telecommunication growth 2) strong more time to evaluate the growth growth recovery, a
emphasis on infrastructure reviving situation and impact of earlier rate
hikes. Upside risks to inflation are
peek in the dynam-
construction 3) higher tourist arriv-
als and 4) deleveraged bank balance likely to sustain for long, in the ics of the Indian and
sheets pulling up bank profitability. presence of rising global commodity world economy is
prices and demand –side pressures
Revival in domestic demand is likely building up. Outlook for growth, at
what this interview
to be complemented by a pick-up on 8% for FY11, is expected to be fi- has to offer.
exports. IMF has projected an expan- nanced by 20% growth in credit and
sion of 5.8% in world trade volume 17% growth in money supply - levels
in 2010 vs. a contraction of 12.3% in that are not consistent with an over-
2009, which is a positive for India heated economy. Hence, we stick to
trade. But, among other factors, the our call of gradual and consistent
competitiveness will be determined rate hikes in the current rate hike
by the extent, if any, of CNY revalu- cycle. We expect a cumulative 125
ation and also RBI’s comfort with bps of Repo and Reverse Repo hike
the pace of INR appreciation. Taking in FY11
these factors into account, we fac-
Niveshak: India has witnessed
tor in a 10% growth in exports. Bank
strong FII inflows in the capi-
credit is likely to play a key role in
tal markets for quite some time
financing growth. We, hence, pencil
in 8.2% GDP growth for FY11. now. FIIs have been consistent-
ly building up their portfolio in
Niveshak: What do you have to the top BSE and NSE companies.
say about the RBI annual policy? Where do you see the FII and FDI
Is it in accordance with the gen- investments heading in the com-
eral market sentiments? ing quarters?
going will likely continue to be good as the major high food prices. Recovery in this segment will be
economies recover and with a build-up in positive hugely contingent upon the performance of mon-
risk environment. On the other hand, as G-3 starts soons. A normal monsoon and higher rural incomes
withdrawing excess liquidity, flows in FY11 (ING es- are likely to be positive for both consumer durable
timates: USD 20 bn) will turn more volatile and will and non-durables.
likely end-up aggregating lower vis-à-vis FY10 (USD
30 bn). But an increase in short-term trade credit Niveshak: What do you think about the ren-
(with a revival in trade) and ECB (as recovery gains minbi (Chinese yuan) exchange rate policy and
momentum) will likely fill the gap. Hence, we expect what will be impacts of the changes if any?
capital account surplus to increase to USD 68 bn in
FY11 vs. USD 62 bn (estimated) for FY10. The pain Ms. Bhargava: The US’s interest in China’s co-opera-
point will be a widening in current account as oil tion on Iran and China’s interest in adopting a more
prices go higher and non-oil imports stage a recov- market-based exchange rate mechanism suggest
ery. With export growth likely to fall short of import compromises are possible. We remain of the view
growth, current account deficit is likely to widen to that Beijing will align the renminbi-dollar trading
2.7% of GDP in FY11 (from 2.5% in FY10) assuming band, now +/- 0.5%, with the bands for the non-dol-
average oil price of USD 90/bbl. lar cross rates, +/- 3% by the end of June. We expect
this will produce a one-off 3% appreciation in the
Thus, from the balance of payments point of view renminbi to the strong end of the trading band. We
though appreciation pressure will exist due to a bal- think other Asian currencies will appreciate by up to
ance of payments surplus, it may not be very ag- the amount the renminbi appreciates. Renminbi ap-
gressive. Greater RBI intervention may further stem preciation is a monetary tightening, which is nega-
the appreciation pressure. Risk of surge in oil prices tive for global growth. We think increased growth
and hence local inflation will likely imply greater angst would cause the dollar to appreciate.
volatility for INR in FY11. We target 42.8 on USD/INR
by fiscal-end.
Niveshak: The IIP numbers were released re-
cently. According to you what impact will it
Cover Story
expense if they are not expected to provide benefits F i n a n c i a l Operating
in future period. Lease Lease
Capitalized expenditure is treated as an invest- Total Assets Higher Lower
ment cash outflow. However an expenditure that is Liabilities Higher Lower
expensed appears as operating cash outflow in the
Net Income ( early year ) Lower Higher
period it is made. Expensing thus reduces the net
Net Income ( subsequent
income in the period it is made as compared to capi- Higher Lower
years )
talizing which results in greater reported profitability
Cash flow from operations Higher Lower
in the year of reporting.
Cash flow from financing Lower Higher
Capitalizing Expensing
Debt Ratios Higher Lower
Total Assets Higher Lower
Shareholders’ Equity Higher Lower Exploitation of the Intent of the Account-
Income Variability Lower Higher ing Principle
Net Income (1st year) Higher Lower
Use of market value method
Net Income (subsequent
Lower Higher Mark to market method of accounting requires
years)
a company to report accounts on the balance sheet
Cash flow from operations Higher Lower
at their fair market values rather than at historical
Cash flow from investing Lower Higher cost. Under the mark to market method of account-
Debt Ratios Lower Higher ing forwards, swaps, options, energy transportation
Interest Coverage ratio (1st contracts are allowed to be shown at their fair val-
Higher Lower
year) ues. However the use of mark to market method of
Interest Coverage ratio (sub- accounting for other types of contracts is somewhat
Lower Higher
sequent years) unusual and presents ample opportunities to distort
revenues and income as the management desires.
Operating vs. Financial Lease
Mark to market method has also been criti-
Certain companies structure
cized in the case of derivatives as outlandish
leases in the form of operating
assumptions, projections and account-
leases in such a way so as to achieve desirable
ing can result in both parties re-
financial ratios (low debt ratios and high return on
porting substantial profits for long
assets). Because a financial lease is economically
periods. According to Warren Buf-
similar to borrowing money to purchase an as-
fet, the practice of reporting “mark to
set, the lessee company (borrower of the asset)
market” leads to “mark to myth” in the
records the leased asset and the related debt on
case of derivatives.
the balance sheet. The income statement in case
of a financial lease reports the interest expense Equity Method of Accounting
along with depreciation expense. Companies can account for the investments
An operating lease however is similar to rent- in a separate business or entity under the consoli-
ing an asset. In an operating lease, only an income dation method or the equity method depending on
expense is recorded on the income statement while control on the subsidiary. Unfortunately, this leaves
no asset or liability is recorded on the balance sheet. the door open to companies that want to conceal
Debt on the balance sheet and expenses on the in- and manipulate the true performance of their sub-
come statement are thus higher in the early years sidiaries or joint ventures.
of a financial lease. Hence firms often prefer to re- Under the equity method, the investment is
port leases as operating leases as it results in higher recorded at cost and is subsequently adjusted to
profit and better solvency position in early years as
leverage ratios of the subsidiary. Operating Cash flow out of line with re-
ported earnings: If a company reports positive
Classification of Recurring items earnings but negative operating cash flows, then
Certain companies try to move “Gains” up the this could be a signal of some wrong doing on the
income statement and report them as revenues part of the management.
and report expenses as “Losses”. Only those items
Fourth Quarter Surprises: Unusually high rev-
should be reported as income and expenses that are
enues or low expenses in the fourth quarter of a
expected to recur over subsequent years.
year should be scrutinized with detail as well.
Conclusion:
Companies can manipulate their financial
statements in many different ways. However, inves-
tors can detect these practices by simply reading
the financial statements a little more closely. Some
of the means to detect abnormalities that should be
looked at include:
FinGyaan
ments, as long as they are not trig-
to investors. In consultation with an
gered.
investment bank, it would create a
special purpose entity that would Key categories of investors
issue the cat bond. Investors would who participate in this market in-
buy the bond, which might pay them clude hedge funds, specialized ca-
a coupon of LIBOR plus a spread, tastrophe-oriented funds, and asset
generally (but not always) between managers. Life insurers, reinsurers,
3 and 20%. If no hurricane hits Ban- banks, pension funds, and other in-
gladesh, then the investors would vestors have also participated in of-
make a healthy return on their in- ferings.
vestment. But if a hurricane were to
HOW IS IT RATED?
hit Bangladesh and trigger the cat
bond, then the principal initially paid Cat bonds are often rated by an
by the investors would be forgiven, agency such as Standard & Poor’s,
and instead used by the sponsor to Moody’s, or Fitch Ratings. A typical
pay its claims to policyholders Ad- corporate bond is rated based on
vantages of CAT bonds are that they its probability of default due to the
are not closely linked with the stock issuer going into bankruptcy. A ca-
software, and then when there is a large event, the abroad, especially in the United States and Europe.
event parameters are run against the exposure da-
Insurance or reinsurance companies can issue
tabase in the cat model. If the modelled losses are
these bonds and place them with various investors.
above a specified threshold, the bond is triggered.
This helps them transfer a part of the risks to the
Indexed to industry loss: instead of adding investors.
up the insurer’s claims, the cat bond is triggered
The insurance company can further invest the
when the insurance industry loss from a certain peril
money generated from selling the bonds.
reaches a specified threshold, say $30 billion. The
cat bond will specify who determines the industry “Cat bonds can be issued by the Government
loss; typically it is a recognized agency like PCS. or financial institutions. Investors can get a slightly
“Modified index” linked securities customize the in- higher return when compared to other securities
dex to a company’s own book of business by weight- and it also offers them an opportunity to diversify
ing the index results for various territories and lines their investments. But if the catastrophe is of huge
of business. proportions, then investors can lose the capital.
Parametric: instead of being based on any The insurance company then uses the amount
claims (the insurer’s actual claims, the modelled raised against Cat bonds to pay policy holders’
claims, or the industry’s claims), the trigger is in- claims,” said Mr K. G. Krishnamoorthy Rao, Chief Ex-
FinGyaan
but it’s worthwhile for regulators to at least examine 5. Rebalancing
this bond.
The first is that of India’s immature capital
markets. It’s true that the low level of financial liter-
6. Small Order Execution
acy dampens much financial activity; however, this System (SOES)
bond caters to a sophisticated investor set, offering
a security unlinked to the usual market volatility. So 7. Royal sun alliance& Sundram
regardless of the weak bond market, this bond can
thrive, depending on insurance. alliance
Though, second, the current state of the insur-
ance market isn’t promising either. According to a 8. Sir John Templeton
paper last year by Crisil and Assocham, India’s insur-
ance business commands 0.6% of its output, against
the world average of 2.14%. Still, as incomes rise
and as more employers offer benefits, this market
has only room to expand.
Third, India’s regulators, who have been con-
Rich
The Indian population clock
has already clocked 1,151,068,507
Canada 3.405 38439.78 the investments be
USA 30.71 44155.00
and is still ticking fast enough to ing made overall.
Mozam- 24.21 377.69
question if this ever growing popu- The general feeling
Poor
bique
lation is generating poverty or eco-
nomic prosperity. At first sight, it Ethiopia 71.739 183.13 amongst the masses
appears that this huge population is Table 2 Source: www.nationmaster.com is that growing pop
a curse to our economy. It is also a The above statistics evidently ulation is a curse
liability for the nation. More people acquits population from the charge but the article does
Perspective
meaning more mouths to be fed that it causes poverty. Highly pop-
that ultimately makes the nation ulated states can both be rich and bring it is as a po-
suffer from poverty, corruption and poor. Singapore with the highest tential bless ing for
ill governance. Many of us even be- population density (per sq. km) of the economy only if
lieve that a growing population will 6386.29 generates 40 times the In-
simply guttle the planet, and lead to dia’s GDP per capita. Similar is the
proper investment is
famine, disease and death of civili- observation for sparsely populated made in the “human
sation as we know it. nations. Hence population growth is beings”.
But a serious thought and re- not the factor that causes poverty or
search would counter the above ar- miseries. So does that mean popula-
gument. Infact there is no correlation tion growth causes economic pros-
between the growing population and perity? Let us try to find that out by
a falling economic and social pros- analysing the statistics below.
perity. The statistics below would India’s Population
vouch for that non-correlation: Year Pop. LEB IMR FGP FGP/
(m) (yrs) (mt) per-
Countries Pop. Den- GDP per
son
sity (per capita $
Table 3 Source: www.censusindia.gov.in
Statistics tells us that Street vendors and hawkers form a major part of over 90% of India’s
workforce which earns its livelihood in the informal sector. As a matter of fact this sector ac-
counts for 63% of the country’s GDP.
Perspective
bution chan- to trade will
nel, on which generate numer-
both producers and ous wealth by doing
consumers rely. Street what they can do best
vendors not only create em- in a free market economy. It will
ployment for themselves through their also enable them to look upon themselves and
own entrepreneurial skills, but also help generate their brethren as a huge asset. Surely, investing in
employment in agriculture as well as small-scale in- human beings is one Nivesh that will reap the ben-
dustry. Hence we can say that street vendors are a efits for hundreds of years to come.
vital and vibrant part of the Indian economy (Source: There are jobs
www.petitiononline.com). a-plenty there—
So street vendors turns out to be a potential I’ll be a watchman,
where we must heavily invest. They must be given waiter, doctor
vending licenses and, on lines of SEZs’ Hawing zones Even a politician—
must be created to let them operate freely. But the if I dare!
sad part is that we are investing blindly in setting up I am there where millions live
of mammoth buildings, malls, multiplexes etc which And a million dreams come true.
don’t even hold a respectful contribution in nation’s I am not a liability I am an asset to accrue.
GDP.
From the above example it is clear that dho-
bis, street vendors, hawkers, and autowalas are all
potential entities to invest in and it is primarily be-
cause they have minds, skills and ability.
Evidently the above example explains the sec-
ond point too, that, for a nation to prosper, it is not
mandatory for each and every one to be educated.
What they must have are skills. The argument may
seem unintelligent because right from the beginning
2. What is the world’s largest gold exchange traded fund and silver exchange traded fund?
3. In which of the following countries is prevalent the Pay as you earn (PAYE), a
withholding tax system?
(A) USA
(B) UK
(C) Australia
(D) Germany
(E) China
4. What term became popular after the newspaper report of Watergate Scandal in the year
1973?
6. Which bank is promoted by 20th Century Finance Corporation and Keppel Tatlee Bank of
Singapore in India?
7. He is the pioneer in mutual fund industry and often referred as the Father of Index
Fund investing. He created the first S&P 500 Index fund. Identify this famous person?
9. Which country’s currency is known as Drachma, which in Greek means ‘to grasp’?
FinSight
10. By how many basis points were CRR and reverse repo rates hiked by RBI in the latest
credit policy released on 20th April?
All entries should be mailed at niveshak.iims@gmail.com by 10th May, 2010 23:59 hours
One lucky winner will receive cash prize of Rs. 500/--
FINQ WINNER
The FinQ Winner for the month March 2010 is
Harshil Suvarnkar
of JBIMS
He receives a cash prize of Rs.500/-
CONGRATULATIONS!!
Instructions
»» Please submit your article with the file name and the email subject as <Title of
the Article>_<Institute Name>_<Author’s name/Group’s name> by 10 May 2010.
»» Article must be sent in Microsoft Word Document (doc/docx), Font: Times New
Roman, Font Size: 12, Line spacing: 1.5
»» Please ensure that the entire document has 1500-2000 words
»» The cover page of the article should only contain the Title of the Article, the
Author’s Name and the Institute’s Name
»» Mention your email id/ blog if you want the readers to contact you for further
discussion
»» Also, if certain entries which could not make the cut to the Niveshak will get
figured on our Blog in the ‘Specials’ section
SUBSCRIBE!!
Get your OWN COPY delivered to inbox
Drop a mail at niveshak.iims@gmail.com
Thanks
Team Niveshak
www.iims-niveshak.com
COMMENTS/FEEDBACK MAIL TO niveshak.iims@gmail.com
http://iims-niveshak.com
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Finance Club
Indian Institute of Management, Shillong
Mayurbhanj Complex,Nongthymmai
Shillong- 793014