Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Introduction
1.1 MEANING
Credit appraisal is an investigation/assessment done by the bank prior to providing any loans
& advances. It involves checking the commercial, financial & technical viability of the
project proposed its funding pattern & further checks the primary & collateral security cover
available for recovery of such funds. It involves obtaining the credit information of the client
and critically evaluating it to come to a decision.
The objective is to understand measure and manage the credit risk and aims at ensuring
sustained growth of healthy loan portfolio while dispensing the credit and managing the risk.
Credit Risk Management, most of the banks (if not all) are found performing several
activities like Industry study, periodic credit calls, periodic plant visits, developing MIS, risk
scoring and annual review of accounts
It is generally carried out by the financial institutions which are involved in providing
financial funding to its customers. The credit managers of the financial institutions are duty
bound to accept or reject a proposal on the basis of its viability or non - viability.
Chapter 2
Industry Profile
Accepting deposits
Making auto, home, and business loans
Reporting what you paid and earned
Issuing credit cards
Online bill payment
Providing investments
The list can go on and on, but those are basic things most banks will offer. However, what
vary from bank to bank are the terms and conditions. That is why everyone should consider
their unique needs and then select the bank that best meets those needs.
Comparing Your Choices
There are national, regional, and local community banks around the country. These banks are
further categorized into the following segments:
Commercial Banks
Savings & Loans (S&C)
Credit Unions
Mutual Funds and Brokerage Firms
Commercial Banks
Commercial Banks serve both individuals and businesses. They typically have multiple, welllocated branches throughout a region, and offer broad range of services. Deposits are FDICinsured up to $100,000 per type of depositors account. The only con is that fees at these
banks can be the highest.
Credit Unions
Credit Unions typically have the lowest fees and loan rates because they are non-profit.
Earnings are paid out to members at the end of the year. The main con is that as few as 1 or 2
percent happen to be federally insured. Like S&Ls, they often have fewer branches; therefore
you can rack up lots of ATM fees for using non-partner banks.
Virtual(Online)Banks
Virtual Banks are all online, thus there are no branches. In many cases, they dont even send
paper statements. Clients are emailed their monthly statements to view or print from online.
They are FDIC-insured. They have started to lose some of their appeal as many commercial
banks and even credit unions offer 100 percent online banking. The primary con here is that
there are a limited number of ATM machines. Thus, if clients cant find partner ATMs they
can pay lots of money annually in ATM fees.
Chapter 3
Company Profile
199
2
199
5
199
Kotak Mahindra takes a significant stake in Ford Credit Kotak Mahindra Limited,
for financing Ford vehicles.
199
(KMAMC).
200
0
200
Launches insurance business, partners Old Mutual from South Africa to form Kotak
200
banking license from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). With this, KMFL becomes
the first non-banking finance company to be converted into a commercial bank Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd.
200
4
200
5
200
5
Enters alternate assets business with the launch of a private equity fund.
Kotak Mahindra Group realigns joint venture in Ford Credit; takes 100% ownership
of Kotak Mahindra Prime (formerly known as Kotak Mahindra Primus Limited) and
sells its stake in Ford credit Mahindra to Ford.
Launches a real estate fund
200
Buys out Goldman Sachs' equity stake in Kotak Mahindra Capital Company and
200
8
200
9
201
2015.
Background
KMBL was converted into a commercial Bank from a nonbanking financial company in 200
3.It is one of Indias leading providers of financial services.
The Bank services its customers base through its network of 249 retail branches and over
497 ATMs across 145 locations in the country. The Bank is also engaged in investment
banking, equity broking, securities-based lending, and car finance through its subsidiaries. As
on march 31, 2010, KMBL had a Tier I capital adequacy ratio (CAR) of 15.4% while overall
CAR of 18.4% while the Banks net worth stood at Rs. 79.8 billons. KMBL sold a 4.5% stake
in the Bank to SMBC in August 2010; this has added Rs. 13.66 billon to its net worth .KMBL
has healthy earnings profile given the different types of business that it operates. The Bank's
gross spreads are higher than the industry average as it operates primarily in the higher yield
retails and midcorporate segments.
It has a high fee income level contributed mainly by its broking and investment banking
business. In the equity broking business, KMBL is among the top equity brokers, with a
market share of 4% with 1281 offices across 435 towns. The Bank established presence
across investment banking segments such as debt and equity capital market issuances,
mergers and acquisitions, and financial advisory services. Its gross non-performing assets
(NPA) stood at 2.2% while net NPAs stood at 1.5% as on March 2010.
The Bank's healthy earnings profile supports its capitalization levels which provide adequate
cushion on against assetside risks
Kotak Mahindra is one of India's leading banking and financial services group, offering a
wide range of financial services that encompass every sphere of life. It is a one stop shop for
all banking needs. The bank offers personal finance solutions of every kind from savings
accounts to credit cards, distribution of mutual funds to life insurance products. Kotak
Mahindra Bank offers transaction banking, operates lending verticals, manages IPOs and
provides working capital loans. Kotak has one of the largest and most respected Wealth
Management teams in India, providing the widest range of solutions to high net worth
individuals, entrepreneurs, business families and employed professionals.
Kotak
Kotak
Kotak
Kotak
Kotak
Kotak
Kotak
Kotak
Securities Ltd
Mahindra Capital Company (KMCC)
Mahindra Prime Ltd (KMPL)
International Business
Mahindra Asset Management Company Ltd (KMAMC)
Private Equity Group (KPEG)
Realty Fund
Mahindra old mutual life Insurance Ltd
3.
4.
Home Loans
Personal Loans
Car Loans
Loan against property
Home Improvement Loans
Home Loan Balance Transfer
Kotak Stock Ace
Gold Loan
Education Loan
Convenience Banking
Anywhere, Anytime Banking
In today's day and age time is money. You work hard and have a busy schedule. Doing
your bankingshould be easy and convenient and not add to your worries.
We at Kotak Mahindra Bank realize this and have specially tailored a wide range of value
addedproducts and services to make your money work for you. These, coupled with the
highest standard of customer care will make your life simpler and easier.
Net Banking
Instant, convenient and secure way of shopping and making payments online.
Mobile Banking
Experience online banking - without a pc or internet connection Unstructured Supplementary
Service Data (USSD)
SMS Banking
Get Alerts on your mobile or by email for events that you would like to keep track of.
Phone Banking
Our constantly growing ATM network brings the bank within your easy reach.
Government Business
Cash Deposit Machine
Cheque Deposit Kiosk
11
Working Capital Is The Life-Blood of any business. A business requires optimal cash flow to
survive on a regular basis. Working capital is also required to further sustain a firms growth,
improve business operation and stay ahead of competition.
At Kotak , We assist business financially with different types of working capital finance in
the form of various fund and non fund based products. We have nationwide presence through
our branches and enjoy correspondent relationship with a large network of overseas banks.
Cash Credit
Cash credit is a running account facility which enables the customer to withdraw amounts
from the current account, up to the extent of the sanctioned limit. Cash credit is provided to
bridge the working capital gap in business. It is extended against hypothecation of stock,
receivables, short term deposits and other current assets which generally hold the liquidity of
a business.
We offer cash credit on an annual renewal basis. Our cash credit program is highly flexible to
12
meet the needs of various business segments.
Key Features:
Seamless account features like net banking, international debit card, RTGS/NEFT, DD and
pay-order etc.
Competitive interest rate
One stop shop for all trade services
Free at par cheques payable across the country
Foreign transaction made easy through online platform FX live variants
Overdraft Facility
A credit agreement made with a financial institution that permits an account holder to use or
withdraw more than they have in their account, without exceeding a specified maximum
negative balance.
Establishing
an
overdraft
facility
with
a bank can
help
an individual or small business with short term cash flow problems, although the negative
13
balance typically needs to be repaid within a month.
Key Features:
Seamless account features like net banking, international debit card, RTGS/NEFT, DD and
pay-order etc.
Competitive interest rate
One stop shop for all trade services
Free at par cheques payable across the country
Foreign transaction made easy through online platform FX live variants
Customer Profile:
Manufactures
Retail/wholesale traders importers/exporters
Service providers
Eligibility:
Acceptable collaterals:
Acceptable Collaterals:14
10 years
Bank Guarantee
There are three parties to a contract guarantee.
Person who guarantees the performance of a promise or liability of a third person is called
guarantor.
Person on whose behalf the guarantee is given is the principal debtor.
Person to whom guarantee is given is the creditor.
15
Letter of credit
This is used for buying raw material / capital goods on credit, both domestic and foreign.
Working capital LC is issued for a maximum period of 3 years.
Benefits:
Key Features:
Customer Profile:
Based on export orders in hand & in addition to existing working capital limits.
16
Chapter 4
Objectives
17
4.1 OBJECTIVE OF STUDY
1. The purpose of study is to understand and analyze the various aspects of financing the
projects of the borrowers which are beyond the powers of the branches and within the
ambit of the Kotak Mahindra Bank.
2. This study covers the process followed by Kotak Mahindra for assessing the credit
worthiness of its clients and granting funds to meet their day to day operations i.e.
assessment of working capital limit loans.
3. To study the procedure adopted in evaluating credit proposal by using case analysis. And
also the credit risk rating parameters used in the particular case.
18
Chapter 5
Project Design &Methodology
19
5.1PROJECTMETHODOLOGY
The data includes some important points noted down from the various client meetings during
the project. Since the research carried out for this project is purely descriptive and analytical
in nature, the documents provided by the client and the official file would require for
understanding the credit appraisal procedure of the bank.
Data Type:
The data used for the study is secondary data to find out
1. Financial statements
Provisional for the current year and the financial projections in case of term
loans
CA check
20
Balance Sheet
Profitability Statements
Operating Statement
Computation of MPBF
Table 5.1: MSMEs classification
Chapter 6
Analysis
22
Ratio Analysis
Intra firm comparison that is review of the trend of the ratios over the years within the firm
and Inter firm comparison.
Reading of notes to accounts and other information: Careful reading and analysis of the
notes on accounts, one can gauge the policies of the management, performance of the
company, and its future planning.
23
1. Basic background information on the company:
2. Required facility
3. Key industry dynamics
4. Management
5. Management information system: Details of the planning, controlling and monitoring
systems which have been put in place have to given.
6. Financials
7. Details of the Security to be pledged
8. Present banking relationship: The bank requires full details of the present credit facilities
being enjoyed at the moment.
Proposal of preparation
Assessment of proposal
Disbursement of Loan
Figure6.1: Credit Appraisal Process
25
4.
5.
6.
7.
Financial Appraisal.
Economic Appraisal.
Environmental Appraisal.
Market Appraisal
BORROWER
APPRAISAL/KNOW
YOUR
CUSTOMER
(KYC)
NORMS:
The borrower is appraised on the following parameters also known as the 3 Cs of the
borrower i.e. character, capacity and capital.
1. Character:
Character is the greatest and the most important asset, which any individual can have. Even if
a borrower has the capacity and capital to repay a loan, it is the character of the borrower
which indicates his intention to repay. If the character or integrity of a borrower is known to
be questionable, every banker would avoid him even if backed by sufficient collaterals.
2. Capacity:
It deals with the ability of the borrower to manage an enterprise or venture successfully with
the resources available to him. His educational, technical and professional qualifications, his
antecedents, present activity, experience in the line of business, experiences of the family,
special skill or knowledge possessed by him, his past record etc. would give a hindsight into
his capacity to manage the show successfully and repay the loan.
3. Capital:
It is his ability to meet the loss, if any, sustained in the business or venture from his own
investment or capital without shifting it to his creditor or banker. Unless a borrower has some
Stake in the business, he may not take much interest in its success.
Monitoring of Transactions
Risk Management
TECHNICAL APPRAISAL:
The technical appraisal of a credit proposal involves a detailed study of the following aspects:
Licensing/registration requirements.
Selection of technology.
MANAGEMENT APPRAISAL:
In case of projects, units or enterprises run by individuals as sole proprietors or partnership
firms, it is usually one or two persons who manage the entire project, unit or the enterprise
whether it be of manufacturing or trading.
However, in case of corporate borrowers and also in case of large borrowal accounts, it is
usually a set of professionals who manage the entity each specialized in a specific area of
management i.e. production, finance, marketing, personnel etc. Unless there is a complete
integration of all these functions within an organization, it cannot function effectively.
FINANCIAL APPRAISAL:
The term financial appraisal refers to the study of the following aspects of the project/unit:
Profitability estimates.
Projected balance-sheet.
ECONOMIC APPRAISAL:
27
The performance of a project is influenced by a variety of other economic, social and cultural
factors. Even if a project is technically feasible and financially viable, it may not satisfy the
economic needs viz. employment potential, development of industrially backward areas,
environmental pollution etc. Further as capital is a scarce resource, it is necessary that it must
be allocated in such a way that it yields best possible return to the society in general and the
investor in particular. As such a detailed appraisal of the project in terms of the return it
generates to the investor and the lending institutions is necessary before a decision is taken to
commit resources. One of the most important methods of appraising this is the computation
of the Internal Rate of Return of the project.
Sensitivity Analysis:
The actual results differ from the projected results. If the actual results are plus/ minus 10%
of projections, it can be considered that the projections have been made very well. DebtService coverage ratio, break-even point and many other ratios have to be calculated on the
basis of these financial projections. If the financial projections go wrong and the expected
cash accruals are not available with the unit, the repayment of term loan will face difficulties.
The appraising officers should ascertain the most sensitive areas of the project. If the working
results of the project are highly sensitive to a particular variable, sufficient study should be
done to find out the probability of change in that variable and its impact on the viability of the
project.
MARKET APPRAISAL:
While appraising a proposal it is not only necessary to find out whether it is technically
feasible and financially viable, but also important to ascertain the marketability of the product
manufactured/sold. If goods produced cannot be sold there would be no point in producing
them. Hence the marketability or salability of goods is of great importance. Existence of a
market for the product provides the rationale for its production. If the product sought to be
manufactured is the only one of its kind for which there are no substitutes, the marketing of
the same may not be a problem excepting when it can be freely imported and that too at a
lesser cost. However, if there are many competitors, the entrepreneur may find the going
28
tough. However a combination of the factors like man behind the show, the quality of the
product and the strategy for its sale will result in its successful marketing
LIQUIDITY RATIOS
Liquidity refers to the ability of a firm to meet its short-term (usually up to 1 year)
obligations. The ratios, which indicate the liquidity of a company, are Current ratio,
Quick/Acid-Test ratio, and Cash ratio.
Sr.
Ratios
Formula
Current ratio
current
Remarks
No.
1.
assets
current liabilities
Quick Ratio
Quick
Assets
solvency
/ Quick ratio is also known as acid test
Current Liabilities
Where ,Quick Assets
InventoriesDoubtful Debtors
29
Prepaid Expenses + considered satisfactory
Advance Tax
3.
CASA Ratio
CASA Deposits =
CASA
Demand Deposits +
Savings
Bank
ratio
stands
for
Current
The
Deposits
CASA
Deposits/Total
Deposits
PROFITABILITY RATIOS
These ratios help measure the profitability of a firm. A firm, which generates a substantial
amount of profits per rupee of sales, can comfortably meet its operating expenses and provide
more returns to its shareholders. The relationship between profit and sales is measured by
profitability ratios. There are different types of profitability ratios.
Sr.No. Ratios
1.
Formula
Remarks
Return
on (PAT/Net
Equity
or Worth ) * 100
Return
on
Net Worth
revealing
how
much profit
company
Operating
(Operating
30
Profit
Profit
Margin
Sales ) * 100
3.
Net
Ratio
* 100
LEVERAGE RATIOS
It shows the relationship between proprietors funds & debts used in financing the assets of
the concern e.g. capital gearing ratios, debt equity ratios, & Proprietary ratios.
Sr.No
1.
Ratios
Interest
Formula
Remarks
(PAT + Interest) / The interest coverage ratio is used to determine
Coverage
Interest
Ratio
2.
Debt-
Debt
Equity
Liabilities)
Ratio
Equity
(Where, Equity =
reserves, premium
on shares, , etc.
balance)
should be kept in view while agreeing to a less
favorable ratio.
TOL
TNW
Ratio
Reserves
Surplus
Intangible Assets)
Total
outside
Liabilities
4.
Debt-
Service
Coverage
Ratio
to
interest,
of
an
principal
entitys
and
(person
lease
or
32
ACTIVITY RATIOS
These ratios are used to analyze how well a company uses its assets and liabilities
internally. It measures how quickly certain current assets are converted into cash or how
efficiently the assets are employed by a firm.
Sr.No.
Ratios
Formula
Remarks
1.
Turnover
Net
Ratio
Assets
2.
Total Assets
arising out of changes in both the internal and the external environment for initiating timely
corrective actions.
Some of the important goals of monitoring are listed as under:
1. To keep a watch on the project during implementation stage so that there are no time & cost
overruns.
2. To ensure that the funds released are utilized for the purpose for which these have been
provided and there is no diversion of such funds.
3. To evaluate operational and financial results, such as production, sales, profit/loss, flow of
funds, etc. and comparing these with the projections/estimates given by the borrower at the
time of sanction of credit facilities.
4. To ensure that the terms and conditions as stipulated in the sanction have been complied with.
5. To monitor operations in the account particularly cash credit facilities which indicate health
of the account.
6. To obtain market report on the borrower, to gather information like reputation/financial
standing etc.
7. To detect signals and symptoms of sickness or deterioration taking place in
conduct/performance of the account.
8. To ensure that the unit's management and organizational set-up is effective.
9. To keep a check on aspects like accumulation of statutory liabilities, creditors, debtors, rawmaterial, stocks-in-process, finished goods, etc.
10. To ensure charging of applicable rate of interest/penal interest/ commitment charges as per
bank's guidelines.
System of supervision & monitoring of credit as laid down by the Bank needs to be
meticulously followed by the branches/controlling offices which, inter alia, covers the
following:
1. Conveying the sanction
2. Maintenance of Loan Document File
34
3. Quarterly Review Sheet
4. Preventive Monitoring System
5. Quarterly Monitoring System
6. Inspection and Physical Verification of stocks Stock Audit
7. Inspection and physical Verification of Securities
CREDIT
RISK
RATING
MODEL
DEVELOPED
BY
KOTAK
MAHINDRA
Models
S.No
Large Corporate
Applicability
Total Limits
Sales
Above Rs.15 Crore Above
Mid Corporate
(OR)
except Trading concerns
Above Rs.5 Cr and Above Rs.25 Cr and upto
upto
Rs.15
Rs.100
Crore,
Cr Rs.100 Cr
(OR)
All trading concerns falling in the Large
Corporate category shall also be rated under this
35
model
Above Rs.50 lakh Upto Rs.25 Cr
Small Loans
(AND)
Above Rs.2 lakh &
NBFC
irrespective of Limit
Above Rs.5 Cr Cost
(OR)
Entrepreneur New Business Borrower
Model
Financial
Companies
of project
above
Rs.15 Cr.
setting Cost of project upto Rs.15
requiring
finance
above
Half
Yearly
Review
Rating
rating
models
availing
limits
10
available
Credit Risk Rating models All Banks & Financial Institutions
11
for Banks/FI
NPA Model
12
Models
Financials
Business
Large
Medium
Small
Small II
40%
40%
40%
36%
Industry
25%
25%
20%
16%
& Management
25%
20%
20%
28%
Conduct of A/c
10%
15%
20%
20%
CASE STUDY
Here is a case of Bhilwara Agro Auto Services Pvt Ltd for which personal description report
is prepared with the help of documents collected under KYC.
PROSPECT NO.:
BORROWER
Bhilwara Agro Auto Service Pvt CONTACT
Vaibhav Jain
NAME :
PRODUCT :
Ltd
WCG
PERSON :
SCHEME :
37
WCTL
Personal detail: Captioned case is sourced by Bhilwara bank branch for funding working
capital facilities in the form of cash credit and WCTL by takeover of working capital facility
with Induslnd Bank. The Ladha family roots from Bhilwara and having strong business setup.
The family is associated with Mahindra from last 40 years as they were having dealership of
Mahindra Tractor which was taken over by cousins on family division.
Shareholding patterns:Name of share
Holdin
S No
holders
Relationship
Director-
1
2
3
4
applicant
Director- son
Director-son
son's wife
g
35.17%
32.28%
32.28%
0.28%
100%
EM over residential plots no 10, 11, 12 and 24, Kamla Nagar, Bhilwara.
Personal guarantee of Mr. Vinod Ladha, Mr. Anil Ladha, Mr. Manish Ladha and
Mrs. Geeta Devi Ladha (w/o Vinod Ladha)
The customer is having sole banking with Induslnd bank from last 3 years but customer is
willing to shift banking facility with us for enhancement and better rate of interest.
38
Bank
Induslnd
Bank
KMBL
Total Fund
Base
(500)
30-90
Nil
Nil
(500)
Nil
Nil
100
100 60 Mths
550
550
700
700
days
Pricing
12.25%
11.85%
On
drawl
basis
11.85%
LTV calculation:Exposure
(Rs in
Products
CC limit
WCTL for 60 mths
collateral required
Collateral available
Commercial Showroom at Araji No. 391/1, National
Lacs)
collateral
LTV required
600.00
1.00
600.00
100.00
0.60
166.67
700.00
766.67
460.99
1.00
460.99
217.89
1.00
217.89
73.18
1.00
73.18
39
Residential property Plot No.- 15, Kamla Vihar, Araji
No.- 373 to 377, Revenue Gram- Jodhdas, Distt.Bhilwara (owner Vinod Ladha)
Open land at Plot No.- 10, Araji No.- 392, Revenue
93.90
1.00
93.90
83.00
0.40
33.20
928.96
879.16
LTV
Effective LTV
75.35%
87.20%
Income: During FY2012-13, the firm has achieved a turnover of Rs.91.36 Cr against
previous year turnover of Rs.59.19 Cr in FY 2011-12 and reflects a growth of 54% over the
corresponding last year. Significant growth in turnover was due to launch of new models and
overall growth in auto industry. Turnover achieved in FY 2014 is approx. 88.63 Cr with
marginal drop of 5% over the previous year. The minor drop in turnover in FY 2014 was due
to slowdown in automobile industry. The turnover is estimated for FY 2015 is Rs.95.00 Cr.
Below is the breakup of sales :Particular
Sales of vehicles &
spares
Services Charges
Total
FY 2014
FY 2013
87.1
1.53
88.63
90.4
0.96
91.36
FY
FY
2012
2011
58.43
0.75
59.18
43.78
0.71
44.49
Profit and Profitability: The firm has recorded a PBDIT margin of 2.40% in FY2012-13
as compared to 2.60% in FY 2011-12. We have considered income like commission on
insurance and various other discounts under operating income as they are part of
companys regular operations. PAT margin of 0.82% was achieved in FY2012-13 which
was increased as compare to previous year. Margins are maintained at same level in the
provisional financials till Feb 2014.
40
Interest coverage Ratio: The firm has interest coverage of 2.17 times for FY 2013 as
compared to 1.89 times in FY 2012. Interest coverage is seems to be comfortable.
Increase in interest cost in prov. financial 2014 was due to increase in CC limit from
Rs.480 to Rs.550 Lacs and availed fresh channel finance limit of Rs.200 Lacs from Axis
bank.
TNW, Leverage/Non-operating income and sustainability: The firms gearing ratio has
been reduced to 2.37 as on FYE 2013 from 1.84 as on FYE 2012. Increase in equity in
FY 2013 was due to retention of profit and increase in unsecured loan from relatives. It is
estimated to remain at same levels in coming years. The same can be considered
acceptable.
Fixed assets: - Fixed assets include showroom land and building at Bhilwara and
Rajsamand, furniture, workshop tools, vehicles and misc. fixed assets. Addition in FA in
FY 2013 was towards building construction for expansion, vehicles and workshop tools.
Cash flow/liquidity: The current ratio for FY 2013 was 1.165 as compared to 1.258
times in FY 2012. Other loan and advances include advances for capital goods and
suppliers.
(Rs in Lacs)
FY 2014
Particular
Statutory dues
Trade advances
advance from
customer
other liabilities
Prov.
39.49
411.44
FY
FY 2013 2012
10.69
36.89
254.66 145.83
46.10
9.56
129.67
17.30
41
0.00
16.00
Deferred tax liability
Total
16.85
523.44
16.85
429.17
12.98
211.7
CC assessment:
CC Assessment
Particulars
Average Sales
Average purchases
Average Debtors (Avg sales* Drs days/30)
Average stock (Avg Purchases * Inventory
(Rs. in lakhs)
Eligible limit
Eligible limit
(based on last
(considering 20%
6M avg)
growth)
725.84
694.72
162.11
871.01
833.67
194.53
holding period/30)
1083.43
1300.11
1245.54
1494.64
21.05
25.26
1224.49
306.12
200.00
382.00
336.36
1469.38
367.35
200.00
382.00
520.04
600.00
600.00
days/30)
Net working capital gap
Less: Margin from Promoters (25%)
Less:- Inventory Finance against stock
Less :- Average trade advance
Balance requirement
Proposed funding from KMBL ( as a CC
limit)
DSCR calculation:DSCR
PBDIT
Existing obligations
Interest on proposed FB facility of Rs.600 L
Proposed EMI of WCTL of Rs. 100 Lacs for
60 mths
Total obligations
DSCR
27.61
146.53
1.73
27.61
146.53
1.50
27.61
146.53
1.03
Following are the strength in the case:1. Mahindra being the market leader in the sports utility segment and a better performer,
the firm stands to benefit from the same.
2. Comfortable key financial ratios viz gearing and liquidity during FY 13.
3. No major borrowing except proposed funding.
4. Banking habits are healthy.
5. Decent capital in the firm.
6. RL sourced customer and will get sole baking.
7. Comfortable DSCR.
8. Reference check is positive.
Deviation Required:1. Cibil of Mr. Vinod Ladha showing overdue of Rs.12 Lacs in non-fund based facility
of Rs.12 Lacs. This is BG limit availed from SBBJ against 100% FD. Overdue
reflecting in cibil due to non-renewal at bank end. Clarification letter from SBBJ
attached for reference.
2. Cibil of Mr. Vinod Ladha showing overdue of Rs.4K in AL of Rs.5.50 Lacs availed
from SBBJ. The repayment of account is proper and overdue in cibil is due to updated
till Feb 2014.
43
Chapter7
Findings & Suggestions
44
7.1 FINDINGS
Electronic database should be designed carrying all the available and important information
related to the proposals accepted. This will help reduce paperwork and loss of information.
Understanding the nature of business and the market conditions is crucial for effective
credit appraisal
7.2 SUGGESTIONS
Bank should charge such a nominal rate of interest from the customers so that they get
attracted to avail the facility at once.
Secondly, Bank should minimize the transaction cost.
Bank should also consider financing new upcoming projects such as infrastructure,
manufacturing industries and big brands business.
Bank should also introduce new loan products which can assist small scale enterprises.
Bank should focus on spreading its network by opening new branches in smaller locations.
45
Chapter8
Learning
46
8.1 LEARNING
The study at Kotak Mahindra gave a vast learning experience to me and has helped to
enhance my knowledge. During the study I learnt how the theoretical financial analysis
aspects are used in practice during the working capital finance and term loan assessment. I
have realized during my project that a credit analyst must own multi-disciplinary talents like
financial, technical as well as legal know-how.
The credit appraisal for business loans has been devised in a systematic way. It is a process of
appraising the credit worthiness of loan applicants. Thus it extremely important for the lender
bank to assess the risk associated with credit; thereby ensure the security for the funds
deposited by the depositors. There are clear guidelines on how the credit analyst or lending
officer has to analyze a loan proposal. It includes phase-wise analysis which consists of 6
phases:
1. Financial statement analysis
2. Working capital and its assessment techniques
3. Techno Economic Feasibility Analysis
4. Credit risk assessment
5. Documentation
6. Loan administration
Kotak Mahindras adoptions of the Projected Balance Sheet method
of assessment
procedures are based on sound principles of lending. This method of assessment has certain
flexibility required to avoid any rigid approach to fixing quantum of finance. The PBS
method have been rationalized and simplified to facilitate complete flexibility in decisionmaking.
47
Chapter9
Bibliography
48
9.1 BIBLIOGRAPHY
49
ANNEXURE
50
51
52
53